Repository navigation
SonKu P8.3 research: diagnose in-head stereo SIDE and design true external virtual speakers - #697
Conversation
…ode faults and measured acceptance
…e correct lateral KEMAR ear sign
… not a sound-quality pass
Deploying arsonmix with
|
| Latest commit: |
df55c0e
|
| Status: | ✅ Deploy successful! |
| Preview URL: | https://42361b48.arsonmix.pages.dev |
| Branch Preview URL: | https://feat-sonku-p83-physical-spea.arsonmix.pages.dev |
P8.3 exact-engine externalization diagnosis: direction-invariant stereo SIDE CONFIRMEDOwner's physical verdict: P8.2 music/tonality sounds good, but sources are internalized or appear above head; FRONT/RIGHT/REAR/LEFT do not resemble real external speakers. This is NOT a request to increase reverb and does not withdraw P8.1/P8.2 tonal approval. New dedicated Draft research PR #697: #697, branch New native C++ source diagnostic CI #43610825163: https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/actions/runs/43610825163 — SUCCESS with all full P8.2 compile flags. Importantly, SUCCESS means reproducibly demonstrated a defect, NOT speaker externalization passing. Measured using actual P8.2
Leading architectural cause is now source-confirmed: P7.5→P8.2 direct uses centered MID KEMAR HRTF + highpass headphone SIDE, not a physical two-loudspeaker binaural transfer matrix. Additional contributors remain unverified hypotheses: generic KEMAR frontal/rear ambiguity, ceiling/floor ER and vertical interpretation, level/DRR, head-fixed field without head tracking, headphone EQ. P8.3 strategy (documented at SONKU_P83_REAL_SPEAKER_EXTERNALIZATION_ARD_20261114.md):
Scope today: measurement test + research ARD only; NO P8.2 DSP modified, NO new Windows binary, no public release, no unproven dearVR parity claim. PR #697 Draft. Issue #683 remains open. |
|
MILESTONE A — research archival (closed, NOT merged). This P8.x SonKu research candidate is historical/experimental and is not the owner-approved P9.9 production path. The real approved main integration is #733, by selective forward-port, not by importing all earlier research commits. Original head |
Owner's verified listening
P8.2 tonality and room sound good, but still head-locked and at times above the head, not a convincing FRONT/RIGHT/REAR/LEFT speaker. This is NOT a request for stronger reverb.
Source findings
This PR intentionally changes NO shipped DSP
tests/sonku_p83_externalization_gap_diagnostic.cppcompares FRONT/RIGHT/REAR/LEFT on the exact P8.2 engine, captures horizontal ear ILD, and intentionally confirms direction-invariant anti-phase SIDE with room OFF, 44.1/48 kHz. This is a reproduction of a defect, not a sound-quality PASS.Proposed P8.3 future stages
Draft / release veto: no public merge, no claims of dearVR parity; current P8.1/P8.2 physical binaries remain unchanged. Engineering issue #683 remains open.