You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
- Clean, reproducible, well-structured code with explicit font sizing
22
+
- All spec requirements met exactly; professional color palette
23
+
weaknesses:
24
+
- 'Design is competent but uses defaults without custom aesthetic sophistication
25
+
(DE-01: 4/8)'
26
+
- 'Visual refinement is minimal; could enhance grid styling or legend positioning
27
+
(DE-02: 2/6)'
28
+
- 'No visual data storytelling—plot displays concept but doesn''t emphasize patterns
29
+
(DE-03: 2/6)'
30
+
- 'Library mastery is modest; doesn''t leverage Altair''s interactive or advanced
31
+
features (LM-02: 1/5)'
32
+
image_description: |-
33
+
Light render (plot-light.png):
34
+
Background: Warm off-white (#FAF8F1) - not pure white, exactly as specified
35
+
Chrome: Title "kagi-basic · altair · anyplot.ai" (28px, dark text), X-axis "Line Index" (22px, dark), Y-axis "Price ($)" (22px, dark), tick labels (18px, dark), legend "Trend" with "Yang (Bullish)" and "Yin (Bearish)" (16-18px, dark text on #FFFDF6 box)
36
+
Data: Yang lines thick (#009E73 brand green, 6px stroke), Yin lines thin (#D55E00 orange, 2px stroke). Reversal algorithm correct with shoulders and waists visible. Multiple trend cycles from $80-$113
37
+
Legibility verdict: PASS - All text clearly readable, proper contrast, no light-on-light issues
38
+
39
+
Dark render (plot-dark.png):
40
+
Background: Warm near-black (#1A1A17) - not pure black, exactly as specified
41
+
Chrome: Title (28px, light text #F0EFE8), X-axis "Line Index" (22px, light), Y-axis "Price ($)" (22px, light), tick labels (18px, #B8B7B0), legend text (16-18px, light on #242420 box)
42
+
Data: Yang lines still green (#009E73 - IDENTICAL to light render), Yin lines still orange (#D55E00 - IDENTICAL to light render). Same price range and reversal pattern
43
+
Legibility verdict: PASS - All text clearly readable on dark background, no dark-on-dark failures, data colors preserved perfectly
44
+
criteria_checklist:
45
+
visual_quality:
46
+
score: 30
47
+
max: 30
48
+
items:
49
+
- id: VQ-01
50
+
name: Text Legibility
51
+
score: 8
52
+
max: 8
53
+
passed: true
54
+
comment: 'All font sizes explicitly set: title 28px, labels 22px, ticks 18px.
55
+
Readable in both themes.'
56
+
- id: VQ-02
57
+
name: No Overlap
58
+
score: 6
59
+
max: 6
60
+
passed: true
61
+
comment: No overlapping text; all elements fully readable
62
+
- id: VQ-03
63
+
name: Element Visibility
64
+
score: 6
65
+
max: 6
66
+
passed: true
67
+
comment: Yang (6px) and Yin (2px) thickness variation is clear and effective
68
+
- id: VQ-04
69
+
name: Color Accessibility
70
+
score: 2
71
+
max: 2
72
+
passed: true
73
+
comment: Okabe-Ito palette with good contrast; CVD-safe
74
+
- id: VQ-05
75
+
name: Layout & Canvas
76
+
score: 4
77
+
max: 4
78
+
passed: true
79
+
comment: Perfect 1600x900 layout with balanced margins
80
+
- id: VQ-06
81
+
name: Axis Labels & Title
82
+
score: 2
83
+
max: 2
84
+
passed: true
85
+
comment: Descriptive labels with units; spec-compliant title
86
+
- id: VQ-07
87
+
name: Palette Compliance
88
+
score: 2
89
+
max: 2
90
+
passed: true
91
+
comment: 'Perfect Okabe-Ito (#009E73, #D55E00); theme-correct chrome in both
92
+
renders'
93
+
design_excellence:
94
+
score: 8
95
+
max: 20
96
+
items:
97
+
- id: DE-01
98
+
name: Aesthetic Sophistication
99
+
score: 4
100
+
max: 8
101
+
passed: false
102
+
comment: Well-configured defaults; professional but not exceptional
103
+
- id: DE-02
104
+
name: Visual Refinement
105
+
score: 2
106
+
max: 6
107
+
passed: false
108
+
comment: Basic defaults with minimal customization
109
+
- id: DE-03
110
+
name: Data Storytelling
111
+
score: 2
112
+
max: 6
113
+
passed: false
114
+
comment: Concept is clear but no visual emphasis on patterns
115
+
spec_compliance:
116
+
score: 15
117
+
max: 15
118
+
items:
119
+
- id: SC-01
120
+
name: Plot Type
121
+
score: 5
122
+
max: 5
123
+
passed: true
124
+
comment: Correct Kagi chart with all features
125
+
- id: SC-02
126
+
name: Required Features
127
+
score: 4
128
+
max: 4
129
+
passed: true
130
+
comment: 'All spec features present: thick/thin lines, colors, reversals'
131
+
- id: SC-03
132
+
name: Data Mapping
133
+
score: 3
134
+
max: 3
135
+
passed: true
136
+
comment: X/Y correctly assigned; all data visible
137
+
- id: SC-04
138
+
name: Title & Legend
139
+
score: 3
140
+
max: 3
141
+
passed: true
142
+
comment: Title format correct; legend labels match
143
+
data_quality:
144
+
score: 15
145
+
max: 15
146
+
items:
147
+
- id: DQ-01
148
+
name: Feature Coverage
149
+
score: 6
150
+
max: 6
151
+
passed: true
152
+
comment: Shows both yang and yin segments across multiple cycles
153
+
- id: DQ-02
154
+
name: Realistic Context
155
+
score: 5
156
+
max: 5
157
+
passed: true
158
+
comment: Realistic stock data (2024, $100-115 range); neutral domain
159
+
- id: DQ-03
160
+
name: Appropriate Scale
161
+
score: 4
162
+
max: 4
163
+
passed: true
164
+
comment: Realistic returns and time period; proportions factually sound
165
+
code_quality:
166
+
score: 10
167
+
max: 10
168
+
items:
169
+
- id: CQ-01
170
+
name: KISS Structure
171
+
score: 3
172
+
max: 3
173
+
passed: true
174
+
comment: Linear flow with no unnecessary abstraction
![github-actions[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/15368?v=4&size=40){kind=avatar}
0 commit comments