Problem
chat send/edit --help says only "Message text in markdown format". It doesn't say the text is converted to Slack blocks (markdownToBlocks), nor that the API text field is kept as the raw-markdown fallback (used for notifications only).
That fallback field is a diagnosis trap. Re-fetching a sent message shows:
text: '**bold** and [link](<https://example.com>)' ← raw fallback, looks broken
blocks: '*bold* and <https://example.com|link>' ← what actually renders, correct
Newlines look collapsed in text too (para one para two) while blocks preserve paragraphs and soft breaks.
Verified fallout (2026-07-16, two independent Claude Code sessions):
- one concluded "holla collapses newlines" and bypassed holla with raw
chat.update calls;
- another concluded "markdown conversion doesn't happen,
**bold** renders literally" and started hand-writing mrkdwn — which the skill itself warns double-converts.
Both messages were in fact rendering perfectly; both sessions were reading the fallback text field.
Proposal
--help for chat send/reply/edit: one NOTE line — "standard markdown, rendered via Slack blocks; the API text field is a raw fallback — verify rendering via blocks, not text".
skills/slack/SKILL.md: add a "Verifying what was sent" section stating the same (check blocks, never judge rendering by text).
- (Optional)
chat get / post-send echo: render from blocks instead of message.text so the CLI itself doesn't display the misleading fallback.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Problem
chat send/edit --helpsays only "Message text in markdown format". It doesn't say the text is converted to Slack blocks (markdownToBlocks), nor that the APItextfield is kept as the raw-markdown fallback (used for notifications only).That fallback field is a diagnosis trap. Re-fetching a sent message shows:
Newlines look collapsed in
texttoo (para one para two) while blocks preserve paragraphs and soft breaks.Verified fallout (2026-07-16, two independent Claude Code sessions):
chat.updatecalls;**bold**renders literally" and started hand-writing mrkdwn — which the skill itself warns double-converts.Both messages were in fact rendering perfectly; both sessions were reading the fallback
textfield.Proposal
--helpforchat send/reply/edit: one NOTE line — "standard markdown, rendered via Slack blocks; the APItextfield is a raw fallback — verify rendering via blocks, not text".skills/slack/SKILL.md: add a "Verifying what was sent" section stating the same (checkblocks, never judge rendering bytext).chat get/ post-send echo: render from blocks instead ofmessage.textso the CLI itself doesn't display the misleading fallback.🤖 Generated with Claude Code