Skip to content

Submit Binay Search -1#2474

Open
sureshb18 wants to merge 1 commit intosuper30admin:masterfrom
sureshb18:master
Open

Submit Binay Search -1#2474
sureshb18 wants to merge 1 commit intosuper30admin:masterfrom
sureshb18:master

Conversation

@sureshb18
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

Strengths:

  • The solution correctly implements the binary search algorithm for a rotated sorted array.
  • The time and space complexity are optimal (O(log n) and O(1) respectively).
  • The code is clean and well-commented.

Areas for Improvement:

  • The student should ensure that only the solution for the requested problem is submitted. Including unrelated code (like BinarySearch1.java and BinarySearch3.java) can be confusing and is unnecessary.
  • While the comments are helpful, they could be more specific to the problem. For example, explaining why we check if the left half is sorted and how that helps in deciding the search direction would be beneficial.
  • The code in BinarySearch2.java has a typo in the class name (it should be "BinarySearch2" but is written as "BinarySearch2" in the code snippet provided). However, this might be a transcription error in the submission.

Overall, the solution for the rotated sorted array search is correct and efficient. Keep up the good work, but remember to focus on the specific problem when submitting solutions.

@sureshb18
Copy link
Author

Strengths:

  • The solution correctly implements the binary search algorithm for a rotated sorted array.
  • The time and space complexity are optimal (O(log n) and O(1) respectively).
  • The code is clean and well-commented.

Areas for Improvement:

  • The student should ensure that only the solution for the requested problem is submitted. Including unrelated code (like BinarySearch1.java and BinarySearch3.java) can be confusing and is unnecessary.
  • While the comments are helpful, they could be more specific to the problem. For example, explaining why we check if the left half is sorted and how that helps in deciding the search direction would be beneficial.
  • The code in BinarySearch2.java has a typo in the class name (it should be "BinarySearch2" but is written as "BinarySearch2" in the code snippet provided). However, this might be a transcription error in the submission.

Overall, the solution for the rotated sorted array search is correct and efficient. Keep up the good work, but remember to focus on the specific problem when submitting solutions.

In the PR link we have 3 problems mentioned, so added all the problems in one repo
https://github.com/super30admin/Binary-Search-1

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

Strengths:

  • The solution correctly implements the binary search algorithm for a rotated sorted array.
  • The time and space complexity are optimal (O(log n) and O(1) respectively).
  • The code is clean and easy to understand with clear comments.

Areas for Improvement:

  • The submission includes multiple files that are not relevant to the problem. For future submissions, ensure that only the solution for the specific problem is provided to avoid confusion.
  • The comments in the code are somewhat generic and could be more specific to the problem. For example, explaining why we check if the left half is sorted and how that helps in deciding the search direction would be beneficial.
  • The class name "BinarySearch2" is not descriptive. It would be better to use a class name that reflects the problem, such as "SearchInRotatedSortedArray".

Overall, the solution is correct and efficient. Great job!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants