Repository navigation
Description
Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17:
P2/factory-fx/feature/backlog. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.Scope / release boundary: Optional native VST3 bonus, not mandatory built-in audio product path.
Exit criteria:
- For every proposed first-party VST3 module verify original rights, exact commit/CID provenance, OS-specific binary, SHA256, manifest and license terms.
- Prove genuine host load, FX parameter/preset recall and audio PCM at relevant OS before advertising it as bundled.
Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.
CURRENT CHECKPOINT — 2026-11-08 (main
c57720ea25585c861af89802e1365ffef7d03d17)Factory FX remains a dedicated product milestone. #446 merged atomic intake for first-party EQ/Comp/Verb/KuPik and source/provenance gates, but a green intake/build or a release metadata asset is not proof that every desired native VST3 module is bundled and loadable on all three OS. Preserve per-plugin manifest/host identity and licensing checks, OS-specific binaries, real FX insertion and GUI/PCM parity. Six-plugin roadmap remains separate from the built-in native PEQ branch #423, now archived as an incompatible old integration branch.
ArSonEQ binary provenance finding: Windows artifact run #40983590331 contains real x64 VST3 with audio module CID
ABCDEF019182FAEB4172734E41724551and published ZIP SHA25663f6ebcbe9ba50078c9f8fedc62ff20336625513d895088dab6f1e3d51fe95d3, but embeddedBUILD.txtcommit37d8b0d...does not match CI head1f9513d.... See EQ #6. Do not promote this engineering binary to official Factory release until provenance is regenerated/matched, JUCE actual host UID is attested and host FAT passes. FXF1 PR #188 native registry/UI is under Windows+Chromium CI at new head c041c5f (first Windows 50/51 CTests; new test executable was omitted from explicit build list; workflow target repaired). No bundled binary approved yet.
IMPLEMENTATION BEGUN — FXF1 registry vertical slice: PR #188 implements fail-closed native FactoryFX manifest/SHA256/host UID discovery, FACTORY FX / MY PLUGINS picker, isolated user Vault, deterministic C++ and JS tests. Branch
feat/fxf1-factory-manifest-discoverybased on merged G5B main@928dfdfd. Chromium UI #41021217153 PASSED; Windows #41021217062 BUILD IN PROGRESS at this update. No VST3 binaries bundled or licensed/host-attested yet; further packaging cannot ship until ArSonEQ release candidate #6 and ASKPVST entitlement #60 are approved. Full six-FX suite remains future; this is meaningful partial execution, NOT complete FXF1 production release.
FACTORY FX / SIX FIRST-PARTY VST3 (2026-10-30): Factory FX ADR · Factory FX PRD · manifest schema · merged architecture PR #187 · epic #185. Six original bundled VST3 targets: ArSonEQ, ArSonComp, ArSonVerb, ArSonHarmony, ArSonColor, ArSonKuPik Enhancer. NO binary FactoryFX modules are currently shipped by this docs change; first qualify ASKPVST public v0.5.26 + ArSonEQ feature branch artifacts and obtain product/AGPL/JUCE/EULA approval; ArSonVerb license and Comp/Harmony/Color DSP are later gates. ASKPVST #60, EQ #6, Verb #4. G5A #178 and MS1 #184 are already MERGED. Factory immutable VST3 modules must use existing native FX graph while USER vault remains separate; protect L2 #176, PDC #95, actual hardware #15. Do NOT mark a plugin loadable from a roadmap card.
Product contract — six ArSonMix Factory FX, not just user-imported third-party VSTs
ArSonMix must be immediately useful after installing/public portable ZIP. It will ship original Factory FX: ArSonEQ, ArSonComp, ArSonVerb (Reverb), ArSonHarmony, ArSonColor, ArSonKuPik Enhancer. All users get the same application capabilities, including custom VST import; no public-vs-private edition or proprietary user VST files in official ZIP. Existing user portable vault #85 remains separate from the immutable factory bundle. New canonical engineering decision: see ADR Factory FX (to be linked by docs PR).
Actual sibling-source audit (2026-10-30)
masarray/askp-vstprivatemaster@d09fc11c: source/plugin wrapper ArSonKuPik, JUCE 8.0.14, VST3 plugin identityMsAr/AkVs, version 0.5.26. Public RELEASE ARTIFACTS are onmasarray/vst-enhancertag v0.5.26 with Windows-x64-VST3 ZIP + SHA256SUMS.vst-enhanceris distribution website, not the canonical DSP source. Proprietary licensing/activation is already defined: do not bypass/change it silently, require factory redistribution/entitlement and JUCE approval.masarray/arson-eqfeature branchfeat/initial-vst3-eq-architecture@1f9513d: real DSP/UI/JUCE9 VST3+Standalone targets,ArsN/ArEQ. Defaultmainhas only LICENSE and NO RELEASE, so do not build main or label public Factory-ready. Needs candidate Windows binary, host/pluginval, semantic/tag/commit provenance, Actual repo license is AGPL-3.0; respect its obligations, avoid changing rights accidentally.masarray/arsonverbmain@69fe83c: reusable DSP core + JUCE9 opt-in VST3 (Arst/Arvb), butLICENSE-STATUS.mdsays outbound distribution license undecided. Blocked for public bundling pending licensing/CI/host qualification.- ArSonComp/ArSonHarmony/ArSonColor: no verified dedicated repo from owner repository search. New independent DSP projects required, not mock UI/plugins.
Non-negotiable native architecture
- Factory FX source artifacts are separately built signed/hashed COMPLETE Windows VST3 bundles (include all .vst3 bundle resources). Do not statically mix JUCE8/9 plugin code with ARMixConsole: VST3 ABI through the existing native host is the shared interface. No VST2.
- App layout
AR MIX Studio.exe+FactoryFX/ArSonEQ/ArSonEQ.vst3,FactoryFX/ArSonKuPik/ArSonKuPik.vst3, etc (actual staged names inspected from archives; no path guessing).Studio/Plugins/VST3is USER vault, never ship private user's plugins. Factory files read-only/replaceable by updater; independent install/portable distribution still same features. - Factory Plugin Registry: first-party manifest with stable productId, VST3 class identity, version/source SHA+artifact SHA256, exact relative bundle path, schema/compatibility, licensing approval/credits, and expected supported mono/stereo buses. Resolve logical
factory://<id>Show identity to installed verified entry. Match native PluginDescription actual class identity, not filename/string. Factory enumerates manifest-only; do not run recursive global scan at every startup; off-RT fingerprint/validation on changed entries and cache exact result. Missing/mismatch -> actionable factory plugin unavailable, never untrusted fallback or silent user plugin substitution. - Loader uses current
PluginCatalogandLiveChannelFxGraphlifecycle, one FX chain and one callback; setup/instantiation, state restore, plugin bus layout negotiation, latency/PDC and safe swaps are control-thread jobs. Do not implement second DSP engine or bypass ARD: All-channel native FX Rack + safe drag reorder + yellow-green toolbar + recessed fader #95/G5A: real 8-slot/channel FX graph foundation + compact collision-free VST UI #178 source owner. Preserve CH1 multi-insert/Orbit and L2 L2 GUI BASELINE LOCK — aligned CH1–10/MASTER faders, left-rail layers, three-tab workspace #176 geometry. Both FACTORY and USER VST can occupy any supported CH/AUX/GROUP/MAIN insert only when DSP supports it. - GUI: plugin picker FACTORY / MY PLUGINS separation, category chips EQ | COMP | REVERB | HARMONY | COLOR | ENHANCER; each installed and verified factory module with name, vendor, native status, legitimate presets and editor; do NOT show planned categories as usable. Favor simple optimized UI and avoid extra WebView2 render contexts during live 10CH stress.
- One distribution flow: fetch/copy independently tested pinned artifacts at controlled build/release stage, verify pinned download SHA256 AND extracted bundle content hash, VST3 IDs, JUCE/AGPL/proprietary/EULA notices, architecture x64, runtime dependencies; stage versioned artifacts, atomic package, reject missing required Factory FX. No binary blobs committed to git, no access tokens or private ASKPVST source in public repository. Stop release if rights or hash/ABI/CI are not approved.
- Factory entitlement for ArSonKuPik is a product owner decision: leave existing commercial EULA/activation intact unless the author explicitly approves a bundled entitlement/license; do not silently strip LicenseManager or claim unrestricted included audio. Distinguish installed/not activated/active in UI. ArSonVerb licensing also must be resolved first.
Large vertical deliverables / acceptance gates (do not fragment into UI-only PRs)
FXF1 — Factory infrastructure + existing two plugin integration: source-pinned distribution policy, first-party registry/manifest, off-RT VST3 validation/cached discovery and safe ID resolver, exact Windows installer/portable package, Factory picker, ArSonKuPik from published v0.5.26 binary and ArSonEQ from branch-qualified VST3 once exact-head artifact exists. One exact-head Windows ZIP containing EXE+complete modules, no third-party/user plugins. If EQ/ASKP legal or CI is missing, mark blocked, do not pretend bundled.
FXF2 — Factory Reverb + Comp/Color/Harmony: ArSonVerb licensing and VST validation; make ArSonComp / ArSonColor / ArSonHarmony reusable standalone DSP-core and VST3 wrappers in their own repos. Different category audio algorithms: compressor (threshold/ratio/attack/release/knee/makeup/optional sidechain), reverb (wet/dry, decay, early/late, bounded tail), color (drive/saturation/oversampling with correct latency), harmony (pitch tracking, intervals, formant/musical stereo, explicit lookahead latency). No naive sample delay pretending harmony is done.
FXF3 — Production upgrade / Show portability: locked plugin ID/state/parameter migration, plugin updates+rollback, real mono/stereo path, PRE/POST shared AUX, multi-VST chain, plugin failure isolation if feasible; license/offline/clean PC install, 44.1/48/96k and 128/256/480 if supported, CPU/memory benchmark and real-hardware FAT after #15. Build once at coherent milestone, targeted tests before heavy CI.
Cross-thread dependency
#170 product epic; #95 all-channel FX/PDC; G5A #178 and MS1 #184 are MERGED; check current main; #173 channel format; #174 AUX/bus; #175 physical output; #176 L2 lock; #85 user vault; #15 zero-FX crackle. No concurrent edits to src/PluginCatalog.h, web/plugin-ui.js, src/LiveDryRoutingLab.h without current HEAD review.
Definition of DONE: user downloads one official Windows package, opens ArSonMix offline on clean PC, sees Factory EQ/Enhancer actually verified and host-loadable without global rescan, inserts into CH1+CH2 with real audible DSP, saves/reopens Show retaining states, gets clear license status, and owns fully functional separate USER VST import. Additional categories become DONE only when real build+host/hardware acceptance passes.
Activity
masarray commentedon Oct 30, 2026
2026-10-31 FXF2 cross-repo implementation: PR #210 adds lightweight auto-detection of public ArSonEQ/ArSonVerb/ArSonKuPik releases and SHA256-pinned VST3 approval→staging→Windows ZIP verification. Existing single native JUCE host is preserved; factory binary download/build never runs on RT. The approved release lock starts EMPTY: source PR is NOT actual bundled FactoryFX. EQ #6 public release+embedded BUILD mismatch, Verb #4 outbound licence/public release, ASKPVST #60 bundling entitlement still gate first real bundle. Native Windows CI for PR #210 is running; no hardware #15 FAT claim. See docs/FACTORYFX_RELEASE_INTAKE_20261031.md.
masarray commentedon Oct 31, 2026
2026-10-31 fourth original FactoryFX sibling reconciled: PR #225 adds real
masarray/arson-comprelease observation and safe Windows VST3Plugin/ArSonComp.vst3packaging with standalone exclusion + offline tests. Original compressor engine/JUCE plugin is onarson-compdraft PR #1, head80a41f52, Linux/Windows CI 41156358804 SUCCESS. Public GitHub Release is not yet published, main source still unmerged and therefore not approved for public Factory FX. ArSonComp release checklist #2 tracks exact artifact provenance, AGPL/JUCE licence, actual host UID/CID, state/sidechain/FAT. Four real source suppliers EQ, COMP, VERB, KuPik; six-effect product requirement unchanged. Approved bundle lock stays empty until evidence permits promotion.masarray commentedon Oct 31, 2026
Reconciliation / real four-sibling FactoryFX: Old PR #225 Windows CI passed but GitHub rejected merge into newer main; replacement PR #229 ports its distinct watcher, Comp
Plugin/ArSonComp.vst3packager support, standalone exclusion, offline tests and docs onto main without overwriting latest AGENTS/device routing code. Exact current-head Windows CI still required before merging. ArSonEQ, Comp, Verb and KuPik are the first four original sibling sources; Harmony/Color future; approved release lock remains EMPTY (no factory binary shipped). Comp sibling latest PR #1 head moved to673c2ca9and has no public GitHub Release; source progress != release provenance and host qualification. Preserve licence/host CID/UID/Show/hardware gates.masarray commentedon Nov 1, 2026
ArSonVerb upstream update (2026-11-01) for Factory FX qualification: canonical upstream issue arsonverb#4 is now closed as superseded by this ArSonMix epic, not as confirmation of Factory FX integration.
Available: official ArSonVerb v1.0.1 Windows VST3-only ZIP, release source + checksum manifest, source tag
4c65f369348790bb6da7465deaffc2b3921fdeee, owner-approved AGPL-3.0-only (with corresponding source obligations), and native JUCE 12/12 tests on Windows/Linux/macOS.Still must be verified HERE before ArSonMix shipping: VST3 class/UID discovery and SHA attestation from the actual binary; licence/JUCE source obligations for bundled redistribution; one true stereo AUX return receiving two MIC PRE/POST sends with no duplicated dry; state/preset/bypass and real hardware FAT, including unresolved ArSonMix #15.
Canonical upstream integration handoff. Please do not infer ArSonMix already bundles or runs the VST3 from upstream test success.
masarray commentedon Nov 1, 2026
Cross-repo handoff from ArSonComp #2 — 2026-11-01
ArSonComp v0.2.0 Stable is now publicly downloadable at https://github.com/masarray/arson-comp/releases/tag/v0.2.0. The Windows Inno Setup, Linux DEB/portable and macOS universal installer assets are present. Stable was promoted byte-for-byte from owner-tested v0.2.0-rc.1, with SHA-256 verification (promotion CI).
FactoryFX integration is a distinct ArSonMix acceptance gate and is NOT automatically complete because a public ArSonComp installer exists. ArSonMix
config/factoryfx-approved-releases.jsonon main still contains an emptypluginsarray, and FactoryFX PR #225 remains an open draft as of this review.Remaining ArSonMix-owned steps:
config/factoryfx-approved-releases.jsonand verify it is shipped by ArSonMix's real Windows installer.This tracks the unfinished host-integration work originally listed in ArSonComp #2. Keep this epic open; neither cross-repo release nor bundled FactoryFX is falsely marked delivered.
masarray commentedon Nov 7, 2026
Owner priority correction — 2026-11-08 (supersedes previous mandatory-six/mandatory-four FactoryFX gates): ArSonMix is FIRST a stable, optimized native mixer with built-in EQ/FX. External ArSonEQ, ArSonComp, ArSonVerb and ArSonKuPik VST3 are OPTIONAL BONUS MODULES. Their absence, upstream download failure, licensing delay, host qualification delay or missing plugin must not block ArSonMix mixer release, installation, native audio output, Show recall or bug fixes. Prefer to include as many independently approved and tested modules as available, ideally at least one; 0–4 is acceptable for a core release with accurate packaging notice. Six-effect roadmap is optional future expansion, not a shipping prerequisite.
Implementation PR #446: per-plugin best-effort hash-locked staging + explicit omission report; independent exact-subset ZIP verification; runtime quarantine of invalid Factory module without disabling healthy Factory modules; native built-in EQ, one JUCE PCM graph and user VST3 import unchanged. Strict source SHA, VST3 class/host identity, license/entitlement and native host gate remain mandatory for each module actually shipped. Zero fake plugin cards, no private activation bypass. Current approved lock remains EMPTY; built-in EQ still ships. Do not claim any VST3 bonus has shipped until exact Windows ZIP and installer contain verified binaries.
This is a binding product-priority correction, not an excuse to treat unqualified binaries as safe.
[-][P0 Factory FX] Bundle first-party ArSonEQ + ArSonKuPik and build six native VST3 effects for ArSonMix[/-][+][P2][OPTIONAL] Factory VST3 bonus — qualify available plugin modules per OS[/+]masarray commentedon Nov 10, 2026
2026-11-10 priority clarification — optional bonus, NOT core release blocker
Owner correction documented on 2026-11-08 supersedes this issue's original P0/six-plugin wording. Native mixer, built-in EQ/Compressor/Harmonice/Vocal Throw and approved /preview/ can progress and release independently of external ArSonEQ/ArSonComp/ArSonVerb/ArSonKuPik artifact availability. Factory VST3 extras are best-effort (0–4 are acceptable when manifest honestly identifies omitted modules); six VST3s are a future roadmap, not mandatory. Per-plugin provenance, compatible OS architecture, independent host-load/PCM state tests and licence rules remain required before claiming that particular bonus plugin is shipped. Merged #446 already introduced optional locked intake; remaining verified bundle acceptance stays open as P2 backlog, not P0. Classification archived in merged #524.