Repository navigation
Description
Reconciled 2026-11-08 — historical process superseded. The 2026-11-04 GUI multi-agent execution handoff, PR #352/#360 collision order and M1-M5 status are no longer authoritative. Current main incorporates later approved GUI composer, native bridge and operator UI tests. Retain individual remaining user-perceptual concerns in #347 (pointer interaction) and #349 (cable physics); real PCM acceptance stays #412/#389. This issue is closed as an obsolete coordination ledger, NOT as a claim that every old item passed field FAT.
Current main at audit:
c57720ea25585c861af89802e1365ffef7d03d17. No statement of physical hardware FAT.
CURRENT EXECUTION HANDOFF — M1–M5 + FX/RAIL (2026-11-04)
THIS IS THE ACTIVE STATUS / EXECUTION ORDER. Original audit and older issue state below are historical; do not act on older claims that #343 or #355 are still open. Re-fetch main/PRs/CI before every milestone because other agents are writing concurrently.
- Verified checkpoint:
main@2f01022370c589205d738366242d2d2aeb77b10d; Chromium #41732923188 PASS, public Pages #41734263288 PASS. - M1 Geometry: MERGED GUI M3 — 70px aligned meters, clip lamps, safe multi-wire inspection and operator controls #343 and V51 GUI V51 — professional portrait LED meter/peak hold + floating WIRE setup and audio-first console #355; 70px meter, dBFS labels left=7px/right=9px, portrait LED/peak hold. Existing geometry test uses 1.3px meter-vs-head tolerance; tighten to contractual ≤1px after measuring actual computed layout, without changing the approved V51 meter visuals.
- M5 Operator toolbar: MERGED GUI V51 — professional portrait LED meter/peak hold + floating WIRE setup and audio-first console #355 (compact 27px title, top ROUTES/MATRIX/WIRE Setup, floating WIRE Configuration). DO NOT restore obsolete two-row toolbar or new crowded bars.
- M2 WIRE, M3 unified controls, M4 cable physics: NOT ACCEPTED. GUI V49 — Selectable WIRE, direct gain, unified wheel and damped cable physics #352 draft HEAD
e974de94cdeddcf85e987ae813370e64c12ff16e, conflicts against current main; older #41711392061 FAILED V43 physics direction before test correction; NO exact latest-head green CI evidenced. [GUI P0][WIRE] Direct cable select/unplug/replug and source-independent send gain #346/[GUI P1][CONTROLS] One direct pointer + hover-wheel interaction model for mixer knobs, sliders and faders #347/[GUI P1][WIRE PHYSICS] Heavier gravity sag and slower, damped, pleasing cable motion #349 remain the owner issues. - In-flight fader polish: GUI V52 — refined recessed fader well, consistent gain ruler surface and visible low-cost thumb shadow #360 draft HEAD
38003b6b0e43b003defafec71aee34ef44c03369; Chromium #41735009594 in progress at checkpoint. Do not overwritemixer-fader-assembly.cssor V51 approved meter while this is in flight. - New FX chassis, grip-before-remove, safe reorder, matching left rail: [GUI P1][FX/RAIL] FX header as unified processor chassis, grip-before-delete, safe reorder and coherent section navigation rail #361 (OPEN, concrete implementation spec). Existing ARD: All-channel native FX Rack + safe drag reorder + yellow-green toolbar + recessed fader #95 is architecture background for native FX lifetime, NOT a new source of UI approval.
- One product reality: GUI Pages is simulation. Native production still separately depends on [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 + GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 + [INTEGRATION/FAT v7 G0] Canonical JUCE WebView ACK/PCM evidence and exact-SHA release gate #270 and physical zero-FX crackle blocker P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15. Never claim LIVE PCM from screenshots.
Release train / ownership (execute; do not create more planning issues)
Gate 0 — synchronize: read AGENTS.md, latest main SHA, #351/#361, PRs #352/#360, and exact CI logs; preserve approved reference checkpoint. One writer per site/preview-v2/index.html and CSS owner; do NOT force-merge the outdated #352 branch or overwrite V51/V25. Finish/reconcile #360 before touching its fader owner.
Gate 1 — P0 stable direct wire/controls/physics (existing #352): on fresh current main, replay/reconcile only the proven V49 deltas, checking generated visual, historical CSS audit and current V51 DOM; if needed create a new integration branch from main and reference #352 rather than erasing its history. Implement:
- SVG wire visible path plus precise transparent hit path and canonical
edge.idselection; click selects, drag occupied IN to another valid IN atomically re-routes; drop blank removes with Undo; Escape/cancel/invalid drop = full rollback, no synthetic change on mere click. Multiple incoming cables require explicit edge choice; off-bank and pinned MAIN preserved. - Receiver/OUT dark-grey when truly disconnected/unarmed; armed/hover pending visually distinct; committed enabled graph edge is the only source of connected indication even if path is hidden. No CH01/CH02 hardcoded paint.
- Direct wire-pot editing without armed OUT when exactly one edge, explicit edge when >1; single delegated pointer/hover-wheel/keyboard model across REAL faders, sliders, pots and sends, no control-selection prerequisite. Respect deltaMode, trackpad granularity, Shift fine, and wheel preventDefault only on eligible focus/hovered control.
- Time-based gravity sag and damped cable deformation with shared render/hit geometry, believable drag endpoints, reduced motion, no idle RAF, no repeated global strip redraw. V43 test should validate timestamped energy packet direction AND attenuation, not fragile single crest phase.
- Add exact-head automated tests on 0/1/multiple routes, drag/replug/delete/Undo, invalid drop and Escape, scroll, keyboard and 60/120Hz timing. Do not weaken tests merely to turn CI green; fix implementation if behavior truly fails.
Acceptance: [GUI P0][WIRE] Direct cable select/unplug/replug and source-independent send gain #346, [GUI P1][CONTROLS] One direct pointer + hover-wheel interaction model for mixer knobs, sliders and faders #347, [GUI P1][WIRE PHYSICS] Heavier gravity sag and slower, damped, pleasing cable motion #349 checks all green; CI+actual screenshots at exact integration SHA; update draft/PR only after success; preserve user-approved meter/header.
Gate 2 — cohesive FX/rail P1 (#361): after shared HTML #352 reconciliation, create one focused feature branch off newest main; implement as a meaningful PR. Existing sectionFx(t) markup must become power → plugin name → drag grip → REMOVE for populated slots, with +Add FX alignment retained. Only grip starts reorder, not entire row; use keyboard accessible alternative, fine insertion marker, cancel/rollback, stable per-instance binding and single commit on drop. NEVER cross-channel-copy only fx[] name + bypass and claim a transferable VST3 instance; reject/fence cross-channel operation until full native state transfer exists. Owner CSS mixer-fx-rack.css forms one raised header plate directly attached to a recessed processing well. The section rail uses existing Chrome/section owner(s): one visual navigation spine, centered consistent icons and 2px semantic active edge, not big cards or mismatched blocks. All geometry remains compact, no new standalone CSS owner or late-layer override.
Acceptance: grip left of remove at every density; pointer on name/power/remove cannot drag; header/body edge alignment; collapse/expand, section rail, master/regular channel, slot count, bypass, reopen and Undo persist; never damage native lease, state/PDC or strip alignment. See #361.
Gate 3 — production integration / FAT: adapt accepted GUI controls only after stable reference tests, using native snapshot/capability -> user intent -> async ACK/revision -> accepted rendering. Stable ChannelId and FX insertId; zero allocations, locks or asset work in callback. Native Windows 0FX/2FX, patch, send, PDC, Route, Show recall and actual hardware FAT remain mandatory separately. #266/#271/#270/#15 gate the physical product.
Efficient verification and reporting
- Run focused local syntax/type/DOM/Playwright checks first; gather screenshots for 1366×768, 1378×911, 1680×900, 1920×1080 and Comfort/Standard/Compact, normal stereo and pinned MAIN. Check wire empty/selected/drag, FX collapsed/open, rail state.
- Run ONE comprehensive exact-head CI per cohesive repaired milestone (no speculative microcommits that burn CI); inspect logs on red, fix root cause and rerun on a new SHA, compare screenshots. Check public Pages after merging main, ensure asset fingerprint refreshed.
- Maintain a simple issue checklist with file + commit + CI run + screenshot + observable behavior; indicate READY / BLOCKED truthfully; merge only green and conflict-free, and never auto-call native FAT from GUI reference CI.
- Do not create duplicate issues, change the approved V51 meter, silently loosen old tests, or rebuild a new UI. One scoped operator-quality product, no CSS patch accumulation.
ArSonMix — 2026-11-04 Operator UX convergence / single execution checkpoint
Status: AUDIT + EXECUTION PLAN, NOT AN IMPLEMENTATION CLAIM. Reference screenshot: 1378×911, public Pages /preview; current verified main:
d9e0931321ca0a4b23f8fe8a8594e49c07c79353at audit. Re-read live main/PR head before implementing. This master issue coordinates existing tasks; do not duplicate or reset them.
Why this epic exists
The console already has an approved dense graphite/navy hardware identity. Remaining operator problems are interdependent:
- Top toolbar mixes BANK, View density, Plugins, Sends on Faders, BUS target, Clear PFL, Snapshot/Save/Recall and More at similar priority; WIRE/MAIN/View/Routes/Matrix competes in a second band. Beginner cannot quickly distinguish navigation, audio action, and show safety.
- Visible SVG cables cannot be selected; receiver detach/replug requires source OUT arming, and wire-pot can become read-only even with a connected edge.
- CH01/CH02 appear illuminated while owner expects an unconnected jack to be dark grey. Require model-based verification first: any actually connected enabled edge must be traceable in the route inspector, otherwise unconnected state must be neutral. Do not infer connectivity from hover, armed source, CSS class, hidden offbank rendering or seed-only UI state.
- Animation reverse wave feels fast/mechanical and cable has insufficient gravity sag (especially during pointer drag).
- Pointer/wheel affordance inconsistent across knobs, sliders and faders.
- Owner's meter/fader geometry contract has not yet been delivered on
main.
Existing canonical owner tasks (don't create new competing work)
| Responsibility | Authority | Delivery status at audit |
|---|---|---|
| SVG hit-test/select/drag-to-unplug/replug, connected wire-pot | #346 | OPEN, planned |
| Hover-wheel and common direct control adapter | #347 | OPEN, planned |
| Toolbar grouping + beginner operator hierarchy | #348 | OPEN, planned |
| Gravity sag + soft time-based cable response | #349 | OPEN, planned |
| 70px meter housing, left alignment, fader shift, clip lamps, More dismissal and +Add FX alignment | PR #343 | OPEN, not merged |
| Native GUI mapping | draft #271 / #268 | Different workstream; only accepted native ACKs are LIVE |
| Native audio/RT graph + integrated FAT | draft #266 / #270 / #15 | Not validated by Pages screenshot |
Canonical GUI reference: site/preview-v2/index.html, component CSS owners mixer-wire-dots.css, mixer-fader-assembly.css, mixer-meter-display.css, mixer-chrome-material.css; follow AGENTS.md and docs/CHECKPOINT_GUI_M1_WIRE_V48_BUTTONS_V23_20261103.md. No stale draft #278 wholesale merges.
Verified implementation diagnosis
wireTray(t)resolvesedgeonly fromarmedWireSource(), whilehasPluggedWireseparately knows if any edge exists. When source is not armed, rendered LVL may be anis-active is-readonlyspan, not editable input. Fix canonical edge selection/binding, not CSS-only cursor tricks. (Owner [GUI P0][WIRE] Direct cable select/unplug/replug and source-independent send gain #346)syncVisibleWireDots(svg)derives LED state from visible path and writesdata-wire-visible/data-wire-arrival. This can diverge from committed edges when focus, offbank, or display filtering changes. Separate graphconnectedvs transientarmed/hover/snapvs displayvisible. Neither CH01 nor CH02 gets a special-case paint.wirePathDatauses a sag-clamped cubic;wireImpactPathData/kickWireSpringanimate a 36-frame backward traveling impulse. Refactor existing geometry/motion source with elapsed-time dynamics; don't stack another animation loop. (Owner [GUI P1][WIRE PHYSICS] Heavier gravity sag and slower, damped, pleasing cable motion #349)- Existing
PR #343expands meter housing to 70px and reserves fader/scale geometry with responsive variants; its claimed geometry must be measured in a browser at exact PR head, then merged, rather than reproduced via later inline CSS.
Integrated execution sequence (large meaningful milestones)
Gate A — Stabilize the in-flight meter PR before touching shared chrome/geometry
- Verify GUI M3 — 70px aligned meters, clip lamps, safe multi-wire inspection and operator controls #343 exact head against current main/updated CSS ownership; inspect visual captures on Comfort, Standard, Compact; 1366×768, 1378×911, 1680×900, 1920×1080, plus pinned Master.
- Check meter-box left edge aligned to fader-head/readout left edge (measure
getBoundingClientRect().left, tolerance ≤1 CSS px), meter-box min/actual width ≥70 CSS px, labels fully inside, fader/well and gain ruler translated right with positive non-overlap gap; check +10/0/-12 etc don't collide. - Confirm top stereo L/R red independent CLIP latch indicators are visible with clips, reset mechanism is explicit, FX placeholder has no power, More dismisses on blur/outside/Escape. Preserve calibrated dBFS vs gain and actual model semantics. Do NOT confuse simulated clip with native PCM.
- Review/merge GUI M3 — 70px aligned meters, clip lamps, safe multi-wire inspection and operator controls #343 only after exact-head green UI regression and aligned screenshot; verify public Pages from merged main, not only PR branch.
Gate B — P0 WIRE direct manipulation and connectivity truth (owner #346)
- One stable route
edge.idis the identity for visible cable, socket, inspector, gain, unplug, Undo and native intent. Separate visible SVG path from transparent 10–14px pointer hit path; hit zones must not steal input from knob, other wire, socket, fader or PAN. Click wire selects exact edge and highlights it. - Unarmed source + single connected IN: drag occupied jack >10px to another valid IN = atomic replug; drop blank patch-bay = unplug that edge; no accidental delete on click; invalid drop/Escape/pointercancel/leave-window = full rollback. Preserve edge gain/mode/id and immediate Undo. Multi-incoming IN: explicit per-route choice (reuse GUI M3 — 70px aligned meters, clip lamps, safe multi-wire inspection and operator controls #343 inspector), never auto-select first edge.
- Neutral socket paint contract: disconnected/unarmed/unhovered OUT/IN = dark grey regardless of channel/selection; pending/hover/armed = temporary distinct style; actual committed enabled edge = connected style; display focus and hidden wire must not fake connection. Test CH01/CH02 with zero edges specifically and after route add/remove/Undo; assertions on state + computed style.
- Wire-pot directly editable on a unique incoming edge without arming OUT. On 2+ incoming edges it requires selecting a route; no applying one knob to all edges; legacy SEND slot never double-processes.
- Primary MAIN protection, duplicate prevention, feedback-cycle guard, offbank + pinned Master correctness, native ACK/rollback preserved.
Gate C — Unified instrument interaction (#347, after B)
- ONE delegated parameter descriptor for fader/PAN/SEND/wire-pot/other real knobs, supporting pointer drag, keyboard, home/end/double-click appropriate defaults and hover-wheel without prior focus/arming.
- Normalize WheelEvent pixel/line/page deltas; trackpad accumulation, unit-aware quantization/clamping, Shift fine, sensible 0.5dB default fader/SEND increments (0.1dB fine) subject to physical testing; preventDefault only over eligible controls; never hijack browser scroll/pinch or inactive elements.
- No state mismatch between displayed values, editable input, native intent ACK and serialized snapshot; no per-control competing listeners or every-tick full-strip rerender.
Gate D — Calmer premium WIRE motion (#349, after stable hit-path geometry)
- Tune sag with span + stage clearance (trial 8–16px lower at center where space permits) and dynamic drag curve with pinned endpoints. NEVER overrun PAN/switch/fader hitboxes.
- Replace frame-count impulse with elapsed-time
requestAnimationFrame(timestamp), gently damped spring/low-frequency traveling wave; test initial 1.2–2.0 s settling envelope and visual frames at 0/200/500/1000/1600 ms. No recurring idle ripple; geometry of visual path/hit path remains identical. - Physically believable cable under drag, neither sharp segmented zigzags nor reverse snap; FPS-independent 60/120Hz, no stray RAF after cancel/unmount, reduced-motion static sag.
Gate E — Operator-first console chrome (#348, after #343 header merge)
- Rework toolbar within existing height budget into visible intent clusters: Channel navigation (bank/density/plugins), Mix & monitor (Sends on Faders + selected BUS, contextual PFL), Show & Safety (scene, guarded Save/Recall, More). Distinguish modes from permanent routing and danger from harmless view selection.
- Simplify WIRE row hierarchy, progressive disclosure of Routes/Matrix; readable compact labels and regular height/spacing/baselines, no big cards/bold titles/new chrome rows or screen-clipped controls.
- Novice 1-screen task: choose real IN → insert FX → connect OUT/MAIN or BUS → set gain → monitor/Mute/PFL → guarded Save Show. Small contextual empty-state affordance, no noisy instructional text; status of GUI demo clearly simulated, native only from ACK.
- Master remains pinned, 10-channel reference and dynamic native channel model retain IDs, hardware visual assets and approved channel colors; no bank/route/fader surprise when toggling VIEW, SOF or scene mode.
Release-quality acceptance matrix
- Visual: 1024/1366/1378/1680/1920 widths × 768/900/911/1080 heights × Comfort/Standard/Compact (sample targeted combinations to avoid quadratic CI explosion). Compare baseline vs new screenshot and measured bounding boxes. No offscreen drawer, overlap, clipped dB labels or changed fixed fader height.
- Behavior: route 0/1/2+, CH01/CH02 disconnected neutral, offbank, selected exact edge, delete/drop/Undo, wheel mouse + high-resolution trackpad, short/long/crossing wires, subwindow/tab interruption, keyboard and reduced motion.
- WCAG 2.2 drag alternative: one-pointer non-drag method in accessible inspector for remove/re-route. Give 24×24px pointer targets or compliant equivalent/spacing; preserve unobstructed visual cables and compact layout.
- Runtime: 60/120Hz elapsed-time behavior; performance instrumentation on modest Windows iGPU, no idle RAF, no console errors, no dirty rerender of entire mixer per wave frame; don't claim an unmeasured FPS guarantee.
- Integrate with current main + GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 native GUI only after Pages contract is stable; native route/parameters must follow intent → ACK → accepted snapshot. Never call simulated Pages visual pass an audio-engine release.
- Final CI: run appropriate existing and new Playwright geometry/functional tests once per cohesive milestone, then exact-head Chromium/Firefox and Pages publish. Native release requires [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 + GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271 + [INTEGRATION/FAT v7 G0] Canonical JUCE WebView ACK/PCM evidence and exact-SHA release gate #270 + physical FAT including zero-FX crackle blocker P0 — Crackling with 0 VST3: diagnose WASAPI clock/input/output buffering before engine expansion #15.
Source-grounded UX references
- Waves LV1 Layer vs Mode: https://assets.wavescdn.com/user-guides/emotion-lv1-classic-console-user-guide.html (separate which channels vs what task).
- Pointer capture: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Element/setPointerCapture
- Wheel deltaMode: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/WheelEvent/deltaMode
- Physics parameters: https://developer.android.com/develop/ui/views/animations/spring-animation
- WCAG 2.2 dragging/targets: https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/#input-modalities
Ownership rule
One writer per shared GUI owner file at a time. Finish/rebase PR #343 before #348 header and #346 routes inspector integration. Coordinate #346 vs #349 wire shared HTML/CSS; #347 reuses #346 binding. Avoid micro-PR CSS churning, outdated asset query cache keys, speculative audio changes or premature 'DONE'. Close this epic only when child tasks have merged and public Pages + native scope are separately substantiated.
Activity
masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
Concurrent CSS ownership update discovered: PR #350 (CSS V21 physical chassis migration) is OPEN and also owns
site/preview-v2/assets/mixer-chrome-material.css, which #343 modifies for header geometry and #348 needs later. Before any #343 / #348 merge or rebase, inspect #350 current status, compare actual CSS cascade/source order and re-run exact-head screenshot/geometry gates. Keep one file writer/merger at a time; migrate owner first only if verified safe, otherwise sequence #343 then reconcile #350 against that merged head. Neither branch should overwrite the other's material. This note updates the master execution dependencies to cover parallel work arriving while this audit was recorded.masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
2026-11-04 execution checkpoint — PR #352 (draft)
Implementation is now real code in a separate GUI reference branch, not only a plan: draft PR #352, branch
gui/v49-wire-direct-gesture-controls-physics-20261104based on merged CSS V21main@5efa4f08. Cohesive V49 source changes: selectable SVG paths by exact WIRE edge ID, occupied-IN unarmed drag/replug, stale/invalid drop rollback, scoped Undo for route changes, unique-edge wire-pot editable without arming, graph-truth socket connected state, shared range hover-wheel for fader/PAN/WIRE/TRIM/SEND, lower gravity sag and 1.6s FPS-independent damped motion. GUI demo only; no ENGINE/native or audio claims.Verification is in progress: PR initial CI #41698898936 failed before V49 browser smoke at V21 historical source fingerprint because genuine V49 HTML changed. Branch now contains an exact reversible V49 delta ledger + historical HTML/WIRE CSS reconstruction, keeping original historical hashes/assertions intact, and registered Playwright V49 smoke. Recheck latest exact-head Actions status before marking any box complete. PR #343 (70px meter/fader/CLIP/header) remains OPEN with old Chrome owner conflict; ownership intact, do not merge it blindly. #348 toolbar work remains future, separately sequenced after M3 geometry. If subsequent V49 CI fails, inspect exact step logs and fix before promotion; this checkpoint is not a PASS claim. No native physical FAT, crackle #15 still separate.
masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
Execution checkpoint — V49 CI blocker repaired in code (2026-11-04)
tests/pages_wire_incoming_v43_smoke.py:41because it asserted the oldv47-css-v16cache key after V49 correctly changed the published stylesheet URL. Prior M3/CSS tests passed; this is NOT a product PASS.tests/pages_wire_incoming_v43_smoke.pyb8c80b5,tests/pages_wire_v45_socket_layout_smoke.py17b91ba, andtests/pages_wire_v44_finish_smoke.py294e602. V45 now asserts connected-edge truth when wire focus hides the path, rather than demanding a falsely idle receiver. All visual/geometry/actual route checks remain intact.294e602085d2d1cab50d961e7a453a0221ed33f6; fresh exact-head CI not yet present in fetched Actions results. Keep draft.main@9b286f4now includes approved M3 (GUI M3 — 70px aligned meters, clip lamps, safe multi-wire inspection and operator controls #343), CSS V21 (CSS V21 — Own V9–V14 physical console chassis and section geometry in existing Chrome stylesheet #350), CSS V22 (CSS V22 — Consolidate legacy mechanical key material under existing Chrome owner #353). GitHub reports PR GUI V49 — Selectable WIRE, direct gain, unified wheel and damped cable physics #352 mergeable_state=dirty against current main: this must be reconciled (source + historical CSS/HTML ledger) and exact-head UI smoke rerun before promotion, never force merge/overwrite.dirtymerge state and verify CI after integration.No native engine/audio/PCM changes or physical release claims.
masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
Execution coordination (2026-11-04): owner-requested meter dBFS tick insets left 7px, right 9px implemented in existing
mixer-meter-display.cssvia PR #354. The 14px numeral span requiredletter-spacing:-.13emto retain true measured right alignment without text overflow (M1 browser checks remain enabled). Prior exact-head #354f1fff79UI Chromium PASS, but CSS V23 #357 merged concurrently, so merge was rejected safely. I made a non-force two-parent reconciliation commit241f3a1based onmain@4a20058: preserves all V23 Chrome/WIRE cleanup and adapts the strict V23 history helper for the cache-key-only meter update. Exact-head UI run #41709425871 in progress; DO NOT call merged until it passes. V49 wire work #352 has a separate selected-edge gain-priority fix + Playwright multi-incoming test, and awaits V23+meter baseline integration. Avoid editing V49 owner files in a second parallel PR.masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
2026-11-04 source-grounded M1–M5 status + new FX/rail scope (main@2f01022)
e974de94cdeddcf85e987ae813370e64c12ff16e, merge-conflicted with main V51/V25; earlier exact-head V49 test #41711392061 failed at V43 wave direction, follow-up test fix committed, no fresh exact-head CI verified.New user feedback fully audited against current main: issue #361 owns one cohesive FX rack/section rail refinement. Current
sectionFx(t)rendersfx-removethen hidden non-focusablespan.grip(wrong placement). Entirefxslot-rowisdraggable, causing accidental drags from other controls; cross-channel drop only copies FX name + bypass, NOT native VST3 state. Header/rows are separate flat backgrounds without attached hardware-plate relationship;rail-cellhas mixed legacy surfaces. Issue #361 has visual, interaction, accessibility, CSS ownership and native-safe acceptance criteria and benchmarks (Waves LV1 Rack Mode, Studio One inserts, DiGiCo inserts).Sequence: Preserve approved V51 meter/toolbar and in-flight #360 fader. Implement #361 via existing FX and rail owners on latest main; keep #352 V49 owned in its branch, reconcile conflicts before combining. Exact-head screenshots + Playwright (Comfort/Standard/Compact, pinned Master) and native ACK boundary must be evidenced. No Pages screenshot is a physical PCM/VST3 success claim.
masarray commentedon Nov 3, 2026
2026-11-04 GUI execution checkpoint — actual P0/P1 code (not yet accepted)
P0 WIRE M2–M4: draft PR #363, HEAD
c30f0967165c906d45b141cb5b9c364a0f699cdc, exact-head Chromium #41739513534 running. Existing V49 #352 was selectively reconciled onto approved V51/merged V26 as a non-force two-parent commit. Implements edge-ID selectable SVG paths, unarmed source-independent knob, deliberate receiver replug/removal with scoped Undo/rollback, connected graph truth, delegated wheel and 1600ms time-based cable impact. V43 escaped-regex test bug corrected; V25/V26 historical byte-fingerprint checks execute only on their fixed historical sources, with full restore and current V49 functional smoke later. Does not touch approved V51 meter or in-flight V52 fader CSS.P1 FX/RAIL: draft stacked PR #364 targets #363 to preserve one shared HTML owner. HEAD
64655212fa8143a685a5ac62330e3a986d92a1ba, Chromium #41739700143 running. Grip-before-REMOVE is a focusable 18px button; only grip initiates drag; Alt+Up/Down, Ctrl+Z undo, stable demo insert ID and same-channel FX+bypass transaction; no cross-channel name-only native VST copy, no native mutation without accepted ACK. FX header+well and rail spine styled within existing owners. New V53 browser functional/geometry smoke at 1366/1378/1680/1920 × 3 densities with screenshots.No release/physical PCM claim. Do not close #346/#347/#349/#361 until direct acceptance is verified.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
2026-11-04 USER-APPROVED WIRE-FIRST EXECUTION OVERRIDE — docs PR #365
Read PRD, ARD, and owner handoff. Main priority before product PCM: canonical WIRE routing including default CH->MAIN, MAIN-colored short hanging OUT cable + matching upward MAIN IN plug (same edge, NO cross-console cable, badges, cards, extra layout), existing socket drag-to-disconnect/replug one selected edge, route-only atomic, 100% connected binding among WIRE/OUT/Navigator/Matrix/Scenes, deterministic Guardian. Dedicated +BUS/+FX RETURN creation deferred; preserve FX inserts and legacy session compatibility. Follow #352/#346/#347/#349 but integrate on current main, don't blindly merge divergent draft, don't damage V51/V52 meter/fader or FX #361. GUI remains simulation until native #266/#271/#270 true PCM. No new planning issue; execute this as updated #351 scope.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
2026-11-04 execution checkpoint — real V53 integration commit
Implemented: fresh non-force main-based PR #367, branch
gui/v53-fx-rail-reconciled-20261104; exact basemain@01d84c30c2dd8026b0324045e0f130e84f534f78; commite5776df2d2b3126f663b9c4d8080948d69b34d29.Changes: context-checked replay of V53 from #364 onto newer main (5 files):
site/preview-v2/index.html, existingmixer-fx-rack.cssandmixer-chrome-material.css,tests/pages_fx_rail_v53_smoke.py, and CI gate.github/workflows/ui-smoke.yml. Dedicated FX grip before REMOVE, pointer+keyboard reorder/Undo, safe cross-channel fence, attached header/recessed chassis and coherent rail. V51 meter owner and #360 fader CSS not edited. Historical PR #364 kept unmerged to avoid duplicate/obsolete changes.P0 sync: #363 merged (merge commit
0215986fbbe2c67971680952f75f069950ac653e), supersedes stale draft #352; don't re-merge #352. Current wire-first routing contract in AGENTS.md still governs default CH→MAIN follow-up, not asserted complete by V53.Truthful gates:
Do not merge #367 or close #361 until exact-head green and screenshots/interaction verification. No native PCM/VST3 FAT claim.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
2026-11-04 — V53 PUBLIC PREVIEW DEPLOYED (verified)
GUI FX/rail release checkpoint:
c02f88cacab71d26f482a0e66443c4c54a9aff5fc02f88cshaandpublisher_main_shaboth c02f88c; latest main matches. Public preview resolves and contains V53 rail CSS cache tokenv53-rail; FX cache tokenv53-chassis.Contract: GUI reference and public preview are SIMULATED, not real PCM/VST3. Engine #266, native GUI #271, FAT #270, crackle #15 remain P0 stop-ship. Default CH→MAIN WIRE-first routing override from AGENTS.md is a distinct unfinished functional scope, not supplied by FX/rail V53. V52 fader #360 remains independently owned and unmerged. Preserve approved V51 meter, V53 FX/rail, and previously merged #363 WIRE when continuing.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
CODING FAST START — merged PR #369, main@1e5a835f (2026-11-04). Execute the 4-packet runbook directly: https://github.com/masarray/arsonmix/blob/main/docs/workstreams/START_HERE_WIRE_FIRST_20261104.md. It recognizes merged V52 fader, V53 FX/rail and V54 WIRE/bypass; do NOT re-polish those or merge outdated #352 blindly. PACKET A: canonical WIRE including default MAIN edge + two MAIN-color physical dangling stubs + per-source unplug/replug with UI graph tests. PACKET C mirrors only native ACK'd graph into GUI. No badges/cards/extra geometry; preserve approved GUI. Post one substantial completion with exact SHA+screenshots/tests.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
Packet A GUI execution checkpoint (2026-11-04): canonical WIRE / MAIN reference work is active on PR #371, head
3b2624990575df16a6b06e750ae50934315d77dc. This is the single GUI reference owner branch; do not fork duplicate routing state or replay stale PR #352. The deterministic Guardian now blocks invalid kinds/taps, atomic rejected graph mutations, duplicate/cyclic routes. Pinned MAIN physical pointer selection fix preserves source focus during capture-phase, and matching main-edge IDs drive both short stubs. Exact-head Chromium UI run #41775245404 has already passed model DAG, real MAIN pointer + Scene/SAFE, V49 WIRE and V53 FX tests; the remaining styling/geometry regression steps are still running. Native GUI #271 received Packet C handoff.State: REFERENCE GUI/SIMULATED ONLY; draft until all CI and Pages publish gates green. ENGINE #266's native transaction, actual callback PCM/VST3 and FAT #270 remain NOT PROVEN by these tests.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
V55 GUI quality checkpoint — 2026-11-04 — PUBLIC PREVIEW VERIFIED
main@6a133e3ca3e9718a30c1c1fefda92194f9df77b9.data-wire-connectedstill derives from accepted canonical graph (default CH→MAIN remains real);data-wire-paintlights only physical endpoints of visible committed WIRE paths. CH1/CH2 inactive receiving IN/dot stays graphite; focus-hidden committed edge remains semantic connected but not falsely colored. No idle RAF or second graph.fxOnbypasses whole channel chain without resetting individual slot flags;slotBypass[index]affects only one insert. Stable demo insert IDs retained. Native bridge remains fail-closed, pending installed supported ops / ACK.docs/workstreams/GUI_V55_CONTEXT_WIRE_FX_NATIVE_HANDOFF_20261104.md. Explicit comments posted on ENGINE [ENGINE SOLE OWNER] One native callback → full-fidelity ChannelId cutover (draft) #266 and native GUI GUI #271 — Native adaptation of approved PR #278 V8 Mixer Console (draft) #271. Stable ChannelId/insertId/edgeId, requestId/epoch/revisions, installed supportedOps gating, intent→ACK→accepted snapshot, no unsafe audio-thread VST operations./preview/build.jsonshaandpublisher_main_shaboth6a133e3ca3e9718a30c1c1fefda92194f9df77b9, and public/preview/containsv55-accepted-wire-paintandv55-depthasset revisions.Separate release blocker: this is a reference GUI only; real hardware-bound PCM/VST3 state, proper native bypass ACK, #266/#271/#270, physical crackle #15, device FAT remain unverified. Do not claim native mixer ready from Pages.
masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
Packet A actual code checkpoint (2026-11-04): Draft PR #376 (
b526f233c794989dbd82a89819eb522803e5c389) updates existingsite/preview-v2/assets/wire-graph-model.jsto reject unresolved legacy output/send/split and nonfinite send gain rather than silently drop saved routing on Scene/Show migration; extends canonical model tests with deterministic randomized DAG/property sequences. Main already contains one WIRE graph reducer, MAIN default edges, MAIN stub paint, and edgeId-based pointer dragging; no duplicate graph/renderer was introduced. Exact-head Chromium CI run #41788888461 started, not yet proven green. Remaining Packet A: physical MAIN cable geometry/gesture browser acceptance, matrix/scene full-route review; native GUI #271 ACK/snapshot remains Packet C and native PCM is not claimed. GUI visual V51–V56 files untouched in this PR.masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
GUI WIRE Packet A ACCEPTED / MERGED (2026-11-04): PR #376 merged to main exact
7ddf79bb3f26bea32bc43fc4995319ec7f04225c; PR head67a3d8a2cfba92a865971b1803135912c50f8f3dUI Chromium CI #41795333725 SUCCESS. Existing single canonical graph now has strict fail-closed legacy/duplicate SEND/OUT/SPLIT import; physical MAIN cable has two short measured cubic SVG fragments of one accepted edge, source OUT and pinned MAIN IN. 9 actual screenshot files (1366×768, 1680×900, 1920×1080 × Comfort/Standard/Compact), all source/Master edge-id/plug-center geometry checks pass; Compact remains folded by intentional layout constraint. Current main V51–V56 fader/meter/FX geometry retained. GUI-only reference, NO native PCM/hardware claim. Packet C consumer operations now staged on owner PR #271 head6b3588b8467cceb53571b33fab42e789cc960694but gate closed until actual ENGINE #266 installs additive graph operation; FAT #270/#15 still pending.masarray commentedon Nov 4, 2026
CI SMART LANES — PR #386 (2026-11-04). GUI team: keep visual/source work in
site/**and browser/UIweb/**; default PR validation is now current critical Chromium/Graph/FX/fader tests rather than replaying V8–V27 CSS history each push. Full historical suite remains available fromUI smoke (Chromium)→workflow_dispatchor integration/product-* PR. When adding an approved new GUI milestone, put its critical acceptance test in the fast lane (do not accidentally mark it manual-only). Successful fast UI on main triggers the existing single GitHub Pages publisher. Don't push micro-commits just to retry a full visual rebuild; source/visual screenshot proof remains required for each milestone. Current CI refactor measured GUI smoke SUCCESS in ~1.6 min at PR #386; Windows build unaffected bysite/**/pure UI paths.