Repository navigation
Closed
Description
Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17:
checkpoint/spatial/checkpoint/archived. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.Scope / release boundary: Completed historical reference; keep exact SHA and checkpoint branch immutable.
Exit criteria:
- Preserve verified P9.1/P9.2 checkpoint SHA 763706a and its branch unchanged.
- Close issue as completed reference only; do not claim the original stacked PR was merged.
Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.
Frozen engineering checkpoint — SonKu P9.1 + P9.2
Date: 2026-11-16 (Asia/Jakarta) · User-confirmed GUI screenshot v0.5.0-dev+g763706a1.
Restore references (DO NOT MOVE THE CHECKPOINT REF)
- Exact qualified source commit:
763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb - Recovery branch:
checkpoint/sonku-p91-p92-operator-confirmed-20261116; created directly from exact commit above. Never force-push or develop on this branch. - Active research branch:
research/sonku-p91-p92-fidelity-bass-reconciled-20261116at same SHA during checkpoint. - PR stack: #719 P9.1/P9.2 (draft, base research P9.0), #717 P9.0 (draft, base P8.9).
main:37985f02caecd93b22f853183888d81e18dc6736. Verifiedmain...checkpointbehind_by=0,merge_base=37985f02...; 279 commits ahead of main in the experimental ancestry. NOT merged to production.- Reconciliation merge:
ea0a7c0a5bb3afb2c4295176447c2eb78bb6835b, parentscd85ffee054dad6b3b752b5351d34921ddc92717(P9.0) and37985f02caecd93b22f853183888d81e18dc6736(current main). Preserves merged #713 ASIO/WASAPI Audio I/O continuity, GUI/operator routing, session and global FX baseline. - Exact-SHA CI: GitHub Actions run #43773841088, overall success, scoped P9 PCM preflight success, fast native contracts success, Windows JUCE GUI & five CTest success. UI Chromium smoke also succeeded. Separate historical P8.3 physical-speaker diagnostic reports failure and was already failing before this checkpoint; not proof all repository checks are green.
- Windows FAT artifact: artifact #14185078724, ZIP SHA256
2ea2a637cd8a2fd0cd7f8c148317d90eb799b4ff583388a29ac0dbe3fa8318f7, source provenance763706a1.... Artifacts expire; reproducible source/checks are preserved by the branch, not the ZIP retention period.
Confirmed at this checkpoint
- Operator confirmed latest Windows build's render-mode dropdown properly shows
P9.1 + P9.2 · MUSIC / BASSand screenshot shows stage captionP9.1 + P9.2 · MUSIC FIDELITY · WORLD BASS · ROOM MODES. This is one combined native moderenderMode=9, not separate modes. - GUI capability flag
p91p92MusicBassFoundation=trueemitted only by reconciled prepared native mode; old P9.0 can retainP9.0label. Native readback cannot make the open dropdown flicker. - P9-only direct HRIR / complementary LF crossover around 165Hz and separately positioned world-speaker low band, stereo L/R early reflections, bounded axial LF room response, legacy bass-shelf double-gain removed, protected gain. No second audio graph; no manual +7dB imposed on all sessions.
- Native 44.1/48k source PCM tested anti-phase, 70Hz head-rotation ear dominance, block parity, bounded peaks, room-off zero modes, P8.9 regression, JUCE state ACK and legacy session restoration.
- User screenshot shows test settings, not new factory defaults: Speaker Angle 82°, Spatial Mix 100%, Output Gain +7dB, Large (28.8×28.8m), source distance 1.6m, reflections 100%, reverb 62%, head yaw 0° and revolution 8.5s. These operator-adjusted settings are NOT an evidence-backed canonical factory preset; saved
.smixstates must remain honored.
Guardrails / unresolved
- Do not rewrite the checkpoint branch, merge draft [SELECTED P9.1/P9.2 AUDIO BASELINE — DRAFT] Reconciled music fidelity and world bass #719 directly into main, or overwrite UI/audio changes with old P8 branch snapshots.
- Project still lacks loudness-matched real music/headphone FAT against raw stereo/dearVR, personalized HRTF/BRIR qualification, field ASIO/device qualification and proof of physical subwoofer parity. Do not claim SonKu matches dearVR just because GUI is accepted.
- Historical P8.3 diagnostic red is tracked separately. P9-specific tested job is green; do not re-enable/alter rejected P8.3 DSP merely to force a green badge.
- On next work: 1) compare latest main and checkpoint before development; 2) create a new feature branch from the verified checkpoint if needed; 3) preserve
mainancestry and old.smixmigration; 4) run fast exact-source PCM and UI gates followed by Windows CTest/FAT; 5) only publish a newly verified artifact, keeping the prior SHA as rollback. - Field handoff and testing requirements:
docs/SONKU_P91_P92_RECONCILED_MUSIC_FIDELITY_BASS_FAT_20261116.md.
Acceptance boundary: This is a reproducible source + operator-confirmed GUI checkpoint, not a public release, irreversible merge, or acoustic/dearVR equivalence certification.
Activity
masarray commentedon Nov 16, 2026
Research-consumer link / CI clarification (2026-11-16)
This immutable operator-confirmed P9.1/P9.2 checkpoint remains pinned to commit
763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccband branchcheckpoint/sonku-p91-p92-operator-confirmed-20261116(unchanged). Active consumer ImerSip uses the same P9 PCM core through PR #722, stacked on selected PR #719. The earlier ImerSip #706 and divergent P9 trial #718 are closed as nonmerged research archives; their branches remain available. The historical P8.3 negative acoustic gate is now scoped to explicitly named P83 PR branches/manual run, rather than blocking unrelated P9/ImerSip work. Details and enforced source contract:docs/SPATIAL_AUDIO_AUTHORITY.md. Operator screenshot settings (+7dB gain, ER 100%, reverb 62%) are a listening checkpoint, not ImerSip factory defaults (0dB, ER 78%, late 33%). No changes were made to this frozen source/branch or to productionmain.