You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The living vision promises one hardware-aware, runtime-configured Akroasis
binary, and current state explicitly says runtime selection plus a shared
collector boundary remain planned. Per-domain plans describe collectors, but
no live issue owns their application-wide lifecycle after the superseded
planning archive is removed.
Desired correction
Give the application one typed owner for configured collector discovery,
qualification, startup, health, restart, hot-plug, cancellation, and shutdown.
Per-domain crates retain their protocol logic and inject adapters into this
lifecycle rather than creating independent task supervisors.
Separate read-only discovery from model/protocol qualification. A cable,
VID:PID, or partial handshake alone cannot authorize writes.
Derive enabled collectors from validated configuration and accepted runtime
capabilities; unknown or unavailable hardware yields explicit state.
Bound queues, retries, restart rate, and task cardinality. Shutdown and
reconfiguration are deterministic and cancel-safe.
Route typed observations into the production Phase 03 signal path with
source identity, freshness, and observable drop/backpressure semantics.
Expose the same live lifecycle state to the CLI/service rather than fixed
placeholders or a second registry.
Operator-requested start/stop/reconfigure/restart consumes the accepted security(runtime): authorize direct effects through one validated caller context #409
caller context and lifecycle scope before transition. Automatic
startup/restart/hot-plug carries explicit accepted configuration/system-policy
authority; it never invents a human principal or bypasses the same bounds.
Before each lifecycle mutation, commit a minimized durable intent with
canonical collector reference plus configuration/policy/schema digest; append
success, partial, recovery, or failure outcome. Raw device paths, captured
payloads, and secrets never enter the receipt.
Done when
The application can start, stop, reconfigure, and report multiple fake
collectors through one lifecycle and deliver their signals to semaino.
Deterministic tests cover simultaneous startup, failed qualification,
disconnect/reconnect, hot-plug churn, stalled consumers, cancellation, and
clean shutdown without hardware.
Injected audit failure, partial transition, backpressure, and restart prove
the declared ordering and recovery relation; a collector does not become
accepted/running after an unrecorded transition.
Missing, stale, revoked, wrong-persona, or insufficient caller authority
performs zero operator-requested lifecycle transition; invalid automatic
system/config authority likewise fails closed.
A per-domain adapter cannot bypass the global bounds or claim a device is
ready before its own qualification contract succeeds.
Boundary
This issue owns the global runtime/lifecycle mechanism and its state-transition
receipts. Domain-specific wire and device acceptance stays with its domain
issues, including mesh #83/#84, radio #79/#80, and SDR qualification. #409 owns
the shared validated-caller type/resolver; this issue owns its lifecycle
adoption and distinguishes human from accepted system/config authority.
Hardware qualification is separately operator-scheduled; this issue authorizes
no hardware use.
Finding
The living vision promises one hardware-aware, runtime-configured Akroasis
binary, and current state explicitly says runtime selection plus a shared
collector boundary remain planned. Per-domain plans describe collectors, but
no live issue owns their application-wide lifecycle after the superseded
planning archive is removed.
Desired correction
Give the application one typed owner for configured collector discovery,
qualification, startup, health, restart, hot-plug, cancellation, and shutdown.
Per-domain crates retain their protocol logic and inject adapters into this
lifecycle rather than creating independent task supervisors.
VID:PID, or partial handshake alone cannot authorize writes.
capabilities; unknown or unavailable hardware yields explicit state.
reconfiguration are deterministic and cancel-safe.
source identity, freshness, and observable drop/backpressure semantics.
placeholders or a second registry.
caller context and lifecycle scope before transition. Automatic
startup/restart/hot-plug carries explicit accepted configuration/system-policy
authority; it never invents a human principal or bypasses the same bounds.
canonical collector reference plus configuration/policy/schema digest; append
success, partial, recovery, or failure outcome. Raw device paths, captured
payloads, and secrets never enter the receipt.
Done when
collectors through one lifecycle and deliver their signals to
semaino.disconnect/reconnect, hot-plug churn, stalled consumers, cancellation, and
clean shutdown without hardware.
the declared ordering and recovery relation; a collector does not become
accepted/running after an unrecorded transition.
performs zero operator-requested lifecycle transition; invalid automatic
system/config authority likewise fails closed.
ready before its own qualification contract succeeds.
Boundary
This issue owns the global runtime/lifecycle mechanism and its state-transition
receipts. Domain-specific wire and device acceptance stays with its domain
issues, including mesh #83/#84, radio #79/#80, and SDR qualification. #409 owns
the shared validated-caller type/resolver; this issue owns its lifecycle
adoption and distinguishes human from accepted system/config authority.
Hardware qualification is separately operator-scheduled; this issue authorizes
no hardware use.