Skip to content

h5p-author: the record of #212's runs is wrong in three places, and route 3 fails where either file does not arrive #213

Closed

Description

@alekswebnet

A review of #212 after it merged found mistakes in what it recorded, and one loose sentence in the skill.

The record, design/author.md:

  • It says one Grok-like Haiku run "tried the verifier's npx first, which hung for the code tool's 110 seconds". That npx was a check I ran in the run's folder while setting the lab up, found in the folder's npm log and taken for the run's. The run's own commands show what was slow: it ran route 1's find / for an archive nobody had attached, to the code tool's limit on this computer's disk.
  • It says four spoiled runs were not counted. Three were. The fourth run of that batch never reached npm's cache or the real registry, and is one of the three counted.
  • It does not say that both offline runs tried the two files before the json block, which is what the fix is for, nor that one of them ran no npm check.
  • It gives the cost in a sandbox that reaches nothing as "about a second". That holds where the network refuses, as in the lab. Where it hangs, the fetch waits for the limit the model gives it, 10 to 90 seconds in the runs' own commands. A hanging network was not measured, nor ChatGPT, where route 4 now comes after the npm check and a fetch.
  • The section's first line counts "Twenty-nine things" and fix(author): route 3 tries the two files wherever Node runs, whatever the code tool says about the internet #212 added the thirtieth.
  • An older bullet says Grok takes the zip "under Skills, then Import". Grok has no place to install a skill (the owner, 2026-11-15): it reads the zip attached to a message.

The skill, references/build/two-files.md: "Where neither file arrives, this route has failed" leaves out the case where one arrives and the other does not. The build needs both.

README.md: it says Claude and Grok take one zip and ChatGPT's Plugins another. The line should not count zips: the guide it links to says which file goes where (missing-elements/missing-elements.github.io#62 makes it one).

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions