Skip to content

Port every Autumn Budget 2026 score into the scorecard #230

Open

Description

@MaxGhenis

Autumn Budget 2026 (28 October 2026) is the first fiscal event for which PolicyEngine published its own Budget-day estimates. The UK Autumn Budget dashboard modelled seven household measures, on policyengine.py 6.11.1 (policyengine-uk 2.151.0) and Microcosm UK data. HM Treasury, the OBR, the Resolution Foundation, the IFS and others published their own figures within a day. This issue ports all of it into the scorecard, following the AB2025 port (#136):

  • A measure registry (data/uk/ab2026_measures.json):
    • one entry per HM Treasury Table 6.1 line (98), plus the packages producers score;
    • each entry carries a computability verdict against the engine the dashboard ran;
    • a measure the engine can't express gets a why, a computed name search and a link back here.
  • A harvest (sources/harvest-uk-ab2026-2026-10-29/):
    • each producer's claims, staged verbatim from hashed primary documents under the AB2025 row contract;
    • conditions.fiscal_event = autumn_budget_2026.
  • Ingest of the harvest into the scorecard DB, with exact accounting.
  • PolicyEngine counterparts from the dashboard's published runs, which needs a certified-pair record for 6.11.1.

Tranches

  1. Registry, vocabulary, the harvest, and tests.
  2. Ingest (scorecard_db/ingest_uk_ab2026.py) with an expected-counts file.
  3. PolicyEngine counterparts from the dashboard's receipts, and the comparison.

Producers expected in tranche 1

  • HM Treasury:
    • Tables 6.1, 6.2 and 6.4;
    • the policy costings;
    • the Budget document;
    • Impact on households;
    • the Pension Tax Allowance explainer.
  • OBR: the October 2026 EFO and its detailed policy table.
  • Resolution Foundation: Spread thin and its Budget-day releases.
  • IFS: the initial response and the 29 October briefing decks.
  • Others: Tax Policy Associates, CenTax, CPAG, NIESR, the Fraser of Allander Institute, the Centre for Policy Studies, the Institute for Government, Age UK and the Welsh Government, where each published a figure of its own.

Development items the engine can't yet express are listed in the registry, each with its name search; the PR body will summarise them.

Activity

  1. MaxGhenis commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @MaxGhenis
    ContributorAuthor

    Development items at policyengine-uk 2.151.0

    The registry in #231 (data/uk/ab2026_measures.json) marks 13 Table 6.1 measures as policyengine-uk development items: the household model could express them with a variable or parameter it doesn't have yet. Each gap's action_link points here. Each entry below gives the Table 6.1 line, the measure key and what the engine needs, in the registry's own words (upstream_item). The registry entry also has the computed name search and why.

    line key needed upstream
    5 ab2026__mileage_allowance_payments_55p business mileage and approved mileage allowance payments for employees' own cars and vans
    6 ab2026__parental_allowance_fathers_partners_adopters a Parental Allowance for fathers, partners and adopters (statutory_paternity_pay is the nearest variable)
    8 ab2026__uc_surplus_earnings_threshold_2500_extended Universal Credit surplus earnings carried between assessment periods
    11 ab2026__cash_isa_limit_held_at_20000 ISA subscriptions, a subscription limit, and Lifetime and first-time-buyer ISA withdrawals
    26 ab2026__founders_relief_cgt capital gains by relief (founders' and other business reliefs beyond BADR)
    38 ab2026__first_time_buyer_isa ISA subscriptions, a subscription limit, and Lifetime and first-time-buyer ISA withdrawals
    39 ab2026__lifetime_isa_withdrawal_charge_20pc_above_cap ISA subscriptions, a subscription limit, and Lifetime and first-time-buyer ISA withdrawals
    53 ab2026__pension_death_benefits_two_year_rule_removed estates, death benefits and their income tax treatment
    66 ab2026__vat_5pc_family_days_out_summer_2026 consumption detailed enough to separate admissions to attractions and days out
    67 ab2026__free_bus_travel_children_august_2026 a free-fare rule for children by age and month within the bus fare model
    83 ab2026__student_loan_interest_cap_6pc_plan_2_and_3 a cap on Plan 2 and postgraduate (Plan 3) student loan interest
    86 ab2026__company_car_tax_rates_2030_31 company cars and their benefit-in-kind appropriate percentages
    93 ab2026__hvcts_deferrals_discounts_exemptions deferrals, discounts and exemptions within the high value council tax surcharge

    The bus fare cap (line 4) is partial rather than a development item. The engine carries the £2 cap from January 2027, but records no pre-measure path to reverse it from (see #106).

  2. MaxGhenis commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @MaxGhenis
    ContributorAuthor

    We're picking up tranche 2 in a cloud build session, on branch uk/ab2026-tranche2 from #231's head (92f364c), with a draft PR into uk/ab2026-harvest at the first commit. We found no tranche 2 work on this issue or in the open PRs.

    In order, we:

    1. register or fold each of the 86 keys in PROPOSED_KEYS.md, and record each call in KEY_DECISIONS.md;
    2. settle Add the Autumn Budget 2026 registry and harvest (tranche 1 of #230) #231's pre-ingest items (sign conventions, shares of GDP, HM Treasury figures staged twice, and the financial transactions, fuel duty freeze and receipts total metrics);
    3. write scorecard_db/ingest_uk_ab2026.py with exact accounting;
    4. test its invariants.

    We leave to the owner the question of staging the OBR estimates review B raised, and FAI's 29 October table.


    Generated by Claude Code

  3. MaxGhenis commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @MaxGhenis
    ContributorAuthor

    We're picking up tranche 3 in a cloud build session, on branch uk/ab2026-tranche3 from #247's head (3812ce4), with a draft PR into uk/ab2026-tranche2 at the first commit. We found no tranche 3 work on this issue or in the open PRs.

    In order, we:

    1. add a certified-pair record for policyengine 6.11.1 from the dashboard's receipts;
    2. vendor the eight pe_modifier measures' artifacts at 1eca3182 with a hashed manifest;
    3. pair each AB2026 claim on those measures with a dashboard column, or tally why not;
    4. pin the accounting, write the pe_results rows and advance_lanes, and test the invariants.

    We leave build_db.py and the tracked feeds alone, so the site shows nothing new until Max decides.


    Generated by Claude Code

  4. added 3 commits that reference this issue on Nov 5, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions