Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
188 changes: 188 additions & 0 deletions NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

98 changes: 98 additions & 0 deletions NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,98 @@
> **Next session (85, the Paper's disclosures and the limits page): Opus 5.5 at high** (ledger S42, then S44). Reason: both
> are judgment prose on settled scores, as S41 was; nothing contested remains to read, so high, not xhigh. If the session
> runs short, S44 can move to Session 86 at the same model and effort.

# NEEC Project Handoff 84 (2026-10-21)

## 1. What changed (Session 84; ledger S67, S68, S69 and S41 done)

**S67.** Pull request #51 (Session 83) was merged on 2026-10-20 and `land-session.yml` tagged `s83`; the start-of-session
check passed (145 of 145, no difference from the captured output).

**S68, by generator, on the s83 state** (`owner_s84.py`, the layer; `apply_owner_s84.py`, the generator; the record
`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`). The owner's answers applied as the adjudication reads them: D66, Degrowth's and Participatory
Economics' C3.4 1.0 to 0.5 (decision 84.1); D67, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 1.0 to 0.5, superseding D65's hold
under 69.4 (84.2). CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4: clauses 1 and 3 had rested on "as audited (the unit's own text)"; both are now
read on the design's documents (the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba: the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis and the integrated
framework's documented ranges for clause 1; the Citizens Internet Portal paper's initiative and binding-referendum
provisions and the PTH charter template's appeal rights for clause 3); both clear, and the verdict holds at 1.0 on
decision 79.3, which governs clause 4 only (84.3). Participatory Economics' C1.2b read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (I12 item
1): its sources distinguish it from Degrowth, Integral and Mutual Credit in strength, not on the point the clause turns on
(no estimate of the wealth Gini, and a bound on the top of the distribution does not bound it), so 0.5 with a close call
toward 1.0 (84.4). I12 items 2 and 3 go to the limits page (84.6). The standing, `weighting_s83.py` (now four states) and
the evidence reports regenerated; the harness passes (v53, 148 checks).

**The standing.** CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP 16.5, first alone; Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism and Participatory
Economics 15.5; Integral, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Ostrom 15.0; no tier changes. First under all four weighting
schemes and every single-criterion drop. **With and without every owner decision** (the record, section 5): reversing any
one of 58.1, 79.1, 79.2 or 79.3 leaves CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP first at 16.0; reversing 79.4 changes only Integral and Ostrom;
reversing D66 puts Participatory Economics second alone at 16.0; reversing D67 restores 17.5. **On the readings alone**
(the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed; D66 and D67 already apply the readings) CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5,
fifth, and Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy and Participatory Economics share first at 15.5. The scores freeze at
the `s84` tag except through the push-back route.

**S69, the name (D68, decision 84.5).** One display-name mapping, `display_names.py`, used by `apply_owner_s84.py` (corpus
`display_name`, CSV, blocks), `build_evidence.py` (the reports; quotations of the v1 rationales keep their words) and
`build_site.py` (every page and data file, the visual suite included). The entry's `key` (`CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH`) and code
(`CCO`) are identifiers and do not change; `site/config.json`'s note now names five components and the earlier name. The
records of Sessions 1 to 83, and the generators that rebuild them, keep the old name; `STATE.md` (Position) says so.

**S41, Report v2.0 Part I** (`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`, about 590 KB). Ordered domain, criterion, entry. The standing,
the counts by domain and every criterion's scorecard of the 23 entries are generated by `build_report_v2.py` from the units'
readings and, for cells no unit read, the published v1 rationales (decision 52.8; harness check 148); each domain's prose,
what moved from v1 and why, the passes and failures, the close calls and what the domain does not show, is by hand. A
checkpoint was pushed after each domain. The draft is for the owner's review; it lands with S43.

**Planned, not built (D69 and its note, decision 84.7).** v2.0 lands with 23 entries; OEIAS (S70) joins in v2.1 as the 24th,
and Claude's system (S71) as the 25th, released with it. S71: the design document is published before any scoring; every
unit also goes to the outside blind reader; the Paper discloses Claude's authorship.

**Found.** Three of Nordic Social Democracy's stored readings (C4.3, C4.4, C5.4) carry unfilled template fields from
`rescoring_s48.py` to `rescoring_s50.py` ("{LAST}", "{RATIO}", "{SPEND}" and others), visible in `evidence/nsd.md` and the
Report's scorecards; statuses and scores are unaffected (decision 84.10; ledger I13; fixed by generator in S43).

The session did not stop at a limit.

## 2. Files

New: `owner_s84.py`, `apply_owner_s84.py`, `display_names.py`, `build_report_v2.py`, `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`,
`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`, `neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json`, `neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv`,
`summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json` (the Session 83 state, byte for byte), `apply_owner_s84_output.txt`,
`apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt`, `build_report_v2_output.txt`, `NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md`.
Changed: `neec_corpus_v2.json`, `neec_scores_v2.csv`, `summary_blocks_v2.json` (regenerated); `final_pass.py`
(`settled_state()`, self-test); `apply_adjudication_s83.py` (writes the s83 snapshots); `weighting_s83.py` (four states;
shared first place handled); `build_evidence.py` (Session 84's layer; the name mapping; the index's sort without a config
`short`); `build_site.py` (the name mapping); `site/config.json` (CCO's note; its `short` removed so the name comes from the
mapping); `evidence/`, `docs/` (regenerated); `run_all_checks.py` (v53, 148 checks) and its regenerated captures
(`final_pass_selftest_output.txt`, `apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt` and its negative control,
`build_evidence_output.txt` and its negative control, `weighting_s83_output.txt`, `run_all_checks_output.txt`); `README.md`
(the check count); `STATE.md` (rewritten).

## 3. Decisions

84.1 (owner, D66) and 84.2 (owner, D67): the four owner items applied. 84.3 (correction to the record): CCO C3.4 clauses 1
and 3 sourced. 84.4 (correction under the delegation): Participatory Economics' C1.2b to 0.5 by rule 4. 84.5 (owner, D68):
the name, through one mapping. 84.6 (record): I12 items 2 and 3 to S44. 84.7 (owner, D69): v2.1 brings OEIAS and Claude's
system. 84.8 (optional, tooling): the layer, the generator, the snapshots, the weighting's four states, harness v53. 84.9
(method, optional): Part I's order and its generated scorecards. 84.10 (record, I13): the template fields. Full text:
`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 7.

## 4. Ledger entries

Applied in the same session (one batch, pinned to version 51; now version 52): S67, S68, S69 and S41 `done`, moved to
`archive/neec/items`; S73 added (the Report's front matter and Part II, which the plan lacked); I13 added; I12's item 1
ticked; S42, S43, S44, S70 and S71 rewritten (S71: Claude's system the 25th entry, with OEIAS in v2.1, design published
first, outside blind reader on every unit, authorship disclosed); `pending`: four flags (review the Part I draft; the
readings-alone finding for the Paper; approve or drop S73; I12 ready to confirm once S44 states items 2 and 3); `msg`
cleared (acted on); `next` S42, S44, S73, S43; `left`, `summary`, `reads`, `watch`, `updated`, `log`. No `conf` set.

## 5. Next session (85): start here

1. `python3 run_all_checks.py > /tmp/out.txt; cmp /tmp/out.txt run_all_checks_output.txt` (no difference; about 4 minutes).
2. Read the ledger (`next`: S42, S44, S73, S43; the `pending` flags and any answers to them).
3. S42, the Paper v2.0 disclosures: the ledger's text. Sources: `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` sections 1 and 5 (the standing
with and without every owner decision, generated), `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` sections 1, 5 and 6, the Report draft's front
matter. Lead with the conflict of interest in the body.
4. S44, the limits page: `STATE.md`, Next work, open items (a) to (e); the adjudication's sections 7 to 9; I12 items 2 and 3;
the clause readings that rest on a design's own text. Then tick I12's items 2 and 3.
5. Finish as `CLAUDE.md` says.
Loading
Loading