Repository navigation
[SUPERSEDED — ARCHIVED] ImerSip P8 acoustic experiment (retained for A/B and IMRS migration) - #706
Conversation
…ealtime ACK queue
Deploying arsonmix with
|
| Latest commit: |
a7a399d
|
| Status: | ✅ Deploy successful! |
| Preview URL: | https://5dc2d261.arsonmix.pages.dev |
| Branch Preview URL: | https://feat-grandstage-p0-sonku-p82.arsonmix.pages.dev |
…e-safe stereo enhancement
…g block-size invariance
…ed phase-safe post stage
…n state and audio-applied SPSC
…nti-phase, bass and chunk parity
…ndStageProcessor.h
…usic_preservation_test.cpp
…ndstage-p0-fast.yml
… restore and invalid bytes
…test in research builds
… and release vetoes
…ows research candidate
… vendor resize behavior
ImerSip UI checkpoint follow-up — exact current head
|
…ack-master independence
OWNER APPROVED 180° SOUND CHECKPOINT — GUI reopen/power/layout repair (16 Nov 2026)Preserve accepted audio without altering a sample: immutable checkpoint branch Reported bugs: (1) active FX Rack ImerSip cannot reopen on clicking the FX slot, (2) no in-editor power/bypass like other built-in effects, (3) cramped/misaligned JUCE editor. Fixes across six forward commits to PR #706, current exact HEAD
Research rationale: JUCE's official AudioProcessor API requires host-owned editor lifetime and explicit process bypass, and documents that editors can be deleted/replaced independently of the processor (https://docs.juce.com/master/classjuce_1_1AudioProcessor.html). Host per-insert bypass has a dedicated click-safe fade rather than a new processor flag. Validation: Baseline pre-follow-up No changes to main; PR remains draft. |
…sting wet midrange
… stronger music default
…ce and HRTF phase
…uching stereo core
OWNER FAT TONAL + GUI REJECTION — source-founded corrective milestone (2026-11-16)Owner screenshots: current ImerSip at Music Default and maximum 180° sound was perceived as thin, mid-forward, short of soft bass and sparkling treble; preset at default was judged subjectively quieter, and controls appeared ineffective. Third screenshot shows existing Harmonice built-in UI with consistent Close / FX Power / preset dropdown / light silver control deck; previous ImerSip used isolated dark JUCE shell. The earlier 180° stereo engine was perceived as an improvement, so must remain recoverable at immutable Current candidate head: Audio repair, scoped to ImerSip only:
Real fixture source tests at 44.1/48k, source + Chromium PASS #43764757972:
GUI / efficient integration:
Outstanding gates: exact-head Windows JUCE full CTest + portable ZIP #43764758030 in progress after Linux source and Chromium PASS. UI native screenshot and owner same-headphone level-matched A/B still required. Do NOT merge or release. Physical owner FAT must test bass warmth, vocal cleanliness, treble sparkle, full 180° stereo, preset audition, power OFF/ON and close→reopen from the rack. Existing 180° checkpoint must stay untouched. |
2026-11-16 — Windows RED root-cause repair (ImerSip v5)Reconciled live PR head Verified failure: Windows run 43764758030, job Code fix: Verification: exact-head run 43771740060 fast PCM/GUI preflight PASS on Acoustic qualification remains separate: neither source PCM nor C++ compilation proves preferred physical headphone tonality, bass weight, sparkling treble, or premium spatial externalization. Preserve owner-approved SonKu P8.4 listening benchmark and avoid unqualified main merge/release. |
ImerSip 16 Nov 2026 — music source-MID fidelity / genuine early-room evidence (draft milestone)Exact HEAD: Root cause: with STEREO KEEP=100%, the measured KEMAR DIRECT HRTF difference still injected 480 Hz+ mid-band into original headphone MID, risking radio/nasal vocal coloration. The older source test demanded >15% overall PCM change on a 370–1270 Hz fixture, effectively rewarding that coloration. Changes:
Exact-head source PCM and compiled Chromium FX Picker: PASS, workflow https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/actions/runs/43774656676. Hold: exact-head full Windows native JUCE + ZIP provenance workflow is pending (SonKu P8.2 field run https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/actions/runs/43774656795). Do NOT recommend older Windows ZIP as containing this change. GUI still uses separate native JUCE editor; although host-bound power/close/factory preset exist, it has NOT been visually unified with Harmonice's existing WebView2 built-in FX chrome. This must be designed/reviewed against existing app UI rather than inventing another skin. Physical equal-loudness headphone A/B vs original and owner-preferred P8.4 still required before public release. |
|
16 Nov ImerSip acoustic direction superseded by new owner-accepted SonKu P9.1/P9.2 listening baseline. Follow successor draft PR #722 for the P9 shared-native-engine integration. Do not merge P8.2/P8.4 bespoke ImerSip DSP/room shelves into P9; preserve #706 as historical A/B checkpoint and old IMRS schema reference. Production main unchanged. |
ARCHIVED / DO NOT MERGE. ImerSip's selected direction is PR #722, using the owner-preferred P9.1/P9.2 checkpoint #720 through PR #719. This older P8 bespoke DSP branch is retained for historical A/B comparison and IMRS v1–v5 parsing only; no source commit or branch is deleted. See
docs/SPATIAL_AUDIO_AUTHORITY.md.Audible PCM output root-cause repair — 15 Nov 2026
The owner physically tested the previous Windows candidate and reported virtually NO audible change despite scene changes. The existing design was wrong: original direct stereo fully dominated; the tiny optional
roomTarget_=.14*immersion*width*(.35+.65*space)was only ~0.05 at previous defaults AND multiplied an already-attenuated complete SonKu output. Previous>1e-5numerical tests could pass while room was functionally near-bypassed.Real fix (not merely new GUI graphics/labels):
LIVE PCM DELTA -xx dBreports output vs incoming source using actual audio callback, whileNO PCM CALLBACK / BYPASSEDorSILENT INSERT INPUTexposes a disconnected/inaudible graph. This is a diagnostic rather than a subjective sound-quality rating..smixis not overwritten.93d4589e; measured default 48k mono RMS delta −29.8 dB, stereo −20.8 dB, full concert mono −23.0 dB, stereo −17.5 dB. These are PCM difference levels, not gain or claims of audible externalization.processBlock48k centered music test was added on6a3788eto reject a binary that compiles the source DSP but fails to change actual inserted FX PCM. Windows JUCE+PE+ZIP gate must complete successfully before recommending this candidate.This remains draft because the user has rejected earlier headphone output; do not claim this will sound better without an actual, loudness-matched physical A/B against user-approved SonKu P8.4. Design/measurements.
Close Orchestra Stage — source 1.6m / early-room detail (15 November 2026)
Owner explicitly requested orchestral instruments close to the listener with more instrument detail/separation/externalization and lively room-supported, phase-coherent bass. Previous SonKu P8.4 preferred physical sound is the comparison; original P8.2 music-safe LF reference must not regress.
Committed exactly
d31c44c2d7fa899099cb5b9cbe97f737221218d2to isolated P8.2-based ImerSip branch:0.075+0.18*Space; ambience0.025+0.10*Space. This is an audition candidate, not a measured BRIR.(1+0.45*Space)room-linked coherent LF120 shelf gain on BOTH ears; no delayed/out-of-phase crossfeed, no separate bass engine. This is room-responsive tonal warmth, not genuine measured modal bass.Root cause of previous RED Windows CI: exact run 43659352042 shows all 7 Windows tests PASSED, actual EXE and packaging completed, then PowerShell
ParserError: Duplicate keys physicalHeadphoneQualifiedduring artifact provenance. It was fixed on91fdc75before this acoustic commit and now has a fast preflight duplicate-key guard. Do not misinterpret previous RED as a DSP or Windows compiler failure.Current exact-commit fast tests and full Windows JUCE ZIP workflow must pass independently. See detailed field FAT. Still DRAFT—user's equal-loudness P8.4 vs ImerSip listening result needed before calling sonic improvement.
ImerSip music-first P8.4 measured fusion (owner P8.4 preferred) — 15 Nov 2026
New owner evidence: user supplied screenshot of SonKu
g641b4eaeand reported that P8.4 sounds noticeably better than P8.2 on real headphones. Previous PR #704 header describing P8.4 as unapproved is now superseded by this subjective preference, although calibrated FAT is still missing. ImerSip must use the P8.4 listening result as a minimum musical benchmark, not discard its progress.Bounded code transfer, commit
dd2d5f0140f185b58a4b8b04759d8baa295a2b91: copied the original 140-tapSonKuP84FusedMusicHrir.hfrom PR #704 WITHOUT the rejected P8.3 base or LF480 path. Only ImerSip's opt-in measured two-speaker core now usesH_center + 0.12 × HP750(H_measured_speaker − H_center)in existing FIR target updates; normal SonKu P8.2 path remains unchanged. ImerSip's processed music MID is still replaced with original direct MID outside the core, preserving vocal transparency. Source test adds original SonKu mode-OFF byte parity, directional impulse, 44.1/48 kHz LF coefficient-sum and anti-phase/vocal/SIDE/bass guard. JUCE editor remains six-control, audio ACK, v1/v2 state.Evidence: current native PCM + actual Chromium picker CI — PASS (exact head
0cc9a4f, including P8.4 header/GUI registration and source contracts); Windows actual JUCE candidate (full compile + JUCE ACK + archive/provenance gate; artifact valid only after SUCCESS). Research design / owner reference: IMERSIP_P84_FUSED_HRIR_EXTRACTION_20261115.md.No false quality claim: ImerSip is NOT identical to full P8.4
Music First; its uncolored dry center and controlled side-room balance differ. Do not assert better sounding/externalization or true phase-cancellation immunity across mastered music from numerical tests. Release remains DRAFT; exact Windows artifact plus side-by-side owner physical A/B (bypass dearVR/other spatial FX) required.v2 DETAIL and editor-state reliability follow-up (source head
359c93fc)v2 field-acoustic redesign — voice/mono regression (15 Nov 2026)
Owner's physical audition REJECTED v1 as muffled/boxed vocal-mid, almost mono, weak externalization. Original V1 was registered but had no editor. P8.2 near-180° virtual speaker geometry from owner's better-sounding baseline is the anchor; DO NOT reuse P8.3 or inflate green source regression as listening success.
Root cause: v1 fixed P8.2 spread to 60°, spatialized all correlated music MID through centered KEMAR HRTF plus strong 6-wall room. Earlier tests only checked MID against that already processed P8.2 baseline, masking spectral coloration. That is now replaced by a source-direct reference and rejection gates.
Committed in v2:
ImerSipEditor.h: stage map, Concert Hall/Cinema/Live Room, Immersion, Stage Width, Venue Space, Bass Impact, Output.hasEditor=true,createEditoropens through existing FX editor host, realtime SPSC/audio-applied ACK. Saved state remains isolatedIMRSv1 32 bytes.Hard blocker: Do not release as public or claim physical improvement until exact-commit Windows build, original stereo A/B and owner's headphone FAT accept it. The previous artifact
#43652508958is rejected, do not recommend.Field fix — missing ImerSip in real FX Picker (15 Nov 2026)
The user tested the authentic Windows candidate
v0.5.0-dev+g80c0af68and the FX Picker did not show ImerSip. Root cause audited:src/NativeBuiltInFx.hguarded the registration withARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_P82_ROOM, but the compiler actually receives onlySONKU_P82_MULTIBAND_ROOM_RESEARCH=1. Thus full P8.2 builds and PCM tests passed while the native FX catalog omitted ImerSip. Fixed both native conditional gates to the REAL compiler define; no separate fake WebUI entry, DSP rewrite or rollback of existing mixer chrome.Gated end-to-end: CMake -> native FX registry ->
ConsoleWindow::emitCatalog-> bridgearMixCatalog-> existing source picker -> nativeLOAD_INSERT(no optimistic audio).ImerSipNativeJuceP82AcceptedStateAckAndRestorenow directly assertsfindNativeBuiltInFx("armix.builtin.imersip.v1"), showInPicker true and constructs the actual JUCE processor through the descriptor./preview/native picker Chromium smoke: one ImerSip row, keyword search, click -> realLOAD_INSERTintent, no speculative FX instance; screenshot artifact — PASS.29ac1ddee079e6dcfe43e495aeeda20b7d82ee53. Download ImerSip P8.2 experimental Windows portable artifact (expires Dec 5, 2026). Native FX picker visually tested in independent Chromium. This is a physical audition candidate, not a public release, commercial sound parity or hardware FAT certification.ImerSip — SonKu P8.2 music enhancement with no added phase cancellation
Owner requested FX brand ImerSip (replacing P0 research name GrandStage), preserved P8.2 bass, more alive/premium musical ambience, and no hollow/quiet stereo regression. This DRAFT stacks on research SonKu P8.2 #695, NEVER on rejected P8.3 #701 and never replaces main/approved preview without FAT.
Implemented (actual native source, not just plan)
1 + b LP120, 0..+0.85 dB), exact-same L/R coefficients, no delayed bass copy; a positive high-pass SIDE shelf (1+k HP680, k<=.20) leaves MID mathematically untouched when bass is not boosted.armix.builtin.imersip.v1catalog identity, 32-byteIMRSstate, realtime SPSC set/completion/accepted snapshot (no editor yet), opt-in research flags only.Important technical honesty
Perfectly anti-phase L/R material by definition sums to zero in mono; no transparent enhancer can make it mono-safe without changing input music. The enforced invariant is no EXTRA mono phase cancellation from ImerSip, plus bass preservation vs the exact P8.2 stereo PCM. Full mastered-music proof, loudness matched listening, true peak, p95/p99 CPU and physical ASIO/headphones are still outstanding.
Current status
DO NOT MERGE/RELEASE until P8.2 stacked history is reconciled with newer main GUI, Windows JUCE test passes, approved /preview/ is used for real editor+ACK, and owner physical A/B accepts quality.
Technical math, validation design and objective vetoes: IMERSIP_P82_PHASE_SAFE_IMPLEMENTATION_20261115.md.