Skip to content

squad cast leaves built-ins (Scribe, Ralph, Rai, Fact Checker) out of team.md, so Claude and Copilot report different rosters #2522

Closed

Description

@bradygaster

Problem

When the Claude Code coordinator casts a team by running squad cast once per member, .squad/team.md ends up listing only the cast members. Scribe, Ralph, Rai and Fact Checker are never added to ## Members, even though squad init creates their charters under .squad/agents/.

The Init Mode protocol (coordinator-init-mode skill) says the roster includes the four always-on built-ins, typically 8–9 rows. #1299 was the same gap for Fact Checker alone, on the Copilot path.

Why it matters across hosts

team.md is the roster both hosts share. Claude's coordinator prompt says the built-ins "always exist even if team.md was rewritten", so Claude reports them. Copilot answers roster questions from team.md, so it reports only the cast members. The same team then looks different depending on which host you ask.

Repro (2.0.0-preview.6 local build)

  1. Fresh repo, then squad init --client copilot,claude. team.md has an empty ## Members table.
  2. claude -p --agent squad --mcp-config .mcp.json with a project description and "cast the team now".
  3. The coordinator runs squad cast for each member (casting/history.json shows three cli-cast snapshots).
  4. team.md ## Members lists Penny, Sterling and Tally only. Claude's reply lists the built-ins too.
  5. copilot --agent squad, then "who's on this team?" returns three specialists and no built-ins.

Cause

updateTeamMdWithAgent in packages/squad-cli/src/cli/commands/cast.ts only adds the member being cast. Nothing in the squad cast path, and nothing in the squad init team.md scaffold, adds the built-in rows.

Suggested fix

Have squad cast (or squad init's team.md scaffold) make sure the four built-in rows are present in ## Members, idempotently, using the canonical rows:

| Scribe | Decision Merger | `.squad/agents/scribe/charter.md` | 📋 Silent |
| Ralph | Work Monitor | `.squad/agents/ralph/charter.md` | 🔄 Monitor |
| Rai | RAI Reviewer | `.squad/agents/rai/charter.md` | 🛡️ RAI |
| Fact Checker | Devil's Advocate & Verification Agent | `.squad/agents/fact-checker/charter.md` | 🔍 Verifier |

Note: keep the Init Mode "no members = unconfigured" check working. If init seeds the built-in rows, that check has to count cast members only.

Related, seen in the same run

  • The em dash in a recorded decision (— the Ledger crew) was stored as -- in decisions.md.
  • The Claude coordinator cast 3 members (the protocol says 4–5) and skipped the Phase 1 propose-and-confirm step. The prompt said "cast now" under claude -p, so this may be expected.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Activity

  1. bradygaster commented on Nov 17, 2026

    @bradygaster
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Related roster wording, seen in the same run after the built-in rows were added back by hand.

    Asked "who's on this team?", Copilot listed Squad / Coordinator as the first member, next to Penny, Sterling, Tally and the built-ins. The row comes from the ## Coordinator table that every team.md has above ## Members (written by the init templates and by cast.ts). Copilot merged the two tables into one member list. Claude's coordinator kept them apart.

    The file is correct; the problem is how it's presented. Users will read "Squad" as a cast member.

    Suggested fix: in the shared coordinator source, say that roster answers list ## Members and that the coordinator describes itself separately ("I'm Squad, the coordinator"). Don't rename ## Members, because GitHub workflows depend on that header.

    🤖 Generated with Claude Code

  2. added a commit that references this issue on Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions