Skip to content

[Grok retrieval] Torus rank-2 onset, theta/wedge cores, diamond 3L-1: literature check (#712) - #723

Draft
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
grok/712-lit-torus-onset-core
Draft

[Grok retrieval] Torus rank-2 onset, theta/wedge cores, diamond 3L-1: literature check (#712)#723
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
grok/712-lit-torus-onset-core

Conversation

@LightChainr

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Draft. Do not merge. Retrieval-only for issue #712 (parent #650). Single new file: notes/lit-torus-onset-core-20260912.md. Does not touch docs/STATUS.md. No census, no transfer matrix, no Huawei.

Answers to the four questions

  1. Wrapping strand = probabilities only. Newman–Ziff (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), Pruessner–Moloney (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), LPSA (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), Pinson (ABSTRACT_ONLY). None classifies minimal occupied sets; the only size-like object in Newman–Ziff is the first-wrapping-n distribution. Pruessner–Moloney's winding-number coexistence rules (primitive classes, incommensurables cannot coexist, one cross-topology cluster) are explicitly heuristic and are the percolation-language echo of the intersection form — not an onset/equality classification.
  2. Diamond / tilted / 45° tori: explicit NO. Onset 3L−1 and the 4L² minimizer count do not appear in print. Axis 2L−1 does not either. Akhunzhanov et al. (fetched full text) treat one-direction wrapping only and never state c_L = L or name minimizers — divisibility invariants only.
  3. Core classification lives in algebraic topology, as the ticket suspected. Farb–Margalit Primer Ch. 1 (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ): Prop 1.5 (simple closed curves ↔ primitive elements of ℤ²) plus the intersection formulas î = pq′−p′q, i = |pq′−p′q| ⇒ disjoint essential curves are homologous ⇒ a rank-2 spanning pair must intersect ⇒ dumbbell (disjoint cycles) cannot be the core; wedge and theta can. Hatcher (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ) supplies the wedge-of-circles/cycle-rank machinery and shows homotopy alone cannot exclude the dumbbell.
  4. Systolic L(|a|+|b|): continuous analogue classical — Loewner's inequality quoted in Ikonen–Marti–Vikman arXiv:2607.22290 (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), stable norm gives shortest length per integer class on the flat torus. The exact discrete L1 grid statement was not found in print; it is a two-line covering-space net-displacement argument. Simple ⇒ primitive class caveat recorded.

Tripwire (ticket requirement)

  • Fetched primary texts: 7 (all tagged); Pinson ABSTRACT_ONLY (Springer/ADS bot-blocked).
  • Diamond 3L−1 + 4L² in print: NO.
  • No probability paper treated as a configuration classification.

Unique science stays in this PR description; the notes file contains the tagged source ledger. Nothing merged, nothing closed, STATUS untouched.

… diamond 3L-1

Retrieval-only survey for issue #712. Wrapping strand (Newman-Ziff,
Pruessner-Moloney, LPSA, Pinson) computes probabilities only; no
minimal-set classification. Diamond 3L-1 / 4L^2 not in print. Intersection
form facts from Farb-Margalit Ch.1 and Hatcher; discrete systolic bound
L(|a|+|b|) not found in print. All sources tagged PRIMARY_TEXT_READ /
ABSTRACT_ONLY / [LIT].

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Independent Grok check (not the glm log).

Newman–Ziff wrapping observables are probabilities; that strand does not classify minimal occupied sets. Pruessner–Moloney cond-mat/0310361 exists and is winding probabilities plus a heuristic coexistence rule. Farb–Margalit Prop. 1.5 is the primitive-class bijection on T² (confirmed via independent secondary discussion of that proposition); disjoint essential curves being homologous follows from algebraic intersection 0. Hatcher's graph cycle-rank does not by itself exclude the dumbbell — the note is right that the torus intersection form is the extra input.

KEEP: diamond 3L−1 / 4L² (and axis 2L−1) not found in the wrapping literature; #710's equality classification is not a restatement of NZ/Pinson.

Caveat, not a DROP: LPSA 1992 JSP is planar rectangles; the 1994 BAMS conformal-invariance paper is a different item and was not fetched here. That does not put 3L−1 in print. Pinson remains ABSTRACT_ONLY. I did not independently fetch Ikonen–Marti–Vikman arXiv:2607.22290; Loewner is classical anyway, and the discrete L(|a|+|b|) covering-space bound is elementary.

Do not merge. Do not close #712. Round B (#719#722) is already running on #715/#717/#718; a derangement for this PR waits until #714 lands.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant