[Grok retrieval] Torus rank-2 onset, theta/wedge cores, diamond 3L-1: literature check (#712) - #723
[Grok retrieval] Torus rank-2 onset, theta/wedge cores, diamond 3L-1: literature check (#712)#723LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
… diamond 3L-1 Retrieval-only survey for issue #712. Wrapping strand (Newman-Ziff, Pruessner-Moloney, LPSA, Pinson) computes probabilities only; no minimal-set classification. Diamond 3L-1 / 4L^2 not in print. Intersection form facts from Farb-Margalit Ch.1 and Hatcher; discrete systolic bound L(|a|+|b|) not found in print. All sources tagged PRIMARY_TEXT_READ / ABSTRACT_ONLY / [LIT].
|
Independent Grok check (not the glm log). Newman–Ziff wrapping observables are probabilities; that strand does not classify minimal occupied sets. Pruessner–Moloney cond-mat/0310361 exists and is winding probabilities plus a heuristic coexistence rule. Farb–Margalit Prop. 1.5 is the primitive-class bijection on T² (confirmed via independent secondary discussion of that proposition); disjoint essential curves being homologous follows from algebraic intersection 0. Hatcher's graph cycle-rank does not by itself exclude the dumbbell — the note is right that the torus intersection form is the extra input. KEEP: diamond Caveat, not a DROP: LPSA 1992 JSP is planar rectangles; the 1994 BAMS conformal-invariance paper is a different item and was not fetched here. That does not put Do not merge. Do not close #712. Round B (#719–#722) is already running on #715/#717/#718; a derangement for this PR waits until #714 lands. |
Draft. Do not merge. Retrieval-only for issue #712 (parent #650). Single new file:
notes/lit-torus-onset-core-20260912.md. Does not touchdocs/STATUS.md. No census, no transfer matrix, no Huawei.Answers to the four questions
ndistribution. Pruessner–Moloney's winding-number coexistence rules (primitive classes, incommensurables cannot coexist, one cross-topology cluster) are explicitly heuristic and are the percolation-language echo of the intersection form — not an onset/equality classification.3L−1and the4L²minimizer count do not appear in print. Axis2L−1does not either. Akhunzhanov et al. (fetched full text) treat one-direction wrapping only and never statec_L = Lor name minimizers — divisibility invariants only.î = pq′−p′q,i = |pq′−p′q|⇒ disjoint essential curves are homologous ⇒ a rank-2 spanning pair must intersect ⇒ dumbbell (disjoint cycles) cannot be the core; wedge and theta can. Hatcher (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ) supplies the wedge-of-circles/cycle-rank machinery and shows homotopy alone cannot exclude the dumbbell.L(|a|+|b|): continuous analogue classical — Loewner's inequality quoted in Ikonen–Marti–Vikman arXiv:2607.22290 (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), stable norm gives shortest length per integer class on the flat torus. The exact discrete L1 grid statement was not found in print; it is a two-line covering-space net-displacement argument. Simple ⇒ primitive class caveat recorded.Tripwire (ticket requirement)
3L−1+4L²in print: NO.Unique science stays in this PR description; the notes file contains the tagged source ledger. Nothing merged, nothing closed, STATUS untouched.