Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
66 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
e91d462
Rewrite uk_trussell_wpi's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
14e962e
Rewrite uk_hmt_tables's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
63b58ab
Rewrite uk_ippr's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
edff535
Rewrite uk_thinktank_misc's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
05594af
Rewrite uk_devolved_govts's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
52e74f7
Keep uk_ippr's "Not staged" heading, which its review notes cite
claude Nov 5, 2026
4a2d675
Rewrite uk_centax's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
78431ad
Rewrite uk_tpa's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
cf0624c
Rewrite uk_hmt_costings's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
811edda
Rewrite uk_rf_ab2026's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
3ac2137
Rewrite uk_obr_tables's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
25976b9
Rewrite uk_hmt_redbook's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
c8da3e1
Rewrite uk_ifs_ab2026's NOTES.md in active voice
claude Nov 5, 2026
ce85fe2
Give five NOTES.md sentences a named actor
claude Nov 5, 2026
794635c
Restore the "Access recipe" headings the review notes cite
claude Nov 5, 2026
fbe0d76
Merge the closed reader of value_raw into the notes rewrite
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
8bb45ad
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_trussell_wpi's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
6e21132
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_hmt_tables's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
76d3fed
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_ippr's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
97e5ca0
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_thinktank_misc's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
1c00ca4
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_devolved_govts's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
1f0f9d8
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_centax's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
7f0273c
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_tpa's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
ee61706
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_hmt_costings's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
8f2511a
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_rf_ab2026's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
9ac6030
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_obr_tables's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
61be4db
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_hmt_redbook's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
4a34051
Answer the fbe0d76c review in uk_ifs_ab2026's notes
claude Nov 5, 2026
9d80c87
Name the coordinator in uk_trussell_wpi's notes (4a34051b review, fin…
claude Nov 5, 2026
56a2f9c
Give IPPR North the verb in uk_ippr's notes (4a34051b review, finding 7)
claude Nov 5, 2026
4c503f7
Return the Barnett key's total to us in uk_devolved_govts's notes (4a…
claude Nov 5, 2026
a3fe375
Tie TPA's 4 November check to review B's fetch and give rule 10 to us…
claude Nov 5, 2026
cfacdd2
List uk_centax's duplicate figures by page (4a34051b review, finding 10)
claude Nov 5, 2026
08b8bf4
Fix the dateModified sentence, name proposed keys as such and list RF…
claude Nov 5, 2026
93de6aa
Name proposed keys as such and fix the social care sentence in uk_obr…
claude Nov 5, 2026
3169c5c
Give us the verbs and list p.60's pages in uk_hmt_costings's notes (4…
claude Nov 5, 2026
b600fb4
Name proposed keys as such, give HM Treasury and us the verbs and lis…
claude Nov 5, 2026
dd8efed
Name proposed keys as such and keep the first lane's record in its vo…
claude Nov 5, 2026
b234743
Keep row 82 among uk_ifs_ab2026's kept Adam rows
claude Nov 5, 2026
5eadd86
Correct uk_ifs_ab2026's addendum sentences and Adam's key counts agai…
claude Nov 5, 2026
68fec00
Give us the Barnett key's scope and cut an intensifier in uk_devolved…
claude Nov 5, 2026
91c3a22
Cut an intensifier in uk_thinktank_misc's notes (b2347435 review, ite…
claude Nov 5, 2026
858d2f4
Join the 4 November run and give us the row verbs in uk_tpa's notes (…
claude Nov 5, 2026
3fcaa7c
Give us the row verbs and move the p.90 sentence out of the page list…
claude Nov 5, 2026
e57844c
Name who registers metrics, scope the proposed keys and drop the impl…
claude Nov 5, 2026
0d146e5
State only what the rows show about the social care reforms in uk_obr…
claude Nov 5, 2026
dbfd766
Give HM Treasury and us the verbs in uk_hmt_redbook's sign convention…
claude Nov 5, 2026
711f51e
Give uk_ifs_ab2026's dropped Wernham metrics to the first lane in the…
claude Nov 5, 2026
96a2fc9
State what #247's ingest does with uk_hmt_tables's Table 6.2 metric a…
claude Nov 5, 2026
e4cefd5
State what #247's ingest does with uk_obr_tables's financing-requirem…
claude Nov 5, 2026
60cbe6d
State what #247's ingest does with uk_rf_ab2026's fuel duty freeze rows
claude Nov 5, 2026
20b859c
State what #247's ingest does with uk_tpa's derived rows and repeated…
claude Nov 5, 2026
ddcecf8
State what #247's ingest does with uk_centax's percentage and 2024-er…
claude Nov 5, 2026
dd47de3
State what #247 does with uk_hmt_redbook's breathing-space row and Ta…
claude Nov 5, 2026
20ee775
State what #247's ingest does with uk_hmt_costings's p.41 rows
claude Nov 5, 2026
b5c3371
State how #247's ingest treats uk_tpa's derived rows
claude Nov 5, 2026
28dd2c4
State how #247's ingest treats uk_centax's childcare costings
claude Nov 5, 2026
2883dcb
State how #247's ingest merges uk_rf_ab2026's repeated figures
claude Nov 5, 2026
a8844a3
Name who registered the keys in the family notes
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
1ad235f
Give today's row numbers in uk_tpa's at-ingest sentence
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
10aa34d
Answer the review of 1ad235f3: the OBR row's reason, row 2740, IFS's …
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
6943033
Merge uk/ab2026-harvest into uk/ab2026-notes-voice
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
a8f6c29
Answer the review of 69430330: restore OBR signs, row 2740, document …
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
207dfec
Answer the low findings in the review of a8f6c299: actors in nine sen…
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
0e444f7
Give the remaining document-as-actor verbs to their actors
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
e78e192
Notes: answer the cloud review of 0e444f7f
MaxGhenis Nov 5, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
168 changes: 87 additions & 81 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_centax/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

187 changes: 97 additions & 90 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_devolved_govts/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

351 changes: 179 additions & 172 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_hmt_costings/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

296 changes: 176 additions & 120 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_hmt_redbook/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

84 changes: 42 additions & 42 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_hmt_tables/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

721 changes: 408 additions & 313 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_ifs_ab2026/NOTES.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

63 changes: 32 additions & 31 deletions sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/uk_ippr/NOTES.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,25 +1,25 @@
# uk_ippr: IPPR, Autumn Budget 2026

This family stages IPPR's three responses to the Budget on 28 October 2026, found on the ippr.org media-office listing:
In this family we stage IPPR's three responses to the Budget on 28 October 2026, which we found on the ippr.org media-office listing:

- "‘Unfinished business’ on economic reform after sound Budget, says IPPR";
- "IPPR North reacts to Andy Burnham’s first Budget";
- "IPPR Scotland reacts to Andy Burnham's first Budget".

The listing shows nothing on 29 October. The source slug is `ippr`, as in the AB2025 `uk_ippr` family.
IPPR lists nothing on 29 October. We use the source slug `ippr`, as in the AB2025 `uk_ippr` family.

**Working files.** `stage.py`, the file meant wherever these notes say `stage.py`, lives on branch `uk/ab2026-harvest-staging` at `harvest-staging/ab2026/lanes/thinktanks-a/uk_ippr/stage.py`; this branch carries only NOTES.md, `manifest.jsonl` and `claims_staged.jsonl.gz`. The lane's local primaries folder (`.ab2026-primaries/uk_ippr/`) was never committed: the repository carries no primary bytes, so fetch each primary from its `manifest.jsonl` URL and check its sha256.
We keep `stage.py` on branch `uk/ab2026-harvest-staging` at `harvest-staging/ab2026/lanes/thinktanks-a/uk_ippr/stage.py`. We commit only NOTES.md, `manifest.jsonl` and `claims_staged.jsonl.gz` to this branch, and no primary bytes to the repository. The lane never committed its local primaries folder (`.ab2026-primaries/uk_ippr/`), so fetch each primary from its `manifest.jsonl` URL and check its sha256.

`stage.py` holds the rows as data and rewrites `manifest.jsonl` and `claims_staged.jsonl.gz` byte for byte. `stage.py --verify` checks each primary's sha256 and finds every quote in its page's text. Result: 0 problems.
We wrote the rows into `stage.py` as data, and it rewrites `manifest.jsonl` and `claims_staged.jsonl.gz` byte for byte. `stage.py --verify` checks each primary's sha256 and finds every quote in its page's text; it reports 0 problems.

- **Rows:** 3 (restated 2, own 1).
- **Primaries:** 3.
- Rows: 3 (restated 2, own 1).
- Primaries: 3.

## Access recipe

- **The listing:** the media-office listing (https://www.ippr.org/media-office, pages 1 and 2) was fetched on 2026-10-29 to find the responses. `/news-and-media` returns 404, and `/articles` lists no Budget piece.
- **The releases:** all three were fetched directly (`curl -sSL`, browser User-Agent, HTTP 200), "Unfinished business" at 16:17Z and the North and Scotland releases at 16:35Z.
- **`dateModified` is a render time, not an edit:** each page's JSON-LD showed a `dateModified` on 29 October (16:04Z, 16:21Z, 16:34Z), after its 28 October `datePublished`. Review B's fetches on 4 November show 14:39–14:46Z that day with byte-identical length, and two fetches of the same page 30 minutes apart differ only in that field and Cloudflare's email tokens. So the field records when the page was served, and no edit after publication is shown. The copies hashed are the fetches above. Nothing came from a local copy.
- We fetched the media-office listing (https://www.ippr.org/media-office, pages 1 and 2) on 2026-10-29 to find the responses. IPPR's `/news-and-media` returns 404, and IPPR lists no Budget piece on its `/articles`.
- We fetched all three releases directly (`curl -sSL`, browser User-Agent, HTTP 200): "Unfinished business" at 16:17Z and the North and Scotland releases at 16:35Z.
- We read each page's JSON-LD `dateModified` as a render time, not an edit. On 29 October IPPR's server gave each page a `dateModified` that day (16:04Z, 16:21Z, 16:34Z), after its 28 October `datePublished`. Review B's fetches on 4 November show 14:39–14:46Z that day with byte-identical length. Two fetches of the same page 30 minutes apart differ only in that field and Cloudflare's email tokens. So IPPR's server stamps the field when it serves the page, and we found no sign of an edit after publication. We hashed the copies from the fetches above and took nothing from a local copy.

## Rows by primary and measure key

Expand All @@ -31,32 +31,33 @@ The listing shows nothing on 29 October. The source slug is `ippr`, as in the AB

| measure_key | rows |
|---|--:|
| `null` (1 with a proposed key, 2 context) | 3 |
| `ab2026_option__income_tax_5pc_share_devolved_to_mayors` | 1 |
| `null` (context) | 2 |

## The three rows

1. **"It will lower inflation by at least 0.2 percentage points"** (Carsten Jung, on "the cost of living support announced today").
- Staged as `cpi_inflation_effect`, 0.2, `range_low`, with `sign_convention: "as worded: positive = reduction in CPI inflation"`: IPPR prints the magnitude unsigned, README rule 10 keeps the producer's sign, and "at least" makes it a lower bound (changed on 4 November, review B finding 1). Context, with no proposed key: IPPR's words do not define the scope (changed on 3 November, thinktanks-a review finding 1).
- IPPR names no source and no period. The OBR's EFO paragraph 3.10 says the fuel duty changes and the temporary VAT cut on domestic electricity (Table 6.1 lines 2 and 3) "reduce CPI inflation by 0.22 percentage points in the second quarter of 2027". So the row is `restated` with `parse_confidence: medium`, at `period` 2027 (`point_in_time`).
- We stage it as `cpi_inflation_effect`, 0.2, `range_low`, with `sign_convention: "as worded: positive = reduction in CPI inflation"`. IPPR prints the magnitude unsigned, under README rule 10 we keep the producer's sign, and "at least" makes it a lower bound; we made this change on 4 November, after review B finding 1. We stage it as context, with no proposed key, because IPPR's words do not define the scope; we made that change on 3 November, after thinktanks-a review finding 1.
- IPPR names no source and no period. In the EFO's paragraph 3.10, the OBR says the fuel duty changes and the temporary VAT cut on domestic electricity (Table 6.1 lines 2 and 3) "reduce CPI inflation by 0.22 percentage points in the second quarter of 2027". We therefore mark the row `restated`, with `parse_confidence: medium`, at `period` 2027 (`point_in_time`).
2. **"the £18 billion annual taxpayer losses at the Bank of England"** (Carsten Jung).
- Staged as `apf_indemnity_losses`, the AB2025 uk_ippr proposal, which staged IPPR's "£22 billion" the same way. `restated`, source not stated.
- It has no year, so it sits at the scoring year 2026-27 with a `year_note`. This is context with no measure key.
- We stage it as `apf_indemnity_losses`, the AB2025 uk_ippr proposal, under which we staged IPPR's "£22 billion" the same way. We mark it `restated`, source not stated.
- Jung gives no year, so we put it at the scoring year 2026-27 with a `year_note`. We stage it as context with no measure key.
3. **"Five per cent of income tax devolved to mayors would see an additional £4billion"** (IPPR North).
- IPPR North's own estimate of an option beyond the Budget's commitment on income tax devolution. Proposed key `ab2026_option__income_tax_5pc_share_devolved_to_mayors`, proposed metric `devolved_revenue` (gbp).
- It has no year, so it sits at the scoring year with a `year_note`. The release links the paper "Devolution that delivers: Fiscal power for regional growth".
- IPPR North estimates, on its own account, an option beyond the Budget's commitment on income tax devolution. We key it to `ab2026_option__income_tax_5pc_share_devolved_to_mayors` and propose the metric `devolved_revenue` (gbp). On 29 October we gave the row `measure_key: null` and proposed this key, and in tranche 2 we registered it.
- IPPR North gives no year, so we put it at the scoring year with a `year_note`. IPPR North links the paper "Devolution that delivers: Fiscal power for regional growth" from the release.

## Proposed keys and their scope
## Option keys and their scope

- **`ab2026_option__income_tax_5pc_share_devolved_to_mayors`:** "Five per cent of income tax devolved to mayors". No Table 6.1 line. The Budget made commitments "on devolving business rates and a share of income tax to England's mayors" (line 21 covers the business rates share) without setting a 5% share.
- **`ab2026_option__income_tax_5pc_share_devolved_to_mayors`:** "Five per cent of income tax devolved to mayors". HM Treasury prints no Table 6.1 line for it. The Budget made commitments "on devolving business rates and a share of income tax to England's mayors" (line 21 covers the business rates share) without setting a 5% share.

## Not staged, and why

- **Design, not estimates** (README rule 8: spending allocations, financing remits and payment amounts are a measure's design):
- IPPR North's "£285million of good growth funds" is HM Treasury's allocation ("£285 million in 2027-28, comprising £165 million to support places with a mayor … to establish Good Growth Funds and £120 million of incubator capital funding for areas transitioning towards a devolution deal"), restated. It is a spending allocation, and part of Table 6.1 line 20, whose costing (−£340m in 2027-28) also includes the subsidy on the £1.5bn finance. The reworked uk_hmt_redbook family does not stage HM Treasury's £285m either (rule 8).
- IPPR North's "£1.5billion borrowing facilities for building infrastructure" is the size of HM Treasury's lending facility for Mayoral Strategic Authorities, a financing remit; the reworked uk_hmt_redbook family stages no `policy_parameter` row and does not stage it either.
- IPPR Scotland's "Bill support of £100 for households in lower council tax bands" is the Household Energy Payment's amount.
- **IPPR Scotland** prints no other number, so it gives 0 rows; it is manifested for the tally.
- **Pre-Budget IPPR releases about this Budget,** outside the assigned "responses of 28–29 October". Each was fetched and hashed on 2026-10-29, and each is a candidate for a follow-up if the family is to include pre-Budget options, as AB2025's did:
- Under README rule 8 we treat spending allocations, financing remits and payment amounts as a measure's design, and left these out:
- IPPR North's "£285million of good growth funds" restates HM Treasury's allocation ("£285 million in 2027-28, comprising £165 million to support places with a mayor … to establish Good Growth Funds and £120 million of incubator capital funding for areas transitioning towards a devolution deal"). HM Treasury makes it a spending allocation and costs it within Table 6.1 line 20, whose costing (−£340m in 2027-28) also includes the subsidy on the £1.5bn finance. In the reworked uk_hmt_redbook family we don't stage HM Treasury's £285m either (rule 8).
- IPPR North restates the size of HM Treasury's lending facility for Mayoral Strategic Authorities, a financing remit, as "£1.5billion borrowing facilities for building infrastructure". In the reworked uk_hmt_redbook family we stage no `policy_parameter` row and leave it out there too.
- In "Bill support of £100 for households in lower council tax bands", IPPR Scotland restates the Household Energy Payment's amount.
- IPPR Scotland prints no other number, so we stage 0 rows from it; we manifest it for the tally.
- We left out IPPR's pre-Budget releases about this Budget, which fall outside the assigned "responses of 28–29 October". We fetched and hashed each on 2026-10-29, and each could seed a follow-up if the family should include pre-Budget options, as AB2025's did:
- 27 October, "Chancellor’s £20bn to invest would cost less than £1 billion in headroom: IPPR analysis" (sha256 `e26f9b14989f14af…`): £20bn of NWF and BBB investment costing under £1bn in debt interest and running costs in 2029-30.
- 15 October, "Get started with tax reform to pay for priorities…" (sha256 `97750268ba93a3b6…`):
- a £16bn package: CGT reform about £10bn, deferring Bank of England losses £5bn, a bank windfall surcharge £1bn;
Expand All @@ -71,18 +72,18 @@ The listing shows nothing on 29 October. The source slug is `ippr`, as in the AB
- multipliers cut from 38.2p and 43p to 28.2p and 41p;
- property taxes at 10.5% of revenue against an OECD average of 5.1%;
- business rates of £27.6bn.
The papers behind them were not fetched: "Cost of living, economic growth and stability: How to make this autumn budget a success", "Bricks vs clicks", "Devolution that delivers" and "Beyond headroom".
We didn't fetch the papers behind them: "Cost of living, economic growth and stability: How to make this autumn budget a success", "Bricks vs clicks", "Devolution that delivers" and "Beyond headroom".

## Review fixes, 3 November 2026

The thinktanks-a review (`harvest-staging/ab2026/reviews/verify-thinktanks-a.md` on the staging branch) approved this family with one fix, applied in an explicit block at the end of `stage.py`'s rows:
In its review (`harvest-staging/ab2026/reviews/verify-thinktanks-a.md` on the staging branch), the thinktanks-a reviewer approved this family with one fix, which we applied in an explicit block at the end of `stage.py`'s rows:

- **Finding 1:** row 0 (−0.2pp CPI) is context. Jung says only "The cost of living support announced today", and Quilter-Pinner "action to support families with the cost of living". The lines 2 and 3 scope came from matching the OBR's paragraph 3.10, which is our inference, and README rule 3 says the scope must be the producer's. So the proposed key `ab2026__package_cost_of_living_support` is withdrawn, the reform hint and note stay, and `value_kind` is `range_high`.
- **Verification:** no primary was re-opened (the session's network policy refused ippr.org); the contract checker reports 3 rows, 0 problems, and a re-run of `stage.py` reproduces both files byte for byte.
- Finding 1: we made row 0 (−0.2pp CPI) context. Jung says only "The cost of living support announced today", and Quilter-Pinner "action to support families with the cost of living". We had taken the lines 2 and 3 scope by matching the OBR's paragraph 3.10, our own inference, and under README rule 3 we must use the producer's scope. So we withdrew the proposed key `ab2026__package_cost_of_living_support`, kept the reform hint and note, and set `value_kind` to `range_high`.
- We re-opened no primary, because the session's network policy refused ippr.org. The contract checker reports 3 rows, 0 problems, and when we re-run `stage.py` it reproduces both files byte for byte.

## Review fixes, 4 November 2026

Review B (PR #231, issue comment 6635498758) approved this family with fixes; review A's K-7(f) asked for the same NOTES correction as its second item. This session re-opened no primary.
Review B (PR #231, issue comment 6635498758) approved this family with fixes, and review A's K-7(f) asked for the same NOTES correction as its second item. We re-opened no primary in this session.

- **Finding 1 (coordinator's call: take the fix):** row 0 stores 0.2, `range_low`, `sign_convention: "as worded: positive = reduction in CPI inflation"`, as the OBR and red book CPI rows keep the magnitude (`uk_obr_tables` row 2653).
- **Finding 2 and K-7(f):** "Not staged" no longer says the red book stages HM Treasury's £285m or the £1.5bn as `policy_parameter`; the reworked red book stages neither. The access recipe reads JSON-LD `dateModified` as a render time, not an edit.
- Finding 1, where the coordinator chose to take the fix: on row 0 we now store 0.2, `range_low`, `sign_convention: "as worded: positive = reduction in CPI inflation"`. We keep the magnitude, as we do on the OBR and red book CPI rows (`uk_obr_tables` row 2653).
- Finding 2 and K-7(f): under "Not staged" we no longer say that the red book family stages HM Treasury's £285m or the £1.5bn as `policy_parameter`; in the reworked red book family we stage neither. In the access recipe we now read JSON-LD `dateModified` as a render time, not an edit.
Loading
Loading