Repository navigation
SonKu P9.4 DRAFT — front/back externalization A/B while preserving 3D ellipse and accepted music baseline - #723
Conversation
…ealtime-safe 45ms smoothing
…ated native source CTest
…ty, anti-phase and block parity
…depth calibration honestly
…llback and unchanged perspective ellipse
…1 fallback and legacy guards
…-exact lateral assertion
…/rear externalization A/B rejection criteria
…h accurate provenance
Deploying arsonmix with
|
| Latest commit: |
766b8d7
|
| Status: | ✅ Deploy successful! |
| Preview URL: | https://8b988d3f.arsonmix.pages.dev |
| Branch Preview URL: | https://feat-sonku-p95-immersive-cin.arsonmix.pages.dev |
…ore opening popup
…erimental binaries
…orce level and lateral parity
…ched CTest reference/candidate
… Linux and Windows
Evidence update: exact-source Linux PCM A/B passed at
|
| rate | 0° FRONT | 90° RIGHT | 180° REAR | 270° LEFT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 44.1k | −0.3791 dB | 0.0000 dB | −0.3787 dB | 0.0000 dB |
| 48k | −0.3826 dB | 0.0000 dB | −0.3820 dB | 0.0000 dB |
ROOM OFF comparison is exact, as is P9.1/P9.2 PCM at 90/270 on these fixtures. Calculated bounded direct/early gain ratio at 0/180 is −2.544dB; this is an electrical ratio proxy, not validated acoustic DRR or headphone SPL.
Additional diagnostic finding: with operator-selected LARGE 28.8m room and 1.6m speaker radius, the current first-order horizontal wall images imply approximately 75–84ms excess propagation versus the direct sound. A physically nearer floor image is ~5ms and ceiling ~29ms at the current 1.45m height. Therefore broad late-wall energy boosting is NOT a defensible substitute for a correctly measured early binaural room response. P9.4 remains a deliberately bounded hypothesis; reject if it sounds echoey or only quieter. Do not silently widen the correction during code review; separate low-latency floor/ceiling BRIR research and HRTF/headphone personalization should follow measured headphone evidence.
Windows JUCE+CTest (including native exact-source P9.4 baseline/candidate CTest), portable packaging, acoustic hearing FAT and ASIO device check remain separate gates. GUI perspective ellipse remains unchanged from checkpoint.
P9.4 exact-source Windows portable research FAT — PASS (2026-11-16)Head Windows x64 portable artifact #14192672665. Downloaded archive Operator A/B: compare against approved P9.1/P9.2 checkpoint |
|
MILESTONE A: archived / CLOSED UNMERGED. Historical private P9.4 front/rear A/B research, superseded by listening-approved SonKu P9.9 on main #733; do not replace the correct elliptical stage. Original source branch |
SonKu P9.4 — front/rear perceived-distance A/B (PRIVATE, draft)
Reconciled baselines: operator-approved checkpoint #720 SHA
763706a15a2617a10d23b5e2e43eb5689e454ccb; GUI PR #721 SHA3648cee51bda236fd7917d04c2a3b40972d3bb17. The 148×83 SVG perspective ellipse is correct and remains unchanged. Neither main nor checkpoint was modified.Actual user defect: the speaker audio trajectory sounds flattened in the front/back direction, though the visual is a coherent circular orbit viewed obliquely in 3D. A generic KEMAR HRTF can lose front/back externalization on the median plane. This PR is an isolated acoustic hypothesis, not a geometry fix, EQ boost, headtracking claim or dearVR parity.
P9.4 private DSP A/B (requires the
ARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_P94_FRONT_BACK_DEPTHCMake option, OFF by default, P9 required):cos^4(head-relative centre azimuth)lookup, 45ms smoothing on PCM. 0°/180° = strongest correction; 90°/270° = strict unity. Zero new allocations/threads, no audio FFT, no novel output bus..smixschema remain untouched. Only a genuine opt-in native build announcesp94FrontBackDepthCue=true; GUI then truthfully displaysP9.4 · FRONT/REAR DEPTH (A/B). Older binaries retain P9.1/P9.2 label; no new selectable phantom mode.CRITICAL: Directional DRR level manipulation is only a hypothesis backed by general externalization research. Numerical values are not externally validated. If it causes audible pumping, muddy/echoey room, front/rear still near-head, bass weakening, tonal shifts or unmatched loudness, REJECT P9.4 and revert to operator-approved checkpoint. Full field listening/ASIO FAT and comparison with dearVR still pending. See
docs/SONKU_P94_FRONT_REAR_EXTERNALIZATION_FAT_20261116.md.Do not merge into main while this PR is draft or call it an acoustic fix until FAT demonstrates benefit.