Skip to content

About

Economic Evaluation

Resources

Contributing

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Latest commit

 

History

190 Commits

Folders and files

NameName
Last commit message
Last commit date
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Repository files navigation

NEEC: Normative Economic Evaluation Criteria

NEEC compares economic systems on one fixed set of normative criteria, so that systems as different as Nordic social democracy, Georgism and state capitalism can be set side by side, with every score traceable to stated evidence. Version 2 scores 23 systems on 26 criteria in five domains: Material Security, Human Autonomy, System Resilience, Ethical Integrity and Implementation Viability.

Status: version 2.0 in preparation. This repository holds the v2 working corpus: the scores, the scoring documents, the scoring protocol, the first blind replication and the verification harness. Version 1 (12 systems, 25 criteria) is published on the NEEC site, with its Paper and Report. Paper v2.0 and Report v2.0 have not been generated yet: NEEC_Paper_v1_4.md and NEEC_Report_v1_6.md are the latest v1.x revisions, and their Part I does not yet include eight of the 23 systems.

How a system is scored

Each criterion is scored 0, 0.5 or 1, and a 0 on any criterion counts as a structural failure. The adequacy tier depends only on the number of structural failures, not on the total: 0 to 2 failures, Potentially Adequate; 3 to 5, Partially Adequate; 6 or more, Structurally Inadequate. A higher total can therefore sit in a lower tier: Universal Basic Income (14.5/26, 7 failures) outscores Georgism / Land Value Tax (13.5/26, 2 failures) and sits two tiers lower.

SCORING_PROTOCOL.md (version 2.0-draft.9) states how each criterion is scored and what a scoring document must contain. Close calls are recorded rather than smoothed over: each scoring document registers the scores a reasonable scorer could set differently, in which direction, and what they would do to the total and the tier.

Current scores (equal weighting)

23 systems: 6 Potentially Adequate, 8 Partially Adequate, 9 Structurally Inadequate. Rank is the competition rank; = marks a tie.

Rank System Score (of 26) Percent Structural failures Adequacy tier
1 CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH 24.5 94% 0 Potentially Adequate
2 Participatory Economics 20.5 79% 1 Potentially Adequate
3= Nordic Social Democracy 19.5 75% 2 Potentially Adequate
3= Integral 19.5 75% 3 Partially Adequate
5 Degrowth Economics 19.0 73% 2 Potentially Adequate
6 Market Socialism 16.5 63% 2 Potentially Adequate
7 MMT + Job Guarantee 15.5 60% 3 Partially Adequate
8= Universal Basic Income 14.5 56% 7 Structurally Inadequate
8= Mutual Credit / LETS 14.5 56% 3 Partially Adequate
8= Ostrom-Style Commons Governance 14.5 56% 3 Partially Adequate
11= Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism 14.0 54% 3 Partially Adequate
11= State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism) 14.0 54% 4 Partially Adequate
13= Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend) 13.5 52% 2 Potentially Adequate
13= Universal Basic Services 13.5 52% 3 Partially Adequate
13= Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking 13.5 52% 5 Partially Adequate
16 Fully Automated Luxury Communism 13.0 50% 10 Structurally Inadequate
17 Doughnut Economics 11.5 44% 8 Structurally Inadequate
18 Status Quo Market Capitalism 10.5 40% 9 Structurally Inadequate
19= Centrally Planned Socialism 10.0 38% 12 Structurally Inadequate
19= Stakeholder Capitalism 10.0 38% 9 Structurally Inadequate
19= State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy) 10.0 38% 8 Structurally Inadequate
22 State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism) 9.0 35% 10 Structurally Inadequate
23 Libertarian Minarchism 8.0 31% 15 Structurally Inadequate

Source: neec_scores.csv (field definitions in neec_scores_data_dictionary.md); the score vectors are in neec_corpus.json. Tiers do not depend on weights. How the ranking responds to three alternative weighting schemes is computed by Appendix A.4's script, run_a4_full_rerun_33.py.

These totals are provisional. A clause-by-clause audit of the scores of 1.0 (NEEC_R4_MultiClause_Audit_s35.md, decision D28) found that most of those resting on a multi-clause Pass Threshold do not yet show every clause cleared. They are re-estimated in a rescoring pass before version 2.0, which can lower totals and ranks but, under that decision, cannot change a failure count or a tier. The same pass applies two rules adopted with scoring protocol draft.5 (decisions D29 and D31: how implementation failures count, and what belongs to a scored mechanism), which can turn a 0.5 into a structural failure; the two such cases identified so far, both in Ostrom-Style Commons Governance, cannot change its tier, and the pass reports any failure count it changes. The pass now also applies the v2.0 criteria (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md): 29 criteria, adding Civil Liberties and Rule of Law, Productive and Innovative Capacity and Harm Internalization, with eight thresholds restated. Unlike D28, these can change failure counts and tiers.

Disclosure

NEEC is written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, one of the scored systems (four of the five components of his Compassionism framework, scored as one system), and it ranks first (24.5/26); Claude does the scoring and the engineering. The Paper addresses this self-referential concern in its Section 10.5. The published protocol, the criterion-by-criterion evidence in the scoring documents, the registers of contestable calls, and blind replication by scorers outside the project exist so that any score can be checked and contested. The first blind replication (Ostrom-style commons governance) is recorded in NEEC_OstromCommons_replication_record.md; the next is planned for CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH itself, with a replicator outside the Claude family.

Reproducing every result

Requirements: Python 3.12 (standard library only) and, for three checks, Node.js.

python3 run_all_checks.py

This runs 148 checks. Each copies exactly the files one script needs into a fresh temporary directory, runs the script there, and compares its output byte for byte with the captured copy in this repository; negative controls confirm that the verifiers reject superseded states. The captured output of the whole run is run_all_checks_output.txt, and GitHub Actions repeats the run on every push. A finished working session reaches main by the owner's merge of its pull request, after harness.yml has run every check on it; on the merge, land-session.yml reruns every check on the merged tree and tags the session. Not covered: the prose of the Paper and the Report, and the fidelity of the Appendix G JavaScript checks to the Compassionism Simulation's source. The repository keeps every file in one flat directory because each check copies its inputs by name.

What is here

  • Data. neec_scores.csv (totals, domain scores, failures, tiers); neec_corpus.json (score vectors); criteria.json (the v2.0 criteria, 29, with their clauses and anchors; the scores above use the 26 of Paper v1.4 until the rescoring pass is applied), with criteria_schema.json and summary_block_schema.json.
  • Canonical scripts. neec_weighting_robustness_analysis_v2.py (the score vectors, weighting schemes and dominance checks) and neec_scores_csv_builder_v2.py (which builds the CSV).
  • Scoring documents. Ten systems have full scoring documents, NEEC_<System>_scoring_scratch.md; the thirteen earlier systems are scored in Paper v1.4 and carried onto the 26-criterion structure by NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md.
  • Protocol and contributing. SCORING_PROTOCOL.md; NEEC_CONTRIBUTING.md.
  • Replication. The issued blind kit (replication_kit_OS_*), the replicator's entry (NEEC_OstromCommons_replication_scoring.md), the record, and compare_replication.py.
  • Verification. run_all_checks.py and the scripts it runs, each with its captured output (*_output.txt).
  • Pinned historical states. *_sNN_snapshot.* files are byte-identical copies of files as they stood at session NN, so that each historical script runs against the corpus it was written for.
  • Working log. NEEC_Project_Handoff_NN.md, one per working session.

Contributing, citing, licence

Challenges to any score are welcome: open an issue naming the system, the criterion, the score you propose and your evidence (NEEC_CONTRIBUTING.md describes replication audits and the scoring of new systems). To cite NEEC, use CITATION.cff ("Cite this repository" on GitHub). Licensed under CC BY 4.0.

Part of the Better To Best Research Hub.

About

Economic Evaluation

Resources

Contributing

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Releases

Packages

Contributors

Languages