Skip to content

Linux: LC_BUILD_VERSION sdk is the deployment target, apps run in iOS compatibility mode (no Liquid Glass) #456

Closed as not planned

Description

@c4software

Description

On Linux, apps built with xtool dev build (SwiftBuild backend) get the deployment target written as the SDK version in LC_BUILD_VERSION:

LC_BUILD_VERSION platform 2 minos 16.0.0 sdk 16.0.0     # built against iPhoneOS27.1.sdk

iOS reads that sdk field as the SDK the app was built with. An app "built with" an SDK older than 26 runs in compatibility mode on iOS 26+: the old tab bar, navigation bars and controls instead of Liquid Glass. The same code built with Xcode 26 gets the iOS 26 design. (App Store processing also rejects such a build with ITMS-90725.)

Minimal repro: a SwiftUI app with platforms: [.iOS("16.0")] and a TabView, built with xtool dev build: sdk 16.0.0, old-style tab bar on device.

Cause

SwiftBuild links the app with swiftc -emit-executable -sdk <iPhoneOS.sdk> .... On Linux the Swift driver hands the SDK to clang as --sysroot. clang's Darwin driver reads SDKSettings.json (and so the SDK version it passes to the linker as -platform_version) only from -isysroot or SDKROOT. Without SDK info it falls back to the deployment target:

clang -target arm64-apple-ios16.0 --sysroot $SDK -fuse-ld=lld -###   →  -platform_version ios 16.0.0 16.0.0
clang -target arm64-apple-ios16.0 -isysroot $SDK -fuse-ld=lld -###   →  -platform_version ios 16.0.0 27.1

Setting SDKROOT in the build environment (in BuildSettings) is not an option: it also applies to host builds, and the package manifest link then fails (swiftrt.o looked up under the iPhoneOS SDK).

Proposed fix

The ld64.lld trampoline written by xtool setup already sits between the driver and the linker. When -platform_version <platform> <min> <sdk> has sdk == min (clang's fallback), it can put back the version of the bundle's SDK for that platform (iPhoneOS27.1.sdk → 27.1). A different, explicit SDK version is kept. PR to follow.

Environment

Host OS: Linux (Arch, x86_64), in a container

iOS device version: iOS 27

Swift version: 6.4.1 (swift-6.4.1-RELEASE)

SDK version: iPhoneOS27.1.sdk (Xcode 27.1 RC)

xtool: built from main-based source (joshuaswarren/xtool @ 7cc56c3, via omarchy-apple-dev). The trampoline and BuildSettings code involved are the same on xtool-org/xtool main (5318ebc).

Activity

  1. c4software commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @c4software
    ContributorAuthor

    Duplicate of #351, sorry for the noise: I missed it when searching. It's already fixed on main by #452 (854767c), which isn't in a tag yet. The xtool I tested with (joshuaswarren/xtool @ 7cc56c3) predates that fix, so the last line of the description is wrong: current main doesn't have this bug. Closing, and I won't open the PR I mentioned.

  2. c4software commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @c4software
    ContributorAuthor

    Correction to my closing comment: #452 is on pre/2.x (2.0.0-beta), not on main. main (1.x, 5318ebc) still records the deployment target as the SDK version: the 1.x build path doesn't have the BuildCoordinator that #452 changes. The discussion stays in #351.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions