Skip to content

Decide whether EuRoC-derived rows may be published #278

Open

Description

@Telschow

Parent

#250

What to build

The committed data includes 8903 per-frame rows derived from EuRoC, whose rights statement is non-commercial. Decide whether the derived rows, and the figures and tables built from them, may be published in this repository. Record the decision where a reader sees the data licence, and reply on the roadmap with the reasoning.

If publication is not permitted, create the follow-up for removing or replacing the rows rather than editing them in place.

Acceptance criteria

  • A written decision cites the EuRoC rights statement and covers both the rows and the derived figures.
  • The EuRoC notice states the decision in the place a reader looks for the licence.
  • If permission is refused, a follow-up ticket describes the removal or aggregate-only replacement.
  • No committed rows are changed without that follow-up.

Blocked by

None (needs a maintainer decision, not code).

Activity

  1. Telschow commented on Nov 7, 2026

    @Telschow
    OwnerAuthor

    Inventory for this decision, from a read-only review at bee838d (2026-11-07). It describes the content of the files; it is not a legal assessment.

    What the EuRoC-derived files contain

    • docs/data/vo_errors.csv has 8903 per-frame rows over MH_01 to MH_05.
      • rot_*, lat_* and dir_err_deg are front-end errors against ground truth. tracked and inliers are front-end outputs.
      • t_s is the camera timestamp minus the first IMU timestamp, at full precision (src/navkit/vo_error.py:88, :118). Adding that one offset back recovers the original timestamps.
      • baseline_m is the norm of the interpolated ground-truth relative translation: a scalar, not a coordinate.
    • The other files hold per-run filter outputs or features: euroc_compare, euroc_validation, separability, fault_classification*, multipath_*, slow_ramp, vision_ramp, vo_clone_check and vo_wide. timing.csv holds aggregates.
    • No file holds raw IMU samples, ground-truth coordinates or images.

    Notices and wording

    • No CSV carries a notice of its own. The non-commercial notice is in README.md (License) and docs/euroc.md.
    • separability, the ramp files, timing and the fault and multipath files also hold TUM VI rows.
    • ADR-0042's decision covers rows. This issue asks about rows and derived figures, and the figures are not addressed there.
    • ADR-0016:13 says CC BY "fits an MIT repository so long as the data is attributed and not redistributed". That reads as a legal conclusion in a decision record.

    Already changed in #309 (draft)

    • The site footer says MIT covers the code.
    • The FAQ no longer says only aggregates are committed.
    • "Not verified here" is replaced by the rights statement.
    • The README points to ADR-0042 and this issue, and says no rights-holder answer is recorded.

    Not found: any message to or answer from the rights holder, in the repo or in this issue. The decision remains open.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    documentationImprovements or additions to documentationready-for-humanRequires human implementation

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions