Skip to content

P0 approved /preview/ — qualify native GUI parity and authoritative PCM readback #389

Closed as duplicate

Description

@masarray

CURRENT CHECKPOINT — 2026-11-08 (main c57720ea25585c861af89802e1365ffef7d03d17)

Single public/native renderer implemented and protected by current main. Merged #418, #440, #442 and later approved GUI/bridge changes produce ONE /preview/ display with generated Pages/native WebView assets; legacy preview URLs are redirect-only. #393's 106-file competing physical-source migration was archived rather than bulk merged. Still open for acceptance: actual native visual/interaction parity across operator states, authoritative PCM/FX/WIRE readback on hardware, and source maintainability improvements without a second renderer. Retired #270/#397 must not re-impose multi-agent coordination.


P0 — Stitch the only approved /preview/ GUI into native JUCE

FINAL USER DECISION 2026-11-04: https://masarray.github.io/arsonmix/preview/ is the ONLY approved GUI. The earlier /preview-v2/ claim was wrong and is revoked. Only one public preview and one Windows GUI may exist. Do NOT design a new native screen, substitute old web/index.html/web/mixer-layout.js/web/console-native.*, ship bare /preview-v2/, or fork the GUI. The engine follows the finished GUI.

Provenance: preserve exactly what user approved

The currently-approved /preview/ previously loaded ../preview-buttons/index.html in an iframe. It is assembled by scripts/build_pages.py from internal site/preview-v2/index.html plus all its WIRE/FX/fader/meter styles/assets, but specifically overrides hardware button CSS/JS/PNG with site/preview-buttons/assets/mixer-control-keys.css, mixer-control-keys.js, mute-solo-pfl-56x37.png. Bare /preview-v2/ is visually wrong; do not bundle it into Windows. Internal directories are build inputs only, not alternative product UIs.

Deliver one publication and one native GUI

  1. Pages source consolidation: publish generated approved HTML and assets DIRECTLY at /preview/ (no competing iframe or alternate page); redirect any old /preview-v2/, /preview-buttons/, archived Vxx public routes to that URL, with no second renderable GUI. Add fail-closed test comparing generated /preview/ HTML to current source with exact approved PNG-button revisions and verifying redirect-only legacy URLs.
  2. Native WebView2 exact parity: deterministic reuse of the exact same assembled /preview/ artifact and CSS/JS/SVG/PNG assets, with SHA256 manifest and CMake BinaryData+ResourceProvider mapping. Actual Windows EXE screenshot/gesture parity at 1366x768, 1680x900, 1920x1080 across density, selection, WIRE fold, FX rack and bank states. A static HTML mock is not native proof.
  3. Thin accepted native adapter: keep renderer/layout; replace simulated authority with real v8 schemaVersion=6 arMixConsoleSubscribe/Snapshot/Intent/Ack, canonical decimal-string uint64 ChannelId/EdgeId/epochs/revisions, matching ACK then later accepted same-revision snapshot, rejection/stale rollback. One accepted graph powers WIRE/OUT/MAIN/Scenes/Undo, meters/FX/faders; no fake LIVE.
  4. One reliable engine: ENGINE PR [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 & WIRE WIRE C2: public v8 ACK edits real native PCM and matches accepted EdgeId snapshot #387 keep ONE installed JUCE PCM graph/callback, ONE VST3 lease/editor and hardware pin truth, off-thread graph prep and RT-safe publish; no new GUI. Preserve CH1 vendor, 10CH+4AUX, Show and physical hardware during migration.
  5. FAT [INTEGRATION/FAT v7 G0] Canonical JUCE WebView ACK/PCM evidence and exact-SHA release gate #270: one exact Windows SHA with approved GUI bundle manifest/hardware button checks + actual screenshot parity and native PCM/VST3/ASIO/WASAPI/0FX-crackle P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15 evidence. No premature UAT. Physical hardware unavailable = pending, not product ready.

Definition of done: installed Windows mixer displays exactly /preview/ including approved PNG buttons; all controls accurately operate real native PCM/VST3, no second GUI or DSP, with one combined exact SHA and verified FAT.

See root AGENTS.md, PRD/ARD WIRE-FIRST and canonical handoff. Source code path site/preview-v2 is temporary internal base and does not authorize a second public page.

Activity

  1. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    Root-cause audit — prior GUI threads rebuilt a competing renderer (2026-11-04)

    Code evidence from actual repo (not screenshot inference):

    1. main/CMakeLists.txt currently embeds web/index.html web/styles.css web/app.js web/mixer-layout.js ...; main/src/Main.cpp::assetFor("/") serves BinaryData::index_html. No production executable binding to current site/preview-v2/**.
    2. ENGINE sole owner PR [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 changes CMake to web/console-native.html/.css/.js and Main.cpp::assetFor("/") to BinaryData::consolenative_html. This is a parallel visual renderer, not a native adapter of the approved GUI. Do not ship this UI even if Windows CTest passes; extract only verified engine/bridge logic.
    3. GUI PR GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 edits web/index.html, web/mixer-layout.js/.css, web/styles.css (legacy workbench DOM); it does not turn current main site/preview-v2/index.html into the compiled native entrypoint. Still-open stale draft INTEGRATION (DRAFT): approved M3 Console in native JUCE, real snapshot/intent path — universal still blocked #356 attempted a source copy from an older M3 revision, but cannot substitute for deterministic build from latest approved main source.
    4. Existing green release gates certify the WRONG GUI: scripts/verify_native_windows_artifact.ps1 demands SHA256 of web/index.html, web/app.js, web/styles.css; tests/native_artifact_packaging_contract_test.mjs asserts BinaryData::index_html; scripts/check_console_puzzle.mjs --release reads web/mixer-layout.js. Therefore green Windows/GUI CI is not proof of the operator-approved Windows screen.
    5. The earlier AGENTS.md at 9d78b453 instructed GUI GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 to reproduce PR V17 — Magnetic OUT→IN Wire Patch Bay: stable controls, soft curves & snap (GUI reference) #278 instead of using the actual site/preview-v2 DOM and assets. Past GUI resume prompts repeated the GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 Packet C owner without insisting on exact native source identity. Both instructions and agent implementation contributed.
    6. URL nuance: site/preview/index.html uses ../preview-buttons/index.html iframe. scripts/build_pages.py derives that variant from site/preview-v2 while replacing mixer-control-keys.css/.js with site/preview-buttons/assets/ versions. For screenshot acceptance, confirm the user-approved deployed URL + button skin; locking preview-v2 source without preview variant parity may still differ from the specific /preview/ screen the owner saw.

    Required fail-closed remediation: treat this as P0 release blocker. The next Windows binary must be generated deterministically from the exact approved Pages GUI and all assets, with SHA256 manifest/ResourceProvider provenance, rendered WebView2 screenshot parity (bank/density/expanded+folded), accepted-v8 snapshot/ACK binding and genuine native PCM + VST3 FAT. Add a release test that rejects compiling either web/index.html legacy or web/console-native.html as the operator UI. Update contradictory native_artifact_packaging_contract_test.mjs, verify_native_windows_artifact.ps1 and check_console_puzzle.mjs together; do not disable audio/driver protections or call Pages SIMULATION LIVE. Keep prior old renderer branches unmerged.

    Owner clarity: issue #389 alone owns the exact GUI-to-JUCE stitch; #266 remains audio PCM backend; #270 joined FAT. Do not create another GUI renderer or start another alternative PR. This comment records audit findings; native source/binary migration is NOT implemented by the comment.

  2. changed the title [-][P0 SINGLE GUI] Stitch approved /preview-v2/ into native JUCE — no alternate renderer[/-] [+][P0 ONE GUI] Integrate ONLY approved /preview/ into native JUCE; remove alternate previews[/+] on Nov 4, 2026
  3. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    P0 #389 IMPLEMENTATION STATUS — approved /preview/ native JUCE source stitch

    Real implementation is underway in DRAFT PR #392, current head a4d2e565205ac5afd124a8e4fe04fe46d59e002b.

    • ONE GUI source: scripts/build_approved_native_gui.py calls the production scripts/build_pages.py to assemble the exact approved /preview/index.html plus its PNG-button CSS/JS/assets, then adds only an invisible approved-native-bridge.js bootstrap with audioReady:false. No separately designed console, no copied outdated M3 mock.
    • CMakeLists.txt compiles only generated approved_gui/index.html and its complete resources into JUCE BinaryData; src/Main.cpp dispatches only through generated ApprovedGuiResources.h, not old web/index.html or web/console-native.html.
    • SHA256 build manifest + independent PE/ZIP source-asset verification (including byte-for-byte PNG); old tests that REQUIRED legacy renderer are inverted to forbid it, while engine/device tests are retained.
    • Exact-head Chromium PASS: #41824823787. Windows provenance preflight, JS native contracts, JUCE configure PASS. Full MSVC executable/RT CTest still compiling: #41824823837.
    • NOT DONE / STOP-SHIP: actual EXE screenshot parity, accepted v8 native snapshot/ACK/channel IDs, real WIRE PCM/VST3 UI binding, physical P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15 crackle, joined Windows packaging verification. PR kept DRAFT and NOT merged. M1 source stitch is real code, not a claim of live product.

    Do not reintroduce another GUI in engine or GUI PRs; continue M2 binding accepted native control state to this exact existing DOM after M1 compile proof.

  4. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M1 exact-source Windows native build evidence — VERIFIED @ a4d2e565205ac5afd124a8e4fe04fe46d59e002b

    • DRAFT PR #392 code now uses one assembler scripts/build_pages.py for native /preview/, with approved PNG skin. The Windows src/Main.cpp WebView ResourceProvider uses only generated approved GUI assets; old web/index.html and web/console-native.html no longer compiled as native product.
    • Windows CI run #41824823837: SUCCESS; exact commit CMake configure, JUCE Windows GUI EXE/MSVC build, full native realtime CTest, plus independent byte/SHA256 bundle preflight and JS contract tests all PASS.
    • Chromium UI run #41824823787: SUCCESS at exact same SHA. No visual redesign or native DSP change.
    • Release pending: actual compiled Windows executable screenshot parity, native accepted v8 WIRE/FX/fader/meter ACK + same-revision snapshot binding, PE ZIP packaging verifier (not run for ordinary draft PR), hardware P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15 crackle and two-VST3 FAT.
    • Keep PR DRAFT / not merged until M2/M3 producer/consumer are actually connected and physical/evidence gates qualified; do not call the visual source proof an audio-live product.

    Next owner work should consume approved GUI as-is; no parallel renderer, leverage ENGINE #266 + #387 rather than duplicating PCM.

  5. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    ENGINEER AUDIT — actual GUI→native readiness, main@8beeccabdea8 (2026-11-04)

    Verdict: M1 visual asset embedding established; native control/state integration M2 is NOT DONE. This is source-read audit (no customer hardware or Windows screenshot claim). Approved frontend is ONLY assembled /preview/ with PNG buttons.

    Evidence from actual main

    • scripts/build_approved_native_gui.py calls ONE scripts/build_pages.py assembler and embeds exact /preview/ HTML/assets + nonvisual bridge into CMake BinaryData; src/Main.cpp uses generated ApprovedGuiResources.h. tests/approved_native_gui_bundle_test.py confirms byte-matched Pages/native visual assets and deliberately asserts adapterState = SCAFFOLD_ONLY__NOT_LIVE_PCM.
    • web/approved-native-bridge.js only sends arMixGuiReady, declares acceptedGraphConnected=false/productionCallbackLive=false. No ConsoleSubscribe, ConsoleSnapshot, ConsoleIntent or ConsoleAck listeners/dispatch. src/Main.cpp registers ONLY arMixGuiReady, arMixParameter, arMixAction, NOT v8 events. Existing old native commands are index/M4-specific.
    • site/preview-v2/index.html is internal visual source: local tracks/wireEdges/nextWireId numeric state; wireGraphCommit immediately mutates JS graph; fader input/format/mute/solo and plugin rack often mutate JS state; animateMeters generates sine-based demo meter values; saveScene/recallScene clone local browser objects. It is NOT a native-accepted state machine.
    • Critical: fxNativeTransactionRequired checks window.chrome?.webview?.postMessage or window.arMixConsoleIntent, not window.JUCE.backend; in JUCE WebView2 with just current native seam this may fail to block browser-only FX mutation.
    • contracts/console-puzzle-v8.json schemaVersion 6 has accepted graph edges[], mainChannelId, stable decimal-string ChannelId/EdgeId, deviceEpoch/baseGraphRevision/baseRosterRevision + requestId, ACK and later matching accepted snapshot. No source/consumer deployment yet.
    • Current standalone release static gate scripts/check_approved_native_gui_release.mjs expects web/approved-preview/{index.html,native-manifest.json}, but actual native generator produces build/approved_gui/{index.html,approved-gui-manifest.json}; scripts/check_console_puzzle.mjs --release still checks old GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 web/mixer-layout.js/obsolete src/ConsoleLiveBridgeV6.h (not on main). The release gate MUST be updated to actual M1 generator and v8 adapter; do not weaken it to pass.
    • M4 native src/Main.cpp already has arMixParameter/action, VST3 catalog/insert/bypass/editor, source routing, audio device inventory/apply, Main/monitor and Show operations. These are reusable real native backend functions, but old action names, numeric channel identity, ack schemas and capabilities are NOT the approved GUI v8 contract.
    • ENGINE [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 / WIRE WIRE C2: public v8 ACK edits real native PCM and matches accepted EdgeId snapshot #387 own real universal ChannelId callback/accepted PCM transition. WIRE C2: public v8 ACK edits real native PCM and matches accepted EdgeId snapshot #387 is a native C++ simulated-device impulse/EdgeId test, not a released physical Windows GUI.

    Exact bridge points — implementation owners

    1. BOOT: WebView arMixGuiReady → native initializes one v8 subscribed snapshot; no demo LIVE; return capabilities, device epoch, true outputArmed/readiness.
    2. IDENTITY: separate GUI viewIndex/bank label from canonical uint64-string ChannelId, EdgeId and insertId; never Number() 64-bit IDs. Same page renderer/CSS.
    3. PARAMETER: fader/pan/mute/solo/phase/MAIN gain to bounded native RT parameters; drag coalesced; readback reconciles without jitter. Unsupported disabled. Native meter data must be atomics/real PCM, not animateMeters synthetic.
    4. WIRE: all output/incoming/Main fragments, Matrix/Navigator, direct connect/replug, tap/gain, undo/scene use accepted native graph.edges[] and APPLY_WIRE_TRANSACTION. Gesture preview local only; commit after matching requestId+epoch/revision ACK and subsequent same-revision accepted snapshot. Protect exact MAIN EdgeId and stale rejection. Cycle/duplicate safety enforced native.
    5. DEVICE: input/output selector from verified enabled JUCE ASIO/WASAPI endpoint mask, source processing Mono/Stereo separate from physical pin count, guarded arm/disarm/hotplug. No made-up pins or auto-ARM.
    6. FX: catalog from real VST3 scan, stable native instanceId on channel insert, add/remove/bypass/reorder/open vendor editor, true latency/PDC and late ACK. Block preview demo insert mutations in native mode.
    7. SHOW: native Show save/recall/sceneSafe/Undo revision-aware atomic graph+FX+ports restoration, never browser-only clone.
    8. MONITOR/CUE: native independent endpoint and truthful solo/PFL/cue, not MAIN-only visual toggle.
    9. TELEMETRY: native actual per-channel/Master peak RMS/clip (and stereo), raw/device status/xruns at bounded cadence; GUI only interpolates last accepted sample, no sine generator.
    10. FAIL-CLOSED RELEASE: update --release checks for actual CMake-generated approved_gui manifest; test producer C++ v8 fixture→same GUI bridge→FAT, Windows EXE screenshot parity to /preview/, actual PCM routing impulses and real VST3, ASIO/WASAPI crackle P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15, one exact SHA.

    Minimal fast product milestone

    Deliver ONE IN1 verified physical/source → CH01 fader/mute/PAN → committed CH01→MAIN WIRE → real MAIN PCM + native meter + persistent Show on the actual approved GUI. All other controls remain honestly UNAVAILABLE until capabilities installed. Then add CH→CH WIRE transaction/replug, per-channel VST3, dynamic channels and full FAT. Do not create another renderer, duplicate callback, mock audio or a new suite/workflow.

    DoD: actual Windows EXE with identical /preview/ GUI and its PNG keys, v8 accepted graph/ACK/rollback, real measured PCM, screenshot parity, coherent C++ fixture and physical evidence. M1 visual pass by itself is NOT a product release.

  6. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M2 implementation directly on latest main — DRAFT PR #395

    Continues merged M1 #392 without a competing GUI or PCM callback. New src/ApprovedConsoleM2Snapshot.h projects REAL JUCE active ASIO/WASAPI mask and verified LiveDryRoutingLab callback ordinals, with empty universal ChannelId graph and productionCallbackLive=false until engine #266/#387 admits it. src/Main.cpp now registers actual arMixConsoleSubscribe, emits arMixConsoleSnapshot, and explicitly REJECTS unadmitted arMixConsoleIntent with arMixConsoleAck; no optimistic UI update or ordinal→ChannelId lie.

    Native-only web/approved-native-m2-state.js validates uint64 decimal IDs, real endpoints, capability gates, request/ACK matching, same epoch/graph/roster snapshot readback, stale/rejected/timeout safety, and fail-closed recovery. web/approved-native-bridge.js subscribes + blocks browser-only simulated audio controls in the approved /preview/ native application (visual DOM/CSS unchanged). Deterministic Pages assembler + binary manifest now embeds both bridge scripts. 11 Node state-machine tests and Windows CI checks added.

    Browser Chromium PASS on run #41897279469. Windows JS/preflight/CMake PASS; exact-head JUCE native C++/CTest still building #41897279227.

    M2 not yet finished: authoritative stable ChannelId→physical GUI strip mapping + admitted PCM/FX/WIRE operations remain dependent on unmerged native engine producer #266/#387. PR remains draft, no M3 product LIVE, no hardware FAT #15 claim. Ownership safety: do not cherry-pick/duplicate ENGINE's PCM source or bring back web/console-native.html.

  7. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M2 EXACT-HEAD VALIDATED — PR #395

    Commit 28862dd4a79d8772bb34b73fd151853b94edb88c is green on BOTH independent gates:

    Native v6 socket is now installed in src/Main.cpp; src/ApprovedConsoleM2Snapshot.h reports only ACTUAL physical device pin masks plus epoch-verified callback ordinals; web/approved-native-m2-state.js commits ONLY after matching native ACK + same-revision/epoch accepted snapshot, including stale/malformed/timeout rejection. Native demos do not control imaginary PCM.

    M2 transport/safety milestone complete, M2 operator-to-PCM journey NOT complete. Main installed callback currently cannot certify universal ChannelId ownership; it advertises productionCallbackLive=false, empty accepted ChannelId roster and zero supported operations. Engine #266/#387 still draft/unmerged. Do NOT merge PR #395 as audio-live product or mark UAT ready; it remains DRAFT while the producer, GUI ChannelId binding, M3 WIRE/VST3, Windows EXE visual parity and hardware crackle #15 FAT remain blocked. No duplicate GUI/DSP allowed.

  8. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    Milestone A — integration coordination (2026-11-05 WIB)

    User authorized parallel execution with other ArSonMix threads. One owner per runtime domain; do not fork GUI or engine. Current main c1a11afd145380a944c9844937ccb6a97b5e0557 already merged M2 #394; treat it as baseline, NOT old #392/#395 checkpoints.

    Milestone A admission: one approved renderer in Windows, one installed ChannelId-native audio callback, one accepted graph drives real faders/meters/FX/WIRE, exact matched ACK→accepted snapshot, no alternative GUI/DSP, exact-SHA Windows native/Chromium PASS. Physical FAT remains explicitly PENDING until measured. This is a coordination lock, not a claim of completion.

  9. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M3 FIRST REAL SOUND — direct implementation checkpoint (2026-11-05)

    Actual code PR: #396 (DRAFT, no premature UAT).

    Merged M2 #394 already provides native-only hooks and contract; M3 audit uncovered two additional integration blockers: (1) the deferred bridge cannot see original /preview/ IIFE-local tracks/render/findTrack/wireEdges, preventing any accepted ChannelId snapshot projection, and (2) the existing external window.pointerup fader callback executes after the original GUI clears faderGesture. Also native FX reorder can mutate demo inserts without a JUCE guard.

    PR #396 adds a deterministic, reversible native-only scope export INSIDE the exact approved Pages GUI, bridges accepted snapshots into that same original model, commits pointer faders at the original gesture owner's release point, prevents native-only demo FX mutations, and forces failure/REJECTED rollback to accepted visuals. Public /preview/ HTML/CSS/PNG assets are unchanged; no new renderer or audio callback. Tests exercise a mocked JUCE socket through snapshot → SET_FADER intent → matching ACK → later actual control readback, and rejected state rollback. Native source bundle and exact asset parity are guarded.

    Truthful milestone status: M3-A gesture/transport integration is in PR; M3-B production native PCM ChannelId cutover and genuine VST3/WIRE through actual callback remain BLOCKED on reconciling engine #266/#387 into approved GUI (NOT on introducing another GUI). Real ASIO/WASAPI hardware and zero-FX crackle #15 remain FAT PENDING. Do not claim First Real Sound or product/UAT ready from the M3-A tests alone. Do not merge until exact PR-head Windows/Chromium tests pass.

  10. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M2.5 reconciliation update: #396 merged (native approved GUI state/fader), #398 merged as 0d23ff90 (release/source admission; exact-head Windows/JUCE/CTest PASS). New central file-ownership handoff and ordering is posted in #397. ENGINE #266 remains merge-dirty and must NOT import web/console-native.* or overwrite the approved M2.5 /preview/ bridge. #393 GUI and #270 FAT must be selectively extracted, not raw merged. Real ChannelId PCM, Windows exact joined EXE and physical #15 FAT remain pending.

  11. masarray commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    M4 GUI-owner handoff, following control-plane PR #404 (no redesign of approved /preview/):

    • Keep ALL existing approved PNG button skin, strips, WIRE geometry and layout unchanged.
    • When native v8 accepted snapshot is available, one-click operator actions may pass to planM4OperatorIntent(approvedController.state().current, {kind,sourceId,destinationId}) from integration/console-v6/m4-operator-routing.mjs. The returned intent is a candidate only, and must be issued via existing controller.intent(operation,targetChannelId,payload); keep spinner/state frozen until native ACK and the later matching accepted graph readback. Return explicit error on cycle, duplicate, double-dry, stale ID, missing capability.
    • ROUTE_ONLY from MIC→GROUP is a safer default than adding a second audible send while MIC→MAIN is still active. SEND_POST to native-verified 100%-wet FX_RETURN preserves dry path. Do NOT infer wet-only from a visual label.
    • SEND_PRE, variable gain, create Group/FX Return and external VST3 SIDECHAIN remain blocked, not mocked, until [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 installs real callback/aux detector bus and exact ACK proof.
    • Desired UX after DSP admission: select channels→Group Selected; strip SEND+→New FX Return; compressor plugin→External Sidechain source. No separate console.

    This is a targeted future GUI wiring contract, NOT a request to edit site/** simultaneously with the M3 #402 owner. PR #404 operates purely in INTEGRATOR-owned paths and does not change any GUI presentation file. See #397 for cross-thread ownership; hardware #15 FAT still pending.

  12. changed the title [-][P0 ONE GUI] Integrate ONLY approved /preview/ into native JUCE; remove alternate previews[/-] [+]P0 approved /preview/ — qualify native GUI parity and authoritative PCM readback[/+] on Nov 8, 2026
  13. masarray commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    Reconciled 2026-11-08 (main b0cea49). The ONE /preview/ public/native renderer integration is already in main through #418/#440/#442 and subsequent GUI/bridge work. Historical competing GUI migration #393 was archived. Retaining this issue is only for distinct native screenshot/interaction parity and real authoritative PCM/ACK readback verification; engine signal FAT is #412, channel lifecycle #192. Do not interpret the old title/body as 'GUI not yet integrated', and do not create a second renderer.

  14. masarray commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @masarray
    OwnerAuthor

    Administrative consolidation (2026-11-10)

    The single approved /preview/ native GUI implementation is already integrated; its remaining independent acceptance has now been explicitly transferred to:

    All these owners remain OPEN until real acceptance. Audit document: merged PR #524. Closing this redundant tracking issue does not claim the product is ready, and does not authorize a second renderer.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions