From 734f405d4b8acaf5ab578a58e9a58bf014c2f558 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: NicolasRodriguezUribe Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:31:01 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] feat(agemoea): AGE-MOEA-II as AGE-MOEA's variant, checked against jMetal AGEMOEAConfig gains variant ("agemoea", the default, or "agemoea_ii"), with its builder method. AGE-MOEA-II (Panichella, GECCO 2022) changes two steps of the first-front score, the two that jMetal's AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection overrides: the exponent p, found by Newton-Raphson from the non-extreme point nearest to the ideal point, and the diversity, measured with geodesic distances through the projected midpoints. Everything else is AGE-MOEA's. tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py and tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java record jMetal's exponents, distances and survival scores (main at 46fb0a61f7) in tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json; the exponents and distances agree on every case, and the scores wherever AGE-MOEA's shared steps agree with jMetal's. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- docs/algorithms/agemoea.md | 3 + docs/reference/algorithms.md | 27 +++ src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/agemoea.py | 24 ++- .../engine/algorithm/agemoea/geometry.py | 92 ++++++++- src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/state.py | 3 + .../engine/algorithm/agemoea/survival.py | 17 +- src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/agemoea.py | 17 +- src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/types.py | 14 ++ tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json | 1 + tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py | 190 ++++++++++++++++++ .../test_constraint_handling_algorithms.py | 2 + tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py | 167 +++++++++++++++ tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java | 89 ++++++++ 13 files changed, 626 insertions(+), 20 deletions(-) create mode 100644 tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json create mode 100644 tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py create mode 100644 tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py create mode 100644 tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java diff --git a/docs/algorithms/agemoea.md b/docs/algorithms/agemoea.md index 8b07e04e5..f6bee6971 100644 --- a/docs/algorithms/agemoea.md +++ b/docs/algorithms/agemoea.md @@ -168,6 +168,7 @@ Evaluations: 400 | Polynomial mutation | Numeric probability `1/12`, eta 20. | | `constraint_mode("feasibility")` | Enables feasibility-based selection if constraints exist; DTLZ2 here is unconstrained. | | `constraint_handling(name, ...)` | **VAMOS 1.2.0:** ranks a constrained population with another of jMetal's techniques; its fronts take the place of the non-dominated ones in the survival and the tournament. See [choose a constraint-handling technique](../reference/constraints.md#choose-a-constraint-handling-technique). | +| `variant("agemoea_ii")` | **Development after 1.4.0:** runs AGE-MOEA-II [2], whose survival estimates the front's geometry by Newton-Raphson and measures diversity with geodesic distances; the default `"agemoea"` is the algorithm of this page. See [AGE-MOEA-II](../reference/algorithms.md#age-moea-ii). | ## Interpret the result and its limits @@ -186,3 +187,5 @@ Increase the budget to 800 while holding the problem and population fixed. Exami ## References [1] Panichella, A. (2019). [An Adaptive Evolutionary Algorithm based on Non-Euclidean Geometry for Many-objective Optimization](https://apanichella.github.io/publication/gecco2019/). *GECCO 2019*. + +[2] Panichella, A. (2022). [An Improved Pareto Front Modeling Algorithm for Large-scale Many-Objective Optimization](https://doi.org/10.1145/3512290.3528732). *GECCO 2022*, 565-573. diff --git a/docs/reference/algorithms.md b/docs/reference/algorithms.md index 37e1de827..68b581274 100644 --- a/docs/reference/algorithms.md +++ b/docs/reference/algorithms.md @@ -182,6 +182,33 @@ on ZDT1, from 0.7426 to 0.7443 on DTLZ2 and from 0.1880 to 0.1892 on DTLZ1, within seed variation of jMetal 7.9's AGE-MOEA (0.8545, 0.7446 and 0.1890). AGE-MOEA results from VAMOS 1.1.0 and earlier differ with the same seed. +### AGE-MOEA-II + +**Development after 1.4.0:** `AGEMOEAConfig.builder().variant("agemoea_ii")` runs +AGE-MOEA-II (Panichella, GECCO 2022). Its survival differs from AGE-MOEA's in two +steps of the first-front score, which are those that jMetal's +`AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection`, written by the author, overrides: + +- the exponent `p` of the front is the one whose Minkowski norm of the + non-extreme point nearest to the ideal point is 1, found by Newton-Raphson + from `p = 1` (precision 0.001, at most 100 steps), instead of a closed form + from the point nearest to the diagonal; +- the diversity uses geodesic distances on the estimated `L_p` manifold: both + points and their midpoint are projected on it, and the distance is the + length of the path through the projected midpoint. + +Everything else, the extreme points, the normalization, the scores of later +fronts and the mating tournament, is AGE-MOEA's above, with that `p`. The +exponents and distances agree with jMetal's on every case of +`tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json`, and so do the survival scores +on the fronts where AGE-MOEA's shared steps agree with jMetal's. They do not +agree where AGE-MOEA's extreme points or its tie-breaking (on exactly linear +fronts) depart from jMetal, as described above for AGE-MOEA. As in AGE-MOEA, +`p` is capped at 20, which pymoo's AGE-MOEA-II also does and jMetal does not; a +point at the ideal point is not projected. pymoo takes the straight Euclidean +distance when `0.95 < p < 1.05`; VAMOS, like jMetal, always goes through the +midpoint, and both coincide when `p = 1`. + ### Where the variants depart from their references These are declared VAMOS choices, not defects; report them when comparing with diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/agemoea.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/agemoea.py index cb165c5dc..58b2d950b 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/agemoea.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/agemoea.py @@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ validate_initial_budget, ) from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.base import normalize_constraint_mode +from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import resolve_agemoea_variant from vamos.engine.archive.factory import resolve_external_archive, setup_archive from vamos.engine.config.variation import ( ensure_operator_tuple, @@ -116,6 +117,11 @@ class AGEMOEA: zero coefficient also falls back to the front maximum, and the default variation is SBX(0.9, 15) with polynomial mutation. + The configuration's ``variant="agemoea_ii"`` runs AGE-MOEA-II (Panichella, + GECCO 2022), whose survival estimates ``p`` by Newton-Raphson and measures + diversity with geodesic distances on the estimated manifold; everything + else is the same. + Parameters ---------- config : dict @@ -149,9 +155,9 @@ def __init__(self, config: dict[str, Any], kernel: KernelBackend | None = None) def _refresh_selection_metrics(self, st: AGEMOEAState) -> None: if st.constraint_handling is not None and st.G is not None: - ranks, scores = technique_selection_metrics(self.kernel, st.F, st.G, st.constraint_handling, st.rng) + ranks, scores = technique_selection_metrics(self.kernel, st.F, st.G, st.constraint_handling, st.rng, variant=st.variant) else: - ranks, scores = population_selection_metrics(self.kernel, st.F, st.G, st.constraint_mode) + ranks, scores = population_selection_metrics(self.kernel, st.F, st.G, st.constraint_mode, st.variant) st.selection_ranks = ranks st.selection_crowding = scores @@ -214,6 +220,7 @@ def initialize( pop_size = int(self.cfg.get("pop_size", 100)) constraint_mode = normalize_constraint_mode(self.cfg.get("constraint_mode", "feasibility")) constraint_handling = run_technique(self.cfg.get("constraint_handling"), constraint_mode) + variant = resolve_agemoea_variant(self.cfg.get("variant", "agemoea")) n_constraints = int(getattr(problem, "n_constraints", 0) or 0) max_evals, hv_config = parse_termination(termination, "AGE-MOEA", pop_size) validate_initial_budget(max_evals, pop_size, "AGE-MOEA") @@ -249,9 +256,9 @@ def initialize( G, ) if constraint_handling is not None and G is not None: - selection_ranks, selection_crowding = technique_selection_metrics(self.kernel, F, G, constraint_handling, rng) + selection_ranks, selection_crowding = technique_selection_metrics(self.kernel, F, G, constraint_handling, rng, variant=variant) else: - selection_ranks, selection_crowding = population_selection_metrics(self.kernel, F, G, constraint_mode) + selection_ranks, selection_crowding = population_selection_metrics(self.kernel, F, G, constraint_mode, variant) result_mode = str(self.cfg.get("result_mode", "non_dominated")).strip().lower() if result_mode not in {"non_dominated", "population"}: @@ -270,6 +277,7 @@ def initialize( variation=variation, constraint_mode=constraint_mode, constraint_handling=constraint_handling, + variant=variant, archive_size=ext_cfg.capacity if ext_cfg is not None else None, archive_X=archive_X, archive_F=archive_F, @@ -380,17 +388,19 @@ def tell(self, eval_result: Any, problem: ProblemProtocol | None = None) -> bool # The technique follows the evaluations before the offspring's. progress = run_progress(st.n_eval, st.max_evals) survivors, survival_scores = technique_age_survival( - F_combined, G_combined, st.pop_size, self.kernel, technique, st.rng, progress + F_combined, G_combined, st.pop_size, self.kernel, technique, st.rng, progress, st.variant ) else: - survivors, survival_scores = constraint_aware_age_survival(F_combined, G_combined, st.pop_size, self.kernel, st.constraint_mode) + survivors, survival_scores = constraint_aware_age_survival( + F_combined, G_combined, st.pop_size, self.kernel, st.constraint_mode, st.variant + ) st.X = X_combined[survivors] st.F = F_combined[survivors] st.G = G_combined[survivors] if G_combined is not None else None st.n_eval += X_off.shape[0] if technique is not None and st.G is not None: st.selection_ranks, st.selection_crowding = technique_selection_metrics( - self.kernel, st.F, st.G, technique, st.rng, survival_scores + self.kernel, st.F, st.G, technique, st.rng, survival_scores, st.variant ) else: st.selection_ranks, st.selection_crowding = selection_metrics(self.kernel, st.F, st.G, st.constraint_mode, survival_scores) diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/geometry.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/geometry.py index cc9a8ecec..db1f048e7 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/geometry.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/geometry.py @@ -1,4 +1,9 @@ -"""Geometry helpers for AGE-MOEA survival selection.""" +"""Geometry helpers for AGE-MOEA survival selection. + +Both variants of Panichella's algorithm share the survival below: AGE-MOEA (GECCO 2019) and +AGE-MOEA-II (GECCO 2022), which estimates the exponent ``p`` of the front by Newton-Raphson and +measures diversity with geodesic distances on the estimated manifold. +""" from __future__ import annotations @@ -6,6 +11,7 @@ import numpy as np +from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import AGEMOEAVariant from vamos.foundation.kernel.backend import KernelBackend, SelectionKernels @@ -82,10 +88,79 @@ def _compute_geometry(front: np.ndarray[Any, Any], extreme: np.ndarray[Any, Any] return float(p) +def _newton_exponent(point: np.ndarray[Any, Any], precision: float = 1e-3, iterations: int = 100) -> float: + """The exponent ``p`` whose Minkowski norm of ``point`` is 1: the zero of ``log(sum_i |a_i|^p)``. + + Newton-Raphson from ``p = 1``, as in jMetal's ``AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection.findZero`` (the + author's port): at most ``iterations`` steps, stopping when a step moves less than ``precision``. + The function sums every coordinate and its derivative only the positive ones. A failed search + returns a non-finite value, which :func:`_compute_geometry_ii` replaces. + """ + raw = np.asarray(point, dtype=float) + a = np.abs(raw) + positive = raw[raw > 0.0] + log_positive = np.log(positive) + x = np.float64(1.0) + past = x + with np.errstate(all="ignore"): + for _ in range(iterations): + f = np.log(np.sum(a**x)) + powers = positive**x + denominator = np.sum(powers) + derivative = np.sum(powers * log_positive) / denominator if denominator != 0.0 else np.float64(1.0) + x = x - f / derivative + if abs(x - past) <= precision: + break + past = x + return float(x) + + +def _compute_geometry_ii(front: np.ndarray[Any, Any], extreme: np.ndarray[Any, Any]) -> float: + """AGE-MOEA-II's exponent of the normalized front. + + The reference point is the non-extreme point nearest to the origin (the ideal point), not the + one nearest to the diagonal as in AGE-MOEA, and ``p`` makes its Minkowski norm 1 + (:func:`_newton_exponent`). As in jMetal, a non-finite ``p`` or one below 0.1 means a flat front, + ``p = 1``; as in AGE-MOEA and pymoo's AGE-MOEA-II, ``p`` is capped at 20. + """ + d = np.sqrt(np.sum(front * front, axis=1)) + d[extreme] = np.inf + index = int(np.argmin(d)) + p = _newton_exponent(front[index]) + if not np.isfinite(p) or p < 0.1: + return 1.0 + return float(min(p, 20.0)) + + +def _project_on_manifold(points: np.ndarray[Any, Any], p: float) -> np.ndarray[Any, Any]: + """``points`` scaled to Minkowski norm 1 of order ``p``; a point of norm 0 stays as it is.""" + norms = np.sum(np.abs(points) ** p, axis=-1) ** (1.0 / p) + scale = np.where(norms > 0.0, 1.0 / np.where(norms > 0.0, norms, 1.0), 1.0) + return np.asarray(points * scale[..., None], dtype=float) + + +def _geodesic_distances(front: np.ndarray[Any, Any], p: float) -> np.ndarray[Any, Any]: + """AGE-MOEA-II's pairwise distances: the geodesic distances on the ``L_p`` manifold, approximated. + + Both points are projected on the manifold, and so is their midpoint; the distance is the + Euclidean length of the path through the projected midpoint, as in jMetal's + ``AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection.pairwiseDistances``. pymoo takes the straight Euclidean distance + when ``0.95 < p < 1.05``; on the simplex (``p = 1``) both coincide. + """ + projected = _project_on_manifold(front, p) + midpoints = _project_on_manifold(0.5 * projected[:, None, :] + 0.5 * projected[None, :, :], p) + to_mid = np.sqrt(np.sum((projected[:, None, :] - midpoints) ** 2, axis=2)) + from_mid = np.sqrt(np.sum((midpoints - projected[None, :, :]) ** 2, axis=2)) + distances = to_mid + from_mid + np.fill_diagonal(distances, 0.0) + return np.asarray(distances, dtype=float) + + def _survival_score( front: np.ndarray[Any, Any], ideal_point: np.ndarray[Any, Any], selection_kernels: SelectionKernels | None = None, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], float, np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: m, n = front.shape crowd_dist = np.zeros(m, dtype=float) @@ -108,11 +183,12 @@ def _survival_score( selected = np.full(m, False) selected[extreme] = True - p = _compute_geometry(front, extreme, n) + ii = variant == "agemoea_ii" + p = _compute_geometry_ii(front, extreme) if ii else _compute_geometry(front, extreme, n) nn = np.linalg.norm(front, ord=p, axis=1) nn[nn < 1e-8] = 1.0 - distances = _pairwise_distances(front, p) + distances = _geodesic_distances(front, p) if ii else _pairwise_distances(front, p) distances[distances < 1e-8] = 1e-8 distances = distances / nn[:, None] @@ -177,8 +253,9 @@ def age_survival( n_survive: int, kernel: KernelBackend, ranks: np.ndarray[Any, Any] | None = None, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: - """Select AGE-MOEA survivors from a combined parent-offspring front. + """Select AGE-MOEA or AGE-MOEA-II survivors from a combined parent-offspring front. Returns the survivor indices in ascending order and their survival scores, as PlatEMO's ``EnvironmentalSelection`` (Panichella's own code) defines @@ -198,6 +275,11 @@ def age_survival( The fronts are the non-dominated ones unless ``ranks`` gives them, as a constraint-handling technique does in Evolver's AGE-MOEA. + + ``variant="agemoea_ii"`` scores the first front as AGE-MOEA-II does (Panichella, GECCO 2022): + the exponent ``p`` by :func:`_compute_geometry_ii` and the diversity by + :func:`_geodesic_distances`. The rest, later fronts included, is AGE-MOEA's, with that ``p``, as + in jMetal, whose AGE-MOEA-II overrides only those two steps. """ n_survive = min(int(n_survive), F.shape[0]) if ranks is None: @@ -222,7 +304,7 @@ def age_survival( front0 = F[ranks == 0, :] ideal_point = np.min(front0, axis=0) - crowd_dist[ranks == 0], p, normalization = _survival_score(front0, ideal_point, kernel.selection_kernels()) + crowd_dist[ranks == 0], p, normalization = _survival_score(front0, ideal_point, kernel.selection_kernels(), variant) for r in range(1, last_rank + 1): front_idx = fronts[r] diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/state.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/state.py index 0bad09475..90503e5b7 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/state.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/state.py @@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ with_constraints, ) from vamos.engine.algorithm.components.state import AlgorithmState +from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import AGEMOEAVariant if TYPE_CHECKING: from vamos.engine.variation.pipeline import VariationPipeline @@ -36,6 +37,8 @@ class AGEMOEAState(AlgorithmState): variation: VariationPipeline | None = None selection_ranks: Any = field(default=None, repr=False, compare=False) selection_crowding: Any = field(default=None, repr=False, compare=False) + # The survival's variant: AGE-MOEA or AGE-MOEA-II. + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea" def build_agemoea_result( diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/survival.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/survival.py index e69541c78..30d800dc1 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/survival.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/agemoea/survival.py @@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ import numpy as np from vamos.engine.algorithm.components.constraint_handling import ConstraintHandlingTechnique, adapted_ranks +from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import AGEMOEAVariant from vamos.foundation.constraints.utils import compute_violation, is_feasible from vamos.foundation.kernel.backend import KernelBackend @@ -19,6 +20,7 @@ def constraint_aware_age_survival( n_survive: int, kernel: KernelBackend, constraint_mode: str, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: """Apply feasibility-first ordering, then AGE geometry among feasible points. @@ -27,19 +29,19 @@ def constraint_aware_age_survival( score 0, because the tournament compares them by violation. """ if G is None or constraint_mode == "none": - return age_survival(F, n_survive, kernel) + return age_survival(F, n_survive, kernel, variant=variant) feasible = is_feasible(G, n=G.shape[0]) feasible_idx = np.flatnonzero(feasible) target = min(int(n_survive), F.shape[0]) if feasible_idx.size >= target: - local, local_scores = age_survival(F[feasible_idx], target, kernel) + local, local_scores = age_survival(F[feasible_idx], target, kernel, variant=variant) return np.asarray(feasible_idx[local], dtype=int), local_scores scores = np.zeros(target, dtype=float) if feasible_idx.size > 0: # Every feasible point survives; score them all, as pymoo's feasibility filter does. - _, scores[: feasible_idx.size] = age_survival(F[feasible_idx], feasible_idx.size, kernel) + _, scores[: feasible_idx.size] = age_survival(F[feasible_idx], feasible_idx.size, kernel, variant=variant) violation = compute_violation(G, n=G.shape[0]) infeasible_idx = np.flatnonzero(~feasible) needed = target - feasible_idx.size @@ -56,6 +58,7 @@ def technique_age_survival( technique: ConstraintHandlingTechnique, rng: np.random.Generator, progress: float, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: """AGE-MOEA's environmental selection over the fronts of a constraint-handling technique. @@ -63,7 +66,7 @@ def technique_age_survival( Evolver's AGE-MOEA; whole fronts survive and the survival score cuts the last one. """ ranks = adapted_ranks(technique, kernel, F, G, rng, progress) - return age_survival(F, n_survive, kernel, ranks=ranks) + return age_survival(F, n_survive, kernel, ranks=ranks, variant=variant) def technique_selection_metrics( @@ -73,6 +76,7 @@ def technique_selection_metrics( technique: ConstraintHandlingTechnique, rng: np.random.Generator, survival_scores: np.ndarray[Any, Any] | None = None, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: """Tournament ranks and tie-break scores with a constraint-handling technique. @@ -82,7 +86,7 @@ def technique_selection_metrics( """ ranks = np.asarray(technique.ranks(kernel, F, G, rng), dtype=int) if survival_scores is None: - survivors, survivor_scores = age_survival(F, F.shape[0], kernel, ranks=ranks) + survivors, survivor_scores = age_survival(F, F.shape[0], kernel, ranks=ranks, variant=variant) scores = np.zeros(F.shape[0], dtype=float) scores[survivors] = survivor_scores else: @@ -126,9 +130,10 @@ def population_selection_metrics( F: np.ndarray[Any, Any], G: np.ndarray[Any, Any] | None, constraint_mode: str, + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea", ) -> tuple[np.ndarray[Any, Any], np.ndarray[Any, Any]]: """Score a whole population by running the survival on it, as PlatEMO does at start-up.""" - survivors, survivor_scores = constraint_aware_age_survival(F, G, F.shape[0], kernel, constraint_mode) + survivors, survivor_scores = constraint_aware_age_survival(F, G, F.shape[0], kernel, constraint_mode, variant) scores = np.zeros(F.shape[0], dtype=float) scores[survivors] = survivor_scores return selection_metrics(kernel, F, G, constraint_mode, scores) diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/agemoea.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/agemoea.py index 95f99e835..f52f3d6fe 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/agemoea.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/agemoea.py @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ from __future__ import annotations from dataclasses import dataclass -from typing import Any +from typing import Any, Self from vamos.engine.archive import ExternalArchiveConfig from vamos.foundation.encoding import EncodingLike @@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ _validate_operators, _warn_without_effect, ) -from .types import RepairConfigValue +from .types import AGEMOEAVariant, RepairConfigValue, resolve_agemoea_variant class _AGEMOEAConfigBuilder( @@ -50,6 +50,16 @@ class _AGEMOEAConfigBuilder( Fluent builder for AGE-MOEA configs. """ + def variant(self, value: AGEMOEAVariant) -> Self: + """The survival: ``"agemoea"`` (the default) or ``"agemoea_ii"``, AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + + AGE-MOEA-II estimates the geometry of the first front by Newton-Raphson from the point + nearest to the ideal point and measures diversity with geodesic distances on the estimated + manifold; the rest of the algorithm is the same. + """ + self._cfg["variant"] = resolve_agemoea_variant(value) + return self + def build(self) -> AGEMOEAConfig: _require_fields( self._cfg, @@ -70,6 +80,7 @@ def build(self) -> AGEMOEAConfig: result_mode=self._cfg.get("result_mode", "non_dominated"), external_archive=self._cfg.get("external_archive"), live_callback_mode=self._cfg.get("live_callback_mode", "population"), + variant=self._cfg.get("variant", "agemoea"), ) @@ -88,9 +99,11 @@ class AGEMOEAConfig(_SerializableConfig): # Fields added after 1.0 go last, so that the constructor keeps the positions of its parameters. constraint_handling: tuple[str, dict[str, float]] | None = None live_callback_mode: LiveCallbackMode = "population" + variant: AGEMOEAVariant = "agemoea" def __post_init__(self) -> None: super().__post_init__() + object.__setattr__(self, "variant", resolve_agemoea_variant(self.variant)) if self.track_genealogy: _warn_without_effect("AGE-MOEA", "track_genealogy", "AGE-MOEA records no genealogy", stacklevel=3) diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/types.py b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/types.py index 8179f81ee..d1c9c5e95 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/types.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/algorithm/config/types.py @@ -13,6 +13,20 @@ class AlgorithmConfigProtocol(Protocol): def to_dict(self) -> AlgorithmConfigMapping: ... +# The survivals of AGE-MOEA (Panichella, GECCO 2019) and AGE-MOEA-II (Panichella, GECCO 2022). +AGEMOEAVariant: TypeAlias = Literal["agemoea", "agemoea_ii"] +AGEMOEA_VARIANTS: tuple[AGEMOEAVariant, ...] = ("agemoea", "agemoea_ii") + + +def resolve_agemoea_variant(value: object) -> AGEMOEAVariant: + """The AGE-MOEA variant named by ``value``, or ``ValueError`` for another name.""" + name = str(value).strip().lower() + for variant in AGEMOEA_VARIANTS: + if name == variant: + return variant + raise ValueError(f"AGE-MOEA variant must be one of: {', '.join(AGEMOEA_VARIANTS)}; got {value!r}.") + + # ── Operator name literals (for IDE autocompletion) ────────────────── CrossoverName: TypeAlias = Literal[ diff --git a/tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json b/tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..248adf4ef --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +{"source":"jMetal main at 46fb0a61f7, package component.catalogue.ea.replacement.impl.agemoea","generator":"tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py","seed":20261118,"cases":[{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.14646505035793653,0.21057040647312267],[0.3292354616574298,0.07710637740732576],[0.11727664931085968,0.25146017986472274],[0.23743573046691077,0.12651348121962874],[0.1546012032212544,0.20075865131655873],[0.15482331217276885,0.2004990617261468],[0.08336591212373634,0.3148233267634258],[0.17751089456468572,0.17604432107362358]],"extremes":[1,6],"p":0.4},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.05271223463444172,0.3981320974679072],[0.29213139286450823,0.09421654697907582],[0.14974705109553701,0.206540177088424],[0.06250356828995146,0.36759884722275765],[0.10989184336013137,0.26352842426081835],[0.10602476762960508,0.27018432868197534],[0.14427721740420654,0.21331361300519927],[0.06657826601811358,0.35613382094865775],[0.12080754288719833,0.24596615823777743],[0.3528127645073939,0.067802618316184],[0.09969165249038973,0.2816333760149657],[0.18517219981699182,0.16861381811487366],[0.1394967070992785,0.21947190175767028],[0.2941681605264945,0.0931891502543682],[0.056655086640848916,0.3852808866441074],[0.05535082628037155,0.3894430135182273],[0.16530803038201272,0.18870996906965568],[0.14532968444083355,0.21198822889684532],[0.05756015226355614,0.3824418454700038],[0.23991240047156623,0.1248279986914248],[0.08860164472157739,0.3035384603893989],[0.20177469600207332,0.15373534539138983],[0.16902918135410258,0.1847334590396247],[0.1452502825230331,0.2120878469052461],[0.3620205436695474,0.06445715895596626]],"extremes":[24,0],"p":0.3999999999761004},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.18856370936322087,0.587280691184256],[0.29159167693321897,0.4569466299188224],[0.5226866770764002,0.23698225771198791],[0.3603693189933578,0.3827287639502649],[0.3413983960503506,0.4023491374266849],[0.8190897325580521,0.05444922307804695],[0.369078016125341,0.3739238691817612],[0.4873179952361806,0.26566653085761316]],"extremes":[5,0],"p":0.7},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.15029279697050968,0.6436755148426792],[0.47848653951001435,0.2730792527230113],[0.5092461937163595,0.24769613192951945],[0.34600407297171354,0.39752924247205657],[0.37738594122839053,0.3656390618227069],[0.4035683758609981,0.3402389048583855],[0.3776270043026437,0.3654003210454619],[0.35823813122166887,0.3849025661825535],[0.2708848362345145,0.4810883274731143],[0.39440318014232245,0.34901007452878535],[0.3788363232872376,0.3642040468605691],[0.2763774418130967,0.4745957729043],[0.3066361767299508,0.43995834943427536],[0.3193320339511874,0.4259642707312038],[0.3271179816686432,0.4175313673615851],[0.370093997465672,0.3729047420538459],[0.6670114077291857,0.1355176569735803],[0.4953227143548787,0.2590352290829641],[0.3182690229663916,0.4271243063067052],[0.43092712037232267,0.31479777480245075],[0.5595813889069817,0.20871429198504757],[0.4411525967318453,0.3055655122108566],[0.2797606532244039,0.4706290175003815],[0.239634660939892,0.5193327621719573],[0.4279637179572506,0.317501022029198]],"extremes":[16,0],"p":0.7},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.0970880889663278,0.9029119110336722],[0.5508285636605892,0.4491714363394107],[0.23815481763916088,0.7618451823608392],[0.17324243050872912,0.8267575694912709],[0.23841699174853861,0.7615830082514613],[0.3457119108108451,0.6542880891891548],[0.34659282361317106,0.6534071763868289],[0.9197920503055664,0.0802079496944335]],"extremes":[7,0],"p":0.9999999999999999},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.38215111881472796,0.6178488811852719],[0.6855585158798166,0.3144414841201834],[0.773950412953725,0.22604958704627492],[0.45598021153156326,0.5440197884684367],[0.7316848092641903,0.2683151907358096],[0.8337122773119938,0.16628772268800615],[0.49672830241728744,0.5032716975827124],[0.15881667559962015,0.8411833244003799],[0.9191219164984352,0.08087808350156482],[0.19559124888027163,0.8044087511197284],[0.6348033993854345,0.3651966006145655],[0.06810790732006156,0.9318920926799386],[0.5228827813998093,0.4771172186001908],[0.5765266241248362,0.4234733758751638],[0.7026780289434392,0.29732197105656083],[0.419257440765792,0.580742559234208],[0.5965271623089413,0.4034728376910588],[0.29625733160795303,0.7037426683920469],[0.4537304436340883,0.5462695563659117],[0.39454384020699673,0.6054561597930033],[0.33296358081155836,0.6670364191884416],[0.38734391162042814,0.6126560883795719],[0.13595129951133955,0.8640487004886604],[0.37713015956017426,0.6228698404398259],[0.7389608010669321,0.26103919893306804]],"extremes":[8,11],"p":0.9999999999999997},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.2728515722084564,0.9025704869895433],[0.15443304014289513,0.9591199482747714],[0.30532282438580094,0.8841011667759194],[0.63518967261946,0.6247095834158645],[0.8455117555771777,0.36722768273933953],[0.46335766899383696,0.7767608319342865],[0.7038754852913599,0.5514163856533386],[0.5606379800417688,0.6956553840888549]],"extremes":[4,1],"p":1.499999999999974},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.7354608834748111,0.5147156522731402],[0.50654961228286,0.7422495634474392],[0.5831400714978102,0.6751007032471675],[0.4370406940471483,0.7966683514526767],[0.45688030476514707,0.7817381388552184],[0.7371601046070759,0.5126812993191014],[0.4445032821881246,0.791107827077042],[0.17774658883050828,0.9493956500352118],[0.15474592841918286,0.9589943287907202],[0.609447778993065,0.6501445480652704],[0.7009516217946569,0.5547114655616744],[0.7394726844982571,0.5099023305239503],[0.5888969911050154,0.6697263343409562],[0.7652738601438303,0.4780592834238343],[0.561809213335666,0.694602989517],[0.8203034619469933,0.4042724154513486],[0.5371006398373317,0.7164081186332578],[0.5946813085922608,0.6642778979466604],[0.6017991731159275,0.6575058166492223],[0.6497635947808257,0.609841124998333],[0.9004175545959004,0.2767510218278138],[0.7220197414846907,0.5305871945560698],[0.6020733407735341,0.6572434642743338],[0.6943648749105602,0.5620739240735085],[0.6627377103018552,0.5963070740705559]],"extremes":[20,8],"p":1.499999999919766},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.290296672380541,0.9569366969683966],[0.8010920726748022,0.5985411356770638],[0.8577700301956541,0.5140336324581753],[0.6989142648698895,0.7152054602429863],[0.5611607849206244,0.827706816129521],[0.8458983263519213,0.5333441866890632],[0.7234810726401405,0.6903442167002427],[0.08956848103131547,0.9959806660802925]],"extremes":[2,7],"p":1.9999999999796896},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.6381023237791917,0.7699515727548037],[0.772142742333866,0.6354491210640999],[0.7847116206930448,0.6198610105090455],[0.513831733775043,0.8578909892088467],[0.8390913046226388,0.5439906088405185],[0.5521613018458992,0.8337373067962366],[0.7042406315186325,0.7099613601585918],[0.7522799265984899,0.6588436172848383],[0.8689434122367671,0.4949114530199558],[0.961832727981896,0.273638088326359],[0.8620656075387215,0.5067966932596293],[0.9716243702746574,0.23652924362195743],[0.09534816220634239,0.995443985347178],[0.7948433799264812,0.6068146351127724],[0.4482685705432262,0.8938989253059502],[0.9513012040179378,0.30826290602993717],[0.994314300501214,0.10648507791602253],[0.995185988774967,0.09800432513920705],[0.6584789761829031,0.7525991216611376],[0.866741286508418,0.4987579996969798],[0.281964978880576,0.9594246977667796],[0.9834793810085836,0.1810201843192445],[0.6330581806717416,0.7741042177152794],[0.97476346141629,0.22324021655546916],[0.2781239579064469,0.9605451910443636]],"extremes":[17,12],"p":1.999999999999999},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.5665746193789105,0.9352764755156635],[0.1794532774429364,0.9980699373169472],[0.9665090914613725,0.45969950053483977],[0.9818392036691823,0.3768036021249061],[0.7808068126871694,0.8061884028941897],[0.8352899697536627,0.7472255369001745],[0.9437177206981651,0.5423424057325201],[0.966037462136027,0.4617739095428339]],"extremes":[3,1],"p":2.999999999999512},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.641726643569077,0.9027604836943404],[0.6602811670350763,0.8930060431324527],[0.9749271916631225,0.4185974564393149],[0.9619315645004354,0.47901542707326744],[0.9941143736576044,0.25988733341602993],[0.981448215332161,0.3794387670848785],[0.40008263595762533,0.9781808284650689],[0.15935527668595337,0.9986492815470281],[0.9535495883418729,0.5104194115538249],[0.8305507594972757,0.7530683130431703],[0.3140330705496256,0.9895685883800349],[0.1635272410171482,0.9985402341605573],[0.28848536553964693,0.991932134549691],[0.8197194152823093,0.7658538044956505],[0.7917333895569912,0.7956579596016904],[0.8082295119651398,0.7786192095293871],[0.8352850425463225,0.7472316938529002],[0.9112484884679224,0.624301618066093],[0.9998497397150399,0.07667140139412992],[0.9998649424258836,0.07399354723181548],[0.4436390119033041,0.9700042277490324],[0.889248862123985,0.6670550353473546],[0.9941436758318543,0.2594578632422999],[0.9938744237776914,0.26335105410419357],[0.3469918251002448,0.98587510330033]],"extremes":[19,7],"p":2.9999999999895617},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.4146321394354794,0.9991513122945894],[0.8628825124694366,0.915098448174933],[0.99928760450837,0.40273233261847585],[0.7504567665450277,0.9677350809532291],[0.8135189993182258,0.9445452695599708],[0.3810139077746185,0.9994894385354972],[0.8239250226315398,0.9393829734429969],[0.9995807138872749,0.368723727136481]],"extremes":[7,5],"p":5.999999999731242},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.1980507671555423,0.9999899418329542],[0.9100907613360595,0.8693851880062587],[0.16557437483705922,0.9999965659135667],[0.5829514861588478,0.9933494137072669],[0.9999884818185613,0.20257558886079394],[0.9487604180091711,0.8042662227617479],[0.8456460202160685,0.9269332802393818],[0.9863438194938786,0.655307557092707],[0.992223503381952,0.5980666730524387],[0.6284701491951216,0.9894562766740851],[0.6918241188023277,0.9808309634833677],[0.9239739876325356,0.8502288665656627],[0.7118106164629615,0.9770433011296872],[0.9234208880444634,0.8510639050768662],[0.14707684589587247,0.9999983129947752],[0.5003494563410867,0.9973676309894077],[0.885714080437044,0.8959367435247493],[0.9980365255621749,0.47662209681915235],[0.7478204646367753,0.9684665692604602],[0.9262398774902675,0.8467376391198315],[0.2851761041669747,0.9999103345995496],[0.6731821744947875,0.9838507067858961],[0.9999862421421315,0.20866415705426114],[0.14330214222899132,0.9999985566674262],[0.3776020139203692,0.9995162959597838]],"extremes":[4,23],"p":5.9999999881241965},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.08789658264239834,0.018160367897965823,0.11480090030461744],[0.03723077152564173,0.0628537402173541,0.1019776541889913],[0.08456178998962294,0.03941677851022321,0.07423990295027576],[0.03560383145957625,0.10871844583150066,0.06020014977433846],[0.036690676121238455,0.10564306378731728,0.060902270813591834],[0.060348385976863865,0.12958941426135534,0.026237576585758676],[0.017326080245681285,0.11687956279441104,0.08831508690607201],[0.08831198692462988,0.060946405350871966,0.04711845149897488]],"extremes":[7,5,1],"p":0.3999999999999921},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.02973772742510901,0.1539871303450302,0.04214296078697769],[0.11888983500026039,0.016190250752544485,0.08971066647139149],[0.07458444734024972,0.07773391523598,0.043744658792755256],[0.08736762200330309,0.08611320679157516,0.030576357975414425],[0.0615951365254727,0.04173279904198829,0.09582583497435623],[0.05610378963763094,0.10729578733618841,0.03950873345522855],[0.08357792149674552,0.06697379786795479,0.04541897032263391],[0.07896835851899377,0.05884593146756208,0.05602191903802066],[0.016475273170126186,0.07629239231721748,0.13524582163588628],[0.04179605351643849,0.053027919093550174,0.10781681586310972],[0.019632848434417264,0.082984825764419,0.11632382076122595],[0.04494548508028818,0.052917673306523506,0.10262251493925638],[0.04468509541562533,0.1061634700571885,0.050873964181433015],[0.09630763774850763,0.032083749329704266,0.07518971138196064],[0.052812566288274236,0.03341147578631556,0.12468454128170808],[0.04223369794200326,0.10043323707862664,0.05756229652625033],[0.030275221962907897,0.08723475315522454,0.08680882793413144],[0.04238159112990885,0.058705219601171504,0.09860814932910121],[0.0704396159907321,0.04551651768265599,0.07959716618315131],[0.08802337469833123,0.06255270560175702,0.04595953460726136],[0.05857113013089887,0.029997365620756992,0.12311468765296972],[0.09470890687821155,0.037424737413804865,0.06828087705618051],[0.04200070169438299,0.06582611391832822,0.0900860604425146],[0.11500257121914018,0.016979791812746014,0.09085659195139631],[0.09530367989065429,0.06840894330036164,0.03699689323226282]],"extremes":[19,0,14],"p":0.39999999999999997},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.3230879521004654,0.27024581086496763,0.06425461908347604],[0.04097096275199845,0.29077512501510866,0.3420962172794252],[0.11131053482821271,0.24390253451992946,0.28222809005398203],[0.5117424032962409,0.1549491282675054,0.03901408854363862],[0.056475673617509735,0.34081417874604664,0.2657896677334147],[0.27732808389972063,0.29995007626578457,0.07430156014904442],[0.2855511150774428,0.17840166026033752,0.1663351614981415],[0.3126105121135151,0.1827377299963483,0.1400779103975701]],"extremes":[3,4,2],"p":0.7},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.34580617766284155,0.26576933668036445,0.0536059367850009],[0.21978982583935278,0.2555359074049519,0.1531985837045374],[0.10792512740259327,0.30379840201461705,0.22795004576222633],[0.2174886328508063,0.22586595040464286,0.18193118603906314],[0.2019144092866015,0.1391938745807516,0.29176239316229663],[0.25782425100012635,0.18027716967914115,0.18887036174235655],[0.17224264340764692,0.08726228644091816,0.40013929231370327],[0.22426701212201602,0.42820377712732893,0.03544729502808144],[0.14572712085565612,0.06016840319371155,0.48257989699129394],[0.17029794485692518,0.30401427758334554,0.15882571176330218],[0.241088155329726,0.30932574357753756,0.09376994123999359],[0.203093239700634,0.2382216469070876,0.18423324611452482],[0.048643756647889294,0.40421556507348283,0.22235617456896475],[0.13259535402040787,0.2936078932108961,0.2077192390305667],[0.3776077009079701,0.12167734536857301,0.15028064343995828],[0.3108385365636222,0.06452532411248191,0.2815770682787189],[0.25802324965283296,0.33114849850572636,0.06732773470490032],[0.05180322333183272,0.3196754156926819,0.2935447695595043],[0.25720953969161514,0.23305727891702843,0.1401372188578899],[0.3554728600746348,0.0228272528106067,0.3137730267044364],[0.07665643796701149,0.233481065835489,0.34330911363478633],[0.20928920430351078,0.2560452767833845,0.16233345026416962],[0.07552682758763185,0.2974987384271735,0.2779110378530173],[0.31048469127461065,0.29690785132854036,0.05518755025429654],[0.13867596874632257,0.5380403464539626,0.03789761708160134]],"extremes":[14,24,8],"p":0.6999999998419861},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.4982049308245432,0.3606519601591327,0.14114310901632401],[0.3135830330200728,0.33596137082376176,0.3504555961561654],[0.056706000329463525,0.7123977920865531,0.23089620758398338],[0.3376191919229876,0.33446248602159223,0.3279183220554202],[0.3040049710415121,0.33694024449364207,0.35905478446484573],[0.5225782385163293,0.3172065582108524,0.16021520327281816],[0.26042244900548983,0.333757232002494,0.40582031899201604],[0.5882014932070911,0.05796262660709879,0.3538358801858101]],"extremes":[5,2,6],"p":1.0},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.6038794820497512,0.226015464623256,0.17010505332699294],[0.11624158833940768,0.3612243922132732,0.5225340194473191],[0.4087801429681908,0.2363606185564872,0.35485923847532197],[0.08629338441023328,0.4332754844406706,0.4804311311490961],[0.5910687272594115,0.2723117702750326,0.13661950246555585],[0.0824700411811276,0.4630977805664592,0.4544321782524133],[0.38910596113585705,0.24777568350529022,0.3631183553588528],[0.06145781181179418,0.6195878585499063,0.3189543296382996],[0.270770752986566,0.38045230055777757,0.34877694645565643],[0.1074049247715514,0.5057301011676503,0.38686497406079834],[0.13917195177257544,0.4895237490872874,0.3713042991401373],[0.09497251505682021,0.0751840121761824,0.8298434727669974],[0.518593871526755,0.18442391084402326,0.29698221762922183],[0.16902740879742642,0.6023806014740456,0.22859198972852796],[0.21563379650172107,0.21725102951984385,0.5671151739784351],[0.045517737443807806,0.4508549449412267,0.5036273176149655],[0.058739884972545856,0.7797229078054478,0.16153720722200618],[0.1267219106663127,0.33258162997260615,0.5406964593610811],[0.7408312452516423,0.14532878765934773,0.11383996708900988],[0.3823247064465919,0.3428066144193963,0.27486867913401164],[0.3144732800892294,0.585347945236499,0.1001787746742715],[0.41540024013627963,0.41021074277557484,0.17438901708814558],[0.3370619720784196,0.3483340267712224,0.31460400115035797],[0.3971607867330171,0.3562749651068371,0.24656424816014588],[0.5265740812862807,0.049569233332293475,0.4238566853814258]],"extremes":[18,16,11],"p":1.0},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.31349966320183387,0.528904692285091,0.578338297400879],[0.30571960805899834,0.5914229616810277,0.5210684989863839],[0.21604630182212042,0.8466740833052326,0.24398193714502234],[0.22158795672678522,0.64116224863393,0.5267445481762001],[0.32072493578256095,0.24092252866893632,0.7884569400217002],[0.6943507474406582,0.34012490025508424,0.3677933024102589],[0.291479888033938,0.246027828355651,0.8037661714943926],[0.6826736124946693,0.4427720622436174,0.2713143838680682]],"extremes":[5,2,6],"p":1.4999999999996365},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.6382929775064383,0.45986987788677003,0.31665951599184683],[0.8163934137629201,0.3663574827819188,0.1181370337214604],[0.21707185483749245,0.6253962009644685,0.5467567206420033],[0.49571937734187854,0.3176859050714272,0.6061465002724885],[0.46365600391768436,0.6302612235674309,0.3234187393255794],[0.3844917770165244,0.22784212687037256,0.7525475222629415],[0.05778592081198622,0.5543353428558045,0.6901836126358578],[0.5238200287033469,0.2548017191633904,0.6234463000139392],[0.22781601252558478,0.316947949085247,0.7979756155641105],[0.13111907810364457,0.9260632547815223,0.15555301694282667],[0.5014664487822802,0.438713821899603,0.5007092019441675],[0.6899314256626642,0.4819341417167511,0.20432935167232652],[0.3485130541274298,0.5892687303629465,0.48896137964800446],[0.5502689590041188,0.40383937653387963,0.48252048658782637],[0.4274555683212072,0.36774120315917713,0.6278797487515899],[0.3565763882059886,0.7877321154332881,0.19773555802650325],[0.658201263331932,0.15258649170972516,0.5486590349052145],[0.36902337545546054,0.6873579733777577,0.34875622506402476],[0.6174268974633859,0.3947288123360125,0.41448692603614473],[0.5824942489483714,0.18167698031105908,0.611339627723626],[0.3990162339201375,0.37656608149366394,0.6440525860148423],[0.2286690603214192,0.550981846142425,0.6144672014037486],[0.4501211010167043,0.774160338621272,0.06573395432870446],[0.743823338692072,0.22691756187400774,0.3972670895523085],[0.12956143818978605,0.6933127208435811,0.5210144804965656]],"extremes":[1,9,8],"p":1.4999999989963761},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.6349938723171298,0.23979903816932419,0.73435631910726],[0.4097545346650845,0.695414894859843,0.5903383312376672],[0.19923865275141067,0.5099241523146767,0.8368281293885628],[0.8555495260921342,0.2389076874377864,0.45930178019103474],[0.30238768044875525,0.7815467376703047,0.5456614220830764],[0.5805312499793612,0.6839115344695551,0.4418693028678262],[0.1776671119275262,0.8724756107347829,0.4552150107501944],[0.4907709343423055,0.34474981041396235,0.8001821406556869]],"extremes":[3,6,2],"p":1.9999999999919547},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.8614830436034328,0.4561171499965702,0.22316834691051515],[0.6932750263465945,0.15069778099181844,0.7047410280722066],[0.6826061682241333,0.6965697580792565,0.22099636022290534],[0.7340438733124766,0.508181107529885,0.450479249246973],[0.08015073309356854,0.3178714102355008,0.944739978268866],[0.20426693411655047,0.8875458367119625,0.4129617504828834],[0.7910449013447683,0.5718621349722811,0.2173054592995542],[0.6848334554892371,0.6344288692200483,0.35847335764717847],[0.5291866265769464,0.6828629444648588,0.50364641697216],[0.2817703522060979,0.674483375734244,0.6824057769947366],[0.8846732110371011,0.4564709142726477,0.09480302788623277],[0.49713607137604254,0.3088151486442013,0.8108569112393716],[0.11672302191801422,0.8667818169800601,0.4848350419545524],[0.8503551634453994,0.3444135642517039,0.39783840030995704],[0.8703591182924515,0.12687555130987135,0.47579155066583784],[0.8430680125503047,0.5001042134356934,0.19781835586806776],[0.5920167563141153,0.6461377169052014,0.4816868391765],[0.5258212748142068,0.8423257091600577,0.11831900371778141],[0.8628909949584028,0.2046890653277442,0.46208388562570757],[0.7170100363401858,0.6589018779908591,0.2274751040610036],[0.8869037898539306,0.40918875525483617,0.21439736499251263],[0.5381929890787351,0.3527062425288703,0.7654714971752131],[0.7397251684653409,0.160004896746689,0.6536092931989298],[0.6298911540618757,0.5181074562525277,0.5786205991927125],[0.15870654160018047,0.9717602485084581,0.17462603778385932]],"extremes":[20,24,4],"p":1.9999999999828963},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.6218097294779497,0.9123085315009821,0.06368367398474231],[0.5113726382078931,0.9516660473044514,0.1636318657068407],[0.36368176413826375,0.7186680542665438,0.8342988138523569],[0.294506148508977,0.8016855222100882,0.7715039564872331],[0.9633152279528601,0.4631327821724807,0.18878358029450173],[0.8365454931860739,0.5922535381133096,0.5913929535001481],[0.7727521470195873,0.05404486397637462,0.8135183950688007],[0.6046838672898012,0.6397152695174448,0.8026513864428628]],"extremes":[4,1,6],"p":2.9999999992700177},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.3332749748880689,0.9720203941917707,0.3546178757842214],[0.06008784037536923,0.9317899052212726,0.5756681218042637],[0.9032335081390295,0.5967643600829098,0.36984651898005944],[0.7679622058305225,0.2783309686926653,0.8069807126444158],[0.8193941136270544,0.4799015003664329,0.6974940053380339],[0.3746223593258265,0.441742502344088,0.9514197509145371],[0.7225904888516437,0.7332421264178167,0.6113448050577319],[0.8842968495261824,0.6504517063359622,0.32171862435909093],[0.24508713345541208,0.7525736797247355,0.8237883277752953],[0.15432476441330972,0.7355584456274196,0.8426604327564028],[0.4791927262444435,0.6804983474585131,0.8314752084533091],[0.4809940970104674,0.25222850124074436,0.9556169095555396],[0.40317343793964,0.961287045889688,0.3587338123192647],[0.7164810526228003,0.7643484747715795,0.5704620557494172],[0.5327696914622271,0.8354094202510024,0.6429108081424898],[0.8032020482788489,0.7090330854212018,0.5005017648766767],[0.40332394035279756,0.977517971518028,0.06926701793093636],[0.4412676468665522,0.748253074414945,0.7911225314006901],[0.7217721615795778,0.6111786284870844,0.7341503120764068],[0.12134701496850325,0.9976576575187848,0.17351100094610744],[0.5105412085373318,0.9461085122295246,0.27164225090755045],[0.08725495632903911,0.9981000866591497,0.1712776696979179],[0.06551533089849326,0.9083052227175424,0.630254612825459],[0.4578822557652657,0.8531191742027158,0.6566122042779078],[0.46893780481191905,0.9624015276651714,0.17637780027229127]],"extremes":[2,21,11],"p":2.99999999277205},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.3100923606926799,0.8139510990204358,0.9441426812030236],[0.9996571148870818,0.3561170285553439,0.15856466305500375],[0.9314520430274769,0.5891037672278411,0.8205031180113203],[0.06324767042692413,0.7552077329038714,0.9663766645118645],[0.9659604556209307,0.3171680707133859,0.7559417558870593],[0.2890608725645385,0.92475757783656,0.8488139379150567],[0.15626040044286452,0.5188148651814987,0.9967205050101603],[0.7792574187775716,0.16231085604090592,0.9586271468329528]],"extremes":[1,5,6],"p":5.999999999999567},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.6843565585664912,0.2804636147307918,0.9820071204749905],[0.8441440907254009,0.7579589097477515,0.8749230819042236],[0.9100541024357116,0.790981912534356,0.7562212274629687],[0.5781389684997689,0.9772979982531644,0.6711202938683117],[0.7146325241774379,0.7465653895869012,0.940858429431164],[0.35298677090936137,0.9799801157674582,0.694624282937743],[0.9191618723171241,0.2456117326694671,0.8572015070198297],[0.3609054150395997,0.1683314817665507,0.9996275553317959],[0.6626149824449648,0.9495133597191338,0.7531604477936134],[0.9970716528733939,0.45463631005103716,0.45273721481311446],[0.6106915359615477,0.9911418394439879,0.2201863479773101],[0.9995578566010759,0.36826647613178953,0.23189078222908224],[0.2709221994850685,0.8946250826506991,0.8869727423729079],[0.45406663425954175,0.9969953991294875,0.45715764044872176],[0.6765917014577284,0.7976940391963947,0.9298647723967366],[0.5745920977165345,0.0803603539375523,0.9939099812506025],[0.9851066177205842,0.45133770091646325,0.6531596476255312],[0.9276554403094268,0.843561374517478,0.3660345258881702],[0.26075196572428794,0.45536396230798576,0.9984557264062219],[0.6696983869610384,0.8937730754484746,0.8583843024756305],[0.880109515103063,0.8878616563061873,0.5972536445700389],[0.6095211223250956,0.6115122168181248,0.9819425796221171],[0.6888408127941259,0.9283290989287568,0.7953419628764924],[0.5029279210496054,0.6724317419846452,0.9810168611337506],[0.7067961659437019,0.7406656292585405,0.9445688429867986]],"extremes":[11,13,7],"p":5.999999999997069},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.00898374740582727,0.06748438569094453,0.009068592392240138,0.00829188151186798,0.019860455143367872],[0.011482184866546221,0.016364577399692836,0.0181887598710733,0.01689650256336894,0.02901146875405089],[0.018204683145217403,0.01039539756758691,0.010547111375454147,0.028596877390700486,0.02661236697700903],[0.009124746229012768,0.013820325914101957,0.030142967557430636,0.007306667977695369,0.041712289831816],[0.030347467377645602,0.005508963594157,0.04269470851443306,0.015463937379868222,0.00963267921855578],[0.016305300525263813,0.0042895325417846505,0.024792358364757315,0.024688858795020537,0.027897867097148574],[0.02613986572031136,0.022821287575381776,0.002325106695629582,0.024518136356406053,0.025775891880109387],[0.03590098357251855,0.019031779865926603,0.008242623298388962,0.021382635880654886,0.011779828029084767]],"extremes":[7,0,4,2,1],"p":0.39999999999943625},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.4,"front":[[0.015624809257092517,0.026749883589932053,0.008601989810021847,0.01872168232959282,0.023407769058985967],[0.015333499608425828,0.015605516102491012,0.025416703017354724,0.015272062548033658,0.018952724529059595],[0.03801132658247655,0.0036086192554371367,0.016923951234816118,0.03871569892552273,0.009646027875672376],[0.012428381040396213,0.02561584963591914,0.03722344998785062,0.02068354301611097,0.004597380141230927],[0.022371650551331928,0.019862421863257318,0.009283587402087734,0.01400821469528542,0.027495515587101726],[0.01920825962964214,0.010830878505801642,0.011710517020273066,0.028059437141866775,0.023302503743452194],[0.033151086502192145,0.0056369483313164,0.014781221856499258,0.017392974251060834,0.026754698963409592],[0.015954070553539344,0.027549302528716357,0.022165193149881208,0.027422290149287636,0.004589479354642584],[0.01012043577841949,0.019548047154970313,0.014907999351819334,0.018501833896213314,0.029672205928988987],[0.009127685640570987,0.030363364872003872,0.019962314297732476,0.01418914586835934,0.019918340577545855],[0.02131421384461746,0.017218582111103914,0.019395323806881245,0.014214200563145537,0.017778754725800906],[0.026691559904209513,0.03681890207693708,0.021304732008711393,0.006289524728991607,0.009035995377116052],[0.02576455905769398,0.005422511847183471,0.007062475094157273,0.07660887362739771,0.00853196092328503],[0.02616555934366966,0.0061168356269385715,0.011172883439449922,0.02688847538152985,0.027014707143833062],[0.0328648084312636,0.011968326168513772,0.00645983545360984,0.030504400890829356,0.016564491261806],[0.013043517821472278,0.01813040088119614,0.021007935944773102,0.011812013552635102,0.0282102371420308],[0.015210722522970684,0.008604113167979703,0.007851688522490784,0.029131036470997143,0.04015416085131929],[0.027322633964571776,0.006845429509811949,0.03291686771513168,0.018741609065029325,0.011545778852135102],[0.012719648794226773,0.02036424160182888,0.013359761973391896,0.018347869370809095,0.02673193299426411],[0.02918047649447518,0.0172416258702172,0.009709775486129897,0.01569668153347076,0.02099747621494508],[0.02483786163765649,0.012260486252248353,0.009686385875675874,0.022414356540367972,0.023914174233055183],[0.015722339145152565,0.029192749973009066,0.02239293929303057,0.0253704811836836,0.004781195766710373],[0.021671879318205318,0.0074593704320394215,0.023251413957367115,0.010446506911254231,0.03436780589122588],[0.005695159113089201,0.028587324937193834,0.023717270874796702,0.012842268807026398,0.02625092259055699],[0.005688530462307138,0.032110306814549086,0.01479969119098199,0.016480390520811225,0.02876572091250998]],"extremes":[19,9,1,12,8],"p":0.39999999864738656},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.03990265396975245,0.207395610663044,0.1562436272570068,0.02282549791882548,0.11424166998313019],[0.08207721473022911,0.08639547347797846,0.13349483988906882,0.09444083100597461,0.1077179665854945],[0.09535065431627954,0.1818188335450218,0.08672966958737667,0.1355625106043989,0.025335211179482776],[0.11936139915074973,0.08894180167090213,0.13747564194385148,0.12468461608166694,0.04170666969425134],[0.13667832964622156,0.12698650944011813,0.035560314579725326,0.051950142939010194,0.17307758938615259],[0.08144546268527524,0.017424143919908677,0.1384420855804979,0.23642009562254324,0.06875746093310943],[0.17022949734170914,0.06863666025492311,0.12301139839736679,0.06533420097118994,0.08519960772021852],[0.05457076957702214,0.12924686643757718,0.11778862640528709,0.08225385954037825,0.12469879062208805]],"extremes":[6,2,1,5,4],"p":0.7},{"kind":"geometry","q":0.7,"front":[[0.06438127246937896,0.1793474623642375,0.04005722863361132,0.07083469169059985,0.17159594031349948],[0.05432384320514294,0.010459889130844724,0.17103402648534222,0.1720047477990311,0.13532424166305812],[0.17376104900196818,0.11169216682148318,0.026393473384293223,0.10371833771176614,0.10572165675190871],[0.02427754853557564,0.06870895111424227,0.1343557158842387,0.17029020992365967,0.1282839361355987],[0.03780230441249653,0.1294397068950041,0.13937459896059645,0.17177406974663065,0.04657614863968538],[0.1720975800155368,0.17367702786431635,0.0462417521230848,0.08487818906510407,0.048601833160511324],[0.040115010459979186,0.08809092698375648,0.018715914407941882,0.16396011185206077,0.24010477692863855],[0.14413866623500618,0.1402158905312096,0.06308033570386497,0.11135145482563177,0.054136109176907345],[0.12544504492961936,0.18939753799985892,0.07010628485897774,0.050930020949176355,0.08232574716204924],[0.09719520311333972,0.032863460078599215,0.11480265781635912,0.1625769184765374,0.10956695020772465],[0.115145432891302,0.12391005896658552,0.11426878906633164,0.06609269578397829,0.08602389504682055],[0.03528457526437912,0.037404161390290444,0.14443684955469097,0.12618936987343196,0.18820414922473902],[0.10304355784091503,0.07622047976517048,0.10464127863320395,0.11319043842265102,0.10589342186387467],[0.0440540956557664,0.07181233480186043,0.18550205085025792,0.11372290650252231,0.10287606176244286],[0.07706086248182151,0.14680528896416603,0.11175455498508831,0.11084404210816867,0.061880673720392396],[0.12207872862870289,0.1323174316807632,0.05548683348271016,0.06532509657923787,0.13614350637511652],[0.12391635548902487,0.2340817313660631,0.015616940238473263,0.12975505858434017,0.044084640578253134],[0.11647622424946578,0.02314191545058184,0.14639121263647917,0.0989949820363731,0.13621172208229665],[0.18596415034838273,0.11143772831734212,0.05789921984653355,0.16899401079993667,0.014864985674101737],[0.12812168976493046,0.02719002889830083,0.11993418297042745,0.11185650508136015,0.13026237405201674],[0.02475358552638804,0.13714894880896394,0.03949303179983143,0.15364379314783203,0.18110789947577205],[0.13032064228872298,0.06475091379011017,0.24352673738074307,0.07010928682675711,0.02955348527847157],[0.04164628056626516,0.10865410064228846,0.13280243308331208,0.12375392612693356,0.10429216664867254],[0.1804568679842512,0.0646959465749582,0.1312427950170803,0.12481459549364796,0.025617913953615006],[0.14596236365809745,0.14660906907276453,0.07112237233508704,0.014646940665064442,0.15406245997131715]],"extremes":[2,8,21,9,6],"p":0.6999999996371933},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.33463736398251465,0.04617152221498137,0.4005320758718867,0.11291545448389698,0.10574358344672033],[0.03937598762784218,0.289010473096679,0.3047896603619098,0.06602036086810462,0.3008035180454643],[0.23741471894061178,0.22846013251658898,0.06438354042790036,0.2587307826614047,0.21101082545349417],[0.27134354518721565,0.28207232042037844,0.14491163129910772,0.1341492259983445,0.16752327709495377],[0.21269182447419777,0.4213339768583477,0.1843728860633869,0.13719554568314976,0.044405766920918015],[0.38605444030966873,0.2610170754316611,0.08183888584537785,0.1109870268582355,0.16010257155505672],[0.1690000649372483,0.3173741595951089,0.3015743893872949,0.17681843313031936,0.03523295295002851],[0.1721557930541471,0.2294726216091455,0.06458355086922499,0.2810273872929296,0.2527606471745528]],"extremes":[5,4,0,7,2],"p":1.0},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.0,"front":[[0.16261029556331874,0.3604512950119021,0.13393050904010054,0.27506258747043294,0.06794531291424577],[0.277683358558463,0.18427179095766003,0.2511420460617509,0.0739269087375363,0.2129758956845899],[0.16289092429369387,0.2632742688601848,0.2530148924770731,0.07677386662740036,0.24404604774164798],[0.3024892769228563,0.23013423574576533,0.27454842662044193,0.15707932452570028,0.03574873618523609],[0.09148888617489903,0.2138889301309009,0.35793830804548443,0.046600642303140205,0.2900832333455753],[0.3423394585409685,0.21952832309796497,0.058539847507426516,0.033486036779149166,0.34610633407449093],[0.37284643260069783,0.1561978759257264,0.023630239258368144,0.18225797055329448,0.2650674816619132],[0.14629875549136867,0.10308919503820216,0.263471803675272,0.18761383619547728,0.29952640959967985],[0.1909856703986872,0.18975603221135853,0.28261078485346214,0.07932734528114763,0.25732016725534446],[0.04788838158633959,0.29058174584832724,0.22778822614475716,0.23141095171120968,0.20233069470936635],[0.14996284528304968,0.2720598300996014,0.1360273818528525,0.2955057012148995,0.1464442415495969],[0.18910435862464187,0.151954031723091,0.3866114493405788,0.198409493863123,0.07392066644856546],[0.20063543855807298,0.12939589576190058,0.20141301738462875,0.08601401189084316,0.38254163640455463],[0.29407066218285477,0.16696870607520264,0.03013971460191165,0.1958417328173543,0.3129791843226767],[0.19077200753883272,0.22260978312144913,0.0357865299176764,0.26692946804800655,0.2839022113740352],[0.07552814404206465,0.2590634720384654,0.33086128948587074,0.28211651441134805,0.0524305800222512],[0.22333497844936512,0.36834031606106865,0.07186653856479792,0.21535450033405043,0.12110366659071777],[0.26262952206709217,0.16241902931451,0.22717748143013783,0.08642935368620945,0.26134461350205046],[0.14737043841951344,0.13706231703758065,0.30113606809806553,0.3363473367706445,0.0780838396741959],[0.022031390777519606,0.28393656906123166,0.30935968656571916,0.22328472269222036,0.16138763090330918],[0.14768014437290913,0.11371205893860184,0.3906578732738666,0.08295819748804702,0.26499172592657533],[0.13480082155965487,0.13739684096749274,0.44411656349757,0.2388046806797545,0.044881093295527925],[0.0731843477761469,0.09811943775134763,0.3092420549705394,0.24190299925635014,0.2775511602456158],[0.19876269401316385,0.1118584008295768,0.16888572879386463,0.3045040098671073,0.21598916649628738],[0.3103407605700524,0.1626090614357109,0.2587575422452203,0.2020575345541561,0.06623510119486031]],"extremes":[6,16,21,23,12],"p":0.9999999999999999},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.6427180839798073,0.3104136840213975,0.14408859946614425,0.39157654165205313,0.05259142794402127],[0.13122435262303261,0.3357712936598275,0.5941704553746617,0.2119177212375529,0.3446602501090811],[0.3576488471152248,0.4950968839889454,0.43548099009042474,0.2721344673249327,0.041341212155234335],[0.3066442670974206,0.5612713261553088,0.2909833897357314,0.3313987808360551,0.15657971892373584],[0.37191645981527227,0.34258385508129985,0.510859611844785,0.23026951799035617,0.21116816104714622],[0.29139593854050166,0.19250283227751797,0.5158270962617854,0.47360148381734646,0.15638149443165575],[0.40128796637561137,0.09077614562512094,0.3430856539180047,0.3773915293273681,0.43373099274862525],[0.36242837324889166,0.3059373262374262,0.49407039648956735,0.08099005437107716,0.3886168537409396]],"extremes":[0,3,1,5,6],"p":1.4999999999978966},{"kind":"geometry","q":1.5,"front":[[0.35065619958689526,0.20342582349079952,0.18383825116768213,0.634271880202803,0.23872408829868694],[0.3862700942822443,0.46222709980803195,0.5264827332471678,0.10053941431180181,0.1003412045550347],[0.09751024404958433,0.4480282596165535,0.2510223265366408,0.31274981358573717,0.5144532695537912],[0.44057796272524635,0.2874546793292718,0.21501661374900136,0.3554290681342432,0.38816853185449945],[0.453843668722892,0.32046193341720547,0.2041920186581482,0.32746257612428287,0.37885057420947593],[0.15614772721225148,0.5157224873372399,0.22724926691394828,0.38971766496151267,0.36035061835200577],[0.34614511294062555,0.20974108014613238,0.4204289774812506,0.4902321445031352,0.1924717897902881],[0.04092301166118454,0.4516464059759706,0.35419559624960373,0.34165297333060546,0.42564504453707647],[0.0413409798341981,0.3945415025523678,0.3536525463303221,0.45950877354768677,0.36660612756902156],[0.2611859474500373,0.3576936277753727,0.7237824720669254,0.03934383365264062,0.0944454462861664],[0.40140749998373426,0.19503271559935276,0.476296402604037,0.18632247601382257,0.3972855623435177],[0.22312122094339476,0.33265546934627044,0.5462787754868366,0.43320806437715287,0.05768387267443614],[0.3306124716215452,0.33931591783282367,0.4550197503699392,0.036911119931005765,0.44636743606330676],[0.3463963228169003,0.3659434489223542,0.06888955268718878,0.6564450407303614,0.0850746308982588],[0.11626858808829982,0.6511408715966194,0.11872033506850728,0.5170862095719838,0.07896897130468652],[0.2256727389549015,0.30311922448782036,0.4871545122155935,0.44030147068453096,0.20633877619057528],[0.643398130952178,0.19970793481721422,0.09281730302456576,0.48461694437521724,0.09445415247325231],[0.43645078828055256,0.1426344850067579,0.4330819025547877,0.3249249293593549,0.32767602593829165],[0.5517620121769924,0.28251265227659417,0.3504071010813375,0.2328873872566355,0.24352400508644576],[0.4129175486415156,0.6419522285351531,0.28342834351940216,0.05164572350621395,0.14930568033053185],[0.23689987316477254,0.5863212324417278,0.3338504168190102,0.14143125030687506,0.33009564225319143],[0.4717553069265313,0.3032364101643456,0.15970525167051813,0.4281250099441066,0.30088419632524915],[0.5654476817176376,0.4964851747831248,0.1425511819565345,0.23833163677125935,0.14427260225583843],[0.3570685787006843,0.33717137407739034,0.3759393335218016,0.20268179774327447,0.4168127601681241],[0.3321563369925236,0.10191912820099888,0.3733796581395119,0.2597416453528637,0.5568198758684054]],"extremes":[16,19,9,0,24],"p":1.4999999999999967},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.5571278119304323,0.5206384691159792,0.3907572836303753,0.2927047645600233,0.42447243932186024],[0.19808605220820266,0.9181628672628416,0.09515211332828605,0.26188031178535065,0.2002589391977686],[0.07427115230725179,0.5102283025723773,0.5063543841302884,0.5625564600497516,0.4016047087838887],[0.15568811875873478,0.7926973149462524,0.5733063698366411,0.09805610800842304,0.0953781030496056],[0.07565566224082089,0.5273061077448139,0.6660630029261676,0.09749499948916641,0.5129125565956647],[0.5445431537209565,0.04814867587446439,0.463499148996014,0.4348212780069366,0.5452095503744919],[0.434518129179991,0.4567491836380683,0.6968789471762002,0.10063585001869388,0.3268123885863026],[0.4652326144949534,0.364921438324036,0.5628244571887022,0.5688052539555699,0.10040005838887292]],"extremes":[0,1,6,7,5],"p":1.9999999999999993},{"kind":"geometry","q":2.0,"front":[[0.48637261795952436,0.4184101149155266,0.24294994690059613,0.32497485778296653,0.6509541591736799],[0.6033555124682075,0.2116283739176325,0.054420039637177016,0.437681999770185,0.6298003519292961],[0.3747935694230737,0.37003359105113953,0.3751467205044402,0.21332033416533602,0.732368960933806],[0.11705890940465255,0.4509250733272685,0.2326919863822189,0.8455216439354293,0.11794650941853813],[0.597114704595287,0.3378773110184307,0.2842597180034393,0.5863796456220104,0.3234938580187396],[0.6083092163920619,0.2401169707168618,0.5536032460228251,0.504596749703622,0.1058739996777534],[0.5927225570102579,0.4657301787507051,0.5626258559883064,0.24056143958618667,0.239494699251789],[0.6120618394136913,0.5153860596213894,0.16721729941301022,0.38674959192863134,0.426873098474855],[0.6194094913062183,0.079172068879197,0.4907443016860831,0.4428046951702261,0.4161222150847049],[0.3875530220217383,0.3339807482746623,0.7402825103785591,0.12526568386626108,0.41779160855245934],[0.7148863448298327,0.3459555877160216,0.060895041195161474,0.5963332505717664,0.09965286510810373],[0.6451463517018394,0.259102392004273,0.20050763458326934,0.5760301612367492,0.3803131304107937],[0.4719285650754821,0.3700122634625912,0.354464336695282,0.44212104315978706,0.5650295315818121],[0.08336025243855162,0.4328826078573715,0.216999420966196,0.5955518570776781,0.635525729581145],[0.4648357787572624,0.35013695745766416,0.07841549184694886,0.6105474595800598,0.5314269658646952],[0.5289700151932408,0.3286309619387715,0.16451067239056372,0.5953145217207005,0.48034287002069526],[0.2443694336229145,0.5498382366714192,0.31346937245510076,0.5308902392692731,0.5077932648097054],[0.21471779059782053,0.0715499109842107,0.7001823810220545,0.662967956052567,0.13782236100397577],[0.057753519841952414,0.35887686706567784,0.562895723998247,0.2749874267899593,0.6894941944954396],[0.48601991902178276,0.4704677569102508,0.34423356765149404,0.040619747053417414,0.649844608405069],[0.6888986320370127,0.2094175194140497,0.6777276992560901,0.12137612898538863,0.0866947421333467],[0.21183319719703783,0.48911522717906764,0.7006159772884422,0.3358857801999914,0.33497908312975944],[0.404771972266995,0.4589076351640818,0.6054661493012712,0.42968649011380344,0.272660402550807],[0.6852104303953367,0.5897246820522679,0.17524601432303974,0.2412062917100233,0.30630021997898876],[0.4701531717390068,0.4282390988272472,0.43441035782781645,0.5513646409752626,0.3207053835430697]],"extremes":[10,23,9,3,2],"p":1.9999999991426174},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.5117628910858741,0.5232999580132267,0.1417184013505263,0.5627410974220064,0.8151352608432519],[0.19236807166171765,0.9409145969596321,0.3860527881683807,0.33998076012119927,0.3979839643236961],[0.686023816030297,0.25643092428446035,0.5822218284501713,0.6155879535342281,0.6123695516294436],[0.498400314623601,0.19957270267896213,0.7026467882230665,0.48531045535363876,0.7411027151339153],[0.3006247784456938,0.21014817355784413,0.6448019429566121,0.7147608854742911,0.6912531009914042],[0.5783567297997861,0.722928209297538,0.710351867312435,0.3230960580409202,0.3318641471565694],[0.5221383545172931,0.7385244662972756,0.7018528036073816,0.40713737582145265,0.3465709474205219],[0.16708839024037375,0.8595713293292865,0.6252338855281316,0.48703907566652277,0.06587596696524867]],"extremes":[2,1,7,4,0],"p":2.9999999999999694},{"kind":"geometry","q":3.0,"front":[[0.5390138581582695,0.7693774630964758,0.5745531474735337,0.5830806750360483,0.040505309962153326],[0.5933175608674467,0.33198886158474045,0.5057028611286633,0.8550237857404483,0.05212360866609084],[0.7792314369949933,0.6085669507892375,0.6648234207653837,0.18627132107013544,0.10494709839430379],[0.416396640085423,0.44175057577600724,0.5142706776237271,0.6887227196245578,0.7236150311513043],[0.5780980059207982,0.3097364694514506,0.8447638671150492,0.2671824425230044,0.5373619111370697],[0.7175761923144638,0.35211650499658437,0.32892091655668837,0.25569430578646635,0.8115757067699798],[0.5218570707082263,0.49464077480053775,0.6497708396980115,0.4549326681750545,0.7168480037855419],[0.40363912289532056,0.5760273073298541,0.8035869587743831,0.5991792294356527,0.2085804333834947],[0.7072230622936618,0.37937072203622957,0.5719714260416882,0.1781131844591604,0.7361306375925851],[0.7382805934978393,0.697781969639496,0.2246344121403922,0.3736504254674487,0.5792360193971142],[0.6014651401830986,0.42533104242868763,0.3776863229249375,0.3440888323055505,0.8484880617459819],[0.17420032964232177,0.3570428110567389,0.7357385783341126,0.1488456599743338,0.818146140149471],[0.6689876073076721,0.7888578370424029,0.3783429449402823,0.21640494650667,0.5258449767350569],[0.40537122228590317,0.8668349497364173,0.3835250424826341,0.6062428149533656,0.14126258801829022],[0.5916356827563024,0.5679372468440613,0.31802047371301856,0.15866448836598837,0.8308572383260073],[0.3678751818864754,0.27547485858954385,0.900189285770472,0.5629132150977164,0.27797333263234975],[0.6566080229925169,0.682328256239754,0.16981779281873524,0.7141794516275611,0.31098190876611703],[0.7628765338979208,0.4999337565074451,0.728938996561823,0.3051456983619935,0.248437105302706],[0.9395154504982222,0.11164495276294176,0.21879241551631054,0.5360330373285283,0.1688669868394065],[0.3748287936298229,0.5546221585762262,0.7870609106070675,0.06153360569300229,0.6611056466076564],[0.5701786571989089,0.7303690036968963,0.33761152354322,0.4011150382184097,0.6854176439201144],[0.10894137990323109,0.7951266596486607,0.26805481305572487,0.7470535061516328,0.39110369927712607],[0.10076995136502435,0.9150633850262416,0.5811668270773418,0.2577487433729187,0.2684285264506115],[0.34081736907555527,0.8364013996608841,0.6758848159700619,0.15367053133742092,0.39770775880086934],[0.4403157579344913,0.34527366590599357,0.5167017698292015,0.6163330043930569,0.7944392822999118]],"extremes":[18,22,15,1,11],"p":2.999999999381362},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.5014274084265484,0.9658426569532055,0.4042165939612364,0.7427945756722633,0.10076905655923517],[0.4604008721044105,0.3869141926186054,0.9660459665298792,0.7400483447651739,0.464502557576437],[0.9191748798965452,0.40662096150770555,0.8554971608845826,0.14303841522521726,0.2653605474304725],[0.6013356683158059,0.8796525961920265,0.8855883113924607,0.43754385145807595,0.15406509368280144],[0.6523974602727773,0.9043219323913065,0.08878810329952369,0.16606126136960622,0.8495438525837878],[0.19647265728858096,0.8551791881001827,0.11509449896873689,0.5284150100002037,0.915044640732771],[0.5146253469888454,0.29606528886782724,0.4489852347504946,0.5569641004266158,0.9902149657351325],[0.8542772724603083,0.863792148178214,0.08744424728407306,0.7512481253951108,0.5028455524342217]],"extremes":[2,0,1,6,5],"p":5.999999999999997},{"kind":"geometry","q":6.0,"front":[[0.4670687384989206,0.39011054654794847,0.20355033283544324,0.9976150620526543,0.2504231377677843],[0.09726349694079081,0.37101897757447927,0.9018632458683254,0.8783845206200119,0.11073111823797965],[0.244031900342155,0.9147910638899045,0.4494798737870895,0.8602751457647493,0.23108926599757432],[0.9304748434526815,0.27205163548310957,0.8184387798179963,0.568503618068574,0.5035868903006745],[0.5638146850899284,0.19322015288618383,0.096470069371575,0.9943241789743198,0.3344416799258278],[0.5546139647297644,0.6210222785959101,0.7469371394451743,0.8751205696149855,0.8139075992125419],[0.3143434239480652,0.5854367178515973,0.10219298530438581,0.6451224184482969,0.9801557112193763],[0.5174435467389928,0.864021784042913,0.6788664271550356,0.88015490661792,0.3542231064159657],[0.21418693924422566,0.9582878676528276,0.7767971177448392,0.42105163071858537,0.2427580712339287],[0.5562255279826068,0.20254587921199077,0.7181145218955572,0.9697176699579348,0.344051313978895],[0.5494054426436762,0.9320479673566453,0.5369880707501954,0.7912926117524464,0.6016945924054525],[0.9143968847957492,0.39917528574617683,0.8503829077497704,0.33396562842252975,0.5630561966897025],[0.3338745590403389,0.9542602650540737,0.31332424734243836,0.11170793610485207,0.7897209388087061],[0.17091325542534844,0.6515626105074047,0.9751896435476418,0.6286266991296539,0.34479519621414373],[0.24438201443520347,0.5699618841285642,0.6725770842487759,0.8766594871500134,0.8650429265891567],[0.9134301961178131,0.7906283628154505,0.6248380963466751,0.6220570636676683,0.6212007674616938],[0.16328259114305602,0.09647554464841482,0.9943377377460898,0.2565486776912636,0.5668971317633971],[0.8815061356797868,0.44863009333893095,0.7700366690981159,0.6116298368033787,0.7998348240234846],[0.8828645326365883,0.34210501362116386,0.8155194611782071,0.783094622304336,0.19754805573190887],[0.8333525859350314,0.6372201112729698,0.9061791621512226,0.5429323977919882,0.5155697660853245],[0.5338729329846065,0.7413312047796955,0.8761161487394642,0.7050590467232434,0.7859882226879858],[0.7398667009780361,0.485756809978604,0.9646096305743687,0.483004735651126,0.4071370324208162],[0.42920807435562497,0.2551812906513171,0.8116008147397707,0.6913781593219634,0.9179923549707106],[0.3724358056570686,0.5242712160236057,0.04891189686766604,0.9434824148237395,0.8045505666905372],[0.7256361087162821,0.8121149925356601,0.309428973470173,0.5883907729326067,0.8981035763796916]],"extremes":[4,12,16,0,6],"p":6.000000000000003},{"kind":"geometry","front":[[0.6156693470065965,0.3395990456669112,0.7110722490286021],[0.6756303511985332,0.6534486218987365,0.34136274998597727],[0.5849340535278735,0.1856207503373789,0.7895549949608571],[0.18208395347192546,0.649870574798637,0.7379116951905038],[0.24652151131835678,0.583506368732097,0.77378773711296],[0.588555146017818,0.0,0.8063200877519374],[0.9289235470350823,0.19506933754872396,0.31472050665958123],[1.210940735267321,0.0978357239357856,0.6957375272271871],[0.35756516549618056,0.3063993722980251,0.8821941833174061],[0.7376114639847782,0.12328152071247461,0.6638757375059371],[0.09051923524055791,0.828554470018225,0.5525429922316296],[0.9053589806301403,0.3277995590601742,0.26994919016790647]],"extremes":[6,10,8],"p":1.989358067638937},{"kind":"geometry","front":[[0.019123567769678797,0.10842268070655982,0.09101384779267557],[0.0513618496013397,0.07322412348094015,0.06919526656188593],[0.037136734747319565,0.02023199765261445,0.19690311627740742],[0.09865197960621283,0.01674733742831178,0.10714690006653732],[0.01,0.01,0.01],[0.0580121586664146,0.11999877733274278,0.03174810710647945],[0.031235455038001427,0.055965512802765016,0.124389641490247],[0.02340575413206815,0.1340521792278644,0.06240456281688813],[0.07039296998586529,0.07009407157401179,0.05294312811510247],[0.037547212416754995,0.08619975464868547,0.07551359996262641]],"extremes":[4,5,2],"p":0.4000000000000001},{"kind":"distances","p":0.5,"front":[[0.5398136021441391,0.22365404772397243],[0.34803137746576196,0.39541926400382654],[0.08477186975345723,0.7561140031339331],[0.40160345555034743,0.34210863967866906],[0.18450399081363295,0.5930160377857397],[0.456952081656552,0.2915869125574567],[0.30064606578325354,0.4466686365827246],[0.24556905243656174,0.5118921660225085],[0.40358551518520613,0.34022262135446557]],"distances":[[0.0,0.1769342626687948,0.5184265499710231,0.12610724920322777,0.35697471877479026,0.07522728390111513,0.22412364480800798,0.28313598573272947,0.12426301086380977],[0.1769342626687948,0.0,0.34321315144178327,0.05089589452935897,0.1807160985370725,0.1017882063304589,0.04730371448038086,0.10652433225269245,0.05274156474714792],[0.5184265499710231,0.34321315144178327,0.0,0.39373526887528226,0.16299171710096003,0.4441523094169789,0.29616286061316255,0.2371327674221907,0.39556544504335966],[0.12610724920322777,0.05089589452935897,0.39373526887528226,0.0,0.2314851647479375,0.05090864702730451,0.09818493343514789,0.1573679790021132,0.0018459791939978497],[0.35697471877479026,0.1807160985370725,0.16299171710096003,0.2314851647479375,0.0,0.28219448264877,0.1334789090707992,0.07427318054061693,0.23332516699144212],[0.07522728390111513,0.1017882063304589,0.4441523094169789,0.05090864702730451,0.28219448264877,0.0,0.14904749926898775,0.2081744103273784,0.04906295201669576],[0.22412364480800798,0.04730371448038086,0.29616286061316255,0.09818493343514789,0.1334789090707992,0.14904749926898775,0.0,0.0592386011895719,0.10002978569831775],[0.28313598573272947,0.10652433225269245,0.2371327674221907,0.1573679790021132,0.07427318054061693,0.2081744103273784,0.0592386011895719,0.0,0.15921111580425146],[0.12426301086380977,0.05274156474714792,0.39556544504335966,0.0018459791939978497,0.23332516699144212,0.04906295201669576,0.10002978569831775,0.15921111580425146,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.0,"front":[[0.5726128449900669,0.8198259142966765],[0.8706567841977018,0.49189100838551275],[0.2358369773303764,0.9717926322645544],[0.9915886165122347,0.12942957777630307],[0.8491741019159863,0.5281130036603703],[0.7490806507115656,0.6624788137967413],[0.5876522147347562,0.8091136351077863],[0.41343153136834176,0.9105352101211835],[0.3611724571979528,0.932499038155854]],"distances":[[0.0,0.3221034830753101,0.30538671639404613,0.6693651786395935,0.29037401505463856,0.16892181536482329,0.013425576153554709,0.13995463797774166,0.1867414206626537],[0.3221034830753101,0.0,0.6274901994693562,0.3472616955642834,0.031729468020671524,0.1531816677104868,0.3086779069217554,0.4620581210530518,0.5088449037379638],[0.30538671639404613,0.6274901994693562,0.0,0.9747518950336396,0.5957607314486847,0.4743085317588694,0.3188122925476008,0.16543207841630445,0.11864529573139243],[0.6693651786395935,0.3472616955642834,0.9747518950336396,0.0,0.3789911635849549,0.5004433632747702,0.6559396024860387,0.8093198166173351,0.8561065993022472],[0.29037401505463856,0.031729468020671524,0.5957607314486847,0.3789911635849549,0.0,0.1214521996898153,0.2769484389010839,0.4303286530323802,0.47711543571729226],[0.16892181536482329,0.1531816677104868,0.4743085317588694,0.5004433632747702,0.1214521996898153,0.0,0.1554962392112686,0.30887645334256497,0.35566323602747696],[0.013425576153554709,0.3086779069217554,0.3188122925476008,0.6559396024860387,0.2769484389010839,0.1554962392112686,0.0,0.15338021413129638,0.2001669968162084],[0.13995463797774166,0.4620581210530518,0.16543207841630445,0.8093198166173351,0.4303286530323802,0.30887645334256497,0.15338021413129638,0.0,0.046786782684912015],[0.1867414206626537,0.5088449037379638,0.11864529573139243,0.8561065993022472,0.47711543571729226,0.35566323602747696,0.2001669968162084,0.046786782684912015,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.7,"front":[[0.25140869169640856,0.9140888376224366],[0.4456849959912715,0.7902211977412423],[0.6226736791442163,0.6372054673527787],[0.4243130064521717,0.8059990729357138],[0.6440925585980958,0.6156681539453699],[0.7383968548455876,0.5111966088134818],[0.6825935081548637,0.5750274717472],[0.8369579716787905,0.3800625716699946],[0.9408350651734007,0.19697544860168126]],"distances":[[0.0,0.23689642927664423,0.4823163646523922,0.20927948443565683,0.5142339172837924,0.6615648024445042,0.5729770916169106,0.830702059785491,1.0410454539565621],[0.23689642927664423,0.0,0.24599845906927412,0.027647620311933605,0.2780306863021723,0.4260131572236099,0.33700910369641546,0.5961751698878268,0.8083531651701664],[0.4823163646523922,0.24599845906927412,0.0,0.2736112129553327,0.03207121160051357,0.18035130766122373,0.09114476657938245,0.35111764573575155,0.5645754108017416],[0.20927948443565683,0.027647620311933605,0.2736112129553327,0.0,0.3056344561438722,0.4535617967213498,0.3645936320293406,0.6236297134947631,0.8356282400452874],[0.5142339172837924,0.2780306863021723,0.03207121160051357,0.3056344561438722,0.0,0.1482951208462839,0.0590765520973253,0.3191118019007264,0.5326978110533065],[0.6615648024445042,0.4260131572236099,0.18035130766122373,0.4535617967213498,0.1482951208462839,0.0,0.08923235102642774,0.17096789120486783,0.3850377146289289],[0.5729770916169106,0.33700910369641546,0.09114476657938245,0.3645936320293406,0.0590765520973253,0.08923235102642774,0.0,0.26012537947341335,0.47392559903046483],[0.830702059785491,0.5961751698878268,0.35111764573575155,0.6236297134947631,0.3191118019007264,0.17096789120486783,0.26012537947341335,0.0,0.21439865631679944],[1.0410454539565621,0.8083531651701664,0.5645754108017416,0.8356282400452874,0.5326978110533065,0.3850377146289289,0.47392559903046483,0.21439865631679944,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":2.0,"front":[[0.6957925895952364,0.718242766941899],[0.6975680695251971,0.7165185192155815],[0.9661258641379677,0.2580713363464939],[0.30900901628782196,0.9510591084958036],[0.8156312173146474,0.5785721366794521],[0.8742814406190933,0.48541936775225886],[0.3836600530540337,0.9234743979616197],[0.6573084804105835,0.7536216302497758],[0.9479901243454507,0.3182997394650155]],"distances":[[0.0,0.002474946776883885,0.53860710537729,0.45438896388708383,0.18423132711577567,0.29416492429356084,0.37521397634596176,0.05227960896055129,0.4762059653692254],[0.002474946776883885,0.0,0.5361545948896995,0.45684780306538403,0.18175897154925535,0.29169662292487497,0.37767793859524845,0.05475433433306587,0.473748529057893],[0.53860710537729,0.5361545948896995,0.0,0.9853714732651735,0.3554819931766485,0.24566269430689147,0.9080291374005709,0.5903645978990836,0.06290742711270933],[0.45438896388708383,0.45684780306538403,0.9853714732651735,0.0,0.6369455310869128,0.7454193194957257,0.07960026860579797,0.4024089554109559,0.9242808149576158],[0.18423132711577567,0.18175897154925535,0.3554819931766485,0.6369455310869128,0.0,0.1101202877262265,0.5582347915957814,0.23643971956089527,0.2927795147432861],[0.29416492429356084,0.29169662292487497,0.24566269430689147,0.7454193194957257,0.1101202877262265,0.0,0.6670658356407315,0.3462778433093544,0.18284363681856786],[0.37521397634596176,0.37767793859524845,0.9080291374005709,0.07960026860579797,0.5582347915957814,0.6670658356407315,0.0,0.32313283338807175,0.8466517305011119],[0.05227960896055129,0.05475433433306587,0.5903645978990836,0.4024089554109559,0.23643971956089527,0.3462778433093544,0.32313283338807175,0.0,0.5280730909654039],[0.4762059653692254,0.473748529057893,0.06290742711270933,0.9242808149576158,0.2927795147432861,0.18284363681856786,0.8466517305011119,0.5280730909654039,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":3.7,"front":[[0.9853345765430931,0.6628631855377667],[0.1173394999857696,0.9999995649745935],[0.9954958045369113,0.5467808912946596],[0.12373023141540909,0.9999994019956404],[0.36195558816434636,0.9996248648573789],[0.8883415838903251,0.893419672066187],[0.952400466085359,0.7956426244001977],[0.9961997515420877,0.5316670543428981],[0.9999888438442824,0.20150026310308244]],"distances":[[0.0,0.9576058341628861,0.10548510193907931,0.9515191954647623,0.7244627940774025,0.23026023026470144,0.12235426543466235,0.11945742237403603,0.4392682354635938],[0.9576058341628861,0.0,1.0564278951465362,0.006387554297117034,0.24261878205214937,0.7417447014018351,0.8438513036463364,1.0696594537425297,1.3816565987658325],[0.10548510193907931,1.0564278951465362,0.0,1.0504311575326502,0.8255576614713984,0.3350005403977165,0.22761624971478733,0.013980048785792426,0.33417016210801553],[0.9515191954647623,0.006387554297117034,1.0504311575326502,0.0,0.23623179034732544,0.7354546215336117,0.8376462424893496,1.0636720184369912,1.3755713678094155],[0.7244627940774025,0.24261878205214937,0.8255576614713984,0.23623179034732544,0.0,0.5023621860437255,0.6072030028528588,0.8389861664635704,1.1465023832339485],[0.23026023026470144,0.7417447014018351,0.3350005403977165,0.7354546215336117,0.5023621860437255,0.0,0.10829727892484443,0.34885761277970306,0.6653658483013765],[0.12235426543466235,0.8438513036463364,0.22761624971478733,0.8376462424893496,0.6072030028528588,0.10829727892484443,0.0,0.24155000683936748,0.5601834434263497],[0.11945742237403603,1.0696594537425297,0.013980048785792426,1.0636720184369912,0.8389861664635704,0.34885761277970306,0.24155000683936748,0.0,0.32021505997336475],[0.4392682354635938,1.3816565987658325,0.33417016210801553,1.3755713678094155,1.1465023832339485,0.6653658483013765,0.5601834434263497,0.32021505997336475,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":20.0,"front":[[0.21969286877636934,0.1393284590127193],[0.24855414951940183,0.11913063020952867],[0.06254611702160634,0.3674756968040576],[0.1573129696599931,0.19761808094719693],[0.19045857209479936,0.16370213496373368],[0.3318750763393532,0.07600892729540289],[0.30795101066457353,0.08651786991682088],[0.11627334536726616,0.25305286024317214],[0.08926830310625347,0.3021478960638576]],"distances":[[0.0,0.1548985718880888,1.008862407567954,0.4888218798142786,0.22331500495578244,0.4051643052722473,0.3532461739937782,0.8068617589913496,0.9171111229926363],[0.1548985718880888,0.0,1.1812620862110783,0.6128557847055849,0.3782059401707917,0.25026573347935366,0.19834760218994055,0.9947487824935146,1.1100443650729535],[1.008862407567954,1.1812620862110783,0.0,0.6254277590038544,0.8540018437025089,1.5248471074434526,1.4540652771967775,0.2892776632060521,0.12524094980569567],[0.4888218798142786,0.6128557847055849,0.6254277590038544,0.0,0.28482451857137425,0.8308727900654784,0.7839321428056485,0.3361504535528416,0.5001869167332127],[0.22331500495578244,0.3782059401707917,0.8540018437025089,0.28482451857137425,0.0,0.628465958164834,0.5765486270754743,0.5811391441581835,0.7341612736588943],[0.4051643052722473,0.25026573347935366,1.5248471074434526,0.8308727900654784,0.628465958164834,0.0,0.05191813128941353,1.1737081667427218,1.3985494163124537],[0.3532461739937782,0.19834760218994055,1.4540652771967775,0.7839321428056485,0.5765486270754743,0.05191813128941353,0.0,1.1450576432261024,1.3566860754295256],[0.8068617589913496,0.9947487824935146,0.2892776632060521,0.3361504535528416,0.5811391441581835,1.1737081667427218,1.1450576432261024,0.0,0.16403671340035664],[0.9171111229926363,1.1100443650729535,0.12524094980569567,0.5001869167332127,0.7341612736588943,1.3985494163124537,1.3566860754295256,0.16403671340035664,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":0.5,"front":[[0.5434606047455546,0.6690673363214451,0.506951152042603],[0.8398199095134492,0.2835111567231314,0.4629513404217921],[0.7262907638634881,0.6213865624435938,0.2939055398272118],[0.4980069191667055,0.6830048499556962,0.5343159022517329],[0.5704547118075944,0.42159672768985335,0.704867094548839],[0.4518980579621462,0.402702346883726,0.7960018624503211],[0.5239831413638194,0.5772148140285267,0.6263104070926149],[0.4830130298048091,0.4251240300711776,0.7654854486499526],[0.48679572880030186,0.6248633190246798,0.6103898352358467]],"distances":[[0.0,0.10464915951478906,0.059618154558877104,0.010714469970141981,0.06268749005152505,0.08196616876100797,0.02947903105205668,0.07208808510907927,0.024486216411809546],[0.10464915951478906,0.0,0.08578754446026912,0.1132443770153034,0.08410291714824056,0.11317122564787038,0.09922266526439763,0.10503426637581373,0.10957243990629664],[0.059618154558877104,0.08578754446026912,0.0,0.06991526224118796,0.09947768458673531,0.12811869510693152,0.08075888967369874,0.11726313337944895,0.08180821737691718],[0.010714469970141981,0.1132443770153034,0.06991526224118796,0.0,0.063230956559209,0.0785446656919398,0.02777185968438435,0.06938260864088377,0.018802738851150733],[0.06268749005152505,0.08410291714824056,0.09947768458673531,0.063230956559209,0.0,0.03163819830951973,0.03575054566748004,0.021721506879084848,0.04720804822861996],[0.08196616876100797,0.11317122564787038,0.12811869510693152,0.0785446656919398,0.03163819830951973,0.0,0.05255365256856148,0.010891760570420989,0.05981507553345044],[0.02947903105205668,0.09922266526439763,0.08075888967369874,0.02777185968438435,0.03575054566748004,0.05255365256856148,0.0,0.04263095199996329,0.012143259991522857],[0.07208808510907927,0.10503426637581373,0.11726313337944895,0.06938260864088377,0.021721506879084848,0.010891760570420989,0.04263095199996329,0.0,0.05087716465680715],[0.024486216411809546,0.10957243990629664,0.08180821737691718,0.018802738851150733,0.04720804822861996,0.05981507553345044,0.012143259991522857,0.05087716465680715,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.0,"front":[[0.9988540143659959,0.1862852884288602,0.4354168034132932],[0.8338348212143122,0.9336542575646903,0.33821686223682484],[0.35790499787815944,0.3579855310187324,0.9992976702667492],[0.8150725174330518,0.9438037939599809,0.09998392708784855],[0.9284644103527983,0.8409105414708556,0.4239255875261305],[0.8846765479475854,0.7742726713682934,0.8205049016515173],[0.9848223849732859,0.5286636830144785,0.6354636607739994],[0.4720617457029532,0.9418554934258786,0.8139773323360535],[0.9608021483176922,0.772855954715814,0.24298810166354476]],"distances":[[0.0,0.4100211304883592,0.5230320458155753,0.48176792596366824,0.33914124474581886,0.33193790496195275,0.2071168445587372,0.5173894328648421,0.33825799276949964],[0.4100211304883592,0.0,0.5179231979481181,0.13175023074131217,0.07357271647113411,0.21847211722161813,0.24716259333171267,0.27611013682247443,0.11082480962778238],[0.5230320458155753,0.5179231979481181,0.0,0.6495268666957681,0.4776726011551798,0.3098697320012398,0.3821173080954144,0.30500103448626226,0.5670041436806676],[0.48176792596366824,0.13175023074131217,0.6495268666957681,0.0,0.1874758516762594,0.3488233339234732,0.35695445730565634,0.39451342564032377,0.1437847587785044],[0.33914124474581886,0.07357271647113411,0.4776726011551798,0.1874758516762594,0.0,0.16860483929542552,0.17489846519790808,0.27543063282204916,0.09458217586962275],[0.33193790496195275,0.21847211722161813,0.3098697320012398,0.3488233339234732,0.16860483929542552,0.0,0.12620918728219926,0.18545183772962745,0.25723340006223283],[0.2071168445587372,0.24716259333171267,0.3821173080954144,0.35695445730565634,0.17489846519790808,0.12620918728219926,0.0,0.3111266983700457,0.22725652448894607],[0.5173894328648421,0.27611013682247443,0.30500103448626226,0.39451342564032377,0.27543063282204916,0.18545183772962745,0.3111266983700457,0.0,0.3673693035574536],[0.33825799276949964,0.11082480962778238,0.5670041436806676,0.1437847587785044,0.09458217586962275,0.25723340006223283,0.22725652448894607,0.3673693035574536,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.7,"front":[[0.18633891500945507,0.5388012801080476,0.6500161942215341],[0.3848855763937388,0.2248923705359166,0.7538831765040434],[0.5535695755514141,0.3812785031078033,0.4991958802723743],[0.5846332101854851,0.3225143637301098,0.5152254612084541],[0.17529627476854281,0.9214456493634355,0.12100497914696104],[0.5504951671252364,0.5344713031473687,0.3429285142984966],[0.3591420388285221,0.48524074378228665,0.5844052313016217],[0.42032386989803594,0.6819180542338381,0.3000738599007583],[0.5367546473609368,0.34039348717095497,0.5502399855033199]],"distances":[[0.0,0.4142142196318139,0.46276016169770684,0.5124227817799474,0.6899275217461472,0.5165151735055415,0.20677735152964016,0.48034049994201755,0.4491570302093604],[0.4142142196318139,0.0,0.3691813784021767,0.35054832698154237,1.0315292976000503,0.584937952233028,0.33496466726163576,0.6982227224927489,0.29935708078589535],[0.46276016169770684,0.3691813784021767,0.0,0.07406408071358278,0.8102970051029728,0.23808277902758462,0.257198525685862,0.417340536375777,0.07332310126829207],[0.5124227817799474,0.35054832698154237,0.07406408071358278,0.0,0.8823247908590541,0.29922473269991773,0.3115301402741936,0.48859381245238037,0.06718227968226265],[0.6899275217461472,1.0315292976000503,0.8102970051029728,0.8823247908590541,0.0,0.6147890279255379,0.7021352093051632,0.40140394634876597,0.8628024206367455],[0.5165151735055415,0.584937952233028,0.23808277902758462,0.29922473269991773,0.6147890279255379,0.0,0.33957643800497406,0.21759870553080607,0.30928714674551727],[0.20677735152964016,0.33496466726163576,0.257198525685862,0.3115301402741936,0.7021352093051632,0.33957643800497406,0.0,0.380729219321404,0.2519361374432799],[0.48034049994201755,0.6982227224927489,0.417340536375777,0.48859381245238037,0.40140394634876597,0.21759870553080607,0.380729219321404,0.0,0.4769137300830524],[0.4491570302093604,0.29935708078589535,0.07332310126829207,0.06718227968226265,0.8628024206367455,0.30928714674551727,0.2519361374432799,0.4769137300830524,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":2.0,"front":[[0.5033437561318321,0.9972306591103192,0.24909755961889712],[0.9341404472491628,0.8243882895756368,0.5278643365254458],[0.9634739083424534,0.7647833333347975,0.07548231894255716],[0.9219013648865365,0.7081337670771516,0.7989026312204857],[0.5215916608425906,0.9963301507174283,0.34484126138857707],[0.9876598847930801,0.14431472894023814,0.6446717891846235],[0.14817439919942382,0.4927967463202317,0.9975968258549764],[0.9451617819032615,0.19689507521367308,0.8121833312469263],[0.07982314768626013,0.9999998170059002,0.09712200498188414]],"distances":[[0.0,0.4035722844417839,0.4549442757966299,0.5565021529849081,0.07942915035583342,0.9317589229437709,0.876885605267526,0.9122213294497457,0.4012057709131397],[0.4035722844417839,0.0,0.34278055497207016,0.2098635410703404,0.3576783453227371,0.53492081435568,0.7828444602589397,0.5272611636062046,0.7945885939897359],[0.4549442757966299,0.34278055497207016,0.0,0.5393808064502723,0.4718548163390984,0.7062133196045104,1.1114136312849061,0.7595575074684906,0.8125240207261528],[0.5565021529849081,0.2098635410703404,0.5393808064502723,0.0,0.49140067451169767,0.42303459630207396,0.6240190823131313,0.36874112792013075,0.9135799310206442],[0.07942915035583342,0.3576783453227371,0.4718548163390984,0.49140067451169767,0.0,0.8813098224415594,0.8025395713916599,0.8525337458160549,0.4414028028702494],[0.9317589229437709,0.53492081435568,0.7062133196045104,0.42303459630207396,0.8813098224415594,0.0,0.8626566390534378,0.13488049404959693,1.305491240091504],[0.876885605267526,0.7828444602589397,1.1114136312849061,0.6240190823131313,0.8025395713916599,0.8626566390534378,0.0,0.7342442574603655,0.9995031442527564],[0.9122213294497457,0.5272611636062046,0.7595575074684906,0.36874112792013075,0.8525337458160549,0.13488049404959693,0.7342442574603655,0.0,1.2686530758253833],[0.4012057709131397,0.7945885939897359,0.8125240207261528,0.9135799310206442,0.4414028028702494,1.305491240091504,0.9995031442527564,1.2686530758253833,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":3.7,"front":[[0.9431750378785978,0.3314649794795973,0.8157637845065241],[0.7260281815662152,0.8648793431901616,0.8704598000682555],[0.9918055986200438,0.6013711740155803,0.3090152190905718],[0.6525425325972657,0.8984911555904914,0.8571812525004333],[0.5305103842037451,0.7267463942651103,0.9694953430410911],[0.9763681624869052,0.7145955614780624,0.28330430633107495],[0.722212593750615,0.9706417612101189,0.5285916092662786],[0.9691578144967922,0.7347770282439389,0.49083673749592144],[0.9160222672899422,0.1142240382693257,0.8616348301765541]],"distances":[[0.0,0.5299918490472842,0.5483906909343549,0.5968512026718152,0.5652277366760957,0.6260485320672912,0.7164775825610885,0.48988603212276227,0.20877784709621683],[0.5299918490472842,0.0,0.6236288937864032,0.07165521910315983,0.22361706152632305,0.604606460353005,0.31989629224699956,0.428773750417846,0.7117863901447188],[0.5483906909343549,0.6236288937864032,0.0,0.6716997952844748,0.821658974988734,0.10648788873646627,0.4869626006394763,0.1993806718742346,0.710645551414446],[0.5968512026718152,0.07165521910315983,0.6716997952844748,0.0,0.2110847436097903,0.6422979159348012,0.31154222603878856,0.4765035148442526,0.7728390318084319],[0.5652277366760957,0.22361706152632305,0.821658974988734,0.2110847436097903,0.0,0.8150375658232538,0.5193589191544429,0.6353009843852637,0.693874066223839],[0.6260485320672912,0.604606460353005,0.10648788873646627,0.6422979159348012,0.8150375658232538,0.0,0.4145634994465699,0.19144282364075066,0.8006096799701243],[0.7164775825610885,0.31989629224699956,0.4869626006394763,0.31154222603878856,0.5193589191544429,0.4145634994465699,0.0,0.3265347286318834,0.91840699574874],[0.48988603212276227,0.428773750417846,0.1993806718742346,0.4765035148442526,0.6353009843852637,0.19144282364075066,0.3265347286318834,0.0,0.6862264482509519],[0.20877784709621683,0.7117863901447188,0.710645551414446,0.7728390318084319,0.693874066223839,0.8006096799701243,0.91840699574874,0.6862264482509519,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":20.0,"front":[[0.10344646134608271,0.04362738639653784,0.05383676403121383],[0.03499670422168189,0.09998505303488252,0.06757088280828603],[0.08420262500118209,0.06451942659451994,0.04696823377209376],[0.06615569273170017,0.06201536124462771,0.06431937111586211],[0.05730611099092593,0.025838466314258218,0.13560348146782547],[0.03240485445111107,0.02273664335677382,0.2008609482180487],[0.1107626823275754,0.06617646395504126,0.03055832302827039],[0.09257617482619494,0.09739387085416332,0.02271833240012395],[0.10853163473080876,0.009940825221074309,0.12161819605207128]],"distances":[[0.0,1.247758268521463,0.3463224980946672,0.6465276146568779,1.0179507083496255,1.1868430787716733,0.3011291605937019,0.6417342870332456,0.6113331833809539],[1.247758268521463,0.0,0.7751125652760549,0.6895205364417686,0.9698792385667309,1.038367882290233,1.0357922132086326,0.7368459430521794,1.202899097461215],[0.3463224980946672,0.7751125652760549,0.0,0.41327136788301555,1.1114682773339237,1.286558690429119,0.3283607654499212,0.40588370609880786,0.8339273177644201],[0.6465276146568779,0.6895205364417686,0.41327136788301555,0.0,0.9071643624739545,1.1375718258569927,0.7376567612310785,0.7195117178026101,0.834290944577345],[1.0179507083496255,0.9698792385667309,1.1114682773339237,0.9071643624739545,0.0,0.2724797134629453,1.3026262920215421,1.5643178974090388,0.47813922067439785],[1.1868430787716733,1.038367882290233,1.286558690429119,1.1375718258569927,0.2724797134629453,0.0,1.5878262722858318,1.8263022308046044,0.7274499028238529],[0.3011291605937019,1.0357922132086326,0.3283607654499212,0.7376567612310785,1.3026262920215421,1.5878262722858318,0.0,0.40187869245308705,0.9030521017969171],[0.6417342870332456,0.7368459430521794,0.40588370609880786,0.7195117178026101,1.5643178974090388,1.8263022308046044,0.40187869245308705,0.0,1.2081378413283657],[0.6113331833809539,1.202899097461215,0.8339273177644201,0.834290944577345,0.47813922067439785,0.7274499028238529,0.9030521017969171,1.2081378413283657,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":0.5,"front":[[0.5528753982230772,0.9119378480543845,0.7426613196849721,0.670698664389403,0.7184013230800628],[0.9168415668452161,0.5132950835211049,0.7834881639859035,0.25987354621400827,0.7337983071031854],[0.3644696512261351,0.8298257594025111,0.8137856997855818,0.8494199352375831,0.4145687000673063],[0.19334494389266793,0.871506075600423,0.9062511775791695,0.3159607614247033,0.43554407458272587],[0.7498885495920057,0.3333460883148761,0.4266736150755741,0.9662618285163891,0.30946952293722607],[0.7701612422789466,0.7410216465839926,0.8170493959199342,0.8305495003151082,0.09959230757337688],[0.8570631373781088,0.7535742880781483,0.593454041575746,0.8450691540752043,0.4825630265693849],[0.3848571196936112,0.9293893503250927,0.25527489851001983,0.596168866432345,0.8213988592084989],[0.7928974830490227,0.7902308130206679,0.4764220675276252,0.2711246144480684,0.8896796775290093]],"distances":[[0.0,0.04129626097971582,0.024811261328897743,0.041138156437274906,0.054573033180283,0.04548140936744756,0.026944309399344148,0.0333654524428635,0.03510383270801898],[0.04129626097971582,0.0,0.05946583689524204,0.06293329671100653,0.06483977157511775,0.059901215157539434,0.04352534501740818,0.06275954227204118,0.029753588514735897],[0.024811261328897743,0.05946583689524204,0.0,0.04074307257692769,0.051377966252786456,0.03503264659328051,0.03312898597633081,0.04955971251689502,0.05946849766600036],[0.041138156437274906,0.06293329671100653,0.04074307257692769,0.0,0.0881111638543043,0.06148605976499255,0.062332125725827706,0.06273037664639176,0.0627133395837305],[0.054573033180283,0.06483977157511775,0.051377966252786456,0.0881111638543043,0.0,0.04151550625277843,0.031814010371646044,0.0699950802401236,0.07072113190411158],[0.04548140936744756,0.059901215157539434,0.03503264659328051,0.06148605976499255,0.04151550625277843,0.0,0.03112881646599014,0.07145228528598727,0.06854088657724455],[0.026944309399344148,0.04352534501740818,0.03312898597633081,0.062332125725827706,0.031814010371646044,0.03112881646599014,0.0,0.046914187782078606,0.043968754825238904],[0.0333654524428635,0.06275954227204118,0.04955971251689502,0.06273037664639176,0.0699950802401236,0.07145228528598727,0.046914187782078606,0.0,0.03952698125405224],[0.03510383270801898,0.029753588514735897,0.05946849766600036,0.0627133395837305,0.07072113190411158,0.06854088657724455,0.043968754825238904,0.03952698125405224,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.0,"front":[[0.016757562255884553,0.017741696897648717,0.01412229952246846,0.029801078779319406,0.013473635678253207],[0.01844310430942582,0.021923363429279696,0.016860991109897378,0.012894589097158697,0.02016448504010165],[0.011865524594081146,0.016206972502918256,0.024506440148524315,0.03183483382749907,0.010133713352781131],[0.005310047666763238,0.05971164511997206,0.01227023750063013,0.010749282315498184,0.02216647115742925],[0.02897774286692907,0.03964771974837905,0.026583316362076302,0.006321776216634422,0.004602622985068578],[0.022470445873680998,0.04554918726820115,0.005104028947375649,0.01245693551815889,0.017025090387538747],[0.02488160084340299,0.024281301399778823,0.013522233460324438,0.0041361045260097495,0.03303709005730798],[0.02219777058970862,0.0210203638812615,0.014532628600480728,0.02451813700650083,0.009876592877363312],[0.0065507649648635195,0.015389803020773939,0.02076234641818623,0.0315362367989016,0.02135113028442915]],"distances":[[0.0,0.207046599695298,0.1286276561854894,0.4425028999641748,0.3618204464690111,0.3414845745588654,0.3482253458844008,0.09806345097967853,0.15472685182641838],[0.207046599695298,0.0,0.26007319671222173,0.3492708312207085,0.2553506431591516,0.251366394295217,0.16275517620986507,0.1763119897123734,0.24708677338559148],[0.1286276561854894,0.26007319671222173,0.0,0.4806887228476361,0.37892909111956696,0.42033257137454205,0.41591033934841504,0.17838124493707175,0.13660713212229686],[0.4425028999641748,0.3492708312207085,0.4806887228476361,0.0,0.35292232931291845,0.21062432828931704,0.3874810453618327,0.41824003641578467,0.4594900809992577],[0.3618204464690111,0.2553506431591516,0.37892909111956696,0.35292232931291845,0.0,0.2588570027667544,0.3373187221618904,0.27841007942873086,0.43999796010025705],[0.3414845745588654,0.251366394295217,0.42033257137454205,0.21062432828931704,0.2588570027667544,0.0,0.2866197937988016,0.288252704061963,0.4213112610291384],[0.3482253458844008,0.16275517620986507,0.41591033934841504,0.3874810453618327,0.3373187221618904,0.2866197937988016,0.0,0.3182542867647515,0.3752980091712528],[0.09806345097967853,0.1763119897123734,0.17838124493707175,0.41824003641578467,0.27841007942873086,0.288252704061963,0.3182542867647515,0.0,0.23521643079543386],[0.15472685182641838,0.24708677338559148,0.13660713212229686,0.4594900809992577,0.43999796010025705,0.4213112610291384,0.3752980091712528,0.23521643079543386,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":1.7,"front":[[0.7830174811595195,0.4334748904162527,0.4960084592508107,0.41665693633073936,0.6249704048946784],[0.6841016056699359,0.3057979449084016,0.6034609904727968,0.3967817047309219,0.717271620814672],[0.24867864632979725,0.3999337245969408,0.9325530534417391,0.47492398070742703,0.13631931943073844],[0.5655553548835843,0.6417716576724601,0.5023559957626126,0.2159806513893174,0.7476537842179881],[0.703155373055673,0.09661446622895067,0.8493202465309836,0.290868312968547,0.24202729347767873],[0.8004195406635202,0.5792772901947215,0.5614224507932147,0.08128185067678845,0.48673922328597585],[0.4483166981524407,0.759954195777836,0.0780707266644787,0.31778936541405545,0.7596834626112998],[0.7820346166207174,0.6445793066006811,0.15755956375034535,0.46889101693321117,0.5276579746633013],[0.10081807546416634,0.24453923849940992,0.33751716371784984,0.9755322479165962,0.2597463698518142]],"distances":[[0.0,0.14938365428139672,0.6245446271210491,0.26547771603346904,0.4646549210620698,0.2789941003821809,0.46482265903524017,0.289973027810551,0.7519706933913034],[0.14938365428139672,0.0,0.5956199711261412,0.28825042568532744,0.4264092063857795,0.34839395805353435,0.5326438065415642,0.4257016227851197,0.7499620920172034],[0.6245446271210491,0.5956199711261412,0.0,0.6578915423032499,0.46475289373801043,0.6542990433872169,0.8885796507010437,0.7907069311954416,0.6694007750860953],[0.26547771603346904,0.28825042568532744,0.6578915423032499,0.0,0.6171329350117642,0.2728000908872676,0.33535384334781104,0.37239594910318796,0.8518572189217715],[0.4646549210620698,0.4264092063857795,0.46475289373801043,0.6171329350117642,0.0,0.4893165575383164,0.9035995751288315,0.7104458710937698,0.8677744468179356],[0.2789941003821809,0.34839395805353435,0.6542990433872169,0.2728000908872676,0.4893165575383164,0.0,0.5291207128376054,0.4052492208567195,0.9681964285442932],[0.46482265903524017,0.5326438065415642,0.8885796507010437,0.33535384334781104,0.9035995751288315,0.5291207128376054,0.0,0.33050952335141137,0.8530381723266887],[0.289973027810551,0.4257016227851197,0.7907069311954416,0.37239594910318796,0.7104458710937698,0.4052492208567195,0.33050952335141137,0.0,0.7717259459614905],[0.7519706933913034,0.7499620920172034,0.6694007750860953,0.8518572189217715,0.8677744468179356,0.9681964285442932,0.8530381723266887,0.7717259459614905,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":2.0,"front":[[0.11767323024197937,0.054467077088064114,0.0817840055042244,0.19791992904437966,0.0670952556151291],[0.07933689141195212,0.19053728367151743,0.10663392632231865,0.03512250908418354,0.10932751156269932],[0.021543350698544426,0.15400801494710098,0.03596972859095189,0.1209894053243745,0.2108989811814886],[0.1677138409722252,0.07268551983133112,0.02597418327763946,0.16780789335895863,0.09292798820786033],[0.0891741414617478,0.07915953300665314,0.21532682710650847,0.057148903343705176,0.07971358292546694],[0.07744278495832166,0.09623782885831708,0.04145854439945771,0.13320250778885148,0.16836357818557562],[0.10262320673604734,0.11382643837669573,0.12201545202591821,0.047750264084211985,0.12258299588471774],[0.046629681292545085,0.14985494256109344,0.05156298766592178,0.11719093304558731,0.15384164641904433],[0.09221567352939193,0.06838329096524208,0.023702425636632524,0.16722382068007646,0.17886632074970132]],"distances":[[0.0,0.874299747614027,0.8047452994199424,0.33026036556357263,0.7698997137960648,0.550739015151047,0.7173430787640906,0.673780564092658,0.5026855048220891],[0.874299747614027,0.0,0.5980200536638821,0.8352096153435173,0.6185709550806344,0.6426580529665059,0.32615023464014004,0.47153229051885204,0.8084193320710029],[0.8047452994199424,0.5980200536638821,0.0,0.7643027144422428,0.9293026445368949,0.30766899482297705,0.6199524489042298,0.19572244351488421,0.44240743344411293],[0.33026036556357263,0.8352096153435173,0.7643027144422428,0.0,0.9020758195085943,0.4867031346394166,0.6962341966761167,0.6445625579370569,0.42789538634763846],[0.7698997137960648,0.6185709550806344,0.9293026445368949,0.9020758195085943,0.0,0.8324287524796506,0.4251862049255261,0.8121094171285723,0.929170951516149],[0.550739015151047,0.6426580529665059,0.30766899482297705,0.4867031346394166,0.8324287524796506,0.0,0.5340622571386966,0.262528388099019,0.17830917887361292],[0.7173430787640906,0.32615023464014004,0.6199524489042298,0.6962341966761167,0.4251862049255261,0.5340622571386966,0.0,0.5015194239710502,0.6708656706893537],[0.673780564092658,0.47153229051885204,0.19572244351488421,0.6445625579370569,0.8121094171285723,0.262528388099019,0.5015194239710502,0.0,0.4249470769024908],[0.5026855048220891,0.8084193320710029,0.44240743344411293,0.42789538634763846,0.929170951516149,0.17830917887361292,0.6708656706893537,0.4249470769024908,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":3.7,"front":[[0.7251643336115781,0.1425888058387886,0.25246684613263704,0.2670130618390588,0.15967118450218032],[0.6414198676560244,0.13269979599996798,0.411593716137492,0.14523772569374807,0.24131732169985676],[0.14631986640989178,0.2091543379371247,0.40792303505864635,0.49013140322483534,0.3912245544700245],[0.31576645777348783,0.3268482434865943,0.36401025745781784,0.3558980909711794,0.3462701477328834],[0.1799119090229179,0.46955258339301875,0.5442990932945464,0.2237542746538675,0.20750691781673544],[0.41181629351102433,0.10419018708964406,0.38544262018069114,0.3174440392401077,0.4320019398630889],[0.22006926984759592,0.44709738312866754,0.4080196572265259,0.3907414048943712,0.20516653842178298],[0.10905377186650622,0.33733346723339236,0.30486067270601136,0.10455802450222323,0.684184722594373],[0.4463576705642156,0.4926527601013186,0.33004008438684457,0.17564489874578912,0.2049464794104798]],"distances":[[0.0,0.3361821348307521,1.1739277929477119,0.8950153097398929,1.1754195992398748,0.7324596275942283,1.0807756400465325,1.3787923802300441,0.7472767034471403],[0.3361821348307521,0.0,1.087417046578215,0.802649492242643,0.9811601663040486,0.5867344595566681,1.0158008587928966,1.187532667030303,0.6889466163153952],[1.1739277929477119,1.087417046578215,0.0,0.4680237113359401,0.7541059667803878,0.5917173870261321,0.5752994345963901,0.8401425715479905,1.0138450499781004],[0.8950153097398929,0.802649492242643,0.4680237113359401,0.0,0.6011752866200505,0.4815474820621828,0.40275747106823306,0.8309334980530891,0.5803352719046149],[1.1754195992398748,0.9811601663040486,0.7541059667803878,0.6011752866200505,0.0,0.9168507196280193,0.3813832621644486,0.9302476882112354,0.5850047151264405],[0.7324596275942283,0.5867344595566681,0.5917173870261321,0.4815474820621828,0.9168507196280193,0.0,0.8400275258585012,0.8404483223751595,0.8527123112422489],[1.0807756400465325,1.0158008587928966,0.5752994345963901,0.40275747106823306,0.3813832621644486,0.8400275258585012,0.0,1.0137760233793451,0.5710184811211143],[1.3787923802300441,1.187532667030303,0.8401425715479905,0.8309334980530891,0.9302476882112354,0.8404483223751595,1.0137760233793451,0.0,1.0349371043853373],[0.7472767034471403,0.6889466163153952,1.0138450499781004,0.5803352719046149,0.5850047151264405,0.8527123112422489,0.5710184811211143,1.0349371043853373,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":20.0,"front":[[0.3558714388848191,0.1608601310755144,0.6161164747442301,0.43197745616802985,0.5303541308670622],[0.6167688857015189,0.24499226248649003,0.6161336468096905,0.1525486783183631,0.39583224093619446],[0.19297020665670864,0.37680781837472405,0.44973389450271367,0.5039594142046142,0.6037737161590526],[0.13310622094343932,0.1373182821242533,0.1744210516958737,0.4132523185687895,0.8730556919598115],[0.10822776345580723,0.594790140415707,0.4214462911251504,0.6078278149232947,0.2957022339855506],[0.395671197862609,0.474158108514227,0.7569936913296058,0.09037458804921239,0.19342020689238054],[0.9394231917770233,0.10580131449930541,0.06798295906361099,0.26140357380938845,0.18258323438455137],[0.6203839741527245,0.4586959497013971,0.1799336373326078,0.45905526416090187,0.4020123144188835],[0.4302306827413725,0.350054816256346,0.43041375258565523,0.4498153562774005,0.5520627972303496]],"distances":[[0.0,0.6637614405458868,0.5836973223446769,0.9629331442633292,1.0920524140561298,0.914876754488493,1.4206825554174811,1.2255884522070843,0.5423044098672629],[0.6637614405458868,0.0,1.1134312183771442,1.3380481208312038,1.4138969110129265,0.6374054873551105,1.027857736204614,0.9153377894844428,0.8415182584929646],[0.5836973223446769,1.1134312183771442,0.0,0.8188134630956462,0.7305165906187434,1.1493282702094492,1.8337854126167141,1.0864964161702646,0.4608558845387813],[0.9629331442633292,1.3380481208312038,0.8188134630956462,0.0,1.4013516232605054,1.7549856861409334,1.6868846574171505,1.2283153827621858,1.033714510381386],[1.0920524140561298,1.4138969110129265,0.7305165906187434,1.4013516232605054,0.0,1.1553230441248936,1.954723065694959,1.062799948822979,0.953078364710614],[0.914876754488493,0.6374054873551105,1.1493282702094492,1.7549856861409334,1.1553230441248936,0.0,1.3380752252679762,1.3909846460325301,1.121167589705431],[1.4206825554174811,1.027857736204614,1.8337854126167141,1.6868846574171505,1.954723065694959,1.3380752252679762,0.0,0.9265949065222119,1.3500852922719537],[1.2255884522070843,0.9153377894844428,1.0864964161702646,1.2283153827621858,1.062799948822979,1.3909846460325301,0.9265949065222119,0.0,0.7457750043829288],[0.5423044098672629,0.8415182584929646,0.4608558845387813,1.033714510381386,0.953078364710614,1.121167589705431,1.3500852922719537,0.7457750043829288,0.0]]},{"kind":"distances","p":2.4,"front":[[0.605469797860956,0.3422952147533506,0.7184986498492331],[0.3574124921623472,0.4521337645719097,0.8172095015235278],[0.0,0.8134476996300577,0.4392497641555782],[0.5012277105210913,0.5063101309160694,0.7017270363450006],[0.30882129253632357,0.30197243552994896,0.901910226938527],[0.8146276894682591,0.1832019129415839,0.5502897297298487],[0.6236724158436682,0.42727977290208463,0.6545721605632686]],"distances":[[0.0,0.3121142326048334,0.9302915921740247,0.21234923013307316,0.3774695611099718,0.33663386920298577,0.11748505885951127],[0.3121142326048334,0.0,0.7059095721641888,0.20896736324758702,0.19131136310116853,0.6454487761694347,0.34043254848865817],[0.9302915921740247,0.7059095721641888,0.0,0.723950146420781,0.8434299428491951,1.2035116012349776,0.8695641644874377],[0.21234923013307316,0.20896736324758702,0.723950146420781,0.0,0.37288277422344773,0.517578979258563,0.16716258104059145],[0.3774695611099718,0.19131136310116853,0.8434299428491951,0.37288277422344773,0.0,0.6764545654443581,0.45428281250548463],[0.33663386920298577,0.6454487761694347,1.2035116012349776,0.517578979258563,0.6764545654443581,0.0,0.35452141554616723],[0.11748505885951127,0.34043254848865817,0.8695641644874377,0.16716258104059145,0.45428281250548463,0.35452141554616723,0.0]]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[-5.925685310292194,6.9542775650164845],[-6.599797998588363,8.249066785720014],[-6.966968453570715,9.166729070642747],[-6.3945481703593785,7.809619584651455],[-6.752537308066609,8.608043373775853]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.2433326724525826,null,2.1384432768087644,0.8168598591972402],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.8244566510603153,null,1.4183040831401121,0.5427599016476334]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[-4.610930729208345,14.388089668469089],[-4.986585144330713,16.652489753476015],[-3.6382125289734564,10.898034267424661],[-3.8456536003853707,11.454015543680775],[-4.997250486196446,16.729235564199328],[-4.537815113831263,14.02765785034523],[-4.767739989596296,15.240619691263113],[-3.808622449508328,11.348999243925842],[-4.904984126580338,16.091414221324357],[-4.769563882519844,15.25123966136978],[-4.791470108672476,15.380161804408424],[-4.120914001127417,12.324878871383275],[-4.770453393721777,15.256425307674421],[-5.052501638643841,17.14048107435861],[-5.180606320032303,18.19267385732146],[-4.78485882889682,15.340984843687977],[-4.949830573587473,16.394196735180934],[-3.0811052060296835,9.728906404228683],[-4.693406122806594,14.822062996931507],[-4.403821421262661,13.419946691676568],[-4.636424634974903,14.51900586574536],[-4.093062392605615,12.228890075918295],[-3.2997472675605883,10.138838072709719],[-3.9530988604900656,11.77420807303182],[-4.93577477558697,16.297873249639153],[-4.997529630190648,16.731255355016614],[-4.292060253985127,12.95945397508561],[-4.589926007587367,14.282305509632504],[-5.511078970793103,21.816718123993592],[-5.420293300813662,20.65130470093982]],"agemoea_scores":[1.3707569687258874,0.15331511217729502,0.421270348527869,1.224943968451059,0.08777881340999347,2.623316885247033,0.345393338619717,0.15208718769598767,0.7188280936735763,0.02809879368376641,0.14215051149996413,0.6506413021688429,0.004245272035560678,0.3332957814946521,1.258311278845286,0.02594005918238903,0.0656095715804153,null,0.17848082612364397,0.2502491861055781,0.09237695591750701,0.14928711553550303,0.5721270471227444,0.2397997151710484,0.3744356442063914,0.01470909369747155,0.4112961991283309,0.07424419858864031,null,0.5439481533037425],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.02736894801448677,0.17515836310760266,0.22705613860485035,0.7211139833362843,0.04604331902677881,0.08749498748371487,0.01609281261982212,0.07964082630970801,0.07576401827291818,0.1893723406127955,0.10813133405117059,0.374177903980088,0.0022594624601429995,0.1261264640865467,0.6944842526769057,0.013799636502683416,0.0345479369168085,null,0.08130461986297366,0.16349845971574276,0.7361196401704432,0.07854103859347702,0.3466585123840128,0.12595227569182899,0.3638259906818824,0.007729466054523389,0.2487269414297729,1.4687635637040206,null,0.33285678155694376]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[4.570481236559619,11.02298383510204],[15.756844690576752,7.436573182844359],[7.66996612279558,9.829369387553944],[4.300290351056734,11.136646891998897],[10.140920342846421,9.000250591722274]],"agemoea_scores":[0.6900590351209642,null,1.1630203737414102,null,2.1453786873800738],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.45834862707230745,null,0.769133331341824,null,1.4186993014596552]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[4.722533213098743,26.489953609296567],[8.231716923848722,10.715700113960365],[8.905741477438259,8.46894719048338],[8.455066852669862,9.950154053323207],[6.963475834422191,15.502596558980603],[11.651412750041436,1.0807300746740953],[4.654967420750572,26.897603856530726],[8.759666684996972,8.939962284156069],[4.600101394058018,27.23344800231933],[11.435710311747052,1.5658903471701544],[7.926793793828478,11.79618260956449],[7.494730427815833,13.400909781500399],[8.054486939931452,11.338635942741575],[7.276461069916833,14.246458622923779],[11.546012721220729,1.3158198206345153],[6.066796162862139,19.42229576309],[8.926802892806109,8.401739191101356],[8.46610839785448,9.912860703300444],[10.440820881798853,4.009259248204694],[6.479390875381986,17.555276726423447],[6.455512991862646,17.660232861913194],[11.138152607349403,2.261140671869202],[10.82501572533839,3.025424604315483],[9.746189734764695,5.919829271730187],[8.358559490701005,10.278313240220406],[9.560753875131969,6.4593456691610935],[7.591107588096289,13.035170648591432],[5.9661492374115666,19.895867181933067],[5.300841958656256,23.232775370052277],[8.378475705423446,10.21026621955421]],"agemoea_scores":[0.07937361936263458,0.2578401154670824,0.23578334416906854,0.02697822476088016,0.5215224569924577,null,1.088858642287623,0.4933543981484234,null,0.08314670579079746,2.2672294839390643,0.10318670844068772,0.09594398899906678,0.2079592984546636,0.5643828522381779,1.06522325280659,0.05638057451193508,0.10560623352674324,0.43687746622328216,0.3129840318221514,0.14670046960870642,0.18707743343968752,0.28996518590693177,0.5373892739823294,0.16187625551811463,1.0562235455527293,1.2039828757452347,0.5460369646660724,0.5069327008596249,0.03313659511508092],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.06197295489176141,0.16034742241127242,0.145649279293205,0.016773183046156822,0.3231411759262906,null,0.36565783520836864,0.3058230535745746,null,0.06412453217621768,1.4277733014617953,0.0642593086533914,0.05975120630582596,0.12939664407200518,0.3621204670806086,0.6866343649654023,0.03493313745166625,0.06567957666666953,0.18170524085254444,0.19339910684170003,0.09039561712179817,0.12318230726861196,0.2694600593729781,0.3386116388276119,0.10058492305306396,0.6666355650859725,0.7578236597630027,0.3446157538720707,0.32071798468662693,0.020603315532947142]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[21.445733644656954,17.884439084915755],[22.94679048480986,16.865634837356186],[27.496191881077173,13.777844060626897],[20.75327723092321,18.354426307711353],[47.433803403016036,0.24569606903270902]],"agemoea_scores":[0.16442803561955327,2.0000000000000004,0.8464837592470538,null,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.11626817900376915,0.35741129266582106,1.4142135623730954,null,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[7.821361144351094,12.849569391099912],[-0.2748770328320411,19.33333599905631],[11.224041470014267,10.124577291032894],[-0.32037871733420786,19.369775428841415],[7.253818930698909,13.30407816084611],[4.268384828562066,15.694924072005291],[15.209139577373392,6.933163516825584],[11.726846742119893,9.721912255464838],[4.4012819381968775,15.588495157380164],[4.135983064389858,15.800956295685861],[8.13690568937356,12.596869663205885],[10.298619155982816,10.865689665281556],[10.417052819086372,10.770843612919498],[16.347939146608333,6.021170754437561],[8.645195954424196,12.189812042671397],[6.3948824717826085,13.991946206325903],[17.01784817346195,5.484682859241618],[5.221364863694992,14.9317424567142],[5.450433877354733,14.7482955287483],[3.8324508828425827,16.04403607917132],[10.298493162258236,10.86579056571042],[3.3932921675764742,16.39573060091353],[5.955591872169842,14.343746345924728],[7.41278407117872,13.176773004165224],[16.36703857633193,6.005875225580484],[2.702137859798908,16.949232501875706],[12.916174575805343,8.769454592386824],[-3.7430147737445534,22.11074881525701],[1.845380802149391,17.635355202313796],[16.43192955371238,5.953908133816466]],"agemoea_scores":[0.1340384575789038,0.20863867990371965,0.1375884605345129,0.5383586982973556,0.25910330308463947,0.025557595990268356,0.2920397461450847,0.2521624873184509,0.08035599784868754,0.13380118007467487,0.0793642164266542,0.7501358319342827,0.022830777365502767,0.07262698432861658,1.4051967674615085,0.12506484550573566,null,0.6550609355272258,0.07073183907065317,0.325225793371933,0.13761273577295607,0.10888882855380216,0.32983514215529264,0.05467424115224956,0.008091225043740146,0.19142461329725813,0.5908531271870701,null,1.9435554657588647,2.000000000000001],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.9936241631734493,0.3806770862768227,0.08922212600594759,0.15062936413473677,0.12709472702013788,0.018071949435544868,0.20650328487518732,0.17023819729271944,0.056820270987818625,0.2799843269627234,0.05611897561884398,0.008076190043883234,0.5865451091905879,0.0513550331158939,0.176816463722357,0.08843420034515359,null,0.12395031269749061,0.05001496305265448,0.09767240118258173,0.10537450609371406,0.07699602906585283,0.40707905398286126,0.03866052667498426,0.0057213600965352295,0.15603401426523278,0.40972864546823096,null,1.4142135623730956,1.0335364760962726]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[12.875367187295776,27.945082035916982],[7.508086222367527,36.22378840253852],[15.437360371050753,22.494132057838403],[18.25135604063552,14.81089943266803],[19.1957840855594,11.574656323211226]],"agemoea_scores":[1.5884167314514164,null,0.882196970292162,1.7952062020115631,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.2800678627047932,null,0.7102999270066668,1.4416422552543664,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[10.310192834744795,37.64216443384817],[45.267364642007166,10.176566632744922],[17.325803266064963,34.655048933916525],[41.502591253672215,15.669144478989228],[33.69799890442065,23.732582746785866],[7.808563381039792,38.45974779464399],[20.830228080100188,32.80254892467891],[34.312925029013336,23.190267597835394],[35.67689699820212,21.94100191634412],[15.32328677380283,35.60674411996983],[32.25659859247706,24.95694223932466],[28.322262554296525,28.0022206623035],[34.91869726591048,22.64357902454988],[34.52266465893465,23.00241211039193],[28.339783735733025,27.98953523706097],[47.24536804099845,5.8529890853290905],[41.47308672914428,15.706025381455174],[35.53467344753838,22.07439680903328],[29.650145266953388,27.01950752082032],[34.470368377716774,23.04939167251404],[33.77502975666931,23.665325635181148],[30.486102781323325,26.377966344734503],[36.30827329016643,21.33950378114266],[27.652958770194832,28.481320576105944],[18.125196045476724,34.253482639964616],[22.92915867044849,31.577047026502953],[18.993576173211878,33.80324278046975],[27.5995493371889,28.519096332041265],[30.31980592426432,26.507041108671423],[39.02655962847909,18.554761543053605]],"agemoea_scores":[0.30627604982424517,1.372954702596204,1.6836014799291659,0.3483177041940346,0.11475899944183929,null,0.4861302414412328,0.050009965045431065,0.03495377232141031,0.2302826619750788,0.385550568040421,0.02703199994614635,0.30522293321928956,0.011476546904818617,0.05615384322761466,null,0.12620609790027368,0.062371399163377014,0.10648299050192671,0.026629712058192936,0.053345287728462795,0.0407148879394621,0.19048929011638172,0.10871231157378428,0.12303225396239423,0.2537007050896083,0.08812091504425237,0.29778059539329493,1.2154050248974277,0.732980282582614],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.21039173031770406,1.2517739406076966,0.16792187852307427,0.3037890442909381,0.09764263112181709,null,0.4571108488548732,0.04255049244307478,0.029772840345985943,1.4663038374488093,0.351785635539844,0.023140066401712626,0.26020571025086914,0.009764740472448121,0.048070426846180445,null,0.10873622524936058,0.053111346100950904,1.1091937589967746,0.022659446073606062,0.04538786929700827,0.034727572294974446,0.1625793757903567,0.06970534147340415,0.10791396739722012,0.2891472682787214,0.07743722254554511,0.22209001169471831,0.09149248924434006,0.6548815718672056]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[9.782287191911857,37.00800259455477],[9.319627163440213,38.155588454734605],[12.875132003638022,22.051265872733964],[8.586386399561812,39.57581696998171],[10.883419179054844,33.37448371185885]],"agemoea_scores":[0.5145806321026234,1.7074652831147206,null,null,1.2970745543333322],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.44485903316855113,1.453291653673534,null,null,1.104359096944423]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[7.888809559625236,47.878185447717605],[14.061694512509131,46.39014683387027],[17.00725022483452,45.301434541148645],[34.58460296656483,31.157554044845906],[27.876190957321548,38.6050260598227],[17.26592677853884,45.19315785383963],[39.42230752302368,21.7066222799591],[16.36182283153795,45.56246364779782],[12.918798827405249,46.74411808533987],[7.834603381948731,47.886784071741964],[40.287998316733116,18.927016285022006],[10.047999655258455,47.4738105934825],[27.786990871055878,38.68174903601029],[40.51717723727998,18.04250966023518],[25.655287273932522,40.38733385122969],[9.976662517837397,47.48911853093263],[33.07724233052369,33.18648438815248],[37.513902999279075,26.213045178370393],[37.01595223146254,27.17873378003723],[25.80807460171875,40.272830502900476],[37.90116212084666,25.41377720018287],[40.662129267960474,17.434549224389848],[24.04932142430247,41.52475530622077],[11.436498047049394,47.14883747245607],[39.94390714148722,20.120036915542215],[39.74087087907836,20.764834740712903],[10.481168319175442,47.37796180438712],[25.350169086575733,40.612630584560094],[28.693037645125266,37.88069044480654],[25.01001025846061,40.85860633011041]],"agemoea_scores":[0.07043997017539604,0.12634711565253076,1.0758849174761251,1.5795522914211282,0.16087588437121703,0.15894149677529074,0.29047347073682106,0.05476605638062393,0.3063015641181557,null,0.11736709213609788,0.11610682561830729,0.04524366041677419,0.05193515833676615,0.019279239246860265,0.0498764464849298,0.3087630457947236,0.06851749668292964,0.23068113687307842,0.10626768730473088,0.5211347562871815,null,0.7712357595838372,0.16543235835330175,0.06546263021035711,0.15195751302211286,0.03042266427579872,0.0334543375749341,0.5074353655800509,0.2002667808585917],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.08190125051967943,1.2057387854402033,0.030541083791959904,0.47699870859636984,0.14885087772326455,0.13735413254366713,0.30959674776361035,0.34908094953877944,0.08504656876469632,null,0.11289121534527989,0.015897028619180974,0.04181197288284729,0.04976097728682037,0.0178627184742977,0.06211914445134836,0.28731826160211904,1.5132188467775496,0.18993149887146232,0.09856818903857198,0.09531083973870408,null,0.5323696399961669,0.1978273285768978,0.0631683214608639,0.14632388562529214,0.1127619000414868,0.031006681277256004,1.0048770709868422,0.1854505147862302]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[23.030098417523263,16.163507480658673],[20.992249295000413,30.820241258024314],[9.573633044513569,39.41596691180249],[22.265035424488985,25.417122504165803],[11.489214120500007,39.33617567381774]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.520600032254966,null,0.646200923620051,0.9114444104082065],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.9129540653041135,null,1.6273560328871866,1.2066688749408632]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[24.90780202206676,6.418965013621226],[24.38544644078968,8.74194620971776],[20.35007605751976,13.598514025170054],[24.692981980934547,7.633782255835507],[10.578869456452907,15.483668825619876],[13.917750234572601,15.330098591035199],[23.836517377099312,10.049608809718116],[24.3968291476235,8.707821246938384],[10.021607741847886,15.489527909824348],[25.026511461703713,5.229395518791364],[24.74596932169983,7.386285861437969],[17.17584720390759,14.80965416721741],[25.097327108755678,3.058480998998034],[24.801814952684474,7.095704074322561],[25.09036921645457,3.654131674718731],[22.224054663368356,12.22229591850977],[15.9050858989831,15.07424714049253],[21.779423218868313,12.621008855443723],[24.942354020012214,6.14292649263622],[23.362489032431455,10.858157299440823],[24.64197584929856,7.851513100377205],[23.76367780673099,10.188079448752134],[24.53371369056807,8.262273770294335],[24.614252512551914,7.96275383622427],[12.92177105715736,15.404110186815242],[20.821747523810032,13.317959172652193],[20.02302234511671,13.773439335534338],[20.746819887493977,13.364944584034898],[15.488704868738353,15.142029861938342],[16.6911532472422,14.921685131882935]],"agemoea_scores":[0.15052922187887846,0.7924267091309749,0.05954398928074113,0.13338351568828952,0.19246469471766595,0.17107718652641773,0.17565655887168546,0.038982732319551835,null,0.32534787239522045,0.04348787055623936,0.8068256523075981,null,0.45880046036634853,0.17470488654038568,0.16276171794153302,0.11320096362072213,1.568930791602127,0.09590822818079836,0.3375928373573529,0.0266274734992061,0.06828042254984748,0.06327058914600434,0.0898998667933444,0.3638244442989371,0.13699144793886298,0.3331234115572069,0.035556053646599875,0.4773384746956765,0.08534958179970104],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.07341959750110028,0.03855540013154541,0.12905739033436497,0.0352195465570236,1.501322426785064,0.39318514766881285,0.35204071966421546,0.13588095638545405,null,0.19676675643991243,0.08860447667886767,0.21502865044571806,null,0.16178371194707258,1.5462820018659165,0.15250934249640524,0.07531430228152149,1.3837176510709501,0.3585736640814101,0.21663577118443594,0.06617231385576927,0.06333757946040093,0.7088587255164398,0.031002133030796943,0.21787623828226554,0.08893064460654465,0.33915725543226294,0.033311340000873935,0.17452690912158167,0.7317428215106064]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[1.1708771376643772,9.406774505774138],[4.020051103443857,7.955382927156772],[4.182495604789315,7.222560201404188],[1.5969620315973643,9.392958201503042],[4.302115384489427,4.007839012621397]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.6211602683463693,0.7253574946006475,0.9172313287372422,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.7633715586223733,1.3981437947891253,1.6009419576261301,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[41.64270135414977,21.6795143839759],[46.47927759617283,20.05228020580774],[52.5693111319394,6.752348610124468],[52.64561000166172,1.4922002729103543],[52.65020769240598,-3.576518769502168],[25.406918640782976,22.876032818792382],[42.964951003359005,21.363309575992673],[12.255549089690252,22.919223279650218],[52.603965677932486,5.521417700620731],[33.08086239586213,22.663430270223103],[52.6499746583705,-1.8054889355529866],[39.62275835100974,22.04670143476224],[47.30123575918682,19.590096385756482],[45.50273061359765,20.507554126015357],[39.32199321395151,22.09175302162334],[52.22255955154981,11.137148753417398],[14.92581234014093,22.918431658910933],[11.63775507792145,22.91929947234337],[52.55933843497288,7.022578295451538],[52.46399668139883,8.806457593523707],[14.371420288077937,22.918682060213364],[52.54974198274327,7.260069774996017],[34.12656749690252,22.603933519567228],[52.531428673135174,7.66481207769581],[16.922399109544124,22.916898493859513],[52.603546383590476,5.540402789536762],[51.097186697531185,15.30453473939521],[23.140383135096215,22.896487464649653],[52.650143921489885,-2.6859474615417946],[44.287708478629455,20.96623114890378]],"agemoea_scores":[0.08170431791538191,0.04636661664850013,0.04464955477639826,0.34411184247905097,null,0.8703722631809199,0.3237465144697037,0.08017239905309151,0.08163164424958093,0.17803954931928018,0.1913036486692703,0.08907285559517485,1.7439212960749408,0.10860691049230023,0.21604165829422806,0.28837825605463485,0.12885876866839088,null,0.08020213569818287,0.13108972624215798,0.06511009981452975,0.02424614719201039,0.5353397635651649,0.7128177783211624,0.3357596251611533,0.42437003183194544,0.8757374695608137,0.2069888335586085,0.06684196575114756,0.06245613280233625],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.08658541419878729,0.04470886228140426,0.059607545239411426,1.50106119708784,null,0.2228808436548424,0.05531421696604098,0.12872494548624866,0.2587332479853066,0.593453384758784,0.10003161503580274,0.10299112266734403,0.11646167208364427,0.2209981706119919,0.20626828132251068,0.20539259043157296,0.06206430249215683,null,0.017422139440156317,0.6908876347970243,0.11364369170510202,0.1116268339192307,0.23361689132273925,0.04483771886325319,1.6245020109905748,0.11333781085595072,0.4229962017878198,0.37219536162395683,0.19070227357255395,1.2076049724558469]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[-7.778636199321522,7.915534812408207,9.40007871151731],[-7.761761332320143,7.445251037523742,9.659178603980147],[-7.721359605157091,7.412233894148382,9.575727457818475],[-7.879054477244015,7.588395635330586,10.041108350824192],[-7.820020915250662,7.310475449513985,10.02890538805113],[-7.824843973811874,7.262609531344968,10.118512238070164]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.1082537812133157,null,2.0420650084396677,0.6927463813234825,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.6572465622961071,null,1.2053018877783417,0.43707507435366694,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[1.6646101799489408,-2.480030988573252,-2.1736673785698386],[1.2555516386057448,0.18609783552339598,-4.104577800733088],[2.1049600471128973,-1.6829327160527836,-3.4206900960294497],[0.09886331508105406,-1.1964120079999383,-2.775478911848531],[4.6234136949487015,-2.0805410351242015,-3.8144915664855565],[3.3544394915513713,-0.6399320485431743,-4.276524959056477],[0.5888343640920914,-2.130644698263441,-2.040530828761272],[1.5711789327304726,-2.7473243185589094,-1.4450495949275823],[-0.29311713245843585,-1.3795914498021333,-2.2312325838942555],[4.331669653426201,-2.5003187873254458,-3.291827712051334],[0.6020322516542036,-0.7185928487975435,-3.452961866914311],[1.6253635492517318,-1.6507530617081392,-3.25259692894031],[2.943316909383614,-2.1866392109762303,-3.2358842704729045],[-0.18252859262492094,-1.7774374658697312,-1.8478146681199479],[2.471868843905261,-1.7743463458016875,-3.476319880680686],[-0.7781979588265263,-0.7892604041683149,-2.2460137772275863],[7.552334733534918,-2.922328025502529,-3.3610113264097192],[0.9694541846715574,-1.896974145593627,-2.6455768370161588],[0.9540196439272797,-1.5750671173758823,-2.9868072701901824],[2.6080554481146976,-1.6506651001785004,-3.619258720298],[-0.25378774571112905,0.6209645369849994,-3.654621931558413],[0.8537864849532819,-0.689214736979916,-3.5897179367668426],[4.744197508310161,-1.7078780706290113,-4.0808483834594815],[-0.8490696356841098,-0.28352977705517324,-2.579143627165186],[0.6777342826911052,-0.5145651739444652,-3.6065227440207357],[0.2740595014402136,-1.1189952356629163,-2.971478354916119],[2.011539171781606,-1.2093340920710565,-3.7233070700418724],[-0.5640619379736869,-0.1480525614725483,-3.0055602983101073],[1.431714873845622,-1.3867407470384028,-3.3857117358887883],[2.0244177028173045,-2.1244180216149013,-2.933406025006719]],"agemoea_scores":[0.6391785150254247,0.902069888602653,0.20779167455961162,0.7605225835151279,0.5397554536700507,2.397339291385183,0.4547752871783378,1.0750628370273474,0.3882282838754365,0.9311514146230384,0.7680574172085094,0.327638203758546,0.47320948488245396,null,0.3578026242165252,0.531639409893018,null,0.5790440762839635,0.4281568432581877,0.7039302080911551,null,0.1484990372255134,1.3485416465234743,1.15251174435704,0.4887864644774789,0.2821526892013676,0.4625018397108104,0.5480370774945444,1.1214888966339485,1.6466292534637776],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.28110698431932407,0.3508348845574242,0.1042806981775177,0.33819061367285297,0.2854438093795615,0.9868434055287088,0.16935309330586715,0.5729089757790701,0.20008049811259537,0.4323495925312125,0.09583557952689377,0.1569592835541747,0.23010052697129604,null,0.7669762461444161,0.16949634015917867,null,0.25864901365784754,0.20150127709793697,0.16564634879841084,null,0.44235975557589924,0.5294910928959001,0.5047221493649502,0.18639607747970882,0.14058914495692104,0.29192304425063187,0.2288532668443564,0.23732236522804018,0.4390769222923278]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[7.085166524504654,-8.23370268138089,10.607189762990162],[6.20277814415018,-5.61762967678198,5.526762224951203],[6.556599020900683,-7.542520729644879,11.037097364588053],[5.966484435863108,-6.825646642596116,13.442209502759226],[5.799248066358542,-6.437918598304185,13.5435065437327],[6.940053476483384,-7.59869095434277,7.953763079772598]],"agemoea_scores":[0.9056800112170788,null,null,0.8941971848665408,1.8054140753107477,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.5542206853711803,null,null,0.5700927178760529,1.1461220718530118,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[17.656574206566354,14.952390597759152,13.245454455745527],[11.785430083749183,15.501263979860855,19.035921368400423],[10.90101949222013,10.525673469574146,27.98450298303506],[16.821786284664615,12.890425406754224,16.355907283681752],[13.805351433512698,13.711090754056494,18.71014925356569],[7.932451762404329,26.50293983129734,13.599128939973927],[21.591476599685585,12.060262565058098,13.008020433392936],[17.629192241314968,11.899340345902953,16.80918231614709],[11.029958925112275,14.676658779492692,21.173159834378087],[20.260921629783997,13.571266183530412,12.467799165800695],[10.030110081317819,15.793137985365888,21.22897475008351],[12.172023512800134,9.922576833476558,27.07378672441883],[13.807390134684477,14.7353035332329,17.417617240992932],[21.089519083646465,10.0852367921117,15.976356557045445],[14.176464212870927,19.96333466515962,11.89026279834544],[14.920576441857989,16.176432033762406,14.584546127322387],[17.582694286531428,15.346791449003119,12.9248765567126],[11.839916430367172,13.66423282196326,21.385867708857237],[9.552936118772156,16.20346369530636,21.46759094339543],[15.846531290607416,12.559553495920023,17.840361515465816],[17.215451461314693,16.271200043630916,12.379538007681084],[13.462510204802937,12.869303370802228,20.29526628463946],[12.112163700531731,14.640943809528894,19.683994742079626],[7.475534960624114,12.9867897013464,30.335914870120437],[8.369177837673966,19.48019914289302,19.529364079762416],[27.15386782911403,8.982180986638168,12.638389822620114],[13.279136738104071,18.079887470761445,14.400319229476256],[17.655364065824887,10.719996389714048,18.47708644346953],[14.008864123017084,20.29756428838244,11.778471818731052],[10.503779324368509,14.9748356451645,21.56939004636569]],"agemoea_scores":[0.4225718901450905,0.6007743425098689,null,0.2809824188671767,0.272791247576608,null,0.49271301182904104,1.8801125854105984,0.2899110180827301,1.1363311921154864,0.14991338734261433,0.6901551539167416,0.5215725618510197,0.7642654732888154,0.3361326252894893,0.9734864304430499,0.1506128506871244,0.4103882965434963,1.6273064699523352,0.4336518885500957,0.5796537548785432,0.9272499045426235,0.2358735724720556,1.0795433118064095,1.0378951293917345,null,0.5220788340764421,0.5042024058130713,2.2509252543127753,0.1880784454956213],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.24033969224785912,0.3791519568509255,null,0.15338529953645347,0.16189203242897102,null,0.27786887066597,1.031455545380022,0.15872351498612697,0.6567696659993482,0.0754734206947823,0.31384194438946766,0.29151038177267286,0.38892902634019066,0.18912976566598116,0.5429448277576309,0.08613697695501668,0.6169917169948945,0.29836772044577264,0.23191886893478963,0.3726366815375739,0.255168651762013,0.13429457229083946,0.6398337438036322,0.8369444405931663,null,0.3083714223641595,0.43006582623092404,1.2852880110183251,0.10229758884878509]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[-7.098100864159209,8.33371505951887,2.220650039481148],[1.7320499250257768,-1.5860131591354767,9.519572038316895],[8.965147756710186,-1.5780779543448054,1.5469170932553205],[2.44036779740434,1.3388209469069317,3.7231974219265958],[0.7743617459759697,-0.20330902422664288,8.201626192511085],[18.83961027979857,-7.149752045154866,0.23850002234994516]],"agemoea_scores":[null,null,1.3200802513744248,0.9092911938378674,0.4800249606411189,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,null,0.9037903350239128,0.5859350112456791,0.2952143227608594,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[14.013313111362331,3.5839498672901757,7.654653394364326],[6.0384462008058835,22.511462162967582,6.672945331372615],[9.214832102750048,14.886348212340419,7.099220231948713],[3.8944293156841727,27.165279860728788,6.586674138177534],[11.965761573189248,7.909451478945631,7.620859262134034],[11.174035043011598,3.5924795827381475,10.055187777592591],[8.90368655486323,21.645015678629782,4.6009849932907505],[12.224603819711447,2.707524701638384,9.52727456105983],[12.839769936458962,22.50284253722336,0.9177794348454229],[18.11539228864052,10.658090070208974,1.290829712297097],[14.533270335187213,5.5858058246162186,6.396419773257342],[7.4709085655302205,23.19630585089112,5.180241584640893],[9.37841182969025,16.977880996548272,6.106088655345685],[5.222502866199479,16.11535083154987,9.977342600503302],[4.002897087415142,12.522847697367164,12.477929239773482],[9.800716931469404,11.59904767155726,7.946386178709078],[13.809947318730947,20.139071023139156,1.0621980789573007],[10.218906644157162,13.765799823886159,6.706940411898161],[5.903061150947185,10.762446263233155,11.588382042043719],[9.483755028537049,13.567266332193594,7.410517518523398],[5.85275414832392,22.306097286606914,6.914085841191228],[16.04131361896943,10.420687296300779,3.143960281896724],[11.798278992565699,23.9532773400806,1.2069437329979158],[8.891222851742317,6.455136181307864,10.818327252040412],[13.822619875265936,9.418965393835997,5.4318476716005],[12.455937408608339,5.045351364518281,8.376136723866153],[5.73440302381788,31.223814527592985,3.3703945604568784],[6.521598923875455,15.283217533133454,9.21741746293659],[8.244592626509611,9.007877588488178,10.32274524630537],[3.7952298792439016,27.59074855347309,6.496814170864441]],"agemoea_scores":[0.3842964507731487,0.22021746999452174,0.23411734845153792,0.9982530756294499,0.5028017571043479,0.3584732372049418,0.39629860456300026,0.7561265544999276,1.3788384903273494,1.8585645841377745,null,0.7073427184951901,1.1897376158534432,0.8092944954023139,1.6581335891298676,0.6439214918775571,0.3390117538604782,0.3241253941714448,0.4821518974035589,0.15782040348239004,0.4724014943867563,0.5259552550665895,0.7342481847136594,null,0.6768670885219417,0.29484963054416585,null,0.4923431292026574,0.38429262401931813,0.29634635233627205],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.2539510165034959,0.142470570854991,0.1498591120058519,0.17911286103095048,0.3216722810925504,0.2210256365008682,0.46771822802389407,0.4657935319019555,0.889503863819918,1.189362569299253,null,0.23661247735597257,0.8103224999927585,0.5188975672260556,1.0326551842982292,0.41469616486676864,0.4191739100337385,0.20151484963871052,0.30172199202214944,0.10196877083944927,0.3990499667332994,0.3520347566959155,0.21683276446200578,null,0.435016482795189,0.18810540148389415,null,0.3038069816886596,0.23731981938344188,0.6514165042289821]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[11.37995464033363,25.992989138609964,13.839613083946144],[3.4219726688291283,34.585791560148024,12.933733696424609],[9.80130482988157,23.474705042283787,20.091878865623535],[11.709432539077277,26.222814907236675,12.806793712558553],[7.062152777325857,24.30602501200901,23.058869786653354],[-4.399212868025012,18.368811395338874,38.5839151788148]],"agemoea_scores":[null,null,0.6296780692198742,0.7232902035082555,1.4288019989823215,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,null,0.47638934798367855,0.5709695115533404,1.0599646560879294,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[20.788012368000544,-0.6388138756422661,20.07160231273376],[19.848545812146728,-1.651352042901185,21.426532881609074],[18.4702584011077,7.207259465868754,17.13068265974192],[23.747869240571085,-4.7601698875927525,18.910058148125337],[12.525038174095563,20.184767009081114,7.7393612425493075],[8.189688439851926,19.312471569298065,12.7409297227812],[18.073425687468195,3.9471667854065515,19.85625447845596],[20.36780753423333,0.5639562830134288,19.825719658685458],[11.164552215113343,21.59316576889468,6.331850002786043],[17.398265226033516,11.162614313426303,14.64442687981017],[9.175947834237984,20.7084690086651,10.122662236744404],[29.69753266052515,-0.9678862433763218,7.6656659885499066],[21.59986675327843,4.447572713071013,16.014004769386787],[8.043231696716058,18.03139865726793,14.403433321427082],[17.92052112638931,12.974355377763622,12.076345593448742],[23.798819867491165,8.041541496622155,9.487362581697159],[25.609408769855943,1.7311555952670243,12.941685745787675],[13.665875736945168,9.401103455738685,19.37568948098857],[22.003210180116824,12.221483632500878,6.401916191457623],[21.3003545197888,-1.7850774944118202,20.147674075964602],[28.560441224606706,-3.0702791958592694,11.682286271555363],[21.46507911401764,-5.214021861764584,21.36426589025352],[15.025010996778391,12.652963577506238,15.42009459569392],[18.70010480245832,3.092096798765901,19.85426207861658],[17.633803304152085,15.884875559837642,8.284549323019196],[25.390960436957513,0.8222332588195034,13.939436648708611],[29.180918175898494,-0.35355386729213656,8.292338521102955],[11.938356297969094,17.743019937243243,12.26031779482837],[7.793593970302816,4.561378205341379,25.514940443929707],[11.86658022700238,4.5712894359542595,23.805593406569237]],"agemoea_scores":[0.292679542971855,0.4001698060903254,0.4225394330900045,0.6162147413360455,0.33330450454746074,0.2547278957734663,0.2405116293288705,0.18896622132199248,null,1.5218599606049008,0.46064678120140073,null,0.5445732138781371,1.00518592850219,0.35350624060067226,0.6121093681133805,0.9677233549602224,0.6463072513925254,1.0910264918527204,0.1506211917645448,0.5219222753373821,1.751218812458725,0.39475236901339616,0.7744239185993655,0.6491586181049706,0.34896479681842846,0.2721691229876563,0.5340082533033319,null,0.8743410360655826],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.3648894743999689,0.21993055645100829,0.2890046189537011,0.4205950147647997,0.26220251511505877,0.19883688549109127,0.7454538739727057,0.14666419861003863,null,0.20614776450092423,0.35781077398452743,null,0.3881904943737685,0.7959576350909163,1.117872465241245,0.4704342547897433,0.26087686267209786,0.5608414100097701,0.7856643615055734,0.12121770551927916,0.4155301770560588,1.3740601951139486,0.33176600519992105,0.18590292823931234,0.3783790897771152,0.6869198467266624,0.21731761384926832,0.44246224202419626,null,0.4446710817762838]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[29.841597828591944,0.5813021814748796,9.183660433944983],[4.777959535689398,5.141132500911203,11.385237762355478],[4.729483795794753,0.6383474614008735,12.505121660841052],[20.571811179845575,1.187459758227484,11.260953264586398],[20.02525478049204,5.631742778095974,8.82087781951272],[31.785845666163866,-1.642918659749465,9.002675742931638]],"agemoea_scores":[0.7930555269137696,null,null,1.3762573262033753,2.0767454269365038,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.5289748250935171,null,null,0.7626545013404469,1.3837262336627552,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[19.192988981349977,10.685433196907667,4.355225970516855],[27.788319844676302,7.829214176578535,1.9597462192101798],[17.580521047102962,1.7802337642801942,5.791728446801947],[13.426909349829554,3.209327224575934,6.009295504074197],[28.56030927412503,6.440578369950148,2.0340227357203364],[16.83221506875562,10.323722590993734,4.7815652171468965],[21.997122734924705,5.460577953613459,4.876454173822465],[21.90974696239384,0.8460516203805808,5.266773723937343],[17.996939576243,3.735949983323371,5.626103103775782],[23.66772961312768,12.219520036928744,2.124033995566503],[23.56441716456721,4.8228556042542525,4.6357472108555555],[16.381995787142927,7.2401678752490035,5.39695288098651],[23.20811338601945,9.489257451089417,3.780018769409083],[14.023221012291652,13.687009887084509,4.0784901799961055],[15.851875677966198,11.834839165818146,4.501902031175799],[21.962751110741227,7.987922043635834,4.465345834306555],[12.262402067513934,1.9734420594973687,6.125118919722249],[19.476269760840765,8.41077050094328,4.831370286627172],[26.11770664098286,0.0016017515725155196,4.365464796512314],[20.842998465477805,10.604270680660957,4.054163196123598],[18.504998522957543,5.255599815876874,5.425673165282885],[26.309016601063306,5.2860491198971715,3.783034929405345],[19.83681034260394,7.842497776518261,4.880356705971095],[19.81406568583741,7.368701535559804,4.964682873344895],[18.711294091524838,13.172661607580855,3.5827847871062226],[29.96201395313886,-0.08026335519887962,2.6034333269637253],[11.928890515248149,17.089383683970077,1.9631302602539364],[25.831725609507306,9.763792138664922,2.48437637424305],[19.80656232725657,10.144167692060938,4.39093815264007],[13.483055018107178,14.174603729370189,3.9342410955341625]],"agemoea_scores":[0.2713223898713015,1.2189902534856678,0.6007712010190807,0.38734014859620025,0.5377959223037461,0.32070420650657666,0.6531978174421849,1.3131071777965486,0.2588887041782352,0.8282486903715107,0.3722605175350476,0.8430869159637393,0.47251353287446396,0.24712574428169112,1.0100527539240804,0.3465427377044319,null,0.46609690697392914,0.7198782352580493,1.7279238922361781,0.4133497787483229,0.939668340588998,0.08003399047175948,0.25166781754988177,0.5135246447013185,null,null,0.4393236434418134,0.15059465260897226,0.6925107450770087],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.2927901463781013,0.2790340573424921,0.514803497039483,1.4294868418704723,1.5194344054976812,0.2435311908082715,0.26346925534752724,0.8331059252643953,0.24824098197363448,0.8860206822779468,0.5121650977937311,0.4766139912538916,0.48797698712075954,0.19987516214523499,0.36342766613614563,0.2915041391720413,null,0.10145855627616662,1.1639205251118168,0.22189013072105013,0.6538186627879002,0.7404863922299745,0.383828201669981,0.17601903828614202,0.445233322894655,null,null,0.4342661379387277,0.12207838388776071,0.7680264164816604]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[17.478237058764527,8.47931890928075,36.2367762741046],[16.830484954889933,4.463253200771589,44.816209136553425],[16.51546189636361,7.836163631140278,44.606407729355],[10.144139528378231,9.615467621155046,52.307673634437855],[15.917417062184064,6.160623404053522,48.446245496202636],[10.391759705639897,13.83154385918359,20.73244816954645]],"agemoea_scores":[1.4094063126957332,2.1457699046558942,0.45306686716967715,null,0.6176115013161835,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.7138433049216495,2.9706585870546616,0.5728953010588465,null,0.7790535411540611,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[26.758255373367405,8.184081245050772,26.297205348524045],[29.53390961456622,7.884850507108945,15.832723078082243],[23.69331914769623,6.921087271771595,35.0816443420658],[28.044590951735124,3.984377328211833,36.245263179847434],[37.636208408993156,-4.488874881077734,15.967106899399074],[14.534487506416207,5.041658722773462,42.1535189614997],[22.13703196200764,8.879378091215674,30.0914905699851],[2.7332451662746413,11.74654264336791,13.92638992857431],[19.87739361250126,10.518822769006512,18.704020746978763],[10.234416093754179,2.1010288649385345,45.0423590470038],[3.9773547283163957,11.639203955596308,18.931611158781934],[27.226826124601494,3.821905844115621,37.24405698978207],[17.419453124134627,10.308879122560818,26.494086285780327],[27.134695562333604,7.941013806430906,26.910224123582584],[4.853372538195717,0.34968855999747017,46.092383100543024],[22.70504031540564,4.632599280465456,39.56759399801104],[26.053052064706335,0.9443257513011281,40.42316981631794],[28.124193603034833,6.798706681232808,30.104338787802227],[34.33489207993595,4.570904434575493,17.530275063509777],[23.558368678220994,-2.8584165206908154,42.84795117426714],[20.64239539557485,3.0548382516196746,42.03148526102552],[32.412021264891095,6.2924687816846685,14.688590265975321],[34.8288116740172,1.6074698857226801,27.44387313270633],[33.55269676344242,5.054808528229154,20.598896185445614],[1.2465912861369626,9.478505507625139,35.280562597410125],[2.896771567049716,5.787994945610784,42.55951442441575],[33.41000048047558,3.4132996555781183,28.21374732044975],[6.365600836506658,5.040108292911613,43.23112201782187],[8.717749757854348,2.405583217225894,45.031298202634154],[17.617757552937356,10.825625937718478,19.2172974261537]],"agemoea_scores":[0.25478353936689846,0.9584427617919455,0.4266162701171624,0.41139773008659397,null,0.4735421582930651,0.3183950702345202,null,0.22049021753974143,0.5990708821828648,0.48194550288653903,0.1711996189708341,0.7690250551176618,0.11265115904100725,null,0.2936599206985889,0.47241339273755,1.5038318051449115,0.48472578915362985,1.4079341926626885,0.8205829429245926,0.24279323212445275,0.7958446192002244,0.20224375886040336,0.755717023911259,1.1845554066395514,0.3212298725419061,0.37607898210616586,0.26885512269466205,0.5042120718525591],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.13810911221839092,1.041606026305522,0.21947370016843143,0.21742191213093778,null,0.28277802351583586,0.17766585963807444,null,0.14334136604643344,0.41982700011993296,0.6483304065567672,0.09191231989204186,0.5264584144214003,0.06088049748237682,null,0.1495961442763616,0.2974129699037297,0.3457868854958083,0.30173765726083224,1.1426446171302094,0.6037891901938809,0.14936264648771658,0.5732140536406802,0.12571053700008603,0.5162744046133777,0.9560007029392332,0.18919525591415526,0.2762124894098728,0.20135660538147368,0.32646406821551005]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[15.908018917056484,8.579526347400181,15.43975238520486],[14.040390193800562,9.285000828442604,13.29269987680125],[10.797008687868466,9.246984418171026,18.109814801423337],[14.72605784938268,9.199052534443794,8.206054611294258],[12.513810346471903,4.312516118844425,24.210611121979365],[15.343663659937516,7.93066691701933,21.685550099023917]],"agemoea_scores":[0.790472536990535,0.6275446499045361,1.6042154959396837,null,null,1.573980905084237],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.8877537870866887,0.6771988953386864,1.9608577938188707,null,null,1.83020645683187]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[38.16906593269087,-2.5835560153314017,14.465026760137201],[10.143533925343007,-2.130341013797943,21.767289823812263],[17.00062283692868,-3.0438544134665366,22.36003576859853],[38.21473937949639,-2.629753252413956,10.650437419499447],[38.20295111026317,-3.1041028589927726,15.394416991194403],[35.577539605963594,-2.117861371878086,18.873290048372894],[38.191010591120346,-3.022210141249467,15.584440399033827],[18.06949392418513,-1.8134857364886525,10.5700063997771],[33.69378114715899,-2.138883271882154,20.397009881125044],[10.345142579911608,-1.8130270068067538,12.174754281205573],[31.196935424933354,-1.8876551693302457,17.107743177698147],[25.663344399948443,-2.6232680664512538,22.23832210864404],[14.480189779349782,-3.0633920967224535,22.36202535451882],[36.87090238283446,-2.1321691758348047,11.644576075787684],[20.953128899306904,-2.04766085904411,21.383619136337536],[37.82702727792778,-2.8957388839852816,17.815387639839635],[19.79251193895667,-1.8141830379193062,11.614993981390901],[38.06742831256048,-2.5281588296966127,15.7685106002847],[33.042458224987314,-3.036046219302857,21.493878598268076],[12.664232491658783,-1.9678128756124127,20.83343857067419],[32.97466883134872,-1.9097727431648344,10.844955794969055],[17.85359328263626,-2.087048023449174,21.595985283063506],[38.23077740075986,-3.141377557807875,14.768344680274595],[33.92482537142648,-1.9405449681049263,14.446651897973672],[38.256193456748406,-2.9584004071422254,13.295231103680475],[10.360481182077674,-2.4154775984445567,22.258212031522724],[35.26769792731157,-3.013629351711262,20.72618717710681],[31.867567823068196,-1.9392243945107335,18.832209396305352],[35.61260901278697,-2.021765443175772,14.454126561702882],[20.63734226906135,-2.1960584444551547,21.936332674861873]],"agemoea_scores":[0.2589290225442469,0.7354387928345666,0.96211826030638,null,0.13896489261315453,0.21155729295627457,0.28527104955961274,0.8279871394353526,0.4124444776631001,null,0.2600587989090143,0.8859743947988898,2.8051261111581756,0.7152202404570652,0.2884758324190806,0.5197680131001138,0.27881504912672445,0.6240031465254826,0.8716396333283256,0.44203824025742205,0.47824414455625464,0.19250928800875355,1.696995732304309,0.19591708043415973,0.61174394140815,null,0.324462658467107,1.0993468141752305,0.3329032053011397,0.5354262910119495],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.08010644715107736,0.2908681386997252,0.35226126956329185,null,0.12744569557226254,0.03514551418375311,0.15925625691910655,0.453959214797519,0.06753305008406722,null,0.08758473747186396,0.1943742593726984,0.9850447274809204,0.11559693066345948,0.1334726656961881,0.11563873511362799,0.1602832880306399,0.16411124996192317,0.30717129357244416,0.09717149399763532,0.24442665897434596,0.03319911929202821,0.8492701420187596,0.03001916617103611,0.2505561841274174,null,0.06633159406467969,0.028213189325987945,0.054205240299911445,0.05861224825534716]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[9.339251160262073,-3.7972536645251487,-0.9315014794387079,3.0435479630681215],[8.550033882644815,-3.480273663559152,-1.2056583415094804,3.0744575131913083],[8.205053862641204,-2.3394219149018274,-0.9354037478558531,3.017568686180077],[8.394475598557623,-3.6321758714088577,-0.5467770979594566,3.0456917208119116],[7.139816533113845,-2.3227764791519787,-0.3136327575361033,3.063867726654003],[8.600028627126234,-3.826987276841246,-0.7642444624407325,3.0655558558969376],[8.291541415714002,-2.6324576694869815,-0.3810696232318185,3.0021690327820227]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.256357922278917,1.79525578809847,null,null,0.6645712970790658,1.2075610456822776],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,1.5858136994320593,2.1723041546613153,null,null,0.9657538134521069,1.5183764395777655]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[-2.5396146177252317,-4.372290459329362,-7.884692323411315,-6.145847307009771],[-1.7639031958138978,-5.5087872868744014,-7.493355791753024,-6.59317091915023],[-2.426527906173747,-5.150253910173701,-7.887389218897493,-5.512697333535918],[-2.450749501154915,-5.7162562570985,-7.6622862277190995,-4.481551640699377],[-2.710365902475661,-4.794927336797646,-7.719384320050582,-5.633861824834371],[-2.124167094454408,-5.571582287328213,-7.928565677633405,-5.025676682017176],[-1.8653855709802025,-5.094118727582976,-8.174297127498027,-5.200734855776512],[-2.49427185255484,-4.615484639160521,-7.9717915651003475,-5.7661583839063475],[-1.7538098590083946,-5.38915828079728,-7.7210492025220185,-6.472889212168042],[-1.7754319821933946,-5.641734069063856,-7.7839090174418475,-5.864919308523049],[-2.5029967699658426,-4.4264755683493195,-8.137750135664245,-5.077063650212281],[-1.3286736904765082,-5.6704698659916275,-8.179705401649674,-4.290677700852649],[-2.7461028990434038,-5.438320401530827,-7.612677038117932,-4.438836782725755],[-1.9586425883978402,-5.048340171447545,-8.091019701236183,-5.711831471041291],[-1.8846132116761227,-4.370919553188354,-7.929194609656096,-6.722427024374317],[-2.309752738134344,-5.278637364351479,-7.858102676297382,-5.648099545747644],[-2.4418221414238763,-5.161752678673009,-8.085910993137963,-4.393034537522997],[-2.0411258361890283,-5.760761332596987,-7.718364790954306,-5.071636399783127],[-2.255617240199916,-4.863621741581584,-7.845587577083169,-6.293630915827006],[-1.8752933511381558,-5.519351181576227,-7.933686704580976,-5.618424326982618],[-2.038291971946815,-5.574242895887399,-7.9492096834243995,-5.1029793235895635],[-2.744609112293617,-4.685924966267676,-7.725668481970231,-5.587144733421302],[-2.1644312859380386,-5.2618490071086725,-7.974948113260843,-5.5452865995965706],[-2.516107349283135,-5.464150059736098,-7.271905470615113,-6.0988468824429365],[-2.6373639882504323,-4.651299246805973,-7.934257738005721,-5.425889943198521],[-2.354045248037529,-5.255968030919731,-7.837865030137993,-5.659043084748453],[-2.056099264676195,-4.7756678293808665,-8.111844452904815,-5.807843689328224],[-2.3395457400420576,-5.197083166047209,-7.930165271817887,-5.48077472410241],[-2.372787401842737,-4.5974304065742295,-7.951788240376122,-6.097941033215998],[-2.5364758434850696,-5.285310412083218,-7.741558135397932,-5.424770524609143]],"agemoea_scores":[null,0.8109594062071506,0.44207965294916085,null,0.37751204316311615,1.0022183917729008,1.7834545560783257,0.6436599527452251,null,0.7205684627496872,0.9130699181426963,1.366071678938124,0.8915029644662946,0.4449977833687758,0.9875687914936481,1.346058884144627,1.1140313596702667,0.6466922751342257,0.7780742490431208,0.5631371907623075,0.3140580762281665,1.0290450492769918,0.520303458492243,null,0.44480792097422817,0.2056473120263143,0.9637512529337238,0.26467670659042253,0.39621986744033993,0.6965639112386908],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.38991842794503495,0.20993451855322792,null,0.5498810616366598,0.178066519630051,0.29255088301905735,0.1682326878263568,null,0.3293197375530183,0.4623112392123123,0.6636668235194292,0.43192485968905797,0.5999318583598416,0.4208526827753537,0.49327077750511533,0.7406032145921542,0.3076510217158773,0.36463817881904226,0.2349888818888757,0.4329618835888641,0.15680364105588318,0.24300893476614724,null,0.28753859839445983,0.09936567987354845,0.2631635705668329,0.12567494209012042,0.22393313764526415,0.3347268194949826]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[-1.1559805780978423,0.44028662046537437,12.081446218098975,-5.590566097336625],[-2.0912476274537,2.9938360616156046,6.620127808142268,-5.472990805532043],[-2.0421402603678334,0.5385728372519849,9.623862837807287,-5.453019225912076],[-1.8098973238311977,0.29651414366765905,10.198852618167084,-5.486414821910573],[-1.8855406380811117,1.6132032085588373,7.407587634956764,-5.466504000769142],[-2.2278684309791097,2.2607276176683966,8.692843097656931,-5.484024747378512],[-1.713385827843347,-0.5425375889034979,13.753530349577941,-5.5245330285896594]],"agemoea_scores":[1.6897454958380609,null,0.7196871726568574,1.1016644440529875,null,0.7197264942871867,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.4306064737863964,null,0.6379779087147303,1.0461847551659238,null,0.5895509820219333,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[0.9741661374047023,-1.3497227984955518,0.802534228855593,-8.443133797952838],[0.7863374912278951,-0.5308797205240272,-0.2374386247430479,-6.9566195238372215],[0.7261980273986304,-1.006030432148201,1.0017150294465107,-8.398223681115109],[0.6707549428041655,-1.3133585138357153,0.8652018241100266,-6.087038458586533],[0.5899738396580952,-0.9818150194767614,1.7141112618857108,-8.839387096813669],[0.5437155992517759,-1.5813792476332291,1.8111445563821569,-5.749769696903322],[0.7918920064703099,-1.4409793287944066,0.37862845402161294,-5.030571913663977],[0.6498279301769052,-1.9905925163511606,1.4134622883499182,-2.7310666682737956],[0.898579572061256,-1.524563598311734,1.0226614217800696,-7.642993904867624],[0.8396145340630174,-1.3111456694836177,0.8714326118593791,-7.767386821013627],[0.6967871919259098,-1.6998931621700049,1.312856835276425,-5.479818747677766],[0.9448194950965216,-1.1065633079462627,-0.10305607144492379,-6.448749907334992],[0.5983508921463607,-0.6384514144102991,0.841284355516863,-8.170354194952534],[0.6405596674125228,-1.843745381022619,0.9648191583030965,-2.4255479091980616],[0.6725878108428488,-0.3525903172000564,0.6571780488252557,-9.249541311680542],[0.8213058072275831,-1.3113958370417835,0.682127215630087,-7.067949833314285],[0.8187338388921672,-1.545902957675565,0.45836126846845615,-4.973817552876868],[0.6462723642027506,-1.8059209097393079,1.471561796682789,-4.581363924454547],[0.7956553083493042,-1.0933729978434414,-0.22667396212989416,-4.446759661830293],[0.5498254189620733,-1.1638883006016694,0.22114792971215536,-2.8453042681369425],[0.7718096818643587,-0.8954002007517035,1.0483550122653051,-9.199113338845063],[0.7833264764431822,-1.2876017673127647,0.8538304546635387,-7.3360370697529245],[1.0542525348697733,-1.2950599788958832,0.10555518351210413,-7.25177114172039],[0.7112932572775952,-1.8109894736539176,0.5816879543926399,-2.18840498394976],[0.8122878399707567,-1.5151082618141474,0.7091359043978647,-5.976410845420388],[1.212899284796312,-1.0410058104296789,0.024712404739732796,-9.057763023016772],[1.0141993157363118,-1.6385232093357458,-0.16906319172009276,-3.6936501334740264],[1.026696893830883,-1.08744731075479,0.6051962902724495,-9.249174907736801],[1.0045365482484612,-1.751888375989904,0.13109510013524817,-4.159344908723503],[0.595202769549847,-1.2934480209695187,0.8676053024570842,-5.26537530372648]],"agemoea_scores":[0.5119510016607132,1.3967369655245379,0.45654365608319364,0.4482886514410318,0.9463268981728925,2.1485767473922213,0.3463832080261335,1.08387115017311,0.8564647775045522,0.2705674695810641,0.7305500792339563,1.0235070415923806,1.598060343758971,0.3989995742078446,0.836377710954143,0.3549236852578529,0.6798792765834316,0.42948452224744194,0.8654424276795164,1.616677755942185,0.7862679063976445,0.5836175811448234,0.7018436612361532,0.8688391946139636,1.4561557942845307,null,null,null,0.5391615359539202,0.9231453409305803],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.3571325629874946,1.018304393857393,0.6613478772136913,0.3768552796510857,0.5300227834577724,1.4576015543753993,0.5302022552509179,0.31333752111003166,0.6261990076869555,0.22490681617910446,0.4892502412169528,0.735012018885963,1.1478437624239868,0.7060186738798437,0.46335698577778583,0.3034788886356185,0.2505405916271826,0.2428420863005093,0.6424213663766314,1.1469776481061338,0.3696904766436661,0.449799084113898,0.44533769365698966,0.4223397434559244,1.0089219625456287,null,null,null,0.39100125997990554,0.6775278616442756]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[-3.050148807587429,-7.020748614208975,13.557014769226498,7.822493275082286],[5.350343644785367,-1.6963734369550378,1.5035158167066522,5.50533498582677],[3.058214984729606,-4.095468186126988,0.9773264930862191,9.455283675548744],[2.941587052680095,-0.9976818185536072,0.8422924391848725,6.191294835334626],[0.2343745080313493,-0.659341339433249,1.0000044745519858,6.913710774323386],[-7.7701468017949065,-2.2877022068811135,10.494483882179338,6.535088618762447],[1.2047969460449988,-1.5486380173310623,9.597313227853,2.324104453483959]],"agemoea_scores":[1.7522429078078128,null,0.9981887869922881,0.35432452142265153,null,null,1.3763900206482689],"agemoea_ii_scores":[2.1901426055094135,null,1.177012477102784,0.4091343303971583,null,null,1.723253637687261]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[1.579007886136849,-1.9075752354158348,13.08616019802821,27.093691456151316],[1.0638729406519327,8.452123521481381,14.308155562735756,16.649667082140464],[1.0759708666879653,2.8079658684890587,20.48465009881827,16.10093320792294],[1.6238200990651461,9.297921267590416,18.9782158992083,9.181457629823143],[1.7117795564778295,12.407923132737462,16.075057654416298,8.66976173857],[2.286208179719672,6.423321554441221,24.8721380190184,4.002045910834375],[3.506459358261483,-1.939018890155761,20.995882303465823,12.902343956057825],[5.644109754491007,6.554603918239451,8.379792598968718,10.41016485672939],[4.082642776726353,-3.8865119882246746,16.360203106416172,17.923013395779048],[0.06151852318331019,4.013268476160215,20.634739737888708,17.868388371080233],[2.028723728223265,-1.3370023716827482,8.97993728184787,29.339217234964323],[-0.6095269796017204,9.311773852797979,20.262095373976162,14.836148764315276],[2.839686306745853,4.699935239317957,14.957249589479732,14.32323117518883],[-0.7352821015584426,-1.5790746956072734,13.825269860198736,33.23789420750812],[4.39843006291671,5.583339335331388,15.781384826876304,7.666066363903143],[-0.9452497221942101,5.898963830761867,19.226440083725855,20.51548288134563],[3.8094090471955733,0.3348940492502832,20.89554666428358,9.687802241481956],[-0.530510362559409,-0.22467409567100383,40.729323434676076,3.3451522446487068],[2.5256130842020346,3.3837936165554527,14.62138769373431,17.026114631224907],[1.428399474948581,8.03311085880789,18.362758916319045,11.748411927060154],[0.8269102474935575,8.149915867230412,23.760062378570133,7.926270830587522],[3.484189590093953,-1.8036550461796925,12.403157400896873,21.72274370718229],[3.695801835787254,3.7810724456435967,15.146152014673037,12.402665847172873],[1.700658777118432,11.021478639139259,17.726952907639813,8.439753277554052],[3.109955879472232,3.744561786855119,12.19158937207958,17.333664562485648],[2.393474746828545,5.2623341895076745,12.114375899158755,18.07715142202329],[2.370334545940752,9.771997088478429,19.718840581918545,5.582109470298019],[2.5737189901920106,6.869295140250838,21.01134492269044,6.631652585957153],[4.293453418973283,10.299184617670317,9.790105333885807,9.281346266150866],[-1.0045153943836738,22.012723137236346,8.391333096223551,15.124608684870681]],"agemoea_scores":[0.5326473822055495,1.0830988941976865,0.725424138113286,0.2374423842797838,0.49834384312649416,1.6513370485958125,0.5091528753766682,null,1.522247852133222,0.4018181303377998,null,0.6424462051245405,0.287852946176138,1.149848481907373,0.7139821866151788,2.018847890313014,1.0083566323381066,null,0.3936370861231414,0.47991357643284616,0.6172032233559366,0.6876404618138605,0.5695360731257468,0.8858945077849063,0.24959967329244093,0.7881109146550223,0.4895913436712195,0.36205379928047376,null,1.7968127681147301],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.3379778172814648,0.368919809375751,0.4669773142951019,0.19099845436120738,0.5202977597006642,0.4773045351389382,0.8237523999356278,null,0.49546739055013445,0.22283398890808626,null,0.4011203051215688,0.17140374868223163,1.078017739325576,0.44256717000459866,0.7909622784066694,0.2985078885238389,null,0.2419232306461016,0.3254716039857599,1.0019373894051529,0.39153651125768724,0.34569185676817393,0.11856035651519622,0.15458183699964118,0.6479934241982153,0.32322633525275934,0.21705816994290197,null,1.2434496847187941]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[8.014237351743676,5.124315957359819,-4.498492901032325,15.60437348025839],[2.005873064139349,-4.117917907047797,3.5079464113521492,26.142789113183916],[16.267697894145662,2.937680819638601,1.0879704062139206,9.73257903853085],[6.5760504809439375,1.1957355253769713,-0.10757877779505787,20.957460984283642],[16.58209543219799,-2.7921055380140665,1.9565358455750008,19.112067902890914],[20.805368459530435,-5.7206273810828066,-3.0590335831193154,21.03010324006396],[-4.171709317327812,1.5423384976103307,14.08562108932797,13.525398966923948]],"agemoea_scores":[null,null,null,1.089781972697936,0.8961628627807321,1.928366168924342,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,null,null,0.6786177316942421,0.5630695139273062,1.2921634679972096,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[5.3968108096560865,12.577578837281642,29.59070423463093,6.578380482413653],[-1.6946444147191642,9.651716498754052,22.63635540058995,12.179541412945182],[1.5533015988656684,2.2725618311406066,31.27162674387363,11.716771513220614],[-0.8990696486285064,4.141396941578006,29.580274412639795,12.217514457134685],[7.95674191164246,7.542221734708612,28.399319722563472,9.247955253571515],[11.259014299702043,13.92651043093593,12.082837644999273,8.202933752376262],[-0.37967809384086326,10.219259045216097,20.705539947634044,12.10752559726781],[-0.6326043098378156,10.661740930265129,19.32454222059764,12.213593858445266],[4.537717320297656,7.289338356261655,30.87830490808632,9.776093023655553],[4.81278746380856,11.589797426738526,28.008353213256175,8.49670771175388],[6.480979431135294,10.746937085087705,20.41692075625037,10.337427405318914],[-2.8071667109298453,5.060161279441956,38.471234688646504,9.877661485291197],[15.76243379503545,4.239264653256631,12.457887708557111,10.551718256919386],[8.099373048295508,9.086418843471522,21.790609204518574,10.24040727070405],[8.31080330617983,10.133044373622557,28.322173619059313,7.728136230131616],[14.022718225842523,11.573994020858155,13.943963009031213,8.015151576692185],[11.220772013339671,10.153344082603414,16.862165581700634,9.610957453241294],[5.176270891684604,16.053382276517212,12.454249793094144,9.285517348216947],[5.449077311725331,2.534175437488583,28.997065635978437,11.30050988456521],[-2.9310466358829053,13.022654488564473,15.829040285169672,12.133201828104607],[-1.9358972588801886,2.993842091703335,39.404064948332746,9.953348475391783],[-0.7443484495988795,7.4245630067555055,29.234156881553226,11.401666619287486],[7.05920420885233,10.935143779882404,22.664021490675687,9.57090845823549],[13.99877050904062,5.699285912283874,26.494519955370382,7.79424903031223],[15.484035219664959,11.32425018097784,14.039117196230965,7.167610202889889],[11.466079074701918,14.161631810572839,16.163795730697984,6.8948866326525104],[13.159053574688192,7.0577155692622915,25.1134092444142,8.122733229629175],[1.5430893002167503,2.0715806424930707,24.788115951100792,13.096147321060368],[8.328847452249917,7.246793734812357,28.559269641740823,9.179685424760985],[5.994989201726904,4.064596108501288,25.74517577806364,11.586352270901127]],"agemoea_scores":[1.8608810989089166,0.4307880673350102,0.41155580374160683,0.5152798402398906,0.2500779887761524,1.3557062591494558,0.15801097870403552,null,0.6150809359831453,0.6692902778625562,0.8908979373147276,0.5547819917924588,null,0.3289042290225124,0.5217462551930996,0.33602283631242336,0.6484300859597318,0.9081770151502471,0.8186702818293115,null,null,0.9086434808048793,0.4241834823862045,0.9801843473781289,0.8055228885440167,0.4786833965378866,0.427747368881247,1.2551812137771514,1.31348451502689,0.5111314620057925],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.7592639116281814,0.40216367896019434,0.3842767966362132,0.4725608809103631,0.2513220005436933,1.2053978891534296,0.1449151552329188,null,0.610810777192057,0.6501052660549445,0.8636171858467456,0.5111263164224797,null,0.3250561583866884,0.5011477641685738,0.28757670304997907,0.5923240510289154,0.6847972345187017,0.7711613463231495,null,null,0.8451023681530634,0.4185407242595814,0.8903535598426338,0.7014802305189712,0.4109819085475598,0.4043529658046312,1.141249084424353,1.2510542200222194,0.4729490879919182]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[14.46449538550323,1.8394373942168598,27.968530986562797,0.8458380014101268],[8.344022318434718,3.4450475864077763,17.57344996249649,1.7051381991478345],[21.616572232450704,8.86241661156191,6.9622767687844505,1.448033356376991],[28.95730406118137,5.612795569678768,18.32897646551016,0.30914414109106436],[8.200048256530966,3.912979516556918,31.71836074779118,0.3738603324783098],[22.207515740142547,8.860290900257226,18.563870911702658,0.8363804269030884],[10.42678343712646,4.446848719170832,27.021093319869635,1.0017942131810564]],"agemoea_scores":[1.3070590365542816,null,null,1.8335929450693205,null,1.0076029633434707,0.9599084346790645],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.3375379813198807,null,null,1.4647431076426956,null,0.6852486994904676,0.8615152730050436]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[4.402615809035112,30.358822501088873,15.779224675592292,4.323079515886841],[14.752929120367295,29.02689951583389,11.970289904312239,-1.8378143171258108],[9.211595462717156,41.212715534365934,7.416158900588464,5.756486886825245],[12.470877910564951,37.11655506949233,5.310041783449049,6.514468438277449],[9.674928453672276,2.423322445119123,17.042130998067318,10.032682895873393],[13.682446126255458,10.194974590600326,13.468405750645104,11.32098592306539],[11.597451311923228,26.46503211869458,7.519390354868365,14.68080948920572],[16.241037072276683,14.64579945556094,6.402429221145775,13.117979775145686],[7.949030296201641,16.832382856671437,15.018254997387157,12.991657762833404],[8.157230937571995,17.110877414856418,7.240147424779931,20.630493031367784],[15.281837188778228,8.992741099182822,8.664592141409283,14.812576428126144],[13.132905684142047,32.106260195439326,5.993977284175173,9.82808082959949],[6.972053210190896,30.752389680356664,15.821914583721211,1.466096944966739],[12.773580610171988,15.645137052842921,16.018874151217744,4.3000162683041125],[5.161188020136054,31.368938110225777,15.725661411676372,2.859647389793526],[11.52756484121006,26.372507900428083,6.894646004914463,15.09732621184421],[4.766501839971895,34.85185322989488,6.740173089688745,14.70172942880013],[10.305622784823965,41.405369792361356,6.052395550728757,4.726452666649029],[16.701813027405457,14.327077200711223,10.64827110449383,8.526198374092598],[15.995408569557464,13.616126866620556,6.491815627576472,13.818116145358763],[10.02019844158788,25.920339996868464,14.725787742525519,6.823640271920805],[12.8168025838046,11.204547642469668,10.302515382547409,16.400105830927437],[4.13897894974944,13.09210956012554,13.343615779803,17.90739561944941],[10.62800438893966,40.94630133570484,9.591723250300598,-1.8066540644857718],[16.572145924974954,28.639177422555584,9.352333964297978,-2.021267430975171],[3.9688358467435867,23.55694190494078,13.564839078913149,14.298076259957101],[5.995168591277071,27.529866463288464,14.130774372756077,10.698459568277103],[16.706162584338248,28.185736652130764,8.786054765181053,0.34347315872569695],[15.874146326053197,17.126629152300985,9.304288697964875,11.009099330072845],[8.155648146345019,22.259399481641516,13.65225466318644,13.153213397774286]],"agemoea_scores":[1.412691941662521,0.6228076962407437,0.7212617005927331,0.3665742741392759,null,0.7066029377548841,0.662404514098146,0.5616596521075443,0.6739378055040566,1.298027177531528,0.8552511903402559,1.1418240496562049,0.5102353805558812,0.6379165203055368,0.21260509940074207,0.3247459823302602,1.823183098578554,0.46056976328463145,null,0.22669507068604644,1.0138613540487575,0.5308467900963354,1.1333957018428449,null,0.9458996619502169,0.742643611491802,0.5185507609022575,0.35988102074190054,0.38272319438870644,0.3810774904327424],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.5667405790688347,1.0187624715889814,0.7964583196673392,0.5208025674875127,null,0.719618961784205,0.8203557687696232,0.7760037766571225,0.8058123924413996,1.4514266513463638,0.47342085249256216,1.3241352220945712,0.5760257221017588,0.7930901405011255,0.22681791621252623,0.3924780715892304,2.101286147071852,0.34866066304539867,null,0.24274844019854408,1.1491092620141177,0.9755059846117884,1.2726915954780318,null,0.3234501203288832,0.8651821217960471,0.630855372791348,0.7256587410232817,0.41893359771459726,0.4726703617714627]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[14.325362310937537,23.191184458659492,7.739551796315135,8.726559235270503],[13.423551250187039,17.74850131828985,5.7122209004984175,11.587412944246724],[8.760534561902455,4.389062061592906,14.798406854861758,11.015105302173726],[14.978826204578215,4.781729475648401,12.537125726444414,6.970620745217039],[6.340759561994621,10.749667732270698,2.6743569789665216,14.360973482331287],[9.625903932099817,20.503570262307655,8.49085926369325,12.349338676235641],[7.03069286657168,36.790898846848535,5.071717662487549,5.836872575259619]],"agemoea_scores":[1.449450623609093,0.7082487221055371,null,null,null,1.1285087851707685,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.3342899710640164,0.5919147159132369,null,null,null,0.9704916851718256,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[6.686136331937817,32.35502715491342,22.039502168123207,18.101299898808826],[9.70058603523296,10.872119382124428,13.399082675538631,30.68668523090534],[2.478529248481978,28.82110664428454,20.225883302788866,25.477069647622272],[21.775990219505204,19.752497727213598,14.973744341208723,11.86849720465221],[11.116963027563772,18.16271904491813,14.176437942328903,29.66452259055184],[17.157386421861283,26.844848704743406,18.878803736762855,18.06547249797857],[20.609785455892045,25.99722506383378,17.241115017544033,9.864713415543145],[10.385667853743646,16.777093805444835,24.304228122093125,3.301111750669275],[0.7247537313636832,40.96140177562472,16.68322218505492,23.03055701261311],[15.379421136069384,34.41896859334207,20.266789081366696,10.537659613904324],[4.06405874077514,46.02242329971839,12.276061026858564,18.61162472602821],[13.251480375004027,43.039775498541836,18.235958413184154,1.8587583328644994],[1.7166310918369225,20.085731261931652,19.59374818931633,28.215639277650524],[14.445739026340833,35.48886976770213,19.73113940437236,14.364159330440636],[15.979890998614783,25.654847482635006,11.449738769796696,25.354052803720943],[16.608191161628874,25.876599344151835,21.84256895814012,-2.388230301921109],[11.20402916386784,46.50432733454956,12.77166020299569,10.915525997525659],[7.040744005551165,33.008760104702894,14.122021211156785,28.10251238231224],[3.60861653162754,42.74483697425889,18.314343782341407,18.516121964263483],[2.9339791035571405,48.83217683900138,15.545510600972154,7.816347495336455],[7.510487288175575,31.66524890230022,23.47423458986298,7.271095101682498],[14.743706794695717,17.198810132852905,23.18957578893481,2.452578984059647],[-0.00687796868206636,8.281287121508143,25.037340623554726,6.850787178929062],[19.38223259170642,12.917207019377594,19.216054551956287,14.683083857448935],[1.033258815336339,45.253622609936635,16.433182641203324,17.893776587912217],[-1.3287716312526827,39.69110190988709,22.43228246715363,-1.1459483753373334],[0.5957356244308816,46.674955106435114,16.98304488405107,13.949877310446691],[1.6997197470258607,20.698274298610702,24.94343356736421,-0.09954964772741626],[7.753867213815463,35.55469005993127,16.095393694438982,25.911892887125408],[-0.48607881530834707,27.1064225482873,16.944272154529852,29.520738203131216]],"agemoea_scores":[0.49273506126035016,null,1.1560303310462712,1.4816633341196703,0.35389318942428516,0.4700982911143474,0.5847058799155738,0.33165512413924647,0.40311263573387146,0.6998333221883104,0.5517957303726728,1.0532637384200592,0.35814784249675485,0.3035931824640887,1.1078313542398586,0.7098801492283786,2.1054287406178704,0.5656307276621173,0.31422664460515437,0.6915827930667373,0.5604207051576235,null,null,0.9481618563834835,0.8842444747786296,null,0.3603558996819942,0.6304920273687923,0.31639985180391494,0.6334792586792724],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.14757434736291708,null,0.11970809858298867,0.7162271310812959,0.21490347649632413,0.13534073485863946,0.19421370331108992,0.15037507962337218,0.10149263151992051,0.2627639711279407,0.3665572818361631,0.5164702905630596,0.20128389870908736,0.08959771608741582,0.4990024353573017,0.31341809160961204,1.0582441208998574,0.18775925943923777,0.1541692119288697,0.33441222140169846,0.214295522960747,null,null,0.4113370171901084,0.2594061929360111,null,0.111876871496838,0.33180136870382904,0.1380806686254789,0.3430879003550621]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[27.244499524241654,20.43993223444504,0.0437551919093746,8.942400485705221],[22.767132285647897,40.518251740428994,14.124185935886892,4.400846950531258],[7.310613667675048,38.622921110171006,20.610714420664014,8.675488349707088],[11.975332861937353,28.0191862848692,21.106241164336247,9.645735557798378],[9.132024460981356,10.309815398642327,31.163245628339123,5.683089050323758],[25.44951312442733,39.144723126324365,-1.3390241389751338,5.432315899791595],[11.915276468072483,41.79838438164856,14.572059755765405,3.3974317498045608]],"agemoea_scores":[null,1.2771384655295648,1.5251631780023622,1.003927375061282,null,1.0460945042558158,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,1.7014821347292357,2.1644580557400097,1.4219402271329105,null,1.3480736628463053,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[10.627814699806,11.007721636672969,14.706966762783866,20.162834217055657],[10.483088915147036,11.201960068283448,23.49835788890956,11.53198366389175],[18.4544035234857,10.827078181095306,22.979880020231022,12.337569031344803],[9.42153454493717,11.157419008759653,23.639026735617776,14.51802233914892],[19.629844653480845,11.146816933457533,16.469365359043472,15.922360953699473],[18.049403370654648,11.016427383555685,22.977768998127598,10.250783968098286],[8.015940094082401,11.191577484564483,21.14763636540672,19.007228030111104],[15.537473299995352,10.362047236241935,17.089105205869746,20.209171713809447],[15.179550793442495,10.905413672034,23.991923147619538,15.150872234105773],[12.686875393256575,11.337400194452334,16.492624938700082,18.912057934724654],[13.968738865738093,11.40161271706044,16.73477110390951,18.06402903252073],[15.613327136133114,11.069571422806767,23.733907781066215,12.420410412596429],[18.13067493887541,10.759005238046308,10.74284482765269,19.5771413132022],[20.248305683215655,10.26900543638453,11.276896645896022,16.01442420916493],[14.774735591092616,10.659749377174384,23.930991913374193,16.807833047085435],[17.259987517649908,11.333165518411313,19.61229578696306,17.299529514506744],[8.63960589501885,10.847006658684084,24.20289609890062,15.006929670416273],[20.21349743141483,10.45023341694943,18.682994887239943,13.688932420558096],[8.336221435413186,11.198349160618754,13.101513082680274,19.749034362525826],[19.89301721169489,10.852765580303979,20.087421528415817,14.200161886627322],[17.86334212256626,10.786341615606602,17.531666996450564,19.597685261743536],[20.03023114204836,11.066650219756418,12.574701103721578,10.982346753453891],[14.09352599804682,11.116532233826277,23.69736187264489,14.746317347239376],[16.740545451326483,11.2647464979306,22.459557983600057,13.56352542765742],[17.975178451275774,10.455146008168835,23.458570923847613,11.911110360844148],[11.683627620824634,10.053021086463138,15.707615525951072,20.374150862727],[7.977390639475071,11.115338692593902,15.404154232049972,19.969925761030343],[7.807329446178535,10.308284457917555,21.71211191016216,19.641540382773176],[18.8920536815141,11.01562246391141,13.772727940303625,18.71314512630274],[9.806909467853712,10.522720263891175,11.834565812899067,20.387363179012677]],"agemoea_scores":[0.37642734652201193,null,0.23751760724145682,0.41101377754747415,0.5195948904473384,1.0310655687524855,0.5370305859866822,0.5896452434040483,0.6998149881886941,0.8009454910012828,0.4075148681675847,0.3654299644673842,0.8057204220571672,1.0214977643318182,0.41524103534420037,1.2923608929292125,1.2127759530720013,0.8147805556048866,null,0.3380842795650405,0.3473116942341847,null,0.28388086854710304,0.44082083233686964,0.5090034787689461,0.5397711185978835,0.4577851979568086,0.8790583835561516,0.43851325898570664,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.27168430038883246,null,0.21085689456477574,0.3229687519036572,0.3214510088206558,0.7966377925228089,0.325453443720943,0.23808963730593835,0.5026520041880991,0.19455004832371015,0.734379922227556,0.30765323781189746,0.44996509127384965,0.9857200364943456,0.2546407992178433,0.24168655867493538,0.9825076741869964,0.5232368689039968,null,0.17873865118753715,0.15915336817103365,null,0.12370644845709569,0.1786786778081999,0.1463235323597424,0.45434714164861983,0.3654022809603927,0.640222201306559,0.2408600149747051,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[-1.5296169841775864,0.21939775650418003,6.44658489585389,-4.793687027274651,-0.30790902528530417],[-2.1275327007095637,-0.02627836982145515,6.470046644852057,-4.49528827728351,-0.545589226089247],[-2.345119133159516,-0.26201620970486095,6.446534845022967,-3.8089377265189848,-0.3603806393344028],[-2.228123646958513,0.35917718333827686,6.457643382624911,-4.77343061272037,-0.1415448264721353],[-2.4097388858102384,0.02646446833452576,6.4701006340080385,-3.7727080044443366,-0.823766113655581],[-1.8816719180283041,-0.39201801447711926,6.435833594382825,-3.842165280896788,-0.3136940688946589],[-2.4800879051823426,0.24939202189971366,6.477293405207531,-4.169939852961664,-0.7559813849079469],[-2.529974511893571,0.11586211181214257,6.4512495065493365,-4.014724534918355,-0.4226399999090824]],"agemoea_scores":[1.2973002886671756,null,0.937612964240547,1.1051465002414542,null,1.7835298779604698,0.8356537646134705,1.30732162669148],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.9052372561435602,null,1.2182821996481228,1.3873650555638335,null,2.724096680305067,1.0561310190505075,2.1137977430684156]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.4,"front":[[7.556409895686176,-2.3013864671763473,-2.2954984769936475,-1.2403072497316652,1.4331496891541295],[7.633311624450625,-2.541110521451308,-1.4322587862815124,-1.0934747542478158,1.2240642938887132],[8.103620172647467,-2.047008828331688,-2.5519068659954516,-1.3687485433891344,1.313663838080732],[7.224105966624456,-2.1142636198237996,-2.234157669977094,-1.3151020525554817,1.6212529956967394],[7.3099633290840496,-2.2023226233592297,-1.4237741404853486,-1.4075070416195172,1.434201830040164],[8.132770729081177,-2.179894403311306,-2.3032362101775288,-1.491820569745534,1.4960974250768082],[8.231022079416348,-2.629545849859204,-1.7432064981112316,-1.1703200867113148,1.2695652168274942],[7.969770752083506,-2.6720726342017382,-1.614976349389718,-1.2054870745191382,1.4384586548094875],[7.242189153468215,-1.9538267988001434,-2.3216476277496993,-1.3805360651609706,1.6392001824109999],[7.852349034169304,-2.373458605821276,-2.7885897872669734,-0.8490935784078144,1.3405122986384965],[7.4346982338474925,-2.140290394749864,-1.9715259790150559,-1.3194349138725543,1.3459691885769813],[7.45349974517686,-2.3224589771479764,-2.5206685990594377,-1.0532540052455528,1.4488401592804363],[7.926444526079163,-2.277912162892968,-2.523948379351461,-1.213676807279349,1.3340268958630839],[8.070929433337357,-1.9406236796629432,-2.4341023063808236,-1.2699700463031989,1.1451571403780008],[7.845010151683053,-2.361792973662475,-2.290311393892235,-1.3220176604498062,1.4445867850654122],[7.6724020254669245,-2.223169305446712,-1.8308079725813415,-1.2061746732157645,1.1627599331983087],[7.586403965285141,-2.3529065956293023,-2.4684016910342716,-1.2322554044223026,1.556989605974949],[8.621829665506722,-2.6393502572254115,-2.3880896396286584,-1.3759555894785322,1.7146002255982264],[7.594497700516014,-2.3324258078973705,-1.8915399662554655,-1.1891881410497298,1.2463379608831708],[7.871626444499971,-2.4296494836924585,-1.9072400600621082,-1.3279697299678062,1.3536699500810734],[8.0910198622481,-2.1137507788083347,-2.8766616072912563,-1.2178849066556545,1.4686867391959544],[7.68411746081929,-2.2692247155323275,-2.0984063120476764,-1.326338955681609,1.360831721094238],[7.305272820754708,-1.8123543157502144,-2.7269761577685623,-0.9133066895932426,1.2634939906140057],[8.469154649575277,-2.620579071836482,-1.6611728169244018,-1.2160992500263434,1.2178099769187225],[8.136546620171412,-2.392314454622292,-1.8313651477929753,-1.3078278136618293,1.2041602501501343],[7.434240490631776,-2.2622360509311146,-2.347382909772619,-1.0497561467196244,1.3184230785366071],[7.700633678050874,-2.320524793517405,-2.3058005196401075,-1.327438022524112,1.4921356694360028],[8.203318139768147,-2.6002542263661006,-1.7796019738353646,-1.3605246007696943,1.4504098119895659],[7.450992594168297,-2.345053956808621,-2.25959904921053,-1.122310911490477,1.395668842109277],[7.861850100745561,-2.313497465314834,-2.3102766326788857,-1.2426211220936234,1.3124027902491038]],"agemoea_scores":[0.4636011216637724,1.1766089567702402,0.6526929612897913,0.6218721308442028,null,1.1452800572078319,0.44407306675729125,0.6267070864613276,1.228259405185658,0.9026360055361764,1.084227370063588,null,null,1.1849106288898479,0.6943936174640309,0.8700701637972339,null,1.2366680540749875,0.5355177261692727,0.528060614695339,0.7724226015757512,0.45856488026467773,null,1.387521757221848,0.6929641640473658,0.6508500267050263,0.34157423335795545,0.8140416605999715,0.40827833441671746,0.37569010957837745],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.20332674434918246,0.30947544016239986,0.3014715875375665,0.2875420369417816,null,0.48889299126985586,0.13633526411086555,0.16712696019859713,0.5702096616356971,0.3657410161328265,0.3962942710689523,null,null,0.43410752179547984,0.16708149765901534,0.5662770597018576,null,0.2826291729043051,0.18426908089642488,0.3600345624837867,0.3151823296558204,0.20565575054591945,null,0.3132651120548091,0.19672858915340263,0.3176285009360217,0.2672666796814055,0.21631454044646115,0.18671138033526058,0.18977855179062725]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[1.9177888776478147,-2.3942888428097366,12.173420430219384,9.632544019872348,4.541880498973127],[1.2754953001138651,-2.7573240161468564,13.985252418715424,9.428465545594078,5.240153748546577],[1.3667479922627108,-2.35227847228561,10.294513317563128,9.593987024395062,4.760577571439462],[-0.21894931120109917,-2.7992075873743985,14.7735298806491,10.151094721761469,5.055322398392356],[-1.3482618014683423,-2.6714050788748156,13.316196421657924,10.49017727697325,5.070422789531353],[0.651633673999997,-2.554044052829704,11.915946593636153,10.001987241201144,4.744407177292632],[0.3254563673976567,-2.4608158850210824,8.052687007513422,10.099709952875498,5.027894572846807],[1.7324668386956756,-2.3389178947232554,6.937303872678434,9.593689816215795,5.073720980485637]],"agemoea_scores":[1.4179570786769924,1.5537007313793334,0.7815711152309714,0.958825535844202,null,1.1805990042662131,null,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.9967349538752077,1.4520167276890126,0.6563262331271067,0.8757546372774265,null,1.307513260599684,null,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":0.7,"front":[[-3.9837325185838837,-3.392136203333165,-1.9673166340437733,-1.8642928921979711,1.1201416334961882],[-4.689391030115214,-3.199887793867035,-3.8349997561898914,-0.8252331120196938,1.36829875258579],[-4.984156969487376,-3.1797442765323876,-1.4637723796304938,-0.9944775115182587,1.2574221653827204],[-4.4459563795019,-4.249394881516149,-3.6619973173630838,-0.6436560205082829,1.3551347801101774],[-4.4112534569339505,-5.059897284430367,-1.4237588831504793,-0.45393812178580983,1.130887617093643],[-4.259176508149273,-3.3531384953902257,-4.6834286102332445,-0.19575401358505462,1.0970903027465673],[-4.033099934071915,-5.858130853458009,-4.053479287594898,-0.2939346334943207,1.5402930513918478],[-4.2375874910309514,-4.239920306357198,-1.7402967123287683,-1.5925798843100685,1.2796051123662129],[-4.425363496154238,-3.325109533153935,-5.25304593515572,-0.2955728899391892,1.3365309275058306],[-4.3879694287283915,-3.4224544539958437,-2.4673248803480963,-1.9167742228514293,1.4677110033677228],[-4.718215712501432,-2.2744095387367658,-1.6554886732692795,-0.5321457522592445,0.8407259724547286],[-4.490624069942172,-4.425560454183616,-0.16983583106046218,-1.2958175497525746,1.1369786712116912],[-4.35948835360729,-3.8432425990167354,-5.096822852107293,-0.8851590617601977,1.5917404445415744],[-3.812839514395,-4.391276109273587,-2.577472231024822,-0.5421266877366848,0.8833340648608843],[-4.7572746554352205,-4.432585071144754,-0.5150121579236888,-1.2129183529436784,1.3233678719782853],[-3.8491318693505137,-2.510855795026329,-4.926815373642622,-0.019687835136009024,0.8025656903439454],[-5.009852734312601,-5.665717736109412,1.1098819874120602,0.7364734022585204,1.043302396570897],[-4.900162310479694,-3.2999150641490087,-4.3686968718552555,-0.0005318208597251406,1.3744332926521388],[-4.707722895999169,-4.738618159041843,-3.481361609934005,-0.287245553977004,1.5115991392729635],[-4.495426555158505,-5.415672385778616,-2.8718708214524225,0.5809930386267781,1.1936777325755368],[-5.078925875967623,-3.3758542044963646,-3.6254591788764605,0.35419101627659133,1.29092149508073],[-4.753052962792823,-3.9570747733188565,-2.114103807193212,-1.4083614549858825,1.530054435438987],[-4.7943180849252185,-4.439571831190167,-1.4704546586362346,-0.7660645538965418,1.3243498103750007],[-5.091097863447059,-2.623417912360193,-4.377311593824196,-0.08290251552749694,1.414555044009944],[-4.013005619735363,-6.0671393864275736,-3.2074262888170333,-0.6314929890808862,1.5735975688731294],[-5.055226298509764,-1.9561918981908075,-2.2250607044795965,-0.18956626244395536,0.9549968806956495],[-4.533892316898136,-6.0923274073339115,0.11901011017518304,-1.2345126043821133,1.6238282254194558],[-4.482784135930096,-6.1167473695272925,-0.0460011266090552,-0.7649091726971347,1.4328462839977965],[-5.300716680149416,-0.7924183313732867,-0.0680177908566364,-1.2200557623605386,1.0046013226390766],[-4.946305719829303,-4.380525259223016,-2.954219890844576,0.09401678321279894,1.3795481630884252]],"agemoea_scores":[1.3983595711470986,0.8125145380953569,1.1130287170745112,0.5282476653455168,1.2361792486101568,0.9736749478713006,null,0.5803573122156331,0.5752856166577329,0.9148620998550486,2.120735274675779,0.792846385626142,null,0.8847456613221114,0.47126822789053896,1.2588773921038234,1.3954238965009522,0.36449582608352404,0.7139695007022535,0.8407005967142366,1.3174891861075988,0.6559639395182781,0.6265801084316925,0.5757208328609725,0.27585927615635497,0.7467516635351861,null,0.5733968186941211,1.4739651127954314,0.4823971209444903],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.3031680402425025,0.7651950183257676,1.1472016152081357,0.5163478325952944,1.0820452949377792,1.071426161464712,null,0.5403977717704604,0.5414239972593219,0.8203437804020662,1.9509478151715025,0.8059036586591074,null,0.8159718671448228,0.46641093543823264,0.5913558736536637,0.8948237266687443,0.33360147891110115,0.6502206940436512,0.7578364895356913,1.233967627995832,0.5798467445296531,0.6629979972421438,0.5246619079421336,0.216613333709334,0.698821223909443,null,0.4340765467222306,0.7896905410577322,0.4548225163709575]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[15.359344669451229,6.660689436921437,12.779190873962397,-4.203496794093388,9.353611559860653],[15.553243782475668,0.31700938895674025,16.417042426837916,-2.363892963008582,6.3702492387155765],[13.364493482099064,-1.176753789632912,13.554694350237124,-2.3095376157720784,16.677356032205815],[12.239016141116174,-1.898022151672731,15.768771553224749,-2.9310816045953816,19.875531412113027],[10.79375462771501,-0.8772299208144254,18.33081100653768,-2.146503332334478,14.67711730447328],[13.910648620571491,-0.5461685366345055,18.517782776532595,-3.8776639897985494,14.751416399870527],[11.727274886231662,-0.9663117915984802,18.007261610624923,-2.551446156181036,15.004281212256616],[15.833018513461031,3.637499005255963,11.981092799180946,-3.8833741172505345,12.749325579879342]],"agemoea_scores":[null,null,null,0.9434328603572952,1.3145934491341684,1.575313916842987,0.5959731968356115,1.2221327922856284],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,null,null,1.609366470593135,1.969099710436499,2.394992864459013,1.1180217574158435,1.7286152341799823]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.0,"front":[[3.5022700322060976,-5.722537472023793,-2.1384062141883855,13.080488534319821,7.372510857933843],[8.054505922209714,-5.955015093177754,6.0716876811541844,8.73381015645353,-1.464471681493166],[4.560003593465008,-5.177661937368518,-0.5787705024633691,11.448213812763312,2.985561584433457],[7.157103301120206,-5.103470139776915,-3.9646894008315234,10.346471037137595,3.2252138173046117],[2.8860520998534125,-6.487108191311641,-0.6822501832199315,15.024152928617028,8.593511098005866],[1.5473056414536654,-6.342121094224579,4.947479660701974,16.062651747096314,2.4470145996312205],[5.164276911571737,-6.0760034840934605,3.6515660453607595,10.875166838815042,3.743448104500323],[9.47161085716876,-6.14774602107263,1.138731552685222,9.303671789071437,1.604390816268011],[1.378015092227394,-6.0543208436232945,2.059380919412069,14.87409991773978,5.924854602457836],[4.245695589950019,-6.006535103356422,0.6929871214424876,13.809915345494511,3.6137571740594128],[5.259656519489356,-5.747869257705009,-2.0536264895849112,11.52400597675886,6.694518939807844],[7.5626276082875385,-5.0656626295393075,-2.999995847139414,10.127926032852116,1.568682038892761],[5.12255745778855,-5.637562009002828,1.0659358703295068,11.758047306834237,2.5502217600047983],[8.727760601944913,-6.279792036376595,-1.3737680552408795,11.217819057519062,3.4911596360039923],[6.129759075294552,-5.602905236958119,-0.5895605424792496,11.648273481939194,2.4853585835335057],[5.352434284986496,-5.946047265897855,-1.3873742967825162,13.70898857016895,3.6556930152046796],[2.843796378715786,-5.123778416405569,2.8443206762850988,9.247721113428517,5.440077544169807],[5.6061464420170495,-5.7520152473782025,0.5739646222911903,9.774078669841014,5.975420939450709],[9.067541165853015,-5.485125882069782,-4.709371272075711,11.04352659388113,1.8709500090426214],[8.859890846338468,-6.672182359029286,0.33795714800266463,12.446279675576307,1.9231084636712605],[2.309329873690047,-5.088071193967484,-1.4378711893321219,12.615538017781038,5.584785443355976],[2.4474930369640866,-5.446984360865791,5.057669903091712,10.121025826658048,4.402099119051004],[5.042188669423091,-5.521098844608765,-4.832868020965714,14.719233358059451,3.753063744888931],[3.463423230589779,-5.293503241956232,2.674496871271467,14.474317032975794,-2.5084446839455743],[5.675122945684339,-5.554971205521414,2.0535882540499912,12.101630396927243,-0.5353231418182203],[5.36474681090928,-5.534282637372927,-2.7287540772095285,16.000983082734013,-0.9817627791624788],[2.3614174280025755,-4.732451090073475,6.557941305795392,9.058407385131456,0.20686409165209563],[5.869281959271317,-5.572930423430666,-0.9901608996354634,10.133526362438516,5.5347815903535125],[8.179349164028874,-6.098498819172088,-0.07769465861562441,9.984061507847214,3.871809365524106],[4.906279359140629,-6.133465307812474,0.8302550841523635,12.547162587578137,5.00999674901424]],"agemoea_scores":[0.6878283518607624,1.3743010552327628,0.712467796064001,0.30204606997306216,1.1755968368562923,1.407076418827466,1.2203642101684138,0.8818098382584532,0.6845768981810771,0.6209621614329328,0.4987117277391242,null,0.4666394043772687,0.48444164025248615,0.6203210577605169,1.0703217625484025,0.9559302927842308,0.5124689617723968,0.5540059807725571,1.5655682211680126,null,0.6326322419943127,0.7357664173432859,1.0962957442958834,0.9173421967482878,null,null,0.9157630186017661,0.6307210669718926,0.4868416835090146],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.5230145161605279,0.9090604402266499,0.7314664943731659,0.2712103376715089,0.8151124162759373,1.0882595254798022,1.2493454179694619,0.7660934548863387,0.5537669221553005,0.6231232973504255,0.6419937726119109,null,0.47158648996743313,0.4532563470700233,0.6402880643695802,0.9954861655469041,0.7341918836149937,0.8804932753045998,0.5002818853613517,1.428781334128221,null,0.553162025900758,0.6465429306014154,0.746137261511463,1.051235596680139,null,null,0.3782878408253294,0.5825260593442383,0.4907698785773819]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[6.0032990374543616,19.333322304705828,6.582737719030956,13.671569697510218,-0.3957441827115633],[7.656770213954343,10.444138281670897,8.030058462704634,9.831650593612375,1.1340962537726185],[2.7603081268377547,8.107188161965164,7.620636912016433,12.38648034825146,7.831594610253918],[5.764229822375131,16.17420361905361,8.335384709468398,9.705299011951402,-2.4349746593810906],[7.428814468798722,9.066521631899784,6.948477702585594,13.03731083365999,3.645375042742171],[6.78187199768984,6.283541320002758,7.771403599201616,12.625555287172944,1.7450540894629638],[6.3625905737136295,12.29550486699203,6.672963315772755,12.507160730212853,6.0117027178929785],[8.867015580677037,-0.40937144713756535,7.121726567829689,12.266779700079127,5.236896948392824]],"agemoea_scores":[1.326701522596485,1.0817943252957107,1.3504640604846339,null,0.7099642787019723,null,1.2351478221040812,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.6145158577501448,1.3635031809636198,1.7149119547542406,null,0.9494782658990719,null,1.5041261899414908,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":1.5,"front":[[17.724217217249745,15.178678938847106,9.716847122092869,9.827226075843853,-2.3700877294509306],[18.157017466659887,16.085005233728403,8.842185502196193,13.668428311641621,-2.411177128999438],[14.316022820239922,8.363897338931931,5.707007598747502,31.454312437015044,8.397484434794407],[16.31238065784914,7.894229550240045,9.461477185414694,20.922577271923117,-1.8952664655161557],[17.127825576187096,18.101069739257873,7.961574568734992,14.626593396717768,5.131973862907648],[13.5543360830743,20.502922453314397,9.167014221229136,16.2955867786146,3.9774762505689303],[17.333372679225622,21.924224603140026,8.96832129902748,7.8701477678020595,-1.8788198942637129],[11.813513217733046,28.330455696171015,9.40042367828073,11.577545779955244,-0.05434679688885158],[13.206705344051215,17.537046149167757,8.461594359773558,16.49579995772103,11.836305918663571],[15.017828149191978,9.956818456970677,9.26428876650002,24.205535221910157,-2.6909748720233253],[11.554506950723505,26.954217281311458,6.801265958362295,24.24609006936361,2.642246255821661],[16.85603888477725,18.662923880592004,5.712405772755565,24.7826917410433,2.0268046938497086],[17.52793729403739,24.99294039008734,7.019005499886234,12.740897214884107,1.577237336805247],[19.608142519651132,15.507490319480826,7.178221295089811,11.113475308758094,5.994332570652157],[17.366927829797845,22.45469216643668,7.986169268791504,14.455710579941837,-2.560591985223551],[16.58341949480056,29.949059184184705,6.8330393015825495,7.955194634891577,2.5376524422077473],[14.74998962861941,23.38085950324519,9.288758858547707,12.780205271636428,-1.0920246356048633],[13.541544947522684,21.265131210328356,8.912341352509571,18.624420648007572,1.6602867729217268],[9.867840733757678,22.850736676323237,8.90606728780654,19.645162619385346,5.603866414448076],[13.731500830340535,22.586618362664197,6.161919163118165,18.16637416963217,13.523104521464488],[15.243892809704139,21.461076921000767,6.53142168237311,18.869613374184556,9.253322516233062],[15.249236301223213,23.422376549321193,8.01947759156955,8.025666661579894,9.860978459343238],[11.53610772127039,8.26940154303313,10.304009497265241,7.64243915459668,17.03241688888562],[16.282825228793083,19.09099301493014,5.884132154483478,11.091156847076302,17.254205660700066],[12.61164325872259,26.15949563210019,7.755967004125518,21.22824008622452,0.763934919466025],[16.57191049668026,9.391764356135013,7.03171917061897,13.898028981310718,17.726087389459806],[10.255492496447467,17.211317117407454,7.302008983973541,9.59527677989682,25.06329392199128],[14.622441512063302,26.304567053136076,5.14823306048962,21.76265448386253,5.367371836486491],[15.525604757573005,26.068637880899793,7.817177647230816,9.344949191544682,6.003722408124119],[15.804827812490402,16.53676341744981,8.22893931417289,18.080475603081393,5.758399656011948]],"agemoea_scores":[null,0.40441491208017255,1.623948839586625,0.6370828965010676,0.509708415078005,0.38958745418459206,0.5565019586787213,null,1.3006766853374865,null,1.4578916489741784,1.1740192027081373,0.5004294245038425,1.0307617133841076,0.8625052125137587,1.1646282428811903,0.5828935886695168,0.7011512936357955,0.8787838601421458,0.8969411316975269,0.5931238393566002,0.8587388475347019,null,1.8966696412354982,0.5223411472355294,1.0120798832763447,1.2050999926299193,0.7612129479854286,0.4332371762809436,0.7641484472913549],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,0.3531007304627155,1.5523852083789007,0.5996406471635137,0.4918438095153428,0.36927020339222144,0.49236576916753827,null,1.270808223025718,null,0.9324261488953014,0.9170683694695794,1.0310264623031322,0.8610090655618541,0.5886469414649425,0.5446992539105867,0.5230329381388543,0.689607484007835,0.8299648536191622,0.8113437081054374,0.5923977728711807,0.8386388483089284,null,1.796199415563868,0.4976657766199559,1.0418304476566214,1.163238343154723,1.3673767888853243,0.3872608720703177,0.8338847677365384]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[7.055594438676231,18.058808321600534,17.89458622736489,0.7552865413657468,-6.2845876964424505],[14.326992579870367,27.426406063229848,-2.045571479437231,4.7970285228119405,-6.236144569552654],[16.344144588553924,17.765700258130472,12.233567698064604,0.04976733527129795,-6.221294544935181],[18.935127853085458,25.17200358086499,14.761606082634518,-6.7200960027540955,-6.566318391231094],[20.13885235039958,32.9180162779528,1.5283506226101036,-0.46757165804020495,-6.586624798001534],[18.900456938006155,16.160609878624047,0.24940573161272184,2.338105336557607,-6.056605033425091],[0.3949253500648888,38.97813132662221,-3.1002455660862567,-3.168373109527492,-6.161885494316131],[20.90966310087535,18.846390408936557,5.4367057939664605,-3.987454455182742,-6.086245447497139]],"agemoea_scores":[null,null,0.6973253501156933,2.476050946031622,1.8173033748338465,null,null,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[null,null,0.18968607333195547,0.8595197724939656,0.6921952974122982,null,null,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":2.0,"front":[[5.35898398976895,3.9925358548188132,24.53095977155902,22.396052337423342,0.8914985302159764],[5.4530237563006985,4.885323399033748,29.637312092496753,4.538282643767374,2.6888486693586877],[8.432172240456477,4.8495058032352425,24.332612949069198,10.101247901240573,5.914976355873838],[9.915377239311994,-0.34675456913324343,30.28082403516255,13.63101552491839,0.5389581765316676],[7.775260629471001,-1.004142172117234,17.775264882545393,14.252776452918066,20.837493218491932],[0.07077850937278773,-4.649630265630661,31.686016284024152,2.693280784118821,19.563840946981166],[9.779679051566449,-1.6438630968187065,17.893363638225303,29.712330335218176,7.213002353930703],[8.692406814348011,4.697649202210828,23.56065740926622,13.087654064631893,4.800918877008476],[8.690365957352038,1.3192101066484616,24.456754365687015,13.335493394921656,13.010187311986494],[0.28315083139527353,-0.7343052897595452,29.96872723765745,27.105809737746384,4.6366090415873575],[5.2771280999215495,-4.725201808408492,24.71650814836011,31.15070611644599,7.789492165262958],[3.7575157518176985,6.008774715968137,12.74978617045574,0.8429377908680666,19.280190879820484],[7.016955353881199,5.7044946425870275,12.121717987868225,24.836472956481064,2.8873385510056746],[12.340633668233389,3.442594950916291,12.065419411230526,10.42160316147721,12.713575910514558],[8.234551515303723,-2.7427570525133933,28.808224105972997,19.734805763959585,8.597329668346463],[-2.42199321691503,5.856608799632202,9.871679840631536,6.298934471784277,21.486460448570277],[5.960817309290777,6.021279223145227,19.772343907724675,1.1538589658584835,14.28355670509988],[0.8435703503592897,-1.562295168893976,37.8257898995924,5.897883242896463,5.035665213888544],[2.535945862667778,-2.167306152267093,20.144396635208125,32.379449195449226,12.804160203420697],[7.379061310453679,3.565609258805347,27.470205736685177,15.06587319687528,0.9824399103619101],[11.497358909445754,-1.3461427966711277,24.598467120274083,15.425625533574099,10.504342444209687],[-2.682719395753549,5.614875451786576,29.77546811262817,0.3739077475025683,9.36384091648696],[12.443819011944383,-3.399552944485516,16.718033645584264,26.52641369722467,8.104739653064556],[6.196850341464227,1.861117566670245,29.895291155648707,17.05782292152025,2.6657028106237],[-0.9997234948889604,1.2429188858442668,28.76276469052999,18.863540582240223,13.243051903994902],[7.865026743935834,6.722495095283476,19.21049122397813,2.8591281118735736,9.801069939080145],[4.367512435024779,3.536341266031931,22.961855833052766,21.838032808361802,9.748848118116058],[11.814026311535361,1.356827765050972,8.870316314102912,10.738934553016287,17.502260470888206],[8.43799550912777,-4.005263745713986,14.910097240720898,21.79915419541348,19.573537190060282],[4.0320641308805545,1.617782041276974,20.219097378126875,20.698485249324907,17.00073460069786]],"agemoea_scores":[0.7252286445974698,0.7639892753086361,0.41783059196185884,1.3352967989746154,0.6606985330577194,1.4738770174659108,0.47455412164868416,0.8631154018355078,0.45918551455097956,0.7580422152558302,1.5293029102788287,0.7833360795835254,null,null,0.573992213097315,null,0.5133394283600627,null,0.6402097052926558,0.4093814226989022,0.7878697719257615,1.0509088059753826,0.8610777538251352,0.5037797015007967,0.9731417371026267,null,0.5363620445269988,0.7932772645670972,1.2514346591330643,0.6058024774098971],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.3221484391466266,0.4758919289381184,0.24069706012233183,0.4445774366404261,0.29272650766008135,0.9223120632774408,0.21518903515929236,0.3811606366937701,0.21967764492614533,0.3962267571479817,0.8790307232444312,0.4733646674857933,null,null,0.2791118964517949,null,0.354445087090856,null,0.2783804021827304,0.7751941335082235,0.5521233763071014,0.6588009555375719,0.4764946786560421,0.1977803912722029,0.27149084583567584,null,0.3018929742866197,0.4849908891831388,0.6617910279175645,0.347246866654207]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[0.42670504326814784,5.46405549319627,17.39510804071672,9.42213727313106,36.24919105181216],[1.2692514020773837,31.072453804033245,9.954431345468963,15.64481126365332,27.944656242659246],[2.183634581645257,25.716551838360765,11.95797416247312,21.088862798239802,22.464483878969816],[2.811718256931537,21.74337906201103,-0.15112868446008942,13.830435409433438,38.80717167461778],[4.102684598575628,7.990766933989278,18.180162996361922,14.747099035691477,13.529855594386214],[5.3839370227484284,18.225253570546386,3.274920206453121,17.83883844700933,15.533050632722597],[2.162374103159286,21.03336014567246,9.423780748550255,23.291336225935083,27.803117706278627],[4.243256625740545,7.740358937533179,16.690269797597708,12.647088351608078,26.146745483457295]],"agemoea_scores":[2.0280612175818837,1.4493485842214007,0.63957853317312,1.7666902029960734,null,null,1.2060919957951,1.1960944851452844],"agemoea_ii_scores":[3.391341407461769,2.7454556487260007,2.0407957225328346,2.241638337019539,null,null,1.2956075745899711,1.605556394752929]},{"kind":"survival","q":3.0,"front":[[13.781898665365759,9.968224399231037,36.540156528202985,11.493204554876232,-2.3493147240528787],[11.479554947497544,5.373640797668712,33.67970884872433,22.39929639693873,-1.7121226024137446],[11.690443727838005,-6.539444148604053,45.6262518091236,18.860432777247816,-3.2149429178155433],[13.203975153948395,11.704272475449283,28.373306718578064,19.175722750157128,-6.005391374956617],[13.880151151041474,11.626153279221388,33.70614216680633,13.560225570839334,-6.99395196307815],[12.972525904406549,10.679492286635679,36.001076689521454,13.493225496941772,-0.9401325301344965],[13.980648831025352,9.545970527281714,12.799087667204974,12.10954738599251,1.511523017822558],[13.477778487980101,-0.5105786231826315,26.543449571627285,15.676567437830887,2.744083123277063],[15.556665082805914,1.641217644319025,19.28484586200227,17.1355192829673,-4.915477610813215],[14.149042615649787,0.8909354825060047,10.380461060417474,23.13399700400158,-3.6332125610631283],[12.436653216347294,11.237032981558372,32.927968734371724,18.558371269228658,-2.412507206095012],[12.42060301677728,2.1140673979335807,40.50039305133435,9.196955136557701,1.8062262673842362],[12.234987627039315,2.1869712681772375,40.27083792738393,20.53244899205173,-2.476105026026235],[13.492835935915505,12.048872356451977,34.43376357703396,8.144564704537494,-2.0617569355821903],[9.96042645209034,9.616782951031471,33.182205442642974,13.61726321014732,2.155438015126954],[13.4716127117601,5.896342384533603,41.46020615547856,15.981907488410585,-4.209748172880365],[12.163912892839637,-3.352203582236349,23.885233467948623,20.60300577026056,2.458481862879829],[10.96908788545733,-5.044560755961425,38.858468498097196,22.383029222185286,-1.7822545624891362],[14.84605450610457,0.8948582260908475,28.199747663374033,18.803085979183493,-2.743454444692299],[10.77327412968626,1.8983675816692367,50.45071270943272,6.916959321981137,-3.6165782419211983],[13.051861086118318,7.979729107059119,6.799624836762749,22.331312544002067,-1.3079592324035607],[14.146403077059698,4.225497055336594,30.37803752300379,6.313751593247306,1.6775790769638341],[13.660220780192509,-3.729339332959542,31.412260248562845,8.43479649621035,2.8356077094021828],[12.920483848371912,15.421263816272731,26.47403233900107,13.303343982989784,-4.394682673276385],[14.303690536180602,-2.7456062121823726,10.442950306511037,21.653495482036526,-0.7042706290871488],[10.401523021976596,16.229315034090988,25.8419557052553,12.61479193957699,-1.1737260274892938],[14.554055339941076,-5.062558334106614,25.7985198331751,21.634929407132013,-5.049213582574751],[11.32771925843766,17.526423272568596,16.27240729180632,14.782714414554372,-5.720099005797958],[14.696125025544383,-3.201252684695607,11.752740541687755,19.70012706000185,-0.08819357446841103],[9.998258966748311,6.260813897412951,26.104480975211693,13.117217638639008,3.8680718731193267]],"agemoea_scores":[0.38792391896175454,1.098064012687284,1.5129520912464707,0.7485053618772046,1.2516090166052982,1.0835785719389919,null,0.7206366147962183,0.7613616186862684,0.5612234141521298,0.5978647907580033,0.6625043832117136,0.5139571698649983,0.809480588109647,0.5658471375936257,0.6645915133679696,0.8686868009679989,0.6248410926796621,0.5333602474507619,null,0.8705931577231849,0.7292097624112952,1.2727574998743303,0.6230309240923341,null,0.9051569975628444,0.8798196618288342,1.6374612260785975,null,1.4294250715954198],"agemoea_ii_scores":[1.0071947659323772,1.5383527928624212,2.2710009660740695,1.717769627922555,3.241393991805591,2.3497000909748813,null,1.0848097828353618,1.189738377225712,0.81280859850857,1.325366375099245,1.5407687398165453,1.0097523465207168,1.6151746406839305,2.5390977332554936,1.5643864996993944,1.5006319836236193,0.9412008498803404,1.0096694425487382,null,1.2934553295899245,1.3004256499236928,2.1938050345565108,1.1123827722093855,null,1.2467941418876394,1.3933279525996518,2.0150403703557607,null,1.1668557212276427]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[20.224147838211614,4.146501936840925,21.9713887637293,11.157639807876068,3.6520880227834227],[18.903297774977027,1.7211439822510757,26.43686690678379,13.95776985298382,2.919874067749513],[14.075688869450074,5.408394812951288,25.021652074321487,12.933855020602682,3.5364566061769906],[20.974766907172047,-0.15425929629784818,22.052511760969058,10.228471331177612,3.635690003803412],[12.47152426598183,3.909008856759691,26.54046565599973,13.61243265259038,4.706959122116005],[13.572298135450028,0.7739235825722166,28.592915920911356,12.632493767610514,1.2776549904927716],[4.870785776049907,5.4985813953598,24.346027723320127,14.524272350859167,3.6517064488757325],[18.863409951672203,1.1866344555625061,14.10384172392579,16.20892147134366,2.2338214591357337]],"agemoea_scores":[1.4363070523947927,0.9966505587814015,0.9028481948577933,2.106371529046955,0.7464375046143161,1.654005216858304,null,null],"agemoea_ii_scores":[2.1308809840839014,1.8621889845915875,1.2986240084708525,3.1825833768267904,1.6620413778011838,2.5748104609399456,null,null]},{"kind":"survival","q":6.0,"front":[[22.750512135228668,5.082160455469882,12.898567370930555,11.078893554432208,20.612200105653827],[12.162388904901379,-6.070418505766321,14.722699260800722,32.274763442267876,32.26340251536027],[14.725548124208814,-2.5997242224892805,2.425650964064586,21.90037385963055,43.3732961417696],[12.529127867838056,2.2698160538479595,17.619832034107965,18.322095702244173,18.519869473359122],[21.084518476969684,-1.2041225760733205,6.136135064997738,31.63953812237072,35.941326939765744],[12.283004775286404,5.051687270512739,7.551863461924749,31.063807602162207,17.25495328009978],[22.690480101650888,4.819147373633175,13.494634786025069,6.305770984216599,26.875110794412283],[21.142225914388714,-2.7995407058381723,3.2240584215526105,22.266893878923906,41.94363343649913],[12.517364052380769,3.507215491721471,6.920673768497075,24.949293027003232,40.97232040840227],[23.82519113335565,-2.207779981307657,8.865457586826961,24.277810788327983,38.19400447096651],[21.00051105620873,-3.7394398041206545,13.555433362266593,29.147537520039673,37.28445945193283],[23.705141634852065,4.85923637763276,7.824710842880744,20.34358378301342,16.231508899166997],[23.282454097639633,3.6368490276290224,5.122039751138769,3.119055348355223,37.16197769148219],[24.233124366441736,-6.259392020632896,8.91463466813864,30.116656712789847,10.4913673302306],[9.452862058184785,0.6261615742184343,17.298693405559234,11.769289116327105,35.22782774896583],[25.289838962394747,-0.8483855178984125,5.7641926753716,4.339754744652889,34.888462465930644],[13.724357792474024,4.488830237153536,15.157585404119603,17.730108174282197,36.35781327553842],[23.816697710736968,1.824226136510367,14.862725785291273,22.953759921370583,17.671813843839814],[20.549573950843364,-8.604068642412253,16.003720694455104,28.842728329224347,30.215552837627552],[25.679962902885094,-4.342483482836964,8.358952172098157,7.025501191865451,32.40680703363204],[23.545739280064435,3.564174539484661,9.369696498977653,27.73747363317465,19.726940669312384],[23.23408359572526,-7.139028880019083,16.566151038485494,12.145036403179537,14.645328076715987],[9.792847392427786,6.86361451954788,4.662304141287833,5.015558526632038,18.330736471208088],[22.79075638547933,-3.848179097689597,12.814913415657088,30.4486280077816,31.2654217903531],[23.362168970717185,5.168529763463178,10.224401769140911,4.886625324303702,12.343819474462137],[23.292363625604878,4.714568317697344,7.825332124841046,24.833815310540675,11.700444814579903],[11.148864925130809,3.578268823666864,12.186291794404179,32.44358629204153,11.417199102364242],[12.231878679828338,4.595648066063957,15.742142862477298,24.99812082381278,28.256671288933305],[16.078652221908634,3.796845996989866,12.443504273304814,31.87850789182797,22.08860590516177],[12.263715714346837,-2.892110606039447,16.61122590062721,30.174287639810856,13.791984630067681]],"agemoea_scores":[0.4711195380632388,1.319607386427983,0.7863364108136903,0.9694626479262524,0.7081531156721128,0.9182444588655339,0.9582594073879368,1.740710194726675,1.1657265452967578,0.5324217690581226,0.4624953686381656,0.6086091938287963,1.3599225212507093,1.419299985253286,1.6016050345167248,0.5088039629012723,0.8020488514379174,0.8710420938290684,0.7686008486631852,1.029489721839697,0.46513908042195024,null,null,1.166753860249726,null,1.3100031256589357,null,0.5499951333295929,0.647652439012552,0.8040294551287226],"agemoea_ii_scores":[0.8155361411583963,1.5647531104515982,1.0265262009381364,1.3601026589909584,1.113158984433602,1.283040131921912,1.5375819911126585,3.0531750370066133,1.6260757544862525,1.453659559847659,1.1080339151678118,0.6841940866198077,2.214834891895054,1.834510954762838,1.8245292117449508,0.7960153782461712,2.7612858641658784,1.4080633626056218,2.28914317588381,1.6047609343241245,2.188777165383022,null,null,0.7630613972431117,null,1.0915783224609448,null,1.1284768281902273,0.9084405877132489,1.1925335178731011]}]} diff --git a/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py b/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7e8db66f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py @@ -0,0 +1,190 @@ +"""AGE-MOEA-II, the ``variant="agemoea_ii"`` of AGE-MOEA, against jMetal's own (tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json).""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import dataclasses +import json +from pathlib import Path +from typing import Any + +import numpy as np +import pytest + +from vamos import optimize +from vamos.algorithms import AGEMOEAConfig +from vamos.engine.algorithm.agemoea.geometry import ( + _compute_geometry_ii, + _geodesic_distances, + _newton_exponent, + _survival_score, + age_survival, +) +from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import AGEMOEA_VARIANTS, resolve_agemoea_variant +from vamos.foundation.kernel.numpy_backend import NumPyKernel +from vamos.problems import DTLZ2, LIRCMOP + +FIXTURE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent / "data" / "agemoea2_jmetal_values.json" +CASES: list[dict[str, Any]] = json.loads(FIXTURE.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))["cases"] +GEOMETRY = [case for case in CASES if case["kind"] == "geometry"] +DISTANCES = [case for case in CASES if case["kind"] == "distances"] +SURVIVAL = [case for case in CASES if case["kind"] == "survival"] + + +def _scores(values: list[float | None]) -> np.ndarray: + return np.array([np.inf if value is None else value for value in values], dtype=float) + + +def _same_scores(actual: np.ndarray, expected: np.ndarray) -> bool: + infinite = np.isinf(expected) + return bool(np.array_equal(np.isinf(actual), infinite) and np.allclose(actual[~infinite], expected[~infinite], rtol=1e-9, atol=1e-12)) + + +def _vamos_scores(case: dict[str, Any], variant: str) -> np.ndarray: + F = np.asarray(case["front"], dtype=float) + scores, _, _ = _survival_score(F, F.min(axis=0), None, resolve_agemoea_variant(variant)) + return scores + + +def _config(variant: str, **changes: Any) -> AGEMOEAConfig: + return dataclasses.replace(AGEMOEAConfig.default(pop_size=40, n_var=12), variant=variant, **changes) + + +# ---- The steps that AGE-MOEA-II overrides, against jMetal --------------------- + + +def test_the_fixture_spans_flat_convex_and_concave_fronts() -> None: + exponents = [case["p"] for case in GEOMETRY] + assert min(exponents) < 0.5 and max(exponents) > 5.0 + assert {case["q"] for case in SURVIVAL} >= {0.4, 1.0, 6.0} + assert {len(case["front"][0]) for case in SURVIVAL} == {2, 3, 4, 5} + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("case", GEOMETRY, ids=lambda case: f"m{len(case['front'])}-n{len(case['front'][0])}") +def test_exponent_matches_jmetal(case: dict[str, Any]) -> None: + front = np.asarray(case["front"], dtype=float) + expected = min(case["p"], 20.0) # VAMOS caps p at 20, as in AGE-MOEA; no case reaches it + assert _compute_geometry_ii(front, np.asarray(case["extremes"])) == pytest.approx(expected, rel=1e-12) + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("case", DISTANCES, ids=lambda case: f"p{case['p']}-n{len(case['front'][0])}") +def test_geodesic_distances_match_jmetal(case: dict[str, Any]) -> None: + front = np.asarray(case["front"], dtype=float) + np.testing.assert_allclose(_geodesic_distances(front, case["p"]), case["distances"], rtol=1e-12, atol=1e-15) + + +def test_survival_scores_match_jmetal_where_the_shared_steps_agree() -> None: + # AGE-MOEA's extreme points and its tie-breaking follow PlatEMO and pymoo, not jMetal; on a front + # where they agree with jMetal (AGE-MOEA's own scores match), AGE-MOEA-II's scores must match too. + compared = 0 + for case in SURVIVAL: + if case["q"] == 1.0 or not _same_scores(_vamos_scores(case, "agemoea"), _scores(case["agemoea_scores"])): + continue + compared += 1 + assert _same_scores(_vamos_scores(case, "agemoea_ii"), _scores(case["agemoea_ii_scores"])), case["front"] + assert compared >= len(SURVIVAL) // 2 + + +# ---- The exponent's bounds ------------------------------------------------------ + + +def test_newton_exponent_is_the_norm_one_exponent() -> None: + point = np.array([0.3, 0.5, 0.7]) + p = _newton_exponent(point, precision=1e-12) + assert np.sum(point**p) == pytest.approx(1.0, abs=1e-9) + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize( + ("point", "expected"), + [ + (np.array([0.99, 0.99, 0.99]), 20.0), # a near-cubic front: p of about 109, capped + (np.array([1e-6, 1e-6]), 1.0), # p of about 0.05: a flat front + (np.array([0.0, 0.0, 0.0]), 1.0), # no positive coordinate: Newton diverges + ], +) +def test_exponent_is_bounded_as_in_agemoea(point: np.ndarray, expected: float) -> None: + front = np.vstack([np.eye(point.size), point]) + assert _compute_geometry_ii(front, np.arange(point.size)) == expected + + +def test_a_point_at_the_ideal_point_has_finite_distances() -> None: + front = np.array([[1.0, 0.0], [0.0, 1.0], [0.0, 0.0], [0.6, 0.6]]) + distances = _geodesic_distances(front, 2.0) + assert np.all(np.isfinite(distances)) + np.testing.assert_allclose(distances, distances.T) + + +def test_numba_selection_kernel_matches_the_numpy_loop() -> None: + pytest.importorskip("numba") + from vamos.foundation.kernel.numba_backend import NumbaKernel + + kernels = NumbaKernel().selection_kernels() + rng = np.random.default_rng(3) + for n_obj in (2, 3, 5): + F = rng.random((40, n_obj)) + F = F / np.sum(F**2.5, axis=1, keepdims=True) ** (1 / 2.5) + reference = _survival_score(F.copy(), F.min(axis=0), None, "agemoea_ii") + compiled = _survival_score(F.copy(), F.min(axis=0), kernels, "agemoea_ii") + np.testing.assert_array_equal(reference[0], compiled[0]) + assert reference[1] == compiled[1] + + +def test_variants_differ_on_a_curved_front() -> None: + rng = np.random.default_rng(5) + F = rng.random((30, 3)) + F = F / np.linalg.norm(F, axis=1, keepdims=True) + kernel = NumPyKernel() + first, _ = age_survival(F, 15, kernel, variant="agemoea") + second, _ = age_survival(F, 15, kernel, variant="agemoea_ii") + assert set(first.tolist()) != set(second.tolist()) + + +# ---- Configuration ----------------------------------------------------------- + + +def test_variant_defaults_to_agemoea_and_round_trips() -> None: + assert AGEMOEAConfig.default().variant == "agemoea" + config = AGEMOEAConfig.builder().pop_size(20).crossover("sbx", prob=0.9, eta=15.0).mutation("pm", prob=0.1, eta=20.0) + built = config.variant("agemoea_ii").build() + assert built.variant == "agemoea_ii" + assert built.to_dict()["variant"] == "agemoea_ii" + assert AGEMOEAConfig(**built.to_dict()) == built + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("bad", ["agemoea2", "AGE-MOEA-II", ""]) +def test_unknown_variant_is_rejected(bad: str) -> None: + with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="agemoea_ii"): + AGEMOEAConfig.builder().variant(bad) # type: ignore[arg-type] + with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="agemoea_ii"): + _config(bad) + + +def test_variant_names() -> None: + assert AGEMOEA_VARIANTS == ("agemoea", "agemoea_ii") + assert resolve_agemoea_variant(" AGEMOEA_II ") == "agemoea_ii" + + +# ---- Runs ---------------------------------------------------------------------- + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("engine", ["numpy", "numba"]) +def test_agemoea_ii_runs_with_an_exact_budget_and_a_seed(engine: str) -> None: + if engine == "numba": + pytest.importorskip("numba") + problem = DTLZ2(n_var=12, n_obj=3) + first = optimize(problem, algorithm="agemoea", algorithm_config=_config("agemoea_ii"), max_evaluations=400, seed=7, engine=engine) + again = optimize(problem, algorithm="agemoea", algorithm_config=_config("agemoea_ii"), max_evaluations=400, seed=7, engine=engine) + other = optimize(problem, algorithm="agemoea", algorithm_config=_config("agemoea"), max_evaluations=400, seed=7, engine=engine) + assert first.data["evaluations"] == 400 + np.testing.assert_array_equal(first.F, again.F) + assert not np.array_equal(np.sort(first.F, axis=0), np.sort(other.F, axis=0)) + + +EPSILON = ("epsilon_constrained", {"initial_quantile": 0.2, "exponent": 5.0, "decay_fraction": 0.8}) + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize("technique", [None, EPSILON]) +def test_agemoea_ii_runs_on_a_constrained_problem(technique: tuple[str, dict[str, float]] | None) -> None: + config = _config("agemoea_ii", constraint_handling=technique) + result = optimize(LIRCMOP(1, n_var=10), algorithm="agemoea", algorithm_config=config, max_evaluations=600, seed=2, engine="numpy") + assert result.data["evaluations"] == 600 + assert result.F.shape[1] == 2 and np.all(np.isfinite(result.F)) diff --git a/tests/engine/test_constraint_handling_algorithms.py b/tests/engine/test_constraint_handling_algorithms.py index 5b54ec40c..48b68b6bf 100644 --- a/tests/engine/test_constraint_handling_algorithms.py +++ b/tests/engine/test_constraint_handling_algorithms.py @@ -113,6 +113,8 @@ def test_constraint_handling_follows_the_fields_of_1_0(config_class: Any) -> Non # Fields added after 1.0 go last, in the order they were added; NSGA-II had live_callback_mode in 1.0. added = ["constraint_handling"] if config_class is NSGAIIConfig else ["constraint_handling", "live_callback_mode"] + if config_class is AGEMOEAConfig: + added.append("variant") # Development after 1.4.0: AGE-MOEA-II assert names[position:] == added assert fields[position].default is None diff --git a/tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py b/tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..36cd98dd5 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py @@ -0,0 +1,167 @@ +"""Regenerate ``tests/engine/data/agemoea2_jmetal_values.json`` with jMetal's AGE-MOEA-II selection. + +Three kinds of case, read by ``tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java``: + +- ``geometry``: a normalized front and its extreme rows; jMetal's ``computeGeometry`` gives the + exponent ``p`` (Newton-Raphson from the non-extreme row nearest to the origin); +- ``distances``: a normalized front and ``p``; jMetal's ``pairwiseDistances`` gives the geodesic + distances, through the projected midpoints; +- ``survival``: a first front in raw objectives; jMetal's ``computeSurvivalScore`` gives the survival + scores of AGE-MOEA and of AGE-MOEA-II (infinite for the extreme rows, stored as ``null``). VAMOS + shares AGE-MOEA's other steps, whose extreme rows and tie-breaking follow PlatEMO and pymoo rather + than jMetal, so the test compares these scores only where those steps agree (``q`` records the + sphere: with ``q = 1`` a two-objective front is a segment, where the greedy selection ties). + +The fronts are points of ``L_q`` spheres, ``u / ||u||_q`` for positive ``u``, with ``q`` from 0.4 +(convex) to 6 (near a hypercube), so that the exponents span the clamp of 0.1 and the cap of 20; the +survival fronts are scaled and shifted per objective, and the geometry and distance fronts include +coordinates that are 0 or above 1. Every survival front has more rows than objectives, as jMetal +scores only those (``computeSurvivalScore`` returns before the geometry otherwise). +``tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py`` checks VAMOS's survival against them. + +Run from a checkout:: + + python tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py --classpath "" + +``--classpath`` lists, separated by the platform's path separator, the classes +``AGEMOEAEnvironmentalSelection``, ``AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection`` and ``SurvivalScoreComparator`` +compiled from jMetal's ``main`` at commit ``JMETAL_COMMIT`` +(``jmetal-component/.../ea/replacement/impl/agemoea``) first, then ``jmetal-core`` and +``jmetal-component`` with their dependencies. ``tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java`` runs with Java +21 or later (source-file mode). +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import json +import subprocess +from pathlib import Path +from typing import Any + +import numpy as np + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] +OUTPUT = ROOT / "tests" / "engine" / "data" / "agemoea2_jmetal_values.json" +JAVA_HELPER = ROOT / "tools" / "jmetal_values" / "AgeMoea2Values.java" +JMETAL_COMMIT = "46fb0a61f7" +SEED = 20261118 +EXPONENTS = (0.4, 0.7, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 3.0, 6.0) + + +def _sphere(rng: np.random.Generator, m: int, n: int, q: float) -> np.ndarray: + """``m`` points of the positive orthant of the unit ``L_q`` sphere.""" + U = rng.uniform(0.05, 1.0, size=(m, n)) + return np.asarray(U / np.sum(U**q, axis=1, keepdims=True) ** (1.0 / q), dtype=float) + + +def _extremes(front: np.ndarray) -> list[int]: + """The row nearest to each axis, as AGE-MOEA picks its extreme points (distinct rows here).""" + chosen: list[int] = [] + for j in range(front.shape[1]): + others = np.delete(front, j, axis=1) + order = np.argsort(np.sum(others**2, axis=1), kind="stable") + chosen.append(int(next(i for i in order if i not in chosen))) + return chosen + + +def _cases(rng: np.random.Generator) -> list[dict[str, Any]]: + cases: list[dict[str, Any]] = [] + for n in (2, 3, 5): + for q in EXPONENTS: + for m in (8, 25): + front = _sphere(rng, m, n, q) + cases.append({"kind": "geometry", "q": q, "front": front.tolist(), "extremes": _extremes(front)}) + # A row with a zero coordinate (the derivative skips it) and rows beyond the unit box. + front = _sphere(rng, 12, 3, 2.0) + front[5, 1] = 0.0 + front[7] *= 1.4 + cases.append({"kind": "geometry", "front": front.tolist(), "extremes": _extremes(front)}) + # The nearest row on the diagonal of a convex front: p falls below 0.1 or diverges. + front = _sphere(rng, 10, 3, 0.4) + front[4] = np.full(3, 0.01) + cases.append({"kind": "geometry", "front": front.tolist(), "extremes": _extremes(front)}) + + for n in (2, 3, 5): + for p in (0.5, 1.0, 1.7, 2.0, 3.7, 20.0): + front = _sphere(rng, 9, n, float(rng.choice(EXPONENTS))) + cases.append({"kind": "distances", "p": p, "front": front.tolist()}) + front = _sphere(rng, 7, 3, 2.0) + front[2, 0] = 0.0 + cases.append({"kind": "distances", "p": 2.4, "front": front.tolist()}) + + for n in (2, 3, 4, 5): + for q in EXPONENTS: + for m in (n + 3, 30): + scale = rng.uniform(0.5, 50.0, size=n) + shift = rng.uniform(-10.0, 10.0, size=n) + front = _sphere(rng, m, n, q) * scale + shift + cases.append({"kind": "survival", "q": q, "front": front.tolist()}) + return cases + + +def _java_input(cases: list[dict[str, Any]]) -> str: + lines = [str(len(cases))] + for case in cases: + front = np.asarray(case["front"], dtype=float) + m, n = front.shape + head = f"{case['kind']} {m} {n}" + if case["kind"] == "distances": + head += f" {case['p']!r}" + lines.append(head) + lines.extend(" ".join(repr(float(v)) for v in row) for row in front) + if case["kind"] == "geometry": + lines.append(f"{len(case['extremes'])} " + " ".join(str(i) for i in case["extremes"])) + return "\n".join(lines) + "\n" + + +def _value(text: str) -> float | None: + value = float(text) + return None if np.isinf(value) else value + + +def _read_output(cases: list[dict[str, Any]], stdout: str) -> None: + lines = stdout.strip().splitlines() + if len(lines) != len(cases): + raise RuntimeError(f"expected {len(cases)} lines from the Java helper, got {len(lines)}") + for case, line in zip(cases, lines, strict=True): + kind, *values = line.split() + if kind != case["kind"]: + raise RuntimeError(f"case kind {case['kind']} answered as {kind}") + m = len(case["front"]) + if kind == "geometry": + case["p"] = float(values[0]) + elif kind == "distances": + case["distances"] = np.asarray([float(v) for v in values]).reshape(m, m).tolist() + else: + case["agemoea_scores"] = [_value(v) for v in values[:m]] + case["agemoea_ii_scores"] = [_value(v) for v in values[m:]] + + +def main() -> None: + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description="Regenerate the fixture of jMetal's AGE-MOEA-II selection values.") + parser.add_argument("--classpath", required=True) + parser.add_argument("--java", default="java") + args = parser.parse_args() + cases = _cases(np.random.default_rng(SEED)) + result = subprocess.run( + [args.java, "-cp", args.classpath, str(JAVA_HELPER)], + input=_java_input(cases), + capture_output=True, + text=True, + check=True, + ) + _read_output(cases, result.stdout) + document = { + "source": f"jMetal main at {JMETAL_COMMIT}, package component.catalogue.ea.replacement.impl.agemoea", + "generator": "tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py", + "seed": SEED, + "cases": cases, + } + OUTPUT.write_text(json.dumps(document, separators=(",", ":")) + "\n", encoding="utf-8") + counts = {kind: sum(case["kind"] == kind for case in cases) for kind in ("geometry", "distances", "survival")} + print(f"{OUTPUT.relative_to(ROOT)}: {len(cases)} cases {counts}") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java b/tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java new file mode 100644 index 000000000..da9f19e14 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/jmetal_values/AgeMoea2Values.java @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +import java.util.ArrayList; +import java.util.List; +import java.util.Locale; +import java.util.Scanner; +import org.uma.jmetal.component.catalogue.ea.replacement.impl.agemoea.AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection; +import org.uma.jmetal.component.catalogue.ea.replacement.impl.agemoea.AGEMOEAEnvironmentalSelection; +import org.uma.jmetal.solution.doublesolution.DoubleSolution; +import org.uma.jmetal.solution.doublesolution.impl.DefaultDoubleSolution; +import org.uma.jmetal.util.bounds.Bounds; + +/** + * Values of jMetal's AGE-MOEA-II environmental selection (package + * component.catalogue.ea.replacement.impl.agemoea), for tools/agemoea2_reference_values.py, which + * documents the input read from standard input. As a subclass, it reaches the two steps that + * AGE-MOEA-II overrides: the exponent of a normalized front and its pairwise distances. + */ +public class AgeMoea2Values extends AGEMOEA2EnvironmentalSelection { + static Scanner in; + + AgeMoea2Values(int numberOfObjectives) { + super(numberOfObjectives); + } + + static List rows(int m, int n) { + List rows = new ArrayList<>(); + for (int i = 0; i < m; i++) { + double[] row = new double[n]; + for (int j = 0; j < n; j++) row[j] = Double.parseDouble(in.next()); + rows.add(row); + } + return rows; + } + + static void print(double value) { + System.out.print(String.format(Locale.ROOT, " %.17g", value)); + } + + static double[] scores(AGEMOEAEnvironmentalSelection selection, List objectives, int n) { + List front = new ArrayList<>(); + for (double[] row : objectives) { + DoubleSolution solution = new DefaultDoubleSolution(List.of(Bounds.create(0.0, 1.0)), n, 0); + System.arraycopy(row, 0, solution.objectives(), 0, n); + front.add(solution); + } + selection.computeSurvivalScore(front); + double[] scores = new double[front.size()]; + for (int i = 0; i < scores.length; i++) { + scores[i] = (Double) front.get(i).attributes().get(AGEMOEAEnvironmentalSelection.getAttributeId()); + } + return scores; + } + + public static void main(String[] args) { + in = new Scanner(System.in); + in.useLocale(Locale.ROOT); + int cases = in.nextInt(); + for (int c = 0; c < cases; c++) { + String kind = in.next(); + int m = in.nextInt(); + int n = in.nextInt(); + AgeMoea2Values selection = new AgeMoea2Values(n); + System.out.print(kind); + switch (kind) { + case "geometry" -> { + List front = rows(m, n); + int k = in.nextInt(); + List extremes = new ArrayList<>(); + for (int i = 0; i < k; i++) extremes.add(in.nextInt()); + print(selection.computeGeometry(front, extremes)); + } + case "distances" -> { + double p = Double.parseDouble(in.next()); + List front = rows(m, n); + selection.P = p; // pairwiseDistances projects the midpoints with the field P + for (double[] row : selection.pairwiseDistances(front, p)) { + for (double value : row) print(value); + } + } + case "survival" -> { + List front = rows(m, n); + for (double value : scores(new AGEMOEAEnvironmentalSelection<>(n), front, n)) print(value); + for (double value : scores(selection, front, n)) print(value); + } + default -> throw new IllegalArgumentException("unknown case kind " + kind); + } + System.out.println(); + } + } +} From 74c4231f0b101395f4a37da37e9587c3f3452caa Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: NicolasRodriguezUribe Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:31:02 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] feat(tuning): AGE-MOEA's spaces choose AGE-MOEA-II, as Evolver's replacement Every AGE-MOEA space (real, constrained, binary, integer, permutation and mixed) offers replacement, Evolver's choice between AGE-MOEA's survival (agemoea, the default) and AGE-MOEA-II's (agemoea_ii, Evolver's agemoeaII). The bridge sets AGEMOEAConfig.variant, and the name table exchanges the parameter and its values with Evolver. The default still builds the configuration of VAMOS 1.4.0. agemoea_constrained now has more than 100 000 discrete combinations, so its exhaustive build moves to the slow tier and the fast tier samples it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- docs/reference/algorithms.md | 3 +++ docs/topics/tuning.md | 12 +++++++++++- .../racing/_bridge_assignment_builders.py | 2 ++ .../engine/tuning/racing/parameter_names.py | 6 ++++++ .../resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea.yaml | 2 ++ .../parameter_spaces/agemoea_binary.yaml | 2 ++ .../parameter_spaces/agemoea_constrained.yaml | 2 ++ .../parameter_spaces/agemoea_integer.yaml | 2 ++ .../parameter_spaces/agemoea_mixed.yaml | 2 ++ .../parameter_spaces/agemoea_permutation.yaml | 2 ++ .../engine/data/parameter_space_snapshot.json | 12 ++++++------ tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py | 19 +++++++++++++++++++ .../engine/test_operator_combo_validation.py | 2 ++ 13 files changed, 61 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/reference/algorithms.md b/docs/reference/algorithms.md index 68b581274..774312d82 100644 --- a/docs/reference/algorithms.md +++ b/docs/reference/algorithms.md @@ -209,6 +209,9 @@ point at the ideal point is not projected. pymoo takes the straight Euclidean distance when `0.95 < p < 1.05`; VAMOS, like jMetal, always goes through the midpoint, and both coincide when `p = 1`. +The tuning spaces of AGE-MOEA choose it with `replacement: agemoea_ii`, the +name of Evolver's parameter (`agemoeaII` in Evolver). + ### Where the variants depart from their references These are declared VAMOS choices, not defects; report them when comparing with diff --git a/docs/topics/tuning.md b/docs/topics/tuning.md index 37386c578..0a6886efe 100644 --- a/docs/topics/tuning.md +++ b/docs/topics/tuning.md @@ -536,6 +536,7 @@ The paragraphs above use the earlier names. | `normalization_epsilon` | `normalization_epsilon` | `epsilonParameterForNormalization` | | `ipbi_theta` | `ipbi_theta` | `ipbiTheta` | | `de_scheme` | `de_scheme` | `differentialEvolutionCrossover` | +| `replacement` | `replacement` | `replacement` | Values that change: mutation `pm` becomes `polynomial` (the name the other spaces already used) and crossover `undx` becomes `undc` (Evolver's `UNDC`). @@ -546,7 +547,9 @@ differently, and the exchange functions translate them: `SBX`, `blxAlpha`, `linkedPolynomial`, `nonUniform`, `levyFlight` and `powerLaw`; `tschebyscheff`, `weightedSum`, `penaltyBoundaryIntersection` and `modifiedTschebyscheff`; `default` (random; **VAMOS 1.4.0:** `auto`), `latinHypercubeSampling`, -`scatterSearch` and `oppositionBased`; `stochasticUniversalSampling`. +`scatterSearch` and `oppositionBased`; `stochasticUniversalSampling`; +**Development after 1.4.0:** AGE-MOEA's `replacement` `agemoeaII` +(`agemoea_ii`). **VAMOS 1.4.0:** Evolver's `modifiedTschebyscheff` is jMetal's `ModifiedTschebyscheff`, `max |f - z*| / w`, which VAMOS calls @@ -703,6 +706,13 @@ spaces of VAMOS 1.3.0, with `pop_size`, `use_external_archive` or an absolute `mutation_prob`, or with the names of VAMOS 1.2.1, builds the configuration it built. +**Development after 1.4.0:** every AGE-MOEA space (`agemoea`, `agemoea_constrained`, +`agemoea_binary`, `agemoea_integer`, `agemoea_permutation` and `agemoea_mixed`) +offers `replacement`, Evolver's choice between AGE-MOEA's survival (`agemoea`, +the default) and AGE-MOEA-II's (`agemoea_ii`, Evolver's `agemoeaII`); see +[AGE-MOEA-II](../reference/algorithms.md#age-moea-ii). The default still builds +the configuration of VAMOS 1.4.0. + ### Constrained spaces **VAMOS 1.2.0:** `nsgaii_constrained`, `nsgaiii_constrained`, diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/_bridge_assignment_builders.py b/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/_bridge_assignment_builders.py index 861d3beef..19c54e8c1 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/_bridge_assignment_builders.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/_bridge_assignment_builders.py @@ -356,6 +356,8 @@ def build_agemoea_config(assignment: dict[str, Any], *, mixed: bool = False) -> apply_optional_repair(builder, assignment) apply_optional_external_archive(builder, assignment, pop_size) apply_constraint_handling(builder, assignment) + if "replacement" in assignment: + builder.variant(assignment["replacement"]) return builder.build() diff --git a/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/parameter_names.py b/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/parameter_names.py index 80a2a6e4a..676cf7999 100644 --- a/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/parameter_names.py +++ b/src/vamos/engine/tuning/racing/parameter_names.py @@ -46,6 +46,8 @@ ("normalization_epsilon", "normalization_epsilon", "epsilonParameterForNormalization"), ("ipbi_theta", "ipbi_theta", "ipbiTheta"), ("de_scheme", "de_scheme", "differentialEvolutionCrossover"), + # Development after 1.4.0: AGE-MOEA's survival, Evolver's replacement of its AGE-MOEA: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's. + ("replacement", "replacement", "replacement"), ) # The values of categorical parameters, by the parameter's earlier name, in the same three forms. @@ -107,6 +109,10 @@ ("crossover_and_mutation", "crossover_and_mutation", "crossoverAndMutationVariation"), ("differential_evolution", "differential_evolution", "differentialEvolutionVariation"), ), + "replacement": ( + ("agemoea", "agemoea", "agemoea"), + ("agemoea_ii", "agemoea_ii", "agemoeaII"), + ), "selection": ( ("tournament", "tournament", "tournament"), ("random", "random", "random"), diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea.yaml index a484cd45e..a17726c7f 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea.yaml @@ -79,3 +79,5 @@ parameters: conditional_parameters: uniform_perturb: {type: real, default: 0.1, range: [0.01, 0.5], role: operator_rate} repair: {type: categorical, default: auto, values: [auto, clip, reflect, random], role: structural} + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_binary.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_binary.yaml index 4ab666458..d38333547 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_binary.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_binary.yaml @@ -31,3 +31,5 @@ parameters: global_sub_parameters: mutation_probability_factor: {type: real, default: 1.0, range: [0.25, 3.0], role: operator_rate} values: [bitflip, segment_inversion] + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_constrained.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_constrained.yaml index 10a01be8a..f861ad51e 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_constrained.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_constrained.yaml @@ -103,3 +103,5 @@ parameters: conditional_parameters: stochastic_ranking_probability: {type: real, default: 0.45, range: [0.0, 0.5], role: operator_rate} self_adaptive_penalty: {} + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_integer.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_integer.yaml index 9a9376de8..4a0a05588 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_integer.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_integer.yaml @@ -47,3 +47,5 @@ parameters: conditional_parameters: gaussian_sigma: {type: real, default: 1.0, range: [0.1, 5.0], role: operator_rate} boundary: {} + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_mixed.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_mixed.yaml index 74988a3f6..e48148453 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_mixed.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_mixed.yaml @@ -112,3 +112,5 @@ parameters: global_sub_parameters: cat_mutation_prob: {type: real, default: 0.1, range: [0.01, 0.5], role: operator_rate} values: [reset] + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_permutation.yaml b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_permutation.yaml index f21e9ebd5..371aa714a 100644 --- a/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_permutation.yaml +++ b/src/vamos/resources/parameter_spaces/agemoea_permutation.yaml @@ -31,3 +31,5 @@ parameters: global_sub_parameters: mutation_prob: {type: real, default: 0.1, range: [0.01, 0.5], role: operator_rate} values: [swap, insert, scramble, inversion, displacement, two_opt] + # The survival, as Evolver's replacement: AGE-MOEA's or AGE-MOEA-II's (Panichella, GECCO 2022). + replacement: {type: categorical, default: agemoea, values: [agemoea, agemoea_ii], role: structural} diff --git a/tests/engine/data/parameter_space_snapshot.json b/tests/engine/data/parameter_space_snapshot.json index f3ff88d86..daecf191f 100644 --- a/tests/engine/data/parameter_space_snapshot.json +++ b/tests/engine/data/parameter_space_snapshot.json @@ -1,12 +1,12 @@ { "settings": {"pop_size": 100, "n_obj": 2, "draws": 3}, "spaces": { - "agemoea": {"sha256":"36c2bb7ac5a7acc94ab2931e53604f49e3c70ec7a20551332c48cad8222d9998","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":15.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.6163894095744779,"alpha":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.30371125210782274}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.7600778375137347,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["pcx",{"prob":0.9263414216486129,"sigma_eta":0.011341865083372567,"sigma_zeta":0.430128095527909}],"mutation":["uniform",{"perturb":0.3675311687506726}],"repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.342360332090027,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["simplex",{"prob":0.8165844880996367,"epsilon":1.5994237810747696}],"mutation":["gaussian",{"sigma":0.06301735497328241}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":0.32787909565002316,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, - "agemoea_binary": {"sha256":"505c49835877d830671ea6c466351ca6d3d451cfd1fa36314ea1ef69ff05d7f8","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["uniform",{"prob":0.9}],"mutation":["bitflip",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["one_point",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["bitflip",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.295450997703455,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["two_point",{"prob":0.9651022309110887}],"mutation":["segment_inversion",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.2561155427059956,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["one_point",{"prob":0.9740289695151073}],"mutation":["segment_inversion",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.4935972738342134,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, - "agemoea_constrained": {"sha256":"6d581204924e745b94b98f0e0e767c1bbe90d8bca9103ed80c3c27c7640ce92a","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":15.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":["cdp",{}],"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.6163894095744779,"alpha":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.30371125210782274}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.7600778375137347,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":["stochastic_ranking",{"probability":0.27181249573271143}],"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["undx",{"prob":0.6010954000680592,"zeta":0.8716638489288124,"eta":0.13022701777491794}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.4317262822525934}],"repair":["reflect",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":20},"mutation_prob_factor":0.7330529566570373,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":["cdp",{}],"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.7690748884790634,"alpha":0.028319671145462966}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":27.651632905098754}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":2.0942171404074834,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":["push_pull",{"change_threshold":0.019245509957667984,"window_fraction":0.09974889422102899,"decay_fraction":0.9337100379597956,"exponent":7.1698778603262525,"feasibility_threshold":0.8252296381339081,"reduction_rate":0.34733889797976064}],"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, - "agemoea_integer": {"sha256":"66fe92ca5f108c6e5445e51d06054eff3595e7b77604618cd30a5d10c0b5dd43","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":20.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["creep",{"step":1}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.295450997703455,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.842654310306872,"eta":30.532379634439945}],"mutation":["gaussian",{"sigma":4.097682415195508}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.8214491654163627,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9429617106350278,"eta":6.175495135691253}],"mutation":["reset",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.2565524776823462,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, - "agemoea_mixed": {"sha256":"4b376c9f2c0aca3146844b5b5654e648356040edab2a1861ef70aa477103098a","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"prob":0.9}],"mutation":["mixed",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"perm_crossover":"pmx","perm_crossover_prob":0.6163894095744779,"real_crossover":"arithmetic","real_crossover_prob":0.925308095680109,"int_crossover":"uniform","int_crossover_prob":0.9651022309110887,"cat_crossover":"uniform","cat_crossover_prob":0.842654310306872}],"mutation":["mixed",{"perm_mutation":"displacement","perm_mutation_prob":0.2763762458180572,"real_mutation":"uniform_reset","real_mutation_prob":0.40976824151955077,"int_mutation":"polynomial","int_mutation_prob":0.011341865083372567,"int_mutation_eta":35.00914968056493,"cat_mutation":"reset","cat_mutation_prob":0.026456931899677537}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"perm_crossover":"pmx","perm_crossover_prob":0.9452715689399547,"real_crossover":"arithmetic","real_crossover_prob":0.719884756214954,"int_crossover":"arithmetic","int_crossover_prob":0.7690748884790634,"cat_crossover":"uniform","cat_crossover_prob":0.6113278684581852}],"mutation":["mixed",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.0942171404074834,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"maxmin","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"perm_crossover":"cycle","perm_crossover_prob":0.8461540445925015,"real_crossover":"mean","real_crossover_prob":0.9988839743156844,"int_crossover":"arithmetic","int_crossover_prob":0.992334135510492,"cat_crossover":"uniform","cat_crossover_prob":0.8742167937922778}],"mutation":["mixed",{"perm_mutation":"inversion","perm_mutation_prob":0.34733889797976064,"real_mutation":"polynomial","real_mutation_prob":0.07619728746098149,"real_mutation_eta":30.25209190679286,"int_mutation":"creep","int_mutation_prob":0.2674236180131057,"int_mutation_step":2,"cat_mutation":"reset","cat_mutation_prob":0.24805932582757664}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, - "agemoea_permutation": {"sha256":"03b9f999230f3e462090d229704e2fb4cec227b377ccdfd18da393e563e479f0","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["ox",{"prob":1.0}],"mutation":["swap",{"prob":0.1}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["cycle",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["insert",{"prob":0.018098541408979256}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["position",{"prob":0.9651022309110887}],"mutation":["inversion",{"prob":0.3674533148821592}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["cycle",{"prob":0.9740289695151073}],"mutation":["inversion",{"prob":0.40976824151955077}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, + "agemoea": {"sha256":"9f81e5ed0e7a80f2c1dc05c43fa20d8433fe4717ab8526c24f55623b888c509f","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":15.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.6163894095744779,"alpha":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.30371125210782274}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.7600778375137347,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["pcx",{"prob":0.9263414216486129,"sigma_eta":0.011341865083372567,"sigma_zeta":0.430128095527909}],"mutation":["uniform",{"perturb":0.3675311687506726}],"repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.342360332090027,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["pcx",{"prob":0.719884756214954,"sigma_eta":0.21711673838685264,"sigma_zeta":0.023876638861276854}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":27.651632905098754}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":10},"mutation_prob_factor":2.0942171404074834,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"}]}, + "agemoea_binary": {"sha256":"1439ab3dda25475a6bb3c9e6e8a084304e305aef391e0fab8cbcb230a8f0ad61","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["uniform",{"prob":0.9}],"mutation":["bitflip",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["one_point",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["bitflip",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.295450997703455,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["two_point",{"prob":0.842654310306872}],"mutation":["segment_inversion",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.744968726529913,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["two_point",{"prob":0.9263414216486129}],"mutation":["segment_inversion",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.607861760615816,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"}]}, + "agemoea_constrained": {"sha256":"1b57d8a3d8f605f76531431f84600aaf833f817945b93757313a792ee1a7d525","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":15.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":["cdp",{}],"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.6163894095744779,"alpha":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.30371125210782274}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.7600778375137347,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":["stochastic_ranking",{"probability":0.27181249573271143}],"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9429617106350278,"eta":6.175495135691253}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"gamma":0.4317262822525934}],"repair":["reflect",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":75},"mutation_prob_factor":0.7330529566570373,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"hv","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":["cdp",{}],"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.6113278684581852}],"mutation":["non_uniform",{"perturbation":0.5}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.5917790103738009,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":["stochastic_ranking",{"probability":0.32359475578712504}],"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"}]}, + "agemoea_integer": {"sha256":"22ed0ab08f57257276401d2d9b19541e13b9d2a54444b0e8d6bd2cbe5bb71d79","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.9,"eta":20.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["creep",{"step":1}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":0.295450997703455,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.842654310306872,"eta":30.532379634439945}],"mutation":["gaussian",{"sigma":4.097682415195508}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.8214491654163627,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.6134342301221857}],"mutation":["boundary",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.2565524776823462,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"crowding","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"}]}, + "agemoea_mixed": {"sha256":"61955a873acc5462e11d272c0f5b5496186dea5f5bb8afee929362a159ce767b","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"prob":0.9}],"mutation":["mixed",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"perm_crossover":"pmx","perm_crossover_prob":0.6163894095744779,"real_crossover":"arithmetic","real_crossover_prob":0.925308095680109,"int_crossover":"uniform","int_crossover_prob":0.9651022309110887,"cat_crossover":"uniform","cat_crossover_prob":0.842654310306872}],"mutation":["mixed",{"perm_mutation":"displacement","perm_mutation_prob":0.2763762458180572,"real_mutation":"uniform_reset","real_mutation_prob":0.40976824151955077,"int_mutation":"polynomial","int_mutation_prob":0.011341865083372567,"int_mutation_eta":35.00914968056493,"cat_mutation":"reset","cat_mutation_prob":0.026456931899677537}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"prob":0.9452715689399547}],"mutation":["mixed",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":1.0742076989778082,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"ref_dirs","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["mixed",{"prob":0.6113278684581852}],"mutation":["mixed",{}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":2.0942171404074834,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"}]}, + "agemoea_permutation": {"sha256":"a6e3d2dff91d9d928d8d4427234c84d88b82b2387304aea99e60d616a2017e58","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["ox",{"prob":1.0}],"mutation":["swap",{"prob":0.1}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["cycle",{"prob":0.6163894095744779}],"mutation":["insert",{"prob":0.018098541408979256}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["aex",{"prob":0.842654310306872}],"mutation":["two_opt",{"prob":0.2763762458180572}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":100,"pruning":"knn","hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea_ii"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["aex",{"prob":0.9263414216486129}],"mutation":["displacement",{"prob":0.430128095527909}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"random"},"mutation_prob_factor":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","track_genealogy":false,"result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":{"capacity":null,"hv_ref_point":null,"rng_seed":null,"objective_tolerance":0.0,"truncate_size":null,"deduplicate_in":"objective","decision_tolerance":1e-32},"constraint_handling":null,"live_callback_mode":"population","variant":"agemoea"}]}, "ccmo": {"sha256":"eef9569bae8ee6d61922b5462ade75a18d186c98f09093f49b701b188492bae4","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":1.0,"eta":20.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"1.0/n","eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["de",{"cr":0.04097352393619469,"f":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["linked_polynomial",{"prob":"2.486493157800749/n","eta":36.94644520472026}],"repair":["reflect",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":50},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["de",{"cr":0.5436249914654229,"f":0.9350724237877682}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"prob":"2.4935972738342134/n","gamma":0.0023665115849038996}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.6702622482410235}],"mutation":["cauchy",{"prob":"2.623742036462188/n","gamma":0.27118914890429674}],"repair":"auto","initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":50},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, "cmoeams": {"sha256":"8d35887a26b3d2e797fd87b7c1e185500bb702b3e8a208b551df0b1167ff31af","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":1.0,"eta":20.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"1.0/n","eta":20.0}],"feasible_ratio_threshold":0.5,"de_variant":"rand_1_bin","repair":"auto","initializer":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.6066110542114116,"eta":33.46445837200953}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"2.7600778375137347/n","eta":26.232252151851295}],"feasible_ratio_threshold":0.6095693498571635,"de_variant":"rand_1_bin","repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["de",{"cr":0.8158535541215322,"f":0.10246465015313329}],"mutation":["non_uniform",{"prob":"0.342360332090027/n","perturbation":0.5}],"feasible_ratio_threshold":0.5348999931723383,"de_variant":"rand_1_exp","repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["arithmetic",{"prob":0.8165844880996367}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"1.4123898582935608/n","eta":5.991188490091204}],"feasible_ratio_threshold":0.6837243571439553,"de_variant":"rand_1_bin","repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":20},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, "ctaea": {"sha256":"c384c2d719e3433acc823b6fc1e562c2325643ab01a57a24c83988c0ad8d5e63","configurations":[{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":1.0,"eta":20.0}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"1.0/n","eta":20.0}],"repair":"auto","initializer":null,"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.6163894095744779,"alpha":0.016527635528529094}],"mutation":["linked_polynomial",{"prob":"2.7600778375137347/n","eta":26.232252151851295}],"repair":["clip",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":50},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["blx_alpha",{"prob":0.9740289695151073,"alpha":0.8158535541215322}],"mutation":["uniform_reset",{"prob":"2.607861760615816/n"}],"repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"scatter","base_size":75},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"},{"pop_size":100,"crossover":["sbx",{"prob":0.8918621785719776,"eta":11.147946721089566}],"mutation":["polynomial",{"prob":"1.7390183556850023/n","eta":15.489916168808467}],"repair":["random",{}],"initializer":{"type":"lhs"},"constraint_mode":"feasibility","result_mode":"non_dominated","external_archive":null,"live_callback_mode":"population"}]}, diff --git a/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py b/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py index 7e8db66f5..057bfe850 100644 --- a/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py +++ b/tests/engine/test_agemoea_ii.py @@ -20,6 +20,8 @@ age_survival, ) from vamos.engine.algorithm.config.types import AGEMOEA_VARIANTS, resolve_agemoea_variant +from vamos.engine.tuning import config_from_assignment +from vamos.engine.tuning.racing.parameter_names import from_evolver, to_evolver from vamos.foundation.kernel.numpy_backend import NumPyKernel from vamos.problems import DTLZ2, LIRCMOP @@ -188,3 +190,20 @@ def test_agemoea_ii_runs_on_a_constrained_problem(technique: tuple[str, dict[str result = optimize(LIRCMOP(1, n_var=10), algorithm="agemoea", algorithm_config=config, max_evaluations=600, seed=2, engine="numpy") assert result.data["evaluations"] == 600 assert result.F.shape[1] == 2 and np.all(np.isfinite(result.F)) + + +# ---- Tuning ------------------------------------------------------------------------ + + +@pytest.mark.parametrize( + "space", ["agemoea", "agemoea_constrained", "agemoea_binary", "agemoea_integer", "agemoea_permutation", "agemoea_mixed"] +) +def test_every_agemoea_space_chooses_the_variant(space: str) -> None: + assert config_from_assignment(space, {"replacement": "agemoea_ii"}).variant == "agemoea_ii" # type: ignore[attr-defined] + assert config_from_assignment(space, {}).variant == "agemoea" # type: ignore[attr-defined] + + +def test_replacement_is_exchanged_with_evolver() -> None: + assert to_evolver({"replacement": "agemoea_ii"}) == {"replacement": "agemoeaII"} + assert from_evolver({"replacement": "agemoeaII"}) == {"replacement": "agemoea_ii"} + assert to_evolver({"replacement": "agemoea"}) == {"replacement": "agemoea"} diff --git a/tests/engine/test_operator_combo_validation.py b/tests/engine/test_operator_combo_validation.py index 4d115df32..6b7b94d64 100644 --- a/tests/engine/test_operator_combo_validation.py +++ b/tests/engine/test_operator_combo_validation.py @@ -356,6 +356,8 @@ def _inject_special_params(algo_name: str, assignment: dict[str, Any]) -> None: "moead_real", "moead_constrained_real", "moead_mixed_mixed", + # Development after 1.4.0: AGE-MOEA's replacement (AGE-MOEA-II) doubles its constrained space. + "agemoea_constrained_real", } # A prime stride over the base product reaches every value of every base parameter. _SAMPLE_BASE_STRIDE = 211