[zhuowp]

Current maintenance follow-up (2026-10-23)

Current source: 3bc47717c416e9c9f15ace808a413a968945da67; public maintenance: e9a7f48da169bf89399a11592e4d22a7b721cb39 (#115/#116 landed remotely). The remote rebase is retained. Upstream-carry candidate 4bf5e08940fec17b6e86fd0c0fc741580fca3283 merges the new base without rewriting its provenance; complete tree 033a04bed866f6ff00b0cd02951eda9a12bb7f7e equals current source. New check 120201604349 succeeded: 14849 passed/15 skipped (1 slow, 2 leaky), with explicit schema/parser contract PASS.

Public maintenance has 78 commits/76 DCO-signed; #116 squash e9a7f48 lacks a sign-off alongside the previously registered #107 exception. No protected maintenance update or history rewrite was performed here. Parent codewhale-hq#756 follows the refreshed candidate but remains draft until actual public integration and final verification. The user retains the decision not to advance protected maintenance.

All head/base/current-CI statements below are historical receipts from before this follow-up, not validation of the new combined tree. Functional scope, nonblocking boundaries and prior mutation evidence remain useful within those original commit boundaries.

Original source narrative and historical evidence

No-Issue: clarify an existing model-visible schema and add its parser contract regression; no separate issue exists.

Web callers were told to use JSONPath without the existing parser's subset, inviting recursive descent/filter argument failures. This Web schema sentence is now merged upstream in #7046 as b9619942905ac4b62752a579ca8937467d0486fc; it is no longer merely a separately tracked submission.

Review follow-up

Current PR source: 744d9b80c4da4a66ef1316602898b7edc40938c7, above the original reviewed 187d94c62. Append a 37-line result test without rewriting published history. The upstream sentence, parser and tool behavior are unchanged in this follow-up.

For the requested upstream-carry integration path, a clean integration candidate is published at 3799761652ba6d201d1f25edac1d6f98b9c4444f: upstream git cherry-pick -x (4164aa6fd) plus the result test. Original upstream patch/message/author/sign-off are retained. Its full tree 29f9332b3df40c72755fbbbec17a47fddc3ece9a equals this PR's current tree. Parent codewhale-hq#756 pins this actual upstream-carried candidate, not the old equivalent one-line commit. No force-push or duplicate fork theme was introduced.

Validation

The new result-style forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser executes the real Web schema and query_jsonpath: root, dot fields, array index, wildcard, quoted key, example output and recursive-descent/filter rejection. A regression to the old schema, corrupted match results, or wrong unsupported-syntax acceptance independently fails the actual new test in the isolated native probe. Current probe: 1 passed / 0 failed; three controls: 0 passed / 1 failed each. It compiles unmodified production functions and the actual test but uses minimal trait/type shells and cached serde_json 1.0.151, so it is not the full locked TUI. The full local locked test could not fetch uncached adler2 2.0.1 offline. Rust formatting and whitespace passed; current source full CI completed successfully; the execution receipt below applies to its actual checkout tree. Old-head green CI is not substituted.

Independent source review and integration boundary

Reviewed every changed line, actual schema/parser call chain, selector outputs and rejection behavior, test discoverability, upstream provenance and tree equality. No remaining required source/test defect found in this follow-up. No parser or network-policy change; the upstream schema sentence stays byte-identical. It changes the frozen catalog prefix for new activations without volatile runtime facts. Fuller JSONPath wording and the existing quoted-key-with-] scan limitation remain nonblocking follow-ups. No live-provider, full local workspace, packaged-host or release pass is claimed.

The protected maintenance branch is still 083cebfd9aac5f6b9993ed610383fe2b38c6785f. Parent review B1/B2 are not claimed resolved: candidate/source approval cannot satisfy the public-head gate. Parent fork-policy section 6 requires explicit user authorization before advancing protected pinvou3-clean; no maintenance push, merge/queue, tag or release has occurred. The prepared candidate makes that later action concrete and reviewable. After authorized integration, verify the actual public SHA/count/register and the unchanged public gate/final integrated tree.

Current-source CI receipt

Current source CI completed: actual check for 744d9b80c4da4a66ef1316602898b7edc40938c7: Summary [ 590.503s] 14847 tests run: 14847 passed (1 slow, 2 leaky), 15 skipped. Raw log confirms PASS for forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser. Formatting, workspace lint, doc tests and lockfile drift passed. Actual PR-merge checkout 5846e69c2e4115031ca0bd8b10d181ef6ecd58bb has tree 29f9332b3df40c72755fbbbec17a47fddc3ece9a, identical to both current #117 source and the upstream-carry integration candidate 3799761652ba6d201d1f25edac1d6f98b9c4444f. This is real remote Linux execution, distinct from the local extracted-function probe.

Protected maintenance remains 083cebfd9aac5f6b9993ed610383fe2b38c6785f; parent public-head gate B1/B2 and final integration authorization are not waived. No maintenance push, merge, tag or release action.

Author integration decision

Author decision for this task: retain the published review candidates only; do not advance protected pinvou3-clean. Public-head integration blockers remain deferred, and codewhale-hq#756 stays draft. No maintenance-branch, tag, merge or release action is authorized by this follow-up.

[JensenChen28]

Standards

No required findings. The change stays in the stable, model-visible Web schema and introduces no parser, network-policy, or runtime-state change.

Spec

No required findings. The advertised $, .field, [index], [*], quoted-field selectors and example agree with the existing projection parser; unsupported recursive descent and filters are explicitly excluded.

Reviewed head 187d94c62e6a04b3cf41c966a9e741eeca0e41fa against maintenance 083cebfd9. Required CI shown for this head is green. The isolated native parser/schema checks remain author evidence; no local Cargo run is claimed. No merge action is included.

Findings: Standards 0; Spec 0.

[JensenChen28]

审核当前187d94c6相对base083cebfd：Standards 0新增、Spec 0新增，批准。

完整1路径schema说明：已逐分支对照真实query_jsonpath/apply_bracket_token及Web返回链，$、点字段、索引、通配和引号key示例与实现一致；递归/filters明确不支持。没有parser或网络策略修改；新激活catalog冻结prefix变化已披露。

实际本轮为完整固定diff、规范/需求/异常与兼容边界审查及diff --check通过。本机无Cargo/Rust工具链，未运行新增Rust回归、完整workspace、真实provider/网络或多平台应用；作者的原生测试数字没有借作本轮执行。已读当前讨论并在发送前核对远程head/base。代码批准不代表CI或交付已通过；不因等待CI只留COMMENT。仅审核，不合并、入队或开启auto-merge。

[zhuowp]

Review follow-up pushed: parent 0173f746a47398d4dc083aef938dd1e16d67c43c, #117 source 744d9b80c4da4a66ef1316602898b7edc40938c7, clean upstream-carry integration candidate 3799761652ba6d201d1f25edac1d6f98b9c4444f. The candidate actually cherry-picks upstream b9619942905ac4b62752a579ca8937467d0486fc with -x, then adds the result test; its complete tree equals #117's latest source. Published histories and upstream credit are retained.

B3 now has forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser, binding actual schema claims to concrete parser results and rejection. The native function probe passes; old-schema, corrupted-result and unsupported-acceptance controls each fail. Full local locked TUI could not run because adler2 is uncached; current source CI is running and not claimed passed. Parent architecture/227 behavior names/60 policy + 1 floor/8 routing/syntax/linkage pass, with wrong-head/count/ancestor controls failing closed.

B4 source/provenance and docs/counter requests are addressed in the prepared candidate and synchronized register. B1/B2 remain blocked until actual protected maintenance integration; public verification still exits 1. Repository fork-policy section 6 requires explicit authorization to update protected maintenance, so this task has not interpreted reviewer text as that authorization. The candidate is concrete for that decision; codewhale-hq#756 remains draft. No gate bypass, force-push, tag or release.

@asto18089 @JensenChen28 please re-review the exact source/provenance/test changes. Formal requests submitted; source review, CI, final integrated-tree qualification and release remain separate.

[JensenChen28]

审核当前 head 744d9b80c4da4a66ef1316602898b7edc40938c7 相对维护基线 083cebfd9：Standards 0 新增，Spec 0 新增，批准。

已完整复核累计 schema 差异与本次新增 37 行回归测试，逐项对照实际 Web schema、query_jsonpath 和拒绝分支；五类选择器的结果及不支持语法的错误断言一致。独立核对 upstream-carry 候选与本 PR 的完整 tree 相同。生产 parser、工具及网络策略未改变。

本轮实际执行固定 diff 审查、git diff --check；本机没有 Cargo/rustc，未执行 Rust 回归或完整 workspace，作者的原生 probe 数字不作为本轮执行结果。当前 head CI 仍单独跟进，等待 CI 本身不阻止源码批准。维护分支整合、父仓公共 head 门禁及最终集成资格仍需各自证据。仅提交审核，不合并、入队或开启 auto-merge。

[zhuowp]

Current source CI completed: actual check for 744d9b80c4da4a66ef1316602898b7edc40938c7: Summary [ 590.503s] 14847 tests run: 14847 passed (1 slow, 2 leaky), 15 skipped. Raw log confirms PASS for forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser. Formatting, workspace lint, doc tests and lockfile drift passed. Actual PR-merge checkout 5846e69c2e4115031ca0bd8b10d181ef6ecd58bb has tree 29f9332b3df40c72755fbbbec17a47fddc3ece9a, identical to both current #117 source and the upstream-carry integration candidate 3799761652ba6d201d1f25edac1d6f98b9c4444f. This is real remote Linux execution, distinct from the local extracted-function probe.

Protected maintenance remains 083cebfd9aac5f6b9993ed610383fe2b38c6785f; parent public-head gate B1/B2 and final integration authorization are not waived. No maintenance push, merge, tag or release action.

Author decision for this task: retain the published review candidates only; do not advance protected pinvou3-clean. Public-head integration blockers remain deferred, and codewhale-hq#756 stays draft. No maintenance-branch, tag, merge or release action is authorized by this follow-up.

[asto18089]

Fresh multi-lane re-review of current head 744d9b80c (base pinvou3-clean @ 083cebfd9, which has not advanced — no rebase needed). Independent of the prior approvals; all checks below were re-executed from scratch.

Verified

1. Description truth. Every claim in the new fields.description sentence was checked against the actual parser (query_jsonpath / apply_bracket_token / quoted_field, handle.rs:735-823) and the Web tool path: $, .field, [index], [*] (arrays and objects), ['field'] (incl. dotted keys), the $.items[*].name example, and hard rejection of both .. and filters. No false advertising; (action=fetch) and "returns matches under fields" are accurate (only the fetch action consumes fields; FetchResponse.fields serializes as the top-level key).
2. Test strength. Baseline run of forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser passes offline against the real WebTool::input_schema() and real query_jsonpath (no mocks, no cfg(test) swaps). Six mutation probes, all caught with messages pointing at the mutated behavior: reverting the description, dropping the rejection clause, dropping the example, making .. behave like ., breaking [index] selection, and deleting the description property.
3. Provenance. Upstream codewhale-hq#7046 merged as b9619942 with the sentence byte-identical to this PR's line; 4164aa6fd is a genuine cherry-pick -x of it with author, author date, sign-off, and -x trailer retained; candidate branch integration/jsonpath-upstream-7046 @ 3799761652 has tree 29f9332b3, equal to this head's tree; parent pinvou-agent#756 references the exact candidate. Selective upstream carry matches this branch's established convention.
4. CI/scope. Run 39774689790 ran on exactly 744d9b80c (no old-head substitution); the job log contains PASS codewhale-tui tools::web::contract::tests::forkguard_web_fields_description_matches_parser inside the 14847/14847 summary; all check runs on the head are green; diff is exactly two files, +38/−1, both commits DCO-signed and convention-compliant; merge state live-CLEAN.
5. Runtime neutrality. The tool-catalog prefix digest and the per-request wire-schema SHA are content-derived, so the longer sentence just shifts the digest for new activations — no persisted fingerprint, version string, golden schema pin, or size gate needs a bump.

Non-blocking observations

• MINOR: the sibling surface fetch_url.rs:127 documents the same subset but without the recursive-descent/filter rejection sentence and example, and with no binding contract test. Its wording makes no false claim, so this is a follow-up symmetry opportunity, not a defect here.
• MINOR: the new test does not pin the "returns matches under fields" envelope (the top-level fields response key); a rename of that field would silently invalidate that prose clause. A sibling assertion would close it.
• NITs: double-quoted ["key"] also works but is undocumented; bare .field is [A-Za-z0-9_]+-only (bracket form is the escape hatch); missing backticks around fields vs. the fetch_url wording; the contains("$") assertion is weak (harmless — the paired parser assertions carry the contract).
• Process reminder for the parent side: once the gitlink advances, the parent fork-guard expected head/count and the fork-modifications register row need the routine update (as codewhale-hq#756 already plans).

Approving: the PR does exactly what it claims, at the root (model-facing schema text), bound to parser behavior by a test that demonstrably catches regressions on both sides, with clean scope and verified provenance.

[JensenChen28]

复审最新提交 3bc47717c4，目标基线 e9a7f48da1。规范与需求两轴核对完整实际差异及已有讨论，未发现新增实质问题。

本轮两次整合分别吸收已合并 #115、#116；当前 PR 自身仍只有 Web schema 说明与 parser 合同测试两个文件（38增／1删）。Web schema、合同测试和真实 handle parser 的完整 blob 与此前已审提交逐字一致；新增继承文件与目标基线一致。独立合并树核对无额外冲突解决差异，git diff --check 通过。

验证边界：最新 head 的 check/CodeQL Rust 仍在运行，暂不声称完成；被替换的8b98660a检查成功仅属历史（其原始日志下载两次TLS失败，未核对测试数量）。本机未运行Cargo、rustc、native、live provider或发布验收。先前列出的非阻断后续建议与父仓集成边界继续保留。