Repository navigation
Description
Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17:
P2/spatial/research/research. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.Scope / release boundary: Not an alpha.26 gate; do not touch listening-approved SonKu P9.9 or Venue golden.
Exit criteria:
- Create clearly distinct own-geometry Cinema/Venue/Studio acoustic impulse/early-reflection model without copying proprietary BRIR/IR.
- Prove level-matched 0–360° front/back/distance A/B and no regression to P9.9 and Venue golden; require new operator approval.
Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.
Goal
Advance SonKu beyond P9.5's curated scene presets of a shared 28.8m room to physically distinct, credible Cinema / Concert Venue / Large Studio binaural acoustic spaces, while preserving operator-approved P9.1/P9.2 musicality and stereo separation. The complaint is auditory front/back flattening, not the approved SVG perspective ellipse.
Ground truth / checkpoints
- Operator baseline [CHECKPOINT] SonKu P9.1 + P9.2 — operator-confirmed Windows FAT, reconciled main (2026-11-16) #720 SHA
763706a1. - GUI SonKu P9.3 (DRAFT): preserve 3D perspective orbit, movable editor, native power and presets #721: correct 3D perspective ellipse, movable/power/presets.
- P9.4 SonKu P9.4 DRAFT — front/back externalization A/B while preserving 3D ellipse and accepted music baseline #723: bounded median-plane DRR experiment; alone insufficient to claim dearVR externalization.
- P9.5 SonKu P9.5 DRAFT — immersive cinema/venue scenes, powerful musical presence, bypass motion fix #725: default Signature based on operator listening references, optional native MusicalPresence and small room LF wet boost; no new independent room geometry yet.
Architectural proposal (future isolated DSP milestone)
- Calibrate front/rear externalization at 0/45/90/135/180/225/270/315°, head yaw 0/+90/−90. Separate phase/ITD/ILD spectral cues from distance/DRR. Do not use ellipse SVG coordinates for audio.
- Model genuinely distinct 3D spaces (dimensions, listener/speaker placement, wall absorption/scattering and first-order image-source early delays), separate from their late diffuse RT60 and modal LF return. Ensure 10m source distance can fit the selected geometry and that 1.6m near reference stays valid.
- Per-space calibrated speaker directivity, 40–150Hz controlled impact, measured/derived room-mode decay and late diffuse tail; high-frequency transients/vocal remain articulate, not simply louder or reverberant. Avoid false 'subwoofer cabinet' claim without measurements.
- Schema and compatibility: new typed room IDs require v12 migration or explicit opt-in capability. Unknown enum/older .smix must never silently render incorrect acoustic room. Keep old 0..3 scenes accessible to saved projects, not cluttering normal UI.
- Bounded realtime engine: prepared FIR/delay/tables, no allocations/locks on callback; single authoritative graph; 44.1/48k, mono/stereo/anti-phase; 64/128/256 buffer parity; no extra latency beyond accepted HRTF.
- Loudness matching (within ±0.5 LU for scientific comparison) separated from user-facing positive output gain. Report peak guard reduction and crest factor alongside tonal/bass fidelity.
Acceptance / rejection
- Per-scene direct/early/late impulse windows and DRR measurements, front/rear ratio, stereo cross-correlation, 30–180Hz impact/decay and per-band energy; compare against exact accepted checkpoint.
- Handset/headphones FAT with actual operator stereo musical materials: bass drum, bass guitar, vocals, cymbals, anti-phase content, slow orbit and static compass. Objectively more perceived distance without losing current musical clarity / bass punch. User A/B judgement required.
- No public 'dearVR parity', no release without native Windows/JUCE and ASIO/WASAPI field evidence. Keep PR draft until accepted.
Scope warning
Do not 'solve' this by relabeling existing Square/Chamber/Large preset buttons or boosting global EQ and master level. P9.5 is a foundation; this issue is the proper distinct-room engineering phase.
Activity
masarray commentedon Nov 16, 2026
Verified reference gap, 16 November 2026
Dear Reality's PRO 2 public documentation describes distance scaling beyond a fixed spherical plane, early reflections with separately adjustable LEFT/FRONT/RIGHT/TOP/BACK/BOTTOM returns, dedicated early/late low/high-pass shaping, master gain, bass boost, head tracking, and a catalog of physically distinct virtual acoustic environments (Studio Room, Live Stage, Live Arena, Concert Hall, etc.). Technical press material: https://cdn.uc.assets.prezly.com/152c508c-5687-430a-a7f6-52c33f005556/-/inline/no/Dear%20Reality%20-%20dearVR%20PRO%202.pdf ; public technical description: https://spaes.org/dearVR-PRO-2 .
Acoustic evidence: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13451706/ finds that adjusting frontal-source direct-to-early-reflection relationships of nonindividualized BRIRs may improve externalization, yet frontal positions can remain below lateral performance. Existing P9.4 cosine^4 correction is a bounded generic DRR hypothesis, not the stronger, angle-specific per-ear BRIR adjustment used in that study. Also https://pub.dega-akustik.de/DAGA_2018/data/articles/000252.pdf compares individual/generic HRTF, dynamic head tracking, reflections/late reverb and headphone equalization.
Implementation priority for P9.6: (a) separate physically distinct image-source room geometries and material-dependent early direction/delay/absorption, (b) independent early and late spectra and DRR based on measured direction and distance rather than just ROOM amount, (c) headphone response calibration and optional tracking-aware world/head transform, (d) bass system LF pressure and modal finite-Q room response without compromising P9.1 musicality, (e) objective impulse/correlation/spectral measurements and level-matched listener FAT. No copied proprietary BRIR assets or claims of reproducing dearVR internals.
[-]SonKu P9.6 — physically distinct Cinema/Venue/Large Studio BRIR & front–rear externalization (post-P9.5)[/-][+][P2][SPATIAL RESEARCH] Distinct Cinema/Venue/Studio geometry beyond approved SonKu P9.9[/+]