fix(会审): tighten dyro-board Record protocol

[Dandre126]

Why

A real board run showed six holes in the 5-line Record protocol. Three of them already produced wrong written conclusions: missing production-line baseline, treating empty seat APIs as “lost”, and asserting test pass from an exit code or task-completed ping.

This PR rewrites the internal dyro-board Record protocol only. Version stays on whatever main currently is. It does not compete with the parallel 0.7.8 bump.

What changed

• dyro-board/SKILL.md remains the single protocol file (user-invocable: false).
• Record protocol now requires:
  • per-repo diff baseline defaulting to the production line (usually origin/release), never master/main
  • close-out of prior P0/P1 on the same development line / same topic as 已闭环 / 未闭环 / 须人工核, or 已检索·无先前会审 when none
  • existing review-directory convention when one exists; if that clashes with a prior-board directory on the same line, the prior-board directory wins
  • chair re-check of every seat claim (未复核·转述 if unchecked)
  • explicit wait window (≥ 10 minutes) starting at first dispatch, not the first empty poll; empty ListAgents / TaskOutput is not a dead seat
  • missed seats are 逾期未交, with a named cover
  • late reports require a revised record
  • test verdicts record the full command, the raw-output summary line, and whether a pipeline/redirect hid the exit code; exit code or a task-completed notification must not assert pass
• /dyro-review-board still says: follow dyro-board exactly; do not invent a second protocol. One-line pointer: protocol now requires baseline + seat lifecycle. Same-turn delivery is still refused.
• docs/agent-orchestration-discipline.md no longer lists the old five-line template; it points at dyro-board/SKILL.md.
• Tests pin the new required phrases and their polarities. Deleting 0b, flipping “is not enough” to “is enough”, or inverting “must not assert pass” / dropping pipeline/redirect hid the exit code fails CI. Hide-board tests stay: help has no /dyro-board / $dyro-board; user-invocable: false.
• CHANGELOG Unreleased bullet only. No version bump, no merge, no tag.

Kept

• Not a mutation: Go does not authorize merge / push / publish / --yes.
• 须人工核 for unprovable claims.
• Record is not Proof and not task review PASS.
• P0/P1/P2 + Go/No-Go output contract.
• Each reviewer writes only in a signed section.

Verification

uv run ruff check src tests experiments
# All checks passed

uv run python -m unittest tests.test_integrations tests.test_seats -v
# Ran 55 tests in 0.931s
# OK

Polarity helpers in tests/test_integrations.py also assert the inverted copies fail: drop 0b, delete 已闭环/未闭环, flip “is not enough” → “is enough”, invert “must not assert pass”, or delete “pipeline/redirect hid the exit code”. Version in pyproject.toml is still 0.7.7.

Out of scope

• Version bump / release tagging (see the separate 0.7.8 PR).
• Copying the protocol into the wrapper.
• Customer names, product-repo names, or personal machine paths.

  

[vercel]

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for GitHub.

Project	Deployment	Actions	Updated (UTC)
dyro	Error		Aug 20, 2026 8:09pm
dyro-engineering-flow	Error		Aug 20, 2026 8:09pm