Results of validating ECFO using OOPS and FOOPS

[inaja]

OOPS
1.1. Important:
1.1.1. Missing disjointness
1.1.2. Missing domain or range: ecfo#hasApplicableLocation and 1 dc property (publisher), 2 qudt properties (abbreviation and value), and 1 schema (molecularFormula)
1.2. Minor
1.2.1. Unconnected elements: prov:Activity, prov:Entity, foaf:Organization, skos:Concept
1.2.2. Missing annotations: foaf:Organization
1.2.3. Missing explicit declaration of inverse relationshipts: 13 cases, 7 are peco: hasTag, hasEmissionTarget, hasScope, hasTargetUnit, hasApplicableLocation, hasSoutceUnit, hasApplicablePeriod, and hasEmissionSource. The rest are dc, time, and prov relationships.
1.2.4.URI contains file extension
FOOPS
2.1. Findable:
2.1.1.  Ontology in metadata registry: Ontology not found in a public registry
2.2. Accessible
2.2.1: FIND_3_BIS: Ontology not found in a public registry (would be solved along witl 2.1.1)
2.3. Interoperable: all good
2.4. Reusable:
2.4.1 Missing recommended metadata: citation and contributor.
2.4.2. Missing detailed metadata: doi, publisher, logo, status, source, issued, backwards compatibility
2.4.3. Missing optional basic provenance metadata: contributor
2.4.4. Missing detailed provenance metadata: issued, publisher

[dgarijo]

Thanks!
Similarly, from OOPS, no further action.
From FOOPS!:

• We are waiting for LOV approval
• We can add a few of these properties that are missing. None of the remarks seem critical, so we are good :)

[dgarijo]

Oh, logos should be solved soon (issue #2 )

[dgarijo]

LOV link: https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov/vocabs/ecfo

[inaja]

Sorry deleted previous comment by mistake:
Update on FOOPS: 98%

1. Findable: all good
2. Accessible: all good
3. Interoperable: all good
4. Reusable: 8.42/9
   4.1 Missing recommended metadata: citation. and optionally contributor.
   4.2. Missing detailed metadata: doi and source. and optionally backwards compatibility.
   4.3. Missing optional basic provenance metadata: contributor

[dgarijo]

I think we have reached a status where we can do a release so we obtain a DOI