Skip to content

[P2][SPATIAL RESEARCH] Distinct Cinema/Venue/Studio geometry beyond approved SonKu P9.9 #726

Open

Description

@masarray

Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17: P2 / spatial / research / research. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.

Scope / release boundary: Not an alpha.26 gate; do not touch listening-approved SonKu P9.9 or Venue golden.

Exit criteria:

  • Create clearly distinct own-geometry Cinema/Venue/Studio acoustic impulse/early-reflection model without copying proprietary BRIR/IR.
  • Prove level-matched 0–360° front/back/distance A/B and no regression to P9.9 and Venue golden; require new operator approval.

Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.


Goal

Advance SonKu beyond P9.5's curated scene presets of a shared 28.8m room to physically distinct, credible Cinema / Concert Venue / Large Studio binaural acoustic spaces, while preserving operator-approved P9.1/P9.2 musicality and stereo separation. The complaint is auditory front/back flattening, not the approved SVG perspective ellipse.

Ground truth / checkpoints

Architectural proposal (future isolated DSP milestone)

  1. Calibrate front/rear externalization at 0/45/90/135/180/225/270/315°, head yaw 0/+90/−90. Separate phase/ITD/ILD spectral cues from distance/DRR. Do not use ellipse SVG coordinates for audio.
  2. Model genuinely distinct 3D spaces (dimensions, listener/speaker placement, wall absorption/scattering and first-order image-source early delays), separate from their late diffuse RT60 and modal LF return. Ensure 10m source distance can fit the selected geometry and that 1.6m near reference stays valid.
  3. Per-space calibrated speaker directivity, 40–150Hz controlled impact, measured/derived room-mode decay and late diffuse tail; high-frequency transients/vocal remain articulate, not simply louder or reverberant. Avoid false 'subwoofer cabinet' claim without measurements.
  4. Schema and compatibility: new typed room IDs require v12 migration or explicit opt-in capability. Unknown enum/older .smix must never silently render incorrect acoustic room. Keep old 0..3 scenes accessible to saved projects, not cluttering normal UI.
  5. Bounded realtime engine: prepared FIR/delay/tables, no allocations/locks on callback; single authoritative graph; 44.1/48k, mono/stereo/anti-phase; 64/128/256 buffer parity; no extra latency beyond accepted HRTF.
  6. Loudness matching (within ±0.5 LU for scientific comparison) separated from user-facing positive output gain. Report peak guard reduction and crest factor alongside tonal/bass fidelity.

Acceptance / rejection

  • Per-scene direct/early/late impulse windows and DRR measurements, front/rear ratio, stereo cross-correlation, 30–180Hz impact/decay and per-band energy; compare against exact accepted checkpoint.
  • Handset/headphones FAT with actual operator stereo musical materials: bass drum, bass guitar, vocals, cymbals, anti-phase content, slow orbit and static compass. Objectively more perceived distance without losing current musical clarity / bass punch. User A/B judgement required.
  • No public 'dearVR parity', no release without native Windows/JUCE and ASIO/WASAPI field evidence. Keep PR draft until accepted.

Scope warning

Do not 'solve' this by relabeling existing Square/Chamber/Large preset buttons or boosting global EQ and master level. P9.5 is a foundation; this issue is the proper distinct-room engineering phase.

Activity

  1. masarray commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    Verified reference gap, 16 November 2026

    Dear Reality's PRO 2 public documentation describes distance scaling beyond a fixed spherical plane, early reflections with separately adjustable LEFT/FRONT/RIGHT/TOP/BACK/BOTTOM returns, dedicated early/late low/high-pass shaping, master gain, bass boost, head tracking, and a catalog of physically distinct virtual acoustic environments (Studio Room, Live Stage, Live Arena, Concert Hall, etc.). Technical press material: https://cdn.uc.assets.prezly.com/152c508c-5687-430a-a7f6-52c33f005556/-/inline/no/Dear%20Reality%20-%20dearVR%20PRO%202.pdf ; public technical description: https://spaes.org/dearVR-PRO-2 .

    Acoustic evidence: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13451706/ finds that adjusting frontal-source direct-to-early-reflection relationships of nonindividualized BRIRs may improve externalization, yet frontal positions can remain below lateral performance. Existing P9.4 cosine^4 correction is a bounded generic DRR hypothesis, not the stronger, angle-specific per-ear BRIR adjustment used in that study. Also https://pub.dega-akustik.de/DAGA_2018/data/articles/000252.pdf compares individual/generic HRTF, dynamic head tracking, reflections/late reverb and headphone equalization.

    Implementation priority for P9.6: (a) separate physically distinct image-source room geometries and material-dependent early direction/delay/absorption, (b) independent early and late spectra and DRR based on measured direction and distance rather than just ROOM amount, (c) headphone response calibration and optional tracking-aware world/head transform, (d) bass system LF pressure and modal finite-Q room response without compromising P9.1 musicality, (e) objective impulse/correlation/spectral measurements and level-matched listener FAT. No copied proprietary BRIR assets or claims of reproducing dearVR internals.

  2. changed the title [-]SonKu P9.6 — physically distinct Cinema/Venue/Large Studio BRIR & front–rear externalization (post-P9.5)[/-] [+][P2][SPATIAL RESEARCH] Distinct Cinema/Venue/Studio geometry beyond approved SonKu P9.9[/+] on Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions