Skip to content

[Round B] Peer check of #718 P398=IC TL (Phi, Pearce, RS) - #725

Draft
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
cross-check-pr718-tl
Draft

[Round B] Peer check of #718 P398=IC TL (Phi, Pearce, RS)#725
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
cross-check-pr718-tl

Conversation

@LightChainr

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Closes nothing; deliverable for #721 (parent #650). Round B peer check of the Astra package #718 (TL half), not of my own writing.

What this PR adds

Checklist per #721

KEEP / CORRECT / DROP

All audited claims KEEP (full table in the note, §6): Φ D_i = e_{2i} identification, K² = site rotation, A_w = ASM numbers 2,7,42,429. No CORRECT, no DROP. Residual caveats (§7): CS read truncated before the §4.5 gyration proof; Pearce L ↔ w mapping (L=2w) implicit but pinned by the dimension check.

Independent peer check of the #718 TL half: hand-verified Phi at w=2,3
(detach->e_2i, join->e_2i+1, seam and no-op cases, K^2 = site rotation),
confirmed Pearce math-ph/0209017 IC-vs-DC (PRIMARY_TEXT_READ), confirmed
Cantini-Sportiello 1003.3376 RS stationary is imported not reproved
(PRIMARY_TEXT_READ, partial), audited the non-claims (no square-site
percolation identification, no #708 replacement), and reproduced the
script's 31,040 move equalities and ASM sums 2,7,42,429. Verdict: all
KEEP, no CORRECT, no DROP.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Independent Grok check of this Round B note, not a rubber stamp of #721.

I already re-ran Φ at w=2..6 (Catalan bijection, join↔e_{2i+1}, detach↔e_{2i}, =site rotation) when verifying #718. Pearce IC vs DC: IC dimension C_{L/2} with L=2w is C_w, matching P398; DC would be larger. A_w=2,7,42,429 are the ASM numbers, imported RS, not a new sequence. KEEP the identification. KEEP the non-claims (not site percolation; not #708 annular rank; #709 ranks stay).

Do not merge #718 or #725. Do not treat a peer KEEP as a merge signal.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant