Skip to content

[SELECTED P9.1/P9.2 AUDIO BASELINE — DRAFT] Reconciled music fidelity and world bass - #719

Closed
masarray wants to merge 26 commits into
research/sonku-p90-external-speaker-20261115from
research/sonku-p91-p92-fidelity-bass-reconciled-20261116
Closed

masarray wants to merge 26 commits into
research/sonku-p90-external-speaker-20261115from
research/sonku-p91-p92-fidelity-bass-reconciled-20261116

Conversation

@masarray

@masarray masarray commented Nov 15, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

AUTHORITATIVE P9 AUDIO BASELINE: selected operator checkpoint is issue #720 and frozen SHA 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb (do not move the checkpoint branch). ImerSip integration lives in child PR #722, not #706. P9.1/P9.2 uses native renderMode=9 / MusicSpatialP90 for compatibility: this does not mean old P9.0 DSP is being used. #718 is a divergent unselected alternative. Public production main remains unchanged; this PR is still draft, not headphone/acoustic certification.


Reconciled P9.1 + P9.2 Music Fidelity & World Bass

Reconciliation merge ea0a7c0 has parents P9.0 cd85ffe and production main 37985f0. All 30 main changes imported, 4 overlapping files exact-context merged. main ancestor, behind=0. Production untouched.

New native world-speaker bass foundation: complementary 165 Hz second-order LP, full measured 2x2 HRTF upper band, two world-positioned independent LF source feeds. No direct headphone-locked LF. P9 only; legacy music paths preserved.

Bounded axial resonances for three existing room sizes; zero modal return with ROOM OFF; smooth room and wet changes. Parametric room model, not a measured subwoofer BRIR.

P9 early reflections and late reverb now receive actual independent stereo L/R at true speaker angle instead of MID collapse. Scene gain corrected from 0.5 to 0.72 in P9 only, retaining linked peak guard and HRTF calibration.

First P9 switch from untouched legacy defaults installs near 1.6 m, 82 degrees, Large, ER78%, late33%, gain 0 dB, orbit OFF. Saved .smix and user-custom settings remain unchanged.

Native PCM tests added 44.1/48 kHz, source channels, yaw, phase, room modes, 128/256 parity and reference loudness floor. Reconciled CI adds Linux preflight and Windows JUCE/portable FAT.

Draft only. Real headphone validation, measured subwoofer/room data and dearVR parity remain unproven. No automatic merging.

…byte (#707)

* feat(qa): attest literal GUI asset bytes in compiled Windows EXE with mmap

* test(qa): detect missing, tampered and escaped GUI bytes in EXE

* test(qa): keep non-ASCII Pages HTML as UTF-8 fixture

* perf(qa): replace quadratic EXE GUI byte scanner with mmap verifier

* test(qa): require bounded mmap EXE attestation instead of bytewise PowerShell loop

* fix(test): use valid JS regex literals for native GUI verifier contract

* ci(native): run fast executable GUI resource attestation regression before Windows
…AN UX (#709)

Integrate the approved single-surface green FX power key and aligned toolbar caption, CEN/L100/R100 PAN labels with centered slider, GAIN/WIRE state, and epoch-fenced native FX A/B across the existing PCM graph. Preserve independent rack/slot bypass flags and JUCE WebView2 authority. Exact-head fast contracts and 3-viewport Chromium checks passed on c535e10. Post-merge Windows native MSVC/CTest is required for hardware qualification.
…#715)

Only the SonKu PCM test fixture allocation changes: use heap-owned SonKuSpatialCore instances, retaining every acoustic assertion, production DSP, hardware routing, and FX/PAN GUI behavior. Proven in PR #713 native Windows 99/99 CTest using identical test file. Exact-head Linux fast native preflight passed on f1b5018. Trigger full native Windows CTest on integrated main.
Reconcile tested Windows ASIO/WASAPI continuity into main without changing approved GUI or other draft PR branches. Preserve native ChannelId graph, pinned physical endpoint and MAIN intent across device STOP; fail closed on unknown devices. Harden session/device XML durability and regression gates. Field preview and full MSVC/CTest passed at source SHA 72cecbb.
… world-bass and route P9 through protected gain stage
@cloudflare-workers-and-pages

cloudflare-workers-and-pages Bot commented Nov 15, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Deploying arsonmix with  Cloudflare Pages  Cloudflare Pages

Latest commit: 763706a
Status: ✅  Deploy successful!
Preview URL: https://e34cd917.arsonmix.pages.dev
Branch Preview URL: https://feat-imersip-on-sonku-p92-si.arsonmix.pages.dev

View logs

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Integrated P9.1 + P9.2 status (2026-11-16)

  • Reconciled main into this acoustic branch in 2-parent merge ea0a7c0; main is an ancestor (behind 0). P0 audio continuity/global FX remain present. Production branch untouched.
  • P9-only world-speaker low-frequency path replaces the old headphone-locked transparent-bass restoration; early-room now processes actual two speaker inputs and angles; bounded three-room axial return and source-referenced gain replace legacy doubled bass shelf.
  • Actual C++ native PCM preflight passed at 44.1/48 kHz on ff705ac: output 0.41656 / 0.41477 versus source 0.40890 sum RMS (approx +0.16/+0.12 dB), 128/256 exact parity, room response, yaw, anti-phase, P8.9 regression. Isolated 70Hz ear-dominance test passed 2.046× near/far energy and reversed with head rotation; this is not headphone SPL or listening parity.
  • A/B-safe reset of tiny P9 LF and coherence states committed subsequently at 54cd380 to prevent stale bass after switching between P8.9 and P9.
  • Windows FAT MUST pass at the exact final head SHA before artifact link is considered valid. Older runs may be cancelled by PR concurrency. No subjective equivalence to dearVR claimed.
  • Separate legacy P8.3 physical-speaker diagnostic remains intentionally RED due to its already-known rejected low-energy candidate; the same failure was present on the previous P9 baseline cd85ffe. It is not the P9.1 PCM gate.
  • See docs/SONKU_P91_P92_RECONCILED_MUSIC_FIDELITY_BASS_FAT_20261116.md.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Final exact-source native FAT build — PASS

Latest HEAD 54cd38030b78ca57d4bf50659580a48784a455fe is the verified Windows portable GUI source SHA. GitHub Actions run #43771382883: scoped Linux PCM PASS; fast native contracts PASS; native Windows x64 CMake + JUCE app PASS; five targeted CTest tests PASS including P8.9 legacy, P9.0 v11 ACK, and P9.1/P9.2 real world-bass. Portable packaging and upload PASS.

Download verified artifact. Archive SHA-256 e670d97d56af53584e2c86d44168abdec49bf52a7fb851c34d33b48a64bf5b8e; local archive CRC integrity checked. ZIP has GUI Windows executable, source-matched BUILD_PROVENANCE.json, Third Party HRTF notice and both P9/P9.1-P9.2 FAT guides. Provenance records publicRelease=false, physicalAsioQualified=false, dearVrParityProven=false, headphoneFat=PENDING.

Separate historical P8.3 physical speaker diagnostic remains red, exactly as baseline P9.0, and is not a P9.1 regression. Keep this PR draft pending musical headphone FAT and device field tests.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

P9.1 + P9.2 dropdown labeling bug — fixed (2026-11-16)

Operator field screenshot shows the old selector "P9.0 · TRUE EXTERNAL SPEAKER" despite P9.1/P9.2 code already active (the stage caption correctly read "P9.1 + P9.2"). Both submilestones were implemented inside the same renderMode=9; they are not independent audio modes. The error was labeling/feature identity, not the core P9.1 LF algorithm.

  • Native prepared-instance capability p91p92MusicBassFoundation=true added to reconciled P9.1/P9.2 build only; older P9.0 schema-v11 builds do not advertise it.
  • GUI now displays compact, untruncated P9.1 + P9.2 · MUSIC / BASS, header RENDER MODE · P9.1 + P9.2 FAT, mode readback NATIVE P9.1+P9.2 WORLD BASS and retains detailed stage caption. Older builds show honest P9.0 fallback.
  • Native menu dataset.nativeModeSet now distinguishes p91p92 from p90; no flicker or option re-creation under readback.
  • Existing tests/sonku_p90_dropdown_stability_test.cjs exercises 40 actual-source readbacks with the popup open, the P9.1→P9.0→P8.9→P8.8→P9.1 transitions, and rejects fake P9.1 claims if native lacks the flag.
  • Exact-head Linux preflight passed on 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb, including P9.1/P9.2 PCM and P8.9 regressions: GitHub Actions run #43773841088.

Windows JUCE portable FAT artifact for the patched build must pass before the operator download is considered current. Keep PR draft until headphone field FAT.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

P9.1/P9.2 selector fix: verified Windows FAT artifact

HEAD 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb passed Actions run 43773841088: source dropdown/native capability regression PASS, UI Chromium PASS, P9.1/P9.2 PCM PASS, 5/5 Windows JUCE/CTest PASS, exact embedded GUI resources PASS, portable package accepted. Windows artifact, SHA-256 2ea2a637cd8a2fd0cd7f8c148317d90eb799b4ff583388a29ac0dbe3fa8318f7. ZIP CRC verified, contains ArSonMix-GUI10CH-P012-Windows-x64.exe (15,100,416 bytes), manifest sourceCommit matches HEAD, and SONKU_P91_P92_FIELD_FAT.md is included. The selector is now P9.1 + P9.2 · MUSIC / BASS (combined mode 9), native capability-gated; older P9.0 executable is still correctly labeled P9.0. No DSP algorithm change and no public release/merge; headphone listening FAT remains pending.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

🔒 Reconciliation checkpoint secured (2026-11-16)

Operator-confirmed Windows build v0.5.0-dev+g763706a1 is now preserved as a dedicated exact-commit recovery branch checkpoint/sonku-p91-p92-operator-confirmed-20261116 at 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb. Full recovery inventory, validated test results, audio/UI guardrails, P0 continuity reconciliation, A/B operator settings and artifact SHA are recorded in permanent checkpoint issue #720.

Important: main is already an ancestor of this branch (behind_by=0); merge ea0a7c0 includes #713 audio continuity. PR #719 and its parent PR #717 are still draft; production main remains unchanged. The old P8.3 diagnostic failure is tracked separately. Windows FAT Actions #43773841088 passed, but headphone/dearVR acoustic FAT remains pending.

Future development must branch off this frozen checkpoint; never rewrite it.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

2026-11-16 research-status clarification (without moving pinned HEAD): The operator-confirmed P9.1/P9.2 checkpoint is immutable SHA 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb / issue #720. A historical P8.3 negative acoustic gate still shows RED on this frozen PR because the old workflow was broad and the original P83 prototype failed its strict music-fidelity veto. This is not a P9.1/P9.2 qualification failure. Do not amend this frozen checkpoint to cosmetically green that legacy check. The downstream ImerSip integration PR #722 properly scopes P83 CI to explicit P83 research branches or manual dispatch, retains its rejection, and pins acoustic source fingerprints. For future work, consult docs/SPATIAL_AUDIO_AUTHORITY.md on #722 and the selected #720 baseline. #718 is an unselected divergent alternative, archived rather than merged.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

MILESTONE A: historical research archived / CLOSED UNMERGED. P9.1/P9.2 operator checkpoint remains an immutable historical reference under issue #720 and its dedicated checkpoint branch. Closing this stacked draft MUST NOT move that checkpoint.

Source branch: research/sonku-p91-p92-fidelity-bass-reconciled-20261116; exact original head: 763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb; target: research/sonku-p90-external-speaker-20261115. Frozen in docs/governance/MILESTONE_A_PR_BRANCH_RECONCILIATION_20261117.md on chore/milestone-a-pr-history-20261117. This closure does NOT import all commits, discard any work, delete any branch/checkpoint, alter audio, or authorize a public release. Future reactivation requires separately approved, scoped evidence.

@masarray masarray closed this Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant