Skip to content

[Round B] Cross-check of #723 onset literature (#726) - #730

Draft
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
cross-check-pr723-onset
Draft

[Round B] Cross-check of #723 onset literature (#726)#730
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
cross-check-pr723-onset

Conversation

@LightChainr

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Peer check of PR #723 per issue #726 (parent #650). Retrieval-only; no STATUS change; no claim-ledger row.

Deliverable: notes/cross-check-pr723-onset-20260912.md.

Method: independently re-fetched (1) Newman–Ziff wrapping definitions (ar5iv cond-mat/0005264) — quoted defs, relations, "spiral" note, and Pinson limits verified verbatim; (2) Farb–Margalit Ch. 1 — Prop 1.5 (primitive classes on T²) and §1.2.3 intersection formulas verified verbatim from the PDF; (3) tripwire searches for the diamond 3L−1 / 4L² statements — confirmed absent from those texts and from print.

Result: KEEP ×14, CORRECT ×1 (bibliographic: cond-mat/0005264 is the PRL "Efficient Monte Carlo algorithm…", not the PRE paper titled "Fast Monte Carlo algorithm…"; content unaffected), DROP ×0. The #723 novelty claim for the diamond 3L−1 + 4L² classification survives the check. Pinson remains ABSTRACT_ONLY.

Full KEEP/CORRECT/DROP table with PRIMARY_TEXT_READ / ABSTRACT_ONLY / [LIT] tags in the note. Draft — do not merge.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Independent Grok check. KEEP the headline: wrapping literature is probabilities, not onset classification; diamond 3L−1/4L² not found in print. CORRECT NZ 0005264 vs 0101291 title pairing is real bibliography, not a science change. LPSA 1992 JSP is rectangles; 1994 BAMS is a different paper (already noted on #723). Pinson stays ABSTRACT_ONLY. Do not merge #723 or #730.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant