Skip to content

SonKu P9.8 DRAFT — lock goosebump Venue; flagship Signature, Cinema bass and Live Studio polish - #729

Closed
masarray wants to merge 4 commits into
feat/sonku-p95-p96-p97-stage-20261116from
feat/sonku-p98-signature-cinema-studio-voicing-20261116
Closed

masarray wants to merge 4 commits into
feat/sonku-p95-p96-p97-stage-20261116from
feat/sonku-p98-signature-cinema-studio-voicing-20261116

Conversation

@masarray

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

P9.8 PRIVATE — operator-approved Venue checkpoint, scene-specific flagship tuning

Owner headphone feedback (2026-11-16): Venue Mega Space is already excellent / goosebumps — FREEZE IT. Cinema needs substantially more tight bass, Live Studio just a little, vocal/instrument center presence slightly higher, Signature should be more compelling than Venue especially in musical clarity rather than just level.

Golden audio checkpoint and isolation

  • Immutable Venue P9.7 branch at exact fda0eef669e0a59575c489e149662c1bf878c998.
  • P9.7 unchanged on PR SonKu P9.7 DRAFT — concert bass impact, external center presence & early air #728; this candidate is its direct child. Main/public installer and competing P9.5 branches untouched. P98 opt-in ARMIX_SONKU_EXPERIMENTAL_P98_SCENE_VOICING=OFF by default.
  • Venue uses all existing full-scene numbers unchanged: 10m, spread 106°, roomAmount=1, ambience=1, outputTrim=1.8, spatialMix=1. Native voicing ID 0 returns exact original P9.7 PCM. Live Orbit also neutral.

Reliable design

  • Replace fragile implicit preset detection with explicit typed sceneVoicing values 0 neutral/Venue, 1 Signature, 2 Studio, 3 Cinema. Refuse invalid IDs; send native ACK and truthful readback. Old native v11 client never accepts speculative v12 property. Saved older v1–v11 scenes restore to neutral; no silent preset or .smix overwrite.
  • P9.8 state version v12, append-only 67B; old 63B v11 accepted intact. Separate Windows JUCE test for older/invalid/reopened v12. A deliberate private schema step is necessary to make preset-specific DSP maintainable; not a public ABI mutation.
  • A single fixed-memory native real-time class SonKuP98SceneVoicing.h enters original same KEMAR world speaker graph. Preset center-panned 2.05kHz details pass through two speaker HRIRs; low-Q 86Hz kick + broad 130Hz body, and stereo-ear spatial 5.2kHz early air. Bass/center final stage is after P9.5 adaptive makeup and before existing linked 0.98 peak guard. No stem separation, fake Haas, sub oscillator, extra JUCE FX, or crossfeed. Gain parameters smooth 55ms.
Scene Bass Center clarity Air
Signature 3.1m Strongest boutique punch/body Rich, gently forward Clearly rendered first images
Large Studio 4.8m Subtle A little more articulate Subtle
Cinema 7.5m Significantly more impactful Mild Modest
Venue 10m UNCHANGED P9.7, id=0 UNCHANGED UNCHANGED
Live Orbit unchanged unchanged unchanged

FAT gates

  • tests/sonku_p98_scene_voicing_source_test.cpp 44.1/48k stereo anti-phase/no-stem, finite, exact neutral.
  • tests/sonku_p98_integrated_scene_test.cpp vs actual P9.7 source (without P98 feature), with real factory wet/distance/gain at 44.1/48k, front & back. scripts/verify_sonku_p98_scenes.py requires exact per-sample hash at full-wet Venue plus 0%-MIX and ROOM OFF, and bounded LF/voice gains on the other scenes.
  • Windows real JUCE v12 native ACK/readback/corrupt/old v11 restoration, Chromium UI and artifact provenance gated by exact SHA. No merge/release without operator headphone FAT and loudness-matched Signature-vs-Venue/Cinema-vs-Venue listening.

Limit: spectra are engineering metrics, not a proof that Signature is subjectively superior to Venue or that center presence genuinely extracts vocals as stems. Reject if vocals become nasal, kicks pump the limiter or stage collapses.

See docs/SONKU_P98_OPERATOR_VENUE_CHECKPOINT_AND_VOICING_FAT_20261116.md.

@cloudflare-workers-and-pages

cloudflare-workers-and-pages Bot commented Nov 16, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Deploying arsonmix with  Cloudflare Pages  Cloudflare Pages

Latest commit: 4a9e5b2
Status: ✅  Deploy successful!
Preview URL: https://3b22efbb.arsonmix.pages.dev
Branch Preview URL: https://feat-sonku-p98-p99-vocal-dep.arsonmix.pages.dev

View logs

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

P9.8 checkpoint audit & source qualification at 2f21933

Operator approval: Venue · Mega Space P9.7 is the accepted "merinding" sound. Frozen branch checkpoint/sonku-p97-venue-mega-space-approved-20261116 at fda0eef669e0a59575c489e149662c1bf878c998. No changes to original P9.7 PR #728 or Venue preset numbers.

Exact-head preflight: Actions run #43828402066. Linux full source C++ tests SUCCESS, Fast native contracts SUCCESS; Chromium native SonKu editor and UI smoke SUCCESS on #43828402149. Windows actual JUCE schema v12 / portable build pending at time of this note.

Measured exact-scene PCM A/B vs P9.7 with real full-wet room settings at 44.1/48k, front 0° / rear 180°, with unchanged source level:

  • Venue 10m (ID0): bit-identical PCM/FNV sample hashes in all four conditions. ROOM OFF and MIX=0% also bit-identical. This is the top gate: owner-approved Venue sound did not change.
  • Signature 3.1m: 86Hz band component 1.276x, center 2050Hz 1.374–1.386x, treble7500Hz 1.007–1.020x. Flagship preference not proven until level-matched headphone FAT.
  • Large Studio 4.8m: bass 1.0865x, center 1.075–1.077x, treble 1.006–1.010x (subtle).
  • Cinema 7.5m: bass 1.2565x, center 1.134–1.136x, treble 1.011–1.022x.
  • Peak guard PCM <=.9805 in all scene renders; isolated voicing anti-phase, finite, coefficient stability also passed.
  • No real vocal isolation: center-panned instruments get the same tonal lift. Signature objective spectral improvement is not a proof of perceptual musical superiority, yet.

Additional UX correction in final HEAD: new native P9.8 SonKu inserts start with its actual sceneVoicing=1 Signature factory program; older v11 accepted sessions restore neutral sceneVoicing=0 by default. JS source-bound test tests/sonku_p98_gui_contract_test.cjs enforces mappings, unchanged Venue values, capability readback and older v11 downlevel behavior. Extra P9.8 dedicated v12 native JUCE state test includes v11 migration, invalid enum, corrupt v12, 67B round-trip, ACK and device repreparation.

Not a release: Windows JUCE FAT and owner headphone test still gate promotion to approved build.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

P9.8 red-CI audit & remediation — 2026-11-16

Exact current head: 4a9e5b2c455818c7a0dc8507ec2b7863be215033. Approved Venue checkpoint remains fda0eef669e0a59575c489e149662c1bf878c998, unchanged.

Root cause 1 — genuine v12 restore admission defect

Earlier Windows run 43828402066 compiled successfully but failed 1/11 CTests at sonku_p90_native_juce_v11_test.cpp:299. Under P9.8 schema v12, a corrupted stored renderMode=2 paired with neutral sceneVoicing=0 was not rejected because v11's explicit mode whitelist did not cover v12. Fixed in commit 6e13289: one coherent permitted-mode gate for current DSP settings + native JSON/queue + versioned v11/v12 state restoration; additional negative tests for both retired P8.3 modes 1/2. After fix, Windows run 43835172308 completed SUCCESS, including actual JUCE CTest and portable package (artifact ID 14210383494).

Root cause 2 — legacy P8.3 known rejected research polluting P9.8

Run 43828402288 failed REJECTED_LOW_ENERGY_OR_SPECTRAL_HOLE in the older, operator-rejected P8.3 physical-speaker research. Its strict test is NOT removed or turned into a pass. It remains hard-failing when explicitly run on a P8.3 research branch or manual dispatch. P9.8 rejects all such obsolete modes. Latest P9.8 job is appropriately SKIPPED.

Root cause 3 — actual malformed YAML zero-job runs

GitHub displayed Invalid workflow file: sonku-p89-windows-field.yml#L346 on run 43835166813. Both P8.9/P9.0 workflow files contained an accidentally concatenated second Windows build/test sequence, with a stray shell if ($LASTEXITCODE) inside the upload-artifact with mapping, and malformed quoted CTest. Fixed on commit 4a9e5b2: true standalone P8.9 v10 legacy job, P9.0 v11 job, one artifact each, proper PowerShell regex quoting, branch-scoped historical field FAT (no repeated heavyweight Windows builds), plus scripts/verify_sonku_legacy_workflows.py in the existing fast P9 preflight. New runs P8.9 #43836593970 and P9.0 #43836594026 are both properly interpreted by GitHub and SKIPPED on this newer P9.8 PR, not YAML failures.

Release guard

The latest exact HEAD still requires its full Windows/Chromium workflow (P1 #43836593905, UI #43836594009) before release. Old 6e13289 actual JUCE pass is independently retained as evidence of the DSP-state repair. Do not merge into main or alter the approved Venue until user headphone FAT confirms Signature/Cinema/Studio actual sound. See docs/SONKU_P98_CI_ROOT_CAUSE_RECOVERY_20261116.md.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Milestone A — ARCHIVED / CLOSED UNMERGED (no code merge or branch deletion). This P9.8 candidate is earlier stacked research, with selected acoustic decisions superseded by listening-approved P9.9 main #733. Venue golden remains protected.

Immutable original head: 4a9e5b2c455818c7a0dc8507ec2b7863be215033. Original source branch: feat/sonku-p98-signature-cinema-studio-voicing-20261116; original PR target: feat/sonku-p95-p96-p97-stage-20261116. Full 47-PR source-head inventory: docs/governance/MILESTONE_A_PR_BRANCH_RECONCILIATION_20261117.md on chore/milestone-a-pr-history-20261117 (planned for main). Closing this review surface is not proof of importing every experimental commit and is not permission to retune released SonKu or ImmerSIB. All branch refs, checkpoints and original code are preserved. Reopening requires a new, precisely scoped owner-approved reason.

@masarray masarray closed this Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant