Skip to content

READINESS.adoc

Latest commit

 

History

History
89 lines (67 loc) · 3.13 KB

READINESS.adoc

File metadata and controls

89 lines (67 loc) · 3.13 KB
Raw

flat-mate Component Readiness Assessment

Standard: Component Readiness Grades (CRG) v1.0 Assessed: 2026-06-11 Assessor: Jonathan D.A. Jewell

Current Grade: C

Grade carried over from the prior TEST-NEEDS.md claim (CRG C, 2026-04-04) and re-assessed 2026-06-11. The grade applies to the matching engine library only — see honest notes below.

Grade Reference

Grade Name Release Stage Meaning

X

Untested

—

No testing performed. Status unknown.

F

Harmful / Wasteful

—

Reject, deprecate, or delegate.

E

Minimal / Salvageable

Pre-alpha

Barely functional. Needs redesign or major work.

D

Partial / Inconsistent

Alpha

Works on some things but not systematically.

C

Self-Validated

Beta

Dogfooded and reliable in home context.

B

Broadly Validated

Release Candidate

Tested on 6+ diverse external targets.

A

Field-Proven

Stable

Real-world feedback confirms value. No harm in wild.

Component Assessment

Component Grade Release Stage Evidence Summary Last Assessed

packages/shared/src/matching (engine v2)

C

Beta

35 unit tests passing across 5 test files; deterministic seed fixtures incl. a deliberately-broken group; lint/fmt clean.

2026-06-11

apps/api

X

—

No tests; not wired to engine v2; no auth.

2026-06-11

apps/web

X

—

No tests; legacy v0 UI; not wired to engine v2.

2026-06-11

apps/mobile

X

—

No tests; Expo app; not wired to engine v2.

2026-06-11

packages/shared/src/domain.js (legacy v0)

X

—

No tests; legacy swipe domain pending quarantine decision.

2026-06-11

Detailed Assessment

packages/shared/src/matching (engine v2)

  • Grade: C (Beta)

  • Last assessed: 2026-06-11

  • Evidence: 35 unit tests covering directional behaviour/tolerance scoring, dealbreakers, group audit (pairwise matrix, budget intersection, dispersion, shared-space minimum forecast), conceal tiers T0/T1/T2, agreement + brief artifacts, and the missing-data policy. Run with deno test packages/shared/src/matching/ --allow-read.

  • Known limitations: Library only — no app consumes it yet. Weights are literature-seeded, not fitted (calibration flywheel is roadmap LATER). No property-based tests.

  • Promotion path: Wire apps/web to auditGroup, real-cohort dogfooding in the Jan–May 2027 wave, external validation targets.

  • Demotion risk: Low — pure functions, deterministic fixtures.

Notes

  • Not production-ready. The tested engine is a library; the apps are unwired, untested, and have no authentication.

  • The legacy v0 swipe+listings stack remains in-tree (marked LEGACY) pending a quarantine/removal decision — see ROADMAP.adoc NEXT.

  • Grades are per-component, not per-project; the headline C reflects the engine library, the only dogfooded component.

  • See the full CRG standard for complete definitions, evidence requirements, and transition criteria.