feat: close WOR-108 legacy orchestration gate - #34
Conversation
Ldsystem
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I found two blocking acceptance-path issues in the WOR-108 implementation. Both are on the production completion path, not just fixture formalism. Details inline. The scoped re-review/context work otherwise looks directionally consistent with WOR-108, but I would not merge until these fail-closed gaps are repaired and covered by regression tests.
|
CI is also currently red on both Ubuntu and macOS. The canonical gate fails in |
Ldsystem
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final review at head fdd5940d63634eb3c94165ac3948bf5c397c08c7 (tree 12e4a696c3caf991654f0b9ac9ef40594699c8d4). The two previously blocking completion-path defects are fixed: fresh initial review-reset completion now composes through the real acceptance path, and completed-task ownership evidence now fails closed when mutation attestation is absent; archive forwards the current compatibility input instead of silently defaulting it. Mutation-event path normalization also closes the reviewed ./ / repeated-separator bypass. GitHub CI run 81 is green on both deterministic Ubuntu and macOS jobs.
I found no remaining WOR-108 product defect that should block this merge. The remaining design debt is explicitly carried into WOR-109: post-acceptance lifecycle replay (mutation_events/ownership/repair evidence), recovery/full handoff-chain reconstruction in the common path, separation of historical task acceptance identity from later release/reproducibility anchors, and canonicalization of both observed and declared scope paths. These should be corrected by the accepted-result simplification rather than extending WOR-108 again.
|
WOR-108 final repair merged from exact head fdd5940, tree 12e4a696c3caf991654f0b9ac9ef40594699c8d4. CI reproducibility uses accepted WOR-105 commit 9dce5df and tree 5a1f38355eae8068bab528923e807ce54e6f6fe5, available in a normal GitHub checkout. WOR-108 verification accepted 22 fixtures and 44 changed surfaces. Final local canonical result: 41 of 41 modules passed and skills passed. GitHub deterministic Ubuntu and macOS jobs both passed. Merge commit: cfa089f. |
Summary
prefer_subagent/visibility semanticsAccepted identity
59699f825637733bdd6e8996c7619e0fead88d4f0a6639bc70a4be591b7ff84b6f43d765a79c17c3review-wor108-integrated-20260906-004(accepted, no findings)Validation
Scope
Closes WOR-108. Does not start WOR-109, WOR-107, or WOR-79 and does not modify
work-bundle-mcp.