Skip to content

[MS6 P1] LV1-grade Show/Scene operational safety: scoped recall, Recall Safe, vendor FX state, portable recovery #180

Open

Description

@masarray

Milestone B verified triage — 2026-11-17: P1 / session / feature / backlog. Classification ≠ completion of product feature or physical FAT.

Scope / release boundary: Show/Scene operational safety and state recovery.

Exit criteria:

  • Demonstrate scoped Recall Safe, no unintended changes to hardware/device/WIRE/FX under partial scene recall.
  • Verify vendor VST3 state restoration, rollback, portable .smix, corrupt input fail-closed and native GUI/PCM readback.

Canonical issue ledger. Preserve historical evidence below; no speculative merging or rewriting approved audio.


FACTORY FX / SIX FIRST-PARTY VST3 (2026-10-30): Factory FX ADR · Factory FX PRD · manifest schema · merged architecture PR #187 · epic #185. Six original bundled VST3 targets: ArSonEQ, ArSonComp, ArSonVerb, ArSonHarmony, ArSonColor, ArSonKuPik Enhancer. NO binary FactoryFX modules are currently shipped by this docs change; first qualify ASKPVST public v0.5.26 + ArSonEQ feature branch artifacts and obtain product/AGPL/JUCE/EULA approval; ArSonVerb license and Comp/Harmony/Color DSP are later gates. ASKPVST #60, EQ #6, Verb #4. G5A #178 and MS1 #184 are already MERGED. Factory immutable VST3 modules must use existing native FX graph while USER vault remains separate; protect L2 #176, PDC #95, actual hardware #15. Do NOT mark a plugin loadable from a roadmap card.

Intent / authority

Separate Show/Scene safety milestone under product epic #170. Reference: Waves LV1 Classic User Guide — Show / Scenes / Scope / Recall Safe and Fender Studio Pro Console / Scene workflows. Preserve portable VST contract #85 and GUI #176.

Current code is a base, not proof of complete recall

Existing src/NativeLiveShowCapture.h, src/NativeShowStore.h, src/NativeShowSchema.h, src/NativeShowSaveWorker.h, src/StudioBackup.h, src/PluginVault.h have partial real native capture/DRY recall/backup/VST vault facilities. Do not overwrite them, duplicate Show formats, or assume every channel's VST binary state and bus output patches already restore.

Definition of Done

  • Session/Show model with stable channel/bus IDs, versioned schema, typed source vs processing format, plugin identity/version/binary state, device stable pin identity, native accepted route revision, scenes within a Show; lossless migration of older schema or actionable rejection.
  • Full audible FX-chain state restore for CH1–10, FX AUX/GROUP/MAIN only where actual native insert capabilities exist; preserve shared return identity, muted tail handling, plugin failures with full transaction rollback.
  • User-defined Recall Scope for sections: gain, MUTE/SOLO, PAN, sends, native routing, insert chain/vendor parameters, selected format; channel/bus filters; operator Recall Safe fences protected channels/parameters. Unknown hardware or missing VST must not silently swap or unmute.
  • Save, duplicate, rename, preview diff, restore and revert Scene, with explicit MODIFIED indicator, human-readable error/negative ACK, no automatic sudden scene-induced output. Structural recall MUTED; accepted graph only after control-thread preparation.
  • Portable backup/restore via same public executable and USER-OWNED vault, deterministic selective plugin discovery, integrity/hash and missing dependency report, manifest migration; never publish private plugins/presets in official release.
  • Blackout/restart/hotplug/stale epoch, invalid VST state/missing plugin/old Show/invalid output pin test suite; same show on compatible 2×2 and 8×8 device rebind remains fail-closed until explicit confirmation.
  • Exact-head Windows CTest/GUI and real-device FAT prior to release claim. Preserve callback no allocation/locks/JSON/plugin instantiation and L2 layout lock.

Dependencies

MS1 #173 + MS2 #174 typed graph; MS3 #175 for any physical output scene; MS4 #95 multi-insert/PDC for full plugin-state parity. Early UI can expose existing DRY Show truthfully and must label non-restorable sections unsupported.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions