Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
{
"capture_path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/captures/capture-1bcc46839134b4a57ebdd77f64a5ae027e9f9c4d4b24cdc4b225094caa520847/manifest.json",
"capture_sha256": "0667c03764b6e59c54b3b2dc652e8a2722972648cf248925d409f93275979fd4"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,140 @@
{
"analysis_id": "issue-1479-oci-anonymous-token-formal-analysis-fc45184b2a54",
"claim": {
"allowed_evidence": [
"production parser and semantic-validator results",
"canonical compiled digests",
"participant contract regression tests",
"pinned protocol, corpus, and execution snapshot"
],
"claim_id": "asr-530-formal-semantic-validation-retest",
"disallowed_evidence": [
"schema success as semantic proof",
"workflow reachability as network or exploit reachability",
"FM labels as gate outcomes",
"attribution as counterfactual proof",
"formal prose or maintainer confidence alone"
],
"evidence_artifacts": [
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/protocol-v2.json",
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/manifest-v4.json",
"@snapshot",
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/finite-domain-satisfiable-v4.json",
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/finite-domain-unsatisfiable-v4.json",
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/typed-exploit-path-valid-v4.json",
"docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/typed-exploit-path-invalid-v4.json"
],
"falsification_protocol": "Replay every retained and new case through its production entrypoint, require complete digest and evidence joins, execute participant fixtures, and derive status from the recorded outcomes.",
"objective_fail_criteria": "A supported negative passes, a positive fails, an observation drifts, a required participant case is missing, or weaker evidence is promoted to solver, exploit-path, runtime-stability, or counterfactual assurance.",
"objective_pass_criteria": "Every claim class has positive and negative cases, all supported cases reproduce the frozen outcome, every participant obligation has passing positive and negative fixtures, and unsupported classes remain untested.",
"statement": "At the recorded source-state digest, the retained RAES controls have the bounded statuses recorded here; historical releases are integrity evidence, not current replay evidence.",
"threats_to_validity": [
"The issue-specific corpus is intentionally small and does not enumerate every validator invariant.",
"The participant fixtures exercise reference production contracts and tests, not every independent backend realization.",
"The replay gate runs on one Python reference configuration and one pinned RAES revision.",
"Unsupported solver-level classes have protocol cases but no executable observations."
]
},
"claim_results": [
{
"case_count": 2,
"claim_class_id": "schema-validity",
"evidence_status": "demonstrated",
"limitations": [
"Bounded to the named source/model structural controls."
],
"matching_case_count": 2,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 2,
"unsupported_case_count": 0
},
{
"case_count": 4,
"claim_class_id": "semantic-consistency",
"evidence_status": "partial",
"limitations": [
"Partial coverage of named static semantics and participant obligations, not universal consistency."
],
"matching_case_count": 4,
"participant_obligation_count": 7,
"replayable_case_count": 4,
"unsupported_case_count": 0
},
{
"case_count": 2,
"claim_class_id": "graph-reachability",
"evidence_status": "partial",
"limitations": [
"Partial workflow control-flow reachability only; not network, service, or exploit reachability."
],
"matching_case_count": 2,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 2,
"unsupported_case_count": 0
},
{
"case_count": 4,
"claim_class_id": "constraint-satisfiability",
"evidence_status": "demonstrated",
"limitations": [
"Demonstrated only for raes-finite-domain-satisfiability-v1 and its pinned solver configuration."
],
"matching_case_count": 4,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 2,
"unsupported_case_count": 2
},
{
"case_count": 4,
"claim_class_id": "exploit-path-validity",
"evidence_status": "demonstrated",
"limitations": [
"Demonstrated only for the admitted snapshot, typed graph, query, semantics, and bounded search profile."
],
"matching_case_count": 4,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 2,
"unsupported_case_count": 2
},
{
"case_count": 2,
"claim_class_id": "determinism-stability",
"evidence_status": "partial",
"limitations": [
"Partial parse-to-compile repeatability only; runtime and backend determinism are untested."
],
"matching_case_count": 2,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 2,
"unsupported_case_count": 0
},
{
"case_count": 2,
"claim_class_id": "counterfactual-necessity",
"evidence_status": "untested",
"limitations": [
"Untested because no governed intervention or ablation entrypoint ran."
],
"matching_case_count": 2,
"participant_obligation_count": 0,
"replayable_case_count": 0,
"unsupported_case_count": 2
}
],
"corpus_revision": "4.0.0",
"evidence_status": "partial",
"execution_id": "issue-1479-oci-anonymous-token-formal-fc45184b2a54",
"generated_at": "2026-10-29T09:42:23.019833+00:00",
"limitations": [
"Satisfiability is limited to raes-finite-domain-satisfiability-v1 and its exact translation, theory, and Z3 configuration.",
"EXP-719 factorial generation, randomized allocation and participant configuration behavior are covered by their dedicated regressions; this retained corpus adds no treatment or live execution claim.",
"Issue 1549 external-backend compatibility and trial realization are verified by dedicated regressions; this retained corpus adds no independent-backend execution claim.",
"Issue 1520 condition membership is verified by dedicated experiment-authoring regressions. This retained offline corpus adds no ontology, domain completeness, or execution claim.",
"The retained research corpus does not certify native descendant creator attribution, ownership, physical effects or independent observation.",
"API-414 support declarations do not establish native participant tool execution; the retained formal cases keep their existing bounded claims.",
"This retained offline corpus adds no modular control runtime or independent backend conformance claim. Issue 1071 has separate bounded runtime probes.",
"Issue 1629 shared runtime sequencing, Temporal recovery and authored retry behavior have separate targeted tests; this offline corpus adds no live backend or durable workflow assurance."
],
"plain_language_outcome": "The retained formal cases reproduce their outcomes on the combined source of current dev and issue #1479's anonymous bearer-token flow for OCI module fetches. Bounded claims and unsupported classes are unchanged.",
"protocol_revision": "2.0.0"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,122 @@
{
"analysis_path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/captures/capture-1bcc46839134b4a57ebdd77f64a5ae027e9f9c4d4b24cdc4b225094caa520847/analysis.json",
"analysis_sha256": "ffef2b75f244b52a5dfceefd7db780b125b3d75822bbf214fd7777e6e1196735",
"artifacts": [
{
"artifact_id": "finite-domain-satisfiable-v2-input",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/satisfiable-control.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "0ca9eaba9dc47171f7a042dc6753faa6c820c65ee966538f9d65fac5342202e8"
},
{
"artifact_id": "finite-domain-satisfiable-v2-evidence",
"kind": "production-evidence",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/finite-domain-satisfiable-v4.json",
"sha256": "554202313d678046958b5c028e2de26ff03c74895cfac552677eed74e8153add"
},
{
"artifact_id": "finite-domain-unsatisfiable-v2-input",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/unsatisfiable-control.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "cfef56a1f56d5f0db9da195377fd75694bdd0f0b92932fdb8fafcbd3f7baf6c5"
},
{
"artifact_id": "finite-domain-unsatisfiable-v2-evidence",
"kind": "production-evidence",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/finite-domain-unsatisfiable-v4.json",
"sha256": "c972725ef64822a75a60380afc11f08eac25b7fe9b091d39b058b3c9f7c8031d"
},
{
"artifact_id": "typed-exploit-path-valid-v2-input",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/exploit-path-valid-v3.json",
"sha256": "0afe635a63db5b6e6380ac70982fd61d09790745d51a10d670321304121e7c39"
},
{
"artifact_id": "typed-exploit-path-valid-v2-evidence",
"kind": "production-evidence",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/typed-exploit-path-valid-v4.json",
"sha256": "1b7f55d04db172da32658187c64a88c13b5f4d565267ce2be7cb86a9d04cb70c"
},
{
"artifact_id": "typed-exploit-path-invalid-v2-input",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/exploit-path-invalid-v3.json",
"sha256": "0b2293d4a8983515ff05c516be6e6b418a4f3f09e055250a00bf15fda861aab3"
},
{
"artifact_id": "typed-exploit-path-invalid-v2-evidence",
"kind": "production-evidence",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/evidence/typed-exploit-path-invalid-v4.json",
"sha256": "244f895a64f14c10916ab0533ab462ce80a328021cd6a50c30a4aa59266d5533"
},
{
"artifact_id": "schema-valid-control-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/schema-valid.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "41a9adffdf9f5f2ccc2f887dcf7b15fba3b47c83a1af15f33db872c4a2449d67"
},
{
"artifact_id": "schema-unknown-field-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/schema-invalid-unknown-field.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "51cf62319a86c95a2517995939d1f370573051835e4b55bb6d5beaf049640481"
},
{
"artifact_id": "semantic-resolved-objective-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/semantic-valid-participant-identity-v2.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "75834bdc883e2003e1c473870bdf75700978955bb83095c6bd718ba6bd3908a6"
},
{
"artifact_id": "semantic-dangling-assertion-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/semantic-invalid-dangling-ref-participant-identity-v2.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "1d25bee5f556054e5f0a518df025e4c62e080e1964035e3c1a12e074d88d3a5d"
},
{
"artifact_id": "semantic-ambiguous-reference-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/semantic-invalid-ambiguous-ref.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "653cbd2fd62e220d49fb86f80133884207df5ae6752846345ae3085b93f6e4ed"
},
{
"artifact_id": "semantic-feature-cycle-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/semantic-invalid-feature-cycle.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "e1f66d95a9ad039687aec8cccbc8843b514072ff08e006c1b4ca6aa5cd8d4ed1"
},
{
"artifact_id": "workflow-reachable-control-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/workflow-reachable.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "54c40ceb98ad47247447d737973b2c55e8fb2045e209c7545c4fb20cf42dc3dc"
},
{
"artifact_id": "workflow-unreachable-step-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/workflow-unreachable.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "ef22ef2e260f1a7fd92d286f9b571716436b192ddfd54aea7bdfcfdda4ca52a2"
},
{
"artifact_id": "compile-repeatability-control-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/determinism-a.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "0bc40900d598c1af7a405d798ca19710405e53ced262d8733081abf12edf89fe"
},
{
"artifact_id": "compile-non-vacuity-control-comparison-fixture",
"kind": "corpus-input",
"path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/determinism-b.sdl.yaml",
"sha256": "d85338f89f20a45515b12da8640173c1a52e47eb17ca0f4f6b4f8f3306e863a1"
}
],
"bundle_id": "raes-formal-semantic-validation",
"corpus_path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/corpus/manifest-v4.json",
"corpus_sha256": "c57207af72406aa4f70882b9bbeb7cedcc79cf3854c878a95e3eb1fa59ea7a72",
"protocol_path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/protocol-v2.json",
"protocol_sha256": "abf94093e344bf495dfb04e8b0c5985c0beaab8ebb17a75e15c8674fa81b1a7c",
"revision": "capture-1bcc46839134b4a57ebdd77f64a5ae027e9f9c4d4b24cdc4b225094caa520847",
"snapshot_path": "docs/research/formal-semantic-validation/captures/capture-1bcc46839134b4a57ebdd77f64a5ae027e9f9c4d4b24cdc4b225094caa520847/snapshot.json",
"snapshot_sha256": "aebf5ed315fc4d2dd264927a02dc88fbebab7062a5dd981a0c7190364277eeb2"
}
Loading
Loading