From e63971ce0f0baad10a23d4844cebee1e42e229db Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Max Ghenis Date: Thu, 22 Oct 2026 12:50:27 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Record comparables for seven analyses published in September and October 2026 Backfill searches of every listed producer for the energy, free childcare, Middle East war, triple lock, child poverty, FUTA and 2025 SPM analyses, brought to the current comparables rules. The triple lock's gap to DWP is pending on uk-triple-lock#13. Index, database feeds and export pins are regenerated. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- app/public/data/lanes.json | 6 +- app/public/data/populations.json | 26802 ++++++++++++---- data/comparables/index.json | 7280 +++++ data/lanes.json | 6 +- data/populations.json | 26802 ++++++++++++---- .../README.md | 111 + .../analysis.json | 1500 + .../annotations.json | 235 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 30 + .../manifest.jsonl | 17 + .../search_log.json | 619 + .../README.md | 49 + .../analysis.json | 790 + .../annotations.json | 60 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 17 + .../manifest.jsonl | 4 + .../search_log.json | 342 + .../README.md | 49 + .../analysis.json | 1708 + .../annotations.json | 39 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 34 + .../manifest.jsonl | 13 + .../search_log.json | 339 + sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/README.md | 99 + sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/analysis.json | 1666 + .../analysis-uk-triple-lock/annotations.json | 244 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 35 + .../analysis-uk-triple-lock/manifest.jsonl | 18 + .../analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json | 329 + .../README.md | 41 + .../analysis.json | 3405 ++ .../annotations.json | 43 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 26 + .../manifest.jsonl | 1 + .../search_log.json | 227 + .../README.md | 74 + .../analysis.json | 1352 + .../annotations.json | 37 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 13 + .../manifest.jsonl | 11 + .../search_log.json | 1173 + .../README.md | 89 + .../analysis.json | 1734 + .../annotations.json | 151 + .../claims_staged.jsonl | 51 + .../manifest.jsonl | 6 + .../search_log.json | 284 + tests/test_export_populations.py | 6 +- 48 files changed, 65712 insertions(+), 12255 deletions(-) create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/search_log.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/README.md create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/search_log.json diff --git a/app/public/data/lanes.json b/app/public/data/lanes.json index 1c5cdb08c..b73c58b8f 100644 --- a/app/public/data/lanes.json +++ b/app/public/data/lanes.json @@ -587,7 +587,7 @@ "stage": "computed", "running": false, "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "1 analysis searched, 22 claims, 22 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "note": "5 analyses searched, 128 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" }, { "id": "analysis-comparables-us", @@ -595,10 +595,10 @@ "area": "every external estimate of each PolicyEngine analysis, found before it is published", "mode": 2, "country": "US", - "stage": "registered", + "stage": "computed", "running": false, "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "0 analyses searched, 0 claims, 0 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "note": "3 analyses searched, 90 claims, 69 PolicyEngine results beside them" } ] } diff --git a/app/public/data/populations.json b/app/public/data/populations.json index 2b9d79ab1..94c50dd78 100644 --- a/app/public/data/populations.json +++ b/app/public/data/populations.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "built": "2026-10-22", "note": "Non-Urban populations exported from scorecard.db: the populace reform-validation registry (issue #20) plus the compute campaign's attached comparisons (US: TPC/CPSP/PWBM/CBO/JCT; UK: the HMRC ready-reckoner family and the complete OBR Policy measures database, including historical HM Treasury scores; BE: JRC EUROMOD-BE claims with demo-grade Axiom concept-mismatch attachments and the 2026 PIT-reform scorekeeper claims; NZ: official budget scores). Claims explicitly opted into pre-result display remain in the feed with latest status not_computed and empty history. Recorded result statuses and calibration relationships are verbatim; nothing here is a pass/fail grade.", "summary": { - "claims": 29739, + "claims": 29935, "multi_release_claims": 270, "by_source": { "aspe_welfare_indicators": 14, @@ -106,20 +106,47 @@ "wi_admin": 1 }, "by_source_in_comparables_records": { - "centax": 14, - "centre_for_british_progress": 8 + "budget_lab": 34, + "cbo": 17, + "cbpp": 2, + "cebr": 2, + "census": 26, + "centax": 26, + "centre_for_british_progress": 30, + "cpsp": 3, + "desnz": 2, + "dwp": 4, + "electricity_bills_taskforce": 1, + "garfinkel_et_al": 1, + "good_energy": 5, + "green_party": 1, + "hm_treasury": 2, + "ifs": 10, + "ippr": 3, + "itep": 2, + "jrf": 3, + "mcs_foundation": 2, + "nef": 2, + "niesr": 3, + "ny_fiscal_note": 1, + "octopus_energy": 1, + "ppic": 1, + "rea": 2, + "resolution_foundation": 25, + "tuc": 4, + "urban": 3 }, "by_latest_status": { - "comparable": 50, - "concept_mismatch": 24, - "constructed": 1669, - "not_computed": 27107, + "comparable": 84, + "concept_mismatch": 131, + "constructed": 1675, + "not_computed": 27156, "pe_gap": 889 }, "by_sign_relative_to_pe": { "magnitude": 14, - "opposite": 489, - "same": 28967, + "opposite": 553, + "same": 29099, "unknown": 269 }, "by_country": { @@ -138,17 +165,17 @@ "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "UK": { - "claims": 29183, - "with_result": 2184, - "with_value": 1199, - "without_result": 26999, + "claims": 29289, + "with_result": 2262, + "with_value": 1277, + "without_result": 27027, "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "US": { - "claims": 535, - "with_result": 535, - "with_value": 535, - "without_result": 0, + "claims": 625, + "with_result": 604, + "with_value": 604, + "without_result": 21, "multi_release_claims": 270 } } @@ -3245,955 +3272,868 @@ } }, { - "claim_id": "498a3108cce7ef3cbf73", - "source": "ca_admin", + "claim_id": "4de87bbcbafc4b106762", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state_ca_eitc", - "name": "California CalEITC", - "window": "TY2023", - "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", - "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2023, + "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_eitc", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_eitc" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 941000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 941000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 1149547855.0776587, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2216236504544726, - "delta": 208547855.07765865 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 819736648.1434908, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.752.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1164308735.9892344, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1225375778.6142159, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1176093695.552145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1149547855.0776587, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9eda40b94ca5ce924e04", - "source": "ca_admin", + "claim_id": "88ef5c5d997294ef224e", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state_ca_yctc", - "name": "California Young Child Tax Credit", - "window": "TY2023", - "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", - "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2023, + "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_yctc", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_yctc" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 413000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 413000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 621910038.0736201, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5058354432775305, - "delta": 208910038.07362008 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 572858122.8276322, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.752.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 641544372.2220612, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 596007571.7019713, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 579675158.4393413, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 621910038.0736201, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "concept_mismatch", - "rationale": "[batch2 D6, confidence medium] Flat refundable child credits (CA YCTC, CO FAC, MD CTC): PE pays full entitlement to every eligible unit, benchmarks count claims", - "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/D.md" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c9b762228722c8e68305", - "source": "ca_fiscal_note", + "claim_id": "e12f890895a1c51811be", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state.ca.ab2591", - "name": "CA AB2591 \u2014 standard deduction increase", - "window": "first full year (FY2027-28)", - "publication_title": "CA FTB via Assembly Revenue & Taxation analysis", - "url": "https://trackbill.com/s3/bills/CA/2025/AB2591", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2028, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "a8f8aa819449e6cf", - "external_value": -7000000000.0, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", - "external_value_pe_sign": -7000000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -6472662333.456696, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9246660476366708, - "delta": 527337666.54330444 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": -5951172549.383606, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.729.0", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6461187332.940857, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6387695352.5572815, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6408273121.757233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6472662333.456696, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1de831292608256d5c2e", - "source": "capital_economics", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "claim_id": "4223cb41ee06165eb1b1", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", - "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "2029-30", - "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", - "reform_hint": "Tax rises of about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November, mostly for households and potentially on property", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", - "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "program": "package", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [], - "parameter_paths": [] + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.5", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", - "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4500000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.857800662444444, + "delta": 17360102981.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "63690887dee50ca31c89", - "source": "capital_economics", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "claim_id": "c214baae04e236c6bda6", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", - "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "2029-30", - "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", - "reform_hint": "raise taxes by about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", - "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "program": "package", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [], - "parameter_paths": [] + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", - "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.083744879302325, + "delta": 17560102981.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9412a33dffe76806b2f5", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "99150d4ff16bf17af23e", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Beneficiary (Dollars)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "per": "beneficiary", - "program": "ssi" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 751.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 4600000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 751.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 789.2905812238647, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0509861267960914, - "delta": 38.290581223864706 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.752196300217391, + "delta": 17260102981.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 789.3138964940113, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 789.2905812238647, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ee5f9b6d36786a5acd03", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "ea3d4478f6cc25aa4308", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Participant (Dollars)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "per": "participant", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.7", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 186.6, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4700000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 186.6, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4700000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 134.25440536253626, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7194769847938707, - "delta": -52.34559463746373 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.841985955106383, + "delta": 18057333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 129.7045752084306, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 134.25440536253626, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6e8f56211bba4272cc31", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "f64af0e6d55ea2c03f9d", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax credits", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "outlays", - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", - "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted", - "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.041351550461811, - "delta": 4321815944.965698 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.292403253255814, + "delta": 18457333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 109071629469.4516, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "eb4cb3d5e81cdf1c63fb", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "03374839dd84e2ef087f", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax creditsd", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "outlays", - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", - "timing": "unadjusted", - "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.041351550461811, - "delta": 4321815944.965698 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.5514667978, + "delta": 17757333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 109071629469.4516, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a44c8e195796cee4e5d7", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "8f9b54af382f54175e11", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Estimated Budget Authority", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "budget_concept": "budget_authority", - "component": "total", - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.8", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 98415000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4800000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 98415000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4800000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 100265316841.38287, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0188011669093417, - "delta": 1850316841.3828735 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.934900797708333, + "delta": 18887523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 90927596849.523, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 100265316841.38287, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2fce267a8ea74d79cdff", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "cecca370a8224315ec80", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Estimated Outlays", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51314-2026-02-tanf.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "tanf", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "total_outlays", - "funder": "federal", - "geography": "US", - "program": "tanf" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 16968000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 16968000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 5045530740.344602, + "value": 23687523829.0, "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", - "ratio": 0.297355654192869, - "delta": -11922469259.6554 + "ratio": 5.508726471860465, + "delta": 19387523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 4936866453.148398, - "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" - }, - { - "value": 5045530740.344602, + "value": 23687523829.0, "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } @@ -4201,1061 +4141,6477 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ffc6d48f894e88134428", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "b35d9b4e066906458cf3", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", - "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 66500000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 66500000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 57855559925.80327, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8700084199368913, - "delta": -8644440074.196732 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.4693441186792455, + "delta": 18387523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 57857268951.65666, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 57855559925.80327, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c7a6ced57044b52a7f91", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "af5a2b191d6052caf288", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Beneficiaries (Thousands of people)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "participant_count", - "unit_concept": "persons", - "value_kind": "count", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 7275000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 7275000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8396415796788986, - "delta": -1166607.5078360122 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.925051316, + "delta": 19625256580.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9be64cb6bef0d6d3da07", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "dd27153805106d58d12b", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Participation (Millions of people)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "participant_count", - "unit_concept": "persons", - "value_kind": "count", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 39300000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 39300000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 62235894.96041095, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5836105587890827, - "delta": 22935894.960410953 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.726803855813953, + "delta": 20325256580.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 58419679.68580754, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a57174c823740e575fd0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.397367246428572, + "delta": 19025256580.0 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 62235894.96041095, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b9df9a9de41ba44a3979", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "5e67a7f6b938c2fabfe4", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "federal.cbo_rates_plus_1pt", - "name": "CBO option \u2014 all individual rates +1pt (applied to 2024 data)", - "window": "FY2026 (first full fiscal year)", - "publication_title": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2025 to 2034 (Dec 2024), 'Increase Individual Income Tax Rates on Ordinary Income', alternative 1 (JCT staff estimate)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/60937", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "pre_obbba_current_law", - "geography": "US" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.2", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "098098619723de7a", - "external_value": 106300000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5200000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", - "external_value_pe_sign": 106300000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5200000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 114386696495.23145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0760742849974736, - "delta": 8086696495.231445 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.909059552307692, + "delta": 20327109672.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 113870114490.94482, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5d42479d7aac10e23abe", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.801615834545455, + "delta": 21127109672.0 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 114386696495.23145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "baa3949221e1f4fa6342", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "96606fc1cac2d351d809", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2025, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", - "income_group": "quintile_1", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a349" + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": -49.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -49.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.254518278666667, + "delta": 19527109672.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d6137cfae4ffb901b7ad", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "14104aa384fd414754dc", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2025, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", - "income_group": "quintile_2", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": -45.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5400000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.902663997407408, + "delta": 21074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acc579c767cf601096b3", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "28878b535852b486bb7d", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "minimum_wage_bite", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2026, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "statistic": "minimum wage as a percentage of the median wage", - "value_verbatim": "62.1%" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 62.1, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 62.1, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.016905815, + "delta": 22074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "337c36901cfd1efcf367", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "416986432aea7c93ef8d", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a312.71", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Living Wage (21 and over)", - "value_verbatim": "1.6%" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 1.6, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.1366227478125, + "delta": 20074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8a11612d6cd9f9163719", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "29734dd65b06be2bac40", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a310.85", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (18-20)", - "value_verbatim": "5.9%" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 5.9, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.905719434285714, + "delta": 21872028832.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9df5404e8cb5c0a5f64a", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "1542f87bf8e409590e6f", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a38.00", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (16-17 and apprentices)", - "value_verbatim": "3.4%" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 3.4, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.243642916363636, + "delta": 23072028832.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d824ee34586fb61b5be0", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "31938eabe9ec4eeb3096", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2029, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2028-29", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.9 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.8", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.04000424, + "delta": 20672028832.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "96919300c9a479caa0f0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.9", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 4900000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5900000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5900000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 4838076868.264832, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9873626261764963, - "delta": -61923131.73516846 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.820461199661017, + "delta": 22540721078.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 4838076868.264832, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cc51fbb31e03b3a5ee67", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "547af640d4aa079506f0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a310.5 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.463800245, + "delta": 24040721078.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0d1ca2899f521e67ad9", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "7.2", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 10500000000.0, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 7200000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 10500000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7200000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7601212159198754, - "delta": -2518727232.8413086 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 3.950100149722222, + "delta": 21240721078.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a3b8e2b1054c2d67c51", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "2a089b2f7a12febdd013", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.1", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 6100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.828760355409836, + "delta": 23355438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9f677b7373f8e49f0781", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "51.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 51600000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 51600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 13347079049.836914, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, - "delta": -2552920950.163086 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.866064177887597, + "delta": 199488911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "286f29324862e5230a70", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.694417765454546, + "delta": 25055438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "93b6be20039f05fc1761", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "43.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 43600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 43600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.758919990344037, + "delta": 207488911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e56810b2d3f1c65a08a8", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "7.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 7600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 3.8757155484210526, + "delta": 21855438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "887b939bccb1285ca035", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "58.7", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 58700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 58700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.277494234735945, + "delta": 192388911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3e2e1acd1b7f8d9c5ede", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "baseline FUTA revenues over the decade", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "baseline projection benchmarked to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab prints a ten-year total; the dashboard's results files print current-law FUTA revenue one calendar year at a time and publish no ten-year baseline total.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "statistic": "approximate ('about $64B')", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "$64B", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 64000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 64000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6245556391.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-baseline-decade-total: The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.097586818609375, + "delta": -57754443609.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6245556391.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-baseline-decade-total: The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "498a3108cce7ef3cbf73", + "source": "ca_admin", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state_ca_eitc", + "name": "California CalEITC", + "window": "TY2023", + "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", + "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_eitc", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_eitc" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 941000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 941000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 1149547855.0776587, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2216236504544726, + "delta": 208547855.07765865 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 819736648.1434908, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.752.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1164308735.9892344, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1225375778.6142159, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1176093695.552145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1149547855.0776587, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9eda40b94ca5ce924e04", + "source": "ca_admin", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state_ca_yctc", + "name": "California Young Child Tax Credit", + "window": "TY2023", + "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", + "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_yctc", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_yctc" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 413000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 413000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 621910038.0736201, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5058354432775305, + "delta": 208910038.07362008 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 572858122.8276322, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.752.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 641544372.2220612, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 596007571.7019713, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 579675158.4393413, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 621910038.0736201, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "concept_mismatch", + "rationale": "[batch2 D6, confidence medium] Flat refundable child credits (CA YCTC, CO FAC, MD CTC): PE pays full entitlement to every eligible unit, benchmarks count claims", + "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/D.md" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "c9b762228722c8e68305", + "source": "ca_fiscal_note", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state.ca.ab2591", + "name": "CA AB2591 \u2014 standard deduction increase", + "window": "first full year (FY2027-28)", + "publication_title": "CA FTB via Assembly Revenue & Taxation analysis", + "url": "https://trackbill.com/s3/bills/CA/2025/AB2591", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a8f8aa819449e6cf", + "external_value": -7000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -6472662333.456696, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9246660476366708, + "delta": 527337666.54330444 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -5951172549.383606, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.729.0", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6461187332.940857, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6387695352.5572815, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6408273121.757233, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6472662333.456696, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1de831292608256d5c2e", + "source": "capital_economics", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "2029-30", + "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", + "reform_hint": "Tax rises of about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November, mostly for households and potentially on property", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", + "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "program": "package", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", + "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "63690887dee50ca31c89", + "source": "capital_economics", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "2029-30", + "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", + "reform_hint": "raise taxes by about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", + "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "program": "package", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", + "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9412a33dffe76806b2f5", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Beneficiary (Dollars)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "per": "beneficiary", + "program": "ssi" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 751.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 751.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 789.2905812238647, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0509861267960914, + "delta": 38.290581223864706 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 789.3138964940113, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 789.2905812238647, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ee5f9b6d36786a5acd03", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Participant (Dollars)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "per": "participant", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 186.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 186.6, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 134.25440536253626, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7194769847938707, + "delta": -52.34559463746373 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 129.7045752084306, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 134.25440536253626, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6e8f56211bba4272cc31", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax credits", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "conditions": { + "component": "outlays", + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted", + "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.041351550461811, + "delta": 4321815944.965698 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 109071629469.4516, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "eb4cb3d5e81cdf1c63fb", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax creditsd", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "conditions": { + "component": "outlays", + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "timing": "unadjusted", + "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.041351550461811, + "delta": 4321815944.965698 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 109071629469.4516, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a44c8e195796cee4e5d7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Estimated Budget Authority", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "budget_concept": "budget_authority", + "component": "total", + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 98415000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 98415000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 100265316841.38287, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0188011669093417, + "delta": 1850316841.3828735 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 90927596849.523, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 100265316841.38287, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2fce267a8ea74d79cdff", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Estimated Outlays", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51314-2026-02-tanf.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "tanf", + "conditions": { + "component": "total_outlays", + "funder": "federal", + "geography": "US", + "program": "tanf" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 16968000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 16968000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 5045530740.344602, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.297355654192869, + "delta": -11922469259.6554 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4936866453.148398, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + }, + { + "value": 5045530740.344602, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ffc6d48f894e88134428", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 66500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 66500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 57855559925.80327, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8700084199368913, + "delta": -8644440074.196732 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 57857268951.65666, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 57855559925.80327, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c7a6ced57044b52a7f91", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Beneficiaries (Thousands of people)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "participant_count", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 7275000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7275000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8396415796788986, + "delta": -1166607.5078360122 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9be64cb6bef0d6d3da07", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Participation (Millions of people)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "participant_count", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 39300000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 39300000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 62235894.96041095, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5836105587890827, + "delta": 22935894.960410953 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 58419679.68580754, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 62235894.96041095, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5ff7fcd866a6f1a923ad", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-1.3" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -1300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -15.991546818461538, + "delta": 22089010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2192be5b3a1d77372203", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, 2026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 24, second alternative", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-3.7" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "63b6d79143266903", + "external_value": -3700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -5.618651584864865, + "delta": 24489010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "457c21d6e672dd77ba93", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, Total 2017\u20132026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "fiscal_year": "FY2017-FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 24, second alternative", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "13.1", + "window": "2017-2026", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "63b6d79143266903", + "external_value": 13100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 13100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.5869473941984733, + "delta": 7689010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b9df9a9de41ba44a3979", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "federal.cbo_rates_plus_1pt", + "name": "CBO option \u2014 all individual rates +1pt (applied to 2024 data)", + "window": "FY2026 (first full fiscal year)", + "publication_title": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2025 to 2034 (Dec 2024), 'Increase Individual Income Tax Rates on Ordinary Income', alternative 1 (JCT staff estimate)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/60937", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "geography": "US" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "098098619723de7a", + "external_value": 106300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", + "external_value_pe_sign": 106300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 114386696495.23145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0760742849974736, + "delta": 8086696495.231445 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 113870114490.94482, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 114386696495.23145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "02ec96dabbab418c4329", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2027", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2027", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-1.9" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -1900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -11.505317358421053, + "delta": 23760102981.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c7103bd74c8dc385924a", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2028", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2028", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-2.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -2500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -9.1029335956, + "delta": 25257333989.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a9046938ff191e2752ed", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, Total 2019\u20132028", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "fiscal_year": "FY2019-FY2028", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "18.1", + "window": "2019-2028", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": 18100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 18100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.2573112701104971, + "delta": 4657333989.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b371bad3af122578c56f", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2025", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2025", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "8.461" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 8461000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8461000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 8493387632.705948, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025\", \"field\": \"validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_fiscal_year_basis\", \"path\": \"frontend/lib/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "annotations": [ + "fiscal-year-futa-collections-construction: The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0038278729117065, + "delta": 32387632.705947876 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 8493387632.705948, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025\", \"field\": \"validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_fiscal_year_basis\", \"path\": \"frontend/lib/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "annotations": [ + "fiscal-year-futa-collections-construction: The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "44747dda3235ec751a3d", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2026", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2026", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "8.948" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 8948000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8948000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4c4f771ee61b51f08fb7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2027", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2027", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2027", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "9.422" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 9422000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 9422000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "dd6f65ee56c6b27cfccb", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2028", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2028", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2028", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "10.007" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 10007000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 10007000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1c218ee794bdad15f168", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2029", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2029", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2029", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "11.345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 11345000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 11345000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ba79ffb3bfd3abea1c01", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2030", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2030", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2030", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "12.846" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 12846000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 12846000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c8dfb4e81b237c014d11", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2031", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2031", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2031", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "14.669" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 14669000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 14669000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "331d5b6a90f45a9f5769", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2032", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2032", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2032", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "16.548" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 16548000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 16548000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e3585e4aeb71f761382c", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2033", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2033", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2033", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "18.402" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 18402000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 18402000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1099266a7ad7ae8db9a7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2034", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2034", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2034", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "19.962" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 19962000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 19962000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "299a3d53d512778e1ce8", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2035", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2035", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2035", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "21.132" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 21132000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 21132000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1cfdcb726ba9b109c441", + "source": "cbpp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Would be lifted above the poverty line by expansion", + "name": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_children_lifted_ca_2024", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores the 2021 design in tax year 2024, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children under 18", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = children lifted above the poverty line, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "tax_year": "2024", + "value_verbatim": "318,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 318000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -318000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2718f2fecf59738f781f", + "source": "cbpp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Total", + "name": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "tcja_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "relative to before American Rescue Plan's temporary expansion", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores tax year 2021 against pre-Rescue Plan law (the $2,000 TCJA credit); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children under 18", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the number of children in poverty, in percent", + "tax_year": "2021", + "value_verbatim": "34%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "45217df19876662b", + "external_value": 34.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -34.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "tcja_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "baa3949221e1f4fa6342", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", + "income_group": "quintile_1", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a349" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": -49.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -49.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d6137cfae4ffb901b7ad", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", + "income_group": "quintile_2", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": -45.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d2b3c34b04894a26a36c", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2026", + "name": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2026", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2026 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes \u00a31,100 lower)", + "statistic": "mean (average UK household)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31,100" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 1100.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1100.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6330cee4b5c8cebd26c9", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2027", + "name": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2027", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2027 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes \u00a31,300 lower)", + "statistic": "mean (average UK household)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31,300" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 1300.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "acc579c767cf601096b3", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "minimum_wage_bite", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "minimum wage as a percentage of the median wage", + "value_verbatim": "62.1%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 62.1, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 62.1, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "337c36901cfd1efcf367", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a312.71", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Living Wage (21 and over)", + "value_verbatim": "1.6%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 1.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8a11612d6cd9f9163719", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a310.85", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (18-20)", + "value_verbatim": "5.9%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 5.9, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9df5404e8cb5c0a5f64a", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a38.00", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (16-17 and apprentices)", + "value_verbatim": "3.4%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 3.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d824ee34586fb61b5be0", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 4900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 4838076868.264832, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9873626261764963, + "delta": -61923131.73516846 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4838076868.264832, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "cc51fbb31e03b3a5ee67", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a310.5 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 10500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 10500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7601212159198754, + "delta": -2518727232.8413086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4a3b8e2b1054c2d67c51", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, + "delta": -2552920950.163086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6daca0af5539cb3b9dde", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/cebrs-reaction-the-autumn-budget-2025/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, + "delta": -2552920950.163086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e931e849f18e52572ae2", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ak", + "name": "Alaska SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AK", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.106, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0985307152971824, + "delta": 0.010444255821501339 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.10329803285169523, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e4d83b427fc214ea4eb3", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_al", + "name": "Alabama SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.1310747038068096, + "delta": 0.019136906755794214 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1505569333413196, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4d6626b38d8bd84c6e7d", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ar", + "name": "Arkansas SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AR", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AR", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.5566199389781833, + "delta": -0.06473348890918523 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.11503155907237178, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7537730fcc7aa9722282", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_az", + "name": "Arizona SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AZ", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AZ", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.147, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.039673436870702, + "delta": 0.005831995219993169 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1921782872434054, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "364841741d272c58b038", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ca", + "name": "California SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.182, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.182, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2629218907726096, + "delta": 0.04785178412061494 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.2159505536043489, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "bc66a347f2c2aa136efe", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_co", + "name": "Colorado SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CO", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CO", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.077, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.4289637601480423, + "delta": 0.03303020953139926 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.13855390686776925, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d69d7a081344f1b4a729", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ct", + "name": "Connecticut SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CT", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CT", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.109, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.3083926442580418, + "delta": 0.033614798224126566 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.17263896958254063, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2cebdc00578e54b45a22", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_dc", + "name": "District of Columbia SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DC", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "DC", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.187, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.187, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.43688408529283, + "delta": 0.0816973239497592 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.14467308939448856, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5be90ddb7e953a22fe29", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_de", + "name": "Delaware SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DE", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "DE", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.103, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.896440171364231, + "delta": 0.09233333765051578 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.22695217212887303, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "e4a68546c4be960ea5d1", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_fl", + "name": "Florida SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "FL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "FL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.176, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.176, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5673740035802572, + "delta": 0.09985782463012527 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.310077108061372, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "ae7020f71018aa71e13b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ga", + "name": "Georgia SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "GA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "GA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.137, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.137, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2492671989835735, + "delta": 0.03414960626074959 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.15099892503706577, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d80f38afc52ad764420b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_hi", + "name": "Hawaii SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "HI", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "HI", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.122, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.122, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7296468117411257, + "delta": -0.032983088967582674 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.10759347113653098, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "664f55921193cc68fe99", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ia", + "name": "Iowa SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "IA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.07, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.1334667332852384, + "delta": 0.00934267132996669 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.12356060759864736, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9b9854e0a7826d3f6971", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_id", + "name": "Idaho SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "ID", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "ID", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.058, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.425414499426542, + "delta": 0.02467404096673944 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.04319380943090882, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "60ca60bce71f685cf470", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_il", + "name": "Illinois SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "IL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.109, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2889150866478662, + "delta": 0.03149174444461743 }, "results": [ { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.22407192001757978, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6daca0af5539cb3b9dde", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/cebrs-reaction-the-autumn-budget-2025/", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", + "claim_id": "ff7246abfe3677335ca6", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_in", + "name": "Indiana SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "geography": "IN", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.1213452458502143, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, - "delta": -2552920950.163086 + "ratio": 1.3334642401122452, + "delta": 0.03034524585021431 }, "results": [ { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.1401888779452793, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e931e849f18e52572ae2", + "claim_id": "5b236b30fa3880759154", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ak", - "name": "Alaska SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ks", + "name": "Kansas SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5266,24 +10622,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.106, + "external_value": 0.097, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.097, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "value": 0.07687780380679853, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5294,12 +10650,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0985307152971824, - "delta": 0.010444255821501339 + "ratio": 0.7925546784206033, + "delta": -0.020122196193201478 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10329803285169523, + "value": 0.11049707808530514, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5312,7 +10668,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "value": 0.07687780380679853, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5328,11 +10684,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e4d83b427fc214ea4eb3", + "claim_id": "a3cc89a80759ebd0e943", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_al", - "name": "Alabama SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ky", + "name": "Kentucky SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5343,24 +10699,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.146, + "external_value": 0.158, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "value": 0.161467256006912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5371,12 +10727,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1310747038068096, - "delta": 0.019136906755794214 + "ratio": 1.021944658271595, + "delta": 0.0034672560069120006 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1505569333413196, + "value": 0.16650483237144315, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5389,7 +10745,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "value": 0.161467256006912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5405,11 +10761,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4d6626b38d8bd84c6e7d", + "claim_id": "53520f720a63c7550d45", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ar", - "name": "Arkansas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_la", + "name": "Louisiana SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5420,24 +10776,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.146, + "external_value": 0.189, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.189, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "value": 0.125609622841254, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5448,12 +10804,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5566199389781833, - "delta": -0.06473348890918523 + "ratio": 0.6646011790542539, + "delta": -0.06339037715874601 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11503155907237178, + "value": 0.14878938671226047, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5466,7 +10822,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "value": 0.125609622841254, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5482,11 +10838,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7537730fcc7aa9722282", + "claim_id": "bd4ea8335108373296f7", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_az", - "name": "Arizona SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ma", + "name": "Massachusetts SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5497,24 +10853,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.147, + "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "value": 0.19868201101176794, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5525,12 +10881,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.039673436870702, - "delta": 0.005831995219993169 + "ratio": 1.7127759569979994, + "delta": 0.08268201101176793 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1921782872434054, + "value": 0.15018924622184068, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5543,7 +10899,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "value": 0.19868201101176794, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5556,14 +10912,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "364841741d272c58b038", + "claim_id": "fee6a482e8ac1fc33989", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ca", - "name": "California SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_md", + "name": "Maryland SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5574,24 +10934,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.182, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.182, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "value": 0.11005888615244076, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5602,12 +10962,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2629218907726096, - "delta": 0.04785178412061494 + "ratio": 0.8875716625196836, + "delta": -0.013941113847559236 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2159505536043489, + "value": 0.2138827361406449, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5620,7 +10980,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "value": 0.11005888615244076, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5636,11 +10996,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bc66a347f2c2aa136efe", + "claim_id": "8896cdbb8213f271fcc1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_co", - "name": "Colorado SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_me", + "name": "Maine SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5651,24 +11011,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "external_value": 0.05, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.05, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "value": 0.12448915934503967, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5679,12 +11039,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4289637601480423, - "delta": 0.03303020953139926 + "ratio": 2.489783186900793, + "delta": 0.07448915934503966 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13855390686776925, + "value": 0.09936430562401276, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5697,7 +11057,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "value": 0.12448915934503967, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5710,14 +11070,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "d69d7a081344f1b4a729", + "claim_id": "ee8a446834a4da49903b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ct", - "name": "Connecticut SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mi", + "name": "Michigan SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5728,24 +11092,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.109, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "value": 0.1055862855424053, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5756,12 +11120,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3083926442580418, - "delta": 0.033614798224126566 + "ratio": 1.025109568372867, + "delta": 0.002586285542405309 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17263896958254063, + "value": 0.1134851140594787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5774,7 +11138,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "value": 0.1055862855424053, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5790,11 +11154,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2cebdc00578e54b45a22", + "claim_id": "6bd14bde63071d64404b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_dc", - "name": "District of Columbia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mn", + "name": "Minnesota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5805,24 +11169,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.187, + "external_value": 0.063, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.187, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.063, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "value": 0.08431433826871325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5833,12 +11197,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.43688408529283, - "delta": 0.0816973239497592 + "ratio": 1.338322829662115, + "delta": 0.021314338268713248 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14467308939448856, + "value": 0.07686412373532482, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5851,7 +11215,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "value": 0.08431433826871325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5867,11 +11231,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5be90ddb7e953a22fe29", + "claim_id": "780a950917b74d17f667", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_de", - "name": "Delaware SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mo", + "name": "Missouri SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5882,24 +11246,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "value": 0.14744900886546072, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5910,12 +11274,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.896440171364231, - "delta": 0.09233333765051578 + "ratio": 1.3652686006061179, + "delta": 0.039449008865460725 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.22695217212887303, + "value": 0.17194807589432126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5928,7 +11292,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "value": 0.14744900886546072, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5941,18 +11305,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e4a68546c4be960ea5d1", + "claim_id": "a27d4ff28bdfca616cb8", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_fl", - "name": "Florida SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ms", + "name": "Mississippi SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5963,24 +11323,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.176, + "external_value": 0.171, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.176, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.171, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "value": 0.12213435064693424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5991,12 +11351,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5673740035802572, - "delta": 0.09985782463012527 + "ratio": 0.7142359686955219, + "delta": -0.04886564935306577 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.310077108061372, + "value": 0.12754007054566846, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6009,7 +11369,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "value": 0.12213435064693424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6022,18 +11382,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae7020f71018aa71e13b", + "claim_id": "0e68641d4fe06928f3ed", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ga", - "name": "Georgia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mt", + "name": "Montana SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6044,24 +11400,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.137, + "external_value": 0.081, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.137, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "value": 0.025309432293635373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6072,12 +11428,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2492671989835735, - "delta": 0.03414960626074959 + "ratio": 0.3124621270819182, + "delta": -0.05569056770636463 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15099892503706577, + "value": 0.10992399534280023, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6090,7 +11446,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "value": 0.025309432293635373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6103,14 +11459,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C4, confidence high] Montana child SPM 0.31x: three cloned source families on about 52 effective households; one is a Census negative-resources artifact", + "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/C.md" + } }, { - "claim_id": "d80f38afc52ad764420b", + "claim_id": "8e871b8216783c3198e1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_hi", - "name": "Hawaii SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nc", + "name": "North Carolina SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6121,24 +11481,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.122, + "external_value": 0.152, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.122, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.152, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "value": 0.1542939471948945, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6149,12 +11509,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7296468117411257, - "delta": -0.032983088967582674 + "ratio": 1.015091757861148, + "delta": 0.002293947194894508 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10759347113653098, + "value": 0.14332420570803683, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6167,7 +11527,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "value": 0.1542939471948945, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6183,11 +11543,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "664f55921193cc68fe99", + "claim_id": "6d24cdfdc704c93ea20e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ia", - "name": "Iowa SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nd", + "name": "North Dakota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6198,24 +11558,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.07, + "external_value": 0.092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "value": 0.1065848033863872, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6226,12 +11586,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1334667332852384, - "delta": 0.00934267132996669 + "ratio": 1.1585304715911653, + "delta": 0.014584803386387207 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12356060759864736, + "value": 0.07863050110524529, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6244,7 +11604,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "value": 0.1065848033863872, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6260,11 +11620,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9b9854e0a7826d3f6971", + "claim_id": "0679c495803fff9001ca", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_id", - "name": "Idaho SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ne", + "name": "Nebraska SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6275,24 +11635,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.058, + "external_value": 0.064, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "value": 0.10709346478114838, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6303,12 +11663,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.425414499426542, - "delta": 0.02467404096673944 + "ratio": 1.6733353872054435, + "delta": 0.04309346478114838 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.04319380943090882, + "value": 0.0905297831973547, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6321,7 +11681,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "value": 0.10709346478114838, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6334,14 +11694,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "60ca60bce71f685cf470", + "claim_id": "c89efbc4ffd24fb15cf3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_il", - "name": "Illinois SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nh", + "name": "New Hampshire SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6352,24 +11716,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.109, + "external_value": 0.07, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "value": 0.10516177420827955, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6380,12 +11744,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2889150866478662, - "delta": 0.03149174444461743 + "ratio": 1.502311060118279, + "delta": 0.03516177420827954 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.22407192001757978, + "value": 0.09182132684377468, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6398,7 +11762,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "value": 0.10516177420827955, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6411,14 +11775,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "ff7246abfe3677335ca6", + "claim_id": "f4182a5794922259b4ce", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_in", - "name": "Indiana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nj", + "name": "New Jersey SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6429,24 +11797,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "external_value": 0.141, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.141, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "value": 0.1092498608281033, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6457,12 +11825,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3334642401122452, - "delta": 0.03034524585021431 + "ratio": 0.7748217080007327, + "delta": -0.03175013917189669 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1401888779452793, + "value": 0.1667374861478505, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6475,7 +11843,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "value": 0.1092498608281033, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6491,11 +11859,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5b236b30fa3880759154", + "claim_id": "bf9816ce2ba4a0b01453", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ks", - "name": "Kansas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nm", + "name": "New Mexico SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6506,24 +11874,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.097, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.097, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07687780380679853, + "value": 0.10150136127945612, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6534,12 +11902,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7925546784206033, - "delta": -0.020122196193201478 + "ratio": 0.9854501095092828, + "delta": -0.0014986387205438712 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11049707808530514, + "value": 0.11106588908140123, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6552,7 +11920,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07687780380679853, + "value": 0.10150136127945612, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6568,11 +11936,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3cc89a80759ebd0e943", + "claim_id": "8e712209885a93f74b4d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ky", - "name": "Kentucky SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nv", + "name": "Nevada SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6583,24 +11951,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.158, + "external_value": 0.15, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.15, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.161467256006912, + "value": 0.16176684459486274, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6611,12 +11979,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.021944658271595, - "delta": 0.0034672560069120006 + "ratio": 1.0784456306324184, + "delta": 0.011766844594862741 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16650483237144315, + "value": 0.17630447354072667, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6629,7 +11997,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.161467256006912, + "value": 0.16176684459486274, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6645,11 +12013,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "53520f720a63c7550d45", + "claim_id": "b8fffe31f672e908c7d8", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_la", - "name": "Louisiana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ny", + "name": "New York SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6660,24 +12028,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.189, + "external_value": 0.155, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.189, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.155, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.125609622841254, + "value": 0.1754383989923551, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6688,12 +12056,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6646011790542539, - "delta": -0.06339037715874601 + "ratio": 1.1318606386603556, + "delta": 0.02043839899235511 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14878938671226047, + "value": 0.2244729385528201, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6706,7 +12074,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.125609622841254, + "value": 0.1754383989923551, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6722,11 +12090,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bd4ea8335108373296f7", + "claim_id": "01289c122011da498528", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ma", - "name": "Massachusetts SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_oh", + "name": "Ohio SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6737,24 +12105,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.116, + "external_value": 0.1, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.19868201101176794, + "value": 0.09456633809921511, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6765,12 +12133,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.7127759569979994, - "delta": 0.08268201101176793 + "ratio": 0.9456633809921511, + "delta": -0.005433661900784897 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15018924622184068, + "value": 0.09512644926695311, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6783,7 +12151,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.19868201101176794, + "value": 0.09456633809921511, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6796,18 +12164,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fee6a482e8ac1fc33989", + "claim_id": "74caf7c832e428617b1a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_md", - "name": "Maryland SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ok", + "name": "Oklahoma SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6818,24 +12182,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.112, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11005888615244076, + "value": 0.13050742890949424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6846,12 +12210,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8875716625196836, - "delta": -0.013941113847559236 + "ratio": 1.1652449009776271, + "delta": 0.018507428909494236 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2138827361406449, + "value": 0.16030445522608297, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6864,7 +12228,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11005888615244076, + "value": 0.13050742890949424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6880,11 +12244,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8896cdbb8213f271fcc1", + "claim_id": "40e68ccaadfc3269a541", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_me", - "name": "Maine SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_or", + "name": "Oregon SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6895,24 +12259,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.05, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.05, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12448915934503967, + "value": 0.13530844855648988, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6923,12 +12287,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.489783186900793, - "delta": 0.07448915934503966 + "ratio": 1.230076805058999, + "delta": 0.02530844855648988 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09936430562401276, + "value": 0.145986362805576, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6941,7 +12305,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12448915934503967, + "value": 0.13530844855648988, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6954,18 +12318,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ee8a446834a4da49903b", + "claim_id": "f277efd6b574264216a2", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mi", - "name": "Michigan SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_pa", + "name": "Pennsylvania SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6976,24 +12336,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1055862855424053, + "value": 0.13397061023553317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7004,12 +12364,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.025109568372867, - "delta": 0.002586285542405309 + "ratio": 1.217914638504847, + "delta": 0.023970610235533166 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1134851140594787, + "value": 0.11846176220706672, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7022,7 +12382,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1055862855424053, + "value": 0.13397061023553317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7038,11 +12398,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6bd14bde63071d64404b", + "claim_id": "64058ab1b6764c42b03b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mn", - "name": "Minnesota SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ri", + "name": "Rhode Island SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7053,24 +12413,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.063, + "external_value": 0.081, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.063, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08431433826871325, + "value": 0.16783042580923363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7081,12 +12441,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.338322829662115, - "delta": 0.021314338268713248 + "ratio": 2.0719805655460943, + "delta": 0.08683042580923363 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07686412373532482, + "value": 0.0965160396310427, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7099,7 +12459,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08431433826871325, + "value": 0.16783042580923363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7112,14 +12472,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "780a950917b74d17f667", + "claim_id": "f9d02a7845633c2b4268", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mo", - "name": "Missouri SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sc", + "name": "South Carolina SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7130,24 +12494,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "external_value": 0.128, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.128, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14744900886546072, + "value": 0.07390512495999252, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7158,12 +12522,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3652686006061179, - "delta": 0.039449008865460725 + "ratio": 0.5773837887499416, + "delta": -0.054094875040007484 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17194807589432126, + "value": 0.12793444859883502, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7176,7 +12540,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14744900886546072, + "value": 0.07390512495999252, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7192,11 +12556,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a27d4ff28bdfca616cb8", + "claim_id": "2ced6a36837da4879451", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ms", - "name": "Mississippi SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sd", + "name": "South Dakota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7207,24 +12571,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.171, + "external_value": 0.074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.171, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.074, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12213435064693424, + "value": 0.10525300686014008, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7235,12 +12599,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7142359686955219, - "delta": -0.04886564935306577 + "ratio": 1.4223379305424335, + "delta": 0.031253006860140084 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12754007054566846, + "value": 0.1489361182482862, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7253,7 +12617,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12213435064693424, + "value": 0.10525300686014008, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7269,11 +12633,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0e68641d4fe06928f3ed", + "claim_id": "fba997fbb6cfd6c39c4e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mt", - "name": "Montana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tn", + "name": "Tennessee SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7284,24 +12648,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.081, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.025309432293635373, + "value": 0.2111625943240533, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7312,12 +12676,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.3124621270819182, - "delta": -0.05569056770636463 + "ratio": 2.575153589317723, + "delta": 0.1291625943240533 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10992399534280023, + "value": 0.1914803710178463, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7330,7 +12694,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.025309432293635373, + "value": 0.2111625943240533, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7345,16 +12709,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C4, confidence high] Montana child SPM 0.31x: three cloned source families on about 52 effective households; one is a Census negative-resources artifact", - "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/C.md" + "rationale": "[batch2 C2, confidence high] SPM resources leave out partnership/S-corp income (and farm rent, non-Schedule-D gains) but subtract the federal and SE tax on it", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/issues/9919" } }, { - "claim_id": "8e871b8216783c3198e1", + "claim_id": "114bc2d1f77f3b6e9d05", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nc", - "name": "North Carolina SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tx", + "name": "Texas SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7365,24 +12729,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.152, + "external_value": 0.158, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.152, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1542939471948945, + "value": 0.1713150228787157, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7393,12 +12757,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.015091757861148, - "delta": 0.002293947194894508 + "ratio": 1.0842722967007323, + "delta": 0.013315022878715693 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14332420570803683, + "value": 0.17787968123647388, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7411,7 +12775,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1542939471948945, + "value": 0.1713150228787157, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7427,40 +12791,39 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6d24cdfdc704c93ea20e", + "claim_id": "02ce16f73ff66b8dd767", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nd", - "name": "North Dakota SPM child poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_us", + "name": "United States SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2024", + "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Table B-2 (under 18)", + "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ND", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ND", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "geography": "US", + "subgroup": "children_under_18" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.092, + "external_value": 0.134, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.134, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1065848033863872, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.15807536413031142, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -7469,14 +12832,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1585304715911653, - "delta": 0.014584803386387207 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.1796668964948613, + "delta": 0.024075364130311416 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07863050110524529, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.1721300089308572, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -7485,11 +12848,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" }, { - "value": 0.1065848033863872, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.15807536413031142, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -7498,17 +12861,17 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0679c495803fff9001ca", + "claim_id": "01b883e821e73bbef43d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ne", - "name": "Nebraska SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ut", + "name": "Utah SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7519,24 +12882,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.064, + "external_value": 0.059, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.059, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10709346478114838, + "value": 0.1321103502473556, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7547,12 +12910,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.6733353872054435, - "delta": 0.04309346478114838 + "ratio": 2.239158478768739, + "delta": 0.0731103502473556 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0905297831973547, + "value": 0.147121617175416, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7565,7 +12928,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10709346478114838, + "value": 0.1321103502473556, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7580,16 +12943,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" } }, { - "claim_id": "c89efbc4ffd24fb15cf3", + "claim_id": "51fa48d774c937b2e09f", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nh", - "name": "New Hampshire SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_va", + "name": "Virginia SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7600,24 +12963,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.07, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10516177420827955, + "value": 0.17844752297198335, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7628,12 +12991,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.502311060118279, - "delta": 0.03516177420827954 + "ratio": 1.60763534208994, + "delta": 0.06744752297198335 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09182132684377468, + "value": 0.20106968715278814, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7646,7 +13009,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10516177420827955, + "value": 0.17844752297198335, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7661,16 +13024,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" } }, { - "claim_id": "f4182a5794922259b4ce", + "claim_id": "55715497136e3eb9c9dc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nj", - "name": "New Jersey SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_vt", + "name": "Vermont SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7681,24 +13044,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.141, + "external_value": 0.08, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.141, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.08, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1092498608281033, + "value": 0.16421433280975725, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7709,12 +13072,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7748217080007327, - "delta": -0.03175013917189669 + "ratio": 2.0526791601219654, + "delta": 0.08421433280975725 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1667374861478505, + "value": 0.1970955552654315, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7727,7 +13090,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1092498608281033, + "value": 0.16421433280975725, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7740,14 +13103,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "bf9816ce2ba4a0b01453", + "claim_id": "2a005f05a8f1ab16c446", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nm", - "name": "New Mexico SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wa", + "name": "Washington SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7758,24 +13125,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.096, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.096, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10150136127945612, + "value": 0.14726240776675822, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7786,12 +13153,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9854501095092828, - "delta": -0.0014986387205438712 + "ratio": 1.5339834142370647, + "delta": 0.05126240776675822 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11106588908140123, + "value": 0.13620803393537964, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7804,7 +13171,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10150136127945612, + "value": 0.14726240776675822, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7817,14 +13184,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "8e712209885a93f74b4d", + "claim_id": "1b88ee46c23451091857", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nv", - "name": "Nevada SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wi", + "name": "Wisconsin SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7835,24 +13206,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.15, + "external_value": 0.065, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.15, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.065, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16176684459486274, + "value": 0.06225078237719991, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7863,12 +13234,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0784456306324184, - "delta": 0.011766844594862741 + "ratio": 0.9577043442646139, + "delta": -0.0027492176228000945 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17630447354072667, + "value": 0.11459686342541692, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7881,7 +13252,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16176684459486274, + "value": 0.06225078237719991, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7897,11 +13268,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b8fffe31f672e908c7d8", + "claim_id": "84359f336a5104b0d41d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ny", - "name": "New York SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wv", + "name": "West Virginia SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7912,24 +13283,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.155, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.155, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1754383989923551, + "value": 0.17931718903265126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7940,12 +13311,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1318606386603556, - "delta": 0.02043839899235511 + "ratio": 1.6301562639331932, + "delta": 0.06931718903265126 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2244729385528201, + "value": 0.1650380028753829, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7958,7 +13329,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1754383989923551, + "value": 0.17931718903265126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7971,14 +13342,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "01289c122011da498528", + "claim_id": "fe35a5d003686d2a4980", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_oh", - "name": "Ohio SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wy", + "name": "Wyoming SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7989,24 +13364,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.1, + "external_value": 0.064, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09456633809921511, + "value": 0.08787718640614912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8017,12 +13392,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9456633809921511, - "delta": -0.005433661900784897 + "ratio": 1.37308103759608, + "delta": 0.023877186406149123 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09512644926695311, + "value": 0.053805953351169424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8035,7 +13410,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09456633809921511, + "value": 0.08787718640614912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8051,14 +13426,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "74caf7c832e428617b1a", + "claim_id": "8e07e6dc19cf58c62acc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ok", - "name": "Oklahoma SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ak", + "name": "Alaska SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8066,24 +13441,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OK", + "geography": "AK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OK", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AK", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.112, + "external_value": 0.104, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.104, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13050742890949424, + "value": 0.09283683014388971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8094,12 +13468,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1652449009776271, - "delta": 0.018507428909494236 + "ratio": 0.8926618283066319, + "delta": -0.01116316985611028 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16030445522608297, + "value": 0.0823918573274956, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8112,7 +13486,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13050742890949424, + "value": 0.09283683014388971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8128,14 +13502,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "40e68ccaadfc3269a541", + "claim_id": "0deaebef07428ab342b5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_or", - "name": "Oregon SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_al", + "name": "Alabama SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8143,24 +13517,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OR", + "geography": "AL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OR", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.135, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13530844855648988, + "value": 0.15479567849859827, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8171,12 +13544,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.230076805058999, - "delta": 0.02530844855648988 + "ratio": 1.1466346555451723, + "delta": 0.019795678498598257 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.145986362805576, + "value": 0.1562689494957049, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8189,7 +13562,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13530844855648988, + "value": 0.15479567849859827, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8205,14 +13578,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f277efd6b574264216a2", + "claim_id": "ddf374e51b7a975400d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_pa", - "name": "Pennsylvania SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ar", + "name": "Arkansas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8220,24 +13593,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "PA", + "geography": "AR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "PA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AR", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.136, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.136, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13397061023553317, + "value": 0.07909137514758192, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8248,12 +13620,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.217914638504847, - "delta": 0.023970610235533166 + "ratio": 0.5815542290263377, + "delta": -0.056908624852418085 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11846176220706672, + "value": 0.09604142003099919, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8266,7 +13638,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13397061023553317, + "value": 0.07909137514758192, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8282,14 +13654,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "64058ab1b6764c42b03b", + "claim_id": "e9b5204d8089fc549e88", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ri", - "name": "Rhode Island SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_az", + "name": "Arizona SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8297,24 +13669,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "RI", + "geography": "AZ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "RI", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AZ", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.081, + "external_value": 0.129, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16783042580923363, + "value": 0.12943847317510282, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8325,12 +13696,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.0719805655460943, - "delta": 0.08683042580923363 + "ratio": 1.003399016861262, + "delta": 0.0004384731751028159 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0965160396310427, + "value": 0.13893523352842632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8343,7 +13714,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16783042580923363, + "value": 0.12943847317510282, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8356,21 +13727,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f9d02a7845633c2b4268", + "claim_id": "cac67258e5b9b5da88d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sc", - "name": "South Carolina SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ca", + "name": "California SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8378,24 +13745,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SC", + "geography": "CA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "SC", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.128, + "external_value": 0.177, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.128, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07390512495999252, + "value": 0.18454909051437005, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8406,12 +13772,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5773837887499416, - "delta": -0.054094875040007484 + "ratio": 1.0426502288947461, + "delta": 0.007549090514370055 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12793444859883502, + "value": 0.18943613023450145, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8424,7 +13790,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07390512495999252, + "value": 0.18454909051437005, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8440,14 +13806,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2ced6a36837da4879451", + "claim_id": "e733922d3029cd79b688", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sd", - "name": "South Dakota SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_co", + "name": "Colorado SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8455,24 +13821,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SD", + "geography": "CO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "SD", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CO", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.074, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.074, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10525300686014008, + "value": 0.09619897585695636, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8483,12 +13848,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4223379305424335, - "delta": 0.031253006860140084 + "ratio": 0.9339706393879259, + "delta": -0.006801024143043635 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1489361182482862, + "value": 0.09561262934066102, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8501,7 +13866,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10525300686014008, + "value": 0.09619897585695636, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8517,14 +13882,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fba997fbb6cfd6c39c4e", + "claim_id": "fd746252fbe7d70168a1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tn", - "name": "Tennessee SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ct", + "name": "Connecticut SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8532,24 +13897,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TN", + "geography": "CT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "TN", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.099, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.099, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.2111625943240533, + "value": 0.13259780956348854, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8560,12 +13924,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.575153589317723, - "delta": 0.1291625943240533 + "ratio": 1.3393718137726116, + "delta": 0.03359780956348854 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1914803710178463, + "value": 0.13782242530526317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8578,7 +13942,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.2111625943240533, + "value": 0.13259780956348854, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8591,21 +13955,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C2, confidence high] SPM resources leave out partnership/S-corp income (and farm rent, non-Schedule-D gains) but subtract the federal and SE tax on it", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/issues/9919" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "114bc2d1f77f3b6e9d05", + "claim_id": "82100da147ca1f887653", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tx", - "name": "Texas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_dc", + "name": "District of Columbia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8613,24 +13973,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TX", + "geography": "DC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "TX", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "DC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.158, + "external_value": 0.153, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.153, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1713150228787157, + "value": 0.18107210121623096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8641,12 +14000,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0842722967007323, - "delta": 0.013315022878715693 + "ratio": 1.1834777857269998, + "delta": 0.028072101216230966 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17787968123647388, + "value": 0.1309506366660333, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8659,7 +14018,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1713150228787157, + "value": 0.18107210121623096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8675,39 +14034,39 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "02ce16f73ff66b8dd767", + "claim_id": "a1ea0acf638b713a5fa9", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_us", - "name": "United States SPM child poverty rate", - "window": "2024", - "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Table B-2 (under 18)", - "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_de", + "name": "Delaware SPM poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "subgroup": "children_under_18" + "geography": "DE", + "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.134, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.134, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15807536413031142, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -8716,14 +14075,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable", - "ratio": 1.1796668964948613, - "delta": 0.024075364130311416 + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.4840914306983672, + "delta": 0.04502050305494815 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1721300089308572, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.1538858096004495, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -8732,11 +14091,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15807536413031142, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -8745,20 +14104,20 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01b883e821e73bbef43d", + "claim_id": "ef92c4a17d9616b84e8d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ut", - "name": "Utah SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_fl", + "name": "Florida SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8766,24 +14125,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "UT", + "geography": "FL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "UT", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "FL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.059, + "external_value": 0.16, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.059, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1321103502473556, + "value": 0.1756647923849868, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8794,12 +14152,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.239158478768739, - "delta": 0.0731103502473556 + "ratio": 1.0979049524061675, + "delta": 0.015664792384986803 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.147121617175416, + "value": 0.1774548672364514, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8812,7 +14170,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1321103502473556, + "value": 0.1756647923849868, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8825,21 +14183,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "51fa48d774c937b2e09f", + "claim_id": "bcf36e2dd6a004196b3b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_va", - "name": "Virginia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ga", + "name": "Georgia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8847,24 +14201,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VA", + "geography": "GA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "VA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "GA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "external_value": 0.135, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17844752297198335, + "value": 0.13817961563629774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8875,12 +14228,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.60763534208994, - "delta": 0.06744752297198335 + "ratio": 1.0235527084170202, + "delta": 0.0031796156362977335 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.20106968715278814, + "value": 0.13963149480286996, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8893,7 +14246,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17844752297198335, + "value": 0.13817961563629774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8906,21 +14259,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "55715497136e3eb9c9dc", + "claim_id": "157409312654547dda54", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_vt", - "name": "Vermont SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_hi", + "name": "Hawaii SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8928,24 +14277,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VT", + "geography": "HI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "VT", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "HI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.08, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.08, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16421433280975725, + "value": 0.09958265744779635, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8956,12 +14304,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.0526791601219654, - "delta": 0.08421433280975725 + "ratio": 0.9220616430351514, + "delta": -0.008417342552203652 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1970955552654315, + "value": 0.113087027347068, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8974,7 +14322,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16421433280975725, + "value": 0.09958265744779635, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8987,21 +14335,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2a005f05a8f1ab16c446", + "claim_id": "f528a45068185199fcfc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wa", - "name": "Washington SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ia", + "name": "Iowa SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9009,24 +14353,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WA", + "geography": "IA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.096, + "external_value": 0.077, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.096, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14726240776675822, + "value": 0.07406942298044937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9037,12 +14380,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5339834142370647, - "delta": 0.05126240776675822 + "ratio": 0.9619405581876542, + "delta": -0.0029305770195506287 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13620803393537964, + "value": 0.08709445083318687, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9055,7 +14398,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14726240776675822, + "value": 0.07406942298044937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9068,21 +14411,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1b88ee46c23451091857", + "claim_id": "1e9d15d956b2f0ffa91a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wi", - "name": "Wisconsin SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_id", + "name": "Idaho SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9090,24 +14429,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WI", + "geography": "ID", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WI", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "ID", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.065, + "external_value": 0.084, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.065, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.06225078237719991, + "value": 0.08136747862108071, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9118,12 +14456,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9577043442646139, - "delta": -0.0027492176228000945 + "ratio": 0.9686604597747702, + "delta": -0.0026325213789192975 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11459686342541692, + "value": 0.05779478684831971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9136,7 +14474,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.06225078237719991, + "value": 0.08136747862108071, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9152,14 +14490,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "84359f336a5104b0d41d", + "claim_id": "ae8c430221bad4ec14e2", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wv", - "name": "West Virginia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_il", + "name": "Illinois SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9167,24 +14505,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WV", + "geography": "IL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WV", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17931718903265126, + "value": 0.12450307799898666, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9195,12 +14532,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.6301562639331932, - "delta": 0.06931718903265126 + "ratio": 1.121649351342222, + "delta": 0.01350307799898666 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1650380028753829, + "value": 0.14616480259783873, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9213,7 +14550,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17931718903265126, + "value": 0.12450307799898666, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9226,21 +14563,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe35a5d003686d2a4980", + "claim_id": "5549a20032311c6bbd31", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wy", - "name": "Wyoming SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_in", + "name": "Indiana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9248,24 +14581,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WY", + "geography": "IN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WY", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.064, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08787718640614912, + "value": 0.10219037521645423, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9276,12 +14608,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.37308103759608, - "delta": 0.023877186406149123 + "ratio": 1.0988212388866045, + "delta": 0.00919037521645423 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.053805953351169424, + "value": 0.12466528560881461, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9294,7 +14626,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08787718640614912, + "value": 0.10219037521645423, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9310,11 +14642,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8e07e6dc19cf58c62acc", + "claim_id": "6a835a8f96aa55b18e21", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ak", - "name": "Alaska SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ks", + "name": "Kansas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9325,23 +14657,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.104, + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.104, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09283683014388971, + "value": 0.07626336362929916, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9352,12 +14684,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8926618283066319, - "delta": -0.01116316985611028 + "ratio": 0.8380589409813094, + "delta": -0.014736636370700842 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0823918573274956, + "value": 0.12229388506033745, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9370,7 +14702,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09283683014388971, + "value": 0.07626336362929916, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9386,11 +14718,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0deaebef07428ab342b5", + "claim_id": "b0fd283612be85825169", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_al", - "name": "Alabama SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ky", + "name": "Kentucky SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9401,23 +14733,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.135, + "external_value": 0.143, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15479567849859827, + "value": 0.13543850005752436, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9428,12 +14760,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1466346555451723, - "delta": 0.019795678498598257 + "ratio": 0.9471223780246459, + "delta": -0.007561499942475625 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1562689494957049, + "value": 0.13756585366158877, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9446,7 +14778,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15479567849859827, + "value": 0.13543850005752436, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9462,11 +14794,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ddf374e51b7a975400d5", + "claim_id": "b708e39de2619d2180ec", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ar", - "name": "Arkansas SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_la", + "name": "Louisiana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9477,23 +14809,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.136, + "external_value": 0.177, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.136, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07909137514758192, + "value": 0.1424661105482937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9504,12 +14836,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5815542290263377, - "delta": -0.056908624852418085 + "ratio": 0.8048932799338627, + "delta": -0.034533889451706296 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09604142003099919, + "value": 0.16335271957443767, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9522,7 +14854,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07909137514758192, + "value": 0.1424661105482937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9538,11 +14870,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e9b5204d8089fc549e88", + "claim_id": "7284f6fa3a580681d475", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_az", - "name": "Arizona SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ma", + "name": "Massachusetts SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9553,23 +14885,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.129, + "external_value": 0.117, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12943847317510282, + "value": 0.17256810101992193, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9580,12 +14912,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.003399016861262, - "delta": 0.0004384731751028159 + "ratio": 1.474941034358307, + "delta": 0.05556810101992192 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13893523352842632, + "value": 0.1771097334992783, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9598,7 +14930,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12943847317510282, + "value": 0.17256810101992193, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9614,11 +14946,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cac67258e5b9b5da88d5", + "claim_id": "f65cc2ffc9f6d7d2987b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ca", - "name": "California SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_md", + "name": "Maryland SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9629,23 +14961,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.177, + "external_value": 0.112, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18454909051437005, + "value": 0.11189291694829119, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9656,12 +14988,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0426502288947461, - "delta": 0.007549090514370055 + "ratio": 0.9990439013240284, + "delta": -0.00010708305170881172 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.18943613023450145, + "value": 0.15459341451928926, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9674,7 +15006,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18454909051437005, + "value": 0.11189291694829119, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9690,11 +15022,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e733922d3029cd79b688", + "claim_id": "5e48c3b704ff32c51d7e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_co", - "name": "Colorado SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_me", + "name": "Maine SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9705,23 +15037,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.067, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.067, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09619897585695636, + "value": 0.07488516809554867, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9732,12 +15064,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9339706393879259, - "delta": -0.006801024143043635 + "ratio": 1.1176890760529652, + "delta": 0.007885168095548664 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09561262934066102, + "value": 0.098578801887256, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9750,7 +15082,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09619897585695636, + "value": 0.07488516809554867, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9766,11 +15098,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd746252fbe7d70168a1", + "claim_id": "a6c9d71019fbeb5e5bf6", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ct", - "name": "Connecticut SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mi", + "name": "Michigan SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9781,23 +15113,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.099, + "external_value": 0.105, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.099, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13259780956348854, + "value": 0.07102190397012025, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9808,12 +15140,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3393718137726116, - "delta": 0.03359780956348854 + "ratio": 0.6763990854297166, + "delta": -0.03397809602987975 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13782242530526317, + "value": 0.08160677232362885, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9826,7 +15158,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13259780956348854, + "value": 0.07102190397012025, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9842,11 +15174,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "82100da147ca1f887653", + "claim_id": "60cef97ef8b7236451da", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_dc", - "name": "District of Columbia SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mn", + "name": "Minnesota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9857,23 +15189,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.153, + "external_value": 0.075, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.153, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.075, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18107210121623096, + "value": 0.06758949424479642, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9884,12 +15216,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1834777857269998, - "delta": 0.028072101216230966 + "ratio": 0.9011932565972857, + "delta": -0.007410505755203578 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1309506366660333, + "value": 0.06557923538426394, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9902,7 +15234,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18107210121623096, + "value": 0.06758949424479642, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9918,11 +15250,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1ea0acf638b713a5fa9", + "claim_id": "95ed0e94365e1c86a831", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_de", - "name": "Delaware SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mo", + "name": "Missouri SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9933,23 +15265,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.1, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "value": 0.1255287300563078, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9960,12 +15292,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4840914306983672, - "delta": 0.04502050305494815 + "ratio": 1.2552873005630778, + "delta": 0.02552873005630779 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1538858096004495, + "value": 0.129895368151217, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9978,7 +15310,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "value": 0.1255287300563078, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9994,11 +15326,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ef92c4a17d9616b84e8d", + "claim_id": "e2c82a2849885aafeec3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_fl", - "name": "Florida SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ms", + "name": "Mississippi SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10009,23 +15341,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.16, + "external_value": 0.164, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.164, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1756647923849868, + "value": 0.09980684214469134, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10036,12 +15368,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0979049524061675, - "delta": 0.015664792384986803 + "ratio": 0.608578305760313, + "delta": -0.06419315785530867 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1774548672364514, + "value": 0.11002544521520172, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10054,7 +15386,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1756647923849868, + "value": 0.09980684214469134, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10070,11 +15402,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bcf36e2dd6a004196b3b", + "claim_id": "554e254ce2ffaa3e3e14", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ga", - "name": "Georgia SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mt", + "name": "Montana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10085,23 +15417,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.135, + "external_value": 0.094, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.094, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13817961563629774, + "value": 0.07042066607104304, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10112,12 +15444,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0235527084170202, - "delta": 0.0031796156362977335 + "ratio": 0.7491560220323727, + "delta": -0.02357933392895696 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13963149480286996, + "value": 0.11110720473304003, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10130,7 +15462,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13817961563629774, + "value": 0.07042066607104304, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10146,11 +15478,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "157409312654547dda54", + "claim_id": "254772c932dcbe1c9548", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_hi", - "name": "Hawaii SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nc", + "name": "North Carolina SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10161,23 +15493,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "external_value": 0.14, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.14, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09958265744779635, + "value": 0.10393183976139309, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10188,12 +15520,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9220616430351514, - "delta": -0.008417342552203652 + "ratio": 0.7423702840099505, + "delta": -0.03606816023860693 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.113087027347068, + "value": 0.10043255572034507, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10206,7 +15538,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09958265744779635, + "value": 0.10393183976139309, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10222,11 +15554,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f528a45068185199fcfc", + "claim_id": "270978b4c4a8ac0af7ca", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ia", - "name": "Iowa SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nd", + "name": "North Dakota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10237,23 +15569,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07406942298044937, + "value": 0.07051397148734871, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10264,12 +15596,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9619405581876542, - "delta": -0.0029305770195506287 + "ratio": 0.8599264815530331, + "delta": -0.011486028512651292 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08709445083318687, + "value": 0.0749131472362356, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10282,7 +15614,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07406942298044937, + "value": 0.07051397148734871, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10298,11 +15630,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1e9d15d956b2f0ffa91a", + "claim_id": "8ddffe87b963da46a42c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_id", - "name": "Idaho SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ne", + "name": "Nebraska SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10313,23 +15645,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.084, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08136747862108071, + "value": 0.07573485585048426, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10340,12 +15672,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9686604597747702, - "delta": -0.0026325213789192975 + "ratio": 0.923595803054686, + "delta": -0.006265144149515747 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.05779478684831971, + "value": 0.0719651806573559, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10358,7 +15690,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08136747862108071, + "value": 0.07573485585048426, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10374,11 +15706,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae8c430221bad4ec14e2", + "claim_id": "7650c5613087799e6b17", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_il", - "name": "Illinois SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nh", + "name": "New Hampshire SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10389,23 +15721,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "external_value": 0.086, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.086, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12450307799898666, + "value": 0.0776467912406654, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10416,12 +15748,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.121649351342222, - "delta": 0.01350307799898666 + "ratio": 0.9028696655891326, + "delta": -0.008353208759334596 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14616480259783873, + "value": 0.06366941779475188, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10434,7 +15766,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12450307799898666, + "value": 0.0776467912406654, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10450,11 +15782,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5549a20032311c6bbd31", + "claim_id": "54ddcd746f6547275e70", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_in", - "name": "Indiana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nj", + "name": "New Jersey SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10465,23 +15797,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10219037521645423, + "value": 0.07840339275102101, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10492,12 +15824,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0988212388866045, - "delta": 0.00919037521645423 + "ratio": 0.6322854254114598, + "delta": -0.04559660724897899 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12466528560881461, + "value": 0.11146468083311312, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10510,7 +15842,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10219037521645423, + "value": 0.07840339275102101, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10526,11 +15858,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6a835a8f96aa55b18e21", + "claim_id": "23d1c79481fc7369131f", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ks", - "name": "Kansas SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nm", + "name": "New Mexico SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10541,23 +15873,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07626336362929916, + "value": 0.12719975402406325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10568,12 +15900,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8380589409813094, - "delta": -0.014736636370700842 + "ratio": 1.025804467935994, + "delta": 0.0031997540240632505 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12229388506033745, + "value": 0.14673047336840364, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10586,7 +15918,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07626336362929916, + "value": 0.12719975402406325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10602,11 +15934,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b0fd283612be85825169", + "claim_id": "1d2f65ad30970d87ebaa", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ky", - "name": "Kentucky SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nv", + "name": "Nevada SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10617,23 +15949,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.143, + "external_value": 0.147, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13543850005752436, + "value": 0.12673120311227293, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10644,12 +15976,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9471223780246459, - "delta": -0.007561499942475625 + "ratio": 0.8621170279746458, + "delta": -0.020268796887727064 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13756585366158877, + "value": 0.17376658579659643, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10662,7 +15994,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13543850005752436, + "value": 0.12673120311227293, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10678,11 +16010,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b708e39de2619d2180ec", + "claim_id": "3b79d1eb7360f13381e3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_la", - "name": "Louisiana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ny", + "name": "New York SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10693,23 +16025,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.177, + "external_value": 0.144, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.144, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1424661105482937, + "value": 0.18031065520530676, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10720,12 +16052,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8048932799338627, - "delta": -0.034533889451706296 + "ratio": 1.2521573278146303, + "delta": 0.03631065520530677 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16335271957443767, + "value": 0.1981954755448971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10738,7 +16070,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1424661105482937, + "value": 0.18031065520530676, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10754,11 +16086,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7284f6fa3a580681d475", + "claim_id": "4647bef66a7f10631c14", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ma", - "name": "Massachusetts SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_oh", + "name": "Ohio SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10769,23 +16101,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.117, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17256810101992193, + "value": 0.07230307252955719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10796,12 +16128,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.474941034358307, - "delta": 0.05556810101992192 + "ratio": 0.7774523927909375, + "delta": -0.020696927470442814 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1771097334992783, + "value": 0.07412244718629316, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10814,7 +16146,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17256810101992193, + "value": 0.07230307252955719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10830,11 +16162,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f65cc2ffc9f6d7d2987b", + "claim_id": "ad44e2913742d294570c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_md", - "name": "Maryland SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ok", + "name": "Oklahoma SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10845,23 +16177,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.112, + "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11189291694829119, + "value": 0.10065601435768795, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10872,12 +16204,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9990439013240284, - "delta": -0.00010708305170881172 + "ratio": 0.8677242617042065, + "delta": -0.015343985642312055 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15459341451928926, + "value": 0.11616680269261215, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10890,7 +16222,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11189291694829119, + "value": 0.10065601435768795, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10906,11 +16238,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5e48c3b704ff32c51d7e", + "claim_id": "5af425967764dab64322", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_me", - "name": "Maine SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_or", + "name": "Oregon SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10921,23 +16253,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.067, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.067, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07488516809554867, + "value": 0.1679968399475719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10948,12 +16280,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1176890760529652, - "delta": 0.007885168095548664 + "ratio": 1.5134850445727197, + "delta": 0.05699683994757189 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.098578801887256, + "value": 0.1833160121976655, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10966,7 +16298,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07488516809554867, + "value": 0.1679968399475719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10979,14 +16311,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "a6c9d71019fbeb5e5bf6", + "claim_id": "ce996b3e88742c0f0c37", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mi", - "name": "Michigan SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_pa", + "name": "Pennsylvania SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10997,23 +16333,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.105, + "external_value": 0.106, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07102190397012025, + "value": 0.11632442953115062, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11024,12 +16360,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6763990854297166, - "delta": -0.03397809602987975 + "ratio": 1.0974002785957606, + "delta": 0.01032442953115062 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08160677232362885, + "value": 0.11567101402347092, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11042,7 +16378,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07102190397012025, + "value": 0.11632442953115062, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11058,11 +16394,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "60cef97ef8b7236451da", + "claim_id": "0b2a6ef72f5008337b42", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mn", - "name": "Minnesota SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ri", + "name": "Rhode Island SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11073,23 +16409,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.075, + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.075, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.06758949424479642, + "value": 0.13513127058469632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11100,12 +16436,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9011932565972857, - "delta": -0.007410505755203578 + "ratio": 1.4849590174142453, + "delta": 0.04413127058469632 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.06557923538426394, + "value": 0.09751264219386363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11118,7 +16454,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.06758949424479642, + "value": 0.13513127058469632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11134,11 +16470,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "95ed0e94365e1c86a831", + "claim_id": "1809c60147fa37f67d49", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mo", - "name": "Missouri SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_sc", + "name": "South Carolina SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11149,23 +16485,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.1, + "external_value": 0.117, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1255287300563078, + "value": 0.08039879884811342, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11176,12 +16512,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2552873005630778, - "delta": 0.02552873005630779 + "ratio": 0.6871692209240463, + "delta": -0.036601201151886587 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.129895368151217, + "value": 0.10111475234510116, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11194,7 +16530,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1255287300563078, + "value": 0.08039879884811342, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11210,11 +16546,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e2c82a2849885aafeec3", + "claim_id": "5d1e107bc05e215503b9", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ms", - "name": "Mississippi SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_sd", + "name": "South Dakota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11225,23 +16561,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.164, + "external_value": 0.079, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.164, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.079, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09980684214469134, + "value": 0.083628263079774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11252,12 +16588,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.608578305760313, - "delta": -0.06419315785530867 + "ratio": 1.0585856086047343, + "delta": 0.004628263079774 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11002544521520172, + "value": 0.11227816321995195, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11270,7 +16606,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09980684214469134, + "value": 0.083628263079774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11286,11 +16622,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "554e254ce2ffaa3e3e14", + "claim_id": "a96a1236c09fa2d4625b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mt", - "name": "Montana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_tn", + "name": "Tennessee SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11301,23 +16637,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.094, + "external_value": 0.101, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.094, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.101, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07042066607104304, + "value": 0.14763097402826147, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11328,12 +16664,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7491560220323727, - "delta": -0.02357933392895696 + "ratio": 1.4616928121610047, + "delta": 0.04663097402826147 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11110720473304003, + "value": 0.13963384587324096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11346,7 +16682,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07042066607104304, + "value": 0.14763097402826147, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11362,11 +16698,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "254772c932dcbe1c9548", + "claim_id": "7a67b187161e75679905", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nc", - "name": "North Carolina SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_tx", + "name": "Texas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11377,23 +16713,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.14, + "external_value": 0.143, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.14, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10393183976139309, + "value": 0.142214311254233, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11404,12 +16740,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7423702840099505, - "delta": -0.03606816023860693 + "ratio": 0.9945056731065246, + "delta": -0.0007856887457669826 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10043255572034507, + "value": 0.14698917939988793, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11422,7 +16758,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10393183976139309, + "value": 0.142214311254233, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11438,39 +16774,38 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "270978b4c4a8ac0af7ca", + "claim_id": "2fb69d82a3df911ce693", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nd", - "name": "North Dakota SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_us", + "name": "United States SPM poverty rate", + "window": "2024", + "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Figure 6 / Table B-1", + "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ND", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ND", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "geography": "US" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.129, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07051397148734871, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.13058122597208743, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -11479,14 +16814,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8599264815530331, - "delta": -0.011486028512651292 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0122575656750963, + "delta": 0.00158122597208743 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0749131472362356, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.1389642332405406, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -11495,11 +16830,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" }, { - "value": 0.07051397148734871, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.13058122597208743, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -11508,17 +16843,17 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8ddffe87b963da46a42c", + "claim_id": "f84919c3454b2fbbde8d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ne", - "name": "Nebraska SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ut", + "name": "Utah SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11529,23 +16864,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.084, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07573485585048426, + "value": 0.11882197918537923, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11556,12 +16891,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.923595803054686, - "delta": -0.006265144149515747 + "ratio": 1.4145473712545147, + "delta": 0.03482197918537923 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0719651806573559, + "value": 0.11892643276403998, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11574,7 +16909,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07573485585048426, + "value": 0.11882197918537923, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11590,11 +16925,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7650c5613087799e6b17", + "claim_id": "c9774fefb7a67dd60d48", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nh", - "name": "New Hampshire SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_va", + "name": "Virginia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11605,23 +16940,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.086, + "external_value": 0.105, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.086, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0776467912406654, + "value": 0.11311486516491787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11632,12 +16967,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9028696655891326, - "delta": -0.008353208759334596 + "ratio": 1.077284430142075, + "delta": 0.00811486516491787 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.06366941779475188, + "value": 0.11440374411905024, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11650,7 +16985,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.0776467912406654, + "value": 0.11311486516491787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11666,11 +17001,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "54ddcd746f6547275e70", + "claim_id": "228154f0104e67513ac7", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nj", - "name": "New Jersey SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_vt", + "name": "Vermont SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11681,23 +17016,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.095, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07840339275102101, + "value": 0.13079380107354177, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11708,12 +17043,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6322854254114598, - "delta": -0.04559660724897899 + "ratio": 1.3767768534057028, + "delta": 0.03579380107354177 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11146468083311312, + "value": 0.14867288881663104, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11726,7 +17061,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07840339275102101, + "value": 0.13079380107354177, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11742,11 +17077,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23d1c79481fc7369131f", + "claim_id": "450ad519bc170f6be9a5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nm", - "name": "New Mexico SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wa", + "name": "Washington SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11757,23 +17092,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12719975402406325, + "value": 0.1059674974573952, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11784,12 +17119,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.025804467935994, - "delta": 0.0031997540240632505 + "ratio": 0.9811805320129185, + "delta": -0.0020325025426048 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14673047336840364, + "value": 0.10977333645706265, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11802,7 +17137,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12719975402406325, + "value": 0.1059674974573952, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11818,11 +17153,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1d2f65ad30970d87ebaa", + "claim_id": "076afee6b488ce9204cb", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nv", - "name": "Nevada SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wi", + "name": "Wisconsin SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11833,23 +17168,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.147, + "external_value": 0.077, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12673120311227293, + "value": 0.1038407477762462, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11860,12 +17195,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8621170279746458, - "delta": -0.020268796887727064 + "ratio": 1.3485811399512495, + "delta": 0.026840747776246204 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17376658579659643, + "value": 0.11340589602569066, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11878,7 +17213,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12673120311227293, + "value": 0.1038407477762462, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11894,11 +17229,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3b79d1eb7360f13381e3", + "claim_id": "5363db12f455bbb7c3be", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ny", - "name": "New York SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wv", + "name": "West Virginia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11909,23 +17244,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.144, + "external_value": 0.125, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.144, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.125, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18031065520530676, + "value": 0.13161600566706727, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11936,12 +17271,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2521573278146303, - "delta": 0.03631065520530677 + "ratio": 1.0529280453365382, + "delta": 0.006616005667067271 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1981954755448971, + "value": 0.13704122259072649, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11954,7 +17289,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18031065520530676, + "value": 0.13161600566706727, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11970,11 +17305,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4647bef66a7f10631c14", + "claim_id": "3da8bf5938b8e36727d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_oh", - "name": "Ohio SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wy", + "name": "Wyoming SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11985,23 +17320,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.083, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.083, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07230307252955719, + "value": 0.0789481576077373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -12012,12 +17347,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7774523927909375, - "delta": -0.020696927470442814 + "ratio": 0.9511826217799674, + "delta": -0.004051842392262708 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07412244718629316, + "value": 0.08282431488411907, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -12030,7 +17365,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07230307252955719, + "value": 0.0789481576077373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -12046,30 +17381,43 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ad44e2913742d294570c", + "claim_id": "09f4bf8dc18147cfb87a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ok", - "name": "Oklahoma SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OK", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "OK", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "11.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", @@ -12077,1189 +17425,2027 @@ "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10065601435768795, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8677242617042065, - "delta": -0.015343985642312055 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9956896551724138, + "delta": -0.0005000000000000004 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11616680269261215, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c1075b632c2595610601", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "11.8" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.118, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.118, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.978813559322034, + "delta": -0.0024999999999999883 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 0.10065601435768795, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3e7166fd417aec214417", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "14.9" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.149, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.149, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9838926174496645, + "delta": -0.0023999999999999855 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9574d34e1d5ec6bca59b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "14.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.004109589041096, + "delta": 0.0006000000000000172 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5af425967764dab64322", + "claim_id": "adeb5b58537ff180d657", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_or", - "name": "Oregon SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OR", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "OR", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "12.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.126, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.126, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.976984126984127, + "delta": -0.0029 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d24483ee5860b28e1ad4", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "12.4" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.124, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.992741935483871, + "delta": -0.000899999999999998 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7f8509f4b8e6b02abee9", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "5.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.056, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.056, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0125, + "delta": 0.0006999999999999992 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9882403f006bd3da0011", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "5.8" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.058, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9775862068965517, + "delta": -0.0013000000000000025 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1d6ce33489bd28c5e81d", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "11.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.116, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9905172413793103, + "delta": -0.0011000000000000038 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d90ead50f4f3e6caa4cc", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "11.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.115, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.115, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9991304347826087, + "delta": -0.00010000000000000286 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3890ba7a4b6d2c306608", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_renter", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "22.3" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.223, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.223, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9923766816143498, + "delta": -0.001700000000000007 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e39bf78545d67fef05d1", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "22.7" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.227, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.227, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1679968399475719, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5134850445727197, - "delta": 0.05699683994757189 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9748898678414096, + "delta": -0.005700000000000011 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1833160121976655, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1679968399475719, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce996b3e88742c0f0c37", + "claim_id": "3f36993a9c0e97005ee5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_pa", - "name": "Pennsylvania SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "PA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "PA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "12.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.106, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.126, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.126, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11632442953115062, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0974002785957606, - "delta": 0.01032442953115062 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.976984126984127, + "delta": -0.0029 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11567101402347092, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11632442953115062, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0b2a6ef72f5008337b42", + "claim_id": "884d6375896e06ea4113", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ri", - "name": "Rhode Island SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "RI", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "RI", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "12.4" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13513127058469632, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4849590174142453, - "delta": 0.04413127058469632 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.992741935483871, + "delta": -0.000899999999999998 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09751264219386363, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13513127058469632, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1809c60147fa37f67d49", + "claim_id": "089c156ec88b7cf82aeb", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_sc", - "name": "South Carolina SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SC", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "SC", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.117, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.006, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.006, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08039879884811342, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6871692209240463, - "delta": -0.036601201151886587 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0863333333333334, + "delta": -0.0005180000000000002 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10111475234510116, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.08039879884811342, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5d1e107bc05e215503b9", + "claim_id": "156266caa5b7ec8874a5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_sd", - "name": "South Dakota SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SD", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "SD", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.079, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.079, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.083628263079774, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0585856086047343, - "delta": 0.004628263079774 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3036, + "delta": -0.0015180000000000003 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11227816321995195, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.083628263079774, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a96a1236c09fa2d4625b", + "claim_id": "891add096fd35c5ddbfc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_tn", - "name": "Tennessee SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TN", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "TN", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.101, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.101, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14763097402826147, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4616928121610047, - "delta": 0.04663097402826147 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.46, + "delta": -0.0023 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13963384587324096, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.14763097402826147, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7a67b187161e75679905", + "claim_id": "b08760f65669373f7cf4", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_tx", - "name": "Texas SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TX", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "TX", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.143, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.142214311254233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0072, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9945056731065246, - "delta": -0.0007856887457669826 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.44, + "delta": -0.0021999999999999997 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14698917939988793, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.142214311254233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0072, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2fb69d82a3df911ce693", + "claim_id": "b929c573c144b8c70e21", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_us", - "name": "United States SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2024", - "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Figure 6 / Table B-1", - "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "US", - "program": null, + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "US" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.3" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.129, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.003, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.003, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13058122597208743, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable", - "ratio": 1.0122575656750963, - "delta": 0.00158122597208743 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.4663333333333333, + "delta": -0.001399 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1389642332405406, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" - }, - { - "value": 0.13058122597208743, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f84919c3454b2fbbde8d", + "claim_id": "d971a213990492ddd29e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ut", - "name": "Utah SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "UT", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "UT", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.084, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11882197918537923, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4145473712545147, - "delta": 0.03482197918537923 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.8798, + "delta": 0.000601 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11892643276403998, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11882197918537923, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c9774fefb7a67dd60d48", + "claim_id": "0568716efd810cd99339", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_va", - "name": "Virginia SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "VA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.7" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.105, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.007, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.007, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11311486516491787, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.077284430142075, - "delta": 0.00811486516491787 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9872857142857142, + "delta": 8.900000000000054e-05 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11440374411905024, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11311486516491787, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "228154f0104e67513ac7", + "claim_id": "e7a397116a98e4abe2b1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_vt", - "name": "Vermont SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VT", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "VT", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.095, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.006, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.095, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.006, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13079380107354177, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.008, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3767768534057028, - "delta": 0.03579380107354177 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3333333333333333, + "delta": -0.002 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14867288881663104, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13079380107354177, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.008, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "450ad519bc170f6be9a5", + "claim_id": "fb56a9c7242136ed9385", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wa", - "name": "Washington SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1059674974573952, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9811805320129185, - "delta": -0.0020325025426048 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3821999999999999, + "delta": -0.0019109999999999995 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10977333645706265, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1059674974573952, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "076afee6b488ce9204cb", + "claim_id": "01e6132c625cb4794118", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wi", - "name": "Wisconsin SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WI", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WI", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.8" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.008, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.008, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1038407477762462, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0108, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3485811399512495, - "delta": 0.026840747776246204 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.35, + "delta": -0.0028000000000000004 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11340589602569066, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1038407477762462, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0108, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5363db12f455bbb7c3be", + "claim_id": "09dce62e198fd6511a83", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wv", - "name": "West Virginia SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WV", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WV", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.8" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.125, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.008, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.125, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.008, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13161600566706727, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0529280453365382, - "delta": 0.006616005667067271 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.4925, + "delta": -0.003939999999999999 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13704122259072649, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13161600566706727, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3da8bf5938b8e36727d5", + "claim_id": "61b590e662acc0df805c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wy", - "name": "Wyoming SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WY", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WY", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-1.1" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.083, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.011, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.083, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.011, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0789481576077373, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9511826217799674, - "delta": -0.004051842392262708 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0854545454545454, + "delta": -0.0009399999999999999 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08282431488411907, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.0789481576077373, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null @@ -25515,6 +31701,320 @@ "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136" } }, + { + "claim_id": "c8248967fabf712d4161", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-170m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -170000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -170000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 11.358823529411765, + "delta": -1761000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "dbed02961788036df898", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-250m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -250000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -250000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 7.724, + "delta": -1681000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "941f70fdd8ebe26cb72e", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-300m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.553333333333334, + "delta": -1666000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a3fcb5268c1ed84cf21c", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-370m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -370000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -370000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.313513513513514, + "delta": -1596000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "fe4ce312800fe0924aba", "source": "centax", @@ -25984,6 +32484,320 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "563c7dd58d2569382e48", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-270m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -270000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -270000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 7.325925925925926, + "delta": -1708000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9a0c495d359b66702ec0", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-190m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -190000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -190000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 10.410526315789474, + "delta": -1788000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "0def9addaf542a9f2a88", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-340m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -340000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -340000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.920588235294118, + "delta": -1673000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3dd2d43d32b935dd48bb", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-410m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -410000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -410000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.909756097560976, + "delta": -1603000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "65b4e630a623a9d8b487", "source": "centax", @@ -26139,6 +32953,320 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "51798d6c66fe98544363", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-210m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -210000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -210000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 9.638095238095238, + "delta": -1814000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "592a6aeab7bc8b8455d7", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-300m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.746666666666667, + "delta": -1724000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4fd2dfe2e32e1e4206d2", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-460m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -460000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -460000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.482608695652174, + "delta": -1602000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6f6785ffe294b5379d87", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-370m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -370000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -370000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.572972972972973, + "delta": -1692000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "f4397e5778474de9cc1c", "source": "centax", @@ -27566,6 +34694,941 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "be973a7de4617b4c30c0", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average Electricity Bill Saving, Total Impact", + "name": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household electricity bill saving", + "value_verbatim": "c. \u00a353 p.a." + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 53.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 53.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 2.452830188679245, + "delta": 77.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d724ceaf137b5618a46b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "0.526" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 526000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -526000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -217230570.25019464, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.41298587500037004, + "delta": -743230570.2501947 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -217230570.25019464, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f3d514bd23d92f7a152d", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.343" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1343000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1343000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -850021418.4095707, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.6329273405879157, + "delta": -2193021418.4095707 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -850021418.4095707, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6ef69606608c7d2fc4e3", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "2.504" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 2504000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2504000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1968205830.921824, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7860246928601533, + "delta": -4472205830.9218235 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1968205830.921824, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1596761586e5d9b405f4", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034/35, mean", + "name": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_post_mean_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "not stated whether before or after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -1.0706044182233354, + "delta": -6211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e1b4c51baa8070b28366", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "3.906" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3906000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3906000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8222768189119319, + "delta": -7117813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f042ca2b3c6eb68410b8", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "5.599" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 5599000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5599000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -4406755640.831539, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7870611967907732, + "delta": -10005755640.83154 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -4406755640.831539, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7511be14ee6e146c39db", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "7.508" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 7508000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7508000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -5885093637.713373, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7838430524391813, + "delta": -13393093637.713373 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -5885093637.713373, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3965d0c26b82f15bd5b6", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "9.638" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 9638000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -9638000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7484298447.570207, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7765406150207727, + "delta": -17122298447.570206 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7484298447.570207, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2c9c7a3ac96d7791454e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "12.109" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 12109000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -12109000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -9271202074.210602, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7656455590230904, + "delta": -21380202074.2106 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -9271202074.210602, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0a74016817fb666896b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039/40, pre-tax", + "name": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_post_pretax_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a314.3 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 14300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7788016541993757, + "delta": -25436863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a017e1d5ad381dc8e715", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "14.901" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 14901000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14901000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7473903533354186, + "delta": -26037863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "3e0f4ed92a011b5a1d9a", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", @@ -27870,6 +35933,84 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "2bbe4e01bdd681720216", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Fiscal Cost, Total Impact", + "name": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Fiscal Cost'", + "value_verbatim": "c. \u00a31.5 bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -2.5533333333333332, + "delta": -5330000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "9af08733f1c6826235aa", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", @@ -28174,6 +36315,726 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "83810920037655d9335b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "0.422" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 422000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 422000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 156417504.22159922, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.37065759294217826, + "delta": -265582495.77840078 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 156417504.22159922, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "bc6769ee02523f4d7fc4", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.073" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1073000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1073000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 608885510.6364938, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.5674608673219886, + "delta": -464114489.3635062 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 608885510.6364938, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c8dd0b6df8f1c222cf5e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.995" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1995000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1995000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 1414229874.178762, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7088871549768231, + "delta": -580770125.821238 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 1414229874.178762, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a9fe70dc1adc1b249ce3", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "3.103" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3103000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3103000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 2296590901.1592994, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7401195298611987, + "delta": -806409098.8407006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 2296590901.1592994, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "417614fe3699cc829530", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "4.439" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4439000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4439000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 3156720894.1896734, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7111333395336051, + "delta": -1282279105.8103266 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 3156720894.1896734, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2743e29e8c7f7236cc80", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "5.939" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 5939000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5939000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 4195554287.92699, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7064412001897609, + "delta": -1743445712.07301 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4195554287.92699, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b66d52ada7defa285d5e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "7.609" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 7609000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7609000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 5327184898.630032, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7001162963109517, + "delta": -2281815101.3699684 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 5327184898.630032, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7a244e7bee38b319029f", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "9.545" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 9545000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 9545000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6572734215.313287, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.6886049466017063, + "delta": -2972265784.686713 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6572734215.313287, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "03eec284a2f55ed9ed87", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "11.729" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 11729000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 11729000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7860994216.190747, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.6702186218936608, + "delta": -3868005783.8092527 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7860994216.190747, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "03d666ddda6fe83bd6f4", "source": "co_admin", @@ -31404,6 +40265,195 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f5b447aa10146b39a7f0", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Percent change", + "name": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "value_verbatim": "41.6%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 41.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -41.6, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1743be8ca03a7581342e", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Percentage point change", + "name": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percentage points", + "value_verbatim": "7.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 7.5, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7.5, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2d05411229afb7cbbb3a", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "reduction in the child poverty rate from the 2021 Child Tax Credit", + "name": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "United States", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_us_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "the 2021 Child Tax Credit against no Child Tax Credit (9.2% to 5.2%)", + "country": "US", + "geography": "United States", + "pe_missing": "National, for 2021, and measured against no Child Tax Credit at all; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit, for California in 2026.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "value_verbatim": "43%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 43.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -43.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "dbb34965f41514214b05", "source": "ct_admin", @@ -32307,6 +41357,158 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "2213a1a3e651029c4184", + "source": "desnz", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "households receiving a rebate", + "name": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", + "metric": "affected_count", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the cohort estimate for the 2026/27 to 2030/31 scheme; Table 6 costs 5.9m rebates in each year", + "population": "households receiving a rebate", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", + "value_verbatim": "around 5.9m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 5900000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5900000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7850000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_households_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].recipients_m\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-proxy-caseload: The dashboard's proxy pays the \u00a3100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates')." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.3305084745762712, + "delta": 1950000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7850000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_households_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].recipients_m\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-proxy-caseload: The dashboard's proxy pays the \u00a3100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates')." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "cbf071793c4087a9ef7e", + "source": "desnz", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average saving per year", + "name": "Breathing space on your energy bill", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Breathing space on your energy bill", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "desnz_vat_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 electricity prices (the current cut, from 1 October 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 45.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 45.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 49.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0888888888888888, + "delta": 4.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 49.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "2fe8f297b2b1288f5ba4", "source": "deutsche_bank", @@ -32472,6 +41674,411 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "9818df23089c94ac93fb", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "price_basis": "nominal", + "program": "state_pension", + "program_note": "State Pension", + "rounding": "nearest \u00a31bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 1: 'negative values denote savings')", + "value_verbatim": "-\u00a315 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": -15000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "survey-bill-below-dwp: Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's \u00a315bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, \u00a311.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is \u00a310.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by \u00a31.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (\u00a35.9bn in 2026-27, \u00a36.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is \u00a3243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the \u00a3286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives \u00a311.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to \u00a31bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "gap unexplained, tracked at https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.7424575770034049, + "delta": 3863136344.948927 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "survey-bill-below-dwp: Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's \u00a315bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, \u00a311.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is \u00a310.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by \u00a31.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (\u00a35.9bn in 2026-27, \u00a36.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is \u00a3243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the \u00a3286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives \u00a311.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to \u00a31bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "gap unexplained, tracked at https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0ad9c361b863e3a413d", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_ame_real_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes nominal savings only; DWP's nominal figure (Table 1) is the one compared.", + "price_basis": "real terms, 2025-26 prices", + "prices": "real", + "program": "state_pension", + "program_note": "State Pension", + "rounding": "nearest \u00a31bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 2: 'negative values denote savings')", + "value_verbatim": "-\u00a311 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": -11000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -11000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-real-terms-table: DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.0124421504591885, + "delta": -136863655.05107307 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-real-terms-table: DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7bb1b7a8341e5e54a790", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034/35, adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate.", + "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", + "program": "state_pension", + "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", + "value_verbatim": "10.3%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 0.103, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.12154651641845704, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.1800632661986121, + "delta": 0.018546516418457046 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.12154651641845704, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe2e34e66137ebd0a2d1", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039/40, adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate.", + "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", + "program": "state_pension", + "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", + "value_verbatim": "9.2%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 0.092, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08826981544494629, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.959454515705938, + "delta": -0.003730184555053709 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.08826981544494629, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "06425bb0992e133916a3", + "source": "electricity_bills_taskforce", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "saving to the average household", + "name": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", + "url": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The Taskforce also removes the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "an additional \u00a3100 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 100.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 100.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3, + "delta": 30.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "559dfd6172fe158c4c63", "source": "ey_item_club", @@ -45702,6 +55309,66 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "4ac90e60c343a03127ed", + "source": "garfinkel_et_al", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "net cost of the $3600-$3000 child allowance", + "name": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", + "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "United States", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "garfinkel_arpa_allowance_net_cost_us_2018", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "static (the paper estimates the earnings response separately)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "data": "2019 CPS ASEC (2018 incomes), 100% take-up assumed", + "dollars": "not stated for the cost; the paper's benefit estimates are in 2019 dollars", + "geography": "United States", + "pe_missing": "A national cost on 2019 survey data (2018 incomes), against the $2,000 credit; the dashboard publishes the cost for California households in 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the federal government (the allowance's net cost)", + "value_verbatim": "$96.8 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 96800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -96800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "f4800dcb6ab3eaeb7fe8", "source": "goldman_sachs", @@ -46033,6 +55700,480 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "65354f670cefc3f5f4b2", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (\u00a3/yr)", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", + "value_verbatim": "19.25" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 19.25, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 19.25, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.753246753246753, + "delta": 110.75 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c9db47e6d17f74b13cb1", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (\u00a3/yr)", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", + "value_verbatim": "20.45" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 20.45, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 20.45, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.356968215158925, + "delta": 109.55 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "afe3d5816e4e99d276fa", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost to the exchequer", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to Warm Home Discount recipients (about 6 million); the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1 million).", + "period_basis": "a one-off payment this winter", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "program_note": "targeted payment", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'at a cost of \u00a31.8bn to the exchequer'", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.8bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "44d7c70f1feb853f", + "external_value": 1800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2430000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-recipients-vs-means-tested-households: Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.35, + "delta": -4230000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2430000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-recipients-vs-means-tested-households: Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5fca7b060156b9d1d45d", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost (\u00a3bn), Dom Elec Direct", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "value_verbatim": "0.61" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 610000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -610000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -6.278688524590164, + "delta": -4440000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "74730b882638341c0e46", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost (\u00a3bn), Dom Elec Direct", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "value_verbatim": "0.57" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 570000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -570000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -6.719298245614035, + "delta": -4400000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c805c4eff8fbe6d6a882", + "source": "green_party", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "sum set aside", + "name": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", + "url": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The Green Party states no period for its \u00a38.4 billion and set it in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path.", + "period_basis": "no period stated; the guarantee would start with the July 2026 cap, in 2026-27", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "program_note": "energy price guarantee", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'setting aside'", + "value_verbatim": "approximately \u00a38.4 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "448ac62bfbb77ae6", + "external_value": 8400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -8400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.8595238095238096, + "delta": -15620000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "ffb1fa41bff7bcb53ad3", "source": "hi_admin", @@ -47870,7 +58011,65 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f7fd0bd182c6e8fa3537", + "claim_id": "f7fd0bd182c6e8fa3537", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", + "name": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6929b353345e31ab14ecf735/E03444720_Budget_2025_Web_Accessible.pdf", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "total (RO + ECO + VAT)", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", + "reform_hint": "Energy bills package: Exchequer funds 75% of the domestic cost of the legacy Renewables Obligation 2026-27 to 2028-29 and the Energy Company Obligation is not renewed from April 2026", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", + "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3134" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "5a24f4aaef397698", + "external_value": 134.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -134.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe66761da6d5dbf51223", "source": "hm_treasury", "country": "UK", "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", @@ -47888,25 +58087,38 @@ "geography": "Great Britain", "program": null, "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "total (RO + ECO + VAT)", + "component": "RO", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "geography": "Great Britain", + "measure_key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The Renewables Obligation share of an electricity bill is not a parameter. The engine has electricity_consumption (LCFS-imputed, NEED-calibrated) and a flat energy_bills_credit lever (gov.treasury.energy_bills_rebate.energy_bills_credit), so the measure is a CONSTRUCTION: bill x domestic RO share (~41%, HMT) x 75%, or the ~GBP 150 average as a flat credit. Either is stated as constructed, never comparable.", "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", - "reform_hint": "Energy bills package: Exchequer funds 75% of the domestic cost of the legacy Renewables Obligation 2026-27 to 2028-29 and the Energy Company Obligation is not renewed from April 2026", + "reform_hint": "Renewables Obligation: Fund 75% of the domestic share of the Renewables Obligation via the Exchequer over the Spending Review period", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3134" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a367" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "electricity_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] }, - "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "5a24f4aaef397698", - "external_value": 134.0, + "reform_key": "9ca24eb4e469691a", + "external_value": 67.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -134.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -67.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -47928,56 +58140,44 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe66761da6d5dbf51223", + "claim_id": "74b11e3f52fd3aa4952c", "source": "hm_treasury", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", - "name": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "source_column": "Saving on the yearly price cap", + "name": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", - "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6929b353345e31ab14ecf735/E03444720_Budget_2025_Web_Accessible.pdf", + "publication_title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "Great Britain", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "static", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_bill_saving_oct2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "RO", + "cap_period": "October to December 2026", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "Great Britain", - "measure_key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The Renewables Obligation share of an electricity bill is not a parameter. The engine has electricity_consumption (LCFS-imputed, NEED-calibrated) and a flat energy_bills_credit lever (gov.treasury.energy_bills_rebate.energy_bills_credit), so the measure is a CONSTRUCTION: bill x domestic RO share (~41%, HMT) x 75%, or the ~GBP 150 average as a flat credit. Either is stated as constructed, never comparable.", - "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", - "reform_hint": "Renewables Obligation: Fund 75% of the domestic share of the Renewables Obligation via the Exchequer over the Spending Review period", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", - "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a367" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "electricity_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "pe_missing": "A saving on the October 2026 annualised cap; the analysis's counterpart is the mean support per household from its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.avg_benefit_per_hh: \u00a349, \u00a362, \u00a381, shown on the dashboard's policy tab), a different period and statistic.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the annual energy bill (printed as \u00a345 off the yearly price cap)", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "9ca24eb4e469691a", - "external_value": 67.0, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 45.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -67.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -69297,6 +79497,67 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "44f99aa9f0bceae4f311", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2026-27", + "name": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "pe_missing": "The Government's cost is for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis costs a full-year extension in 2027-28 (elec_vat_cut_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a31.55bn, \u00a31.95bn, \u00a32.56bn), a different year and length of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "scoring_method": "Government estimate at estimated electricity prices; 'Updated costs will be set out at Budget'", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3850 million" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 850000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -850000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "00887d5246feae037324", "source": "hm_treasury", @@ -125309,10 +135570,160 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "876791e3e4f7f30b24fc", + "claim_id": "876791e3e4f7f30b24fc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Poorest", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_1", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", + "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "1167.584" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", + "external_value": 1167.584, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1167.584, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9989d327d3cfc06959e4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Richest", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_10", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", + "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "11d22b255c4a3c12cf8a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125338,18 +135749,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", - "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", - "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", + "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1167.584" + "value_verbatim": "3310.047" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -125358,11 +135769,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", - "external_value": 1167.584, + "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", + "external_value": 3310.047, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1167.584, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3310.047, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125384,10 +135795,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9989d327d3cfc06959e4", + "claim_id": "f789972776cbbc92a1e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125413,18 +135824,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", - "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", - "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", + "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "2906.925" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -125433,11 +135844,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", + "external_value": 2906.925, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2906.925, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125459,10 +135870,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "11d22b255c4a3c12cf8a", + "claim_id": "2e118b11475abb95da64", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125488,7 +135899,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125496,7 +135907,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3310.047" + "value_verbatim": "2021.746" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125509,10 +135920,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 3310.047, + "external_value": 2021.746, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3310.047, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2021.746, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125534,10 +135945,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f789972776cbbc92a1e1", + "claim_id": "873e6e6ccda9c7be5768", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125563,7 +135974,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125571,7 +135982,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2906.925" + "value_verbatim": "673.0972" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125584,10 +135995,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 2906.925, + "external_value": 673.0972, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2906.925, + "external_value_pe_sign": 673.0972, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125609,10 +136020,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2e118b11475abb95da64", + "claim_id": "b4502a7d78e7cd153c57", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125638,7 +136049,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125646,7 +136057,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2021.746" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125659,10 +136070,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 2021.746, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2021.746, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125684,10 +136095,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "873e6e6ccda9c7be5768", + "claim_id": "928df844dd5891fe8c26", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125713,7 +136124,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125721,7 +136132,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "673.0972" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125734,10 +136145,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 673.0972, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 673.0972, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125759,10 +136170,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b4502a7d78e7cd153c57", + "claim_id": "d34ca758972ca6c5ce7c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125788,7 +136199,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125796,7 +136207,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125809,10 +136220,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125834,10 +136245,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "928df844dd5891fe8c26", + "claim_id": "a17671b3c67c05c8f8bd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125863,7 +136274,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125909,10 +136320,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d34ca758972ca6c5ce7c", + "claim_id": "aa36a6129b10da093198", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125938,7 +136349,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125946,7 +136357,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1865.64" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125959,10 +136370,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1865.64, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1865.64, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125984,10 +136395,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a17671b3c67c05c8f8bd", + "claim_id": "1546ba08331f579094f7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126013,7 +136424,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126021,7 +136432,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1608.468" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -126034,10 +136445,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1608.468, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1608.468, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126059,10 +136470,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aa36a6129b10da093198", + "claim_id": "7ea73eac8644ff0f5ac4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126088,7 +136499,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126096,7 +136507,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1865.64" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -126109,10 +136520,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 1865.64, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1865.64, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126134,10 +136545,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1546ba08331f579094f7", + "claim_id": "7edc1a905cc6e14b3c61", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126163,18 +136574,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", - "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", - "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", + "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1608.468" + "value_verbatim": "2148.367" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -126183,11 +136594,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 1608.468, + "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", + "external_value": 2148.367, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1608.468, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2148.367, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126209,10 +136620,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ea73eac8644ff0f5ac4", + "claim_id": "3ca5368164aadb96fc14", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126238,18 +136649,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", - "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", - "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", + "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1596.851" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -126258,11 +136669,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", + "external_value": 1596.851, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1596.851, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126284,10 +136695,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7edc1a905cc6e14b3c61", + "claim_id": "188da279068c78628784", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126313,7 +136724,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126321,7 +136732,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2148.367" + "value_verbatim": "913.2991" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126334,10 +136745,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 2148.367, + "external_value": 913.2991, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2148.367, + "external_value_pe_sign": 913.2991, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126359,10 +136770,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3ca5368164aadb96fc14", + "claim_id": "719defb266ed7b2371a0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126388,7 +136799,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126396,7 +136807,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1596.851" + "value_verbatim": "382.1102" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126409,10 +136820,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1596.851, + "external_value": 382.1102, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1596.851, + "external_value_pe_sign": 382.1102, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126434,10 +136845,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "188da279068c78628784", + "claim_id": "eaa1a616d3f6e406a0ee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126463,7 +136874,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126471,7 +136882,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "913.2991" + "value_verbatim": "65.7583" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126484,10 +136895,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 913.2991, + "external_value": 65.7583, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 913.2991, + "external_value_pe_sign": 65.7583, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126509,10 +136920,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "719defb266ed7b2371a0", + "claim_id": "2b605bfbc86c67f9e5b2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126538,7 +136949,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126546,7 +136957,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "382.1102" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126559,10 +136970,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 382.1102, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 382.1102, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126584,10 +136995,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "eaa1a616d3f6e406a0ee", + "claim_id": "7f7aa7bb5cd4500dbad6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126613,7 +137024,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126621,7 +137032,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "65.7583" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126634,10 +137045,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 65.7583, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 65.7583, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126659,10 +137070,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2b605bfbc86c67f9e5b2", + "claim_id": "ecb9f84fe7d77448c249", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126688,7 +137099,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126734,10 +137145,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7f7aa7bb5cd4500dbad6", + "claim_id": "8b2f44248e876704af4b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126763,7 +137174,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126771,7 +137182,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1299.181" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126784,10 +137195,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1299.181, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1299.181, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126809,10 +137220,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ecb9f84fe7d77448c249", + "claim_id": "f0044a1922baf643525a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126838,7 +137249,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126846,7 +137257,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1838.762" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126859,10 +137270,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1838.762, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1838.762, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126884,10 +137295,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8b2f44248e876704af4b", + "claim_id": "08e384253c6ef4f5c1e7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126913,7 +137324,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126921,7 +137332,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1299.181" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126934,10 +137345,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1299.181, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1299.181, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126959,10 +137370,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f0044a1922baf643525a", + "claim_id": "137585418b73550ae066", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126977,7 +137388,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -126988,31 +137398,34 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", - "option": "Introduce 50% child element", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", - "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1838.762" + "value_verbatim": "4302.053" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "partial", + "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit" + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1838.762, + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 4302.053, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1838.762, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4302.053, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127034,10 +137447,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "08e384253c6ef4f5c1e7", + "claim_id": "176915e4113a700e3f83", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127052,7 +137465,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -127063,31 +137475,34 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", - "option": "Introduce 50% child element", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", - "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "3316.293" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "partial", + "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit" + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 3316.293, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3316.293, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127109,10 +137524,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "137585418b73550ae066", + "claim_id": "fe098a528f54e583391e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127137,14 +137552,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "4302.053" + "value_verbatim": "2087.725" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127161,10 +137576,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 4302.053, + "external_value": 2087.725, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4302.053, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2087.725, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127186,10 +137601,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "176915e4113a700e3f83", + "claim_id": "534dc21f3c4d8c755ad7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127214,14 +137629,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3316.293" + "value_verbatim": "829.0254" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127238,10 +137653,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 3316.293, + "external_value": 829.0254, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3316.293, + "external_value_pe_sign": 829.0254, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127263,10 +137678,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe098a528f54e583391e", + "claim_id": "d1b11dd95153969d6f2f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127291,14 +137706,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2087.725" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127315,10 +137730,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 2087.725, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2087.725, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127340,10 +137755,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "534dc21f3c4d8c755ad7", + "claim_id": "4ef00847a53357a54394", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127368,14 +137783,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "829.0254" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127392,10 +137807,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 829.0254, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 829.0254, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127417,10 +137832,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d1b11dd95153969d6f2f", + "claim_id": "06cd474f45a6aa26a1bd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127445,14 +137860,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127469,10 +137884,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127494,10 +137909,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4ef00847a53357a54394", + "claim_id": "9794b6be574b6a9cce05", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127522,7 +137937,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -127571,10 +137986,87 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "06cd474f45a6aa26a1bd", + "claim_id": "ed451413070a348635bf", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / All", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "2613.37" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 2613.37, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 2613.37, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "792f5e298aa4331cbb80", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127599,14 +138091,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "3511.657" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127623,10 +138115,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 3511.657, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3511.657, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127648,10 +138140,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9794b6be574b6a9cce05", + "claim_id": "e42763231cd9502e4e1c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127676,7 +138168,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -127725,10 +138217,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ed451413070a348635bf", + "claim_id": "a963f3bd4bd29553781c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127753,17 +138245,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2613.37" + "value_verbatim": "3017.333" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127776,11 +138268,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 2613.37, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 3017.333, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2613.37, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3017.333, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127802,10 +138294,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "792f5e298aa4331cbb80", + "claim_id": "af2cb7d46caa9609d937", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127830,17 +138322,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3511.657" + "value_verbatim": "2640.092" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127853,11 +138345,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 3511.657, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 2640.092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3511.657, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2640.092, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127879,10 +138371,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e42763231cd9502e4e1c", + "claim_id": "36928182aeb4e0cb485d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127907,17 +138399,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_4", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1651.358" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127930,11 +138422,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 1651.358, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1651.358, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127956,10 +138448,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a963f3bd4bd29553781c", + "claim_id": "97ee14c1319888f1b273", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127984,14 +138476,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3017.333" + "value_verbatim": "755.2086" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128008,10 +138500,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 3017.333, + "external_value": 755.2086, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3017.333, + "external_value_pe_sign": 755.2086, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128033,10 +138525,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "af2cb7d46caa9609d937", + "claim_id": "9484b047818b904c7ecc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128061,14 +138553,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2640.092" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128085,10 +138577,164 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 2640.092, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2640.092, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "119ef29c082f2d805c3b", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 7", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_7", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "85c8557e3112d5e9b992", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 8", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_8", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128110,10 +138756,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "36928182aeb4e0cb485d", + "claim_id": "798260b399ee65eb2f80", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128138,14 +138784,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1651.358" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128162,10 +138808,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 1651.358, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1651.358, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128187,10 +138833,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "97ee14c1319888f1b273", + "claim_id": "7ceb762b850e15354772", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128215,14 +138861,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "755.2086" + "value_verbatim": "1907.131" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128239,10 +138885,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 755.2086, + "external_value": 1907.131, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 755.2086, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1907.131, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128264,10 +138910,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9484b047818b904c7ecc", + "claim_id": "732daff2183383bcb2f8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128292,14 +138938,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "2431.835" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128316,10 +138962,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 2431.835, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2431.835, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128341,10 +138987,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "119ef29c082f2d805c3b", + "claim_id": "c1ba3cb2c8886a771f69", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128369,7 +139015,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -128418,64 +139064,62 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "85c8557e3112d5e9b992", + "claim_id": "27352855b0b13547dc30", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 8", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "value_kind": "range_high", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "almost \u00a31,000 per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 1000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128495,64 +139139,61 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "798260b399ee65eb2f80", + "claim_id": "62a51fb068990b423ec1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 9", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3360 per employee per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 360.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128572,64 +139213,60 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ceb762b850e15354772", + "claim_id": "9c6229d4274cf5ac4624", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / All", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1907.131" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3151" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 1907.131, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1907.131, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 151.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128649,64 +139286,62 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "732daff2183383bcb2f8", + "claim_id": "b4f8bd23bbe5d4f12aee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Poorest", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "value_kind": "range_low", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2431.835" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "slightly over \u00a3140 per employee per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 2431.835, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2431.835, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 140.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128726,64 +139361,61 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c1ba3cb2c8886a771f69", + "claim_id": "bdafa33ca4895d387f3a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Richest", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3123" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 123.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128803,7 +139435,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "27352855b0b13547dc30", + "claim_id": "f8d6381bca0a75936332", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -128813,7 +139445,7 @@ "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "range_high", + "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, @@ -128824,18 +139456,16 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "range_high", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "almost \u00a31,000 per year" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a337" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -128853,7 +139483,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1000.0, + "external_value": 37.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -128878,14 +139508,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "62a51fb068990b423ec1", + "claim_id": "52422b20e74fe0235278", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1 to 9", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -128899,17 +139529,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", + "employer_size": "1 to 9", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3360 per employee per year" + "value_verbatim": "3.0461222622592534" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -128927,7 +139557,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 360.0, + "external_value": 3.0461222622592534, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -128952,14 +139582,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c6229d4274cf5ac4624", + "claim_id": "8c3c2f730a0e85ebf022", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10 to 49", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -128973,165 +139603,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "10 to 49", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3151" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 151.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "b4f8bd23bbe5d4f12aee", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "range_low", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "range_low", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "slightly over \u00a3140 per employee per year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 140.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "bdafa33ca4895d387f3a", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3123" + "value_verbatim": "9.145301761361411" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129149,7 +139631,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.0, + "external_value": 9.145301761361411, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129174,14 +139656,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f8d6381bca0a75936332", + "claim_id": "f816876c96e9d84520c5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -129195,16 +139677,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a337" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "43.77400352541435" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129222,7 +139705,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 37.0, + "external_value": 43.77400352541435, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129247,10 +139730,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "52422b20e74fe0235278", + "claim_id": "a5c1d3943f4f2a5f705a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1 to 9", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10000 to 29999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129268,7 +139751,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1 to 9", + "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129278,7 +139761,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "3.0461222622592534" + "value_verbatim": "41.62994582977899" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129296,7 +139779,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 3.0461222622592534, + "external_value": 41.62994582977899, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129321,10 +139804,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8c3c2f730a0e85ebf022", + "claim_id": "4757627f8c543c204d9e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10 to 49", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 200 to 999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129342,7 +139825,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10 to 49", + "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129352,7 +139835,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "9.145301761361411" + "value_verbatim": "34.53187139226558" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129370,7 +139853,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 9.145301761361411, + "external_value": 34.53187139226558, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129395,10 +139878,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f816876c96e9d84520c5", + "claim_id": "bcf54f5cdceda1dd625e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 3", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129416,17 +139899,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "43.77400352541435" + "value_verbatim": "0.8678732461057174" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129444,7 +139927,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 43.77400352541435, + "external_value": 0.8678732461057174, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129469,10 +139952,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a5c1d3943f4f2a5f705a", + "claim_id": "38077c875ba1fa188cfa", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10000 to 29999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 30000+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129490,7 +139973,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", + "employer_size": "30000+", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129500,7 +139983,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "41.62994582977899" + "value_verbatim": "19.152681951998563" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129518,7 +140001,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 41.62994582977899, + "external_value": 19.152681951998563, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129543,10 +140026,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4757627f8c543c204d9e", + "claim_id": "7806a956cead33f8d9b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 200 to 999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 4", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129564,17 +140047,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "34.53187139226558" + "value_verbatim": "2.113901667282074" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129592,7 +140075,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 34.53187139226558, + "external_value": 2.113901667282074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129617,10 +140100,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bcf54f5cdceda1dd625e", + "claim_id": "5a278d8d4fba36cc7668", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 3", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129642,13 +140125,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.8678732461057174" + "value_verbatim": "5.136721095318348" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129666,7 +140149,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.8678732461057174, + "external_value": 5.136721095318348, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129691,10 +140174,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "38077c875ba1fa188cfa", + "claim_id": "57084f9cc3bfbbc50f95", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 30000+", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 50 to 199", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129712,7 +140195,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "30000+", + "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129722,7 +140205,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "19.152681951998563" + "value_verbatim": "18.302703499759048" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129740,7 +140223,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 19.152681951998563, + "external_value": 18.302703499759048, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129765,10 +140248,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7806a956cead33f8d9b0", + "claim_id": "225a474c4f8a9536f968", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 4", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5000 to 9999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129786,17 +140269,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "2.113901667282074" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "53.406588185522" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129814,7 +140297,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 2.113901667282074, + "external_value": 53.406588185522, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129839,10 +140322,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5a278d8d4fba36cc7668", + "claim_id": "ade7cf1e0631672dc381", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 6", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129864,13 +140347,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "5.136721095318348" + "value_verbatim": "12.16568214613685" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129888,7 +140371,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 5.136721095318348, + "external_value": 12.16568214613685, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129913,10 +140396,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "57084f9cc3bfbbc50f95", + "claim_id": "ff10be10b69194bbac95", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 50 to 199", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 7", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129934,17 +140417,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "18.302703499759048" + "value_verbatim": "25.187239955955185" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129962,7 +140445,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 18.302703499759048, + "external_value": 25.187239955955185, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129987,10 +140470,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "225a474c4f8a9536f968", + "claim_id": "5eff7f72fbedc7a6463c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5000 to 9999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 8", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130008,17 +140491,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "53.406588185522" + "value_verbatim": "21.716237881548597" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130036,7 +140519,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 53.406588185522, + "external_value": 21.716237881548597, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130061,10 +140544,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ade7cf1e0631672dc381", + "claim_id": "43d1b5b0124723cdf191", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 6", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130086,13 +140569,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "12.16568214613685" + "value_verbatim": "24.4095432289078" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130110,7 +140593,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 12.16568214613685, + "external_value": 24.4095432289078, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130135,10 +140618,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ff10be10b69194bbac95", + "claim_id": "fd6d9ea7c06603875804", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 7", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Accommodation & food services", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130159,14 +140642,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "25.187239955955185" + "sector": "Accommodation & food services", + "value_verbatim": "1.1275214508351372" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130184,7 +140666,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 25.187239955955185, + "external_value": 1.1275214508351372, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130209,10 +140691,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5eff7f72fbedc7a6463c", + "claim_id": "e583541a3710cfa3c7bc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 8", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Administrative & support", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130233,14 +140715,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "21.716237881548597" + "sector": "Administrative & support", + "value_verbatim": "10.138172997969372" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130258,7 +140739,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 21.716237881548597, + "external_value": 10.138172997969372, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130283,10 +140764,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "43d1b5b0124723cdf191", + "claim_id": "520e3e8a2fbe9f83cde2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 9", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 16-29", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130301,20 +140782,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "16-29", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "24.4095432289078" + "subgroup": "Age 16-29", + "value_verbatim": "11.653768814427075" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130332,7 +140813,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 24.4095432289078, + "external_value": 11.653768814427075, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130357,10 +140838,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd6d9ea7c06603875804", + "claim_id": "2876fe1456fd14c74d87", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Accommodation & food services", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 30-39", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130375,6 +140856,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "30-39", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130386,8 +140868,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Accommodation & food services", - "value_verbatim": "1.1275214508351372" + "subgroup": "Age 30-39", + "value_verbatim": "23.921537770771934" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130405,7 +140887,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1.1275214508351372, + "external_value": 23.921537770771934, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130430,10 +140912,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e583541a3710cfa3c7bc", + "claim_id": "f83a271b33090bcae7e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Administrative & support", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 40-49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130448,6 +140930,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130459,8 +140942,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Administrative & support", - "value_verbatim": "10.138172997969372" + "subgroup": "Age 40-49", + "value_verbatim": "26.71745027504521" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130478,7 +140961,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 10.138172997969372, + "external_value": 26.71745027504521, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130503,10 +140986,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "520e3e8a2fbe9f83cde2", + "claim_id": "4363a50fbfc2f5449762", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 16-29", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 50-59", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130521,7 +141004,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "16-29", + "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130533,8 +141016,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 16-29", - "value_verbatim": "11.653768814427075" + "subgroup": "Age 50-59", + "value_verbatim": "23.833895616840955" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130552,7 +141035,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 11.653768814427075, + "external_value": 23.833895616840955, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130577,10 +141060,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2876fe1456fd14c74d87", + "claim_id": "551368eea8ea4e822f1d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 30-39", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 60+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130595,7 +141078,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "30-39", + "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130607,8 +141090,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 30-39", - "value_verbatim": "23.921537770771934" + "subgroup": "Age 60+", + "value_verbatim": "12.66413756684722" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130626,7 +141109,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.921537770771934, + "external_value": 12.66413756684722, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130651,10 +141134,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f83a271b33090bcae7e1", + "claim_id": "93c5c773491ab50d93c1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 40-49", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130669,20 +141152,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 40-49", - "value_verbatim": "26.71745027504521" + "value_verbatim": "20.78243671212471" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130700,7 +141183,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 26.71745027504521, + "external_value": 20.78243671212471, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130725,10 +141208,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4363a50fbfc2f5449762", + "claim_id": "9686cf929d2fc570e5bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 50-59", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130743,7 +141226,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130755,8 +141237,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 50-59", - "value_verbatim": "23.833895616840955" + "subgroup": "all employees", + "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130774,7 +141256,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.833895616840955, + "external_value": 20.782436702128095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130799,10 +141281,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "551368eea8ea4e822f1d", + "claim_id": "f7b1e9f4eddb53c779e6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 60+", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130817,7 +141299,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130829,8 +141310,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 60+", - "value_verbatim": "12.66413756684722" + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130848,7 +141329,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 12.66413756684722, + "external_value": 20.782436702128095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130873,10 +141354,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "93c5c773491ab50d93c1", + "claim_id": "9d1387b52bd6b5b893bb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Construction", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130897,14 +141378,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "20.78243671212471" + "sector": "Construction", + "value_verbatim": "17.058063051425354" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130922,7 +141402,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.78243671212471, + "external_value": 17.058063051425354, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130947,10 +141427,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9686cf929d2fc570e5bf", + "claim_id": "250e731de2b34dd8ebff", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130971,13 +141451,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "all employees", - "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" + "value_verbatim": "116.0880640534236" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130995,7 +141476,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.782436702128095, + "external_value": 116.0880640534236, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131020,10 +141501,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f7b1e9f4eddb53c779e6", + "claim_id": "00476510d16eed030bba", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131044,13 +141525,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" + "value_verbatim": "0.07450457486077758" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131068,7 +141550,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.782436702128095, + "external_value": 0.07450457486077758, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131093,10 +141575,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9d1387b52bd6b5b893bb", + "claim_id": "ca2d56dc8e36d0a1710a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Construction", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Finance & insurance", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131122,8 +141604,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Construction", - "value_verbatim": "17.058063051425354" + "sector": "Finance & insurance", + "value_verbatim": "74.34333015035952" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131141,7 +141623,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 17.058063051425354, + "external_value": 74.34333015035952, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131166,10 +141648,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "250e731de2b34dd8ebff", + "claim_id": "9f5c08c636647995adef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Information & communication", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131190,14 +141672,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "116.0880640534236" + "sector": "Information & communication", + "value_verbatim": "63.34366017625928" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131215,7 +141696,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 116.0880640534236, + "external_value": 63.34366017625928, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131240,10 +141721,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "00476510d16eed030bba", + "claim_id": "f3cc0c2f7a065e448967", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Manufacturing", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131264,14 +141745,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.07450457486077758" + "sector": "Manufacturing", + "value_verbatim": "32.66468604698881" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131289,7 +141769,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.07450457486077758, + "external_value": 32.66468604698881, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131314,10 +141794,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ca2d56dc8e36d0a1710a", + "claim_id": "7f076d4380720272ddf6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Finance & insurance", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Men", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131343,8 +141823,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Finance & insurance", - "value_verbatim": "74.34333015035952" + "sex": "men", + "subgroup": "Men", + "value_verbatim": "27.530805267378295" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131362,7 +141843,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 74.34333015035952, + "external_value": 27.530805267378295, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131387,10 +141868,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9f5c08c636647995adef", + "claim_id": "d48dd27bf371b43059a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Information & communication", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Other industries", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131416,8 +141897,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Information & communication", - "value_verbatim": "63.34366017625928" + "sector": "Other industries", + "value_verbatim": "14.942446233186413" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131435,7 +141916,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 63.34366017625928, + "external_value": 14.942446233186413, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131460,10 +141941,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f3cc0c2f7a065e448967", + "claim_id": "981a35c0beef69999765", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Manufacturing", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Private sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131489,8 +141970,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Manufacturing", - "value_verbatim": "32.66468604698881" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "25.130604430409704" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131508,7 +141989,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 32.66468604698881, + "external_value": 25.130604430409704, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131533,10 +142014,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7f076d4380720272ddf6", + "claim_id": "4faf6b6deff0a09c388e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Men", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131562,9 +142043,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "men", - "subgroup": "Men", - "value_verbatim": "27.530805267378295" + "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", + "value_verbatim": "36.68112711725161" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131582,7 +142062,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 27.530805267378295, + "external_value": 36.68112711725161, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131607,10 +142087,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d48dd27bf371b43059a7", + "claim_id": "47853d9ffc0a8fd8b294", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Other industries", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Public sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131636,8 +142116,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Other industries", - "value_verbatim": "14.942446233186413" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "7.37718587675984" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131655,7 +142135,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.942446233186413, + "external_value": 7.37718587675984, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131680,10 +142160,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "981a35c0beef69999765", + "claim_id": "bd4abdf3671f29e5fe54", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Private sector", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Real Estate", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131709,8 +142189,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "25.130604430409704" + "sector": "Real Estate", + "value_verbatim": "21.31531199800756" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131728,7 +142208,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 25.130604430409704, + "external_value": 21.31531199800756, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131753,10 +142233,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4faf6b6deff0a09c388e", + "claim_id": "071fd0bf739fb73f5c1e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131782,8 +142262,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", - "value_verbatim": "36.68112711725161" + "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", + "value_verbatim": "23.23759789230727" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131801,7 +142281,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 36.68112711725161, + "external_value": 23.23759789230727, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131826,10 +142306,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "47853d9ffc0a8fd8b294", + "claim_id": "11e65c8d87823d466aef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Public sector", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Transport & storage", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131855,8 +142335,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "7.37718587675984" + "sector": "Transport & storage", + "value_verbatim": "23.225032393278717" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131874,7 +142354,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 7.37718587675984, + "external_value": 23.225032393278717, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131899,10 +142379,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bd4abdf3671f29e5fe54", + "claim_id": "6b3c55ab8e1ab7877869", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Real Estate", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Women", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131928,8 +142408,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Real Estate", - "value_verbatim": "21.31531199800756" + "sex": "women", + "subgroup": "Women", + "value_verbatim": "14.085935195305458" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131947,7 +142428,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 21.31531199800756, + "external_value": 14.085935195305458, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131972,10 +142453,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "071fd0bf739fb73f5c1e", + "claim_id": "feed61e01a1fae757b18", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1 to 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131993,16 +142474,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1 to 9", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", - "value_verbatim": "23.23759789230727" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "14.39960984510036" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132020,7 +142502,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.23759789230727, + "external_value": 14.39960984510036, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132045,10 +142527,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "11e65c8d87823d466aef", + "claim_id": "29cc4a350ec3785aa271", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Transport & storage", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10 to 49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132066,16 +142548,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "10 to 49", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Transport & storage", - "value_verbatim": "23.225032393278717" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "54.97683520545021" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132093,7 +142576,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.225032393278717, + "external_value": 54.97683520545021, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132118,10 +142601,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6b3c55ab8e1ab7877869", + "claim_id": "63ed03e7cf6589bd8bff", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Women", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1000 to 4999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132139,17 +142622,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "women", - "subgroup": "Women", - "value_verbatim": "14.085935195305458" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "265.86339870276527" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132167,7 +142650,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.085935195305458, + "external_value": 265.86339870276527, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132192,10 +142675,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "feed61e01a1fae757b18", + "claim_id": "a061fb3a0d21e087f208", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1 to 9", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10000 to 29999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132213,7 +142696,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1 to 9", + "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132223,7 +142706,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "14.39960984510036" + "value_verbatim": "234.41532113116642" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132241,7 +142724,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.39960984510036, + "external_value": 234.41532113116642, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132266,10 +142749,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "29cc4a350ec3785aa271", + "claim_id": "f98dd834eb8df34e0e93", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10 to 49", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 200 to 999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132287,7 +142770,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10 to 49", + "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132297,7 +142780,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "54.97683520545021" + "value_verbatim": "213.00534999908092" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132315,7 +142798,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 54.97683520545021, + "external_value": 213.00534999908092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132340,10 +142823,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "63ed03e7cf6589bd8bff", + "claim_id": "8ed5282ce5d33f61d2d0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 3", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132361,17 +142844,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "265.86339870276527" + "value_verbatim": "1.5767570267140745" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132389,7 +142872,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 265.86339870276527, + "external_value": 1.5767570267140745, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132414,10 +142897,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a061fb3a0d21e087f208", + "claim_id": "5d163d8d3b3c5296624b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10000 to 29999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 30000+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132435,7 +142918,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", + "employer_size": "30000+", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132445,7 +142928,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "234.41532113116642" + "value_verbatim": "126.52805790967456" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132463,7 +142946,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 234.41532113116642, + "external_value": 126.52805790967456, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132488,10 +142971,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f98dd834eb8df34e0e93", + "claim_id": "a203da93012f0074b7c7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 200 to 999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 4", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132509,17 +142992,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "213.00534999908092" + "value_verbatim": "3.9567333831938782" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132537,7 +143020,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 213.00534999908092, + "external_value": 3.9567333831938782, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132562,10 +143045,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8ed5282ce5d33f61d2d0", + "claim_id": "8544e0ffa34f10f6eaee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 3", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132587,13 +143070,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "1.5767570267140745" + "value_verbatim": "9.607267637613042" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132611,7 +143094,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1.5767570267140745, + "external_value": 9.607267637613042, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132636,10 +143119,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5d163d8d3b3c5296624b", + "claim_id": "cfa4832f36c5ead91c44", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 30000+", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 50 to 199", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132657,7 +143140,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "30000+", + "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132667,7 +143150,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "126.52805790967456" + "value_verbatim": "112.5623621920566" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132685,7 +143168,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 126.52805790967456, + "external_value": 112.5623621920566, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132710,10 +143193,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a203da93012f0074b7c7", + "claim_id": "fdc6bcf96dd28032dc52", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 4", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5000 to 9999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132731,17 +143214,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "3.9567333831938782" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "311.85429704048397" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132759,7 +143242,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 3.9567333831938782, + "external_value": 311.85429704048397, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132784,10 +143267,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8544e0ffa34f10f6eaee", + "claim_id": "539ab08f47405d1160fa", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 6", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132809,13 +143292,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "9.607267637613042" + "value_verbatim": "22.829496880411863" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132833,7 +143316,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 9.607267637613042, + "external_value": 22.829496880411863, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132858,10 +143341,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cfa4832f36c5ead91c44", + "claim_id": "39c7ae6ac1d83c82e42e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 50 to 199", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 7", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132879,17 +143362,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "112.5623621920566" + "value_verbatim": "47.302440969417866" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132907,7 +143390,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 112.5623621920566, + "external_value": 47.302440969417866, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132932,10 +143415,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fdc6bcf96dd28032dc52", + "claim_id": "c4bf9c7c8eee36dea646", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5000 to 9999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 8", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132953,17 +143436,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "311.85429704048397" + "value_verbatim": "95.54673178579887" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132981,7 +143464,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 311.85429704048397, + "external_value": 95.54673178579887, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133006,10 +143489,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "539ab08f47405d1160fa", + "claim_id": "ced45f7be2e8d9ef49c1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 6", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133031,13 +143514,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "22.829496880411863" + "value_verbatim": "180.45343539349838" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133055,7 +143538,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 22.829496880411863, + "external_value": 180.45343539349838, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133080,10 +143563,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "39c7ae6ac1d83c82e42e", + "claim_id": "a40492f0ee2e04575bdd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 7", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Accommodation & food services", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133104,14 +143587,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "47.302440969417866" + "sector": "Accommodation & food services", + "value_verbatim": "6.13022096388335" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133129,7 +143611,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 47.302440969417866, + "external_value": 6.13022096388335, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133154,10 +143636,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c4bf9c7c8eee36dea646", + "claim_id": "4a5464acb70bd7916ea8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 8", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Administrative & support", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133178,14 +143660,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "95.54673178579887" + "sector": "Administrative & support", + "value_verbatim": "56.08248408750178" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133203,7 +143684,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 95.54673178579887, + "external_value": 56.08248408750178, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133228,10 +143709,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ced45f7be2e8d9ef49c1", + "claim_id": "a2eddc6a2c66b2997f9a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 9", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 16-29", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133246,20 +143727,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "16-29", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "180.45343539349838" + "subgroup": "Age 16-29", + "value_verbatim": "52.55572182647085" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133277,7 +143758,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 180.45343539349838, + "external_value": 52.55572182647085, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133302,10 +143783,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a40492f0ee2e04575bdd", + "claim_id": "284b09136dba78f07595", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Accommodation & food services", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 30-39", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133320,6 +143801,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "30-39", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133331,8 +143813,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Accommodation & food services", - "value_verbatim": "6.13022096388335" + "subgroup": "Age 30-39", + "value_verbatim": "143.27787710165185" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133350,7 +143832,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 6.13022096388335, + "external_value": 143.27787710165185, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133375,10 +143857,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a5464acb70bd7916ea8", + "claim_id": "d5d46e69e7f1c7e06306", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Administrative & support", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 40-49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133393,6 +143875,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133404,8 +143887,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Administrative & support", - "value_verbatim": "56.08248408750178" + "subgroup": "Age 40-49", + "value_verbatim": "171.13698501393932" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133423,7 +143906,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 56.08248408750178, + "external_value": 171.13698501393932, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133448,10 +143931,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a2eddc6a2c66b2997f9a", + "claim_id": "9af5223777c562b943f5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 16-29", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 50-59", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133466,7 +143949,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "16-29", + "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133478,8 +143961,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 16-29", - "value_verbatim": "52.55572182647085" + "subgroup": "Age 50-59", + "value_verbatim": "145.29025498183447" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133497,7 +143980,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 52.55572182647085, + "external_value": 145.29025498183447, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133522,10 +144005,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "284b09136dba78f07595", + "claim_id": "a918d02fce8cbf358882", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 30-39", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 60+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133540,7 +144023,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "30-39", + "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133552,8 +144035,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 30-39", - "value_verbatim": "143.27787710165185" + "subgroup": "Age 60+", + "value_verbatim": "72.82329120507924" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133571,7 +144054,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 143.27787710165185, + "external_value": 72.82329120507924, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133596,10 +144079,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d5d46e69e7f1c7e06306", + "claim_id": "03ceeaea1f2b5ca0873c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 40-49", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133614,20 +144097,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 40-49", - "value_verbatim": "171.13698501393932" + "value_verbatim": "123.44323245099713" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133645,7 +144128,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 171.13698501393932, + "external_value": 123.44323245099713, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133670,10 +144153,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9af5223777c562b943f5", + "claim_id": "4b69418dca85d19f0046", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 50-59", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133688,7 +144171,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133700,8 +144182,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 50-59", - "value_verbatim": "145.29025498183447" + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "123.05899521234191" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133719,7 +144201,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 145.29025498183447, + "external_value": 123.05899521234191, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133744,10 +144226,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a918d02fce8cbf358882", + "claim_id": "5e57bd71f66a60c1ccf7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 60+", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133762,7 +144244,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133774,8 +144255,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 60+", - "value_verbatim": "72.82329120507924" + "subgroup": "all employees", + "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133793,7 +144274,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 72.82329120507924, + "external_value": 123.44323239161938, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133818,7 +144299,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "03ceeaea1f2b5ca0873c", + "claim_id": "8c8986ba539b79b3cf44", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", @@ -133835,6 +144316,152 @@ "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01867db201c74fc2ffba", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Construction", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "metric": "average_tax_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Construction", + "value_verbatim": "112.5634262423248" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 112.5634262423248, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c3a87af8902514d385e8", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "metric": "average_tax_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, "conditions": { "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -133843,13 +144470,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323245099713" + "value_verbatim": "872.8689059490712" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133867,7 +144494,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323245099713, + "external_value": 872.8689059490712, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133892,10 +144519,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4b69418dca85d19f0046", + "claim_id": "9a43fc94ddf359fb4d11", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133916,13 +144543,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "123.05899521234191" + "value_verbatim": "0.18017585554843393" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133940,7 +144568,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.05899521234191, + "external_value": 0.18017585554843393, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133965,10 +144593,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5e57bd71f66a60c1ccf7", + "claim_id": "a2285e1ce6dd2b00665e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Finance & insurance", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133994,8 +144622,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "all employees", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + "sector": "Finance & insurance", + "value_verbatim": "444.9788051762739" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134013,7 +144641,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "external_value": 444.9788051762739, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134038,10 +144666,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8c8986ba539b79b3cf44", + "claim_id": "b21a521737f658c9611b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Information & communication", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134067,8 +144695,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + "sector": "Information & communication", + "value_verbatim": "421.44733349528576" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134086,7 +144714,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "external_value": 421.44733349528576, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134111,10 +144739,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01867db201c74fc2ffba", + "claim_id": "2c2b42f6030332820c06", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Construction", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Manufacturing", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134140,8 +144768,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Construction", - "value_verbatim": "112.5634262423248" + "sector": "Manufacturing", + "value_verbatim": "198.05285550065074" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134159,7 +144787,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 112.5634262423248, + "external_value": 198.05285550065074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134184,10 +144812,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c3a87af8902514d385e8", + "claim_id": "94239833e6c5465a27fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Men", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134208,14 +144836,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "872.8689059490712" + "sex": "men", + "subgroup": "Men", + "value_verbatim": "171.76513414861247" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134233,7 +144861,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 872.8689059490712, + "external_value": 171.76513414861247, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134258,10 +144886,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9a43fc94ddf359fb4d11", + "claim_id": "5b56a8aec66dfe36e332", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Other industries", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134282,14 +144910,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.18017585554843393" + "sector": "Other industries", + "value_verbatim": "78.1994195641592" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134307,7 +144934,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.18017585554843393, + "external_value": 78.1994195641592, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134332,10 +144959,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a2285e1ce6dd2b00665e", + "claim_id": "b295532c1e195da9408e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Finance & insurance", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Private sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134361,8 +144988,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Finance & insurance", - "value_verbatim": "444.9788051762739" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "151.43091783766553" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134380,7 +145007,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 444.9788051762739, + "external_value": 151.43091783766553, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134405,10 +145032,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b21a521737f658c9611b", + "claim_id": "a1f6b471b435208df58e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Information & communication", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134434,8 +145061,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Information & communication", - "value_verbatim": "421.44733349528576" + "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", + "value_verbatim": "241.91582585068468" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134453,7 +145080,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 421.44733349528576, + "external_value": 241.91582585068468, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134478,10 +145105,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2c2b42f6030332820c06", + "claim_id": "2b7aa8ac2582843173c7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Manufacturing", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Public sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134507,8 +145134,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Manufacturing", - "value_verbatim": "198.05285550065074" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "37.158127192375716" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134526,7 +145153,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 198.05285550065074, + "external_value": 37.158127192375716, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134551,10 +145178,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "94239833e6c5465a27fb", + "claim_id": "acdd7568f5c5ab61fb61", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Men", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Real Estate", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134580,9 +145207,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "men", - "subgroup": "Men", - "value_verbatim": "171.76513414861247" + "sector": "Real Estate", + "value_verbatim": "109.27190895967401" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134600,7 +145226,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 171.76513414861247, + "external_value": 109.27190895967401, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134625,10 +145251,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5b56a8aec66dfe36e332", + "claim_id": "dd039b4bdcdd7b1856ca", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Other industries", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134654,8 +145280,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Other industries", - "value_verbatim": "78.1994195641592" + "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", + "value_verbatim": "136.39035161095623" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134673,7 +145299,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 78.1994195641592, + "external_value": 136.39035161095623, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134698,10 +145324,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b295532c1e195da9408e", + "claim_id": "9d5983e1abde01d96034", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Private sector", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Transport & storage", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134727,8 +145353,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "151.43091783766553" + "sector": "Transport & storage", + "value_verbatim": "142.10874467995092" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134746,7 +145372,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 151.43091783766553, + "external_value": 142.10874467995092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134771,10 +145397,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1f6b471b435208df58e", + "claim_id": "7ff9c846fae551d5baef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Women", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134800,8 +145426,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", - "value_verbatim": "241.91582585068468" + "sex": "women", + "subgroup": "Women", + "value_verbatim": "75.49270574681057" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134819,7 +145446,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 241.91582585068468, + "external_value": 75.49270574681057, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134844,18 +145471,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2b7aa8ac2582843173c7", + "claim_id": "8d5203be30a1d2354c63", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Public sector", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 0", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -134865,37 +145492,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "0", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "37.158127192375716" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 37.158127192375716, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -134917,18 +145552,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acdd7568f5c5ab61fb61", + "claim_id": "4dfaf9a547743e2a6fe2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Real Estate", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 1000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -134938,37 +145573,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "1000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Real Estate", - "value_verbatim": "109.27190895967401" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 109.27190895967401, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -134990,18 +145633,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dd039b4bdcdd7b1856ca", + "claim_id": "571c7e3f95eef0f0e44d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 10000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135011,37 +145654,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "10000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", - "value_verbatim": "136.39035161095623" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 136.39035161095623, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 35.99089, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135063,18 +145714,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9d5983e1abde01d96034", + "claim_id": "08b5844f627afc0e5d3c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Transport & storage", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 100000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135084,37 +145735,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "100000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Transport & storage", - "value_verbatim": "142.10874467995092" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 142.10874467995092, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 603.4957, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135136,18 +145795,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ff9c846fae551d5baef", + "claim_id": "62b39684b27c520e89cb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Women", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 101000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135157,38 +145816,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "101000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "women", - "subgroup": "Women", - "value_verbatim": "75.49270574681057" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 75.49270574681057, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 596.2975, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135210,10 +145876,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8d5203be30a1d2354c63", + "claim_id": "d5fb1da34fb7cdd13897", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 0", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 102000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135231,7 +145897,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "0", + "earnings": "102000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135243,7 +145909,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135266,10 +145932,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135291,10 +145957,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4dfaf9a547743e2a6fe2", + "claim_id": "7e5b37cb063421ef87ec", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 1000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 103000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135312,7 +145978,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "1000", + "earnings": "103000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135324,7 +145990,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135347,10 +146013,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135372,10 +146038,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "571c7e3f95eef0f0e44d", + "claim_id": "6368e91e8ec065f1fc5f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 10000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 104000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135393,7 +146059,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "10000", + "earnings": "104000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135405,7 +146071,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135428,10 +146094,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135453,10 +146119,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "08b5844f627afc0e5d3c", + "claim_id": "c8699d488e1a879ec872", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 100000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 105000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135474,7 +146140,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "100000", + "earnings": "105000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135486,7 +146152,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135509,10 +146175,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135534,10 +146200,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "62b39684b27c520e89cb", + "claim_id": "845b15051db75c823af8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 101000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 106000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135555,7 +146221,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "101000", + "earnings": "106000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135615,10 +146281,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d5fb1da34fb7cdd13897", + "claim_id": "097bb2f8167d8e31b5a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 102000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 107000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135636,7 +146302,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "102000", + "earnings": "107000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135696,10 +146362,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7e5b37cb063421ef87ec", + "claim_id": "2ede21259538f5759cb2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 103000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 108000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135717,7 +146383,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "103000", + "earnings": "108000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135777,10 +146443,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6368e91e8ec065f1fc5f", + "claim_id": "26748dcf99bce817b836", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 104000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 109000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135798,7 +146464,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "104000", + "earnings": "109000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135858,10 +146524,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c8699d488e1a879ec872", + "claim_id": "aea39360b457880dedfc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 105000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 11000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135879,7 +146545,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "105000", + "earnings": "11000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135891,7 +146557,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135914,10 +146580,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135939,10 +146605,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "845b15051db75c823af8", + "claim_id": "870bb607fac728f114d5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 106000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 110000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135960,7 +146626,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "106000", + "earnings": "110000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136020,10 +146686,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "097bb2f8167d8e31b5a7", + "claim_id": "cb7f1de3e18db431ca46", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 107000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 111000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136041,7 +146707,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "107000", + "earnings": "111000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136101,10 +146767,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2ede21259538f5759cb2", + "claim_id": "dfebd279dd241747956f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 108000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 112000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136122,7 +146788,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "108000", + "earnings": "112000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136182,10 +146848,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "26748dcf99bce817b836", + "claim_id": "05d57a372e04ac081085", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 109000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 113000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136203,7 +146869,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "109000", + "earnings": "113000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136263,91 +146929,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aea39360b457880dedfc", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 11000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "11000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "870bb607fac728f114d5", + "claim_id": "0b76db8b670a99f84031", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 110000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 114000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136365,7 +146950,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "110000", + "earnings": "114000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136425,10 +147010,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cb7f1de3e18db431ca46", + "claim_id": "3896e071a379b4269209", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 111000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 115000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136446,7 +147031,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "111000", + "earnings": "115000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136506,10 +147091,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dfebd279dd241747956f", + "claim_id": "183a666246c93b501364", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 112000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 116000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136527,7 +147112,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "112000", + "earnings": "116000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136587,10 +147172,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "05d57a372e04ac081085", + "claim_id": "494aeb57fbf30e8f9c31", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 113000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 117000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136608,7 +147193,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "113000", + "earnings": "117000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136668,10 +147253,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0b76db8b670a99f84031", + "claim_id": "e76a7596e00206c4eaa8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 114000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 118000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136689,7 +147274,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "114000", + "earnings": "118000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136749,10 +147334,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3896e071a379b4269209", + "claim_id": "1f4a547a4be657a64a71", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 115000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 119000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136770,7 +147355,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "115000", + "earnings": "119000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136830,10 +147415,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "183a666246c93b501364", + "claim_id": "685c5bd1e675fe1c673d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 116000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 12000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136851,7 +147436,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "116000", + "earnings": "12000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136863,7 +147448,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -136886,10 +147471,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -136911,10 +147496,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "494aeb57fbf30e8f9c31", + "claim_id": "b0758e7c23f34a6914eb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 117000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 120000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136932,7 +147517,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "117000", + "earnings": "120000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136992,10 +147577,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e76a7596e00206c4eaa8", + "claim_id": "8bbc16d6c98d0b56b490", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 118000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 121000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137013,7 +147598,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "118000", + "earnings": "121000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137073,10 +147658,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1f4a547a4be657a64a71", + "claim_id": "739f84d666caf2a5191a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 119000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 122000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137094,7 +147679,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "119000", + "earnings": "122000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137154,91 +147739,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "685c5bd1e675fe1c673d", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 12000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "12000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "b0758e7c23f34a6914eb", + "claim_id": "69686646c0aa944c11e3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 120000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 123000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137256,7 +147760,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "120000", + "earnings": "123000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137268,7 +147772,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "500.5586" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137291,10 +147795,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 500.5586, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 500.5586, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137316,10 +147820,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8bbc16d6c98d0b56b490", + "claim_id": "c7595d92d8c6a377163a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 121000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 124000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137337,7 +147841,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "121000", + "earnings": "124000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137349,7 +147853,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137372,10 +147876,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137397,10 +147901,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "739f84d666caf2a5191a", + "claim_id": "fc45fe50bc853719e445", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 122000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 125000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137418,7 +147922,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "122000", + "earnings": "125000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137430,7 +147934,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137453,10 +147957,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137478,10 +147982,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "69686646c0aa944c11e3", + "claim_id": "e717e269148c722a263a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 123000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 126000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137499,7 +148003,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "123000", + "earnings": "126000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137511,7 +148015,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "500.5586" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137534,10 +148038,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 500.5586, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 500.5586, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137559,10 +148063,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c7595d92d8c6a377163a", + "claim_id": "c42c2b54be196f6002fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 124000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 127000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137580,7 +148084,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "124000", + "earnings": "127000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137640,10 +148144,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fc45fe50bc853719e445", + "claim_id": "cbcbe26cf8070c0fbbe2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 125000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 128000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137661,7 +148165,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "125000", + "earnings": "128000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137721,10 +148225,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e717e269148c722a263a", + "claim_id": "9c1e7287d5fa9133262d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 126000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 129000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137742,7 +148246,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "126000", + "earnings": "129000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137802,10 +148306,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c42c2b54be196f6002fb", + "claim_id": "4f99475a6e16449579d8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 127000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 13000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137823,7 +148327,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "127000", + "earnings": "13000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137835,7 +148339,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137858,10 +148362,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137883,10 +148387,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cbcbe26cf8070c0fbbe2", + "claim_id": "18a8efc3e46e2675ebcc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 128000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 130000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137904,7 +148408,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "128000", + "earnings": "130000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137964,10 +148468,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c1e7287d5fa9133262d", + "claim_id": "be0f6c3eb8d12cb317dc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 129000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 131000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137985,7 +148489,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "129000", + "earnings": "131000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138045,10 +148549,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4f99475a6e16449579d8", + "claim_id": "21c04e327956d7e7ccf7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 13000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 132000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138066,7 +148570,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "13000", + "earnings": "132000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138078,7 +148582,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138101,10 +148605,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -138126,10 +148630,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "18a8efc3e46e2675ebcc", + "claim_id": "713c0102cabc053e1207", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 130000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 133000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138147,7 +148651,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "130000", + "earnings": "133000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138207,10 +148711,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "be0f6c3eb8d12cb317dc", + "claim_id": "9c09cf91dc8a2923d9e2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 131000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 134000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138228,7 +148732,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "131000", + "earnings": "134000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138288,10 +148792,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "21c04e327956d7e7ccf7", + "claim_id": "155ddca6f0af43f794b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 132000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 135000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138309,7 +148813,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "132000", + "earnings": "135000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138369,10 +148873,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "713c0102cabc053e1207", + "claim_id": "f34d18e138ffd12abe0a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 133000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 136000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138390,7 +148894,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "133000", + "earnings": "136000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138450,10 +148954,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c09cf91dc8a2923d9e2", + "claim_id": "bbc43c2dd5466de2a829", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 134000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 137000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138471,7 +148975,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "134000", + "earnings": "137000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138531,10 +149035,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "155ddca6f0af43f794b0", + "claim_id": "892573efa899589b80a5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 135000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 138000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138552,7 +149056,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "135000", + "earnings": "138000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138612,10 +149116,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f34d18e138ffd12abe0a", + "claim_id": "210dcf2c90829af8046b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 136000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 139000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138633,7 +149137,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "136000", + "earnings": "139000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138693,10 +149197,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bbc43c2dd5466de2a829", + "claim_id": "e6aee8eb66d6fd8d5b8d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 137000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 14000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138714,7 +149218,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "137000", + "earnings": "14000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138726,7 +149230,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138749,10 +149253,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -138774,10 +149278,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "892573efa899589b80a5", + "claim_id": "ef84a6ef82ecd2fe2b30", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 138000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 140000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138795,7 +149299,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "138000", + "earnings": "140000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138855,10 +149359,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "210dcf2c90829af8046b", + "claim_id": "23cf3eb55edcbb28f516", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 139000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 141000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138876,7 +149380,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "139000", + "earnings": "141000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138936,10 +149440,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e6aee8eb66d6fd8d5b8d", + "claim_id": "23d5fbf3bc8d7c82ce2b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 14000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 142000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138957,7 +149461,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "14000", + "earnings": "142000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138969,7 +149473,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138992,10 +149496,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139017,10 +149521,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ef84a6ef82ecd2fe2b30", + "claim_id": "8006ec5687201fb592f2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 140000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 143000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139038,7 +149542,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "140000", + "earnings": "143000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139098,10 +149602,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23cf3eb55edcbb28f516", + "claim_id": "1a8686319da974d822db", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 141000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 144000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139119,7 +149623,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "141000", + "earnings": "144000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139179,10 +149683,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23d5fbf3bc8d7c82ce2b", + "claim_id": "f8899adc104ec1a461ca", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 142000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 145000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139200,7 +149704,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "142000", + "earnings": "145000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139260,10 +149764,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8006ec5687201fb592f2", + "claim_id": "13c7a428c22d989a842c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 143000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 146000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139281,7 +149785,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "143000", + "earnings": "146000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139341,10 +149845,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1a8686319da974d822db", + "claim_id": "656e558ecf9f382b10bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 144000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 147000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139362,7 +149866,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "144000", + "earnings": "147000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139422,10 +149926,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f8899adc104ec1a461ca", + "claim_id": "d4fee346ffe6d0de112c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 145000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 148000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139443,7 +149947,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "145000", + "earnings": "148000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139503,10 +150007,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13c7a428c22d989a842c", + "claim_id": "3a499976f699e6354fb4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 146000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 149000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139524,7 +150028,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "146000", + "earnings": "149000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139584,10 +150088,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "656e558ecf9f382b10bf", + "claim_id": "8f537d2100e156598dce", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 147000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 15000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139605,7 +150109,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "147000", + "earnings": "15000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139617,7 +150121,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139640,10 +150144,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139665,10 +150169,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d4fee346ffe6d0de112c", + "claim_id": "4f34913397b3b37e201b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 148000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 150000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139686,7 +150190,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "148000", + "earnings": "150000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139746,10 +150250,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3a499976f699e6354fb4", + "claim_id": "d97cc750532ccfab4133", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 149000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 16000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139767,7 +150271,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "149000", + "earnings": "16000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139779,7 +150283,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139802,10 +150306,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139827,10 +150331,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8f537d2100e156598dce", + "claim_id": "96f632b441ec9b644262", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 15000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 17000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139848,7 +150352,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "15000", + "earnings": "17000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139908,10 +150412,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4f34913397b3b37e201b", + "claim_id": "89204c62e62b5b63e469", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 150000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 18000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139929,7 +150433,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "150000", + "earnings": "18000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139941,7 +150445,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139964,10 +150468,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139989,10 +150493,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d97cc750532ccfab4133", + "claim_id": "9ae81f17c7326746d622", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 16000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 19000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140010,7 +150514,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "16000", + "earnings": "19000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140070,10 +150574,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "96f632b441ec9b644262", + "claim_id": "5262e8fc72227907758a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 17000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 2000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140091,7 +150595,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "17000", + "earnings": "2000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140103,7 +150607,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -140126,10 +150630,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -140151,10 +150655,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "89204c62e62b5b63e469", + "claim_id": "84c657086c6d32bebe83", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 18000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 20000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140172,7 +150676,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "18000", + "earnings": "20000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140232,10 +150736,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9ae81f17c7326746d622", + "claim_id": "ae4c07aeadb21eef7e66", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 19000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 21000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140253,7 +150757,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "19000", + "earnings": "21000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140313,10 +150817,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5262e8fc72227907758a", + "claim_id": "217c05d738c8ce23f33f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 2000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 22000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140334,7 +150838,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "2000", + "earnings": "22000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140346,7 +150850,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -140369,10 +150873,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -140394,10 +150898,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "84c657086c6d32bebe83", + "claim_id": "3e3e15f2edbd81a5cfe7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 20000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 23000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140415,7 +150919,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "20000", + "earnings": "23000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140475,10 +150979,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae4c07aeadb21eef7e66", + "claim_id": "370085d411c02f1ea097", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 21000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 24000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140496,7 +151000,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "21000", + "earnings": "24000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140556,10 +151060,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "217c05d738c8ce23f33f", + "claim_id": "4a16c81bc1d7bdd3ede1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 22000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 25000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140577,7 +151081,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "22000", + "earnings": "25000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140637,10 +151141,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3e3e15f2edbd81a5cfe7", + "claim_id": "24f95947c03f5553ab86", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 23000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 26000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140658,7 +151162,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "23000", + "earnings": "26000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140718,10 +151222,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "370085d411c02f1ea097", + "claim_id": "c31fd99e90105533107b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 24000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 27000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140739,7 +151243,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "24000", + "earnings": "27000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140799,10 +151303,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a16c81bc1d7bdd3ede1", + "claim_id": "3ef7521c636bb2a32823", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 25000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 28000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140820,7 +151324,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "25000", + "earnings": "28000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140880,10 +151384,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "24f95947c03f5553ab86", + "claim_id": "80c72dbaac623449d1f6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 26000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 29000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140901,7 +151405,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "26000", + "earnings": "29000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140961,10 +151465,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c31fd99e90105533107b", + "claim_id": "097761ca82db479e7258", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 27000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 3000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140982,7 +151486,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "27000", + "earnings": "3000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140994,7 +151498,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141017,10 +151521,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141042,10 +151546,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3ef7521c636bb2a32823", + "claim_id": "bb065b1707bee3d4de26", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 28000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 30000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141063,7 +151567,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "28000", + "earnings": "30000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141123,10 +151627,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "80c72dbaac623449d1f6", + "claim_id": "73b7acb3346be6cc1835", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 29000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 31000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141144,7 +151648,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "29000", + "earnings": "31000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141204,10 +151708,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "097761ca82db479e7258", + "claim_id": "28f894eafc23e05eb558", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 3000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 32000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141225,7 +151729,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "3000", + "earnings": "32000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141237,7 +151741,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141260,10 +151764,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141285,10 +151789,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bb065b1707bee3d4de26", + "claim_id": "954d437c73a629da9840", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 30000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 33000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141306,7 +151810,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "30000", + "earnings": "33000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141366,10 +151870,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "73b7acb3346be6cc1835", + "claim_id": "4bb4625c4a8717930c86", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 31000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 34000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141387,7 +151891,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "31000", + "earnings": "34000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141447,10 +151951,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "28f894eafc23e05eb558", + "claim_id": "4161e0d52649a240230d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 32000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 35000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141468,7 +151972,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "32000", + "earnings": "35000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141528,10 +152032,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "954d437c73a629da9840", + "claim_id": "24259052a0cd4f343a8f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 33000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 36000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141549,7 +152053,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "33000", + "earnings": "36000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141609,10 +152113,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4bb4625c4a8717930c86", + "claim_id": "867bc2386cd205745276", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 34000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 37000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141630,7 +152134,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "34000", + "earnings": "37000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141690,10 +152194,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4161e0d52649a240230d", + "claim_id": "e71d86dfdd752a94eb73", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 35000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 38000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141711,7 +152215,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "35000", + "earnings": "38000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141771,10 +152275,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "24259052a0cd4f343a8f", + "claim_id": "b0e7b0e509a1a76eb8b9", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 36000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 39000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141792,7 +152296,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "36000", + "earnings": "39000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141852,10 +152356,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "867bc2386cd205745276", + "claim_id": "db192b5f001e0acd0c81", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 37000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 4000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141873,7 +152377,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "37000", + "earnings": "4000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141885,7 +152389,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141908,10 +152412,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141933,10 +152437,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e71d86dfdd752a94eb73", + "claim_id": "b49235fbe6819fc13fd3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 38000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 40000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141954,7 +152458,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "38000", + "earnings": "40000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142014,10 +152518,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b0e7b0e509a1a76eb8b9", + "claim_id": "182dff67000399270ed8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 39000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 41000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142035,7 +152539,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "39000", + "earnings": "41000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142095,10 +152599,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "db192b5f001e0acd0c81", + "claim_id": "f42080865f73c39986e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 4000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 42000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142116,7 +152620,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "4000", + "earnings": "42000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142128,7 +152632,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142151,10 +152655,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142176,10 +152680,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b49235fbe6819fc13fd3", + "claim_id": "a3628878a5af99eab6c2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 40000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 43000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142197,7 +152701,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "40000", + "earnings": "43000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142257,10 +152761,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "182dff67000399270ed8", + "claim_id": "a9b9c99f3ddaad62ea8a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 41000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 44000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142278,7 +152782,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "41000", + "earnings": "44000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142338,10 +152842,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f42080865f73c39986e1", + "claim_id": "b7ded692740012907add", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 42000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 45000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142359,7 +152863,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "42000", + "earnings": "45000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142371,7 +152875,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "270.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142394,10 +152898,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 270.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 270.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142419,10 +152923,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3628878a5af99eab6c2", + "claim_id": "1b4b4542d59fd9efc720", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 43000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 46000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142440,7 +152944,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "43000", + "earnings": "46000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142452,7 +152956,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "410.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142475,10 +152979,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 410.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 410.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142500,10 +153004,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a9b9c99f3ddaad62ea8a", + "claim_id": "815f5d0ece1ae30d23de", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 44000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 47000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142521,7 +153025,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "44000", + "earnings": "47000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142533,7 +153037,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "550.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142556,10 +153060,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 550.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 550.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142581,10 +153085,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b7ded692740012907add", + "claim_id": "c49cce47d26c1d5d27b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 45000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 48000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142602,7 +153106,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "45000", + "earnings": "48000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142614,7 +153118,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "270.4588" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142637,10 +153141,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 270.4588, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 270.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142662,10 +153166,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1b4b4542d59fd9efc720", + "claim_id": "98be12cebfc529b1cd10", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 46000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 49000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142683,7 +153187,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "46000", + "earnings": "49000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142695,7 +153199,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "410.4588" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142718,10 +153222,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 410.4588, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 410.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142743,10 +153247,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "815f5d0ece1ae30d23de", + "claim_id": "a18ada81dd54ea335ef8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 47000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 5000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142764,7 +153268,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "47000", + "earnings": "5000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142776,7 +153280,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "550.4588" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142799,10 +153303,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 550.4588, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 550.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142824,10 +153328,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c49cce47d26c1d5d27b0", + "claim_id": "8dadafbe3bf0fb0ddbcd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 48000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 50000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142845,7 +153349,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "48000", + "earnings": "50000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142905,10 +153409,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "98be12cebfc529b1cd10", + "claim_id": "dd6cea05595173b93703", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 49000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 51000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142926,7 +153430,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "49000", + "earnings": "51000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142986,10 +153490,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a18ada81dd54ea335ef8", + "claim_id": "13fdecb5f020c68b701a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 5000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 52000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143007,7 +153511,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "5000", + "earnings": "52000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143019,7 +153523,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143042,10 +153546,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143067,10 +153571,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8dadafbe3bf0fb0ddbcd", + "claim_id": "639d082f402bfcff98ec", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 50000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 53000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143088,7 +153592,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "50000", + "earnings": "53000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143148,10 +153652,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dd6cea05595173b93703", + "claim_id": "22f21b670f0aa25b74b8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 51000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 54000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143169,7 +153673,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "51000", + "earnings": "54000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143229,10 +153733,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13fdecb5f020c68b701a", + "claim_id": "e3aa4cfb40ea54beac8b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 52000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 55000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143250,7 +153754,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "52000", + "earnings": "55000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143310,10 +153814,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "639d082f402bfcff98ec", + "claim_id": "a57d6451fab16db0a9db", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 53000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 56000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143331,7 +153835,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "53000", + "earnings": "56000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143391,10 +153895,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "22f21b670f0aa25b74b8", + "claim_id": "e22a4bf0d0af9a3f3720", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 54000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 57000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143412,7 +153916,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "54000", + "earnings": "57000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143472,10 +153976,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e3aa4cfb40ea54beac8b", + "claim_id": "c0a599410b27950de717", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 55000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 58000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143493,7 +153997,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "55000", + "earnings": "58000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143553,10 +154057,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a57d6451fab16db0a9db", + "claim_id": "21b94eec2b7dca74b73a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 56000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 59000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143574,7 +154078,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "56000", + "earnings": "59000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143634,10 +154138,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e22a4bf0d0af9a3f3720", + "claim_id": "29700f726d59e1df2a00", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 57000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 6000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143655,7 +154159,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "57000", + "earnings": "6000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143667,7 +154171,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143690,10 +154194,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143715,10 +154219,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c0a599410b27950de717", + "claim_id": "4845a19d7cad33f3ce75", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 58000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 60000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143736,7 +154240,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "58000", + "earnings": "60000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143796,10 +154300,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "21b94eec2b7dca74b73a", + "claim_id": "51a529a918342633a2d3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 59000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 61000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143817,7 +154321,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "59000", + "earnings": "61000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143877,10 +154381,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "29700f726d59e1df2a00", + "claim_id": "d082556ae57b7419cc1c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 6000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 62000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143898,7 +154402,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "6000", + "earnings": "62000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143910,7 +154414,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143933,10 +154437,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143958,10 +154462,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4845a19d7cad33f3ce75", + "claim_id": "b06d8576e4a7fae7b217", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 60000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 63000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143979,7 +154483,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "60000", + "earnings": "63000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144039,10 +154543,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "51a529a918342633a2d3", + "claim_id": "a7f0daf26f8154d7a926", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 61000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 64000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144060,7 +154564,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "61000", + "earnings": "64000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144120,10 +154624,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d082556ae57b7419cc1c", + "claim_id": "ce644cadddd2f637dc11", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 62000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 65000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144141,7 +154645,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "62000", + "earnings": "65000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144201,10 +154705,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b06d8576e4a7fae7b217", + "claim_id": "bea06b159005f6c6ef9e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 63000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 66000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144222,7 +154726,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "63000", + "earnings": "66000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144282,10 +154786,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a7f0daf26f8154d7a926", + "claim_id": "0a70fba72e2aaa84a3fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 64000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 67000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144303,7 +154807,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "64000", + "earnings": "67000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144363,10 +154867,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce644cadddd2f637dc11", + "claim_id": "01896ab61c64cc6dc9ad", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 65000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 68000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144384,7 +154888,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "65000", + "earnings": "68000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144444,10 +154948,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bea06b159005f6c6ef9e", + "claim_id": "22dcc9e1370b03864a01", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 66000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 69000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144465,7 +154969,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "66000", + "earnings": "69000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144525,10 +155029,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0a70fba72e2aaa84a3fb", + "claim_id": "591260ab136938684942", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 67000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 7000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144546,7 +155050,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "67000", + "earnings": "7000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144558,7 +155062,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -144581,10 +155085,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -144606,10 +155110,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01896ab61c64cc6dc9ad", + "claim_id": "215efbfb42dc69416670", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 68000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 70000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144627,7 +155131,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "68000", + "earnings": "70000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144687,10 +155191,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "22dcc9e1370b03864a01", + "claim_id": "ce57424e7c89ef057961", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 69000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 71000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144708,7 +155212,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "69000", + "earnings": "71000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144768,10 +155272,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "591260ab136938684942", + "claim_id": "6bf539ecd5e112236af4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 7000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 72000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144789,7 +155293,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "7000", + "earnings": "72000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144801,7 +155305,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -144824,10 +155328,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -144849,10 +155353,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "215efbfb42dc69416670", + "claim_id": "a1fb568cd270c84e5c74", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 70000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 73000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144870,7 +155374,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "70000", + "earnings": "73000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144930,10 +155434,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce57424e7c89ef057961", + "claim_id": "8124e25b2e2efe5f1f20", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 71000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 74000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144951,7 +155455,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "71000", + "earnings": "74000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145011,10 +155515,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6bf539ecd5e112236af4", + "claim_id": "9fe7d6220dbf07d3eccc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 72000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 75000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145032,7 +155536,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "72000", + "earnings": "75000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145092,10 +155596,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1fb568cd270c84e5c74", + "claim_id": "44d3901e1a6c601993e6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 73000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 76000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145113,7 +155617,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "73000", + "earnings": "76000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145173,10 +155677,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8124e25b2e2efe5f1f20", + "claim_id": "3a414355a663ceb12987", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 74000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 77000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145194,7 +155698,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "74000", + "earnings": "77000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145254,10 +155758,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9fe7d6220dbf07d3eccc", + "claim_id": "aff7a315c044724a4f6f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 75000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 78000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145275,7 +155779,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "75000", + "earnings": "78000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145335,10 +155839,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "44d3901e1a6c601993e6", + "claim_id": "8d88acb69a401541e5b6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 76000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 79000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145356,7 +155860,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "76000", + "earnings": "79000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145416,10 +155920,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3a414355a663ceb12987", + "claim_id": "1010791d1b192f878df8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 77000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 8000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145437,7 +155941,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "77000", + "earnings": "8000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145449,7 +155953,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -145472,10 +155976,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -145497,10 +156001,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aff7a315c044724a4f6f", + "claim_id": "aebb4cb72868b9ed169b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 78000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 80000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145518,7 +156022,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "78000", + "earnings": "80000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145578,10 +156082,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8d88acb69a401541e5b6", + "claim_id": "782debd16234ab5d2d5b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 79000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 81000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145599,7 +156103,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "79000", + "earnings": "81000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145659,91 +156163,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1010791d1b192f878df8", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 8000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "8000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "aebb4cb72868b9ed169b", + "claim_id": "a7fee44b6298b93eef72", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 80000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 82000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145761,7 +156184,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "80000", + "earnings": "82000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145821,10 +156244,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "782debd16234ab5d2d5b", + "claim_id": "3eb6391c4283d0a917bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 81000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 83000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145842,7 +156265,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "81000", + "earnings": "83000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145902,10 +156325,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a7fee44b6298b93eef72", + "claim_id": "26ea437b0f15d9bb43be", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 82000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 84000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145923,7 +156346,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "82000", + "earnings": "84000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145983,10 +156406,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3eb6391c4283d0a917bf", + "claim_id": "e0eb0b06fc065c3e7a4e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 83000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 85000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146004,7 +156427,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "83000", + "earnings": "85000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146064,10 +156487,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "26ea437b0f15d9bb43be", + "claim_id": "fcacec9605852f95e183", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 84000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 86000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146085,7 +156508,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "84000", + "earnings": "86000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146145,10 +156568,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e0eb0b06fc065c3e7a4e", + "claim_id": "0a5540360e3f29bb32c9", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 85000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 87000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146166,7 +156589,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "85000", + "earnings": "87000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146226,10 +156649,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fcacec9605852f95e183", + "claim_id": "c088a61a5906224e6661", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 86000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 88000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146247,7 +156670,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "86000", + "earnings": "88000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146307,10 +156730,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0a5540360e3f29bb32c9", + "claim_id": "13222c58729a8e8ec1a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 87000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 89000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146328,7 +156751,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "87000", + "earnings": "89000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146388,10 +156811,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c088a61a5906224e6661", + "claim_id": "5ccd8200ac0315441b29", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 88000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 9000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146409,7 +156832,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "88000", + "earnings": "9000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146421,7 +156844,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -146444,10 +156867,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -146469,10 +156892,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13222c58729a8e8ec1a7", + "claim_id": "7f3f49698a58db18452e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 89000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 90000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146490,7 +156913,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "89000", + "earnings": "90000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146550,91 +156973,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5ccd8200ac0315441b29", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 9000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "9000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "7f3f49698a58db18452e", + "claim_id": "31bd5381cb2820c8e5f6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 90000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 91000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146652,7 +156994,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "90000", + "earnings": "91000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146712,10 +157054,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "31bd5381cb2820c8e5f6", + "claim_id": "4920c6e94a89d122df3e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 91000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 92000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146733,7 +157075,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "91000", + "earnings": "92000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146793,10 +157135,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4920c6e94a89d122df3e", + "claim_id": "67603d8fdeb1a70274a8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 92000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 93000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146814,7 +157156,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "92000", + "earnings": "93000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146874,10 +157216,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "67603d8fdeb1a70274a8", + "claim_id": "fe64d87d0a68f647a7f4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 93000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 94000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146895,7 +157237,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "93000", + "earnings": "94000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146955,10 +157297,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe64d87d0a68f647a7f4", + "claim_id": "5f3bd59b23084e2de3e2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 94000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 95000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146976,7 +157318,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "94000", + "earnings": "95000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147036,10 +157378,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5f3bd59b23084e2de3e2", + "claim_id": "a3bd93e5eab5fb4c3cee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 95000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 96000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147057,7 +157399,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "95000", + "earnings": "96000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147117,10 +157459,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3bd93e5eab5fb4c3cee", + "claim_id": "be7bd83396c3a34442fd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 96000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 97000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147138,7 +157480,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "96000", + "earnings": "97000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147198,10 +157540,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "be7bd83396c3a34442fd", + "claim_id": "55eb739f0ee9f768a576", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 97000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 98000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147219,7 +157561,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "97000", + "earnings": "98000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147279,10 +157621,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "55eb739f0ee9f768a576", + "claim_id": "65fa2ec5e082727f0a0e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 98000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 99000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147300,7 +157642,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "98000", + "earnings": "99000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147360,84 +157702,75 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "65fa2ec5e082727f0a0e", + "claim_id": "a08e1521d074011ce421", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 99000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "source_column": "2026-27", + "name": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", + "publication_title": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_since_2011_fy2026", "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the new triple lock applied since 2011 against spending as it is", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "99000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "fy": "2026-27", + "price_basis": "cash, 2026-27", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (expenditure in 2026-27 'would be \u00a39 billion lower')", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a39 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "reform_key": "8e17757fd40fb263", + "external_value": 9000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -9000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -7253585729.199216, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"history_since_2012_gross_fy2026\", \"field\": \"trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.805953969911024, + "delta": -16253585729.199215 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -7253585729.199216, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"history_since_2012_gross_fy2026\", \"field\": \"trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -147652,6 +157985,83 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "85e0adaf74f06a20923e", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034-35", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_saving_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "IFS's expectation ('we expect'); not stated whether gross spending or net of tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "not stated", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the reform 'will save around \u00a34 billion per year')", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-price-basis-not-stated: The comparison takes IFS's 'around \u00a34 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the \u00a311bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about \u00a34.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is \u00a32.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8029533136675016, + "delta": -7211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-price-basis-not-stated: The comparison takes IFS's 'around \u00a34 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the \u00a311bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about \u00a34.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is \u00a32.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "ab1977b0d4a5bebcc7c2", "source": "ifs", @@ -148778,6 +159188,162 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "9dbeaaa5d65adab8054f", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039-40, range high", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_range_high_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.5568431827525536, + "delta": -31136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7722e305e72571c0bf0c", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039-40, range low", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_range_low_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -2.7842159137627682, + "delta": -15136863655.051073 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "e85d1329a69f36bd540e", "source": "ifs", @@ -171727,6 +182293,308 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f6312ce2feae21469395", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annual cost of a permanent electricity VAT cut", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_vat_cut_permanent_annual_cost", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate made permanent", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1c2e01042aeed16a", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -1.0333333333333334, + "delta": -3050000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8e0937c6231e31775400", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "19ef9f65bb9ad8de", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.68125, + "delta": -5380000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "94527daa06a339c9677d", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32.7 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "19ef9f65bb9ad8de", + "external_value": 2700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.8074074074074075, + "delta": -4880000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "059df1c2d9ae37dc8a00", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual cost of a permanent cut", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_vat_permanent_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the annual cost of keeping the cut beyond 31 March 2027, whose first year is 2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.9666666666666667, + "delta": -2950000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "47a54f754504b06fad4b", "source": "ifs", @@ -172022,32 +182890,258 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", - "external_value": 400000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:not_this_quantity", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "external_value": 400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:not_this_quantity", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "992cf9045b3e6dbb2413", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "Freezes to the employee and self-employed NICs thresholds (primary threshold / lower profits limit since July 2022 and April 2023; upper earnings limit since April 2021) versus default uprating", + "scenario": "current policy (employee and self-employed NICs threshold freezes)", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "085b03d8f3a69af6", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c3bd749d25d0bc1007dc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "No band-multiplier parameter at the pin. council_tax_band and the council_tax liability exist on the bundle, so the option is a CONSTRUCTION: scale council_tax by 2 where band is G or H (England), via a simulation modifier; stated as constructed.", + "reform_hint": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (revenue to central government)", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (\u00a34.4 billion)" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", + "program": "council_tax", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "council_tax" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "47935814eb2f7ce4", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c50b921fd6817a8487c4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025 (inflation, earnings and other incomes)", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "keep all currently frozen NICs and income tax thresholds frozen for two further years (until April 2030)", + "scope": "includes extending the freeze of the employer NICs secondary threshold", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a38.3 billion a year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", + "external_value": 8300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9615991285733363, + "delta": -318727232.8413086 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "992cf9045b3e6dbb2413", + "claim_id": "dc69ba150b68b9e55b32", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -172072,18 +183166,18 @@ "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "Freezes to the employee and self-employed NICs thresholds (primary threshold / lower profits limit since July 2022 and April 2023; upper earnings limit since April 2021) versus default uprating", - "scenario": "current policy (employee and self-employed NICs threshold freezes)", + "reform_hint": "Freezes to the thresholds at which the basic (20%) and higher (40%) rates of income tax begin to apply (current policy, frozen since April 2021, due to end April 2028) versus default CPI uprating", + "scenario": "current policy (basic- and higher-rate threshold freezes to April 2028)", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion a year" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a339 billion a year" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "085b03d8f3a69af6", - "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "reform_key": "0a361f3d9c7bebbc", + "external_value": 39000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 39000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172105,7 +183199,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c3bd749d25d0bc1007dc", + "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -172120,37 +183214,25 @@ "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "England", + "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "England", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "No band-multiplier parameter at the pin. council_tax_band and the council_tax liability exist on the bundle, so the option is a CONSTRUCTION: scale council_tax by 2 where band is G or H (England), via a simulation modifier; stated as constructed.", - "reform_hint": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (revenue to central government)", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (\u00a34.4 billion)" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", - "program": "council_tax", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "council_tax" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "47935814eb2f7ce4", - "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172172,144 +183254,45 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c50b921fd6817a8487c4", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025 (inflation, earnings and other incomes)", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "keep all currently frozen NICs and income tax thresholds frozen for two further years (until April 2030)", - "scope": "includes extending the freeze of the employer NICs secondary threshold", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a38.3 billion a year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", - "external_value": 8300000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 8300000000.0, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9615991285733363, - "delta": -318727232.8413086 - }, - "results": [ - { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" - } - ], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "dc69ba150b68b9e55b32", + "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", "conditions": { - "basis": "static", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "Freezes to the thresholds at which the basic (20%) and higher (40%) rates of income tax begin to apply (current policy, frozen since April 2021, due to end April 2028) versus default CPI uprating", - "scenario": "current policy (basic- and higher-rate threshold freezes to April 2028)", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a339 billion a year" + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "0a361f3d9c7bebbc", - "external_value": 39000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 39000000000.0, + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172331,40 +183314,45 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", - "external_value": 20000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -174673,6 +185661,67 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f21ebec2320c9c12c6f4", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Subsidy level 1 (families not in receipt of means-tested benefits) 75%, subsidy level 2 (families in receipt of means-tested benefits) 95%: Cost", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "current market rates and take up (Table S.1 note)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "IPPR's figure is the total cost of one subsidy replacing both Tax-Free Childcare and the UC childcare element (95% for UC families) and covering school-age care, in a world with 30 free hours for every child from six months, at 2022 rates. The analysis publishes the change in spending from replacing Tax-Free Childcare alone with a 75% subsidy, keeping the UC element at 85% and the 2025 entitlements, in 2027-28 to 2029-30. Its results file also holds the reform's spending on the subsidy (legs.subsidy.spending.tax_free_childcare, 5.5062 in 2027), which the dashboard does not publish and which leaves out UC families; neither figure measures IPPR's quantity.", + "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", + "scope": "total cost of the scheme, before the Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare spending it replaces", + "sign_convention": "positive = spending on the scheme", + "subsidy_rates": "75% of costs for families not on means-tested benefits; 95% for families on them", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "749db1b6edb574ff", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "bc2a557801796af138ca", "source": "ippr", @@ -177936,6 +188985,128 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "191b30d8daacfd7dfadc", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Universal 15-hour offer for two-year-olds: cost per annum", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "ages": "two-year-olds", + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds_fy2022", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under \u00a3100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.9 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6ed38b702a1b0e27", + "external_value": 900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "78914d869fbad04926dc", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Universal offer of 15 funded hours per week for under twos: cost per annum", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "ages": "under twos, modelled from six months", + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos_fy2022", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under \u00a3100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.9 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1abb3501cc4aa692", + "external_value": 900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "af0126e0f2cdd3a746e9", "source": "ippr", @@ -188894,6 +200065,137 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f530eb3894d7d857003b", + "source": "itep", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", + "name": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "itep_arpa_ctc_cost_ca_2023", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "ITEP scores the 2021 design in 2023, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable credit included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", + "tax_year": "2023", + "value_verbatim": "-$10,705,800" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -10705800000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -10705800000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4a9e3cca4ebaee48769c", + "source": "itep", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", + "name": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "wptra", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "program": "wptra", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable EITC included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", + "tax_year": "2026", + "value_verbatim": "-$2,523,100" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "51f53788a8375c2d", + "external_value": -2523100000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2523100000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2400731391.718506, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"wptra_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[2].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9515006903089477, + "delta": 122368608.28149414 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2400731391.718506, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"wptra_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[2].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "256e2230f3480d4272d5", "source": "jct", @@ -196374,6 +207676,85 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "65d635205506df7b1a15", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "value to the average household", + "name": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "JRF also moves the Warm Home Discount off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a360 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 60.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 60.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 2.1666666666666665, + "delta": 70.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "5ffca7194aa9533095f3", "source": "jrf", @@ -200823,6 +212204,143 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "aba93f2ccff65b4d934d", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of an EPG-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", + "name": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "July 2026 cost projections", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A cap holding prices at the April 2026 cap, on July 2026 projections; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a32.5bn, \u00a317.51bn, \u00a340.02bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "program_note": "Energy Price Guarantee-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "af552f4096a22b06", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a8ccdfbda29f4b0767d6", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost of an EPG-style intervention", + "name": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "JRF states no period for its \u00a35 billion and prices it on April 2026 projections of the July 2026 cap; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path.", + "period_basis": "no period stated; the intervention would start in July 2026, in 2026-27", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "program_note": "energy price guarantee", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "448ac62bfbb77ae6", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.444, + "delta": -12220000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "19b295d6f2ae6fb9d235", "source": "jrf", @@ -201878,6 +213396,164 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "a4f27e8f43fe16b12fab", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average saving per year", + "name": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average across Ofgem household archetypes", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3120" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 120.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 120.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.0833333333333333, + "delta": 10.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "71e38e0e0e8be6f4f63c", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost to the Treasury per year", + "name": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost the Treasury'", + "value_verbatim": "just over \u00a33 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.2766666666666666, + "delta": -6830000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "e598532e06e1a4b95e8f", "source": "md_admin", @@ -203502,6 +215178,130 @@ "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/55" } }, + { + "claim_id": "6e85ea09710040ba0c06", + "source": "nef", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", + "name": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_low_fy2025", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "fy": "2025-26", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition.", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "~\u00a33" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a7f3d7a4c1536d89", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f8a2b25f8d51e7475655", + "source": "nef", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", + "name": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_high_fy2025", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "fy": "2025-26", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition.", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "3.4bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a7f3d7a4c1536d89", + "external_value": 3400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "bc03594bf85e384ac116", "source": "nef", @@ -206308,7 +218108,108 @@ "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.18467634608195596, + "delta": 2.853632788713154 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1622ccd142efd0f6cb0e", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "decile 7", + "name": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/2025-autumn-budget-reaction", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "freeze to 2030-31 (implied)", + "income_concept": "real household disposable income", + "income_group": "decile_7", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the income-tax threshold freeze to 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "3.5 per cent" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": -3.5, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3.5, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -0.7779929807480296, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.89.2", "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", @@ -206323,12 +218224,12 @@ ], "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.18467634608195596, - "delta": 2.853632788713154 + "ratio": 0.2222837087851513, + "delta": 2.7220070192519703 }, "results": [ { - "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "value": -0.7779929807480296, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.89.2", "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", @@ -206348,104 +218249,185 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1622ccd142efd0f6cb0e", + "claim_id": "13921a0208c75c7eb7c9", "source": "niesr", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "decile 7", - "name": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "source_column": "Additional households in absolute poverty", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", - "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/2025-autumn-budget-reaction", - "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2031, + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_absolute_poverty_households_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "freeze to 2030-31 (implied)", - "income_concept": "real household disposable income", - "income_group": "decile_7", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the income-tax threshold freeze to 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "3.5 per cent" + "fy": "2026-27", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "pe_missing": "NIESR counts households below an absolute after-housing-costs line in 2026-27, from a functional VAR of oil shocks and the income distribution; the analysis counts households below an anchored before-housing-costs line in 2027-28 after netting the price rises off income (newly_below_line_households_low, _central, _severe: 185,699, 750,843, 1,159,588), a different year, line and method.", + "poverty_line": "absolute: 60% of 2023/24 median household income", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the absolute poverty line", + "value_verbatim": "195,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 195000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 195000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": -3.5, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "931f28dd4f2e26083785", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Additional households in relative poverty", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_relative_poverty_households_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "pe_missing": "A relative-poverty count for 2026-27, whose line moves with the median; the analysis holds its line fixed at the 2027-28 pre-shock median and counts households newly below it in 2027-28, a different year and line.", + "poverty_line": "relative: 60% of 2026/27 median household income", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the relative poverty line", + "value_verbatim": "5,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 5000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -3.5, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -0.7779929807480296, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.2222837087851513, - "delta": 2.7220070192519703 + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, - "results": [ - { - "value": -0.7779929807480296, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" - } - ], + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "08e8ab0187d715b91f87", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a310 per week Universal Credit uplift for 6 months", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_uc_uplift_10_six_months_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "autumn and winter", + "pe_missing": "A \u00a310 a week uplift for six months of 2026-27; the analysis costs a \u00a320 a week uplift for the whole of 2027-28 (uc_uplift_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a36.28bn), a different policy and year.", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "program_note": "\u00a310 a week Universal Credit uplift for six months", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "249d081ba12fdf76", + "external_value": 2000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -207138,6 +219120,84 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "b209e0e7726ba74ef59a", + "source": "ny_fiscal_note", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Forecast 2026", + "name": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", + "url": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "New York", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "static; each tax expenditure measured separately, other provisions and behaviour held constant", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "New York", + "pe_missing": "Same reform, year and time basis as ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026, but not the same quantity: the report's figure is New York State tax on resident and nonresident returns, and the dashboard's is the net change in federal, state and New York City income tax less benefits for resident households (annotation ny-dependent-exemption-scope). The two are 0.7% apart.", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield from removing the exemption: Table 1 prints the dependent exemptions' tax expenditure, the liability the exemption removes, in millions of dollars", + "tax": "New York State personal income tax", + "tax_year": "2026", + "value_verbatim": "264.0" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "99597eee17190011", + "external_value": 264000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 264000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 265890931.5627365, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[6].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "ny-dependent-exemption-scope: The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.00716261955582, + "delta": 1890931.5627365112 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 265890931.5627365, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[6].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "ny-dependent-exemption-scope: The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "a8fd159d67c404bc42ef", "source": "nz_treasury", @@ -321686,76 +333746,155 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd0d8450084c8bfa6141", - "source": "obr_pmd", + "claim_id": "fd0d8450084c8bfa6141", + "source": "obr_pmd", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2030-31", + "name": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Policy_measures_database_November_2025_.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "costing_phase": "original_scorecard", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "obr_measure_key": "autumn_budget_2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "sign_convention": "positive_gain_to_exchequer", + "tax_head": "Stamp duty", + "value_verbatim": "-25.641342" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.additional", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.basic", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.higher" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "042a362ae0e01b97", + "external_value": -25641342.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -25641342.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025__policy_parameters", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e3e7db2c1f2b9155f4d0", + "source": "octopus_energy", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "2030-31", - "name": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "source_column": "further saving a year on electricity bills", + "name": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost \u00a3200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", - "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Policy_measures_database_November_2025_.xlsx", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", + "publication_title": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost \u00a3200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", + "url": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2031, + "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "costing_phase": "original_scorecard", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "obr_measure_key": "autumn_budget_2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "sign_convention": "positive_gain_to_exchequer", - "tax_head": "Stamp duty", - "value_verbatim": "-25.641342" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.additional", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.basic", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.higher" - ] + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "Octopus moves every remaining levy (WHD, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT) off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "per family (not stated whether typical or mean)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a375" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "042a362ae0e01b97", - "external_value": -25641342.0, + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 75.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -25641342.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 75.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025__policy_parameters", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.7333333333333334, + "delta": 55.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -331017,6 +343156,68 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "80dcc282d763cdcd88de", + "source": "ppic", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "share of children lifted out of poverty", + "name": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", + "url": "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "ppic_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "PPIC scores the 2021 design in 2018 data on the California Poverty Measure, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "California Poverty Measure (PPIC and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of poor children lifted out of poverty (fewer children in poverty)", + "value_verbatim": "32%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 32.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -32.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "4c559ea2068903e155fc", "source": "public_first", @@ -331893,6 +344094,164 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "e5fdb8732e39dd84b16d", + "source": "rea", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "typical dual-fuel bill saving", + "name": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs; its figure is for a typical household, not the mean over all households.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical dual-fuel household", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3112" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 112.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 112.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.1607142857142858, + "delta": 18.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2362ba6f433795190b25", + "source": "rea", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Treasury cost over a full year", + "name": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario ('over the course of a full year'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = revenue forgone by the Treasury (printed as 'would forgo')", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.196875, + "delta": -7030000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "b2d349aa50a7a601eebe", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332101,6 +344460,80 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f6892c4460e3b2743b8d", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "share of households reached", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_share_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "program_note": "targeted energy discount", + "value_verbatim": "around 40 per cent" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 40.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 40.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 41.7, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0425, + "delta": 1.7000000000000028 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 41.7, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "a1eaca088305c4e6eb81", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332599,6 +345032,400 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "0cc0c62def7fb2f18c1a", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average discount per eligible household", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27), not per eligible household; its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input.", + "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over eligible households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3175" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 175.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 175.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 73.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "per-eligible-vs-all-households: RF's \u00a3175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.41714285714285715, + "delta": -102.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 73.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "per-eligible-vs-all-households: RF's \u00a3175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "157722b55f1b38c46348", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Feed in Tariffs", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the Feed-in Tariffs alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a324 a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 24.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 24.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.416666666666667, + "delta": 106.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01f3449bc494d103c45c", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "rest of the Renewables Obligation", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the remaining Renewables Obligation alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a326 a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 26.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 26.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.0, + "delta": 104.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8c6799851591ef765826", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "total bill impact", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households, before VAT (\u00a3134 with it)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3128" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 128.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 128.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.015625, + "delta": 2.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1e697c0e26214d15cbe9", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "value of the FiT and remaining RO per year", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 levy rates; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "per household (RF gives the VAT cut's value 'for the typical household' two paragraphs earlier)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a342 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 42.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 42.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 3.0952380952380953, + "delta": 88.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "96369379e09773cb026b", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332807,6 +345634,67 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "7895dccb9fd9c5e39dc0", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Median working-age household, change against no conflict", + "name": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households \u00a3480 worse off this year", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households \u00a3480 worse off this year", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_median_working_age_income_loss_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "pe_missing": "RF's figure is the median working-age household's real-income loss in 2026-27 against a no-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the mean direct cost of the price rises per household in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), a different year and statistic.", + "population": "working-age households", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "market pricing for energy after the ceasefire announcement, against no conflict", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as \u00a3480 worse off)", + "statistic": "median", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3480" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 480.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -480.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "303fb838efaeb155ce35", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -392082,6 +404970,238 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "58b8ec4c95ef449f75e3", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "after five years", + "name": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule.", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "159e3a7e10443cf5", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.6423626509340012, + "delta": -8211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7fb23b7cba8cb9550988", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2010s decade replayed", + "name": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "pe_missing": "One replayed historical decade, not an expectation over paths; the dashboard publishes no saving for a single replayed decade in 2039-40.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "scenario": "the 2030s repeat the decade following 2016", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a324 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 24000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -24000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-one-decade-replayed: RF's \u00a324bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.46403598562712806, + "delta": -35136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-one-decade-replayed: RF's \u00a324bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3d00d8d4e5cbfd322f0d", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "after ten years", + "name": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule.", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "159e3a7e10443cf5", + "external_value": 15000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.7424575770034049, + "delta": -26136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "58fb680ac65c11b696f6", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -393075,6 +406195,245 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "97d7ec09f35149db5dd1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise at current prices", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_current_prices_mar2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "wholesale prices at mid-March 2026 levels", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised (direct debit, typical consumption, GB; Figure 3)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3230" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 230.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 230.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a2343e5bfda3e8a7611f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise if recent highs persist", + "name": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_high_case_jul2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "recent highs in gas prices become the norm for the rest of the assessment period", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3440" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 440.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 440.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c276c38f1f9b6e9ccba1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise, best case", + "name": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_best_case_jul2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "best case: wholesale gas prices fall immediately to pre-war levels", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3130" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 130.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 130.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3ee9e893aeeee5f230ea", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Typical annual energy bill if recent price rises are sustained", + "name": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_bill_rise_if_sustained", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A rise in the typical annual bill under the price cap at sustained March 2026 prices; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil and gas price rises since the conflict began (to 4 March 2026) sustained", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the typical annual energy bill", + "statistic": "typical annual energy bill (Ofgem price cap)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3500" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 500.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 500.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "132c51d617ac4c0106f4", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -414386,144 +427745,798 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c02612bd97e05eeee62f", + "claim_id": "c02612bd97e05eeee62f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "Warm Homes Discount and Energy Company Obligation to general taxation", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", + "reform_hint": "WHD and ECO funded from general taxation", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.3 billion per year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "domestic_energy_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", + "external_value": 1300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c270fe209963a53f127b", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "Carbon Price Support scrapped", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "horizon": "fades to virtually zero by 2030", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", + "reform_hint": "Disbanding [the Carbon Price Support]", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3200 million per year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "domestic_energy_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", + "external_value": 200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "47fe58888758a3e1c88f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost of bringing the UC rise forward", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_uc_pc_uprating_brought_forward_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "annualised, from September 2026", + "pe_missing": "An annualised 2026-27 cost of bringing forward planned Universal Credit rises; the analysis's accelerated uprating raises CPI-uprated benefits by the shock's residual CPI addition in 2027-28 (accelerated_uprating_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.66bn, \u00a33.64bn, \u00a37.27bn), a different policy and year.", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "program_note": "Universal Credit standard allowance above-inflation rises brought forward to September 2026, plus a temporary Pension Credit boost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "5bda27a706e76715", + "external_value": 1200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6ef43f88a816f9e4f01f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a blanket price cap offsetting the inflation rise", + "name": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_price_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_energy_discounts_offset_cpi_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "a year from Q3 2026", + "pe_missing": "A blanket discount sized to offset a 1.5 point CPI rise for a year from Q3 2026; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a32.5bn, \u00a317.51bn, \u00a340.02bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_price_discount", + "scoring_method": "full pass-through: 1.5 per cent of \u00a31.4 trillion of CPI-covered household spending, 'around \u00a320 billion annually' (footnote 9)", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "298b279d189b38fb", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "99faf909155dbfea78c9", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "source_column": "cost of the temporary scheme this year", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "GB", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "Warm Homes Discount and Energy Company Obligation to general taxation", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "GB", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", - "reform_hint": "WHD and ECO funded from general taxation", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.3 billion per year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "domestic_energy_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "'this year' in an October 2026 briefing, for a scheme switched on from January 2027", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "program_note": "targeted energy discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost \u00a32 billion'", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", - "external_value": 1300000000.0, + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 2000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -2000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -2140000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -1.07, + "delta": -4140000000.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -2140000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c270fe209963a53f127b", + "claim_id": "599d73275aebe63ce719", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "source_column": "full-year cost of each option", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "GB", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "warm_home_discount", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "Carbon Price Support scrapped", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "GB", - "horizon": "fades to virtually zero by 2030", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", - "reform_hint": "Disbanding [the Carbon Price Support]", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF's option adds \u00a3570 to the Warm Home Discount; the dashboard's adds \u00a3100.", + "period_basis": "a full year of support in 2026-27 (RF: 'If any of the options were brought in for only part of a year (such as from the October price cap) they would have a proportionately lower cost')", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a33.75 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "2aa7809414d06d94", + "external_value": 3750000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3750000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -780000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-570-not-100: RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by \u00a3570, sized to its \u00a33.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by \u00a3100. The two price different changes to the same scheme." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.208, + "delta": -4530000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -780000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-570-not-100: RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by \u00a3570, sized to its \u00a33.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by \u00a3100. The two price different changes to the same scheme." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7d69cebde4a74c79c0f1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annual cost of the VAT cut in future years", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_annual_cost_future_years", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate continued after 31 March 2027", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3200 million per year" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.7 billion" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "domestic_energy_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1c2e01042aeed16a", + "external_value": 1700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -0.9117647058823529, + "delta": -3250000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "30a22f60ca0cdeeddf0e", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost relative to current policy, 2027-28", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "lower_bound", + "fy": "2027-28", + "pe_missing": "RF costs a gradual reversal of the 5p cut against current policy; the analysis costs keeping the whole 5p cut for 2027-28, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "steady fuel duty rises reversing the 5p cut, then about 3 per cent a year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer, relative to current policy", + "value_verbatim": "over \u00a31 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "71add44c3b0ea34f", + "external_value": 1000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -2.18, + "delta": -3180000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4386b03d13fd70f68a2b", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual cost in future years", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_annual_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the annual cost of the 0% rate in future years, the first of which is 2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.7 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", - "external_value": 200000000.0, + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 1700000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -200000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -1700000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8529411764705882, + "delta": -3150000000.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2d9d37f7b21aba27d650", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "costs transferred to taxpayers", + "name": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF does not list its 'remaining levies' here; its Power struggle (March 2026) counts the remaining policy costs as the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, more than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as costs transferred 'from billpayers to taxpayers')", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a32.6 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 2600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.4730769230769232, + "delta": -6430000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "0b9c264b1f6c21419208", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "full-year cost of removing more policy costs", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity and gas policy costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a33.75 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3750000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3750000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.0213333333333334, + "delta": -7580000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -421724,49 +435737,170 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b1c70abe1e003ca4808c", + "claim_id": "b1c70abe1e003ca4808c", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age with kids", + "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "household_type": "Working-age with kids", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", + "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", + "unit_population": "households", + "value_verbatim": "2.53%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", + "external_value": 0.0253, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0253, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6f8a0ac4b386ede74638", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age, no kids", + "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "household_type": "Working-age, no kids", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", + "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", + "unit_population": "households", + "value_verbatim": "4.30%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", + "external_value": 0.043, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.043, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a29af8606a518d8f969e", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age with kids", - "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, poorest fifth", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", - "metric": "share_no_change", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2030, + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_poorest_fifth", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "household_type": "Working-age with kids", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", - "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", - "unit_population": "households", - "value_verbatim": "2.53%" + "fy": "2026-27", + "income_group": "quintile_1", + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the bottom quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "value_verbatim": "16 per cent" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", - "external_value": 0.0253, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 0.16, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0253, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -421786,49 +435920,46 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6f8a0ac4b386ede74638", + "claim_id": "8c4e58628e774581842e", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age, no kids", - "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, richest fifth", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", - "metric": "share_no_change", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2030, + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_richest_fifth", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "household_type": "Working-age, no kids", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", - "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", - "unit_population": "households", - "value_verbatim": "4.30%" + "fy": "2026-27", + "income_group": "quintile_5", + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the top quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "value_verbatim": "25 per cent" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", - "external_value": 0.043, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 0.25, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.043, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.25, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -431153,63 +445284,259 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0153f63556b8ce75975b", - "source": "trussell_wpi", + "claim_id": "0153f63556b8ce75975b", + "source": "trussell_wpi", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", + "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "measure_type": "relative change", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", + "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", + "subgroup": "children", + "value_verbatim": "a 15% decrease" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", + "external_value": -15.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "acda07109bec1f3c3286", + "source": "trussell_wpi", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", + "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "measure_type": "relative change", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", + "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", + "subgroup": "all people", + "value_verbatim": "a 7% decrease" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", + "external_value": -7.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4190a011999733649ed0", + "source": "tuc", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_high", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.8bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "ac7a488a6f353f32", + "external_value": 3800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a3ffebf3f9efa29c2d56", + "source": "tuc", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", - "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", - "metric": "poverty_rate_change", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_high", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", - "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "measure_type": "relative change", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", - "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", - "subgroup": "children", - "value_verbatim": "a 15% decrease" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" - ] + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35.9bn" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", - "external_value": -15.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -15.0, + "reform_key": "b8151f6cd328def3", + "external_value": 5900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5900000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -431229,63 +445556,107 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acda07109bec1f3c3286", - "source": "trussell_wpi", + "claim_id": "b4bb15c70b966d6a0f20", + "source": "tuc", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", - "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", - "metric": "poverty_rate_change", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_low", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", - "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "measure_type": "relative change", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", - "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", - "subgroup": "all people", - "value_verbatim": "a 7% decrease" + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35.2bn" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" - ] + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "b8151f6cd328def3", + "external_value": 5200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe39fe0bcab0a4f14051", + "source": "tuc", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_low", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.4bn" + }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", - "external_value": -7.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -7.0, + "reform_key": "ac7a488a6f353f32", + "external_value": 3400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -471972,6 +486343,191 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "316573c62fe7e0edaf3c", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Number removed (thousands)", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_children_removed_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = children removed from poverty, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "value_verbatim": "613" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 613000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -613000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "12e6457518e550604c6b", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage change", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (percentage change after implementation)", + "value_verbatim": "-33.3%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -33.3, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -33.3, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "95a11dac98b507dce1b7", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage-point change", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (change after implementation)", + "value_verbatim": "-6.8%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -6.8, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -6.8, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "93368a42000c01f07cc3", "source": "ut_admin", diff --git a/data/comparables/index.json b/data/comparables/index.json index 1599bc131..845b52abf 100644 --- a/data/comparables/index.json +++ b/data/comparables/index.json @@ -839,6 +839,7286 @@ "pe_missing": null } ] + }, + "analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget": { + "id": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "uk", + "slug": "energy-autumn-budget", + "title": "Energy bills and the Autumn Budget 2026", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", + "published": "2026-10-14", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:138a17f941e49c538d7dd1ccc9cdf5e6e746ce11834b453a4657773e86d1df19", + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:138a17f941e49c538d7dd1ccc9cdf5e6e746ce11834b453a4657773e86d1df19", + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "centax", + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dfe", + "dwp", + "fabian_society", + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "ippr", + "jrf", + "landman_economics", + "lse_case", + "niesr", + "obr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation", + "tax_policy_associates", + "uk_hmrc", + "ukmod" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "centre_for_british_progress", + "ifs", + "jrf", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation" + ], + "found_not_staged": [ + "hm_treasury" + ], + "not_applicable": [ + "scottish_fiscal_commission" + ], + "found": 30 + } + ], + "claims": 30, + "compared": 9, + "beside_nearest": 21, + "over_threshold": 4, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 4, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 2.0952, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "rf_ted_cost_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "locator": "Summary, PDF page 5", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£2 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost £2 billion'", + "estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026", + "estimate_label": "Cost to government of the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2026-27", + "pe_value": -2140000000, + "gap": 0.07, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "rf_ted_share_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "locator": "'Surgical strikes' section, PDF page 29", + "metric": "affected_share", + "basis": "static", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 40.0, + "value_raw": "around 40 per cent", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026", + "estimate_label": "Share of households helped by the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2026-27", + "pe_value": 41.7, + "gap": 0.0425, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "locator": "'Surgical strikes' section, PDF page 29", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 175.0, + "value_raw": "£175", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 73, + "nearest_gap": -0.5829, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF's £175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (£73 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat £175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates.", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (£73 in 2026-27), not per eligible household; its per-eligible amount is the flat £175 it takes from RF as an input." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2600000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £2.6 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as costs transferred 'from billpayers to taxpayers')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.4731, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "RF does not list its 'remaining levies' here; its Power struggle (March 2026) counts the remaining policy costs as the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, more than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_vat_annual_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "locator": "paragraph on how the cut is funded", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1700000000.0, + "value_raw": "£1.7 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "estimate": "extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Cost to government of the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "pe_value": -1450000000, + "gap": -0.1471, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "locator": "paragraph comparing the VAT cut with levies", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "static", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 42.0, + "value_raw": "£42 per year", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "pe_value": 130, + "gap": 2.0952, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes £120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a £3.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. £1.5bn and £53 a household (£780m and £730m), RF at £42 a year and, as mean averages, £26 and £24 a year, Good Energy at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-£2,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near £0.7bn. £120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of £128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around £120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's £112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its £3.83bn is close to RF's £3.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's £3.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over £3bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from £2,580m in 2026-27 to £2,100m), and the FiT part (£0.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. £0.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about £2.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's £42 is per household and the dashboard's £130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is £120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_vat_permanent_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 'The outlook for the public finances', section 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1500000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £1.5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "estimate": "extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Cost to government of the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "pe_value": -1450000000, + "gap": -0.0333, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "locator": "Section 1, table 'Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving', report page 14 of 29 (PDF page 14)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1500000000.0, + "value_raw": "c. £1.5 bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Fiscal Cost'", + "estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Cost to government of the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "pe_value": -3830000000, + "gap": 1.5533, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes £120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a £3.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. £1.5bn and £53 a household (£780m and £730m), RF at £42 a year and, as mean averages, £26 and £24 a year, Good Energy at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-£2,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near £0.7bn. £120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of £128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around £120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's £112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its £3.83bn is close to RF's £3.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's £3.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over £3bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from £2,580m in 2026-27 to £2,100m), and the FiT part (£0.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. £0.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about £2.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's £42 is per household and the dashboard's £130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is £120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "locator": "Section 1, table 'Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving', report page 14 of 29 (PDF page 14)", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "static", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 53.0, + "value_raw": "c. £53 p.a.", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "pe_value": 130, + "gap": 1.4528, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes £120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a £3.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. £1.5bn and £53 a household (£780m and £730m), RF at £42 a year and, as mean averages, £26 and £24 a year, Good Energy at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-£2,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near £0.7bn. £120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of £128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around £120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's £112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its £3.83bn is close to RF's £3.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's £3.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over £3bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from £2,580m in 2026-27 to £2,100m), and the FiT part (£0.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. £0.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about £2.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's £42 is per household and the dashboard's £130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is £120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "jrf", + "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", + "title": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", + "locator": "section on inflation and levies", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 60.0, + "value_raw": "£60 per year", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 1.1667, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "JRF also moves the Warm Home Discount off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "jrf", + "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", + "title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "locator": "section 'Comparing approaches'", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": -7220000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.444, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to £300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of £1,663 and £1,723, Cornwall Insight's £1,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity.", + "pe_missing": "JRF states no period for its £5 billion and prices it on April 2026 projections of the July 2026 cap; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path." + }, + { + "claim": "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "desnz", + "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", + "title": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", + "locator": "'Estimated cohort size', paragraph 40, PDF page 11", + "metric": "affected_count", + "basis": "static", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5900000.0, + "value_raw": "around 5.9m", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "whd_top_up_households_fy2026", + "estimate_label": "Households reached by the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2026-27", + "pe_value": 7850000, + "gap": 0.3305, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": "The dashboard's proxy pays the £100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates').", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "publisher": "The MCS Foundation", + "title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "locator": "Conclusion, PDF page 16", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3000000000.0, + "value_raw": "just over £3 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost the Treasury'", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.2767, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "publisher": "The MCS Foundation", + "title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "locator": "Conclusion, PDF page 16", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 120.0, + "value_raw": "around £120", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 0.0833, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "rea", + "publisher": "Association for Renewables and Clean Technology (REA)", + "title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "locator": "third paragraph", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3200000000.0, + "value_raw": "£3.2 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = revenue forgone by the Treasury (printed as 'would forgo')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.1969, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "rea", + "publisher": "Association for Renewables and Clean Technology (REA)", + "title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "locator": "third paragraph", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 112.0, + "value_raw": "around £112", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 0.1607, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs; its figure is for a typical household, not the mean over all households." + }, + { + "claim": "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "electricity_bills_taskforce", + "publisher": "E3G", + "title": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", + "url": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", + "locator": "paragraph beginning 'Examples of taxes which the Electricity Bills Taskforce advocates removing from bills'", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 100.0, + "value_raw": "an additional £100 per year", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 0.3, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "The Taskforce also removes the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "octopus_energy", + "publisher": "Octopus Energy", + "title": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost £200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", + "url": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", + "locator": "second bullet and footnote **", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 75.0, + "value_raw": "£75", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 0.7333, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "Octopus moves every remaining levy (WHD, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT) off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs." + }, + { + "claim": "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "good_energy", + "publisher": "Good Energy", + "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "locator": "'Immediate reforms', PDF page 11; table row 'Additional payment of £300 to 6m households', PDF page 19", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1800000000.0, + "value_raw": "£1.8bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'at a cost of £1.8bn to the exchequer'", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": -2430000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.35, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Good Energy pays £300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's £300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies.", + "pe_missing": "Good Energy pays £300 to Warm Home Discount recipients (about 6 million); the dashboard's £300 Cost of Living Payment goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1 million)." + }, + { + "claim": "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "green_party", + "publisher": "Green Party of England and Wales", + "title": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", + "url": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", + "locator": "speech text, paragraph on energy bills", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 8400000000.0, + "value_raw": "approximately £8.4 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'setting aside'", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": -7220000000, + "nearest_gap": -0.1405, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to £300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of £1,663 and £1,723, Cornwall Insight's £1,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity.", + "pe_missing": "The Green Party states no period for its £8.4 billion and set it in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to £300 per household'; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 26.0, + "value_raw": "£26 a year", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 4.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the remaining Renewables Obligation alone." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 24.0, + "value_raw": "£24 a year", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 4.4167, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the Feed-in Tariffs alone." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 128.0, + "value_raw": "£128", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 0.0156, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 5", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3750000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £3.75 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 0.0213, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 5 (cost) and page 6 (the £570 option)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3750000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £3.75 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "whd_top_up_cost_fy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": -780000000, + "nearest_gap": -0.792, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by £570, sized to its £3.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by £100. The two price different changes to the same scheme.", + "pe_missing": "RF's option adds £570 to the Warm Home Discount; the dashboard's adds £100." + }, + { + "claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "good_energy", + "publisher": "Good Energy", + "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 610000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.61", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 5.2787, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone." + }, + { + "claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "good_energy", + "publisher": "Good Energy", + "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 20.45, + "value_raw": "20.45", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 5.357, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone." + }, + { + "claim": "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "good_energy", + "publisher": "Good Energy", + "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 570000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.57", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -3830000000, + "nearest_gap": 5.7193, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone." + }, + { + "claim": "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "good_energy", + "publisher": "Good Energy", + "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 19.25, + "value_raw": "19.25", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 130, + "nearest_gap": 5.7532, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone." + }, + { + "claim": "desnz_vat_saving_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "desnz", + "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", + "title": "Breathing space on your energy bill", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", + "locator": "second paragraph", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "basis": "static", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 45.0, + "value_raw": "£45", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "estimate": "extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027", + "estimate_label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "pe_value": 49, + "gap": 0.0889, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + } + ] + }, + "analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform": { + "id": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "uk", + "slug": "free-childcare-reform", + "title": "Free childcare hours and a 75% subsidy", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/free-childcare-reform", + "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", + "published": "2026-09-03", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform@1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8:c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform@1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8:c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "centax", + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dfe", + "dwp", + "fabian_society", + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "ippr", + "jrf", + "landman_economics", + "lse_case", + "niesr", + "obr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation", + "tax_policy_associates", + "uk_hmrc", + "ukmod" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "centax", + "ippr", + "open_search" + ], + "found_not_staged": [ + "lse_case" + ], + "not_applicable": [ + "scottish_fiscal_commission" + ], + "found": 17 + } + ], + "claims": 17, + "compared": 0, + "beside_nearest": 12, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": null, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -300000000, + "value_raw": "-300m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -1966000000, + "nearest_gap": 5.5533, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -170000000, + "value_raw": "-170m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -1931000000, + "nearest_gap": 10.3588, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.1, printed page 83 (PDF page 84)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2029, + "fy": "2028-29", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -340000000, + "value_raw": "-340m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": -2013000000, + "nearest_gap": 4.9206, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.1, printed page 83 (PDF page 84)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2029, + "fy": "2028-29", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -190000000, + "value_raw": "-190m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": -1978000000, + "nearest_gap": 9.4105, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -370000000, + "value_raw": "-370m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": -2062000000, + "nearest_gap": 4.573, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -210000000, + "value_raw": "-210m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": -2024000000, + "nearest_gap": 8.6381, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -370000000, + "value_raw": "-370m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -1966000000, + "nearest_gap": 4.3135, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -250000000, + "value_raw": "-250m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": -1931000000, + "nearest_gap": 6.724, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2029, + "fy": "2028-29", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -410000000, + "value_raw": "-410m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": -2013000000, + "nearest_gap": 3.9098, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2029, + "fy": "2028-29", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -270000000, + "value_raw": "-270m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": -1978000000, + "nearest_gap": 6.3259, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -460000000, + "value_raw": "-460m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": -2062000000, + "nearest_gap": 3.4826, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centax", + "publisher": "CenTax", + "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -300000000, + "value_raw": "-300m", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": -2024000000, + "nearest_gap": 5.7467, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone." + }, + { + "claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos_fy2022", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ippr", + "publisher": "IPPR", + "title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "locator": "Summary, Recommendation 2, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated on printed page 24 and in Table S.2", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2023, + "fy": "2022-23", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 900000000, + "value_raw": "£0.9 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under £100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline." + }, + { + "claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds_fy2022", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ippr", + "publisher": "IPPR", + "title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "locator": "Summary, Recommendation 2, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated on printed page 24 and in Table S.2", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "period": 2023, + "fy": "2022-23", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 900000000, + "value_raw": "£0.9 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under £100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline." + }, + { + "claim": "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ippr", + "publisher": "IPPR", + "title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table S.1, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated as Table 1, printed page 25", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "basis": "static", + "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", + "period": 2023, + "fy": "2022-23", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3200000000, + "value_raw": "£3.2bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = spending on the scheme", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "IPPR's figure is the total cost of one subsidy replacing both Tax-Free Childcare and the UC childcare element (95% for UC families) and covering school-age care, in a world with 30 free hours for every child from six months, at 2022 rates. The analysis publishes the change in spending from replacing Tax-Free Childcare alone with a 75% subsidy, keeping the UC element at 85% and the 2025 entitlements, in 2027-28 to 2029-30. Its results file also holds the reform's spending on the subsidy (legs.subsidy.spending.tax_free_childcare, 5.5062 in 2027), which the dashboard does not publish and which leaves out UC families; neither figure measures IPPR's quantity." + }, + { + "claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_low_fy2025", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "nef", + "publisher": "New Economics Foundation", + "title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "locator": "Summary, printed page 2 (PDF page 2); repeated on printed page 8", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "period": 2026, + "fy": "2025-26", + "value_kind": "range_low", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "value": 3000000000, + "value_raw": "~£3", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition." + }, + { + "claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_high_fy2025", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "nef", + "publisher": "New Economics Foundation", + "title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "locator": "Summary, printed page 2 (PDF page 2); repeated on printed page 8", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "period": 2026, + "fy": "2025-26", + "value_kind": "range_high", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "value": 3400000000, + "value_raw": "3.4bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition." + } + ] + }, + "analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards": { + "id": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "uk", + "slug": "middle-east-war-living-standards", + "title": "Impact of the Middle East war on UK living standards", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", + "published": "2026-09-25", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards@45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515:382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards@45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515:382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "centax", + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dfe", + "dwp", + "fabian_society", + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "ippr", + "jrf", + "landman_economics", + "lse_case", + "niesr", + "obr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation", + "tax_policy_associates", + "uk_hmrc", + "ukmod" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "jrf", + "niesr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation" + ], + "found_not_staged": [], + "not_applicable": [ + "scottish_fiscal_commission" + ], + "found": 34 + } + ], + "claims": 34, + "compared": 2, + "beside_nearest": 3, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 0.0882, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "rf_median_working_age_income_loss_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households £480 worse off this year", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", + "locator": "press release, first paragraph", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 480, + "value_raw": "£480", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as £480 worse off)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "RF's figure is the median working-age household's real-income loss in 2026-27 against a no-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the mean direct cost of the price rises per household in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), a different year and statistic." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_typical_bill_rise_if_sustained", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", + "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 500, + "value_raw": "£500", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the typical annual energy bill", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A rise in the typical annual bill under the price cap at sustained March 2026 prices; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_best_case_jul2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 130, + "value_raw": "£130", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_high_case_jul2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 440, + "value_raw": "£440", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_current_prices_mar2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "page 3 (PDF page 3)", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 230, + "value_raw": "£230", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_uc_pc_uprating_brought_forward_cost", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "locator": "page 8 (PDF page 8), section 'A mixture of action on prices and incomes would partially replicate the benefits of a social tariff'", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1200000000, + "value_raw": "£1.2 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An annualised 2026-27 cost of bringing forward planned Universal Credit rises; the analysis's accelerated uprating raises CPI-uprated benefits by the shock's residual CPI addition in 2027-28 (accelerated_uprating_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.66bn, £3.64bn, £7.27bn), a different policy and year." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_household_energy_fuel_spending_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", + "locator": "page 3 (PDF page 3); footnote 2", + "metric": "household_energy_and_fuel_spending_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 11000000000, + "value_raw": "£11 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher household spending on energy and fuel", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The analysis publishes the total cost of energy, fuel and food rises for 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn: £17.0bn, £42.1bn, £72.7bn), which no registered metric names; RF's figure is energy and fuel only, in calendar 2026." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_energy_discounts_offset_cpi_cost", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", + "locator": "pages 8-9 (PDF pages 8-9), footnote 9", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_price_discount", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 20000000000, + "value_raw": "£20 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A blanket discount sized to offset a 1.5 point CPI rise for a year from Q3 2026; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: £2.5bn, £17.51bn, £40.02bn), a different design and year." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_richest_fifth", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "locator": "comment, ninth paragraph", + "metric": "spending_share", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.25, + "value_raw": "25 per cent", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the top quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_poorest_fifth", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "locator": "comment, ninth paragraph", + "metric": "spending_share", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.16, + "value_raw": "16 per cent", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the bottom quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_vat_cut_annual_cost_future_years", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "locator": "comment, 'Finally, the Government should be clear' paragraph", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1700000000, + "value_raw": "£1.7 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": "elec_vat_cut_cost_low", + "estimate_label": "Gross outlay of the electricity VAT cut extension, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "pe_value": -1550000000.0, + "gap": -0.0882, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "locator": "printed page 32 (PDF page 32), Fuel Duty section", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "lower_bound", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1000000000, + "value_raw": "over £1 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer, relative to current policy", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", + "nearest_pe_value": -2180000000.0, + "nearest_gap": 1.18, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over £1 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, £2.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same £2.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost).", + "pe_missing": "RF costs a gradual reversal of the 5p cut against current policy; the analysis costs keeping the whole 5p cut for 2027-28, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies)." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_vat_cut_permanent_annual_cost", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1500000000, + "value_raw": "£1.5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": "elec_vat_cut_cost_low", + "estimate_label": "Gross outlay of the electricity VAT cut extension, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "pe_value": -1550000000.0, + "gap": 0.0333, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2700000000, + "value_raw": "£2.7 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", + "nearest_pe_value": -2180000000.0, + "nearest_gap": -0.1926, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over £1 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, £2.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same £2.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost).", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies)." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "period": 2028, + "fy": "2027-28", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3200000000, + "value_raw": "£3.2 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", + "nearest_pe_value": -2180000000.0, + "nearest_gap": -0.3187, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over £1 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, £2.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same £2.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost).", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies)." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4000000000, + "value_raw": "£4 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "period": 2030, + "fy": "2029-30", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4500000000, + "value_raw": "£4.5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only." + }, + { + "claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "publisher": "Prime Minister's Office, HM Treasury and DESNZ (GOV.UK)", + "title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "locator": "news story, 'This action is estimated to cost' paragraph", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 850000000, + "value_raw": "£850 million", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Government's cost is for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis costs a full-year extension in 2027-28 (elec_vat_cut_cost_low, _central, _severe: £1.55bn, £1.95bn, £2.56bn), a different year and length of relief." + }, + { + "claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_bill_saving_oct2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "publisher": "Prime Minister's Office, HM Treasury and DESNZ (GOV.UK)", + "title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "locator": "news story, 'Cutting VAT on electricity bills' paragraph", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 45, + "value_raw": "£45", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the annual energy bill (printed as £45 off the yearly price cap)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A saving on the October 2026 annualised cap; the analysis's counterpart is the mean support per household from its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.avg_benefit_per_hh: £49, £62, £81, shown on the dashboard's policy tab), a different period and statistic." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_absolute_poverty_households_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards'", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 195000, + "value_raw": "195,000", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the absolute poverty line", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NIESR counts households below an absolute after-housing-costs line in 2026-27, from a functional VAR of oil shocks and the income distribution; the analysis counts households below an anchored before-housing-costs line in 2027-28 after netting the price rises off income (newly_below_line_households_low, _central, _severe: 185,699, 750,843, 1,159,588), a different year, line and method." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_relative_poverty_households_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards'", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000, + "value_raw": "5,000", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the relative poverty line", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A relative-poverty count for 2026-27, whose line moves with the median; the analysis holds its line fixed at the 2027-28 pre-shock median and counts households newly below it in 2027-28, a different year and line." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_uc_uplift_10_six_months_cost", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications' and Table B1", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2000000000, + "value_raw": "£2bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A £10 a week uplift for six months of 2026-27; the analysis costs a £20 a week uplift for the whole of 2027-28 (uc_uplift_cost_low, _central, _severe: £6.28bn), a different policy and year." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_1", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", + "metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 50, + "value_raw": "£50", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_2", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", + "metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 120, + "value_raw": "£120", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping." + }, + { + "claim": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_3", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "niesr", + "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", + "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", + "metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 150, + "value_raw": "£150", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping." + }, + { + "claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "jrf", + "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", + "title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "locator": "article, section 'Comparing approaches'", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000000000, + "value_raw": "£5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A cap holding prices at the April 2026 cap, on July 2026 projections; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: £2.5bn, £17.51bn, £40.02bn), a different design and year." + }, + { + "claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cebr", + "publisher": "Cebr", + "title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "locator": "blog, first paragraph and Figure 2", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1100, + "value_raw": "£1,100", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes £1,100 lower)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2026 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), with no wage or labour-market effects." + }, + { + "claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cebr", + "publisher": "Cebr", + "title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "locator": "blog, first paragraph and Figure 2", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1300, + "value_raw": "£1,300", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes £1,300 lower)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2027 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), with no wage or labour-market effects." + }, + { + "claim": "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cebr", + "publisher": "Cebr", + "title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "locator": "blog, eighth paragraph", + "metric": "household_real_income_change_aggregate", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 31500000000, + "value_raw": "£31.5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as an erosion of real incomes)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An aggregate calendar-2026 real-income loss including wage effects; the analysis's aggregate is the total cost of the price rises in 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn), which no registered metric names." + }, + { + "claim": "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cebr", + "publisher": "Cebr", + "title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "locator": "blog, eighth paragraph", + "metric": "household_real_income_change_aggregate", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 38900000000, + "value_raw": "£38.9 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as an erosion of real incomes)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An aggregate calendar-2027 real-income loss including wage effects; the analysis's aggregate is the total cost of the price rises in 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn), which no registered metric names." + }, + { + "claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_low", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "tuc", + "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", + "title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 6", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "range_low", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "value": 3400000000, + "value_raw": "£3.4bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year." + }, + { + "claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_high", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "tuc", + "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", + "title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 6", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "range_high", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "value": 3800000000, + "value_raw": "£3.8bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year." + }, + { + "claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_low", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "tuc", + "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", + "title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 7", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "range_low", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "value": 5200000000, + "value_raw": "£5.2bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year." + }, + { + "claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_high", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "tuc", + "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", + "title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "locator": "PDF page 7", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "range_high", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "value": 5900000000, + "value_raw": "£5.9bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year." + } + ] + }, + "analysis-uk-triple-lock": { + "id": "uk/triple-lock", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "uk", + "slug": "triple-lock", + "title": "The Burnham plan vs the triple lock", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/triple-lock", + "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", + "published": "2026-10-16", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock@5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d:e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock@5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d:e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "centax", + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dfe", + "dwp", + "fabian_society", + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "ippr", + "jrf", + "landman_economics", + "lse_case", + "niesr", + "obr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation", + "tax_policy_associates", + "uk_hmrc", + "ukmod" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dwp", + "ifs", + "obr", + "resolution_foundation" + ], + "found_not_staged": [ + "open_search" + ], + "not_applicable": [ + "scottish_fiscal_commission" + ], + "found": 35 + } + ], + "claims": 35, + "compared": 16, + "beside_nearest": 16, + "over_threshold": 4, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 3, + "pending": 1, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 1.7842, + "tracking_issues": [ + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + ], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "dwp", + "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", + "title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "locator": "Impacts, Table 1: Estimated AME savings of adjusted Triple Lock policy relative to Triple Lock (nominal)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -15000000000.0, + "value_raw": "-£15 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 1: 'negative values denote savings')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "gap": -0.2575, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "pending", + "cause": "Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's £15bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, £11.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is £10.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by £1.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (£5.9bn in 2026-27, £6.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is £243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the £286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives £11.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to £1bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "dwp_ame_real_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "dwp", + "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", + "title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "locator": "Impacts, Table 2: Estimated AME savings of adjusted Triple Lock policy relative to Triple Lock (real)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -11000000000.0, + "value_raw": "-£11 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 2: 'negative values denote savings')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "nearest_gap": 0.0124, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp.", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes nominal savings only; DWP's nominal figure (Table 1) is the one compared." + }, + { + "claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "dwp", + "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", + "title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "locator": "Impacts, Chart 1 (the 2034/35 vertex of the line)", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.103, + "value_raw": "10.3%", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.12154651641845704, + "nearest_gap": 0.1801, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed.", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate." + }, + { + "claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "dwp", + "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", + "title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "locator": "Impacts, Chart 1 (the 2039/40 vertex of the line)", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.092, + "value_raw": "9.2%", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.08826981544494629, + "nearest_gap": -0.0405, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed.", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_saving_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, second paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4000000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £4 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the reform 'will save around £4 billion per year')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2034-35", + "pe_value": -3211813254.6700063, + "gap": -0.197, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "The comparison takes IFS's 'around £4 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the £11bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about £4.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is £2.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_range_low_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, first paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "range_low", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "value": 4000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£4 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "gap": 1.7842, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": 0.0, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "IFS's £4bn to £20bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (£11.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (£3.9bn to £18.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_range_high_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, first paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "range_high", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "value": 20000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£20 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "gap": -0.4432, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": 0.0, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "IFS's £4bn to £20bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (£11.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (£3.9bn to £18.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_since_2011_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", + "locator": "'What would the effects of the new triple lock be?', fifth paragraph ('The chart therefore shows'), before Figure 2", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£9 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (expenditure in 2026-27 'would be £9 billion lower')", + "estimate": "history_since_2012_gross_fy2026", + "estimate_label": "Gross saving in 2026-27 had the Burnham plan applied from April 2012", + "pe_value": -7253585729.199216, + "gap": -0.194, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", + "locator": "'It depends which decade we are about to have', final paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 24000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£24 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "nearest_gap": -0.536, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF's £24bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's £11.14bn.", + "pe_missing": "One replayed historical decade, not an expectation over paths; the dashboard publishes no saving for a single replayed decade in 2039-40." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_reconstruction_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", + "locator": "Second paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 15000000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £15 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "obr_wedge_gross_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": -10292565051.193663, + "nearest_gap": -0.3138, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF's 'around £15 billion' reproduces the government's figure. It takes the OBR's average triple-lock premium of 0.53 points a year, compounds it over ten years (5.43%), and applies it to the whole projected State Pension bill of £286bn in 2039-40. That bill includes the pre-2016 components DWP says the triple lock does not uprate. It is not a run of the plan's rule on a path. The dashboard's nearest figure, its OBR-wedge path (£10.29bn, UK), runs both rules with the triple lock paying the OBR's long-term premium on the survey's flat-rate bill.", + "pe_missing": "A reconstruction of the government's figure from an average premium, not a run of the plan's rule on any path." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "locator": "Press release, fourth paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000000000.0, + "value_raw": "around £5 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": -3211813254.6700063, + "nearest_gap": -0.3576, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF gives £5bn after five years and £15bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's.", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "locator": "Press release, fourth paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 15000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£15 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "nearest_gap": -0.2575, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "RF gives £5bn after five years and £15bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's.", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule." + }, + { + "claim": "rf_level_since_2012_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", + "title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "locator": "Press release, fifth paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_rate_change_pct", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2027, + "fy": "2026-27", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5.9, + "value_raw": "5.9 per cent lower", + "sign_convention": "positive = lower than under the triple lock (printed: '5.9 per cent lower')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints the same quantity, 'today's full new State Pension would be 6.3% lower' had the plan started in April 2012 (results.json trajectories.history.groups[0].level_ratio.2026 = 0.9370), but no registered metric names a change in a benefit's rate, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_post_mean_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "locator": "'How much money will this save?', first paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3000000000.0, + "value_raw": "£3 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2034-35", + "pe_value": -3211813254.6700063, + "gap": 0.0706, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_post_pretax_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "locator": "'How much money will this save?', third paragraph", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 14300000000.0, + "value_raw": "£14.3 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "gap": -0.2212, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[5] (savings.years[5] = 2031)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2032, + "fy": "2031-32", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 526000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.526", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2031", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2031-32", + "pe_value": -217230570.25019464, + "gap": -0.587, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[6] (savings.years[6] = 2032)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2033, + "fy": "2032-33", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1343000000.0, + "value_raw": "1.343", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2032", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2032-33", + "pe_value": -850021418.4095707, + "gap": -0.3671, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[7] (savings.years[7] = 2033)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2034, + "fy": "2033-34", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2504000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.504", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2033", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2033-34", + "pe_value": -1968205830.921824, + "gap": -0.214, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[8] (savings.years[8] = 2034)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3906000000.0, + "value_raw": "3.906", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2034-35", + "pe_value": -3211813254.6700063, + "gap": -0.1777, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[9] (savings.years[9] = 2035)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2036, + "fy": "2035-36", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5599000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.599", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2035", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2035-36", + "pe_value": -4406755640.831539, + "gap": -0.2129, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[10] (savings.years[10] = 2036)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2037, + "fy": "2036-37", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7508000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.508", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2036", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2036-37", + "pe_value": -5885093637.713373, + "gap": -0.2162, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[11] (savings.years[11] = 2037)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2038, + "fy": "2037-38", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9638000000.0, + "value_raw": "9.638", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2037", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2037-38", + "pe_value": -7484298447.570207, + "gap": -0.2235, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[12] (savings.years[12] = 2038)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2039, + "fy": "2038-39", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 12109000000.0, + "value_raw": "12.109", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2038", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2038-39", + "pe_value": -9271202074.210602, + "gap": -0.2344, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[13] (savings.years[13] = 2039)", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 14901000000.0, + "value_raw": "14.901", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "estimate_label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "pe_value": -11136863655.051073, + "gap": -0.2526, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": true, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[5] (savings.years[5] = 2031)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2032, + "fy": "2031-32", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 422000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.422", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2031", + "nearest_pe_value": 156417504.22159922, + "nearest_gap": -0.6293, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[6] (savings.years[6] = 2032)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2033, + "fy": "2032-33", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1073000000.0, + "value_raw": "1.073", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2032", + "nearest_pe_value": 608885510.6364938, + "nearest_gap": -0.4325, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[7] (savings.years[7] = 2033)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2034, + "fy": "2033-34", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1995000000.0, + "value_raw": "1.995", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2033", + "nearest_pe_value": 1414229874.178762, + "nearest_gap": -0.2911, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[8] (savings.years[8] = 2034)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2035, + "fy": "2034-35", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3103000000.0, + "value_raw": "3.103", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": 2296590901.1592994, + "nearest_gap": -0.2599, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[9] (savings.years[9] = 2035)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2036, + "fy": "2035-36", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4439000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.439", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 3156720894.1896734, + "nearest_gap": -0.2889, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[10] (savings.years[10] = 2036)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2037, + "fy": "2036-37", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5939000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.939", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2036", + "nearest_pe_value": 4195554287.92699, + "nearest_gap": -0.2936, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[11] (savings.years[11] = 2037)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2038, + "fy": "2037-38", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7609000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.609", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2037", + "nearest_pe_value": 5327184898.630032, + "nearest_gap": -0.2999, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[12] (savings.years[12] = 2038)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2039, + "fy": "2038-39", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9545000000.0, + "value_raw": "9.545", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2038", + "nearest_pe_value": 6572734215.313287, + "nearest_gap": -0.3114, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2039", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", + "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[13] (savings.years[13] = 2039)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 11729000000.0, + "value_raw": "11.729", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2039", + "nearest_pe_value": 7860994216.190747, + "nearest_gap": -0.3298, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing." + }, + { + "claim": "obr_wedge_frs2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "obr", + "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", + "title": "Fiscal risks and sustainability - July 2026", + "url": "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2026/", + "locator": "Chapter 3, footnote 80 (state pension)", + "metric": "uprating_premium_over_earnings", + "basis": "outturn", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.56, + "value_raw": "0.56 percentage points", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's Benchmarks tab prints the triple lock's expected premium over earnings for the April 2034-2039 rises, 0.55 points a year (results.json expected_value.gap_by_calibration.means_shift.mean_rate_minus_earnings_2034_2039.triple_lock = 0.00546), but no registered metric names an uprating premium over earnings, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided." + }, + { + "claim": "obr_lted_premium", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "obr", + "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", + "title": "Long-term economic determinants, March 2026 Economic and fiscal outlook", + "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Long-term-economic-determinants-March-2026-EFO.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Growth rate assumptions', row 19 ('Triple lock'), column E ('Notes on 2025 Long-term economic determinants')", + "metric": "uprating_premium_over_earnings", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "state_pension", + "period": 2040, + "fy": "2039-40", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.6, + "value_raw": "0.6 percentage points", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's Benchmarks tab prints the triple lock's expected premium over earnings for the April 2034-2039 rises, 0.55 points a year (results.json expected_value.gap_by_calibration.means_shift.mean_rate_minus_earnings_2034_2039.triple_lock = 0.00546), but no registered metric names an uprating premium over earnings, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided." + } + ] + }, + "analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure": { + "id": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "kind": "post", + "country_id": "us", + "slug": "2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "title": "2025 Supplemental Poverty Measure: what Census reported, and what threshold growth did to it", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/research/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "owner": "max-ghenis", + "published": "2026-09-18", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20:a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20:a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "budget_lab", + "cbo", + "cbpp", + "cpsp", + "crfb", + "itep", + "jct", + "open_search", + "pwbm", + "tax_foundation", + "tpc", + "urban" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "open_search" + ], + "found_not_staged": [ + "cbpp" + ], + "not_applicable": [ + "state_fiscal_note" + ], + "found": 26 + } + ], + "claims": 26, + "compared": 11, + "beside_nearest": 15, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 0.1202, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_all", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.124, + "value_raw": "12.4", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_all", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, all people", + "pe_value": 0.1231, + "gap": -0.0073, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_all", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.007, + "value_raw": "-0.7", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all", + "estimate_label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, all people", + "pe_value": -0.006911, + "gap": -0.0127, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_under_18", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.124, + "value_raw": "12.4", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, children under 18", + "pe_value": 0.1231, + "gap": -0.0073, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_under_18", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.011, + "value_raw": "-1.1", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "estimate_label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, children under 18", + "pe_value": -0.01194, + "gap": 0.0855, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.116, + "value_raw": "11.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 18 to 64", + "pe_value": 0.1155, + "gap": -0.0043, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.006, + "value_raw": "-0.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "estimate_label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 18 to 64", + "pe_value": -0.006518, + "gap": 0.0863, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.146, + "value_raw": "14.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 65 and over", + "pe_value": 0.1466, + "gap": 0.0041, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.005, + "value_raw": "-0.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "estimate_label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 65 and over", + "pe_value": -0.004399, + "gap": -0.1202, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.056, + "value_raw": "5.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, owners with a mortgage", + "pe_value": 0.0567, + "gap": 0.0125, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.115, + "value_raw": "11.5", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, owners without a mortgage", + "pe_value": 0.1149, + "gap": -0.0009, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_renter", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.4, page 12", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.223, + "value_raw": "22.3", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_renter", + "estimate_label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, renters", + "pe_value": 0.2213, + "gap": -0.0076, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.126, + "value_raw": "12.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_all", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.1231, + "nearest_gap": -0.023, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.2, page 10", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.005, + "value_raw": "-0.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.006911, + "nearest_gap": 0.3822, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.006, + "value_raw": "-0.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_all", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.008, + "nearest_gap": 0.3333, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.126, + "value_raw": "12.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.1231, + "nearest_gap": -0.023, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.2, page 10", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.008, + "value_raw": "-0.8", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.01194, + "nearest_gap": 0.4925, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.008, + "value_raw": "-0.8", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.0108, + "nearest_gap": 0.35, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.118, + "value_raw": "11.8", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.1155, + "nearest_gap": -0.0212, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.2, page 10", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.005, + "value_raw": "-0.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.006518, + "nearest_gap": 0.3036, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.005, + "value_raw": "-0.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.0073, + "nearest_gap": 0.46, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.149, + "value_raw": "14.9", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.1466, + "nearest_gap": -0.0161, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.2, page 10", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.003, + "value_raw": "-0.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.004399, + "nearest_gap": 0.4663, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -0.005, + "value_raw": "-0.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "nearest_pe_value": -0.0072, + "nearest_gap": 0.44, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.058, + "value_raw": "5.8", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.0567, + "nearest_gap": -0.0224, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.116, + "value_raw": "11.6", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.1149, + "nearest_gap": -0.0095, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + }, + { + "claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "census", + "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", + "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "locator": "Table A.3, page 11", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "basis": "static", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.227, + "value_raw": "22.7", + "sign_convention": null, + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_renter", + "nearest_pe_value": 0.2213, + "nearest_gap": -0.0251, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds." + } + ] + }, + "analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard": { + "id": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "us", + "slug": "child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "title": "Child poverty impact dashboard", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "owner": "david-trimmer", + "published": "2026-09-15", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:bd4b4bf4403e4301fb0c1209764d93fe5932b2f8323c22a88a6800d5e6caab35" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:bd4b4bf4403e4301fb0c1209764d93fe5932b2f8323c22a88a6800d5e6caab35" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "budget_lab", + "cbo", + "cbpp", + "cpsp", + "itep", + "jct", + "open_search", + "pwbm", + "state_fiscal_note", + "tax_foundation", + "tpc", + "urban" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "academic", + "cbpp", + "cpsp", + "itep", + "open_search", + "state_fiscal_note", + "urban" + ], + "found_not_staged": [], + "not_applicable": [ + "crfb" + ], + "found": 13 + } + ], + "claims": 13, + "compared": 1, + "beside_nearest": 1, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 0.0485, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "itep", + "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", + "title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'WPTRA national and state', table 'Impacts of Working Parents Tax Relief Act in 2026 in California' (row 15), row 23 TOTAL, cell E23 ('Tax Change 1000s')", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "wptra", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -2523100000.0, + "value_raw": "-$2,523,100", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "estimate": "wptra_cost_2026", + "estimate_label": "Net budget cost of the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "pe_value": -2400731391.718506, + "gap": -0.0485, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "comparable", + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ny_fiscal_note", + "publisher": "New York State Department of Taxation and Finance and Division of the Budget", + "title": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", + "url": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1 '2026 personal income tax expenditure estimates (in millions of dollars)', row 25, column Forecast 2026, printed page 16 (PDF page 19); table title printed page 15 (PDF page 18)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 264000000.0, + "value_raw": "264.0", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield from removing the exemption: Table 1 prints the dependent exemptions' tax expenditure, the liability the exemption removes, in millions of dollars", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 265890931.5627365, + "nearest_gap": 0.0072, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json.", + "pe_missing": "Same reform, year and time basis as ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026, but not the same quantity: the report's figure is New York State tax on resident and nonresident returns, and the dashboard's is the net change in federal, state and New York City income tax less benefits for resident households (annotation ny-dependent-exemption-scope). The two are 0.7% apart." + }, + { + "claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbpp", + "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", + "title": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 3, row California, column Total, printed page 14 (PDF page 14)", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 34.0, + "value_raw": "34%", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the number of children in poverty, in percent", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores tax year 2021 against pre-Rescue Plan law (the $2,000 TCJA credit); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_children_lifted_ca_2024", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbpp", + "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", + "title": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", + "locator": "Table 1, row California, column 'Would be lifted above the poverty line by expansion'", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2024, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 318000.0, + "value_raw": "318,000", + "sign_convention": "positive = children lifted above the poverty line, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores the 2021 design in tax year 2024, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "urban", + "publisher": "Urban Institute", + "title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Percentage-point change', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2018, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -6.8, + "value_raw": "-6.8%", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (change after implementation)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "urban", + "publisher": "Urban Institute", + "title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Percentage change', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2018, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -33.3, + "value_raw": "-33.3%", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (percentage change after implementation)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_children_removed_ca_2018", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "urban", + "publisher": "Urban Institute", + "title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Number removed (thousands)', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2018, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 613000.0, + "value_raw": "613", + "sign_convention": "positive = children removed from poverty, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "ppic_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "ppic", + "publisher": "Public Policy Institute of California", + "title": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", + "url": "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", + "locator": "Blog post, paragraph 4", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2018, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 32.0, + "value_raw": "32%", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of poor children lifted out of poverty (fewer children in poverty)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "PPIC scores the 2021 design in 2018 data on the California Poverty Measure, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "itep_arpa_ctc_cost_ca_2023", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "itep", + "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", + "title": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'ARPA CTC US & state', table 'Impacts of Extending the ARPA CTC Expansion if in Effect in 2023 in California' (row 62), row 72 TOTAL, cell E72 ('Tax Change 1000s')", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2023, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -10705800000.0, + "value_raw": "-$10,705,800", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "ITEP scores the 2021 design in 2023, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world)." + }, + { + "claim": "garfinkel_arpa_allowance_net_cost_us_2018", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "garfinkel_et_al", + "publisher": "Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis 13(3), 335-362 (Garfinkel, Sariscsany, Ananat, Collyer, Hartley, Wang and Wimer)", + "title": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", + "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", + "locator": "Micro-simulation estimates, printed page 349 (PDF page 15); the abstract rounds it to '$97 billion per year'", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2018, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 96800000000.0, + "value_raw": "$96.8 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the federal government (the allowance's net cost)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "A national cost on 2019 survey data (2018 incomes), against the $2,000 credit; the dashboard publishes the cost for California households in 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds." + }, + { + "claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_us_2021", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cpsp", + "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University (Wimer, Collyer, Harris and Lee)", + "title": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 3 (PDF page 3), first paragraph; the key findings on page 1 repeat it", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 43.0, + "value_raw": "43%", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "National, for 2021, and measured against no Child Tax Credit at all; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit, for California in 2026." + }, + { + "claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cpsp", + "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University", + "title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, row California, printed page 3 (PDF page 3)", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7.5, + "value_raw": "7.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percentage points", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds." + }, + { + "claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cpsp", + "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University", + "title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, row California, printed page 3 (PDF page 3)", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 41.6, + "value_raw": "41.6%", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds." + } + ] + }, + "analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard": { + "id": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "us", + "slug": "futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "title": "FUTA taxable wage base dashboard", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "owner": "david-trimmer", + "published": "2026-09-17", + "current_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:ebd2d43e12865e9f73265dd928ea23a22ef1e504066d327b669fd4d723423245" + ], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:ebd2d43e12865e9f73265dd928ea23a22ef1e504066d327b669fd4d723423245" + ], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "budget_lab", + "cbo", + "cbpp", + "cpsp", + "crfb", + "itep", + "jct", + "open_search", + "pwbm", + "tax_foundation", + "tpc", + "urban" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "budget_lab", + "cbo" + ], + "found_not_staged": [ + "open_search" + ], + "not_applicable": [ + "state_fiscal_note" + ], + "found": 51 + } + ], + "claims": 51, + "compared": 1, + "beside_nearest": 40, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": 0.0038, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -1300000000.0, + "value_raw": "-1.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": -16.9915, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -1900000000.0, + "value_raw": "-1.9", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 21860102981.0, + "nearest_gap": -12.5053, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -2500000000.0, + "value_raw": "-2.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": 22757333989.0, + "nearest_gap": -10.1029, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 18100000000.0, + "value_raw": "18.1", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": 22757333989.0, + "nearest_gap": 0.2573, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 24, printed page 175 (PDF page 187)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -3700000000.0, + "value_raw": "-3.7", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": -6.6187, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "locator": "Revenues—Option 24, printed page 175 (PDF page 187)", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 13100000000.0, + "value_raw": "13.1", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": 0.5869, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2025, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D36)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2025, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 8461000000.0, + "value_raw": "8.461", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": "futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025", + "estimate_label": "FUTA revenue on a fiscal-year basis, unadjusted model output, FY2025 (the validation cards)", + "pe_value": 8493387632.705948, + "gap": 0.0038, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": "constructed", + "cause": "The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO.", + "pe_missing": null + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2026, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D37)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 8948000000.0, + "value_raw": "8.948", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2027, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D38)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9422000000.0, + "value_raw": "9.422", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2028, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D39)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 10007000000.0, + "value_raw": "10.007", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2029, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D40)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2029, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 11345000000.0, + "value_raw": "11.345", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2030", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2030, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D41)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2030, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 12846000000.0, + "value_raw": "12.846", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2031, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D42)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2031, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 14669000000.0, + "value_raw": "14.669", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2032, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D43)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2032, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 16548000000.0, + "value_raw": "16.548", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2033, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D44)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2033, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 18402000000.0, + "value_raw": "18.402", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2034, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D45)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2034, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 19962000000.0, + "value_raw": "19.962", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "cbo", + "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", + "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2035, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D46)", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 21132000000.0, + "value_raw": "21.132", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8347, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 21860102981.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.0837, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": 22757333989.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.2924, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2029, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": 23687523829.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.5087, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2030, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", + "nearest_pe_value": 24625256580.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.7268, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2031, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4400000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", + "nearest_pe_value": 25527109672.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.8016, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2032, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4400000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", + "nearest_pe_value": 26474385586.0, + "nearest_gap": 5.0169, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2033, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4400000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", + "nearest_pe_value": 27472028832.0, + "nearest_gap": 5.2436, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2034, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4400000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": 28440721078.0, + "nearest_gap": 5.4638, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4400000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 29455438168.0, + "nearest_gap": 5.6944, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 43600000000.0, + "value_raw": "43.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 251088911579.0, + "nearest_gap": 4.7589, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8347, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4500000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.5", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 21860102981.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8578, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4700000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.7", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": 22757333989.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.842, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2029, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4800000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.8", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": 23687523829.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.9349, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2030, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.0", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", + "nearest_pe_value": 24625256580.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.9251, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2031, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5200000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.2", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", + "nearest_pe_value": 25527109672.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.9091, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2032, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5400000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", + "nearest_pe_value": 26474385586.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.9027, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2033, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5600000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", + "nearest_pe_value": 27472028832.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.9057, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2034, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5900000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.9", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": 28440721078.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8205, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6100000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.1", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 29455438168.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8288, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 51600000000.0, + "value_raw": "51.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 251088911579.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8661, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4300000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "nearest_pe_value": 20789010864.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.8347, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2027, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4600000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "nearest_pe_value": 21860102981.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.7522, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2028, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5000000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.0", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "nearest_pe_value": 22757333989.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.5515, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2029, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5300000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.3", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", + "nearest_pe_value": 23687523829.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.4693, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2030, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5600000000.0, + "value_raw": "5.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", + "nearest_pe_value": 24625256580.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.3974, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2031, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6000000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.0", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", + "nearest_pe_value": 25527109672.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.2545, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2032, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6400000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.4", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", + "nearest_pe_value": 26474385586.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.1366, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2033, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6800000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.8", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", + "nearest_pe_value": 27472028832.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.04, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2034, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7200000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.2", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", + "nearest_pe_value": 28440721078.0, + "nearest_gap": 2.9501, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7600000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.6", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 29455438168.0, + "nearest_gap": 2.8757, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 58700000000.0, + "value_raw": "58.7", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 251088911579.0, + "nearest_gap": 3.2775, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000." + }, + { + "claim": "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035", + "found_on": "2026-10-21", + "source": "budget_lab", + "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", + "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "locator": "Page 2, footnote 1", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "basis": "forecast", + "program": "futa", + "period": 2035, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "cumulative", + "range_group": null, + "value": 64000000000.0, + "value_raw": "$64B", + "sign_convention": "level", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "nearest_pe_value": 6245556391.0, + "nearest_gap": -0.9024, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "cause": "The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023.", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab prints a ten-year total; the dashboard's results files print current-law FUTA revenue one calendar year at a time and publish no ten-year baseline total." + } + ] } } } diff --git a/data/lanes.json b/data/lanes.json index 1c5cdb08c..b73c58b8f 100644 --- a/data/lanes.json +++ b/data/lanes.json @@ -587,7 +587,7 @@ "stage": "computed", "running": false, "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "1 analysis searched, 22 claims, 22 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "note": "5 analyses searched, 128 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" }, { "id": "analysis-comparables-us", @@ -595,10 +595,10 @@ "area": "every external estimate of each PolicyEngine analysis, found before it is published", "mode": 2, "country": "US", - "stage": "registered", + "stage": "computed", "running": false, "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "0 analyses searched, 0 claims, 0 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "note": "3 analyses searched, 90 claims, 69 PolicyEngine results beside them" } ] } diff --git a/data/populations.json b/data/populations.json index 2b9d79ab1..94c50dd78 100644 --- a/data/populations.json +++ b/data/populations.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "built": "2026-10-22", "note": "Non-Urban populations exported from scorecard.db: the populace reform-validation registry (issue #20) plus the compute campaign's attached comparisons (US: TPC/CPSP/PWBM/CBO/JCT; UK: the HMRC ready-reckoner family and the complete OBR Policy measures database, including historical HM Treasury scores; BE: JRC EUROMOD-BE claims with demo-grade Axiom concept-mismatch attachments and the 2026 PIT-reform scorekeeper claims; NZ: official budget scores). Claims explicitly opted into pre-result display remain in the feed with latest status not_computed and empty history. Recorded result statuses and calibration relationships are verbatim; nothing here is a pass/fail grade.", "summary": { - "claims": 29739, + "claims": 29935, "multi_release_claims": 270, "by_source": { "aspe_welfare_indicators": 14, @@ -106,20 +106,47 @@ "wi_admin": 1 }, "by_source_in_comparables_records": { - "centax": 14, - "centre_for_british_progress": 8 + "budget_lab": 34, + "cbo": 17, + "cbpp": 2, + "cebr": 2, + "census": 26, + "centax": 26, + "centre_for_british_progress": 30, + "cpsp": 3, + "desnz": 2, + "dwp": 4, + "electricity_bills_taskforce": 1, + "garfinkel_et_al": 1, + "good_energy": 5, + "green_party": 1, + "hm_treasury": 2, + "ifs": 10, + "ippr": 3, + "itep": 2, + "jrf": 3, + "mcs_foundation": 2, + "nef": 2, + "niesr": 3, + "ny_fiscal_note": 1, + "octopus_energy": 1, + "ppic": 1, + "rea": 2, + "resolution_foundation": 25, + "tuc": 4, + "urban": 3 }, "by_latest_status": { - "comparable": 50, - "concept_mismatch": 24, - "constructed": 1669, - "not_computed": 27107, + "comparable": 84, + "concept_mismatch": 131, + "constructed": 1675, + "not_computed": 27156, "pe_gap": 889 }, "by_sign_relative_to_pe": { "magnitude": 14, - "opposite": 489, - "same": 28967, + "opposite": 553, + "same": 29099, "unknown": 269 }, "by_country": { @@ -138,17 +165,17 @@ "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "UK": { - "claims": 29183, - "with_result": 2184, - "with_value": 1199, - "without_result": 26999, + "claims": 29289, + "with_result": 2262, + "with_value": 1277, + "without_result": 27027, "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "US": { - "claims": 535, - "with_result": 535, - "with_value": 535, - "without_result": 0, + "claims": 625, + "with_result": 604, + "with_value": 604, + "without_result": 21, "multi_release_claims": 270 } } @@ -3245,955 +3272,868 @@ } }, { - "claim_id": "498a3108cce7ef3cbf73", - "source": "ca_admin", + "claim_id": "4de87bbcbafc4b106762", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state_ca_eitc", - "name": "California CalEITC", - "window": "TY2023", - "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", - "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2023, + "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_eitc", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_eitc" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 941000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 941000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 1149547855.0776587, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2216236504544726, - "delta": 208547855.07765865 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 819736648.1434908, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.752.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1164308735.9892344, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1225375778.6142159, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1176093695.552145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 1149547855.0776587, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9eda40b94ca5ce924e04", - "source": "ca_admin", + "claim_id": "88ef5c5d997294ef224e", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state_ca_yctc", - "name": "California Young Child Tax Credit", - "window": "TY2023", - "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", - "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2023, + "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_yctc", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", - "program": "ca_yctc" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 413000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 413000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 621910038.0736201, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5058354432775305, - "delta": 208910038.07362008 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 572858122.8276322, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.752.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 641544372.2220612, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 596007571.7019713, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 579675158.4393413, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 621910038.0736201, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "concept_mismatch", - "rationale": "[batch2 D6, confidence medium] Flat refundable child credits (CA YCTC, CO FAC, MD CTC): PE pays full entitlement to every eligible unit, benchmarks count claims", - "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/D.md" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c9b762228722c8e68305", - "source": "ca_fiscal_note", + "claim_id": "e12f890895a1c51811be", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "state.ca.ab2591", - "name": "CA AB2591 \u2014 standard deduction increase", - "window": "first full year (FY2027-28)", - "publication_title": "CA FTB via Assembly Revenue & Taxation analysis", - "url": "https://trackbill.com/s3/bills/CA/2025/AB2591", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2026", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2028, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "CA", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "CA" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "a8f8aa819449e6cf", - "external_value": -7000000000.0, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", - "external_value_pe_sign": -7000000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -6472662333.456696, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9246660476366708, - "delta": 527337666.54330444 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.834653689302326, + "delta": 16489010864.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": -5951172549.383606, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.729.0", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", - "release": "l0-refit", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6461187332.940857, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", - "release": "buildi", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6387695352.5572815, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", - "release": "buildj", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6408273121.757233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": -6472662333.456696, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1de831292608256d5c2e", - "source": "capital_economics", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "claim_id": "4223cb41ee06165eb1b1", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", - "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "2029-30", - "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", - "reform_hint": "Tax rises of about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November, mostly for households and potentially on property", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", - "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "program": "package", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [], - "parameter_paths": [] + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.5", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", - "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4500000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.857800662444444, + "delta": 17360102981.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "63690887dee50ca31c89", - "source": "capital_economics", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "claim_id": "c214baae04e236c6bda6", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", - "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "2029-30", - "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", - "reform_hint": "raise taxes by about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", - "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", - "program": "package", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [], - "parameter_paths": [] + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", - "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.083744879302325, + "delta": 17560102981.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9412a33dffe76806b2f5", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "99150d4ff16bf17af23e", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Beneficiary (Dollars)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2027", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "per": "beneficiary", - "program": "ssi" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2027", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 751.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 4600000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 751.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 789.2905812238647, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0509861267960914, - "delta": 38.290581223864706 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.752196300217391, + "delta": 17260102981.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 789.3138964940113, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 789.2905812238647, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ee5f9b6d36786a5acd03", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "ea3d4478f6cc25aa4308", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Participant (Dollars)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "per": "participant", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.7", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 186.6, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4700000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 186.6, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4700000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 134.25440536253626, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7194769847938707, - "delta": -52.34559463746373 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.841985955106383, + "delta": 18057333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 129.7045752084306, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 134.25440536253626, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6e8f56211bba4272cc31", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "f64af0e6d55ea2c03f9d", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax credits", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "outlays", - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", - "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted", - "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.041351550461811, - "delta": 4321815944.965698 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.292403253255814, + "delta": 18457333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 109071629469.4516, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "eb4cb3d5e81cdf1c63fb", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "03374839dd84e2ef087f", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax creditsd", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2028", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "outlays", - "geography": "US", - "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", - "timing": "unadjusted", - "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2028", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.041351550461811, - "delta": 4321815944.965698 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.5514667978, + "delta": 17757333989.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 109071629469.4516, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 108835815944.9657, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a44c8e195796cee4e5d7", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "8f9b54af382f54175e11", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Estimated Budget Authority", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "budget_concept": "budget_authority", - "component": "total", - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.8", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 98415000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 4800000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 98415000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4800000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 100265316841.38287, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0188011669093417, - "delta": 1850316841.3828735 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.934900797708333, + "delta": 18887523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 90927596849.523, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 100265316841.38287, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2fce267a8ea74d79cdff", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "cecca370a8224315ec80", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Estimated Outlays", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51314-2026-02-tanf.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "tanf", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "component": "total_outlays", - "funder": "federal", - "geography": "US", - "program": "tanf" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 16968000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 16968000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 5045530740.344602, + "value": 23687523829.0, "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", - "ratio": 0.297355654192869, - "delta": -11922469259.6554 + "ratio": 5.508726471860465, + "delta": 19387523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 4936866453.148398, - "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" - }, - { - "value": 5045530740.344602, + "value": 23687523829.0, "status": "concept_mismatch", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } @@ -4201,1061 +4141,6477 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ffc6d48f894e88134428", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "b35d9b4e066906458cf3", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2029", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "benefit_cost", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", - "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2029", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 66500000000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 66500000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 57855559925.80327, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8700084199368913, - "delta": -8644440074.196732 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.4693441186792455, + "delta": 18387523829.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 57857268951.65666, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 57855559925.80327, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c7a6ced57044b52a7f91", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "af5a2b191d6052caf288", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Beneficiaries (Thousands of people)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", - "metric": "participant_count", - "unit_concept": "persons", - "value_kind": "count", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "ssi" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 7275000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 7275000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8396415796788986, - "delta": -1166607.5078360122 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.925051316, + "delta": 19625256580.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 6108392.492163988, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9be64cb6bef0d6d3da07", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "dd27153805106d58d12b", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "Average Monthly Participation (Millions of people)", - "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", - "metric": "participant_count", - "unit_concept": "persons", - "value_kind": "count", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "average_month", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap", + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "program": "snap" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.3", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 39300000.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4300000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 39300000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 62235894.96041095, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5836105587890827, - "delta": 22935894.960410953 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.726803855813953, + "delta": 20325256580.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 58419679.68580754, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", - "release": "buildp", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a57174c823740e575fd0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2030", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2030", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 5600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.397367246428572, + "delta": 19025256580.0 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 62235894.96041095, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b9df9a9de41ba44a3979", - "source": "cbo", + "claim_id": "5e67a7f6b938c2fabfe4", + "source": "budget_lab", "country": "US", - "source_column": "federal.cbo_rates_plus_1pt", - "name": "CBO option \u2014 all individual rates +1pt (applied to 2024 data)", - "window": "FY2026 (first full fiscal year)", - "publication_title": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2025 to 2034 (Dec 2024), 'Increase Individual Income Tax Rates on Ordinary Income', alternative 1 (JCT staff estimate)", - "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/60937", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value_kind": "usd", - "period": 2026, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "pre_obbba_current_law", - "geography": "US" + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.2", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "098098619723de7a", - "external_value": 106300000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5200000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", - "external_value_pe_sign": 106300000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5200000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 114386696495.23145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0760742849974736, - "delta": 8086696495.231445 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.909059552307692, + "delta": 20327109672.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 113870114490.94482, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5d42479d7aac10e23abe", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.801615834545455, + "delta": 21127109672.0 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 114386696495.23145, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "baa3949221e1f4fa6342", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "96606fc1cac2d351d809", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2031", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2025, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", - "income_group": "quintile_1", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a349" + "calendar_year": "CY2031", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.0", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": -49.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -49.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.254518278666667, + "delta": 19527109672.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 25527109672.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d6137cfae4ffb901b7ad", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "14104aa384fd414754dc", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2025, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", - "income_group": "quintile_2", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": -45.0, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5400000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.902663997407408, + "delta": 21074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acc579c767cf601096b3", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "28878b535852b486bb7d", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "minimum_wage_bite", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2026, + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "UK", - "statistic": "minimum wage as a percentage of the median wage", - "value_verbatim": "62.1%" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 62.1, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 62.1, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.016905815, + "delta": 22074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "337c36901cfd1efcf367", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "416986432aea7c93ef8d", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2032", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a312.71", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Living Wage (21 and over)", - "value_verbatim": "1.6%" + "calendar_year": "CY2032", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 1.6, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.1366227478125, + "delta": 20074385586.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 26474385586.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8a11612d6cd9f9163719", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "29734dd65b06be2bac40", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a310.85", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (18-20)", - "value_verbatim": "5.9%" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 5.9, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.905719434285714, + "delta": 21872028832.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9df5404e8cb5c0a5f64a", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "1542f87bf8e409590e6f", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", - "metric": "real_income_growth", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", - "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", - "rate": "\u00a38.00", - "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", - "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (16-17 and apprentices)", - "value_verbatim": "3.4%" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", - "external_value": 3.4, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.243642916363636, + "delta": 23072028832.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d824ee34586fb61b5be0", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "31938eabe9ec4eeb3096", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2033", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2029, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2028-29", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.9 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2033", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.8", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 6800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.04000424, + "delta": 20672028832.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 27472028832.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "96919300c9a479caa0f0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "5.9", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 4900000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 5900000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5900000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 4838076868.264832, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9873626261764963, - "delta": -61923131.73516846 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.820461199661017, + "delta": 22540721078.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 4838076868.264832, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cc51fbb31e03b3a5ee67", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "547af640d4aa079506f0", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a310.5 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.463800245, + "delta": 24040721078.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0d1ca2899f521e67ad9", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2034", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2034", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "7.2", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 10500000000.0, + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 7200000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 10500000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7200000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7601212159198754, - "delta": -2518727232.8413086 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 3.950100149722222, + "delta": 21240721078.0 }, "results": [ { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a3b8e2b1054c2d67c51", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "claim_id": "2a089b2f7a12febdd013", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "6.1", + "wage_base": "$14,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 6100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 6100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.828760355409836, + "delta": 23355438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9f677b7373f8e49f0781", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "chained CPI-U", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "51.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "reform_key": "d56c8d19f1c1b446", + "external_value": 51600000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 51600000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 13347079049.836914, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, - "delta": -2552920950.163086 + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.866064177887597, + "delta": 199488911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "286f29324862e5230a70", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "4.4", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.694417765454546, + "delta": 25055438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "93b6be20039f05fc1761", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "none", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "43.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a64e781b300bf36a", + "external_value": 43600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 43600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.758919990344037, + "delta": 207488911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e56810b2d3f1c65a08a8", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2035", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2035", + "country": "US", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "7.6", + "wage_base": "$14,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 7600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 3.8757155484210526, + "delta": 21855438168.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 29455438168.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "887b939bccb1285ca035", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "indexing": "SSA average wage index", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", + "value_verbatim": "58.7", + "wage_base": "$14,000", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "06f45665ad33880e", + "external_value": 58700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 58700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.277494234735945, + "delta": 192388911579.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 251088911579.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035\", \"field\": \"sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset: Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3e2e1acd1b7f8d9c5ede", + "source": "budget_lab", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "baseline FUTA revenues over the decade", + "name": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", + "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "baseline projection benchmarked to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab prints a ten-year total; the dashboard's results files print current-law FUTA revenue one calendar year at a time and publish no ten-year baseline total.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "statistic": "approximate ('about $64B')", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "$64B", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 64000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 64000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6245556391.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-baseline-decade-total: The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.097586818609375, + "delta": -57754443609.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6245556391.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2035, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "budget-lab-baseline-decade-total: The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "498a3108cce7ef3cbf73", + "source": "ca_admin", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state_ca_eitc", + "name": "California CalEITC", + "window": "TY2023", + "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", + "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_eitc", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_eitc" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 941000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 941000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 1149547855.0776587, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2216236504544726, + "delta": 208547855.07765865 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 819736648.1434908, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.752.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1164308735.9892344, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1225375778.6142159, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1176093695.552145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 1149547855.0776587, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_eitc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9eda40b94ca5ce924e04", + "source": "ca_admin", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state_ca_yctc", + "name": "California Young Child Tax Credit", + "window": "TY2023", + "publication_title": "CA FTB, California EITC / YCTC / FYTC Report (Oct 2025), Table 1 p.8", + "url": "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2023.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_yctc", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "program": "ca_yctc" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 413000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 413000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 621910038.0736201, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5058354432775305, + "delta": 208910038.07362008 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 572858122.8276322, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.752.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 641544372.2220612, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 596007571.7019713, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 579675158.4393413, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 621910038.0736201, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:ca_yctc", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "concept_mismatch", + "rationale": "[batch2 D6, confidence medium] Flat refundable child credits (CA YCTC, CO FAC, MD CTC): PE pays full entitlement to every eligible unit, benchmarks count claims", + "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/D.md" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "c9b762228722c8e68305", + "source": "ca_fiscal_note", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "state.ca.ab2591", + "name": "CA AB2591 \u2014 standard deduction increase", + "window": "first full year (FY2027-28)", + "publication_title": "CA FTB via Assembly Revenue & Taxation analysis", + "url": "https://trackbill.com/s3/bills/CA/2025/AB2591", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "CA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a8f8aa819449e6cf", + "external_value": -7000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -6472662333.456696, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9246660476366708, + "delta": 527337666.54330444 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -5951172549.383606, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.729.0", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-sparse-l0-refit-57k-71a0887-national-only-20260701", + "release": "l0-refit", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-01T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6461187332.940857, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildi-sparse-rmloss100-6e8e929-20260709T034135Z", + "release": "buildi", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-09T03:41:35", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6387695352.5572815, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildj-sparse-rmloss100-75d5add-20260710T094201Z", + "release": "buildj", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-10T09:42:01", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6408273121.757233, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": -6472662333.456696, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:ca_income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1de831292608256d5c2e", + "source": "capital_economics", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "2029-30", + "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", + "reform_hint": "Tax rises of about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November, mostly for households and potentially on property", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", + "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "program": "package", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", + "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "63690887dee50ca31c89", + "source": "capital_economics", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "UK Autumn Budget 2025: Economic, financial and housing market implications (key-issues hub; abstracts of the Focus notes)", + "url": "https://www.capitaleconomics.com/key-issues/uk-budget", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fiscal_measure": "package_tax_rise_size", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "2029-30", + "measure_key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "measure_type": "expected tax rises in the Budget", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The package total sums measures the household model cannot express (business taxes, administrative yields, departmental spending). A PE package number is the sum of the expressible household legs only, stated as constructed with the omitted lines listed; it is never compared to the Table 4.1 total as if like-for-like.", + "reform_hint": "raise taxes by about \u00a338bn in the Budget on 26th November", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "timing": "pre-Budget expectation", + "value_verbatim": "about \u00a338bn" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__package_total_tax_policy_decisions", + "program": "package", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "acd5910cec32e067", + "external_value": 38000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 38000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9412a33dffe76806b2f5", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Beneficiary (Dollars)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "per": "beneficiary", + "program": "ssi" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 751.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 751.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 789.2905812238647, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0509861267960914, + "delta": 38.290581223864706 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 789.3138964940113, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 789.2905812238647, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 ssi dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ee5f9b6d36786a5acd03", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Benefit per Participant (Dollars)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "average_monthly_benefit", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "per": "participant", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 186.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 186.6, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 134.25440536253626, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7194769847938707, + "delta": -52.34559463746373 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 129.7045752084306, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 134.25440536253626, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 snap dollars / year-grid part_pop / 12 (per annual-ever person-month) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta); denominator concept differs -> ratio inherits caseload delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6e8f56211bba4272cc31", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax credits", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "conditions": { + "component": "outlays", + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted", + "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.041351550461811, + "delta": 4321815944.965698 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 109071629469.4516, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "eb4cb3d5e81cdf1c63fb", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Earned income, child, and other tax creditsd", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51118-2026-02-Budget-Projections.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "conditions": { + "component": "outlays", + "geography": "US", + "program": "eitc_ctc_other_credits", + "timing": "unadjusted", + "variant": "outlay_portion_of_refundable_credits" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 104514000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 104514000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.041351550461811, + "delta": 4321815944.965698 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 109071629469.4516, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 108835815944.9657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "eitc+refundable_ctc CY2026 (composite; CBO line includes 'other credits' \u2014 scope note) | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO composite line broader than EITC+ACTC (named scope delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a44c8e195796cee4e5d7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Estimated Budget Authority", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "budget_concept": "budget_authority", + "component": "total", + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 98415000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 98415000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 100265316841.38287, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0188011669093417, + "delta": 1850316841.3828735 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 90927596849.523, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 100265316841.38287, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate snap total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is BUDGET AUTHORITY (FY); PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named concept + timing deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2fce267a8ea74d79cdff", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Estimated Outlays", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51314-2026-02-tanf.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "tanf", + "conditions": { + "component": "total_outlays", + "funder": "federal", + "geography": "US", + "program": "tanf" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 16968000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 16968000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 5045530740.344602, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.297355654192869, + "delta": -11922469259.6554 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4936866453.148398, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + }, + { + "value": 5045530740.344602, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate tanf total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Estimated Outlays), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas); CBO TANF outlays = full block grant (incl. non-cash state uses); PE models cash assistance only (~quarter of block-grant spending) \u2014 named scope delta", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ffc6d48f894e88134428", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "timing": "payment_shift_adjusted" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 66500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 66500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 57855559925.80327, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8700084199368913, + "delta": -8644440074.196732 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 57857268951.65666, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 57855559925.80327, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "pass2 aggregate ssi total_usd CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); CBO row is outlays (Total Outlays, Adjusted for Date of Payment Shiftb), cash FY; PE totals are accrual entitlement dollars (named deltas)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c7a6ced57044b52a7f91", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Beneficiaries (Thousands of people)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51313-2026-02-ssi.xlsx", + "metric": "participant_count", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "ssi" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 7275000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7275000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8396415796788986, + "delta": -1166607.5078360122 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 6108392.492163988, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid ssi part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9be64cb6bef0d6d3da07", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Average Monthly Participation (Millions of people)", + "name": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2026 to 2036 (supplemental data)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/51312-2026-02-snap.xlsx", + "metric": "participant_count", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "average_month", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "program": "snap" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 39300000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 39300000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 62235894.96041095, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5836105587890827, + "delta": 22935894.960410953 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 58419679.68580754, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildp-sparse-rmloss100-cae8640-20260728T011454Z", + "release": "buildp", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-08-07T02:24:55.382758+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 62235894.96041095, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "year-grid snap part_pop US CY2026 | CBO federal fiscal year vs PE calendar year (named delta); PE annual-ever persons in units with benefit>0 vs CBO avg-monthly participation (named delta)", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-06T16:06:30.161645+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5ff7fcd866a6f1a923ad", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-1.3" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -1300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -15.991546818461538, + "delta": 22089010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2192be5b3a1d77372203", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, 2026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 24, second alternative", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-3.7" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "63b6d79143266903", + "external_value": -3700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -5.618651584864865, + "delta": 24489010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "457c21d6e672dd77ba93", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, Total 2017\u20132026", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "fiscal_year": "FY2017-FY2026", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 24, second alternative", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "13.1", + "window": "2017-2026", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "63b6d79143266903", + "external_value": 13100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 13100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.5869473941984733, + "delta": 7689010864.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 20789010864.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b9df9a9de41ba44a3979", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "federal.cbo_rates_plus_1pt", + "name": "CBO option \u2014 all individual rates +1pt (applied to 2024 data)", + "window": "FY2026 (first full fiscal year)", + "publication_title": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2025 to 2034 (Dec 2024), 'Increase Individual Income Tax Rates on Ordinary Income', alternative 1 (JCT staff estimate)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/60937", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "geography": "US" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "098098619723de7a", + "external_value": 106300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "us_signed_change", + "external_value_pe_sign": 106300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "pre_obbba_current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 114386696495.23145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0760742849974736, + "delta": 8086696495.231445 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 113870114490.94482, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 114386696495.23145, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "reform_delta:income_tax", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "02ec96dabbab418c4329", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2027", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2027", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-1.9" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -1900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -11.505317358421053, + "delta": 23760102981.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 21860102981.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c7103bd74c8dc385924a", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2028", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2028", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "-2.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": -2500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -9.1029335956, + "delta": 25257333989.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a9046938ff191e2752ed", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change in Revenues, Total 2019\u20132028", + "name": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "estimate_kind": "cumulative", + "fiscal_year": "FY2019-FY2028", + "option": "Revenues\u2014Option 23", + "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", + "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", + "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", + "value_verbatim": "18.1", + "window": "2019-2028", + "window_kind": "total" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "74d31ec94a188d2c", + "external_value": 18100000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 18100000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.2573112701104971, + "delta": 4657333989.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 22757333989.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028\", \"field\": \"calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd\", \"path\": \"analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes: CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b371bad3af122578c56f", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2025", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2025", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "8.461" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 8461000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8461000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 8493387632.705948, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025\", \"field\": \"validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_fiscal_year_basis\", \"path\": \"frontend/lib/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "annotations": [ + "fiscal-year-futa-collections-construction: The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0038278729117065, + "delta": 32387632.705947876 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 8493387632.705948, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.0.0 policyengine_us==2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025\", \"field\": \"validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_fiscal_year_basis\", \"path\": \"frontend/lib/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "annotations": [ + "fiscal-year-futa-collections-construction: The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "44747dda3235ec751a3d", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2026", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2026", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2026", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "8.948" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 8948000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8948000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4c4f771ee61b51f08fb7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2027", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2027", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2027", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "9.422" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 9422000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 9422000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "dd6f65ee56c6b27cfccb", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2028", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2028", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2028", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "10.007" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 10007000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 10007000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1c218ee794bdad15f168", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2029", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2029", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2029", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "11.345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 11345000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 11345000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ba79ffb3bfd3abea1c01", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2030", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2030", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2030", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "12.846" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 12846000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 12846000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c8dfb4e81b237c014d11", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2031", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2031", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2031", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "14.669" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 14669000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 14669000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "331d5b6a90f45a9f5769", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2032", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2032", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2032", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "16.548" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 16548000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 16548000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e3585e4aeb71f761382c", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2033", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2033", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2033", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "18.402" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 18402000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 18402000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1099266a7ad7ae8db9a7", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2034", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2034", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2034", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "19.962" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 19962000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 19962000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "299a3d53d512778e1ce8", + "source": "cbo", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2035", + "name": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", + "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "futa", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2035", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", + "country": "US", + "fiscal_year": "FY2035", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept.", + "program": "futa", + "sign_convention": "level", + "tax": "FUTA", + "value_verbatim": "21.132" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 21132000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 21132000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1cfdcb726ba9b109c441", + "source": "cbpp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Would be lifted above the poverty line by expansion", + "name": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_children_lifted_ca_2024", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores the 2021 design in tax year 2024, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children under 18", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = children lifted above the poverty line, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "tax_year": "2024", + "value_verbatim": "318,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 318000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -318000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2718f2fecf59738f781f", + "source": "cbpp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Total", + "name": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", + "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "tcja_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "relative to before American Rescue Plan's temporary expansion", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "CBPP scores tax year 2021 against pre-Rescue Plan law (the $2,000 TCJA credit); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children under 18", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the number of children in poverty, in percent", + "tax_year": "2021", + "value_verbatim": "34%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "45217df19876662b", + "external_value": 34.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -34.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "tcja_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "baa3949221e1f4fa6342", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", + "income_group": "quintile_1", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a349" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": -49.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -49.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d6137cfae4ffb901b7ad", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "data": "Asda Income Tracker (Cebr)", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "from the pre-cost-of-living-crisis peak", + "income_group": "quintile_2", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": -45.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d2b3c34b04894a26a36c", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2026", + "name": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2026", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2026 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes \u00a31,100 lower)", + "statistic": "mean (average UK household)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31,100" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 1100.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1100.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6330cee4b5c8cebd26c9", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2027", + "name": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war \u2013 Middle East conflict to strip \u00a370.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2027", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2027 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes \u00a31,300 lower)", + "statistic": "mean (average UK household)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31,300" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 1300.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "acc579c767cf601096b3", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "minimum_wage_bite", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "minimum wage as a percentage of the median wage", + "value_verbatim": "62.1%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 62.1, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 62.1, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "337c36901cfd1efcf367", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a312.71", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Living Wage (21 and over)", + "value_verbatim": "1.6%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 1.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8a11612d6cd9f9163719", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a310.85", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (18-20)", + "value_verbatim": "5.9%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 5.9, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9df5404e8cb5c0a5f64a", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "real_income_growth", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "income_concept": "real-terms hourly pay at the wage floor", + "price_basis": "real (Cebr CPI forecast)", + "rate": "\u00a38.00", + "reform_hint": "National Living Wage \u00a312.71 (21+), National Minimum Wage \u00a310.85 (18-20) and \u00a38.00 (16-17 and apprentices) from April 2026", + "subgroup": "National Minimum Wage (16-17 and apprentices)", + "value_verbatim": "3.4%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "24d78b23704f227d", + "external_value": 3.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d824ee34586fb61b5be0", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 4900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 4838076868.264832, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9873626261764963, + "delta": -61923131.73516846 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4838076868.264832, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2028.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:35.135337+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2028 on the certified world proxies FY 2028-29; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "cc51fbb31e03b3a5ee67", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a310.5 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 10500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 10500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7601212159198754, + "delta": -2518727232.8413086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:43.283596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4a3b8e2b1054c2d67c51", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr's Immediate Reaction: Autumn Budget Briefing, November 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Cebr-Briefing-Note-Autumn-Budget-2025.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "method": "Cebr's own earnings-growth and CPI forecasts applied to the frozen thresholds ('stronger consumer price growth and, in turn, higher wage growth')", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, + "delta": -2552920950.163086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6daca0af5539cb3b9dde", + "source": "cebr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", + "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/cebrs-reaction-the-autumn-budget-2025/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, + "delta": -2552920950.163086 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 13347079049.836914, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e931e849f18e52572ae2", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ak", + "name": "Alaska SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AK", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.106, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0985307152971824, + "delta": 0.010444255821501339 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.10329803285169523, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e4d83b427fc214ea4eb3", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_al", + "name": "Alabama SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.1310747038068096, + "delta": 0.019136906755794214 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1505569333413196, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4d6626b38d8bd84c6e7d", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ar", + "name": "Arkansas SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AR", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AR", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.5566199389781833, + "delta": -0.06473348890918523 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.11503155907237178, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7537730fcc7aa9722282", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_az", + "name": "Arizona SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "AZ", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "AZ", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.147, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.039673436870702, + "delta": 0.005831995219993169 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1921782872434054, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "364841741d272c58b038", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ca", + "name": "California SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.182, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.182, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2629218907726096, + "delta": 0.04785178412061494 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.2159505536043489, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "bc66a347f2c2aa136efe", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_co", + "name": "Colorado SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CO", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CO", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.077, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.4289637601480423, + "delta": 0.03303020953139926 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.13855390686776925, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d69d7a081344f1b4a729", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ct", + "name": "Connecticut SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "CT", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "CT", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.109, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.3083926442580418, + "delta": 0.033614798224126566 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.17263896958254063, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2cebdc00578e54b45a22", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_dc", + "name": "District of Columbia SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DC", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "DC", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.187, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.187, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.43688408529283, + "delta": 0.0816973239497592 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.14467308939448856, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5be90ddb7e953a22fe29", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_de", + "name": "Delaware SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DE", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "DE", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.103, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.896440171364231, + "delta": 0.09233333765051578 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.22695217212887303, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "e4a68546c4be960ea5d1", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_fl", + "name": "Florida SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "FL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "FL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.176, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.176, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.5673740035802572, + "delta": 0.09985782463012527 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.310077108061372, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } + }, + { + "claim_id": "ae7020f71018aa71e13b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ga", + "name": "Georgia SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "GA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "GA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.137, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.137, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2492671989835735, + "delta": 0.03414960626074959 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.15099892503706577, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d80f38afc52ad764420b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_hi", + "name": "Hawaii SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "HI", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "HI", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.122, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.122, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.7296468117411257, + "delta": -0.032983088967582674 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.10759347113653098, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "664f55921193cc68fe99", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ia", + "name": "Iowa SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IA", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "IA", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.07, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.1334667332852384, + "delta": 0.00934267132996669 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.12356060759864736, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9b9854e0a7826d3f6971", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_id", + "name": "Idaho SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "ID", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "ID", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.058, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.425414499426542, + "delta": 0.02467404096673944 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.04319380943090882, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "60ca60bce71f685cf470", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_il", + "name": "Illinois SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IL", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "geography": "IL", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.109, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.2889150866478662, + "delta": 0.03149174444461743 }, "results": [ { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.22407192001757978, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6daca0af5539cb3b9dde", - "source": "cebr", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Cebr\u2019s Reaction: The Autumn Budget 2025", - "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/cebrs-reaction-the-autumn-budget-2025/", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", + "claim_id": "ff7246abfe3677335ca6", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_in", + "name": "Indiana SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "IN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "basis": "forecast", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the freeze on income tax thresholds by three more years, to the 2030/31 financial year", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a315.9 billion" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "geography": "IN", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "window_kind": "annual_average" }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 15900000000.0, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 15900000000.0, + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.1213452458502143, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8394389339520072, - "delta": -2552920950.163086 + "ratio": 1.3334642401122452, + "delta": 0.03034524585021431 }, "results": [ { - "value": 13347079049.836914, + "value": 0.1401888779452793, "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "engine_version": "1.764.6", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", + "release": "buildo", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + }, + { + "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.2.1", + "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", + "release": "spm-20260915", + "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e931e849f18e52572ae2", + "claim_id": "5b236b30fa3880759154", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ak", - "name": "Alaska SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ks", + "name": "Kansas SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5266,24 +10622,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.106, + "external_value": 0.097, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.097, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "value": 0.07687780380679853, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5294,12 +10650,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0985307152971824, - "delta": 0.010444255821501339 + "ratio": 0.7925546784206033, + "delta": -0.020122196193201478 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10329803285169523, + "value": 0.11049707808530514, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5312,7 +10668,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11644425582150134, + "value": 0.07687780380679853, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5328,11 +10684,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e4d83b427fc214ea4eb3", + "claim_id": "a3cc89a80759ebd0e943", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_al", - "name": "Alabama SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ky", + "name": "Kentucky SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5343,24 +10699,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.146, + "external_value": 0.158, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "value": 0.161467256006912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5371,12 +10727,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1310747038068096, - "delta": 0.019136906755794214 + "ratio": 1.021944658271595, + "delta": 0.0034672560069120006 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1505569333413196, + "value": 0.16650483237144315, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5389,7 +10745,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1651369067557942, + "value": 0.161467256006912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5405,11 +10761,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4d6626b38d8bd84c6e7d", + "claim_id": "53520f720a63c7550d45", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ar", - "name": "Arkansas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_la", + "name": "Louisiana SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5420,24 +10776,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.146, + "external_value": 0.189, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.189, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "value": 0.125609622841254, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5448,12 +10804,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5566199389781833, - "delta": -0.06473348890918523 + "ratio": 0.6646011790542539, + "delta": -0.06339037715874601 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11503155907237178, + "value": 0.14878938671226047, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5466,7 +10822,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08126651109081476, + "value": 0.125609622841254, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5482,11 +10838,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7537730fcc7aa9722282", + "claim_id": "bd4ea8335108373296f7", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_az", - "name": "Arizona SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ma", + "name": "Massachusetts SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5497,24 +10853,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.147, + "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "value": 0.19868201101176794, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5525,12 +10881,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.039673436870702, - "delta": 0.005831995219993169 + "ratio": 1.7127759569979994, + "delta": 0.08268201101176793 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1921782872434054, + "value": 0.15018924622184068, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5543,7 +10899,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15283199521999316, + "value": 0.19868201101176794, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5556,14 +10912,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "364841741d272c58b038", + "claim_id": "fee6a482e8ac1fc33989", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ca", - "name": "California SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_md", + "name": "Maryland SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5574,24 +10934,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.182, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.182, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "value": 0.11005888615244076, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5602,12 +10962,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2629218907726096, - "delta": 0.04785178412061494 + "ratio": 0.8875716625196836, + "delta": -0.013941113847559236 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2159505536043489, + "value": 0.2138827361406449, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5620,7 +10980,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.22985178412061494, + "value": 0.11005888615244076, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5636,11 +10996,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bc66a347f2c2aa136efe", + "claim_id": "8896cdbb8213f271fcc1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_co", - "name": "Colorado SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_me", + "name": "Maine SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5651,24 +11011,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "external_value": 0.05, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.05, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "value": 0.12448915934503967, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5679,12 +11039,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4289637601480423, - "delta": 0.03303020953139926 + "ratio": 2.489783186900793, + "delta": 0.07448915934503966 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13855390686776925, + "value": 0.09936430562401276, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5697,7 +11057,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11003020953139926, + "value": 0.12448915934503967, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5710,14 +11070,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "d69d7a081344f1b4a729", + "claim_id": "ee8a446834a4da49903b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ct", - "name": "Connecticut SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mi", + "name": "Michigan SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5728,24 +11092,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.109, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "value": 0.1055862855424053, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5756,12 +11120,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3083926442580418, - "delta": 0.033614798224126566 + "ratio": 1.025109568372867, + "delta": 0.002586285542405309 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17263896958254063, + "value": 0.1134851140594787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5774,7 +11138,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14261479822412657, + "value": 0.1055862855424053, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5790,11 +11154,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2cebdc00578e54b45a22", + "claim_id": "6bd14bde63071d64404b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_dc", - "name": "District of Columbia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mn", + "name": "Minnesota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5805,24 +11169,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.187, + "external_value": 0.063, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.187, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.063, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "value": 0.08431433826871325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5833,12 +11197,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.43688408529283, - "delta": 0.0816973239497592 + "ratio": 1.338322829662115, + "delta": 0.021314338268713248 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14467308939448856, + "value": 0.07686412373532482, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5851,7 +11215,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.2686973239497592, + "value": 0.08431433826871325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5867,11 +11231,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5be90ddb7e953a22fe29", + "claim_id": "780a950917b74d17f667", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_de", - "name": "Delaware SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mo", + "name": "Missouri SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5882,24 +11246,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "value": 0.14744900886546072, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5910,12 +11274,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.896440171364231, - "delta": 0.09233333765051578 + "ratio": 1.3652686006061179, + "delta": 0.039449008865460725 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.22695217212887303, + "value": 0.17194807589432126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -5928,7 +11292,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.19533333765051578, + "value": 0.14744900886546072, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5941,18 +11305,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e4a68546c4be960ea5d1", + "claim_id": "a27d4ff28bdfca616cb8", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_fl", - "name": "Florida SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ms", + "name": "Mississippi SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -5963,24 +11323,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.176, + "external_value": 0.171, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.176, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.171, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "value": 0.12213435064693424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -5991,12 +11351,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5673740035802572, - "delta": 0.09985782463012527 + "ratio": 0.7142359686955219, + "delta": -0.04886564935306577 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.310077108061372, + "value": 0.12754007054566846, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6009,7 +11369,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.27585782463012526, + "value": 0.12213435064693424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6022,18 +11382,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae7020f71018aa71e13b", + "claim_id": "0e68641d4fe06928f3ed", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ga", - "name": "Georgia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mt", + "name": "Montana SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6044,24 +11400,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.137, + "external_value": 0.081, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.137, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "value": 0.025309432293635373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6072,12 +11428,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2492671989835735, - "delta": 0.03414960626074959 + "ratio": 0.3124621270819182, + "delta": -0.05569056770636463 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15099892503706577, + "value": 0.10992399534280023, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6090,7 +11446,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1711496062607496, + "value": 0.025309432293635373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6103,14 +11459,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C4, confidence high] Montana child SPM 0.31x: three cloned source families on about 52 effective households; one is a Census negative-resources artifact", + "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/C.md" + } }, { - "claim_id": "d80f38afc52ad764420b", + "claim_id": "8e871b8216783c3198e1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_hi", - "name": "Hawaii SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nc", + "name": "North Carolina SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6121,24 +11481,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.122, + "external_value": 0.152, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.122, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.152, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "value": 0.1542939471948945, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6149,12 +11509,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7296468117411257, - "delta": -0.032983088967582674 + "ratio": 1.015091757861148, + "delta": 0.002293947194894508 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10759347113653098, + "value": 0.14332420570803683, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6167,7 +11527,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08901691103241732, + "value": 0.1542939471948945, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6183,11 +11543,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "664f55921193cc68fe99", + "claim_id": "6d24cdfdc704c93ea20e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ia", - "name": "Iowa SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nd", + "name": "North Dakota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6198,24 +11558,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.07, + "external_value": 0.092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "value": 0.1065848033863872, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6226,12 +11586,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1334667332852384, - "delta": 0.00934267132996669 + "ratio": 1.1585304715911653, + "delta": 0.014584803386387207 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12356060759864736, + "value": 0.07863050110524529, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6244,7 +11604,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.0793426713299667, + "value": 0.1065848033863872, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6260,11 +11620,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9b9854e0a7826d3f6971", + "claim_id": "0679c495803fff9001ca", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_id", - "name": "Idaho SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ne", + "name": "Nebraska SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6275,24 +11635,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.058, + "external_value": 0.064, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "value": 0.10709346478114838, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6303,12 +11663,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.425414499426542, - "delta": 0.02467404096673944 + "ratio": 1.6733353872054435, + "delta": 0.04309346478114838 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.04319380943090882, + "value": 0.0905297831973547, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6321,7 +11681,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08267404096673944, + "value": 0.10709346478114838, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6334,14 +11694,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "60ca60bce71f685cf470", + "claim_id": "c89efbc4ffd24fb15cf3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_il", - "name": "Illinois SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nh", + "name": "New Hampshire SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6352,24 +11716,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.109, + "external_value": 0.07, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.109, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "value": 0.10516177420827955, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6380,12 +11744,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2889150866478662, - "delta": 0.03149174444461743 + "ratio": 1.502311060118279, + "delta": 0.03516177420827954 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.22407192001757978, + "value": 0.09182132684377468, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6398,7 +11762,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14049174444461743, + "value": 0.10516177420827955, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6411,14 +11775,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "ff7246abfe3677335ca6", + "claim_id": "f4182a5794922259b4ce", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_in", - "name": "Indiana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nj", + "name": "New Jersey SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6429,24 +11797,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "external_value": 0.141, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.141, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "value": 0.1092498608281033, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6457,12 +11825,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3334642401122452, - "delta": 0.03034524585021431 + "ratio": 0.7748217080007327, + "delta": -0.03175013917189669 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1401888779452793, + "value": 0.1667374861478505, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6475,7 +11843,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1213452458502143, + "value": 0.1092498608281033, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6491,11 +11859,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5b236b30fa3880759154", + "claim_id": "bf9816ce2ba4a0b01453", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ks", - "name": "Kansas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nm", + "name": "New Mexico SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6506,24 +11874,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.097, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.097, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07687780380679853, + "value": 0.10150136127945612, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6534,12 +11902,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7925546784206033, - "delta": -0.020122196193201478 + "ratio": 0.9854501095092828, + "delta": -0.0014986387205438712 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11049707808530514, + "value": 0.11106588908140123, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6552,7 +11920,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07687780380679853, + "value": 0.10150136127945612, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6568,11 +11936,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3cc89a80759ebd0e943", + "claim_id": "8e712209885a93f74b4d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ky", - "name": "Kentucky SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nv", + "name": "Nevada SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6583,24 +11951,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.158, + "external_value": 0.15, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.15, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.161467256006912, + "value": 0.16176684459486274, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6611,12 +11979,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.021944658271595, - "delta": 0.0034672560069120006 + "ratio": 1.0784456306324184, + "delta": 0.011766844594862741 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16650483237144315, + "value": 0.17630447354072667, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6629,7 +11997,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.161467256006912, + "value": 0.16176684459486274, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6645,11 +12013,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "53520f720a63c7550d45", + "claim_id": "b8fffe31f672e908c7d8", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_la", - "name": "Louisiana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ny", + "name": "New York SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6660,24 +12028,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.189, + "external_value": 0.155, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.189, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.155, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.125609622841254, + "value": 0.1754383989923551, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6688,12 +12056,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6646011790542539, - "delta": -0.06339037715874601 + "ratio": 1.1318606386603556, + "delta": 0.02043839899235511 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14878938671226047, + "value": 0.2244729385528201, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6706,7 +12074,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.125609622841254, + "value": 0.1754383989923551, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6722,11 +12090,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bd4ea8335108373296f7", + "claim_id": "01289c122011da498528", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ma", - "name": "Massachusetts SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_oh", + "name": "Ohio SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6737,24 +12105,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.116, + "external_value": 0.1, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.19868201101176794, + "value": 0.09456633809921511, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6765,12 +12133,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.7127759569979994, - "delta": 0.08268201101176793 + "ratio": 0.9456633809921511, + "delta": -0.005433661900784897 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15018924622184068, + "value": 0.09512644926695311, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6783,7 +12151,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.19868201101176794, + "value": 0.09456633809921511, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6796,18 +12164,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fee6a482e8ac1fc33989", + "claim_id": "74caf7c832e428617b1a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_md", - "name": "Maryland SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ok", + "name": "Oklahoma SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6818,24 +12182,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.112, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11005888615244076, + "value": 0.13050742890949424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6846,12 +12210,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8875716625196836, - "delta": -0.013941113847559236 + "ratio": 1.1652449009776271, + "delta": 0.018507428909494236 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2138827361406449, + "value": 0.16030445522608297, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6864,7 +12228,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11005888615244076, + "value": 0.13050742890949424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6880,11 +12244,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8896cdbb8213f271fcc1", + "claim_id": "40e68ccaadfc3269a541", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_me", - "name": "Maine SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_or", + "name": "Oregon SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6895,24 +12259,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.05, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.05, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12448915934503967, + "value": 0.13530844855648988, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6923,12 +12287,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.489783186900793, - "delta": 0.07448915934503966 + "ratio": 1.230076805058999, + "delta": 0.02530844855648988 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09936430562401276, + "value": 0.145986362805576, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -6941,7 +12305,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12448915934503967, + "value": 0.13530844855648988, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -6954,18 +12318,14 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ee8a446834a4da49903b", + "claim_id": "f277efd6b574264216a2", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mi", - "name": "Michigan SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_pa", + "name": "Pennsylvania SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -6976,24 +12336,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1055862855424053, + "value": 0.13397061023553317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7004,12 +12364,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.025109568372867, - "delta": 0.002586285542405309 + "ratio": 1.217914638504847, + "delta": 0.023970610235533166 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1134851140594787, + "value": 0.11846176220706672, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7022,7 +12382,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1055862855424053, + "value": 0.13397061023553317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7038,11 +12398,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6bd14bde63071d64404b", + "claim_id": "64058ab1b6764c42b03b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mn", - "name": "Minnesota SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ri", + "name": "Rhode Island SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7053,24 +12413,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.063, + "external_value": 0.081, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.063, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08431433826871325, + "value": 0.16783042580923363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7081,12 +12441,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.338322829662115, - "delta": 0.021314338268713248 + "ratio": 2.0719805655460943, + "delta": 0.08683042580923363 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07686412373532482, + "value": 0.0965160396310427, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7099,7 +12459,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08431433826871325, + "value": 0.16783042580923363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7112,14 +12472,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "780a950917b74d17f667", + "claim_id": "f9d02a7845633c2b4268", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mo", - "name": "Missouri SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sc", + "name": "South Carolina SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7130,24 +12494,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "external_value": 0.128, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.128, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14744900886546072, + "value": 0.07390512495999252, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7158,12 +12522,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3652686006061179, - "delta": 0.039449008865460725 + "ratio": 0.5773837887499416, + "delta": -0.054094875040007484 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17194807589432126, + "value": 0.12793444859883502, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7176,7 +12540,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14744900886546072, + "value": 0.07390512495999252, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7192,11 +12556,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a27d4ff28bdfca616cb8", + "claim_id": "2ced6a36837da4879451", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ms", - "name": "Mississippi SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sd", + "name": "South Dakota SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7207,24 +12571,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.171, + "external_value": 0.074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.171, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.074, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12213435064693424, + "value": 0.10525300686014008, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7235,12 +12599,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7142359686955219, - "delta": -0.04886564935306577 + "ratio": 1.4223379305424335, + "delta": 0.031253006860140084 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12754007054566846, + "value": 0.1489361182482862, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7253,7 +12617,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12213435064693424, + "value": 0.10525300686014008, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7269,11 +12633,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0e68641d4fe06928f3ed", + "claim_id": "fba997fbb6cfd6c39c4e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_mt", - "name": "Montana SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tn", + "name": "Tennessee SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7284,24 +12648,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.081, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.025309432293635373, + "value": 0.2111625943240533, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7312,12 +12676,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.3124621270819182, - "delta": -0.05569056770636463 + "ratio": 2.575153589317723, + "delta": 0.1291625943240533 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10992399534280023, + "value": 0.1914803710178463, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7330,7 +12694,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.025309432293635373, + "value": 0.2111625943240533, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7345,16 +12709,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C4, confidence high] Montana child SPM 0.31x: three cloned source families on about 52 effective households; one is a Census negative-resources artifact", - "action_link": "diagnosis/batch2/C.md" + "rationale": "[batch2 C2, confidence high] SPM resources leave out partnership/S-corp income (and farm rent, non-Schedule-D gains) but subtract the federal and SE tax on it", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/issues/9919" } }, { - "claim_id": "8e871b8216783c3198e1", + "claim_id": "114bc2d1f77f3b6e9d05", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nc", - "name": "North Carolina SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tx", + "name": "Texas SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7365,24 +12729,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.152, + "external_value": 0.158, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.152, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1542939471948945, + "value": 0.1713150228787157, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7393,12 +12757,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.015091757861148, - "delta": 0.002293947194894508 + "ratio": 1.0842722967007323, + "delta": 0.013315022878715693 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14332420570803683, + "value": 0.17787968123647388, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7411,7 +12775,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1542939471948945, + "value": 0.1713150228787157, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7427,40 +12791,39 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6d24cdfdc704c93ea20e", + "claim_id": "02ce16f73ff66b8dd767", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nd", - "name": "North Dakota SPM child poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_us", + "name": "United States SPM child poverty rate", + "window": "2024", + "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Table B-2 (under 18)", + "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ND", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ND", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "geography": "US", + "subgroup": "children_under_18" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.092, + "external_value": 0.134, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.134, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1065848033863872, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.15807536413031142, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -7469,14 +12832,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1585304715911653, - "delta": 0.014584803386387207 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.1796668964948613, + "delta": 0.024075364130311416 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07863050110524529, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.1721300089308572, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -7485,11 +12848,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" }, { - "value": 0.1065848033863872, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.15807536413031142, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -7498,17 +12861,17 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0679c495803fff9001ca", + "claim_id": "01b883e821e73bbef43d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ne", - "name": "Nebraska SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ut", + "name": "Utah SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7519,24 +12882,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.064, + "external_value": 0.059, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.059, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10709346478114838, + "value": 0.1321103502473556, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7547,12 +12910,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.6733353872054435, - "delta": 0.04309346478114838 + "ratio": 2.239158478768739, + "delta": 0.0731103502473556 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0905297831973547, + "value": 0.147121617175416, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7565,7 +12928,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10709346478114838, + "value": 0.1321103502473556, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7580,16 +12943,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" } }, { - "claim_id": "c89efbc4ffd24fb15cf3", + "claim_id": "51fa48d774c937b2e09f", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nh", - "name": "New Hampshire SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_va", + "name": "Virginia SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7600,24 +12963,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.07, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.07, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10516177420827955, + "value": 0.17844752297198335, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7628,12 +12991,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.502311060118279, - "delta": 0.03516177420827954 + "ratio": 1.60763534208994, + "delta": 0.06744752297198335 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09182132684377468, + "value": 0.20106968715278814, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7646,7 +13009,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10516177420827955, + "value": 0.17844752297198335, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7661,16 +13024,16 @@ ], "diagnosis": { "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" } }, { - "claim_id": "f4182a5794922259b4ce", + "claim_id": "55715497136e3eb9c9dc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nj", - "name": "New Jersey SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_vt", + "name": "Vermont SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7681,24 +13044,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.141, + "external_value": 0.08, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.141, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.08, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1092498608281033, + "value": 0.16421433280975725, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7709,12 +13072,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7748217080007327, - "delta": -0.03175013917189669 + "ratio": 2.0526791601219654, + "delta": 0.08421433280975725 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1667374861478505, + "value": 0.1970955552654315, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7727,7 +13090,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1092498608281033, + "value": 0.16421433280975725, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7740,14 +13103,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "bf9816ce2ba4a0b01453", + "claim_id": "2a005f05a8f1ab16c446", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nm", - "name": "New Mexico SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wa", + "name": "Washington SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7758,24 +13125,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.096, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.096, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10150136127945612, + "value": 0.14726240776675822, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7786,12 +13153,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9854501095092828, - "delta": -0.0014986387205438712 + "ratio": 1.5339834142370647, + "delta": 0.05126240776675822 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11106588908140123, + "value": 0.13620803393537964, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7804,7 +13171,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10150136127945612, + "value": 0.14726240776675822, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7817,14 +13184,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" + } }, { - "claim_id": "8e712209885a93f74b4d", + "claim_id": "1b88ee46c23451091857", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_nv", - "name": "Nevada SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wi", + "name": "Wisconsin SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7835,24 +13206,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.15, + "external_value": 0.065, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.15, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.065, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16176684459486274, + "value": 0.06225078237719991, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7863,12 +13234,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0784456306324184, - "delta": 0.011766844594862741 + "ratio": 0.9577043442646139, + "delta": -0.0027492176228000945 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17630447354072667, + "value": 0.11459686342541692, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7881,7 +13252,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16176684459486274, + "value": 0.06225078237719991, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7897,11 +13268,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b8fffe31f672e908c7d8", + "claim_id": "84359f336a5104b0d41d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ny", - "name": "New York SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wv", + "name": "West Virginia SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7912,24 +13283,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.155, + "external_value": 0.11, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.155, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1754383989923551, + "value": 0.17931718903265126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7940,12 +13311,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1318606386603556, - "delta": 0.02043839899235511 + "ratio": 1.6301562639331932, + "delta": 0.06931718903265126 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.2244729385528201, + "value": 0.1650380028753829, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -7958,7 +13329,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1754383989923551, + "value": 0.17931718903265126, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -7971,14 +13342,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "01289c122011da498528", + "claim_id": "fe35a5d003686d2a4980", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_oh", - "name": "Ohio SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wy", + "name": "Wyoming SPM child poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", @@ -7989,24 +13364,24 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.1, + "external_value": 0.064, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09456633809921511, + "value": 0.08787718640614912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8017,12 +13392,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9456633809921511, - "delta": -0.005433661900784897 + "ratio": 1.37308103759608, + "delta": 0.023877186406149123 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09512644926695311, + "value": 0.053805953351169424, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8035,7 +13410,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09456633809921511, + "value": 0.08787718640614912, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8051,14 +13426,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "74caf7c832e428617b1a", + "claim_id": "8e07e6dc19cf58c62acc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ok", - "name": "Oklahoma SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ak", + "name": "Alaska SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8066,24 +13441,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OK", + "geography": "AK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OK", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AK", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.112, + "external_value": 0.104, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.104, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13050742890949424, + "value": 0.09283683014388971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8094,12 +13468,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1652449009776271, - "delta": 0.018507428909494236 + "ratio": 0.8926618283066319, + "delta": -0.01116316985611028 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16030445522608297, + "value": 0.0823918573274956, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8112,7 +13486,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13050742890949424, + "value": 0.09283683014388971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8128,14 +13502,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "40e68ccaadfc3269a541", + "claim_id": "0deaebef07428ab342b5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_or", - "name": "Oregon SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_al", + "name": "Alabama SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8143,24 +13517,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OR", + "geography": "AL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OR", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.135, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13530844855648988, + "value": 0.15479567849859827, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8171,12 +13544,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.230076805058999, - "delta": 0.02530844855648988 + "ratio": 1.1466346555451723, + "delta": 0.019795678498598257 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.145986362805576, + "value": 0.1562689494957049, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8189,7 +13562,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13530844855648988, + "value": 0.15479567849859827, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8205,14 +13578,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f277efd6b574264216a2", + "claim_id": "ddf374e51b7a975400d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_pa", - "name": "Pennsylvania SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ar", + "name": "Arkansas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8220,24 +13593,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "PA", + "geography": "AR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "PA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AR", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.136, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.136, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13397061023553317, + "value": 0.07909137514758192, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8248,12 +13620,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.217914638504847, - "delta": 0.023970610235533166 + "ratio": 0.5815542290263377, + "delta": -0.056908624852418085 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11846176220706672, + "value": 0.09604142003099919, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8266,7 +13638,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13397061023553317, + "value": 0.07909137514758192, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8282,14 +13654,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "64058ab1b6764c42b03b", + "claim_id": "e9b5204d8089fc549e88", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ri", - "name": "Rhode Island SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_az", + "name": "Arizona SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8297,24 +13669,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "RI", + "geography": "AZ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "RI", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "AZ", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.081, + "external_value": 0.129, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.081, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16783042580923363, + "value": 0.12943847317510282, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8325,12 +13696,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.0719805655460943, - "delta": 0.08683042580923363 + "ratio": 1.003399016861262, + "delta": 0.0004384731751028159 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0965160396310427, + "value": 0.13893523352842632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8343,7 +13714,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16783042580923363, + "value": 0.12943847317510282, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8356,21 +13727,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f9d02a7845633c2b4268", + "claim_id": "cac67258e5b9b5da88d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sc", - "name": "South Carolina SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ca", + "name": "California SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8378,24 +13745,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SC", + "geography": "CA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "SC", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.128, + "external_value": 0.177, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.128, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07390512495999252, + "value": 0.18454909051437005, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8406,12 +13772,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5773837887499416, - "delta": -0.054094875040007484 + "ratio": 1.0426502288947461, + "delta": 0.007549090514370055 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12793444859883502, + "value": 0.18943613023450145, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8424,7 +13790,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07390512495999252, + "value": 0.18454909051437005, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8440,14 +13806,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2ced6a36837da4879451", + "claim_id": "e733922d3029cd79b688", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_sd", - "name": "South Dakota SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_co", + "name": "Colorado SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8455,24 +13821,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SD", + "geography": "CO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "SD", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CO", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.074, + "external_value": 0.103, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.074, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10525300686014008, + "value": 0.09619897585695636, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8483,12 +13848,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4223379305424335, - "delta": 0.031253006860140084 + "ratio": 0.9339706393879259, + "delta": -0.006801024143043635 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1489361182482862, + "value": 0.09561262934066102, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8501,7 +13866,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10525300686014008, + "value": 0.09619897585695636, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8517,14 +13882,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fba997fbb6cfd6c39c4e", + "claim_id": "fd746252fbe7d70168a1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tn", - "name": "Tennessee SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ct", + "name": "Connecticut SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8532,24 +13897,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TN", + "geography": "CT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "TN", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "CT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.099, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.099, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.2111625943240533, + "value": 0.13259780956348854, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8560,12 +13924,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.575153589317723, - "delta": 0.1291625943240533 + "ratio": 1.3393718137726116, + "delta": 0.03359780956348854 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1914803710178463, + "value": 0.13782242530526317, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8578,7 +13942,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.2111625943240533, + "value": 0.13259780956348854, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8591,21 +13955,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C2, confidence high] SPM resources leave out partnership/S-corp income (and farm rent, non-Schedule-D gains) but subtract the federal and SE tax on it", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/issues/9919" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "114bc2d1f77f3b6e9d05", + "claim_id": "82100da147ca1f887653", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_tx", - "name": "Texas SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_dc", + "name": "District of Columbia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8613,24 +13973,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TX", + "geography": "DC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "TX", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "DC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.158, + "external_value": 0.153, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.158, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.153, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1713150228787157, + "value": 0.18107210121623096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8641,12 +14000,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0842722967007323, - "delta": 0.013315022878715693 + "ratio": 1.1834777857269998, + "delta": 0.028072101216230966 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17787968123647388, + "value": 0.1309506366660333, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8659,7 +14018,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1713150228787157, + "value": 0.18107210121623096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8675,39 +14034,39 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "02ce16f73ff66b8dd767", + "claim_id": "a1ea0acf638b713a5fa9", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_us", - "name": "United States SPM child poverty rate", - "window": "2024", - "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Table B-2 (under 18)", - "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_de", + "name": "Delaware SPM poverty rate", + "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "US", + "period_start": 2022, + "period_end": 2024, + "geography": "DE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "US", - "subgroup": "children_under_18" + "geography": "DE", + "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.134, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.134, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15807536413031142, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -8716,14 +14075,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable", - "ratio": 1.1796668964948613, - "delta": 0.024075364130311416 + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.4840914306983672, + "delta": 0.04502050305494815 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1721300089308572, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.1538858096004495, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -8732,11 +14091,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15807536413031142, - "status": "comparable", + "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -8745,20 +14104,20 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "constructed" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01b883e821e73bbef43d", + "claim_id": "ef92c4a17d9616b84e8d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_ut", - "name": "Utah SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_fl", + "name": "Florida SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8766,24 +14125,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "UT", + "geography": "FL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "UT", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "FL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.059, + "external_value": 0.16, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.059, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1321103502473556, + "value": 0.1756647923849868, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8794,12 +14152,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.239158478768739, - "delta": 0.0731103502473556 + "ratio": 1.0979049524061675, + "delta": 0.015664792384986803 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.147121617175416, + "value": 0.1774548672364514, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8812,7 +14170,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1321103502473556, + "value": 0.1756647923849868, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8825,21 +14183,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "51fa48d774c937b2e09f", + "claim_id": "bcf36e2dd6a004196b3b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_va", - "name": "Virginia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ga", + "name": "Georgia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8847,24 +14201,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VA", + "geography": "GA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "VA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "GA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "external_value": 0.135, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17844752297198335, + "value": 0.13817961563629774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8875,12 +14228,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.60763534208994, - "delta": 0.06744752297198335 + "ratio": 1.0235527084170202, + "delta": 0.0031796156362977335 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.20106968715278814, + "value": 0.13963149480286996, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8893,7 +14246,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17844752297198335, + "value": 0.13817961563629774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8906,21 +14259,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "55715497136e3eb9c9dc", + "claim_id": "157409312654547dda54", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_vt", - "name": "Vermont SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_hi", + "name": "Hawaii SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -8928,24 +14277,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VT", + "geography": "HI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "VT", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "HI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.08, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.08, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.16421433280975725, + "value": 0.09958265744779635, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8956,12 +14304,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 2.0526791601219654, - "delta": 0.08421433280975725 + "ratio": 0.9220616430351514, + "delta": -0.008417342552203652 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1970955552654315, + "value": 0.113087027347068, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -8974,7 +14322,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.16421433280975725, + "value": 0.09958265744779635, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -8987,21 +14335,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2a005f05a8f1ab16c446", + "claim_id": "f528a45068185199fcfc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wa", - "name": "Washington SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ia", + "name": "Iowa SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9009,24 +14353,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WA", + "geography": "IA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WA", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.096, + "external_value": 0.077, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.096, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14726240776675822, + "value": 0.07406942298044937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9037,12 +14380,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5339834142370647, - "delta": 0.05126240776675822 + "ratio": 0.9619405581876542, + "delta": -0.0029305770195506287 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13620803393537964, + "value": 0.08709445083318687, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9055,7 +14398,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.14726240776675822, + "value": 0.07406942298044937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9068,21 +14411,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C1, confidence high (mechanism); medium (magnitude: first-order counterfactual)] Pooled 2022-2024 ASEC incomes stay in nominal own-year dollars but are tested against 2024 SPM thresholds (largest #646 component)", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/944" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1b88ee46c23451091857", + "claim_id": "1e9d15d956b2f0ffa91a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wi", - "name": "Wisconsin SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_id", + "name": "Idaho SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9090,24 +14429,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WI", + "geography": "ID", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WI", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "ID", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.065, + "external_value": 0.084, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.065, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.06225078237719991, + "value": 0.08136747862108071, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9118,12 +14456,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9577043442646139, - "delta": -0.0027492176228000945 + "ratio": 0.9686604597747702, + "delta": -0.0026325213789192975 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11459686342541692, + "value": 0.05779478684831971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9136,7 +14474,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.06225078237719991, + "value": 0.08136747862108071, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9152,14 +14490,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "84359f336a5104b0d41d", + "claim_id": "ae8c430221bad4ec14e2", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wv", - "name": "West Virginia SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_il", + "name": "Illinois SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9167,24 +14505,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WV", + "geography": "IL", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WV", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IL", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.11, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17931718903265126, + "value": 0.12450307799898666, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9195,12 +14532,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.6301562639331932, - "delta": 0.06931718903265126 + "ratio": 1.121649351342222, + "delta": 0.01350307799898666 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1650380028753829, + "value": 0.14616480259783873, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9213,7 +14550,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17931718903265126, + "value": 0.12450307799898666, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9226,21 +14563,17 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe35a5d003686d2a4980", + "claim_id": "5549a20032311c6bbd31", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_child_poverty_wy", - "name": "Wyoming SPM child poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_in", + "name": "Indiana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by Age, State, and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state_by_age.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", @@ -9248,24 +14581,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WY", + "geography": "IN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "WY", - "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "geography": "IN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.064, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.064, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08787718640614912, + "value": 0.10219037521645423, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9276,12 +14608,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.37308103759608, - "delta": 0.023877186406149123 + "ratio": 1.0988212388866045, + "delta": 0.00919037521645423 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.053805953351169424, + "value": 0.12466528560881461, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9294,7 +14626,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08787718640614912, + "value": 0.10219037521645423, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9310,11 +14642,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8e07e6dc19cf58c62acc", + "claim_id": "6a835a8f96aa55b18e21", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ak", - "name": "Alaska SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ks", + "name": "Kansas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9325,23 +14657,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AK", + "geography": "KS", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.104, + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.104, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09283683014388971, + "value": 0.07626336362929916, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9352,12 +14684,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8926618283066319, - "delta": -0.01116316985611028 + "ratio": 0.8380589409813094, + "delta": -0.014736636370700842 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0823918573274956, + "value": 0.12229388506033745, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9370,7 +14702,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09283683014388971, + "value": 0.07626336362929916, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9386,11 +14718,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0deaebef07428ab342b5", + "claim_id": "b0fd283612be85825169", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_al", - "name": "Alabama SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ky", + "name": "Kentucky SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9401,23 +14733,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AL", + "geography": "KY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.135, + "external_value": 0.143, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.15479567849859827, + "value": 0.13543850005752436, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9428,12 +14760,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1466346555451723, - "delta": 0.019795678498598257 + "ratio": 0.9471223780246459, + "delta": -0.007561499942475625 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1562689494957049, + "value": 0.13756585366158877, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9446,7 +14778,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.15479567849859827, + "value": 0.13543850005752436, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9462,11 +14794,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ddf374e51b7a975400d5", + "claim_id": "b708e39de2619d2180ec", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ar", - "name": "Arkansas SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_la", + "name": "Louisiana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9477,23 +14809,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AR", + "geography": "LA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.136, + "external_value": 0.177, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.136, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07909137514758192, + "value": 0.1424661105482937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9504,12 +14836,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.5815542290263377, - "delta": -0.056908624852418085 + "ratio": 0.8048932799338627, + "delta": -0.034533889451706296 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09604142003099919, + "value": 0.16335271957443767, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9522,7 +14854,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07909137514758192, + "value": 0.1424661105482937, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9538,11 +14870,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e9b5204d8089fc549e88", + "claim_id": "7284f6fa3a580681d475", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_az", - "name": "Arizona SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ma", + "name": "Massachusetts SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9553,23 +14885,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "AZ", + "geography": "MA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.129, + "external_value": 0.117, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12943847317510282, + "value": 0.17256810101992193, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9580,12 +14912,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.003399016861262, - "delta": 0.0004384731751028159 + "ratio": 1.474941034358307, + "delta": 0.05556810101992192 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13893523352842632, + "value": 0.1771097334992783, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9598,7 +14930,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12943847317510282, + "value": 0.17256810101992193, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9614,11 +14946,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cac67258e5b9b5da88d5", + "claim_id": "f65cc2ffc9f6d7d2987b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ca", - "name": "California SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_md", + "name": "Maryland SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9629,23 +14961,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CA", + "geography": "MD", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.177, + "external_value": 0.112, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18454909051437005, + "value": 0.11189291694829119, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9656,12 +14988,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0426502288947461, - "delta": 0.007549090514370055 + "ratio": 0.9990439013240284, + "delta": -0.00010708305170881172 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.18943613023450145, + "value": 0.15459341451928926, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9674,7 +15006,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18454909051437005, + "value": 0.11189291694829119, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9690,11 +15022,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e733922d3029cd79b688", + "claim_id": "5e48c3b704ff32c51d7e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_co", - "name": "Colorado SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_me", + "name": "Maine SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9705,23 +15037,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CO", + "geography": "ME", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.103, + "external_value": 0.067, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.067, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09619897585695636, + "value": 0.07488516809554867, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9732,12 +15064,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9339706393879259, - "delta": -0.006801024143043635 + "ratio": 1.1176890760529652, + "delta": 0.007885168095548664 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09561262934066102, + "value": 0.098578801887256, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9750,7 +15082,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09619897585695636, + "value": 0.07488516809554867, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9766,11 +15098,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd746252fbe7d70168a1", + "claim_id": "a6c9d71019fbeb5e5bf6", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ct", - "name": "Connecticut SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mi", + "name": "Michigan SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9781,23 +15113,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "CT", + "geography": "MI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.099, + "external_value": 0.105, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.099, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13259780956348854, + "value": 0.07102190397012025, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9808,12 +15140,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3393718137726116, - "delta": 0.03359780956348854 + "ratio": 0.6763990854297166, + "delta": -0.03397809602987975 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13782242530526317, + "value": 0.08160677232362885, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9826,7 +15158,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13259780956348854, + "value": 0.07102190397012025, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9842,11 +15174,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "82100da147ca1f887653", + "claim_id": "60cef97ef8b7236451da", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_dc", - "name": "District of Columbia SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mn", + "name": "Minnesota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9857,23 +15189,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DC", + "geography": "MN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.153, + "external_value": 0.075, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.153, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.075, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18107210121623096, + "value": 0.06758949424479642, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9884,12 +15216,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1834777857269998, - "delta": 0.028072101216230966 + "ratio": 0.9011932565972857, + "delta": -0.007410505755203578 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1309506366660333, + "value": 0.06557923538426394, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9902,7 +15234,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18107210121623096, + "value": 0.06758949424479642, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9918,11 +15250,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1ea0acf638b713a5fa9", + "claim_id": "95ed0e94365e1c86a831", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_de", - "name": "Delaware SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mo", + "name": "Missouri SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -9933,23 +15265,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "DE", + "geography": "MO", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.1, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "value": 0.1255287300563078, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9960,12 +15292,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4840914306983672, - "delta": 0.04502050305494815 + "ratio": 1.2552873005630778, + "delta": 0.02552873005630779 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1538858096004495, + "value": 0.129895368151217, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -9978,7 +15310,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13802050305494815, + "value": 0.1255287300563078, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -9994,11 +15326,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ef92c4a17d9616b84e8d", + "claim_id": "e2c82a2849885aafeec3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_fl", - "name": "Florida SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ms", + "name": "Mississippi SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10009,23 +15341,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "FL", + "geography": "MS", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.16, + "external_value": 0.164, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.164, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1756647923849868, + "value": 0.09980684214469134, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10036,12 +15368,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0979049524061675, - "delta": 0.015664792384986803 + "ratio": 0.608578305760313, + "delta": -0.06419315785530867 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1774548672364514, + "value": 0.11002544521520172, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10054,7 +15386,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1756647923849868, + "value": 0.09980684214469134, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10070,11 +15402,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bcf36e2dd6a004196b3b", + "claim_id": "554e254ce2ffaa3e3e14", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ga", - "name": "Georgia SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_mt", + "name": "Montana SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10085,23 +15417,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "GA", + "geography": "MT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.135, + "external_value": 0.094, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.135, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.094, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13817961563629774, + "value": 0.07042066607104304, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10112,12 +15444,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0235527084170202, - "delta": 0.0031796156362977335 + "ratio": 0.7491560220323727, + "delta": -0.02357933392895696 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13963149480286996, + "value": 0.11110720473304003, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10130,7 +15462,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13817961563629774, + "value": 0.07042066607104304, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10146,11 +15478,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "157409312654547dda54", + "claim_id": "254772c932dcbe1c9548", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_hi", - "name": "Hawaii SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nc", + "name": "North Carolina SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10161,23 +15493,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "HI", + "geography": "NC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "external_value": 0.14, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.14, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09958265744779635, + "value": 0.10393183976139309, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10188,12 +15520,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9220616430351514, - "delta": -0.008417342552203652 + "ratio": 0.7423702840099505, + "delta": -0.03606816023860693 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.113087027347068, + "value": 0.10043255572034507, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10206,7 +15538,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09958265744779635, + "value": 0.10393183976139309, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10222,11 +15554,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f528a45068185199fcfc", + "claim_id": "270978b4c4a8ac0af7ca", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ia", - "name": "Iowa SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nd", + "name": "North Dakota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10237,23 +15569,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IA", + "geography": "ND", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07406942298044937, + "value": 0.07051397148734871, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10264,12 +15596,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9619405581876542, - "delta": -0.0029305770195506287 + "ratio": 0.8599264815530331, + "delta": -0.011486028512651292 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08709445083318687, + "value": 0.0749131472362356, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10282,7 +15614,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07406942298044937, + "value": 0.07051397148734871, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10298,11 +15630,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1e9d15d956b2f0ffa91a", + "claim_id": "8ddffe87b963da46a42c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_id", - "name": "Idaho SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ne", + "name": "Nebraska SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10313,23 +15645,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ID", + "geography": "NE", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.084, + "external_value": 0.082, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08136747862108071, + "value": 0.07573485585048426, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10340,12 +15672,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9686604597747702, - "delta": -0.0026325213789192975 + "ratio": 0.923595803054686, + "delta": -0.006265144149515747 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.05779478684831971, + "value": 0.0719651806573559, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10358,7 +15690,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.08136747862108071, + "value": 0.07573485585048426, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10374,11 +15706,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae8c430221bad4ec14e2", + "claim_id": "7650c5613087799e6b17", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_il", - "name": "Illinois SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nh", + "name": "New Hampshire SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10389,23 +15721,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IL", + "geography": "NH", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "external_value": 0.086, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.086, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12450307799898666, + "value": 0.0776467912406654, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10416,12 +15748,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.121649351342222, - "delta": 0.01350307799898666 + "ratio": 0.9028696655891326, + "delta": -0.008353208759334596 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14616480259783873, + "value": 0.06366941779475188, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10434,7 +15766,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12450307799898666, + "value": 0.0776467912406654, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10450,11 +15782,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5549a20032311c6bbd31", + "claim_id": "54ddcd746f6547275e70", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_in", - "name": "Indiana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nj", + "name": "New Jersey SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10465,23 +15797,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "IN", + "geography": "NJ", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10219037521645423, + "value": 0.07840339275102101, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10492,12 +15824,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0988212388866045, - "delta": 0.00919037521645423 + "ratio": 0.6322854254114598, + "delta": -0.04559660724897899 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12466528560881461, + "value": 0.11146468083311312, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10510,7 +15842,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10219037521645423, + "value": 0.07840339275102101, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10526,11 +15858,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6a835a8f96aa55b18e21", + "claim_id": "23d1c79481fc7369131f", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ks", - "name": "Kansas SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nm", + "name": "New Mexico SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10541,23 +15873,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KS", + "geography": "NM", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07626336362929916, + "value": 0.12719975402406325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10568,12 +15900,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8380589409813094, - "delta": -0.014736636370700842 + "ratio": 1.025804467935994, + "delta": 0.0031997540240632505 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.12229388506033745, + "value": 0.14673047336840364, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10586,7 +15918,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07626336362929916, + "value": 0.12719975402406325, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10602,11 +15934,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b0fd283612be85825169", + "claim_id": "1d2f65ad30970d87ebaa", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ky", - "name": "Kentucky SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_nv", + "name": "Nevada SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10617,23 +15949,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "KY", + "geography": "NV", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.143, + "external_value": 0.147, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13543850005752436, + "value": 0.12673120311227293, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10644,12 +15976,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9471223780246459, - "delta": -0.007561499942475625 + "ratio": 0.8621170279746458, + "delta": -0.020268796887727064 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13756585366158877, + "value": 0.17376658579659643, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10662,7 +15994,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.13543850005752436, + "value": 0.12673120311227293, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10678,11 +16010,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b708e39de2619d2180ec", + "claim_id": "3b79d1eb7360f13381e3", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_la", - "name": "Louisiana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ny", + "name": "New York SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10693,23 +16025,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "LA", + "geography": "NY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.177, + "external_value": 0.144, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.177, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.144, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1424661105482937, + "value": 0.18031065520530676, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10720,12 +16052,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8048932799338627, - "delta": -0.034533889451706296 + "ratio": 1.2521573278146303, + "delta": 0.03631065520530677 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.16335271957443767, + "value": 0.1981954755448971, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10738,7 +16070,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1424661105482937, + "value": 0.18031065520530676, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10754,11 +16086,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7284f6fa3a580681d475", + "claim_id": "4647bef66a7f10631c14", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ma", - "name": "Massachusetts SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_oh", + "name": "Ohio SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10769,23 +16101,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MA", + "geography": "OH", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.117, + "external_value": 0.093, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.17256810101992193, + "value": 0.07230307252955719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10796,12 +16128,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.474941034358307, - "delta": 0.05556810101992192 + "ratio": 0.7774523927909375, + "delta": -0.020696927470442814 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1771097334992783, + "value": 0.07412244718629316, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10814,7 +16146,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.17256810101992193, + "value": 0.07230307252955719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10830,11 +16162,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f65cc2ffc9f6d7d2987b", + "claim_id": "ad44e2913742d294570c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_md", - "name": "Maryland SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ok", + "name": "Oklahoma SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10845,23 +16177,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MD", + "geography": "OK", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.112, + "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.112, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11189291694829119, + "value": 0.10065601435768795, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10872,12 +16204,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9990439013240284, - "delta": -0.00010708305170881172 + "ratio": 0.8677242617042065, + "delta": -0.015343985642312055 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.15459341451928926, + "value": 0.11616680269261215, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10890,7 +16222,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.11189291694829119, + "value": 0.10065601435768795, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10906,11 +16238,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5e48c3b704ff32c51d7e", + "claim_id": "5af425967764dab64322", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_me", - "name": "Maine SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_or", + "name": "Oregon SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10921,23 +16253,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ME", + "geography": "OR", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.067, + "external_value": 0.111, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.067, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07488516809554867, + "value": 0.1679968399475719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10948,12 +16280,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.1176890760529652, - "delta": 0.007885168095548664 + "ratio": 1.5134850445727197, + "delta": 0.05699683994757189 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.098578801887256, + "value": 0.1833160121976655, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -10966,7 +16298,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07488516809554867, + "value": 0.1679968399475719, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -10979,14 +16311,18 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" } ], - "diagnosis": null + "diagnosis": { + "class": "pe_gap", + "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" + } }, { - "claim_id": "a6c9d71019fbeb5e5bf6", + "claim_id": "ce996b3e88742c0f0c37", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mi", - "name": "Michigan SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_pa", + "name": "Pennsylvania SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -10997,23 +16333,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MI", + "geography": "PA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.105, + "external_value": 0.106, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07102190397012025, + "value": 0.11632442953115062, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11024,12 +16360,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6763990854297166, - "delta": -0.03397809602987975 + "ratio": 1.0974002785957606, + "delta": 0.01032442953115062 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08160677232362885, + "value": 0.11567101402347092, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11042,7 +16378,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07102190397012025, + "value": 0.11632442953115062, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11058,11 +16394,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "60cef97ef8b7236451da", + "claim_id": "0b2a6ef72f5008337b42", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mn", - "name": "Minnesota SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ri", + "name": "Rhode Island SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11073,23 +16409,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MN", + "geography": "RI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.075, + "external_value": 0.091, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.075, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.06758949424479642, + "value": 0.13513127058469632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11100,12 +16436,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9011932565972857, - "delta": -0.007410505755203578 + "ratio": 1.4849590174142453, + "delta": 0.04413127058469632 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.06557923538426394, + "value": 0.09751264219386363, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11118,7 +16454,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.06758949424479642, + "value": 0.13513127058469632, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11134,11 +16470,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "95ed0e94365e1c86a831", + "claim_id": "1809c60147fa37f67d49", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mo", - "name": "Missouri SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_sc", + "name": "South Carolina SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11149,23 +16485,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MO", + "geography": "SC", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.1, + "external_value": 0.117, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.1, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1255287300563078, + "value": 0.08039879884811342, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11176,12 +16512,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2552873005630778, - "delta": 0.02552873005630779 + "ratio": 0.6871692209240463, + "delta": -0.036601201151886587 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.129895368151217, + "value": 0.10111475234510116, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11194,7 +16530,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.1255287300563078, + "value": 0.08039879884811342, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11210,11 +16546,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e2c82a2849885aafeec3", + "claim_id": "5d1e107bc05e215503b9", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ms", - "name": "Mississippi SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_sd", + "name": "South Dakota SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11225,23 +16561,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MS", + "geography": "SD", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.164, + "external_value": 0.079, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.164, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.079, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.09980684214469134, + "value": 0.083628263079774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11252,12 +16588,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.608578305760313, - "delta": -0.06419315785530867 + "ratio": 1.0585856086047343, + "delta": 0.004628263079774 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11002544521520172, + "value": 0.11227816321995195, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11270,7 +16606,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.09980684214469134, + "value": 0.083628263079774, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11286,11 +16622,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "554e254ce2ffaa3e3e14", + "claim_id": "a96a1236c09fa2d4625b", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_mt", - "name": "Montana SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_tn", + "name": "Tennessee SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11301,23 +16637,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "MT", + "geography": "TN", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.094, + "external_value": 0.101, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.094, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.101, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07042066607104304, + "value": 0.14763097402826147, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11328,12 +16664,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7491560220323727, - "delta": -0.02357933392895696 + "ratio": 1.4616928121610047, + "delta": 0.04663097402826147 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11110720473304003, + "value": 0.13963384587324096, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11346,7 +16682,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07042066607104304, + "value": 0.14763097402826147, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11362,11 +16698,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "254772c932dcbe1c9548", + "claim_id": "7a67b187161e75679905", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nc", - "name": "North Carolina SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_tx", + "name": "Texas SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11377,23 +16713,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NC", + "geography": "TX", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.14, + "external_value": 0.143, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.14, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10393183976139309, + "value": 0.142214311254233, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11404,12 +16740,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7423702840099505, - "delta": -0.03606816023860693 + "ratio": 0.9945056731065246, + "delta": -0.0007856887457669826 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10043255572034507, + "value": 0.14698917939988793, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11422,7 +16758,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.10393183976139309, + "value": 0.142214311254233, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11438,39 +16774,38 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "270978b4c4a8ac0af7ca", + "claim_id": "2fb69d82a3df911ce693", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nd", - "name": "North Dakota SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_us", + "name": "United States SPM poverty rate", + "window": "2024", + "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Figure 6 / Table B-1", + "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "ND", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "ND", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "geography": "US" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.129, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07051397148734871, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.13058122597208743, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -11479,14 +16814,14 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8599264815530331, - "delta": -0.011486028512651292 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0122575656750963, + "delta": 0.00158122597208743 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0749131472362356, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.1389642332405406, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", "release": "buildo", @@ -11495,11 +16830,11 @@ "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" }, { - "value": 0.07051397148734871, - "status": "constructed", + "value": 0.13058122597208743, + "status": "comparable", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", "release": "spm-20260915", @@ -11508,17 +16843,17 @@ "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8ddffe87b963da46a42c", + "claim_id": "f84919c3454b2fbbde8d", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ne", - "name": "Nebraska SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_ut", + "name": "Utah SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11529,23 +16864,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NE", + "geography": "UT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.082, + "external_value": 0.084, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.082, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07573485585048426, + "value": 0.11882197918537923, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11556,12 +16891,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.923595803054686, - "delta": -0.006265144149515747 + "ratio": 1.4145473712545147, + "delta": 0.03482197918537923 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.0719651806573559, + "value": 0.11892643276403998, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11574,7 +16909,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07573485585048426, + "value": 0.11882197918537923, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11590,11 +16925,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7650c5613087799e6b17", + "claim_id": "c9774fefb7a67dd60d48", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nh", - "name": "New Hampshire SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_va", + "name": "Virginia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11605,23 +16940,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NH", + "geography": "VA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.086, + "external_value": 0.105, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.086, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0776467912406654, + "value": 0.11311486516491787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11632,12 +16967,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9028696655891326, - "delta": -0.008353208759334596 + "ratio": 1.077284430142075, + "delta": 0.00811486516491787 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.06366941779475188, + "value": 0.11440374411905024, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11650,7 +16985,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.0776467912406654, + "value": 0.11311486516491787, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11666,11 +17001,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "54ddcd746f6547275e70", + "claim_id": "228154f0104e67513ac7", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nj", - "name": "New Jersey SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_vt", + "name": "Vermont SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11681,23 +17016,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NJ", + "geography": "VT", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.095, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07840339275102101, + "value": 0.13079380107354177, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11708,12 +17043,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6322854254114598, - "delta": -0.04559660724897899 + "ratio": 1.3767768534057028, + "delta": 0.03579380107354177 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11146468083311312, + "value": 0.14867288881663104, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11726,7 +17061,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07840339275102101, + "value": 0.13079380107354177, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11742,11 +17077,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23d1c79481fc7369131f", + "claim_id": "450ad519bc170f6be9a5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nm", - "name": "New Mexico SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wa", + "name": "Washington SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11757,23 +17092,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NM", + "geography": "WA", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.124, + "external_value": 0.108, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12719975402406325, + "value": 0.1059674974573952, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11784,12 +17119,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.025804467935994, - "delta": 0.0031997540240632505 + "ratio": 0.9811805320129185, + "delta": -0.0020325025426048 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14673047336840364, + "value": 0.10977333645706265, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11802,7 +17137,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12719975402406325, + "value": 0.1059674974573952, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11818,11 +17153,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1d2f65ad30970d87ebaa", + "claim_id": "076afee6b488ce9204cb", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_nv", - "name": "Nevada SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wi", + "name": "Wisconsin SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11833,23 +17168,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NV", + "geography": "WI", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.147, + "external_value": 0.077, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.147, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.12673120311227293, + "value": 0.1038407477762462, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11860,12 +17195,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8621170279746458, - "delta": -0.020268796887727064 + "ratio": 1.3485811399512495, + "delta": 0.026840747776246204 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.17376658579659643, + "value": 0.11340589602569066, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11878,7 +17213,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.12673120311227293, + "value": 0.1038407477762462, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11894,11 +17229,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3b79d1eb7360f13381e3", + "claim_id": "5363db12f455bbb7c3be", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ny", - "name": "New York SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wv", + "name": "West Virginia SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11909,23 +17244,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "NY", + "geography": "WV", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.144, + "external_value": 0.125, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.144, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.125, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.18031065520530676, + "value": 0.13161600566706727, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11936,12 +17271,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.2521573278146303, - "delta": 0.03631065520530677 + "ratio": 1.0529280453365382, + "delta": 0.006616005667067271 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1981954755448971, + "value": 0.13704122259072649, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -11954,7 +17289,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.18031065520530676, + "value": 0.13161600566706727, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -11970,11 +17305,11 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4647bef66a7f10631c14", + "claim_id": "3da8bf5938b8e36727d5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_oh", - "name": "Ohio SPM poverty rate", + "source_column": "spm_poverty_wy", + "name": "Wyoming SPM poverty rate", "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", @@ -11985,23 +17320,23 @@ "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": 2022, "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "program": null, "conditions": { - "geography": "OH", + "geography": "WY", "window_kind": "annual_average" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "baseline", "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.093, + "external_value": 0.083, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.093, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.083, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.07230307252955719, + "value": 0.0789481576077373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -12012,12 +17347,12 @@ "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.7774523927909375, - "delta": -0.020696927470442814 + "ratio": 0.9511826217799674, + "delta": -0.004051842392262708 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.07412244718629316, + "value": 0.08282431488411907, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "1.764.6", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", @@ -12030,7 +17365,7 @@ "status_effective": "constructed" }, { - "value": 0.07230307252955719, + "value": 0.0789481576077373, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.2.1", "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", @@ -12046,30 +17381,43 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ad44e2913742d294570c", + "claim_id": "09f4bf8dc18147cfb87a", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ok", - "name": "Oklahoma SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OK", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "OK", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "11.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", "external_value": 0.116, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", @@ -12077,1189 +17425,2027 @@ "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.10065601435768795, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.8677242617042065, - "delta": -0.015343985642312055 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9956896551724138, + "delta": -0.0005000000000000004 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11616680269261215, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c1075b632c2595610601", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "11.8" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.118, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.118, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.978813559322034, + "delta": -0.0024999999999999883 + }, + "results": [ { - "value": 0.10065601435768795, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1155, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3e7166fd417aec214417", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "14.9" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.149, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.149, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9838926174496645, + "delta": -0.0023999999999999855 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9574d34e1d5ec6bca59b", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "14.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.146, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.146, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.004109589041096, + "delta": 0.0006000000000000172 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1466, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5af425967764dab64322", + "claim_id": "adeb5b58537ff180d657", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_or", - "name": "Oregon SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "OR", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "OR", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "12.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.126, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.126, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.976984126984127, + "delta": -0.0029 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d24483ee5860b28e1ad4", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "12.4" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.124, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.992741935483871, + "delta": -0.000899999999999998 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7f8509f4b8e6b02abee9", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "5.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.056, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.056, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0125, + "delta": 0.0006999999999999992 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9882403f006bd3da0011", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "5.8" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.058, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.058, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9775862068965517, + "delta": -0.0013000000000000025 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.0567, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1d6ce33489bd28c5e81d", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "11.6" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.116, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.116, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9905172413793103, + "delta": -0.0011000000000000038 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d90ead50f4f3e6caa4cc", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "11.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.115, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.115, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9991304347826087, + "delta": -0.00010000000000000286 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.1149, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3890ba7a4b6d2c306608", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_renter", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "22.3" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.223, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.223, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9923766816143498, + "delta": -0.001700000000000007 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e39bf78545d67fef05d1", + "source": "census", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "22.7" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.111, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.227, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.111, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.227, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1679968399475719, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.5134850445727197, - "delta": 0.05699683994757189 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.9748898678414096, + "delta": -0.005700000000000011 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1833160121976655, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1679968399475719, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.2213, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_renter\", \"field\": \"by_tenure.renter.anchored\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], - "diagnosis": { - "class": "pe_gap", - "rationale": "[batch2 C3, confidence high (FL medium)] Thin state samples around a common national shift: the state gaps are within PE's own sampling error; no state-specific defect", - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/microcosm/issues/1116" - } + "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce996b3e88742c0f0c37", + "claim_id": "3f36993a9c0e97005ee5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_pa", - "name": "Pennsylvania SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "PA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "PA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "12.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.106, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": 0.126, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.106, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.126, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11632442953115062, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0974002785957606, - "delta": 0.01032442953115062 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.976984126984127, + "delta": -0.0029 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11567101402347092, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11632442953115062, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0b2a6ef72f5008337b42", + "claim_id": "884d6375896e06ea4113", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ri", - "name": "Rhode Island SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "RI", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "RI", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "12.4" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.091, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": 0.124, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.091, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.124, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13513127058469632, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4849590174142453, - "delta": 0.04413127058469632 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.992741935483871, + "delta": -0.000899999999999998 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.09751264219386363, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13513127058469632, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": 0.1231, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1809c60147fa37f67d49", + "claim_id": "089c156ec88b7cf82aeb", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_sc", - "name": "South Carolina SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SC", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "SC", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.117, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.006, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.117, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.006, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.08039879884811342, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.6871692209240463, - "delta": -0.036601201151886587 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0863333333333334, + "delta": -0.0005180000000000002 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10111475234510116, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.08039879884811342, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5d1e107bc05e215503b9", + "claim_id": "156266caa5b7ec8874a5", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_sd", - "name": "South Dakota SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "SD", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "SD", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.079, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.079, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.083628263079774, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0585856086047343, - "delta": 0.004628263079774 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3036, + "delta": -0.0015180000000000003 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11227816321995195, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.083628263079774, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006518, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"18 to 64.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a96a1236c09fa2d4625b", + "claim_id": "891add096fd35c5ddbfc", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_tn", - "name": "Tennessee SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TN", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "TN", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.101, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.101, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.14763097402826147, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4616928121610047, - "delta": 0.04663097402826147 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.46, + "delta": -0.0023 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13963384587324096, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.14763097402826147, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.18-64\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7a67b187161e75679905", + "claim_id": "b08760f65669373f7cf4", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_tx", - "name": "Texas SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "TX", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "TX", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.143, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.143, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.142214311254233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0072, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9945056731065246, - "delta": -0.0007856887457669826 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.44, + "delta": -0.0021999999999999997 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14698917939988793, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.142214311254233, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0072, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.65+\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2fb69d82a3df911ce693", + "claim_id": "b929c573c144b8c70e21", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_us", - "name": "United States SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2024", - "publication_title": "Poverty in the United States: 2024 (P60-287), Figure 6 / Table B-1", - "url": "https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2025/demo/p60-287.html", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "US", - "program": null, + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "US" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.3" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.129, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.003, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.129, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.003, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13058122597208743, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable", - "ratio": 1.0122575656750963, - "delta": 0.00158122597208743 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.4663333333333333, + "delta": -0.001399 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.1389642332405406, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" - }, - { - "value": 0.13058122597208743, - "status": "comparable", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "comparable" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f84919c3454b2fbbde8d", + "claim_id": "d971a213990492ddd29e", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_ut", - "name": "Utah SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "UT", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "UT", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.084, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.084, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11882197918537923, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.4145473712545147, - "delta": 0.03482197918537923 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.8798, + "delta": 0.000601 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11892643276403998, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11882197918537923, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.004399, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus\", \"field\": \"65 and over.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c9774fefb7a67dd60d48", + "claim_id": "0568716efd810cd99339", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_va", - "name": "Virginia SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "VA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-0.7" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.105, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.007, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.105, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.007, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.11311486516491787, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.077284430142075, - "delta": 0.00811486516491787 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9872857142857142, + "delta": 8.900000000000054e-05 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11440374411905024, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.11311486516491787, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "228154f0104e67513ac7", + "claim_id": "e7a397116a98e4abe2b1", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_vt", - "name": "Vermont SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "VT", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "VT", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.6" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.095, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.006, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.095, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.006, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13079380107354177, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.008, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3767768534057028, - "delta": 0.03579380107354177 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3333333333333333, + "delta": -0.002 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.14867288881663104, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13079380107354177, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.008, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.all\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "450ad519bc170f6be9a5", + "claim_id": "fb56a9c7242136ed9385", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wa", - "name": "Washington SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "All People: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WA", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WA", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.5" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.108, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.005, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.108, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.005, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1059674974573952, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9811805320129185, - "delta": -0.0020325025426048 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3821999999999999, + "delta": -0.0019109999999999995 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.10977333645706265, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1059674974573952, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.006911, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all\", \"field\": \"All people.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "076afee6b488ce9204cb", + "claim_id": "01e6132c625cb4794118", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wi", - "name": "Wisconsin SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WI", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WI", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.8" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.077, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.008, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.077, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.008, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.1038407477762462, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0108, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.3485811399512495, - "delta": 0.026840747776246204 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.35, + "delta": -0.0028000000000000004 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.11340589602569066, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.1038407477762462, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.0108, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py==13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv", + "release": " ASEC public", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"threshold_effect_pp.children\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5363db12f455bbb7c3be", + "claim_id": "09dce62e198fd6511a83", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wv", - "name": "West Virginia SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WV", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WV", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds.", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", + "value_verbatim": "-0.8" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.125, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e0fcdcf32d56dc09", + "external_value": -0.008, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.125, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.008, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.13161600566706727, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 1.0529280453365382, - "delta": 0.006616005667067271 + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.4925, + "delta": -0.003939999999999999 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.13704122259072649, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.13161600566706727, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", - "annotations": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu: Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly." + ], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" } ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3da8bf5938b8e36727d5", + "claim_id": "61b590e662acc0df805c", "source": "census", "country": "US", - "source_column": "spm_poverty_wy", - "name": "Wyoming SPM poverty rate", - "window": "2022-2024 3-year average", - "publication_title": "Number and Percentage of People in Poverty by State and Different Poverty Measures Using 3-Year Average Over: 2022, 2023, and 2024 (P60-287, Poverty in the United States: 2024)", - "url": "https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/demo/tables/p60/287/spm_opm_state.xlsx", - "metric": "poverty_rate", + "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", + "name": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", + "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value_kind": "share", - "period": 2024, + "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", - "period_start": 2022, - "period_end": 2024, - "geography": "WY", - "program": null, + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "US", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "conditions": { - "geography": "WY", - "window_kind": "annual_average" + "analysis": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "analysis_claim": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_under_18", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", + "country": "US", + "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", + "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", + "value_verbatim": "-1.1" }, "measure": null, - "reform_framework": "baseline", - "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", - "external_value": 0.083, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "076a58765a598feb", + "external_value": -0.011, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.083, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -0.011, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": 0.0789481576077373, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9511826217799674, - "delta": -0.004051842392262708 + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0854545454545454, + "delta": -0.0009399999999999999 }, "results": [ { - "value": 0.08282431488411907, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "1.764.6", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-buildo-sparse-rmloss100-22bd902-20260722T232627Z", - "release": "buildo", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-07-22T23:26:27", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" - }, - { - "value": 0.0789481576077373, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.2.1", - "data_bundle": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915", - "release": "spm-20260915", - "construction": "level:in_poverty", + "value": -0.01194, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "spm-threshold-paper==4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "data_bundle": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290", + "release": "m Census P60", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure\", \"commit\": \"4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18\", \"field\": \"Under 18.resources_step\", \"path\": \"analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper\", \"sha256\": \"f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", "annotations": [], "baseline": "current_law", - "status_effective": "constructed" + "status_effective": "comparable" } ], "diagnosis": null @@ -25515,6 +31701,320 @@ "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136" } }, + { + "claim_id": "c8248967fabf712d4161", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-170m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -170000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -170000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 11.358823529411765, + "delta": -1761000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "dbed02961788036df898", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-250m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -250000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -250000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 7.724, + "delta": -1681000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1931000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "941f70fdd8ebe26cb72e", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-300m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.553333333333334, + "delta": -1666000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a3fcb5268c1ed84cf21c", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-370m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -370000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -370000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.313513513513514, + "delta": -1596000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1966000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2027\", \"field\": \"by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "fe4ce312800fe0924aba", "source": "centax", @@ -25984,6 +32484,320 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "563c7dd58d2569382e48", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-270m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -270000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -270000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 7.325925925925926, + "delta": -1708000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9a0c495d359b66702ec0", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-190m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -190000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -190000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 10.410526315789474, + "delta": -1788000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1978000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "0def9addaf542a9f2a88", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-340m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -340000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -340000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.920588235294118, + "delta": -1673000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3dd2d43d32b935dd48bb", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2028-29", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-410m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -410000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -410000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.909756097560976, + "delta": -1603000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2013000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2028\", \"field\": \"by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "65b4e630a623a9d8b487", "source": "centax", @@ -26139,6 +32953,320 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "51798d6c66fe98544363", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-210m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -210000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -210000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 9.638095238095238, + "delta": -1814000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "592a6aeab7bc8b8455d7", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-300m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.746666666666667, + "delta": -1724000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2024000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_dynamic_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4fd2dfe2e32e1e4206d2", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-460m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "c89be2f132a1db42", + "external_value": -460000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -460000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 4.482608695652174, + "delta": -1602000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6f6785ffe294b5379d87", + "source": "centax", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (\u00a3)", + "name": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", + "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", + "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above \u00a3100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-\u00a3100,000 group alone.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "scenario": "central", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", + "value_verbatim": "-370m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fe959c9fa0c5beea", + "external_value": -370000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -370000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.572972972972973, + "delta": -1692000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2062000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.94.0", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "release": "057fe4e7fd1a", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/free-childcare-reform\", \"commit\": \"1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"free_hours_static_fy2029\", \"field\": \"by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform\", \"sha256\": \"c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours: CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above \u00a3100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the \u00a3100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "f4397e5778474de9cc1c", "source": "centax", @@ -27566,6 +34694,941 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "be973a7de4617b4c30c0", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Average Electricity Bill Saving, Total Impact", + "name": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household electricity bill saving", + "value_verbatim": "c. \u00a353 p.a." + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 53.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 53.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 2.452830188679245, + "delta": 77.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d724ceaf137b5618a46b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "0.526" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 526000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -526000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -217230570.25019464, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.41298587500037004, + "delta": -743230570.2501947 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -217230570.25019464, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f3d514bd23d92f7a152d", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.343" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1343000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1343000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -850021418.4095707, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.6329273405879157, + "delta": -2193021418.4095707 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -850021418.4095707, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6ef69606608c7d2fc4e3", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "2.504" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 2504000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2504000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1968205830.921824, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7860246928601533, + "delta": -4472205830.9218235 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1968205830.921824, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1596761586e5d9b405f4", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034/35, mean", + "name": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_post_mean_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "not stated whether before or after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -1.0706044182233354, + "delta": -6211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e1b4c51baa8070b28366", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "3.906" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3906000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3906000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8222768189119319, + "delta": -7117813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f042ca2b3c6eb68410b8", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "5.599" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 5599000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5599000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -4406755640.831539, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7870611967907732, + "delta": -10005755640.83154 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -4406755640.831539, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7511be14ee6e146c39db", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "7.508" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 7508000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7508000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -5885093637.713373, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7838430524391813, + "delta": -13393093637.713373 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -5885093637.713373, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3965d0c26b82f15bd5b6", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "9.638" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 9638000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -9638000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7484298447.570207, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7765406150207727, + "delta": -17122298447.570206 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7484298447.570207, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2c9c7a3ac96d7791454e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "12.109" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 12109000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -12109000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -9271202074.210602, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7656455590230904, + "delta": -21380202074.2106 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -9271202074.210602, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0a74016817fb666896b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039/40, pre-tax", + "name": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", + "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_post_pretax_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a314.3 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 14300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7788016541993757, + "delta": -25436863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a017e1d5ad381dc8e715", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "before income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "14.901" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 14901000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14901000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.7473903533354186, + "delta": -26037863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths: Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (\u00a3241.30 new, \u00a3184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about \u00a3146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's \u00a3115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's \u00a314.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (\u00a30.22bn against \u00a30.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "3e0f4ed92a011b5a1d9a", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", @@ -27870,6 +35933,84 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "2bbe4e01bdd681720216", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Fiscal Cost, Total Impact", + "name": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", + "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Fiscal Cost'", + "value_verbatim": "c. \u00a31.5 bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -2.5533333333333332, + "delta": -5330000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "9af08733f1c6826235aa", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", @@ -28174,6 +36315,726 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "83810920037655d9335b", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "0.422" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 422000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 422000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 156417504.22159922, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.37065759294217826, + "delta": -265582495.77840078 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 156417504.22159922, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2031\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2031.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "bc6769ee02523f4d7fc4", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.073" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1073000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1073000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 608885510.6364938, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.5674608673219886, + "delta": -464114489.3635062 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 608885510.6364938, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2032\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2032.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c8dd0b6df8f1c222cf5e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "1.995" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 1995000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1995000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 1414229874.178762, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7088871549768231, + "delta": -580770125.821238 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 1414229874.178762, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2033\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2033.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a9fe70dc1adc1b249ce3", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "3.103" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 3103000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3103000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 2296590901.1592994, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7401195298611987, + "delta": -806409098.8407006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 2296590901.1592994, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "417614fe3699cc829530", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "4.439" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4439000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4439000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 3156720894.1896734, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7111333395336051, + "delta": -1282279105.8103266 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 3156720894.1896734, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2035\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2035.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2743e29e8c7f7236cc80", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "5.939" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 5939000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5939000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 4195554287.92699, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7064412001897609, + "delta": -1743445712.07301 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 4195554287.92699, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2036\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2036.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b66d52ada7defa285d5e", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "7.609" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 7609000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 7609000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 5327184898.630032, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.7001162963109517, + "delta": -2281815101.3699684 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 5327184898.630032, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2037\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2037.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7a244e7bee38b319029f", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "9.545" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 9545000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 9545000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 6572734215.313287, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.6886049466017063, + "delta": -2972265784.686713 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 6572734215.313287, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2038\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2038.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "03eec284a2f55ed9ed87", + "source": "centre_for_british_progress", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", + "name": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", + "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "cbp_tool_net_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "after income tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", + "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", + "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", + "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", + "value_verbatim": "11.729" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 11729000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 11729000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7860994216.190747, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.6702186218936608, + "delta": -3868005783.8092527 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7860994216.190747, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_net_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only: CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 \u00a30.81bn of the \u00a33.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "03d666ddda6fe83bd6f4", "source": "co_admin", @@ -31404,6 +40265,195 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f5b447aa10146b39a7f0", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Percent change", + "name": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "value_verbatim": "41.6%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 41.6, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -41.6, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1743be8ca03a7581342e", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Percentage point change", + "name": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percentage points", + "value_verbatim": "7.5" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 7.5, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7.5, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2d05411229afb7cbbb3a", + "source": "cpsp", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "reduction in the child poverty rate from the 2021 Child Tax Credit", + "name": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", + "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "United States", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_us_2021", + "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "comparison": "the 2021 Child Tax Credit against no Child Tax Credit (9.2% to 5.2%)", + "country": "US", + "geography": "United States", + "pe_missing": "National, for 2021, and measured against no Child Tax Credit at all; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit, for California in 2026.", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", + "value_verbatim": "43%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f067fcf37f7118fb", + "external_value": 43.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -43.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "no_ctc", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "dbb34965f41514214b05", "source": "ct_admin", @@ -32307,6 +41357,158 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "2213a1a3e651029c4184", + "source": "desnz", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "households receiving a rebate", + "name": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", + "metric": "affected_count", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the cohort estimate for the 2026/27 to 2030/31 scheme; Table 6 costs 5.9m rebates in each year", + "population": "households receiving a rebate", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", + "value_verbatim": "around 5.9m" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 5900000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5900000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 7850000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_households_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].recipients_m\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-proxy-caseload: The dashboard's proxy pays the \u00a3100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates')." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.3305084745762712, + "delta": 1950000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 7850000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_households_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].recipients_m\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-proxy-caseload: The dashboard's proxy pays the \u00a3100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates')." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "cbf071793c4087a9ef7e", + "source": "desnz", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average saving per year", + "name": "Breathing space on your energy bill", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Breathing space on your energy bill", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "desnz_vat_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 electricity prices (the current cut, from 1 October 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 45.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 45.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 49.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 1.0888888888888888, + "delta": 4.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 49.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "2fe8f297b2b1288f5ba4", "source": "deutsche_bank", @@ -32472,6 +41674,411 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "9818df23089c94ac93fb", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "price_basis": "nominal", + "program": "state_pension", + "program_note": "State Pension", + "rounding": "nearest \u00a31bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 1: 'negative values denote savings')", + "value_verbatim": "-\u00a315 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": -15000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "survey-bill-below-dwp: Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's \u00a315bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, \u00a311.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is \u00a310.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by \u00a31.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (\u00a35.9bn in 2026-27, \u00a36.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is \u00a3243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the \u00a3286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives \u00a311.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to \u00a31bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "gap unexplained, tracked at https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.7424575770034049, + "delta": 3863136344.948927 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "survey-bill-below-dwp: Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's \u00a315bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, \u00a311.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is \u00a310.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by \u00a31.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (\u00a35.9bn in 2026-27, \u00a36.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is \u00a3243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the \u00a3286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives \u00a311.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to \u00a31bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "gap unexplained, tracked at https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f0ad9c361b863e3a413d", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_ame_real_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes nominal savings only; DWP's nominal figure (Table 1) is the one compared.", + "price_basis": "real terms, 2025-26 prices", + "prices": "real", + "program": "state_pension", + "program_note": "State Pension", + "rounding": "nearest \u00a31bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 2: 'negative values denote savings')", + "value_verbatim": "-\u00a311 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": -11000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -11000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-real-terms-table: DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.0124421504591885, + "delta": -136863655.05107307 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-real-terms-table: DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7bb1b7a8341e5e54a790", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034/35, adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate.", + "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", + "program": "state_pension", + "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", + "value_verbatim": "10.3%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 0.103, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.103, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.12154651641845704, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.1800632661986121, + "delta": 0.018546516418457046 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.12154651641845704, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe2e34e66137ebd0a2d1", + "source": "dwp", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039/40, adjusted Triple Lock", + "name": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate.", + "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", + "program": "state_pension", + "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", + "value_verbatim": "9.2%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 0.092, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.092, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 0.08826981544494629, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.959454515705938, + "delta": -0.003730184555053709 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 0.08826981544494629, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039\", \"field\": \"central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty: DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "06425bb0992e133916a3", + "source": "electricity_bills_taskforce", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "saving to the average household", + "name": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", + "url": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The Taskforce also removes the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "an additional \u00a3100 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 100.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 100.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.3, + "delta": 30.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "559dfd6172fe158c4c63", "source": "ey_item_club", @@ -45702,6 +55309,66 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "4ac90e60c343a03127ed", + "source": "garfinkel_et_al", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "net cost of the $3600-$3000 child allowance", + "name": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", + "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "United States", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "garfinkel_arpa_allowance_net_cost_us_2018", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "static (the paper estimates the earnings response separately)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "data": "2019 CPS ASEC (2018 incomes), 100% take-up assumed", + "dollars": "not stated for the cost; the paper's benefit estimates are in 2019 dollars", + "geography": "United States", + "pe_missing": "A national cost on 2019 survey data (2018 incomes), against the $2,000 credit; the dashboard publishes the cost for California households in 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the federal government (the allowance's net cost)", + "value_verbatim": "$96.8 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 96800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -96800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "f4800dcb6ab3eaeb7fe8", "source": "goldman_sachs", @@ -46033,6 +55700,480 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "65354f670cefc3f5f4b2", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (\u00a3/yr)", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", + "value_verbatim": "19.25" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 19.25, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 19.25, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.753246753246753, + "delta": 110.75 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c9db47e6d17f74b13cb1", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (\u00a3/yr)", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", + "value_verbatim": "20.45" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 20.45, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 20.45, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 6.356968215158925, + "delta": 109.55 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "afe3d5816e4e99d276fa", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost to the exchequer", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to Warm Home Discount recipients (about 6 million); the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1 million).", + "period_basis": "a one-off payment this winter", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "program_note": "targeted payment", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'at a cost of \u00a31.8bn to the exchequer'", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.8bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "44d7c70f1feb853f", + "external_value": 1800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2430000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-recipients-vs-means-tested-households: Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.35, + "delta": -4230000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2430000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-recipients-vs-means-tested-households: Good Energy pays \u00a3300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's \u00a3300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5fca7b060156b9d1d45d", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost (\u00a3bn), Dom Elec Direct", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "value_verbatim": "0.61" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 610000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -610000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -6.278688524590164, + "delta": -4440000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "74730b882638341c0e46", + "source": "good_energy", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost (\u00a3bn), Dom Elec Direct", + "name": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", + "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", + "value_verbatim": "0.57" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 570000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -570000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -6.719298245614035, + "delta": -4400000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c805c4eff8fbe6d6a882", + "source": "green_party", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "sum set aside", + "name": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", + "url": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The Green Party states no period for its \u00a38.4 billion and set it in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path.", + "period_basis": "no period stated; the guarantee would start with the July 2026 cap, in 2026-27", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "program_note": "energy price guarantee", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'setting aside'", + "value_verbatim": "approximately \u00a38.4 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "448ac62bfbb77ae6", + "external_value": 8400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -8400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.8595238095238096, + "delta": -15620000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "ffb1fa41bff7bcb53ad3", "source": "hi_admin", @@ -47870,7 +58011,65 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f7fd0bd182c6e8fa3537", + "claim_id": "f7fd0bd182c6e8fa3537", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", + "name": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6929b353345e31ab14ecf735/E03444720_Budget_2025_Web_Accessible.pdf", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "total (RO + ECO + VAT)", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", + "reform_hint": "Energy bills package: Exchequer funds 75% of the domestic cost of the legacy Renewables Obligation 2026-27 to 2028-29 and the Energy Company Obligation is not renewed from April 2026", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", + "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3134" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "5a24f4aaef397698", + "external_value": 134.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -134.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe66761da6d5dbf51223", "source": "hm_treasury", "country": "UK", "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", @@ -47888,25 +58087,38 @@ "geography": "Great Britain", "program": null, "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "total (RO + ECO + VAT)", + "component": "RO", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "geography": "Great Britain", + "measure_key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "The Renewables Obligation share of an electricity bill is not a parameter. The engine has electricity_consumption (LCFS-imputed, NEED-calibrated) and a flat energy_bills_credit lever (gov.treasury.energy_bills_rebate.energy_bills_credit), so the measure is a CONSTRUCTION: bill x domestic RO share (~41%, HMT) x 75%, or the ~GBP 150 average as a flat credit. Either is stated as constructed, never comparable.", "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", - "reform_hint": "Energy bills package: Exchequer funds 75% of the domestic cost of the legacy Renewables Obligation 2026-27 to 2028-29 and the Energy Company Obligation is not renewed from April 2026", + "reform_hint": "Renewables Obligation: Fund 75% of the domestic share of the Renewables Obligation via the Exchequer over the Spending Review period", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3134" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a367" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "electricity_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] }, - "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "5a24f4aaef397698", - "external_value": 134.0, + "reform_key": "9ca24eb4e469691a", + "external_value": 67.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -134.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -67.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -47928,56 +58140,44 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe66761da6d5dbf51223", + "claim_id": "74b11e3f52fd3aa4952c", "source": "hm_treasury", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap", - "name": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", + "source_column": "Saving on the yearly price cap", + "name": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Budget 2025 (HC 1492)", - "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6929b353345e31ab14ecf735/E03444720_Budget_2025_Web_Accessible.pdf", + "publication_title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "Great Britain", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "static", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_bill_saving_oct2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "RO", + "cap_period": "October to December 2026", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "geography": "Great Britain", - "measure_key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "The Renewables Obligation share of an electricity bill is not a parameter. The engine has electricity_consumption (LCFS-imputed, NEED-calibrated) and a flat energy_bills_credit lever (gov.treasury.energy_bills_rebate.energy_bills_credit), so the measure is a CONSTRUCTION: bill x domestic RO share (~41%, HMT) x 75%, or the ~GBP 150 average as a flat credit. Either is stated as constructed, never comparable.", - "period_detail": "Q1 2026 dual fuel cap announced on 21 November 2025", - "reform_hint": "Renewables Obligation: Fund 75% of the domestic share of the Renewables Obligation via the Exchequer over the Spending Review period", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (reduction in costs)", - "subgroup": "typical dual fuel household (Ofgem price cap typical domestic consumption values)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a367" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__renewables_obligation_exchequer_funded_75pct", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "electricity_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "pe_missing": "A saving on the October 2026 annualised cap; the analysis's counterpart is the mean support per household from its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.avg_benefit_per_hh: \u00a349, \u00a362, \u00a381, shown on the dashboard's policy tab), a different period and statistic.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the annual energy bill (printed as \u00a345 off the yearly price cap)", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a345" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "9ca24eb4e469691a", - "external_value": 67.0, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 45.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -67.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -45.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -69297,6 +79497,67 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "44f99aa9f0bceae4f311", + "source": "hm_treasury", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2026-27", + "name": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", + "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "pe_missing": "The Government's cost is for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis costs a full-year extension in 2027-28 (elec_vat_cut_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a31.55bn, \u00a31.95bn, \u00a32.56bn), a different year and length of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "scoring_method": "Government estimate at estimated electricity prices; 'Updated costs will be set out at Budget'", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3850 million" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 850000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -850000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "00887d5246feae037324", "source": "hm_treasury", @@ -125309,10 +135570,160 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "876791e3e4f7f30b24fc", + "claim_id": "876791e3e4f7f30b24fc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Poorest", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_1", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", + "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "1167.584" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", + "external_value": 1167.584, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1167.584, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "9989d327d3cfc06959e4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Richest", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_10", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", + "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "11d22b255c4a3c12cf8a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125338,18 +135749,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", - "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", - "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", + "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1167.584" + "value_verbatim": "3310.047" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -125358,11 +135769,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", - "external_value": 1167.584, + "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", + "external_value": 3310.047, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1167.584, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3310.047, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125384,10 +135795,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9989d327d3cfc06959e4", + "claim_id": "f789972776cbbc92a1e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt children under age 5 / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125413,18 +135824,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", - "option": "Exempt children under age 5", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An age-based exemption from the limit is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no age condition (the start_year born-after rule is the only conditional).", - "reform_hint": "Exempt children under age 5", + "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", + "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "2906.925" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_children_under_5_or_under_1", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -125433,11 +135844,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "183c700b6f75b789", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", + "external_value": 2906.925, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2906.925, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125459,10 +135870,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "11d22b255c4a3c12cf8a", + "claim_id": "2e118b11475abb95da64", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125488,7 +135899,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125496,7 +135907,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3310.047" + "value_verbatim": "2021.746" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125509,10 +135920,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 3310.047, + "external_value": 2021.746, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3310.047, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2021.746, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125534,10 +135945,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f789972776cbbc92a1e1", + "claim_id": "873e6e6ccda9c7be5768", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125563,7 +135974,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125571,7 +135982,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2906.925" + "value_verbatim": "673.0972" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125584,10 +135995,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 2906.925, + "external_value": 673.0972, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2906.925, + "external_value_pe_sign": 673.0972, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125609,10 +136020,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2e118b11475abb95da64", + "claim_id": "b4502a7d78e7cd153c57", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125638,7 +136049,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125646,7 +136057,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2021.746" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125659,10 +136070,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 2021.746, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2021.746, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125684,10 +136095,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "873e6e6ccda9c7be5768", + "claim_id": "928df844dd5891fe8c26", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125713,7 +136124,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125721,7 +136132,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "673.0972" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125734,10 +136145,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 673.0972, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 673.0972, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125759,10 +136170,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b4502a7d78e7cd153c57", + "claim_id": "d34ca758972ca6c5ce7c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125788,7 +136199,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125796,7 +136207,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125809,10 +136220,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125834,10 +136245,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "928df844dd5891fe8c26", + "claim_id": "a17671b3c67c05c8f8bd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125863,7 +136274,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125909,10 +136320,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d34ca758972ca6c5ce7c", + "claim_id": "aa36a6129b10da093198", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -125938,7 +136349,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -125946,7 +136357,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1865.64" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -125959,10 +136370,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1865.64, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1865.64, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -125984,10 +136395,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a17671b3c67c05c8f8bd", + "claim_id": "1546ba08331f579094f7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126013,7 +136424,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126021,7 +136432,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1608.468" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -126034,10 +136445,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1608.468, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1608.468, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126059,10 +136470,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aa36a6129b10da093198", + "claim_id": "7ea73eac8644ff0f5ac4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126088,7 +136499,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126096,7 +136507,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1865.64" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", @@ -126109,10 +136520,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 1865.64, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1865.64, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126134,10 +136545,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1546ba08331f579094f7", + "claim_id": "7edc1a905cc6e14b3c61", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126163,18 +136574,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", - "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", - "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", + "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1608.468" + "value_verbatim": "2148.367" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -126183,11 +136594,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 1608.468, + "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", + "external_value": 2148.367, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1608.468, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2148.367, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126209,10 +136620,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ea73eac8644ff0f5ac4", + "claim_id": "3ca5368164aadb96fc14", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Exempt familes with earnings from work / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126238,18 +136649,18 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", - "option": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "An exemption condition on the limit (work status, hours) is a formula construction; the limit parameter has no eligibility conditions.", - "reform_hint": "Exempt familes with earnings from work", + "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", + "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1596.851" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_exempt_working_families", + "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "partial", "head_variables": [ @@ -126258,11 +136669,11 @@ "parameter_paths": [] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "2c22630fb01d50d3", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", + "external_value": 1596.851, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1596.851, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126284,10 +136695,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7edc1a905cc6e14b3c61", + "claim_id": "188da279068c78628784", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126313,7 +136724,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126321,7 +136732,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2148.367" + "value_verbatim": "913.2991" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126334,10 +136745,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 2148.367, + "external_value": 913.2991, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2148.367, + "external_value_pe_sign": 913.2991, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126359,10 +136770,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3ca5368164aadb96fc14", + "claim_id": "719defb266ed7b2371a0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126388,7 +136799,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126396,7 +136807,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1596.851" + "value_verbatim": "382.1102" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126409,10 +136820,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1596.851, + "external_value": 382.1102, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1596.851, + "external_value_pe_sign": 382.1102, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126434,10 +136845,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "188da279068c78628784", + "claim_id": "eaa1a616d3f6e406a0ee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126463,7 +136874,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126471,7 +136882,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "913.2991" + "value_verbatim": "65.7583" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126484,10 +136895,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 913.2991, + "external_value": 65.7583, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 913.2991, + "external_value_pe_sign": 65.7583, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126509,10 +136920,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "719defb266ed7b2371a0", + "claim_id": "2b605bfbc86c67f9e5b2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126538,7 +136949,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126546,7 +136957,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "382.1102" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126559,10 +136970,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 382.1102, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 382.1102, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126584,10 +136995,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "eaa1a616d3f6e406a0ee", + "claim_id": "7f7aa7bb5cd4500dbad6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126613,7 +137024,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126621,7 +137032,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "65.7583" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126634,10 +137045,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 65.7583, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 65.7583, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126659,10 +137070,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2b605bfbc86c67f9e5b2", + "claim_id": "ecb9f84fe7d77448c249", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126688,7 +137099,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126734,10 +137145,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7f7aa7bb5cd4500dbad6", + "claim_id": "8b2f44248e876704af4b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126763,7 +137174,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126771,7 +137182,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1299.181" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126784,10 +137195,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1299.181, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1299.181, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126809,10 +137220,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ecb9f84fe7d77448c249", + "claim_id": "f0044a1922baf643525a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126838,7 +137249,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126846,7 +137257,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1838.762" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126859,10 +137270,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 1838.762, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1838.762, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126884,10 +137295,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8b2f44248e876704af4b", + "claim_id": "08e384253c6ef4f5c1e7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126913,7 +137324,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", "option": "Introduce 50% child element", "pe_expressibility": "partial", @@ -126921,7 +137332,7 @@ "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1299.181" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", @@ -126934,10 +137345,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1299.181, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1299.181, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -126959,10 +137370,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f0044a1922baf643525a", + "claim_id": "137585418b73550ae066", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -126977,7 +137388,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -126988,31 +137398,34 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", - "option": "Introduce 50% child element", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", - "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1838.762" + "value_verbatim": "4302.053" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "partial", + "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit" + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 1838.762, + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 4302.053, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1838.762, + "external_value_pe_sign": 4302.053, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127034,10 +137447,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "08e384253c6ef4f5c1e7", + "claim_id": "176915e4113a700e3f83", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Introduce 50% child element / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127052,7 +137465,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -127063,31 +137475,34 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", - "option": "Introduce 50% child element", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "child.limit.child_count is a count, not a rate schedule; a reduced element for children beyond the second needs a per-child-rank amount the element formula does not have.", - "reform_hint": "Introduce 50% child element", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "3316.293" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__two_child_limit_partial_child_element_for_third_plus_children", + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "partial", + "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit" + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "3b444d58d2c14d26", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 3316.293, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3316.293, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127109,10 +137524,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "137585418b73550ae066", + "claim_id": "fe098a528f54e583391e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127137,14 +137552,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "4302.053" + "value_verbatim": "2087.725" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127161,10 +137576,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 4302.053, + "external_value": 2087.725, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4302.053, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2087.725, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127186,10 +137601,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "176915e4113a700e3f83", + "claim_id": "534dc21f3c4d8c755ad7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127214,14 +137629,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3316.293" + "value_verbatim": "829.0254" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127238,10 +137653,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 3316.293, + "external_value": 829.0254, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3316.293, + "external_value_pe_sign": 829.0254, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127263,10 +137678,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe098a528f54e583391e", + "claim_id": "d1b11dd95153969d6f2f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127291,14 +137706,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2087.725" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127315,10 +137730,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 2087.725, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2087.725, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127340,10 +137755,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "534dc21f3c4d8c755ad7", + "claim_id": "4ef00847a53357a54394", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 7", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127368,14 +137783,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "829.0254" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127392,10 +137807,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 829.0254, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 829.0254, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127417,10 +137832,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d1b11dd95153969d6f2f", + "claim_id": "06cd474f45a6aa26a1bd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 8", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127445,14 +137860,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127469,10 +137884,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127494,10 +137909,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4ef00847a53357a54394", + "claim_id": "9794b6be574b6a9cce05", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127522,7 +137937,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -127571,10 +137986,87 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "06cd474f45a6aa26a1bd", + "claim_id": "ed451413070a348635bf", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / All", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "2613.37" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", + "external_value": 2613.37, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 2613.37, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "792f5e298aa4331cbb80", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 8", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127599,14 +138091,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "3511.657" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", @@ -127623,10 +138115,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 3511.657, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3511.657, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127648,10 +138140,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9794b6be574b6a9cce05", + "claim_id": "e42763231cd9502e4e1c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / 9", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127676,7 +138168,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", "option": "Scrap two-child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -127725,10 +138217,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ed451413070a348635bf", + "claim_id": "a963f3bd4bd29553781c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / All", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 2", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127753,17 +138245,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_2", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2613.37" + "value_verbatim": "3017.333" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127776,11 +138268,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 2613.37, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 3017.333, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2613.37, + "external_value_pe_sign": 3017.333, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127802,10 +138294,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "792f5e298aa4331cbb80", + "claim_id": "af2cb7d46caa9609d937", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Poorest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 3", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127830,17 +138322,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_3", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3511.657" + "value_verbatim": "2640.092" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127853,11 +138345,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 3511.657, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 2640.092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3511.657, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2640.092, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127879,10 +138371,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e42763231cd9502e4e1c", + "claim_id": "36928182aeb4e0cb485d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Scrap two-child limit / Richest", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 4", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127907,17 +138399,17 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", - "option": "Scrap two-child limit", + "income_group": "decile_4", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Scrap two-child limit", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "1651.358" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__scrap_two_child_limit", + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "program": "universal_credit", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ @@ -127930,11 +138422,11 @@ ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6c20af5360b5c0e0", - "external_value": 0.0, + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 1651.358, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1651.358, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -127956,10 +138448,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a963f3bd4bd29553781c", + "claim_id": "97ee14c1319888f1b273", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 2", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 5", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -127984,14 +138476,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_2", + "income_group": "decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "3017.333" + "value_verbatim": "755.2086" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128008,10 +138500,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 3017.333, + "external_value": 755.2086, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3017.333, + "external_value_pe_sign": 755.2086, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128033,10 +138525,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "af2cb7d46caa9609d937", + "claim_id": "9484b047818b904c7ecc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 3", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 6", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128061,14 +138553,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_3", + "income_group": "decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2640.092" + "value_verbatim": "135.7898" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128085,10 +138577,164 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 2640.092, + "external_value": 135.7898, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2640.092, + "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "119ef29c082f2d805c3b", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 7", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_7", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "85c8557e3112d5e9b992", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 8", + "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "decile_8", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "option": "Three child limit", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "Three child limit", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128110,10 +138756,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "36928182aeb4e0cb485d", + "claim_id": "798260b399ee65eb2f80", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 4", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 9", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128138,14 +138784,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_4", + "income_group": "decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1651.358" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128162,10 +138808,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 1651.358, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1651.358, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128187,10 +138833,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "97ee14c1319888f1b273", + "claim_id": "7ceb762b850e15354772", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 5", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / All", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128215,14 +138861,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_5", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "755.2086" + "value_verbatim": "1907.131" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128239,10 +138885,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 755.2086, + "external_value": 1907.131, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 755.2086, + "external_value_pe_sign": 1907.131, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128264,10 +138910,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9484b047818b904c7ecc", + "claim_id": "732daff2183383bcb2f8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 6", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Poorest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128292,14 +138938,14 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_6", + "income_group": "decile_1", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "reform_hint": "Three child limit", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "135.7898" + "value_verbatim": "2431.835" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", @@ -128316,10 +138962,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 135.7898, + "external_value": 2431.835, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 135.7898, + "external_value_pe_sign": 2431.835, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "latest": { @@ -128341,10 +138987,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "119ef29c082f2d805c3b", + "claim_id": "c1ba3cb2c8886a771f69", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 7", + "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Richest", "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", @@ -128369,7 +139015,7 @@ "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_7", + "income_group": "decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", "option": "Three child limit", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", @@ -128418,64 +139064,62 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "85c8557e3112d5e9b992", + "claim_id": "27352855b0b13547dc30", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 8", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "value_kind": "range_high", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_8", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "almost \u00a31,000 per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 1000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128495,64 +139139,61 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "798260b399ee65eb2f80", + "claim_id": "62a51fb068990b423ec1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / 9", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_9", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3360 per employee per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 360.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128572,64 +139213,60 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ceb762b850e15354772", + "claim_id": "9c6229d4274cf5ac4624", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / All", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "1907.131" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3151" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 1907.131, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 1907.131, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 151.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128649,64 +139286,62 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "732daff2183383bcb2f8", + "claim_id": "b4f8bd23bbe5d4f12aee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Poorest", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "value_kind": "range_low", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_1", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "2431.835" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "slightly over \u00a3140 per employee per year" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 2431.835, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 2431.835, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 140.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128726,64 +139361,61 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c1ba3cb2c8886a771f69", + "claim_id": "bdafa33ca4895d387f3a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "\u00a3 change / Among households with families of three or more children / Three child limit / Richest", - "name": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 25591134: What is the average income change from various options to mitigate the two-child limit? (comment Figure 3, story 3377796)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/25591134/embed", - "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2035, - "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "facet": "Among households with families of three or more children", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "long run (two-child limit fully rolled out)", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "equivalised household income decile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "decile_10", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "option": "Three child limit", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "Three child limit", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "subgroup": "households with families of three or more children", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3123" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__three_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "917dd5c7cc2fa30a", - "external_value": 0.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 123.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "ifs_2cl_fp_removal_rolled_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -128803,7 +139435,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "27352855b0b13547dc30", + "claim_id": "f8d6381bca0a75936332", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -128813,7 +139445,7 @@ "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "range_high", + "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, @@ -128824,18 +139456,16 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "range_high", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "almost \u00a31,000 per year" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a337" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -128853,7 +139483,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1000.0, + "external_value": 37.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -128878,14 +139508,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "62a51fb068990b423ec1", + "claim_id": "52422b20e74fe0235278", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1 to 9", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -128899,17 +139529,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", + "employer_size": "1 to 9", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3360 per employee per year" + "value_verbatim": "3.0461222622592534" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -128927,7 +139557,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 360.0, + "external_value": 3.0461222622592534, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -128952,14 +139582,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c6229d4274cf5ac4624", + "claim_id": "8c3c2f730a0e85ebf022", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10 to 49", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -128973,165 +139603,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "10 to 49", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3151" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 151.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "b4f8bd23bbe5d4f12aee", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "range_low", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "range_low", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "employee plus employer NICs", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "slightly over \u00a3140 per employee per year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 140.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "bdafa33ca4895d387f3a", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a3123" + "value_verbatim": "9.145301761361411" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129149,7 +139631,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.0, + "external_value": 9.145301761361411, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129174,14 +139656,14 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f8d6381bca0a75936332", + "claim_id": "f816876c96e9d84520c5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Publication page: Assessing the government's reform to the National Insurance treatment of salary sacrifice pension contributions (full report text)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/assessing-governments-reform-national-insurance-treatment-salary-sacrifice-pension", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", @@ -129195,16 +139677,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a337" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "43.77400352541435" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129222,7 +139705,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 37.0, + "external_value": 43.77400352541435, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129247,10 +139730,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "52422b20e74fe0235278", + "claim_id": "a5c1d3943f4f2a5f705a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1 to 9", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10000 to 29999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129268,7 +139751,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1 to 9", + "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129278,7 +139761,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "3.0461222622592534" + "value_verbatim": "41.62994582977899" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129296,7 +139779,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 3.0461222622592534, + "external_value": 41.62994582977899, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129321,10 +139804,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8c3c2f730a0e85ebf022", + "claim_id": "4757627f8c543c204d9e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10 to 49", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 200 to 999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129342,7 +139825,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10 to 49", + "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129352,7 +139835,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "9.145301761361411" + "value_verbatim": "34.53187139226558" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129370,7 +139853,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 9.145301761361411, + "external_value": 34.53187139226558, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129395,10 +139878,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f816876c96e9d84520c5", + "claim_id": "bcf54f5cdceda1dd625e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 3", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129416,17 +139899,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "43.77400352541435" + "value_verbatim": "0.8678732461057174" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129444,7 +139927,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 43.77400352541435, + "external_value": 0.8678732461057174, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129469,10 +139952,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a5c1d3943f4f2a5f705a", + "claim_id": "38077c875ba1fa188cfa", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 10000 to 29999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 30000+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129490,7 +139973,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", + "employer_size": "30000+", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129500,7 +139983,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "41.62994582977899" + "value_verbatim": "19.152681951998563" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129518,7 +140001,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 41.62994582977899, + "external_value": 19.152681951998563, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129543,10 +140026,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4757627f8c543c204d9e", + "claim_id": "7806a956cead33f8d9b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 200 to 999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 4", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129564,17 +140047,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "34.53187139226558" + "value_verbatim": "2.113901667282074" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129592,7 +140075,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 34.53187139226558, + "external_value": 2.113901667282074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129617,10 +140100,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bcf54f5cdceda1dd625e", + "claim_id": "5a278d8d4fba36cc7668", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 3", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129642,13 +140125,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.8678732461057174" + "value_verbatim": "5.136721095318348" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129666,7 +140149,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.8678732461057174, + "external_value": 5.136721095318348, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129691,10 +140174,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "38077c875ba1fa188cfa", + "claim_id": "57084f9cc3bfbbc50f95", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 30000+", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 50 to 199", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129712,7 +140195,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "30000+", + "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -129722,7 +140205,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "19.152681951998563" + "value_verbatim": "18.302703499759048" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129740,7 +140223,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 19.152681951998563, + "external_value": 18.302703499759048, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129765,10 +140248,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7806a956cead33f8d9b0", + "claim_id": "225a474c4f8a9536f968", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 4", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5000 to 9999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129786,17 +140269,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "2.113901667282074" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "53.406588185522" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129814,7 +140297,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 2.113901667282074, + "external_value": 53.406588185522, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129839,10 +140322,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5a278d8d4fba36cc7668", + "claim_id": "ade7cf1e0631672dc381", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 6", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129864,13 +140347,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "5.136721095318348" + "value_verbatim": "12.16568214613685" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129888,7 +140371,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 5.136721095318348, + "external_value": 12.16568214613685, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129913,10 +140396,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "57084f9cc3bfbbc50f95", + "claim_id": "ff10be10b69194bbac95", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 50 to 199", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 7", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -129934,17 +140417,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "18.302703499759048" + "value_verbatim": "25.187239955955185" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -129962,7 +140445,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 18.302703499759048, + "external_value": 25.187239955955185, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -129987,10 +140470,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "225a474c4f8a9536f968", + "claim_id": "5eff7f72fbedc7a6463c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 5000 to 9999", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 8", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130008,17 +140491,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "53.406588185522" + "value_verbatim": "21.716237881548597" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130036,7 +140519,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 53.406588185522, + "external_value": 21.716237881548597, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130061,10 +140544,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ade7cf1e0631672dc381", + "claim_id": "43d1b5b0124723cdf191", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 6", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130086,13 +140569,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "12.16568214613685" + "value_verbatim": "24.4095432289078" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130110,7 +140593,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 12.16568214613685, + "external_value": 24.4095432289078, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130135,10 +140618,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ff10be10b69194bbac95", + "claim_id": "fd6d9ea7c06603875804", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 7", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Accommodation & food services", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130159,14 +140642,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "25.187239955955185" + "sector": "Accommodation & food services", + "value_verbatim": "1.1275214508351372" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130184,7 +140666,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 25.187239955955185, + "external_value": 1.1275214508351372, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130209,10 +140691,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5eff7f72fbedc7a6463c", + "claim_id": "e583541a3710cfa3c7bc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 8", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Administrative & support", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130233,14 +140715,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "21.716237881548597" + "sector": "Administrative & support", + "value_verbatim": "10.138172997969372" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130258,7 +140739,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 21.716237881548597, + "external_value": 10.138172997969372, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130283,10 +140764,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "43d1b5b0124723cdf191", + "claim_id": "520e3e8a2fbe9f83cde2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / 9", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 16-29", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130301,20 +140782,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "16-29", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "24.4095432289078" + "subgroup": "Age 16-29", + "value_verbatim": "11.653768814427075" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130332,7 +140813,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 24.4095432289078, + "external_value": 11.653768814427075, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130357,10 +140838,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd6d9ea7c06603875804", + "claim_id": "2876fe1456fd14c74d87", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Accommodation & food services", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 30-39", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130375,6 +140856,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "30-39", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130386,8 +140868,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Accommodation & food services", - "value_verbatim": "1.1275214508351372" + "subgroup": "Age 30-39", + "value_verbatim": "23.921537770771934" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130405,7 +140887,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1.1275214508351372, + "external_value": 23.921537770771934, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130430,10 +140912,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e583541a3710cfa3c7bc", + "claim_id": "f83a271b33090bcae7e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Administrative & support", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 40-49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130448,6 +140930,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130459,8 +140942,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Administrative & support", - "value_verbatim": "10.138172997969372" + "subgroup": "Age 40-49", + "value_verbatim": "26.71745027504521" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130478,7 +140961,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 10.138172997969372, + "external_value": 26.71745027504521, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130503,10 +140986,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "520e3e8a2fbe9f83cde2", + "claim_id": "4363a50fbfc2f5449762", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 16-29", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 50-59", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130521,7 +141004,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "16-29", + "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130533,8 +141016,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 16-29", - "value_verbatim": "11.653768814427075" + "subgroup": "Age 50-59", + "value_verbatim": "23.833895616840955" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130552,7 +141035,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 11.653768814427075, + "external_value": 23.833895616840955, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130577,10 +141060,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2876fe1456fd14c74d87", + "claim_id": "551368eea8ea4e822f1d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 30-39", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 60+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130595,7 +141078,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "30-39", + "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130607,8 +141090,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 30-39", - "value_verbatim": "23.921537770771934" + "subgroup": "Age 60+", + "value_verbatim": "12.66413756684722" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130626,7 +141109,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.921537770771934, + "external_value": 12.66413756684722, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130651,10 +141134,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f83a271b33090bcae7e1", + "claim_id": "93c5c773491ab50d93c1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 40-49", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130669,20 +141152,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 40-49", - "value_verbatim": "26.71745027504521" + "value_verbatim": "20.78243671212471" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130700,7 +141183,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 26.71745027504521, + "external_value": 20.78243671212471, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130725,10 +141208,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4363a50fbfc2f5449762", + "claim_id": "9686cf929d2fc570e5bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 50-59", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130743,7 +141226,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130755,8 +141237,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 50-59", - "value_verbatim": "23.833895616840955" + "subgroup": "all employees", + "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130774,7 +141256,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.833895616840955, + "external_value": 20.782436702128095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130799,10 +141281,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "551368eea8ea4e822f1d", + "claim_id": "f7b1e9f4eddb53c779e6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Age 60+", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130817,7 +141299,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -130829,8 +141310,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 60+", - "value_verbatim": "12.66413756684722" + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130848,7 +141329,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 12.66413756684722, + "external_value": 20.782436702128095, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130873,10 +141354,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "93c5c773491ab50d93c1", + "claim_id": "9d1387b52bd6b5b893bb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Construction", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130897,14 +141378,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "20.78243671212471" + "sector": "Construction", + "value_verbatim": "17.058063051425354" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130922,7 +141402,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.78243671212471, + "external_value": 17.058063051425354, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -130947,10 +141427,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9686cf929d2fc570e5bf", + "claim_id": "250e731de2b34dd8ebff", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -130971,13 +141451,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "all employees", - "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" + "value_verbatim": "116.0880640534236" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -130995,7 +141476,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.782436702128095, + "external_value": 116.0880640534236, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131020,10 +141501,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f7b1e9f4eddb53c779e6", + "claim_id": "00476510d16eed030bba", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131044,13 +141525,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "20.782436702128095" + "value_verbatim": "0.07450457486077758" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131068,7 +141550,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 20.782436702128095, + "external_value": 0.07450457486077758, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131093,10 +141575,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9d1387b52bd6b5b893bb", + "claim_id": "ca2d56dc8e36d0a1710a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Construction", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Finance & insurance", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131122,8 +141604,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Construction", - "value_verbatim": "17.058063051425354" + "sector": "Finance & insurance", + "value_verbatim": "74.34333015035952" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131141,7 +141623,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 17.058063051425354, + "external_value": 74.34333015035952, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131166,10 +141648,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "250e731de2b34dd8ebff", + "claim_id": "9f5c08c636647995adef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Information & communication", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131190,14 +141672,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "116.0880640534236" + "sector": "Information & communication", + "value_verbatim": "63.34366017625928" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131215,7 +141696,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 116.0880640534236, + "external_value": 63.34366017625928, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131240,10 +141721,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "00476510d16eed030bba", + "claim_id": "f3cc0c2f7a065e448967", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Manufacturing", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131264,14 +141745,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employee NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.07450457486077758" + "sector": "Manufacturing", + "value_verbatim": "32.66468604698881" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131289,7 +141769,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.07450457486077758, + "external_value": 32.66468604698881, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131314,10 +141794,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ca2d56dc8e36d0a1710a", + "claim_id": "7f076d4380720272ddf6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Finance & insurance", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Men", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131343,8 +141823,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Finance & insurance", - "value_verbatim": "74.34333015035952" + "sex": "men", + "subgroup": "Men", + "value_verbatim": "27.530805267378295" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131362,7 +141843,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 74.34333015035952, + "external_value": 27.530805267378295, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131387,10 +141868,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9f5c08c636647995adef", + "claim_id": "d48dd27bf371b43059a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Information & communication", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Other industries", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131416,8 +141897,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Information & communication", - "value_verbatim": "63.34366017625928" + "sector": "Other industries", + "value_verbatim": "14.942446233186413" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131435,7 +141916,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 63.34366017625928, + "external_value": 14.942446233186413, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131460,10 +141941,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f3cc0c2f7a065e448967", + "claim_id": "981a35c0beef69999765", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Manufacturing", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Private sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131489,8 +141970,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Manufacturing", - "value_verbatim": "32.66468604698881" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "25.130604430409704" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131508,7 +141989,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 32.66468604698881, + "external_value": 25.130604430409704, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131533,10 +142014,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7f076d4380720272ddf6", + "claim_id": "4faf6b6deff0a09c388e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Men", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131562,9 +142043,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "men", - "subgroup": "Men", - "value_verbatim": "27.530805267378295" + "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", + "value_verbatim": "36.68112711725161" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131582,7 +142062,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 27.530805267378295, + "external_value": 36.68112711725161, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131607,10 +142087,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d48dd27bf371b43059a7", + "claim_id": "47853d9ffc0a8fd8b294", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Other industries", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Public sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131636,8 +142116,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Other industries", - "value_verbatim": "14.942446233186413" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "7.37718587675984" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131655,7 +142135,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.942446233186413, + "external_value": 7.37718587675984, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131680,10 +142160,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "981a35c0beef69999765", + "claim_id": "bd4abdf3671f29e5fe54", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Private sector", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Real Estate", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131709,8 +142189,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "25.130604430409704" + "sector": "Real Estate", + "value_verbatim": "21.31531199800756" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131728,7 +142208,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 25.130604430409704, + "external_value": 21.31531199800756, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131753,10 +142233,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4faf6b6deff0a09c388e", + "claim_id": "071fd0bf739fb73f5c1e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131782,8 +142262,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", - "value_verbatim": "36.68112711725161" + "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", + "value_verbatim": "23.23759789230727" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131801,7 +142281,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 36.68112711725161, + "external_value": 23.23759789230727, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131826,10 +142306,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "47853d9ffc0a8fd8b294", + "claim_id": "11e65c8d87823d466aef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Public sector", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Transport & storage", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131855,8 +142335,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "7.37718587675984" + "sector": "Transport & storage", + "value_verbatim": "23.225032393278717" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131874,7 +142354,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 7.37718587675984, + "external_value": 23.225032393278717, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131899,10 +142379,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bd4abdf3671f29e5fe54", + "claim_id": "6b3c55ab8e1ab7877869", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Real Estate", + "source_column": "Employee NICs / Women", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131928,8 +142408,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Real Estate", - "value_verbatim": "21.31531199800756" + "sex": "women", + "subgroup": "Women", + "value_verbatim": "14.085935195305458" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -131947,7 +142428,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 21.31531199800756, + "external_value": 14.085935195305458, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -131972,10 +142453,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "071fd0bf739fb73f5c1e", + "claim_id": "feed61e01a1fae757b18", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1 to 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -131993,16 +142474,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1 to 9", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", - "value_verbatim": "23.23759789230727" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "14.39960984510036" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132020,7 +142502,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.23759789230727, + "external_value": 14.39960984510036, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132045,10 +142527,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "11e65c8d87823d466aef", + "claim_id": "29cc4a350ec3785aa271", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Transport & storage", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10 to 49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132066,16 +142548,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "10 to 49", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Transport & storage", - "value_verbatim": "23.225032393278717" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "54.97683520545021" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132093,7 +142576,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 23.225032393278717, + "external_value": 54.97683520545021, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132118,10 +142601,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6b3c55ab8e1ab7877869", + "claim_id": "63ed03e7cf6589bd8bff", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employee NICs / Women", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1000 to 4999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132139,17 +142622,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employee NICs", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "women", - "subgroup": "Women", - "value_verbatim": "14.085935195305458" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "265.86339870276527" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132167,7 +142650,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.085935195305458, + "external_value": 265.86339870276527, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132192,10 +142675,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "feed61e01a1fae757b18", + "claim_id": "a061fb3a0d21e087f208", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1 to 9", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10000 to 29999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132213,7 +142696,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1 to 9", + "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132223,7 +142706,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "14.39960984510036" + "value_verbatim": "234.41532113116642" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132241,7 +142724,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 14.39960984510036, + "external_value": 234.41532113116642, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132266,10 +142749,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "29cc4a350ec3785aa271", + "claim_id": "f98dd834eb8df34e0e93", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10 to 49", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 200 to 999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132287,7 +142770,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10 to 49", + "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132297,7 +142780,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "54.97683520545021" + "value_verbatim": "213.00534999908092" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132315,7 +142798,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 54.97683520545021, + "external_value": 213.00534999908092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132340,10 +142823,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "63ed03e7cf6589bd8bff", + "claim_id": "8ed5282ce5d33f61d2d0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 1000 to 4999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 3", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132361,17 +142844,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "1000 to 4999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "265.86339870276527" + "value_verbatim": "1.5767570267140745" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132389,7 +142872,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 265.86339870276527, + "external_value": 1.5767570267140745, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132414,10 +142897,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a061fb3a0d21e087f208", + "claim_id": "5d163d8d3b3c5296624b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 10000 to 29999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 30000+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132435,7 +142918,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "10000 to 29999", + "employer_size": "30000+", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132445,7 +142928,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "234.41532113116642" + "value_verbatim": "126.52805790967456" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132463,7 +142946,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 234.41532113116642, + "external_value": 126.52805790967456, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132488,10 +142971,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f98dd834eb8df34e0e93", + "claim_id": "a203da93012f0074b7c7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 200 to 999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 4", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132509,17 +142992,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "200 to 999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "213.00534999908092" + "value_verbatim": "3.9567333831938782" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132537,7 +143020,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 213.00534999908092, + "external_value": 3.9567333831938782, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132562,10 +143045,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8ed5282ce5d33f61d2d0", + "claim_id": "8544e0ffa34f10f6eaee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 3", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132587,13 +143070,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_3", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "1.5767570267140745" + "value_verbatim": "9.607267637613042" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132611,7 +143094,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 1.5767570267140745, + "external_value": 9.607267637613042, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132636,10 +143119,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5d163d8d3b3c5296624b", + "claim_id": "cfa4832f36c5ead91c44", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 30000+", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 50 to 199", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132657,7 +143140,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "30000+", + "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", @@ -132667,7 +143150,7 @@ "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "126.52805790967456" + "value_verbatim": "112.5623621920566" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132685,7 +143168,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 126.52805790967456, + "external_value": 112.5623621920566, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132710,10 +143193,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a203da93012f0074b7c7", + "claim_id": "fdc6bcf96dd28032dc52", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 4", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5000 to 9999", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132731,17 +143214,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_4", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "3.9567333831938782" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "311.85429704048397" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132759,7 +143242,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 3.9567333831938782, + "external_value": 311.85429704048397, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132784,10 +143267,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8544e0ffa34f10f6eaee", + "claim_id": "539ab08f47405d1160fa", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 6", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132809,13 +143292,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_5", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "9.607267637613042" + "value_verbatim": "22.829496880411863" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132833,7 +143316,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 9.607267637613042, + "external_value": 22.829496880411863, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132858,10 +143341,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cfa4832f36c5ead91c44", + "claim_id": "39c7ae6ac1d83c82e42e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 50 to 199", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 7", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132879,17 +143362,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "50 to 199", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "112.5623621920566" + "value_verbatim": "47.302440969417866" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132907,7 +143390,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 112.5623621920566, + "external_value": 47.302440969417866, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -132932,10 +143415,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fdc6bcf96dd28032dc52", + "claim_id": "c4bf9c7c8eee36dea646", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 5000 to 9999", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 8", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -132953,17 +143436,17 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "employer_size": "5000 to 9999", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "311.85429704048397" + "value_verbatim": "95.54673178579887" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -132981,7 +143464,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 311.85429704048397, + "external_value": 95.54673178579887, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133006,10 +143489,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "539ab08f47405d1160fa", + "claim_id": "ced45f7be2e8d9ef49c1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 6", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / 9", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133031,13 +143514,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_6", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "22.829496880411863" + "value_verbatim": "180.45343539349838" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133055,7 +143538,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 22.829496880411863, + "external_value": 180.45343539349838, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133080,10 +143563,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "39c7ae6ac1d83c82e42e", + "claim_id": "a40492f0ee2e04575bdd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 7", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Accommodation & food services", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133104,14 +143587,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_7", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "47.302440969417866" + "sector": "Accommodation & food services", + "value_verbatim": "6.13022096388335" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133129,7 +143611,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 47.302440969417866, + "external_value": 6.13022096388335, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133154,10 +143636,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c4bf9c7c8eee36dea646", + "claim_id": "4a5464acb70bd7916ea8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 8", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Administrative & support", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133178,14 +143660,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_8", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "95.54673178579887" + "sector": "Administrative & support", + "value_verbatim": "56.08248408750178" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133203,7 +143684,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 95.54673178579887, + "external_value": 56.08248408750178, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133228,10 +143709,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ced45f7be2e8d9ef49c1", + "claim_id": "a2eddc6a2c66b2997f9a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / 9", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 16-29", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133246,20 +143727,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "16-29", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_9", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "180.45343539349838" + "subgroup": "Age 16-29", + "value_verbatim": "52.55572182647085" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133277,7 +143758,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 180.45343539349838, + "external_value": 52.55572182647085, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133302,10 +143783,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a40492f0ee2e04575bdd", + "claim_id": "284b09136dba78f07595", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Accommodation & food services", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 30-39", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133320,6 +143801,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "30-39", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133331,8 +143813,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Accommodation & food services", - "value_verbatim": "6.13022096388335" + "subgroup": "Age 30-39", + "value_verbatim": "143.27787710165185" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133350,7 +143832,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 6.13022096388335, + "external_value": 143.27787710165185, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133375,10 +143857,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a5464acb70bd7916ea8", + "claim_id": "d5d46e69e7f1c7e06306", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Administrative & support", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 40-49", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133393,6 +143875,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { + "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133404,8 +143887,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Administrative & support", - "value_verbatim": "56.08248408750178" + "subgroup": "Age 40-49", + "value_verbatim": "171.13698501393932" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133423,7 +143906,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 56.08248408750178, + "external_value": 171.13698501393932, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133448,10 +143931,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a2eddc6a2c66b2997f9a", + "claim_id": "9af5223777c562b943f5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 16-29", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 50-59", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133466,7 +143949,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "16-29", + "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133478,8 +143961,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 16-29", - "value_verbatim": "52.55572182647085" + "subgroup": "Age 50-59", + "value_verbatim": "145.29025498183447" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133497,7 +143980,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 52.55572182647085, + "external_value": 145.29025498183447, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133522,10 +144005,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "284b09136dba78f07595", + "claim_id": "a918d02fce8cbf358882", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 30-39", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 60+", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133540,7 +144023,7 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "30-39", + "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133552,8 +144035,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 30-39", - "value_verbatim": "143.27787710165185" + "subgroup": "Age 60+", + "value_verbatim": "72.82329120507924" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133571,7 +144054,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 143.27787710165185, + "external_value": 72.82329120507924, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133596,10 +144079,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d5d46e69e7f1c7e06306", + "claim_id": "03ceeaea1f2b5ca0873c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 40-49", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133614,20 +144097,20 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "40-49", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "all", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 40-49", - "value_verbatim": "171.13698501393932" + "value_verbatim": "123.44323245099713" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133645,7 +144128,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 171.13698501393932, + "external_value": 123.44323245099713, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133670,10 +144153,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9af5223777c562b943f5", + "claim_id": "4b69418dca85d19f0046", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 50-59", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133688,7 +144171,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "50-59", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133700,8 +144182,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 50-59", - "value_verbatim": "145.29025498183447" + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "123.05899521234191" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133719,7 +144201,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 145.29025498183447, + "external_value": 123.05899521234191, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133744,10 +144226,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a918d02fce8cbf358882", + "claim_id": "5e57bd71f66a60c1ccf7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Age 60+", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133762,7 +144244,6 @@ "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "age_group": "60+", "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", @@ -133774,8 +144255,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "Age 60+", - "value_verbatim": "72.82329120507924" + "subgroup": "all employees", + "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133793,7 +144274,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 72.82329120507924, + "external_value": 123.44323239161938, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133818,7 +144299,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "03ceeaea1f2b5ca0873c", + "claim_id": "8c8986ba539b79b3cf44", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", @@ -133835,6 +144316,152 @@ "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "All", + "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01867db201c74fc2ffba", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Construction", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "metric": "average_tax_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", + "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", + "sector": "Construction", + "value_verbatim": "112.5634262423248" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", + "program": "national_insurance", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", + "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", + "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", + "national_insurance" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", + "external_value": 112.5634262423248, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c3a87af8902514d385e8", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "metric": "average_tax_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, "conditions": { "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", @@ -133843,13 +144470,13 @@ "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "all", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323245099713" + "value_verbatim": "872.8689059490712" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133867,7 +144494,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323245099713, + "external_value": 872.8689059490712, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133892,10 +144519,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4b69418dca85d19f0046", + "claim_id": "9a43fc94ddf359fb4d11", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133916,13 +144543,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", + "income_axis": "earnings_decile", + "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "123.05899521234191" + "value_verbatim": "0.18017585554843393" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -133940,7 +144568,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.05899521234191, + "external_value": 0.18017585554843393, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -133965,10 +144593,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5e57bd71f66a60c1ccf7", + "claim_id": "a2285e1ce6dd2b00665e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Finance & insurance", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -133994,8 +144622,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "subgroup": "all employees", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + "sector": "Finance & insurance", + "value_verbatim": "444.9788051762739" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134013,7 +144641,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "external_value": 444.9788051762739, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134038,10 +144666,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8c8986ba539b79b3cf44", + "claim_id": "b21a521737f658c9611b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / All", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Information & communication", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134067,8 +144695,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "All", - "value_verbatim": "123.44323239161938" + "sector": "Information & communication", + "value_verbatim": "421.44733349528576" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134086,7 +144714,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 123.44323239161938, + "external_value": 421.44733349528576, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134111,10 +144739,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01867db201c74fc2ffba", + "claim_id": "2c2b42f6030332820c06", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Construction", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Manufacturing", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134140,8 +144768,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Construction", - "value_verbatim": "112.5634262423248" + "sector": "Manufacturing", + "value_verbatim": "198.05285550065074" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134159,7 +144787,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 112.5634262423248, + "external_value": 198.05285550065074, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134184,10 +144812,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c3a87af8902514d385e8", + "claim_id": "94239833e6c5465a27fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Decile 10 (highest)", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Men", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134208,14 +144836,14 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_10", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "872.8689059490712" + "sex": "men", + "subgroup": "Men", + "value_verbatim": "171.76513414861247" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134233,7 +144861,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 872.8689059490712, + "external_value": 171.76513414861247, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134258,10 +144886,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9a43fc94ddf359fb4d11", + "claim_id": "5b56a8aec66dfe36e332", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Deciles 1 & 2 (lowest)", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Other industries", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134282,14 +144910,13 @@ "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "income_axis": "earnings_decile", - "income_group": "earnings_decile_1_2", "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", "nics_component": "Employer NICs", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "value_verbatim": "0.18017585554843393" + "sector": "Other industries", + "value_verbatim": "78.1994195641592" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134307,7 +144934,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 0.18017585554843393, + "external_value": 78.1994195641592, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134332,10 +144959,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a2285e1ce6dd2b00665e", + "claim_id": "b295532c1e195da9408e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Finance & insurance", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Private sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134361,8 +144988,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Finance & insurance", - "value_verbatim": "444.9788051762739" + "sector": "Private sector", + "value_verbatim": "151.43091783766553" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134380,7 +145007,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 444.9788051762739, + "external_value": 151.43091783766553, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134405,10 +145032,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b21a521737f658c9611b", + "claim_id": "a1f6b471b435208df58e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Information & communication", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134434,8 +145061,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Information & communication", - "value_verbatim": "421.44733349528576" + "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", + "value_verbatim": "241.91582585068468" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134453,7 +145080,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 421.44733349528576, + "external_value": 241.91582585068468, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134478,10 +145105,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2c2b42f6030332820c06", + "claim_id": "2b7aa8ac2582843173c7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Manufacturing", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Public sector", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134507,8 +145134,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Manufacturing", - "value_verbatim": "198.05285550065074" + "sector": "Public sector", + "value_verbatim": "37.158127192375716" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134526,7 +145153,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 198.05285550065074, + "external_value": 37.158127192375716, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134551,10 +145178,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "94239833e6c5465a27fb", + "claim_id": "acdd7568f5c5ab61fb61", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Men", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Real Estate", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134580,9 +145207,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "men", - "subgroup": "Men", - "value_verbatim": "171.76513414861247" + "sector": "Real Estate", + "value_verbatim": "109.27190895967401" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134600,7 +145226,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 171.76513414861247, + "external_value": 109.27190895967401, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134625,10 +145251,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5b56a8aec66dfe36e332", + "claim_id": "dd039b4bdcdd7b1856ca", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Other industries", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134654,8 +145280,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Other industries", - "value_verbatim": "78.1994195641592" + "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", + "value_verbatim": "136.39035161095623" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134673,7 +145299,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 78.1994195641592, + "external_value": 136.39035161095623, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134698,10 +145324,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b295532c1e195da9408e", + "claim_id": "9d5983e1abde01d96034", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Private sector", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Transport & storage", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134727,8 +145353,8 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Private sector", - "value_verbatim": "151.43091783766553" + "sector": "Transport & storage", + "value_verbatim": "142.10874467995092" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134746,7 +145372,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 151.43091783766553, + "external_value": 142.10874467995092, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134771,10 +145397,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1f6b471b435208df58e", + "claim_id": "7ff9c846fae551d5baef", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Professional, scientific & technical", + "source_column": "Employer NICs / Women", "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", @@ -134800,8 +145426,9 @@ "pe_expressibility": "expressible", "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Professional, scientific & technical", - "value_verbatim": "241.91582585068468" + "sex": "women", + "subgroup": "Women", + "value_verbatim": "75.49270574681057" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", @@ -134819,7 +145446,7 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 241.91582585068468, + "external_value": 75.49270574681057, "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", "external_value_pe_sign": null, @@ -134844,18 +145471,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2b7aa8ac2582843173c7", + "claim_id": "8d5203be30a1d2354c63", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Public sector", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 0", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -134865,37 +145492,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "0", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Public sector", - "value_verbatim": "37.158127192375716" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 37.158127192375716, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -134917,18 +145552,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acdd7568f5c5ab61fb61", + "claim_id": "4dfaf9a547743e2a6fe2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Real Estate", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 1000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -134938,37 +145573,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "1000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Real Estate", - "value_verbatim": "109.27190895967401" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 109.27190895967401, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -134990,18 +145633,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dd039b4bdcdd7b1856ca", + "claim_id": "571c7e3f95eef0f0e44d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Retail & wholesale trade", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 10000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135011,37 +145654,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "10000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Retail & wholesale trade", - "value_verbatim": "136.39035161095623" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 136.39035161095623, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 35.99089, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135063,18 +145714,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9d5983e1abde01d96034", + "claim_id": "08b5844f627afc0e5d3c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Transport & storage", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 100000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135084,37 +145735,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "100000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sector": "Transport & storage", - "value_verbatim": "142.10874467995092" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 142.10874467995092, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 603.4957, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135136,18 +145795,18 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7ff9c846fae551d5baef", + "claim_id": "62b39684b27c520e89cb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Employer NICs / Women", - "name": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 101000", + "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Download data behind the figures (salary-sacrifice report, sheets fig1..fig10)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/underlying_data_0.xlsx", + "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", "metric": "average_tax_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, @@ -135157,38 +145816,45 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", + "earnings": "101000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "nics_component": "Employer NICs", + "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", + "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "current prices (2026-27)", - "reform_hint": "salary sacrifice pension contributions above \u00a32,000 per year no longer exempt from employer and employee NICs from 2029-30 (no behavioural response)", - "sex": "women", - "subgroup": "Women", - "value_verbatim": "75.49270574681057" + "price_base": "2025-26 prices", + "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", + "unit_population": "individual employee", + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__salary_sacrifice_pension_nics_cap_2000", - "program": "national_insurance", + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", "computability": "expressible", "head_variables": [ - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employee", - "salary_sacrifice_pension_ni_employer", - "salary_sacrifice_broad_base_haircut", - "national_insurance" + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" ], "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.salary_sacrifice_pension_cap" + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" ] }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "6405ee1c18d09a53", - "external_value": 75.49270574681057, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "no_stated_convention", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": 596.2975, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135210,10 +145876,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8d5203be30a1d2354c63", + "claim_id": "d5fb1da34fb7cdd13897", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 0", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 102000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135231,7 +145897,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "0", + "earnings": "102000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135243,7 +145909,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135266,10 +145932,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135291,10 +145957,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4dfaf9a547743e2a6fe2", + "claim_id": "7e5b37cb063421ef87ec", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 1000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 103000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135312,7 +145978,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "1000", + "earnings": "103000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135324,7 +145990,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135347,10 +146013,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135372,10 +146038,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "571c7e3f95eef0f0e44d", + "claim_id": "6368e91e8ec065f1fc5f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 10000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 104000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135393,7 +146059,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "10000", + "earnings": "104000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135405,7 +146071,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135428,10 +146094,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135453,10 +146119,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "08b5844f627afc0e5d3c", + "claim_id": "c8699d488e1a879ec872", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 100000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 105000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135474,7 +146140,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "100000", + "earnings": "105000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135486,7 +146152,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "596.2975" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135509,10 +146175,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 596.2975, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135534,10 +146200,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "62b39684b27c520e89cb", + "claim_id": "845b15051db75c823af8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 101000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 106000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135555,7 +146221,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "101000", + "earnings": "106000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135615,10 +146281,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d5fb1da34fb7cdd13897", + "claim_id": "097bb2f8167d8e31b5a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 102000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 107000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135636,7 +146302,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "102000", + "earnings": "107000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135696,10 +146362,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "7e5b37cb063421ef87ec", + "claim_id": "2ede21259538f5759cb2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 103000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 108000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135717,7 +146383,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "103000", + "earnings": "108000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135777,10 +146443,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6368e91e8ec065f1fc5f", + "claim_id": "26748dcf99bce817b836", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 104000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 109000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135798,7 +146464,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "104000", + "earnings": "109000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135858,10 +146524,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c8699d488e1a879ec872", + "claim_id": "aea39360b457880dedfc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 105000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 11000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135879,7 +146545,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "105000", + "earnings": "11000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -135891,7 +146557,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -135914,10 +146580,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -135939,10 +146605,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "845b15051db75c823af8", + "claim_id": "870bb607fac728f114d5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 106000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 110000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -135960,7 +146626,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "106000", + "earnings": "110000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136020,10 +146686,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "097bb2f8167d8e31b5a7", + "claim_id": "cb7f1de3e18db431ca46", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 107000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 111000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136041,7 +146707,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "107000", + "earnings": "111000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136101,10 +146767,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "2ede21259538f5759cb2", + "claim_id": "dfebd279dd241747956f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 108000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 112000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136122,7 +146788,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "108000", + "earnings": "112000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136182,10 +146848,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "26748dcf99bce817b836", + "claim_id": "05d57a372e04ac081085", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 109000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 113000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136203,7 +146869,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "109000", + "earnings": "113000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136263,91 +146929,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aea39360b457880dedfc", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 11000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "11000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "870bb607fac728f114d5", + "claim_id": "0b76db8b670a99f84031", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 110000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 114000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136365,7 +146950,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "110000", + "earnings": "114000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136425,10 +147010,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cb7f1de3e18db431ca46", + "claim_id": "3896e071a379b4269209", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 111000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 115000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136446,7 +147031,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "111000", + "earnings": "115000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136506,10 +147091,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dfebd279dd241747956f", + "claim_id": "183a666246c93b501364", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 112000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 116000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136527,7 +147112,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "112000", + "earnings": "116000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136587,10 +147172,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "05d57a372e04ac081085", + "claim_id": "494aeb57fbf30e8f9c31", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 113000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 117000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136608,7 +147193,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "113000", + "earnings": "117000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136668,10 +147253,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0b76db8b670a99f84031", + "claim_id": "e76a7596e00206c4eaa8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 114000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 118000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136689,7 +147274,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "114000", + "earnings": "118000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136749,10 +147334,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3896e071a379b4269209", + "claim_id": "1f4a547a4be657a64a71", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 115000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 119000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136770,7 +147355,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "115000", + "earnings": "119000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136830,10 +147415,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "183a666246c93b501364", + "claim_id": "685c5bd1e675fe1c673d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 116000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 12000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136851,7 +147436,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "116000", + "earnings": "12000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136863,7 +147448,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -136886,10 +147471,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -136911,10 +147496,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "494aeb57fbf30e8f9c31", + "claim_id": "b0758e7c23f34a6914eb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 117000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 120000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -136932,7 +147517,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "117000", + "earnings": "120000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -136992,10 +147577,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e76a7596e00206c4eaa8", + "claim_id": "8bbc16d6c98d0b56b490", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 118000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 121000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137013,7 +147598,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "118000", + "earnings": "121000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137073,10 +147658,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1f4a547a4be657a64a71", + "claim_id": "739f84d666caf2a5191a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 119000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 122000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137094,7 +147679,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "119000", + "earnings": "122000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137154,91 +147739,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "685c5bd1e675fe1c673d", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 12000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "12000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "b0758e7c23f34a6914eb", + "claim_id": "69686646c0aa944c11e3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 120000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 123000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137256,7 +147760,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "120000", + "earnings": "123000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137268,7 +147772,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "500.5586" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137291,10 +147795,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 500.5586, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 500.5586, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137316,10 +147820,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8bbc16d6c98d0b56b490", + "claim_id": "c7595d92d8c6a377163a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 121000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 124000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137337,7 +147841,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "121000", + "earnings": "124000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137349,7 +147853,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137372,10 +147876,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137397,10 +147901,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "739f84d666caf2a5191a", + "claim_id": "fc45fe50bc853719e445", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 122000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 125000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137418,7 +147922,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "122000", + "earnings": "125000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137430,7 +147934,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "596.2975" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137453,10 +147957,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 596.2975, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 596.2975, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137478,10 +147982,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "69686646c0aa944c11e3", + "claim_id": "e717e269148c722a263a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 123000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 126000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137499,7 +148003,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "123000", + "earnings": "126000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137511,7 +148015,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "500.5586" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137534,10 +148038,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 500.5586, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 500.5586, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137559,10 +148063,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c7595d92d8c6a377163a", + "claim_id": "c42c2b54be196f6002fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 124000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 127000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137580,7 +148084,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "124000", + "earnings": "127000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137640,10 +148144,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fc45fe50bc853719e445", + "claim_id": "cbcbe26cf8070c0fbbe2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 125000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 128000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137661,7 +148165,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "125000", + "earnings": "128000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137721,10 +148225,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e717e269148c722a263a", + "claim_id": "9c1e7287d5fa9133262d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 126000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 129000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137742,7 +148246,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "126000", + "earnings": "129000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137802,10 +148306,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c42c2b54be196f6002fb", + "claim_id": "4f99475a6e16449579d8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 127000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 13000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137823,7 +148327,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "127000", + "earnings": "13000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137835,7 +148339,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -137858,10 +148362,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -137883,10 +148387,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "cbcbe26cf8070c0fbbe2", + "claim_id": "18a8efc3e46e2675ebcc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 128000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 130000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137904,7 +148408,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "128000", + "earnings": "130000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -137964,10 +148468,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c1e7287d5fa9133262d", + "claim_id": "be0f6c3eb8d12cb317dc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 129000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 131000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -137985,7 +148489,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "129000", + "earnings": "131000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138045,10 +148549,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4f99475a6e16449579d8", + "claim_id": "21c04e327956d7e7ccf7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 13000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 132000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138066,7 +148570,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "13000", + "earnings": "132000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138078,7 +148582,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138101,10 +148605,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -138126,10 +148630,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "18a8efc3e46e2675ebcc", + "claim_id": "713c0102cabc053e1207", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 130000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 133000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138147,7 +148651,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "130000", + "earnings": "133000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138207,10 +148711,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "be0f6c3eb8d12cb317dc", + "claim_id": "9c09cf91dc8a2923d9e2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 131000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 134000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138228,7 +148732,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "131000", + "earnings": "134000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138288,10 +148792,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "21c04e327956d7e7ccf7", + "claim_id": "155ddca6f0af43f794b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 132000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 135000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138309,7 +148813,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "132000", + "earnings": "135000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138369,10 +148873,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "713c0102cabc053e1207", + "claim_id": "f34d18e138ffd12abe0a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 133000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 136000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138390,7 +148894,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "133000", + "earnings": "136000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138450,10 +148954,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9c09cf91dc8a2923d9e2", + "claim_id": "bbc43c2dd5466de2a829", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 134000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 137000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138471,7 +148975,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "134000", + "earnings": "137000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138531,10 +149035,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "155ddca6f0af43f794b0", + "claim_id": "892573efa899589b80a5", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 135000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 138000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138552,7 +149056,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "135000", + "earnings": "138000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138612,10 +149116,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f34d18e138ffd12abe0a", + "claim_id": "210dcf2c90829af8046b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 136000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 139000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138633,7 +149137,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "136000", + "earnings": "139000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138693,10 +149197,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bbc43c2dd5466de2a829", + "claim_id": "e6aee8eb66d6fd8d5b8d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 137000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 14000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138714,7 +149218,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "137000", + "earnings": "14000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138726,7 +149230,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138749,10 +149253,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -138774,10 +149278,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "892573efa899589b80a5", + "claim_id": "ef84a6ef82ecd2fe2b30", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 138000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 140000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138795,7 +149299,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "138000", + "earnings": "140000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138855,10 +149359,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "210dcf2c90829af8046b", + "claim_id": "23cf3eb55edcbb28f516", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 139000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 141000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138876,7 +149380,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "139000", + "earnings": "141000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138936,10 +149440,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e6aee8eb66d6fd8d5b8d", + "claim_id": "23d5fbf3bc8d7c82ce2b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 14000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 142000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -138957,7 +149461,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "14000", + "earnings": "142000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -138969,7 +149473,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "393.5896" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -138992,10 +149496,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 393.5896, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139017,10 +149521,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ef84a6ef82ecd2fe2b30", + "claim_id": "8006ec5687201fb592f2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 140000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 143000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139038,7 +149542,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "140000", + "earnings": "143000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139098,10 +149602,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23cf3eb55edcbb28f516", + "claim_id": "1a8686319da974d822db", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 141000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 144000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139119,7 +149623,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "141000", + "earnings": "144000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139179,10 +149683,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "23d5fbf3bc8d7c82ce2b", + "claim_id": "f8899adc104ec1a461ca", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 142000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 145000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139200,7 +149704,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "142000", + "earnings": "145000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139260,10 +149764,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8006ec5687201fb592f2", + "claim_id": "13c7a428c22d989a842c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 143000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 146000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139281,7 +149785,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "143000", + "earnings": "146000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139341,10 +149845,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1a8686319da974d822db", + "claim_id": "656e558ecf9f382b10bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 144000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 147000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139362,7 +149866,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "144000", + "earnings": "147000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139422,10 +149926,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f8899adc104ec1a461ca", + "claim_id": "d4fee346ffe6d0de112c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 145000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 148000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139443,7 +149947,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "145000", + "earnings": "148000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139503,10 +150007,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13c7a428c22d989a842c", + "claim_id": "3a499976f699e6354fb4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 146000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 149000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139524,7 +150028,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "146000", + "earnings": "149000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139584,10 +150088,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "656e558ecf9f382b10bf", + "claim_id": "8f537d2100e156598dce", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 147000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 15000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139605,7 +150109,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "147000", + "earnings": "15000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139617,7 +150121,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139640,10 +150144,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139665,10 +150169,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d4fee346ffe6d0de112c", + "claim_id": "4f34913397b3b37e201b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 148000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 150000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139686,7 +150190,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "148000", + "earnings": "150000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139746,10 +150250,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3a499976f699e6354fb4", + "claim_id": "d97cc750532ccfab4133", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 149000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 16000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139767,7 +150271,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "149000", + "earnings": "16000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139779,7 +150283,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139802,10 +150306,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139827,10 +150331,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8f537d2100e156598dce", + "claim_id": "96f632b441ec9b644262", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 15000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 17000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139848,7 +150352,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "15000", + "earnings": "17000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139908,10 +150412,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4f34913397b3b37e201b", + "claim_id": "89204c62e62b5b63e469", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 150000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 18000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -139929,7 +150433,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "150000", + "earnings": "18000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -139941,7 +150445,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "393.5896" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -139964,10 +150468,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 393.5896, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 393.5896, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -139989,10 +150493,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d97cc750532ccfab4133", + "claim_id": "9ae81f17c7326746d622", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 16000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 19000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140010,7 +150514,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "16000", + "earnings": "19000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140070,10 +150574,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "96f632b441ec9b644262", + "claim_id": "5262e8fc72227907758a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 17000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 2000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140091,7 +150595,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "17000", + "earnings": "2000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140103,7 +150607,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -140126,10 +150630,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -140151,10 +150655,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "89204c62e62b5b63e469", + "claim_id": "84c657086c6d32bebe83", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 18000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 20000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140172,7 +150676,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "18000", + "earnings": "20000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140232,10 +150736,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9ae81f17c7326746d622", + "claim_id": "ae4c07aeadb21eef7e66", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 19000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 21000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140253,7 +150757,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "19000", + "earnings": "21000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140313,10 +150817,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5262e8fc72227907758a", + "claim_id": "217c05d738c8ce23f33f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 2000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 22000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140334,7 +150838,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "2000", + "earnings": "22000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140346,7 +150850,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -140369,10 +150873,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -140394,10 +150898,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "84c657086c6d32bebe83", + "claim_id": "3e3e15f2edbd81a5cfe7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 20000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 23000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140415,7 +150919,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "20000", + "earnings": "23000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140475,10 +150979,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ae4c07aeadb21eef7e66", + "claim_id": "370085d411c02f1ea097", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 21000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 24000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140496,7 +151000,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "21000", + "earnings": "24000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140556,10 +151060,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "217c05d738c8ce23f33f", + "claim_id": "4a16c81bc1d7bdd3ede1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 22000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 25000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140577,7 +151081,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "22000", + "earnings": "25000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140637,10 +151141,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3e3e15f2edbd81a5cfe7", + "claim_id": "24f95947c03f5553ab86", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 23000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 26000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140658,7 +151162,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "23000", + "earnings": "26000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140718,10 +151222,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "370085d411c02f1ea097", + "claim_id": "c31fd99e90105533107b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 24000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 27000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140739,7 +151243,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "24000", + "earnings": "27000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140799,10 +151303,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4a16c81bc1d7bdd3ede1", + "claim_id": "3ef7521c636bb2a32823", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 25000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 28000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140820,7 +151324,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "25000", + "earnings": "28000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140880,10 +151384,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "24f95947c03f5553ab86", + "claim_id": "80c72dbaac623449d1f6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 26000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 29000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140901,7 +151405,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "26000", + "earnings": "29000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140961,10 +151465,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c31fd99e90105533107b", + "claim_id": "097761ca82db479e7258", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 27000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 3000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -140982,7 +151486,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "27000", + "earnings": "3000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -140994,7 +151498,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141017,10 +151521,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141042,10 +151546,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3ef7521c636bb2a32823", + "claim_id": "bb065b1707bee3d4de26", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 28000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 30000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141063,7 +151567,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "28000", + "earnings": "30000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141123,10 +151627,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "80c72dbaac623449d1f6", + "claim_id": "73b7acb3346be6cc1835", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 29000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 31000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141144,7 +151648,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "29000", + "earnings": "31000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141204,10 +151708,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "097761ca82db479e7258", + "claim_id": "28f894eafc23e05eb558", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 3000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 32000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141225,7 +151729,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "3000", + "earnings": "32000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141237,7 +151741,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141260,10 +151764,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141285,10 +151789,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bb065b1707bee3d4de26", + "claim_id": "954d437c73a629da9840", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 30000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 33000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141306,7 +151810,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "30000", + "earnings": "33000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141366,10 +151870,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "73b7acb3346be6cc1835", + "claim_id": "4bb4625c4a8717930c86", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 31000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 34000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141387,7 +151891,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "31000", + "earnings": "34000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141447,10 +151951,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "28f894eafc23e05eb558", + "claim_id": "4161e0d52649a240230d", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 32000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 35000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141468,7 +151972,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "32000", + "earnings": "35000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141528,10 +152032,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "954d437c73a629da9840", + "claim_id": "24259052a0cd4f343a8f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 33000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 36000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141549,7 +152053,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "33000", + "earnings": "36000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141609,10 +152113,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4bb4625c4a8717930c86", + "claim_id": "867bc2386cd205745276", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 34000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 37000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141630,7 +152134,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "34000", + "earnings": "37000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141690,10 +152194,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4161e0d52649a240230d", + "claim_id": "e71d86dfdd752a94eb73", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 35000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 38000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141711,7 +152215,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "35000", + "earnings": "38000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141771,10 +152275,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "24259052a0cd4f343a8f", + "claim_id": "b0e7b0e509a1a76eb8b9", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 36000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 39000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141792,7 +152296,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "36000", + "earnings": "39000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141852,10 +152356,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "867bc2386cd205745276", + "claim_id": "db192b5f001e0acd0c81", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 37000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 4000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141873,7 +152377,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "37000", + "earnings": "4000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -141885,7 +152389,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -141908,10 +152412,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 0.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -141933,10 +152437,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e71d86dfdd752a94eb73", + "claim_id": "b49235fbe6819fc13fd3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 38000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 40000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -141954,7 +152458,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "38000", + "earnings": "40000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142014,10 +152518,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b0e7b0e509a1a76eb8b9", + "claim_id": "182dff67000399270ed8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 39000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 41000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142035,7 +152539,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "39000", + "earnings": "41000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142095,10 +152599,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "db192b5f001e0acd0c81", + "claim_id": "f42080865f73c39986e1", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 4000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 42000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142116,7 +152620,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "4000", + "earnings": "42000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142128,7 +152632,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "0" + "value_verbatim": "220.1462" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142151,10 +152655,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 0.0, + "external_value": 220.1462, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142176,10 +152680,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b49235fbe6819fc13fd3", + "claim_id": "a3628878a5af99eab6c2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 40000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 43000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142197,7 +152701,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "40000", + "earnings": "43000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142257,10 +152761,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "182dff67000399270ed8", + "claim_id": "a9b9c99f3ddaad62ea8a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 41000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 44000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142278,7 +152782,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "41000", + "earnings": "44000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142338,10 +152842,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "f42080865f73c39986e1", + "claim_id": "b7ded692740012907add", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 42000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 45000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142359,7 +152863,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "42000", + "earnings": "45000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142371,7 +152875,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "270.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142394,10 +152898,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 270.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 270.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142419,10 +152923,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3628878a5af99eab6c2", + "claim_id": "1b4b4542d59fd9efc720", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 43000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 46000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142440,7 +152944,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "43000", + "earnings": "46000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142452,7 +152956,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "410.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142475,10 +152979,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 410.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 410.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142500,10 +153004,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a9b9c99f3ddaad62ea8a", + "claim_id": "815f5d0ece1ae30d23de", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 44000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 47000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142521,7 +153025,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "44000", + "earnings": "47000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142533,7 +153037,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "220.1462" + "value_verbatim": "550.4588" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142556,10 +153060,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 220.1462, + "external_value": 550.4588, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 220.1462, + "external_value_pe_sign": 550.4588, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142581,10 +153085,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b7ded692740012907add", + "claim_id": "c49cce47d26c1d5d27b0", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 45000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 48000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142602,7 +153106,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "45000", + "earnings": "48000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142614,7 +153118,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "270.4588" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142637,10 +153141,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 270.4588, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 270.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142662,10 +153166,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1b4b4542d59fd9efc720", + "claim_id": "98be12cebfc529b1cd10", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 46000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 49000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142683,7 +153187,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "46000", + "earnings": "49000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142695,7 +153199,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "410.4588" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142718,10 +153222,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 410.4588, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 410.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142743,10 +153247,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "815f5d0ece1ae30d23de", + "claim_id": "a18ada81dd54ea335ef8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 47000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 5000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142764,7 +153268,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "47000", + "earnings": "5000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142776,7 +153280,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "550.4588" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -142799,10 +153303,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 550.4588, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 550.4588, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -142824,10 +153328,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c49cce47d26c1d5d27b0", + "claim_id": "8dadafbe3bf0fb0ddbcd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 48000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 50000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142845,7 +153349,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "48000", + "earnings": "50000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142905,10 +153409,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "98be12cebfc529b1cd10", + "claim_id": "dd6cea05595173b93703", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 49000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 51000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -142926,7 +153430,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "49000", + "earnings": "51000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -142986,10 +153490,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a18ada81dd54ea335ef8", + "claim_id": "13fdecb5f020c68b701a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 5000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 52000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143007,7 +153511,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "5000", + "earnings": "52000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143019,7 +153523,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143042,10 +153546,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143067,10 +153571,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8dadafbe3bf0fb0ddbcd", + "claim_id": "639d082f402bfcff98ec", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 50000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 53000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143088,7 +153592,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "50000", + "earnings": "53000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143148,10 +153652,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "dd6cea05595173b93703", + "claim_id": "22f21b670f0aa25b74b8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 51000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 54000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143169,7 +153673,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "51000", + "earnings": "54000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143229,10 +153733,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13fdecb5f020c68b701a", + "claim_id": "e3aa4cfb40ea54beac8b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 52000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 55000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143250,7 +153754,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "52000", + "earnings": "55000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143310,10 +153814,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "639d082f402bfcff98ec", + "claim_id": "a57d6451fab16db0a9db", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 53000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 56000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143331,7 +153835,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "53000", + "earnings": "56000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143391,10 +153895,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "22f21b670f0aa25b74b8", + "claim_id": "e22a4bf0d0af9a3f3720", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 54000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 57000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143412,7 +153916,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "54000", + "earnings": "57000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143472,10 +153976,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e3aa4cfb40ea54beac8b", + "claim_id": "c0a599410b27950de717", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 55000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 58000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143493,7 +153997,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "55000", + "earnings": "58000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143553,10 +154057,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a57d6451fab16db0a9db", + "claim_id": "21b94eec2b7dca74b73a", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 56000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 59000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143574,7 +154078,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "56000", + "earnings": "59000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143634,10 +154138,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e22a4bf0d0af9a3f3720", + "claim_id": "29700f726d59e1df2a00", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 57000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 6000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143655,7 +154159,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "57000", + "earnings": "6000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143667,7 +154171,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143690,10 +154194,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143715,10 +154219,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c0a599410b27950de717", + "claim_id": "4845a19d7cad33f3ce75", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 58000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 60000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143736,7 +154240,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "58000", + "earnings": "60000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143796,10 +154300,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "21b94eec2b7dca74b73a", + "claim_id": "51a529a918342633a2d3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 59000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 61000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143817,7 +154321,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "59000", + "earnings": "61000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143877,10 +154381,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "29700f726d59e1df2a00", + "claim_id": "d082556ae57b7419cc1c", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 6000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 62000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143898,7 +154402,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "6000", + "earnings": "62000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -143910,7 +154414,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -143933,10 +154437,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -143958,10 +154462,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4845a19d7cad33f3ce75", + "claim_id": "b06d8576e4a7fae7b217", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 60000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 63000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -143979,7 +154483,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "60000", + "earnings": "63000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144039,10 +154543,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "51a529a918342633a2d3", + "claim_id": "a7f0daf26f8154d7a926", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 61000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 64000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144060,7 +154564,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "61000", + "earnings": "64000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144120,10 +154624,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "d082556ae57b7419cc1c", + "claim_id": "ce644cadddd2f637dc11", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 62000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 65000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144141,7 +154645,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "62000", + "earnings": "65000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144201,10 +154705,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b06d8576e4a7fae7b217", + "claim_id": "bea06b159005f6c6ef9e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 63000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 66000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144222,7 +154726,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "63000", + "earnings": "66000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144282,10 +154786,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a7f0daf26f8154d7a926", + "claim_id": "0a70fba72e2aaa84a3fb", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 64000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 67000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144303,7 +154807,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "64000", + "earnings": "67000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144363,10 +154867,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce644cadddd2f637dc11", + "claim_id": "01896ab61c64cc6dc9ad", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 65000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 68000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144384,7 +154888,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "65000", + "earnings": "68000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144444,10 +154948,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "bea06b159005f6c6ef9e", + "claim_id": "22dcc9e1370b03864a01", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 66000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 69000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144465,7 +154969,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "66000", + "earnings": "69000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144525,10 +155029,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0a70fba72e2aaa84a3fb", + "claim_id": "591260ab136938684942", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 67000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 7000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144546,7 +155050,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "67000", + "earnings": "7000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144558,7 +155062,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -144581,10 +155085,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -144606,10 +155110,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "01896ab61c64cc6dc9ad", + "claim_id": "215efbfb42dc69416670", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 68000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 70000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144627,7 +155131,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "68000", + "earnings": "70000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144687,10 +155191,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "22dcc9e1370b03864a01", + "claim_id": "ce57424e7c89ef057961", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 69000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 71000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144708,7 +155212,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "69000", + "earnings": "71000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144768,10 +155272,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "591260ab136938684942", + "claim_id": "6bf539ecd5e112236af4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 7000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 72000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144789,7 +155293,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "7000", + "earnings": "72000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144801,7 +155305,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" + "value_verbatim": "603.4957" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -144824,10 +155328,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, + "external_value": 603.4957, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, + "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -144849,10 +155353,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "215efbfb42dc69416670", + "claim_id": "a1fb568cd270c84e5c74", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 70000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 73000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144870,7 +155374,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "70000", + "earnings": "73000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -144930,10 +155434,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ce57424e7c89ef057961", + "claim_id": "8124e25b2e2efe5f1f20", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 71000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 74000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -144951,7 +155455,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "71000", + "earnings": "74000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145011,10 +155515,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6bf539ecd5e112236af4", + "claim_id": "9fe7d6220dbf07d3eccc", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 72000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 75000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145032,7 +155536,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "72000", + "earnings": "75000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145092,10 +155596,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a1fb568cd270c84e5c74", + "claim_id": "44d3901e1a6c601993e6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 73000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 76000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145113,7 +155617,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "73000", + "earnings": "76000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145173,10 +155677,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8124e25b2e2efe5f1f20", + "claim_id": "3a414355a663ceb12987", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 74000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 77000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145194,7 +155698,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "74000", + "earnings": "77000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145254,10 +155758,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "9fe7d6220dbf07d3eccc", + "claim_id": "aff7a315c044724a4f6f", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 75000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 78000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145275,7 +155779,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "75000", + "earnings": "78000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145335,10 +155839,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "44d3901e1a6c601993e6", + "claim_id": "8d88acb69a401541e5b6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 76000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 79000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145356,7 +155860,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "76000", + "earnings": "79000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145416,10 +155920,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3a414355a663ceb12987", + "claim_id": "1010791d1b192f878df8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 77000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 8000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145437,7 +155941,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "77000", + "earnings": "8000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145449,7 +155953,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -145472,10 +155976,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -145497,10 +156001,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "aff7a315c044724a4f6f", + "claim_id": "aebb4cb72868b9ed169b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 78000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 80000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145518,7 +156022,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "78000", + "earnings": "80000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145578,10 +156082,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "8d88acb69a401541e5b6", + "claim_id": "782debd16234ab5d2d5b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 79000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 81000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145599,7 +156103,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "79000", + "earnings": "81000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145659,91 +156163,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1010791d1b192f878df8", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 8000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "8000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "aebb4cb72868b9ed169b", + "claim_id": "a7fee44b6298b93eef72", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 80000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 82000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145761,7 +156184,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "80000", + "earnings": "82000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145821,10 +156244,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "782debd16234ab5d2d5b", + "claim_id": "3eb6391c4283d0a917bf", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 81000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 83000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145842,7 +156265,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "81000", + "earnings": "83000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145902,10 +156325,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a7fee44b6298b93eef72", + "claim_id": "26ea437b0f15d9bb43be", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 82000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 84000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -145923,7 +156346,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "82000", + "earnings": "84000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -145983,10 +156406,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "3eb6391c4283d0a917bf", + "claim_id": "e0eb0b06fc065c3e7a4e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 83000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 85000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146004,7 +156427,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "83000", + "earnings": "85000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146064,10 +156487,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "26ea437b0f15d9bb43be", + "claim_id": "fcacec9605852f95e183", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 84000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 86000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146085,7 +156508,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "84000", + "earnings": "86000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146145,10 +156568,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "e0eb0b06fc065c3e7a4e", + "claim_id": "0a5540360e3f29bb32c9", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 85000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 87000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146166,7 +156589,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "85000", + "earnings": "87000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146226,10 +156649,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fcacec9605852f95e183", + "claim_id": "c088a61a5906224e6661", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 86000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 88000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146247,7 +156670,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "86000", + "earnings": "88000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146307,10 +156730,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0a5540360e3f29bb32c9", + "claim_id": "13222c58729a8e8ec1a7", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 87000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 89000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146328,7 +156751,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "87000", + "earnings": "89000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146388,10 +156811,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c088a61a5906224e6661", + "claim_id": "5ccd8200ac0315441b29", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 88000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 9000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146409,7 +156832,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "88000", + "earnings": "9000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146421,7 +156844,7 @@ "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" + "value_verbatim": "35.99089" }, "measure": { "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", @@ -146444,10 +156867,10 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, + "external_value": 35.99089, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -146469,10 +156892,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "13222c58729a8e8ec1a7", + "claim_id": "7f3f49698a58db18452e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 89000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 90000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146490,7 +156913,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "89000", + "earnings": "90000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146550,91 +156973,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5ccd8200ac0315441b29", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 9000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "earnings": "9000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "35.99089" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 35.99089, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 35.99089, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null - }, - "results": [], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "7f3f49698a58db18452e", + "claim_id": "31bd5381cb2820c8e5f6", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 90000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 91000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146652,7 +156994,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "90000", + "earnings": "91000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146712,10 +157054,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "31bd5381cb2820c8e5f6", + "claim_id": "4920c6e94a89d122df3e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 91000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 92000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146733,7 +157075,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "91000", + "earnings": "92000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146793,10 +157135,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "4920c6e94a89d122df3e", + "claim_id": "67603d8fdeb1a70274a8", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 92000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 93000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146814,7 +157156,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "92000", + "earnings": "93000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146874,10 +157216,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "67603d8fdeb1a70274a8", + "claim_id": "fe64d87d0a68f647a7f4", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 93000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 94000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146895,7 +157237,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "93000", + "earnings": "94000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -146955,10 +157297,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fe64d87d0a68f647a7f4", + "claim_id": "5f3bd59b23084e2de3e2", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 94000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 95000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -146976,7 +157318,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "94000", + "earnings": "95000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147036,10 +157378,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "5f3bd59b23084e2de3e2", + "claim_id": "a3bd93e5eab5fb4c3cee", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 95000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 96000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147057,7 +157399,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "95000", + "earnings": "96000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147117,10 +157459,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "a3bd93e5eab5fb4c3cee", + "claim_id": "be7bd83396c3a34442fd", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 96000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 97000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147138,7 +157480,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "96000", + "earnings": "97000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147198,10 +157540,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "be7bd83396c3a34442fd", + "claim_id": "55eb739f0ee9f768a576", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 97000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 98000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147219,7 +157561,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "97000", + "earnings": "98000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147279,10 +157621,10 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "55eb739f0ee9f768a576", + "claim_id": "65fa2ec5e082727f0a0e", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 98000", + "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 99000", "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", "window": "", "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", @@ -147300,7 +157642,7 @@ "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "98000", + "earnings": "99000", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2030-31", "geography": "UK", @@ -147360,84 +157702,75 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "65fa2ec5e082727f0a0e", + "claim_id": "a08e1521d074011ce421", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Real increase in tax liability / Earnings 99000", - "name": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", + "source_column": "2026-27", + "name": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Flourish 26497565: Effect of new threshold freezes on employee tax liabilities in 2030-31 (IFS data item, 27 Nov 2025)", - "url": "https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/26497565/embed", - "metric": "average_tax_change", + "publication_title": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2031, + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_since_2011_fy2026", "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the new triple lock applied since 2011 against spending as it is", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "earnings": "99000", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "incidence": "employer NICs rise assumed incident on employees", - "income_axis": "employee earnings (\u00a3, 2025-26 prices)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "price_base": "2025-26 prices", - "reform_hint": "new threshold freezes: income tax and NICs thresholds (including the employer NICs secondary threshold) frozen for three further years to April 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the employee's tax liability", - "unit_population": "individual employee", - "value_verbatim": "603.4957" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "fy": "2026-27", + "price_basis": "cash, 2026-27", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (expenditure in 2026-27 'would be \u00a39 billion lower')", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a39 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": 603.4957, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:tax_increase:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 603.4957, + "reform_key": "8e17757fd40fb263", + "external_value": 9000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -9000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -7253585729.199216, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"history_since_2012_gross_fy2026\", \"field\": \"trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.805953969911024, + "delta": -16253585729.199215 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -7253585729.199216, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"history_since_2012_gross_fy2026\", \"field\": \"trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -147652,6 +157985,83 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "85e0adaf74f06a20923e", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2034-35", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_saving_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "IFS's expectation ('we expect'); not stated whether gross spending or net of tax", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "not stated", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the reform 'will save around \u00a34 billion per year')", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-price-basis-not-stated: The comparison takes IFS's 'around \u00a34 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the \u00a311bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about \u00a34.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is \u00a32.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8029533136675016, + "delta": -7211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-price-basis-not-stated: The comparison takes IFS's 'around \u00a34 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the \u00a311bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about \u00a34.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is \u00a32.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "ab1977b0d4a5bebcc7c2", "source": "ifs", @@ -148778,6 +159188,162 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "9dbeaaa5d65adab8054f", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039-40, range high", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_range_high_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.5568431827525536, + "delta": -31136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7722e305e72571c0bf0c", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2039-40, range low", + "name": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_range_low_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "fy": "2039-40", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -2.7842159137627682, + "delta": -15136863655.051073 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "ifs-range-of-outcomes: IFS's \u00a34bn to \u00a320bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (\u00a311.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (\u00a33.9bn to \u00a318.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "e85d1329a69f36bd540e", "source": "ifs", @@ -171727,6 +182293,308 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f6312ce2feae21469395", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annual cost of a permanent electricity VAT cut", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_vat_cut_permanent_annual_cost", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate made permanent", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1c2e01042aeed16a", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -1.0333333333333334, + "delta": -3050000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8e0937c6231e31775400", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "19ef9f65bb9ad8de", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.68125, + "delta": -5380000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "94527daa06a339c9677d", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32.7 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "19ef9f65bb9ad8de", + "external_value": 2700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.8074074074074075, + "delta": -4880000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "059df1c2d9ae37dc8a00", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual cost of a permanent cut", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_vat_permanent_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the annual cost of keeping the cut beyond 31 March 2027, whose first year is 2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 1500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.9666666666666667, + "delta": -2950000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "47a54f754504b06fad4b", "source": "ifs", @@ -172022,32 +182890,258 @@ }, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", - "external_value": 400000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:not_this_quantity", - "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "external_value": 400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "unknown", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:not_this_quantity", + "external_value_pe_sign": null, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "992cf9045b3e6dbb2413", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "Freezes to the employee and self-employed NICs thresholds (primary threshold / lower profits limit since July 2022 and April 2023; upper earnings limit since April 2021) versus default uprating", + "scenario": "current policy (employee and self-employed NICs threshold freezes)", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "085b03d8f3a69af6", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c3bd749d25d0bc1007dc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "England", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "No band-multiplier parameter at the pin. council_tax_band and the council_tax liability exist on the bundle, so the option is a CONSTRUCTION: scale council_tax by 2 where band is G or H (England), via a simulation modifier; stated as constructed.", + "reform_hint": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (revenue to central government)", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (\u00a34.4 billion)" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", + "program": "council_tax", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "council_tax" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "47935814eb2f7ce4", + "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c50b921fd6817a8487c4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025 (inflation, earnings and other incomes)", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "keep all currently frozen NICs and income tax thresholds frozen for two further years (until April 2030)", + "scope": "includes extending the freeze of the employer NICs secondary threshold", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a38.3 billion a year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", + "external_value": 8300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", + "external_value_pe_sign": 8300000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.9615991285733363, + "delta": -318727232.8413086 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 7981272767.158691, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", + "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "992cf9045b3e6dbb2413", + "claim_id": "dc69ba150b68b9e55b32", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -172072,18 +183166,18 @@ "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", "fy": "2029-30", "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "Freezes to the employee and self-employed NICs thresholds (primary threshold / lower profits limit since July 2022 and April 2023; upper earnings limit since April 2021) versus default uprating", - "scenario": "current policy (employee and self-employed NICs threshold freezes)", + "reform_hint": "Freezes to the thresholds at which the basic (20%) and higher (40%) rates of income tax begin to apply (current policy, frozen since April 2021, due to end April 2028) versus default CPI uprating", + "scenario": "current policy (basic- and higher-rate threshold freezes to April 2028)", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a33 billion a year" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a339 billion a year" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "085b03d8f3a69af6", - "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "reform_key": "0a361f3d9c7bebbc", + "external_value": 39000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 3000000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 39000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172105,7 +183199,7 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c3bd749d25d0bc1007dc", + "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", "source_column": "", @@ -172120,37 +183214,25 @@ "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "England", + "geography": "UK", "program": null, "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "England", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "No band-multiplier parameter at the pin. council_tax_band and the council_tax liability exist on the bundle, so the option is a CONSTRUCTION: scale council_tax by 2 where band is G or H (England), via a simulation modifier; stated as constructed.", - "reform_hint": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (revenue to central government)", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "a new council tax surcharge that acted to double council tax rates on band G and H properties (\u00a34.4 billion)" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__council_tax_double_bands_g_and_h_england", - "program": "council_tax", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "council_tax" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "47935814eb2f7ce4", - "external_value": 4400000000.0, + "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 4400000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172172,144 +183254,45 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c50b921fd6817a8487c4", - "source": "ifs", - "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "window": "", - "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", - "period_start": null, - "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, - "conditions": { - "basis": "static", - "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025 (inflation, earnings and other incomes)", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "keep all currently frozen NICs and income tax thresholds frozen for two further years (until April 2030)", - "scope": "includes extending the freeze of the employer NICs secondary threshold", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a38.3 billion a year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] - }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "cdd331f931966963", - "external_value": 8300000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "result_oriented_to_claim", - "external_value_pe_sign": 8300000000.0, - "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "current_law", - "latest": { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.9615991285733363, - "delta": -318727232.8413086 - }, - "results": [ - { - "value": 7981272767.158691, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "two_year_variant_of_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031 on the certified world (ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025_option__personal_tax_threshold_freeze_two_more_years_to_2030_2029.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:59:57.816596+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2029 on the certified world proxies FY 2029-30; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "PE static exchequer effect = \u0394gov_tax \u2212 \u0394gov_spending on the certified world", - "claim sign: positive = yield to the Exchequer, PE's own orientation" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" - } - ], - "diagnosis": null - }, - { - "claim_id": "dc69ba150b68b9e55b32", + "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "How are frozen tax thresholds reshaping who pays personal taxes? (Delestre, Oulton, Waters; IFS comment, DOI 10.1920/co.ifs.2025.0070)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-are-frozen-tax-thresholds-reshaping-who-pays-personal-taxes", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", "conditions": { - "basis": "static", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "forecast_vintage": "OBR March 2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "Freezes to the thresholds at which the basic (20%) and higher (40%) rates of income tax begin to apply (current policy, frozen since April 2021, due to end April 2028) versus default CPI uprating", - "scenario": "current policy (basic- and higher-rate threshold freezes to April 2028)", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a339 billion a year" + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "0a361f3d9c7bebbc", - "external_value": 39000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 39000000000.0, + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -172331,40 +183314,45 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", - "external_value": 20000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -174673,6 +185661,67 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f21ebec2320c9c12c6f4", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Subsidy level 1 (families not in receipt of means-tested benefits) 75%, subsidy level 2 (families in receipt of means-tested benefits) 95%: Cost", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "benefit_cost", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "current market rates and take up (Table S.1 note)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "IPPR's figure is the total cost of one subsidy replacing both Tax-Free Childcare and the UC childcare element (95% for UC families) and covering school-age care, in a world with 30 free hours for every child from six months, at 2022 rates. The analysis publishes the change in spending from replacing Tax-Free Childcare alone with a 75% subsidy, keeping the UC element at 85% and the 2025 entitlements, in 2027-28 to 2029-30. Its results file also holds the reform's spending on the subsidy (legs.subsidy.spending.tax_free_childcare, 5.5062 in 2027), which the dashboard does not publish and which leaves out UC families; neither figure measures IPPR's quantity.", + "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", + "scope": "total cost of the scheme, before the Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare spending it replaces", + "sign_convention": "positive = spending on the scheme", + "subsidy_rates": "75% of costs for families not on means-tested benefits; 95% for families on them", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "749db1b6edb574ff", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "bc2a557801796af138ca", "source": "ippr", @@ -177936,6 +188985,128 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "191b30d8daacfd7dfadc", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Universal 15-hour offer for two-year-olds: cost per annum", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "ages": "two-year-olds", + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds_fy2022", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under \u00a3100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.9 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "6ed38b702a1b0e27", + "external_value": 900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "78914d869fbad04926dc", + "source": "ippr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Universal offer of 15 funded hours per week for under twos: cost per annum", + "name": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", + "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "conditions": { + "ages": "under twos, modelled from six months", + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos_fy2022", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2022-23", + "geography": "England", + "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", + "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under \u00a3100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline.", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.9 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1abb3501cc4aa692", + "external_value": 900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -900000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "af0126e0f2cdd3a746e9", "source": "ippr", @@ -188894,6 +200065,137 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f530eb3894d7d857003b", + "source": "itep", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", + "name": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2023, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "itep_arpa_ctc_cost_ca_2023", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "ITEP scores the 2021 design in 2023, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable credit included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", + "tax_year": "2023", + "value_verbatim": "-$10,705,800" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -10705800000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -10705800000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4a9e3cca4ebaee48769c", + "source": "itep", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", + "name": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", + "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "wptra", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026", + "basis": "static", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "California", + "program": "wptra", + "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", + "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable EITC included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", + "tax_year": "2026", + "value_verbatim": "-$2,523,100" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "51f53788a8375c2d", + "external_value": -2523100000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2523100000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2400731391.718506, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"wptra_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[2].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 0.9515006903089477, + "delta": 122368608.28149414 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2400731391.718506, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"wptra_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[2].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "256e2230f3480d4272d5", "source": "jct", @@ -196374,6 +207676,85 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "65d635205506df7b1a15", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "value to the average household", + "name": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "JRF also moves the Warm Home Discount off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average household", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a360 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 60.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 60.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 2.1666666666666665, + "delta": 70.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "5ffca7194aa9533095f3", "source": "jrf", @@ -200823,6 +212204,143 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "aba93f2ccff65b4d934d", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of an EPG-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", + "name": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "July 2026 cost projections", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A cap holding prices at the April 2026 cap, on July 2026 projections; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a32.5bn, \u00a317.51bn, \u00a340.02bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "program_note": "Energy Price Guarantee-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "af552f4096a22b06", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a8ccdfbda29f4b0767d6", + "source": "jrf", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost of an EPG-style intervention", + "name": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", + "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "JRF states no period for its \u00a35 billion and prices it on April 2026 projections of the July 2026 cap; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path.", + "period_basis": "no period stated; the intervention would start in July 2026, in 2026-27", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "program_note": "energy price guarantee", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "448ac62bfbb77ae6", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.444, + "delta": -12220000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -7220000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"cap_freeze_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "cap-freeze-unstated-period: Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to \u00a3300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of \u00a31,663 and \u00a31,723, Cornwall Insight's \u00a31,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "19b295d6f2ae6fb9d235", "source": "jrf", @@ -201878,6 +213396,164 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "a4f27e8f43fe16b12fab", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average saving per year", + "name": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "average across Ofgem household archetypes", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3120" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 120.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 120.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.0833333333333333, + "delta": 10.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "71e38e0e0e8be6f4f63c", + "source": "mcs_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "cost to the Treasury per year", + "name": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", + "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost the Treasury'", + "value_verbatim": "just over \u00a33 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.2766666666666666, + "delta": -6830000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "e598532e06e1a4b95e8f", "source": "md_admin", @@ -203502,6 +215178,130 @@ "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/55" } }, + { + "claim_id": "6e85ea09710040ba0c06", + "source": "nef", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", + "name": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_low_fy2025", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "fy": "2025-26", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition.", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "~\u00a33" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a7f3d7a4c1536d89", + "external_value": 3000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f8a2b25f8d51e7475655", + "source": "nef", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", + "name": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", + "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "England", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "analysis_claim": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_high_fy2025", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "fy": "2025-26", + "geography": "England", + "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition.", + "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", + "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "3.4bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "a7f3d7a4c1536d89", + "external_value": 3400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3400000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "bc03594bf85e384ac116", "source": "nef", @@ -206308,7 +218108,108 @@ "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 0.18467634608195596, + "delta": 2.853632788713154 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "2.89.2", + "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", + "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", + "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", + "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", + "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" + ], + "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1622ccd142efd0f6cb0e", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "decile 7", + "name": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/2025-autumn-budget-reaction", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "horizon": "freeze to 2030-31 (implied)", + "income_concept": "real household disposable income", + "income_group": "decile_7", + "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "reform_hint": "the extension of the income-tax threshold freeze to 2031", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "value_verbatim": "3.5 per cent" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax", + "ni_class_1_employee", + "ni_class_1_employer", + "ni_class_4" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", + "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", + "external_value": -3.5, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3.5, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -0.7779929807480296, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.89.2", "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", @@ -206323,12 +218224,12 @@ ], "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.18467634608195596, - "delta": 2.853632788713154 + "ratio": 0.2222837087851513, + "delta": 2.7220070192519703 }, "results": [ { - "value": -0.6463672112868458, + "value": -0.7779929807480296, "status": "constructed", "engine_version": "2.89.2", "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", @@ -206348,104 +218249,185 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "1622ccd142efd0f6cb0e", + "claim_id": "13921a0208c75c7eb7c9", "source": "niesr", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "decile 7", - "name": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", + "source_column": "Additional households in absolute poverty", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "window": "", - "publication_title": "2025 Autumn Budget Reaction: A High-Tax, High-Debt Steady State", - "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/2025-autumn-budget-reaction", - "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2031, + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_absolute_poverty_households_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "horizon": "freeze to 2030-31 (implied)", - "income_concept": "real household disposable income", - "income_group": "decile_7", - "measure_key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "reform_hint": "the extension of the income-tax threshold freeze to 2031", - "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", - "value_verbatim": "3.5 per cent" + "fy": "2026-27", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "pe_missing": "NIESR counts households below an absolute after-housing-costs line in 2026-27, from a functional VAR of oil shocks and the income distribution; the analysis counts households below an anchored before-housing-costs line in 2027-28 after netting the price rises off income (newly_below_line_households_low, _central, _severe: 185,699, 750,843, 1,159,588), a different year, line and method.", + "poverty_line": "absolute: 60% of 2023/24 median household income", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the absolute poverty line", + "value_verbatim": "195,000" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax", - "ni_class_1_employee", - "ni_class_1_employer", - "ni_class_4" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.allowances.personal_allowance.amount", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.uk[1].threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.primary_threshold", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_1.thresholds.upper_earnings_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.lower_profits_limit", - "gov.hmrc.national_insurance.class_4.thresholds.upper_profits_limit" - ] + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 195000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 195000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, - "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "e542376bc4ed0687", - "external_value": -3.5, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "931f28dd4f2e26083785", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Additional households in relative poverty", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_relative_poverty_households_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "pe_missing": "A relative-poverty count for 2026-27, whose line moves with the median; the analysis holds its line fixed at the 2027-28 pre-shock median and counts households newly below it in 2027-28, a different year and line.", + "poverty_line": "relative: 60% of 2026/27 median household income", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the relative poverty line", + "value_verbatim": "5,000" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 5000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -3.5, + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 5000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": -0.7779929807480296, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed", - "ratio": 0.2222837087851513, - "delta": 2.7220070192519703 + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, - "results": [ - { - "value": -0.7779929807480296, - "status": "constructed", - "engine_version": "2.89.2", - "data_bundle": "populace-uk-2023-dd68c73-4aa4b14-20260619T023711Z", - "release": "8c73-4aa4b14", - "construction": "delta_on_modified_baseline on the certified world (ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031); artifact results/uk/ab2025/ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031_2030.json", - "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "2026-09-28T10:49:51.376780+00:00", - "annotations": [ - "PE calendar year 2030 on the certified world proxies FY 2030-31; static, no behavioural response", - "executed baseline: certified world with pe_baseline_modifier; the claim is scored against current_law", - "per cent change in the group's household net income (housing basis BHC ASSUMED (the claim does not state it))" - ], - "baseline": "pre_ab2025__personal_tax_thresholds_freeze_to_2031", - "status_effective": "constructed" - } - ], + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "08e8ab0187d715b91f87", + "source": "niesr", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "\u00a310 per week Universal Credit uplift for 6 months", + "name": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", + "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "niesr_uc_uplift_10_six_months_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "autumn and winter", + "pe_missing": "A \u00a310 a week uplift for six months of 2026-27; the analysis costs a \u00a320 a week uplift for the whole of 2027-28 (uc_uplift_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a36.28bn), a different policy and year.", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "program_note": "\u00a310 a week Universal Credit uplift for six months", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "249d081ba12fdf76", + "external_value": 2000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -207138,6 +219120,84 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "b209e0e7726ba74ef59a", + "source": "ny_fiscal_note", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Forecast 2026", + "name": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", + "url": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "value_kind": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "New York", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "static; each tax expenditure measured separately, other provisions and behaviour held constant", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "geography": "New York", + "pe_missing": "Same reform, year and time basis as ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026, but not the same quantity: the report's figure is New York State tax on resident and nonresident returns, and the dashboard's is the net change in federal, state and New York City income tax less benefits for resident households (annotation ny-dependent-exemption-scope). The two are 0.7% apart.", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield from removing the exemption: Table 1 prints the dependent exemptions' tax expenditure, the liability the exemption removes, in millions of dollars", + "tax": "New York State personal income tax", + "tax_year": "2026", + "value_verbatim": "264.0" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "99597eee17190011", + "external_value": 264000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 264000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 265890931.5627365, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[6].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "ny-dependent-exemption-scope: The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.00716261955582, + "delta": 1890931.5627365112 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 265890931.5627365, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine-us==~1.729.5", + "data_bundle": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "release": "P on 2026-08", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"commit\": \"d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026\", \"field\": \"rows[6].res.dashboard.annual_cost\", \"path\": \"analysis/reform_scores/results.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard\", \"sha256\": \"b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "annotations": [ + "ny-dependent-exemption-scope: The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "a8fd159d67c404bc42ef", "source": "nz_treasury", @@ -321686,76 +333746,155 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fd0d8450084c8bfa6141", - "source": "obr_pmd", + "claim_id": "fd0d8450084c8bfa6141", + "source": "obr_pmd", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2030-31", + "name": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Policy_measures_database_November_2025_.xlsx", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025", + "basis": "forecast", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "costing_phase": "original_scorecard", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2030-31", + "geography": "UK", + "measure_key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "obr_measure_key": "autumn_budget_2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "sign_convention": "positive_gain_to_exchequer", + "tax_head": "Stamp duty", + "value_verbatim": "-25.641342" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", + "program": "income_tax", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "income_tax" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.additional", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.basic", + "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.higher" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "042a362ae0e01b97", + "external_value": -25641342.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -25641342.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025__policy_parameters", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e3e7db2c1f2b9155f4d0", + "source": "octopus_energy", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "2030-31", - "name": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", + "source_column": "further saving a year on electricity bills", + "name": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost \u00a3200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Policy measures database (November 2025)", - "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Policy_measures_database_November_2025_.xlsx", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", + "publication_title": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost \u00a3200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", + "url": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2031, + "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025", - "basis": "forecast", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "costing_phase": "original_scorecard", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2030-31", - "geography": "UK", - "measure_key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "obr_measure_key": "autumn_budget_2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "sign_convention": "positive_gain_to_exchequer", - "tax_head": "Stamp duty", - "value_verbatim": "-25.641342" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__property_income_separate_rates", - "program": "income_tax", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "income_tax" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.additional", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.basic", - "gov.hmrc.income_tax.rates.property.higher" - ] + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "Octopus moves every remaining levy (WHD, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT) off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "per family (not stated whether typical or mean)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a375" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "042a362ae0e01b97", - "external_value": -25641342.0, + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 75.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -25641342.0, + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 75.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "obr_pre_measures_autumn_budget_2025__policy_parameters", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", - "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.7333333333333334, + "delta": 55.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -331017,6 +343156,68 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "80dcc282d763cdcd88de", + "source": "ppic", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "share of children lifted out of poverty", + "name": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", + "url": "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "ppic_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "PPIC scores the 2021 design in 2018 data on the California Poverty Measure, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "California Poverty Measure (PPIC and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality)", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of poor children lifted out of poverty (fewer children in poverty)", + "value_verbatim": "32%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 32.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -32.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "4c559ea2068903e155fc", "source": "public_first", @@ -331893,6 +344094,164 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "e5fdb8732e39dd84b16d", + "source": "rea", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "typical dual-fuel bill saving", + "name": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs; its figure is for a typical household, not the mean over all households.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "typical dual-fuel household", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3112" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 112.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 112.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.1607142857142858, + "delta": 18.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2362ba6f433795190b25", + "source": "rea", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Treasury cost over a full year", + "name": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", + "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario ('over the course of a full year'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = revenue forgone by the Treasury (printed as 'would forgo')", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.196875, + "delta": -7030000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "b2d349aa50a7a601eebe", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332101,6 +344460,80 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "f6892c4460e3b2743b8d", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "share of households reached", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_share_fy2026", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "program_note": "targeted energy discount", + "value_verbatim": "around 40 per cent" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 40.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 40.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 41.7, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": 1.0425, + "delta": 1.7000000000000028 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 41.7, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "a1eaca088305c4e6eb81", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332599,6 +345032,400 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "0cc0c62def7fb2f18c1a", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "average discount per eligible household", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27), not per eligible household; its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input.", + "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over eligible households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3175" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 175.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 175.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 73.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "per-eligible-vs-all-households: RF's \u00a3175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 0.41714285714285715, + "delta": -102.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 73.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "per-eligible-vs-all-households: RF's \u00a3175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (\u00a373 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat \u00a3175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "157722b55f1b38c46348", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Feed in Tariffs", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the Feed-in Tariffs alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a324 a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "4c474815662dd663", + "external_value": 24.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 24.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.416666666666667, + "delta": 106.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01f3449bc494d103c45c", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "rest of the Renewables Obligation", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the remaining Renewables Obligation alone.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a326 a year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be8f788e1e114373", + "external_value": 26.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 26.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 5.0, + "delta": 104.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-components: Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill) and RF at \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's \u00a33.83bn and \u00a3130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "8c6799851591ef765826", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "total bill impact", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "mean over households, before VAT (\u00a3134 with it)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3128" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 128.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 128.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": 1.015625, + "delta": 2.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1e697c0e26214d15cbe9", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "value of the FiT and remaining RO per year", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 levy rates; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", + "statistic": "per household (RF gives the VAT cut's value 'for the typical household' two paragraphs earlier)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a342 per year" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "f08a90197a7df76d", + "external_value": 42.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 42.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": 3.0952380952380953, + "delta": 88.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": 130.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"same\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "levy-scope-120-assumption: The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes \u00a3120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a \u00a33.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. \u00a31.5bn and \u00a353 a household (\u00a3780m and \u00a3730m), RF at \u00a342 a year and, as mean averages, \u00a326 and \u00a324 a year, Good Energy at \u00a30.61bn and \u00a30.57bn (\u00a320.45 and \u00a319.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-\u00a32,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near \u00a30.7bn. \u00a3120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of \u00a3128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around \u00a3120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's \u00a3112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its \u00a33.83bn is close to RF's \u00a33.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's \u00a33.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over \u00a33bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from \u00a32,580m in 2026-27 to \u00a32,100m), and the FiT part (\u00a30.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. \u00a30.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about \u00a32.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's \u00a342 is per household and the dashboard's \u00a3130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is \u00a3120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "96369379e09773cb026b", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -332807,6 +345634,67 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "7895dccb9fd9c5e39dc0", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Median working-age household, change against no conflict", + "name": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households \u00a3480 worse off this year", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households \u00a3480 worse off this year", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_median_working_age_income_loss_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "pe_missing": "RF's figure is the median working-age household's real-income loss in 2026-27 against a no-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the mean direct cost of the price rises per household in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3538, \u00a31,334, \u00a32,304), a different year and statistic.", + "population": "working-age households", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "market pricing for energy after the ceasefire announcement, against no conflict", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as \u00a3480 worse off)", + "statistic": "median", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3480" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 480.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -480.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "303fb838efaeb155ce35", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -392082,6 +404970,238 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "58b8ec4c95ef449f75e3", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "after five years", + "name": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2034-35", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule.", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a35 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "159e3a7e10443cf5", + "external_value": 5000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.6423626509340012, + "delta": -8211813254.670006 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2034\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7fb23b7cba8cb9550988", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "2010s decade replayed", + "name": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "pe_missing": "One replayed historical decade, not an expectation over paths; the dashboard publishes no saving for a single replayed decade in 2039-40.", + "price_basis": "cash", + "program": "state_pension", + "scenario": "the 2030s repeat the decade following 2016", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a324 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "3451bda7a31bc458", + "external_value": 24000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -24000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-one-decade-replayed: RF's \u00a324bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.46403598562712806, + "delta": -35136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-one-decade-replayed: RF's \u00a324bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's \u00a311.14bn." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3d00d8d4e5cbfd322f0d", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "after ten years", + "name": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "state_pension", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/triple-lock", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2039-40", + "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule.", + "price_basis": "not stated", + "program": "state_pension", + "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a315 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "159e3a7e10443cf5", + "external_value": 15000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:spending:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.7424575770034049, + "delta": -26136863655.05107 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.6 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)", + "release": "d72b8d960b6)", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/triple-lock\", \"commit\": \"5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"ev_gross_fy2039\", \"field\": \"expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock\", \"sha256\": \"e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link: RF gives \u00a35bn after five years and \u00a315bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "58fb680ac65c11b696f6", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -393075,6 +406195,245 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "97d7ec09f35149db5dd1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise at current prices", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_current_prices_mar2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "wholesale prices at mid-March 2026 levels", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised (direct debit, typical consumption, GB; Figure 3)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3230" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 230.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 230.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a2343e5bfda3e8a7611f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise if recent highs persist", + "name": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_high_case_jul2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "recent highs in gas prices become the norm for the rest of the assessment period", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3440" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 440.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 440.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c276c38f1f9b6e9ccba1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise, best case", + "name": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_price_cap_rise_best_case_jul2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "best case: wholesale gas prices fall immediately to pre-war levels", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", + "statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3130" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 130.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 130.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "3ee9e893aeeee5f230ea", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Typical annual energy bill if recent price rises are sustained", + "name": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_typical_bill_rise_if_sustained", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "pe_missing": "A rise in the typical annual bill under the price cap at sustained March 2026 prices; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: \u00a3238, \u00a3713, \u00a31,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~\u00a3500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "scenario": "oil and gas price rises since the conflict began (to 4 March 2026) sustained", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the typical annual energy bill", + "statistic": "typical annual energy bill (Ofgem price cap)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a3500" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "baseline", + "reform_key": "03395a10966bb849", + "external_value": 500.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:bill_increase:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 500.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "132c51d617ac4c0106f4", "source": "resolution_foundation", @@ -414386,144 +427745,798 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c02612bd97e05eeee62f", + "claim_id": "c02612bd97e05eeee62f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "Warm Homes Discount and Energy Company Obligation to general taxation", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", + "reform_hint": "WHD and ECO funded from general taxation", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.3 billion per year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "domestic_energy_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", + "external_value": 1300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c270fe209963a53f127b", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "GB", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", + "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "component": "Carbon Price Support scrapped", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "GB", + "horizon": "fades to virtually zero by 2030", + "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "pe_expressibility": "partial", + "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", + "reform_hint": "Disbanding [the Carbon Price Support]", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3200 million per year" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", + "program": "energy_bills", + "computability": "partial", + "head_variables": [ + "domestic_energy_consumption", + "energy_bills_rebate" + ], + "parameter_paths": [] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", + "external_value": 200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "47fe58888758a3e1c88f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost of bringing the UC rise forward", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_uc_pc_uprating_brought_forward_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "annualised, from September 2026", + "pe_missing": "An annualised 2026-27 cost of bringing forward planned Universal Credit rises; the analysis's accelerated uprating raises CPI-uprated benefits by the shock's residual CPI addition in 2027-28 (accelerated_uprating_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.66bn, \u00a33.64bn, \u00a37.27bn), a different policy and year.", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "program_note": "Universal Credit standard allowance above-inflation rises brought forward to September 2026, plus a temporary Pension Credit boost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.2 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "5bda27a706e76715", + "external_value": 1200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6ef43f88a816f9e4f01f", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost of a blanket price cap offsetting the inflation rise", + "name": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_price_discount", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_energy_discounts_offset_cpi_cost", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2026-27", + "fy_note": "a year from Q3 2026", + "pe_missing": "A blanket discount sized to offset a 1.5 point CPI rise for a year from Q3 2026; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a32.5bn, \u00a317.51bn, \u00a340.02bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_price_discount", + "scoring_method": "full pass-through: 1.5 per cent of \u00a31.4 trillion of CPI-covered household spending, 'around \u00a320 billion annually' (footnote 9)", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "298b279d189b38fb", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "99faf909155dbfea78c9", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "source_column": "cost of the temporary scheme this year", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "GB", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_ted_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "static", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "Warm Homes Discount and Energy Company Obligation to general taxation", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "GB", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", - "reform_hint": "WHD and ECO funded from general taxation", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a31.3 billion per year" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "domestic_energy_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" - ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "'this year' in an October 2026 briefing, for a scheme switched on from January 2027", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "program_note": "targeted energy discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost \u00a32 billion'", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a32 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", - "external_value": 1300000000.0, + "reform_key": "81253fb0fae19ea9", + "external_value": 2000000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -1300000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -2000000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -2140000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -1.07, + "delta": -4140000000.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -2140000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "c270fe209963a53f127b", + "claim_id": "599d73275aebe63ce719", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", + "source_column": "full-year cost of each option", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Splitting the bill: How can Government help families with high energy bills? (Jonathan Marshall)", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/10/Splitting-the-bill.pdf", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", + "value_kind": "gbp", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "GB", - "program": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "warm_home_discount", "conditions": { - "action_link": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/issues/136", - "basis": "'per year'; first full year 2026-27 assumed", + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "component": "Carbon Price Support scrapped", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "GB", - "horizon": "fades to virtually zero by 2030", - "measure_key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "pe_expressibility": "partial", - "pe_missing": "Policy costs on bills are not parameters; the legs are constructions on electricity_consumption and gas_consumption (levy share x bill), the same shape as the announced RO measure.", - "reform_hint": "Disbanding [the Carbon Price Support]", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF's option adds \u00a3570 to the Warm Home Discount; the dashboard's adds \u00a3100.", + "period_basis": "a full year of support in 2026-27 (RF: 'If any of the options were brought in for only part of a year (such as from the October price cap) they would have a proportionately lower cost')", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a33.75 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "2aa7809414d06d94", + "external_value": 3750000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3750000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -780000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-570-not-100: RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by \u00a3570, sized to its \u00a33.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by \u00a3100. The two price different changes to the same scheme." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -0.208, + "delta": -4530000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -780000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"whd_top_up_cost_fy2026\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "whd-570-not-100: RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by \u00a3570, sized to its \u00a33.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by \u00a3100. The two price different changes to the same scheme." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "7d69cebde4a74c79c0f1", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annual cost of the VAT cut in future years", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_annual_cost_future_years", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate continued after 31 March 2027", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "around \u00a3200 million per year" + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.7 billion" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025_option__energy_levies_whd_eco_ro_fit_cps_off_bills", - "program": "energy_bills", - "computability": "partial", - "head_variables": [ - "domestic_energy_consumption", - "energy_bills_rebate" + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "1c2e01042aeed16a", + "external_value": 1700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed", + "ratio": -0.9117647058823529, + "delta": -3250000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -1550000000.0, + "status": "constructed", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"elec_vat_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "constructed" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "30a22f60ca0cdeeddf0e", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost relative to current policy, 2027-28", + "name": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "lower_bound", + "fy": "2027-28", + "pe_missing": "RF costs a gradual reversal of the 5p cut against current policy; the analysis costs keeping the whole 5p cut for 2027-28, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "steady fuel duty rises reversing the 5p cut, then about 3 per cent a year", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer, relative to current policy", + "value_verbatim": "over \u00a31 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "71add44c3b0ea34f", + "external_value": 1000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -1000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." ], - "parameter_paths": [] + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -2.18, + "delta": -3180000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -2180000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==5.3.0 policyengine_uk==2.90.2", + "data_bundle": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "release": "6 (bundle uk", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/middle-east-war-living-standards\", \"commit\": \"45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"fuel_duty_cut_cost_low\", \"field\": \"policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn\", \"path\": \"dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards\", \"sha256\": \"382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "fuel-duty-different-policies: Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over \u00a31 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, \u00a32.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same \u00a32.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4386b03d13fd70f68a2b", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "annual cost in future years", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_annual_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "period_basis": "the annual cost of the 0% rate in future years, the first of which is 2027-28", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a31.7 billion" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "772e36b38e65606f", - "external_value": 200000000.0, + "reform_key": "0797df4ce01fa5a1", + "external_value": 1700000000.0, "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -200000000.0, + "external_value_pe_sign": -1700000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { - "value": null, - "status": "not_computed", - "engine_version": "", - "data_bundle": "", - "release": "", - "construction": "", + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", "policyengine_variables": [], - "computed_at": "", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", "annotations": [], - "baseline": null, - "status_effective": "not_computed", - "ratio": null, - "delta": null + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable", + "ratio": -0.8529411764705882, + "delta": -3150000000.0 }, - "results": [], + "results": [ + { + "value": -1450000000.0, + "status": "comparable", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": true, \"estimate\": \"extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "comparable" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2d9d37f7b21aba27d650", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "costs transferred to taxpayers", + "name": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF does not list its 'remaining levies' here; its Power struggle (March 2026) counts the remaining policy costs as the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, more than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity levies", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as costs transferred 'from billpayers to taxpayers')", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a32.6 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 2600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -2600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.4730769230769232, + "delta": -6430000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "0b9c264b1f6c21419208", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "full-year cost of removing more policy costs", + "name": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "Great Britain", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "analysis_claim": "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2027-28", + "geography": "Great Britain", + "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT.", + "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", + "program": "electricity_policy_costs", + "program_note": "electricity and gas policy costs", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", + "value_verbatim": "around \u00a33.75 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "9590b97fcfae8cfc", + "external_value": 3750000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3750000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch", + "ratio": -1.0213333333333334, + "delta": -7580000000.0 + }, + "results": [ + { + "value": -3830000000.0, + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "engine_version": "policyengine==6.2.7 policyengine_core==3.33.0 policyengine_uk==2.125.1", + "data_bundle": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "release": "1002T230158Z", + "construction": "{\"analysis\": \"uk/energy-autumn-budget\", \"commit\": \"4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be\", \"compared\": false, \"estimate\": \"remove_levies_cost_fy2027\", \"field\": \"options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn\", \"path\": \"src/data/options.json\", \"relation\": \"opposite\", \"repo\": \"PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget\", \"sha256\": \"c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba\", \"superseded_on\": null}", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "annotations": [ + "wider-levy-scope: These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its \u00a3120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption)." + ], + "baseline": "current_law", + "status_effective": "concept_mismatch" + } + ], "diagnosis": null }, { @@ -421724,49 +435737,170 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "b1c70abe1e003ca4808c", + "claim_id": "b1c70abe1e003ca4808c", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age with kids", + "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "household_type": "Working-age with kids", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", + "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", + "unit_population": "households", + "value_verbatim": "2.53%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", + "external_value": 0.0253, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0253, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "6f8a0ac4b386ede74638", + "source": "resolution_foundation", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age, no kids", + "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "household_type": "Working-age, no kids", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", + "income_group": "all", + "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", + "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", + "unit_population": "households", + "value_verbatim": "4.30%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", + "external_value": 0.043, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.043, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a29af8606a518d8f969e", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age with kids", - "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, poorest fifth", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", - "metric": "share_no_change", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2030, + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_poorest_fifth", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "household_type": "Working-age with kids", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", - "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", - "unit_population": "households", - "value_verbatim": "2.53%" + "fy": "2026-27", + "income_group": "quintile_1", + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the bottom quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "value_verbatim": "16 per cent" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", - "external_value": 0.0253, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 0.16, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0253, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.16, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -421786,49 +435920,46 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "6f8a0ac4b386ede74638", + "claim_id": "8c4e58628e774581842e", "source": "resolution_foundation", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "No change (+/-\u00a310p.a.) / Working-age, no kids", - "name": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", + "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, richest fifth", + "name": "Trimming the VAT", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Stairway to headroom: Putting the Autumn Budget 2025 decisions on tax, spending and borrowing into context", - "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/11/Stairway-to-headroom.pdf", - "metric": "share_no_change", + "publication_title": "Trimming the VAT", + "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", - "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "period": 2030, + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "rf_vat_cut_share_richest_fifth", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "country": "UK", - "estimate_kind": "approx_chart_reading", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", - "geography": "UK", - "household_type": "Working-age, no kids", - "housing_costs": "ahc", - "income_axis": "net equivalised household income vigintile, after housing costs", - "income_group": "all", - "no_change_band": "+/-\u00a310 per year", - "reform_hint": "tax and benefit policies announced since Autumn Budget 2024", - "unit_population": "households", - "value_verbatim": "4.30%" + "fy": "2026-27", + "income_group": "quintile_5", + "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the top quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", + "value_verbatim": "25 per cent" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "bbb12ea8853515cb", - "external_value": 0.043, + "reform_key": "706b5a24b72be424", + "external_value": 0.25, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", "sign_basis": "level", - "external_value_pe_sign": 0.043, + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.25, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "rf_permanent_measures_since_ab2024", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -431153,63 +445284,259 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "0153f63556b8ce75975b", - "source": "trussell_wpi", + "claim_id": "0153f63556b8ce75975b", + "source": "trussell_wpi", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", + "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "measure_type": "relative change", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", + "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", + "subgroup": "children", + "value_verbatim": "a 15% decrease" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", + "external_value": -15.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -15.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "acda07109bec1f3c3286", + "source": "trussell_wpi", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", + "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", + "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "measure_type": "relative change", + "pe_expressibility": "expressible", + "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", + "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", + "subgroup": "all people", + "value_verbatim": "a 7% decrease" + }, + "measure": { + "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", + "program": "universal_credit", + "computability": "expressible", + "head_variables": [ + "universal_credit", + "child_tax_credit" + ], + "parameter_paths": [ + "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", + "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" + ] + }, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", + "external_value": -7.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -7.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4190a011999733649ed0", + "source": "tuc", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_high", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.8bn" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "ac7a488a6f353f32", + "external_value": 3800000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3800000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a3ffebf3f9efa29c2d56", + "source": "tuc", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", - "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", - "metric": "poverty_rate_change", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_high", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", - "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "measure_type": "relative change", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", - "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", - "subgroup": "children", - "value_verbatim": "a 15% decrease" - }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" - ] + "estimate_kind": "range_high", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35.9bn" }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", - "external_value": -15.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -15.0, + "reform_key": "b8151f6cd328def3", + "external_value": 5900000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5900000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -431229,63 +445556,107 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "acda07109bec1f3c3286", - "source": "trussell_wpi", + "claim_id": "b4bb15c70b966d6a0f20", + "source": "tuc", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Our response to lifting the two-child limit (Helen Barnard, press release)", - "url": "https://www.trussell.org.uk/news-and-research/news/our-response-to-lifting-the-two-child-limit", - "metric": "poverty_rate_change", - "unit_concept": "percent", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2027, - "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", "conditions": { - "baseline_policy": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_low", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "benchmark_class": "different_model", - "counterfactual": "WPI Economics projection of hunger and hardship to 2026/27 (Year 5) from a 2022/23 FRS base under policy as of April 2025 (\"headline estimates made for the 2022/23 year, year five policy impacts based on results from 2026/27\"), 2023/24 prices", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2026-27", - "geography": "UK", - "hardship_definition": "a family faces hunger and hardship if it is more than 25% below the Social Metrics Commission poverty line (WPI technical report, footnote 1)", - "horizon": "by 2027 (WPI Year 5 = 2026/27)", - "measure_key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "measure_type": "relative change", - "pe_expressibility": "expressible", - "poverty_measure": "wpi_severe_hardship", - "reform_hint": "Removing it in full", - "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number expected to face hunger and hardship", - "subgroup": "all people", - "value_verbatim": "a 7% decrease" + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", + "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a35.2bn" }, - "measure": { - "key": "ab2025__uc_child_element_remove_two_child_limit", - "program": "universal_credit", - "computability": "expressible", - "head_variables": [ - "universal_credit", - "child_tax_credit" - ], - "parameter_paths": [ - "gov.dwp.tax_credits.child_tax_credit.limit.child_count", - "gov.dwp.universal_credit.elements.child.limit.child_count" - ] + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "b8151f6cd328def3", + "external_value": 5200000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -5200000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fe39fe0bcab0a4f14051", + "source": "tuc", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", + "name": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", + "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_low", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "estimate_kind": "range_low", + "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below \u00a320,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: \u00a30.71bn, \u00a32.12bn, \u00a34.25bn), a different design and year.", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", + "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a33.4bn" + }, + "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "7a6e8bc22701a1c1", - "external_value": -7.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": -7.0, + "reform_key": "ac7a488a6f353f32", + "external_value": 3400000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -3400000000.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", - "claim_baseline": "wpi_hunger_and_hardship_projection_2026_27", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { "value": null, "status": "not_computed", @@ -471972,6 +486343,191 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "316573c62fe7e0edaf3c", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Number removed (thousands)", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_children_removed_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = children removed from poverty, i.e. fewer children in poverty", + "value_verbatim": "613" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": 613000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -613000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "12e6457518e550604c6b", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage change", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (percentage change after implementation)", + "value_verbatim": "-33.3%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -33.3, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -33.3, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "95a11dac98b507dce1b7", + "source": "urban", + "country": "US", + "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage-point change", + "name": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", + "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2018, + "time_basis": "annual", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "California", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "analysis_claim": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "country": "US", + "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", + "geography": "California", + "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", + "population": "children", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "program": "arpa_ctc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (change after implementation)", + "value_verbatim": "-6.8%" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "fed62140ac0cbc7e", + "external_value": -6.8, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:more_poverty:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -6.8, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "93368a42000c01f07cc3", "source": "ut_admin", diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/README.md b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fba359063 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# Energy bills and the Autumn Budget 2026: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md). The dashboard was +published on 14 October 2026, before the gate existed. The search ran on 21 October 2026, a +week before the Budget, so no Budget-day costing exists yet. + +## What is pinned + +`analysis.json` pins 39 estimates from `PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget` at `4d916d5`, +the commit behind the production deployment of 14 October 2026: + +- for each option and year, the cost to government, the share of households helped and the + average gain over all households (`src/data/options.json`); +- the reach of the Warm Home Discount top-up in 2026-27, 7.85m households (`options.json`); +- the average extra energy cost against April–June 2026 rates (`src/data/years.json`). + +Both files match the run's receipt (`reproducibility.json`, 12 October 2026: policyengine +6.2.7, policyengine-uk 2.125.1, Microcosm UK 2024-25). + +Some published figures are not pinned: + +- The breakdowns by decile, household type and region. The search found no producer that + publishes them for these options. +- The bill levels: a mean of £1,649 and £1,789, and a typical bill of £1,996 and £2,170. The + vocabulary has no metric for an energy bill level, only `energy_bill_change`. +- The quarterly price path. It is the dashboard's input (Ofgem caps and forecasts), not an + estimate. +- The poverty effects. They are in the results file but not on the page. + +## What the search found + +The search covered every UK producer and staged 30 claims from 11 producers. + +| Producer | What was staged | +|---|---| +| Resolution Foundation | The targeted discount's cost, reach and average; the levies in total and one by one; the VAT rate's annual cost; a £570 Warm Home Discount increase | +| IFS | A permanent 0% VAT rate on electricity | +| Centre for British Progress | The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation (RO) and the Feed-in Tariffs (FiT), the option's exact scope | +| JRF | A wider levy scope; an EPG-style cap | +| Open search | DESNZ's Warm Home Discount caseload and the VAT cut's average saving; Good Energy's levy components and its £300 to Warm Home Discount recipients; wider-levy costings (MCS Foundation, REA, the Electricity Bills Taskforce, Octopus Energy); the Green Party's freeze | + +Two figures were logged as found but not staged, because neither has a readable primary: +the Treasury's reported £600m for a £100 Warm Home Discount top-up, and the energy secretary's +reported £120 and £3.2bn levy plan. + +## The gaps + +**Levy removal.** The dashboard puts the option at £3.83bn and £130 a household. That is +155% above CBP's c. £1.5bn, and 145% and 210% above CBP's and RF's per-household values. + +- The option does not price its two levies. It applies a press-reported £120 typical-bill + saving (`LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL`) as a 12.6% cut to every electricity bill. +- The two levies it names are worth about £50 a household. RF's mean averages are £26 and + £24; Good Energy puts them at £0.61bn and £0.57bn. +- £120 is what producers put on removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of £128, the + MCS Foundation's £120 and the REA's £112. Those estimates sit beside the option as concept + mismatches. +- Against those wider scopes, the dashboard's cost is within 2% of RF's £3.75bn (every + remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support) and 20–28% above the REA's £3.2bn and + the MCS Foundation's £3bn. +- The annotation cites the code, CBP, RF, MCS Foundation, REA, Good Energy and HM Treasury's + costing of the 75% of the RO already moved. + +**Warm Home Discount top-up reach.** The dashboard reaches 7.85m households, 33% above DESNZ's +5.9m rebates. + +- The dashboard's proxy pays every household with a means-tested benefit. That population is + close to DESNZ's 8.3m households on a qualifying benefit, an English Housing Survey count + cited in the annotation rather than staged. +- DESNZ's impact assessment explains why only about 70–85% of those households get the rebate. +- On DESNZ's 5.9m, £100 a household would cost about £0.59bn, against the dashboard's £0.78bn. + No producer's costing of the top-up has a readable primary. + +**Close matches.** + +| Comparison | Dashboard against producer | +|---|---| +| Targeted discount cost (RF) | +7% | +| Targeted discount share of households (RF) | +4% | +| VAT extension cost in 2027-28 (IFS) | −3% | +| VAT extension cost in 2027-28 (RF) | −15% | +| VAT cut's average saving (DESNZ) | +9% | + +RF's £1.7bn is twice the government's £850m for six winter months, so it is staged with +`source_model: arithmetic`. + +**Denominators.** The dashboard's shares and means count all UK households, with Northern +Ireland at zero for the options paid only in Great Britain. Against Great Britain figures they +therefore read slightly low. + +## Periods + +Producers give levy, VAT and per-household figures per year at 2026 rates. These are staged +against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the Budget and the only year the +dashboard costs those options; `conditions.period_basis` says so on each claim. + +The year does not explain the levy gap. On the Treasury's costing the RO part falls in 2027-28, +and the FiT part (£0.57bn to c. £0.73bn) is too small to make up a difference of about £2.3bn. + +## Not read + +- Energy UK's report returned 401. +- Cornwall Insight, the Commons Library and obr.uk returned 403. The OBR was read through + Wayback and gov.uk mirrors. +- ifs.org.uk's HTML pages returned 403. The Green Budget PDF was read, but its launch day + could not be confirmed (the PDF was created on 10 October, first archived on 15 October), so + its date is the month as printed. +- landmaneconomics.co.uk did not resolve. +- The Guardian and FT reports are known only from press citations. +- The session's web search budget ran out before an obr.uk site search and deeper searches of + ECIU, Green Alliance, Uswitch and MoneySavingExpert. diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2f0dc7998 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,1500 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "country": "UK", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "energy-autumn-budget", + "country_id": "uk" + }, + "title": "Energy bills and the Autumn Budget 2026", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "published": "2026-10-14", + "owner": { + "author": "vahid-ahmadi" + }, + "scope": "uk_wide", + "subject": "Household energy bills at forecast prices in 2026-27 and 2027-28 (the average extra cost against April–June 2026 cap rates), and the cost to government, reach and average gain of seven Autumn Budget 2026 energy support options: a Resolution Foundation-style targeted discount, a £100 Warm Home Discount top-up, a £300 Cost of Living Payment, £400 to every household, a cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, keeping 0% VAT on domestic electricity through 2027-28, and moving the remaining Renewables Obligation and Feed-in Tariff levies to taxation.", + "search_terms": [ + "energy bill support cost 2026", + "energy price guarantee cost", + "Autumn Budget 2026 energy bills", + "household energy bills forecast 2027", + "warm home discount expansion cost", + "targeted energy discount cost", + "electricity VAT zero rate cost 2027-28", + "remaining levies off electricity bills cost", + "cost of living payment 2026 cost", + "energy price cap freeze cost" + ], + "worlds": { + "targeted_discount_flat": { + "policy": "uk_energy_targeted_discount_flat_175", + "description": "The dashboard's simplified Resolution Foundation discount: a flat £175 to every Great Britain household on a means-tested benefit or whose highest individual income is under £24,000, on annual income, with full take-up." + }, + "rf_targeted_energy_discount": { + "policy": "uk_energy_rf_targeted_energy_discount", + "description": "The Resolution Foundation's Targeted Energy Discount: a discount on gas and electricity unit prices for households on means-tested benefits or whose highest individual income over the previous three months is under £24,000, funded from general taxation (Billing me softly; Hitting the buffers)." + }, + "whd_top_up": { + "policy": "uk_energy_whd_top_up_100", + "description": "£100 on top of the £150 Warm Home Discount, paid from taxation; the dashboard models it as £100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit." + }, + "cost_of_living_payment": { + "policy": "uk_energy_cost_of_living_payment_300", + "description": "A £300 Cost of Living Payment to households on means-tested benefits, the 2022-24 design." + }, + "whd_recipients_payment_300": { + "policy": "uk_energy_whd_recipients_payment_300", + "description": "Good Energy's proposal: an additional £300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients this winter." + }, + "flat_400": { + "policy": "uk_energy_bills_support_400", + "description": "£400 off every household's energy bill, the 2022 Energy Bills Support Scheme design." + }, + "cap_freeze": { + "policy": "uk_energy_cap_freeze_apr_jun_2026", + "description": "Household energy prices held at the April–June 2026 price cap (unit rates and standing charges), the government paying suppliers the difference: an Energy Price Guarantee at the April 2026 level." + }, + "extend_vat_cut": { + "policy": "uk_energy_domestic_electricity_vat_zero_2027_28", + "description": "VAT on domestic electricity in Great Britain kept at 0% through 2027-28 instead of returning to 5% on 1 April 2027 (SI 2026/987 sets 0% from 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027)." + }, + "remove_levies": { + "policy": "uk_energy_remove_remaining_ro_and_fit", + "description": "The remaining 25% of the domestic Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs moved from household electricity bills to general taxation." + }, + "remove_remaining_ro": { + "policy": "uk_energy_remove_remaining_ro", + "description": "The remaining 25% of the domestic Renewables Obligation moved from household electricity bills to general taxation: one of the two levies in the dashboard's option." + }, + "remove_fit": { + "policy": "uk_energy_remove_fit", + "description": "The Feed-in Tariffs moved from household electricity bills to general taxation: one of the two levies in the dashboard's option." + }, + "whd_increase_570": { + "policy": "uk_energy_whd_increase_570", + "description": "The Resolution Foundation's option of raising the Warm Home Discount payment by £570 (Power struggle, March 2026)." + }, + "remove_wider_levies": { + "policy": "uk_energy_remove_wider_electricity_levies", + "description": "More than the remaining Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs moved from household electricity bills to general taxation: at least the Warm Home Discount as well, and for most producers every remaining levy (each producer's list is in its claim's reform_hint)." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Cost to government of the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2026-27", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2140000000, + "value_raw": "2.14", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026", + "label": "Share of households helped by the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2026-27", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 41.7, + "value_raw": "41.7", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2026-27", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 73, + "value_raw": "73", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Cost to government of the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2026-27", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -780000000, + "value_raw": "0.78", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "warm_home_discount" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_share_fy2026", + "label": "Share of households helped by the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2026-27", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 26.7, + "value_raw": "26.7", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_avg_gain_fy2026", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2026-27", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 27, + "value_raw": "27", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_households_fy2026", + "label": "Households reached by the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2026-27", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "affected_count", + "unit_concept": "households", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7850000, + "value_raw": "7.85", + "normalization": "millions x 1e6", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "take_up": "full", + "published_as": "our 2026-27 proxy reaches about 7.8 million (policy box, Dashboard.jsx)", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=whd_top_up].recipients_m" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Cost to government of the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2026-27", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2430000000, + "value_raw": "2.43", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_share_fy2026", + "label": "Share of households helped by the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2026-27", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 27.6, + "value_raw": "27.6", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_avg_gain_fy2026", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2026-27", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 83, + "value_raw": "83", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Cost to government of the £400 to every household, 2026-27", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -11740000000, + "value_raw": "11.74", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "flat_energy_payment" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=flat_400].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_share_fy2026", + "label": "Share of households helped by the £400 to every household, 2026-27", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 100.0, + "value_raw": "100.0", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "flat_energy_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=flat_400].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_avg_gain_fy2026", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the £400 to every household, 2026-27", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 400, + "value_raw": "400", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "flat_energy_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=flat_400].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Cost to government of the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2026-27", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7220000000, + "value_raw": "7.22", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_share_fy2026", + "label": "Share of households helped by the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2026-27", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 94.6, + "value_raw": "94.6", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_avg_gain_fy2026", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2026-27", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 246, + "value_raw": "246", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2026-27, option_id=cap_freeze].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2027-28", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2110000000, + "value_raw": "2.11", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2027-28", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 40.9, + "value_raw": "40.9", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the targeted discount (RF, simplified: flat £175), 2027-28", + "world": "targeted_discount_flat", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 72, + "value_raw": "72", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "rf_targeted_discount", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "targeted_energy_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=rf_targeted_discount].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2027-28", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -790000000, + "value_raw": "0.79", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "warm_home_discount" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=whd_top_up].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2027-28", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 26.7, + "value_raw": "26.7", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=whd_top_up].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "whd_top_up_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the Warm Home Discount +£100 (means-tested-household proxy), 2027-28", + "world": "whd_top_up", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 27, + "value_raw": "27", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "whd_top_up", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "warm_home_discount", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=whd_top_up].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2027-28", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2430000000, + "value_raw": "2.43", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2027-28", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 27.5, + "value_raw": "27.5", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "cost_of_living_payment_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the £300 Cost of Living Payment, 2027-28", + "world": "cost_of_living_payment", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 83, + "value_raw": "83", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cost_of_living_payment", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cost_of_living_payment].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the £400 to every household, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -11780000000, + "value_raw": "11.78", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "flat_energy_payment" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=flat_400].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the £400 to every household, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 100.0, + "value_raw": "100.0", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "flat_energy_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=flat_400].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_400_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the £400 to every household, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_400", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 400, + "value_raw": "400", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "flat_400", + "method": "PolicyEngine reform; cost is the change in household net income summed over households", + "geography": "UK", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "flat_energy_payment", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=flat_400].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2027-28", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -11390000000, + "value_raw": "11.39", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cap_freeze].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2027-28", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 94.7, + "value_raw": "94.7", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cap_freeze].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "cap_freeze_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the cap freeze at April–June 2026 tariffs, 2027-28", + "world": "cap_freeze", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 387, + "value_raw": "387", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "cap_freeze", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's bill (forecast bill minus bill at April–June 2026 tariffs, floored at zero)", + "geography": "UK (Northern Ireland on GB prices as a proxy)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=cap_freeze].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "world": "extend_vat_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1450000000, + "value_raw": "1.45", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "extend_vat_cut", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (5/105 of the GB bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "extend_vat_cut_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "world": "extend_vat_cut", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 97.4, + "value_raw": "97.4", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "extend_vat_cut", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (5/105 of the GB bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the 0% VAT on domestic electricity kept through 2027-28, 2027-28", + "world": "extend_vat_cut", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 49, + "value_raw": "49", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "extend_vat_cut", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (5/105 of the GB bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=extend_vat_cut].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Cost to government of the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "world": "remove_levies", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -3830000000, + "value_raw": "3.83", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "options.json prints each option's cost to government as a positive number of pounds billion (cost_bn); revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "remove_levies", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (the share that takes £120 off the typical 2027-28 electricity bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "remove_levies_share_fy2027", + "label": "Share of households helped by the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "world": "remove_levies", + "metric": "affected_share", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 97.4, + "value_raw": "97.4", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "remove_levies", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (the share that takes £120 off the typical 2027-28 electricity bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "denominator": "all households", + "take_up": "full", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].share_receiving_pct" + } + }, + { + "key": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", + "label": "Average gain per household (all households) from the remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT moved to taxation, 2027-28", + "world": "remove_levies", + "metric": "average_annual_gain", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 130, + "value_raw": "130", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "option": "remove_levies", + "method": "price cut costed from each household's electricity bill (the share that takes £120 off the typical 2027-28 electricity bill)", + "geography": "Great Britain (paid to GB households; averages and shares over all UK households)", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", + "basis": "static" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/options.json", + "sha256": "c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba", + "field": "options[fy=2027-28, option_id=remove_levies].avg_per_household" + } + }, + { + "key": "price_rise_mean_extra_cost_fy2026", + "label": "Average extra energy cost per household at forecast prices against April–June 2026 cap rates, 2026-27", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 246, + "value_raw": "246", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "comparison": "current law at forecast prices minus the same kWh at April–June 2026 tariffs", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual bill", + "program": "domestic_energy_bills", + "basis_note": "static (same kWh at every price)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/years.json", + "sha256": "138a17f941e49c538d7dd1ccc9cdf5e6e746ce11834b453a4657773e86d1df19", + "field": "years[fy=2026-27].mean_extra_cost" + } + }, + { + "key": "price_rise_mean_extra_cost_fy2027", + "label": "Average extra energy cost per household at forecast prices against April–June 2026 cap rates, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 386, + "value_raw": "386", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "comparison": "current law at forecast prices minus the same kWh at April–June 2026 tariffs", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual bill", + "program": "domestic_energy_bills", + "basis_note": "static (same kWh at every price)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "commit": "4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be", + "computed_at": "2026-10-12T14:31:27+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.7", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "microcosm-uk-2024-25-national-20261002T230158Z-5c6b3f68", + "path": "src/data/years.json", + "sha256": "138a17f941e49c538d7dd1ccc9cdf5e6e746ce11834b453a4657773e86d1df19", + "field": "years[fy=2027-28].mean_extra_cost" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bf63b216f --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,235 @@ +[ + { + "id": "levy-scope-120-assumption", + "claims": [ + "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", + "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027" + ], + "status": "comparable", + "explains_gap": true, + "cause": "The dashboard does not price the two levies. It sets the cut so that it takes £120 off a typical 2027-28 electricity bill of 2,500 kWh, a figure it takes from press reports with a £3.2bn price tag (LEVY_SAVING_TYPICAL in budget_options.py, citing the Guardian of 6 October and the FT of 11 October 2026), and applies that share, 12.6%, to every GB household's electricity bill. The remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs are worth far less: CBP prices them together at c. £1.5bn and £53 a household (£780m and £730m), RF at £42 a year and, as mean averages, £26 and £24 a year, Good Energy at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill), and HM Treasury's costing of the 75% of the domestic RO already funded (-£2,100m in 2027-28) puts the remaining quarter near £0.7bn. £120 is the size producers give for removing every remaining policy cost: RF's mean of £128 for all of them (Power struggle), the MCS Foundation's average of around £120 (at its archetypes' 3,955 kWh), the REA's £112 for a typical bill. So the option prices that wider change under the narrower label (annotation wider-levy-scope): its £3.83bn is close to RF's £3.75bn for every remaining policy cost plus the Carbon Price Support, and 20-28% above the REA's £3.2bn and the MCS Foundation's just over £3bn. The year does not close the gap: the producers' figures are at 2026 levy rates, the RO part falls in 2027-28 (the Treasury's 75% costing goes from £2,580m in 2026-27 to £2,100m), and the FiT part (£0.57bn in Good Energy's table to c. £0.73bn in CBP's) is too small to make up a difference of about £2.3bn whatever its indexation. RF's £42 is per household and the dashboard's £130 is the mean over all households; the dashboard's own typical-household saving is £120, so the statistic accounts for little of the gap.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/energy_budget/budget_options.py#L56-L61" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/energy_budget/budget_options.py#L228-L233" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/components/Dashboard.jsx#L522" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf#page=14" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf#page=9" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf#page=16" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf#page=19" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/692872fd2a37784b16ecf676/Budget_2025-Policy_Costings.pdf#page=12" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "whd-proxy-caseload", + "claims": [ + "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026" + ], + "status": "constructed", + "explains_gap": true, + "cause": "The dashboard's proxy pays the £100 to every Great Britain household where anyone receives a listed means-tested benefit (the note on the option in its results file), so it reaches 7.85m households, close to the 8.3m DESNZ estimates are on a qualifying benefit. Not all of them receive the Warm Home Discount: the benefit recipient or partner must be named on the energy bill and data matching misses some households, so DESNZ expects around 5.9m rebates, from about 85% of Pension Credit recipients and about 70% of recipients of other means-tested benefits (impact assessment, paragraphs 38 to 40). A top-up paid with the rebate reaches those 5.9m, so the proxy overstates its reach by about a third. The dashboard states the gap itself ('Modelled caseload 7.8m households against about 6m in official estimates').", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf#page=11" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/options.json" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/energy_budget/budget_options.py#L306-L316" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "wider-levy-scope", + "claims": [ + "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", + "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", + "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", + "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", + "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "These producers price a wider change than the option, which moves only the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs off household electricity bills. The MCS Foundation removes all remaining social and environmental levies and the REA all remaining levies on household electricity bills; Octopus lists the Warm Home Discount, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT; JRF adds the Warm Home Discount; the Electricity Bills Taskforce adds the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy; RF's Power struggle moves the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC and removes the Carbon Price Support, and its August 'remaining levies' are not listed. They are shown beside the option because its £120 assumption is the size of this wider change (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf#page=16" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf#page=3" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf#page=9" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf#page=5" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "levy-components", + "claims": [ + "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", + "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", + "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", + "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Each figure prices one of the option's two levies, the remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation or the Feed-in Tariffs, not the option; the dashboard publishes no figure for either alone. Good Energy prices the two at £0.61bn and £0.57bn (£20.45 and £19.25 on a typical bill) and RF at £26 and £24 a year as mean averages; each pair is far below the dashboard's £3.83bn and £130 for both together (annotation levy-scope-120-assumption).", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf#page=9" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf#page=19" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "whd-570-not-100", + "claims": [ + "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "RF's option raises the Warm Home Discount payment by £570, sized to its £3.75 billion envelope for a full year; the dashboard's option raises it by £100. The two price different changes to the same scheme.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf#page=5" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "per-eligible-vs-all-households", + "claims": [ + "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "RF's £175 is the average discount per eligible household; the dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (£73 in 2026-27). Its per-eligible amount is the flat £175 it takes from RF as an input (the option's assumptions in its results file), so the two figures are not independent estimates.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf#page=29" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/options.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "whd-recipients-vs-means-tested-households", + "claims": [ + "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Good Energy pays £300 to the roughly 6 million Warm Home Discount recipients; the dashboard's £300 Cost of Living Payment, the 2022-24 design, goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1m in 2026-27 in its results file). The two pay different households, so their costs measure different policies.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf#page=11" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/options.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "cap-freeze-unstated-period", + "claims": [ + "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026", + "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Neither producer states the period its cost covers, and both priced the freeze before the October 2026 cap and the January 2027 forecast: JRF on 'current cost projections for July 2026' (9 April 2026), the Green Party in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to £300 per household'. The dashboard's 2026-27 cost holds every quarter of the year at April-June 2026 rates on its price path (Ofgem caps of £1,663 and £1,723, Cornwall Insight's £1,999 forecast for January-March 2027), as each household's forecast bill minus its bill at April-June tariffs (cap_freeze_support). A cost with no stated period on an earlier price path is not the dashboard's quantity.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/price_path.json" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/energy_budget/budget_options.py#L221-L225" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b56753f48 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +{"key": "rf_ted_cost_fy2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2000000000.0, "value_raw": "£2 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "'this year' in an October 2026 briefing, for a scheme switched on from January 2027", "geography": "Great Britain", "basis": "static", "program": "targeted_energy_discount", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost £2 billion'", "program_note": "targeted energy discount"}, "world": "rf_targeted_energy_discount", "reform_hint": "applying a temporary discount to gas and electricity prices for households where no individual has an income above £24,000", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "locator": "Summary, PDF page 5", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Summary", "source_column": "cost of the temporary scheme this year", "quote": "Such a temporary scheme would cost £2 billion this year and could provide an average £175 per eligible household, with heavier energy users enjoying more relief.", "note": "RF sets the scheme at £2 billion and derives the £175 average from it (Billing me softly, p.9: 'for a scheme costing £2 billion ... a flat discount ... would be worth, on average, £175 per household'); the dashboard fixes £175 and derives the cost.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_cost_fy2026", "across_worlds": {"reason": "Both give an average £175 to each eligible household in the same group (households on means-tested benefits and households whose highest individual income is under £24,000), so each cost is the eligible count times £175 and each share is that group's share of households. The dashboard's simplifications (a flat payment, an annual income test, full take-up) are listed in its results file.", "basis": [{"kind": "document", "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf#page=29"}, {"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/options.json"}]}}} +{"key": "rf_ted_share_fy2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "affected_share", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": 40.0, "value_raw": "around 40 per cent", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", "geography": "Great Britain", "denominator": "all households", "program": "targeted_energy_discount", "program_note": "targeted energy discount", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "rf_targeted_energy_discount", "reform_hint": "applying a temporary discount to gas and electricity prices for households where no individual has an income above £24,000", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "locator": "'Surgical strikes' section, PDF page 29", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "share of households reached", "quote": "A threshold of £24,000 would reach around 40 per cent of households, covering 75 per cent of those in the poorest four income deciles.", "note": "Billing me softly (10 August 2026, p.1) gives the same share for a threshold of £24,000 per year.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_share_fy2026", "across_worlds": {"reason": "Both give an average £175 to each eligible household in the same group (households on means-tested benefits and households whose highest individual income is under £24,000), so each cost is the eligible count times £175 and each share is that group's share of households. The dashboard's simplifications (a flat payment, an annual income test, full take-up) are listed in its results file.", "basis": [{"kind": "document", "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf#page=29"}, {"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/data/options.json"}]}}} +{"key": "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 175.0, "value_raw": "£175", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "the scheme proposed for this winter", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "mean over eligible households", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "targeted_energy_discount", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "rf_targeted_energy_discount", "reform_hint": "applying a temporary discount to gas and electricity prices for households where no individual has an income above £24,000", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "locator": "'Surgical strikes' section, PDF page 29", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "average discount per eligible household", "quote": "A £2 billion scheme, funded from general taxation rather than yet another levy on bills, could provide an average discount of £175 per eligible household.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rf_targeted_discount_avg_gain_fy2026", "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes the average gain over all households (£73 in 2026-27), not per eligible household; its per-eligible amount is the flat £175 it takes from RF as an input."} +{"key": "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2600000000.0, "value_raw": "around £2.6 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as costs transferred 'from billpayers to taxpayers')", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "remove the remaining 'levies' from electricity bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", "date": "2026-08-10", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "cc8414073c6421627c43333acc2ed2ae2952ad06ccd4f6a74be4cd9927060445", "locator": "PDF page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "costs transferred to taxpayers", "quote": "One is to remove the remaining ‘levies’ from electricity bills, transferring around £2.6 billion of costs from billpayers to taxpayers and thereby finishing the job that Rachel Reeves started in the 2025 Budget.", "note": "RF does not list the levies it counts.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "RF does not list its 'remaining levies' here; its Power struggle (March 2026) counts the remaining policy costs as the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Home Discount, the nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, more than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT."} +{"key": "rf_vat_annual_cost_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "arithmetic", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1700000000.0, "value_raw": "£1.7 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "the annual cost of the 0% rate in future years, the first of which is 2027-28", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "extend_vat_cut", "reform_hint": "the VAT cut on electricity ... unfunded in future years", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Trimming the VAT", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "locator": "paragraph on how the cut is funded", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "annual cost in future years", "quote": "In effect, today’s announcement is funded by departmental savings that have not been specified this year and is unfunded in future years (at an annual cost of £1.7 billion).", "note": "RF gives no method: £1.7 billion is twice the government's £850 million for the six months from October, which fall in winter, when more electricity is used.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027"}} +{"key": "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 42.0, "value_raw": "£42 per year", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 levy rates; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "per household (RF gives the VAT cut's value 'for the typical household' two paragraphs earlier)", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "remove_levies", "reform_hint": "funding some of these implicit taxes (the Feed-in-tariff and remainder of the Renewables Obligation)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Trimming the VAT", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "locator": "paragraph comparing the VAT cut with levies", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "value of the FiT and remaining RO per year", "quote": "And indeed a similar saving could have been delivered by funding some of these implicit taxes (the Feed-in-tariff and remainder of the Renewables Obligation are worth £42 per year, for example).", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027"}} +{"key": "ifs_vat_permanent_cost_fy2027", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1500000000.0, "value_raw": "around £1.5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "the annual cost of keeping the cut beyond 31 March 2027, whose first year is 2027-28", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", "program_note": "VAT on domestic electricity", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "extend_vat_cut", "reform_hint": "Making the cut in VAT on household electricity bills permanent", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 'The outlook for the public finances', section 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "annual cost of a permanent cut", "quote": "Making the cut in VAT on household electricity bills permanent would have an annual cost of around £1.5 billion, although the exact cost would depend on future household electricity spending.", "note": "The same paragraph restates the Treasury's £850 million for the six-month cut.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "extend_vat_cut_cost_fy2027"}} +{"key": "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_levy_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1500000000.0, "value_raw": "c. £1.5 bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Fiscal Cost'", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "remove_levies", "reform_hint": "removing the remaining 25% of the RO scheme and all of the feed-in tariff scheme costs from household bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", "date": "2026-06-01", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "9bffc6ae6405a1c3c716819c145b63ad6accf2bca8f61978e8f8953f33781552", "locator": "Section 1, table 'Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving', report page 14 of 29 (PDF page 14)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving", "source_column": "Fiscal Cost, Total Impact", "quote": "We estimate that removing the remaining 25% of the RO scheme and all of the feed-in tariff scheme costs from household bills would reduce domestic electricity bills by c. £53 p.a. at a cost of c. £1.5 bn p.a.", "note": "The table splits it as c. £780m p.a. (remaining 25% of the RO) and c. £730m p.a. (Feed-in Tariffs).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027"}} +{"key": "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_levy_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 53.0, "value_raw": "c. £53 p.a.", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates ('p.a.'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "average household electricity bill saving", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "renewables_obligation_and_feed_in_tariffs", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "remove_levies", "reform_hint": "removing the remaining 25% of the RO scheme and all of the feed-in tariff scheme costs from household bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", "url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", "date": "2026-06-01", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "9bffc6ae6405a1c3c716819c145b63ad6accf2bca8f61978e8f8953f33781552", "locator": "Section 1, table 'Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving', report page 14 of 29 (PDF page 14)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Policy / Fiscal Cost / Average Electricity Bill Saving", "source_column": "Average Electricity Bill Saving, Total Impact", "quote": "We estimate that removing the remaining 25% of the RO scheme and all of the feed-in tariff scheme costs from household bills would reduce domestic electricity bills by c. £53 p.a. at a cost of c. £1.5 bn p.a.", "note": "The table splits it as £27 p.a. (remaining 25% of the RO) and £26 p.a. (Feed-in Tariffs).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027"}} +{"key": "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", "source": "jrf", "found_by": "jrf", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "jrf_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 60.0, "value_raw": "£60 per year", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "average household", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "Removing what remains of the Renewable Obligation as well as the cost of the Feed-in Tariff and Warm Homes Discount from electricity bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", "date": "2026-10-14", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "primary_sha256": "9a41014178da34d4547fe48dcb48741de837603d3d1745e0ae0ada4ea1298be5", "locator": "section on inflation and levies", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "value to the average household", "quote": "Removing what remains of the Renewable Obligation as well as the cost of the Feed-in Tariff and Warm Homes Discount from electricity bills is worth £60 per year to the average household.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "JRF also moves the Warm Home Discount off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026", "source": "jrf", "found_by": "jrf", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "jrf_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5000000000.0, "value_raw": "£5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "no period stated; the intervention would start in July 2026, in 2026-27", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", "program_note": "energy price guarantee", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "cap_freeze", "reform_hint": "an EPG-style intervention that would cap prices at the April 2026 price cap", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", "date": "2026-04-09", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b6f5f95dd28bda01fb0afe064c977fa7084dad6d7167a463aaa75c273532e99", "locator": "section 'Comparing approaches'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "cost of an EPG-style intervention", "quote": "We have modelled each policy at a cost of £5 billion, which is reflective of the cost of an EPG-style intervention that would cap prices at the April 2026 price cap, based on current cost projections for July 2026.", "note": "The same paragraph splits it as £3.7 billion of support to gas bills and £1.3 billion to electricity.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", "pe_missing": "JRF states no period for its £5 billion and prices it on April 2026 projections of the July 2026 cap; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path."} +{"key": "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026", "source": "desnz", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "desnz_whd_appraisal", "metric": "affected_count", "unit_concept": "households", "value": 5900000.0, "value_raw": "around 5.9m", "normalization": "millions x 1e6", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "the cohort estimate for the 2026/27 to 2030/31 scheme; Table 6 costs 5.9m rebates in each year", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "warm_home_discount", "population": "households receiving a rebate", "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", "date": "2026-01-30", "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", "primary_sha256": "b0adabd4056cf33b4c718d79dc2c9edd410c24ef3d6f5e69e9a1302da7e6d9c0", "locator": "'Estimated cohort size', paragraph 40, PDF page 11", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Estimated cohort size", "source_column": "households receiving a rebate", "quote": "Out of the 8.3m households estimated to receive a qualifying means-tested benefit in GB, it is estimated that around 5.9m will go on to receive a rebate.", "note": "A projection for the 2026/27 to 2030/31 scheme from DESNZ's count of households on a qualifying benefit (the 8.3m, from the 2024 English Housing Survey scaled to GB, footnote 19) and the scheme's delivery experience. Footnote markers 19 and 20 are omitted from the quote. DESNZ's press releases of 31 July and 26 August 2026 put this winter's caseload at around six million.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "whd_top_up_households_fy2026", "across_worlds": {"reason": "A top-up of the Warm Home Discount is paid with the rebate, so it reaches the scheme's rebate recipients; the dashboard describes the option as £100 added to the £150 discount.", "basis": [{"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget/blob/4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be/src/components/Dashboard.jsx#L505-L515"}, {"kind": "document", "ref": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf#page=11"}]}}} +{"key": "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", "source": "mcs_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "mcs_foundation_levy_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3000000000.0, "value_raw": "just over £3 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'would cost the Treasury'", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "full levy reform, whereby all remaining social and environmental levies are removed from electricity bills and funded through general taxation", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", "date": "2026-06-30", "publisher": "The MCS Foundation", "primary_sha256": "92a088670a87fb9c8ef28bd24bd66371a4d29e40c2063000f9fb5680e8df3dd8", "locator": "Conclusion, PDF page 16", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "cost to the Treasury per year", "quote": "We estimate that delivering this policy through general taxation would cost the Treasury just over £3 billion per year.", "note": "'Just over' £3 billion, staged as a point.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", "source": "mcs_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "mcs_foundation_levy_model", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 120.0, "value_raw": "around £120", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at Q3 2026 price-cap policy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "average across Ofgem household archetypes", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "Removing the remaining levies from electricity bills and permanently funding them through general taxation", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", "url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", "date": "2026-06-30", "publisher": "The MCS Foundation", "primary_sha256": "92a088670a87fb9c8ef28bd24bd66371a4d29e40c2063000f9fb5680e8df3dd8", "locator": "Conclusion, PDF page 16", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "average saving per year", "quote": "Our analysis shows that every household archetype would benefit, with average savings of around £120 per year.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "MCS removes every remaining social and environmental levy from electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", "source": "rea", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rea_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3200000000.0, "value_raw": "£3.2 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario ('over the course of a full year'); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "sign_convention": "positive = revenue forgone by the Treasury (printed as 'would forgo')", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "scrap all remaining levies on household electricity bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", "date": "2026-08-27", "publisher": "Association for Renewables and Clean Technology (REA)", "primary_sha256": "01bdd1b25c8b7139befdb83d4da8da006a164362f4555e8098c61220031ee7d7", "locator": "third paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "Treasury cost over a full year", "quote": "By moving these levies onto general taxation, the Treasury would forgo £3.2 billion over the course of a full year, but the maths suggest it would get most of that back.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", "source": "rea", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rea_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 112.0, "value_raw": "around £112", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at REA's January 2027 price scenario; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "typical dual-fuel household", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "scrap all remaining levies on household electricity bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", "url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", "date": "2026-08-27", "publisher": "Association for Renewables and Clean Technology (REA)", "primary_sha256": "01bdd1b25c8b7139befdb83d4da8da006a164362f4555e8098c61220031ee7d7", "locator": "third paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "typical dual-fuel bill saving", "quote": "The REA is proposing a relatively simple answer: scrap all remaining levies on household electricity bills, cutting the typical dual-fuel household bill by around £112, or 6%, compared to the scenario in which ministers do not do this.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "REA removes all remaining levies from household electricity bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs; its figure is for a typical household, not the mean over all households."} +{"key": "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", "source": "electricity_bills_taskforce", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "electricity_bills_taskforce_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 100.0, "value_raw": "an additional £100 per year", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at current levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "average household", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "Removing the remainder of this levy [the Renewables Obligation], as well as the others mentioned above [the Feed-in-Tariff, the Warm Homes Discount and the Nuclear levy] from electricity", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", "url": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", "date": "2026-09-11", "publisher": "E3G", "primary_sha256": "f9bc10d809504d715732387f9f16df5c1d08847909deb51ab493c70163ba6ade", "locator": "paragraph beginning 'Examples of taxes which the Electricity Bills Taskforce advocates removing from bills'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "saving to the average household", "quote": "Removing the remainder of this levy, as well as the others mentioned above from electricity, would immediately reduce the average household bill by an additional £100 per year, bringing the total savings to almost £200 per year in 2029 onwards.", "note": "E3G publishes the Electricity Bills Taskforce's analysis (the letter's footnote 4).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "The Taskforce also removes the Warm Home Discount and the nuclear levy, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", "source": "octopus_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "octopus_energy_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 75.0, "value_raw": "£75", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 levy rates (no year stated); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "per family (not stated whether typical or mean)", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "shifted levies into general taxation ... The £75 includes levies for the Warm Homes Discount, Renewable Obligations, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and the Feed-in-Tariff.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost £200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", "url": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", "date": "2026-07-17", "publisher": "Octopus Energy", "primary_sha256": "4cf769de5e121d41258bf87a72f3e62f53a3072fc6ae6a8f1a183714f128a31f", "locator": "second bullet and footnote **", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "further saving a year on electricity bills", "quote": "Families could save a FURTHER £75 a year on electricity bills if the government shifted levies into general taxation, with higher earners picking up more of the cost through the tax system.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "Octopus moves every remaining levy (WHD, RO, Sizewell C, Network Charging Compensation, AAHEDC and FiT) off bills, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the Renewables Obligation and the Feed-in Tariffs."} +{"key": "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026", "source": "good_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "good_energy_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1800000000.0, "value_raw": "£1.8bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "a one-off payment this winter", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "cost_of_living_payment", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'at a cost of £1.8bn to the exchequer'", "program_note": "targeted payment", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "whd_recipients_payment_300", "reform_hint": "provide an additional £300 currently provided to approximately 6 million WHD recipients", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "primary_sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "locator": "'Immediate reforms', PDF page 11; table row 'Additional payment of £300 to 6m households', PDF page 19", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "cost to the exchequer", "quote": "Government should therefore provide an additional £300 currently provided to approximately 6 million WHD recipients, at a cost of £1.8bn to the exchequer.", "note": "", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "cost_of_living_payment_cost_fy2026", "pe_missing": "Good Energy pays £300 to Warm Home Discount recipients (about 6 million); the dashboard's £300 Cost of Living Payment goes to every household on a means-tested benefit (8.1 million)."} +{"key": "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", "source": "green_party", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "not_stated", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 8400000000.0, "value_raw": "approximately £8.4 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "no period stated; the guarantee would start with the July 2026 cap, in 2026-27", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "energy_price_cap_freeze", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'setting aside'", "program_note": "energy price guarantee", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "cap_freeze", "reform_hint": "guarantee right now that it will not allow energy bills to rise beyond the April-June price cap", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", "url": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Green Party of England and Wales", "primary_sha256": "930b4755c7f9fa81fb100bba40889394f2b4a74ffef7d778a4a814968f44b14f", "locator": "speech text, paragraph on energy bills", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "sum set aside", "quote": "That’s why the government should guarantee right now that it will not allow energy bills to rise beyond the April-June price cap – instead setting aside approximately £8.4 billion to prevent a rise of up to £300 per household that could be coming down the track.", "note": "A party's costing with no method given.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", "pe_missing": "The Green Party states no period for its £8.4 billion and set it in March 2026 against 'a rise of up to £300 per household'; the dashboard costs the full 2026-27 year on its own price path."} +{"key": "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 26.0, "value_raw": "£26 a year", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "mean over households", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_remaining_ro", "reform_hint": "moving into taxation: the rest of the Renewables Obligation", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "footnote 1", "source_column": "rest of the Renewables Obligation", "quote": "the rest of the Renewables Obligation (£26 a year on electricity unit prices), Feed in Tariffs (£24 a year on electricity unit prices)", "note": "the scenario's figures are 'mean averages and therefore slightly higher than those applied to ‘typical’ bills' (footnote 1).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the remaining Renewables Obligation alone."} +{"key": "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 24.0, "value_raw": "£24 a year", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "mean over households", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "feed_in_tariffs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_fit", "reform_hint": "moving into taxation: ... Feed in Tariffs", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "footnote 1", "source_column": "Feed in Tariffs", "quote": "the rest of the Renewables Obligation (£26 a year on electricity unit prices), Feed in Tariffs (£24 a year on electricity unit prices)", "note": "the scenario's figures are 'mean averages and therefore slightly higher than those applied to ‘typical’ bills' (footnote 1).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for the Feed-in Tariffs alone."} +{"key": "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 128.0, "value_raw": "£128", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "mean over households, before VAT (£134 with it)", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "Removing more policy costs from energy bills, as well as the carbon price support: the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Homes Discount, the Nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, and removing the Carbon Price Support", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "footnote 1, PDF page 9", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "footnote 1", "source_column": "total bill impact", "quote": "The total bill impact is an average of £128, but once reduced VAT is taken into account that rises to £134, or 8 per cent of the Q2 2026 price cap.", "note": "the scenario's figures are 'mean averages and therefore slightly higher than those applied to ‘typical’ bills' (footnote 1).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT."} +{"key": "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3750000000.0, "value_raw": "around £3.75 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at the Q2 2026 price cap (March 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "electricity_policy_costs", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", "program_note": "electricity and gas policy costs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_wider_levies", "reform_hint": "Removing more policy costs from energy bills, as well as the carbon price support: the rest of the RO, the FiT, the Warm Homes Discount, the Nuclear RAB, Network Charging Compensation, the Green Gas Levy and AAHEDC, and removing the Carbon Price Support", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "PDF page 5", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "full-year cost of removing more policy costs", "quote": "We consider four options in addition to a social tariff, all of which would cost around £3.75 billion if implemented for a full year, a realistic maximum that can be achieved through reducing policy costs, equivalent to roughly £130 per household:", "note": "RF calls £3.75 billion 'a realistic maximum that can be achieved through reducing policy costs' and sizes its other options to it.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "RF moves every remaining policy cost off bills and removes the Carbon Price Support, a wider change than the option's remaining 25% of the RO and the FiT."} +{"key": "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "resolution_foundation_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3750000000.0, "value_raw": "around £3.75 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "period_basis": "a full year of support in 2026-27 (RF: 'If any of the options were brought in for only part of a year (such as from the October price cap) they would have a proportionately lower cost')", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "warm_home_discount", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost)", "program_note": "Warm Home Discount", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "whd_increase_570", "reform_hint": "Increase the Warm Home Discount payment by £570", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "PDF page 5 (cost) and page 6 (the £570 option)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "full-year cost of each option", "quote": "We consider four options in addition to a social tariff, all of which would cost around £3.75 billion if implemented for a full year, a realistic maximum that can be achieved through reducing policy costs, equivalent to roughly £130 per household:", "note": "RF sizes the increase (£570) to its £3.75 billion envelope.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "whd_top_up_cost_fy2026", "pe_missing": "RF's option adds £570 to the Warm Home Discount; the dashboard's adds £100."} +{"key": "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", "source": "good_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "good_energy_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 610000000.0, "value_raw": "0.61", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_remaining_ro", "reform_hint": "Remaining 25% of Domestic RO to Exchequer", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "primary_sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts", "source_column": "Cost (£bn), Dom Elec Direct", "quote": "Remaining 25% of Domestic RO to Exchequer | 20.45 | 0.61 | 0.61 | 0.05 | 0.06 | 0.04", "note": "Table row as printed; the label wraps over two lines.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone."} +{"key": "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", "source": "good_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "good_energy_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 20.45, "value_raw": "20.45", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "renewables_obligation_remainder", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_remaining_ro", "reform_hint": "Remaining 25% of Domestic RO to Exchequer", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "primary_sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts", "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (£/yr)", "quote": "Remaining 25% of Domestic RO to Exchequer | 20.45 | 0.61 | 0.61 | 0.05 | 0.06 | 0.04", "note": "Table row as printed; the label wraps over two lines.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone."} +{"key": "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", "source": "good_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "good_energy_analysis", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 570000000.0, "value_raw": "0.57", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "program": "feed_in_tariffs", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer (printed as a cost): 'Direct' cost", "program_note": "electricity levies", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_fit", "reform_hint": "Domestic Feed in Tariff to Exchequer", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "primary_sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts", "source_column": "Cost (£bn), Dom Elec Direct", "quote": "Domestic Feed in Tariff to Exchequer | 19.25 | 0.57 | 0.57 | 0.05 | 0.06 | 0.03", "note": "Table row as printed; the label wraps over two lines.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_cost_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone."} +{"key": "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027", "source": "good_energy", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "good_energy_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 19.25, "value_raw": "19.25", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at July 2026 price-cap levy costs; staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "typical domestic electricity bill", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "feed_in_tariffs", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "remove_fit", "reform_hint": "Domestic Feed in Tariff to Exchequer", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "primary_sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "locator": "'Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts', Step 1, PDF page 19", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table summary of measures, savings, and inflationary impacts", "source_column": "Savings, Dom Elec (£/yr)", "quote": "Domestic Feed in Tariff to Exchequer | 19.25 | 0.57 | 0.57 | 0.05 | 0.06 | 0.03", "note": "Table row as printed; the label wraps over two lines.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "remove_levies_avg_gain_fy2027", "pe_missing": "One of the option's two levies, not the option: the dashboard publishes no figure for either levy alone."} +{"key": "desnz_vat_saving_fy2027", "source": "desnz", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "desnz_analysis", "metric": "average_annual_gain", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 45.0, "value_raw": "£45", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "period_basis": "a cost or saving per year at 2026 electricity prices (the current cut, from 1 October 2026); staged against 2027-28, the first full year of a measure announced at the 28 October 2026 Budget and the only year the dashboard costs this option", "geography": "Great Britain", "statistic": "average household", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households (printed as a bill saving)", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "extend_vat_cut", "reform_hint": "VAT will be removed from household electricity bills", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Breathing space on your energy bill", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", "date": "2026-08-26", "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", "primary_sha256": "6d25c410a11a90d13740be3f4dc79b8e00b67752dac15f17ef54b8b166e69b34", "locator": "second paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "text", "source_column": "average saving per year", "quote": "From 1 October 2026, VAT will be removed from household electricity bills, saving households an average of £45 per year.", "note": "The 21 July 2026 announcement gives the same £45 as 'off the yearly Ofgem price cap'.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "extend_vat_cut_avg_gain_fy2027"}} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..715b9ce68 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "bytes": 960798, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Briefing dated October 2026; its PDF was created on 13 October 2026."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", "title": "Billing me softly: How to design targeted energy discounts", "date": "2026-08-10", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "cc8414073c6421627c43333acc2ed2ae2952ad06ccd4f6a74be4cd9927060445", "bytes": 375609, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "title": "Trimming the VAT", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "bytes": 132991, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Comment."} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "date": "2026-10", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "bytes": 6601086, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Dated October 2026 on its cover; the PDF was created on 10 October 2026 and first captured by the Wayback Machine on 15 October 2026. ifs.org.uk pages returned 403, so the launch day was not confirmed and the date is the month as printed."} +{"url": "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", "title": "Quid Pro quo: Cheaper electricity now, for longer term market reforms", "date": "2026-06-01", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "sha256": "9bffc6ae6405a1c3c716819c145b63ad6accf2bca8f61978e8f8953f33781552", "bytes": 2935743, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", "title": "Helping households with energy costs this winter", "date": "2026-10-14", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "sha256": "9a41014178da34d4547fe48dcb48741de837603d3d1745e0ae0ada4ea1298be5", "bytes": 105063, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The same text is served as a PDF at https://www.jrf.org.uk/pdf/15660."} +{"url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", "title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", "date": "2026-04-09", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "sha256": "0b6f5f95dd28bda01fb0afe064c977fa7084dad6d7167a463aaa75c273532e99", "bytes": 85561, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", "title": "Continuing the Warm Home Discount 2026-2031: final stage impact assessment (DESNZ002(F)-26-EAC)", "date": "2026-01-30", "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", "sha256": "b0adabd4056cf33b4c718d79dc2c9edd410c24ef3d6f5e69e9a1302da7e6d9c0", "bytes": 640284, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", "title": "The case for further levy reform: Impacts on energy bills, fuel poverty and the clean heat transition", "date": "2026-06-30", "publisher": "The MCS Foundation", "sha256": "92a088670a87fb9c8ef28bd24bd66371a4d29e40c2063000f9fb5680e8df3dd8", "bytes": 1025530, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Cover dated July 2026; the PDF was created on 30 June 2026."} +{"url": "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", "title": "Geopolitical tensions are making UK energy bills more expensive", "date": "2026-08-27", "publisher": "Association for Renewables and Clean Technology (REA)", "sha256": "01bdd1b25c8b7139befdb83d4da8da006a164362f4555e8098c61220031ee7d7", "bytes": 129035, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", "title": "Over 120 organisations call for hidden taxes to come off electricity bills", "date": "2026-09-11", "publisher": "E3G", "sha256": "f9bc10d809504d715732387f9f16df5c1d08847909deb51ab493c70163ba6ade", "bytes": 72612, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Publishes the Electricity Bills Taskforce's analysis."} +{"url": "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", "title": "New Prime Minister can slash household energy bills by almost £200 a year by fixing Britain's broken electricity market", "date": "2026-07-17", "publisher": "Octopus Energy", "sha256": "4cf769de5e121d41258bf87a72f3e62f53a3072fc6ae6a8f1a183714f128a31f", "bytes": 311064, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Press release."} +{"url": "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", "title": "Rewiring the Market: How to Tackle the Hidden Causes of High Energy Bills", "date": "2026-06-25", "publisher": "Good Energy", "sha256": "6dd261a759cb703f03ac55846b788dbf8964ed3c49227c2013d84f0d49eb3338", "bytes": 3622082, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "No date printed; the PDF was created on 25 June 2026."} +{"url": "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", "title": "Zack Polanski lays out plans to back the 'caring majority' in major speech", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Green Party of England and Wales", "sha256": "930b4755c7f9fa81fb100bba40889394f2b4a74ffef7d778a4a814968f44b14f", "bytes": 114389, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Speech text."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "bytes": 148613, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", "title": "Breathing space on your energy bill", "date": "2026-08-26", "publisher": "Department for Energy Security and Net Zero", "sha256": "6d25c410a11a90d13740be3f4dc79b8e00b67752dac15f17ef54b8b166e69b34", "bytes": 68054, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "News story."} +{"url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/692872fd2a37784b16ecf676/Budget_2025-Policy_Costings.pdf", "title": "Budget 2025: Policy Costings", "date": "2025-11-26", "publisher": "HM Treasury", "sha256": "e4b87104f1a6cd1aeb7081e7815b604a7aa9ff1b760668e4a4c2e4719477fda4", "bytes": 817945, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "No claim staged: its Renewables Obligation costing (75% of the domestic share, -£2,100m in 2027-28) is cited in annotation levy-scope-120-assumption."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69b9d2b62 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-energy-autumn-budget/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,619 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113608-cmp-uk-energy-autumn-budget", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "obr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "gov.uk search API: filter_organisations=office-for-budget-responsibility, newest first (results 1-40)", + "Wayback CDX: obr.uk/efo/* captures from 2026", + "Wayback CDX: obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/, obr.uk/publications/ and obr.uk/docs/ captures from July 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://obr.uk/", + "https://obr.uk/publications/", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2026", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a4cb4c74889d85e75ab40e0/E03599617_OBR_FRS_2026_Accessible.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20260608144821/https://obr.uk/efo/economic-and-fiscal-outlook-march-2026/", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20260316092224id_/https://obr.uk/docs/d055fbf02d5b3g6jq8l2/efo-march-2026-detailed-forecast-tables-receipts.xlsx", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20261002001129id_/https://obr.uk/docs/5b333286c0b5e1bbb5b333286c0b/PSF_commentary_August_2026.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20260821161551id_/https://obr.uk/docs/efc0bd6f46ee4e6e8990cd53/PSF_commentary_July_2026.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No OBR costing of any option. The March 2026 EFO (forecast closed before the Middle East escalation) has domestic energy support at zero in every year (Table A.7) and forecasts the Renewables Obligation and Warm Home Discount levies, not their removal; the July 2026 Fiscal risks and sustainability report has no energy-support scenario; the July and August 2026 public finances commentaries do not mention the electricity VAT cut. obr.uk returned 403 to direct fetches, so OBR documents were read through Wayback captures and gov.uk mirrors; the web search budget was exhausted before an obr.uk site search could run." + }, + { + "producer": "hm_treasury", + "result": "found_not_staged", + "queries": [ + "VAT domestic electricity zero rate October 2026 cost to Exchequer £ billion tax information and impact note", + "£850 million VAT electricity October 2026 March 2027", + "gov.uk news VAT domestic electricity cut Prime Minister July 2026", + "gov.uk search API q='energy bills support cost' filter_organisations=hm-treasury (newest first)", + "gov.uk search API q='Budget 2025 policy costings' filter_organisations=hm-treasury", + "gov.uk search API q='Spring Statement 2026' / 'Spring Forecast 2026'", + "Parliament committees API: Treasury Committee publications from 2026-06-01", + "warm home discount £250 increase cost £600m budget Reeves", + "Treasury weighs targeted energy bill support warm home discount £250 means-tested Times report", + "Guardian Healey warm home discount £100 extra £1bn energy bills budget October 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/energy-bill-tax-cut-starts-today-to-give-families-breathing-space", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/chancellor-says-it-is-my-job-to-protect-resilience-of-the-uk-economy-and-the-budget-will-do-that-in-the-face-of-international-headwinds", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/spring-forecast-2026-the-right-economic-plan-for-britain", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supporting-documents-for-budget-2025", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/692872fd2a37784b16ecf676/Budget_2025-Policy_Costings.pdf", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/69269df29fd433badebc31b3/Table_4.1_-_Budget_2025_Policy_Decisions.xlsx", + "https://committees-api.parliament.uk/api/Publications?CommitteeId=158&StartDate=2026-06-01&Take=60", + "https://committees-api.parliament.uk/api/Publications/54694/Document/303841/OriginalFormat", + "https://committees-api.parliament.uk/api/Publications/54698/Document/303847/OriginalFormat", + "https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/poorer-uk-households-could-given-081831584.html", + "https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/budget-2026-burnham-healey-could-100512000.html", + "https://investinginsiders.co.uk/live-news/what-could-the-autumn-budget-deliver-if-youre-struggling-with-household-bills/", + "https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/chancellors-intervention-plans-cut-energy-bills-for-millions-1billion-5HjdjXX_2/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The Treasury's reported preferred option, £100 on the Warm Home Discount, is put at around £600 million for about six million households (Investing Insiders, 13 October 2026, citing the FT of 11 October) and the Chancellor's targeted package at 'over £1bn' (The Independent via Yahoo, 7 October 2026, citing the Guardian); no Treasury document publishes either figure, so neither is staged (harvest rule 8). The Treasury's £850 million for the 0% electricity VAT rate (21 July 2026 press release; Chancellor's letter to the Treasury Committee of the same day) costs the October 2026 to March 2027 cut, which is current law in the dashboard's baseline, not an option it scores. Budget 2025's costings price measures already in the baseline: 75% of the domestic Renewables Obligation (-£2,100m in 2027-28, cited in annotation levy-scope-120-assumption) and the Warm Home Discount expansion (about £600 million a year gross)." + }, + { + "producer": "uk_hmrc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "VAT domestic electricity zero rate October 2026 cost to Exchequer £ billion tax information and impact note", + "VAT zero rate domestic electricity 1 October 2026 tax information and impact note exchequer impact", + "gov.uk search API q='VAT domestic electricity zero rate'", + "gov.uk search API q='\"Direct effects of illustrative tax changes\"'", + "gov.uk search API q='tax information and impact note electricity' filter_organisations=hm-revenue-customs", + "gov.uk search API q='Climate Change Levy tax information and impact note 2026' filter_organisations=hm-revenue-customs", + "gov.uk search API q='Estimated costs of tax reliefs' filter_organisations=hm-revenue-customs" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-in-great-britain-for-domestic-electricity", + "https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/987/made", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/direct-effects-of-illustrative-tax-changes", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/direct-effects-of-illustrative-tax-changes/direct-effects-of-illustrative-tax-changes-bulletin-january-2025", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/68552862b46781eacfd71d71/June_2025_TRR_ODS__1_.ods", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/tax-reliefs", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/69a0194e3e672177d0bc76e6/tax_relief_statistics_january_2026.ods" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "HMRC's policy paper on the temporary zero rate (8 September 2026) leaves its Exchequer impact table blank until the OBR scrutinises the costing at the Budget. The latest ready reckoner (June 2025) costs a 1-point change in the whole reduced rate (£480m in 2027-28), not domestic electricity; the January 2026 tax relief statistics cost the 5% rate on domestic fuel and power against the standard rate (£7.0bn in 2025-26). Neither estimates an option the dashboard scores." + }, + { + "producer": "dwp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "gov.uk search API q='Cost of Living Payment' filter_organisations=department-for-work-pensions", + "gov.uk search API q='cost of living payment 2026' filter_organisations=department-for-work-pensions (newest first)", + "gov.uk search API q='impact assessment energy cost of living payment 2026' department-for-work-pensions", + "gov.uk search API q='benefit expenditure and caseload tables 2026' department-for-work-pensions" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/guidance/cost-of-living-payment", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cost-of-living-payment-2023-to-2024-management-information", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cost-of-living-payment-2023-to-2024-management-information/cost-of-living-payment-2023-to-2024-management-information", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/benefit-expenditure-and-caseload-tables-2026", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/69dcdc8c6b695d635c34dcc4/outturn-and-forecast-tables-spring-forecast-2026.xlsx" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No 2026 Cost of Living Payment has been announced or costed: DWP's guidance says it is not planning more payments, and the Spring Forecast 2026 tables carry no Cost of Living spending in 2026-27 or 2027-28. The autumn 2023 £300 payment went to 8.3 million households at £2.5 billion (management information, February 2024): the same design in a year the dashboard does not estimate, and an administrative outturn." + }, + { + "producer": "dfe", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "gov.uk search API q='energy bills support' filter_organisations=department-for-education" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/api/search.json?q=energy+bills+support&filter_organisations=department-for-education&count=10" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "DfE publishes nothing on household energy support; the results were school estate energy guidance and school costs." + }, + { + "producer": "scottish_fiscal_commission", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "Its applies_to is Scotland; the analysis is UK-wide and its options are reserved." + }, + { + "producer": "ifs", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:ifs.org.uk energy bills 2026 support cost", + "IFS Zaranko VAT energy bills cut £850 million 2026", + "IFS Green Budget 2026 energy bills support options", + "IFS Green Budget 2026 published October 2026 VAT electricity permanent £1.5 billion", + "site:ifs.org.uk energy bills Iran price cap support households 2026 comment", + "\"Temporary VAT cut on household electricity bills: IFS response\"", + "IFS October 2026 energy bills winter support Healey Budget warm home discount comment ifs.org.uk", + "Institute for Fiscal Studies 2026 \"Energy Price Guarantee\" cost estimate price cap January 2027 households" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20260707083110/https://ifs.org.uk/articles/what-does-war-middle-east-mean-energy-prices-and-how-could-government-respond", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20260821164000/https://ifs.org.uk/collections/autumn-budget-2026" + ], + "claims": [ + "ifs_vat_permanent_cost_fy2027" + ], + "note": "The Green Budget (October 2026) also restates the Treasury's £850 million for the six-month VAT cut and Budget 2025's £2 billion a year for 75% of the domestic RO; it costs no targeted discount, Warm Home Discount top-up, cap freeze or £400 payment. ifs.org.uk HTML pages returned 403, and the 21 July 2026 VAT response had no Wayback capture, so it was not read." + }, + { + "producer": "resolution_foundation", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Resolution Foundation \"Billing me softly\" targeted energy discount cost households eligible", + "Resolution Foundation \"Billing me softly\" energy bills 2026", + "resolutionfoundation.org \"Billing me softly\"", + "Resolution Foundation March 2026 social tariff £3.7 billion energy bills report", + "Resolution Foundation energy price cap October 2026 Autumn Budget energy support", + "Resolution Foundation price cap rise July 2026 energy bills press release", + "Resolution Foundation Budget 2026 preview October energy bills VAT levies", + "site:resolutionfoundation.org energy 2026", + "Resolution Foundation \"Counting the cost\" five years high inflation October 2026 energy", + "Resolution Foundation VAT electricity cut Burnham July 2026 response £45 typical household", + "Resolution Foundation Curtice Smith \"self-defeating\" cost of living measures September 2026", + "Resolution Foundation April 2026 targeted time-limited energy discounts low-income households analysis" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/billing-me-softly/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/government-must-be-ready-to-provide-targeted-energy-support-if-further-price-spikes-cause-more-families-to-struggle-this-winter/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=46698", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/hitting-the-buffers/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/counting-cost/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Counting-the-cost.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/power-struggle/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/efforts-to-deliver-a-new-social-tariff-for-energy-bills-should-start-now-to-help-vulnerable-families-this-winter/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/chancellor-right-to-target-energy-bill-support-at-vulnerable-customers-rather-than-repeat-than-blank-cheque-mistake-of-the-last-energy-crisis/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=45585", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=46579", + "https://resolutionfoundation.substack.com/p/trimming-the-vat", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=46097", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/02/Power-cut.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=45307", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=45334", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=45348", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=46534", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=46753", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/?p=45817", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/crowd-pleasing-cost-of-living-measures-risk-being-self-defeating/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/zero-to-hero/" + ], + "claims": [ + "rf_ted_cost_fy2026", + "rf_ted_share_fy2026", + "rf_ted_per_eligible_fy2026", + "rf_remaining_levies_cost_fy2027", + "rf_vat_annual_cost_fy2027", + "rf_ro_fit_saving_fy2027", + "rf_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "rf_fit_saving_fy2027", + "rf_all_policy_costs_saving_fy2027", + "rf_policy_costs_cost_fy2027", + "rf_whd_570_cost_fy2026" + ], + "note": "Hitting the buffers' £900 million for doubling the Warm Home Discount cites press reports of government plans (footnote 32), so it is not staged as RF's own estimate; its 5.5 million WHD recipients in 2025-26 restate DESNZ statistics for a year the dashboard does not estimate. From Power struggle (18 March 2026), not staged: the combined scenario's £2 billion for the remaining RO and the Warm Home Discount (a different pair of levies from the option's), the £3.75 billion EPG budget (a 9% unit-price discount, not a freeze at April-June 2026 rates) and the UC boost (another policy). Trimming the VAT's £45 a year restates the government's figure. Counting the cost (October 2026) restates 2022-24 outturns. Billing me softly gives no year for its £2 billion; the year is Hitting the buffers' ('£2 billion this year')." + }, + { + "producer": "centax", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:centax.org.uk energy", + "Centax energy bills VAT electricity 2026 analysis", + "\"CenTax\" Centre for the Analysis of Taxation 2026 publication" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://centax.org.uk/", + "https://centax.org.uk/policy/", + "https://centax.org.uk/research/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CenTax's policy and research lists (2020-2026) cover no energy bills, energy VAT, levies or energy support." + }, + { + "producer": "centre_for_british_progress", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "\"Centre for British Progress\" energy bills levies", + "britishprogress.org energy bills report 2026", + "\"Centre for British Progress\" electricity prices report Hezlet", + "\"Centre for British Progress\" energy bills winter 2026 Budget levies report September October", + "site:britishprogress.org reports energy" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://britishprogress.org/", + "https://britishprogress.org/reports", + "https://britishprogress.org/api/articles?limit=300&depth=0", + "https://britishprogress.org/sitemap.xml", + "https://britishprogress.org/reports/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te", + "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/quid-pro-quo-cheaper-electricity-now-for-longer-te-2.pdf", + "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/post-haste-lets-care-for-our-electrical" + ], + "claims": [ + "cbp_ro_fit_cost_fy2027", + "cbp_ro_fit_saving_fy2027" + ], + "note": "Quid pro quo (1 June 2026) is CBP's only 2026 energy-bill report. Its wider £4 billion package (adding the Warm Home Discount, Climate Change Levy and the ETS for generators, about £115 a household) is not an option the dashboard scores, so it is not staged." + }, + { + "producer": "ippr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "IPPR price caps and economic stability Iran war energy shock", + "IPPR 2026 energy bills report social tariff warm home discount cost", + "site:ippr.org energy price cap 2026", + "IPPR energy bills Autumn Budget 2026 Iran war cost of living proposal", + "IPPR 2026 \"energy\" bills households analysis report ippr.org/articles" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.ippr.org/articles/price-caps-and-economic-stability", + "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/Price_caps_and_economic_stability_May26.pdf?dm=1778662271", + "https://ippr-org.files.svdcdn.com/production/Downloads/Price_caps_and_economic_stability_May26.pdf", + "https://www.ippr.org/articles/cost-of-living-autumn-budget", + "https://www.ippr.org/media-office/get-started-with-tax-reform-to-pay-for-priorities-on-cost-of-living-and-economic-growth-ippr-urges-chancellor" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "IPPR costs a £2,000 bill cap with a 10p fuel duty cut (up to £5 billion or about £24 billion, May 2026) and a £2,000 ceiling for January to June 2027 with a fuel duty freeze ('less than £0.5 billion in total', October 2026): caps at £2,000 bundled with fuel duty, not a freeze at April-June 2026 rates, with no year-by-year cost. Its £11.9 billion for the EBSS restates the 2022-23 outturn." + }, + { + "producer": "fabian_society", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Fabian Society energy bills 2026", + "site:fabians.org.uk energy bills cost of living support warm home discount social tariff", + "\"Fabian Society\" 2026 energy support households billion proposal winter Iran" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://fabians.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Living-Standards-Web-final-js.pdf", + "https://fabians.org.uk/grid-system/", + "https://fabians.org.uk/cut-to-the-quick/", + "https://fabians.org.uk/no-time-to-waste-2/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Standard Issue (June 2026) argues for a social tariff without a cost; the 2025-26 Fabian articles opened give no comparable figure." + }, + { + "producer": "niesr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "NIESR energy bills 2026 households cost price cap October 2026", + "site:niesr.ac.uk Autumn Budget 2026 energy", + "NIESR living standards tracker 2026 energy price cap households real income", + "NIESR \"energy\" support households cost of living 2026 Budget preview", + "NIESR \"Economic Outlook\" Autumn 2026", + "NIESR pre-Budget October 2026 households energy support targeted low income", + "NIESR CPI tracker \"Ofgem Price Cap Re-energises Inflation\"", + "NIESR CPI tracker September 2026 \"Inflation Momentum Strengthens\" VAT electricity", + "NIESR \"New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities\" Economic Outlook April 2026 published" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://niesr.ac.uk/news/niesrs-response-ofgem-energy-price-cap-announcement", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-summer-2026", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Economic-Outlook-Summer-2026.pdf?ver=w8hqL3qtyyaWKQSEebj4", + "https://www.niesr.ac.uk/publications/search", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Economic-Outlook-Spring-2026.pdf", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The Spring 2026 Economic Outlook (Box B) costs a six-month £10-a-week Universal Credit uplift (around £2 billion) and income top-ups, and estimates the oil shock's effect on energy and fuel spending by decile and on poverty; none is an option or a quantity the dashboard publishes. The Summer 2026 Outlook is macroeconomic." + }, + { + "producer": "ukmod", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "CeMPA UKMOD energy prices 2026 households support working paper", + "site:microsimulation.ac.uk energy 2026", + "CeMPA working paper 2026 cost of living energy bills UKMOD distributional", + "\"UKMOD\" energy bills 2026 OR \"price cap\" OR \"Warm Home Discount\" OR \"VAT on electricity\"" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.microsimulation.ac.uk/publications/", + "https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/files/working-papers/cempa/cempa3-26.pdf", + "https://www.microsimulation.ac.uk/about/news/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CeMPA's 2026 working papers include no energy bill measures; WP 3/26 (the Autumn Budget 2025 brief) models no levy, WHD or VAT change." + }, + { + "producer": "lse_case", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "LSE CASE energy costs fuel poverty 2026 paper", + "sticerd.lse.ac.uk CASE paper energy bills support households distribution social tariff", + "LSE \"Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion\" 2026 energy cost of living households report" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case/_new/publications/series.asp?prog=CASE", + "https://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case/", + "https://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case/_new/publications/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No CASE publication from June 2025 to September 2026 covers energy bills or energy support." + }, + { + "producer": "jrf", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "JRF energy bills Autumn Budget 2026 support cost", + "site:jrf.org.uk energy 2026 social tariff price cap low income households", + "JRF responds Ofgem price cap August 2026 October cap low-income households", + "Joseph Rowntree Foundation \"Budget\" 2026 representation energy \"Warm Home Discount\" OR \"cost of living payment\" cost billion", + "cost of freezing energy price cap 2026 billion estimate winter 2026/27 energy price guarantee" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/helping-households-with-energy-costs-this-winter", + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/pdf/15660", + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/an-affordable-energy-guarantee", + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/income-savings-and-debt/rebuilding-living-standards-and-economic-security" + ], + "claims": [ + "jrf_ro_fit_whd_saving_fy2027", + "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost_fy2026" + ], + "note": "JRF's £6.3 billion winter package (levy removal plus cash tiered by historic consumption) is not an option the dashboard scores, and its £11.9 billion for the EBSS restates IPPR. The Affordable Energy Guarantee paper (May 2026) and the June 2026 energy allowance (£6.9 billion in 2029-30) cost other policies." + }, + { + "producer": "landman_economics", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Landman Economics\" energy bills 2026", + "Howard Reed Landman Economics energy price cap support households report 2026 OR 2025", + "\"Landman Economics\" report 2026 cost of living OR \"energy\" OR \"fuel poverty\" commissioned TUC OR IPPR OR NEF", + "\"Landman Economics\" 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "landmaneconomics.co.uk did not resolve, so the site could not be read; search found no 2025-26 Landman energy report, and the TUC's May 2026 social tariff paper credits no outside modeller." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_policy_associates", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "taxpolicy.org.uk VAT electricity 2026", + "Tax Policy Associates Dan Neidle VAT on domestic electricity cut cost energy levies 2026", + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk energy", + "Dan Neidle \"VAT\" electricity \"zero rate\" Burnham analysis cost who benefits" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/", + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/?s=electricity", + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/?s=energy" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "TPA's July to October 2026 articles do not cover energy VAT, levies or bill support; its energy pieces are 2022 windfall-tax articles." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "distributional impact Energy Price Guarantee Energy Bills Support Scheme UK microsimulation journal article", + "IZA OR SSRN OR CEPR paper UK energy price shock 2022 household support cost targeted versus universal Energy Price Guarantee", + "social tariff energy Great Britain cost estimate academic paper Energy Policy journal 2024 OR 2025 OR 2026 microsimulation", + "pass-through VAT cut domestic energy UK incidence paper 5% VAT energy bills distributional", + "\"Exploring social tariffs for energy\" University of York Social Policy Research Unit Bradshaw cost billion", + "VoxEU 2026 UK households energy price shock support Middle East gas price targeted transfers", + "working paper 2026 UK household energy bills 2026-27 distributional analysis price cap \"Family Resources Survey\" OR \"Living Costs and Food Survey\"", + "ISER working paper energy prices UK households Understanding Society 2025 OR 2026 energy bill support", + "\"Policy design challenges for energy affordability following price hikes in the UK\"", + "UKERC OR academic analysis moving policy levies off electricity bills general taxation cost £bn households 2025 2026 Renewables Obligation Feed-in Tariff", + "\"Energy Price Guarantee\" cost distribution income decile UK academic paper 2024 \"Fiscal Studies\" OR \"Energy Economics\" OR \"Energy Policy\"", + "arXiv OR SSRN 2026 \"energy price cap\" UK households microsimulation poverty energy support options", + "energy bill increases mental well-being dynamic microsimulation United Kingdom energy price cap rebates vulnerable groups" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-11/WP202555-The-welfare-effects-of-price-shocks-and-household-relief-packages-evidence-from-an-energy-crisis.pdf", + "https://www.economic-policy.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Fetzer-et-al.pdf", + "https://www.york.ac.uk/media/policyengine/documents/EXPLORING%20SOCIAL%20TARIFFS%20FOR%20ENERGY.pdf", + "https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/198630/", + "https://ideas.repec.org/p/ris/fcnwpa/021757.html", + "https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/?p=233268", + "https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/82776/1/Turner_etal_CEP_2022_The_impacts_of_the_October_2022_gas_and_electricity.pdf", + "https://ukerc.ac.uk/publications/the-cost-of-electricity-in-the-uk-drivers-challenges-and-opportunities-for-reform/", + "https://d2e1qxpsswcpgz.cloudfront.net/uploads/2026/07/UKERC-Mission-on-bills-brochure-v7acc.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "UKERC's The cost of electricity in the UK (July 2026) prices the remaining RO at about £25 on a typical electricity bill, one component of the levy option rather than its cost or average gain. The IFS working paper on 2022-23 relief (Levell, O'Connell and Smith) and York's 2023 social tariff paper cost a different period; no academic paper estimates a 2026-27 or 2027-28 option." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Autumn Budget 2026 energy bills support options cost October 2026", + "remove remaining levies electricity bills Renewables Obligation general taxation £3.2bn £120 off bills October 2026", + "Warm Home Discount impact assessment 2026/27 scheme spending levy per bill", + "DESNZ 2026 estimate cost Renewables Obligation Feed-in Tariff remaining levies domestic bills general taxation 2027-28", + "warm home discount expansion cost", + "warm home discount £250 cost", + "Budget 2025 data sources Renewables Obligation 75% general taxation household saving", + "VAT zero rate domestic electricity 1 October 2026 tax information and impact note exchequer impact", + "£850 million VAT electricity October 2026 March 2027", + "gov.uk news VAT domestic electricity cut Prime Minister July 2026", + "Ofgem breakdown typical bill October 2026 policy costs share", + "Ofgem warm home discount cost allowance", + "Energy UK economic defence tackling energy bills winter 2026/27 levies VAT cost", + "Energy UK economic defence report energy bills October 2026", + "Energy UK Dhara Vyas October 2026 support all households", + "MCS Foundation report electricity levies off bills saving £530 general taxation cost", + "MCS Foundation case for further levy reform 2026", + "REA modelling moving energy levies to general taxation", + "REA geopolitical tensions energy bills levies £3.2 billion", + "levies off bills cost 2027", + "renewables obligation taxation cost", + "next prime minister must tackle Britain's broken energy system Good Energy report", + "E3G 2026 levies electricity bills general taxation cost Autumn Budget remaining Renewables Obligation", + "E3G hidden taxes off electricity bills", + "Citizens Advice 2026 energy bills support proposal cost winter 2026/27", + "citizensadvice.org.uk 2026 Warm Home Discount increase cost social tariff", + "New Economics Foundation 2026 energy bills proposal cost price cap freeze support households winter 2026", + "Cornwall Insight price cap forecast April 2027 annual bill 2027-28", + "cornwall-insight.com price cap forecast January 2027", + "House of Commons Library energy bill support 2026 briefing cost options Warm Home Discount levies", + "commonslibrary.parliament.uk energy prices 2026 household support research briefing", + "Institute for Government 2026 energy bills support options cost", + "instituteforgovernment.org.uk 2026 energy bills Autumn Budget support cost", + "National Energy Action 2026 energy bills winter cost Warm Home Discount increase £250 Autumn Budget submission", + "National Energy Action Autumn Budget 2026 representation", + "End Fuel Poverty Coalition 2026 Autumn Budget energy bills cost estimate", + "End Fuel Poverty Coalition October 2026 Warm Home Discount £250", + "SSE powering secure affordable energy 2026", + "ECIU 2026 energy bills analysis cost of gas price rise households winter 2026/27", + "Green Alliance OR ECIU 2026 levies off bills cost Autumn Budget", + "Martin Lewis MoneySavingExpert 2026 Warm Home Discount £250 Treasury cost levies off bills", + "Bank of England Monetary Policy Report August 2026 Ofgem price cap assumption household energy", + "E.ON Next price cap forecast 2027", + "British Gas price cap forecast January 2027 April 2027", + "EDF energy price cap prediction January 2027", + "Bloomberg Economics UK energy bills 25% January £2,150 Iran war inflation above 4%", + "Capital Economics UK energy price cap forecast 2027 inflation Ofgem January", + "Green Party Polanski energy bills plan 2026 price freeze cost", + "Green Party \"£8.4bn\" energy bills April-June price cap rise £300", + "Octopus Energy Greg Jackson proposal energy bills support 2026 cost government January", + "Octopus Energy press release incoming prime minister market reform £114 levies general taxation £75 2026", + "TUC OR Unite OR GMB energy bills freeze price cap 2026 cost billion call government", + "TUC social tariff 18.7 million households £559 energy bills 2026", + "TUC \"Funding a cut in energy bills with a bank tax\" social tariff cost billion", + "Conservatives Badenoch energy bills plan cost costed 2026 scrap levies VAT", + "Conservatives \"Cheap Power Plan\" 2026 cost VAT energy bills £ billion carbon price", + "average household energy bill forecast 2027 price cap", + "TaxPayers' Alliance energy bills VAT levies 2026 cost", + "VAT cut domestic electricity 0% cost £ billion 2026 Burnham £45", + "Public First \"Closing the fuel poverty gap\" report cost Warm Home Discount £400 social tariff", + "\"Electricity Bills Taskforce\" levies general taxation £120 cost £3.2 billion report", + "remove levies electricity bills £120 cost \"£3.2bn\" OR \"£3.2 billion\" budget 2026", + "Liberal Democrats energy bills plan 2026 cost £ billion autumn budget", + "Energy Security and Net Zero Committee 2026 report energy bills support winter Middle East households", + "Treasury Committee energy support cost living 2026 inquiry energy bills fiscal cost", + "Scottish Government energy bills 2026 UK Government support call price cap January fuel poverty estimate", + "Northern Ireland energy support payment 2026 households Middle East heating oil cost Executive", + "Policy Exchange energy bills 2026 cost of support households price cap", + "Social Market Foundation energy bills autumn budget 2026", + "Onward OR \"Centre for Policy Studies\" energy bills support plan 2026 cost households January price cap", + "Common Wealth think tank energy bills 2026 windfall tax price cap Middle East support", + "Child Poverty Action Group energy bills support budget October 2026", + "Trussell energy bills cost of living payment 2026 budget call", + "Which? consumer group energy bills January 2027 support call government analysis households £", + "Autumn Budget 2026 energy bills support cost billion", + "energy price cap freeze cost 2026 billion government", + "\"freeze the price cap\" OR \"freezing the price cap\" 2026 cost Treasury billion January Burnham Healey", + "\"£400\" energy rebate every household 2026 call cost \"£11\" OR \"£12\" billion", + "\"cost of living payment\" 2026 budget £300 means-tested benefits cost \"£2\" billion call", + "households pay extra billion energy bills winter 2026-27 price cap rise total cost estimate", + "warm home discount top-up £100 cost analysis 2026 households eligible million think tank estimate", + "Aurora Energy Research OR Baringa OR \"LCP Delta\" household energy bills 2027 forecast UK price cap", + "Reform UK energy bills plan cost 2026 £ billion", + "Fair By Design OR \"Independent Age\" OR \"Age UK\" energy support 2026 budget call cost £ billion winter", + "Policy in Practice energy bills 2026 cost of living payment analysis households" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/697b454bf8f4a746d9572efe/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-government-response.pdf", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6978a8b51c24881f40a4d675/continuing-the-warm-home-discount-scheme-impact-assessment.pdf", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/breathing-space-on-your-energy-bill", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/energy-bill-tax-cut-starts-today-to-give-families-breathing-space", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/what-does-the-autumn-budget-mean-for-your-energy-bills", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/697a744c005d288bf850df2f/ro-indexation-analytical-annex.pdf", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/feed-in-tariffs-fit-scheme-indexation-changes/changes-to-inflation-indexation-in-the-feed-in-tariffs-fit-scheme-consultation-document-html", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/renewables-obligation-level-calculations-2027-to-2028/calculating-the-level-of-the-renewables-obligation-for-2027-to-2028", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-in-great-britain-for-domestic-electricity", + "https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/987/made", + "https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/987/memorandum/contents", + "https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2026-08/Summary-of-changes-to-energy-price-cap-1-October-to-31-December-2026.pdf", + "https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/news/changes-energy-price-cap-between-1-october-and-31-december-2026", + "https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2025-11/Energy%20price%20cap%20proposed%20changes%20to%20Warm%20Home%20Discount%20Scheme%20cost%20allowance%20decision.pdf", + "https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/your-energy-supply/your-energy-bill/energy-price-cap-and-standing-charges-explained", + "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/MCSF-The-case-for-further-levy-reform-Report-2026-1.pdf", + "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/MCSF-Rebalancing-Electricity-Levies-in-the-UK-Report-Final.pdf", + "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Cut-the-Cost-of-Electricity-The-MCS-Foundation-April-2026.pdf", + "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/news/households-could-save-up-to-530-if-electricity-levies-moved-off-bills-new-report/", + "https://mcsfoundation.org.uk/?p=4057", + "https://www.r-e-a.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/UK-energy-bills-to-rise-in-July-as-geopolitical-strains-hit-gas.pdf", + "https://www.r-e-a.net/vat-off-electricity-bills-but-the-economy-needs-more/", + "https://www.r-e-a.net/geopolitical-tensions-are-making-uk-energy-bills-more-expensive/", + "https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Lowering-energy-bills-report.pdf", + "https://www.e3g.org/news/over-120-organisations-call-for-hidden-taxes-to-come-off-electricity-bills/", + "https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/Energy-UK-x-EBT-Levies-Letter-summer-2026-with-signatories-1.pdf", + "https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/about-us/media-centre/press-releases/more-than-a-third-of-brits-worried-about-affording-energy-bills-this-winter-warns-citizens-advice/", + "https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/policy/publications/hitting-the-rationing-wall/", + "https://assets.ctfassets.net/mfz4nbgura3g/XOarKUJjFQZp7ScW70bEo/5141ac4d77e31595ab1a44ac620f2be5/Policy_paperr_on_rationing_and_adjusting_budgets_.pdf", + "https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/about-us/media-centre/press-releases/rising-energy-costs-to-hit-those-who-never-recovered-from-the-last-crisis-as-4-6-million-worry-about-affording-bills/", + "https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/about-us/media-centre/press-releases/citizens-advice-reveals-how-to-save-struggling-households-gbp950-a-year/", + "https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/wales/policy/publications/winter-warning-the-urgent-case-for-energy-bill-support-this-winter/", + "https://neweconomics.org/2026/10/government-must-act-to-protect-essential-energy-consumption-for-all", + "https://energymadeeasy.co.uk/news/january-price-cap-forecast-eases", + "https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/managing-economic-consequences-iran-war", + "https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/rachel-reeves-should-not-rushed-action-energy-bills", + "https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/domestic-energy-bills", + "https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/report/addressing-rising-energy-bills", + "https://www.nea.org.uk/news-insights/government-cuts-vat-on-electricity-bills/", + "https://www.endfuelpoverty.org.uk/households-face-a-332-trump-tax-on-energy-bills-from-july/", + "https://www.endfuelpoverty.org.uk/coalition-sets-out-winter-rescue-plan-for-chancellors-budget/", + "https://www.endfuelpoverty.org.uk/chancellor-confirms-energy-bill-support-planning/", + "https://www.sse.com/about-us/our-campaigns/powering-secure-affordable-energy/", + "https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/letter/2026/governor-cpi-inflation-letter-september.pdf", + "https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/monetary-policy-report/2026/july/monetary-policy-report-july-2026.pdf", + "https://www.eonnext.com/electricity-and-gas/price-cap/predictions", + "https://www.britishgas.co.uk/energy/price-cap.html", + "https://www.edfenergy.com/gas-and-electricity/price-cap-predictions", + "https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/utilities/energy-price-cap-prediction/", + "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/03/18/zack-polanski-lays-out-plans-to-back-the-caring-majority-in-major-speech/", + "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/07/02/greens-call-on-burnham-to-cut-bills-by-150-before-winter-as-new-energy-price-cap-kicks-in/", + "https://greenparty.org.uk/2026/10/12/polanski-calls-for-bold-and-immediate-action-on-the-cost-of-living-in-october-budget/", + "https://octopus.energy/press/more-news-press-releases/new-prime-minister-can-slash-household-energy-bills-by-almost-pound200-a-year-by-fixing-britain-s-broken-electricity-market/", + "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "https://pocketwise.co.uk/energy/bills-and-switching/energy-price-cap-january-2027/", + "https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-energy-bills-likely-to-rise-despite-burnhams-vat-cut", + "https://www.ukgovproposals.com/news/electricity-vat-cut/", + "https://www.scope.org.uk/news-and-stories/closing-the-fuel-poverty-gap-a-plan-for-targeted-energy-support", + "https://media.nesta.org.uk/documents/Cheaper_electricity_fairer_bills_lXiIIac.pdf", + "https://kpmg.com/uk/en/media/press-releases/2025/11/kpmg-uk-fairer-energy-bills.html", + "https://www.mpamag.com/uk/news/general/economist-sees-2-inflation-by-end-of-2027-challenging-market-rate-bets/594024", + "https://www.libdems.org.uk/news", + "https://api.parliament.uk/committees/publications/52206", + "https://api.parliament.uk/committees/publications/53481", + "https://www.which.co.uk/policy-and-insight/article/increase-support-to-help-people-with-terrifying-energy-bills-hike-which-urges-government-acIQw0c9SpHf" + ], + "claims": [ + "desnz_whd_rebates_fy2026", + "mcs_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "mcs_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "rea_all_levies_cost_fy2027", + "rea_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "ebt_ro_fit_whd_nuclear_saving_fy2027", + "octopus_all_levies_saving_fy2027", + "good_energy_whd_payment_cost_fy2026", + "green_party_cap_freeze_cost_fy2026", + "good_energy_ro_remainder_cost_fy2027", + "good_energy_ro_remainder_saving_fy2027", + "good_energy_fit_cost_fy2027", + "good_energy_fit_saving_fy2027", + "desnz_vat_saving_fy2027" + ], + "note": "Not staged: the energy secretary's levy plan ('as much as £120' off a typical bill, 'as much as £3.2bn', Guardian 6 October and FT 11 October 2026, as the dashboard's code cites them) has no published primary; DESNZ's 8.3m households on a qualifying means-tested benefit is a count from the 2024 English Housing Survey (impact assessment footnote 19), calibration material cited in annotation whd-proxy-caseload; the REA's 29 July £2.99bn (28.6m households saving £105) is superseded by its own 27 August estimate for the same change; Citizens Advice's £39 is for a package that also reforms the Warm Home Discount, for households not on means-tested benefits; supplier and Bank of England cap forecasts are price-path inputs, not estimates of a published quantity; the TUC's social tariff, JRF's package and NIESR's UC uplift are other policies; 2022-23 EBSS and EPG outturns are a different period. DESNZ, found here for the Warm Home Discount caseload and the VAT cut's average saving, publishes the official figures for energy measures and is a candidate for the UK producer list." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:138a17f941e49c538d7dd1ccc9cdf5e6e746ce11834b453a4657773e86d1df19", + "PolicyEngine/uk-energy-autumn-budget@4d916d54c15f12407d6d463d23acb47ac89b55be:c047f33a2af9bfe3e6e872a2cbe76a45e173bb74b53d1ef332af4de896213cba" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/README.md b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7d90079ce --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +# Free childcare hours and a 75% subsidy: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md): the dashboard was +listed on policyengine.org on 3 September 2026, before the gate existed. + +- **Published figures** (pinned in `analysis.json`): 21 estimates from + `PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform` at `1a832f1` (the commit of the live Vercel deployment, + 29 September 2026), `dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json`, the file the + dashboard fetches (byte-identical to `data/free_childcare_reform_results.json`). They are the + static cost and the cost with the central labour supply response of the free-hours leg + (England), the 75% subsidy leg (UK, and its England share) and both legs together, for + 2027-28 to 2029-30: £1.97bn, £4.84bn and £6.64bn static in 2027-28. The free-hours leg is + costed from age 1, not 9 months: FRS ages are whole years, so the 9-month floor binds at 1 + (`reforms.py`, which puts the missing cohort at about £0.44bn). The file's own + provenance block says it was generated on 2 September 2026 at analysis commit `5150486` + from a dirty working tree; it has not changed since `ba56ebb`. +- **Not pinned**: net employment entrants (the scorecard has no registered employment-change + metric), distributional gains, the take-up, Universal Credit scope and fee-base + sensitivities, and the extended-entitlement take-up variant. No producer published a + figure comparable to any of them. +- **What the search found** (2026-10-21, every UK producer): no external estimate of either + leg or of both together. Three near analogues are staged, none compared: + - CenTax's row "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s": one group the + free-hours leg also reaches (under-3s of working parents above £100,000), static and net, + central scenario, 2027-28 to 2029-30, on both of the report's income tests: actual ANI + (Table 4.3, its primary results, and Table B.1) and today's expected ANI (Table B.2). The + rows match the free-hours estimates on metric, unit, period and time basis, so each names + its nearest estimate and the annotation `centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours` says + why the two differ. + - IPPR, Towards a childcare guarantee (September 2022): the only costing found of a 75% + childcare subsidy (read as a scheme total; 95% for families on means-tested benefits; + replacing Tax-Free Childcare and the UC element), and universal 15 hours for under-twos + and for two-year-olds, all on the 2022 system. + - NEF, The Universal Family Childcare Promise (July 2025): the analysis's own "closest + published analogue", a replacement of the whole system with 15 hours from 9 months plus + an earnings cap. +- **Found but not staged**: CASE and the Early Education and Childcare Coalition's Reforming + childcare subsidies (19 October 2026). Its report refused every fetch, and the LSE release + gives its cost only as a percentage increase on an unstated base. +- **Not staged, other reforms**: the analysis's other listed comparables (the IFS costing for + the Sutton Trust, 2021; HM Treasury and OBR on the 2023 expansion; the Women's Budget + Group, 2017) score reforms the analysis does not make. Each is logged in `search_log.json`. +- **Gaps**: no claim is compared, so none is over the threshold. +- **Not read**: obr.uk answered every fetch with a Cloudflare challenge, so the OBR entry + rests on search results; ifs.org.uk HTML pages were read through a reader proxy. + +Primaries were downloaded and hashed on 2026-10-21 outside the repository; `manifest.jsonl` +holds their SHA-256s. The CenTax PDF is the same file as in +`sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold/`. diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e3889d97e --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,790 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "uk/free-childcare-reform", + "country": "UK", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "free-childcare-reform", + "country_id": "uk" + }, + "title": "Free childcare hours and a 75% subsidy", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/free-childcare-reform", + "published": "2026-09-03", + "owner": { + "author": "vahid-ahmadi" + }, + "scope": "uk_wide", + "subject": "The cost and household impact, 2027-28 to 2029-30, of a two-part childcare reform: 15 free hours a week for every child from 9 months to school age, with no work or income test (England), and a 75% subsidy of childcare costs replacing Tax-Free Childcare, with no work test, cap or £100,000 limit and the Universal Credit childcare element kept at 85% (UK-wide); each leg and both together, static and with a labour supply response.", + "search_terms": [ + "75% childcare subsidy cost", + "replace Tax-Free Childcare cost", + "universal free childcare hours cost", + "childcare subsidy reform UK cost", + "15 free hours all children from nine months cost", + "extend free childcare to non-working parents cost", + "remove childcare work test cost" + ], + "worlds": { + "free_hours_from_9_months": { + "policy": "uk_free_childcare_15_hours_from_9_months", + "description": "Leg 1: 15 free hours a week for every child from 9 months to school age, regardless of parental work or income, plus a further 15 hours where parents work and earn under £100,000 (England). Costed from age 1: FRS ages are whole years, so the 9-month floor binds at 1 and the 9-to-12-month cohort is not costed (reforms.py)." + }, + "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc": { + "policy": "uk_childcare_subsidy_75_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "description": "Leg 2: a 75% subsidy of childcare costs replacing Tax-Free Childcare, with no work test, per-child cap or £100,000 limit; the Universal Credit childcare element kept at 85% (UK-wide)." + }, + "both_legs": { + "policy": "uk_free_childcare_15_hours_from_9_months_and_75_subsidy", + "description": "Both legs run together, with the new free hours displacing paid care before the 75% subsidy applies." + }, + "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani": { + "policy": "uk_free_childcare_first_15_hours_under_3s_100k_limit_removed_actual_ani", + "description": "CenTax section 4.2.3, primary results: the £100,000 limit removed for the first 15 hours for 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents and kept for the second 15 hours, with eligibility tested on actual rather than expected ANI (England)." + }, + "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani": { + "policy": "uk_free_childcare_first_15_hours_under_3s_100k_limit_removed", + "description": "CenTax section 4.2.3, Appendix B: the £100,000 limit removed for the first 15 hours for 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents and kept for the second 15 hours, on today's expected-ANI test (England)." + }, + "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos": { + "policy": "ippr_2022_universal_15_hours_under_twos", + "description": "IPPR (September 2022): a universal offer of 15 funded hours a week for every child under two, modelled from six months, added to the 2022 system (England)." + }, + "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds": { + "policy": "ippr_2022_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds", + "description": "IPPR (September 2022): the 15-hour offer for disadvantaged two-year-olds made universal, added to the 2022 system (England)." + }, + "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95": { + "policy": "ippr_2022_reformed_childcare_subsidy_75_95", + "description": "IPPR (September 2022): Tax-Free Childcare and the UC childcare element replaced by one subsidy paying 75% of costs for families not on means-tested benefits and 95% for families on them, in a world with 30 free hours for every child from six months to four (England)." + }, + "nef_universal_family_childcare_promise": { + "policy": "nef_universal_family_childcare_promise", + "description": "NEF with Pregnant Then Screwed and JRF (July 2025): the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support replaced by 15 free hours for every child from 9 months to 4 plus a cap, at 5% (or 7.5%) of family earnings, on the cost of further hours for working families (England)." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "free_hours_static_fy2027", + "label": "Static cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1), England, 2027-28", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1966000000, + "value_raw": "1.966", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "free_hours_static_fy2028", + "label": "Static cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1), England, 2028-29", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2013000000, + "value_raw": "2.013", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "free_hours_static_fy2029", + "label": "Static cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1), England, 2029-30", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2062000000, + "value_raw": "2.062", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2027", + "label": "Cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1) with the labour supply response, England, 2027-28", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1931000000, + "value_raw": "1.931", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2028", + "label": "Cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1) with the labour supply response, England, 2028-29", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1978000000, + "value_raw": "1.978", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2029", + "label": "Cost of 15 free hours for every child from 9 months (costed from age 1) with the labour supply response, England, 2029-30", + "world": "free_hours_from_9_months", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2024000000, + "value_raw": "2.024", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.free_hours.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_fy2027", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, UK, 2027-28", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4839000000, + "value_raw": "4.839", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.subsidy.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_fy2028", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, UK, 2028-29", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4956000000, + "value_raw": "4.956", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.subsidy.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_fy2029", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, UK, 2029-30", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -5088000000, + "value_raw": "5.088", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.subsidy.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_england_fy2027", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, England, 2027-28", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4037800000, + "value_raw": "4.0378", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.subsidy.static_cost_by_country_bn.england" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_england_fy2028", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, England, 2028-29", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4135400000, + "value_raw": "4.1354", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.subsidy.static_cost_by_country_bn.england" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_static_england_fy2029", + "label": "Static cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare, England, 2029-30", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4242400000, + "value_raw": "4.2424", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "static", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "England", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.subsidy.static_cost_by_country_bn.england" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_dynamic_fy2027", + "label": "Cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare with the labour supply response, UK, 2027-28", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4168000000, + "value_raw": "4.168", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.subsidy.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_dynamic_fy2028", + "label": "Cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare with the labour supply response, UK, 2028-29", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4241000000, + "value_raw": "4.241", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.subsidy.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "subsidy_dynamic_fy2029", + "label": "Cost of a 75% childcare subsidy replacing Tax-Free Childcare with the labour supply response, UK, 2029-30", + "world": "subsidy_75_replacing_tfc", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4347000000, + "value_raw": "4.347", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "childcare_subsidy_replacing_tax_free_childcare", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.subsidy.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_static_fy2027", + "label": "Static cost of both legs together, UK, 2027-28", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6638000000, + "value_raw": "6.638", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.legs.combined.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_static_fy2028", + "label": "Static cost of both legs together, UK, 2028-29", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6798000000, + "value_raw": "6.798", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.legs.combined.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_static_fy2029", + "label": "Static cost of both legs together, UK, 2029-30", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6977000000, + "value_raw": "6.977", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "static", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.legs.combined.static_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_dynamic_fy2027", + "label": "Cost of both legs together with the labour supply response, UK, 2027-28", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -5949000000, + "value_raw": "5.949", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2027.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_dynamic_fy2028", + "label": "Cost of both legs together with the labour supply response, UK, 2028-29", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6064000000, + "value_raw": "6.064", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2028-29", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2028.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "both_legs_dynamic_fy2029", + "label": "Cost of both legs together with the labour supply response, UK, 2029-30", + "world": "both_legs", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6216000000, + "value_raw": "6.216", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "the results file prints each cost as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2029-30", + "basis": "post_behavioural", + "program": "free_childcare_hours_and_childcare_subsidy", + "geography": "UK", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "basis_note": "with labour supply responses: participation (OBR elasticities, central scale) and hours among parents in work (elasticity -0.042)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform", + "commit": "1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json", + "sha256": "c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285", + "computed_at": "2026-09-02T15:37:19+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.94.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@7b0a06f0f08bec4bdb81c5d0fdb4057fe4e7fd1a", + "field": "by_year.2029.dynamic_cost.central.dynamic_cost_bn" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6405d9d05 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +[ + { + "id": "centax-over-100k-group-inside-free-hours", + "claims": [ + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "CenTax's rows give the first 15 hours only to 9-month- to 2-year-olds of working parents above £100,000 (section 4.2.3), and Table 4.3's and B.1's also move the income test for the remaining hours from expected to actual ANI (printed page 43). The analysis's free-hours leg gives 15 hours to every child from age 1 (FRS ages are whole years, so its 9-month floor binds at 1: reforms.py) to school age, regardless of parental work or income (results file reform_definition.free_hours), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk 2.94.0 extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), as in CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It therefore also reaches under-threes whose parents do not meet the work test, whom CenTax's rows leave out, and does not reach the 9-to-12-month-olds CenTax includes. CenTax's net figures net off bunching and partners entering work; the analysis's dynamic figures net off participation and hours responses. The CenTax rows cost one group the leg also reaches, not the leg.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=44" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=45" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=46" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=83" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=84" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf#page=85" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-uk/blob/2.94.0/policyengine_uk/variables/gov/dfe/extended_childcare_entitlement/conditions/extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements.py" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform/blob/1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8/src/free_childcare_reform/reforms.py#L56-L70" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform/blob/1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8/dashboard/public/data/free_childcare_reform_results.json" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..79284676d --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -300000000, "value_raw": "-300m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)"}, "source_table": "Table 4.3", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2028 11,930 -300m +80m +50m -170m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2027", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -170000000, "value_raw": "-170m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)"}, "source_table": "Table 4.3", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2028 11,930 -300m +80m +50m -170m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2027", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -340000000, "value_raw": "-340m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2028-29", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.1, printed page 83 (PDF page 84)"}, "source_table": "Table B.1", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2029 13,230 -340m +100m +50m -190m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2028", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -190000000, "value_raw": "-190m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2028-29", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.1 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.1, printed page 83 (PDF page 84)"}, "source_table": "Table B.1", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2029 13,230 -340m +100m +50m -190m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2028", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -370000000, "value_raw": "-370m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)"}, "source_table": "Table 4.3", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2030 14,690 -370m +110m +50m -210m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2029", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -210000000, "value_raw": "-210m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "actual ANI for the year (the basis of the report's primary results, which assumes a change from expected ANI)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table 4.3 notes: 'Negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_actual_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 4.3, printed page 44 (PDF page 45)"}, "source_table": "Table 4.3", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2030 14,690 -370m +110m +50m -210m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2029", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -370000000, "value_raw": "-370m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2028 11,930 -370m +80m +50m -250m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2027", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -250000000, "value_raw": "-250m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2028: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2028 11,930 -370m +80m +50m -250m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2027", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -410000000, "value_raw": "-410m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2028-29", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2029 13,230 -410m +90m +50m -270m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2028", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -270000000, "value_raw": "-270m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2028-29", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2029: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2029 13,230 -410m +90m +50m -270m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2028", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -460000000, "value_raw": "-460m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "scenario": "central", "basis": "static", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Static Cost (£)", "quote": "2030 14,690 -460m +100m +50m -300m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_static_fy2029", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029", "source": "centax", "found_by": "centax", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmrc_administrative_microdata", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -300000000, "value_raw": "-300m", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "scenario": "central", "basis": "post_behavioural", "income_measure": "expected ANI (today's income test)", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer (Table B.2 notes: 'negative = cost to the Exchequer')", "basis_note": "net of intensive and extensive behavioural margins"}, "world": "centax_first_15_hours_under_3s_expected_ani", "reform_hint": "Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000; Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "primary_sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table B.2, printed page 84 (PDF page 85)"}, "source_table": "Table B.2", "source_column": "Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s, tax year 2030: Net Fiscal Cost (£)", "quote": "2030 14,690 -460m +100m +50m -300m", "note": "CenTax labels tax years by their later year ('tax year 2021-22 is given as 2022', printed page 2), so 2028 is 2027-28. Section 4.2.3 (printed page 45): 'Extending 15 hours of childcare for 9-month- to 2-year-olds to parents earning over £100,000 would mean that crossing the threshold costs that group 15 hours of childcare rather than 30'. Printed page 43: 'the primary results we present continue to assume a change in the income definition determining eligibility to actual ANI. Supplementary results in which the income definition remains expected ANI are provided in Appendix B.' Not staged: the 2031 rows (no published PolicyEngine year), the low- and high-cost scenarios (Appendix C), and the other rows of Tables 4.2, 4.3, B.1 and B.2 (full removal, higher thresholds, tapers), which score reforms of the £100,000 limit this analysis does not make; the full removal is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "free_hours_dynamic_fy2029", "pe_missing": "CenTax costs one group the analysis's free-hours leg also reaches: under-3s of working parents above £100,000, who gain the first 15 hours. The leg also reaches under-3s whose parents do not meet the work test, is costed from age 1 rather than 9 months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), and keeps the £100,000 limit on the second 15 hours, tested on the year's modelled adjusted net income (policyengine-uk extended_childcare_entitlement_meets_income_requirements), the concept of CenTax's actual-ANI rows. It publishes no figure for the over-£100,000 group alone."} +{"key": "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos_fy2022", "source": "ippr", "found_by": "ippr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ippr_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 900000000, "value_raw": "£0.9 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2023, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2022-23", "basis": "unstated", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", "ages": "under twos, modelled from six months", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response"}, "world": "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos", "reform_hint": "Introducing a universal offer of 15 funded hours per week for under twos", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", "date": "2022-09-22", "publisher": "IPPR", "primary_sha256": "6a567e2c98e55d99e6437718e8c7c286810264ccdf8fb7fe34e306ddd65ce3de", "access": "direct", "locator": "Summary, Recommendation 2, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated on printed page 24 and in Table S.2"}, "source_table": "Summary, Recommendation 2", "source_column": "Universal offer of 15 funded hours per week for under twos: cost per annum", "quote": "Introducing a universal offer of 15 funded hours per week for under twos would cost an estimated £0.9 billion per annum, rising to £1.4 billion for 30 hours", "note": "Footnote 4: 'This has been modelled to start at six months.' Table S.2 labels it '£0.9bn in additional investment for 15 hours'. Printed page 24 gives £1.1 billion for 48 weeks. The report states no year and no behavioural basis for the hours costings. It was published in September 2022 and costs the hours against the 2022 system; 2022-23 is staged as that price and policy base, not as a year IPPR states.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under £100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline."} +{"key": "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds_fy2022", "source": "ippr", "found_by": "ippr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ippr_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 900000000, "value_raw": "£0.9 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2023, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2022-23", "basis": "unstated", "geography": "England", "program": "free_childcare_hours", "hours": "15 a week, 38 weeks a year", "ages": "two-year-olds", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "basis_note": "IPPR does not say whether the cost allows for any behavioural response"}, "world": "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds", "reform_hint": "Making the current 15-hour offer available to some two-year-olds universal", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", "date": "2022-09-22", "publisher": "IPPR", "primary_sha256": "6a567e2c98e55d99e6437718e8c7c286810264ccdf8fb7fe34e306ddd65ce3de", "access": "direct", "locator": "Summary, Recommendation 2, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated on printed page 24 and in Table S.2"}, "source_table": "Summary, Recommendation 2", "source_column": "Universal 15-hour offer for two-year-olds: cost per annum", "quote": "Making the current 15-hour offer available to some two-year-olds universal would cost an estimated £0.9 billion per annum.", "note": "Table S.2: 'Universalise 15 free hours offer for two-year-olds on higher hourly rate', '£0.9bn in additional investment'. The report states no year and no behavioural basis for the hours costings. It was published in September 2022 and costs the hours against the 2022 system; 2022-23 is staged as that price and policy base, not as a year IPPR states.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "IPPR adds the 15 hours to the 2022 system, when under-threes of working parents had no funded hours and only disadvantaged two-year-olds had 15. The analysis's free-hours leg starts from the system after the 2023-25 expansion, where under-threes of working parents under £100,000 already have 30 hours, gives 15 hours to the children not already entitled, from age 1 rather than six or nine months (FRS ages are whole years: reforms.py), in 2027-28 to 2029-30, and publishes no figure for one age group or on IPPR's baseline."} +{"key": "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022", "source": "ippr", "found_by": "ippr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ippr_costing_coram_dwp_ons", "metric": "benefit_cost", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3200000000, "value_raw": "£3.2bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2023, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2022-23", "basis": "static", "geography": "England", "program": "reformed_childcare_subsidy_scheme", "subsidy_rates": "75% of costs for families not on means-tested benefits; 95% for families on them", "scope": "total cost of the scheme, before the Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare spending it replaces", "sign_convention": "positive = spending on the scheme", "basis_note": "current market rates and take up (Table S.1 note)"}, "world": "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95", "reform_hint": "expand and reform the tax-free childcare offer to subsidise costs for parents of school-age children, and additional hours for parents of under 5s. This would see the childcare element of universal credit scrapped and replaced with a more generous reimbursement mechanism", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", "url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", "date": "2022-09-22", "publisher": "IPPR", "primary_sha256": "6a567e2c98e55d99e6437718e8c7c286810264ccdf8fb7fe34e306ddd65ce3de", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table S.1, printed page 7 (PDF page 7); repeated as Table 1, printed page 25"}, "source_table": "Table S.1: Estimated costs of a reformed childcare subsidy scheme", "source_column": "Subsidy level 1 (families not in receipt of means-tested benefits) 75%, subsidy level 2 (families in receipt of means-tested benefits) 95%: Cost", "quote": "75% 95% £3.2bn", "note": "Table note: 'IPPR costings based on current market rates and take up. Analysis assumes complete rollout of 30 free hours for all children between six months and four years. The earnings cap is expected to have a negligible effect on costs'. IPPR and Save the Children's Delivering a childcare guarantee (December 2022) says the 60% version 'would cost £2.7 billion (not accounting for current spending)' (printed page 22) and '£2.7 billion per annum in total – with and estimated £1.6 billion recouped from current spending on the childcare element of universal credit and the current tax free childcare scheme' (printed page 34), so Table S.1's costs are read as scheme totals; IPPR states this of the 60% row only. The scheme covers school-age children too. Geography: the report sets out 'a new vision for childcare in England'; Table S.1 states none, and Tax-Free Childcare is UK-wide. The report states no year; Table S.1's sources are Coram Family and Childcare (2022), DWP (2021) and ONS (2021; 2022c). 2022-23 is staged as the price and policy base of a report published in September 2022, not as a year IPPR states.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "IPPR's figure is the total cost of one subsidy replacing both Tax-Free Childcare and the UC childcare element (95% for UC families) and covering school-age care, in a world with 30 free hours for every child from six months, at 2022 rates. The analysis publishes the change in spending from replacing Tax-Free Childcare alone with a 75% subsidy, keeping the UC element at 85% and the 2025 entitlements, in 2027-28 to 2029-30. Its results file also holds the reform's spending on the subsidy (legs.subsidy.spending.tax_free_childcare, 5.5062 in 2027), which the dashboard does not publish and which leaves out UC families; neither figure measures IPPR's quantity."} +{"key": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_low_fy2025", "source": "nef", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "nef_frs_childcare_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3000000000, "value_raw": "~£3", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_low", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2025-26", "basis": "post_behavioural", "geography": "England", "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025"}, "world": "nef_universal_family_childcare_promise", "reform_hint": "Universal core provision of 15 hours a week, free for all children from nine months to four years old ... For working families, a cap on childcare costs as a percentage of family earnings (we propose 5% but we also model for 7.5% to demonstrate the impact on costs) for hours purchased above this core provision to enable them to work.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", "date": "2025-07-31", "publisher": "New Economics Foundation", "primary_sha256": "3ccd8436ba587ffeca1e87f8e26bd0e75166af24e9811c872b4b74050f253530", "locator": "Summary, printed page 2 (PDF page 2); repeated on printed page 8", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Summary", "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", "quote": "At current hours of usage our proposed system would initially be cost-neutral, but as usage expanded it would present a net additional cost to the government of ~£3-3.4bn (based on current rates paid to providers, which we believe need to be reviewed regardless of the system in place) compared to the fully expanded funded hours system.", "note": "Printed as one range, '~£3-3.4bn', staged as its two ends. 'Current rates' are the 2025/26 government rates of Table A.2 (printed page 23); the period is that price base, not a year in which the cost falls: 'Any expanded system would not cost the full amount presented immediately, as it would take time for families to respond to the new offer' (printed page 18). The model is built on the 2022-23 Family Resources Survey. Printed page 18: at current reported hours the system 'costs an estimated £27m more to £331m less than the funded hours-based system', rising to 'a net additional cost of £3.0-£4.1bn a year more for our system under Model 1 (assuming no labour market response)' across its 5% and 7.5% caps and current and 10%-higher provider rates; printed page 8: net additional costs 'decline by as much as 11.4% once dynamic estimates of potential labour market response are accounted for'. The analysis lists this costing in its own comparable_costings as the closest published analogue to its free-hours leg.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition."} +{"key": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_high_fy2025", "source": "nef", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "nef_frs_childcare_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3400000000, "value_raw": "3.4bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_high", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2025-26", "basis": "post_behavioural", "geography": "England", "program": "universal_family_childcare_promise", "comparison": "net additional cost against the fully expanded funded hours system", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "basis_note": "with a childcare-use response (Model 1), before any labour market response", "range_group": "nef_ufcp_net_cost_fy2025"}, "world": "nef_universal_family_childcare_promise", "reform_hint": "Universal core provision of 15 hours a week, free for all children from nine months to four years old ... For working families, a cap on childcare costs as a percentage of family earnings (we propose 5% but we also model for 7.5% to demonstrate the impact on costs) for hours purchased above this core provision to enable them to work.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", "url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", "date": "2025-07-31", "publisher": "New Economics Foundation", "primary_sha256": "3ccd8436ba587ffeca1e87f8e26bd0e75166af24e9811c872b4b74050f253530", "locator": "Summary, printed page 2 (PDF page 2); repeated on printed page 8", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Summary", "source_column": "Net additional cost to the government as usage expands, current provider rates", "quote": "At current hours of usage our proposed system would initially be cost-neutral, but as usage expanded it would present a net additional cost to the government of ~£3-3.4bn (based on current rates paid to providers, which we believe need to be reviewed regardless of the system in place) compared to the fully expanded funded hours system.", "note": "Printed as one range, '~£3-3.4bn', staged as its two ends. 'Current rates' are the 2025/26 government rates of Table A.2 (printed page 23); the period is that price base, not a year in which the cost falls: 'Any expanded system would not cost the full amount presented immediately, as it would take time for families to respond to the new offer' (printed page 18). The model is built on the 2022-23 Family Resources Survey. Printed page 18: at current reported hours the system 'costs an estimated £27m more to £331m less than the funded hours-based system', rising to 'a net additional cost of £3.0-£4.1bn a year more for our system under Model 1 (assuming no labour market response)' across its 5% and 7.5% caps and current and 10%-higher provider rates; printed page 8: net additional costs 'decline by as much as 11.4% once dynamic estimates of potential labour market response are accounted for'. The analysis lists this costing in its own comparable_costings as the closest published analogue to its free-hours leg.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NEF's figure is the net cost of replacing the whole system (the funded hours, Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support) with 15 universal hours from nine months plus an earnings cap on further hours, once families buy more childcare. The analysis keeps the working-parent 30 hours and the UC element, lets no childcare use respond to the 75% subsidy (results file subsidy_take_up.note: 'Neither models new childcare use'), treats 90.53% of new free hours as displacing care families already buy (assumptions.free_hours_displacement), and publishes no figure on NEF's definition."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e050759f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +{"url": "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", "title": "Removing the childcare cliff-edge: impacts and cost of reform", "date": "2026-09-09", "publisher": "CenTax", "sha256": "733b7a1d48409071135303c3363482126ead83c4d6e02d9b7f049e4d3113140a", "bytes": 2709003, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Same bytes as sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold and sources/centax-childcare-100k (scorecard#207)."} +{"url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", "title": "Towards a childcare guarantee", "date": "2022-09-22", "publisher": "IPPR", "sha256": "6a567e2c98e55d99e6437718e8c7c286810264ccdf8fb7fe34e306ddd65ce3de", "bytes": 295962, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Statham, Parkes and Nanda. The IPPR article page links the same file with a ?dm= cache parameter."} +{"url": "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/delivering-a-childcare-guarantee-dec-22.pdf", "title": "Delivering a childcare guarantee", "date": "2022-12-06", "publisher": "IPPR and Save the Children", "sha256": "14b0ff6db62dde1f63b3b4747aa478d9e5f8c2f6495b012830870b21adff7327", "bytes": 402548, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "No claim is staged from it. Cited in the note on ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022 for the gross basis of IPPR's subsidy costings (printed page 34)."} +{"url": "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", "title": "The Universal Family Childcare Promise: Guaranteeing support for parents and children", "date": "2025-07-31", "publisher": "New Economics Foundation", "sha256": "3ccd8436ba587ffeca1e87f8e26bd0e75166af24e9811c872b4b74050f253530", "bytes": 1125420, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Policy briefing by Tom Pollard and Tom Stephens, developed with Pregnant Then Screwed and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation; linked from https://neweconomics.org/2025/07/the-universal-family-childcare-promise."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..241f2b4aa --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-free-childcare-reform/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,342 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113610-cmp-uk-free-childcare-reform", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "obr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:obr.uk childcare expansion costing free hours working parents 9 months Spring Budget 2023 labour supply", + "site:obr.uk Tax-Free Childcare costing", + "site:obr.uk childcare \"free hours\" costing uncertainty policy costings March 2023 supplementary", + "site:obr.uk November 2023 EFO childcare measure re-estimated welfare savings" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No OBR costing of either leg: neither is government policy. The OBR's March 2023 costing of the working-parent expansion scores the system this analysis takes as its baseline. obr.uk answered every fetch with a Cloudflare challenge, so OBR pages were seen in search results only." + }, + { + "producer": "hm_treasury", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Spring Budget 2023 policy costings childcare expansion free hours nine months HM Treasury", + "Autumn Budget 2025 childcare review Tax-Free Childcare free hours policy costing red book", + "Spending Review 2015 policy costings \"Tax-Free Childcare\" eligibility minimum income £100,000 costing note", + "gov.uk search API, HM Treasury: childcare cost; policy costings; the analysis's search terms", + "Parliament written questions API: \"Tax-Free Childcare\" (Treasury answers)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6419c8dde90e0769ea4a4eb6/Print_Budget_2023.pdf", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6411603be90e076ccf66d781/Costing_Document_-_Spring_Budget_2023.pdf", + "https://questions-statements-api.parliament.uk/api/writtenquestions/questions/1605950" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The Treasury has published no costing of either leg. Asked the cost of raising Tax-Free Childcare to 25% or 30% of childcare costs (written answer 170766, 28 March 2023), it replied 'Up-to-date estimates are not readily available and could only be provided at disproportionate cost.' Spring Budget 2023 Table 4.1 costs the working-parent expansion already in the analysis's baseline." + }, + { + "producer": "uk_hmrc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Tax-Free Childcare tax information and impact note", + "\"Tax-Free Childcare\" budget policy costing HMRC change 2025 OR 2026", + "gov.uk search API, HMRC: impact assessments, policy papers and FOI releases on Tax-Free Childcare" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/652939/Tax-free_childcare_Impact_Assessment-March_2017.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No tax information and impact note or HMRC costing of any change to Tax-Free Childcare's rate, cap, work test or income limit. HMRC's Tax-Free Childcare statistics are the outturn the analysis benchmarks its baseline against, not estimates of a reform." + }, + { + "producer": "dwp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Universal Credit childcare costs upfront raise cap 2023 impact assessment DWP costing", + "gov.uk search API, DWP: childcare impact assessments and equality analyses" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2023/593/pdfs/uksiem_20230593_en_002.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The 75% subsidy leg keeps the Universal Credit childcare element at 85%; DWP's costings of the 2023 changes to that element score a different measure." + }, + { + "producer": "dfe", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "written question estimate cost extending free childcare hours to children of non-working parents Department for Education", + "\"Early Education and Childcare Review\" Department for Education 2026", + "Parliament written questions API, Department for Education: non-working parents; universal childcare; free childcare; funded hours; nine months; 15 hours; childcare subsidy; 75 per cent", + "site:gov.uk 75% childcare subsidy cost OR replace Tax-Free Childcare cost OR universal free childcare hours cost OR extend free childcare non-working parents cost" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/66221ba8252f0d71cf757d2b/Spring_budget_2023_childcare_expansion_costing_note_information.pdf", + "https://questions-statements-api.parliament.uk/api/writtenquestions/questions/1926266", + "https://questions-statements-api.parliament.uk/api/writtenquestions/questions/1939139" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "DfE has published no costing of extending free hours to every child from 9 months. Asked the annual cost of extending the 30 hours to non-working parents (written answer 17308, 4 August 2026), it gave none; the answer says 'Nearly 1.5 million children aged 9 months to school age are excluded from the full 30-hour entitlement'. Its 2023 expansion costing note (about £4.1bn by 2027-28) scores the baseline. Written answer 28019 (14 September 2026) values the 30 hours the £100,000 limit withholds at £446m to £874m in 2025/26, at full take-up and full use: a different quantity from the analysis's 15 hours for all." + }, + { + "producer": "scottish_fiscal_commission", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "The SFC's list applies to Scotland-scoped analyses; this one is UK-wide." + }, + { + "producer": "ifs", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:ifs.org.uk remove work test childcare cost free hours non-working parents", + "site:ifs.org.uk tax-free childcare reform cost increase rate cap", + "IFS universal childcare cost all children 15 hours \"regardless of\" work status England estimate billion", + "IFS 2025 OR 2026 childcare entitlements cost extending to non-working families under-threes Farquharson Drayton", + "IFS Green Budget 2025 childcare chapter early years entitlements cost options", + "IFS \"Fair Start\" Sutton Trust 2021 remove work test 30 hours cost" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/BN264-proposals-for-the-early-years-in-england.pdf", + "https://www.ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2023-09/IFS-R274-Early-years-spending-update-Budget-reforms-and-beyond.pdf", + "https://www.suttontrust.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Costing-options-for-extending-the-30-hour-entitlement.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The IFS costings found score other reforms: BN264 (November 2019) prices the 2019 parties' 30- and 35-hour pledges against the pre-2023 system; Farquharson's costing for the Sutton Trust (August 2021) prices removing the work test from the 30 hours for 3-4 year olds (about £250m in 2024-25), an age group whose hours the analysis does not change; R274 (September 2023) prices the 2023 expansion. No IFS costing of 15 hours for every child from 9 months or of replacing Tax-Free Childcare. ifs.org.uk HTML pages refuse plain fetches; they were read through a reader proxy, the PDFs directly." + }, + { + "producer": "resolution_foundation", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:resolutionfoundation.org childcare tax-free childcare reform cost", + "Resolution Foundation childcare extend free hours non-working parents cost billion report", + "resolutionfoundation.org \"tax-free childcare\" cost scrap OR replace OR reform 2026", + "Resolution Foundation childcare 2026 report \"funded hours\" OR \"free hours\" cost extend" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/hard-lessons/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Hard lessons (November 2024) costs an extra 15 hours for 3-4 year olds of student parents (£130m in 2024/25), a different reform. No RF costing of extending the entitlements to non-working parents or of reforming Tax-Free Childcare." + }, + { + "producer": "centax", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:centax.org.uk childcare", + "CenTax childcare tax-free childcare reform cost cliff edge report taper options" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://centax.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/AdvaniFlewPepin-HallSummers2026_Removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge.pdf", + "https://centax.org.uk/removing-the-childcare-cliff-edge-impacts-and-cost-of-reform/" + ], + "claims": [ + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_static_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_actual_ani_net_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2027", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2028", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_static_fy2029", + "centax_first_15_under_3s_expected_ani_net_fy2029" + ], + "note": "The row 'Abolish the threshold for the first 15 Hours to Under-3s' costs one group the free-hours leg also reaches, static and net, central scenario: on actual ANI (Table 4.3, the report's primary results, and Table B.1 for 2029) and on expected ANI, today's test (Table B.2), for 2027-28 to 2029-30. The report does not cost Tax-Free Childcare changes, and no other CenTax childcare publication was found." + }, + { + "producer": "centre_for_british_progress", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Centre for British Progress \"Rates and Wrongs\" childcare", + "britishprogress.org childcare tax-free childcare free hours cost" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/rates_and_wrongs_technical_appendix.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Rates and Wrongs (March 2026) costs removing the £100,000 limit from both the working-parent 30 hours and Tax-Free Childcare, net of behaviour; it is staged in sources/analysis-uk-childcare-100k-threshold. It changes neither Tax-Free Childcare's rate nor its work test, and its free-hours side gives the over-£100,000 families all 30 hours, which this analysis does not." + }, + { + "producer": "ippr", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:ippr.org childcare cost universal free hours extend all children", + "IPPR universal childcare guarantee report cost 2026", + "IPPR \"tax-free childcare\" reform replace co-payment scheme cost 2025 OR 2026", + "IPPR 2025 OR 2026 childcare report free hours non-working parents universal entitlement cost billion" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/towards-a-childcare-guarantee-sept-22.pdf", + "https://files.ippr.org/production/Downloads/delivering-a-childcare-guarantee-dec-22.pdf", + "https://www.ippr.org/articles/towards-a-childcare-guarantee", + "https://www.ippr.org/articles/delivering-a-childcare-guarantee" + ], + "claims": [ + "ippr_universal_15_hours_under_twos_fy2022", + "ippr_universal_15_hours_two_year_olds_fy2022", + "ippr_reformed_subsidy_75_95_fy2022" + ], + "note": "Towards a childcare guarantee (September 2022) has the only costing found of a 75% childcare subsidy (with 95% for families on means-tested benefits, replacing Tax-Free Childcare and the UC element) and of universal 15 hours for under-twos and two-year-olds, all on the 2022 system. Its 30% and 60% subsidy rows and its 30-hour and 48-week variants are not staged. Delivering a childcare guarantee (December 2022) repeats the hours costings and gives its 60% subsidy scheme's cost as a total 'not accounting for current spending'. IPPR's Childcare challenge (December 2024) proposes extending the entitlement to all two-year-olds below £100,000 without a cost." + }, + { + "producer": "fabian_society", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:fabians.org.uk childcare cost universal free hours", + "site:fabians.org.uk Tax-Free Childcare replace subsidy cost", + "Fabian Society childcare report cost billion free hours all children", + "\"Fabian Society\" childcare 2026 report free hours universal cost" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://fabians.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/FABP10686-Tract-Plans-for-power-230925-WEB.pdf", + "https://fabians.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/FIRST-STEPS-PDF-23-May.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Plans for Power (2023) proposes 30 hours from 9 months for low-income children 'irrespective of parents' employment status' with no cost; First Steps (2025) costs social security options only." + }, + { + "producer": "niesr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:niesr.ac.uk childcare cost free hours reform", + "site:niesr.ac.uk Tax-Free Childcare subsidy", + "NIESR childcare policy costing employment effect universal childcare UK", + "NIESR \"Living Standards Review\" 2026 childcare" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://niesr.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/JC871-NIESR-UK-Living-Standards-Review-2025-final-version.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "ukmod", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:microsimulation.ac.uk childcare UKMOD", + "UKMOD childcare subsidy simulation CeMPA working paper", + "UKMOD \"childcare\" policy reform cost estimate \"Tax-Free Childcare\" microsimulation" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "CeMPA has published no childcare costing. De Henau's UKMOD simulation of universal full-time childcare (2022, a journal article) is logged under academic." + }, + { + "producer": "lse_case", + "result": "found_not_staged", + "queries": [ + "Paull CASE Early Education and Childcare Coalition report reforming childcare support single system Universal Credit Tax-Free Childcare October 2026", + "\"Reforming childcare subsidies\" Early Education and Childcare Coalition CASE report pdf", + "LSE CASE Kitty Stewart cost extending free childcare hours to all children non-working families" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.lse.ac.uk/research-shows-how-childcare-support-could-be-improved-without-substantial-government-cost", + "https://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case/_new/news/abstract/?index=1560" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Reforming childcare subsidies (Gillian Paull, CASE, with the Early Education and Childcare Coalition, 19 October 2026) models replacing Tax-Free Childcare and UC childcare support with one subsidy for working families that tapers with earnings. The LSE release gives its cost only as a percentage of an unstated base ('the increase in subsidy costs for the Government is estimated to be 15% for an hourly subsidy compared to 56% for the smooth subsidy rate'), on Family Resources Survey data updated to 2026/27, assuming parents do not change their work patterns or childcare use. The report at https://www.earlyeducationchildcare.org/reforming-childcare-subsidies refused every fetch (403), so there is no primary to stage (harvest rule 8). Its options cover working families, taper the rate with earnings and absorb the UC element, unlike the analysis's flat 75% subsidy for all." + }, + { + "producer": "jrf", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:jrf.org.uk childcare cost free hours universal", + "site:jrf.org.uk Tax-Free Childcare reform cost", + "site:jrf.org.uk Universal Family Childcare Promise", + "JRF childcare offer extend to non-working parents cost estimate child poverty strategy funded hours" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/sites/default/files/pdfs/a-new-social-contract-in-the-childcare-system-afab9ab8d7e504eb213769c1abdf9965.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "JRF co-developed NEF's Universal Family Childcare Promise; the costing is NEF's and is staged under open_search with source nef. JRF's own childcare costings score other reforms (a Scottish offer, 2024; workforce and market reforms, 2024)." + }, + { + "producer": "landman_economics", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Landman Economics\" childcare free hours cost universal Howard Reed", + "\"Landman Economics\" \"Tax-Free Childcare\" OR \"childcare subsidy\" modelling TUC OR IPPR OR \"Women's Budget Group\"" + ], + "checked": [ + "http://www.landman-economics.co.uk/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Landman's model appears only inside other producers' work (De Henau's WBG costings, 2017 and 2019; Fabian reports), none of which costs either leg." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_policy_associates", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk childcare cliff Tax-Free Childcare £100,000", + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk free childcare hours cost reform", + "Tax Policy Associates childcare cliff edge cost of fixing Dan Neidle" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2024/10/17/reform-income-tax-end-the-scandal-of-high-marginal-rates/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "TPA's 'somewhere between £5-10bn' (October 2024) is an unsourced range for making child benefit, the personal allowance and childcare subsidies universal together; no cost of either leg." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Simulating employment and fiscal effects of public investment in high-quality universal childcare in the UK\" De Henau", + "microsimulation childcare subsidy reform UK maternal labour supply fiscal cost structural model working paper 2022 2023 2024", + "\"Tax-Free Childcare\" reform simulation paper labour supply UK IZA OR ISER OR \"working paper\"", + "\"universal childcare\" UK \"under-threes\" fiscal cost simulation journal article employment effects", + "IZA discussion paper free childcare England maternal labour supply 30 hours" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8853244/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "De Henau (2022, International Journal of Child Care and Education Policy) costs free universal childcare at 40 hours a week, 48 weeks a year, from six months, with staff pay reform (gross £26.6bn to £49.4bn, UK, 2018): not either leg. Brewer, Cattan, Crawford and Rabe (2022) estimate employment effects of free hours, not a cost. No paper costs universal 15 hours from 9 months or a flat-rate subsidy in the UK." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "75% childcare subsidy replace Tax-Free Childcare cost UK", + "universal 15 free childcare hours from 9 months all children no work test cost estimate £bn", + "childcare subsidy reform UK cost replace tax-free childcare single subsidy think tank 2026", + "\"75 per cent of childcare costs\" OR \"75% of childcare costs\" UK proposal subsidy 2025 OR 2026", + "extend 30 hours free childcare to families on benefits non-working parents cost £bn 2026 government plan", + "Sutton Trust extend free childcare hours non-working families cost Frontier Economics", + "Women's Budget Group De Henau universal free childcare cost billion", + "Onward \"First Steps\" fixing childcare tax-free childcare report cost", + "Policy Exchange July 2026 childcare report", + "Liberal Democrat 2024 manifesto costings free childcare all parents nine months regardless of work cost billion" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://new-economicsf.files.svdcdn.com/production/files/The-Universal-Family-Childcare-Promise-final.pdf?dm=1753872465", + "https://neweconomics.org/2025/07/the-universal-family-childcare-promise", + "https://www.suttontrust.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Opportunity-for-all-TechnicalAppendix.pdf", + "https://wbg.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/De_Henau_WBG_childcare_briefing3_2017_02_20-1.pdf", + "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/A-Matter-of-Choice_.pdf", + "https://www.ukonward.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Onward-First-Steps-Version-1.pdf", + "https://www.libdems.org.uk/fileadmin/groups/2_Federal_Party/Documents/PolicyPapers/Manifesto_2024/Funding_a_Fair_Deal_-_Liberal_Democrat_Manifesto_Costings_2024.pdf", + "https://www.openanursery.co.uk/government-considers-extending-30-hours-free-childcare-to-families-on-benefits", + "https://streamlinefeed.co.ke/news/uk-labour-urged-to-halt-15-billion-plan-for-universal-childcare-benefits" + ], + "claims": [ + "nef_ufcp_net_cost_low_fy2025", + "nef_ufcp_net_cost_high_fy2025" + ], + "note": "NEF's Universal Family Childcare Promise (July 2025, source nef) is staged. Checked and not comparable: the Sutton Trust's BCG costings (May 2024: 30 hours for two-year-olds, 20 hours for 2-4 year olds with a sliding subsidy); the Women's Budget Group's universal full-time childcare (2017, 2020); Policy Exchange's cost-neutral replacement of every scheme with a payment card (July 2026); Onward's childcare credit (December 2022, no cost for all 1-4 year olds); the Liberal Democrats' 2024 costings (no free hours from 9 months); the HM Treasury and OBR costing of the 2023 expansion, which the analysis cites as a cost anchor. A July 2026 press figure of '£15 billion' for 30 hours for families on benefits names no producer and has no primary. No other UK proposal of a 75% childcare subsidy was found." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/free-childcare-reform@1a832f1703b56c8cd044c8d3f87d469f70e3d3e8:c559e6f07417bcaf7ac89d68d6c1fa61d182a34bcfb85d666f75cce818816285" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/README.md b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1e3a306f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +# Middle East war and UK living standards: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md). The dashboard was +listed on policyengine.org on 25 September 2026, before the gate existed. + +- **Published figures** (pinned in `analysis.json`, 42 estimates, all for 2027-28): for each of + the three annual stress tests (Summer 2026 prices, Sustained escalation, Severe escalation), + the mean cost of the energy, fuel and food price rises per household, the energy channel per + household, and the people and households newly below the anchored poverty line; and the + gross outlay of each of the ten policy responses. They are read from + `PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards` at `45592bb`, the Vercel production + deployment the live page serves, `dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json`, SHA-256 + `382d64b9…`; the live page's copy has the same hash. +- **These are the figures live today, not those of 25 September.** The results file was + regenerated eleven times on 28 September. Against the results file of the 25 September + production deployments (the last, `928851a`, at 16:07 UTC), the accelerated uprating cost + moved from £1.11bn, £2.64bn and £4.51bn to £0.66bn, £3.64bn and £7.27bn, the combined package + from £38.07bn, £54.62bn and £79.0bn to £37.63bn, £55.61bn and £81.76bn, and the household + poverty count was added; the other pinned figures are unchanged. + The file's own provenance records generation at `976b7a8` from a dirty tree, before the + commit that holds it. +- **What the search found** (2026-10-21, every UK producer): 34 claims from the Resolution + Foundation, IFS, HM Treasury, NIESR, JRF, Cebr and the TUC. Most are for 2026 or 2026-27, + while the dashboard models 2027-28 only, so each says in `pe_missing` why it is not compared. + They include the price-cap figures the dashboard sets beside its own energy channel (RF's + ~£500 if prices were sustained, and its £130, £230 and £440 July 2026 cap scenarios). +- **The comparisons**: two, both constructed across worlds. IFS puts the annual cost of making + the electricity VAT cut permanent at about £1.5bn and RF the cut's annual cost in future years + at £1.7bn; the dashboard's full-year 2027-28 extension costs £1.55bn under Summer 2026 prices, + 3% above IFS and 9% below RF. Neither producer names a year, so the 2027-28 reading is noted + on each claim; the dashboard's version also covers Northern Ireland, which the enacted cut + does not, and omits the non-household supplies the relief covers. Under the escalation + scenarios the same extension costs £1.95bn and £2.56bn. +- **Annotated**: the IFS cost of making the 5p fuel duty cut permanent and freezing duty for a + further year (£2.7bn, or £3.2bn on Barclays inflation) and RF's cost of reversing the cut + gradually (over £1bn in 2027-28) score different policies from the dashboard's 5p cut + (£2.18bn), so they are recorded as concept mismatches, not compared. +- **Not staged**, with the reason in `search_log.json`: figures whose primary could not be + read (IFS's VAT-cut response, behind Cloudflare; Cornwall Insight's cap forecasts, including + the £288 JRF cites, behind a 401); figures a producer repeats from others (the Government + costs RF and IFS restate, the 2022 schemes); budgets a producer chose rather than estimated + (RF's £3.75bn envelopes and £2bn targeted discounts); options with no counterpart among the + dashboard's ten; Ofgem's announced caps, which anchor the Summer 2026 prices scenario; and + inflation figures, since the dashboard's CPI additions are scenario parameters, not + estimates. + +One of the dashboard's own external comparisons links the wrong page: it cites RF's 2 April +2026 release for the ~£500 bill rise, which is in RF's 4 March release. Its NIESR figure of +about 200,000 households is NIESR's own rounding of the 195,000 staged here. diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b0051c4b9 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,1708 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "country": "UK", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "middle-east-war-living-standards", + "country_id": "uk" + }, + "title": "Impact of the Middle East war on UK living standards", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "published": "2026-09-25", + "owner": { + "author": "vahid-ahmadi" + }, + "scope": "uk_wide", + "subject": "What energy, motor fuel and food price rises from the Middle East conflict and Strait of Hormuz disruption would cost UK households in 2027-28 under three annual stress-test scenarios (cost per household, the energy channel and people newly below an anchored poverty line), and the gross cost of ten policy responses.", + "search_terms": [ + "Middle East war UK living standards", + "Strait of Hormuz energy prices households", + "energy shock household incomes 2027", + "oil price shock UK households cost", + "Iran war cost UK households", + "energy price guarantee 2026 cost", + "electricity VAT cut cost", + "fuel duty 5p cut extension cost", + "social tariff energy 2026 cost", + "energy price shock poverty UK households" + ], + "worlds": { + "epg": { + "policy": "uk_mew_epg_bill_rise_capped_at_10pct", + "description": "The analysis's stylised Energy Price Guarantee: government pays each household's energy bill rise above 10% of its baseline energy spending (EPG_CAP_PCT = 0.10), for 2027-28." + }, + "flat_rebate": { + "policy": "uk_mew_flat_energy_rebate_400", + "description": "A flat £400 energy rebate to every household in 2027-28, modelled on the 2022 Energy Bills Support Scheme." + }, + "ct_rebate": { + "policy": "uk_mew_council_tax_rebate_300_bands_a_to_d", + "description": "A £300 rebate to every household in council tax bands A to D, UK-wide (stylised; the 2022 scheme paid £150 in England)." + }, + "uc_uplift": { + "policy": "uk_mew_uc_uplift_20_per_week", + "description": "A £20 a week uplift to every Universal Credit recipient household for 2027-28, matching the 2020-21 uplift." + }, + "fuel_duty_cut": { + "policy": "uk_mew_fuel_duty_5p_cut_2027_28", + "description": "A 5p a litre fuel duty cut for the whole of 2027-28, after the cut in force to 31 December 2026. The pinned outlay is 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres (compute_policies); a separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same £2.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost)." + }, + "means_tested": { + "policy": "uk_mew_means_tested_payment_650", + "description": "A £650 cost-of-living payment in two instalments (£326 and £324) to households on a benefit that qualified for the 2022 payment, each paid at an assumed 85% per-window entitlement rate." + }, + "elec_vat_cut": { + "policy": "uk_mew_domestic_electricity_vat_zero_2027_28", + "description": "VAT on domestic electricity at 0% rather than 5% for the whole of 2027-28, extending the cut in force from 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027, for every UK household: compute_policies applies it with no region filter, so Northern Ireland is included, while the enacted cut covers Great Britain only." + }, + "accelerated_uprating": { + "policy": "uk_mew_accelerated_cpi_benefit_uprating", + "description": "CPI-uprated benefit rates raised at once by each scenario's residual CPI addition (the part of the shock September 2026 CPI did not capture), for 2027-28." + }, + "social_tariff": { + "policy": "uk_mew_social_tariff_half_of_energy_rise", + "description": "Households on Universal Credit or with household net income below £20,000 have half of their energy price rise offset." + }, + "combined": { + "policy": "uk_mew_combined_package", + "description": "The eight measures other than the social tariff applied together, the Energy Price Guarantee capping the bill before the electricity VAT relief applies to it." + }, + "elec_vat_cut_six_months": { + "policy": "uk_domestic_electricity_vat_zero_oct_2026_mar_2027", + "description": "The enacted temporary zero rate of VAT on domestic electricity in Great Britain from 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027 (announced 21 July 2026)." + }, + "elec_vat_cut_gb_continued": { + "policy": "uk_domestic_electricity_vat_zero_rate_gb_continued_after_march_2027", + "description": "The Great Britain zero rate of VAT on domestic electricity continued after 31 March 2027: IFS's 'permanent' cut, and RF's annual cost of the cut in future years." + }, + "fuel_duty_gradual_reversal": { + "policy": "uk_rf_fuel_duty_quarterly_rises_reversing_5p_cut", + "description": "Resolution Foundation: small quarterly fuel duty rises that reverse the 5p cut and then raise duty by, say, 3 per cent a year, costed against current policy." + }, + "uc_and_pension_credit_uprating_brought_forward": { + "policy": "uk_rf_uc_above_inflation_rise_brought_forward_sept_2026", + "description": "Resolution Foundation: the Parliament's planned above-inflation rises in the Universal Credit standard allowance brought forward to September 2026, with an equivalent temporary boost for Pension Credit." + }, + "fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze": { + "policy": "uk_fuel_duty_5p_cut_permanent_and_2027_freeze", + "description": "IFS Green Budget 2026: the 5p fuel duty cut made permanent and fuel duty rates frozen for a further year instead of rising with RPI." + }, + "fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030": { + "policy": "uk_fuel_duty_5p_cut_permanent_and_freeze_to_2029_30", + "description": "IFS Green Budget 2026: the 5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended until 2029-30." + }, + "epg_style_cap_at_april_2026": { + "policy": "uk_jrf_epg_style_cap_at_april_2026_price_cap", + "description": "JRF: an Energy Price Guarantee-style intervention capping energy prices at the April 2026 Ofgem price cap, on July 2026 cost projections." + }, + "energy_discounts_offset_cpi_rise": { + "policy": "uk_rf_energy_price_discounts_offset_1_5pp_cpi", + "description": "Resolution Foundation: energy price discounts large enough to offset the roughly 1.5 percentage point rise in the Bank of England's inflation outlook for Q3 2026, continued for a year." + }, + "uc_uplift_10_six_months": { + "policy": "uk_niesr_uc_uplift_10_per_week_six_months", + "description": "NIESR: a temporary £10 a week uplift to Universal Credit for six months over the autumn and winter." + }, + "tuc_standard_social_tariff": { + "policy": "uk_tuc_standard_social_tariff_25_15", + "description": "TUC: a 25% bill reduction for households below the relative poverty line and 15% for those between it and median income (equivalised BHC household income)." + }, + "tuc_energy_crisis_social_tariff": { + "policy": "uk_tuc_energy_crisis_social_tariff_30_20_10", + "description": "TUC: during an energy crisis, a 30%, 20% or 10% bill reduction for households below the relative poverty line, below median income and below mean income respectively." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "household_cost_low", + "label": "Mean direct cost of the energy, fuel and food price rises per household, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -538.0, + "value_raw": "538", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the cost of the price rises as a positive £ per household (summary.mean_net_impact); average_household_income_change is positive = gain to households, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "income_concept": "cost netted off household resources at fixed consumption; nominal income unchanged (the poverty measure nets the same cost off HBAI income, metadata.poverty_definition)", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.low_shock.summary.mean_net_impact" + } + }, + { + "key": "energy_bill_rise_low", + "label": "Mean rise in household gas and electricity spending, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 238.0, + "value_raw": "238", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "channel": "energy: the scenario percentage applied to each household's own baseline gas and electricity spending, not a price-cap calculation (metadata.energy_channel_basis)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in annual household energy spending", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.low_shock.channel_decomposition.energy_shock" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_persons_low", + "label": "People newly below the anchored poverty line, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 379109.0, + "value_raw": "379,109", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.low_shock.summary.n_pushed_into_poverty" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_households_low", + "label": "Households newly below the anchored poverty line, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 185699.0, + "value_raw": "185,699", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.low_shock.summary.n_households_newly_below_anchored_line" + } + }, + { + "key": "household_cost_central", + "label": "Mean direct cost of the energy, fuel and food price rises per household, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1334.0, + "value_raw": "1334", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the cost of the price rises as a positive £ per household (summary.mean_net_impact); average_household_income_change is positive = gain to households, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "income_concept": "cost netted off household resources at fixed consumption; nominal income unchanged (the poverty measure nets the same cost off HBAI income, metadata.poverty_definition)", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.central_shock.summary.mean_net_impact" + } + }, + { + "key": "energy_bill_rise_central", + "label": "Mean rise in household gas and electricity spending, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 713.0, + "value_raw": "713", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "channel": "energy: the scenario percentage applied to each household's own baseline gas and electricity spending, not a price-cap calculation (metadata.energy_channel_basis)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in annual household energy spending", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.central_shock.channel_decomposition.energy_shock" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_persons_central", + "label": "People newly below the anchored poverty line, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 1508923.0, + "value_raw": "1,508,923", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.central_shock.summary.n_pushed_into_poverty" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_households_central", + "label": "Households newly below the anchored poverty line, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 750843.0, + "value_raw": "750,843", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.central_shock.summary.n_households_newly_below_anchored_line" + } + }, + { + "key": "household_cost_severe", + "label": "Mean direct cost of the energy, fuel and food price rises per household, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2304.0, + "value_raw": "2304", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the cost of the price rises as a positive £ per household (summary.mean_net_impact); average_household_income_change is positive = gain to households, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "income_concept": "cost netted off household resources at fixed consumption; nominal income unchanged (the poverty measure nets the same cost off HBAI income, metadata.poverty_definition)", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.severe_shock.summary.mean_net_impact" + } + }, + { + "key": "energy_bill_rise_severe", + "label": "Mean rise in household gas and electricity spending, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "energy_bill_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 1426.0, + "value_raw": "1426", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "statistic": "mean over all households", + "channel": "energy: the scenario percentage applied to each household's own baseline gas and electricity spending, not a price-cap calculation (metadata.energy_channel_basis)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in annual household energy spending", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.severe_shock.channel_decomposition.energy_shock" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_persons_severe", + "label": "People newly below the anchored poverty line, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "persons", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 2337905.0, + "value_raw": "2,337,905", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.severe_shock.summary.n_pushed_into_poverty" + } + }, + { + "key": "newly_below_line_households_severe", + "label": "Households newly below the anchored poverty line, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "households", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 1159588.0, + "value_raw": "1,159,588", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_line": "60% of the 2027-28 pre-shock person-weighted median equivalised HBAI household net income (BHC), held fixed; modelled costs netted off income (metadata.poverty_definition)", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number below the anchored poverty line", + "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "scenarios.severe_shock.summary.n_households_newly_below_anchored_line" + } + }, + { + "key": "epg_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the Energy Price Guarantee, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "epg", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2500000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.5", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.epg.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_rebate_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the flat £400 energy rebate, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -12630000000.0, + "value_raw": "12.63", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "flat_energy_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.flat_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "ct_rebate_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £300 council tax rebate (bands A-D), Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "ct_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7580000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.58", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "council_tax_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.ct_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "uc_uplift_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £20 a week Universal Credit uplift, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "uc_uplift", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6280000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.28", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.uc_uplift.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the 5p fuel duty cut extension, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "fuel_duty_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2180000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.18", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "means_tested_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £650 means-tested cost-of-living payment, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "means_tested", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4320000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.32", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.means_tested.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "elec_vat_cut_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the electricity VAT cut extension, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "elec_vat_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1550000000.0, + "value_raw": "1.55", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "accelerated_uprating_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the accelerated benefit uprating, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "accelerated_uprating", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -660000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.66", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.accelerated_uprating.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "social_tariff_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the social tariff, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "social_tariff", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -710000000.0, + "value_raw": "0.71", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.social_tariff.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "combined_cost_low", + "label": "Gross outlay of the combined package, Summer 2026 prices, 2027-28", + "world": "combined", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -37630000000.0, + "value_raw": "37.63", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Summer 2026 prices", + "scenario_key": "low_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +15%, motor fuel +22%, food +2% (scenarios.low_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "combined_support_package", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.low_shock.combined.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "epg_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the Energy Price Guarantee, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "epg", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -17510000000.0, + "value_raw": "17.51", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.epg.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_rebate_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the flat £400 energy rebate, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -12630000000.0, + "value_raw": "12.63", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "flat_energy_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.flat_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "ct_rebate_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £300 council tax rebate (bands A-D), Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "ct_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7580000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.58", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "council_tax_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.ct_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "uc_uplift_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £20 a week Universal Credit uplift, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "uc_uplift", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6280000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.28", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.uc_uplift.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the 5p fuel duty cut extension, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "fuel_duty_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2180000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.18", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "means_tested_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £650 means-tested cost-of-living payment, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "means_tested", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4320000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.32", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.means_tested.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "elec_vat_cut_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the electricity VAT cut extension, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "elec_vat_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1950000000.0, + "value_raw": "1.95", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "accelerated_uprating_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the accelerated benefit uprating, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "accelerated_uprating", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -3640000000.0, + "value_raw": "3.64", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.accelerated_uprating.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "social_tariff_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the social tariff, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "social_tariff", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2120000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.12", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.social_tariff.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "combined_cost_central", + "label": "Gross outlay of the combined package, Sustained escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "combined", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -55610000000.0, + "value_raw": "55.61", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Sustained escalation", + "scenario_key": "central_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +45%, motor fuel +46%, food +4% (scenarios.central_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "combined_support_package", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.central_shock.combined.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "epg_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the Energy Price Guarantee, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "epg", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -40020000000.0, + "value_raw": "40.02", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_price_guarantee", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.epg.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "flat_rebate_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the flat £400 energy rebate, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "flat_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -12630000000.0, + "value_raw": "12.63", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "flat_energy_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.flat_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "ct_rebate_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £300 council tax rebate (bands A-D), Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "ct_rebate", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7580000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.58", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "council_tax_rebate", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.ct_rebate.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "uc_uplift_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £20 a week Universal Credit uplift, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "uc_uplift", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -6280000000.0, + "value_raw": "6.28", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "universal_credit_uplift", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.uc_uplift.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the 5p fuel duty cut extension, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "fuel_duty_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2180000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.18", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.fuel_duty_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "means_tested_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the £650 means-tested cost-of-living payment, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "means_tested", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4320000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.32", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "cost_of_living_payment", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.means_tested.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "elec_vat_cut_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the electricity VAT cut extension, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "elec_vat_cut", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2560000000.0, + "value_raw": "2.56", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.elec_vat_cut.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "accelerated_uprating_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the accelerated benefit uprating, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "accelerated_uprating", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7270000000.0, + "value_raw": "7.27", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "benefit_uprating", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.accelerated_uprating.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "social_tariff_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the social tariff, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "social_tariff", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4250000000.0, + "value_raw": "4.25", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "energy_social_tariff", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.social_tariff.gross_outlay_bn" + } + }, + { + "key": "combined_cost_severe", + "label": "Gross outlay of the combined package, Severe escalation, 2027-28", + "world": "combined", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -81760000000.0, + "value_raw": "81.76", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints each policy's gross outlay as a positive number of pounds billion; revenue_change is stated positive = yield to the Exchequer, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2027-28", + "scenario": "Severe escalation", + "scenario_key": "severe_shock", + "price_assumptions": "energy +90%, motor fuel +62%, food +6.5% (scenarios.severe_shock.params)", + "basis": "static", + "cost_basis": "gross modelled household transfer, before tax and benefit interactions, take-up, behavioural response, administration, non-household use and financing", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "program": "combined_support_package", + "basis_note": "annual stress test: full-year 2027-28 price rises at fixed consumption, no time path or behavioural response (metadata.scenario_type)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards", + "commit": "45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json", + "sha256": "382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead", + "computed_at": "2026-09-28T17:09:48+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "5.3.0", + "policyengine_uk": "2.90.2" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25 policyengine-uk-data-1.56.16 (bundle uk-5.3.0)", + "field": "policy_responses.severe_shock.combined.gross_outlay_bn" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b17622f82 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,39 @@ +[ + { + "id": "fuel-duty-different-policies", + "claims": [ + "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", + "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", + "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Each figure scores a different fuel duty policy. IFS costs making the 5p cut permanent together with freezing fuel duties for a further year; the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) reverses the cut on 1 January and 1 March 2027 and records that Budget 2025 announced RPI uprating in future years, so the IFS policy also forgoes an uprating. IFS names no year, and the figures are staged as 2027-28 on that reading. RF costs steady rises that reverse the cut gradually, at over £1 billion in 2027-28 against current policy. The analysis costs a 5p cut for the whole of 2027-28 at 5p on each vehicle-owning household's modelled petrol and diesel litres, £2.18bn in every scenario (compute_policies); its separate PolicyEngine reform cutting PolicyEngine's 2027-28 rate of 59.25p by 5p gives the same £2.18bn (parameters.fuel_duty_exchequer_cost).", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf#page=89" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf#page=32" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/amended-fuel-duty-rates-for-2026-to-2027/amended-fuel-duty-rates-2026-to-2027" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L692-L700" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L570" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/dashboard/public/data/iran_impact_results.json" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..71aff5460 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{"key": "rf_median_working_age_income_loss_fy2027", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_living_standards_forecast", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 480, "value_raw": "£480", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "statistic": "median", "population": "working-age households", "scenario": "market pricing for energy after the ceasefire announcement, against no conflict", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as £480 worse off)", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households £480 worse off this year", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", "date": "2026-04-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "38b27a4655540ec3ccbd31eed7417a5d9cabed4a2ab92b7c1d347b2961b492f2", "locator": "press release, first paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Press release text", "source_column": "Median working-age household, change against no conflict", "note": "'This year' is the current financial year: the release puts the £480 as the difference between the 0.9 per cent growth expected before the conflict and a 0.6 per cent fall 'over the course of the current financial year'. The statistic is a median; the metric's statistic rides in conditions.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "RF's figure is the median working-age household's real-income loss in 2026-27 against a no-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the mean direct cost of the price rises per household in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), a different year and statistic.", "quote": "Higher energy prices due to the conflict in the Middle East are set to deal a blow to British living standards, with market pricing suggesting that the median working-age household will be £480 worse off this year than they would have been if the conflict had not taken place, the Resolution Foundation said today (Monday).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_typical_bill_rise_if_sustained", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "price_cap_arithmetic", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 500, "value_raw": "£500", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"statistic": "typical annual energy bill (Ofgem price cap)", "scenario": "oil and gas price rises since the conflict began (to 4 March 2026) sustained", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the typical annual energy bill", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", "date": "2026-03-04", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "cd1ea581e0173ad97dc9512d3b58849278d01e1586bcf939631b313b80128609", "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Press release text", "source_column": "Typical annual energy bill if recent price rises are sustained", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "RF names no year. 'Power struggle' (18 March 2026) puts the same ~£500 as the July 2026 price cap's uplift on April's level if gas prices returned to their early-March highs for a prolonged period (Figure 3), so it is staged as a 2026 bill change.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A rise in the typical annual bill under the price cap at sustained March 2026 prices; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", "quote": "If recent rises in the price of oil and gas were to be sustained they could add around a percentage point to inflation and £500 on to typical annual energy bills.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_price_cap_rise_best_case_jul2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "price_cap_arithmetic", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 130, "value_raw": "£130", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", "scenario": "best case: wholesale gas prices fall immediately to pre-war levels", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", "date": "2026-04-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "724d5e936b645d80f7cccdaa2b1da6934075638c18b7265b389b44283a086a5c", "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Press release text", "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise, best case", "note": "RF measures the rise against the April to June 2026 cap, which Ofgem announced on 25 February 2026, before the conflict began (the analysis's metadata.pre_conflict_baseline).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", "quote": "While there remains a high degree of uncertainty around the future path of energy bills, even a plausible best-case scenario – in which wholesale gas prices fall immediately to pre-war levels – would still mean around a £130 increase in the energy price cap in July.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_price_cap_rise_high_case_jul2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "price_cap_arithmetic", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 440, "value_raw": "£440", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", "scenario": "recent highs in gas prices become the norm for the rest of the assessment period", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", "date": "2026-04-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "724d5e936b645d80f7cccdaa2b1da6934075638c18b7265b389b44283a086a5c", "locator": "press release, fifth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Press release text", "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise if recent highs persist", "note": "RF measures the rise against the April to June 2026 cap, which Ofgem announced on 25 February 2026, before the conflict began (the analysis's metadata.pre_conflict_baseline).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", "quote": "Alternatively, if the recent highs in gas prices become the norm for the remainder of the assessment period, the price cap could increase by close to £440, to around £2,100.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_price_cap_rise_current_prices_mar2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "price_cap_arithmetic", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 230, "value_raw": "£230", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised (direct debit, typical consumption, GB; Figure 3)", "cap_period": "July to September 2026, against the April to June 2026 cap", "scenario": "wholesale prices at mid-March 2026 levels", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the annual price cap bill", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "page 3 (PDF page 3)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Spotlight text", "source_column": "July 2026 price cap rise at current prices", "note": "RF measures the rise against the April to June 2026 cap, which Ofgem announced on 25 February 2026, before the conflict began (the analysis's metadata.pre_conflict_baseline). The ~£500 in the same sentence is staged once, from RF's 4 March release.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A change in the annualised price cap for the July-September 2026 quarter; the analysis's energy channel is the mean rise in each household's own gas and electricity spending over 2027-28 (energy_bill_rise_low, _central, _severe: £238, £713, £1,426), a different period and statistic. The dashboard sets RF's ~£500 beside that channel in its comparison table.", "quote": "This creates huge uncertainty over where the July price cap will land: current prices imply an increase of around £230 on April’s level", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_uc_pc_uprating_brought_forward_cost", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1200000000, "value_raw": "£1.2 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "program": "benefit_uprating", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "Universal Credit standard allowance above-inflation rises brought forward to September 2026, plus a temporary Pension Credit boost", "fy_note": "annualised, from September 2026", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "uc_and_pension_credit_uprating_brought_forward", "reform_hint": "Bringing all the above-inflation rise forward to September 2026, with the rate rising in line with inflation from then on", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "locator": "page 8 (PDF page 8), section 'A mixture of action on prices and incomes would partially replicate the benefits of a social tariff'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Spotlight text", "source_column": "Annualised cost of bringing the UC rise forward", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "RF gives an annualised cost 'in the short term' for a change from September 2026, read as 2026-27. The report gives no source line for this figure.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An annualised 2026-27 cost of bringing forward planned Universal Credit rises; the analysis's accelerated uprating raises CPI-uprated benefits by the shock's residual CPI addition in 2027-28 (accelerated_uprating_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.66bn, £3.64bn, £7.27bn), a different policy and year.", "quote": "This (plus an equivalent temporary boost for Pension Credit claimants) would cost an annualised £1.2 billion in the short term but would have no additional fiscal impact in 2029-30.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_household_energy_fuel_spending_2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_spending_projection", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_energy_and_fuel_spending_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 11000000000, "value_raw": "£11 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"scenario": "July 2026 price cap of £1,973 from July to December and petrol and diesel at 158p and 192p for the rest of 2026, against early-2026 prices (footnote 2)", "sign_convention": "positive = higher household spending on energy and fuel", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", "date": "2026-04-22", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "94175a64dd6c7f07db7b00b04327f266dcb6eab68fe1fd6cffb2cc5f325faba2", "locator": "page 3 (PDF page 3); footnote 2", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Section 'Sustained conflict in the Middle East could deliver an £11 billion hit to UK family finances'", "source_column": "Extra household spending on fuel and energy, 2026", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The analysis publishes the total cost of energy, fuel and food rises for 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn: £17.0bn, £42.1bn, £72.7bn), which no registered metric names; RF's figure is energy and fuel only, in calendar 2026.", "quote": "But a sustained return to these peaks would see British households spending an extra £11 billion on fuel and energy in 2026 than if prices had remained at early-2026 levels (assuming no real-terms consumption cuts)", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_energy_discounts_offset_cpi_cost", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "arithmetic", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 20000000000, "value_raw": "£20 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "scoring_method": "full pass-through: 1.5 per cent of £1.4 trillion of CPI-covered household spending, 'around £20 billion annually' (footnote 9)", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program": "energy_price_discount", "fy_note": "a year from Q3 2026", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "energy_discounts_offset_cpi_rise", "reform_hint": "offsetting the roughly 1.5 percentage point increase in the Bank of England’s inflation outlook for Q3 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", "date": "2026-04-22", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "94175a64dd6c7f07db7b00b04327f266dcb6eab68fe1fd6cffb2cc5f325faba2", "locator": "pages 8-9 (PDF pages 8-9), footnote 9", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Section 'The fiscal response must be grounded in the reality of our stretched public finances'", "source_column": "Cost of a blanket price cap offsetting the inflation rise", "note": "A year from Q3 2026 runs from July 2026 to June 2027; staged as 2026-27, which holds three of its four quarters.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A blanket discount sized to offset a 1.5 point CPI rise for a year from Q3 2026; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: £2.5bn, £17.51bn, £40.02bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "It would be extremely costly: offsetting the roughly 1.5 percentage point increase in the Bank of England’s inflation outlook for Q3 2026 would cost about £20 billion if continued for a year.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_vat_cut_share_richest_fifth", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_distributional_analysis", "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.25, "value_raw": "25 per cent", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "income_group": "quintile_5", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_six_months", "reform_hint": "the VAT cut", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Trimming the VAT", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "locator": "comment, ninth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Comment text", "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, richest fifth", "note": "The £ amounts beside the shares are RF's shares of the Government's £850 million, so only the share is staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the top quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", "quote": "As such, of the £850 million the Government says the VAT cut will cost, 25 per cent (£213 million) will flow to the richest fifth of British households, against just 16 per cent (£136 million) for the poorest fifth.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_vat_cut_share_poorest_fifth", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_distributional_analysis", "metric": "spending_share", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.16, "value_raw": "16 per cent", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "income_group": "quintile_1", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_six_months", "reform_hint": "the VAT cut", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Trimming the VAT", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "locator": "comment, ninth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Comment text", "source_column": "Share of the VAT cut's cost, poorest fifth", "note": "The £ amounts beside the shares are RF's shares of the Government's £850 million, so only the share is staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "RF's shares are for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis gives quintile shares of its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.by_quintile.benefit_share_pct: 18.8% to the bottom quintile in every scenario, quintiles of PolicyEngine's household income decile), a different year and period of relief.", "quote": "As such, of the £850 million the Government says the VAT cut will cost, 25 per cent (£213 million) will flow to the richest fifth of British households, against just 16 per cent (£136 million) for the poorest fifth.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_vat_cut_annual_cost_future_years", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "arithmetic", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1700000000, "value_raw": "£1.7 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate continued after 31 March 2027", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_gb_continued", "reform_hint": "today’s announcement is funded by departmental savings that have not been specified this year and is unfunded in future years", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Trimming the VAT", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "locator": "comment, 'Finally, the Government should be clear' paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Comment text", "source_column": "Annual cost of the VAT cut in future years", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "RF gives an annual cost 'in future years' without naming one; 2027-28 is the first year after the cut's 31 March 2027 end, so it is staged as 2027-28. The £1.7 billion is twice the Government's £850 million for the six months from October; RF does not say how it was annualised. It is compared with the Summer 2026 prices scenario, the one anchored to the observed July 2026 cap rise (parameters.registry.low_shock); under the escalation scenarios the same extension costs £1.95bn and £2.56bn.", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "elec_vat_cut_cost_low", "across_worlds": {"reason": "Both zero-rate Great Britain households' domestic electricity for 2027-28. The analysis also covers Northern Ireland's households, which the enacted measure leaves at 5%, and omits the non-household supplies the relief covers (charities' non-business use, relevant residential buildings and de minimis supplies, in HMRC's note); its cost is a gross household transfer at full pass-through, each household's scenario electricity spending times 5/105 (compute_policies; metadata.policy_cost_basis).", "basis": [{"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L728-L730"}, {"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L492"}, {"kind": "document", "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-in-great-britain-for-domestic-electricity"}]}}, "quote": "In effect, today’s announcement is funded by departmental savings that have not been specified this year and is unfunded in future years (at an annual cost of £1.7 billion).", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1000000000, "value_raw": "over £1 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "lower_bound", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "program": "fuel_duty", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer, relative to current policy", "program_note": "steady fuel duty rises reversing the 5p cut, then about 3 per cent a year", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "fuel_duty_gradual_reversal", "reform_hint": "steady rises reversing the 5p cut and then of, say, 3 per cent a year", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "locator": "printed page 32 (PDF page 32), Fuel Duty section", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Briefing text", "source_column": "Cost relative to current policy, 2027-28", "note": "'Over £1 billion' is a lower bound, staged as range_low.", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", "pe_missing": "RF costs a gradual reversal of the 5p cut against current policy; the analysis costs keeping the whole 5p cut for 2027-28, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", "quote": "For example, as shown in Figure 15, if over the coming years there are steady rises reversing the 5p cut and then of, say, 3 per cent a year, this would cost money in the short term relative to the current policy – likely over £1 billion in 2027-28 – but would be broadly revenue neutral by 2029-30, the year against which the fiscal rules are assessed.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "ifs_vat_cut_permanent_annual_cost", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1500000000, "value_raw": "£1.5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate made permanent", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "basis not recorded by the backfill search; compared as a cost at today's consumption, the dashboard's basis"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_gb_continued", "reform_hint": "Making the cut in VAT on household electricity bills permanent", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chapter 2 text", "source_column": "Annual cost of a permanent electricity VAT cut", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "IFS states an annual cost without naming a year. The cut is in force to 31 March 2027, so 2027-28 is the first full year a permanent cut adds; staged as 2027-28. IFS gives no price assumption beyond 'future household electricity spending'. It is compared with the Summer 2026 prices scenario, the one anchored to the observed July 2026 cap rise (parameters.registry.low_shock); under the escalation scenarios the same extension costs £1.95bn and £2.56bn.", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "elec_vat_cut_cost_low", "across_worlds": {"reason": "Both zero-rate Great Britain households' domestic electricity for 2027-28. The analysis also covers Northern Ireland's households, which the enacted measure leaves at 5%, and omits the non-household supplies the relief covers (charities' non-business use, relevant residential buildings and de minimis supplies, in HMRC's note); its cost is a gross household transfer at full pass-through, each household's scenario electricity spending times 5/105 (compute_policies; metadata.policy_cost_basis).", "basis": [{"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L728-L730"}, {"kind": "engine_metadata", "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards/blob/45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515/src/iran_impact/pipeline.py#L492"}, {"kind": "document", "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-in-great-britain-for-domestic-electricity"}]}}, "quote": "Making the cut in VAT on household electricity bills permanent would have an annual cost of around £1.5 billion, although the exact cost would depend on future household electricity spending.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2700000000, "value_raw": "£2.7 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", "program": "fuel_duty", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze", "reform_hint": "Making the 5p cut permanent and freezing fuel duties for an extra year", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chapter 2 text", "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (OBR March 2026 forecast)", "parse_confidence": "low", "note": "IFS names no year. Staged as 2027-28, the first year the extra year's freeze applies; the sentence can also be read as a 2029-30 figure, the year its next clause gives for the longer freeze.", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", "quote": "Making the 5p cut permanent and freezing fuel duties for an extra year would cost £2.7 billion, while if the freeze were extended until 2029–30 the cost would reach £4 billion a year by then under the OBR’s March forecast for inflation.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3200000000, "value_raw": "£3.2 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2027-28", "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", "program": "fuel_duty", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and rates frozen for a further year", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze", "reform_hint": "Making the 5p cut permanent and freezing fuel duties for an extra year", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chapter 2 text", "source_column": "Cost of a permanent 5p cut and a one-year freeze (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", "parse_confidence": "low", "note": "'Those figures' are the £2.7 billion and £4 billion of the previous sentence; staged as 2027-28 on the same reading, which could also be 2029-30.", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "fuel_duty_cut_cost_low", "pe_missing": "IFS costs the 5p cut together with a further year's freeze; the analysis costs the 5p cut alone, so the two are different policies (annotation fuel-duty-different-policies).", "quote": "But higher inflation would push the cost higher: under the Barclays inflation forecast, those figures would be £3.2 billion and £4.5 billion respectively.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4000000000, "value_raw": "£4 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", "program": "fuel_duty", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030", "reform_hint": "if the freeze were extended until 2029–30", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chapter 2 text", "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", "quote": "Making the 5p cut permanent and freezing fuel duties for an extra year would cost £2.7 billion, while if the freeze were extended until 2029–30 the cost would reach £4 billion a year by then under the OBR’s March forecast for inflation.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4500000000, "value_raw": "£4.5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2029-30", "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", "program": "fuel_duty", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030", "reform_hint": "if the freeze were extended until 2029–30", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "locator": "chapter 2, section 2.4, 'Temporary giveaways', printed page 88 (PDF page 89)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chapter 2 text", "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", "quote": "But higher inflation would push the cost higher: under the Barclays inflation forecast, those figures would be £3.2 billion and £4.5 billion respectively.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", "source": "hm_treasury", "found_by": "hm_treasury", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "hmt_costing_not_obr_certified", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 850000000, "value_raw": "£850 million", "normalization": "GBP m x 1e6 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "geography": "GB", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "scoring_method": "Government estimate at estimated electricity prices; 'Updated costs will be set out at Budget'", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "domestic electricity VAT zero rate, 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_six_months", "reform_hint": "a tax cut to remove VAT from domestic electricity bills from October 1", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Prime Minister's Office, HM Treasury and DESNZ (GOV.UK)", "primary_sha256": "15719bec715ef7294bf11d96149bdc58f8c17c3629e9ad716d5e1adc9c1a0c50", "locator": "news story, 'This action is estimated to cost' paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "News story text", "source_column": "Cost in 2026-27", "note": "HMRC's tax information and impact note (8 September 2026) leaves the Exchequer impact to a future fiscal event, so this is the only official cost found.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Government's cost is for the six-month cut in 2026-27; the analysis costs a full-year extension in 2027-28 (elec_vat_cut_cost_low, _central, _severe: £1.55bn, £1.95bn, £2.56bn), a different year and length of relief.", "quote": "This action is estimated to cost around £850 million in 2026-27 on the basis of estimated electricity prices.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "hmt_elec_vat_cut_bill_saving_oct2026", "source": "hm_treasury", "found_by": "hm_treasury", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "price_cap_arithmetic", "metric": "energy_bill_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 45, "value_raw": "£45", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"statistic": "Ofgem price cap, annualised", "cap_period": "October to December 2026", "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the annual energy bill (printed as £45 off the yearly price cap)", "program": "domestic_electricity_vat", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "elec_vat_cut_six_months", "reform_hint": "a tax cut to remove VAT from domestic electricity bills from October 1", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Prime Minister's Office, HM Treasury and DESNZ (GOV.UK)", "primary_sha256": "15719bec715ef7294bf11d96149bdc58f8c17c3629e9ad716d5e1adc9c1a0c50", "locator": "news story, 'Cutting VAT on electricity bills' paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "News story text", "source_column": "Saving on the yearly price cap", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A saving on the October 2026 annualised cap; the analysis's counterpart is the mean support per household from its full-year 2027-28 extension (policy_responses.*.elec_vat_cut.avg_benefit_per_hh: £49, £62, £81, shown on the dashboard's policy tab), a different period and statistic.", "quote": "Cutting VAT on electricity bills is expected to take around £45 off the yearly Ofgem price cap in October.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_absolute_poverty_households_fy2027", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_functional_var", "metric": "poverty_count_change", "unit_concept": "households", "value": 195000, "value_raw": "195,000", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "poverty_line": "absolute: 60% of 2023/24 median household income", "housing_costs": "ahc", "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the absolute poverty line", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B", "source_column": "Additional households in absolute poverty", "note": "The box's policy section rounds the same estimate to 'around 200,000', the figure the analysis's dashboard cites; only the 195,000 is staged.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NIESR counts households below an absolute after-housing-costs line in 2026-27, from a functional VAR of oil shocks and the income distribution; the analysis counts households below an anchored before-housing-costs line in 2027-28 after netting the price rises off income (newly_below_line_households_low, _central, _severe: 185,699, 750,843, 1,159,588), a different year, line and method.", "quote": "The effect on absolute poverty is much larger: around 195,000 additional households, equivalent to about 0.7 per cent of UK households, fall below the absolute poverty line (defined as below 60 per cent of median household income in 2023/24, which is the base year).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_relative_poverty_households_fy2027", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_functional_var", "metric": "poverty_count_change", "unit_concept": "households", "value": 5000, "value_raw": "5,000", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "poverty_line": "relative: 60% of 2026/27 median household income", "housing_costs": "ahc", "scenario": "oil price shock from about $63 (December 2025) to about $103 a barrel (March 2026), one year after the shock", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in the number of households below the relative poverty line", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B", "source_column": "Additional households in relative poverty", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A relative-poverty count for 2026-27, whose line moves with the median; the analysis holds its line fixed at the 2027-28 pre-shock median and counts households newly below it in 2027-28, a different year and line.", "quote": "We estimate that around 5,000 additional households fall into relative poverty, defined as having income below 60 per cent of median household income in 2026/27.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_uc_uplift_10_six_months_cost", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2000000000, "value_raw": "£2bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "program": "universal_credit_uplift", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "£10 a week Universal Credit uplift for six months", "fy_note": "autumn and winter", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "uc_uplift_10_six_months", "reform_hint": "a temporary six-month uplift to Universal Credit during the autumn and winter", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications' and Table B1", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B, Table B1 'Estimated cost of selected policy options'", "source_column": "£10 per week Universal Credit uplift for 6 months", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A £10 a week uplift for six months of 2026-27; the analysis costs a £20 a week uplift for the whole of 2027-28 (uc_uplift_cost_low, _central, _severe: £6.28bn), a different policy and year.", "quote": "A six-month £10 per week uplift would cost around £2bn, depending on the precise number of claimants covered.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_1", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_engel_curves", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 50, "value_raw": "£50", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "income_group": "decile_1", "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B text", "source_column": "Increase in energy and fuel expenditure, decile 1", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "NIESR gives no period or comparison for the £ amounts; they sit beside Figure B2, 'Projected growth in household expenditure by income decile, 2026-27 relative to 2025-26' (assuming aggregate inflation of 4 per cent and energy inflation of 5.5 per cent), so they are read as 2026-27 increases.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping.", "quote": "On our estimates, the increase in energy and fuel expenditure is around £50 for households in the bottom decile, £120 for households in decile 2 and £150 for households in decile 3.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_2", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_engel_curves", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 120, "value_raw": "£120", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "income_group": "decile_2", "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B text", "source_column": "Increase in energy and fuel expenditure, decile 2", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "NIESR gives no period or comparison for the £ amounts; they sit beside Figure B2, 'Projected growth in household expenditure by income decile, 2026-27 relative to 2025-26' (assuming aggregate inflation of 4 per cent and energy inflation of 5.5 per cent), so they are read as 2026-27 increases.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping.", "quote": "On our estimates, the increase in energy and fuel expenditure is around £50 for households in the bottom decile, £120 for households in decile 2 and £150 for households in decile 3.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_3", "source": "niesr", "found_by": "niesr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "niesr_engel_curves", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "energy_and_fuel_spending_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 150, "value_raw": "£150", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "income_group": "decile_3", "sign_convention": "positive = higher spending on energy and fuel", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "primary_sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "locator": "Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards', 'Policy implications'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Box B text", "source_column": "Increase in energy and fuel expenditure, decile 3", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "NIESR gives no period or comparison for the £ amounts; they sit beside Figure B2, 'Projected growth in household expenditure by income decile, 2026-27 relative to 2025-26' (assuming aggregate inflation of 4 per cent and energy inflation of 5.5 per cent), so they are read as 2026-27 increases.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "NIESR's figures are 2026-27 increases by income decile; the analysis gives the shock's energy and fuel cost against no shock in 2027-28 by income quintile (scenarios.*.by_quintile.energy and .fuel), a different year and grouping.", "quote": "On our estimates, the increase in energy and fuel expenditure is around £50 for households in the bottom decile, £120 for households in decile 2 and £150 for households in decile 3.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost", "source": "jrf", "found_by": "jrf", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "jrf_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5000000000, "value_raw": "£5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"program": "energy_price_guarantee", "basis": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "Energy Price Guarantee-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", "basis_note": "July 2026 cost projections"}, "world": "epg_style_cap_at_april_2026", "reform_hint": "an EPG-style intervention that would cap prices at the April 2026 price cap", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", "url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", "date": "2026-04-09", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b6f5f95dd28bda01fb0afe064c977fa7084dad6d7167a463aaa75c273532e99", "locator": "article, section 'Comparing approaches'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Article text", "source_column": "Cost of an EPG-style cap at the April 2026 price cap", "parse_confidence": "medium", "note": "The £5 billion is JRF's estimate of an EPG-style cap's cost, which it then uses as the budget for each option it models. JRF states no period; the costing rests on July 2026 projections, so it is staged as 2026.", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A cap holding prices at the April 2026 cap, on July 2026 projections; the analysis's Energy Price Guarantee pays each household's bill rise above 10% in 2027-28 (epg_cost_low, _central, _severe: £2.5bn, £17.51bn, £40.02bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "We have modelled each policy at a cost of £5 billion, which is reflective of the cost of an EPG-style intervention that would cap prices at the April 2026 price cap, based on current cost projections for July 2026.", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2026", "source": "cebr", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cebr_macro_forecast", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 1100, "value_raw": "£1,100", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"statistic": "mean (average UK household)", "basis": "forecast", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes £1,100 lower)", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", "date": "2026-08-31", "publisher": "Cebr", "primary_sha256": "5df0374f50d3b425edb0eb0be4335cf99fa0b21c60b11c3c2227cb73e81c13f0", "locator": "blog, first paragraph and Figure 2", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Blog text", "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2026", "note": "The £2,400 is the sum of the two years and is not staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2026 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", "quote": "we estimate that for the average UK household, real incomes will be £1,100 lower in 2026 and £1,300 lower in 2027 than they would otherwise have been, bringing the total cost per household to £2,400.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2027", "source": "cebr", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cebr_macro_forecast", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 1300, "value_raw": "£1,300", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"statistic": "mean (average UK household)", "basis": "forecast", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as real incomes £1,300 lower)", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis_note": "real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast: higher inflation and slower nominal wage growth"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", "date": "2026-08-31", "publisher": "Cebr", "primary_sha256": "5df0374f50d3b425edb0eb0be4335cf99fa0b21c60b11c3c2227cb73e81c13f0", "locator": "blog, first paragraph and Figure 2", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Blog text", "source_column": "Average household real income loss, 2027", "note": "The £2,400 is the sum of the two years and is not staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "Cebr's is a calendar-2027 real-income loss including slower wage growth, against its pre-conflict forecast; the analysis estimates the direct cost of the price rises at fixed consumption in 2027-28 (household_cost_low, _central, _severe: £538, £1,334, £2,304), with no wage or labour-market effects.", "quote": "we estimate that for the average UK household, real incomes will be £1,100 lower in 2026 and £1,300 lower in 2027 than they would otherwise have been, bringing the total cost per household to £2,400.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2026", "source": "cebr", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cebr_macro_forecast", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_real_income_change_aggregate", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 31500000000, "value_raw": "£31.5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "forecast", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as an erosion of real incomes)", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis_note": "aggregate real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", "date": "2026-08-31", "publisher": "Cebr", "primary_sha256": "5df0374f50d3b425edb0eb0be4335cf99fa0b21c60b11c3c2227cb73e81c13f0", "locator": "blog, eighth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Blog text", "source_column": "Erosion of aggregate real incomes, 2026", "note": "The headline £70.4 billion is the sum of the two years and is not staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An aggregate calendar-2026 real-income loss including wage effects; the analysis's aggregate is the total cost of the price rises in 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn), which no registered metric names.", "quote": "Indeed, consumer spending is expected to slow through the rest of 2026 and into 2027, reflecting the erosion of real incomes by an estimated £31.5 billion and £38.9 billion, respectively.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2027", "source": "cebr", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cebr_macro_forecast", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_real_income_change_aggregate", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 38900000000, "value_raw": "£38.9 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "forecast", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households (printed as an erosion of real incomes)", "program": "middle_east_war_price_shock", "basis_note": "aggregate real household income against Cebr's January 2026 pre-conflict forecast"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", "url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", "date": "2026-08-31", "publisher": "Cebr", "primary_sha256": "5df0374f50d3b425edb0eb0be4335cf99fa0b21c60b11c3c2227cb73e81c13f0", "locator": "blog, eighth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Blog text", "source_column": "Erosion of aggregate real incomes, 2027", "note": "The headline £70.4 billion is the sum of the two years and is not staged (harvest rule 1).", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An aggregate calendar-2027 real-income loss including wage effects; the analysis's aggregate is the total cost of the price rises in 2027-28 (scenarios.*.summary.total_impact_bn), which no registered metric names.", "quote": "Indeed, consumer spending is expected to slow through the rest of 2026 and into 2027, reflecting the erosion of real incomes by an estimated £31.5 billion and £38.9 billion, respectively.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_low", "source": "tuc", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "tuc_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3400000000, "value_raw": "£3.4bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_low", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"program": "energy_social_tariff", "basis": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost"}, "world": "tuc_standard_social_tariff", "reform_hint": "standard social tariff", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", "date": "2026-05-29", "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", "primary_sha256": "37824eccdba0a526a661a01586b13b1a9c700849b80994439cde6a5f005c3e8c", "locator": "PDF page 6", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "'Who would be covered?'", "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "This model thus supports around half of households at two different rates, and, annualised, would cost the Treasury between £3.4bn and £3.8bn.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_high", "source": "tuc", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "tuc_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3800000000, "value_raw": "£3.8bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_high", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"program": "energy_social_tariff", "basis": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "25% off bills below the relative poverty line, 15% between it and median income", "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "range_group": "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost"}, "world": "tuc_standard_social_tariff", "reform_hint": "standard social tariff", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", "date": "2026-05-29", "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", "primary_sha256": "37824eccdba0a526a661a01586b13b1a9c700849b80994439cde6a5f005c3e8c", "locator": "PDF page 6", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "'Who would be covered?'", "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "This model thus supports around half of households at two different rates, and, annualised, would cost the Treasury between £3.4bn and £3.8bn.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_low", "source": "tuc", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "tuc_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5200000000, "value_raw": "£5.2bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_low", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"program": "energy_social_tariff", "basis": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost"}, "world": "tuc_energy_crisis_social_tariff", "reform_hint": "energy crisis social tariff", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", "date": "2026-05-29", "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", "primary_sha256": "37824eccdba0a526a661a01586b13b1a9c700849b80994439cde6a5f005c3e8c", "locator": "PDF page 7", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "'Who would be covered?'", "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "This model supports around two-thirds of households on three distinct rates. Annualised, it would cost the Treasury between £5.2bn and £5.9bn.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} +{"key": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_high", "source": "tuc", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "tuc_costing", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5900000000, "value_raw": "£5.9bn", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_high", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"program": "energy_social_tariff", "basis": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "program_note": "30%, 20% and 10% off bills below the relative poverty line, median income and mean income", "basis_note": "annualised at the April-June and July-September 2026 price caps; the range is whether the cap stays at July-September rates or falls back to April-June rates (footnote 4)", "range_group": "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost"}, "world": "tuc_energy_crisis_social_tariff", "reform_hint": "energy crisis social tariff", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", "date": "2026-05-29", "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", "primary_sha256": "37824eccdba0a526a661a01586b13b1a9c700849b80994439cde6a5f005c3e8c", "locator": "PDF page 7", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "'Who would be covered?'", "source_column": "Annualised cost to the Treasury", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "An annualised cost at 2026 price caps of a percentage cut to whole bills for half or two-thirds of households by equivalised income; the analysis's social tariff offsets half the energy price rise for Universal Credit households and those with household net income below £20,000 in 2027-28 (social_tariff_cost_low, _central, _severe: £0.71bn, £2.12bn, £4.25bn), a different design and year.", "quote": "This model supports around two-thirds of households on three distinct rates. Annualised, it would cost the Treasury between £5.2bn and £5.9bn.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok"} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..365d51127 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", "title": "War in Middle East threatens bumper year of living standards growth for lower-income families", "date": "2026-03-04", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "cd1ea581e0173ad97dc9512d3b58849278d01e1586bcf939631b313b80128609", "bytes": 117306, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Press release on RF's overnight analysis of the Spring Forecast 2026. 'Power struggle' (18 March 2026) repeats the ~£500 as a price cap uplift (Figure 3)."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", "title": "Poorest households are set to see inflation nearly a third higher than the richest", "date": "2026-04-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "724d5e936b645d80f7cccdaa2b1da6934075638c18b7265b389b44283a086a5c", "bytes": 116011, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Press release for 'Happy new tax year 2026'. The analysis's dashboard links this page for RF's ~£500 bill rise, which is in the 4 March release."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", "title": "Higher energy prices could leave typical British households £480 worse off this year", "date": "2026-04-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "38b27a4655540ec3ccbd31eed7417a5d9cabed4a2ab92b7c1d347b2961b492f2", "bytes": 114218, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Press release; Mike Brewer's comment of 15 April 2026 gives the same £480."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", "title": "Power struggle: Assessing the options for supporting families with the rise in the cost of energy", "date": "2026-03-18", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "eaa4f571a9a90a661b5c356eb0c77789bc59a3a4c592d5b357b2217c9f8da864", "bytes": 148613, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Spotlight by Clegg, Curtice, Leather, Marshall, Smith and Try; dated 18 March 2026 on its cover."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", "title": "The Macroeconomic Policy Outlook: Q2 2026", "date": "2026-04-22", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "94175a64dd6c7f07db7b00b04327f266dcb6eab68fe1fd6cffb2cc5f325faba2", "bytes": 171943, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Pittaway, Smith and Thwaites; the publication page is dated 22 April 2026 00:01 BST."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", "title": "Trimming the VAT", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "bfeeb9b1f5ccf9e7458a2caee0438aec7599467ca11abfc01b7abac262dce95b", "bytes": 132991, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Comment by Jonny Marshall; amended on 22 July 2026 to reflect newer price cap forecasts. RF's 'Counting the cost' (October 2026) repeats the £213m / £136m split."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf", "title": "Hitting the buffers: Previewing the key decisions for Autumn Budget 2026 in the context of another rise in the cost of living", "date": "2026-10-13", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "f0a708d52b2875ee56e5463e5478240f2c5c5301c71ecdf829b73333e12153a5", "bytes": 960798, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Briefing note; the publication page is dated 13 October 2026 00:01 BST."} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", "title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", "date": "2026-10-12", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "3123cb0b5bfa466c6c6552a2658c89eb4f4d669ec5767d46b0d3fc3298306b09", "bytes": 6601086, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Full report (with Barclays, funded by the Nuffield Foundation); it prints only 'October 2026', so 12 October 2026 is taken from launch coverage seen in search results (a Bloomberg article dated 11 October 2026); the PDF metadata says created 10 October 2026. Chapter 2, 'The outlook for the public finances' (Ridpath, Sousa and Stockton)."} +{"url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", "title": "New PM cuts tax on household electricity bills to give breathing space on cost of living", "date": "2026-07-21", "publisher": "Prime Minister's Office, HM Treasury and DESNZ (GOV.UK)", "sha256": "15719bec715ef7294bf11d96149bdc58f8c17c3629e9ad716d5e1adc9c1a0c50", "bytes": 76662, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Joint news story of No 10, HM Treasury and DESNZ."} +{"url": "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", "title": "Economic Outlook: New Shock, Old Vulnerabilities (Spring 2026)", "date": "2026-04-29", "publisher": "National Institute of Economic and Social Research", "sha256": "1c0e250079babe6a9bdadd70bfd3f6f47576692e40b5e38801d78f22b082b33a", "bytes": 290262, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "HTML edition; Box B 'The Impact of the Oil Price Shock on UK Household Living Standards'. The PDF edition (niesr.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Economic-Outlook-Spring-2026.pdf) timed out on 2026-10-21."} +{"url": "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis", "title": "Addressing the 2026 energy price crisis", "date": "2026-04-09", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "sha256": "0b6f5f95dd28bda01fb0afe064c977fa7084dad6d7167a463aaa75c273532e99", "bytes": 85561, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Dated 9 April 2026 on the page; modified 4 September 2026."} +{"url": "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", "title": "Forecasting Eye: The cost of war – Middle East conflict to strip £70.4 billion from UK households' real disposable incomes", "date": "2026-08-31", "publisher": "Cebr", "sha256": "5df0374f50d3b425edb0eb0be4335cf99fa0b21c60b11c3c2227cb73e81c13f0", "bytes": 72688, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Page dated 31 August 2026 00:01 BST."} +{"url": "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", "title": "Futureproof social tariffs: TUC proposal for a crisis-proof, targeted, flexible approach to domestic energy support in 2026", "date": "2026-05-29", "publisher": "Trades Union Congress", "sha256": "37824eccdba0a526a661a01586b13b1a9c700849b80994439cde6a5f005c3e8c", "bytes": 249773, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Dated from the PDF's creation date; the TUC report page (tuc.org.uk/research-analysis/reports/futureproof-social-tariffs) returned 403 on 2026-10-21."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..daf991036 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,339 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113609-cmp-uk-middle-east-war-livin", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "obr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:obr.uk Middle East conflict energy prices households 2026", + "OBR Strait of Hormuz oil price shock UK fiscal outlook 2026 energy", + "obr.uk \"energy prices\" 2026 forecast household energy bills Iran conflict briefing", + "OBR fiscal risks and sustainability July 2026 energy price shock scenario Middle East", + "site:obr.uk Iran energy prices 2026 March forecast scenario household energy", + "OBR \"forecast evaluation report\" June 2026 energy prices Middle East conflict household energy bills inflation estimate" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a4cb4c74889d85e75ab40e0/E03599617_OBR_FRS_2026_Accessible.pdf", + "https://obr.uk/fer/forecast-evaluation-report-june-2026/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No OBR estimate of the household cost, poverty effect or support-policy costs. The Fiscal risks and sustainability report (July 2026) names the conflict as a risk without a household estimate; the forecast evaluation report (June 2026) returned 403 and was not read. The OBR's only war-specific figure seen is David Miles's 10 March 2026 evidence (prices about 1 per cent higher by end-2026), quoted on the dashboard, not read at its source. The dashboard sets it beside its CPI additions, which are scenario parameters (parameters.registry: the Summer 2026 prices value is the Bank of England's June 2026 projection of about 1 point, raised to the 1.28 point first-round effect of the scenario's own prices; the two escalation values are set at that first-round effect) that it says are not forecasts and uses only to size the uprating shortfall; they are not pinned, so no inflation figure is staged. The Autumn Budget is on 28 October 2026 (the analysis's config.py), after this search." + }, + { + "producer": "hm_treasury", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"HM Treasury\" energy bills Middle East conflict support households 2026", + "gov.uk \"cuts tax on household electricity bills\" breathing space cost of living £850 million", + "gov.uk fuel duty 5p cut maintained until end of 2026 written ministerial statement cost 2026-27", + "fuel duty 5p cut extended end of 2026 May 2026 Treasury cost £210 million gov.uk announcement" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-pm-cuts-tax-on-household-electricity-bills-to-give-breathing-space-on-cost-of-living", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/chancellor-protects-drivers-and-businesses-from-rising-fuel-costs" + ], + "claims": [ + "hmt_elec_vat_cut_cost_fy2027", + "hmt_elec_vat_cut_bill_saving_oct2026" + ], + "note": "The 21 July 2026 announcement costs the six-month electricity VAT cut. Its 0.10 point CPI effect is an inflation figure and is not staged (see obr). The 20 May 2026 release extending the 5p fuel duty cut to 31 December 2026 gives no cost; the figures quoted elsewhere (IFS Green Budget 'around £200 million', RF's table '£210m in 2026-27') have no Treasury primary found, so none is staged." + }, + { + "producer": "uk_hmrc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk HMRC \"tax information and impact note\" VAT domestic electricity zero rate 2026", + "fuel duty 5p cut extension 2026 cost Treasury HMRC tax information and impact note", + "\"amended fuel duty rates\" 2026 to 2027 gov.uk cost exchequer extension 5p" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-for-domestic-electricity-in-great-britain/temporary-zero-rate-of-vat-in-great-britain-for-domestic-electricity", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/amended-fuel-duty-rates-for-2026-to-2027/amended-fuel-duty-rates-2026-to-2027" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Both notes leave the Exchequer impact to a future fiscal event: the tax information and impact note for the temporary zero rate (8 September 2026) gives no figure, and the amended fuel duty rates note (22 May 2026) prints a blank Exchequer impact table. The fuel duty note's CPI effect (0.04 points lower in Q4 2026) is an inflation figure and is not staged." + }, + { + "producer": "dwp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "DWP cost of living payment 2026 impact assessment Middle East energy universal credit", + "cost of living payment 2026 £650 means-tested benefits cost estimate Iran energy crisis UK", + "benefit uprating April 2027 September 2026 CPI inflation energy shock households lose out cost of early uprating estimate" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No DWP estimate of the shock or of a cost-of-living payment, UC uplift or early uprating in 2026; no 2026 payment scheme exists to cost." + }, + { + "producer": "dfe", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"Department for Education\" energy prices households 2026 Middle East cost of living" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "The analysis has no education or childcare element; no DfE estimate bears on it." + }, + { + "producer": "scottish_fiscal_commission", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "A UK-wide analysis of reserved tax, benefit and energy measures; the SFC covers devolved Scottish measures only." + }, + { + "producer": "ifs", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "IFS energy price shock 2026 Iran war households cost of living", + "site:ifs.org.uk energy bills support options 2026 cost price cap households targeted", + "IFS 2026 energy price shock \"who is most exposed\" households energy bills distribution analysis Middle East", + "IFS Green Budget 2026 energy prices living standards 2027-28 households cost of living", + "\"Temporary VAT cut on household electricity bills\" IFS response Zaranko richest poorest households gain" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-09/IFS%20Green%20Budget%20Chapter%202026%20-%20Electricity%20prices.pdf", + "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/temporary-vat-cut-household-electricity-bills-ifs-response" + ], + "claims": [ + "ifs_vat_cut_permanent_annual_cost", + "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_obr_inflation", + "ifs_fuel_duty_5p_permanent_and_freeze_barclays_inflation", + "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation" + ], + "note": "Green Budget chapter 2 costs a permanent electricity VAT cut and fuel duty freezes. The electricity prices chapter (8) has no costing of the analysis's measures. IFS's response to the VAT cut (ifs.org.uk/articles/temporary-vat-cut-household-electricity-bills-ifs-response) could not be read: Cloudflare returned 403 to both a direct fetch and WebFetch, and the Wayback Machine has no copy. Not staged: chapter 2's unattributed 'one-off cost of around £200 million' for the four-month fuel duty extension (RF's annex gives £210m 'as announced by the Government'; no Government primary was found) and the Treasury's £850 million, which IFS attributes to the Treasury and which is staged from the Government's own release. Chapter 1 (Barclays) forecasts the economy, not households." + }, + { + "producer": "resolution_foundation", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Resolution Foundation Middle East war energy price shock households cost 2026", + "Resolution Foundation £480 worse off typical household Middle East energy prices April 2026", + "Resolution Foundation \"Billing me softly\" targeted energy discounts cost", + "Resolution Foundation \"Losing energy\" fuel-price shocks households 2026", + "Resolution Foundation living standards outlook summer 2026 poverty projections energy prices 2027-28" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/war-in-middle-east-threatens-bumper-year-of-living-standards-growth-for-lower-income-families/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/poorest-households-are-set-to-see-inflation-nearly-a-third-higher-than-the-richest/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/higher-energy-prices-could-leave-typical-british-households-480-worse-off-this-year/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/04/MPO-Q2-2026.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/further-deterioration-in-middle-east-conflict-could-deal-a-16-billion-hit-to-the-public-finances/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/03/Power-struggle.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/trimming-the-vat/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/08/Billing-me-softly.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Counting-the-cost.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/10/Hitting-the-buffers.pdf" + ], + "claims": [ + "rf_median_working_age_income_loss_fy2027", + "rf_typical_bill_rise_if_sustained", + "rf_price_cap_rise_best_case_jul2026", + "rf_price_cap_rise_high_case_jul2026", + "rf_price_cap_rise_current_prices_mar2026", + "rf_uc_pc_uprating_brought_forward_cost", + "rf_household_energy_fuel_spending_2026", + "rf_energy_discounts_offset_cpi_cost", + "rf_vat_cut_share_richest_fifth", + "rf_vat_cut_share_poorest_fifth", + "rf_vat_cut_annual_cost_future_years", + "rf_fuel_duty_gradual_reversal_cost_fy2028" + ], + "note": "Not staged: the £3.75 billion option envelopes in 'Power struggle' and the £2 billion Targeted Energy Discounts scheme ('Billing me softly', 'Hitting the buffers'), budgets RF chose rather than estimates of a policy's cost; restated Government and historical figures ('Hitting the buffers' annex: £850m VAT cut, £210m fuel duty extension; 'Counting the cost' Table 1: the 2022-24 schemes and the 5p cut at £2.5bn a year); options with no counterpart among the analysis's ten ('Power struggle': moving Renewables Obligation and Warm Home Discount costs into taxation at £2 billion a year and removing the carbon price support at about £200 million, a £3.4 billion combined scenario; 'Billing me softly': removing the remaining electricity levies, about £2.6 billion); figures RF repeats from others ('Hitting the buffers': about £900 million to double the Warm Home Discount, from press reports; 'Trimming the VAT': the VAT cut 'worth around £45 per year for the typical household', the Government's figure, staged from its release); and the £16 billion borrowing scenario, a public-finance effect. The analysis's dashboard links the 2 April release for RF's ~£500 bill rise, which is in the 4 March release." + }, + { + "producer": "centax", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:centax.org.uk energy fuel duty VAT 2026" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "centre_for_british_progress", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Centre for British Progress\" energy prices 2026 Middle East households" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "ippr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "IPPR 2026 energy bills Middle East war households support cost analysis", + "site:ippr.org energy bills 2026 Middle East households support" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "fabian_society", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:fabians.org.uk energy prices 2026 Iran households cost of living", + "Fabian Society 2026 energy bills cost of living war Iran policy proposal cost" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "niesr", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "NIESR Economic Outlook spring 2026 absolute poverty households oil price shock 200,000", + "niesr.ac.uk 2026 energy price shock households poverty destitution Middle East analysis" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-spring-2026", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/reports/economic-outlook-summer-2026", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/what-actually-happening-uk-living-standards" + ], + "claims": [ + "niesr_absolute_poverty_households_fy2027", + "niesr_relative_poverty_households_fy2027", + "niesr_uc_uplift_10_six_months_cost", + "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_1", + "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_2", + "niesr_energy_fuel_spending_rise_decile_3" + ], + "note": "Spring 2026 Box B. The Summer 2026 outlook and the living standards blog carry no estimate of the shock's household cost or poverty effect. NIESR's CPI scenarios (about 3, 4 or 5 per cent from July 2026, as the analysis quotes them in parameters.registry.central_shock; the NIESR blog itself was not read) are total inflation rates that the analysis cites for context only, and no inflation figure is staged (see obr). Not staged: the £377 million and £1.3 billion top-ups to affected households (no counterpart policy in the analysis)." + }, + { + "producer": "ukmod", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "UKMOD CeMPA energy price shock 2026 households microsimulation Middle East Iran" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.microsimulation.ac.uk/research/publications/cempa-working-paper-series/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No 2026 CeMPA working paper (to CEMPA11/26, September 2026) models the energy shock or the support options." + }, + { + "producer": "lse_case", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "LSE CASE 2026 energy prices low income households analysis cost of living Middle East" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "jrf", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "JRF addressing the 2026 energy price crisis households energy bills", + "site:jrf.org.uk 2026 energy price rise households low income cost Middle East essentials guarantee" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/cost-of-living/addressing-the-2026-energy-price-crisis" + ], + "claims": [ + "jrf_epg_style_cap_cost" + ], + "note": "The £5 billion is JRF's estimate of an EPG-style cap's cost, then used as the budget for each option it models. The article's 'possible £288 annual increase' in bills, which the analysis's dashboard lists as 'JRF: +£288 predicted', is not JRF's own estimate: 'Current predictions suggest' links to Cornwall Insight's price cap predictions page, which could not be read (see open_search), so it is not staged." + }, + { + "producer": "landman_economics", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Landman Economics 2026 energy price shock distributional analysis households" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "tax_policy_associates", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk fuel duty VAT energy 2026", + "Tax Policy Associates Dan Neidle VAT electricity cut 2026 fuel duty cost" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "working paper 2026 UK households energy price shock Iran distributional impact microsimulation Living Costs and Food Survey", + "VoxEU OR CEPR OR IZA 2026 UK energy price shock Middle East household welfare loss estimate" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.lse.ac.uk/CFM/assets/pdf/CFM-Discussion-Papers-2026/CFMDP2026-13-Summary.pdf", + "https://joint-research-centre.ec.europa.eu/jrc-news-and-updates/war-middle-east-economic-impact-hits-low-income-households-hardest-2026-07-10_en" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No UK estimate. The 2026 papers found are for other countries: Chankova and Komatsu (LSE CFM DP 2026-13, US Consumer Expenditure Survey) and the European Commission Joint Research Centre's analysis of EU households (10 July 2026 news release)." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Middle East war UK living standards", + "Strait of Hormuz energy prices households", + "energy shock household incomes 2027", + "oil price shock UK households cost", + "Middle East war cost UK households per household 2027 estimate energy fuel food poverty analysis", + "\"2027-28\" UK energy bills households cost Middle East conflict estimate per household think tank", + "Energy Price Guarantee 2026 cost estimate £ billion reintroduce cap Iran war UK think tank", + "£20 universal credit uplift 2026 cost £ billion reinstate energy crisis estimate", + "£400 energy bill rebate 2026 every household cost estimate council tax rebate cost of living package Middle East", + "social tariff energy 2026 cost estimate £ billion households below income threshold discount UK proposal analysis", + "Iran war UK child poverty increase estimate 2026 2027 energy prices pushed into poverty analysis charity", + "Policy in Practice OR CPAG OR Trussell 2026 energy price rise Middle East households poverty estimate", + "National Energy Action OR Citizens Advice 2026 Iran conflict energy bills households fuel poverty estimate million", + "New Economics Foundation 2026 energy bills Iran war households cost analysis windfall", + "Institute for Government 2026 energy bill support options cost Middle East households" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://cebr.com/blogs/forecasting-eye-the-cost-of-war-middle-east-conflict-to-strip-70-4-billion-from-uk-households-real-disposable-incomes/", + "https://www.tuc.org.uk/sites/default/files/2026-05/Domestic_energy_support_policy_proposal.pdf", + "https://www.rsmuk.com/insights/economic-voice/conflict-in-the-middle-east-household-incomes-under-pressure", + "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2026/04/energy-prices-are-spiking-again_04fdd46b/a68e5c37-en.pdf", + "https://www.endfuelpoverty.org.uk/damage-already-done-to-uk-household-finances-from-iran-conflict/", + "https://www.energy-uk.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Energy-UK-A-better-approach-to-energy-bill-support-March-2026.pdf", + "https://www.cornwall-insight.com/predictions-and-insights-into-the-default-tariff-cap/", + "https://www.cornwall-insight.com/press-releases/fall-in-wholesale-market-lowers-price-cap-forecasts-but-big-rises-still-expected-in-july/", + "https://cornwall-insight.com/press-and-media/press-release/july-price-cap-forecast-rises-to-1800-as-conflict-in-the-middle-east-drives-up-gas-prices" + ], + "claims": [ + "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2026", + "cebr_avg_household_real_income_loss_2027", + "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2026", + "cebr_aggregate_real_income_erosion_2027", + "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_low", + "tuc_standard_social_tariff_cost_high", + "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_low", + "tuc_crisis_social_tariff_cost_high" + ], + "note": "Staged: Cebr (real-income loss per household and in aggregate, 2026 and 2027) and the TUC's social tariff costings. Price-cap figures are staged where their primary can be read (RF's and HM Treasury's), as energy_bill_change claims: the dashboard sets such figures beside its energy channel in its own comparison table. Cornwall Insight's forecasts, the source JRF cites for £288, could not be read: its press releases and predictions page returned 401 to both a direct fetch and WebFetch. Ofgem's announced caps are administrative outturns (the July 2026 rise of 13.5% anchors the Summer 2026 prices scenario, parameters.registry.low_shock) and are not staged. Seen and not staged: RSM's 2026 real household disposable income scenarios (aggregate macro scenarios); the OECD's April 2026 report (describes UK measures, gives no UK estimate); the End Fuel Poverty Coalition's 8 April 2026 post (prices only; fuel-poverty counts attributed to the Coalition appeared only in search results, and the analysis publishes no fuel poverty figure, metadata.fuel_poverty); Energy UK's March 2026 paper (401, not read)." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/impact-iran-war-living-standards@45592bb72bdb0e6f4bca0facd1cceb7996eea515:382d64b98cd35a1d8bfd3064f2e4eec2895155abb1ba7de9613fdee0b94afead" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/README.md b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..73a1cdd58 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,99 @@ +# The Burnham plan vs the triple lock: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md). The dashboard was listed +on policyengine.org on 16 October 2026, before the gate existed. The search ran on 21 October 2026 +against every UK producer. + +## What is pinned + +`analysis.json` holds 45 estimates, read from `dashboard/public/data/results.json` in +`PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock` at `5a6acc5`, the commit the 20 October production deployment builds +from. The file is byte-identical to `data/results.json` and has not changed since 15 October +(SHA-256 `e35c1fac…`). The estimates are: + +- the expected gross and net saving for every year from 2031-32 to 2039-40 (£11.14bn gross and + £7.86bn net in 2039-40); +- the lowest and highest of the reweightings the Summary tab charts; +- the OBR central-path, OBR-wedge and ±0.5-point earnings scenarios; +- the plan replayed from April 2012 and from April 2017; +- the share of households with less income; +- pensioner absolute poverty on the central path. + +## What the search found + +35 claims are staged: + +- **DWP:** £15bn (cash) and £11bn (2025-26 prices) for 2039-40, and Chart 1's pensioner relative + poverty for 2034-35 and 2039-40, read from the chart's vector file. +- **IFS:** around £4bn in 2034-35; £4bn to £20bn for 2039-40; and £9bn lower spending in 2026-27 + had the new rule run since 2011. +- **Resolution Foundation:** + - £24bn if the 2030s repeat the decade after 2016; + - its reconstruction of the government's figure (restated); + - £5bn after five years and £15bn after ten; + - the pension 5.9% lower had the rule run since 2012. +- **Centre for British Progress:** the post's £3bn and £14.3bn, and the calculator's mean savings + before and after income tax for each year. +- **OBR:** the triple-lock wedge of 0.56 and 0.6 points. + +AJ Bell's £600 and £490 a year is logged as found but not staged, because only press coverage +carries it. The search log lists figures left unstaged because they score the triple lock against +an earnings link: the OBR's £15.5bn, the IFS's £16bn, and RF's £9bn net (with the OBR's £12.6bn it +reports). + +## Gaps over the threshold + +**DWP.** The dashboard's UK figure is 26% below DWP's £15bn, and its Great Britain figure 28% below. +The gap is `pending` on `uk-triple-lock#13`, which says its cause is not established, so the +analysis may not be promoted until that issue is closed and the cause written. The annotation +gives a partial account: + +- The survey's basic and new State Pension bill is about 14 to 16% below DWP's in every year DWP + publishes. DWP's figure includes payments abroad, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to + 16%. +- On any path the saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill. The engine + enforces this, and the paired Microcosm run confirms it: a bill 10.1% larger, a saving £1.12bn + larger, the share unchanged. +- That leaves about 14 to 19% (the Microcosm run gives 20%), inside the threshold. The remainder + could come from DWP's unpublished path, its population projection or its rounding, and none can + be checked. + +This is an accounting decomposition, not the matched full-run counterfactual `uk-triple-lock#13` +asks for, which is why the gap stays pending. + +**IFS range.** IFS's £4bn to £20bn for 2039-40 is compared as a range with the expected gross saving, +£11.14bn, which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, as it does IFS's £4bn +for 2034-35; IFS does not say. + +**CBP calculator.** The dashboard is 25% below the calculator in 2039-40, 37% below in 2032-33 and +59% below in 2031-32. CBP's own methodology documents why: + +- Its spending base is about 27% larger: more pensioners, including those abroad, each priced at the + full rate. +- Its price and earnings paths are its own, not the OBR's. + +## Not compared, by design + +These claims are recorded beside their nearest estimate with a concept-mismatch annotation: + +- DWP's real-terms table (`prices: real`); +- DWP's relative poverty (the dashboard prints absolute levels only); +- RF's decade replay, its reconstruction, and its £5bn and £15bn (staged, unlike RF's other + earnings-link figures, because The Telegraph reported them as the plan's saving; they score an + earnings link, recorded as their own world); +- CBP's net figures, which are after income tax only. + +Two have a nearby figure that cannot be pinned: + +- The "middle 80% of paths" card, £3.9bn to £18.9bn, is the like-for-like spread for IFS's range. + The page shows it, but the results file does not store it. +- Relative pensioner poverty, 13.8%, is well above DWP's chart (about 9% in 2039-40). The results + file stores it, but the page does not show it. The record claims no cause for that difference. + +The OBR wedge and RF's 5.9% wait on proposed metrics (`uprating_premium_over_earnings`, +`benefit_rate_change_pct`) before the dashboard's 0.55 points and 6.3% can be pinned. + +## Primaries + +Primaries were fetched on 21 October 2026 and hashed in `manifest.jsonl`. IFS and OBR pages were +read from Wayback Machine captures, because both sites return HTTP 403 to automated fetches. diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cd84bf294 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,1666 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "uk/triple-lock", + "country": "UK", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "triple-lock", + "country_id": "uk" + }, + "title": "The Burnham plan vs the triple lock", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/triple-lock", + "published": "2026-10-16", + "owner": { + "author": "vahid-ahmadi" + }, + "scope": "uk_wide", + "subject": "The fiscal saving from the Burnham plan for the State Pension (from April 2030, rises of at least the higher of CPI and 2.5%, topped up to keep the 2029-30 value relative to earnings) against the triple lock to 2039-40: its expected value over paths of prices and earnings and its range across reweightings, the saving on the OBR central and OBR-wedge paths, what it would have saved had it started in 2012 or 2017, and which households have less income, from full PolicyEngine UK runs.", + "search_terms": [ + "triple lock cost", + "Burnham state pension plan", + "state pension uprating cost", + "triple lock alternatives", + "pensioner poverty triple lock", + "adjusted triple lock 2030 savings" + ], + "worlds": { + "burnham_2030": { + "policy": "uk_state_pension_adjusted_triple_lock_from_2030", + "description": "The Burnham plan: from April 2030 the basic and new State Pension rise by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5%, and by more where needed to keep their 2029-30 value relative to earnings; scored against the triple lock (current law), which applies to every earlier April under both rules." + }, + "burnham_since_2012": { + "policy": "uk_state_pension_adjusted_triple_lock_replayed_from_2012", + "description": "The plan's rule replayed on published inputs from April 2012 (the same path from any April 2012 to 2015), against the triple lock as paid; the dashboard's 'If the Burnham plan had started earlier' section." + }, + "burnham_since_2017": { + "policy": "uk_state_pension_adjusted_triple_lock_replayed_from_2017", + "description": "The plan's rule replayed on published inputs from April 2017 (the same path from any April 2016 to 2018), against the triple lock as paid; the scenario envelope's last-decade replay." + }, + "earnings_link_instead_of_triple_lock": { + "policy": "uk_state_pension_earnings_link", + "description": "The Resolution Foundation's approximation of the plan: the basic and new State Pension uprated in line with earnings instead of by the triple lock, with no CPI or 2.5% floor; scored against the triple lock." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2031", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2031-32", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -217230570.25019464, + "value_raw": "0.21723057025019463", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2031.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2032", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2032-33", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -850021418.4095707, + "value_raw": "0.8500214184095707", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2032.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2033", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2033-34", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -1968205830.921824, + "value_raw": "1.968205830921824", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2033.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2034", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -3211813254.6700063, + "value_raw": "3.2118132546700062", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2035", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2035-36", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -4406755640.831539, + "value_raw": "4.406755640831539", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2035.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2036", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2036-37", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -5885093637.713373, + "value_raw": "5.885093637713373", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2036.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2037", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2037-38", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7484298447.570207, + "value_raw": "7.484298447570207", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2037.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2038", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2038-39", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -9271202074.210602, + "value_raw": "9.271202074210603", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2038.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_fy2039", + "label": "Expected gross saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -11136863655.051073, + "value_raw": "11.136863655051073", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.gross.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2031", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2031-32", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 156417504.22159922, + "value_raw": "0.15641750422159922", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2031-32", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2031.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2032", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2032-33", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 608885510.6364938, + "value_raw": "0.6088855106364938", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2032-33", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2032.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2033", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2033-34", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 1414229874.178762, + "value_raw": "1.414229874178762", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2033-34", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2033.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2034", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 2296590901.1592994, + "value_raw": "2.2965909011592993", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2035", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2035-36", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2036, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 3156720894.1896734, + "value_raw": "3.1567208941896734", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2035-36", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2035.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2036", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2036-37", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2037, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 4195554287.92699, + "value_raw": "4.19555428792699", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2036-37", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2036.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2037", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2037-38", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2038, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 5327184898.630032, + "value_raw": "5.327184898630032", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2037-38", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2037.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2038", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2038-39", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2039, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 6572734215.313287, + "value_raw": "6.572734215313287", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2038-39", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2038.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_net_fy2039", + "label": "Expected net saving, Burnham plan vs triple lock, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7860994216.190747, + "value_raw": "7.860994216190747", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.net.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_lowest_reweighting_fy2039", + "label": "Lowest expected gross saving across the reweightings of the same full runs, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7051185677.507401, + "value_raw": "7.0511856775074016", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "the same full runs reweighted (shift_dynamics.2001_2025.covid_excluded); the lowest of the six reweightings the Summary tab's 'by weighting' chart shows (dataHelpers.js SENSITIVITY_LABELS)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.sensitivities[\"shift_dynamics.2001_2025.covid_excluded\"].gross.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "ev_gross_highest_reweighting_fy2039", + "label": "Highest expected gross saving across the reweightings of the same full runs, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -12413230769.264679, + "value_raw": "12.413230769264679", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "the same full runs reweighted (shift_dynamics.2010_2025.published); the highest of the six reweightings the Summary tab's 'by weighting' chart shows (dataHelpers.js SENSITIVITY_LABELS)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.sensitivities[\"shift_dynamics.2010_2025.published\"].gross.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_gross_fy2034", + "label": "Gross saving on the OBR central forecast path, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -664875682.2009432, + "value_raw": "0.6648756822009432", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.saving_bn.2034.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_net_fy2034", + "label": "Net saving on the OBR central forecast path, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 463548410.26550275, + "value_raw": "0.46354841026550275", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.saving_bn.2034.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "obr_wedge_gross_fy2034", + "label": "Gross saving on the OBR-wedge path, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -3166534783.5759687, + "value_raw": "3.166534783575969", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the central path, with the triple lock paying the OBR long-term economic determinants' 'Triple lock' row (March 2026)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.obr_wedge.run.saving_bn.2034.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "obr_wedge_net_fy2034", + "label": "Net saving on the OBR-wedge path, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 2272647263.687645, + "value_raw": "2.272647263687645", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "one path: the central path, with the triple lock paying the OBR long-term economic determinants' 'Triple lock' row (March 2026)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.obr_wedge.run.saving_bn.2034.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_gross_fy2039", + "label": "Gross saving on the OBR central forecast path, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -864839483.8525916, + "value_raw": "0.8648394838525917", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.saving_bn.2039.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_net_fy2039", + "label": "Net saving on the OBR central forecast path, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 623953294.6522104, + "value_raw": "0.6239532946522104", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.saving_bn.2039.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "obr_wedge_gross_fy2039", + "label": "Gross saving on the OBR-wedge path, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -10292565051.193663, + "value_raw": "10.292565051193662", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the central path, with the triple lock paying the OBR long-term economic determinants' 'Triple lock' row (March 2026)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.obr_wedge.run.saving_bn.2039.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "obr_wedge_net_fy2039", + "label": "Net saving on the OBR-wedge path, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7276094234.114907, + "value_raw": "7.2760942341149075", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "one path: the central path, with the triple lock paying the OBR long-term economic determinants' 'Triple lock' row (March 2026)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.obr_wedge.run.saving_bn.2039.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_plus_half_gross_fy2034", + "label": "Expected gross saving with earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -3530567992.0874047, + "value_raw": "3.5305679920874047", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_plus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.gross.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_plus_half_net_fy2034", + "label": "Expected net saving with earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 2521770072.8587217, + "value_raw": "2.521770072858722", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_plus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.net.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_plus_half_gross_fy2039", + "label": "Expected gross saving with earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -11032301979.859085, + "value_raw": "11.032301979859085", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_plus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.gross.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_plus_half_net_fy2039", + "label": "Expected net saving with earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7739533490.641373, + "value_raw": "7.739533490641373", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth +0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_plus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.net.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_minus_half_gross_fy2034", + "label": "Expected gross saving with earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -2795002041.844587, + "value_raw": "2.7950020418445867", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_minus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.gross.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_minus_half_net_fy2034", + "label": "Expected net saving with earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 1998290655.207842, + "value_raw": "1.998290655207842", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_minus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.net.2034.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_minus_half_gross_fy2039", + "label": "Expected gross saving with earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -10438500443.470476, + "value_raw": "10.438500443470476", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_minus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.gross.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "earnings_minus_half_net_fy2039", + "label": "Expected net saving with earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7409692041.497155, + "value_raw": "7.409692041497156", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "expected value over the same paths with calendar earnings growth -0.5 points a year from 2031 (mean_path_scenarios)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "mean_path_scenarios.scenarios.earnings_minus_0_5pp.scenario_path_set.net.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "history_since_2012_gross_fy2026", + "label": "Gross saving in 2026-27 had the Burnham plan applied from April 2012", + "world": "burnham_since_2012", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -7253585729.199216, + "value_raw": "7.253585729199216", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "the plan's rule replayed on published September CPI and May-July earnings from April 2012 (any start from April 2012 to April 2015 gives the same path); April 2022's earnings leg suspended under both rules, as in law" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "history_since_2012_net_fy2026", + "label": "Net saving in 2026-27 had the Burnham plan applied from April 2012", + "world": "burnham_since_2012", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 5239332032.375046, + "value_raw": "5.239332032375046", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "the plan's rule replayed on published September CPI and May-July earnings from April 2012 (any start from April 2012 to April 2015 gives the same path); April 2022's earnings leg suspended under both rules, as in law" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "trajectories.history.groups[0].model_years.saving_bn.2026.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "replay_since_2017_gross_fy2026", + "label": "Gross saving in 2026-27 had the Burnham plan applied from April 2017", + "world": "burnham_since_2017", + "metric": "benefit_cost_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": -5993873234.776714, + "value_raw": "5.993873234776714", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints the saving as a positive number of pounds billion (gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending); benefit_cost_change is stated positive = increase in spending, so a saving is negative", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "gross: the fall in basic and new State Pension spending", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in State Pension spending", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "historical legal replay of April 2017 to 2026 on published inputs (the scenario envelope's last-decade replay); not a forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.last_decade_replay.counterfactual.model_years.saving_bn.2026.gross", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "replay_since_2017_net_fy2026", + "label": "Net saving in 2026-27 had the Burnham plan applied from April 2017", + "world": "burnham_since_2017", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 4328832665.8718, + "value_raw": "4.328832665871801", + "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2026-27", + "geography": "UK", + "measure": "net: the gross saving less lower income tax and higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits", + "basis": "static", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the Exchequer", + "program": "state_pension_with_tax_and_benefits", + "basis_note": "historical legal replay of April 2017 to 2026 on published inputs (the scenario envelope's last-decade replay); not a forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "scenario_envelope.last_decade_replay.counterfactual.model_years.saving_bn.2026.net", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "households_losing_share_fy2039", + "label": "Expected share of UK households with less income under the plan, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 0.26957605883007135, + "value_raw": "26.957605883007133", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "unit_of_count": "households", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "model-conditional expected value over a distribution of 50,000 paths of prices and earnings (monthly VAR(1) with bootstrap shocks, means shifted to the OBR March 2026 central path), estimated from a 160-slot stratified sample of 161 unique full PolicyEngine UK runs; provisional pre-Budget release under ruling (c)" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "expected_value.estimates.primary.households_losing_pct.2039.mean", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_triple_lock_fy2034", + "label": "Pensioners in absolute poverty after housing costs under the triple lock, OBR central forecast path, 2034-35", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 0.12121166229248047, + "value_raw": "12.121166229248047", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "subgroup": "pensioners", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "poverty_line": "absolute, as results.json names it (pensioners_absolute_ahc)", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.poverty_pct.triple_lock.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_triple_lock_fy2039", + "label": "Pensioners in absolute poverty after housing costs under the triple lock, OBR central forecast path, 2039-40", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 0.08789018630981446, + "value_raw": "8.789018630981445", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "subgroup": "pensioners", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "poverty_line": "absolute, as results.json names it (pensioners_absolute_ahc)", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.poverty_pct.triple_lock.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034", + "label": "Pensioners in absolute poverty after housing costs under the Burnham plan, OBR central forecast path, 2034-35", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 0.12154651641845704, + "value_raw": "12.154651641845703", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2034-35", + "geography": "UK", + "subgroup": "pensioners", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "poverty_line": "absolute, as results.json names it (pensioners_absolute_ahc)", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2034.pensioners_absolute_ahc", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + }, + { + "key": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039", + "label": "Pensioners in absolute poverty after housing costs under the Burnham plan, OBR central forecast path, 2039-40", + "world": "burnham_2030", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2040, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 0.08826981544494629, + "value_raw": "8.826981544494629", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "fy": "2039-40", + "geography": "UK", + "subgroup": "pensioners", + "housing_costs": "ahc", + "poverty_line": "absolute, as results.json names it (pensioners_absolute_ahc)", + "basis": "static", + "program": "state_pension", + "basis_note": "one path: the OBR March 2026 central forecast" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock", + "commit": "5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d", + "path": "dashboard/public/data/results.json", + "sha256": "e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781", + "field": "central.run.poverty_pct.burnham_2030.2039.pensioners_absolute_ahc", + "computed_at": "2026-10-15T14:44:51+00:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.2.6", + "policyengine_uk": "2.125.1", + "policyengine_core": "3.33.0" + }, + "dataset": "enhanced_frs_2024_25@1.58.0 (runtime sha256 5ba399ea5ab9a6c7d4e9aaf6c623080beb34d9ad5f330f6244dbad72b8d960b6)" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f7b8672a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,244 @@ +[ + { + "id": "survey-bill-below-dwp", + "claims": [ + "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039" + ], + "status": "pending", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Unexplained; tracked in PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock#13, which says the cause of this gap is not established. A partial account, from measured bills and one paired run rather than matched model runs: DWP's £15bn is for Great Britain. The dashboard sets it beside its UK figure, £11.14bn (26% below), and the results file's Great Britain figure is £10.83bn (28% below). Much of the gap is the size of the pension bill. On any one path the gross saving is a fixed share of the basic and new State Pension bill: the engine fails a run unless every such pension scales by the ratio of the two rules' amounts (engine.py), and the results file's paired run on Microcosm, whose 2026-27 basic and new bill is 10.1% larger, raises the 2039-40 saving by £1.12bn with the share unchanged (expected_value.paired_difference.gross_share_flat_rate_spending_pct: 0.0000001 points). The dashboard's basic and new State Pension spending in Great Britain is 84 to 86% of DWP's figure, which includes payments abroad (flat_rate_bn: 0.856 in 2026-27, 0.837 in 2030-31; coverage.by_year). DWP separates payments abroad (£5.9bn in 2026-27, £6.6bn in 2030-31) only for all State Pension types together, so the like-for-like shortfall is about 10 to 16%. The Enhanced FRS has 11.16m recipients in Great Britain against DWP's 12.15m in 2026-27, and the method grows the survey's own counts by ONS growth rather than matching ONS levels (METHOD.md), so the shortfall carries forward. On the OBR-wedge path the dashboard's 2039-40 State Pension bill under the triple lock is £243.2bn for the UK, 85% of the £286bn the Resolution Foundation cites for that year; RF does not say whether that includes payments abroad, which the survey omits. Taking the bill shortfall out leaves the Great Britain figure about 14 to 19% below DWP's, and the paired Microcosm run, whose basic and new bill is 0.94 of DWP's figure including payments abroad, gives £11.94bn for Great Britain, 20% below: inside the threshold either way. The remainder is consistent with a different uprating path, with Pensim3's projection of the population and pension types after 2030-31, or with DWP's rounding to £1bn, and none of these can be checked. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating' but does not publish it. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). This is an accounting decomposition from measured bills and one paired run, not the matched full-run counterfactual the analysis's issue #13 asks for.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/src/triple_lock/engine.py#L1166-L1172" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/docs/METHOD.md#L63" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-10-05/hl3774" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/" + }, + { + "kind": "issue", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://questions-statements-api.parliament.uk/api/writtenquestions/questions/1944151?expandMember=true" + } + ], + "tracking_issue": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/issues/13" + }, + { + "id": "dwp-real-terms-table", + "claims": [ + "dwp_ame_real_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "DWP's Table 2 gives the same saving in 2025-26 prices; the dashboard publishes cash figures, which DWP gives in Table 1, compared under survey-bill-below-dwp.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "dwp-relative-vs-absolute-poverty", + "claims": [ + "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", + "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "DWP's Chart 1 is relative low income (below 60% of a median projected forward with average earnings) for pensioners in Great Britain under the adjusted Triple Lock. The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line (the population step's bars) and relative poverty only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures the same thing. Its results file does hold the central path's relative level, which the page does not show: 13.85% in 2034-35 and 13.77% in 2039-40 under the plan (central.run.poverty_pct), against DWP's chart readings of about 10.3% and 9.2%. DWP projects the population and individual pension outcomes in Pensim3; the dashboard holds survey ages fixed and reweights them to the ONS projection (results.json assumptions[0]). Nothing measured here separates that difference from others, so no cause of the level gap is claimed.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/src/components/StepPopulation.jsx#L182-L190" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "cbp-full-rate-base-and-own-paths", + "claims": [ + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039" + ], + "status": "comparable", + "explains_gap": true, + "cause": "Two differences documented in CBP's methodology put its savings above the dashboard's. First, the spending base, which 'the savings scale with'. CBP counts 13.39 million pensioners in 2026 (tool_data.json population: 5.89m new, 7.51m basic), from DWP's caseload, which includes pensioners abroad (CBP leaves only their share out of its tax calculation), against the survey's 11.46m UK recipients (results.json coverage). It prices each at the full weekly rate (£241.30 new, £184.90 basic), which 'ignores partial entitlements'. That makes CBP's base about £146bn in 2026-27 against the dashboard's £115.2bn UK bill, 27% larger: a count 17% higher, and full rates 8 to 9% above survey amounts. By 2039-40 the gap narrows to about 23% at 2026 rates (CBP's 15.05m pensioners against the dashboard's central-path bill deflated by its own triple-lock index). The dashboard's saving is a fixed share of its bill on each path (engine.py), so the base accounts for about 70% of the 2039-40 gap, where CBP's £14.90bn is 34% above the dashboard's £11.14bn. Second, the paths. CBP's baseline is 'the model's own projection of the Triple Lock, not the OBR's forecast, so savings will not match a costing scored against the OBR's Economic and Fiscal Outlook'. CBP says its inflation 'settles too high' (2.9% a year over 2032-49) and its earnings growth is 'too volatile', both raising the savings, while normal shocks understate large inflation surprises, which works the other way ('the net effect is unclear'). The dashboard's paths are shifted so their means match the OBR's March 2026 central path, on which CPI is 2.0% and the earnings input stays below 2.5% for the April 2028 to 2031 rises. On that path the 2.5% floor sets both rules' rise and the plan saves nothing until 2032-33 (central.run.rate_sources, central.run.saving_bn). That is where the early years part most: the dashboard is 59% below CBP in 2031-32 (£0.22bn against £0.53bn) and 37% below in 2032-33.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/methodology" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/src/triple_lock/engine.py#L1166-L1172" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "cbp-net-after-income-tax-only", + "claims": [ + "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "CBP's net figures subtract income tax only, and its model 'does not include Pension Credit, whose spending would rise for some pensioners if the State Pension grew more slowly'. The dashboard's net saving also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit, council tax reduction and other benefits: in 2039-40 £0.81bn of the £3.28bn between its gross and net figures (results.json expected_value.estimates.primary.component.*). The two net figures measure different things.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/methodology" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "ifs-price-basis-not-stated", + "claims": [ + "ifs_saving_fy2034" + ], + "status": "comparable", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "The comparison takes IFS's 'around £4 billion' as cash and gross, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS states neither. If it is in today's prices, as the £11bn in the paragraph before it is, its cash value in 2034-35 is higher (about £4.7bn at 2% a year inflation) and the gap about -32%. If it is net of tax, the dashboard's figure is £2.30bn net and the gap -43%. Either reading would put it over the threshold, so the -20% here rests on the cash, gross reading.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "ifs-range-of-outcomes", + "claims": [ + "ifs_range_low_fy2039", + "ifs_range_high_fy2039" + ], + "status": "comparable", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "IFS's £4bn to £20bn is a range of outcomes, where the saving 'could reasonably be'; it is compared, as a range, with the dashboard's expected gross saving for 2039-40 (£11.14bn), which lies inside it. The comparison reads IFS's figures as cash, the basis of the dashboard's figure; IFS does not say whether its range is in cash or today's prices. The dashboard's like-for-like spread, its 'Middle 80% of paths' card (£3.9bn to £18.9bn gross), is computed in the browser from the paths (dataHelpers.js getSavingSpread), so the results file stores no percentile to pin.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/src/lib/dataHelpers.js#L397" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "rf-one-decade-replayed", + "claims": [ + "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "RF's £24bn is the saving if the 2030s repeat the price and earnings record of the decade after 2016, set beside 'nothing' if they repeat the 1990s or 2000s: one historical path per decade, not an expectation over paths like the dashboard's £11.14bn.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "rf-reconstruction-of-government-figure", + "claims": [ + "rf_reconstruction_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "RF's 'around £15 billion' reproduces the government's figure. It takes the OBR's average triple-lock premium of 0.53 points a year, compounds it over ten years (5.43%), and applies it to the whole projected State Pension bill of £286bn in 2039-40. That bill includes the pre-2016 components DWP says the triple lock does not uprate. It is not a run of the plan's rule on a path. The dashboard's nearest figure, its OBR-wedge path (£10.29bn, UK), runs both rules with the triple lock paying the OBR's long-term premium on the survey's flat-rate bill.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock/blob/5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d/dashboard/public/data/results.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "rf-triple-lock-against-earnings-link", + "claims": [ + "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", + "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "RF gives £5bn after five years and £15bn after ten as what the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by', having described the replacement as 'a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run'. Its next paragraph says the new mechanism keeps minimum rises of inflation or 2.5% and would have left the pension 4.5% above 'just a link to earnings' since 2012. So RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models. The release presents the figures as the saving from ending the triple lock, and The Telegraph (30 September 2026) reported them as the plan's.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bdecd585d --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{"key": "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039", "source": "dwp", "found_by": "dwp", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "dwp_pensim3", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -15000000000.0, "value_raw": "-£15 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "geography": "Great Britain", "price_basis": "nominal", "basis": "static", "program": "state_pension", "rounding": "nearest £1bn", "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 1: 'negative values denote savings')", "program_note": "State Pension", "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "From April 2030 the government will adjust the Triple Lock ... In any given year it will go up by at least inflation or 2.5% – and anything more that is needed to retain that value.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "primary_sha256": "d11f6f649d019b7900f213171aad03ea9a110374a91a731927df20c3abb5199d", "locator": "Impacts, Table 1: Estimated AME savings of adjusted Triple Lock policy relative to Triple Lock (nominal)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", "quote": "In-year AME savings (nominal terms, rounded to nearest billion, negative values denote savings) 2039 to 2040 2049 to 2050 Adjusted Triple Lock -£15 billion -£50 billion", "note": "Table 1's 2049-50 column (-£50bn) is outside the dashboard's years and is not staged. DWP's page says the analysis 'applies a path for uprating the basic and new State Pension' and does not publish it; asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774). Compared with the UK headline, as the dashboard's own DWP benchmark does; DWP's figure is for Great Britain, and the results file's Great Britain figure is £10.83bn.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039"}} +{"key": "dwp_ame_real_fy2039", "source": "dwp", "found_by": "dwp", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "dwp_pensim3", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -11000000000.0, "value_raw": "-£11 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "geography": "Great Britain", "price_basis": "real terms, 2025-26 prices", "basis": "static", "program": "state_pension", "rounding": "nearest £1bn", "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in AME spending (Table 2: 'negative values denote savings')", "program_note": "State Pension", "basis_note": "direct effect on Annually Managed Expenditure; no tax or debt interest effects", "prices": "real"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "From April 2030 the government will adjust the Triple Lock ... In any given year it will go up by at least inflation or 2.5% – and anything more that is needed to retain that value.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "primary_sha256": "d11f6f649d019b7900f213171aad03ea9a110374a91a731927df20c3abb5199d", "locator": "Impacts, Table 2: Estimated AME savings of adjusted Triple Lock policy relative to Triple Lock (real)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 2", "source_column": "2039 to 2040, Adjusted Triple Lock", "quote": "In-year AME savings (real terms, 2025 to 2026 prices, rounded to nearest billion, negative values denote savings) 2039 to 2040 2049 to 2050 Adjusted Triple Lock -£11 billion -£30 billion", "note": "Table 2's 2049-50 column (-£30bn) is outside the dashboard's years and is not staged.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", "pe_missing": "The dashboard publishes nominal savings only; DWP's nominal figure (Table 1) is the one compared."} +{"key": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", "source": "dwp", "found_by": "dwp", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "dwp_pensim3", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.103, "value_raw": "10.3%", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "geography": "Great Britain", "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", "program": "state_pension", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "From April 2030 the government will adjust the Triple Lock ... In any given year it will go up by at least inflation or 2.5% – and anything more that is needed to retain that value.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "primary_sha256": "015b3a366f18040d228488fd16fa00e2f91ca97207d84074e25cfc206c94a39c", "locator": "Impacts, Chart 1 (the 2034/35 vertex of the line)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chart 1", "source_column": "2034/35, adjusted Triple Lock", "quote": "Chart 1 shows that relative pensioner poverty after housing costs under the adjusted Triple Lock is projected to fall from around 14% in 2024 to 2025 to around 8% in 2049 to 2050.", "note": "Read from the chart's vector file, not by eye: the line's 2034/35 vertex is at y=854.028, against gridlines at 0% (y=1483.5) and 16% (y=506.5), 61.06 px a point, which gives 10.31%. The chart labels only its first (14%) and last (8%) points, both outside the dashboard's years. One line, under the adjusted Triple Lock; DWP gives no triple-lock line. The quote is the page's own sentence on Chart 1.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2034", "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate."} +{"key": "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039", "source": "dwp", "found_by": "dwp", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "dwp_pensim3", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.092, "value_raw": "9.2%", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "approx_chart_reading", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "geography": "Great Britain", "subgroup": "pensioners (above State Pension age)", "housing_costs": "ahc", "poverty_line": "relative low income: below 60% of the median, threshold from HBAI FYE 2025 projected forward with average earnings", "model": "Pensim3, ONS 2024-based population projections", "program": "state_pension", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "From April 2030 the government will adjust the Triple Lock ... In any given year it will go up by at least inflation or 2.5% – and anything more that is needed to retain that value.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", "url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "primary_sha256": "015b3a366f18040d228488fd16fa00e2f91ca97207d84074e25cfc206c94a39c", "locator": "Impacts, Chart 1 (the 2039/40 vertex of the line)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Chart 1", "source_column": "2039/40, adjusted Triple Lock", "quote": "Chart 1 shows that relative pensioner poverty after housing costs under the adjusted Triple Lock is projected to fall from around 14% in 2024 to 2025 to around 8% in 2049 to 2050.", "note": "Read from the chart's vector file, not by eye: the line's 2039/40 vertex is at y=922.03, against gridlines at 0% (y=1483.5) and 16% (y=506.5), 61.06 px a point, which gives 9.20%. The chart labels only its first (14%) and last (8%) points, both outside the dashboard's years. One line, under the adjusted Triple Lock; DWP gives no triple-lock line. The quote is the page's own sentence on Chart 1.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "central_pensioner_absolute_poverty_ahc_burnham_fy2039", "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints pensioner poverty levels on an absolute line; relative poverty appears only as the change between the rules, so no published figure measures DWP's relative rate."} +{"key": "ifs_saving_fy2034", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_own_analysis", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4000000000.0, "value_raw": "around £4 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "geography": "not stated", "price_basis": "not stated", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the reform 'will save around £4 billion per year')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "IFS's expectation ('we expect'); not stated whether gross spending or net of tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "its reform to the triple lock (the Prime Minister's announcement of 29 September 2026)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", "date": "2026-09-30", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "23deb9f07f955956ac416928f2cb93f55f9ca0bfe41bd0e3fb3a27f463fc1c02", "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, second paragraph", "access": "wayback 20261004022725"}, "source_table": "Press comment", "source_column": "2034-35", "quote": "In 2034–35, we expect that the reform will save around £4 billion per year, but it could easily save nothing at all if earnings growth is strong.", "note": "IFS publishes no table or method with this comment and does not say whether the figure is in cash or today's prices; the paragraph before restates the government's £15bn (cash) as £11bn in today's terms. Compared with the nominal expected gross saving; Telegraph coverage the same day (via Yahoo News) adds no price basis. The dashboard's 'middle 80% of paths' for 2034-35 runs from £0.0bn to £7.4bn gross, in line with IFS's 'could easily save nothing'.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034"}} +{"key": "ifs_range_low_fy2039", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_own_analysis", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4000000000.0, "value_raw": "£4 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_low", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "not stated", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "its reform to the triple lock (the Prime Minister's announcement of 29 September 2026)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", "date": "2026-09-30", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "23deb9f07f955956ac416928f2cb93f55f9ca0bfe41bd0e3fb3a27f463fc1c02", "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, first paragraph", "access": "wayback 20261004022725"}, "source_table": "Press comment", "source_column": "2039-40, range low", "quote": "However, the saving is very uncertain, because of how unpredictable the old triple lock is, and new IFS analysis shows it could reasonably be anywhere between £4 billion and £20 billion.", "note": "The year is the paragraph's: it opens with the government's estimate 'by 2039–40'. IFS does not publish the analysis behind the range or say whether it is in cash or today's prices.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039"}} +{"key": "ifs_range_high_fy2039", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_own_analysis", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 20000000000.0, "value_raw": "£20 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "range_high", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "not stated", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "a range of outcomes: where the saving 'could reasonably be'", "range_group": "ifs_saving_range_fy2039"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "its reform to the triple lock (the Prime Minister's announcement of 29 September 2026)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", "date": "2026-09-30", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "23deb9f07f955956ac416928f2cb93f55f9ca0bfe41bd0e3fb3a27f463fc1c02", "locator": "Comment by Jonathan Cribb, first paragraph", "access": "wayback 20261004022725"}, "source_table": "Press comment", "source_column": "2039-40, range high", "quote": "However, the saving is very uncertain, because of how unpredictable the old triple lock is, and new IFS analysis shows it could reasonably be anywhere between £4 billion and £20 billion.", "note": "The year is the paragraph's: it opens with the government's estimate 'by 2039–40'. IFS does not publish the analysis behind the range or say whether it is in cash or today's prices.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039"}} +{"key": "ifs_since_2011_fy2026", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "ifs_own_analysis", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 9000000000.0, "value_raw": "£9 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "price_basis": "cash, 2026-27", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (expenditure in 2026-27 'would be £9 billion lower')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "the new triple lock applied since 2011 against spending as it is"}, "world": "burnham_since_2012", "reform_hint": "If the new triple lock had been in place instead [since 2010–11]", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "ed9012deb2595b274f2f9a7f3297d382f437c4c888830bb0158e4796ea4116fe", "locator": "'What would the effects of the new triple lock be?', fifth paragraph ('The chart therefore shows'), before Figure 2", "access": "wayback 20261001061000"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "2026-27", "quote": "If the new triple lock had been in place instead, expenditure in 2026–27 would be £9 billion lower than it currently is.", "note": "IFS starts the new rule in 2011; the dashboard's history starts it in April 2012. IFS's datafile (Figure 2) has the old and new triple lock rising together to 2015, and the dashboard's history gives the same path for any start from April 2012 to 2015, so the start year does not move the comparison. IFS's response the same day restates the figure ('if the new policy had been in place since 2011 ... £9 billion lower'); it is staged once.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "history_since_2012_gross_fy2026"}} +{"key": "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_historical_decade_replay", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 24000000000.0, "value_raw": "£24 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "cash", "scenario": "the 2030s repeat the decade following 2016", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "the new 'adjusted' triple lock announced this week; under which the pension will rise by the higher of inflation or 2.5 per cent, but will never fall below the value of earnings at introduction", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "6edff1abde4d65cbbdb83f6b767b00546db521eb905e4e490e7c537382a7952b", "locator": "'It depends which decade we are about to have', final paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "2010s decade replayed", "quote": "The adjusted triple lock saves most in a volatile world, and so saves nothing in the 90s or 00s, and £24 billion in the 10s.", "note": "RF prints no year for the £24bn; 2039-40 is inferred from 'if the 2030s turns out like one of these three decades' and the 2039-40 bill two paragraphs earlier. 'Nothing' for the 1990s and 2000s replays prints no number and is not staged. The same paragraph gives the triple lock's cost against an earnings uprating (nothing, £32bn, £24bn), a world the dashboard does not score.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", "pe_missing": "One replayed historical decade, not an expectation over paths; the dashboard publishes no saving for a single replayed decade in 2039-40."} +{"key": "rf_reconstruction_fy2039", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_illustrative_calculation", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 15000000000.0, "value_raw": "around £15 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "the OBR's 0.53-point average premium compounded over ten years (5.43%) applied to a £286bn State Pension bill"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "The Government ... expect this change to reduce the pensions bill by £15 billion after ten years", "attribution": "restated", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "6edff1abde4d65cbbdb83f6b767b00546db521eb905e4e490e7c537382a7952b", "locator": "Second paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "2039-40", "quote": "Applying that to the total State Pension bill – projected under the triple lock to reach £286 billion in 2039-40 (in cash terms) – shows how you get around £15 billion.", "note": "RF's arithmetic reproducing the government's £15bn ('That looks like a reasonable central case'), so staged as restated.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "obr_wedge_gross_fy2039", "pe_missing": "A reconstruction of the government's figure from an average premium, not a run of the plan's rule on any path."} +{"key": "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_typical_variation", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5000000000.0, "value_raw": "around £5 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "price_basis": "not stated", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'"}, "world": "earnings_link_instead_of_triple_lock", "reform_hint": "The Government has said it will replace the triple lock with a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run, rather than ratcheting above it.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "039e9e1f29caf99ef76729c84f1552939cee0d7fcd9c81a4bc97c416509193eb", "locator": "Press release, fourth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "after five years", "quote": "However, based on typical variation in the economy, it tends to increase the pension bill by around £5 billion annually after five years, but by £15 billion after ten years.", "note": "RF prints no years; five and ten years after the April 2030 switch are 2034-35 and 2039-40. The Telegraph (Melissa Lawford, 30 September 2026, via Yahoo News) reported them as the plan's: 'The Resolution Foundation calculated that the tweak could save the Government as much as £5bn per year by 2035 and £15bn per year by 2040.' Staged, unlike RF's other earnings-link figures, because they were attributed to the plan.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034", "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule."} +{"key": "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_typical_variation", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 15000000000.0, "value_raw": "£15 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "not stated", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the triple lock 'tends to increase the pension bill by' this)", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "the triple lock's typical extra cost against a system that grows in line with earnings, 'based on typical variation in the economy'"}, "world": "earnings_link_instead_of_triple_lock", "reform_hint": "The Government has said it will replace the triple lock with a system that grows in line with earnings in the long-run, rather than ratcheting above it.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "039e9e1f29caf99ef76729c84f1552939cee0d7fcd9c81a4bc97c416509193eb", "locator": "Press release, fourth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "after ten years", "quote": "However, based on typical variation in the economy, it tends to increase the pension bill by around £5 billion annually after five years, but by £15 billion after ten years.", "note": "RF prints no years; five and ten years after the April 2030 switch are 2034-35 and 2039-40. The Telegraph (Melissa Lawford, 30 September 2026, via Yahoo News) reported them as the plan's: 'The Resolution Foundation calculated that the tweak could save the Government as much as £5bn per year by 2035 and £15bn per year by 2040.' Staged, unlike RF's other earnings-link figures, because they were attributed to the plan.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039", "pe_missing": "RF approximates the plan by an earnings link and leaves out the CPI and 2.5% floor the dashboard models (its next paragraph sets the new mechanism 4.5 per cent above 'just a link to earnings'), so the two do not score the same rule."} +{"key": "rf_level_since_2012_fy2026", "source": "resolution_foundation", "found_by": "resolution_foundation", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "rf_historical_replay", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percent", "proposed_metric": "benefit_rate_change_pct", "value": 5.9, "value_raw": "5.9 per cent lower", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2026-27", "quantity": "the State Pension's level against the triple lock", "sign_convention": "positive = lower than under the triple lock (printed: '5.9 per cent lower')", "program": "state_pension", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "burnham_since_2012", "reform_hint": "If the new mechanism had been in place since 2012", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", "url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "primary_sha256": "039e9e1f29caf99ef76729c84f1552939cee0d7fcd9c81a4bc97c416509193eb", "locator": "Press release, fifth paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "this year (2026-27)", "quote": "If the new mechanism had been in place since 2012 it would have left the State Pension 4.5 per cent higher than just a link to earnings, but 5.9 per cent lower than it is with the triple lock this year.", "note": "The 4.5 per cent is against an earnings link, a world the dashboard does not score; not staged.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard prints the same quantity, 'today's full new State Pension would be 6.3% lower' had the plan started in April 2012 (results.json trajectories.history.groups[0].level_ratio.2026 = 0.9370), but no registered metric names a change in a benefit's rate, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided."} +{"key": "cbp_post_mean_fy2034", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3000000000.0, "value_raw": "£3 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "price_basis": "cash", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "not stated whether before or after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "An annual double lock: the state pension will go up by whichever is the highest of inflation or 2.5%. AND an earnings catch-up, to ensure pensions keep their value relative to average earnings over time.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "7ac6d7873c3433e26f6277bdc5d675615befdacab7a56b5245f77857706a73eb", "locator": "'How much money will this save?', first paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "2034/35, mean", "quote": "The mean savings are £3 billion (annually) by 2034/35 rising to £57.4 billion (annually) by 2049/50.", "note": "The post is dated 2 October 2026; the calculator's model changed on 1 and 5 October and its figures were re-exported on 6 October (Methodology page; staged below). The post's £57.4bn mean for 2049/50 is above its own £55.7bn pre-tax figure for that year, so its paragraphs may come from different runs. It does not say whether this mean is before or after income tax; it is compared with the gross figure, the basis of the post's own comparison with DWP. 2049/50 figures are outside the dashboard's years and are not staged.", "parse_confidence": "medium", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034"}} +{"key": "cbp_post_pretax_fy2039", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 14300000000.0, "value_raw": "£14.3 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "sign_convention": "positive = saving", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "An annual double lock: the state pension will go up by whichever is the highest of inflation or 2.5%. AND an earnings catch-up, to ensure pensions keep their value relative to average earnings over time.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", "url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "7ac6d7873c3433e26f6277bdc5d675615befdacab7a56b5245f77857706a73eb", "locator": "'How much money will this save?', third paragraph", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "2039/40, pre-tax", "quote": "The Department for Work and Pensions has forecast that the change will raise £15 billion in 2039/40 and £50 billion in 2049/50. However, these figures do not account for the loss of income tax revenue that results from a lower state pension. Our analysis produces very similar pre-tax savings: £14.3 billion and £55.7 billion respectively.", "note": "The post (2 October) predates the 5 October correction to the plan's earnings path; the calculator's 6 October export gives £14.901bn (staged below).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 526000000.0, "value_raw": "0.526", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2031-32", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[5] (savings.years[5] = 2031)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2031"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1343000000.0, "value_raw": "1.343", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2032-33", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[6] (savings.years[6] = 2032)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2032"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2504000000.0, "value_raw": "2.504", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2033-34", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[7] (savings.years[7] = 2033)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2033"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3906000000.0, "value_raw": "3.906", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[8] (savings.years[8] = 2034)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2034"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5599000000.0, "value_raw": "5.599", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2036, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2035-36", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[9] (savings.years[9] = 2035)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2035"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 7508000000.0, "value_raw": "7.508", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2037, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2036-37", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[10] (savings.years[10] = 2036)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2036"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 9638000000.0, "value_raw": "9.638", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2038, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2037-38", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[11] (savings.years[11] = 2037)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2037"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 12109000000.0, "value_raw": "12.109", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2039, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2038-39", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[12] (savings.years[12] = 2038)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2038"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "benefit_cost_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 14901000000.0, "value_raw": "14.901", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving (the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "before income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.annual_mean[13] (savings.years[13] = 2039)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", "quote": "\"annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.526, 1.343, 2.504, 3.906, 5.599, 7.508, 9.638, 12.109, 14.901, 17.837, 21.123, 24.703, 28.544, 32.661, 37.173, 42.276, 47.786, 53.646, 60.089]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "ev_gross_fy2039"}} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 422000000.0, "value_raw": "0.422", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2031-32", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[5] (savings.years[5] = 2031)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2031 (2031/32)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2031", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1073000000.0, "value_raw": "1.073", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2032-33", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[6] (savings.years[6] = 2032)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2032 (2032/33)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2032", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 1995000000.0, "value_raw": "1.995", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2033-34", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[7] (savings.years[7] = 2033)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2033 (2033/34)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2033", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3103000000.0, "value_raw": "3.103", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2034-35", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[8] (savings.years[8] = 2034)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2034 (2034/35)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2034", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4439000000.0, "value_raw": "4.439", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2036, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2035-36", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[9] (savings.years[9] = 2035)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2035 (2035/36)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2035", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5939000000.0, "value_raw": "5.939", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2037, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2036-37", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[10] (savings.years[10] = 2036)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2036 (2036/37)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2036", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 7609000000.0, "value_raw": "7.609", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2038, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2037-38", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[11] (savings.years[11] = 2037)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2037 (2037/38)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2037", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 9545000000.0, "value_raw": "9.545", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2039, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2038-39", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[12] (savings.years[12] = 2038)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2038 (2038/39)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2038", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "cbp_tool_net_fy2039", "source": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_by": "centre_for_british_progress", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbp_triple_lock_simulation_model", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 11729000000.0, "value_raw": "11.729", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "price_basis": "cash", "basis": "static", "statistic": "mean across 10,000 simulations", "geography": "State Pension caseload (DWP Stat-Xplore)", "spending_base": "pensioners by type times the full weekly rate", "sign_convention": "positive = saving to the Exchequer (after income tax; the calculator: 'Positive = cheaper than the Triple Lock')", "program": "state_pension_with_income_tax", "basis_note": "after income tax"}, "world": "burnham_2030", "reform_hint": "RF Smoothed Triple Lock — the PM's plan from April 2030: the pension rises by at least the higher of CPI and 2.5% every year ... When a 2.5% or inflation-driven rise takes it above the [earnings] path, it gets only the higher of CPI and 2.5% until earnings growth catches the path up", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "primary_sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "locator": "policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings.net_annual_mean[13] (savings.years[13] = 2039)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "tool_data.json, policies.rf_smoothed_triple_lock.savings", "source_column": "net_annual_mean, uprating year 2039 (2039/40)", "quote": "\"net_annual_mean\": [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.422, 1.073, 1.995, 3.103, 4.439, 5.939, 7.609, 9.545, 11.729, 14.021, 16.581, 19.362, 22.337, 25.517, 28.993, 32.916, 37.146, 41.644, 46.583]", "note": "Exported 6 October 2026. 'Years are uprating years (2030 = 2030/31)' (Solutions page). The 10th-90th percentiles in the same file are not staged: the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ev_net_fy2039", "pe_missing": "CBP's net subtracts income tax only; the dashboard's net also takes off higher Pension Credit, Housing Benefit and other benefits, so no published figure measures the same thing."} +{"key": "obr_wedge_frs2026", "source": "obr", "found_by": "obr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "obr_long_term_projections", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percentage_points", "proposed_metric": "uprating_premium_over_earnings", "value": 0.56, "value_raw": "0.56 percentage points", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "quantity": "the triple lock's average annual uprating above earnings growth", "horizon": "a constant annual wedge applied in every year of the long-term projection; staged at 2039-40, the end of the window the dashboard's figure covers", "basis": "outturn", "program": "state_pension", "basis_note": "observed inflation and earnings trends since 1990"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Fiscal risks and sustainability - July 2026", "url": "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2026/", "date": "2026-07-07", "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", "primary_sha256": "9989dc6f05af3ec50c0a30f49905df419c2b58a8a832e4b46d53e1fe231928a0", "locator": "Chapter 3, footnote 80 (state pension)", "access": "wayback 20261001061001"}, "source_table": "Footnote 80", "source_column": "triple lock wedge", "quote": "Our latest estimate of this wedge is 0.56 percentage points.", "note": "The same document's £15.5bn (2025 FRS) and 50-year % of GDP figures compare the triple lock with earnings uprating, not the plan; not staged.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's Benchmarks tab prints the triple lock's expected premium over earnings for the April 2034-2039 rises, 0.55 points a year (results.json expected_value.gap_by_calibration.means_shift.mean_rate_minus_earnings_2034_2039.triple_lock = 0.00546), but no registered metric names an uprating premium over earnings, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided."} +{"key": "obr_lted_premium", "source": "obr", "found_by": "obr", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "obr_long_term_projections", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percentage_points", "proposed_metric": "uprating_premium_over_earnings", "value": 0.6, "value_raw": "0.6 percentage points", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2040, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2039-40", "quantity": "the triple lock's long-term growth-rate assumption above average earnings growth", "vintage": "2025 Long-term economic determinants (note column)", "horizon": "a long-term assumption; staged at 2039-40, the end of the window the dashboard's figure covers", "program": "state_pension", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "baseline", "reform_hint": null, "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Long-term economic determinants, March 2026 Economic and fiscal outlook", "url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Long-term-economic-determinants-March-2026-EFO.xlsx", "date": "2026-05-28", "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", "primary_sha256": "8983f5a1ed4912fe5b950e3d9d9fbd0cd973eb8ac47940e622899eeef4d35112", "locator": "Sheet 'Growth rate assumptions', row 19 ('Triple lock'), column E ('Notes on 2025 Long-term economic determinants')", "access": "wayback 20261014191320"}, "source_table": "Growth rate assumptions", "source_column": "Notes on 2025 Long-term economic determinants", "quote": "Average earnings growth plus 0.6 percentage points", "note": "The analysis's own results.json benchmark cites this cell (obr_lted_triple_lock_premium).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's Benchmarks tab prints the triple lock's expected premium over earnings for the April 2034-2039 rises, 0.55 points a year (results.json expected_value.gap_by_calibration.means_shift.mean_rate_minus_earnings_2034_2039.triple_lock = 0.00546), but no registered metric names an uprating premium over earnings, so it cannot be pinned until the proposed metric is decided."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e2bf395f --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{"url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", "title": "State Pension uprating (State Pension uprating analysis 2026)", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "sha256": "d11f6f649d019b7900f213171aad03ea9a110374a91a731927df20c3abb5199d", "bytes": 86317, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The analysis's own results.json benchmark quotes the same Tables 1 and 2."} +{"url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg", "title": "Chart 1: Projected changes in pensioner relative poverty after housing costs compared to 2024 to 2025", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "sha256": "015b3a366f18040d228488fd16fa00e2f91ca97207d84074e25cfc206c94a39c", "bytes": 5118, "doc_type": "svg", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The vector image the State Pension uprating page embeds as Chart 1; one line, under the adjusted Triple Lock, a vertex per year 2024/25 to 2049/50."} +{"url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/triple-lock-reform-factsheet", "title": "Triple Lock reform factsheet", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "sha256": "771aa18ed8a514ce511e698fca7b0d9c644693e23e1d8852ea05fb9f473dceaf", "bytes": 68221, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Read in full; it gives no figure."} +{"url": "https://questions-statements-api.parliament.uk/api/writtenquestions/questions/1944151?expandMember=true", "title": "Written question HL3774: State Pension uprating assumptions (answered 15 October 2026)", "date": "2026-10-15", "publisher": "UK Parliament (answer by DWP, Baroness Sherlock)", "sha256": "5f45f812cd458f926025a62c1f9d6fc60ee91be14c3a8c9e2301767e32c58fa5", "bytes": 2035, "doc_type": "json", "access": "direct (Parliament written questions API)", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The question page returns HTTP 403 to automated fetches; the API returns the same question and answer."} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", "title": "How will the new triple lock work and what effects will it have?", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "ed9012deb2595b274f2f9a7f3297d382f437c4c888830bb0158e4796ea4116fe", "bytes": 210899, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback 20261001061000", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "ifs.org.uk article pages return HTTP 403 to automated fetches; read from the Wayback Machine capture"} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", "title": "Savings from triple lock reform could be large but will not be able to fund social care", "date": "2026-09-30", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "23deb9f07f955956ac416928f2cb93f55f9ca0bfe41bd0e3fb3a27f463fc1c02", "bytes": 195469, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback 20261004022725", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "ifs.org.uk article pages return HTTP 403 to automated fetches; read from the Wayback Machine capture"} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/new-triple-lock-much-improved-not-perfect-and-not-enough-fund-universal-social-care", "title": "New triple lock much improved but not perfect, and not enough to fund universal social care", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "39224d3ef1b81dd21558de1a97b2aeb3bdecd09324d3fb4f0d13fe29dc87aebd", "bytes": 189482, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback 20260930080947", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "ifs.org.uk article pages return HTTP 403 to automated fetches; read from the Wayback Machine capture. Restates the £9bn and £16bn of the analysis comment; not staged twice."} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-09/Triple%20lock%20datafile.xlsx", "title": "Triple lock datafile (Figures 1 and 2 of 'How will the new triple lock work')", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "582b13e2dfcdaa90d1776e9f154c3b5d548e129bcc8e16a6c0468212f4153c8f", "bytes": 165653, "doc_type": "xlsx", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Cumulative growth of the pension under each rule since 2010; Figure 2 has the old and new triple lock equal to 2015."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", "title": "Why nobody knows how much we'll save from the triple lock announcement (Curtice and Pandya)", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "6edff1abde4d65cbbdb83f6b767b00546db521eb905e4e490e7c537382a7952b", "bytes": 131095, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", "title": "Recycling savings from ending the triple lock into social care is good news for vulnerable pensioners", "date": "2026-09-29", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "039e9e1f29caf99ef76729c84f1552939cee0d7fcd9c81a4bc97c416509193eb", "bytes": 114613, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/06/What-a-ratchet.pdf", "title": "What a ratchet! (Curtice and Clegg)", "date": "2026-06-10", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "67eee89562b48d2484ad11816035f85a8f7d2192e096524025b48ecb62521042", "bytes": 135646, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Its figures compare the triple lock with an earnings link or RF's smoothed earnings link, not the plan; none staged."} +{"url": "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", "title": "How much will the government's Triple Lock reform save? (Lawrence and Stubbs)", "date": "2026-10-02", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "sha256": "7ac6d7873c3433e26f6277bdc5d675615befdacab7a56b5245f77857706a73eb", "bytes": 184894, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Live page; its figures are the same as the Wayback capture of 3 October 2026 (20261003055336)."} +{"url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", "title": "Triple lock calculator data (the Prime Minister's plan, reform from April 2030)", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "sha256": "1c8bc4e6791bdffd95d4bc72930452a4b56cbb65ed3f76f44c6805d65cca31b2", "bytes": 976971, "doc_type": "json", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The data file the calculator's Solutions page reads; exported 6 October 2026 (Methodology page). Same bytes on a second fetch on 2026-10-21."} +{"url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/solutions.html", "title": "The Triple Lock calculator: Solutions", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "sha256": "d1c357d48e7a113a245a0e3b5f31ba1c531ba3e2838773d680a6ff43d08f8b80", "bytes": 75233, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/methodology", "title": "The Triple Lock calculator: Methodology", "date": "2026-10-06", "publisher": "Centre for British Progress", "sha256": "a3bd444c5c76fe529ce5bfbad14ba5b423775cbf81dc3da146c2064c3434609a", "bytes": 43172, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2026/", "title": "Fiscal risks and sustainability - July 2026", "date": "2026-07-07", "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", "sha256": "9989dc6f05af3ec50c0a30f49905df419c2b58a8a832e4b46d53e1fe231928a0", "bytes": 560087, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback 20261001061001", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "obr.uk returns HTTP 403 to automated fetches; read from the Wayback Machine capture."} +{"url": "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Long-term-economic-determinants-March-2026-EFO.xlsx", "title": "Long-term economic determinants, March 2026 Economic and fiscal outlook", "date": "2026-05-28", "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", "sha256": "8983f5a1ed4912fe5b950e3d9d9fbd0cd973eb8ac47940e622899eeef4d35112", "bytes": 40388, "doc_type": "xlsx", "access": "wayback 20261014191320", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Same bytes as uk-triple-lock data/raw/Long-term-economic-determinants-March-2026-EFO.xlsx."} +{"url": "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2025/", "title": "Fiscal risks and sustainability - July 2025", "date": "2025-07-08", "publisher": "Office for Budget Responsibility", "sha256": "6943664c85fa89de248fade5d420a668aad2d58767ec43fd68fb88b375a2d705", "bytes": 591092, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback 20250708101212", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Its £15.5bn is the triple lock against earnings uprating since 2012, not the plan; not staged."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8044729c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-triple-lock/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,329 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113608-cmp-uk-triple-lock", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "obr", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:obr.uk triple lock cost state pension uprating 2026", + "OBR adjusted triple lock April 2030 Burnham costing state pension earnings link", + "OBR \"£12.6 billion\" triple lock earnings uprating state pension 2026-27", + "OBR \"0.53 percentage points\" triple lock earnings", + "site:obr.uk triple lock adjusted 2030 state pension saving", + "OBR Burnham adjusted triple lock costing October 2026 Budget state pension" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2026/", + "https://obr.uk/frs/fiscal-risks-and-sustainability-july-2025/", + "https://obr.uk/docs/dlm_uploads/Long-term-economic-determinants-March-2026-EFO.xlsx" + ], + "claims": [ + "obr_wedge_frs2026", + "obr_lted_premium" + ], + "note": "No OBR costing of the plan was found (none is scored before the 28 October 2026 Budget). Staged: the OBR's triple-lock wedge over earnings (0.56 points, July 2026 FRS; 0.6 points, the 2025 long-term determinants note), against the dashboard's 0.55 points. Not staged: the FRS's £15.5bn (2025 FRS) and its 50-year % of GDP figures, which compare the triple lock with earnings uprating, a world the dashboard does not score." + }, + { + "producer": "hm_treasury", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"HM Treasury\" triple lock adjusted 2030 state pension savings", + "site:gov.uk \"HM Treasury\" adjusted triple lock state pension 2030 savings social care" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/prime-minister-andy-burnham-sets-out-plans-for-a-new-national-care-service" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The Prime Minister's Office release of 29 September restates DWP's £15bn and £50bn; no Treasury costing was found." + }, + { + "producer": "uk_hmrc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"tax information and impact note\" state pension triple lock", + "HMRC income tax state pension adjusted triple lock 2030 tax receipts estimate" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No tax information and impact note or HMRC estimate of the plan's income tax effect was found." + }, + { + "producer": "dwp", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk DWP \"impact assessment\" state pension uprating adjusted triple lock" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/state-pension-uprating", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026/triple-lock-reform-factsheet", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/state-pension-uprating-analysis-2026", + "https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-10-05/hl3774", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6abbac623fe1a15db6aff25e/Adjusted_TL_poverty_chart.svg" + ], + "claims": [ + "dwp_ame_nominal_fy2039", + "dwp_ame_real_fy2039", + "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2034", + "dwp_pensioner_relative_poverty_ahc_fy2039" + ], + "note": "Staged: Table 1 (nominal) and Table 2 (2025-26 prices) for 2039-40, and Chart 1's pensioner relative poverty under the adjusted Triple Lock for 2034-35 and 2039-40, read from the chart's vector file. Not staged: 2049-50 (-£50bn, -£30bn) and the chart's labelled points (about 14% in 2024-25, about 8% in 2049-50), outside the dashboard's years. The factsheet (6 October) gives no figure. Asked for its yearly earnings and CPI assumptions, DWP answered that the analysis 'did not use single year assumptions for earnings or prices growth' (HL3774, 15 October)." + }, + { + "producer": "dfe", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"Department for Education\" triple lock state pension" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No DfE publication on the plan was found." + }, + { + "producer": "scottish_fiscal_commission", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "A UK-wide analysis of a reserved benefit; the Commission's list covers Scotland only." + }, + { + "producer": "ifs", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:ifs.org.uk triple lock reform savings social care 2039-40", + "IFS Burnham triple lock earnings link April 2030 savings estimate October 2026", + "\"no significant saving before 2034\" triple lock", + "IFS \"has the triple lock been fixed\"", + "site:ifs.org.uk triple lock October 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/how-will-new-triple-lock-work-and-what-effects-will-it-have", + "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/savings-triple-lock-reform-could-be-large-will-not-be-able-fund-social-care", + "https://ifs.org.uk/articles/new-triple-lock-much-improved-not-perfect-and-not-enough-fund-universal-social-care", + "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-09/Triple%20lock%20datafile.xlsx" + ], + "claims": [ + "ifs_saving_fy2034", + "ifs_range_low_fy2039", + "ifs_range_high_fy2039", + "ifs_since_2011_fy2026" + ], + "note": "Staged: around £4bn in 2034-35, the £4bn to £20bn range for 2039-40, and £9bn lower spending in 2026-27 had the new rule applied since 2011. Not staged: the government's £15bn and £11bn as IFS restates them; the old triple lock's £16bn in 2026-27 against earnings indexation (a world the dashboard does not score); the 6% real rise since 2010 (the dashboard publishes no real-growth figure). The IFS response of 29 September restates the £9bn and £16bn. 'Has the triple lock been fixed?' is a podcast episode and was not read. IFS article pages return HTTP 403 to automated fetches; they were read from Wayback Machine captures." + }, + { + "producer": "resolution_foundation", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:resolutionfoundation.org triple lock 2026 social care savings Burnham", + "Resolution Foundation adjusted triple lock 2030 cost pensioners lose analysis", + "site:resolutionfoundation.org adjusted triple lock October 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/why-nobody-knows-how-much-well-save-from-the-triple-lock-announcement/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/recycling-savings-from-ending-the-triple-lock-into-social-care-is-good-news-for-vulnerable-pensioners/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/what-a-ratchet/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2026/06/What-a-ratchet.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/pension-commissions-evidence-should-be-used-to-set-end-date-for-triple-lock/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/government-should-call-time-on-the-costly-triple-lock-ratchet/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/comment/the-triple-lock-has-been-far-more-damaging-than-i-ever-feared/" + ], + "claims": [ + "rf_decade_2010s_fy2039", + "rf_reconstruction_fy2039", + "rf_typical_after_five_years_fy2034", + "rf_typical_after_ten_years_fy2039", + "rf_level_since_2012_fy2026" + ], + "note": "Staged: £24bn in 2039-40 if the 2030s repeat the decade after 2016; RF's reconstruction of the government's figure (around £15bn, staged as restated); the press release's 'around £5 billion annually after five years, but by £15 billion after ten years', which press coverage reported as the plan's saving, set beside the dashboard with a concept mismatch because RF gives it as the triple lock against a system rising with earnings; the pension 5.9% lower in 2026-27 had the new mechanism applied since 2012. Not staged: £32bn and £24bn for the triple lock against an earnings uprating, the new mechanism 4.5% above an earnings link, the 8.3% decade gap, and What a ratchet!'s £9bn (and the OBR's £12.6bn it reports) and £650m, all against an earnings link or RF's smoothed earnings link. The May and June 2026 releases and the July 2025 comment predate the plan." + }, + { + "producer": "centax", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:centax.org.uk triple lock state pension", + "site:centax.org.uk state pension income tax pensioners 2026" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "centre_for_british_progress", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "\"Centre for British Progress\" triple lock state pension cost", + "britishprogress.org fix the triple lock to save it report savings estimate" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://britishprogress.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-governments-triple", + "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/solutions.html", + "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/methodology", + "https://triple-lock.britishprogress.org/data/tool_data.json", + "https://britishprogress.org/reports/fix-the-triple-lock-to-save-it" + ], + "claims": [ + "cbp_post_mean_fy2034", + "cbp_post_pretax_fy2039", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2031", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2032", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2033", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2034", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2035", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2036", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2037", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2038", + "cbp_tool_gross_fy2039", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2031", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2032", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2033", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2034", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2035", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2036", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2037", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2038", + "cbp_tool_net_fy2039" + ], + "note": "Staged: the post's £3bn (2034/35) and £14.3bn pre-tax (2039/40), written on the 1 October model, and the calculator's 6 October export, mean savings before and after income tax for 2031/32 to 2039/40 (the 'RF Smoothed Triple Lock', which the calculator labels the PM's plan from April 2030). Not staged: 2040/41 onwards (outside the dashboard's years), the 10th to 90th percentiles (the dashboard stores no percentile to set beside them), and the November 2025 report 'Fix the triple lock to save it', which costs CBP's own lookback reform." + }, + { + "producer": "ippr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:ippr.org triple lock state pension 2026 Burnham", + "IPPR triple lock Burnham 2030 state pension pensioner poverty response" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "fabian_society", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:fabians.org.uk triple lock pension", + "Fabian Society triple lock reform 2026 state pension earnings link" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "niesr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:niesr.ac.uk triple lock state pension 2030", + "NIESR triple lock adjusted 2030 Burnham state pension analysis" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://niesr.ac.uk/blog/triple-lock-pensions-urgent-case-change" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The only NIESR piece found, 'The triple lock on pensions: An urgent case for change?', is from August 2016." + }, + { + "producer": "ukmod", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "UKMOD CeMPA triple lock state pension uprating simulation", + "UKMOD CeMPA microsimulation state pension triple lock reform 2026 working paper" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "lse_case", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "LSE CASE paper triple lock state pension uprating pensioner poverty", + "site:sticerd.lse.ac.uk triple lock state pension" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "jrf", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:jrf.org.uk triple lock pensioner poverty 2026", + "Joseph Rowntree Foundation triple lock change 2030 pensioner poverty Burnham" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "landman_economics", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Landman Economics\" triple lock state pension", + "Landman Economics state pension uprating triple lock distributional analysis 2026" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "tax_policy_associates", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk triple lock pension", + "Tax Policy Associates Dan Neidle triple lock state pension Burnham" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "" + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "working paper triple lock state pension indexation uncertainty fiscal cost stochastic simulation UK", + "triple lock state pension uprating reform cost uncertainty stochastic simulation paper 2024 2025 2026 smoothed earnings link", + "SSRN OR IZA OR ISER working paper \"triple lock\" state pension indexation United Kingdom 2025 2026", + "\"triple lock\" pensions journal article fiscal cost earnings indexation Fiscal Studies OR \"National Institute Economic Review\" OR \"Political Quarterly\" 2024 2025 2026" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No working paper or article estimating the plan was found; the uncertainty literature found (IFS R272, 2023) is the IFS's and costs the triple lock against earnings indexation." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found_not_staged", + "queries": [ + "adjusted triple lock 2030 savings estimate pensioners lose per year analysis October 2026", + "Pensions Policy Institute adjusted triple lock 2030 analysis state pension value pensioners", + "House of Commons Library triple lock 2030 adjusted research briefing costs", + "House of Commons Library CBP-11126 triple lock", + "Burnham triple lock change pensioners worse off by 2040 £ a year AJ Bell OR Quilter OR \"Hargreaves Lansdown\" OR \"Royal London\" calculation", + "AJ Bell Burnham triple lock \"since 2011\" new state pension worth less per year analysis", + "\"£490\" \"triple lock\" Burnham basic state pension AJ Bell", + "\"triple lock\" Burnham plan estimate savings 2034-35 OR 2039-40 think tank analysis IEA OR \"Policy Exchange\" OR \"Tony Blair Institute\" OR \"Social Market Foundation\" OR Onward", + "Hansard 13 October 2026 Pensions Triple Lock debate savings estimate", + "scenarios.uk Burnham plan triple lock model savings" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://moneyweek.com/personal-finance/state-pensions/state-pension-triple-lock-unsustainable-changing-mechanism-overdue", + "https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-11126/", + "https://www.ii.co.uk/analysis-commentary/burnhams-triple-lock-shake-and-what-it-could-mean-pensioners-ii540447", + "https://www.cityam.com/?p=2461989", + "https://hannahritchie.substack.com/p/uk-triple-lock-pension-explainer", + "https://scenarios.uk/blog/burnham-plan-to-scrap-the-triple-lock", + "https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/scrapping-triple-lock-could-save-103014605.html" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "AJ Bell: had the plan's method been used since 2011, the full new State Pension would be about £600 a year lower today and the full basic State Pension about £490 lower (Moneyweek, 2 October 2026). Only press coverage carries it; no AJ Bell primary was found, so it is not staged (the dashboard's comparable figure is the plan-from-2012 replay's weekly rate). The Commons Library briefing CBP-11126 returns HTTP 403 to automated fetches and has no Wayback capture, so it could not be read. The other pages checked restate DWP's or the IFS's figures." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/uk-triple-lock@5a6acc5a62d43cb00c61a41f99622b9ac2b51d9d:e35c1fac84f7191c1eadf88426ffde50e75503a38090e55285aabba717ce8781" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/README.md b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..78bc0827e --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +# 2025 Supplemental Poverty Measure post: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md): the post was published on +18 September 2026, before the gate existed. + +- **Published figures** (pinned in `analysis.json`, 90 estimates): the post's calculations are in + `PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper` PR #8, which the post links, pinned at its head + `4b8df66` (`analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/`): `anchored_results.json` (2025 rates at + 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, the threshold effect, tenure, and the recomputed published + rates), `anchored_results_chained.json` (the C-CPI-U column), `waterfall_data.json` (the + 2024-to-2025 change at anchored thresholds, the post's "fell 0.7 points"), + `state_age_results.json` (finer ages) and `by_state.csv` (the state tile map). The post's 2024 + rates on the earlier population controls (footnote 2: 12.93, 13.35, 12.16, 14.95; and 14.50 for + under 6) are pinned to `analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json` on the same + repository's master (`22d8b7a`; the same bytes were committed on 17 September in `a79c03a`). The + post does not link that file. These are recomputations from the Census public-use files with + Census's own SPM variables; no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved. The page was read + from policyengine-app-v2 main at `24550022d` + (`app/src/data/posts/articles/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure.md`, last changed in `a326e0e`). + Every figure the post prints was checked against the file it is pinned to, including all 51 + state tiles and the waterfall chart's data. +- **Not pinned**: the post's 2024 rates for under 4 (14.95†), 6 to 17 (12.84†) and 75 and over + (16.49†), and its † change column. No results file in the repository carries them. Census's own + figures that the post reports (P60-290 rates, Table 17 state averages) are not PolicyEngine + estimates. +- **What the search found** (2026-10-21, every US producer): Census's working paper + SEHSD-WP2026-22, released with P60-290, anchors the 2024 thresholds two ways. Its CPI-U table + (A.4) is the post's own counterfactual, and is staged and compared: 12.4 percent for all people + against the post's 12.31, and a 0.7-point fall from 2024 against the post's 0.69. Its headline + FCSUti-anchored tables (A.2, A.3) are staged as a concept mismatch, because the FCSUti index rose + 3.44 percent against CPI-U's 2.63. CBPP's blog of 16 September restates the FCSUti figures and + is logged as found but not staged: its page returns a Cloudflare challenge. Columbia CPSP's 2025 + databook anchors in 2025 and prints no figure on the post's quantities. +- **The gaps**: every compared claim is within the 25 percent threshold. The largest are the + 2024-to-2025 changes for people 65 and over (−0.44 against −0.5, −12 percent) and for children + and 18 to 64 year olds (about +9 percent). Census prints its rates and differences to one + decimal, and the post's change starts from Census's 2024 rates as printed (13.0, 13.5, 12.2, + 15.1). +- **Not on the producer list**: the Census Bureau was the one producer with a comparable, found by + open search. A US poverty analysis will usually meet its anchored-threshold papers, so it is a + candidate for `data/comparables/producers.json` with a `why`. diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9045e2186 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,3405 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "us/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "country": "US", + "registry": { + "kind": "post", + "slug": "2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "country_id": "us" + }, + "title": "2025 Supplemental Poverty Measure: what Census reported, and what threshold growth did to it", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/research/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "published": "2026-09-18", + "owner": { + "author": "max-ghenis" + }, + "scope": "federal", + "subject": "Census's 2025 Supplemental Poverty Measure rates by age, housing tenure and state, PolicyEngine's recomputation of them from the 2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (with finer age groups), and its estimate of what threshold growth beyond inflation did: the 2025 SPM rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (12.31 percent, 0.69 points below Census's 2024 rate of 13.0) and by C-CPI-U, and the points that threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds to the 2025 rate (0.80 for all people) by age, tenure and state.", + "search_terms": [ + "2025 SPM threshold growth effect", + "SPM threshold inflation counterfactual", + "supplemental poverty measure 2025 analysis", + "SPM thresholds rose faster than inflation", + "anchored supplemental poverty measure 2025", + "SPM 2025 poverty rate if thresholds adjusted only for inflation", + "how updating annual poverty thresholds affects poverty rates 2024-2025" + ], + "worlds": { + "thresholds_anchored_cpiu": { + "policy": "us_spm_2025_thresholds_anchored_2024_cpiu", + "description": "The post's counterfactual: 2025 SPM poverty with each tenure group's national base threshold set to its corrected 2024 BLS value grown by CPI-U (32,649/31,812, 1.02631); the equivalence scale, the geographic adjustment and every unit's resources stay at their published 2025 values. The baseline is the published 2025 SPM." + }, + "thresholds_anchored_ccpiu": { + "policy": "us_spm_2025_thresholds_anchored_2024_chained_cpiu", + "description": "The post's chained variant: as thresholds_anchored_cpiu, with the 2024 bases grown by C-CPI-U (1.0248, an eleven-month 2025 mean)." + }, + "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti": { + "policy": "us_spm_2025_thresholds_anchored_2024_fcsuti", + "description": "Census SEHSD-WP2026-22's headline counterfactual: the corrected 2024 SPM thresholds inflated to 2025 by BLS's FCSUti price index (3.44 percent; Table A.1: $40,581, $34,011 and $40,570). The post publishes no figure in this world." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_all", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, all people", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1231, + "value_raw": "12.31", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, children under 18", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1231, + "value_raw": "12.31", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 18 to 64", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1155, + "value_raw": "11.55", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 65 and over", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1466, + "value_raw": "14.66", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, owners with a mortgage", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.0567, + "value_raw": "5.67", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.anchored", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, owners without a mortgage", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1149, + "value_raw": "11.49", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.anchored", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_cpiu_renter", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, renters", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.2213, + "value_raw": "22.13", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.renter.anchored", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_all", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, all people (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.008, + "value_raw": "0.8", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "anchored_results.json prints threshold_effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "threshold_effect_pp.all", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, children under 18 (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0108, + "value_raw": "1.08", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "anchored_results.json prints threshold_effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "threshold_effect_pp.children", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, people 18 to 64 (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0073, + "value_raw": "0.73", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "anchored_results.json prints threshold_effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "threshold_effect_pp.18-64", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, people 65 and over (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0072, + "value_raw": "0.72", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "anchored_results.json prints threshold_effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "threshold_effect_pp.65+", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_0_3", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, children under 4 (ages 0 to 3) (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0123, + "value_raw": "1.23", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "state_age_results.json prints by_age..effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_0_3", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.2", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_0_3.effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_under_6", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, children under 6 (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.012, + "value_raw": "1.2", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "state_age_results.json prints by_age..effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_6", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.17", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.under_6.effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_6_17", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, children 6 to 17 (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0103, + "value_raw": "1.03", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "state_age_results.json prints by_age..effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_6_17", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.12", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_6_17.effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_75_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, people 75 and over (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0075, + "value_raw": "0.75", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "state_age_results.json prints by_age..effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_75_plus", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.1", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_75_plus.effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_al", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, AL, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0171, + "value_raw": "1.71", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "AL", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.52", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=AL, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ak", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, AK, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0035, + "value_raw": "0.35", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "AK", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.34", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=AK, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_az", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, AZ, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0136, + "value_raw": "1.36", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "AZ", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.51", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=AZ, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ar", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, AR, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.008, + "value_raw": "0.8", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "AR", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.33", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=AR, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ca", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, CA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0108, + "value_raw": "1.08", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.2", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=CA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_co", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, CO, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0046, + "value_raw": "0.46", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CO", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.29", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=CO, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ct", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, CT, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0081, + "value_raw": "0.81", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "CT", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.31", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=CT, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_de", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, DE, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0137, + "value_raw": "1.37", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "DE", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.72", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=DE, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_dc", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, DC, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0112, + "value_raw": "1.12", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "DC", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.46", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=DC, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_fl", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, FL, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0101, + "value_raw": "1.01", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "FL", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.17", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=FL, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ga", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, GA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0074, + "value_raw": "0.74", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "GA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.27", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=GA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_hi", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, HI, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0114, + "value_raw": "1.14", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "HI", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.43", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=HI, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_id", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, ID, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0058, + "value_raw": "0.58", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "ID", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.3", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=ID, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_il", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, IL, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0061, + "value_raw": "0.61", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "IL", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.25", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=IL, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_in", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, IN, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0138, + "value_raw": "1.38", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "IN", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.67", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=IN, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ia", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, IA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0107, + "value_raw": "1.07", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "IA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.47", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=IA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ks", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, KS, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0008, + "value_raw": "0.08", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "KS", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.08", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=KS, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ky", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, KY, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0063, + "value_raw": "0.63", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "KY", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.32", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=KY, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_la", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, LA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0113, + "value_raw": "1.13", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "LA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.37", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=LA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_me", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, ME, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0007, + "value_raw": "0.07", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "ME", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.07", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=ME, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_md", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MD, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0055, + "value_raw": "0.55", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MD", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.32", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MD, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ma", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0083, + "value_raw": "0.83", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.27", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_mi", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MI, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0044, + "value_raw": "0.44", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MI", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.22", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MI, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_mn", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MN, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0015, + "value_raw": "0.15", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MN", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.1", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MN, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ms", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MS, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.007, + "value_raw": "0.7", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MS", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.27", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MS, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_mo", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MO, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0097, + "value_raw": "0.97", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MO", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.3", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MO, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_mt", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, MT, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0147, + "value_raw": "1.47", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "MT", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.59", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=MT, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ne", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NE, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.0, + "value_raw": "0.0", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NE", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.0", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NE, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nv", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NV, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0121, + "value_raw": "1.21", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NV", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.43", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NV, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nh", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NH, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.01, + "value_raw": "1.0", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NH", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.53", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NH, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nj", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NJ, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0058, + "value_raw": "0.58", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NJ", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.23", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NJ, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nm", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NM, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.007, + "value_raw": "0.7", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NM", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.46", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NM, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ny", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NY, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.015, + "value_raw": "1.5", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NY", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.37", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NY, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nc", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, NC, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0046, + "value_raw": "0.46", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "NC", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.22", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=NC, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_nd", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, ND, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0029, + "value_raw": "0.29", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "ND", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.17", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=ND, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_oh", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, OH, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0048, + "value_raw": "0.48", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "OH", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.33", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=OH, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ok", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, OK, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.006, + "value_raw": "0.6", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "OK", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.33", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=OK, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_or", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, OR, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0041, + "value_raw": "0.41", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "OR", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.19", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=OR, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_pa", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, PA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0031, + "value_raw": "0.31", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "PA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.15", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=PA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ri", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, RI, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0087, + "value_raw": "0.87", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "RI", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.47", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=RI, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_sc", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, SC, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.008, + "value_raw": "0.8", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "SC", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.34", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=SC, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_sd", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, SD, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0039, + "value_raw": "0.39", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "SD", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.33", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=SD, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_tn", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, TN, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0075, + "value_raw": "0.75", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "TN", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.27", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=TN, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_tx", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, TX, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0102, + "value_raw": "1.02", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "TX", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.22", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=TX, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_ut", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, UT, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0031, + "value_raw": "0.31", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "UT", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.13", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=UT, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_vt", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, VT, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0032, + "value_raw": "0.32", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "VT", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.2", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=VT, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_va", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, VA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0024, + "value_raw": "0.24", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "VA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.12", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=VA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_wa", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, WA, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0014, + "value_raw": "0.14", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "WA", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.13", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=WA, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_wv", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, WV, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0108, + "value_raw": "1.08", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "WV", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.4", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=WV, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_wi", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, WI, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0021, + "value_raw": "0.21", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "WI", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.17", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=WI, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "threshold_effect_cpiu_state_wy", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published rate, WY, single-year estimate (the post's threshold effect, sign reversed)", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.0043, + "value_raw": "0.43", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "by_state.csv prints effect_pp as the published 2025 rate minus the rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U (the points threshold growth beyond CPI-U adds); poverty_rate_change is stated as the anchored world minus the published 2025 SPM, positive = increase in poverty, so the effect is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "WY", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus the published 2025 rate, single CPS ASEC year", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (anchored world minus published 2025 SPM)", + "standard_error_pp": "0.27", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/by_state.csv", + "sha256": "3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "field": "state=WY, column effect_pp", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all", + "label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, all people", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.006911, + "value_raw": "-0.6911", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus Census's 2024 rate (P60-290, restated on Vintage 2025 population controls)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (2025 anchored rate minus the 2024 rate)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "file_note": "no script in the repository writes waterfall_data.json (waterfall.py reads it); its anchored_2025 and published_2025 values round to anchored_results.json's", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json", + "sha256": "f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b", + "field": "All people.resources_step", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290" + } + }, + { + "key": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18", + "label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, children under 18", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.01194, + "value_raw": "-1.194", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus Census's 2024 rate (P60-290, restated on Vintage 2025 population controls)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (2025 anchored rate minus the 2024 rate)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "file_note": "no script in the repository writes waterfall_data.json (waterfall.py reads it); its anchored_2025 and published_2025 values round to anchored_results.json's", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json", + "sha256": "f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b", + "field": "Under 18.resources_step", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290" + } + }, + { + "key": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", + "label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 18 to 64", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.006518, + "value_raw": "-0.6518", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus Census's 2024 rate (P60-290, restated on Vintage 2025 population controls)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (2025 anchored rate minus the 2024 rate)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "file_note": "no script in the repository writes waterfall_data.json (waterfall.py reads it); its anchored_2025 and published_2025 values round to anchored_results.json's", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json", + "sha256": "f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b", + "field": "18 to 64.resources_step", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290" + } + }, + { + "key": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", + "label": "Change in SPM poverty from 2024 to 2025 at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U, people 65 and over", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.004399, + "value_raw": "-0.4399", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "comparison": "2025 rate at 2024 thresholds grown by CPI-U minus Census's 2024 rate (P60-290, restated on Vintage 2025 population controls)", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (2025 anchored rate minus the 2024 rate)", + "threshold_basis": "national base thresholds set to the corrected 2024 BLS values (39,231 / 32,879 / 39,220) times 32,649/31,812 (1.02631), by tenure; equivalence scale, geographic adjustment and resources at their published 2025 values", + "file_note": "no script in the repository writes waterfall_data.json (waterfall.py reads it); its anchored_2025 and published_2025 values round to anchored_results.json's", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/waterfall_data.json", + "sha256": "f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b", + "field": "65 and over.resources_step", + "computed_at": "2026-09-18T18:31:45-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv; 2024 rates from Census P60-290" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_ccpiu_all", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by C-CPI-U, all people", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_ccpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1229, + "value_raw": "12.29", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "threshold_basis": "as thresholds_anchored_cpiu with C-CPI-U (SUUR0000SA0) annual means, 178.697/174.372 = 1.0248; the 2025 mean uses eleven months", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results_chained.json", + "sha256": "a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.all", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_ccpiu_under_18", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by C-CPI-U, children under 18", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_ccpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.123, + "value_raw": "12.3", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "as thresholds_anchored_cpiu with C-CPI-U (SUUR0000SA0) annual means, 178.697/174.372 = 1.0248; the 2025 mean uses eleven months", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results_chained.json", + "sha256": "a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.children", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_ccpiu_age_18_64", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by C-CPI-U, people 18 to 64", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_ccpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1153, + "value_raw": "11.53", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "as thresholds_anchored_cpiu with C-CPI-U (SUUR0000SA0) annual means, 178.697/174.372 = 1.0248; the 2025 mean uses eleven months", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results_chained.json", + "sha256": "a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.18-64", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_anchored_ccpiu_age_65_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate at 2024 thresholds grown by C-CPI-U, people 65 and over", + "world": "thresholds_anchored_ccpiu", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1462, + "value_raw": "14.62", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "as thresholds_anchored_cpiu with C-CPI-U (SUUR0000SA0) annual means, 178.697/174.372 = 1.0248; the 2025 mean uses eleven months", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results_chained.json", + "sha256": "a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "field": "spm_anchored_2024_thresholds.65+", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_all", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, all people, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1311, + "value_raw": "13.11", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_published_replication.all", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_under_18", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, children under 18, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1339, + "value_raw": "13.39", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_published_replication.children", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_age_18_64", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, people 18 to 64, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1228, + "value_raw": "12.28", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_published_replication.18-64", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_age_65_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, people 65 and over, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1538, + "value_raw": "15.38", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "spm_published_replication.65+", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_owner_mortgage", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, owners with a mortgage, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.06, + "value_raw": "6.0", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.owner_with_mortgage.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_owner_no_mortgage", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, owners without a mortgage, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1189, + "value_raw": "11.89", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.owner_without_mortgage.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_renter", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, renters, recomputed from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.2396, + "value_raw": "23.96", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "tenure_renter", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json", + "sha256": "b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "field": "by_tenure.renter.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15T13:17:52-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/replicate_and_anchor.py": "13ca491bd80edeaa898a8aa33208360fd590863f" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_age_0_3", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, children under 4 (ages 0 to 3), from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1413, + "value_raw": "14.13", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_0_3", + "standard_error_pp": "0.57", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_0_3.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_under_6", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, children under 6, from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1415, + "value_raw": "14.15", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_6", + "standard_error_pp": "0.52", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.under_6.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_age_6_17", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, children 6 to 17, from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1306, + "value_raw": "13.06", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_6_17", + "standard_error_pp": "0.39", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_6_17.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_published_age_75_plus", + "label": "2025 SPM poverty rate, people 75 and over, from the public-use file", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1657, + "value_raw": "16.57", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_75_plus", + "standard_error_pp": "0.47", + "threshold_basis": "published 2025 SPM thresholds (SPM_POOR)", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c", + "path": "analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_results.json", + "sha256": "2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "field": "by_age.age_75_plus.published", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T07:26:14-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/state_age_anchored.py": "4dd83566c10220365be19558f1a2a9625fa755ae" + }, + "dataset": "2026 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub26csv.zip): pppub26.csv, hhpub26.csv, asec_csv_repwgt_2026.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_2024_from_2025_file_all", + "label": "2024 SPM poverty rate, all people, recomputed from the 2025 public-use file (earlier population controls)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1293, + "value_raw": "12.93", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "threshold_basis": "2024 SPM thresholds as carried in the 2025 file (SPM_POOR)", + "file_note": "the post prints this figure (footnote 2, or the under-6 row of its by-age table) but does not link this file; the prediction-grade analysis in the same repository committed it with the same bytes on 2026-09-17 (a79c03a), before the post", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20", + "path": "analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json", + "sha256": "a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "field": "replication_2024_published_flag.all", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T17:35:59-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/prediction-grade-2025/raw_aging.py": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20" + }, + "dataset": "2025 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub25csv.zip): pppub25.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_2024_from_2025_file_under_18", + "label": "2024 SPM poverty rate, children under 18, recomputed from the 2025 public-use file (earlier population controls)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1335, + "value_raw": "13.35", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_18", + "threshold_basis": "2024 SPM thresholds as carried in the 2025 file (SPM_POOR)", + "file_note": "the post prints this figure (footnote 2, or the under-6 row of its by-age table) but does not link this file; the prediction-grade analysis in the same repository committed it with the same bytes on 2026-09-17 (a79c03a), before the post", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20", + "path": "analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json", + "sha256": "a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "field": "replication_2024_published_flag.under_18", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T17:35:59-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/prediction-grade-2025/raw_aging.py": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20" + }, + "dataset": "2025 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub25csv.zip): pppub25.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_2024_from_2025_file_under_6", + "label": "2024 SPM poverty rate, children under 6, recomputed from the 2025 public-use file (earlier population controls)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.145, + "value_raw": "14.5", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "children_under_6", + "threshold_basis": "2024 SPM thresholds as carried in the 2025 file (SPM_POOR)", + "file_note": "the post prints this figure (footnote 2, or the under-6 row of its by-age table) but does not link this file; the prediction-grade analysis in the same repository committed it with the same bytes on 2026-09-17 (a79c03a), before the post", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20", + "path": "analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json", + "sha256": "a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "field": "replication_2024_published_flag.under_6", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T17:35:59-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/prediction-grade-2025/raw_aging.py": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20" + }, + "dataset": "2025 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub25csv.zip): pppub25.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_2024_from_2025_file_age_18_64", + "label": "2024 SPM poverty rate, people 18 to 64, recomputed from the 2025 public-use file (earlier population controls)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1216, + "value_raw": "12.16", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_18_64", + "threshold_basis": "2024 SPM thresholds as carried in the 2025 file (SPM_POOR)", + "file_note": "the post prints this figure (footnote 2, or the under-6 row of its by-age table) but does not link this file; the prediction-grade analysis in the same repository committed it with the same bytes on 2026-09-17 (a79c03a), before the post", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20", + "path": "analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json", + "sha256": "a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "field": "replication_2024_published_flag.age_18_64", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T17:35:59-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/prediction-grade-2025/raw_aging.py": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20" + }, + "dataset": "2025 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub25csv.zip): pppub25.csv" + } + }, + { + "key": "rate_2024_from_2025_file_age_65_plus", + "label": "2024 SPM poverty rate, people 65 and over, recomputed from the 2025 public-use file (earlier population controls)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "poverty_rate", + "unit_concept": "share", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.1495, + "value_raw": "14.95", + "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", + "conditions": { + "geography": "US", + "poverty_measure": "spm", + "subgroup": "age_65_plus", + "threshold_basis": "2024 SPM thresholds as carried in the 2025 file (SPM_POOR)", + "file_note": "the post prints this figure (footnote 2, or the under-6 row of its by-age table) but does not link this file; the prediction-grade analysis in the same repository committed it with the same bytes on 2026-09-17 (a79c03a), before the post", + "method": "recomputation from the Census public-use microdata (Census's own SPM_RESOURCES, SPM_POVTHRESHOLD and SPM_POOR); no PolicyEngine microsimulation model is involved; pandas and numpy versions are not pinned in the repository", + "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", + "basis": "outturn" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper", + "commit": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20", + "path": "analysis/prediction-grade-2025/results/raw_aging.json", + "sha256": "a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "field": "replication_2024_published_flag.age_65_plus", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T17:35:59-04:00", + "engine": { + "spm-threshold-paper/analysis/prediction-grade-2025/raw_aging.py": "22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20" + }, + "dataset": "2025 CPS ASEC public-use file (asecpub25csv.zip): pppub25.csv" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1d3496d75 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +[ + { + "id": "fcsuti-anchor-not-cpiu", + "claims": [ + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Census's headline anchored series inflates the 2024 thresholds by BLS's FCSUti price index, the index of the threshold's own components, which rose 3.44 percent in 2025, so its 2025 anchored thresholds are about 1.0344 times the 2024 values ($40,581, $34,011 and $40,570, Table A.1). The post inflates them by CPI-U (1.02631, anchored_results.json cpi_factor) and C-CPI-U (1.0248). Higher thresholds against the same resources count at least as many people poor, so these rates and changes describe a different counterfactual from any the post publishes: Census's FCSUti-anchored 2025 rate is 12.6 percent against 12.4 in its own CPI-U table. The like-for-like comparison is Census's CPI-U table (A.4), compared directly.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf#page=3" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf#page=9" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.bls.gov/pir/spm/spm_thresholds_2025.htm" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper/blob/4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c/analysis/asec-2026-anchored-thresholds/anchored_results.json" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c3eb9c8ea --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_all", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.124, "value_raw": "12.4", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "All People 13.0 12.4 -0.7 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_all"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_all", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.007, "value_raw": "-0.7", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "All People: Difference", "quote": "All People 13.0 12.4 -0.7 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_under_18", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.124, "value_raw": "12.4", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Under 18 years 13.5 12.4 -1.1 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_under_18", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.011, "value_raw": "-1.1", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", "quote": "Under 18 years 13.5 12.4 -1.1 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_18_64", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.116, "value_raw": "11.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_18_64", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "18 to 64 years 12.2 11.6 -0.6 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_18_64", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.006, "value_raw": "-0.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_18_64", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", "quote": "18 to 64 years 12.2 11.6 -0.6 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_65_plus", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.146, "value_raw": "14.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_65_plus", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "65 years and older 15.1 14.6 -0.5", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.005, "value_raw": "-0.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_65_plus", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 CPI-U-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", "quote": "65 years and older 15.1 14.6 -0.5", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.056, "value_raw": "5.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Owner with mortgage 6.2 5.6 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.115, "value_raw": "11.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Owner, no mortgage 11.9 11.5 -0.4", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_renter", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.223, "value_raw": "22.3", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_renter", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by CPI-U", "comparison": "2025 rate at CPI-U-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.4 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_cpiu", "reform_hint": "If the 2024 SPM thresholds had been anchored using the CPI-U", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.4, page 12"}, "source_table": "Table A.4: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a CPI-U-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Renter 23.2 22.3 -0.9", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. The paper says only that the anchored threshold 'uses a CPI-U inflator' and does not state its factor; BLS's 2025 thresholds page gives 2.631 percent for the official CPI-U and 2.699 percent for a 12-month average, and the post uses 1.02631.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_renter"}} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.126, "value_raw": "12.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "All People: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "All People 13.1 12.6 -0.6 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_all", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.005, "value_raw": "-0.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.2, page 10"}, "source_table": "Table A.2: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a FCSUti-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "All People: Difference", "quote": "All People 13.0 12.6 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_all", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.006, "value_raw": "-0.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "All People: Difference", "quote": "All People 13.1 12.6 -0.6 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_all", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.126, "value_raw": "12.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "Under 18 years: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Under 18 years 13.4 12.6 -0.8 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_under_18", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.008, "value_raw": "-0.8", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.2, page 10"}, "source_table": "Table A.2: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a FCSUti-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", "quote": "Under 18 years 13.5 12.6 -0.8 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_under_18", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.008, "value_raw": "-0.8", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "children_under_18", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "Under 18 years: Difference", "quote": "Under 18 years 13.4 12.6 -0.8 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_under_18", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.118, "value_raw": "11.8", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_18_64", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "18 to 64 years: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "18 to 64 years 12.3 11.8 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.005, "value_raw": "-0.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_18_64", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.2, page 10"}, "source_table": "Table A.2: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a FCSUti-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", "quote": "18 to 64 years 12.2 11.8 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_18_64", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.005, "value_raw": "-0.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_18_64", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "18 to 64 years: Difference", "quote": "18 to 64 years 12.3 11.8 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_18_64", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.149, "value_raw": "14.9", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_65_plus", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "65 years and older: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "65 years and older 15.4 14.9 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.003, "value_raw": "-0.3", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_65_plus", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2024 production rate", "significance": "Table A.2 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2024 production) not significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2024 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.2, page 10"}, "source_table": "Table A.2: Change in Supplemental Poverty Measure Rate using a FCSUti-Anchored 2025 Threshold: 2024 to 2025", "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", "quote": "65 years and older 15.1 14.9 -0.3", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "change_from_2024_anchored_cpiu_age_65_plus", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": -0.005, "value_raw": "-0.5", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "age_65_plus", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 FCSUti-anchored rate minus the 2025 production rate", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (Difference column: 2025 anchored rate minus 2025 production rate, as printed)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "65 years and older: Difference", "quote": "65 years and older 15.4 14.9 -0.5 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "threshold_effect_cpiu_age_65_plus", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.058, "value_raw": "5.8", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_owner_with_mortgage", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "Owner with mortgage: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Owner with mortgage 6.0 5.8 -0.2 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_mortgage", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.116, "value_raw": "11.6", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_owner_without_mortgage", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "Owner, no mortgage: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Owner, no mortgage 11.9 11.6 -0.2 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_owner_no_mortgage", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} +{"key": "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter", "source": "census", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "census_spm_internal_cps_asec", "metric": "poverty_rate", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.227, "value_raw": "22.7", "normalization": "percent / 100 -> fraction", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "US", "poverty_measure": "spm", "subgroup": "tenure_renter", "threshold_basis": "2024 thresholds (BLS corrected series, July 2026) inflated to 2025 by the FCSUti price index", "comparison": "2025 rate at FCSUti-anchored thresholds", "significance": "Table A.3 marks the Difference (2025 anchored minus 2025 production) significant at the 90 percent level", "data": "internal CPS ASEC 2025 and 2026 (Census Disclosure Review Board CBDRB-FY25-SEHSD003-086)", "program": "supplemental_poverty_measure", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "rates on the 2025 data at counterfactual thresholds; no behavioural response"}, "world": "thresholds_anchored_fcsuti", "reform_hint": "The 2024 threshold values are inflated to 2025 using the FCSUti price index, resulting in a 2025 anchored threshold.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "primary_sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table A.3, page 11"}, "source_table": "Table A.3: Percentage of People in Poverty Using Different Threshold Adjustment Methods: 2025", "source_column": "Renter: 2025 Anchored", "quote": "Renter 24.0 22.7 -1.3 *", "note": "Census's own computation on the internal CPS ASEC file (DiTommaso, SEHSD-WP2026-22); the post's recomputation uses the public-use file. Table A.2 prints the same 2025 anchored rate; staged once, from Table A.3.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "rate_anchored_cpiu_renter", "pe_missing": "Census anchors the 2024 thresholds with the FCSUti price index (3.44 percent in 2025); the post anchors with CPI-U (1.02631) and C-CPI-U (1.0248) and publishes no figure at FCSUti-anchored thresholds."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..17fa7faa0 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +{"url": "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", "title": "How Updating Annual Poverty Thresholds Affects Poverty Rates: 2024-2025", "date": "2026-09-15", "publisher": "U.S. Census Bureau", "sha256": "281366df077ed79b1f95598566592d9bf40930a6a9c5e568424e99513e592e2c", "bytes": 383340, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "SEHSD-WP2026-22, Adrienne DiTommaso; landing page https://www.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.html (DC.date 2026-09-15)."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6e2f44ac6 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-2025-supplemental-poverty-measure/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,227 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113611-cmp-us-2025-supplemental-pov", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "cbo", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:cbo.gov supplemental poverty measure thresholds 2025", + "CBO poverty measure 1979 2021 in-kind transfers employer-sponsored health insurance fixed thresholds report" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No CBO estimate for 2025 found. Cato's 16 September 2026 blog (read via the Wayback Machine, logged under open_search) cites a CBO poverty measure with fixed thresholds that found 0.5 percent of Americans poor in 2021, averaged over 1979 to 2021; search results point to CBO's 'Reconciling the Official Poverty Measure and CBO's Distributional Analysis of Household Income' (cbo.gov/publication/61157), which returns HTTP 403 to direct fetches and was not read." + }, + { + "producer": "jct", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:jct.gov supplemental poverty measure poverty thresholds" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No JCT page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "tpc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicycenter.org supplemental poverty measure 2025 thresholds inflation", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org OR site:crfb.org OR site:bipartisanpolicy.org OR site:brookings.edu \"supplemental poverty measure\" 2025 thresholds" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No Tax Policy Center page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "pwbm", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu supplemental poverty measure 2025" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No Penn Wharton Budget Model page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "budget_lab", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetlab.yale.edu poverty supplemental poverty measure 2025" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No Budget Lab page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_foundation", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxfoundation.org supplemental poverty measure 2025 Census poverty" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No Tax Foundation page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "urban", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:urban.org supplemental poverty measure 2025 thresholds Census release", + "urban.org 2025 poverty Census release September 2026 SPM \"thresholds\"" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No Urban Institute page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "cbpp", + "result": "found_not_staged", + "queries": [ + "CBPP poverty 2025 Census data supplemental poverty measure September 2026", + "\"anchored Supplemental Poverty Measure\" CBPP 2025 \"12.6 percent\"", + "site:cbpp.org supplemental poverty measure thresholds 2025 anchored poverty fell" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/official-poverty-measure-and-anchored-supplemental-poverty-measure-show-poverty-rate-declined", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/9-10-26pov.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/9-15-26pov-stmt.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/analyzing-the-census-bureaus-2025-poverty-income-and-health-insurance-data" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CBPP's blog of 16 September 2026, 'Official Poverty Measure and Anchored Supplemental Poverty Measure Show Poverty Rate Declined in 2025', restates Census's FCSUti-anchored SPM ('By Census' anchored SPM, the poverty rate fell to 12.6 percent in 2025, from 13.0 percent in 2024', citing SEHSD-WP2026-22) and says the lagged spending factor added 'a sizeable 0.5 percentage points to the poverty rate'. The figures are Census's FCSUti-anchored rates, staged from the Census paper under open_search. The blog returns HTTP 403 (a Cloudflare challenge) to direct fetches and has no Wayback capture, so it was read only through a reader proxy (r.jina.ai) and is not staged (harvest rule 8). The 10 September preview (9-10-26pov.pdf, read) has no estimate: it expected the SPM to rise because thresholds rose 4.4 to 6.3 percent. Parrott's statement of 15 September (9-15-26pov-stmt.pdf, read) has no anchored figure. CBPP's live blog 'Analyzing the Census Bureau's 2025 Poverty, Income, and Health Insurance Data' (16 September; read through the same proxy) excerpts the anchored post and links to it, with no further figure on these quantities." + }, + { + "producer": "itep", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:itep.org supplemental poverty measure 2025 Census" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No ITEP page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "cpsp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:povertycenter.columbia.edu 2025 supplemental poverty measure anchored Census release", + "Columbia Center on Poverty and Social Policy 2025 SPM poverty September 2026 brief thresholds", + "povertycenter.columbia.edu \"2025 poverty rates in historical perspective\" anchored SPM pdf", + "Columbia poverty center anchored SPM 2025 poverty rate 2024 2025 historical SPM fell rose September 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/2025-Poverty-Rates-in-Historical-Perspective-Databook_CPSP-2026.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CPSP's 'Databook: 2025 Poverty Rates in Historical Perspective' (Ortiz, Collyer, Wimer and Vinh, 15 September 2026, anchored results updated 12 October 2026 for a threshold error) anchors SPM thresholds in 2025 and carries them back by inflation. Its charts label only 1967 and 2025; Figure 1 Panel B labels 2025 at 13.1 percent, the published rate. Panel B also plots an unlabelled 2024 point: a 2024 rate at 2025 real thresholds, which the post does not estimate, and a change taken from it would be derived from two numbers (harvest rule 1). The databook prints no 2025 rate at 2024 thresholds, no 2024-to-2025 change and no threshold effect, so there is no figure on the post's quantities. (The databook page itself returns a Cloudflare challenge; its PDF downloads directly.)" + }, + { + "producer": "crfb", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:crfb.org poverty supplemental poverty measure 2025" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "No CRFB page returned." + }, + { + "producer": "state_fiscal_note", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "A federal analysis; state fiscal notes apply to state and local analyses." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "NBER OR SSRN working paper 2026 supplemental poverty measure threshold growth relative absolute poverty 2025", + "\"anchored\" \"supplemental poverty measure\" 2025 rate Corinth OR Meyer OR Burkhauser OR Wimer paper 2026" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.nber.org/papers/w34759" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No working paper or article estimates 2025 SPM poverty at fixed real thresholds: Burkhauser and Corinth (NBER w34759, January 2026) run to 2023. Census working papers are logged under open_search." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "2025 supplemental poverty measure thresholds rose faster than inflation poverty would have fallen", + "SPM thresholds inflation-adjusted counterfactual 2025 poverty rate Census P60-290", + "Winship AEI supplemental poverty measure 2025 thresholds relative inflation September 2026", + "aei.org 2025 poverty Census supplemental poverty measure thresholds \"anchored\" OR \"inflation\" September 2026", + "Cato \"Census Poverty Report Paints an Inaccurate Picture\" 2026 supplemental poverty measure", + "\"Fact Focus\" poverty rate all-time low 2025 supplemental poverty measure thresholds experts", + "SPM poverty 2025 \"would have\" fallen thresholds \"beyond inflation\" OR \"only for inflation\" analysis economist", + "heritage.org OR manhattan-institute.org OR epi.org OR peoplespolicyproject.org 2025 supplemental poverty measure thresholds Census September 2026", + "\"supplemental poverty measure\" 2025 thresholds CPI-U \"12.4 percent\" OR \"12.3 percent\" anchored", + "census.gov research-matters 2026 blog supplemental poverty measure thresholds updating 2025 anchored", + "Institute for Research on Poverty OR Brookings OR Niskanen 2025 SPM poverty thresholds rose faster than CPI analysis", + "Horpedahl OR Bruenig OR Winship SPM 2025 thresholds \"CPI\" poverty would have fallen", + "SPM poverty thresholds 2025 renters 6.3 percent poverty effect tenure analysis blog", + "\"comparing poverty measures\" Census blog September 2026 anchored SPM" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.pdf", + "https://www.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-22.html", + "https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/2026/demo/p60-290.pdf", + "https://www2.census.gov/library/working-papers/2026/demo/sehsd-wp2026-09.pdf", + "https://www.census.gov/newsroom/blogs/random-samplings/2026/09/comparing-poverty-measures.html", + "https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/IN/PDF/IN12737/IN12737.1.pdf", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/poverty-rates-diverged-in-2025-but-will-likely-rise-following-the-one-big-beautiful-bill-acts-implementation/", + "https://scottwinship.substack.com/p/how-not-to-redefine-poverty", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20260916215249/https://www.cato.org/blog/census-bureaus-measure-paints-inaccurate-picture-poverty-america", + "https://www.bls.gov/pir/spm/spm_thresholds_2025.htm" + ], + "claims": [ + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_all", + "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_all", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_under_18", + "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_under_18", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_cpiu_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "census_wp22_cpiu_rate_2025_renter", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_all", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_under_18", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_18_64", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_change_from_2024_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_threshold_effect_age_65_plus", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_mortgage", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_owner_no_mortgage", + "census_wp22_fcsuti_rate_2025_renter" + ], + "note": "Census SEHSD-WP2026-22 (DiTommaso, released with P60-290 on 15 September 2026) is the one comparable: Table A.4 anchors the 2024 thresholds with CPI-U, the post's own world (staged and compared), and Tables A.2 and A.3 with the FCSUti price index (staged, annotated concept_mismatch). Only the rows the post estimates are staged (all people, under 18, 18 to 64, 65 and over, and the three tenure groups' 2025 rates); the sex, race, education and work rows, the tenure changes and the 2024 and 2025 production columns (Census's published rates, survey levels) are not. P60-290 states only that faster growth in the threshold's components raises SPM thresholds more than CPI-U would; SEHSD-WP2026-09 (Creamer, May 2026) runs to 2024; the 9 September Census blog predates the data; CRS IN12737 (16 September 2026) describes the difference in threshold updating in words, with no figure; the Center for American Progress (15 September 2026) restates BLS's 4.4 to 6.3 percent threshold growth with no poverty effect; Winship's 'How Not to Redefine Poverty' is from November 2025. Cato's 16 September blog (Boccia and Turman; direct fetch blocked by an Incapsula challenge, read via the Wayback Machine) argues that SPM thresholds rise in real terms and gives the 2025 official and SPM rates, with no figure on the post's quantities. A New Mexico legislative handout on the poverty release returned 404 and is out of scope for a federal analysis." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@22d8b7a1b9f97d94f796042bc067813b649a2f20:a858c852645352183ba945afad658396b82f10be23dc66c47b3c4358056b9a42", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:2b5a8700d7d93dee01e59028baaa5eb3ea484d07465c44fd9e39462c5c9a2e83", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:3834da7303242fda849230ac5d93b2c9e8f96a6ff999b196015c98dd857531ce", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:a03efe127158a5cb2d595678896dbb9e98ac70bd4aac23881e5d3a0f826c0d4f", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:b2868dcf5718d49c4ce6cb2ff65cea62f532ab54d1c606f7ffbf0b2c904e883e", + "PolicyEngine/spm-threshold-paper@4b8df6615e2beca582835713d0b2ca3c1ab3bf9c:f448d5f5d6910536e61d99190222c4e8f66f29c9f34fcbb2c561d9274b897a4b" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/README.md b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..67ee2f2eb --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +# Child poverty impact dashboard: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md): the dashboard was listed on +policyengine.org on 15 September 2026, before the gate existed. Searched on 21 October 2026, every US +producer. + +- **What is pinned.** The page has no default reform and no static results: the report wizard starts + empty and every figure is computed on demand on the dashboard's Modal backend. The record pins the + figures the dashboard's own repository publishes, at the commit policyengine.org serves + (`PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard` at `d918ca2`): + - `analysis/reform_scores/results.json`, its scorecard of seven representative reforms for 2026 + (restoring the 2021 CTC amounts, a $3,000 child allowance and the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, + each scored for California; a $2,000 Young Child Tax Credit and a 100% CalEITC adjustment factor in + California; a $2,000 Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 and repeal of the dependent + exemption in New York). For each: net budget cost and the change in child and all-ages SPM poverty; + for the six expansions, children lifted out of poverty too. + - `analysis/state_audit/ANALYSIS_BUILDP.md`, whose Build P audit gives -4.2 percentage points of child + poverty for restoring the 2021 CTC in California. The same note gives -6.5 points on the sparse + Populace pin; that figure is not pinned, because the note records neither its engine nor its run and + the dashboard no longer serves that dataset. + + Both files are byte-identical at the launch-day production deployment (`dfd03a8`, 15 September) and + at `d918ca2`. The repository's state audit also sets the dashboard's 2026 baseline child poverty rates + and state credit costs beside Census and official figures; those are baseline levels, which belong in + producer-level sources, so this record holds only reform effects. +- **Vintage.** results.json records no engine or dataset. Its runs went to the deployed Modal endpoint, + not the repository pin: SWEEP.md at the same commit says the deployment was behind the pin, predates + policyengine-us 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5, and the New York dependent-exemption row matches + that sweep to every digit. The backend loaded the per-state CPS files from 29 May to 7 July 2026, then + a sparse Populace pin, then Microcosm Build P from 20 August. The About page says results from before + the August switch are not comparable with what the live page computes (live backend on 21 October: + policyengine-us 1.825.2, Build P release `592ae5d6`). The Build P figure is the only pinned one on the + current dataset. +- **The comparison.** One, for 2026, within the 25% threshold, against the June run: ITEP's Working + Parents Tax Relief Act table puts California's 2026 cost at $2.523bn; the dashboard's is $2.401bn + (-4.9%). +- **A pairing labelled concept mismatch.** New York's FY2027 tax expenditure report puts the dependent + exemptions at $264.0m for tax year 2026; the dashboard has repeal raising $265.9m, 0.7% more. Same + reform and year, but the report counts New York State tax on resident and nonresident returns, while the + dashboard counts federal and state income tax, including New York City tax for households its file + places in the city, less benefits, for resident households. The claim names the estimate as its + nearest, as the worked example does, and the annotation cites the code and report pages. +- **Staged, not compared.** The rule: a producer's own estimate of the same reform at the geography the + dashboard publishes (California for the federal and California reforms, New York for the New York + ones), the latest vintage of each quantity, plus the two national estimates the dashboard's own prior + file (`analysis/reform_scores/priors.yaml`) cites beside its scenarios. Cousins and other national + figures are in the search log's notes. + - California estimates of the 2021 CTC design against the $2,000 credit: CBPP (34% fewer children in + poverty in tax year 2021; 318,000 children lifted in 2024), Urban (-6.8 points, -33.3%, 613,000 + children, 2018), PPIC (32% on the California Poverty Measure, 2018 data) and ITEP ($10.7bn in 2023). + - CPSP's California row for the whole 2021 credit against no credit (7.5 points, 41.6%, 2021). + - The priors: CPSP's national 43% (the whole 2021 credit against none) and Garfinkel et al.'s national + $96.8bn (2018 incomes). + - Each is for an earlier year, another baseline or another geography, so no 2026 estimate shares its + quantity; each carries `pe_missing`. +- **The California poverty effects differ.** CBPP, Urban and PPIC put the 2021 design's effect, against + the $2,000 credit, at about a third of child poverty (34%, 33.3%, 32%), against 14.1% in the June + scorecard; Urban's 6.8 points compare with 3.4 in June and 4.2 on Build P. One difference is in the + dashboard's code: its "Restore 2021 expanded CTC" option sets only the ARPA amounts, refundability and + phase-out and leaves the credit's age limit at 17, so the restoration gives 17-year-olds nothing (they + keep the $500 credit for other dependents), although the option's description says ages 6-17. The 2021 + design covered them, and the texts of all four producers of the 2021-design estimates (CBPP, Urban, + PPIC, ITEP) say their estimates do. The years, baselines and datasets also differ, and the gate does not + compare across years, so the record does not size these differences. +- **No estimate for California or New York** was found of the $3,000 child allowance, the $2,000 Young + Child Tax Credit, a 100% CalEITC adjustment factor or the $2,000 young-child Empire State Child Credit, + in any year. National $3,000 allowances that replace the CTC (Shaefer et al. 2018, the National + Academies 2019) and a 2017 Tax Policy Center estimate of the total cost of the 2015 CalEITC design at a + 100% factor are in the search log's notes. +- **Search limits.** The session's web-search allowance ran out part-way; the remaining searches used + producers' own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes. HTML pages on cbo.gov, jct.gov, + cbpp.org and ppic.org refuse scripted requests; the manifest names each Internet Archive capture it + holds. CBPP's analysis of the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, cited in the sponsor's press release, was + not found. diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b817e996e --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,1352 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "country": "US", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "country_id": "us" + }, + "title": "Child poverty impact dashboard", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "published": "2026-09-15", + "owner": { + "author": "david-trimmer" + }, + "scope": "state", + "subject": "How federal and state tax and benefit reforms (Child Tax Credits, EITCs, child allowances, dependent exemptions, SNAP) would change child poverty, household incomes and government budgets in a chosen state. The page has no default reform and no static results: every figure is computed on demand for the reform and state a user picks. The figures pinned here are the dashboard's own scorecard of seven representative reforms for 2026 (analysis/reform_scores/results.json, scored in California or New York) and its Build P audit's California figure for restoring the 2021 Child Tax Credit.", + "search_terms": [ + "state child tax credit child poverty effect", + "child allowance child poverty estimate", + "state EITC cost child poverty", + "Columbia CPSP state child poverty", + "Urban TRIM child poverty reform", + "restore 2021 expanded child tax credit California child poverty", + "Working Parents Tax Relief Act state estimate", + "California Young Child Tax Credit increase cost", + "CalEITC adjustment factor 100 percent cost", + "Empire State Child Credit children under 4 $2,000", + "New York dependent exemption tax expenditure" + ], + "worlds": { + "arpa_ctc_restored": { + "policy": "us_ctc_arpa_amounts_restored_under_17", + "description": "The dashboard's 'Restore 2021 expanded CTC' option in 2026: it sets only the ARPA amounts ($3,600 under 6, $3,000 older), full refundability and the ARPA phase-out (frontend/lib/reforms.ts federal_ctc_expanded; gov.irs.credits.ctc.amount.arpa, refundable.fully_refundable, phase_out.arpa.in_effect). With full refundability each child's refundable maximum is the larger of the base and ARPA amounts (ctc_refundable_maximum). The age limit stays at 17: ctc_qualifying_child uses the top threshold of gov.irs.credits.ctc.amount.base, 17 from 2022, so 17-year-olds are not covered, although the option's description says ages 6-17 (policyengine-us at 1.729.5, commit 03b804dd)." + }, + "arpa_ctc_2021": { + "policy": "us_ctc_arpa_2021_design", + "description": "The American Rescue Plan Child Tax Credit design of 2021 as the producers model it: $3,600 per child under 6, $3,000 for children 6 to 17 (17-year-olds included), fully refundable. What each claim measures it against is in its baseline_policy (null: the law in force in the year the producer scores) and its conditions." + }, + "child_allowance_3000": { + "policy": "us_universal_child_allowance_3000_under_18", + "description": "A federal cash allowance of $3,000 a year for every child under 18 with no income test (gov.contrib.ubi_center.basic_income, three age tiers all at $3,000, cutoff 18), added to 2026 law." + }, + "wptra": { + "policy": "us_working_parents_tax_relief_act", + "description": "Rep. McDonald Rivet's Working Parents Tax Relief Act from 2026: the federal EITC credit percentage rises for each qualifying child under 4 (42.24 points with one child; 30.07 points per young child, up to 3, with two or more) and the phase-out rate rises 5 points per young child (gov.contrib.congress.mcdonald_rivet.working_parents_tax_relief_act). ITEP describes the same bill as raising the maximum credit by $5,500 per child under 4, for up to 3 children." + }, + "ca_yctc_2000": { + "policy": "ca_young_child_tax_credit_2000", + "description": "California's Young Child Tax Credit maximum raised to $2,000 per return in 2026 (current law $1,189 in 2025, indexed)." + }, + "ny_escc_under4_2000": { + "policy": "ny_empire_state_child_credit_under_4_2000", + "description": "New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 raised from $1,000 (the 2025 budget's amount for 2025-2027) to $2,000 in 2026." + }, + "ca_eitc_100": { + "policy": "ca_eitc_adjustment_factor_100", + "description": "The CalEITC adjustment factor (gov.states.ca.tax.income.credits.earned_income.adjustment.factor) raised from 85% to 100% in 2026." + }, + "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed": { + "policy": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", + "description": "New York's $1,000 personal income tax exemption per dependent (Tax Law section 616) removed in 2026." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -8809704043.35559, + "value_raw": "8809704043.35559", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_ctc_expanded", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[0].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -3.375764846801757, + "value_raw": "-0.03375764846801757", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_ctc_expanded", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[0].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -14.135828382243613, + "value_raw": "0.14135828382243612", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_ctc_expanded", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[0].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -1.3451728820800786, + "value_raw": "-0.013451728820800785", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_ctc_expanded", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[0].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -300940.0, + "value_raw": "300940.0", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_ctc_expanded", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[0].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "child_allowance_3000_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of a universal $3,000 child allowance (children under 18), California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "child_allowance_3000", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -26744160256.0, + "value_raw": "26744160256.0", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "child_allowance_3000", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "child_allowance_3000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[1].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "child_allowance_3000_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from a universal $3,000 child allowance (children under 18), California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "child_allowance_3000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -6.817230224609375, + "value_raw": "-0.06817230224609375", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "child_allowance_3000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "child_allowance_3000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[1].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "child_allowance_3000_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from a universal $3,000 child allowance (children under 18), California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "child_allowance_3000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -28.54677410028181, + "value_raw": "0.2854677410028181", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "child_allowance_3000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "child_allowance_3000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[1].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "child_allowance_3000_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from a universal $3,000 child allowance (children under 18), California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "child_allowance_3000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -2.776607513427734, + "value_raw": "-0.02776607513427734", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "child_allowance_3000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "child_allowance_3000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[1].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "child_allowance_3000_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by a universal $3,000 child allowance (children under 18), California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "child_allowance_3000", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -607736.75, + "value_raw": "607736.75", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "child_allowance_3000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "child_allowance_3000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[1].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "wptra_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "wptra", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -2400731391.718506, + "value_raw": "2400731391.718506", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_working_parents_tax_relief", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "wptra" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[2].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "wptra_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "wptra", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -1.4185485839843748, + "value_raw": "-0.014185485839843748", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_working_parents_tax_relief", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "wptra" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[2].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "wptra_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "wptra", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -5.940093651391528, + "value_raw": "0.05940093651391528", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_working_parents_tax_relief", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "wptra" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[2].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "wptra_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "wptra", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.6164207458496107, + "value_raw": "-0.006164207458496107", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_working_parents_tax_relief", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "wptra" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[2].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "wptra_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "wptra", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -126459.640625, + "value_raw": "126459.640625", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "federal_working_parents_tax_relief", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "wptra" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[2].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_yctc_2000_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of raising California's Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000, California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_yctc_2000", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -330901077.3715668, + "value_raw": "330901077.3715668", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_ctc_2000", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "ca_yctc_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[3].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_yctc_2000_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising California's Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_yctc_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.16907501220702892, + "value_raw": "-0.0016907501220702892", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_yctc_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[3].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_yctc_2000_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising California's Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_yctc_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.7079922520517493, + "value_raw": "0.0070799225205174935", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_yctc_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[3].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_yctc_2000_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from raising California's Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_yctc_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.06751632690429887, + "value_raw": "-0.0006751632690429887", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_yctc_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[3].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_yctc_2000_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by raising California's Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_yctc_2000", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -15072.73046875, + "value_raw": "15072.73046875", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "ca_yctc_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[3].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_escc_under4_2000_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of raising New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 to $2,000, New York households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_escc_under4_2000", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -744249834.746376, + "value_raw": "744249834.746376", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_ctc_2000", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "ny_escc_under4_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[4].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_escc_under4_2000_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 to $2,000, New York, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_escc_under4_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.45414161682128806, + "value_raw": "-0.004541416168212881", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_escc_under4_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[4].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_escc_under4_2000_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 to $2,000, New York, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_escc_under4_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -2.0092329816951247, + "value_raw": "0.020092329816951245", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_escc_under4_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[4].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_escc_under4_2000_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from raising New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 to $2,000, New York, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_escc_under4_2000", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.1722564697265644, + "value_raw": "-0.0017225646972656439", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_escc_under4_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[4].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_escc_under4_2000_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by raising New York's Empire State Child Credit for children under 4 to $2,000, New York, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_escc_under4_2000", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -19224.458984375, + "value_raw": "19224.458984375", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_ctc_2000", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "ny_escc_under4_2000" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[4].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_eitc_100_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of raising the CalEITC adjustment factor from 85% to 100%, California households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_eitc_100", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -97134188.40045166, + "value_raw": "97134188.40045166", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_eitc_100", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "ca_eitc_100" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[5].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_eitc_100_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising the CalEITC adjustment factor from 85% to 100%, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_eitc_100", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.054506301879880814, + "value_raw": "-0.0005450630187988081", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_eitc_100", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_eitc_100" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[5].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_eitc_100_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from raising the CalEITC adjustment factor from 85% to 100%, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_eitc_100", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.22824212114618447, + "value_raw": "0.0022824212114618448", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_eitc_100", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_eitc_100" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[5].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_eitc_100_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from raising the CalEITC adjustment factor from 85% to 100%, California, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_eitc_100", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -0.021289825439455012, + "value_raw": "-0.00021289825439455012", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_eitc_100", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ca_eitc_100" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[5].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ca_eitc_100_children_lifted_2026", + "label": "Children lifted out of SPM poverty by raising the CalEITC adjustment factor from 85% to 100%, California, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ca_eitc_100", + "metric": "poverty_count_change", + "unit_concept": "children_under_18", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -4859.244140625, + "value_raw": "4859.244140625", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints children_lifted, the weighted count of children in SPM poverty under current law and not under the reform, as a positive number; poverty_count_change is stated positive = more people in poverty, so it is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ca_eitc_100", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "count_basis": "gross: children in poverty under current law who are not under the reform; the file prints no count of children newly in poverty", + "sign_convention": "positive = more people in poverty", + "program": "ca_eitc_100" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[5].res.dashboard.children_lifted", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/CA.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026", + "label": "Net budget cost of eliminating New York's dependent exemption, New York households, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 265890931.5627365, + "value_raw": "-265890931.5627365", + "normalization": "as printed", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints annual_cost = -total_budgetary_impact (positive = costs money; score_reforms.py summarize_dashboard); revenue_change is stated positive = higher government revenue, so a cost is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_dependent_exemption_eliminate", + "concept": "change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits for the state's households (scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py total_budgetary_impact)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[6].res.dashboard.annual_cost", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_dependent_exemption_child_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from eliminating New York's dependent exemption, New York, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.18571090698242254, + "value_raw": "0.0018571090698242254", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_dependent_exemption_eliminate", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[6].res.dashboard.poverty_child_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_dependent_exemption_child_poverty_pct_2026", + "label": "Percent change in the child SPM poverty rate from eliminating New York's dependent exemption, New York, 2026 (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.8216302262305856, + "value_raw": "-0.008216302262305856", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "sign": -1, + "sign_basis": "results.json prints child_poverty_rel_reduction = -(reform - baseline) / baseline, a reduction as a positive fraction; poverty_rate_change is stated positive = more poverty, so a reduction is negative", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_dependent_exemption_eliminate", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "relative_percent", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (relative to the current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[6].res.dashboard.child_poverty_rel_reduction", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "ny_dependent_exemption_all_poverty_pp_2026", + "label": "Change in the all-ages SPM poverty rate from eliminating New York's dependent exemption, New York, 2026, percentage points (dashboard scorecard, June 2026)", + "world": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 0.07890892028808438, + "value_raw": "0.0007890892028808438", + "normalization": "fraction x 100 -> percent", + "conditions": { + "geography": "New York", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "source_file_scenario": "ny_dependent_exemption_eliminate", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "all persons", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "ny_dependent_exemption" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/reform_scores/results.json", + "sha256": "b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "field": "rows[6].res.dashboard.poverty_all_delta", + "computed_at": "2026-06-25T16:43:04-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "~1.729.5" + }, + "dataset": "hf://policyengine/policyengine-us-data/states/NY.h5 (per-state calibrated CPS file, loaded without a revision, so the file version is not recoverable; the backend used these files from 2026-05-29, 6bd1bf5, to 2026-07-07, 2d26cac, then a sparse Populace pin, 053baf6c, until Microcosm Build P on 2026-08-20, a4dce6a)", + "note": "results.json records no run time, engine or dataset. score_reforms.py posts each scenario to the deployed Modal endpoint, not the repository pin: analysis/reform_scores/SWEEP.md at the same commit (0525a73) says the deployed endpoint was 'behind the repo pin (1.739.4)', predates 1.731.0, and labels it about 1.729.5 (the pin moved to 1.742.0 on 24 June). results.json's New York dependent-exemption row equals sweep/1.729.5.json's NY:ny_dependent_exemption to every digit, which dates that row; every row has seconds 0, so all seven were written from the same uncommitted cache, and the other six are taken to share the deployment. The engine is therefore that deployment, version not recorded, about 1.729.5. computed_at is the commit time of the file. The dashboard's About page says results predating its August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes." + } + }, + { + "key": "arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_2026_buildp", + "label": "Change in the child SPM poverty rate from restoring the 2021 (ARPA) Child Tax Credit amounts, California, 2026, percentage points (Build P audit, August 2026)", + "world": "arpa_ctc_restored", + "metric": "poverty_rate_change", + "unit_concept": "percentage_points", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": -4.2, + "value_raw": "−4.2pp", + "normalization": "percent as printed", + "conditions": { + "geography": "California", + "year": "2026", + "basis": "static", + "poverty_measure": "SPM", + "population": "children under 18", + "change_type": "percentage_point", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (reform rate minus current-law rate)", + "program": "arpa_ctc" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "commit": "d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab", + "path": "analysis/state_audit/ANALYSIS_BUILDP.md", + "sha256": "bd4b4bf4403e4301fb0c1209764d93fe5932b2f8323c22a88a6800d5e6caab35", + "field": "Standing caveats, dataset transition note: 'restore-2021-CTC in CA: −6.5pp child poverty on the sparse pin → −4.2pp on Build P'", + "computed_at": "2026-08-20T14:29:49-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine-us": "1.808.0" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-buildp-acs-local-592ae5d6-20260819T020303Z (Microcosm Build P, per-state slices)", + "note": "A figure printed in the dashboard's Build P production audit (commit 8145950, 2026-08-20), which ran policyengine-us 1.808.0 on the Build P release the live page still serves (backend /healthz on 2026-10-21: policyengine-us 1.825.2, same dataset release). No results file records this run; computed_at is the audit's commit time." + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d7d2a90c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +[ + { + "id": "ny-dependent-exemption-scope", + "claims": [ + "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "The two figures are close (+0.7%) but measure different things. The report's tax expenditure is New York State personal income tax liability alone, from a study file of full-year resident, part-year resident and nonresident returns. The dashboard's figure is the net budget effect for New York resident households: the change in federal income tax plus state income tax minus household benefits (total_budgetary_impact in scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py at 0525a73). Its state income tax includes New York City income tax (state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits lists nyc_income_tax_before_refundable_credits; nyc_taxable_income adds ny_taxable_income), which applies to households the dataset places in the five NYC counties (in_nyc reads county_str); whether the June state file placed households in those counties is not recorded. The run did not save the state-only change (state_tax_change), so the components cannot be separated from results.json.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf#page=17" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf#page=6" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard/blob/0525a73cb25f50cfad5cbb77355837f32ca95e0c/scripts/modal_cpid_endpoint.py" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/blob/03b804ddeaeffc98dec9cdd0861c7c80dcbb6f2d/policyengine_us/parameters/gov/states/household/state_income_tax_before_refundable_credits.yaml" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/blob/03b804ddeaeffc98dec9cdd0861c7c80dcbb6f2d/policyengine_us/variables/gov/local/ny/nyc/tax/income/taxable_income/nyc_taxable_income.py" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-us/blob/03b804ddeaeffc98dec9cdd0861c7c80dcbb6f2d/policyengine_us/variables/household/demographic/geographic/in_nyc.py" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..44fc429e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{"key": "itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026", "source": "itep", "found_by": "itep", "source_model": "itep_microsimulation", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -2523100000.0, "value_raw": "-$2,523,100", "normalization": "USD k x 1e3 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "tax_year": "2026", "basis": "static", "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable EITC included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", "program": "wptra"}, "world": "wptra", "reform_hint": "The bill would expand the EITC by increasing the maximum possible credit by $5,500 for up to 3 children under age 4.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", "date": "2026-04-30", "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", "primary_sha256": "2ff6cbda690881bb30e8520f30d37c8a89a6f83e7fc971ec43995160efc2fe10", "locator": "Sheet 'WPTRA national and state', table 'Impacts of Working Parents Tax Relief Act in 2026 in California' (row 15), row 23 TOTAL, cell E23 ('Tax Change 1000s')", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Impacts of Working Parents Tax Relief Act in 2026 in California", "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", "quote": "Impacts of Working Parents Tax Relief Act in 2026 in California ... TOTAL $154,900 -$2,523,100 -$130 -0.1% 100% 3% $4,480 1,254,600 4% 950,700 12%", "note": "Cell E23 holds -2523100 with number format +$#,##0;-$#,##0;$0, so it prints -$2,523,100 (thousands of dollars). Same table: 950,700 children in tax units with a tax cut. ITEP's figure is the federal tax change; the dashboard's is the net budget effect (federal and state income tax, less benefits) for California households. In the dashboard's model the bill does not move California income tax, because the CalEITC formula reads only California parameters (ca_eitc at policyengine-us 1.729.5); whether it moves any benefit was not checked. The dashboard figure is its June 2026 scorecard run (engine about 1.729.5, per-state CPS file); its About page says results from before the August 2026 dataset switch are not comparable with what the live page computes, so this agreement is for that run.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "wptra_cost_2026"}, "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026", "source": "ny_fiscal_note", "found_by": "state_fiscal_note", "source_model": "nys_pit_population_study_file", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 264000000.0, "value_raw": "264.0", "normalization": "USD m x 1e6 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "New York", "tax_year": "2026", "basis": "static", "tax": "New York State personal income tax", "sign_convention": "positive = yield from removing the exemption: Table 1 prints the dependent exemptions' tax expenditure, the liability the exemption removes, in millions of dollars", "program": "ny_dependent_exemption_ny_state_income_tax", "basis_note": "static; each tax expenditure measured separately, other provisions and behaviour held constant"}, "world": "ny_dependent_exemption_repealed", "reform_hint": "'25. Dependent exemptions' (Table 1); 'The reduction in taxpayer liability is the difference between tax liability under the current Tax Law and tax liability if the particular expenditure did not exist.' (printed page 3)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", "url": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", "date": "2026-02-27", "publisher": "New York State Department of Taxation and Finance and Division of the Budget", "primary_sha256": "8c658a4c81187a3897b99192a2ebc0d216e0f15612099581fa3dd29257afa9ba", "locator": "Table 1 '2026 personal income tax expenditure estimates (in millions of dollars)', row 25, column Forecast 2026, printed page 16 (PDF page 19); table title printed page 15 (PDF page 18)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1: 2026 personal income tax expenditure estimates (in millions of dollars)", "source_column": "Forecast 2026", "quote": "25. Dependent exemptions 281.6 269.2 268.3 261.9 258.7 264.0 1", "note": "Columns: History 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023; Forecast 2026; reliability level. The report estimates 2026 from the 2023 Personal Income Tax Population Study File under the Tax Law in effect on 1 January 2026, and warns that 'the tax expenditure estimates provided in this report are not equivalent to the impact on the State's Financial Plan if the expenditure were repealed or modified' (printed page 3). The dashboard's figure is the static change in federal and state income tax less benefits for New York households, from its June 2026 scorecard run (engine about 1.729.5, per-state CPS file), which its About page says is not comparable with what the live page computes.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026", "pe_missing": "Same reform, year and time basis as ny_dependent_exemption_cost_2026, but not the same quantity: the report's figure is New York State tax on resident and nonresident returns, and the dashboard's is the net change in federal, state and New York City income tax less benefits for resident households (annotation ny-dependent-exemption-scope). The two are 0.7% apart.", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", "source": "cbpp", "found_by": "cbpp", "source_model": "cbpp_cps_acs_spm", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": 34.0, "value_raw": "34%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "tax_year": "2021", "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", "population": "children under 18", "change_type": "relative_percent", "comparison": "relative to before American Rescue Plan's temporary expansion", "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the number of children in poverty, in percent", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "Permanent Expansion of Child Tax Credit (Relative to before American Rescue Plan's temporary expansion)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": "tcja_ctc", "publication": {"title": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", "date": "2021-05-24", "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", "primary_sha256": "fc8099b51117e77847716037476ab706b00b23345f7b6a6308f7db62ee8fe240", "locator": "Appendix Table 3, row California, column Total, printed page 14 (PDF page 14)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 3: Estimated Reduction in Child Poverty Each Year From Permanent Expansion of Child Tax Credit, by State and Race/Ethnicity", "source_column": "Total", "quote": "California 34% 30% 35% 33% 26% 32%", "note": "Notes to the table: 'Estimates reflect a pre-pandemic economy, using tax year 2021 tax rules and incomes adjusted for inflation to 2021 dollars.' Source: March 2019 CPS allocated by state with ACS 2016-2018. Appendix Table 1 of the same report gives 582,000 California children lifted above the poverty line (the later 2024 estimate is staged instead).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBPP scores tax year 2021 against pre-Rescue Plan law (the $2,000 TCJA credit); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "cbpp_arpa_ctc_children_lifted_ca_2024", "source": "cbpp", "found_by": "cbpp", "source_model": "cbpp_cps_acs_spm", "metric": "poverty_count_change", "unit_concept": "children_under_18", "value": 318000.0, "value_raw": "318,000", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2024, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "tax_year": "2024", "poverty_measure": "SPM (Census SPM research files for the ACS)", "population": "children under 18", "sign_convention": "positive = children lifted above the poverty line, i.e. fewer children in poverty", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "Reinstating Rescue Plan Child Tax Credit; 'Estimates reflect the impact of a Rescue Plan Child Tax Credit at $3,600 for children aged 5 and younger and $3,000 for children aged 6 to 17 in tax year 2024.'", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", "url": "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", "date": "2024-09-19", "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", "primary_sha256": "5725df6e165b4ed7f5201589e36df5144f01bf415f2f67aea3ba747cbcd51ec7", "locator": "Table 1, row California, column 'Would be lifted above the poverty line by expansion'", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Table 1: Reinstating Rescue Plan Child Tax Credit Would Lift 2.6 Million Children Above the Poverty Line and Provide an Income Boost to More Than 60 Million Children (Estimated children under 18, by state, for 2024)", "source_column": "Would be lifted above the poverty line by expansion", "quote": "California 318,000 7,099,000", "note": "Source line: CBPP analysis of the March 2023 CPS for the national total, allocated by state with the ACS for 2017-2019; incomes aged to 2024. Figures rounded to the nearest 1,000.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBPP scores the 2021 design in tax year 2024, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018", "source": "urban", "found_by": "urban", "source_model": "urban_attis", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percentage_points", "value": -6.8, "value_raw": "-6.8%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2018, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", "poverty_measure": "SPM", "population": "children", "change_type": "percentage_point", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (change after implementation)", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "The proposed expansions to the CTC would raise the maximum credit from $2,000 per child to $3,600 per child under age 6 and to $3,000 for older children, make 17-year-old children eligible for the credit, and make the credit fully refundable", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", "date": "2021-08-05", "publisher": "Urban Institute", "primary_sha256": "f2c86a18e8f3d9be54ce25d3f672edb7e5b93119517ca00a0ab1457639e825e9", "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Percentage-point change', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5: Percentage of Children in SPM Poverty by State Before and after Expansion of CTC", "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage-point change", "quote": "California 20.5% 13.7% -6.8% -33.3% 613", "note": "Source line: Urban Institute's ATTIS model, 2018 American Community Survey. Models 78 percent take-up among non-filers (printed page 11).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", "source": "urban", "found_by": "urban", "source_model": "urban_attis", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -33.3, "value_raw": "-33.3%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2018, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", "poverty_measure": "SPM", "population": "children", "change_type": "relative_percent", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in poverty (percentage change after implementation)", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "The proposed expansions to the CTC would raise the maximum credit from $2,000 per child to $3,600 per child under age 6 and to $3,000 for older children, make 17-year-old children eligible for the credit, and make the credit fully refundable", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", "date": "2021-08-05", "publisher": "Urban Institute", "primary_sha256": "f2c86a18e8f3d9be54ce25d3f672edb7e5b93119517ca00a0ab1457639e825e9", "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Percentage change', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5: Percentage of Children in SPM Poverty by State Before and after Expansion of CTC", "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Percentage change", "quote": "California 20.5% 13.7% -6.8% -33.3% 613", "note": "Same row as urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "urban_arpa_ctc_children_removed_ca_2018", "source": "urban", "found_by": "urban", "source_model": "urban_attis", "metric": "poverty_count_change", "unit_concept": "children_under_18", "value": 613000.0, "value_raw": "613", "normalization": "thousands x 1e3", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2018, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "data_year": "2018 (a 'typical year')", "poverty_measure": "SPM", "population": "children", "sign_convention": "positive = children removed from poverty, i.e. fewer children in poverty", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "The proposed expansions to the CTC would raise the maximum credit from $2,000 per child to $3,600 per child under age 6 and to $3,000 for older children, make 17-year-old children eligible for the credit, and make the credit fully refundable", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", "url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", "date": "2021-08-05", "publisher": "Urban Institute", "primary_sha256": "f2c86a18e8f3d9be54ce25d3f672edb7e5b93119517ca00a0ab1457639e825e9", "locator": "Table 5, row California, column 'Number removed (thousands)', printed page 10 (PDF page 10)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5: Percentage of Children in SPM Poverty by State Before and after Expansion of CTC", "source_column": "Change after Implementation: Number removed (thousands)", "quote": "California 20.5% 13.7% -6.8% -33.3% 613", "note": "Same row as urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "Urban scores the 2021 design in 2018, a typical pre-pandemic year, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "ppic_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", "source": "ppic", "found_by": "open_search", "source_model": "california_poverty_measure", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": 32.0, "value_raw": "32%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2018, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "data_year": "2018", "poverty_measure": "California Poverty Measure (PPIC and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality)", "population": "children", "change_type": "relative_percent", "sign_convention": "positive = share of poor children lifted out of poverty (fewer children in poverty)", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "Under the ARPA, the CTC increases from $2,000 to $3,000 for children under age 18, including 17-year-olds for the first time, and rises to $3,600 for children under age 6.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", "url": "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", "date": "2021-03-23", "publisher": "Public Policy Institute of California", "primary_sha256": "a18b5b6f366e9a81dd24c4d0549e42138c0fe1fdd6141dc0e5621cde30ce3af5", "locator": "Blog post, paragraph 4", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Blog post text", "source_column": "share of children lifted out of poverty", "quote": "While the expansion could lift 32% of children out of poverty, effects will vary across the state.", "note": "The preceding paragraph: 'In California, these additions to the CTC could cut child poverty by a third, from 18.8% to 12.8% ... based on data from the California Poverty Measure (CPM) ... These data are from 2018'. 32% is the relative fall of the rate (18.8% to 12.8%).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "PPIC scores the 2021 design in 2018 data on the California Poverty Measure, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "itep_arpa_ctc_cost_ca_2023", "source": "itep", "found_by": "itep", "source_model": "itep_microsimulation", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -10705800000.0, "value_raw": "-$10,705,800", "normalization": "USD k x 1e3 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2023, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "tax_year": "2023", "basis": "static", "tax": "federal income tax, the refundable credit included (ITEP 'Tax Change')", "sign_convention": "positive = tax increase, i.e. higher government revenue (the 'Tax Change' column prints a tax cut as a negative number of thousands of dollars)", "program": "arpa_ctc"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "Impacts of Extending the ARPA CTC Expansion if in Effect in 2023", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", "url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", "date": "2022-09-07", "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", "primary_sha256": "62f53a23c08a12f319b1b9cef02be3601505ca65fa9a1852888f968c81b20ecb", "locator": "Sheet 'ARPA CTC US & state', table 'Impacts of Extending the ARPA CTC Expansion if in Effect in 2023 in California' (row 62), row 72 TOTAL, cell E72 ('Tax Change 1000s')", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Impacts of Extending the ARPA CTC Expansion if in Effect in 2023 in California", "source_column": "Tax Change, 1000s (TOTAL row)", "quote": "Impacts of Extending the ARPA CTC Expansion if in Effect in 2023 in California ... TOTAL $143,100 -$10,705,800 -$570 -0.4%", "note": "Cell E72 holds -10705800 with number format +$#,##0;-$#,##0;$0. The report (September 2022) models 'a full extension of the CTC expansion in ARPA' against current law if fully in effect in 2023. ITEP repeated the same California figure in its March 2023 estimate of the President's budget.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "ITEP scores the 2021 design in 2023, against the then-current $2,000 credit (TCJA); the dashboard publishes 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, so no PolicyEngine estimate shares this claim's year. The designs also differ: the 2021 design covers 17-year-olds, and the dashboard's restoration covers children under 17 (see the arpa_ctc_restored world).", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "garfinkel_arpa_allowance_net_cost_us_2018", "source": "garfinkel_et_al", "found_by": "academic", "source_model": "cpsp_cps_asec_microsimulation", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 96800000000.0, "value_raw": "$96.8 billion", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2018, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "United States", "data": "2019 CPS ASEC (2018 incomes), 100% take-up assumed", "dollars": "not stated for the cost; the paper's benefit estimates are in 2019 dollars", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the federal government (the allowance's net cost)", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis_note": "static (the paper estimates the earnings response separately)"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "converting the $2000 Child Tax Credit in the federal income tax code into a fully refundable and more generous child allowance of $3600 per child ages 0-5 and $3000 per child ages 6-17, as enacted for 1 year in the American Rescue Plan", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", "date": "2022-09-23", "publisher": "Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis 13(3), 335-362 (Garfinkel, Sariscsany, Ananat, Collyer, Hartley, Wang and Wimer)", "primary_sha256": "34e0f7d347dc01e73b3f4b869ceb3129eeaa08ade0257864098a7eb23331f587", "locator": "Micro-simulation estimates, printed page 349 (PDF page 15); the abstract rounds it to '$97 billion per year'", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "net cost of the $3600-$3000 child allowance", "quote": "The net cost of the $3600–$3000 child allowance is $96.8 billion.", "note": "The dashboard's own prior file names this paper's working-paper version (analysis/reform_scores/priors.yaml: 'Niskanen/NBER w29854 (~$97B/yr)') beside its restore-2021-CTC and child-allowance scenarios. Period 2018 is the income year of the 2019 CPS ASEC the micro-simulation uses; the paper does not state the cost's dollar year ('All results are reported in 2019 dollars' is a footnote to Table 1's benefit estimates).", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "A national cost on 2019 survey data (2018 incomes), against the $2,000 credit; the dashboard publishes the cost for California households in 2026 only, against OBBBA's $2,200 credit, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_us_2021", "source": "cpsp", "found_by": "cpsp", "source_model": "cpsp_cps_asec_spm", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": 43.0, "value_raw": "43%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"geography": "United States", "poverty_measure": "SPM", "population": "children", "change_type": "relative_percent", "comparison": "the 2021 Child Tax Credit against no Child Tax Credit (9.2% to 5.2%)", "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "Altogether, the Child Tax Credit cut the child poverty rate by 43% in 2021 (from 9.2% to 5.2%)", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", "publication": {"title": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", "date": "2022-11-02", "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University (Wimer, Collyer, Harris and Lee)", "primary_sha256": "3370fc0cc94f0b5e0e06b226bc7cd0c17798e01ab1fe9bf649f1f10033e1e3d3", "locator": "Printed page 3 (PDF page 3), first paragraph; the key findings on page 1 repeat it", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Text", "source_column": "reduction in the child poverty rate from the 2021 Child Tax Credit", "quote": "Altogether, the Child Tax Credit cut the child poverty rate by 43% in 2021 (from 9.2% to 5.2%), moving 2.9 million children out of poverty (Figure 1).", "note": "The dashboard's own prior file cites 'Columbia CPSP 2021 (~43%)' for its restore-2021-CTC scenario (analysis/reform_scores/priors.yaml). The figure is the whole 2021 credit against no credit; the same paragraph puts child poverty at 8.1% 'absent the expansion', so the expansion's own share is the fall from 8.1% to 5.2%, printed as levels only. CPSP's summaries call the 43% the expansion's effect (key findings: 'the expanded Child Tax Credit, which by itself cut child poverty by 43 percent'), but the body and Figure 1 ('If no CTC / If pre-ARP CTC / With ARP CTC') measure it against no credit.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "National, for 2021, and measured against no Child Tax Credit at all; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit, for California in 2026.", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021", "source": "cpsp", "found_by": "cpsp", "source_model": "cpsp_acs_spm", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "annual", "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "All results show the total impact of the full 2021 Child Tax Credit in its expanded form.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", "publication": {"title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", "date": "2023-10-23", "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University", "primary_sha256": "fa972955f30f3ce7bfbdc3cabf7413d35ed6dd6674737a6f999c15ea5eaeb594", "locator": "Table 1, row California, printed page 3 (PDF page 3)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1. Child Poverty Rates (SPM) Before and After Counting the 2021 Child Tax Credit by State", "quote": "California 18.0% 10.5% 7.5 41.6%", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percentage_points", "value": 7.5, "value_raw": "7.5", "normalization": "as printed", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", "population": "children", "change_type": "percentage_point", "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percentage points", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "source_column": "Percentage point change", "note": "Columns: SPM child poverty rate if no CTC; with 2021 Child Tax Credit; percentage point change; percent change. The table prints the fall as a positive change. Footnote iii: 'All results show the total impact of the full 2021 Child Tax Credit in its expanded form.'", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} +{"key": "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", "source": "cpsp", "found_by": "cpsp", "source_model": "cpsp_acs_spm", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "annual", "world": "arpa_ctc_2021", "reform_hint": "All results show the total impact of the full 2021 Child Tax Credit in its expanded form.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": "no_ctc", "publication": {"title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", "url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", "date": "2023-10-23", "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University", "primary_sha256": "fa972955f30f3ce7bfbdc3cabf7413d35ed6dd6674737a6f999c15ea5eaeb594", "locator": "Table 1, row California, printed page 3 (PDF page 3)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1. Child Poverty Rates (SPM) Before and After Counting the 2021 Child Tax Credit by State", "quote": "California 18.0% 10.5% 7.5 41.6%", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The whole 2021 credit against no Child Tax Credit, in 2021; the dashboard publishes the effect of restoring the 2021 amounts on top of OBBBA's $2,200 credit in 2026, and its restoration leaves out 17-year-olds.", "metric": "poverty_rate_change", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": 41.6, "value_raw": "41.6%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "conditions": {"geography": "California", "poverty_measure": "SPM (2021 ACS, Census ACS SPM research extract)", "population": "children", "change_type": "relative_percent", "comparison": "'If no CTC' 18.0% against 'With 2021 Child Tax Credit' 10.5%", "sign_convention": "positive = reduction in the child poverty rate, in percent", "program": "arpa_ctc", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "source_column": "Percent change", "note": "Same row as cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021.", "found_on": "2026-10-21"} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b76fe8fa6 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{"url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", "title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs: data (Working Parents Tax Relief Act, national and state)", "date": "2026-04-30", "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", "sha256": "2ff6cbda690881bb30e8520f30d37c8a89a6f83e7fc971ec43995160efc2fe10", "bytes": 29636, "doc_type": "xlsx", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Linked from https://itep.org/eitc-expansion-working-parents-tax-relief-act/ (next line)."} +{"url": "https://itep.org/eitc-expansion-working-parents-tax-relief-act/", "title": "New EITC Proposal Would Help Families Dealing with Rising Costs", "date": "2026-04-30", "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", "sha256": "1593cb1e713ef2caa6bcae085719289ee5b179e635619f8ac94d756862d30ad3", "bytes": 67717, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The report page: the bill's design in ITEP's words (reform_hint of itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026)."} +{"url": "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", "title": "Fiscal Year 2027 Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures", "date": "2026-02-27", "publisher": "New York State Department of Taxation and Finance and Division of the Budget", "sha256": "8c658a4c81187a3897b99192a2ebc0d216e0f15612099581fa3dd29257afa9ba", "bytes": 4591564, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Date is the PDF's creation date."} +{"url": "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", "title": "Congress Should Adopt American Families Plan's Permanent Expansions of Child Tax Credit and EITC, Make Additional Provisions Permanent", "date": "2021-05-24", "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", "sha256": "fc8099b51117e77847716037476ab706b00b23345f7b6a6308f7db62ee8fe240", "bytes": 629554, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21"} +{"url": "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", "title": "Expanding the Child Tax Credit Should Be a Top Priority in 2025 Tax Debate", "date": "2024-09-19", "publisher": "Center on Budget and Policy Priorities", "sha256": "5725df6e165b4ed7f5201589e36df5144f01bf415f2f67aea3ba747cbcd51ec7", "bytes": 83784, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "cbpp.org returns HTTP 403 (Cloudflare) to scripted requests; the bytes are the raw Internet Archive capture https://web.archive.org/web/20251017091031id_/https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate"} +{"url": "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", "title": "How a Permanent Expansion of the Child Tax Credit Could Affect Poverty", "date": "2021-08-05", "publisher": "Urban Institute", "sha256": "f2c86a18e8f3d9be54ce25d3f672edb7e5b93119517ca00a0ab1457639e825e9", "bytes": 365041, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "First published 29 July 2021; this file is the update (cover: 'July 2021 (updated August 2021)'; PDF creation date 2021-08-05)."} +{"url": "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", "title": "How the Expanded Child Tax Credit Reduces Child Poverty", "date": "2021-03-23", "publisher": "Public Policy Institute of California", "sha256": "a18b5b6f366e9a81dd24c4d0549e42138c0fe1fdd6141dc0e5621cde30ce3af5", "bytes": 199904, "doc_type": "html", "access": "wayback", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "ppic.org returns HTTP 403 to scripted requests; the bytes are the raw Internet Archive capture https://web.archive.org/web/20241007135504id_/https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/"} +{"url": "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", "title": "National and State-by-State Estimates of Two Approaches to Expanding the Child Tax Credit: data for download", "date": "2022-09-07", "publisher": "Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy", "sha256": "62f53a23c08a12f319b1b9cef02be3601505ca65fa9a1852888f968c81b20ecb", "bytes": 219563, "doc_type": "xlsx", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21"} +{"url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", "title": "The Benefits and Costs of a Child Allowance", "date": "2022", "publisher": "Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis 13(3), 335-362 (Garfinkel, Sariscsany, Ananat, Collyer, Hartley, Wang and Wimer)", "sha256": "34e0f7d347dc01e73b3f4b869ceb3129eeaa08ade0257864098a7eb23331f587", "bytes": 503954, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "doi:10.1017/bca.2022.15; the journal version of NBER working paper w29854, 'The Benefits and Costs of a U.S. Child Allowance'."} +{"url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", "title": "The 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion: Child Poverty Reduction and the Children Formerly Left Behind (Poverty & Social Policy Brief Vol. 6 No. 8)", "date": "2022-11-02", "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University (Wimer, Collyer, Harris and Lee)", "sha256": "3370fc0cc94f0b5e0e06b226bc7cd0c17798e01ab1fe9bf649f1f10033e1e3d3", "bytes": 351740, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21"} +{"url": "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", "title": "State-Level Poverty Impacts of the Child Tax Credit in 2021 (fact sheet)", "date": "2023-10-23", "publisher": "Center on Poverty and Social Policy, Columbia University", "sha256": "fa972955f30f3ce7bfbdc3cabf7413d35ed6dd6674737a6f999c15ea5eaeb594", "bytes": 360246, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21"} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4c2fd89d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-child-poverty-impact-dashboard/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,1173 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113610-cmp-us-child-poverty-impact", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "cbo", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "WebSearch: site:cbo.gov expanded child tax credit cost estimate American Rescue Plan", + "WebSearch: site:cbo.gov American Family Act cost estimate child tax credit", + "WebSearch: CBO budgetary effects of making permanent American Rescue Plan child tax credit expansion cost estimate", + "WebSearch: cbo.gov child tax credit options for reducing the deficit expand child tax credit", + "WebSearch: cbo.gov child allowance universal child benefit cost", + "WebSearch: cbo.gov Working Parents Tax Relief Act earned income tax credit parents of young children", + "WebSearch: CBO child poverty effect expanded child tax credit supplemental poverty measure analysis", + "WebSearch: Congressional Budget Office \"Estimated Budgetary Effects of\" extending expanded child tax credit permanently Build Back Better H.R. 5376 child tax credit", + "WebSearch: Congressional Budget Office cost estimate Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act of 2024 H.R. 7024 child tax credit", + "WebSearch: Congressional Budget Office child tax credit refundable 2026 cost fully refundable proposal estimate", + "WebSearch: Congressional Budget Office report child poverty effects of government programs Supplemental Poverty Measure CBO analysis children", + "WebSearch (extended): CBO \"child tax credit\" 2021 expansion \"Congressional Budget Office\" report effects on low-income households distribution household income 2021 ARPA", + "WebSearch: CRS Factors Affecting the Cost of Extending the Expanded Child Tax Credit CBO estimates table", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov): child tax credit expanded American Rescue Plan permanent cost", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov, jct.gov): Working Parents Tax Relief Act earned income credit children under four", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov, jct.gov): child allowance universal per child payment cost estimate", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov): estimated budget effects 2026 child tax credit earned income credit proposal cost estimate", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov): distributional analysis child tax credit households with children income poverty", + "Wayback CDX/raw-capture lookups for each cbo.gov file listed under checked (cdx search + web.archive.org/web/id_/)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57056", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57012", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57673", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57666", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/59916", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60341", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60706", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60809", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61157", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/62105", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60557", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/60950", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/58698", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57037", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/55420", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61422", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2021-02/Estimated_Budget_Effects_of_the_American_Rescue_Plan_Act_of_2021_0.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2021-03/Estimated_Budgetary_Effects_of_HR_1319_as_passed_0.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60809-poverty.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2021-12/57673-BBBA-GrahamSmith-Letter.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60437", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2021-09/57343-Pandemic.pdf", + "https://cbo.gov/system/files/2024-05/60114-Budgetary-Outcomes.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-01/hr1834.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-12/s3385.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57373", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57676", + "https://www.cbo.gov/robots.txt", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2021-03/Estimated_Budget_Effects_of_H.R._1319_as_Engrossed_by_the_House.pdf", + "https://www.govtrack.us/api/v2/bill?q=Working+Parents+Tax+Relief+Act", + "https://itep.org/eitc-expansion-working-parents-tax-relief-act/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CBO publishes no state figures and has scored none of the seven reforms for any state. National estimates seen: the Build Back Better CTC made permanent, $1,597bn over FY2022-31 ($172bn in FY2026) on a pre-OBBBA baseline (letter 57673, 10 December 2021); ARPA's 2021 CTC outlays, $88.8bn (H.R. 1319 tables). Nothing on a universal child allowance or the Working Parents Tax Relief Act. cbo.gov refuses scripted requests, so its files were read from Internet Archive captures. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "jct", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "WebSearch: site:jct.gov American Family Act estimated revenue effects child tax credit", + "WebSearch: site:jct.gov JCX-14-21 American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 estimated budget effects", + "WebSearch: JCX Joint Committee on Taxation estimated revenue effects H.R. 7024 Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act of 2024 JCX-", + "WebSearch: Joint Committee on Taxation JCX Build Back Better Act H.R. 5376 estimated budget effects child tax credit extension 2022", + "WebSearch: Joint Committee on Taxation JCX 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act estimated budget effects child tax credit $2,200", + "WebSearch: Joint Committee on Taxation scores American Family Act 2025 DeLauro Bennet child tax credit JCT estimate", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains jct.gov): child tax credit", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains jct.gov): estimated revenue effects child credit refundable", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains jct.gov): JCX-21-25 Joint Committee on Taxation", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov, jct.gov): Working Parents Tax Relief Act earned income credit children under four", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains cbo.gov, jct.gov): child allowance universal per child payment cost estimate", + "WebSearch: \"Macroeconomic Analysis of a Permanent Child Tax Credit Expansion\" Joint Committee on Taxation October 2022", + "WebSearch (allowed_domains jct.gov): JCX-3-24 estimated revenue effects H.R. 7024 child tax credit 2023 2024 2025 billion", + "Wayback CDX/raw-capture lookups for each jct.gov file listed under checked" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2021/jcx-14-21/", + "https://www.jct.gov/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=52961732-5521-49ea-8443-59a539b71b62", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2021/jcx-45-21/", + "https://www.jct.gov/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=3fbf5966-deea-41eb-a159-eda2c599e56b", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2022/macroeconomic-analysis-of-a-permanent-child-tax-credit-expansion/", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/655c151f-fa6a-4660-a961-05d028c2d000/Child-Tax-Credit-Expansion.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2024/jcx-3-24/", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/1961674e-5a44-4214-bfd3-baacda809577/x-3-24.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/eb21dc77-6439-4fc3-8f5d-fc23a8c377e0/x-35-25.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/?subject_name=Individual", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/?category_name=Revenue+Estimates", + "https://www.jct.gov/", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/x", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications-xml/xml/?name=119th+Congress", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2024/jcx-6-24/", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2024/jcx-2-24/", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/f402bf1b-246a-4fc0-8f55-0a033b41cff3/x-26-25R.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/765709fb-9a4b-430a-8f9e-4d342ec97f7e/x-48-24.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/publications/2025/jcx-21-25/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "JCT publishes no state figures. National estimates seen: JCX-14-21 (ARPA 2021 CTC, -$109.5bn FY2021-31); the October 2022 macroeconomic analysis of making the ARPA CTC permanent from 2023 (-$1,253.8bn conventional, FY2023-32, pre-OBBBA baseline); JCX-45-21; JCX-3-24. No JCX estimate of the American Family Act, a universal child allowance or the Working Parents Tax Relief Act was found. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "tpc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicycenter.org state child tax credit child poverty effect", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org expanded child tax credit restore 2026 cost", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org American Family Act", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org child allowance child poverty estimate", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org Working Parents Tax Relief Act", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org child poverty by state", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org state EITC cost", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org California young child tax credit CalEITC", + "site:taxpolicycenter.org New York Empire State Child Credit dependent exemption", + "Tax Policy Center expanded child tax credit would reduce poverty below 10 percent nearly all states", + "Tax Policy Center model estimates child tax credit proposals state distribution share of benefit by state", + "Tax Policy Center Harris child tax credit proposal $6,000 newborn $3,600 analysis cost", + "taxpolicycenter.org briefs analysis Family First Act child tax credit", + "taxpolicycenter.org model estimates 2025 child tax credit ARPA 2021 extension restore fully refundable $3,600 $3,000 revenue 2026", + "Tax Policy Center state tax model California New York child tax credit EITC state-level revenue estimate", + "\"How Increasing the Federal EITC and CTC Could Affect State Taxes\" Maag Weiner pdf", + "Tax Policy Center \"Options to Expand the Child Tax Credit\" April 2026 model estimates", + "taxpolicycenter.org Stronger Start for Working Families Act would help low-income workers", + "Tax Policy Center model estimates extend American Rescue Plan child tax credit permanently 2022 revenue estimate \"Tax Policy Center\" cost per year", + "Tax Policy Center child benefit universal child allowance $3,000 per child cost estimate TaxVox", + "Tax Policy Center Briefing Book \"How did the 2021 American Rescue Plan Act change the child tax credit\"", + "Tax Policy Center estimates by state distribution federal tax proposal families with children \"by state\" tax model analysis 2025 OR 2026", + "Tax Policy Center child tax credit state-level estimates number of children benefit each state 2026", + "[direct fetch, no search] taxpolicycenter.org/search?keys=american+family+act -> Cloudflare 403 'Access blocked' (TPC site search not usable)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/expanded-child-tax-credit-would-reduce-poverty-below-10-percent-nearly-all-states", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/emaag_9.8.21_blog.png", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/working-parents-tax-relief-act-would-deliver-larger-eitc-families-young-children", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/tax-model-analysis/working-parents-tax-relief-act", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/t26-0022", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/t26-0023", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/t26-0024", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/t26-0028", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/T26-0022.xlsx", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/T26-0022_0.xlsx", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/T26-0023.xls", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/T26-0024.xls", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/american-family-act-would-mark-significant-investment-low-and-moderate-income-families", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/tax-model-analysis/american-family-act", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/t26-0029", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/T26-0029.xlsx", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/analyses-child-tax-credit-and-earned-income-tax-credit-proposals-119th-congress", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/tax-model-analysis/options-expand-child-tax-credit", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/tax-model-analysis/options-expand-child-tax-credit-ctc-updated-april-2026", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/fiscal-facts/child-tax-credit-options-119th-congress", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/extend-3000-ctc-arp-phase-outs-september-2021/t21-0189-extend-3000-ctc-arp-phase", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/model-estimates/spreadsheet/t21-0189.xlsx", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/daily-deduction/tpc-estimates-benefits-newborn-tax-credit", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/newborn-tax-credit-could-be-worthwhile-sound-administration", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/tax-model-analysis/options-increase-eitc-and-ctc-august-2024", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates/options-increase-eitc-ctc-august-2024/t24-0058", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/model-estimates/spreadsheet/t24_0056.xls", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/model-estimates/spreadsheet/t24_0058.xls", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/publication/165795/constructing-state-child-tax-credits_0.pdf", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/publications/how-increasing-federal-eitc-and-ctc-could-affect-state-taxes", + "https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/publication/161932/how-increasing-the-federal-eitc-and-ctc-could-affect-state-taxes.pdf", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/An_Analysis_of_the_Family_First_Act_%28FFA%29.pdf", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/search?keys=american+family+act", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/2025-reconciliation-and-child-tax-credit", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/model-estimates", + "https://web.archive.org/web/2024/https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/publications/how-increasing-federal-eitc-and-ctc-could-affect-state-taxes", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/93261/upward-mobility-and-state-level-eitcs-evaluating-californias-earned-income-tax_credit_3.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "TPC's tables are national. Same bill as reform 3, national only: T26-0022 (14 May 2026), Working Parents Tax Relief Act, -$303.4bn over FY2026-35 (-$32.0bn in FY2027). Also national: T26-0029 (American Family Act 2025), T21-0189 (ARPA CTC permanent, 2021 vintage). TPC's state CTC work models Illinois, Michigan, Nebraska and Virginia only. A December 2022 brief on taxpolicycenter.org with California rows (Werner, Airi and Maag, Urban's ATTIS model) is logged under urban. Rueben and Sammartino (TPC) with Stark, Tax Law Review (2017), estimate that a fully funded CalEITC, 100% rather than the 85% adopted, 'would cost the state of California $524 million' at 2011 incomes: a total cost of the 2015 design, not the cost of raising today's factor, so not staged. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "pwbm", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu child tax credit", + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu child allowance child poverty", + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu American Family Act OR \"Working Parents Tax Relief Act\" OR \"expanded child tax credit\"", + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu state EITC OR California OR \"New York\" child credit", + "[direct] full PWBM sitemap-0.xml (728 URLs) filtered by child|ctc|eitc|poverty|famil|allowance|credit|state|california|york|dependent|harris|trump|reconcil|tcja|american-rescue; 30 candidate pages downloaded and counted for 'poverty', 'California', 'New York' (zero hits for all three except 2019 state-eitc-adoption: 5 poverty mentions, no CA/NY)", + "[remaining suffix queries not run as WebSearch: shared 200-search session budget exhausted; replaced by the sitemap enumeration above]" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/sitemap-index.xml", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/sitemap-0.xml", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/issues/2021/10/25/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-effects", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/estimates/2024-08-20-harris-campaign-revenue-effects-of-ctc-eitc-and-aca/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2024-08-26-the-2024-harris-campaign-policy-proposals/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2020-09-24-presidential-candidate-joe-bidens-proposed-child-tax-credit-expansion/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2021-03-03-ctc-proposals/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2021-05-04-president-biden-s-american-families-plan/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2021-10-25-expanding-the-child-tax-credit/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2023-06-14-the-tax-cuts-for-working-families-act-estimated-budgetary-and-distributional-effects/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2019-05-15-state-eitc-adoption/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2018-10-25-analyzing-the-budgetary-and-incentive-effects-of-senator-harriss-proposed-lift-credit/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2024-05-22-president-bidens-fy2025-budget-proposal/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2024-05-22-tcja-extenders/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2025-05-19-house-reconciliation-bill-budget-economic-and-distributional-effects/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2025-07-01-senate-reconciliation-bill-budget-economic-and-distributional-effects-june-29-2025/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2025-07-08-president-trump-signed-reconciliation-bill/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2026-03-11-the-keep-your-pay-act-budgetary-and-distributional-effects/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2026-03-16-working-americans-tax-cut-act-revenue-and-distributional-effects/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2026-03-16-deductions-vs-rate-caps-zero-bracket-expansion/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/estimates/", + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/legacy-briefs/2016-12-16-tax-policy-toward-low-income-families/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "PWBM publishes no state or poverty estimates for child credits. National, same design as reform 1: 'Restore 2021 CTC', -$135bn in 2026 and -$1,662bn over 2025-34 on a TCJA-sunset baseline (20 August 2024). Not scored: the Working Parents Tax Relief Act, a $3,000 universal allowance, the state reforms." + }, + { + "producer": "budget_lab", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetlab.yale.edu child tax credit child poverty", + "Budget Lab at Yale state child tax credits report Iselin child-based tax relief states", + "budgetlab.yale.edu research child tax credit poverty analysis 2025 OR 2026", + "Yale Budget Lab \"child tax credit\" \"child poverty\" restoring 2021 expansion estimate", + "[direct] budgetlab.yale.edu/our-work?page=0..16 (pages 0-9 populated, 142 distinct /research/ slugs) filtered by child|ctc|poverty|famil|state|eitc|credit|allowance|dependent|obbb|reconcil; topic pages /topic/children-and-families and /topic/state-economy pages 0-2", + "[remaining suffix queries not run as WebSearch: shared 200-search session budget exhausted; replaced by the full listing enumeration above]" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/options-expanding-child-tax-credit", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-04/TBL-ThirdWay-20250409.pdf", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-04/TBL%20Data%20Third%20Way%20CTC%2020250409.xlsx", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/child-tax-credit-conventional-budget-scores", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/page_to_pdf/158/publication_158.pdf", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2024-04/TBL%20Data%20CTC%20Options%20202404.xlsx", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/who-benefits-under-each-ctc-reform", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/how-would-each-ctc-reform-affect-employment-and-childrens-economic-outcomes", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/simulating-long-term-impact-cash-assistance-children-future-earnings", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/child-tax-credit-simulator", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/ctc-expansion-can-take-many-forms-full-refundability-best-low-income-families", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/beneficiaries-fully-refundable-ctc-would-change-year-year", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/understanding-child-tax-credits-history-helps-chart-path-forward", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/budgetary-and-distributional-effects-updated-family-security-act-framework", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/effect-tariffs-poverty", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/tcjas-tax-benefits-parents-are-shrinking", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/how-would-each-reform-affect-us-economy", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/our-work?page=0", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/topic/children-and-families?page=0..2", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/topic/state-economy?page=0..2", + "https://ctmirror.org/2026/01/21/ct-child-tax-credit-advocates/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No state-level or poverty-rate estimates. National: '2021 law' CTC from 2026, -$152bn in FY2026 (12 April 2024, TCJA-sunset baseline); a $3,000 credit with ARPA phase-out, -$1,219bn FY2026-35 (Third Way, 9 April 2025)." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_foundation", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxfoundation.org California young child tax credit CalEITC [WebSearch not performed: session budget exhausted]", + "site:taxfoundation.org New York Empire State Child Credit dependent exemption [WebSearch not performed: session budget exhausted]", + "site:taxfoundation.org state child tax credit child poverty effect [WebSearch not performed: session budget exhausted]", + "site:taxfoundation.org expanded child tax credit restore 2026 cost American Family Act child allowance [WebSearch not performed: session budget exhausted]", + "[direct] https://taxfoundation.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search?search= (WordPress REST site search, per_page 30) for: state child tax credit child poverty effect; child allowance child poverty estimate; expanded child tax credit restore 2026 cost; American Family Act; state EITC cost; California young child tax credit; CalEITC; California earned income tax credit; New York Empire State Child Credit; New York dependent exemption; Working Parents Tax Relief Act; child poverty by state; child tax credit; child allowance; young child tax credit; state child tax credit; earned income tax credit state; dependent exemption; universal child benefit; Family Security Act; baby bonus newborn credit (296 distinct hits, filtered by keyword: no CalEITC, YCTC, Empire State Child Credit, NY dependent exemption, WPTRA, or state child-poverty item)", + "[direct] all 31 Tax Foundation sitemaps (10,624 URLs) grep for child-tax|child-credit|ctc|child-allowance|working-famil|family-act|dependent|young-child|eitc|earned-income|empire|state-eitc|child-poverty|newborn|baby-bonus|obbba|big-beautiful", + "[direct] tag pages /tags/child-tax-credit-ctc/ and /tags/earned-income-tax-credit-eitc/ pages 1-5" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/expanded-child-tax-credit-permanent/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/child-tax-credit-reform/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/kamala-harris-tax-plan-2024/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/van-hollen-cory-booker-tax-cut-plans/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/biden-budget-2025-tax-proposals/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/tcja-family-provisions-tax-reform-2025/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/child-tax-credit/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/child-tax-credit-changes-reform/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/child-tax-credit-reform-debate/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/child-tax-credit-debate/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/democrats-expand-child-tax-credit/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/blog/democrats-child-tax-credit-plan/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/federal/tax-savings-child-tax-credit-vary-significantly-state-state/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/state/monday-map-average-child-tax-credit-received-tax-return/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/federal/where-are-most-child-tax-credits-claimed/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/state/big-beautiful-bill-state-tax-impact/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/state/new-york-budget-gap-new-york-revenue-shortfall/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/statetaxindex/states/new-york/", + "https://taxfoundation.org/robots.txt", + "https://taxfoundation.org/sitemap_index.xml", + "https://taxfoundation.org/?s=" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Only national CTC cost estimates (ARPA CTC made permanent, -$1,557.8bn 2022-31, March 2021; Harris plan 2024; Keep Your Pay Act 2026). No CalEITC, Young Child Tax Credit, Empire State Child Credit, New York dependent exemption or state child-poverty estimate." + }, + { + "producer": "urban", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "WebSearch NOT used (budget exhausted). Urban site search https://www.urban.org/search?search_api_fulltext=child%20tax%20credit%20california -> 403 Access blocked (query strings are Cloudflare-blocked on urban.org)", + "Urban sitemaps: https://www.urban.org/sitemap.xml (200, index); /publications/sitemap.xml (200 index) but ?page=1..3 -> Cloudflare 'Just a moment' (curl and headless Playwright); /project-pages/, /projects/, /features/, /landing-pages/, /microsites/, /taxonomy-landing-pages/ sitemap.xml (200) filtered for tax|ctc|child-poverty|poverty|safety-net|eitc|cash|california|new-york", + "Urban author pages (page 0 only; ?page=N blocked): kevin-werner, gregory-acs, laura-wheaton, linda-giannarelli, elaine-maag, sarah-minton, ilham-dehry, margaret-todd, sarah-knowles, kevin-moclair, danielle-kwon, paul-johnson, joyce-morton, katherine-hueston, nikhita-airi, elaine-waxman, heather-hahn, michael-karpman, lisa-dubay, poonam-gupta, jorge-hernandez-perez, alex-haralampoudis(404), christin-durham, lauren-simpson, doug-wissoker(404), silke-taylor", + "Urban tag pages (page 0 only): /tags/child-tax-credit, /tags/earned-income-tax-credit, /tags/individual-taxes, /tags/poverty, /tags/welfare-and-safety-net-programs, /tags/families-low-incomes, /tags/attis-microsimulation-model; /tags/child-poverty and /tags/tax-credits 404", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/research/publication/* from=2022 filter original:.*(child-tax|ctc|child-credit|child-allowance|young-child|children-out-poverty|child-poverty|family-act|rescue-plan).* (283 rows)", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/urban-wire/* from=2022 filter original:.*(child-tax|ctc|child-credit|child-allowance|young-child|child-poverty|family-act|rescue-plan|eitc|earned-income).* (56 rows)", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/research/publication/* from=2022 filter original:.*(poverty|california|new-york|reconciliation|obbba|big-beautiful|tax-cut|safety-net|cash|tcja|families-hardest|attis|trim3|anti-poverty|antipoverty|cost-living|economic-security).* (966 rows); same for urban-wire (offline page returned)", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/research/publication/* from=202501 filter original:.*(child|tax|credit|poverty|famil|kids|cash|income|benefit|ctc|eitc|safety|reconciliation|obbba|state).* (4803 rows)", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/sites/default/files/20* filter (?i).*(child|tax|credit|poverty|ctc|eitc|california|new.york|allowance|famil|kids|safety|reconciliation|obbba|big.beautiful|cash).* (1034 rows; 222 dated 2022-2026 PDF/XLSX after topic filter, reviewed by title)", + "Wayback CDX: url=apps.urban.org/features/* filter (?i).*(child|tax|credit|poverty|ctc|eitc|safety|state|famil|kids|cash|attis|reconciliation).* (3132 rows; features missing-ctc-map, cash-payments-factsheets, attis-benefits-full-participation, state-of-the-safety-net-data-tool, eitc-fact-sheet-map reviewed by URL)", + "Wayback CDX: url=urban.org/tags/child-tax-credit* (no captures); url=urban.org/publications/sitemap.xml* (CDX offline at the time)", + "Wayback CDX: url=otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/* from=2025 and url=otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/* from=2025 (all Urban CPRAC attachments 2023-2025 listed; no 2025-2026 Urban XLSX for new ESCC options)", + "Wayback CDX attempts that failed (IA 'Temporarily Offline' / 504): taxpolicycenter.org/* filter infant|parents-infants|low-income-workers; taxpolicycenter.org/briefs/* filter child|ctc|infant|eitc; taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/* from=2024 filter infant|child.tax.credit|ctc; urban.org/research/publication/* all-time first-capture keyword query", + "Wayback availability API (archive.org/wayback/available) for taxpolicycenter.org briefs: expanding-child-tax-credit-low-income-workers-or-parents-infants-would-have-modest (none), how-policymakers-could-use-tax-code-better-serve-children (20250723160950), options-reform-child-tax-credit-2025-tax-debate (20250725082038), taxvox/congress-could-expand-child-tax-credit-low-and-middle-income-families (20251026153827), 2025-reconciliation-and-child-tax-credit (20260110121439), one-big-beautiful-bill-act-obbba-shifts... (20260209134926), taxvox/lessons-2021-child-tax-credit-expansion-informing-state-policy-debates (20260308202710), taxvox/child-tax-credit-grows-lift-millions-children-out-poverty (20251031201840)", + "Crossref API https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1177/00027162241272312 (abstract of Maag, Airi, Collyer ANNALS article)", + "Previous searcher (reconstructed from scratch/): cdx_run.sh CDX queries url=urban.org/research/publication/* with filter keywords ctc, young-child, poverty-projections, child-allowance, american-family-act, family-security-act, state-child-tax-credit, rescue-plan, child-credit, projected-poverty, cash-assistance, antipoverty; sm/cdx_pub_* keyword files california, child-allowance, child-poverty, child-tax-credit, ctc, earned-income, eitc, new-york, poverty-projections, state-level, states, young-child; scratch/cdx_cprac.txt + cdx_meetings.txt (otda.ny.gov CPRAC attachments); one DuckDuckGo/Bing query in scratch/ddg: 'site:urban.org California child poverty child tax credit simulation'" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/how-permanent-expansion-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/104626/how-a-permanent-expansion-of-the-child-tax-credit-could-affect-poverty_1.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/expanding-child-tax-credit-could-lift-millions-children-out-poverty", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2022-06/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-could-lift-millions-of-children-out-of-poverty.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/covid-19-pandemic-underscored-child-tax-credits-power-alleviate-family-poverty", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/comparing-plans-reduce-child-poverty-family-security-act-20-framework-and", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/publication/164597/comparing_plans_to_reduce_child_poverty_-_family_security_act_2.0_and_the_expanded_child_tax_credit.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/constructing-state-child-tax-credit-that-fits-every-state", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/expanding-child-tax-credit-low-income-workers-or-parents-infants-would-have", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/how-policymakers-could-use-tax-code-better-serve-children", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/options-reform-child-tax-credit-2025-tax-debate", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/implications-alternative-designs-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/lessons-2021-child-tax-credit-expansion-informing-state-policy-debates", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/child-tax-credit-grows-lift-millions-children-out-poverty", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/congress-could-expand-child-tax-credit-low-and-middle-income-families", + "https://taxpolicycenter.org/2025-reconciliation-and-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2025-10/The-One-Big-Beautiful-Bill-Act-(OBBBA", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/how-work-based-policy-package-can-reduce-us-poverty", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2025-08/How%20a%20Work-Based%20Policy%20Package%20Can%20Reduce%20US%20Poverty.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/house-reconciliation-bill-will-hit-lowest-income-families-hardest", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2025-06/House-Reconciliation-Bill-Will-Hit-Lowest-Income-Families-the%20Hardest.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/who-gains-and-who-loses-under-tax-cut-extension-medicaid-and-snap-spending", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/bridging-true-cost-living-gap-new-york-city", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/Bridging-the-True-Cost-of-Living-Gap-in-New-York-City-final%20%282%29.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2024-12/An_Expanded_Child_Tax_Credit_Could_Help_Low-Income_Families_Facing_Material_Hardships.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/2025-11/Final%20slide%20deck%20-%20State%20Tax%20Credits.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/absence-expanded-child-tax-credit-many-families-children-faced-material", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/impact-expanded-child-tax-credit-oklahoma", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/district-columbia-child-tax-credit-would-provide-important-support-families", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/national-survey-families-faced-financial-strain-when-expanded-ctc-expired", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/understanding-how-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduced-poverty-and-hardship-2021", + "https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/permanently-expanding-child-tax-credit-would-increase-kids-lifetime-earnings-and", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/return-investing-children", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/the-long-term-impacts-of-cash-assistance-to-families", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/comparing-long-term-impacts-different-child-well-being-improvements", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/how-supplemental-income-can-support-children-and-caregivers", + "https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/how-many-people-your-state-have-resources-thrive", + "https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/amid-federal-safety-net-cuts-marylands-approach-fighting-child-poverty-offers-path-other", + "https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/increasing-child-tax-credit-could-drastically-reduce-child-poverty", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/innovations-cash-assistance-children/research-and-resources", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/state-safety-net", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/state-safety-net/publications", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/state-safety-net/state-fact-sheets", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/state-safety-net/about", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/how-much-would-poverty-decrease-each-state-if-every-eligible-person-received-safety-net", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/redesigning-child-tax-credit-reduce-economic-inequality", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/research-inform-2025-reconciliation-taxes-safety-net-and-beyond", + "https://www.urban.org/projects/research-inform-2025-reconciliation-taxes-safety-net-and-beyond/taxes", + "https://www.urban.org/tags/attis-microsimulation-model", + "https://www.urban.org/research/data-methods/data-analysis/quantitative-data-analysis/microsimulation/transfer-income-model-trim", + "https://www.urban.org/states-and-territories/california", + "https://www.urban.org/states-and-territories/new-york", + "https://www.urban.org/annual-impact-report/2025/federal-policy-impact/connecting-changemakers-evidence-child-tax-credit-expansion", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/upward-mobility-and-state-level-eitcs-evaluating-californias-earned-income-tax-credit", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/93261/upward-mobility-and-state-level-eitcs-evaluating-californias-earned-income-tax_credit_3.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/extending-california-earned-income-tax-credit-postsecondary-students", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/analysis-young-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/addressing-family-sized-hole-federal-tax-reform-left-states", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/99354/addressing_the_family-sized_hole.pdf", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/reducing-child-poverty-us-updated-analysis-policies-proposed-childrens-defense-fund", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/using-microsimulation-identify-strategies-cutting-child-poverty-half", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/how-much-could-policy-changes-reduce-poverty-new-york-city", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/2021-poverty-projections-assessing-four-american-rescue-plan-policies", + "https://www.urban.org/research/publication/2021-poverty-projections-assessing-impact-benefits-and-stimulus-measures", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-03-14/attachments/CPRAC-Urban-Institute-Proposed-Policy-Results-CTC-Simulations.xlsx", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-03-14/attachments/CPRAC-Urban-Institute-Proposed-Policy-Results-CTC-EITC-Overviews.xlsx", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-06-06/attachments/2024-06-06-CPRAC-All-Policy-Overviews-Package-Examples.xlsx", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-06-06/attachments/2024-06-06-CPRAC-All-Policy-Overviews-Committee-Priorities.xlsx", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2023-12-06/attachments/2023-12-06-CPRAC-Urban-Institute-Microsimulation-Modeling-Summary.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-03-14/attachments/2024-03-14-Child-Tax-Credit-Presentation.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2025-06-10/attachments/2025-06-10-CPRAC-Presentation.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2025-10-14/attachments/2025-10-14-CPRAC-Presentation.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/reports/CPRAC-2024-Recommendations-and-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/reports/CPRAC-2025-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/" + ], + "claims": [ + "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pp_ca_2018", + "urban_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018", + "urban_arpa_ctc_children_removed_ca_2018" + ], + "note": "Acs and Werner (July 2021, updated August 2021), Table 5: the ARPA design made permanent, SPM, 2018 ACS. Not staged: the December 2022 update (TPC-hosted, Urban authors) prints only levels (California 20.3% to 13.5%); Urban's ATTIS simulations for New York's Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council (2019 data) score decoupled ESCC designs, the nearest being $2,000 under 6 with $1,500 for ages 6-17 (-25.5%, $3,721.79m), not the dashboard's $1,000-to-$2,000 step for children under 4 on 2025 law. The 2017 CalEITC estimate on urban.org is a Tax Policy Center paper, logged under tpc. No Urban state estimate for 2025 or 2026 was found. The first Urban search was interrupted; a second completed it without the web-search tool (urban.org sitemaps, author and tag pages, Internet Archive indexes)." + }, + { + "producer": "cbpp", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:cbpp.org state child tax credit children lifted above poverty by state American Rescue Plan", + "site:cbpp.org expanded child tax credit state-by-state children lifted above poverty line California New York", + "site:cbpp.org restore expanded child tax credit state", + "cbpp.org \"making the American Rescue Plan\" Child Tax Credit EITC permanent updated estimates by state children lifted above poverty", + "CBPP \"Child Tax Credit\" \"by state\" children \"lifted above the poverty line\" Build Back Better 2021", + "CBPP 2024 bipartisan tax bill child tax credit expansion help kids every state congressional district", + "cbpp.org 2024 \"Child Tax Credit\" \"lift\" children above poverty \"by state\" Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act", + "cbpp.org 2025 House Republican tax bill child tax credit leaves out 17 million children state table", + "cbpp.org \"19 million children\" left out full child tax credit by state 2022 2023", + "cbpp.org child tax credit expansion \"every state and congressional district\"", + "site:cbpp.org American Family Act child tax credit 2025 children lifted above poverty", + "site:cbpp.org megabill child tax credit $2,200 children left out by state 2025", + "site:cbpp.org California Young Child Tax Credit CalEITC", + "site:cbpp.org New York Empire State Child Credit expansion", + "site:cbpp.org \"Working Parents Tax Relief Act\"", + "site:cbpp.org child allowance poverty Romney Family Security Act estimate", + "cbpp McDonald Rivet EITC parents young children under 4 bill 2025", + "site:cbpp.org universal child allowance $3,000 per child", + "site:cbpp.org state child tax credits 2025 states enacted expanded New York California", + "cbpp.org policy basics state earned income tax credits", + "cbpp.org states enacted expanded child tax credits EITCs 2025 legislative sessions blog", + "cbpp.org \"Empire State Child Credit\"", + "cbpp.org \"Young Child Tax Credit\" California", + "Wayback CDX enumeration (replacement for site search): url=cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/ matchType=prefix statuscode:200 (577 URLs; filtered for child|ctc|eitc|famil|poverty|rescue|megabill|bipartisan|working|kids|allowance)", + "Wayback CDX enumeration: url=cbpp.org/blog/ matchType=prefix statuscode:200 (7,302 URLs; filtered for child-tax|ctc|allowance|eitc|empire|california|new-york|young-child|child-poverty|veteran)", + "Wayback CDX enumeration: cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/* (438 URLs), cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/ (14), cbpp.org/press/statements/ (652), filtered for CTC/EITC/state-credit/census terms", + "Internet Archive CDX: cbpp.org blog, research and press pages captured April-October 2026, filtered for Working Parents Tax Relief Act, young children, EITC" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/american-rescue-plan-act-includes-critical-expansions-of-child-tax-credit-and", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/3-12-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/congress-should-adopt-american-families-plans-permanent-expansions-of-child", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/5-24-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/house-covid-relief-bill-includes-critical-expansions-of-child-tax-credit-and", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/2-9-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/recovery-package-should-permanently-include-families-with-low-incomes-in-full", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/build-back-betters-child-tax-credit-changes-would-protect-millions-from", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/11-11-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/if-congress-fails-to-act-monthly-child-tax-credit-payments-will-stop-child", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/12-2-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/earnings-requirement-would-undermine-child-tax-credits-poverty-reducing-impact", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/benefits-of-expanding-child-tax-credit-outweigh-small-employment-effects", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/3-1-21tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/3000-per-child-allowance-would-slash-child-poverty-even-accounting-for-slight-work-reductions", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/3-1-21tax-f1.png", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/year-end-tax-policy-priority-expand-the-child-tax-credit-for-the-19-million", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/11-15-22tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/policymakers-should-expand-child-tax-credit-in-year-end-legislation-to-fight", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/top-tax-priority-expanding-the-child-tax-credit-in-upcoming-economic", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/6-7-23tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/any-year-end-tax-legislation-should-expand-child-tax-credit-to-cut-child", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/11-7-23tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/child-tax-credit-expansion-should-prioritize-cutting-child-poverty", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/about-16-million-children-in-low-income-families-would-gain-in-first-year-of", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/1-16-24tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/child-tax-credit-proposal-impacts-by-the-numbers", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/bipartisan-child-tax-credit-expansion-would-benefit-about-6-million-young-children", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/house-passed-bipartisan-tax-bills-child-tax-credit-expansion-would-especially-help-children", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-should-be-a-top-priority-in-2025-tax-debate", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/policymakers-should-expand-the-child-tax-credit-for-the-17-million-children-currently-left-out", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/by-the-numbers-house-republican-tax-agenda-favors-the-wealthy-and-leaves", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/by-the-numbers-harmful-republican-megabill-favors-the-wealthy-and-leaves", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/analyzing-the-census-bureaus-2024-poverty-income-and-health-insurance-data", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/republican-megabill-tax-provisions-are-skewed-to-the-rich-fail-to-deliver-for", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/12-17-25tax.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/the-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/policybasics-ctc.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/2025-tax-debate-begins-offers-opportunity-for-course-correction", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/biden-harris-child-tax-credit-expansion-would-lift-10-million-children-above-or-closer-to", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/tax-season-message-congress-should-dramatically-and-permanently-cut-child-poverty-with-an", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/2022-04/Tax%20Day%202022%20CTC%20blog_f0.png", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/this-mothers-day-congress-can-support-mothers-by-expanding-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/the-expanded-child-tax-credit-must-be-permanent-and-monthly", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/make-child-tax-credit-improvements-permanent-in-upcoming-recovery-legislation", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/states-should-create-and-expand-child-tax-credits", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/american-rescue-plan-act-2-years-later", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/canadian-style-child-benefit-would-cut-us-child-poverty-by-more-than-half", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/plan-would-cut-child-poverty-by-60-percent", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/report-strengthening-child-tax-credit-would-reduce-poverty-improve-opportunity", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/despite-flaws-romney-proposal-on-child-tax-credit-creates-opening-for-bipartisan-action", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/romney-child-tax-credit-proposal-is-step-forward-but-falls-short-targets-low", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/working-families-tax-relief-act-would-help-46-million-households-cut-poverty", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/4-10-19tax2.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/as-mothers-day-approaches-a-proposal-to-help-millions-of-mothers-and-their-children", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/temporarily-expanding-child-tax-credit-and-earned-income-tax-credit-would", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/expanding-child-tax-credit-and-earned-income-tax-credit-would-benefit-more-than", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/expansions-of-the-earned-income-tax-credit-and-child-tax-credit-would-benefit", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/rescue-plans-expansions-of-earned-income-tax-credit-child-tax-credit-will", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/stimulus-payments-child-tax-credit-expansion-were-critical-parts-of-successful", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/a-top-priority-to-address-poverty-strengthening-the-child-tax-credit-for-very", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/state-fact-sheets-the-earned-income-and-child-tax-credits", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/interactive-house-gop-child-tax-credit-increase-leaves-out-millions-of-children", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/state-and-local-child-tax-credit-outreach-needed-to-help-lift-hardest-to-reach", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/chart-book-the-earned-income-tax-credit-and-child-tax-credit", + "https://www.cbpp.org/press/statements/in-pandemics-second-year-government-policies-helped-drive-child-poverty-rate-to-a", + "https://www.cbpp.org/press/statements/record-rise-in-poverty-highlights-importance-of-child-tax-credit-health-coverage", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/states-can-enact-or-expand-child-tax-credits-and-earned-income-tax", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/3-3-21sfp.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/states-should-invest-in-their-communities-by-enacting-and-expanding", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/states-should-continue-enacting-and-expanding-child-tax-credits-and", + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/how-much-would-a-state-earned-income-tax-credit-cost-in-fiscal-year", + "https://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/policybasics-seitc.pdf", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/movement-for-state-child-tax-credits-continues-to-grow", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/momentum-for-new-and-expanded-state-child-tax-credits-earned-income-tax-credits-continued-in", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/momentum-builds-for-a-california-eitc", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/three-steps-to-estimating-the-cost-of-a-state-eitc", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/child-poverty-remains-high-but-states-can-make-a-difference", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/child-poverty-up-in-most-states-with-damaging-consequences", + "https://www.cbpp.org/blog/a-state-by-state-look-at-the-eitc-and-child-tax-credit", + "https://mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/media/press-releases/icymi-congresswoman-mcdonald-rivet-introduces-game-changing-tax-cut-working", + "http://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=cbpp.org/blog/&matchType=prefix&from=202603&to=202610&output=json&fl=original,timestamp,statuscode&collapse=urlkey&limit=5000", + "http://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=cbpp.org/research/&matchType=prefix&from=20260401&to=20261021&output=json&fl=original,timestamp,statuscode&collapse=urlkey&limit=20000", + "http://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=cbpp.org/press/&matchType=prefix&from=20260401&to=20261021&output=json&fl=original,timestamp,statuscode&collapse=urlkey&limit=20000" + ], + "claims": [ + "cbpp_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "cbpp_arpa_ctc_children_lifted_ca_2024" + ], + "note": "The latest CBPP California estimate of each quantity for the ARPA design is staged. Earlier vintages logged, not staged: 553,000 children lifted (tax year 2020 rules, March 2021, superseded by CBPP); 582,000 (tax year 2021, May 2021, restated November 2021). CBPP has no estimate of reforms 2 to 7 for California or New York; its 2023 state-credit cost table ($1,000 per child plus $500 under 5: California $7,060m) is a different design. Rep. McDonald Rivet's press release of 22 April 2026 cites 'new analysis from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities' that the Working Parents Tax Relief Act 'would lift more than 400,000 kids under the age of four out of poverty in 2026 alone', a national figure; no CBPP publication of it was found on cbpp.org or in Internet Archive indexes of CBPP's blog and research pages captured April to October 2026, so whether it has state figures is unknown. cbpp.org HTML pages were read from raw Internet Archive captures (HTTP 403 to scripted requests)." + }, + { + "producer": "itep", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "WebSearch(extended): site:itep.org child tax credit state-by-state estimates", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org American Rescue Plan child tax credit by state", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org American Family Act state-by-state", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org restore expanded child tax credit by state", + "WebSearch(extended): ITEP American Family Act 2025 state-by-state child tax credit One Big Beautiful Bill comparison", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org Harris child tax credit plan state-by-state", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act child tax credit state-by-state", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org California young child tax credit", + "WebSearch: ITEP Harris Child Tax Credit proposal $6,000 newborn analysis state", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org Working Families Tax Credit New York", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org Empire State Child Credit expansion", + "WebSearch: site:itep.org CalEITC expansion California cost", + "WebSearch(extended): \"Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy\" New York \"Working Families Tax Credit\" estimate cost child poverty", + "WebSearch: \"ITEP\" \"Empire State Child Credit\" estimate cost children under 4 microsimulation", + "WebSearch: \"ITEP\" California \"Young Child Tax Credit\" expansion estimate cost microsimulation (NOT RUN: session web-search budget exhausted)", + "itep.org WP REST search (wp-json/wp/v2/posts?search=): american family act (unquoted); \"American Family Act\"; \"Working Parents\"; \"child allowance\"; \"Young Child Tax Credit\"; \"Empire State Child Credit\"; \"CalEITC\"; \"Working Families Tax Credit\"; \"Harris\" \"child tax credit\"; \"Boosting Incomes\"; \"dependent exemption\" \"New York\"; \"state-by-state\" \"child tax credit\"; \"Build Back Better\" \"child tax credit\" state; \"Wyden\" \"child tax credit\"; \"Earned Income Tax Credit\" \"under 4\"; \"Family Security Act\"; \"baby bonus\"; \"under age 4\"; \"Wyden-Smith\"; \"Smith-Wyden\"; \"universal child\"" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit-2026-obbba-trump-taxes/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Child-Tax-Credit-Changes-in-One-Big-Beautful-Bill-Act-vs.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Children-Left-Out-of-Full-Child-Tax-Credit-Changes-under-OBBBA.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/trumps-tax-laws-tiny-child-tax-credit-increase-fails-to-help-those-who-need-it-most/", + "https://itep.org/eitc-expansion-working-parents-tax-relief-act/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WPTRA-EITC-data.xlsx", + "https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/EcNC8/2/", + "https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/EcNC8/2/dataset.csv", + "https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/JZ3h7/2/", + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit-enhancements-under-the-american-rescue-plan/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP-Child-Tax-Credit_American-Rescue-Plan_National-and-50-State-Data-1.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP_Child-Tax-Credit-Enhancements-Under-the-American-Rescue-Plan.pdf", + "https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/iS1b0/2/", + "https://itep.org/romney-child-tax-credit-leaves-many-families-worse-off/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Two-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Data-for-Download.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/National-and-State-by-State-Estimates-of-2-Approaches-to-Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit.pdf", + "https://itep.org/romney-child-tax-credit-plan-would-leave-millions-of-children-worse-off-and-raise-taxes-for-the-average-black-family/", + "https://itep.org/effects-of-president-bidens-proposal-to-expand-the-child-tax-credit/", + "https://sfo2.digitaloceanspaces.com/itep/biden-budget-CTC.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit-expansion-would-help-60-million-kids/", + "https://sfo2.digitaloceanspaces.com/itep/Expanding-the-Child-Tax-Credit-Would-Help-Nearly-60-Million-Kids.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/estimates-on-senate-and-house-reconciliation-bills-cash-payment-and-tax-credit-provisions/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP-American-Rescue-Plan-Act.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/details-of-house-democrats-cash-payments-and-tax-credit-expansions/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Ways-Means-Relief-Plan-National-and-State.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/new-analysis-cash-and-tax-provisions-in-bidens-economic-recovery-plan/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP-Estimates-Major-Cash-and-Tax-Provisions-in-the-American-Rescue-Plan-1.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit-is-critical-component-of-biden-administrations-recovery-package/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/American-Families-Plan_CTC-expansion_ITEP.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/itep-data-on-child-tax-credit-and-earned-income-tax-credit-provisions-before-congress/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP-CTC-and-EITC-Estimates-for-BBB-Act.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/analysis-of-the-house-of-representatives-build-back-better-legislation/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Build-Back-Better-November-data-for-download-VALUED.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/tax-credit-reforms-in-build-back-better-would-benefit-a-diverse-group-of-families/", + "https://itep.org/tax-credits-in-build-back-better-support-millions-of-families/", + "https://itep.org/full-refundability-itin-inclusion-key-components-of-ways-and-means-ctc-proposal/", + "https://itep.org/new-itep-estimates-on-bidens-proposal-to-expand-the-child-tax-credit/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/HEROES-Act-Child-Tax-Credit-Expansion-2020_ITEP.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/national-and-state-by-state-estimates-of-house-passed-improvements-in-tax-credits-for-workers-and-children/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/ITEP-House-EITC-CTC.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/american-family-act/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/AFA-2020_ITEP-Data-for-Download.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/understanding-five-major-federal-tax-credit-proposals/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/052219-Tax-Credit-Proposals_ITEP-Data-for-Download-2.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/five-recent-federal-tax-credit-proposals-target-benefits-to-bottom-60-percent-of-taxpayers/", + "https://itep.org/the-working-families-tax-relief-act-would-boost-incomes-and-economic-security-for-workers-and-children/", + "https://itep.org/new-itep-data-shows-the-house-ways-and-means-bill-to-expand-eitc-and-child-tax-credit-would-benefit-low-and-moderate-income-people-and-families/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/WM-V2-amended-valued.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/the-case-for-extending-state-level-child-tax-credits-to-those-left-out-a-50-state-analysis/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-Child-Tax-Credit_ITEP-CPSP.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-CTC-ITEP-CPSP-California.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-CTC-ITEP-CPSP-New-York.pdf", + "https://itep.org/new-50-state-analysis-state-child-tax-credits-would-lift-2-1-to-4-5-million-children-out-of-poverty/", + "https://itep.org/states-can-halve-child-poverty-with-child-tax-credits/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-and-child-poverty-50-state-analysis-2022/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-and-child-poverty-50-state-analysis/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Report-State-Child-Tax-Credits-and-Child-Poverty-A-50-State-Analysis-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Child-Tax-Credit-Options-California-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Child-Tax-Credit-Options-New-York-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-have-enormous-potential-to-cut-child-poverty/", + "https://itep.org/a-distributional-analysis-of-kamala-harris-tax-plan/", + "https://sfo2.digitaloceanspaces.com/itep/Harris-Tables-for-Appendix.xlsx", + "https://sfo2.digitaloceanspaces.com/itep/A-Distributional-Analysis-of-Kamala-Harris-Tax-Plan-Appendix-Tables.pdf", + "https://itep.org/senator-van-hollen-working-americans-tax-cut-act-analysis/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Sen-Van-Hollen-WACTA-estimate-2026.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/impacts-of-tax-relief-for-american-families-and-workers-act/", + "https://itep.org/itep-statement-on-federal-tax-deal-on-child-tax-credit-business-tax-breaks/", + "https://itep.org/itep-statement-american-family-act-prioritizes-tax-credits-for-low-and-middle-income-families/", + "https://itep.org/expanding-the-child-tax-credit-would-advance-racial-equity-in-the-tax-code/", + "https://itep.org/congress-should-not-leave-children-out-of-possible-year-end-tax-deal/", + "https://itep.org/census-data-shows-need-to-make-2021-child-tax-credit-expansion-permanent/", + "https://itep.org/the-problems-with-returning-to-a-2000-non-refundable-child-tax-credit/", + "https://itep.org/the-compelling-data-and-moral-case-for-continuing-the-child-tax-credit-expansion/", + "https://itep.org/tax-provisions-in-trump-megabill-national-and-state-level-estimates/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Current-law-and-current-policy-megabill-national-and-state-data.xlsx", + "https://itep.org/potential-of-local-child-tax-credits-to-reduce-child-poverty/", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Potential-of-Local-Child-Tax-Credits-to-Reduce-Child-Poverty-Appendices.pdf", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-2027/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-2025/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-2024/", + "https://itep.org/states-are-boosting-economic-security-with-child-tax-credits-in-2023/", + "https://itep.org/more-states-are-boosting-economic-security-with-child-tax-credits-2022/", + "https://itep.org/state-earned-income-tax-credits-2027/", + "https://itep.org/state-earned-income-tax-credits-support-families-and-workers-in-2025/", + "https://itep.org/state-earned-income-tax-credits-2024/", + "https://itep.org/boosting-incomes-improving-equity-state-earned-income-tax-credits-in-2023/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-earned-income-tax-credits-2025/", + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit-eitc-improvement-2024/", + "https://itep.org/2026-state-legislative-sessions-child-tax-credit-eitc/", + "https://itep.org/state-tax-watch/", + "https://itep.org/undocumented-immigrants-child-tax-credit-eitc/", + "https://itep.org/child-tax-credit/", + "https://itep.org/wp-json/wp/v2/types", + "https://immresearch.org/publications/a-better-solution-for-more-new-yorkers-working-families-tax-credit-vs-escc/", + "https://immresearch.org/publications/the-working-families-tax-credit-a-sustainable-solution-for-millions-of-new-yorkers/", + "https://immresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/WFTC_Hochul-Comparison-1.pdf", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2025/andrew-gounardes/sen-gounardes-working-families-tax-credit-would", + "https://economicsecurity.us/news/new-data-almost-340k-children-deprived-of-full-ny-child-tax-credit-due-to-outmoded-income-tests/", + "https://nysfocus.com/2024/04/09/child-tax-credit-poverty-new-york", + "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/politics/2023/04/07/expanding-new-york-s-child-tax-credit-is-on-the-negotiating-table" + ], + "claims": [ + "itep_wptra_cost_ca_2026", + "itep_arpa_ctc_cost_ca_2023" + ], + "note": "The Working Parents Tax Relief Act table (30 April 2026) gives California's 2026 cost; it prints no poverty effect. For the ARPA design the latest California cost is the 2023 estimate (September 2022); earlier vintages logged, not staged: 2020 incomes (-$13,693,800k, March 2021), 2022 (-$12,984,900k, June 2021). Cousins, not staged: the inflation-indexed ARPA CTC for 2024 (-$12,308,200k), the American Family Act 2025 (state averages only), the 2019 ITEP-CPSP state top-up (California -38%, 659,000, $12.1bn) and the 2022 state child-allowance-style credits. No ITEP estimate of reforms 2, 4, 5, 6 or 7." + }, + { + "producer": "cpsp", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu state child tax credit child poverty California New York", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu Empire State Child Credit", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu California young child tax credit", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu child allowance child poverty estimate", + "WebSearch: \"State Child Tax Credits and Child Poverty: A 50-State Analysis\" pdf Collyer", + "WebSearch: povertycenter.columbia.edu American Family Act state-by-state child poverty reduction", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu New York child poverty tax credit", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu \"Working Families Tax Credit\" New York", + "WebFetch: https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/publications/2021/poverty-reduction-analysis-american-family-act (403)", + "WebSearch: povertycenter.columbia.edu sites default files State Child Tax Credits Child Poverty 50 State Analysis CPSP ITEP 2022 pdf", + "WebSearch: Columbia Center on Poverty and Social Policy Working Families Tax Credit New York modeling deep child poverty 22%", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu child tax credit by state 2021 expansion child poverty state estimates", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu earned income tax credit state child poverty", + "WebFetch: https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-and-child-poverty-50-state-analysis/ (PDF links)", + "WebSearch: \"State-Child-Tax-Credits\" \"50-State\" CPSP pdf Share Our Strength 2022 povertycenter", + "WebSearch: \"What Would 2022 Child Poverty Rates Have Looked Like\" Child Tax Credit povertycenter.columbia.edu pdf", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu California child poverty", + "WebSearch: Columbia Center on Poverty and Social Policy American Rescue Plan child poverty state-level estimates 2021 permanent expansion by state", + "WebSearch: \"Working Parents Tax Relief Act\" child poverty Columbia", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu child allowance state-level estimates", + "WebSearch: site:povertycenter.columbia.edu \"Potential of Local Child Tax Credits\"", + "WebSearch: \"Poverty Reduction Analysis of the American Family Act\" 2019 state Columbia California 38 percent child poverty", + "WebSearch: Columbia CPSP American Family Act child poverty by state California New York fact sheet March 2019", + "Wayback CDX: povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/ prefix (1095 URLs; saved wayback_cdx_sites.txt)", + "WebFetch: https://itep.org/the-case-for-extending-state-level-child-tax-credits-to-those-left-out-a-50-state-analysis (PDF links)", + "WebFetch: https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/attachments/2023-01-12-CPRAC-Reforming-Child-Credit.pdf (ECONNRESET; used Wayback 20250523164016 copy)", + "Wayback CDX: otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/attachments/2023-01-12-CPRAC-Reforming-Child-Credit.pdf", + "Wayback CDX: otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/ prefix (CPRAC attachment list)", + "WebSearch (NOT RUN - session web-search budget exhausted): Center on Poverty and Social Policy Columbia CalEITC OR \"Young Child Tax Credit\" California analysis poverty", + "WebSearch (NOT RUN - budget exhausted): Columbia Center on Poverty and Social Policy New York \"dependent exemption\" Empire State Child Credit", + "WebSearch (NOT RUN - budget exhausted): Columbia poverty center Harris child tax credit plan $6,000 newborn child poverty estimate 2024", + "WebSearch (NOT RUN - budget exhausted): povertycenter.columbia.edu \"American Family Act\" 2025 state estimates child poverty by state", + "WebFetch: https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/publications (403 Cloudflare)", + "WebFetch: https://itep.org/potential-of-local-child-tax-credits-to-reduce-child-poverty/ (PDF links)", + "Wayback CDX: povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication prefix (1595 URLs; saved wayback_cdx_publication_pages.txt); slugs filtered for state/NY/CA/CTC/allowance/EITC", + "Wayback CDX: www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/news-internal/2019/3/5/the-afa-and-child-poverty", + "Wayback CDX: povertycenter.columbia.edu/publications/2021/poverty-reduction-analysis-american-family-act", + "Wayback CDX: www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/s/041719-Child-Tax-Credit_ITEP-CPSP-nnxf.pdf", + "Wayback CDX: www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/category/State* and /publication/tag/california", + "Wayback CDX: otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/{2024-03-14,2023-10-06,2025-02-26}/attachments/* (CREI and CPRAC-authored, not CPSP)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://itep.org/potential-of-local-child-tax-credits-to-reduce-child-poverty/", + "https://itep.org/state-child-tax-credits-and-child-poverty-50-state-analysis/", + "https://itep.org/the-case-for-extending-state-level-child-tax-credits-to-those-left-out-a-50-state-analysis", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-CTC-ITEP-CPSP-California.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-CTC-ITEP-CPSP-New-York.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/041719-Child-Tax-Credit_ITEP-CPSP.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Child-Tax-Credit-Options-California-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Child-Tax-Credit-Options-New-York-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/Report-State-Child-Tax-Credits-and-Child-Poverty-A-50-State-Analysis-2022.pdf", + "https://itep.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Potential-of-Local-Child-Tax-Credits-to-Reduce-Child-Poverty.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/attachments/2023-01-12-CPRAC-Reforming-Child-Credit.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/2022/state-child-tax-credits-child-poverty-50-state-analysis", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/publications", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/AECF%20Toolkit%20State%20PDFs/California-youth-poverty-policy-factsheet-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/AECF%20Toolkit%20State%20PDFs/New%20York-youth-poverty-policy-factsheet-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/American%20Family%20Act-CTC/AFA-Supplementary-Analysis-CPSP-4.20.21.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/American%20Family%20Act-CTC/American-Family-Act-child-poverty-racial-ethnic-analysis-CPSP-2020.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/American%20Family%20Act-CTC/Child-Tax-Credit-Earnings-Requirements-CPSP-2019.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/American%20Family%20Act-CTC/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-American-Family-Act-CPSP-2020.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/American%20Rescue%20Plan/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-American-Rescue-Plan-CPSP-2021-dn2g.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Benefit-Cost-Model-Update-4.26.24.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Biden%20Fact%20Sheet%202.25.21.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/CTC-and-EITC-Lookback-Potential-Effects-on-poverty-CPSP-2017.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Child-Allowance-CBA-NY-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Child-Allowance-CBA-NYC-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Comparing-Income-Maintenance-Proposals-CPSP-2020.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Expanded-CTC-and-Child-Poverty-in-2021-CPSP.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Long-Term-Benefits-of-Child-Poverty-Reduction-Policies-NY-CPSP-2025.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Poverty%20in%20the%2050%20states/Data%20files/California.xlsx", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Poverty%20in%20the%2050%20states/Data%20files/New-York.xlsx", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-American-Families-Plan-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-American-Rescue-Plan-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-Biden-Economic-Relief-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Progressive-Tax-Credit-Proposals-CPSP-2019.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/Refundable-State-Child-Tax-Credit-Designs-Child-Poverty-CPSP-2025.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/US-and-50-state-youth-poverty-policy-analyses-CPSP-2021.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/What-Could-2023-Child-Poverty-Rates-Have-Looked-Like-CPSP.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/What-Would-2022-Child-Poverty-Rates-Have-Looked-Like-CPSP.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Publications/california-child-tax-credit-2018.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/2021-Child-Tax-Credit-State-Poverty-Factsheet-CPSP.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/Larger-Child-Tax-Credit-Design-Matters-CPSP-2025.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/Memo/Connecticut_BCA_4-13-26.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/Role-Tax-Credits-and-Transfers-on-Reducing-State-Level-Poverty-50-State-Analysis-CPSP-2025.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/Role-Tax-Credits-and-Transfers-on-Reducing-State-Level-Poverty-50-State-Analysis_CPSP-2026.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/Washington-DC-CTC-EITC-Expansion-Memo_12.18.2025.pdf", + "https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/sites/povertycenter.columbia.edu/files/content/Publications/What-Could-2024-Child-Poverty-Rates-Have-Looked-Like-CPSP-2025.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20190309184355id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/news-internal/2019/3/5/the-afa-and-child-poverty", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20210609060911id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/s/041719-Child-Tax-Credit_ITEP-CPSP-nnxf.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20210617003746id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/2019/state-child-tax-credit", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20210620021303id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/2019/tax-credit-proposals-nyc-impacts", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20241014010735id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/category/State+by+State+Analyses", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20241014010827id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/tag/california", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20250523164016id_/https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/attachments/2023-01-12-CPRAC-Reforming-Child-Credit.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20250711092131id_/https://povertycenter.columbia.edu/publications/2021/poverty-reduction-analysis-american-family-act", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20251207184528id_/https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/publication/child-tax-credit-and-poverty-reduction-in-states", + "https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/s/Extend-State-Child-Tax-Credits-CPSP-ITEP-2019.pdf", + "https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/s/Poverty-Reduction-Analysis-American-Rescue-Plan-CPSP-2021-dn2g.pdf", + "https://www.povertycenter.columbia.edu/s/What-Would-2022-Child-Poverty-Rates-Have-Looked-Like-CPSP.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20251214124839id_/https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2024-03-14/attachments/2024-03-14-Child-Tax-Credit-Presentation.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20251214141406id_/https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2023-10-06/attachments/2023-10-06-CPRAC-Tax-Policy-Notes.pdf", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20251214131958id_/https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2025-02-26/attachments/2025-02-26-CPRAC-Childrens-Research-Education-Institute-Presentation.pdf" + ], + "claims": [ + "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pp_ca_2021", + "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_ca_2021", + "cpsp_ctc_2021_child_poverty_pct_us_2021" + ], + "note": "Staged: the October 2023 state fact sheet's California row (the whole 2021 credit against none, the latest CPSP California estimate of the 2021 design), and the November 2022 brief's national 43%, because the dashboard's own prior file cites 'Columbia CPSP 2021 (~43%)'. CPSP has published no estimate of the dashboard's seven reforms as specified for California or New York. Cousins seen: the American Family Act (H.R. 1560, 116th Congress) state table, California -7.3 pp and -36.2% on 2018 data against TCJA; the ITEP-CPSP state credit analyses (2019, 2022); a January 2023 presentation to New York's poverty council on ESCC options for children under 6; New York's 2025 policy package (-46.7%, not separable); national AFA and OBBBA estimates for 2022-2024. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "crfb", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "producers.json lists CRFB for federal-scope analyses; this record's scope is state, since the dashboard scores every reform, federal ones included, for one state's households. CRFB's costings are national." + }, + { + "producer": "state_fiscal_note", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Annual Report on New York State Tax Expenditures FY 2027 dependent exemption Empire State child credit", + "New York State tax expenditure report fiscal year 2026 pdf budget.ny.gov", + "FY 2026 Enacted Budget Empire State Child Credit expansion $1,000 under 4 cost estimate Division of the Budget", + "\"Enacted Budget Financial Plan\" FY 2026 New York \"Empire State Child Credit\" millions", + "New York FY 2026 enacted budget child tax credit cost $825 million fully phased in Empire State Child Credit annual cost", + "Working Families Tax Credit New York bill S277 A3226 2025 fiscal implications", + "New York Empire State Child Credit $2,000 per child under four bill 2026 Senate", + "New York Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council report Empire State Child Credit cost estimate options", + "\"Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council\" \"2024 Recommendations and Progress Report\" pdf", + "Wayback CDX: otda.ny.gov/cprac/reports/*", + "Site navigation: budget.ny.gov FY26 and FY27 enacted and executive index pages; nysenate.gov Blue Book and one-house pages; nyassembly.gov/Reports WAM pages; nysenate.gov bill pages for S9077, S277 (2023), A3226 (2023), S367 and A10126", + "California bill increase Young Child Tax Credit to $2,000 Franchise Tax Board bill analysis revenue estimate", + "ftb.ca.gov bill analysis young child tax credit increase 2025 revenue impact", + "California bill CalEITC adjustment factor 100 percent of federal earned income tax credit FTB analysis", + "ftb.ca.gov \"legislative analyses\" 2025-2026 bill analysis list franchise tax board", + "\"Young Child Tax Credit\" increase \"$1,000\" OR \"$1,500\" OR \"$2,000\" bill California 2024 2025 2026 AB SB credit amount", + "lao.ca.gov Young Child Tax Credit increase cost options CalEITC expansion analysis", + "California Department of Finance Tax Expenditure Report 2025-26 Young Child Tax Credit earned income tax credit", + "LAO \"Young Child Tax Credit\" options increase credit amount cost estimate report", + "California 2026 bill raise Young Child Tax Credit amount \"young child tax credit\" increase maximum credit legislation Senate", + "\"adjustment factor\" CalEITC increase \"100 percent\" cost LAO OR \"Franchise Tax Board\" OR \"Department of Finance\"", + "lao.ca.gov California Earned Income Tax Credit Young Child Tax Credit budget analysis 2022 2023 2024 cost expansion", + "LAO site search: young child tax credit; CalEITC", + "FTB index scan: assembly-bill-analyses.html and senate-bill-analyses.html (2023-24 and 2025-26 sessions) filtered for child, EITC, dependent, family and poverty bills" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/research/stats/expenditure-reports/fy27ter.pdf", + "https://www.tax.ny.gov/data/stats/ter/fiscal-year27/", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy26/ex/ter/fy26ter.pdf", + "https://www.tax.ny.gov/data/stats/ter/fiscal-year26/", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/ter/index.html", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy26/ex/book/revenueactions.pdf", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/ex/book/revenueactions.pdf", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy26/en/index.html", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy26/en/fy26fp-en.pdf", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy26/ex/index.html", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/en/index.html", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/en/fy27fp-en.pdf", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/ex/index.html", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/ex/fp/fy27fp-ex.pdf", + "https://www.budget.ny.gov/pubs/archive/fy27/ex/ero/fy27ero.pdf", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/issues/blue-book", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/sites/default/files/admin/structure/media/manage/filefile/a/2025-02/bluebook-2025.pdf", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/sites/default/files/admin/structure/media/manage/filefile/a/2026-01/bluebook_2026-edit_0.pdf", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2026/new-york-state-senate-advances-2026-one-house-budget-resolution", + "https://nyassembly.gov/Reports/WAM/AssemblyBudgetProposal/2025/2025AssemblySummary.pdf", + "https://nyassembly.gov/Reports/WAM/AssemblyBudgetProposal/2026/2026AssemblySummary.pdf", + "https://nyassembly.gov/Reports/WAM/2025yellow/pdfs/yellow_book_2025.pdf", + "https://nyassembly.gov/Reports/WAM/2025summary_changes/summary_2025.pdf", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/S9077", + "https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2025/A10126", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/S277", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2023/A3226", + "https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/S367", + "https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2025/A1972", + "https://otda.ny.gov/cprac/reports/CPRAC-2024-Recommendations-and-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/cprac/reports/CPRAC-2025-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://www.otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2025-02-26/attachments/2025-02-26-CPRAC-2025-2026-Executive-Budget.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/assembly-bill-analyses.html", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/senate-bill-analyses.html", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/AB397-020325.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/AB1690-020326.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/AB1690-041326.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2023-2024/AB2977-032124-042424.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2023-2024/AB1128-021523.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/AB398-020425.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2023-2024/AB1498-042623.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/SB1144-021826.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/tax-pros/law/legislation/2025-2026/AB2591-022026.pdf", + "https://arev.assembly.ca.gov/media/898", + "https://arev.assembly.ca.gov/media/828", + "https://arev.assembly.ca.gov/system/files/2026-04/ab-1690.pdf", + "https://dof.ca.gov/forecasting/revenue-and-taxation/tax-expenditure-reports/", + "https://dof.ca.gov/media/docs/forecasting/revenue-and-taxation/tax-expenditure-reports/2025-26-Tax-Expenditure-Report.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report-2024.pdf", + "https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/data-reports-plans/California-Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-and-Young-Child-Tax-credit-Report.pdf", + "https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Detail/3417", + "https://lao.ca.gov/handouts/state_admin/2022/2022-Update-on-the-CalEITC-100322.pdf", + "https://lao.ca.gov/handouts/Conf_Comm/2019/CalEITC-053019.pdf" + ], + "claims": [ + "ny_dependent_exemptions_tax_expenditure_2026" + ], + "note": "New York: the FY2027 tax expenditure report's 2026 estimate for the dependent exemption is staged; the FY2026 report gives 271.9 ($m) for tax year 2025. No New York estimate of a $2,000 young-child ESCC was found: the Division of the Budget's $471m and $825m are for the enacted 2025 enhancement, which is the dashboard's baseline, and the Senate bills (S277 of 2023, S9077) list fiscal implications as to be determined. California: no Franchise Tax Board, LAO or Department of Finance estimate of a $2,000 Young Child Tax Credit or a 100% CalEITC adjustment factor; FTB revenue estimates exist for cousins (AB 397, AB 1690, AB 2977 and AB 1128 widen YCTC eligibility; AB 398 and AB 1498 add a CalEITC minimum credit). Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "[WebSearch extended] state-level child poverty effects of the expanded child tax credit simulation journal article", + "[WebSearch] child tax credit child poverty by state simulation working paper TRIM3 OR \"Supplemental Poverty Measure\" state estimates", + "[WebSearch] universal child allowance $3,000 per child poverty simulation journal", + "[WebSearch] restoring 2021 expanded child tax credit 2025 2026 child poverty projection paper", + "[WebSearch] \"Targeted Child Tax Credit\" Parolin state governments child poverty TANF California New York", + "[WebSearch] \"How Do State Child Tax Credits Affect Employment and Poverty\" Unrath Goldin Homonoff Michelmore", + "[WebSearch extended] California Young Child Tax Credit poverty effect simulation study California Poverty Measure", + "[WebSearch] CalEITC poverty reduction simulation increase CalEITC child poverty estimate", + "[WebSearch] Empire State Child Credit expansion child poverty simulation New York children under 4 $1,000", + "[WebSearch] Bastian \"How Would a Permanent 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion Affect Poverty and Employment\"", + "[WebSearch] Jacob Bastian permanent 2021 child tax credit poverty employment working paper pdf 367,000 parents 28 percent", + "[WebSearch] \"Working Parents Tax Relief Act\" EITC young children poverty", + "[WebSearch] EITC increase for parents of young children under 4 poverty simulation paper", + "[WebSearch] New York State child poverty reduction simulation working paper Empire State Child Credit Working Families Tax Credit academic", + "[WebSearch] RSF Russell Sage Foundation Journal 2026 tax-based safety net issue state child tax credits poverty", + "[WebSearch] \"child tax credit\" \"by state\" child poverty \"American Community Survey\" simulation working paper SPM 2024 OR 2025", + "[WebSearch] One Big Beautiful Bill child tax credit $2,200 child poverty effect working paper 2026 restore 2021 CTC", + "[WebSearch, NOT RUN: session budget hit 200/200] California Policy Lab Young Child Tax Credit analysis poverty CalEITC expansion simulation", + "[WebSearch, NOT RUN: budget] Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality California Poverty Measure child tax credit simulation expanded 2021 California children lifted", + "[WebSearch, NOT RUN: budget] \"Lifting Children and Families Out of Poverty\" task force California report simulation CalEITC young child tax credit Hoynes", + "[OpenAlex] child tax credit child poverty state (2020+)", + "[OpenAlex] state child tax credit poverty simulation", + "[OpenAlex] child allowance poverty simulation", + "[OpenAlex] young child tax credit California", + "[OpenAlex] Empire State Child Credit (no relevant hits)", + "[OpenAlex] CalEITC poverty", + "[OpenAlex] \"California Poverty Measure\" (no relevant hits)", + "[OpenAlex] \"Young Child Tax Credit\"", + "[OpenAlex] \"Working Parents Tax Relief Act\" (0 hits)", + "[OpenAlex] \"American Family Act\" poverty", + "[OpenAlex] \"New York\" child poverty simulation tax credit", + "[OpenAlex] earned income tax credit young children poverty simulation", + "[OpenAlex] dependent exemption state income tax child poverty", + "[OpenAlex] child allowance state poverty simulation United States", + "[OpenAlex] TRIM3 child tax credit poverty", + "[OpenAlex] Supplemental Poverty Measure state child tax credit simulation", + "[OpenAlex] expanded child tax credit California child poverty", + "[OpenAlex] How Would a Permanent 2021 Child Tax Credit Expansion Affect Poverty and Employment", + "[OpenAlex journal filter, 'child tax credit', 2021+] ANNALS of the AAPSS; Socius; Demography; JPAM; Social Service Review; National Tax Journal; RSF; Journal of Children and Poverty", + "[OpenAlex author filter] Jessica Pac (child); Zachary Parolin (child tax credit); Sophie M. Collyer (poverty)", + "[NBER API] child tax credit poverty; state child tax credit; child allowance; California earned income tax credit; child poverty simulation", + "[OSF API] preprints/3b2nq (Parolin replication: do-files only); guids/mcbta (White, Xu, Hamad, Parolin 2026 state CTC project: no results)", + "[Semantic Scholar API] DOI:10.1002/pam.70026 (openAccessPdf = Wiley, blocked); batch abstracts -> 429", + "[Europe PMC API] PMC7194072 supplementaryFiles; PMC6145823 fullTextXML", + "[WebSearch] child tax credit child poverty by state simulation working paper TRIM3 OR \"Supplemental Poverty Measure\" state estimates (surfaced NASEM 2026 Pathways report)", + "[curl] nationalacademies.org/read/29163 chapters 1,10,11 (2026 Pathways)", + "[curl] nationalacademies.org/read/25246 chapters 1,7,8,9,17 (2019 Roadmap)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/pam.70026", + "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1002/pam.70026", + "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/pam.70026", + "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/pam.70026", + "https://osf.io/3b2nq", + "https://www.zachparolin.com/research", + "https://iris.unibocconi.it/simple-search?query=%22Targeted+Child+Tax+Credit%22", + "https://hdl.handle.net/11565/4069836", + "https://api.osf.io/v2/guids/mcbta/", + "https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pandp.20261088", + "https://wagner.nyu.edu/files/faculty/publications/Unrath-Tollett-Goldin-Homonoff-Lal-and-Michelmore-2026.pdf", + "https://www.openicpsr.org/openicpsr/project/248241/version/V1/view", + "https://academic.oup.com/cpn/article/39/1/1/8658559", + "https://sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0190740919313209", + "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7194072/", + "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/instance/7194072/bin/mmc1.pdf", + "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC7194072/supplementaryFiles", + "https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/728703", + "https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/728703", + "https://ideas.repec.org/a/ucp/nattax/doi10.1086-728703.html", + "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29366/w29366.pdf", + "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29342/w29342.pdf", + "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w32343/w32343.pdf", + "https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/665380DF301F990D8FDB06A7BB3D5BD9/S219458882200015Xa.pdf/div-class-title-the-benefits-and-costs-of-a-child-allowance-div.pdf", + "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC6145823/fullTextXML", + "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00027162241272312", + "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00027162241260581", + "https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1177/00027162231205148", + "https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1177/00027162241272312", + "https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1002/pam.70096", + "https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1086/723219", + "https://api.openalex.org/works/doi:10.1177/23780231221141165", + "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29285/w29285.pdf", + "https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Supporting_children_and_incentivizing_employment_July2026.pdf", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/1", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/2", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/3", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/10", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/11", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/29163/chapter/21", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/1", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/7", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/8", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/9", + "https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/17", + "https://nap.nationalacademies.org/read/25246/chapter/1", + "https://www.hamiltonproject.org/publication/paper/the-antipoverty-effects-of-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-across-states/", + "https://www.hamiltonproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/20230301_ES_THP_CTCbyState.pdf", + "https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-antipoverty-effects-of-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-across-states-where-were-the-historic-reductions-felt/", + "https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2023/beyond-bls/state-level-effects-of-the-expandedhi-cld-tax-credit.htm" + ], + "claims": [ + "garfinkel_arpa_allowance_net_cost_us_2018" + ], + "note": "Staged: Garfinkel et al. (2022), national, because the dashboard's own prior file names it (priors.yaml cites its NBER version, w29854, for about $97bn a year); its poverty figure restates CPSP and is not staged. The prior file's '~50% child-poverty reduction' for an income-tested allowance names no document (Garfinkel et al. cite CPSP 2020 for 45%, a restatement). Its other sources are not estimates of a reform (the Census-measured fall in child poverty from 2020 to 2021) or are staged under cpsp ('Columbia CPSP 2021 (~43%)'). No paper from the last five years gives a California or New York estimate of the seven reforms. Parolin (2025, JPAM) models a state-funded targeted CTC, a design that is none of the seven; its abstract reports results for the average state and says every state could fund it, and the full text (publisher 403) may hold state rows. National cousins: Bastian (2024), Corinth et al. (NBER w29366), Goldin, Maag and Michelmore (NBER w29342), Shaefer et al. (2018), the National Academies' 2019 Roadmap and 2026 Pathways. The Hamilton Project (2023) reports the 2021 CTC by groups of states, not single states. PPIC's 2021 estimate, also seen here, is logged under open_search. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "[WebSearch extended] California Young Child Tax Credit poverty effect simulation study California Poverty Measure", + "[archive.org availability API] ppic.org blog and publication URLs", + "PPIC expanded child tax credit California child poverty California Poverty Measure", + "PPIC \"child tax credit\" restore California children lifted out of poverty estimate", + "PPIC report policy options reduce child poverty California Young Child Tax Credit CalEITC simulation", + "ppic.org \"child tax credit\" \"child poverty\" California 2025 expanded credit would", + "PPIC \"Fewer California Adults and Far Fewer Children Are in Poverty in 2021\" child tax credit", + "PPIC child allowance California poverty simulation universal child benefit", + "PPIC blog Young Child Tax Credit poverty California 2024 2025 expansion would reduce child poverty", + "PPIC \"Poverty in California\" fact sheet 2025 child tax credit child poverty", + "PPIC CalEITC poverty effect report \"CalEITC\" \"Young Child Tax Credit\" simulate increase", + "Wayback CDX ppic.org/blog/* and ppic.org/publication/* filtered for tax-credit/eitc/ctc/child-poverty", + "Niskanen Center Family Security Act child allowance state child poverty estimates by state (WebSearch NOT executed: budget exhausted)", + "WP REST search niskanencenter.org: child tax credit state; Family Security Act; child allowance cost benefit; state-by-state; California child tax credit; Working Parents Tax Relief; child poverty by state; American Family Act; net benefit; economic benefits child tax credit state; billion net benefit; Biden child credit; Biden child allowance analysis", + "New York dependent exemption eliminate revenue Empire State Child Credit proposal $1,000 exemption", + "New York Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council recommendations Empire State Child Credit modeling child poverty reduction", + "Wayback CDX otda.ny.gov/cprac/reports/*", + "New York Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council recommendations Empire State Child Credit modeling child poverty reduction (surfaced on otda.ny.gov)", + "Fiscal Policy Institute Empire State Child Credit expansion child poverty estimate", + "Fiscal Policy Institute New York child tax credit 2025 analysis cost poverty fiscalpolicy.org", + "WP REST search fiscalpolicy.org: child tax credit poverty; dependent exemption", + "Robin Hood Poverty Tracker child tax credit restore expanded New York child poverty estimate", + "Raising New York Empire State Child Credit babies toddlers under 4 child poverty estimate", + "Citizens' Committee for Children New York Empire State Child Credit $1,500 report child poverty reduction estimate", + "WP REST search cccnewyork.org: child tax credit poverty; dependent exemption", + "Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality California Poverty Measure child tax credit expansion estimate", + "Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality targeted child tax credit California 450,000 children $2.4 billion", + "Lifting Children and Families Out of Poverty Task Force report California 2018 targeted child tax credit estimate poverty reduction", + "Economic Security California child tax credit state estimate poverty children lifted proposal", + "WP REST search economicsecurityproject.org and economicsecurity.us: child tax credit poverty; Young Child Tax Credit; Working Parents Tax Relief Act; child allowance poverty", + "site crawl mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/media/press-releases?page=1..13 (titles containing tax/EITC/child/families)", + "California Budget & Policy Center Young Child Tax Credit increase child poverty estimate", + "calbudgetcenter.org child tax credit permanent California \"613,000\" children poverty", + "California Budget & Policy Center CalEITC Young Child Tax Credit expansion poverty analysis 2025 federal CTC One Big Beautiful Bill California families", + "WP REST search calbudgetcenter.org: child tax credit poverty; Young Child Tax Credit", + "California Budget & Policy Center Young Child Tax Credit increase child poverty estimate (surfaced CSBA)", + "\"Young Child Tax Credit\" \"$2,000\" California proposal increase cost poverty", + "Schuyler Center Empire State Child Credit expansion children lifted out of poverty estimate 2025", + "WP REST search scaany.org: child tax credit poverty; dependent exemption", + "Community Service Society New York Empire State Child Credit child poverty analysis expansion estimate", + "Fiscal Policy Institute Empire State Child Credit expansion child poverty estimate (surfaced rockinst.org)", + "WP REST search raisingnewyork.org: child tax credit poverty; dependent exemption", + "Empire Center Empire State Child Credit expansion cost analysis", + "WP REST search empirecenter.org: child tax credit poverty; dependent exemption", + "Citizens Budget Commission New York dependent exemption child tax credit reform revenue", + "WP REST search cbcny.org (403 Cloudflare)", + "Golden State Opportunity CalEITC Young Child Tax Credit expansion poverty estimate report", + "WP REST search goldenstateopportunity.org: child tax credit poverty; Young Child Tax Credit", + "End Child Poverty in California GRACE plan child tax credit Young Child Tax Credit increase estimate children lifted", + "WP REST search endchildpovertyca.org: child tax credit poverty; Young Child Tax Credit", + "California Policy Lab CalEITC Young Child Tax Credit analysis poverty impact simulation", + "WP REST search capolicylab.org", + "Children Now California child tax credit child poverty estimate restore expanded federal credit California children", + "WP REST search childrennow.org (403)", + "Center for American Progress child tax credit state fact sheet California New York children lifted out of poverty expanded (WebSearch NOT executed: budget exhausted)", + "Wayback CDX americanprogress.org/article/* filtered child-tax-credit", + "People's Policy Project child allowance $3,000 per child poverty reduction estimate cost (WebSearch NOT executed: budget exhausted)", + "WP REST search firstfocus.org: child tax credit California; Working Parents Tax Relief Act; child allowance poverty", + "WP REST search childrensdefense.org: child tax credit California; Working Parents Tax Relief Act; child allowance poverty", + "WP REST search aecf.org (403)", + "WP REST search bipartisanpolicy.org (403)", + "WP REST search aei.org (403)", + "WP REST search pgpf.org: child tax credit poverty; Young Child Tax Credit", + "Wayback CDX delbene.house.gov/uploadedfiles/*", + "bennet.senate.gov AFA page", + "(covered by search-academic)" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20241007135504/https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-reduces-child-poverty/", + "https://www.ppic.org/publication/geography-of-child-poverty-in-california/", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20250725014339/https://www.ppic.org/blog/fewer-california-adults-and-far-fewer-children-are-in-poverty-in-2021/", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20260118003308/https://www.ppic.org/blog/steep-declines-in-child-poverty-have-been-driven-by-safety-net-programs/", + "http://web.archive.org/web/20250725042857/https://www.ppic.org/blog/testimony-the-role-of-state-tax-credits-in-helping-low-income-families/", + "https://wedrawthelines.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/64/2023/01/Bohn__Sarah_et_al.__Poverty_in_California__Public_Policy_Institute_of_California_July_2021.pdf", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/steep-declines-in-child-poverty-have-been-driven-by-safety-net-programs/", + "https://www.ppic.org/interactive/interactive-reducing-child-poverty-in-california/", + "https://www.ppic.org/publication/reducing-child-poverty-in-california-a-look-at-housing-costs-wages-and-the-safety-net/", + "https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/r_1117sbr.pdf", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/tax-hurdles-may-limit-impact-of-the-expanded-child-tax-credit/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/an-in-depth-look-at-californias-poverty-trends-over-time/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/how-did-the-pandemic-transform-californias-safety-net/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/refundable-tax-credits-ease-poverty-in-california/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/interactive-a-look-at-child-poverty-across-california/", + "https://www.ppic.org/publication/poverty-in-california/", + "https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/JTF_PovertyJTF.pdf", + "https://www.ppic.org/publication/understanding-the-reach-of-the-california-earned-income-tax-credit/", + "https://www.ppic.org/publication/evaluating-state-eitc-options-for-california/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/testimony-the-role-of-state-tax-credits-in-helping-low-income-families/", + "https://www.ppic.org/blog/child-poverty-and-californias-high-cost-of-living/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/factsheet-senator-romneys-family-security-act/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Analysis-of-the-Romney-Child-Allowance_final.pdf", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/analysis-of-the-family-security-act-2-0/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/new-yorks-proposed-working-family-tax-credit-is-the-boldest-reform-yet/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/a-child-allowance-could-be-worth-eight-times-the-costs/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/the-american-family-act-child-poverty/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/niskanens-work-on-the-child-tax-credit/", + "https://otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/reports/CPRAC-2024-Recommendations-and-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/CPRAC/reports/CPRAC-2025-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2025-02-26/attachments/2025-02-26-CPRAC-2025-2026-Executive-Budget.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/attachments/2023-01-12-CPRAC-Reforming-Child-Credit.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/CPRAC/2024-11-19/attachments/2024-11-19-2024-CPRAC-Progress-Report.pdf", + "https://www.otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2023-11-20/attachments/2023-11-20-CPRAC-Presentation.pdf", + "https://otda.ny.gov/news/meetings/cprac/2023-12-06/attachments/2023-12-06-CPRAC-Presentation.pdf", + "https://fiscalpolicy.org/reworking-new-york-states-family-tax-credits", + "https://www.scaany.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/3-Bills_EITCs-and-ESCC_2019.pdf", + "https://fiscalpolicy.org/inequality-in-new-york-options-for-progressive-tax-reform", + "https://robinhood.org/reports/poverty-tracker-spotlight-2025-annual-cprac/", + "https://www.robinhood.org/dont-wait-on-washington-child-care-nys/", + "https://robinhood.org/?p=2320", + "https://robinhood.org/news/state-budget-poverty-leading-nyc-anti-poverty-organization-robin-hood-releases-memo-outlining-measures-to-fight-poverty-through-new-yorks-fy24-budget/", + "https://robinhood.org/?p=9713", + "https://cccnewyork.org/press-and-media/how-much-should-the-empire-state-child-credit-offer-families", + "https://cccnewyork.org/data-publications/tax-policy-changes-that-will-reduce-child-poverty-in-nys/", + "https://cccnewyork.org/strengthening-tax-credits-for-ny-families-will-reduce-child-poverty/", + "https://cccnewyork.org/data-publications/tax-credit-reform-can-impact-child-poverty-in-new-york-state/", + "https://cccnewyork.org/press-and-media/hochul-budget-must-expand-empire-state-child-tax-credit-to-better-support-families-with-children-and-reduce-racial-disparities-in-child-poverty/", + "https://inequality.stanford.edu/node/7884", + "https://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/reports-briefs/other-reports-and-briefs/introduction-of-caleitc", + "https://inequality.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/EITC-california.pdf", + "https://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/reports-briefs/other-reports-and-briefs/policy-brief-series-california-hr1", + "https://cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/CDSS-Programs/Poverty-Task-Force", + "https://cdss.ca.gov/Portals/9/CalWORKs/AB1520%20-%20Final%20Report.pdf?ver=2018-11-19-145600-677", + "https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2018.1/WorkGroups/ACCP/Reports%20and%20Resources/W~CALIFORNIA%20LIFTING%20CHILDREN%20AND%20FAMILIES%20OUT%20OF%20POVERTY%20TASK%20FORCE~Recommendations%20to%20the%20California%20Legislature~11-27-2018.pdf", + "https://economicsecurity.us/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Copy-of-CA-CTC-State-Factsheets-June-2023Final.pdf", + "https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/state-child-tax-credits-and-child-poverty-a-50-state-analysis/", + "https://mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/media/press-releases", + "https://mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/media/press-releases/congresswoman-mcdonald-rivet-introduces-bill-cut-taxes-working-families", + "https://mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/media/press-releases/icymi-congresswoman-mcdonald-rivet-introduces-game-changing-tax-cut-working", + "https://mcdonaldrivet.house.gov/issues/working-parents-tax-relief-act", + "https://calbudgetcenter.org/news/ending-child-poverty-is-a-choice-we-can-make/", + "https://calbudgetcenter.org/news/ending-child-poverty-is-a-choice-we-can-make-2/", + "https://calbudgetcenter.org/resources/lowest-income-californians-lose-as-federal-child-tax-credit-expansion-ends/", + "https://calbudgetcenter.org/resources/expanding-the-young-child-tax-credit-would-help-more-families-afford-basic-needs/", + "https://calbudgetcenter.org/resources/strengthening-the-child-tax-credit-to-support-families-and-reduce-poverty/", + "https://blog.csba.org/tackling-child-poverty/", + "https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/california-bill-97-billion-surplus-expand-child-tax-credit-lowest-income-families/", + "https://calmatters.org/california-divide/2022/04/per-child-payment/", + "https://www.capradio.org/articles/2023/04/22/california-bills-to-expand-state-tax-credits-could-send-1-billion-to-low-income-families", + "https://scaany.org/2025-budget-win-for-families-expansion-of-new-yorks-child-tax-credit/", + "https://scaany.org/2026-end-of-session-roundup/", + "https://scaany.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Memo-in-Support-Working-Family-Tax-Credit-02282024.pdf", + "https://scaany.org/resource/schuyler-center-report-finds-child-poverty-remains-high-in-ny-and-that-tax-credits-can-help/", + "https://scaany.org/resource/strong-refundable-tax-credits-to-end-child-poverty/", + "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/news/2025/03/31/schuyler-center-for-analysis-and-advocacy-on-tax-credit-and-child-care-in-the-budget", + "https://www.cssny.org/news/entry/state-lawmakers-must-increase-expand-child-tax-credit", + "https://rockinst.org/blog/expanding-the-empire-state-child-credit-considering-the-research-context-and-potential-outcomes/", + "https://raisingnewyork.org/2022/09/15/despite-significant-child-poverty-new-york-lags-behind-other-states-in-providing-tax-credit-relief-to-families-of-young-children/", + "https://raisingnewyork.org/2024/02/15/poverty-reduction-and-working-families-tax-credit-advocacy-continues/", + "https://www.empirecenter.org/publications/testimony-fy2021-new-york-state-budget-taxes/", + "https://www.empirecenter.org/publications/hochuls-pushing-affordability-it-would-cost-a-lot/", + "https://cbcny.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search", + "https://www.tax.ny.gov/data/stats/ter/fiscal-year27/executive-budget-tax-expenditure-proposals.htm", + "https://www.goldenstateopportunity.org/news/16-million-children-will-benefit-from-the-child-tax-credit-expansion-lifting-500000-children-out-of-poverty/", + "https://www.goldenstateopportunity.org/blog/poverty-responds-to-policy-we-can-choose-differently/", + "https://www.endchildpovertyca.org/ab-1996-bonta-advancing-the-no-more-child-poverty-act-in-california/", + "https://www.endchildpovertyca.org/release-senator-susan-rubios-bill-champions-young-child-tax-credit-expansion/", + "https://www.endchildpovertyca.org/californias-poverty-rates-remain-unacceptably-high-in-2025-but-policymakers-have-the-choice-to-lift-children-and-families-out-of-poverty/", + "https://www.endchildpovertyca.org/take-action-support-the-targeted-child-tax-credit-endchildpoverty-passtheplan/", + "https://capolicylab.org/how-the-expanded-child-tax-credit-helped-california-families/", + "https://www.childrennow.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/interactive-enhancing-the-child-tax-credit-would-substantially-lessen-the-depth-of-child-poverty-across-states/", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/harnessing-state-child-tax-credits-will-dramatically-reduce-child-poverty/", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/expanded-child-tax-credit-lift-millions-children-poverty/", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/child-tax-credit-will-keep-millions-children-poverty/", + "https://www.americanprogress.org/article/making-ctc-eitc-expansions-permanent-reduce-poverty-grow-economy/", + "https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/projects/family-fun-pack/", + "https://firstfocus.org/resource/tackling-poverty-through-the-implementation-of-a-child-allowance-program/", + "https://www.childrensdefense.org/blog/latest-child-allowance-proposals/", + "https://womenandinequality.senate.ca.gov/sites/womenandinequality.senate.ca.gov/files/end_child_poverty_now_california_rev.pdf", + "https://childrensdefense.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Joint-Statement-on-ESCC-April-27-2023.pdf", + "https://www.aecf.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search", + "https://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search", + "https://www.aei.org/wp-json/wp/v2/search", + "https://www.pgpf.org/article/what-is-the-child-tax-credit/", + "https://delbene.house.gov/uploadedfiles/american_family_act_one_pager.pdf", + "https://delbene.house.gov/uploadedfiles/ctc_fact_sheet.pdf", + "https://www.bennet.senate.gov/american-family-act/" + ], + "claims": [ + "ppic_arpa_ctc_child_poverty_pct_ca_2018" + ], + "note": "PPIC (California Poverty Measure, 2018 data) is staged. Seen, not staged: PPIC's October 2022 post says 'The temporary 2021 federal advance Child Tax Credit (CTC), which provided monthly payments to most families with children, moved 380,000 children out of poverty' (fall 2021, CPM) without saying whether it counts the whole credit or the advance payments, or against what; Niskanen's February 2021 Romney analysis prints California child-poverty counts under the ARPA design (1,567,098 to 1,083,757; the change is not printed); PPIC's 2017 CalEITC and child-credit scenarios (other designs); New York's Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council (Urban-modelled ESCC designs, logged under urban); FPI 2019; the Robin Hood, CCC, CSS, Schuyler Center, California Budget & Policy Center, CSBA, Economic Security Project and Rep. McDonald Rivet pages, which restate other producers; press-reported California bill costs for YCTC and CalEITC cousins. Not readable (HTTP 403): Citizens Budget Commission, Annie E. Casey, Bipartisan Policy Center, AEI, Children Now. Some planned web searches could not run because the session's web-search allowance ran out; the producer's own site search, sitemaps and Internet Archive indexes were used instead." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:b3066c11ca45a7e366cb7ef88ca8463f9ae6f97031f56eaa6883a92da32a576b", + "PolicyEngine/child-poverty-impact-dashboard@d918ca2b84b65525743aaf30f4ce4e0af23922ab:bd4b4bf4403e4301fb0c1209764d93fe5932b2f8323c22a88a6800d5e6caab35" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/README.md b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/README.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f13ee5191 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +# FUTA taxable wage base dashboard: comparables record + +A backfill under the pre-publish comparables gate (docs/COMPARABLES.md). The dashboard was +published on 17 September 2026, before the gate existed. This is its first search, run on +21 October 2026 across every US producer. + +## Published figures + +The estimates are pinned in `analysis.json`. They cover FUTA revenue from raising the taxable +wage base from $7,000 to $43,000 in 2026 and indexing it to the CPI-U, at the unchanged 0.6% +net rate. They count the FUTA line only, for calendar years 2026 to 2035. Every figure comes +from `PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard` at `72e3137`, the commit Vercel serves in +production. + +- **Two series per year.** Each year is pinned in both of the dashboard's series: + - The adjusted series the page leads with removes FUTA-exempt employers and applies one + wage base per employer. It is pinned from `analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv`, which + the page's CSV download reproduces byte for byte. + - The unadjusted model output is pinned from `frontend/lib/results.json`, the file the page + reads. +- **Ten-year totals.** The page's totals, $251.1 billion adjusted and $317.4 billion + unadjusted, are sums the page computes from the annual figures (`frontend/lib/data.ts`). + No file prints them, so each is pinned as that sum over the pinned file, and its + `derivation` condition says so. +- **Other figures.** The current-law FUTA revenue for the same years is pinned, along with + the fiscal-year figures for FY2024 and FY2025 in both series. + +## What the search found + +No producer has scored the dashboard's policy, a base near $43,000 at the 0.6% rate. The +nearest precedent is Kletzer and Rosen (Hamilton Project, 2006). They put a $45,000 base at +the then-current 0.8% net rate at $8.7 billion, with no year stated. It is logged under +`academic` and not staged. + +**Staged:** + +- **The Budget Lab at Yale** (November 2025, for the Niskanen Center) scores bases of $8,000 + to $14,000 for calendar 2026-35, net of an income-tax offset of about 25%. Its $14,000 rows + under each indexing rule are staged, with its decade baseline ("about $64B"). +- **CBO's budget options** raise the base to $40,000, index it to wages and cut the net rate + to 0.167%. CBO counts the state unemployment taxes that follow. Staged: + - the December 2018 option for FY2026 to FY2028, with its ten-year total; + - the December 2016 option for FY2026, with its ten-year total. +- **CBO's January 2025 baseline** gives FUTA revenue for FY2025 to FY2035. + +**Logged, not staged:** + +- Treasury's own estimate of the FY2017 budget's $40,000 proposal ($46.3 billion over + 2017-26) and CBO's estimate of the same proposal. Both are estimated after the budget's + permanent FUTA surtax, a baseline `scorecard_db/baselines.py` does not register (harvest + rule 7). Their primaries are hashed in `manifest.jsonl`. The `open_search` entry records + Treasury's hold and the `cbo` entry records CBO's. +- The Searchlight Institute's "north of $250 billion" (8 October 2026), which restates this + dashboard. + +## The comparison + +One claim is compared: CBO's January 2025 projection of FY2025 FUTA revenue, $8.461 billion. +The dashboard's unadjusted fiscal-year figure for FY2025 is $8.493 billion, which puts the gap +at +0.4%. The comparison is `constructed`, and its annotation states what differs: + +- The dashboard builds its fiscal-year figure from calendar-year liability to sit beside gross + collections. +- CBO's series matches collections net of refunds. +- CBO's figure is a projection. +- The adjusted fiscal-year figure is 13.7% below CBO. + +The other claims have no like-for-like counterpart: + +- The Budget Lab's $14,000 rows score a different policy. Each year sits beside the + dashboard's adjusted estimate for that year, and each budget window beside its adjusted + ten-year total, labelled `concept_mismatch`. +- CBO's options score a different policy, on fiscal years. +- CBO's FY2026-FY2035 baseline projections are fiscal-year collections. For those years the + dashboard publishes only calendar-year liability without surcharges. +- The Budget Lab's baseline is a decade total. + +No gap is over the threshold. + +## Registry note + +The apps.json description still gives "$317 billion over ten years", the unadjusted total. +Since PR #6 (17 September 2026), the page has led with the adjusted $251.1 billion. + +## Primaries + +The primaries are hashed in `manifest.jsonl`. cbo.gov blocks scripted fetches, so its files +came from Wayback Machine captures, recorded as the `wayback_snapshot` on each line. The Budget +Lab PDF has no text layer, so its rows were read from a 300 dpi render. diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2fd8e58e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,1734 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "country": "US", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "country_id": "us" + }, + "title": "FUTA taxable wage base dashboard", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "published": "2026-09-17", + "owner": { + "author": "david-trimmer" + }, + "scope": "federal", + "subject": "Federal revenue from raising the FUTA taxable wage base from $7,000 to $43,000 in 2026 and indexing it to the CPI-U, with the 0.6% net rate unchanged: the additional FUTA revenue by calendar year 2026-2035, adjusted (the headline, $251.1 billion over ten years) and unadjusted ($317.4 billion), counting the FUTA line only; the model's current-law FUTA revenue; and its fiscal-year validation against IRS collections for FY2024 and FY2025.", + "search_terms": [ + "FUTA wage base increase revenue", + "raise FUTA taxable wage base CBO", + "unemployment insurance wage base revenue estimate", + "FUTA reform score", + "federal unemployment tax wage base $40,000 index wage growth", + "index the FUTA wage base inflation revenue", + "FUTA revenue projections" + ], + "worlds": { + "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed": { + "policy": "us_futa_wage_base_43000_2026_cpiu_indexed", + "description": "The dashboard's reform: the FUTA taxable wage base raised from $7,000 to $43,000 in 2026 and, from 2027, set to $43,000 times the prior calendar year's average CPI-U over the 2025 average, rounded to the nearest $100 ($53,200 in 2035); the 6.0% rate and the 5.4% maximum state credit (0.6% net) unchanged." + }, + "cbo_2016_option_futa_base_40000": { + "policy": "us_cbo_2016_option_futa_base_40000_2017_wage_indexed_net_rate_0167", + "description": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026, Revenues Option 24, second alternative: the FUTA wage base raised to $40,000 in January 2017 and indexed to wage growth, the net FUTA rate cut from 0.6% to 0.167%; states must raise their own wage bases to at least $40,000." + }, + "cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000": { + "policy": "us_cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000_2019_wage_indexed_net_rate_0167", + "description": "CBO, Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028, Revenues Option 23: the FUTA wage base raised to $40,000 in January 2019 and indexed to wage growth, the net FUTA rate cut from 0.6% to 0.167%; states must raise their own wage bases to at least $40,000." + }, + "futa_base_14000_unindexed": { + "policy": "us_futa_wage_base_14000_2026_unindexed", + "description": "The Budget Lab's largest option: the FUTA wage base raised to $14,000 in 2026 and not indexed, at the 0.6% net rate." + }, + "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed": { + "policy": "us_futa_wage_base_14000_2026_chained_cpiu_indexed", + "description": "The Budget Lab: the FUTA wage base raised to $14,000 in 2026 and indexed to the chained CPI-U, at the 0.6% net rate." + }, + "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed": { + "policy": "us_futa_wage_base_14000_2026_awi_indexed", + "description": "The Budget Lab: the FUTA wage base raised to $14,000 in 2026 and indexed to SSA's average wage index, at the 0.6% net rate." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [ + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2026", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 20789010864.0, + "value_raw": "20789010864", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2026", + "wage_base": "$43,000", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2026, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2026", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2026", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 26445727221.164425, + "value_raw": "26445727221.164425", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2026", + "wage_base": "$43,000", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2026].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2027", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 21860102981.0, + "value_raw": "21860102981", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2027", + "wage_base": "$44,400", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2027, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2027", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2027", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 27775809923.729805, + "value_raw": "27775809923.729805", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2027", + "wage_base": "$44,400", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2027].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2028", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 22757333989.0, + "value_raw": "22757333989", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2028", + "wage_base": "$45,400", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2028, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2028", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2028", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 28871786578.340942, + "value_raw": "28871786578.340942", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2028", + "wage_base": "$45,400", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2028].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2029", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 23687523829.0, + "value_raw": "23687523829", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2029", + "wage_base": "$46,500", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2029, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2029", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2029", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 30010764288.81463, + "value_raw": "30010764288.81463", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2029", + "wage_base": "$46,500", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2029].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2030", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 24625256580.0, + "value_raw": "24625256580", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2030", + "wage_base": "$47,600", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2030, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2030", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2030", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 31157727278.0039, + "value_raw": "31157727278.0039", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2030", + "wage_base": "$47,600", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2030].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2031", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 25527109672.0, + "value_raw": "25527109672", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2031", + "wage_base": "$48,600", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2031, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2031", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2031", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 32253147838.69234, + "value_raw": "32253147838.69234", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2031", + "wage_base": "$48,600", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2031].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2032", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 26474385586.0, + "value_raw": "26474385586", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2032", + "wage_base": "$49,700", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2032, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2032", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2032", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 33407766959.18235, + "value_raw": "33407766959.18235", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2032", + "wage_base": "$49,700", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2032].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2033", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 27472028832.0, + "value_raw": "27472028832", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2033", + "wage_base": "$50,900", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2033, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2033", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2033", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 34625856446.449615, + "value_raw": "34625856446.449615", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2033", + "wage_base": "$50,900", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2033].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2034", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 28440721078.0, + "value_raw": "28440721078", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2034", + "wage_base": "$52,000", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2034, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2034", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2034", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 35799969047.833305, + "value_raw": "35799969047.833305", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2034", + "wage_base": "$52,000", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2034].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), calendar 2035", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 29455438168.0, + "value_raw": "29455438168", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2035", + "wage_base": "$53,200", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2035, adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2035", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2035", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 37035407834.14354, + "value_raw": "37035407834.14354", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2035", + "wage_base": "$53,200", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2035].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2026", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 5917474348.0, + "value_raw": "5917474348", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2026", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2026, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2026", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2026", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2026, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6820184824.3903475, + "value_raw": "6820184824.3903475", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2026", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2026].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2027", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 5968918170.0, + "value_raw": "5968918170", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2027", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2027, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2027", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2027", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2027, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6870789894.265245, + "value_raw": "6870789894.265245", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2027", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2027].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2028", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6013031722.0, + "value_raw": "6013031722", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2028", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2028, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2028", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2028", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2028, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6913470019.150374, + "value_raw": "6913470019.150374", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2028", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2028].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2029", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6051080997.0, + "value_raw": "6051080997", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2029", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2029, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2029", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2029", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2029, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6949815158.545585, + "value_raw": "6949815158.545585", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2029", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2029].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2030", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6088111620.0, + "value_raw": "6088111620", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2030", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2030, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2030", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2030", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6984905249.686273, + "value_raw": "6984905249.686273", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2030", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2030].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2031", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6123762803.0, + "value_raw": "6123762803", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2031", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2031, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2031", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2031", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2031, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 7018646642.922077, + "value_raw": "7018646642.922077", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2031", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2031].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2032", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6158122935.0, + "value_raw": "6158122935", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2032", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2032, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2032", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2032", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2032, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 7050868168.878946, + "value_raw": "7050868168.878946", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2032", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2032].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2033", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6189028903.0, + "value_raw": "6189028903", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2033", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2033, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2033", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2033", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2033, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 7080321728.574486, + "value_raw": "7080321728.574486", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2033", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2033].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2034", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6217756724.0, + "value_raw": "6217756724", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2034", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2034, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2034", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2034", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2034, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 7107725250.240143, + "value_raw": "7107725250.240143", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2034", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2034].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, adjusted, calendar 2035", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 6245556391.0, + "value_raw": "6245556391", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2035", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "calendar_year=2035, adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "baseline_revenue_unadjusted_cy2035", + "label": "Current-law FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, calendar 2035", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_liability", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 7133790605.786127, + "value_raw": "7133790605.786127", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "2035", + "wage_base": "$7,000 (current law)", + "net_rate": "0.6% flat; credit-reduction surcharges not included", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "program": "futa", + "basis": "forecast", + "basis_note": "the model's current-law projection" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "results[year=2035].baseline_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, adjusted (headline), ten-year total, calendar 2026-2035", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 251088911579.0, + "value_raw": "251088911579", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "derivation": "sum of the file's ten annual figures; the page's TEN_YEAR_ADJUSTED (frontend/lib/data.ts) sums the same series unrounded, 251088911579.81, printed as $251.1B", + "file": "the page builds its CSV download from frontend/lib/results.json and frontend/lib/adjustments.json; frontend/__tests__/data.test.ts asserts it is this file byte for byte", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv", + "sha256": "e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "field": "sum over calendar_year=2026..2035 of adjusted_additional_revenue_usd", + "computed_at": "2026-09-17T16:32:38-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "additional_revenue_unadjusted_cy2026_2035", + "label": "Additional FUTA revenue, unadjusted model output, ten-year total, calendar 2026-2035", + "world": "futa_base_43000_cpi_indexed", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2035, + "time_basis": "annual", + "value": 317383963416.35486, + "value_raw": "317383963416.35486", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", + "window": "2026-2035", + "window_kind": "total", + "net_rate": "0.6%", + "basis": "static", + "scope": "FUTA line only (state unemployment taxes not counted)", + "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "derivation": "sum of the file's ten annual figures in year order, the page's TEN_YEAR_TOTAL (frontend/lib/data.ts), printed as $317.4B", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "static, no behavioural response, gross of any income or payroll tax offset" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "sum over results[year=2026..2035].additional_revenue_flat_06", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2024", + "label": "FUTA revenue on a fiscal-year basis, unadjusted model output, FY2024 (the validation cards)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7840065243.642772, + "value_raw": "7840065243.642772", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fiscal_year": "FY2024 (October 2023 to September 2024)", + "basis": "forecast", + "prior_year_surcharge": "2023 statutory credit-reduction rates applied to the 2024 wage distribution (the dataset has no 2023 weights)", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "flat 0.6% base tax for calendar 2024 plus the credit-reduction surcharge for calendar 2023, which employers pay with the fourth-quarter deposit the following January; built to sit beside IRS gross collections" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "validation[fiscal_year=2024].model_fiscal_year_basis", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "futa_collections_model_adjusted_fy2024", + "label": "FUTA revenue on a fiscal-year basis, adjusted, FY2024 (the page states it as a gap below IRS collections)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2024, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 6747188910.6393585, + "value_raw": "6747188910.6393585", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fiscal_year": "FY2024 (October 2023 to September 2024)", + "basis": "forecast", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "prior_year_surcharge": "2023 statutory credit-reduction rates applied to the 2024 wage distribution (the dataset has no 2023 weights)", + "published_as": "the page reads this file and prints the gap to IRS gross collections in whole percent ('17% below in fiscal 2024 and 2025'); gap_even_split_covered_wages = -0.1701", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "flat 0.6% base tax for calendar 2024 plus the credit-reduction surcharge for calendar 2023, which employers pay with the fourth-quarter deposit the following January; built to sit beside IRS gross collections" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/adjustments.json", + "sha256": "ebd2d43e12865e9f73265dd928ea23a22ef1e504066d327b669fd4d723423245", + "field": "validation[fiscal_year=2024].model_even_split_covered_wages", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T23:35:18-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025", + "label": "FUTA revenue on a fiscal-year basis, unadjusted model output, FY2025 (the validation cards)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 8493387632.705948, + "value_raw": "8493387632.705948", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fiscal_year": "FY2025 (October 2024 to September 2025)", + "basis": "forecast", + "prior_year_surcharge": "modeled", + "series": "unadjusted: model output, all wages, one wage base per worker", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "flat 0.6% base tax for calendar 2025 plus the credit-reduction surcharge for calendar 2024, which employers pay with the fourth-quarter deposit the following January; built to sit beside IRS gross collections" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/results.json", + "sha256": "6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "field": "validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_fiscal_year_basis", + "computed_at": "2026-09-15", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + }, + { + "key": "futa_collections_model_adjusted_fy2025", + "label": "FUTA revenue on a fiscal-year basis, adjusted, FY2025 (the page states it as a gap below IRS collections)", + "world": "baseline", + "metric": "tax_collections", + "unit_concept": "usd", + "period": 2025, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "value": 7301920494.985943, + "value_raw": "7301920494.985943", + "normalization": "as printed", + "conditions": { + "fiscal_year": "FY2025 (October 2024 to September 2025)", + "basis": "forecast", + "series": "adjusted: FUTA-exempt employers' wages removed and the wage base applied per employer (analysis/futa_adjustments.py, CPS ASEC 2023-2025 employer fields); the page's headline series", + "prior_year_surcharge": "modeled", + "published_as": "the page reads this file and prints the gap to IRS gross collections in whole percent ('17% below in fiscal 2024 and 2025'); gap_even_split_covered_wages = -0.1680", + "tax": "FUTA", + "sign_convention": "level", + "program": "futa", + "basis_note": "flat 0.6% base tax for calendar 2025 plus the credit-reduction surcharge for calendar 2024, which employers pay with the fourth-quarter deposit the following January; built to sit beside IRS gross collections" + }, + "provenance": { + "repo": "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "commit": "72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55", + "path": "frontend/lib/adjustments.json", + "sha256": "ebd2d43e12865e9f73265dd928ea23a22ef1e504066d327b669fd4d723423245", + "field": "validation[fiscal_year=2025].model_even_split_covered_wages", + "computed_at": "2026-09-16T23:35:18-04:00", + "engine": { + "policyengine": "6.0.0", + "policyengine_us": "2.2.1" + }, + "dataset": "populace-us-2024-spm-20260915" + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0c522f37a --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +[ + { + "id": "fiscal-year-futa-collections-construction", + "claims": [ + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025" + ], + "status": "constructed", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "The dashboard's fiscal-year figure is a construction: calendar-year FUTA liability at the flat 0.6% rate plus the prior calendar year's credit-reduction surcharge, built to sit beside IRS gross collections; the page notes that 'about a quarter of a calendar year's base tax is deposited after September 30'. CBO's series is not gross: its FY2024 actual, $8.005 billion, matches IRS collections net of refunds ($7.997 billion, from the dashboard's validation fields) to 0.1%, against $8.130 billion gross. CBO's FY2025 figure is its January 2025 projection; FY2025 collections came in at $8.777 billion gross and $8.628 billion net of refunds. The compared figure is the unadjusted series the page's validation cards show (+0.4% against CBO); the page says its closeness to collections 'reflects two errors that offset', and the adjusted fiscal-year figure, $7.302 billion, is -13.7% against CBO.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/app/(shell)/page.tsx#L540-L546" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/app/(shell)/page.tsx#L656-L661" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/lib/results.json" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/lib/adjustments.json" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "budget-lab-14000-net-of-offset", + "claims": [ + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "Different reforms and a different revenue concept. The Budget Lab scores FUTA bases of $8,000 to $14,000 (the $14,000 rows are staged: unindexed, indexed to the chained CPI-U and to SSA's average wage index), and its figures are net of an income-tax offset it puts at 'about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised'. The dashboard scores a $43,000 base indexed to the CPI-U ($53,200 by 2035), and its figures are gross of any such offset (its methodology: 'The figures here are gross of any such offset'). Each Budget Lab year sits beside the dashboard's adjusted estimate for the same calendar year, and each 2026-35 budget window beside the dashboard's adjusted ten-year total, so the scale is visible; no gap is computed between different reforms.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf#page=1" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf#page=2" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/app/(shell)/page.tsx#L795-L805" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "budget-lab-baseline-decade-total", + "claims": [ + "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "The Budget Lab's 'about $64B' is current-law FUTA revenue summed over calendar 2026-35; the nearest published estimate is the dashboard's current-law FUTA revenue for 2035 alone, so the two are a decade and a year. Summed over the same ten years, the pinned files give $61.0 billion adjusted (analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv adjusted_baseline_revenue_usd) and $69.9 billion unadjusted (frontend/lib/results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), -5% and +9% against $64B; the dashboard's baseline excludes credit-reduction surcharges, and the Budget Lab benchmarks its baseline to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf#page=2" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/analysis/futa_wage_base_estimates.csv" + }, + { + "kind": "engine_metadata", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/lib/results.json" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/app/(shell)/page.tsx#L535-L538" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "cbo-option-rate-cut-and-state-taxes", + "claims": [ + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", + "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", + "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026" + ], + "status": "concept_mismatch", + "explains_gap": false, + "cause": "CBO's options raise the base to $40,000, index it to wage growth and cut the net FUTA rate from 0.6% to 0.167%, and CBO counts the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, which the federal budget includes ('The initial rise would primarily be attributable to added proceeds from SUTA taxes'), net of the rate cuts it expects states to make; its years are fiscal years. The December 2018 volume adds that its estimates for options raising employer payroll contributions 'include an offset' for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U and counts the FUTA line only ('This dashboard counts only the FUTA line. A CBO score would also count the state base expansion and the state rate cuts CBO assumes in response') and is gross of any offset.", + "basis": [ + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf#page=274" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf#page=211" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf#page=187" + }, + { + "kind": "document", + "ref": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard/blob/72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55/frontend/app/(shell)/page.tsx#L671-L705" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5195515eb --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +{"key": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -1300000000.0, "value_raw": "-1.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2026", "option": "Revenues—Option 23", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)"}, "world": "cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the option would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2019 and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages. It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "date": "2018-12-13", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b346e9bec3a1b9199c9572cadbcde3a7f5641ea10b224222203796e6078f2b4e", "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 23: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2026", "quote": "Change in Revenues 5.6 7.5 6.8 6.7 0.6 -1.9 -1.4 -1.3 -1.9 -2.5 27.1 18.1", "note": "Billions of dollars by federal fiscal year (volume notes, page 2). The option takes effect in January 2019.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026"} +{"key": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -1900000000.0, "value_raw": "-1.9", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2027", "option": "Revenues—Option 23", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)"}, "world": "cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the option would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2019 and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages. It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "date": "2018-12-13", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b346e9bec3a1b9199c9572cadbcde3a7f5641ea10b224222203796e6078f2b4e", "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 23: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2027", "quote": "Change in Revenues 5.6 7.5 6.8 6.7 0.6 -1.9 -1.4 -1.3 -1.9 -2.5 27.1 18.1", "note": "Billions of dollars by federal fiscal year (volume notes, page 2). The option takes effect in January 2019.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027"} +{"key": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -2500000000.0, "value_raw": "-2.5", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2028", "option": "Revenues—Option 23", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)"}, "world": "cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the option would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2019 and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages. It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "date": "2018-12-13", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b346e9bec3a1b9199c9572cadbcde3a7f5641ea10b224222203796e6078f2b4e", "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 23: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, 2028", "quote": "Change in Revenues 5.6 7.5 6.8 6.7 0.6 -1.9 -1.4 -1.3 -1.9 -2.5 27.1 18.1", "note": "Billions of dollars by federal fiscal year (volume notes, page 2). The option takes effect in January 2019.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028"} +{"key": "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 18100000000.0, "value_raw": "18.1", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2019-FY2028", "window": "2019-2028", "window_kind": "total", "option": "Revenues—Option 23", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "includes an offset for the reduction in income subject to income and payroll taxes (volume, printed page 201)"}, "world": "cbo_2018_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the option would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2019 and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages. It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "date": "2018-12-13", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b346e9bec3a1b9199c9572cadbcde3a7f5641ea10b224222203796e6078f2b4e", "locator": "Revenues—Option 23, printed page 264 (PDF page 274)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 23: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, Total 2019–2028", "quote": "Change in Revenues 5.6 7.5 6.8 6.7 0.6 -1.9 -1.4 -1.3 -1.9 -2.5 27.1 18.1", "note": "Ten-year total, billions of dollars, fiscal years 2019 to 2028; the text: 'CBO estimates that this option would raise revenues by $18 billion from 2019 to 2028.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028"} +{"key": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": -3700000000.0, "value_raw": "-3.7", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2026", "option": "Revenues—Option 24, second alternative", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "cbo_2016_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the approach would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2017 (and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages). It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", "date": "2016-12-08", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "ab4dbe494158ba3a64472c2798a1745643cfa1540556f771e0fd00fc27074d1d", "locator": "Revenues—Option 24, printed page 175 (PDF page 187)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 24: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, 2026", "quote": "Increase the FUTA wage base to $40,000, index the base to future wage growth, and decrease the net FUTA rate to 0.167 percent 14.9 11.9 3.9 -0.1 -2.2 -2.2 -2.6 -3.5 -3.4 -3.7 28.4 13.1", "note": "Billions of dollars by federal fiscal year (volume notes, page 2). The option takes effect in January 2017; the first alternative (a 0.8% net rate, no base change) is not a wage-base change and is not staged.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026"} +{"key": "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_budget_options", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 13100000000.0, "value_raw": "13.1", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2017-FY2026", "window": "2017-2026", "window_kind": "total", "option": "Revenues—Option 24, second alternative", "scope": "federal budget revenues: FUTA plus the state unemployment (SUTA) taxes the higher base raises, which the budget counts, net of the rate cuts CBO expects states to make", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (CBO volume notes: 'positive numbers for revenues reduce the deficit')", "program": "futa", "basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared"}, "world": "cbo_2016_option_futa_base_40000", "reform_hint": "the approach would raise the amount of wages subject to the FUTA tax from $7,000 to $40,000 in 2017 (and then index that threshold to the growth in future wages). It would also reduce the net FUTA tax rate, after accounting for the 5.4 percent state tax credit, from 0.6 percent under current law to 0.167 percent.", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", "date": "2016-12-08", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "ab4dbe494158ba3a64472c2798a1745643cfa1540556f771e0fd00fc27074d1d", "locator": "Revenues—Option 24, printed page 175 (PDF page 187)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Revenues—Option 24: Increase Taxes That Finance the Federal Share of the Unemployment Insurance System", "source_column": "Change in Revenues, wage-base alternative, Total 2017–2026", "quote": "Increase the FUTA wage base to $40,000, index the base to future wage growth, and decrease the net FUTA rate to 0.167 percent 14.9 11.9 3.9 -0.1 -2.2 -2.2 -2.6 -3.5 -3.4 -3.7 28.4 13.1", "note": "Billions of dollars by federal fiscal year (volume notes, page 2). The option takes effect in January 2017; the first alternative (a 0.8% net rate, no base change) is not a wage-base change and is not staged.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "CBO scores a different policy: a $40,000 base indexed to wage growth with the net FUTA rate cut to 0.167%, counting the state unemployment taxes the higher base raises, by fiscal year. The dashboard holds the 0.6% rate, indexes a $43,000 base to the CPI-U, counts the FUTA line only and reports calendar years; it publishes no estimate of CBO's option.", "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026"} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 8461000000.0, "value_raw": "8.461", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2025, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2025", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2025, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D36)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2025", "quote": "2025 | 39.73 | 33.314 | 8.461", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": {"pe_estimate": "futa_collections_model_unadjusted_fy2025"}} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2026", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 8948000000.0, "value_raw": "8.948", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2026", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2026, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D37)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2026", "quote": "2026 | 43.78 | 34.454 | 8.948", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2027", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 9422000000.0, "value_raw": "9.422", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2027", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2027, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D38)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2027", "quote": "2027 | 45.79 | 34.491 | 9.422", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2028", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 10007000000.0, "value_raw": "10.007", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2028", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2028, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D39)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2028", "quote": "2028 | 47.585 | 35.123 | 10.007", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2029", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 11345000000.0, "value_raw": "11.345", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2029", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2029, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D40)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2029", "quote": "2029 | 49.055 | 36.448 | 11.345", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2030", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 12846000000.0, "value_raw": "12.846", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2030", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2030, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D41)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2030", "quote": "2030 | 50.58 | 37.064 | 12.846", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2031", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 14669000000.0, "value_raw": "14.669", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2031, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2031", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2031, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D42)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2031", "quote": "2031 | 52.24 | 37.333 | 14.669", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2032", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 16548000000.0, "value_raw": "16.548", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2032", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2032, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D43)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2032", "quote": "2032 | 53.93 | 37.439 | 16.548", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2033", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 18402000000.0, "value_raw": "18.402", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2033", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2033, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D44)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2033", "quote": "2033 | 55.555 | 37.646 | 18.402", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2034", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 19962000000.0, "value_raw": "19.962", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2034", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2034, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D45)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2034", "quote": "2034 | 57.195 | 37.86 | 19.962", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2035", "source": "cbo", "found_by": "cbo", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "cbo_baseline_projections", "metric": "tax_collections", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 21132000000.0, "value_raw": "21.132", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fiscal_year": "FY2035", "basis": "forecast", "tax": "FUTA", "concept": "FUTA revenues, shown separately from SUTA revenues", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "CBO January 2025 baseline projection"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "primary_sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "locator": "Sheet 'Figure 2', row 2035, column 'FUTA revenues' (cell D46)", "access": "wayback"}, "source_table": "Figure 2. Outlays for Regular Unemployment Insurance and Revenues From State and Federal Unemployment Taxes (billions of dollars)", "source_column": "FUTA revenues, 2035", "quote": "2035 | 58.865 | 38.141 | 21.132", "note": "The row as stored: year | regular UI outlays | SUTA revenues | FUTA revenues, billions of dollars; the sheet displays two decimals. Figure 2's note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'. The report (page 4): 'For 2025, CBO projected that ... the federal government would collect more than $8 billion in FUTA revenues.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The dashboard's fiscal-year FUTA figures (the flat 0.6% tax for the year plus the prior year's credit-reduction surcharge) cover FY2024 and FY2025, its validation years. For 2026 to 2035 it publishes calendar-year revenue at the flat 0.6% rate without credit-reduction surcharges (results.json baseline_revenue_flat_06), a different time basis and concept."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2026", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2027", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2027", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2028", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2028", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2029", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2029", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2030", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2030", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4400000000.0, "value_raw": "4.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2031, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2031", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2031", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4400000000.0, "value_raw": "4.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2032", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2032", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4400000000.0, "value_raw": "4.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2033", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2033", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4400000000.0, "value_raw": "4.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2034", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2034", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4400000000.0, "value_raw": "4.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2035", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, 2035", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 43600000000.0, "value_raw": "43.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", "window": "2026-2035", "window_kind": "total", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "none", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_unindexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "No Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", "quote": "No Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 43.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2026", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4500000000.0, "value_raw": "4.5", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2027", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2027", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4700000000.0, "value_raw": "4.7", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2028", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2028", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4800000000.0, "value_raw": "4.8", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2029", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2029", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5000000000.0, "value_raw": "5.0", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2030", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2030", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5200000000.0, "value_raw": "5.2", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2031, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2031", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2031", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5400000000.0, "value_raw": "5.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2032", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2032", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5600000000.0, "value_raw": "5.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2033", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2033", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5900000000.0, "value_raw": "5.9", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2034", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2034", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 6100000000.0, "value_raw": "6.1", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2035", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, 2035", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 51600000000.0, "value_raw": "51.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", "window": "2026-2035", "window_kind": "total", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "chained CPI-U", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_chained_cpi_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Inflation Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", "quote": "Inflation Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.5 4.7 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.9 6.1 51.6", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4300000000.0, "value_raw": "4.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2026", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 4600000000.0, "value_raw": "4.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2027, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2027", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2027", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2027", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5000000000.0, "value_raw": "5.0", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2028, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2028", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2028", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2028", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5300000000.0, "value_raw": "5.3", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2029, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2029", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2029", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2029", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 5600000000.0, "value_raw": "5.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2030, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2030", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2030", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2030", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 6000000000.0, "value_raw": "6.0", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2031, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2031", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2031", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2031", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 6400000000.0, "value_raw": "6.4", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2032, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2032", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2032", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2032", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 6800000000.0, "value_raw": "6.8", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2033, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2033", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2033", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2033", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 7200000000.0, "value_raw": "7.2", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2034, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2034", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2034", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2034", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 7600000000.0, "value_raw": "7.6", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2035", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, 2035", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 58700000000.0, "value_raw": "58.7", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", "window": "2026-2035", "window_kind": "total", "wage_base": "$14,000", "indexing": "SSA average wage index", "net_rate": "0.6%", "basis": "static", "sign_convention": "positive = higher government revenue (net revenue effects)", "program": "futa_with_income_and_payroll_tax_offset", "basis_note": "net of the income tax offset ('about 25% of the additional gross FUTA revenues raised')"}, "world": "futa_base_14000_wage_indexed", "reform_hint": "reforms to the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) wage base, all of which would come into effect in 2026 ... each $1,000 increment between the current-law value of $7,000 and a doubling to $14,000 ... three options: no indexing, inflation indexing (chained CPIU), and wage indexing (SSA's average wage index) starting in 2026", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Appendix Table 1, page 3", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Appendix Table 1. Estimated Annual Budgetary Effects (Billions of Dollars)", "source_column": "Wage Indexing, $14,000, Budget Window", "quote": "Wage Indexing $14,000 4.3 4.6 5.0 5.3 5.6 6.0 6.4 6.8 7.2 7.6 58.7", "note": "The PDF has no text layer; the row was read from a 300 dpi render of page 3, and its ten years sum to the printed Budget Window within rounding. Table 1 (page 2, 'CY2026-35') gives the window rounded to whole billions.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "additional_revenue_adjusted_cy2026_2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab scores a $14,000 base net of an income-tax offset of about 25%; the dashboard scores a $43,000 CPI-U-indexed base, gross of any offset, and publishes no estimate at $14,000."} +{"key": "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035", "source": "budget_lab", "found_by": "budget_lab", "found_on": "2026-10-21", "source_model": "budget_lab_tax_simulator_2989c41", "metric": "tax_liability", "unit_concept": "usd", "value": 64000000000.0, "value_raw": "$64B", "normalization": "USD bn x 1e9 -> USD", "value_kind": "cumulative", "period": 2035, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"calendar_year": "CY2026-CY2035", "window": "2026-2035", "window_kind": "total", "statistic": "approximate ('about $64B')", "tax": "FUTA", "basis": "forecast", "sign_convention": "level", "program": "futa", "basis_note": "baseline projection benchmarked to DOL's FUTA receipts for 2021-2023"}, "world": "baseline", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "primary_sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "locator": "Page 2, footnote 1", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Footnote 1", "source_column": "baseline FUTA revenues over the decade", "quote": "We project that baseline FUTA revenues will be about $64B over the decade.", "note": "Read from the 300 dpi render of page 2. The decade is the report's budget window, calendar 2026-35 (Table 1). Methodological Assumptions: 'Our baseline estimates are benchmarked to the DOL's historical and projected FUTA receipts for 2021-2023.'", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "nearest_estimate": "baseline_revenue_adjusted_cy2035", "pe_missing": "The Budget Lab prints a ten-year total; the dashboard's results files print current-law FUTA revenue one calendar year at a time and publish no ten-year baseline total."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..88779b2ec --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +{"url": "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", "title": "Private Request for Analysis: Niskanen Center. Budgetary effects of FUTA reform", "date": "2025-11-20", "publisher": "The Budget Lab at Yale", "sha256": "4a22cbeae037208d18c66547f2fa6819171ae2a9e54f2d7102fd7559506545f8", "bytes": 529996, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Linked as 'Download the Score' from budgetlab.yale.edu/research/budgetary-effects-federal-unemployment-tax-act-reform (dated November 20, 2025); the report itself is dated August 4, 2025, a private analysis published once the Niskanen Center cited it. The PDF has no text layer; its tables were read from a 300 dpi render."} +{"url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028", "date": "2018-12-13", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "sha256": "b346e9bec3a1b9199c9572cadbcde3a7f5641ea10b224222203796e6078f2b4e", "bytes": 3478681, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "wayback", "wayback_snapshot": "https://web.archive.org/web/20260918083524id_/https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "cbo.gov blocks scripted fetches; the original bytes came from the Wayback Machine (id_ form). The option's web page is www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2018/54809."} +{"url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", "title": "Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2017 to 2026", "date": "2016-12-08", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "sha256": "ab4dbe494158ba3a64472c2798a1745643cfa1540556f771e0fd00fc27074d1d", "bytes": 1937863, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "wayback", "wayback_snapshot": "https://web.archive.org/web/20260217124621id_/https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "cbo.gov blocks scripted fetches; the original bytes came from the Wayback Machine (id_ form). The option's web page is www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2016/52270."} +{"url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "title": "Unemployment Insurance: Budgetary History and Projections (data file)", "date": "2025-01-23", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "sha256": "b6a764258ac90d86651272ef3eaffc906b968127144aa026ad2d0a6313c1be22", "bytes": 750538, "doc_type": "xlsx", "access": "wayback", "wayback_snapshot": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250512063021id_/https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "The data behind the report's Figures (www.cbo.gov/publication/60776, January 23, 2025). The report's Figure 2 note: 'The projections for 2025 to 2035 are from CBO's January 2025 baseline'; its notes: 'all years referred to in this report are federal fiscal years'."} +{"url": "https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanations-FY2017.pdf", "title": "General Explanations of the Administration's Fiscal Year 2017 Revenue Proposals", "date": "2016-02-09", "publisher": "U.S. Department of the Treasury", "sha256": "2938824787071eb15506d0526c0cb0e6e034e7c9325a7ddbccfa0e3bd75f6ca7", "bytes": 1938765, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Read and hashed; no claim is staged from it. The FUTA base row is estimated after the budget's permanent FUTA surtax, a baseline scorecard_db/baselines.py does not register, so harvest rule 7 holds it out (search_log.json)."} +{"url": "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-03/56253-2016-03-29-unemployment.pdf", "title": "Proposals for Unemployment Compensation—CBO's Estimate of the President's Fiscal Year 2017 Budget", "date": "2016-03-29", "publisher": "Congressional Budget Office", "sha256": "e4b18d673be632edf32f0f65bfb6c8121a1fd44f88bffb231c1cadc5ea647d1d", "bytes": 70084, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "wayback", "wayback_snapshot": "https://web.archive.org/web/20250205071023id_/https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-03/56253-2016-03-29-unemployment.pdf", "retrieved": "2026-10-21", "note": "Read and hashed; no claim is staged from it. The FUTA base row is estimated after the budget's permanent FUTA surtax, a baseline scorecard_db/baselines.py does not register, so harvest rule 7 holds it out (search_log.json). The date is the file name's; the PDF was created on 2016-03-21."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ffda8d1e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-us-futa-wage-base-dashboard/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,284 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-21", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261021-113611-cmp-us-futa-wage-base-dashbo", + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "cbo", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "CBO option increase FUTA taxable wage base revenue estimate", + "site:cbo.gov \"Federal Unemployment Tax Act\" wage base option 2024 OR 2025 OR 2026", + "CBO estimate President's budget unemployment compensation proposals \"FUTA\" wage base site:cbo.gov", + "\"Expand FUTA Base\" CBO reestimate President's budget 2015 OR 2012 unemployment compensation", + "\"Unemployment Insurance Modernization and Recession Readiness Act\" FUTA wage base cost estimate CBO OR JCT", + "site:cbo.gov cost estimate \"Federal Unemployment Tax Act\" \"wage base\" increase bill", + "CBO baseline projections unemployment compensation 51316 unemployment pdf 2026", + "CBO February 2026 \"Revenue Projections, by Category\" 51138 xlsx" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2018/54809", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-06/54667-budgetoptions-2.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2016/52270", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2018-09/52142-budgetoptions2.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2014/49644", + "https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2013/44815", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-03/56253-2016-03-29-unemployment.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2020-03/56253-2015-03-12-unemployment.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60776", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-unemployment-insurance.pdf", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-01/60776-data.xlsx", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2026-02/51138-2026-02-Revenue.xlsx", + "https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2024-12/60557-budget-options.pdf" + ], + "claims": [ + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2026", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2027", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2028", + "cbo_option_2018_futa_base_fy2019_2028", + "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2026", + "cbo_option_2016_futa_base_fy2017_2026", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2025", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2026", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2027", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2028", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2029", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2030", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2031", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2032", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2033", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2034", + "cbo_jan2025_futa_revenues_fy2035" + ], + "note": "Staged: CBO's two most recent FUTA wage-base options (December 2016 and December 2018: $40,000, wage-indexed, net rate 0.167%, state taxes counted), the years they share with the dashboard (2026-2028) and their ten-year totals; and the January 2025 baseline's FUTA revenues for FY2025-FY2035, FY2025 compared with the dashboard's fiscal-year validation figure. Not staged: CBO's estimate of the President's FY2017 budget ('Expand FUTA Base', -$1,060 million over 2017-2026; Treasury describes the proposal as a $40,000 base from 2018) is estimated after the budget's permanent FUTA surtax (its footnote c), a baseline scorecard_db/baselines.py does not register, so harvest rule 7 holds it out; the 2013 and 2014 options ($14,000 base, net rate 0.33%) and CBO's estimates of the FY2012-FY2016 budgets cover windows that end before 2026. The December 2024 options volume has no FUTA option, nor do the December 2020 and 2022 volumes; no CBO cost estimate of a bill raising the FUTA base was found. CBO's February 2026 revenue projections show only a combined unemployment-insurance line (state and federal), so the January 2025 UI report's FUTA series is the latest FUTA-only projection. All cbo.gov pages were read through Wayback Machine captures (cbo.gov blocks scripted fetches)." + }, + { + "producer": "jct", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:jct.gov FUTA wage base increase estimated revenue effects", + "Joint Committee on Taxation \"Estimated Budget Effects of the Revenue Provisions Contained in the President's\" budget proposal FUTA unemployment", + "jct.gov \"FUTA\" \"wage base\" estimated revenue effects JCX" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/0d9fc4f5-abc6-4579-b58e-1c77f770796f/x-15-16-4902.pdf", + "https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/3f1f8ba9-c73f-4093-874a-89e651ac5b60/x-50-15-4739.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "JCT's revenue tables for the President's FY2012-FY2017 budgets (e.g. JCX-15-16, JCX-50-15) print the FUTA base proposals with the footnote 'Estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office'; those are CBO's estimates, logged under cbo. No JCT estimate of its own and no JCT score of a bill raising the FUTA base was found." + }, + { + "producer": "tpc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicycenter.org FUTA wage base", + "TaxVox unemployment insurance taxable wage base raise $7,000 FUTA", + "\"federal unemployment\" tax wage base increase revenue estimate (taxpolicycenter.org)", + "Tax Proposals in the Budget FUTA wage base $40,000" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/26931/1001524-Tax-Proposals-in-the-Budget.PDF" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "TPC's 'Tax Proposals in the 2012 Budget' (March 2011) restates Treasury's estimate of the FY2012 proposal ($15,000 base; '$46 billion' over 2012-2021); it is not TPC's own estimate and its window ends in 2021. TPC's payroll-tax briefing pages give total unemployment-insurance receipts, not FUTA." + }, + { + "producer": "pwbm", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu unemployment insurance FUTA", + "\"Federal Unemployment Tax\" OR FUTA Penn Wharton Budget Model", + "PWBM unemployment insurance trust fund payroll tax wage base" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/p/2024-04-22-policy-options-for-reducing-the-federal-debt-spring-2024/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "PWBM's debt-reduction options and expenditure modules have no FUTA option or FUTA revenue figure." + }, + { + "producer": "budget_lab", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:budgetlab.yale.edu FUTA unemployment wage base", + "\"Budget Lab\" FUTA wage base estimate indexing revenue 2026-2035", + "\"Federal Unemployment Tax Act\" Budget Lab Yale" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/budgetary-effects-federal-unemployment-tax-act-reform", + "https://budgetlab.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2025-11/TBL-FUTA-20251120.pdf", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/broaden-the-base-lower-the-improper-payment-rates/" + ], + "claims": [ + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_no_index_cy2026_2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_cpi_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2027", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2028", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2029", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2030", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2031", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2032", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2033", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2034", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2035", + "budget_lab_base_14000_wage_indexed_cy2026_2035", + "budget_lab_baseline_futa_revenue_cy2026_2035" + ], + "note": "'Budgetary effects of FUTA reform' (published November 20, 2025; a private analysis for the Niskanen Center dated August 4, 2025) scores bases of $8,000 to $14,000 under three indexing rules, calendar 2026-35, net of an income-tax offset. Staged: the $14,000 rows of Appendix Table 1 (the nearest to the dashboard's $43,000) under each indexing rule, and footnote 1's decade baseline. Not staged: the $8,000-$13,000 rows and Table 1, which rounds the same windows. The Niskanen Center's 'Broaden the base, lower the (improper payment) rates' (Will Raderman, November 20, 2025) restates Table 1." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_foundation", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxfoundation.org FUTA wage base federal unemployment tax raise revenue", + "Options for Reforming America's Tax Code unemployment tax FUTA" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Options3_book_7-22.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Options for Reforming America's Tax Code 3.0 describes FUTA but has no FUTA option; its payroll options are Social Security and Medicare." + }, + { + "producer": "urban", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:urban.org FUTA wage base unemployment insurance financing Vroman", + "Urban Institute raise FUTA taxable wage base revenue", + "TRIM3 unemployment insurance tax FUTA simulation" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/26716/412450-Unemployment-Insurance-and-the-Great-Recession.PDF", + "https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/26046/901499-Unemployment-Insurance-Performance-and-Trust-Fund-Restoration.PDF" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Vroman (2011) sizes the federal taxable payroll under a $15,000 base in 2014 and the revenue-neutral rate, with no revenue estimate; TRIM3 has no FUTA tax module." + }, + { + "producer": "cbpp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:cbpp.org FUTA taxable wage base raise unemployment insurance financing", + "site:cbpp.org federal unemployment tax wage base $7,000 index revenue billion" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.cbpp.org/research/rebuilding-the-unemployment-insurance-system-a-deficit-neutral-plan-that-limits-tax" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CBPP's 2011 plan pairs a higher, wage-indexed base with a rate cut designed to be deficit neutral and gives no revenue estimate of the base increase." + }, + { + "producer": "itep", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:itep.org FUTA federal unemployment tax wage base", + "ITEP unemployment insurance tax wage base $7,000 regressive raise" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "ITEP's federal analyses include unemployment-insurance taxes in baseline distributions only; no estimate of a FUTA base change." + }, + { + "producer": "cpsp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:povertycenter.columbia.edu unemployment insurance taxable wage base raise revenue", + "\"FUTA\" OR \"Federal Unemployment Tax\" Center on Poverty and Social Policy Columbia" + ], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "CPSP's work on unemployment insurance covers benefits and poverty, not FUTA financing." + }, + { + "producer": "crfb", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:crfb.org FUTA wage base $40,000 President's budget unemployment insurance", + "site:crfb.org FUTA federal unemployment tax" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://crfb.org/sites/default/files/cbo_analysis_presidents_fy_2015_budget.pdf", + "https://www.crfb.org/sites/default/files/analysis_of_the_presidents_fy2016_budget.pdf", + "https://crfb.org/sites/default/files/analysis_of_cbo_pb_reest_fy_2016.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CRFB's analyses of the FY2015 and FY2016 budgets restate OMB's and CBO's lines for the unemployment-tax reform (e.g. '-$60 billion' OMB, '-$20 billion' CBO, rounded to $5 billion, windows ending 2024-2025); no CRFB estimate of its own." + }, + { + "producer": "state_fiscal_note", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "A federal tax; state fiscal notes apply to state and local analyses." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "Hamilton Project FUTA wage base revenue", + "nber/ssrn \"federal taxable wage base\" unemployment insurance revenue", + "Guo Johnston unemployment insurance tax base FUTA", + "O'Leary Wandner 2018 Upjohn FUTA wage base", + "NBER/SSRN/IZA unemployment insurance wage base simulation" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.hamiltonproject.org/assets/legacy/files/downloads_and_links/Reforming_Unemployment_Insurance_for_the_Twenty-First_Century_Workforce.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No working paper or article from the last five years estimates the revenue from a higher FUTA base. Kletzer and Rosen (Hamilton Project, 2006) put a $45,000 base 'while maintaining the same tax rate', then a 0.8% net rate ('making the effective FUTA tax rate 0.8 percent', with the 0.2-point surtax), at '$8.7 billion in increased revenue', with no year stated, twenty years before the dashboard's window. Upjohn Institute pages (O'Leary and Wandner 2018) could not be read (Cloudflare 403, including Wayback)." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found_not_staged", + "queries": [ + "raise FUTA wage base $43,000 revenue Searchlight Institute unemployment insurance", + "\"FUTA\" \"wage base\" increase revenue estimate billion over ten years proposal 2025", + "Treasury General Explanations \"FUTA wage base\" $40,000 revenue estimate unemployment insurance reform budget proposal", + "\"raise the FUTA wage base\" billion", + "\"federal unemployment tax\" \"taxable wage base\" \"over 10 years\" -cbo", + "Searchlight Raderman FUTA", + "tcf.org FUTA billion", + "NELP wage base billion" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanations-FY2017.pdf", + "https://www.searchlightinstitute.org/research/dignity-in-looking-for-work-enhancing-unemployment-insurance-benefits-the-jfk-way/", + "https://www.niskanencenter.org/back-to-the-base-ics-how-taxable-wage-base-reforms-can-strengthen-unemployment-program-solvency/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Treasury's own estimate of the FY2017 budget's 'Expand Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) base and reform FUTA credit reduction rules' ($40,000 base from 2018, wage-indexed, net rate to 0.167%): $7,113 million in FY2026 and $46,292 million over 2017-26 (General Explanations FY2017, printed page 269). The primary was read and hashed (sha256 2938824787071eb15506d0526c0cb0e6e034e7c9325a7ddbccfa0e3bd75f6ca7), but the row is estimated after the budget's permanent FUTA surtax ('reduce the net Federal UI tax from 0.8 percent (after the proposed permanent reenactment and extension of the FUTA surtax)'), a baseline scorecard_db/baselines.py does not register; harvest rule 7 holds it out until it is registered. Searchlight Institute (Will Raderman, October 8, 2026; read through its Wayback capture, web.archive.org/web/20261008154132) restates the dashboard: 'north of $250 billion could be raised over a 10-year period' (footnote 60 cites PolicyEngine), so it is not an external estimate; its '$59 billion over 10 years' for a wage-indexed $14,000 base restates the Budget Lab (footnote 58). The Niskanen Center's February 23, 2026 piece has no estimate. No other producer's own estimate was found." + } + ], + "results_pins": [ + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:6b796506bfbb43fb6a86ce06b20b30287c5b2ea62bf7b1151e70053b36a8d20c", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:e5c17882bbd7eae1854b222797e0ea2fa83a9b36392a17bb776e9e726e17ba7b", + "PolicyEngine/futa-wage-base-dashboard@72e31379e3cd4be6465fd449293369df425e7e55:ebd2d43e12865e9f73265dd928ea23a22ef1e504066d327b669fd4d723423245" + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/tests/test_export_populations.py b/tests/test_export_populations.py index 1ee5f2616..24832b479 100644 --- a/tests/test_export_populations.py +++ b/tests/test_export_populations.py @@ -410,7 +410,7 @@ def test_integration_committed_db(tmp_path): # Pre-publish comparables (docs/COMPARABLES.md) add every staged claim of # each analysis record: 20 for the £100,000 childcare dashboard (12 CenTax, # 8 Centre for British Progress), with or without a result. - assert dist == {"US": 535, "UK": 5163 + 23_752 + 246 + 22, "BE": 9, "NZ": 12} + assert dist == {"US": 535 + 90, "UK": 5163 + 23_752 + 246 + 128, "BE": 9, "NZ": 12} nz = [row for row in payload["rows"] if row["country"] == "NZ"] assert len(nz) == 12 assert {row["source"] for row in nz} == {"nz_treasury"} @@ -445,8 +445,8 @@ def test_integration_committed_db(tmp_path): assert committed["summary"] == payload["summary"] assert committed["event_archives"] == payload["event_archives"] # Every event is reachable in the deployed copy, with bounded requests. - # 5,719 + the 22 pre-publish comparables rows of the childcare record - assert len(payload["rows"]) == 5719 + 22 + # 5,719 + the 218 rows of the comparables records (128 UK, 90 US) + assert len(payload["rows"]) == 5719 + 218 for archive in payload["event_archives"]: relative = archive["path"].removeprefix("data/") freshly_exported = (tmp_path / relative).read_bytes() From 50529bedb74b2752cae7585a191eb91019ded846 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Max Ghenis Date: Thu, 22 Oct 2026 14:03:22 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Record the comparables search for the UK marriage calculator A household calculator, searched under the calculator path: no fixed estimate to pin, 97 claims staged, none compared. Index, feeds and export pins regenerated (258 comparables rows). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- app/public/data/lanes.json | 6 +- app/public/data/populations.json | 2793 +++++++++++++- data/comparables/index.json | 3272 +++++++++++++++++ data/lanes.json | 6 +- data/populations.json | 2793 +++++++++++++- sources/analysis-uk-marriage/analysis.json | 55 + sources/analysis-uk-marriage/annotations.json | 1 + .../analysis-uk-marriage/claims_staged.jsonl | 97 + sources/analysis-uk-marriage/manifest.jsonl | 29 + sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json | 466 +++ tests/test_export_populations.py | 6 +- 11 files changed, 9355 insertions(+), 169 deletions(-) create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-marriage/analysis.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-marriage/annotations.json create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-marriage/claims_staged.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-marriage/manifest.jsonl create mode 100644 sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json diff --git a/app/public/data/lanes.json b/app/public/data/lanes.json index b73c58b8f..42f590a12 100644 --- a/app/public/data/lanes.json +++ b/app/public/data/lanes.json @@ -586,8 +586,8 @@ "country": "UK", "stage": "computed", "running": false, - "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "5 analyses searched, 128 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "updated": "2026-10-22", + "note": "6 analyses searched, 168 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" }, { "id": "analysis-comparables-us", @@ -597,7 +597,7 @@ "country": "US", "stage": "computed", "running": false, - "updated": "2026-10-21", + "updated": "2026-10-22", "note": "3 analyses searched, 90 claims, 69 PolicyEngine results beside them" } ] diff --git a/app/public/data/populations.json b/app/public/data/populations.json index 94c50dd78..69427c251 100644 --- a/app/public/data/populations.json +++ b/app/public/data/populations.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "built": "2026-10-22", "note": "Non-Urban populations exported from scorecard.db: the populace reform-validation registry (issue #20) plus the compute campaign's attached comparisons (US: TPC/CPSP/PWBM/CBO/JCT; UK: the HMRC ready-reckoner family and the complete OBR Policy measures database, including historical HM Treasury scores; BE: JRC EUROMOD-BE claims with demo-grade Axiom concept-mismatch attachments and the 2026 PIT-reform scorekeeper claims; NZ: official budget scores). Claims explicitly opted into pre-result display remain in the feed with latest status not_computed and empty history. Recorded result statuses and calibration relationships are verbatim; nothing here is a pass/fail grade.", "summary": { - "claims": 29935, + "claims": 29975, "multi_release_claims": 270, "by_source": { "aspe_welfare_indicators": 14, @@ -113,6 +113,7 @@ "census": 26, "centax": 26, "centre_for_british_progress": 30, + "centre_for_social_justice": 1, "cpsp": 3, "desnz": 2, "dwp": 4, @@ -121,7 +122,7 @@ "good_energy": 5, "green_party": 1, "hm_treasury": 2, - "ifs": 10, + "ifs": 45, "ippr": 3, "itep": 2, "jrf": 3, @@ -130,6 +131,7 @@ "niesr": 3, "ny_fiscal_note": 1, "octopus_energy": 1, + "policy_exchange": 4, "ppic": 1, "rea": 2, "resolution_foundation": 25, @@ -140,13 +142,13 @@ "comparable": 84, "concept_mismatch": 131, "constructed": 1675, - "not_computed": 27156, + "not_computed": 27196, "pe_gap": 889 }, "by_sign_relative_to_pe": { "magnitude": 14, - "opposite": 553, - "same": 29099, + "opposite": 562, + "same": 29130, "unknown": 269 }, "by_country": { @@ -165,10 +167,10 @@ "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "UK": { - "claims": 29289, + "claims": 29329, "with_result": 2262, "with_value": 1277, - "without_result": 27027, + "without_result": 27067, "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "US": { @@ -37035,6 +37037,69 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "bfc2838896f933cb199e", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Existing couples affected by material couple penalty", + "name": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "metric": "affected_count", + "unit_concept": "benefit_units", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2009, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "csj_2009_material_penalty_couples", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2.3 synthetically separates existing FRS couples with fixed gross earnings and family characteristics (page 111 footnote 13); these incidence figures do not apply a labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "Standard of living together versus a fully equivalised income from living apart. This retains the producer\u2019s adjustment for savings from sharing a household.", + "country": "UK", + "data": "FRS 2005/06 and matching HBAI 2005/06. Report page 45 footnote 18 and page 169 footnote 21.", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "population": "Existing couples represented as FRS benefit units; not couples discouraged from forming.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous 2009 report snapshot of current couple penalties; input survey 2005/06 is recorded separately. No exact model fiscal year assigned.", + "sign_convention": "positive = more units", + "value_verbatim": "1.8 million" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "65f8a8774b6c3fcb", + "external_value": 1800000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1800000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "03d666ddda6fe83bd6f4", "source": "co_admin", @@ -126476,6 +126541,534 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "393a7ea6f1f7944fa897", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "51.59" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 51.59, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -51.59, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "58961ccaea7ff2003163", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "44.7" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 44.7, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -44.7, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2215f7c88571fd6499a4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "95.30" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 95.3, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -95.3, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ec112283c9663139e024", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "85.11" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 85.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -85.11, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "062c1d2cb3281cbeeb81", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "16.91" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 16.91, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -16.91, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f208721c905d2f798d34", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "13.22" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 13.22, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -13.22, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "53df18f191d5979911a2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "47.05" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 47.05, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -47.05, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c910c409634bf88405bc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "39.22" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 39.22, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -39.22, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "111608638bd5d2d834af", "source": "ifs", @@ -182180,6 +182773,198 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "80545ae5dd6bed2deb45", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate net penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_net_penalty", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a334.3 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 34300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 34300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "efb426811062025377f7", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate penalty amongst those with penalties", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_penalties", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "couples_with_penalty", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a334.7 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 34700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 34700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ef0afe266b1c7b183c73", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate premium amongst those with premiums", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_premiums", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "couples_with_premium", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.6 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "4235f56a23af01b464bd", "source": "ifs", @@ -183199,40 +183984,1612 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "530e698cd8a5ff35c608", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.35" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.35, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.35, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d8469d14d533fb2c4c15", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.04" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.04, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.04, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01f534560eda12b91bec", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.03" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.03, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.03, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b0f9c7393d6171512818", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.11" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a0fac7d5633329069f81", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.03" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.03, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.03, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f7ada9840cfbf91f3287", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.61" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.61, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.61, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1ec19ce9c558c1d6c676", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.09" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.09, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.09, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d099d41551214b7d5d56", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.23" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.23, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.23, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "20f236cf6ff80a0a79a2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.68" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.68, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.68, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "eddb2fd1f37ad7b5e0bb", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.64" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.64, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.64, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2bb01c2cf3f830216160", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.95" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.95, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.95, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "715ebd6a38eb07ced642", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.89" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.89, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.89, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "62e209142979e4998cbd", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.37" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.37, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.37, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "821d8bde5ea4f38b33a3", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.41" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.41, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.41, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "415b1168631a36b54ca5", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.77" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.77, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.77, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4ba70168b6c9225533c2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.81" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.81, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.81, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1918c6a8e457e8ede3ff", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.01" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.01, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.01, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "84dfe42003f1d4fe245a", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.27" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.27, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.27, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4debf25b6fdd8df747ac", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.02" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.02, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.02, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "97fb3217efada64bcc79", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a40461d5a9304bbf23c9", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.02" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.02, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.02, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a53b11a9e2e87d7ce00b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2010-11", "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.56" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", - "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.56, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.56, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -183254,45 +185611,51 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", + "claim_id": "af1ad461c79b895cfbf3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", - "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": null, - "program": "fuel_duty", + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { - "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", - "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", - "basis": "unstated", - "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fy": "2029-30", - "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", - "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", - "program": "fuel_duty", - "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.11" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", - "external_value": 4500000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -183314,45 +185677,51 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", + "claim_id": "c43902849a4ce1607c75", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", - "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": null, - "program": "fuel_duty", + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { - "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", - "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", - "basis": "unstated", - "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fy": "2029-30", - "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", - "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", - "program": "fuel_duty", - "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", - "external_value": 4000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -335966,6 +338335,270 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "3da46557d4b371cc93bb", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3330/week", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-14.66%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -14.66, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14.66, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5a53a36540ba743a8ba1", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-12.4%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -12.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -12.4, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d90a8b0eccac93bf60b8", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3165/week", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3330/week", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-24.44%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -24.44, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -24.44, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e37add237f04c8f3c924", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3165/week", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-8.4%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -8.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -8.4, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "01c5b5f5f094361c1391", "source": "policy_exchange", diff --git a/data/comparables/index.json b/data/comparables/index.json index 7b0d85f9f..b7fbf332b 100644 --- a/data/comparables/index.json +++ b/data/comparables/index.json @@ -850,6 +850,7 @@ "slug": "energy-autumn-budget", "title": "Energy bills and the Autumn Budget 2026", "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/energy-autumn-budget", + "deployments": [], "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", "published": "2026-10-14", "current_pins": [ @@ -1912,6 +1913,7 @@ "slug": "free-childcare-reform", "title": "Free childcare hours and a 75% subsidy", "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/free-childcare-reform", + "deployments": [], "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", "published": "2026-09-03", "current_pins": [ @@ -2534,6 +2536,3271 @@ } ] }, + "analysis-uk-marriage": { + "id": "uk/marriage", + "kind": "app", + "country_id": "uk", + "slug": "marriage", + "title": "Marriage calculator", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/marriage", + "deployments": [], + "owner": "max-ghenis", + "published": "2026-09-11", + "current_pins": [], + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-22", + "kind": "backfill", + "results_pins": [], + "producers_searched": [ + "academic", + "centax", + "centre_for_british_progress", + "dfe", + "dwp", + "fabian_society", + "hm_treasury", + "ifs", + "ippr", + "jrf", + "landman_economics", + "lse_case", + "niesr", + "obr", + "open_search", + "resolution_foundation", + "tax_policy_associates", + "uk_hmrc", + "ukmod" + ], + "producers_with_finds": [ + "academic", + "ifs", + "jrf", + "open_search" + ], + "found_not_staged": [], + "not_applicable": [ + "scottish_fiscal_commission" + ], + "found": 97 + } + ], + "claims": 97, + "compared": 0, + "beside_nearest": 0, + "over_threshold": 0, + "sign_disagreements": 0, + "explained": 0, + "pending": 0, + "unbounded_gaps": 0, + "max_abs_gap": null, + "tracking_issues": [], + "search_log": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/policyengine-scorecard/blob/main/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json", + "comparisons": [ + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.41, + "value_raw": "0.41", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.03, + "value_raw": "0.03", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.56, + "value_raw": "0.56", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 13.22, + "value_raw": "13.22", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.95, + "value_raw": "0.95", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.03, + "value_raw": "0.03", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.02, + "value_raw": "0.02", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 85.11, + "value_raw": "85.11", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.81, + "value_raw": "0.81", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.09, + "value_raw": "0.09", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.11, + "value_raw": "0.11", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 39.22, + "value_raw": "39.22", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.68, + "value_raw": "0.68", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.04, + "value_raw": "0.04", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.27, + "value_raw": "0.27", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 44.7, + "value_raw": "44.7", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.37, + "value_raw": "0.37", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.61, + "value_raw": "0.61", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.02, + "value_raw": "0.02", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 16.91, + "value_raw": "16.91", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.89, + "value_raw": "0.89", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.11, + "value_raw": "0.11", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.0, + "value_raw": "0", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 95.3, + "value_raw": "95.30", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.77, + "value_raw": "0.77", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.23, + "value_raw": "0.23", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.0, + "value_raw": "0", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 47.05, + "value_raw": "47.05", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_penalty_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with penalty", + "metric": "share_losing", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.64, + "value_raw": "0.64", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_premium_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with premium", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.35, + "value_raw": "0.35", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_neutral_share", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with neither", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 0.01, + "value_raw": "0.01", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 51.59, + "value_raw": "51.59", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_net_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 34300000000, + "value_raw": "£34.3 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_penalties", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 34700000000, + "value_raw": "£34.7 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_premiums", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "ifs", + "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", + "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "period": 2011, + "fy": "2010-11", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 600000000, + "value_raw": "£0.6 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate." + }, + { + "claim": "jrf_2011_minimum_wage_state_support_couple_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "jrf", + "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", + "title": "Does the tax and benefit system create a couple penalty?", + "url": "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix 3, Table 10, printed/PDF page 48", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_support_tax_credits_housing_benefit_council_tax_benefit", + "period": 2011, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "central", + "range_group": null, + "value": 106.48, + "value_raw": "106.48", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households when living together", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine household calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates results for inputs entered by the user." + }, + { + "claim": "jrf_2011_nine_pounds_hour_state_support_couple_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "jrf", + "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", + "title": "Does the tax and benefit system create a couple penalty?", + "url": "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix 3, Table 10, printed/PDF page 48", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_support_tax_credits_housing_benefit_council_tax_benefit", + "period": 2011, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "central", + "range_group": null, + "value": 153.4, + "value_raw": "153.40", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households when living together", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine household calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates results for inputs entered by the user." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_0_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPE 0 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4696, + "value_raw": "4696", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7586, + "value_raw": "7586", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7782, + "value_raw": "7782", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 13234, + "value_raw": "13234", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9406, + "value_raw": "9406", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE p 50", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6066, + "value_raw": "6066", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 20780, + "value_raw": "20780", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 17130, + "value_raw": "17130", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 50", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 13790, + "value_raw": "13790", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 90", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2108, + "value_raw": "2108", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_0_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPE 0 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2418, + "value_raw": "2418", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4994, + "value_raw": "4994", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3336, + "value_raw": "3336", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 8075, + "value_raw": "8075", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3587, + "value_raw": "3587", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE p 50", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -609, + "value_raw": "-609", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SE 0", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 13411, + "value_raw": "13411", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 10", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9049, + "value_raw": "9049", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 50", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3148, + "value_raw": "3148", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "oecd", + "publisher": "OECD Publishing", + "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", + "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 90", + "metric": "household_tax_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", + "period": 1998, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -610, + "value_raw": "-610", + "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters." + }, + { + "claim": "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_20000", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", + "title": "The Stability Advantage: Marriage, Family Breakdown and Poverty in the UK", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34", + "metric": "illustrative_household_income_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 5700, + "value_raw": "£5,700", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_30000", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", + "title": "The Stability Advantage: Marriage, Family Breakdown and Poverty in the UK", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34", + "metric": "illustrative_household_income_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "period": 2026, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9600, + "value_raw": "£9,600", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_income_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -14.66, + "value_raw": "-14.66%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_uc_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -37.0, + "value_raw": "-37.0%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_income_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -12.4, + "value_raw": "-12.4%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_uc_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -12.4, + "value_raw": "-12.4%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_income_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -24.44, + "value_raw": "-24.44%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_uc_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -92.1, + "value_raw": "-92.1%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_income_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "basis": "static", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -8.4, + "value_raw": "-8.4%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_uc_loss", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "publisher": "Policy Exchange", + "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "universal_credit", + "period": 2021, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -14.0, + "value_raw": "-14.0%", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_5k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £5k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -4680, + "value_raw": "-£4,680", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_10k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £10k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -3212, + "value_raw": "-£3,212", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_15k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £15k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": -1162, + "value_raw": "-£1,162", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_20k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £20k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 888, + "value_raw": "£888", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_25k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £25k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2938, + "value_raw": "£2,938", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_30k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £30k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 3265, + "value_raw": "£3,265", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_5k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £5k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 678, + "value_raw": "£678", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_10k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £10k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2728, + "value_raw": "£2,728", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_15k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £15k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4778, + "value_raw": "£4,778", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_20k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £20k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6828, + "value_raw": "£6,828", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_25k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £25k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7155, + "value_raw": "£7,155", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_30k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £30k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7155, + "value_raw": "£7,155", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_5k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £5k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2050, + "value_raw": "£2,050", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_10k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £10k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4100, + "value_raw": "£4,100", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_15k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £15k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6150, + "value_raw": "£6,150", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_20k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £20k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_25k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £25k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_30k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £30k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_5k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £5k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2050, + "value_raw": "£2,050", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_10k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £10k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 4100, + "value_raw": "£4,100", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_15k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £15k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6150, + "value_raw": "£6,150", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_20k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £20k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_25k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £25k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_30k", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £30k", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "static", + "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", + "period": 2014, + "fy": "2013-14", + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 6477, + "value_raw": "£6,477", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "csj_2009_material_penalty_couples", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", + "title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16", + "metric": "affected_count", + "basis": "static", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "period": 2009, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1800000, + "value_raw": "1.8 million", + "sign_convention": "positive = more units", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "csj_2009_average_equivalised_shortfall", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", + "title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16", + "metric": "average_equivalised_income_shortfall", + "basis": "static", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "period": 2009, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 1336, + "value_raw": "£1,336", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "csj_2009_aggregate_equivalised_shortfall", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", + "title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16", + "metric": "aggregate_equivalised_couple_penalty", + "basis": "static", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "period": 2009, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 2400000000, + "value_raw": "£2.4 billion", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the exchequer", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_1_children_penalty_maximum", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", + "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 1-child scenario", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "tax_credits", + "period": 2013, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "upper_bound", + "range_group": null, + "value": 7100, + "value_raw": "£7,100", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_2_children_penalty_maximum", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", + "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 2-child scenario", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "tax_credits", + "period": 2013, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "upper_bound", + "range_group": null, + "value": 9985, + "value_raw": "£9,985", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + }, + { + "claim": "marriage_foundation_2013_3_children_penalty_maximum", + "found_on": "2026-10-22", + "source": "marriage_foundation", + "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", + "title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", + "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", + "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 3-child scenario", + "metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", + "basis": "unstated", + "program": "tax_credits", + "period": 2013, + "fy": null, + "value_kind": "point", + "range_group": null, + "value": 11917, + "value_raw": "£11,917", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "estimate": null, + "estimate_label": null, + "pe_value": null, + "gap": null, + "gap_unbounded": false, + "group_gap": null, + "sign_disagrees": false, + "over_threshold": false, + "nearest_estimate": null, + "nearest_pe_value": null, + "nearest_gap": null, + "status": null, + "cause": null, + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user." + } + ] + }, "analysis-uk-middle-east-war-living-standards": { "id": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", "kind": "app", @@ -2541,6 +5808,7 @@ "slug": "middle-east-war-living-standards", "title": "Impact of the Middle East war on UK living standards", "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "deployments": [], "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", "published": "2026-09-25", "current_pins": [ @@ -3732,6 +7000,7 @@ "slug": "triple-lock", "title": "The Burnham plan vs the triple lock", "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/triple-lock", + "deployments": [], "owner": "vahid-ahmadi", "published": "2026-10-16", "current_pins": [ @@ -4959,6 +8228,7 @@ "slug": "2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", "title": "2025 Supplemental Poverty Measure: what Census reported, and what threshold growth did to it", "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/research/2025-supplemental-poverty-measure", + "deployments": [], "owner": "max-ghenis", "published": "2026-09-18", "current_pins": [ @@ -5887,6 +9157,7 @@ "slug": "child-poverty-impact-dashboard", "title": "Child poverty impact dashboard", "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/child-poverty-impact-dashboard", + "deployments": [], "owner": "david-trimmer", "published": "2026-09-15", "current_pins": [ @@ -6382,6 +9653,7 @@ "slug": "futa-wage-base-dashboard", "title": "FUTA taxable wage base dashboard", "url": "https://policyengine.org/us/futa-wage-base-dashboard", + "deployments": [], "owner": "david-trimmer", "published": "2026-09-17", "current_pins": [ diff --git a/data/lanes.json b/data/lanes.json index b73c58b8f..42f590a12 100644 --- a/data/lanes.json +++ b/data/lanes.json @@ -586,8 +586,8 @@ "country": "UK", "stage": "computed", "running": false, - "updated": "2026-10-21", - "note": "5 analyses searched, 128 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" + "updated": "2026-10-22", + "note": "6 analyses searched, 168 claims, 100 PolicyEngine results beside them" }, { "id": "analysis-comparables-us", @@ -597,7 +597,7 @@ "country": "US", "stage": "computed", "running": false, - "updated": "2026-10-21", + "updated": "2026-10-22", "note": "3 analyses searched, 90 claims, 69 PolicyEngine results beside them" } ] diff --git a/data/populations.json b/data/populations.json index 94c50dd78..69427c251 100644 --- a/data/populations.json +++ b/data/populations.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "built": "2026-10-22", "note": "Non-Urban populations exported from scorecard.db: the populace reform-validation registry (issue #20) plus the compute campaign's attached comparisons (US: TPC/CPSP/PWBM/CBO/JCT; UK: the HMRC ready-reckoner family and the complete OBR Policy measures database, including historical HM Treasury scores; BE: JRC EUROMOD-BE claims with demo-grade Axiom concept-mismatch attachments and the 2026 PIT-reform scorekeeper claims; NZ: official budget scores). Claims explicitly opted into pre-result display remain in the feed with latest status not_computed and empty history. Recorded result statuses and calibration relationships are verbatim; nothing here is a pass/fail grade.", "summary": { - "claims": 29935, + "claims": 29975, "multi_release_claims": 270, "by_source": { "aspe_welfare_indicators": 14, @@ -113,6 +113,7 @@ "census": 26, "centax": 26, "centre_for_british_progress": 30, + "centre_for_social_justice": 1, "cpsp": 3, "desnz": 2, "dwp": 4, @@ -121,7 +122,7 @@ "good_energy": 5, "green_party": 1, "hm_treasury": 2, - "ifs": 10, + "ifs": 45, "ippr": 3, "itep": 2, "jrf": 3, @@ -130,6 +131,7 @@ "niesr": 3, "ny_fiscal_note": 1, "octopus_energy": 1, + "policy_exchange": 4, "ppic": 1, "rea": 2, "resolution_foundation": 25, @@ -140,13 +142,13 @@ "comparable": 84, "concept_mismatch": 131, "constructed": 1675, - "not_computed": 27156, + "not_computed": 27196, "pe_gap": 889 }, "by_sign_relative_to_pe": { "magnitude": 14, - "opposite": 553, - "same": 29099, + "opposite": 562, + "same": 29130, "unknown": 269 }, "by_country": { @@ -165,10 +167,10 @@ "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "UK": { - "claims": 29289, + "claims": 29329, "with_result": 2262, "with_value": 1277, - "without_result": 27027, + "without_result": 27067, "multi_release_claims": 0 }, "US": { @@ -37035,6 +37037,69 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "bfc2838896f933cb199e", + "source": "centre_for_social_justice", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Existing couples affected by material couple penalty", + "name": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", + "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "metric": "affected_count", + "unit_concept": "benefit_units", + "value_kind": "count", + "period": 2009, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "csj_2009_material_penalty_couples", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2.3 synthetically separates existing FRS couples with fixed gross earnings and family characteristics (page 111 footnote 13); these incidence figures do not apply a labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison": "Standard of living together versus a fully equivalised income from living apart. This retains the producer\u2019s adjustment for savings from sharing a household.", + "country": "UK", + "data": "FRS 2005/06 and matching HBAI 2005/06. Report page 45 footnote 18 and page 169 footnote 21.", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "population": "Existing couples represented as FRS benefit units; not couples discouraged from forming.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "taxes_and_benefits", + "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous 2009 report snapshot of current couple penalties; input survey 2005/06 is recorded separately. No exact model fiscal year assigned.", + "sign_convention": "positive = more units", + "value_verbatim": "1.8 million" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "65f8a8774b6c3fcb", + "external_value": 1800000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 1800000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "03d666ddda6fe83bd6f4", "source": "co_admin", @@ -126476,6 +126541,534 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "393a7ea6f1f7944fa897", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "51.59" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 51.59, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -51.59, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "58961ccaea7ff2003163", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "44.7" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 44.7, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -44.7, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2215f7c88571fd6499a4", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "95.30" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 95.3, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -95.3, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ec112283c9663139e024", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "85.11" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 85.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -85.11, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "062c1d2cb3281cbeeb81", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "16.91" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 16.91, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -16.91, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f208721c905d2f798d34", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "13.22" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 13.22, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -13.22, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "53df18f191d5979911a2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "47.05" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 47.05, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -47.05, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "c910c409634bf88405bc", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (\u00a3/wk)", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "average_household_income_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "39.22" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 39.22, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -39.22, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "111608638bd5d2d834af", "source": "ifs", @@ -182180,6 +182773,198 @@ "results": [], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "80545ae5dd6bed2deb45", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate net penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_net_penalty", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a334.3 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 34300000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 34300000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "efb426811062025377f7", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate penalty amongst those with penalties", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_penalties", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "couples_with_penalty", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a334.7 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 34700000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 34700000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "ef0afe266b1c7b183c73", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Aggregate premium amongst those with premiums", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_premiums", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "subgroup": "couples_with_premium", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a30.6 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 600000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -600000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "4235f56a23af01b464bd", "source": "ifs", @@ -183199,40 +183984,1612 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "claim_id": "ebbbecb80227bc790c88", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "", + "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "point", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": null, + "conditions": { + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", + "fy": "2029-30", + "geography": "UK", + "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", + "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", + "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4500000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", + "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", + "metric": "revenue_change", + "unit_concept": "gbp", + "value_kind": "gbp", + "period": 2030, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "fuel_duty", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", + "basis": "unstated", + "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2029-30", + "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", + "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", + "program": "fuel_duty", + "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", + "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", + "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", + "external_value": 4000000000.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", + "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", + "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "530e698cd8a5ff35c608", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.35" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.35, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.35, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d8469d14d533fb2c4c15", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.04" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.04, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.04, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "01f534560eda12b91bec", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.03" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.03, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.03, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "b0f9c7393d6171512818", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.11" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a0fac7d5633329069f81", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.03" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.03, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.03, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "f7ada9840cfbf91f3287", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.61" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.61, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.61, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1ec19ce9c558c1d6c676", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.09" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.09, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.09, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d099d41551214b7d5d56", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_gaining", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.23" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.23, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.23, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "20f236cf6ff80a0a79a2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.68" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.68, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.68, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "eddb2fd1f37ad7b5e0bb", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.64" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.64, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.64, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "2bb01c2cf3f830216160", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.95" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.95, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.95, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "715ebd6a38eb07ced642", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.89" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.89, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.89, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "62e209142979e4998cbd", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.37" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.37, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.37, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "821d8bde5ea4f38b33a3", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.41" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.41, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.41, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "415b1168631a36b54ca5", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.77" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.77, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.77, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4ba70168b6c9225533c2", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_losing", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.81" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.81, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.81, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "1918c6a8e457e8ede3ff", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.01" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.01, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.01, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "84dfe42003f1d4fe245a", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "all_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.27" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.27, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.27, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "4debf25b6fdd8df747ac", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.02" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.02, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.02, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "97fb3217efada64bcc79", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_children", + "value_verbatim": "0" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a40461d5a9304bbf23c9", + "source": "ifs", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, + "time_basis": "fiscal_year", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", + "country": "UK", + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.02" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.02, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.02, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "a53b11a9e2e87d7ce00b", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "", - "name": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", + "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "Options for tax increases (Adam, Delestre, Miller; IFS Green Budget 2025 chapter 4)", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/2025-10/Options_for_tax_increases_IFS_Green_Biudget_2025_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "point", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, "geography": "UK", - "program": null, + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fiscal_event": "autumn_budget_2025", - "fy": "2029-30", + "fy": "2010-11", "geography": "UK", - "reform_hint": "illustrative package: G/H council tax surcharge \u00a34.4bn + abolish the residence nil-rate band \u00a36bn + bank surcharge to 6% \u00a31.2bn + end CGT forgiveness at death \u00a32.3bn + abolish BADR \u00a30.9bn + reduce the small companies tax gap by \u00a35bn", - "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a320 billion" + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", + "value_verbatim": "0.56" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "72d10bcafe58d454", - "external_value": 20000000000.0, + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.56, "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:same", - "external_value_pe_sign": 20000000000.0, + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.56, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -183254,45 +185611,51 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "118664b70582e70a6823", + "claim_id": "af1ad461c79b895cfbf3", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1))", - "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": null, - "program": "fuel_duty", + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { - "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", - "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_barclays_inflation", - "basis": "unstated", - "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fy": "2029-30", - "inflation_assumption": "Barclays forecast (IFS Green Budget 2026, chapter 1)", - "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", - "program": "fuel_duty", - "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34.5 billion" + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario A", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0.11" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", - "external_value": 4500000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -4500000000.0, + "reform_key": "287eff36777afba1", + "external_value": 0.11, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.11, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -183314,45 +185677,51 @@ "diagnosis": null }, { - "claim_id": "fb13f165afcad9bfb399", + "claim_id": "c43902849a4ce1607c75", "source": "ifs", "country": "UK", - "source_column": "Cost in 2029-30 of a freeze to 2029-30 (OBR March 2026 forecast)", - "name": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", + "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", + "name": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "window": "", - "publication_title": "The IFS Green Budget: October 2026", - "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/system/files/2026-10/IFS_Green_Budget_2026_0.pdf", - "metric": "revenue_change", - "unit_concept": "gbp", - "value_kind": "gbp", - "period": 2030, + "publication_title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", + "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "metric": "share_no_change", + "unit_concept": "share", + "value_kind": "share", + "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "period_start": null, "period_end": null, - "geography": null, - "program": "fuel_duty", + "geography": "UK", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "conditions": { - "analysis": "uk/middle-east-war-living-standards", - "analysis_claim": "ifs_fuel_duty_freeze_to_2030_obr_inflation", - "basis": "unstated", - "basis_note": "not recorded by the backfill search; the claim is not compared", + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24\u201327: TAXBEN on FRS 2006\u201307, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "country": "UK", - "fy": "2029-30", - "inflation_assumption": "OBR March 2026 forecast", - "pe_missing": "A 2029-30 cost; the analysis estimates 2027-28 only.", - "program": "fuel_duty", - "program_note": "5p fuel duty cut made permanent and the freeze extended to 2029-30", - "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", - "value_verbatim": "\u00a34 billion" + "fy": "2010-11", + "geography": "UK", + "housing_costs": "bhc", + "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", + "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate.", + "price_base": "2010-11", + "prices": "real", + "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", + "scenario": "Scenario B", + "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", + "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", + "value_verbatim": "0" }, "measure": null, "reform_framework": "policy_ref", - "reform_key": "be54b7545a648920", - "external_value": 4000000000.0, - "sign_relative_to_pe": "opposite", - "sign_basis": "stated:exchequer:opposite", - "external_value_pe_sign": -4000000000.0, + "reform_key": "e53522e98b1c759a", + "external_value": 0.0, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "level", + "external_value_pe_sign": 0.0, "calibration_relationship": "held_out", "claim_baseline": "current_law", "latest": { @@ -335966,6 +338335,270 @@ ], "diagnosis": null }, + { + "claim_id": "3da46557d4b371cc93bb", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3330/week", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-14.66%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -14.66, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -14.66, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "5a53a36540ba743a8ba1", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-12.4%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -12.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -12.4, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "d90a8b0eccac93bf60b8", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3165/week", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3330/week", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-24.44%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -24.44, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -24.44, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, + { + "claim_id": "e37add237f04c8f3c924", + "source": "policy_exchange", + "country": "UK", + "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", + "name": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "window": "", + "publication_title": "Taxing Families Fairly", + "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", + "unit_concept": "percent", + "value_kind": "percent", + "period": 2021, + "time_basis": "point_in_time", + "period_start": null, + "period_end": null, + "geography": null, + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "conditions": { + "analysis": "uk/marriage", + "analysis_claim": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_income_loss", + "basis": "static", + "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", + "benchmark_class": "different_model", + "children": "two children under 5", + "country": "UK", + "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", + "minimum_wage": "\u00a38.91 hourly", + "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a3165/week", + "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "\u00a30", + "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", + "prices": "unstated", + "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", + "reference_date": "2021-10-15", + "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", + "statistic": "illustrative household", + "value_verbatim": "-8.4%", + "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week" + }, + "measure": null, + "reform_framework": "policy_ref", + "reform_key": "184dc6f2d0f53edc", + "external_value": -8.4, + "sign_relative_to_pe": "same", + "sign_basis": "stated:household_gain:same", + "external_value_pe_sign": -8.4, + "calibration_relationship": "held_out", + "claim_baseline": "current_law", + "latest": { + "value": null, + "status": "not_computed", + "engine_version": "", + "data_bundle": "", + "release": "", + "construction": "", + "policyengine_variables": [], + "computed_at": "", + "annotations": [], + "baseline": null, + "status_effective": "not_computed", + "ratio": null, + "delta": null + }, + "results": [], + "diagnosis": null + }, { "claim_id": "01c5b5f5f094361c1391", "source": "policy_exchange", diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/analysis.json b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..27ee2f7ec --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/analysis/1", + "id": "uk/marriage", + "country": "UK", + "registry": { + "kind": "app", + "slug": "marriage", + "country_id": "uk" + }, + "title": "Marriage calculator", + "url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/marriage", + "published": "2026-09-11", + "owner": { + "author": "max-ghenis" + }, + "scope": "uk_wide", + "subject": "For a couple described by the user, compares taxes, benefits and net household income when living together against the combined income of two separate households. The income grid varies those household earnings; it is not a population distribution.", + "search_terms": [ + "UK couple penalty benefits", + "marriage penalty universal credit", + "living together penalty", + "marriage allowance claims", + "couple penalty number of households" + ], + "worlds": { + "living_together": { + "policy": "uk_couple_living_together", + "description": "Two adults live together as one couple and household under the tax-benefit rules for the selected year, compared with the same adults living in separate households. The app keeps children with the first adult when separated; external specimens record their own child-allocation assumptions." + }, + "living_apart": { + "policy": "uk_couple_living_apart", + "description": "The two adults live in separate households under the same tax-benefit rules, with household-specific earnings, children and housing arrangements." + }, + "ifs_scenario_a": { + "policy": "uk_2010_11_couple_penalty_same_household", + "description": "IFS 2010–11 Scenario A: compare an existing mixed-sex couple with the same adults assessed as single people while remaining in the same household. Children stay with the woman; characteristics, income sources and asset ownership otherwise stay fixed." + }, + "ifs_scenario_b": { + "policy": "uk_2010_11_couple_penalty_separate_households", + "description": "IFS 2010–11 Scenario B: compare an existing mixed-sex couple with the same adults assessed as single people in separate single-adult households, with housing costs assigned from matched households. Children stay with the woman; characteristics, income sources and asset ownership otherwise stay fixed." + }, + "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples": { + "policy": "uk_1998_couple_penalty_hypothetical_families", + "description": "OECD WP76 section5: fixed-earnings hypothetical couples under 1998 UK tax-transfer rules, comparing married/cohabiting status with two separated single adults. Rent is divided equally; in the two-child cases each separated adult has custody of one child. The ten income configurations use primary- and secondary-earner earnings percentiles; money values are converted to 2007 euros using compensation-per-employee indices and exchange rates." + }, + "csj_2009_equivalised_comparison": { + "policy": "uk_2009_couple_material_penalty_needs_adjusted", + "description": "CSJ Dynamic Benefits current-system 2009 snapshot: existing FRS couples compared with synthetic separation after equivalising income to allow for savings from living together. Material penalties concern a lower standard of living, not unadjusted combined cash transfers. The input survey is 2005/06; the publication does not supply an exact policy fiscal year." + } + }, + "pe_estimates": [], + "calculator": { + "reason": "The live UK page computes taxes, benefits and net-income changes for the household the user enters, together and as two separate households, including an income-grid chart for that household. It publishes no fixed population count, fiscal cost, share or specimen-household estimate and reads no aggregate results file. The live HTML deployment ID dpl_6F85da9qGCBcVmpyNtGAY3Lwo9Ms matches the successful Vercel status on PolicyEngine/marriage commit 2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852. At that commit app/MarriageApp.jsx initializes results to null and calculates on submission; lib/api.js computes the couple and two separate households through the runtime service, lib/countries.js selects /uk/calculate, and backend/uk.py accepts exactly one household. Code and deployment evidence URLs and hashes are recorded with the open_search checks; there is no results file to pin." + } +} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/annotations.json b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/annotations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe51488c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/annotations.json @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +[] diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/claims_staged.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/claims_staged.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dcd1cefbf --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/claims_staged.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.41, "value_raw": "0.41", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.41 0.03 0.56 13.22 34.28 20.53 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.03, "value_raw": "0.03", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.41 0.03 0.56 13.22 34.28 20.53 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.56, "value_raw": "0.56", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.41 0.03 0.56 13.22 34.28 20.53 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 13.22, "value_raw": "13.22", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, no children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.41 0.03 0.56 13.22 34.28 20.53 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.95, "value_raw": "0.95", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.95 0.03 0.02 85.11 90.37 16.85 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.03, "value_raw": "0.03", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.95 0.03 0.02 85.11 90.37 16.85 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.02, "value_raw": "0.02", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.95 0.03 0.02 85.11 90.37 16.85 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 85.11, "value_raw": "85.11", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Couple, children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.95 0.03 0.02 85.11 90.37 16.85 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.81, "value_raw": "0.81", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.81 0.09 0.11 39.22 50.62 18.17 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.09, "value_raw": "0.09", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.81 0.09 0.11 39.22 50.62 18.17 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.11, "value_raw": "0.11", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.81 0.09 0.11 39.22 50.62 18.17 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 39.22, "value_raw": "39.22", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row Pensioner couple, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.81 0.09 0.11 39.22 50.62 18.17 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.68, "value_raw": "0.68", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.68 0.04 0.27 44.7 66.49 18.62 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.04, "value_raw": "0.04", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.68 0.04 0.27 44.7 66.49 18.62 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.27, "value_raw": "0.27", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.68 0.04 0.27 44.7 66.49 18.62 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 44.7, "value_raw": "44.7", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 96 (PDF page 97), row All, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 1", "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.68 0.04 0.27 44.7 66.49 18.62 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.37, "value_raw": "0.37", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.37 0.61 0.02 16.91 67.05 13.44 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.61, "value_raw": "0.61", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.37 0.61 0.02 16.91 67.05 13.44 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.02, "value_raw": "0.02", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.37 0.61 0.02 16.91 67.05 13.44 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 16.91, "value_raw": "16.91", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_no_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, no children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, no children: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.37 0.61 0.02 16.91 67.05 13.44 6395524", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.89, "value_raw": "0.89", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.89 0.11 0 95.30 108.38 10.93 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.11, "value_raw": "0.11", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.89 0.11 0 95.30 108.38 10.93 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.0, "value_raw": "0", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, children: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.89 0.11 0 95.30 108.38 10.93 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 95.3, "value_raw": "95.30", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "working_age_children", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Couple, children, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Couple, children: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.89 0.11 0 95.30 108.38 10.93 5386965", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.77, "value_raw": "0.77", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.77 0.23 0 47.05 65.87 16.11 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.23, "value_raw": "0.23", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.77 0.23 0 47.05 65.87 16.11 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.0, "value_raw": "0", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.77 0.23 0 47.05 65.87 16.11 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 47.05, "value_raw": "47.05", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "pensioner_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row Pensioner couple, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "Pensioner couple: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.77 0.23 0 47.05 65.87 16.11 2990696", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_penalty_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_losing", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.64, "value_raw": "0.64", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples facing a loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with penalty", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "All: Proportion with penalty", "quote": "0.64 0.35 0.01 51.59 87.64 13.51 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_premium_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_gaining", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.35, "value_raw": "0.35", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples gaining household income", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with premium", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "All: Proportion with premium", "quote": "0.64 0.35 0.01 51.59 87.64 13.51 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_neutral_share", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "share_no_change", "unit_concept": "share", "value": 0.01, "value_raw": "0.01", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = share of couples with no household income change", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Proportion with neither", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "All: Proportion with neither", "quote": "0.64 0.35 0.01 51.59 87.64 13.51 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "average_household_income_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 51.59, "value_raw": "51.59", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario B", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "income_concept": "benefits_and_tax_credits_less_tax_liability", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status", "housing_costs": "bhc"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_b", "reform_hint": "Scenario B", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Table 24, printed page 113 (PDF page 114), row All, column Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 24", "source_column": "All: Mean penalty/premium (£/wk)", "quote": "0.64 0.35 0.01 51.59 87.64 13.51 14773185", "note": "Published table cell, not a chart reading. These are 2010–11 tax-benefit rules and 2010–11 prices; the data are FRS 2006–07. The paper measures tax-benefit net state support, not the overall financial gains from shared living costs. Pensioner couples include a partner over state pension age; the other family groups are working age. Same-sex couples are excluded (p 27). Shares are printed as fractions and rounded; rows can fail to sum exactly to one. With non-state income sources fixed, a positive couple penalty is a loss of combined disposable income when coupled rather than assessed as two singles.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_net_penalty", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 34300000000, "value_raw": "£34.3 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "all_couples", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Section 5.1.1, aggregate penalty and footnote 22", "source_column": "Aggregate net penalty", "quote": "£34.3 billion", "note": "The IFS authors publish this annual aggregate explicitly on p 34 (also the executive summary p 4); it is not derived here. It is the extra net state support arising if couples split into separate benefit units in the same household. The net penalty is the Exchequer saving from coupled assessment relative to single assessment. The sum across couples with premiums is an Exchequer cost in that same direction. IFS footnote 22 says the printed gross figures do not reconcile to the net figure because of rounding. The model excludes behavioural responses and uses 2010–11 prices.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_penalties", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 34700000000, "value_raw": "£34.7 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "couples_with_penalty", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = yield to the Exchequer", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Section 5.1.1, aggregate penalty and footnote 22", "source_column": "Aggregate penalty amongst those with penalties", "quote": "£34.7 billion", "note": "The IFS authors publish this annual aggregate explicitly on p 34 (also the executive summary p 4); it is not derived here. It is the extra net state support arising if couples split into separate benefit units in the same household. The net penalty is the Exchequer saving from coupled assessment relative to single assessment. The sum across couples with premiums is an Exchequer cost in that same direction. IFS footnote 22 says the printed gross figures do not reconcile to the net figure because of rounding. The model excludes behavioural responses and uses 2010–11 prices.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_premiums", "source": "ifs", "found_by": "ifs", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "ifs_taxben", "metric": "revenue_change", "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 600000000, "value_raw": "£0.6 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2010-11", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2, pp 24–27: TAXBEN on FRS 2006–07, full take-up of benefits and tax credits; individual characteristics, income sources and asset ownership held fixed when household relationship status is changed. No labour-supply response.", "program": "uk_taxes_benefits_and_tax_credits", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2010-11", "subgroup": "couples_with_premium", "scenario": "Scenario A", "sign_convention": "positive = cost to the Exchequer", "comparison_direction": "coupled status relative to single status"}, "world": "ifs_scenario_a", "reform_hint": "Scenario A", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "primary_sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "locator": "Section 5.1.1, printed page 34 (PDF page 35), aggregate penalty paragraph and footnote 22", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Section 5.1.1, aggregate penalty and footnote 22", "source_column": "Aggregate premium amongst those with premiums", "quote": "£0.6 billion", "note": "The IFS authors publish this annual aggregate explicitly on p 34 (also the executive summary p 4); it is not derived here. It is the extra net state support arising if couples split into separate benefit units in the same household. The net penalty is the Exchequer saving from coupled assessment relative to single assessment. The sum across couples with premiums is an Exchequer cost in that same direction. IFS footnote 22 says the printed gross figures do not reconcile to the net figure because of rounding. The model excludes behavioural responses and uses 2010–11 prices.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator computes taxes and benefits for households the user enters and publishes no fixed population aggregate, share or average with which to compare this IFS estimate."} +{"key": "jrf_2011_minimum_wage_state_support_couple_penalty", "source": "jrf", "found_by": "jrf", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "minimum_income_calculator", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 106.48, "value_raw": "106.48", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "central", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"month": "2011-04", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Page 25 describes a static comparison. Pages 7 and 10 hold work patterns unchanged across together/apart scenarios.", "program": "income_support_tax_credits_housing_benefit_council_tax_benefit", "program_note": "Table 10 totals tax credits plus Income Support and Housing Benefit plus Council Tax Benefit; the printed value excludes the separate needs adjustment.", "prices": "cash", "geography": "England", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households when living together", "hourly_wage_gbp": "5.93", "household": "Couple with one full-time earner and two children aged 3 and 7; mother does not work; children remain with mother when separated.", "housing_assumption": "Council rent for the parent with children; 25th percentile England private one-bedroom rent for the separated father."}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "How much less together than apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Does the tax and benefit system create a couple penalty?", "url": "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf", "date": "2012-06-18", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "primary_sha256": "2dd75571e1eece4a06243d5fd2828b5d15ff9bb75c6b0a524259bd9934d5e27c", "locator": "Appendix 3, Table 10, printed/PDF page 48", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 10", "source_column": "Total; hourly wage GBP 5.93", "quote": "How much less together than apart 30.19 76.29 106.48", "note": "This is a fixed illustrative state-support reduction for one family, not a population mean, fiscal cost, or the needs-adjusted couple penalties used elsewhere in the paper. The source prints separate together/apart net-income levels but does not print their unadjusted difference; no difference was derived.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine household calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates results for inputs entered by the user."} +{"key": "jrf_2011_nine_pounds_hour_state_support_couple_penalty", "source": "jrf", "found_by": "jrf", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "minimum_income_calculator", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change", "unit_concept": "gbp_per_week", "value": 153.4, "value_raw": "153.40", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "central", "period": 2011, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"month": "2011-04", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Page 25 describes a static comparison. Pages 7 and 10 hold work patterns unchanged across together/apart scenarios.", "program": "income_support_tax_credits_housing_benefit_council_tax_benefit", "program_note": "Table 10 totals tax credits plus Income Support and Housing Benefit plus Council Tax Benefit; the printed value excludes the separate needs adjustment.", "prices": "cash", "geography": "England", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households when living together", "hourly_wage_gbp": "9", "household": "Couple with one full-time earner and two children aged 3 and 7; mother does not work; children remain with mother when separated.", "housing_assumption": "Council rent for the parent with children; 25th percentile England private one-bedroom rent for the separated father."}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "How much less together than apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Does the tax and benefit system create a couple penalty?", "url": "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf", "date": "2012-06-18", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "primary_sha256": "2dd75571e1eece4a06243d5fd2828b5d15ff9bb75c6b0a524259bd9934d5e27c", "locator": "Appendix 3, Table 10, printed/PDF page 48", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 10", "source_column": "Total; hourly wage GBP 9", "quote": "How much less together than apart 66.21 87.19 153.40", "note": "This is a fixed illustrative state-support reduction for one family, not a population mean, fiscal cost, or the needs-adjusted couple penalties used elsewhere in the paper. The source prints separate together/apart net-income levels but does not print their unadjusted difference; no difference was derived.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine household calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates results for inputs entered by the user."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_0_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 4696, "value_raw": "4696", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "0", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPE 0 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PE 0 - SE 0", "quote": "4696", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 7586, "value_raw": "7586", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p10", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp10 - SE 0", "quote": "7586", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 7782, "value_raw": "7782", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p10", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp10 - SEp10", "quote": "7782", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 13234, "value_raw": "13234", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SE 0", "quote": "13234", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 9406, "value_raw": "9406", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SEp10", "quote": "9406", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 6066, "value_raw": "6066", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p50", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE p 50", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SE p50", "quote": "6066", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 20780, "value_raw": "20780", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SE 0", "quote": "20780", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 17130, "value_raw": "17130", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp10", "quote": "17130", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 13790, "value_raw": "13790", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p50", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 50", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp50", "quote": "13790", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 2108, "value_raw": "2108", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p90", "children": "2", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage", "child_custody": "one child with each separated adult"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table 5, printed page 45 (PDF page 46), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 90", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table 5", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp90", "quote": "2108", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_0_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 2418, "value_raw": "2418", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "0", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPE 0 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PE 0 - SE 0", "quote": "2418", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 4994, "value_raw": "4994", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p10", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp10 - SE 0", "quote": "4994", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 3336, "value_raw": "3336", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p10", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 10 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp10 - SEp10", "quote": "3336", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 8075, "value_raw": "8075", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SE 0", "quote": "8075", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 3587, "value_raw": "3587", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SEp10", "quote": "3587", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": -609, "value_raw": "-609", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p50", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p50", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 50 - SE p 50", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp50 - SE p50", "quote": "-609", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 13411, "value_raw": "13411", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "0", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SE 0", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SE 0", "quote": "13411", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 9049, "value_raw": "9049", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p10", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 10", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp10", "quote": "9049", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": 3148, "value_raw": "3148", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p50", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 50", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp50", "quote": "3148", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty", "source": "oecd", "found_by": "academic", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "euromod", "metric": null, "proposed_metric": "household_tax_change", "unit_concept": "eur", "value": -610, "value_raw": "-610", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 1998, "time_basis": "annual", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 5, paragraphs 63–66 and footnote 20: the marriage penalty is the combined tax liability net of transfers when coupled minus that of two individuals; individual earnings are held constant at separation.", "program": "uk_taxes_and_transfers", "program_note": "Earned-income tax and transfer treatment of hypothetical couples; unearned income excluded (footnote22).", "geography": "UK", "prices": "real", "price_base": "2007", "price_note": "The authors convert 1998 amounts using national compensation-per-employee indices, not a consumer-price index, and apply 2007 average annual GBP/EUR exchange rates (table notes).", "primary_earner_earnings": "p90", "secondary_earner_earnings": "p90", "children": "0", "housing": "rental; each separated adult bears half the couple rent", "specimen": "hypothetical_family", "sign_convention": "positive = increase in combined tax liability net of transfers following marriage"}, "world": "oecd_1998_hypothetical_couples", "reform_hint": "marriage penalty", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "primary_sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "locator": "Table A 4, printed page 53 (PDF page 54), UK column, rowPEp 90 - SEp 90", "access": "direct"}, "source_table": "Table A 4", "source_column": "UK; PEp90 - SEp90", "quote": "-610", "note": "A labelled table cell for one hypothetical family, not a population average or a chart reading. Source year is 1998;2007 is the money-value base. Positive values are marriage/cohabitation penalties and negative values are subsidies. These values are printed identically in IZA DP 3965; that duplicate is not separately staged. The registered average_tax_change metric would imply a population average, so this single-household calculation retains the harvest household_tax_change proposal.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The Marriage calculator publishes no fixed population aggregate and no pinned result for this historical OECD hypothetical household; its results depend on the household the user enters."} +{"key": "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_20000", "source": "centre_for_social_justice", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "policy_in_practice_better_off_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 5700, "value_raw": "£5,700", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "The report states these are example scenarios worked at Policy in Practice; it does not state a behavioural basis.", "program": "taxes_and_benefits", "program_note": "Mother’s annual financial loss on marrying or moving in with the father; programme components are not separately stated.", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "mother_age": "30", "mother_work": "not in work; looks after one-year-old full time", "child_age": "1", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "20000", "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous July 2026 snapshot of the report’s current tax and benefit system; no tax year is stated."}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "she marries, or even moves in with, the child’s father", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Stability Advantage: Marriage, Family Breakdown and Poverty in the UK", "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", "date": "2026-07-06", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "primary_sha256": "6b870a2e5cdd74ba98f9b3d3cfe39ca7a0cc776ba9d8b15708e9ac34d23fc1d7", "access": "direct", "locator": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34"}, "source_table": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34", "source_column": "Annual financial loss when marrying or moving in with father earning £20000 gross", "quote": "£5,700", "note": "Fixed worked example by CSJ author using Policy in Practice’s calculator, not a population average or a Policy in Practice publication. Snapshot is dated to July 2026 publication; no fiscal-year assignment is inferred.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_income_change"} +{"key": "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_30000", "source": "centre_for_social_justice", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "policy_in_practice_better_off_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 9600, "value_raw": "£9,600", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2026, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "The report states these are example scenarios worked at Policy in Practice; it does not state a behavioural basis.", "program": "taxes_and_benefits", "program_note": "Mother’s annual financial loss on marrying or moving in with the father; programme components are not separately stated.", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households", "mother_age": "30", "mother_work": "not in work; looks after one-year-old full time", "child_age": "1", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "30000", "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous July 2026 snapshot of the report’s current tax and benefit system; no tax year is stated."}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "she marries, or even moves in with, the child’s father", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "The Stability Advantage: Marriage, Family Breakdown and Poverty in the UK", "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", "date": "2026-07-06", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "primary_sha256": "6b870a2e5cdd74ba98f9b3d3cfe39ca7a0cc776ba9d8b15708e9ac34d23fc1d7", "access": "direct", "locator": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34"}, "source_table": "Printed page 12 (PDF page 14), Address the couple penalty, footnote 34", "source_column": "Annual financial loss when marrying or moving in with father earning £30000 gross", "quote": "£9,600", "note": "Fixed worked example by CSJ author using Policy in Practice’s calculator, not a population average or a Policy in Practice publication. Snapshot is dated to July 2026 publication; no fiscal-year assignment is inferred.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_income_change"} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_income_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -14.66, "value_raw": "-14.66%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£330/week", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime", "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£0 £330/week £1,707.53 £2,000.98 -14.66% -37.0%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user."} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_uc_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -37.0, "value_raw": "-37.0%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "household Universal Credit receipts", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£330/week", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income fulltime", "source_column": "Loss in Total Universal Credit (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£0 £330/week £1,707.53 £2,000.98 -14.66% -37.0%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change"} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_income_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -12.4, "value_raw": "-12.4%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed", "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£0 £0 £984.06 £1,123.81 -12.4% -12.4%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user."} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_uc_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -12.4, "value_raw": "-12.4%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "household Universal Credit receipts", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), no income unemployed", "source_column": "Loss in Total Universal Credit (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£0 £0 £984.06 £1,123.81 -12.4% -12.4%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change"} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_income_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -24.44, "value_raw": "-24.44%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£165/week", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£330/week", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime", "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£165/week £330/week £1,915.86 £2,535.79 -24.44% -92.1%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user."} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_uc_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -92.1, "value_raw": "-92.1%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "household Universal Credit receipts", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£165/week", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£330/week", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime fulltime", "source_column": "Loss in Total Universal Credit (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£165/week £330/week £1,915.86 £2,535.79 -24.44% -92.1%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change"} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_income_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": "pct_change_after_tax_income", "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -8.4, "value_raw": "-8.4%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "income_tax_national_insurance_universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "after-tax-and-transfer household income", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£165/week", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed", "source_column": "Loss in Total Income (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£165/week £0 £1518.09 £1657.84 -8.4% -14.0%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user."} +{"key": "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_uc_loss", "source": "policy_exchange", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "turn2us_benefits_calculator", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "percent", "value": -14.0, "value_raw": "-14.0%", "normalization": "percent as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2021, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Table 1 keeps stated earnings and family characteristics fixed, and applies tax, National Insurance, Married Couples Allowance and calculator UC entitlements under each living arrangement.", "program": "universal_credit", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "income_concept": "household Universal Credit receipts", "statistic": "illustrative household", "partner_a_gross_weekly_earnings": "£165/week", "partner_b_gross_weekly_earnings": "£0", "children": "two children under 5", "minimum_wage": "£8.91 hourly", "working_hours": "full-time 37 per week; part-time 18.5 per week", "reference_date": "2021-10-15"}, "world": "living_together", "reform_hint": "live together rather than separately", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "primary_sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "access": "direct", "locator": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed"}, "source_table": "Table 1, printed page 23 (PDF page 24), parttime unemployed", "source_column": "Loss in Total Universal Credit (%) if living together, rather than separately", "quote": "£165/week £0 £1518.09 £1657.84 -8.4% -14.0%", "note": "Own illustrative modelling using Turn 2us, as footnote 30 states. Figures representative as of 15 October 2021; monthly household income loss is expressed as a percentage, without annualisation. Monetary together/apart levels are table inputs to this published contrast. The total-income percentage is not a population average.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_pct_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_5k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -4680, "value_raw": "-£4,680", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£5k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £5k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £5k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£5k £3,265 £4,680 £7,945 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 -£4,680", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_10k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -3212, "value_raw": "-£3,212", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£10k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £10k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £10k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£10k £3,265 £3,212 £6,477 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 -£3,212", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_15k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": -1162, "value_raw": "-£1,162", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£15k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £15k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £15k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£15k £3,265 £1,162 £4,427 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 -£1,162", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_20k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 888, "value_raw": "£888", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£20k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £20k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £20k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£20k £2,377 £0 £2,377 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 £888", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_25k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2938, "value_raw": "£2,938", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£25k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £25k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £25k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£25k £327 £0 £327 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 £2,938", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_30k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 3265, "value_raw": "£3,265", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (no income support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£30k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £30k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (no income support), Dad earns £30k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£30k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,265", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_5k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 678, "value_raw": "£678", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£5k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £5k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £5k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£5k £3,265 £3,212 £6,477 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £678", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_10k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2728, "value_raw": "£2,728", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£10k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £10k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £10k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£10k £3,265 £1,162 £4,427 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £2,728", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_15k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4778, "value_raw": "£4,778", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£15k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £15k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £15k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£15k £2,377 £0 £2,377 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £4,778", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_20k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6828, "value_raw": "£6,828", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£20k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £20k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £20k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£20k £327 £0 £327 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £6,828", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_25k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 7155, "value_raw": "£7,155", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£25k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £25k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £25k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£25k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £7,155", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_30k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 7155, "value_raw": "£7,155", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Stay at home mum (on Income Support)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£30k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £30k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Stay at home mum (on Income Support), Dad earns £30k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£30k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £0 £3,890 £7,155 £7,155", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_5k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2050, "value_raw": "£2,050", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£5k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £5k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £5k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£5k £3,265 £1,162 £4,427 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £2,050", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_10k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4100, "value_raw": "£4,100", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£10k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £10k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £10k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£10k £2,377 £0 £2,377 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £4,100", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_15k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6150, "value_raw": "£6,150", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£15k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £15k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £15k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£15k £327 £0 £327 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,150", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_20k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£20k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £20k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £20k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£20k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_25k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£25k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £25k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £25k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£25k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_30k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£30k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £30k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Part time mum (works 20 hours weekly, £5,000 pa), Dad earns £30k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£30k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_5k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2050, "value_raw": "£2,050", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£5k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £5k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £5k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£5k £3,265 £1,162 £4,427 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £2,050", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_10k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 4100, "value_raw": "£4,100", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£10k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £10k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £10k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£10k £2,377 £0 £2,377 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £4,100", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_15k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6150, "value_raw": "£6,150", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£15k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £15k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £15k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£15k £327 £0 £327 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,150", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_20k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£20k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £20k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £20k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£20k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_25k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£25k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £25k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £25k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£25k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_30k", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_hmrc_tax_credit_income_support_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 6477, "value_raw": "£6,477", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2014, "time_basis": "fiscal_year", "conditions": {"fy": "2013-14", "basis": "static", "basis_note": "Appendix A directly calculates tax credits and Income Support for fixed earnings and family arrangements using HMRC 2013-2014 information.", "program": "child_tax_credit_working_tax_credit_income_support", "program_note": "Annual combined CTC, WTC and IS; excludes housing costs, most benefits and income tax.", "prices": "cash", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "statistic": "illustrative household", "household_scenario": "Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa)", "father_gross_annual_earnings": "£30k", "children": "one young child", "reference_period_note": "Appendix A explicitly states calculations are based on HMRC website information for 2013-2014."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "whether the couple lives together or apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "primary_sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "access": "direct", "locator": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £30k"}, "source_table": "Appendix A, printed page 6 (PDF page 6), Full time working mum (works 40 hours weekly, £10,000 pa), Dad earns £30k", "source_column": "Better off apart? (NO YES)", "quote": "£30k £0 £0 £0 £3,265 £3,212 £0 £6,477 £6,477", "note": "Own HMRC-rate calculation. The last column is the printed annual difference in selected state support if apart rather than together. It is not a full disposable-income calculation or a population average. The author motivates the contrast partly as pretending to live apart; this record retains the stated benefit-assessment scenarios without adopting the report’s fraud inference.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "csj_2009_material_penalty_couples", "source": "centre_for_social_justice", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "csj_frs_synthetic_separation", "metric": "affected_count", "unit_concept": "benefit_units", "value": 1800000, "value_raw": "1.8 million", "normalization": "millions x 1e6", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2009, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2.3 synthetically separates existing FRS couples with fixed gross earnings and family characteristics (page 111 footnote 13); these incidence figures do not apply a labour-supply response.", "program": "taxes_and_benefits", "prices": "unstated", "geography": "UK", "population": "Existing couples represented as FRS benefit units; not couples discouraged from forming.", "data": "FRS 2005/06 and matching HBAI 2005/06. Report page 45 footnote 18 and page 169 footnote 21.", "comparison": "Standard of living together versus a fully equivalised income from living apart. This retains the producer’s adjustment for savings from sharing a household.", "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous 2009 report snapshot of current couple penalties; input survey 2005/06 is recorded separately. No exact model fiscal year assigned.", "sign_convention": "positive = more units"}, "world": "csj_2009_equivalised_comparison", "reform_hint": "compared each couple’s current income with their income had they lived apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", "date": "2009-09-16", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "primary_sha256": "8a7dad31edc2d58cafe132dfbc31802616ec8f3f466eac12cf6f684bf850d448", "access": "direct", "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16"}, "source_table": "Section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty", "source_column": "Existing couples affected by material couple penalty", "quote": "1.8 million", "note": "Own CSJ FRS-based synthetic-separation calculation. These are material penalties after adjusting income needs for living together, not raw cash differences. Exact release date 16 September 2009 is supported by Commons Library CBP 9090 printedpage 11 footnote 33. The report distinguishes its descriptive material-penalty incidence from subsequent behavioural reform modelling.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user."} +{"key": "csj_2009_average_equivalised_shortfall", "source": "centre_for_social_justice", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "csj_frs_synthetic_separation", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp_per_household", "value": 1336, "value_raw": "£1,336", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2009, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2.3 synthetically separates existing FRS couples with fixed gross earnings and family characteristics (page 111 footnote 13); these incidence figures do not apply a labour-supply response.", "program": "taxes_and_benefits", "prices": "unstated", "geography": "UK", "population": "Existing couples represented as FRS benefit units; not couples discouraged from forming.", "data": "FRS 2005/06 and matching HBAI 2005/06. Report page 45 footnote 18 and page 169 footnote 21.", "comparison": "Standard of living together versus a fully equivalised income from living apart. This retains the producer’s adjustment for savings from sharing a household.", "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous 2009 report snapshot of current couple penalties; input survey 2005/06 is recorded separately. No exact model fiscal year assigned.", "sign_convention": "positive = loss to households"}, "world": "csj_2009_equivalised_comparison", "reform_hint": "compared each couple’s current income with their income had they lived apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", "date": "2009-09-16", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "primary_sha256": "8a7dad31edc2d58cafe132dfbc31802616ec8f3f466eac12cf6f684bf850d448", "access": "direct", "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16"}, "source_table": "Section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty", "source_column": "Average annual shortfall against fully equivalised level", "quote": "£1,336", "note": "Own CSJ FRS-based synthetic-separation calculation. These are material penalties after adjusting income needs for living together, not raw cash differences. Exact release date 16 September 2009 is supported by Commons Library CBP 9090 printedpage 11 footnote 33. The report distinguishes its descriptive material-penalty incidence from subsequent behavioural reform modelling.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "average_equivalised_income_shortfall"} +{"key": "csj_2009_aggregate_equivalised_shortfall", "source": "centre_for_social_justice", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "csj_frs_synthetic_separation", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 2400000000, "value_raw": "£2.4 billion", "normalization": "GBP bn x 1e9 -> GBP", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2009, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "static", "basis_note": "Section 4.2.3 synthetically separates existing FRS couples with fixed gross earnings and family characteristics (page 111 footnote 13); these incidence figures do not apply a labour-supply response.", "program": "taxes_and_benefits", "prices": "unstated", "geography": "UK", "population": "Existing couples represented as FRS benefit units; not couples discouraged from forming.", "data": "FRS 2005/06 and matching HBAI 2005/06. Report page 45 footnote 18 and page 169 footnote 21.", "comparison": "Standard of living together versus a fully equivalised income from living apart. This retains the producer’s adjustment for savings from sharing a household.", "reference_period_note": "Contemporaneous 2009 report snapshot of current couple penalties; input survey 2005/06 is recorded separately. No exact model fiscal year assigned.", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to the exchequer"}, "world": "csj_2009_equivalised_comparison", "reform_hint": "compared each couple’s current income with their income had they lived apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", "url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", "date": "2009-09-16", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "primary_sha256": "8a7dad31edc2d58cafe132dfbc31802616ec8f3f466eac12cf6f684bf850d448", "access": "direct", "locator": "Printed page 112 (PDF page 112), section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty; footnotes 13 and 16"}, "source_table": "Section 4.2.3 The magnitude of the couple penalty", "source_column": "Annual Government saving relative to fully equivalised treatment", "quote": "£2.4 billion", "note": "Own CSJ FRS-based synthetic-separation calculation. These are material penalties after adjusting income needs for living together, not raw cash differences. Exact release date 16 September 2009 is supported by Commons Library CBP 9090 printedpage 11 footnote 33. The report distinguishes its descriptive material-penalty incidence from subsequent behavioural reform modelling.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "aggregate_equivalised_couple_penalty"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_1_children_penalty_maximum", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_tax_credit_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 7100, "value_raw": "£7,100", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "upper_bound", "period": 2013, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "The release gives rounded maximum gains for claiming to live apart. It does not specify model assumptions for the two- and three-child cases.", "program": "tax_credits", "program_note": "Release describes gains in tax credits from claiming to live apart.", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "children": "1", "reference_period_note": "Snapshot as of the release date 2013-09-15. This webpage does not separately state the model tax year for its two- and three-child maxima."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "pretending to live apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "access": "direct", "primary_sha256": "14f699f9243bbd10ea0a143e11c818367a9b596909d2a1ca35ed1c7b6e5961bb", "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 1-child scenario"}, "source_table": "Own release: Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "source_column": "Maximum extra annual income claiming to live apart; 1 child", "quote": "up to £7,100", "note": "Own Marriage Foundation release corresponding to September 2013 report. Webpage datePublished is 2013-09-15. First maximum is the rounded headline synopsis (not the exact £7,155 Appendix A maximum). The two- and three-child maxima appear on this own release but are not itemised in the one-child appendix. All are treated as maxima in the release’s up-to comparison; no annualisation or re-signing.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_2_children_penalty_maximum", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_tax_credit_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 9985, "value_raw": "£9,985", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "upper_bound", "period": 2013, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "The release gives rounded maximum gains for claiming to live apart. It does not specify model assumptions for the two- and three-child cases.", "program": "tax_credits", "program_note": "Release describes gains in tax credits from claiming to live apart.", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "children": "2", "reference_period_note": "Snapshot as of the release date 2013-09-15. This webpage does not separately state the model tax year for its two- and three-child maxima."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "pretending to live apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "access": "direct", "primary_sha256": "14f699f9243bbd10ea0a143e11c818367a9b596909d2a1ca35ed1c7b6e5961bb", "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 2-child scenario"}, "source_table": "Own release: Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "source_column": "Maximum extra annual income claiming to live apart; 2 children", "quote": "up to £9,985", "note": "Own Marriage Foundation release corresponding to September 2013 report. Webpage datePublished is 2013-09-15. First maximum is the rounded headline synopsis (not the exact £7,155 Appendix A maximum). The two- and three-child maxima appear on this own release but are not itemised in the one-child appendix. All are treated as maxima in the release’s up-to comparison; no annualisation or re-signing.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} +{"key": "marriage_foundation_2013_3_children_penalty_maximum", "source": "marriage_foundation", "found_by": "open_search", "found_on": "2026-10-22", "source_model": "author_tax_credit_calculations", "metric": null, "unit_concept": "gbp", "value": 11917, "value_raw": "£11,917", "normalization": "as printed", "value_kind": "point", "period": 2013, "time_basis": "point_in_time", "conditions": {"basis": "unstated", "basis_note": "The release gives rounded maximum gains for claiming to live apart. It does not specify model assumptions for the two- and three-child cases.", "program": "tax_credits", "program_note": "Release describes gains in tax credits from claiming to live apart.", "prices": "unstated", "sign_convention": "positive = gain to households", "children": "3", "reference_period_note": "Snapshot as of the release date 2013-09-15. This webpage does not separately state the model tax year for its two- and three-child maxima."}, "world": "living_apart", "reform_hint": "pretending to live apart", "attribution": "own", "benchmark_class": "different_model", "baseline_policy": null, "publication": {"title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "access": "direct", "primary_sha256": "14f699f9243bbd10ea0a143e11c818367a9b596909d2a1ca35ed1c7b6e5961bb", "locator": "Release body, paragraph beginning Cohabiting couples; 3-child scenario"}, "source_table": "Own release: Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "source_column": "Maximum extra annual income claiming to live apart; 3 children", "quote": "£11,917", "note": "Own Marriage Foundation release corresponding to September 2013 report. Webpage datePublished is 2013-09-15. First maximum is the rounded headline synopsis (not the exact £7,155 Appendix A maximum). The two- and three-child maxima appear on this own release but are not itemised in the one-child appendix. The three-child figure is a point because the source does not explicitly say up to for it. No annualisation or re-signing.", "parse_confidence": "high", "status": "ok", "compare_to": null, "pe_missing": "The PolicyEngine Marriage calculator publishes no aggregate or fixed household estimate; it calculates tax and benefit differences only for the household entered by its user.", "proposed_metric": "illustrative_household_state_support_change"} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/manifest.jsonl b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/manifest.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8a47abe13 --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/manifest.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +{"url": "https://policyengine.org/uk/marriage", "title": "Marriage calculator live page", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "88e60af15ccfc5337ef887f03dcd2dd187060574a48e919d9837c6cc397e8a32", "bytes": 41458, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/live-page.html."} +{"url": "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/commits/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/status", "title": "Marriage calculator commit deployment status", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "7bcfe8c8d9e5102b796ee30792b43efc1e41169ad4a082f4713268a36010c55e", "bytes": 5126, "doc_type": "json", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/commit-status.json.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/deployments/6348928002/statuses", "title": "Marriage calculator production deployment status", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "3d27e5611d30eccefc1f9773e6291b71f42e40127e7608d7d9ce63a3341067e3", "bytes": 1734, "doc_type": "json", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/production-statuses.json.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/git/trees/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852?recursive=1", "title": "Marriage calculator repository tree", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "7d01d6e1d1d14becfed74a0896efa1e90df961070f92ee607594ba38fd547386", "bytes": 23439, "doc_type": "json", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/repository-tree.json.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/app/MarriageApp.jsx", "title": "Marriage calculator app/MarriageApp.jsx", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "f037fb19020eec9cab022d9c6cf9b21caa20434cc17a1cb3bfb9c281fdb9262d", "bytes": 23632, "doc_type": "text", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/app/MarriageApp.jsx.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/app/components/ResultsDisplay.jsx", "title": "Marriage calculator app/components/ResultsDisplay.jsx", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "f13c51669b019d8d71bcc58f7f8deb2058bcbbd92696b12bb06731255b91f4f9", "bytes": 17383, "doc_type": "text", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/app/components/ResultsDisplay.jsx.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/lib/api.js", "title": "Marriage calculator lib/api.js", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "a86485de1fbe2bb9ca73784891a5229a707a0d784a1740f7340c1d8795a98e31", "bytes": 31367, "doc_type": "text", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/lib/api.js.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/lib/countries.js", "title": "Marriage calculator lib/countries.js", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "7aad4c44199f249e568a0fd33a7d861b7ad4db6b5fcb59aa77cfdea000fc72ca", "bytes": 18724, "doc_type": "text", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/lib/countries.js.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/backend/uk.py", "title": "Marriage calculator backend/uk.py", "publisher": "PolicyEngine", "sha256": "76b1737b38eb9db91a8a547a40e414592bb754bee0bae7e6edd8ed2e9ee3d1d9", "bytes": 8750, "doc_type": "text", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Downloaded outside repository to calculator-evidence-20261022/backend/uk.py.", "date": "2026-09-09"} +{"url": "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", "title": "Couple penalties and premiums in the UK tax and benefit system", "date": "2010-04-29", "publisher": "Institute for Fiscal Studies", "sha256": "e499bcf060eddf428c845f576f41d5a96ae1c9a7a93993ce3918e722fb14ea66", "bytes": 944243, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "IFS publication landing page dates the report 29 April 2010. PDF Tables 1 and 24 visually checked; section 4.2 supplies model and static assumptions."} +{"url": "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf", "title": "Does the tax and benefit system create a couple penalty?", "date": "2012-06-18", "publisher": "Joseph Rowntree Foundation", "sha256": "2dd75571e1eece4a06243d5fd2828b5d15ff9bb75c6b0a524259bd9934d5e27c", "bytes": 224830, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Author-hosted copy of JRF Programme Paper by Donald Hirsch (June 2012), ISBN 978 1 85935 917 4; JRF landing page and migrated PDF paths returned 404. Downloaded outside repository to jrf-hirsch-2012-20261022/author-couple.pdf."} +{"url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", "title": "An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples in European Countries", "date": "2009-01-23", "publisher": "OECD Publishing", "sha256": "1811df818bf52482661f73711073728199e124a94f8a3b49a92c7b2b9f823b55", "bytes": 1279625, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No.76, DOI 10.1787/227200406151. PDF second page prints 23-Jan-2009; OECD publication landing page independently prints 23 January 2009. This is the same authors and paper as IZA DP 3965, whose cover states only January 2009; the OECD primary is used to avoid inventing a day."} +{"url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1167979/living-together-fraud-household-formation.pdf", "title": "Are household formation decisions and living together fraud & error affected by the Living Together as a Married Couple policy? An Evidence Review", "publisher": "Department for Work and Pensions", "sha256": "922a61141bef7c78273e7b42343db092b09438200222f1649272071ba5d47a02", "bytes": 900216, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Primary retained outside repository at /private/tmp/claude-501/comparables-primaries/analysis-uk-marriage/context-primaries-20261022/dwp-living-together-review.pdf; reviewed as context, not a staged comparator."} +{"url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/tax-reliefs/tax-relief-statistics-january-2026", "title": "Tax relief statistics (January 2026)", "publisher": "HM Revenue and Customs", "sha256": "ebef95acc7cbc00f69a77247496a78309c8bdaa777452a4caba78f000c851bb3", "bytes": 676621, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Primary retained outside repository at /private/tmp/claude-501/comparables-primaries/analysis-uk-marriage/context-primaries-20261022/hmrc-tax-reliefs.html; reviewed as context, not a staged comparator."} +{"url": "https://www.royallondon.com/siteassets/site-docs/media-centre/policy-papers/royal-london-policy-paper-1-the-living-together-penalty.pdf", "title": "The living together penalty", "publisher": "Royal London", "sha256": "e10873987ae040282873c64e8a45565a06eab37e02362ed7b0f91c5a779f5075", "bytes": 1006794, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Primary retained outside repository at /private/tmp/claude-501/comparables-primaries/analysis-uk-marriage/context-primaries-20261022/royal-london.pdf; reviewed as context, not a staged comparator."} +{"url": "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/04/Saving-penalties.pdf", "title": "Saving penalties: Reforming the capital rules in Universal Credit", "publisher": "Resolution Foundation", "sha256": "e754f21e5f00902a9b95af94ed1fbc4efa2e885bbe6aa8cb3337d5cd8d3b5a62", "bytes": 1026766, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Primary retained outside repository at /private/tmp/claude-501/comparables-primaries/analysis-uk-marriage/context-primaries-20261022/rf-saving-penalties.pdf; reviewed as context, not a staged comparator.", "date": "2025-04-24"} +{"url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", "title": "The Stability Advantage: Marriage, Family Breakdown and Poverty in the UK", "date": "2026-07-06", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "sha256": "6b870a2e5cdd74ba98f9b3d3cfe39ca7a0cc776ba9d8b15708e9ac34d23fc1d7", "bytes": 262997, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", "title": "A marriage tax break must counter the crazy incentive for parents to pretend to live apart", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "sha256": "0b951dc5301d0b9cc80434862d11a94e77792adbd28eced8155307242b5358c1", "bytes": 136886, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", "title": "Taxing Families Fairly", "date": "2022-08-09", "publisher": "Policy Exchange", "sha256": "783951861ec09139a600aaab6aec27c1e682b216362c4833adade2284f6e7692", "bytes": 1948925, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://www.civitas.org.uk/content/files/Reform-the-Marriage-Allowance.pdf", "title": "Reform the Marriage Allowance", "date": "2022-11", "publisher": "Civitas", "sha256": "c62922f7d0be867ffd4ed5b80674d310686b2bed7d85a8bb457ef06ff68aa2a2", "bytes": 606761, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/MarriagePaperFINAL_ii_.pdf", "title": "Why is the Government anti-Marriage?", "date": "2009-12", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "sha256": "c2b228f4ca7b9b09ffaa153b494193ab4dc60b2495872e3659228b100a66711c", "bytes": 203170, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://iea.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/IEA%20Redefining%20Poverty%20Debate.pdf", "title": "Redefining the Poverty Debate", "date": "2012", "publisher": "Institute of Economic Affairs", "sha256": "9a00c05cc22f293b566ceff076ebfb0a8394df4842d5fe40d2fa08cb5d47f5b8", "bytes": 1210467, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/MF-policy-brief-Refocus-the-Marriage-Allowance.pdf", "title": "Refocus the Marriage Allowance", "date": "2024-05", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "sha256": "af60960f11f12d569fd344ef9a434a28b241a9ee20d8a14d45335e190f72b722", "bytes": 796244, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/election-special-refocus-the-marriage-allowance/", "title": "Election special: Refocus the marriage allowance", "date": null, "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "sha256": "986e92d5bae83eb1cf79e63087cd71d8a7d6a021c26bf860035514aa9b9befdf", "bytes": 107397, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/newsroom/10000-couple-penalty-shatters-wedding-prospects-for-low-income-british-couples", "title": "£10,000 couple penalty shatters wedding prospects for low-income British couples", "date": "2026-07-06", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "sha256": "0fa6b49fb163723239682b66768fd4565aa00040ad82f858a93c98877b2533d9", "bytes": 110815, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", "title": "Quarter of a million couples pretend to live apart", "date": "2013-09-15", "publisher": "Marriage Foundation", "sha256": "14f699f9243bbd10ea0a143e11c818367a9b596909d2a1ca35ed1c7b6e5961bb", "bytes": 110680, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22"} +{"url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", "title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works", "date": "2009-09-16", "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "sha256": "8a7dad31edc2d58cafe132dfbc31802616ec8f3f466eac12cf6f684bf850d448", "bytes": 2561206, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/library/dynamic-benefits-towards-welfare-that-works", "title": "Dynamic Benefits: Towards welfare that works (publication page)", "date": null, "publisher": "Centre for Social Justice", "sha256": "ab4fbd0fd5afac22d2812dca0adc0d67675a8416abedd031f478ce5e81fce7b4", "bytes": 96606, "doc_type": "html", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": ""} +{"url": "https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-9090/CBP-9090.pdf?download=1", "title": "The aims of ten years of welfare reform2010-2020", "date": "2020-12-18", "publisher": "House of Commons Library", "sha256": "769bc09fe534cbe0ceb6efa98aa7ef2c0eda01231c76eea0cf02c1f72ca5ea52", "bytes": 497349, "doc_type": "pdf", "access": "direct", "retrieved": "2026-10-22", "note": "Commons Library footnote 33 on printedpage 11 dates the CSJ report to 16 September 2009."} diff --git a/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..be12c423a --- /dev/null +++ b/sources/analysis-uk-marriage/search_log.json @@ -0,0 +1,466 @@ +{ + "schema": "comparables/search/1", + "searches": [ + { + "date": "2026-10-22", + "kind": "backfill", + "by": "subfleet:20261022-125054-cmp2-uk-marriage", + "results_pins": [], + "producers": [ + { + "producer": "obr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:obr.uk \"couple penalty\" benefits marriage", + "site:obr.uk marriage allowance policy costings supplementary briefing papers" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://obr.uk/data/", + "https://obr.uk/category/policy-costings/", + "https://obr.uk/forecasts-in-depth/brief-explainers/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No estimate of the tax-benefit difference between coupled and separate households found. Search results cover the policy-measures database, EFO costings/supplementary material and briefing/working papers; Marriage Allowance policy costings are a single tax-policy change rather than the couple-formation contrast. Direct attempts at data/costing pages returned 403 and the explainer URL was inaccessible: this part of the search used indexed text, not downloaded OBR tables." + }, + { + "producer": "hm_treasury", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"HM Treasury\" \"couple penalty\"", + "site:gov.uk \"HM Treasury\" marriage allowance budget policy costings impact households" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supporting-documents-for-budget-2025", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supporting-documents-for-spring-statement-2025/spring-statement-2025-policy-costings", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supporting-documents-for-spring-statement-2025/impact-on-households-distributional-analysis-to-accompany-spring-statement-2025" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Checked costings, scorecard and distributional-analysis publication locations. No coupled-versus-separated estimate found. Budget 2014 transferable-Marriage-Allowance introduction and current allowance indexation are policy reforms/parameters, not the joint tax-benefit change on household formation; current distributional charts score government policy packages against a policy baseline." + }, + { + "producer": "uk_hmrc", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"tax information and impact note\" marriage allowance couples", + "site:gov.uk HMRC \"couple penalty\" \"marriage\"", + "site:gov.uk HMRC direct effects illustrative tax changes marriage allowance statistics" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/tax-information-and-impact-notes-tiins", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/direct-effects-of-illustrative-tax-changes/direct-effects-of-illustrative-tax-changes-bulletin-january-2025", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/tax-reliefs/tax-relief-statistics-january-2026" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No HMRC estimate of couple formation versus living apart found. The ready reckoner prices tax-rate/allowance reforms. Tax-relief statistics section 3.32 gives Marriage Allowance costs and successful-claimant administrative counts, not a modeled couple penalty; these are calibration material for a producer-level source under docs/COMPARABLES.md and are not staged here. The 2014 introduction TIIN scores introducing one relief, not the full coupled/separated contrast." + }, + { + "producer": "dwp", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"impact assessment\" DWP \"couple penalty\"", + "site:gov.uk DWP \"living together\" \"Universal Credit\" penalty estimate households", + "site:gov.uk DWP benefit expenditure caseload tables 2026 couples" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/benefit-expenditure-and-caseload-tables-2026", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/universal-credit-and-couples-an-introduction/universal-credit-further-information-for-couples", + "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1167979/living-together-fraud-household-formation.pdf", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/pathways-to-work-reforming-benefits-and-support-to-get-britain-working-green-paper/spring-statement-2025-health-and-disability-benefit-reforms-impacts" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "The DWP/RAND evidence review concerns household formation, fraud/error and perceptions of the Living Together as a Married Couple policy; no own modeled couple-formation tax-benefit amount or affected-population estimate found. Guidance explains joint assessment; caseload/expenditure releases are administrative or baseline levels. Disability-reform impact assessments score a different policy change." + }, + { + "producer": "dfe", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:gov.uk \"Department for Education\" \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "site:explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk living together couples funded early education", + "site:gov.uk \"Department for Education\" marriage living together impact assessment parliamentary FOI" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/methodology/funded-early-education-and-childcare", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/department-for-education/about/publication-scheme", + "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/childrens-wellbeing-and-schools-act-impact-assessments" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Checked childcare statistics/methodology, impact-assessment publication locations, and the publication scheme listing parliamentary answers and FOI releases. No DfE coupled-versus-separated tax-benefit estimate found; funded-childcare take-up levels and education/social-care policy assessments measure other quantities." + }, + { + "producer": "scottish_fiscal_commission", + "result": "not_applicable", + "queries": [], + "checked": [], + "claims": [], + "note": "The producer list applies only to Scotland-scoped analyses; this analysis is uk_wide." + }, + { + "producer": "ifs", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:ifs.org.uk \"couple penalty\"", + "site:ifs.org.uk \"marriage penalty\" benefits", + "site:ifs.org.uk living together benefits couples penalty Green Budget working paper" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/couple-penalties-and-premiums-uk-tax-and-benefit-system", + "https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn102.pdf", + "https://ifs.org.uk/publications/green-budget-2026-full-report", + "https://ifs.org.uk/research-and-analysis/working-papers" + ], + "claims": [ + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_no_children_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_working_age_children_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_pensioner_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_penalty_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_premium_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_neutral_share", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_b_all_couples_net_penalty_mean", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_net_penalty", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_penalties", + "ifs_2010_11_scenario_a_annual_gross_premiums" + ], + "note": "Directly relevant historical TAXBEN study of couple penalties and premiums. Staged the central main family-type shares/mean penalties for both household-separation assumptions, plus the three printed aggregate annual amounts; retained each printed number. These are 2010-11 policy-system estimates, not current-year claims. Detailed distribution quantiles, income-band cells, tax-component decompositions, 1997-98 policy counterfactuals and hypothetical individual matching exercises are not replicated; the main central aggregate distribution is covered. Calculator publishes no aggregate." + }, + { + "producer": "resolution_foundation", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:resolutionfoundation.org \"couple penalty\" benefits", + "site:resolutionfoundation.org \"marriage penalty\" OR \"living together\" benefits", + "site:resolutionfoundation.org reports universal credit couples budget penalty" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/saving-penalties/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2025/04/Saving-penalties.pdf", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/listen-and-learn/", + "https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/app/uploads/2015/06/UC-FINAL-REPORT1.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No quantified together-versus-apart penalty found in reports/briefings or UC budget/reform material. Saving penalties estimates couples affected by capital means-testing relative to no capital test, not the loss caused by forming a couple. Listen and learn and Making the most of UC cost administrative and design reforms; those policies differ from the calculator contrast." + }, + { + "producer": "centax", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:centax.org.uk \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\" OR \"marriage allowance\"", + "site:centax.org.uk couples living together tax benefits reports estimates" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://centax.org.uk/research/", + "https://centax.org.uk/policy/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Research and policy-publication catalogues and subject searches found no coupled-versus-separated tax-benefit estimate. Business partnership income, inheritance-tax spouse transferability and childcare threshold reforms score other tax bases or policy changes." + }, + { + "producer": "centre_for_british_progress", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Centre for British Progress\" \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage\" OR \"living together\"", + "site:britishprogress.org marriage couple benefits penalty estimate" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.britishprogress.org/", + "https://britishprogress.org/reports/rates-and-wrongs-fixing-uk-tax-cliff-edges-and-tap", + "https://britishprogress.org/api/media/file/rates_and_wrongs_technical_appendix.pdf" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No estimate of couple formation found. Rates and wrongs and its technical appendix model childcare/earnings cliff and taper reforms, not living together versus apart. The www homepage was inaccessible; the report and appendix on the bare domain were readable." + }, + { + "producer": "ippr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:ippr.org \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "site:ippr.org \"living together\" tax benefits couples penalty" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.ippr.org/research", + "https://www.ippr.org/research-and-ideas" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No own coupled-versus-separated tax-benefit estimate found in research and briefings; targeted exact-phrase searches returned no results." + }, + { + "producer": "fabian_society", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:fabians.org.uk \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "site:fabians.org.uk living together couples benefits tax universal credit" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://fabians.org.uk/publications/", + "https://fabians.org.uk/publication/in-the-shadows/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No direct coupled-versus-separated tax-benefit contrast found. In the shadows compares working/no-earnings families and tax-free allowances/social-security payments, not otherwise identical adults living together/apart." + }, + { + "producer": "niesr", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:niesr.ac.uk \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "site:niesr.ac.uk \"living together\" benefits couples tax", + "site:niesr.ac.uk publications household universal credit marriage couples", + "site:niesr.ac.uk \"marriage allowance\"" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://niesr.ac.uk/publications", + "https://www.niesr.ac.uk/publications", + "https://niesr.ac.uk/publications/uk-living-standards-review-2025-part-two" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "No couple-formation amount/count/share found. Publication listings returned 403; indexed living-standards and household research discusses benefit adequacy, household composition and UC rules without estimating the coupled/separated contrast. This producer could be checked only through indexed text and search snippets, not a complete publications download." + }, + { + "producer": "ukmod", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:microsimulation.ac.uk \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\" OR \"living together\"", + "UKMOD CeMPA working paper marriage penalty universal credit couples", + "site:microsimulation.ac.uk UKMOD country report couples tax benefit" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.microsimulation.ac.uk/publications/", + "https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/research/publications/publication-547705", + "https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/research/publications/working-papers/cempa/cempa11-26" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CeMPA working-paper and UKMOD country-report locations checked via the ISER publisher after microsimulation.ac.uk failed. Country reports describe model implementation; the recent UC-rollout paper measures mental health, not the tax-benefit penalty from couple formation. No own UKMOD/CeMPA quantified comparator found. The older EUROMOD study found in academic is attributed to its authors/OECD, not to the newer UKMOD producer." + }, + { + "producer": "lse_case", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "\"LSE CASE paper\" living together couples benefits penalty" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://sticerd.lse.ac.uk/case/_new/publications/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "CASE paper/report catalogue and subject searches found no own couple-formation tax-benefit estimate. Retrieved work on cohabitation law, housing, child poverty and household needs covers other outcomes; authors with LSE affiliations publishing outside CASE are not attributed to CASE." + }, + { + "producer": "jrf", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "site:jrf.org.uk \"couple penalty\"", + "site:jrf.org.uk \"marriage penalty\" OR \"living together\" benefits", + "\"benefits-tax-families-full.pdf\"", + "\"Does the tax and benefit system create\" filetype:pdf", + "JRF Hirsch 2012 couple penalty 220 KB benefits tax families" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.jrf.org.uk/care/does-the-tax-and-benefit-system-create-a-couple-penalty", + "https://www.donaldhirsch.com/couple.pdf" + ], + "claims": [ + "jrf_2011_minimum_wage_state_support_couple_penalty", + "jrf_2011_nine_pounds_hour_state_support_couple_penalty" + ], + "note": "Official landing and migrated PDF paths returned 404; the author-hosted JRF primary was recovered and read. Appendix 3 Table 10 prints two unadjusted weekly state-support losses, staged as illustrative household transfers. Headline needs-adjusted MIS/OECD income-adequacy penalties are different quantities, not ordinary cash-income changes or population shares. No differences were calculated from tables that print only together/apart levels." + }, + { + "producer": "landman_economics", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "\"Landman Economics\" \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\"", + "site:landmaneconomics.co.uk \"living together\" OR \"marriage allowance\"", + "\"Landman Economics\" couple penalty benefits report" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://www.landmaneconomics.co.uk/", + "https://www.gov.scot/publications/tackling-child-poverty-delivery-plan-forecasting-child-poverty-scotland/pages/8/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Homepage inaccessible. Subject searches and commissioned-report results (including IPPR/RF/Fabian work) found tax-policy-package impacts and poverty forecasts, not an own together-versus-apart comparison. Read the commissioned Scottish forecast methodology identifying Landman TTM and its policy-reform contrast; no couple-formation amount/count/share found." + }, + { + "producer": "tax_policy_associates", + "result": "none_found", + "queries": [ + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk \"couple penalty\" OR \"marriage penalty\" OR \"marriage allowance\"", + "site:taxpolicy.org.uk couples living together benefits tax estimate" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/reports/", + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2024/04/12/living_with_spouse/", + "https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2025/11/12/the-budget-2025-tax-calculator/" + ], + "claims": [], + "note": "Report index URL inaccessible; articles and calculator description readable. Living with your spouse explains CGT legal definitions without estimating the couple-formation income effect. Budget tax calculator accepts individual earnings and excludes means-tested working-age benefits other than Child Benefit. No fixed coupled/separated numeric comparator found." + }, + { + "producer": "academic", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "Google Scholar UK couple penalty benefits marriage 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026", + "SSRN UK marriage penalty universal credit living together", + "IZA discussion papers UK couple penalty cohabitation tax benefits", + "CEPR VoxEU ISER working papers UK marriage cohabitation tax benefit penalty 2021 2026", + "site:papers.ssrn.com UK \"couple penalty\" benefits", + "site:scholar.google.com UK \"marriage penalty\" universal credit", + "site:iser.essex.ac.uk \"couple penalty\" 2021 OR 2022 OR 2023 OR 2024 OR 2025 OR 2026", + "\"An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment\" OECD published date 2009 2008", + "site:oecd.org \"An Evaluation of the Tax-Transfer Treatment of Married Couples\" 2009 date" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://cepr.org/publications/dp18138", + "https://www.iza.org/publications/dp/3965/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries", + "https://docs.iza.org/dp3965.pdf", + "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_227200406151.html", + "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2009/01/an-evaluation-of-the-tax-transfer-treatment-of-married-couples-in-european-countries_g17a1c7d/227200406151.pdf", + "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/09589287231159492" + ], + "claims": [ + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_0_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_2_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_0_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p10_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p50_se_p50_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_0_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p10_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p50_penalty", + "oecd_1998_children_0_pe_p90_se_p90_penalty" + ], + "note": "Searched the required recent five-year working-paper/journal locations and followed a directly relevant older EUROMOD paper. Staged its UK annual specimen-household marriage penalties in 1998 rules, in real 2007 euros, from the OECD edition whose cover and landing supply the exact publication day; the IZA edition gives only a month. CEPR DP18138 studies the US federal income tax. The 2023 EU marriage/cohabitation paper considers marital status among cohabitants, not separate-household formation; its full-text fetch timed out, so only indexed abstract/description checked. IFS results remain logged under ifs." + }, + { + "producer": "open_search", + "result": "found", + "queries": [ + "UK couple penalty benefits living together number households estimate 2026", + "marriage penalty universal credit UK estimate households cost marriage foundation", + "couple penalty benefits UK Centre Social Justice cost 2025 2026", + "\"couple penalty\" benefits estimate cost households", + "\"marriage penalty\" \"Universal Credit\" estimate", + "site:marriagefoundation.org.uk \"couple penalty\"", + "site:centreforsocialjustice.org.uk \"couple penalty\"", + "\"couple penalty\" cost estimate poverty UK 2026 -site:reddit.com -site:ifs.org.uk -site:wikipedia.org", + "\"living together penalty\" UK benefits estimate", + "\"marriage penalty\" \"Universal Credit\" \"£\" -site:reddit.com -site:wikipedia.org", + "site:centreforsocialjustice.org.uk \"The Stability Advantage\"", + "\"Harry Benson\" \"Stability Advantage\" \"2026\"", + "site:policyexchange.org.uk \"Taxing Families Fairly\" \"2022\"", + "\"Marriage Foundation\" \"couple penalty\" \"7,100\"", + "site:centreforsocialjustice.org.uk \"Dynamic Benefits\" \"2009\" \"1,336\"", + "\"Dynamic Benefits\" \"September\" \"2009\" \"16\"", + "site:centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/library \"Dynamic Benefits\"", + "site:centreforsocialjustice.org.uk \"Dynamic Benefits\" \"September 16\"" + ], + "checked": [ + "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/election-special-refocus-the-marriage-allowance/", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/MarriagePaperFINAL_ii_.pdf", + "https://www.civitas.org.uk/content/files/Reform-the-Marriage-Allowance.pdf", + "https://iea.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/IEA%20Redefining%20Poverty%20Debate.pdf", + "https://www.familyeducationtrust.org.uk/media/latest-news-statements/five-to-one-65-per-cent-of-the-public-want-the-welfare-couple-penalty-abolished-new-poll-finds/", + "https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/SN03372/", + "https://www.royallondon.com/siteassets/site-docs/media-centre/policy-papers/royal-london-policy-paper-1-the-living-together-penalty.pdf", + "https://care.org.uk/cause/marriage-and-family/cares-work-on-marriage-and-family", + "https://policyengine.org/uk/marriage", + "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/commits/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/status", + "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/deployments/6348928002/statuses", + "https://api.github.com/repos/PolicyEngine/marriage/git/trees/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852?recursive=1", + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/app/MarriageApp.jsx", + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/app/components/ResultsDisplay.jsx", + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/lib/api.js", + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/lib/countries.js", + "https://github.com/PolicyEngine/marriage/blob/2864e4092d6a9dd259845fd76925878bcb69e852/backend/uk.py", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/CSJ-Poverty_and_Family_Stability.pdf", + "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/MF-paper-better-off-apart.pdf", + "https://policyexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Taxing-Families-Fairly.pdf", + "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/MF-policy-brief-Refocus-the-Marriage-Allowance.pdf", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/newsroom/10000-couple-penalty-shatters-wedding-prospects-for-low-income-british-couples", + "https://marriagefoundation.org.uk/research/quarter-of-a-million-couples-pretend-to-live-apart/", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/library/the-stability-advantage", + "https://policyexchange.org.uk/publication/taxing-families-fairly/", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/library/dynamic-benefits-towards-welfare-that-works", + "https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/CSJ-dynamic-benefits.pdf", + "https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-9090/CBP-9090.pdf?download=1" + ], + "claims": [ + "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_20000", + "csj_2026_mother_loss_father_30000", + "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_income_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_fulltime_uc_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_income_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_no_income_unemployed_uc_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_income_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_fulltime_uc_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_income_loss", + "policy_exchange_2021_parttime_unemployed_uc_loss", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_5k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_10k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_15k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_20k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_25k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_no_income_support_father_30k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_5k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_10k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_15k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_20k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_25k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_income_support_father_30k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_5k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_10k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_15k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_20k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_25k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_part_time_father_30k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_5k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_10k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_15k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_20k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_25k", + "marriage_foundation_2013_full_time_father_30k", + "csj_2009_material_penalty_couples", + "csj_2009_average_equivalised_shortfall", + "csj_2009_aggregate_equivalised_shortfall", + "marriage_foundation_2013_1_children_penalty_maximum", + "marriage_foundation_2013_2_children_penalty_maximum", + "marriage_foundation_2013_3_children_penalty_maximum" + ], + "note": "Own household examples traced to CSJ, Policy Exchange (via Civitas), and Marriage Foundation, keeping each producer attribution. IFS restatements in Civitas/CARE/CSJ are not duplicated under open_search. Family Education Trust is an opinion poll, Commons Library explains legal status/demographic levels, and Royal London costs bereavement eligibility for cohabitants versus married couples, not two living adults together versus apart. CARE international family tax-wedge comparisons and IEA needs/working-tax-credit illustrations measure other contrasts. PolicyEngine live page/code/deployment records checked here to establish calculator status, not as external comparators. Further primary URLs and specimen scopes are recorded in the claims. Historical CSJ Dynamic Benefits material-penalty count, average and aggregate are staged in their own needs-adjusted world; the exact release date is corroborated in Commons Library CBP9090 footnote 33. Marriage Foundation direct Appendix A differences and its three headline amounts are staged separately; the first two headlines are upper bounds. The report’s fraudulent-claimant discrepancy, Appendix B reform costings, and the 2024 marriage-allowance reform are different quantities and not staged. For CSJ July 2026 examples, no underlying calculator input record, component decomposition or exact tax year is published; for the Marriage Foundation two-/three-child web figures, assumptions and exact tax year are unstated. These limits are retained in claim conditions, without inventing them." + } + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/tests/test_export_populations.py b/tests/test_export_populations.py index 24832b479..47b56823e 100644 --- a/tests/test_export_populations.py +++ b/tests/test_export_populations.py @@ -410,7 +410,7 @@ def test_integration_committed_db(tmp_path): # Pre-publish comparables (docs/COMPARABLES.md) add every staged claim of # each analysis record: 20 for the £100,000 childcare dashboard (12 CenTax, # 8 Centre for British Progress), with or without a result. - assert dist == {"US": 535 + 90, "UK": 5163 + 23_752 + 246 + 128, "BE": 9, "NZ": 12} + assert dist == {"US": 535 + 90, "UK": 5163 + 23_752 + 246 + 168, "BE": 9, "NZ": 12} nz = [row for row in payload["rows"] if row["country"] == "NZ"] assert len(nz) == 12 assert {row["source"] for row in nz} == {"nz_treasury"} @@ -445,8 +445,8 @@ def test_integration_committed_db(tmp_path): assert committed["summary"] == payload["summary"] assert committed["event_archives"] == payload["event_archives"] # Every event is reachable in the deployed copy, with bounded requests. - # 5,719 + the 218 rows of the comparables records (128 UK, 90 US) - assert len(payload["rows"]) == 5719 + 218 + # 5,719 + the 258 rows of the comparables records (168 UK, 90 US) + assert len(payload["rows"]) == 5719 + 258 for archive in payload["event_archives"]: relative = archive["path"].removeprefix("data/") freshly_exported = (tmp_path / relative).read_bytes()