Repository navigation
Open
Description
Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17:
P2/spatial/research/research. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.Scope / release boundary: Legacy P7.1 XYZ exploration; not a dependency for approved P9.9/ImmerSIB release.
Exit criteria:
- Separate optional 3D XYZ admission from already-approved P9.9's two-speaker spatial orbit.
- Require source-exact native XYZ ACK/PCM tests, target-interface hardware proof and a new operator listening decision before any enable.
Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.
Remaining production qualification after P7.1 research closure
Source of truth: P7.1 PR #681, stacked P7 #679 → P6 #678 → P0–P5 #674.
Closed / source-level proven on 14 November 2026
- Measured KEMAR true 3D direct HRTF + physically consistent six-boundary reflections, native 44.1/48 kHz PCM; no new DSP authority
- P7.1 immutable quiescent control (including reset protection); original P6/default and P0–P7 negative controls pass
- Reference P7 vs P7.1 FIR: all 8 WAVs max 1 LSB; 12 native XYZ matched original stereo WAVs plus tonal/ILD/phase metrics
- Interleaved hosted Linux CPU evidence documented, not treated as ASIO qualification
- Exact P7.1 Windows MSVC core native Release CTest 2/2 PASS
- Exact P7.1 Linux native CI PASS
- P6 experimental real Windows JUCE adapter CTest 2/2 PASS
Still blocking ANY public 3D elevation / dearVR-parity claim
- Windows JUCE full mixer P7.1 user-controllable opt-in integration with approved GUI→bridge→ACK, coherent VST3+WIRE controls; no competing engine
- Backward-compatible, versioned
.smix/ FX preset 3D position schema; exact restore/readback, invalid geometry rejection, changed sample-rate/device restarts - Actual Windows ASIO 44.1/48k at 64/128/256 frames, 1/2/4 concurrent inserts, WIRE+VST3 graph, p95/p99/XRUN/continuity and no clicks
- Explicit host prepare/admission budget or bounded quality policy; no callback-time arbitrary adaptive switching, dropped HRIR taps, allocations, mutexes or per-buffer clocks
- Headphone loudness-matched blind A/B with dearVR, real music and independent listener(s): front/back, elevations, distance/DRR, nonindividual KEMAR, anti-phase artifacts, natural timbre and externalization
- Reconcile stacked P0–P7.1 drafts against latest
mainat the time of publication without rolling back GUI, Player, Guitar FX or other concurrent changes - Third-party measured MIT KEMAR attribution, redistribution notice, installer/package license and public release approval
Release policy: current public SonKu remains LIGHT/default. P7 and P7.1 are research macros only. Keep PR #681 and ancestors draft until native field and human evidence exist. This issue permits closing the old ChatGPT engineering thread without losing unfinished production gates.
Activity
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
14 Nov 2026 milestone reconciliation — P7.2 COMPLETED (source-level, unshipped)
Draft PR #685, exact head
08596bf44ab09da5ac07c1ee854a0359c36a14ba.Issue #683 remains OPEN for user-facing GUI/bridge with authoritative
.smixschema, actual Windows ASIO with multi-inserts/VST3/WIRE/XRUN, ear-tested dearVR comparison, release admission, license and stacked PR/main reconciliation. Research code is not public or merged.The P7.2 implementation thread can be closed independently without marking this entire production issue resolved.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P7.3 source/GUI bridge milestone — CLOSED; full production release gate STILL OPEN (14 November 2026)
Draft stacked PR #687 checkpoint, exact HEAD
cf34921d471836559713b52828b77ba3eb44474b.Main.cpptyped native SonKu bridge now uses the same strict codec to decode v2/v3 incoming UI edits and publish accepted v2/v3 snapshots; explicit schema v3 only under native research compile switch, normal v2 build rejects elevation fieldsStill explicitly unproven: entire Windows
ARMixConsolecompile with v3 option, actual running experimental host click/ACK/save/open.smixworkflow (rather than separately proven Chromium v2 and JUCE v3 tests), actual ASIO with 64/128/256 frames, VST3 + WIRE and 1/2/4 instances p95/p99/XRUN under real hardware, independent headphones volume-matched blinded dearVR benchmark, and package license. Keep #683 OPEN and no merge/release authorization; next milestone should target full experimental host + session qualification, not invent subjective performance.masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
SonKu P7.4 physical Windows field candidate (14 Nov 2026)
New draft PR #688 reconciles
main@baf88ddd+ P7.3cf34921dusing immutable two-parent merge9374719fe71ed310027610782515c701d71cc072, preserving latest Player/WIRE/GUI and existing SonKu native geometry. No public main merge, installer, release or default-option change.ARMixConsoleapp withARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_NATIVE_XYZ_RT=ON, scoped native JUCE v3 ACK + legacy state and exact GUI package provenance.Open release veto: hardware ASIO 44.1/48k and 64/128/256 frames with 1/2/4 inserts + WIRE/VST3, reliable real .smix save/open & device-restart qualification, actual headphone blind matched-SPL dearVR comparison, CPU admission budget, and final license/release approval. Do not close issue #683 or claim dearVR-equivalent sound because of CI success.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P7.4 exact-SHA Windows physical tester — artifact published (14 Nov 2026)
Exact PR HEAD:
c0c866db02682da2403f325c8146f90144af491cCI: full Windows experimental build and native acceptance SUCCESS
Portable Windows x64 artifact: ArSonMix-SonKu-P74-XYZ-Windows-x64-43569075876, GitHub artifact ID
14103842244, 15,055,845 bytes, retained until 2026-12-05.Independently verified on this exact commit
ARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_NATIVE_XYZ_RT=ON, pinned JUCE 8.0.15 + WebView2 SDK, fullARMixConsoleWindows x64 Release GUI compile PASS (not merely a JUCE test target).sonkuExperimentmetadata says v3 enabled, no public release or human/ASIO certification.CRITICAL: This is only a verified hardware-test candidate, NOT evidence that real ASIO load, multi-insert XRUN, .smix hardware Save/Open, subjective externalization, or dearVR parity passed. Keep PR #688 DRAFT, Issue #683 OPEN and public CMake default OFF. Perform actual field protocol before sound-quality or product-release approval.
Source: field FAT guide.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
REAL HEADPHONE FIELD FAILURE — P7.4 rejected (14 Nov 2026)
Owner has now listened to the P7.4 experimental Windows build and reports severe phase cancellation / music sounding destroyed. This is a FAILED physical audio qualification, overriding previous CI-only "test candidate" framing. The green build / three CTests / artifact SHA only established software packaging, not musical correctness. Do not recommend P7.4 artifact for live monitoring, do not promote/merge/release it and do not assert dearVR parity.
Initial source-level failure mechanisms: per-ear sum of two offset directional HRIRs can cancel components of real stereo music; MID center correction is gated by 20ms correlation evidence and may miss spectrally complex partial coherence; side-rescue is a separate phase-unaligned direct addition. P0–P7.4 synthetic stereo tests did not prove natural complex-music preservation. These are mechanisms to investigate, not a verified physical root-cause attribution without matched input/output capture.
A quarantined P7.5 research candidate is under review in draft PR #689: measured centered MID + unconditional SIDE, dedicated music-phase PCM tests, full Windows native build and headphone qualification still REQUIRED. Original production/default LIGHT must remain unchanged. Need actual dry/wet sample captures and ASIO + independent listening before any quality statement.
Issue #683 stays OPEN.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P7.5 exact-SHA experimental Windows audio candidate — CI PASS, headphone sound NOT YET PASSED
Owner’s P7.4 physical field verdict remains FAILED: severe audible cancellation. Do not endorse the old artifact as good audio.
Exact SHA
089520f43c7e9d4900d70ee9ea5b10f83d167226· Actions PASS · Windows portable research artifact (ArSonMix-SonKu-P75-Music-Safe-Windows-x64-43591146247, artifact ID14112507871, 15,056,166 bytes; retention through 2026-12-05).Verified
ARMixConsoleJUCE 8.0.15 built with both explicit research flagsARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_NATIVE_XYZ_RT=ON,ARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_MUSIC_SAFE=ON. Runtime plugin and focused P7.5 test share the compile profile, not a separate simulated engine.Still an UNSIGNED audio-quality gate
No validated physical audio improvement yet. New mode preserves stereo side but head-locking/tonal issues, intermediate MIX coloration, mono hard-left sources, multi-insert ASIO XRUNs, actual Save/Open .smix, and independent headphone dearVR A/B remain open. Source-only numeric tests cannot prove that the owner hears natural audio. Do not merge, publish as a release, or claim dearVR parity. PR remains DRAFT.
Physical test and failure reproduction guide.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
New real-listening report: P7.5 still FAILS tonal and room fidelity (14 Nov 2026)
After the original severe P7.4 cancellation and P7.5 music-safe source tests, the owner now reports P7.5 still has prominent/nasal mids, attenuated bass, unnatural consolidated stereo, and a flat/in-head room versus dearVR PRO 2. This supersedes any impression that P7.5 numeric anti-phase PASS means the audio quality problem is solved. The old P7.5 ZIP remains a CI-verified research build, not an owner-approved acoustic result.
New engineering RFC: SonKu P8 — official dearVR benchmark and measured acoustic architecture based on Dear Reality official manual and Sennheiser Clarity technical explanation, then verified against exact P7.5 code. Key issues:
Public defaults unchanged. Need captured dry/wet or controlled matched listening to validate the cause and perceptual improvement. Keep #683 open and #689 draft.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.0/P8.1 implementation and reproducible 48kHz objective spectrum (2026-11-14)
Draft PR #693 implements research-only original stereo LF pressure below a prepared 220Hz crossover, highpass KEMAR spatial direct, highpass-only stereo SIDE, and true stereo sources for 6-wall ER + late FDN. The public LIGHT/default, old V1/V2/V3 FX schema, WIRE graph and installer remain unchanged.
A real FFT-free HRIR-bank calibration
SonKuHrtfTonalCalibration.hcomputes common-ear corrective biquad coefficients inpreparefrom the 37-direction x two-ear MIT KEMAR horizontal bank. 44.1/48k measured presence cut -4.645 dB (2.2k Q .85), high-air shelf +3.306 dB (6.2k). Same coefficients for both ears, direct HRTF only; preserves L/R directional ratios without asserting a dearVR Clarity match. No per-sample trig/FFT/memory allocation.Actual native PCM response at 48 kHz FRONT, 100% wet, ROOM OFF, 0.75 trim, duplicated mono (RMS output/dry input, synthetic sine):
Important: this is objective evidence, not subjective sound acceptance, not a fully externalized stereo object renderer nor a calibrated real-room BRIR. Owner's P7.4/P7.5 poor headphone verdict stands. Physical ASIO and level-matched dearVR A/B still pending; no production/default changes. Full P8 JUCE Windows portable CI run 43603900923 is pending while this comment is written; artifact must pass integrity checks before being shared.
Keep issue OPEN and PR DRAFT; do not label "dearVR equivalent" until human listening approves actual musical tonality and room depth.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.0+P8.1 measured LF / KEMAR tonality / stereo room — Windows candidate DONE at exact SHA
Result: experimental full Windows x64 CI #43603900923 SUCCESS, exact source
d2d8fb03c82fa1d678b850ec240e435e34bfe019.Test artifact: P8-Bass-Room-Research-Windows-x64; GitHub artifact ID
14117224898, size 15,061,261 bytes, retained through 2026-12-05. Full native JUCEARMixConsoleRelease compile PASS (not just source tests). FIVE scoped MSVC/JUCE CTests PASS (v3 PCM ACK + previous state migration + P7.5 phase integrity + new P8 per-band/room evidence), PE/embedded approved GUI hashes and portable provenance/ZIP verifier PASS, hash-checked MIT KEMAR notice and P8 physical FAT instructions included. Source output measurements 44.1/48k PASS.Measured 48kHz FRONT mono ROOM OFF PCM (RMS output/dry input, .75 trim, synthetic tones): 2 kHz BEFORE P8 bank EQ 1.5207x, AFTER 0.8739x; 4k 1.3034→1.0599, 8k .1447→.1873, 63Hz remains .6702x. Room impulse generates actual post-direct reflection+FDN tail; low-L/R stereo and polarity-inverted width-60 waveform preserved in source test.
Physical release veto still OPEN: no verified ASIO audio or headphone owner acceptance of timbre and cubic room, no blinded dearVR A/B, no real music frequency-by-band capture, no 1/2/4 insert XRUN p95/p99, and P8.2 more physically calibrated room + P8.3 genuine stereo binaural source-object architecture remain open. P7.4/P7.5 feedback stays FAILED. This build is research-only, not public installer; PR #693 Draft. Public/main unchanged. Do not market as 'equal dearVR' based only on green CI.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.2 source checkpoint — real P8.1 headphone improvement preserved
Owner says P8.1 music now sounds much better than previous P7.4/P7.5, and explicitly requests further P8.2 work focused on room. The improved P8.1 Windows candidate remains available unchanged (artifact 14117224898). P8.2 is isolated on draft PR #695, no public main change.
P8.2 source commit now passes the source preflight Actions run #43607515719 at 44.1/48 kHz. New real DSP components:
P8.2 model is room-specific parametric fidelity research; do not claim perceptual dearVR parity from numerical tests. Keep Issue #683 OPEN, PR #695 DRAFT.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.2 exact-source Windows candidate — 6/6 native CTests PASS, owner headphone A/B still pending
Baseline: The owner confirms P8.1 sounds much better; it stays preserved in its independent artifact 14117224898. P8.2 is ONLY a new acoustic room model in this Draft, not a replacement for approved tonal/bass rendering.
Exact tested commit
751ff03fa27fbf1cf623eda002af50978c7888e5. Windows P8.2 CI run 43607515719 completed SUCCESS:ARMixConsolefull Release executable COMPILED (no source-only proxy)./preview/GUI assets SHA, PE provenance, portable ZIP verifier,BUILD_PROVENANCE.json, MIT KEMAR third-party notice, and P8.2 field-FAT guide hashes verified.Portable test artifact: ArSonMix-SonKu-P82-Multiband-Room-Windows-x64-43607515719, GitHub Actions artifact ID
14118867259, 15,065,808 bytes, expires 2026-12-05. Standalone tester only, no public installer.Release veto: Still requires owner headphone A/B versus P8.1 with ROOM OFF (must match) and ROOM ON 7.2/14.4/28.8; no physical ASIO XRUN/CPU p95/p99 qualification, no actual room RIR DRR/IACC/T20/T30, no proven dearVR listening parity. This is a material-based parametric P8.2, not dearVR IR/Clarity. Never merge/release this branch on CI alone; PR stays DRAFT, Issue #683 OPEN.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.3 exact-engine externalization diagnosis: direction-invariant stereo SIDE CONFIRMED
Owner's physical verdict: P8.2 music/tonality sounds good, but sources are internalized or appear above head; FRONT/RIGHT/REAR/LEFT do not resemble real external speakers. This is NOT a request to increase reverb and does not withdraw P8.1/P8.2 tonal approval.
New dedicated Draft research PR #697: #697, branch
research/sonku-p83-speaker-externalization-20261114, exact headdf55c0e958b858906f7329b61fa2df7b11f5a2d6.New native C++ source diagnostic CI #43610825163: https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/actions/runs/43610825163 — SUCCESS with all full P8.2 compile flags. Importantly, SUCCESS means reproducibly demonstrated a defect, NOT speaker externalization passing.
Measured using actual P8.2
SonKuSpatialCoreinput with hard antiphase stereo (SIDE-only) and ROOM OFF:Leading architectural cause is now source-confirmed: P7.5→P8.2 direct uses centered MID KEMAR HRTF + highpass headphone SIDE, not a physical two-loudspeaker binaural transfer matrix. Additional contributors remain unverified hypotheses: generic KEMAR frontal/rear ambiguity, ceiling/floor ER and vertical interpretation, level/DRR, head-fixed field without head tracking, headphone EQ.
P8.3 strategy (documented at SONKU_P83_REAL_SPEAKER_EXTERNALIZATION_ARD_20261114.md):
Speaker Monitormode: coherent-safe physical 2-input×2-ear speaker HRTF/BRIR matrix with consistent direct and wall images; keep existing P8.2Music Bedintact.Scope today: measurement test + research ARD only; NO P8.2 DSP modified, NO new Windows binary, no public release, no unproven dearVR parity claim. PR #697 Draft. Issue #683 remains open.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
2026-11-15 PHYSICAL HEADPHONE FAT: SonKu P8.3 research mixer candidate REJECTED by owner (quiet, hollow/boxed-in, constricted, significantly worse than P8.2). This overrides prior green Windows 8/8 CTest. Source confirms positionedMode disables P8.2 transparent bass, music-safe MID/SIDE and stereo SIDE restoration. Previous 48k anti-phase P8.2 energy 8.9678 vs P8.3 physical 1.5209 (−7.71dB) and LF480 5.4893 (−2.13dB). New 44.1k native source gate explicitly fails: physical mono −6.98dB, physical anti-phase −8.46dB, LF480 461Hz −5.67dB / mono 1703Hz −3.395dB. PR #701 labeled HEADPHONE FAT REJECTED, draft; source gate commit e40e723. Windows build now manual with source veto, no new release. P8.2 golden audio retained. Follow-up requires redesigned coherent music-safe positioned stereo, broader impulse/music measurement, and owner listening approval; not gain/reverb patch.
masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.4 stage-1 draft PR #704 now passes strict native SOURCE-only musical quality on exact head
24553abd6080c1cb4f8f237d8e0d00a29b491c11. Verified run https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/actions/runs/43640144217 : P8.2 golden bit-identical bypass, 24 cases at 44.1/48k six stereo programs room OFF/ON, 240 spectral probes, worst frequency abs 2.022dB, worst program broadband abs 0.312dB, room and yaw PCM difference. Original 18% influence FAILED -3.208dB near 5.4k; measured 12% variant passed without weakening the limit. This is an OFFLINE two-native-core study, not a mixer/ASIO or externalization achievement. P8.3 bad headphone FAT still rejected, and no new Windows portable authorized until coherent single-core externalization and actual owner listening. Sennheiser/AES references in PR docs.masarray commentedon Nov 14, 2026
P8.4 Stage 2 evidence — actual one-native-PCM-core (15 Nov 2026)
Draft PR #704 at source commit
1d9f2d702a2decbd0f19e1ff230b41e0f5de4de2, not merged to main. Owner's bad P8.3 physical FAT remains a hard rejection.Verified source CI:
tools/sonku_p84_offline_audition.cpprenders user's own WAV to four independently rendered native P8.2/P8.4 + simulated yaw0/±60 WAVs and true RMS/peak CSV. GitHub CI checks ROOM OFF/ON and float32 WAVE fact output.Containment: PR #704 is stacked on rejected P8.3 PR #701 and MUST NOT be merged through that dependency. If further measured BRIR and headphone-listening evaluation approves the concept, extract only P8.4 HRIR fusion onto a clean approved P8.2 branch with host v5/SPSC/ACK and verified world-fixed BRIR. Until then no P8.4 Windows portable, GUI control, installer or parity claim with dearVR. Owner-approved P8.2 is unchanged; no proprietary dearVR algorithm/data copied.
[-]8D-SonKu after P7.1: ASIO/dearVR headphone validation and production 3D XYZ admission[/-][+][P2][SPATIAL RESEARCH] Optional full XYZ admission beyond approved SonKu P9.9[/+]