You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
A read tool's card makes a noReply note visible #3358
An Event Turn that ends with noReply and a note should store the note as a Quiet message. deliverAssistantMessage in chat/task-execution/conversation-turn.ts keeps quiet only when cards.length === 0. Commit 270b94f (#2659) added this rule for a reply that carries a card. But loadPendingMessageCards also returns the object cards of read-only tools such as github_getPullRequest. So an Event Turn that reads a PR and then ends with noReply stores the note as a normal message with the card attached, and the Location gets it.
This affects any Event Turn that reads a PR or issue before it decides that nobody needs to know, for example PR maintenance on pull_request.checks.recovered.
Verified with an integration test through the conversation work harness and a plugin read tool that returns an object annotation:
Event Turn 1 calls the read tool, then noReply {note}: the note is stored as an assistant message with meta.objectCards and no meta.quiet.
Event Turn 2 calls only noReply {note}: the note is stored with meta.quiet: true.
changed the title [-]noReply notes from PR events are posted in the Slack thread[/-][+]noReply note is posted when an Event Turn has a card[/+]on Nov 13, 2026
Fixed on main by #3433 (noReply posts nothing, so a pending card can no longer make the note visible) and #3437 (read-only tools no longer return Annotations). #3360 is closed as superseded.
Activity
[-]noReply notes from PR events are posted in the Slack thread[/-][+]noReply note is posted when an Event Turn has a card[/+][-]noReply note is posted when an Event Turn has a card[/-][+]A read tool's card makes a noReply note visible[/+]fix(events): Deliver a no-reply note only for cards from changes
sentry-junior commentedon Nov 14, 2026
Fixed on main by #3433 (
noReplyposts nothing, so a pending card can no longer make the note visible) and #3437 (read-only tools no longer return Annotations). #3360 is closed as superseded.