From dd0951413bdeb2cb46a7018211b10dfd081a4893 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:30:12 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/5] NEEC checkpoint s84: owner items D66/D67 applied by generator, CCO C3.4 clauses 1 and 3 sourced, PE C1.2b by rule 4 (owner_s84.py, apply_owner_s84.py); entry shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (display_names.py); harness v53 (148); Report v2.0 Part I generator and Domains 1-2 prose Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JSRwEe3ANJ8vNhgXmYKT7f --- NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md | 181 + NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md | 5797 +++++++++++++++++ README.md | 2 +- STATE.md | 25 +- apply_adjudication_s83.py | 14 +- ...adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt | 6 +- apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt | 6 +- apply_owner_s84.py | 264 + apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt | 14 + apply_owner_s84_output.txt | 14 + build_evidence.py | 100 +- build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt | 6 +- build_evidence_output.txt | 6 +- build_report_v2.py | 168 + build_report_v2_output.txt | 1 + build_site.py | 8 +- display_names.py | 43 + docs/404.html | 2 +- docs/contribute.html | 2 +- docs/criteria/c1-1.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c1-2a.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c1-2b.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c1-3.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c1-4.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c1-5.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c2-1.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c2-2.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c2-3.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c2-4.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c2-5.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c2-6.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c3-1.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c3-2.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c3-3.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c3-4.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c3-5.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c3-6.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c4-1.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c4-2.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c4-3.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c4-4.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c4-5.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c4-6.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c5-1.html | 4 +- docs/criteria/c5-2.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c5-3.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c5-4.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/c5-5.html | 6 +- docs/criteria/index.html | 2 +- docs/data/neec.json | 60 +- docs/findings.html | 12 +- docs/index.html | 10 +- docs/llms.txt | 2 +- docs/method.html | 4 +- docs/replicate.html | 6 +- docs/systems/cco.html | 28 +- docs/systems/cn.html | 4 +- docs/systems/cps.html | 4 +- docs/systems/de.html | 4 +- docs/systems/dg.html | 12 +- docs/systems/falc.html | 4 +- docs/systems/geo.html | 6 +- docs/systems/if.html | 6 +- docs/systems/index.html | 6 +- docs/systems/int.html | 4 +- docs/systems/lm.html | 4 +- docs/systems/mc.html | 4 +- docs/systems/mmt.html | 4 +- docs/systems/ms.html | 6 +- docs/systems/nsd.html | 6 +- docs/systems/os.html | 4 +- docs/systems/pe.html | 12 +- docs/systems/qa.html | 4 +- docs/systems/sc.html | 4 +- docs/systems/sg.html | 4 +- docs/systems/sq.html | 4 +- docs/systems/swf.html | 4 +- docs/systems/ubi.html | 6 +- docs/systems/ubs.html | 4 +- docs/thresholds.html | 6 +- evidence/cco.md | 60 +- evidence/cn.md | 2 +- evidence/cps.md | 2 +- evidence/de.md | 2 +- evidence/dg.md | 30 +- evidence/falc.md | 4 +- evidence/geo.md | 6 +- evidence/if.md | 4 +- evidence/index.md | 16 +- evidence/int.md | 4 +- evidence/lm.md | 2 +- evidence/mc.md | 2 +- evidence/mmt.md | 2 +- evidence/ms.md | 4 +- evidence/nsd.md | 4 +- evidence/os.md | 2 +- evidence/pe.md | 54 +- evidence/qa.md | 2 +- evidence/sc.md | 2 +- evidence/sg.md | 2 +- evidence/sq.md | 2 +- evidence/swf.md | 2 +- evidence/ubi.md | 8 +- evidence/ubs.md | 2 +- final_pass.py | 56 + final_pass_selftest_output.txt | 2 + neec_corpus_v2.json | 14 +- neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json | 888 +++ neec_scores_v2.csv | 46 +- neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv | 24 + owner_s84.py | 83 + run_all_checks.py | 70 +- run_all_checks_output.txt | 37 +- site/config.json | 3 +- summary_blocks_v2.json | 190 +- summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json | 5360 +++++++++++++++ weighting_s83.py | 56 +- weighting_s83_output.txt | 29 +- 118 files changed, 13607 insertions(+), 514 deletions(-) create mode 100644 NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md create mode 100644 NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md create mode 100644 apply_owner_s84.py create mode 100644 apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt create mode 100644 apply_owner_s84_output.txt create mode 100644 build_report_v2.py create mode 100644 build_report_v2_output.txt create mode 100644 display_names.py create mode 100644 neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json create mode 100644 neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv create mode 100644 owner_s84.py create mode 100644 summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json diff --git a/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md b/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c417c2d --- /dev/null +++ b/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md @@ -0,0 +1,181 @@ +# NEEC Session 84: the owner's items applied, and two consistency gaps closed (ledger S68) + +> Session 84, 2026-10-21. The layer: `owner_s84.py`; the generator: `apply_owner_s84.py` (writes `neec_corpus_v2.json`, +> `neec_scores_v2.csv`, `summary_blocks_v2.json` and the tables of this record between its `generated` markers; never by +> hand). The Session 83 state is kept byte for byte as `neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json` and its two companions. From this +> session the entry is shown as **CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP** (ledger D68, decision 84.5); the records of Sessions 1 to 83, and +> the parts of this record that quote them, keep the old name, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH. + +## 1. What was done, and the result + +Session 83's adjudication of the outside review (`NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`) put four readings to the owner and named +three consistency questions outside its scope (its section 9; ledger I12). The owner answered in the ledger on 2026-10-20. +This session applied the answers by generator, and closed the two gaps the owner's instructions named: + + +The layer writes 6 units: 4 owner items applied (decisions 84.1 and 84.2), 1 clause revision with the verdict held (84.3) and 1 class reading (84.4); 5 verdicts change. First place: CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP at 16.5, ahead of Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism, Participatory Economics at 15.5; tier changes: none. On the readings alone (no owner decision: the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed): Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism, Participatory Economics first at 15.5, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP 14.5. + + + +| Decision | Criterion | Entry | Before | After | What changed | +|---|---|---|---:|---:|---| +| 84.1 | C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability | Degrowth Economics | 1.0 | 0.5 | the owner's answer to D66: the adjudication's reading applied | +| 84.1 | C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability | Participatory Economics | 1.0 | 0.5 | the owner's answer to D66: the adjudication's reading applied | +| 84.2 | C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity | CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 1.0 | 0.5 | the owner's answer to D67: the adjudication's reading applied | +| 84.2 | C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability | CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 1.0 | 0.5 | the owner's answer to D67: the adjudication's reading applied | +| 84.3 | C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability | CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 1.0 | 1.0 | clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources; the verdict holds | +| 84.4 | C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation | Participatory Economics | 1.0 | 0.5 | read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (one reading per class) | + + +**The finding the Paper must state.** On the scores as decided, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is first alone at 16.5, by 1.0, under +all four weighting schemes and every single-criterion drop. On the readings alone, without any of the owner's decisions, +it stands at 14.5, fifth level with Integral and Ostrom-Style Commons Governance, and Market Socialism, Nordic Social +Democracy and Participatory Economics share first place at 15.5. First place rests on the owner's five raises (58.1, 79.1 +to 79.4, which touch four CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP cells), each disclosed with the reading it replaced (section 5). + +## 2. The owner's answers (decisions 84.1 and 84.2) + +**84.1 (owner, ledger D66).** Degrowth Economics' and Participatory Economics' C3.4 return to 0.5. Decision 79.4 raised C3.4 +to 1.0 where clauses 1 to 3 are cleared and no collapse is located; for Degrowth (clauses 1 and 2) and Participatory +Economics (clause 2) those clearances rested only on the published rationale's words, which rule 3 of decision 83.4 does +not accept. The adjudication's units (`adjudicate_s83.OWNER`) are applied unchanged: Degrowth 14.5 to 14.0, Participatory +Economics 16.5 to 16.0 (before 84.4). Decision 79.4 stands for Integral and Ostrom-Style Commons Governance, whose +clauses 1 to 3 are cleared on sources. + +**84.2 (owner, ledger D67; supersedes D65's hold under decision 69.4).** CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 go to 0.5, as +the adjudication reads them: C2.2's provision is unconditional but pays citizens and legal residents 18 and over, and the +design's own model leaves adults below their cost of living; C5.3's papers put minimum viable participation at 55 to 65%, +against an integrated framework's 30% that states no computation. Each keeps the published reading as its close call +toward 1.0. The owner's reason: holding these two while the adjudication lowers other entries' cells on the same footing +would be a double standard; the route back up is the push-back route (ledger S72) and the Hub v2 work, which feeds the +24th entry (S70), not these cells. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP 17.5 to 16.5. + +One point for the record: C5.3's unit, as the adjudication wrote it, still clears clauses 2 to 4 "as audited (the unit's +own text)". The verdict is 0.5 on clause 1 whatever those clauses read, so nothing turns on them now; a push-back case on +C5.3 (S72) must source them as section 3 sources C3.4's. + +## 3. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4: clauses 1 and 3 sourced (decision 84.3, correction to the record) + +The unit's clauses 1 and 3 rested on "as audited (the unit's own text)", the footing rule 3 of decision 83.4 rejected for +Degrowth and Participatory Economics. Decision 79.3 governs clause 4 only. Each clause is now read on the design's own +documents (the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba, as cached for the outside review in `outside_kit_sources/`): + +| # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis cuts the maximum octaves from 8 to 4 (50%) and runs participation from 5% to 35%, keeping inflation below 1.8% and 89% of the welfare gains; the integrated framework sets the conversion multiplier at 1-9x against tested alternatives of 1-5x and 1-12x, and a regional adjustment factor of 0.8-1.2; the scorer's adjustment run on the v5.6 engine moves the Basic Unit 30% either way from year 10 | dual-currency-inflation.html, section 5.3; cco-ptf-integrated-framework.html, sections 3.1.2 and 5.4; `NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md`, reading 3.11 | +| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | under the Citizens Internet Portal any citizen can submit a proposal (signature threshold, 30-90 day comment period, amendment); a binding change passes by a 60-67% supermajority with geographic distribution; referenda move from advisory to binding in the second phase (years 4-7); the PTH charter template adds notice, hearing and appeal rights on every enforcement action | citizens-internet-portal.html, sections 4.4 and 7.1; democratic-governance-pth.html, Appendix B.1, Article VI, section 2 | + +Both clear, so the verdict holds at 1.0 on decision 79.3's reading of clause 4. The class check (rule 4): Degrowth's and +Participatory Economics' clause 3 were cleared in Session 83 on the same kind of provision (citizens' assemblies, +referendums, councils of those affected that decide and can reverse), so the readings agree. Two limits stand in the +record: the supermajority makes reversal harder than enactment's simple majority for advisory votes, and binding +referenda begin only in the design's second phase. Neither is a bar the clause sets. The outside reader cleared both +clauses on the same documents (its clause 4 was short, the cell decision 79.3 decides). + +## 4. Participatory Economics' C1.2b by rule 4 (decision 84.4, correction under the delegation; ledger I12 item 1) + +The adjudication lowered Degrowth's, Integral's and Mutual Credit's class W 1.0s on C1.2b ("Gini <0.35 for wealth +distribution") because none rested on an estimate of the distribution, or on a structural argument that bounds all of it. +Participatory Economics' 1.0 rests on the same class W reading; the outside reader agreed with it, so the adjudication did +not reach it. Rule 4 of decision 83.4 (one reading per class) asks whether Participatory Economics' sources distinguish it. + +**The reading: 0.5, the clause not shown.** They distinguish it in strength, not on the point the clause turns on. The +design removes private productive property, capital markets and income from ownership, and rates incomes by effort and +sacrifice; that bounds the top of the distribution more firmly than Degrowth's caps (which keep private property and +markets) or Integral's network (which runs beside existing market and state systems). But it states no bound on personal +holdings, which unequal effort ratings and saving across a lifetime leave unequal, and no source the unit cites, and none +the outside reader names, estimates the wealth Gini; the reader projected it from the design's mechanisms, closed book, +which rule 3 does not accept where the threshold asks for a figure. A bound on the top does not bound a Gini, which the +bottom of the distribution also sets. The unit keeps the published reading as its close call toward 1.0. Participatory +Economics 16.0 to 15.5; its failures are unchanged. + +## 5. The standing, with and without every owner decision + + +| Entry | Session 83 (rank) | Session 84 (rank) | Change | Failures | Tier | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| +| CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 17.5 (1) | 16.5 (1) | -1.0 | 0 to 0 | Potentially Adequate | +| Nordic Social Democracy | 15.5 (3) | 15.5 (2) | 0.0 | 0 to 0 | Potentially Adequate | +| Market Socialism | 15.5 (3) | 15.5 (2) | 0.0 | 0 to 0 | Potentially Adequate | +| Participatory Economics | 16.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | -1.0 | 0 to 0 | Potentially Adequate | +| Integral | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 0.0 | 2 to 2 | Potentially Adequate | +| Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 0.0 | 2 to 2 | Potentially Adequate | +| Ostrom-Style Commons Governance | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 0.0 | 3 to 3 | Partially Adequate | +| Universal Basic Income | 14.0 (9) | 14.0 (8) | 0.0 | 4 to 4 | Partially Adequate | +| Degrowth Economics | 14.5 (8) | 14.0 (8) | -0.5 | 1 to 1 | Potentially Adequate | +| Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend) | 14.0 (9) | 14.0 (8) | 0.0 | 2 to 2 | Potentially Adequate | +| Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking | 14.0 (9) | 14.0 (8) | 0.0 | 3 to 3 | Partially Adequate | +| Mutual Credit / LETS | 13.5 (12) | 13.5 (12) | 0.0 | 3 to 3 | Partially Adequate | +| State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism) | 13.5 (12) | 13.5 (12) | 0.0 | 3 to 3 | Partially Adequate | +| Status Quo Market Capitalism | 13.0 (14) | 13.0 (14) | 0.0 | 6 to 6 | Structurally Inadequate | +| Universal Basic Services | 13.0 (14) | 13.0 (14) | 0.0 | 4 to 4 | Partially Adequate | +| MMT + Job Guarantee | 12.5 (16) | 12.5 (16) | 0.0 | 4 to 4 | Partially Adequate | +| Fully Automated Luxury Communism | 12.0 (17) | 12.0 (17) | 0.0 | 7 to 7 | Structurally Inadequate | +| Stakeholder Capitalism | 11.5 (18) | 11.5 (18) | 0.0 | 6 to 6 | Structurally Inadequate | +| State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy) | 11.5 (18) | 11.5 (18) | 0.0 | 8 to 8 | Structurally Inadequate | +| State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism) | 10.0 (20) | 10.0 (20) | 0.0 | 10 to 10 | Structurally Inadequate | +| Libertarian Minarchism | 9.5 (21) | 9.5 (21) | 0.0 | 11 to 11 | Structurally Inadequate | +| Doughnut Economics | 9.5 (21) | 9.5 (21) | 0.0 | 10 to 10 | Structurally Inadequate | +| Centrally Planned Socialism | 6.5 (23) | 6.5 (23) | 0.0 | 17 to 17 | Structurally Inadequate | + + +Each column below reverses one owner decision and keeps the rest; the last reverses all of them, so every cell stands at +its reading. A raise (58.1, 79.1 to 79.4) reverses to the 0.5 it replaced. D66 and D67 applied the readings, so reversing +either restores the 1.0 it replaced (79.4's raise for Degrowth and Participatory Economics; D65's hold under 69.4 for +CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP); on the readings alone their cells stay at 0.5. The ten entries highest now are shown; the others are +unaffected. + + +| Entry | Session 84 | without 58.1 (C3.2) | without 79.1 (C1.2a) | without 79.2 (C2.5) | without 79.3 (C3.4) | without 79.4 (C3.4 for Integral and Ostrom) | without D66 (C3.4 for Degrowth and PE) | without D67 (C2.2 and C5.3) | on the readings alone (no owner decision) | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 16.5 (1) | 16.0 (1) | 16.0 (1) | 16.0 (1) | 16.0 (1) | 16.5 (1) | 16.5 (1) | 17.5 (1) | 14.5 (5) | +| Nordic Social Democracy | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (3) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (1) | +| Market Socialism | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (3) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (1) | +| Participatory Economics | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 16.0 (2) | 15.5 (2) | 15.5 (1) | +| Integral | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 14.5 (6) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 14.5 (5) | +| Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (4) | +| Ostrom-Style Commons Governance | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 14.5 (6) | 15.0 (5) | 15.0 (5) | 14.5 (5) | +| Universal Basic Income | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (9) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | +| Degrowth Economics | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.5 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | +| Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (9) | 14.0 (8) | 14.0 (8) | + + +The weighting robustness rerun (`weighting_s83.py`, now four states): on the scores as decided, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is +first under all four schemes and under every single-criterion drop. If all its close calls resolved down and the best of +the three entries at 15.5 resolved all of its up, that entry (Nordic Social Democracy, 17.5) would be first. On the +readings alone first place is shared by Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy and Participatory Economics on equal +weights, and moves with the scheme (Nordic Social Democracy alone when Domain 1 is doubled; Market Socialism and +Participatory Economics when Domain 5 is halved). + +## 6. Ledger I12, items 2 and 3 (decision 84.6) + +Not readings this session changes. They go to the limits page (ledger S44) as stated in `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`, +section 9: C2.2's means-tested floors (read as no baseline for Status Quo, China, Singapore and Qatar, while the 0.5 band's +"conditional" could read them at 0.5; a class question held for consistency), and C2.1's clause 1 measure (Gallup's latest +year or the World Happiness Report's three-year average; the measurement field is silent). + +## 7. Decisions + +- **84.1** (owner, recorded; ledger D66): Degrowth's and Participatory Economics' C3.4 to 0.5, as the adjudication reads them. +- **84.2** (owner, recorded; ledger D67, superseding D65's hold under 69.4): CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 to 0.5. +- **84.3** (correction to the record): CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP C3.4's clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources; both clear; the + verdict holds. +- **84.4** (correction under the delegation, decision 57.2; ledger I12 item 1): Participatory Economics' C1.2b 1.0 to 0.5 by + rule 4 of decision 83.4. +- **84.5** (owner, recorded; ledger D68): the entry is shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP through one display-name mapping + (`display_names.py`) in the generators of the current state (corpus, CSV, blocks, evidence reports, site and its visual + suite); its key (`CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH`) and code (`CCO`) are identifiers and do not change; records before Session 84 keep the + old name. Quotations of published documents (the v1 rationales in the evidence reports) keep their words. +- **84.6** (record): ledger I12 items 2 and 3 go to the limits page (S44). +- **84.7** (owner, recorded; ledger D69 and its note): v2.0 lands with 23 entries; OEIAS (S70) joins in v2.1 as the 24th, and + the system Claude may design (S71) as the 25th, released with it. +- **84.8** (optional, tooling): `owner_s84.py`, `final_pass.settled_state()` with its self-test, `apply_owner_s84.py` with + `--check` and a negative control, the Session 83 snapshots, `weighting_s83.py`'s four states and its handling of a + shared first place, harness v53. + +## 8. What this record does not do, and disclosure + +It changes no reading other than the six units above, and no criterion. The scores freeze here (decision 83.13, now at the +`s84` tag) except through the push-back route. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP was designed by the owner, who co-authors NEEC; decisions +84.1, 84.2 and 84.5 are the owner's, and two of them lower the owner's own entry. Claude (Anthropic) made the readings of +84.3 and 84.4 in this session. diff --git a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a470d04 --- /dev/null +++ b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md @@ -0,0 +1,5797 @@ +# NEEC Report v2.0, Part I: the scorecards, domain by domain + +> **Draft (Session 84, ledger S41).** Johnson and Claude (Anthropic), 2026. The scores are those of the `s84` state: +> the rescoring pass on the v2.0 criteria (Sessions 37 to 65), the blind re-read (Sessions 71 to 77), the owner's decisions +> (58.1, 79.1 to 79.4, Session 79; D66 and D67, Session 84), the adjudication of the outside blind review (Session 83) and +> Session 84's two consistency readings. They change only through the push-back route, by a recorded pass applied by a +> generator. Every scorecard below is generated by `build_report_v2.py` from the units' own readings (decision 52.8); the +> prose between the scorecards is written by hand and reports what the scorecards show. The full sources for every unit +> are in the evidence reports (`evidence/.md`), linked from each entry. + +## How to read Part I + +Each of the 29 criteria has one scorecard. It gives the v2.0 Pass Threshold, how many of the 23 entries score 1.0, 0.5 and +0.0 now and did in v1 (on the 26 criteria v1 scored), and then each entry in the order of the standing: its v2.0 score, its +v1 score, and the reading behind it. A cell that a unit of v2.0 read shows one line per clause of the threshold, with its +status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot) and the reading; a cell no unit read shows the published v1 +rationale, quoted. A score of 1.0 needs every clause cleared on an estimate; any clause not cleared makes it 0.5; 0.0 is a +structural failure, which needs one of protocol 2.1's conditions for the criterion as a whole, stated beside it. A close call +is a score a reasonable scorer could set differently; it names the other score and the reading that supports it. + +**A note on what changed between v1 and v2.0.** v2.0 restated or sharpened most thresholds (each scorecard names its +revision class), and the pass read each cell clause by clause against them. Most of the movement is downward, and most of +it has one cause: a v1 score of 1.0 that rested on a design's description of what it would achieve, with no estimate of +the quantity the threshold names. Under v2.0's rule such a clause is not shown, and the cell is 0.5. A fall of this kind +records what the sources establish, not a finding that the system performs worse. + +**The entry's name.** From Session 84 the owner's design is shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (ledger D68). NEEC's records +before Session 84, and quotations from them, call it CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH; it is the same entry, read on the same sources. + +**Disclosure.** CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP was designed by Duke Johnson, one of NEEC's two authors. Its first place rests on the +owner's decisions; on the readings alone it would stand fifth (the standing below; `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 5). +The Paper states this in its body. + +## The standing + +The 23 entries on the 29 criteria (domain sums D1 to D5; failures are 0.0 scores; tiers by failure count: 0 to 2 +Potentially Adequate, 3 to 5 Partially Adequate, 6 or more Structurally Inadequate). The last column is the v1 total on 26 +criteria, for reference only: the two totals are not on one scale. + + +| Rank | Entry | Total of 29 | D1 | D2 | D3 | D4 | D5 | Failures | Tier | v1 (of 26) | +|---:|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|---:| +| 1 | CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | 16.5 | 3.5 | 3.5 | 4.0 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 24.5 | +| 2 | Nordic Social Democracy | 15.5 | 3.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 19.5 | +| 2 | Market Socialism | 15.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 3.5 | 2.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 16.5 | +| 2 | Participatory Economics | 15.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 4.0 | 2.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 20.5 | +| 5 | Integral | 15.0 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 4.0 | 2.5 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 19.5 | +| 5 | Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism | 15.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 14.0 | +| 5 | Ostrom-Style Commons Governance | 15.0 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 3.0 | 4.0 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 14.5 | +| 8 | Universal Basic Income | 14.0 | 1.5 | 3.5 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 14.5 | +| 8 | Degrowth Economics | 14.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 2.0 | 1 | Potentially Adequate | 19.0 | +| 8 | Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend) | 14.0 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 13.5 | +| 8 | Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking | 14.0 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.5 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 13.5 | +| 12 | Mutual Credit / LETS | 13.5 | 1.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 14.5 | +| 12 | State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism) | 13.5 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 14.0 | +| 14 | Status Quo Market Capitalism | 13.0 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 1.5 | 3.5 | 6 | Structurally Inadequate | 10.5 | +| 14 | Universal Basic Services | 13.0 | 1.5 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 13.5 | +| 16 | MMT + Job Guarantee | 12.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 15.5 | +| 17 | Fully Automated Luxury Communism | 12.0 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 1.0 | 7 | Structurally Inadequate | 13.0 | +| 18 | Stakeholder Capitalism | 11.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 | 6 | Structurally Inadequate | 10.0 | +| 18 | State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy) | 11.5 | 3.0 | 1.0 | 3.5 | 1.5 | 2.5 | 8 | Structurally Inadequate | 10.0 | +| 20 | State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism) | 10.0 | 2.5 | 1.5 | 2.5 | 1.5 | 2.0 | 10 | Structurally Inadequate | 9.0 | +| 21 | Libertarian Minarchism | 9.5 | 1.0 | 2.5 | 2.0 | 1.5 | 2.5 | 11 | Structurally Inadequate | 8.0 | +| 21 | Doughnut Economics | 9.5 | 0.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 10 | Structurally Inadequate | 11.5 | +| 23 | Centrally Planned Socialism | 6.5 | 2.5 | 0.0 | 1.5 | 1.5 | 1.0 | 17 | Structurally Inadequate | 10.0 | + + +Where the score of each domain's cells came from, and how many moved from v1 (the new criteria C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 have no +v1 score and count in neither column): + + +| Domain | Cells | Read in v2.0 | Held | Up from v1 | Down from v1 | Close calls | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 1. Material Security | 138 | 99 | 39 | 3 | 31 | 34 | +| 2. Human Autonomy | 138 | 118 | 20 | 5 | 35 | 29 | +| 3. System Resilience | 138 | 105 | 33 | 7 | 37 | 38 | +| 4. Ethical Integrity | 138 | 138 | 0 | 14 | 32 | 48 | +| 5. Implementation Viability | 115 | 59 | 56 | 6 | 27 | 36 | + + +## Domain 1: Material Security + +Six criteria: poverty (C1.1), wealth building (C1.2a) and its prevention of concentration (C1.2b), housing (C1.3), +automation (C1.4) and access to a wealth pathway (C1.5). v1 scored 32 of these 138 cells at 1.0; v2.0 scores three, and no +entry clears more than one of the six. The fall is the domain's main finding, and it is a finding about evidence: the +thresholds name quantities (a reduction in the poverty headcount over 20 years, a wealth Gini, a housing stability rate, +poverty and demand under 30%, 50% and 70% displacement of paid hours), and almost no source, for a design or for an +economy, states them. + +**C1.1, poverty.** None of the nine v1 passes holds; 21 entries score 0.5 and two 0.0. The threshold asks for a 90% +reduction within 20 years and 85% under stress. Seven designs clear the first clause on their own projections (Market +Socialism, Participatory Economics, Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, MMT + Job Guarantee, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, +and Centrally Planned Socialism on its record of absolute poverty), but none states a figure under stress; where a stress +episode is documented, as Cuba's Special Period is for Centrally Planned Socialism, it records a fall in food intake, not a +held reduction. The configured economies +are read on v2.0's indicator, the World Bank's Societal Poverty Line, and on it the headcount rose: in the United States +from 19.2% (2005) to 20.2% (2024), and in each Nordic economy from 2005 to 2023 (Sweden 9.8% to 12.4%), which is why Nordic +Social Democracy falls from 1.0. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is read on its own model (v5.6.0, 500 seeds): poverty on the line is +7.7% at year 20 against 7.9% with no programme, and higher than with no programme in the adverse environment. The two +failures are Libertarian Minarchism, whose sources leave poverty relief to private charity, and Doughnut Economics, which +names the target and adopts no instrument to meet it (a fall from 0.5; a close call toward 0.5). + +**C1.2a, wealth building.** One entry passes: CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, on the owner's decision 79.1 (its close call toward 0.5 +records the reading it replaced: the clause holds only if new output backs what the design pays, which its sources do not +state). The three other v1 passes fall: Nordic Social Democracy, because on Norway's register data the 30th percentile of +household net wealth is below the bar (the one Nordic register that publishes the distribution); Singapore, because a median +above the bar does not show 70% of participants; Market Socialism, for want of any figure. MMT + Job Guarantee falls to 0.0 +as a correction (a wage holds no asset, the 0.0 band, as for Universal Basic Income and Georgism's dividend), and Libertarian +Minarchism rises to 0.5 (a shortfall of reach is 0.5 under protocol 2.1, as for Status Quo). + +**C1.2b, preventing concentration.** No entry passes; v1 had five passes. Four were class W cells the pass never re-read, +whose 1.0 rested on the 1.0 band's description of a structural mechanism with no estimate of the wealth distribution; the +adjudication of the outside review lowered Degrowth's, Integral's and Mutual Credit's, and Session 84 Participatory +Economics' by the same rule (one reading per class): a bound on the top of the distribution does not bound a Gini, which +the bottom also sets. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is read on its model, which gives a wealth Gini of 0.49 at year 20 against 0.76 +with no programme: a large reduction, short of 0.35. Fully Automated Luxury Communism rises from 0.0 to 0.5. Seventeen cells +are held at their published scores. + +**C1.3, housing.** One pass: Centrally Planned Socialism, the band's own anchor (no mortgages, rents unchanged since 1928, +housing fees near 3% of income at 80% of the median), with a close call toward 0.5. Eight v1 passes fall. The designs state +no stability rate and no housing cost at 80% of the median; CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's model has no housing tenure or rent line to +compute them. Nordic Social Democracy is stable but short on cost (in Denmark's lowest income quintile 44.6% to 60.4% of +households spend more than 40% of disposable income on housing, across the EU-SILC series), and Singapore is stable for +residents but not for the rental segment, which houses most non-residents. + +**C1.4, automation.** No entry passes; v1 had four passes. No source, for any entry, models poverty and aggregate demand in +the three displacement scenarios, and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's model, which v2.0 names, cannot yet run them. A mechanism that +decouples income from work (Universal Basic Income, Participatory Economics' average income for those who cannot work) is +credited at 0.5, not 1.0. Five entries fail, each on protocol 2.1's first condition (no mechanism addresses the criterion): +Islamic Finance, Status Quo, Stakeholder Capitalism, Libertarian Minarchism and Doughnut Economics, under each of which +income and demand run through paid work with nothing added for displacement. + +**C1.5, access to a wealth pathway.** A class W criterion, so the pass held 22 cells at their published scores; Nordic +Social Democracy keeps the domain's other 1.0. The one cell re-read, Libertarian Minarchism's, rose from 0.0 to 0.5 in the +adjudication (markets open to anyone, gated by income rather than prior wealth; no figure either way), with a close call +toward 0.0. + +**What the domain does not show.** Its 39 held cells, all on the two class W criteria (C1.2b and C1.5), rest on v1 +rationales the pass did not re-read, because v2.0 changed only their wording; the outside blind reader agreed with 27 of +them, and the adjudication held the other 12 on their sources. The limits page states which held cells no reading of v2.0 reached. + + +### C1.1 Poverty Elimination Capacity + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario, ≥85% under stress testing. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 21 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 9 at 1.0, 13 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. on the design's published model at v5.6.0 (500 seeds, 20 years, the Reference environment), poverty on the Societal Poverty Line, v2.0's indicator, computed from the engine's disposable income per adult, is 7.7% at year 20 in the release row (nothing the Source pays backed by new output, the model's main reading) against 7.9% in the paired run with no programme and today's safety net, a reduction of 1.5%, and 9.5% at full backing; with the in-kind value of price cuts counted, 4.6%; it was 7.3% at adoption, so it rises over the run; the largest reduction on any measure the engine reports is 74.5% (below 30 days of basic living, at full backing), and the release's own measure, adults below their cost of living, falls 60.3% (release row) and 70.7% (full backing) against no programme (readings 3.3, 3.4) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. in the Adverse environment (recessions, an automation wave and 2% outside inflation), poverty on the Societal Poverty Line is 8.3% at year 20 in the release row and 9.7% at full backing, against 7.3% with no programme, higher in both; the share below the cost of living falls 52.9% against no programme; no measure falls 85% (reading 3.4) + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: the headcount at the Societal Poverty Line rose in each of the four economies over the window -- DNK 6.6% in 2005 to 7.4% in 2023, a reduction of -12.1%; FIN 7.3% in 2005 to 8.7% in 2023, a reduction of -19.2%; NOR 7.2% in 2005 to 8.5% in 2023, a reduction of -18.1%; SWE 9.8% in 2005 to 12.4% in 2023, a reduction of -26.5%; the lines rose with the medians (Sweden's from $21.92 to $29.10 a day), and the rates, among the world's lowest, did not fall (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: below 85% in every economy; the rates rose after 2008 (Sweden 10.1% to 10.8% by 2012) (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. demonstrate poverty elimination capacity +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. the documented stress episode is Spain's 2008-13 crisis: Fagor Electrodomesticos, the group's founding cooperative, failed in 2013 with about 5,700 employees; the group's mechanisms (relocation, early retirement, Lagun-Aro) covered its 1,898 members, of whom 417 were relocated within two months with solutions aimed at 1,000-1,200, while non-member employees of its subsidiaries were outside them; no poverty-reduction figure under stress is located for members or for the wider workforce (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. would eliminate poverty +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. remuneration by effort and sacrifice and universal access to consumption councils are specified; no stress scenario or estimate is stated or cited (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: the white paper states that access to essentials is 'structurally guaranteed' and that fair-access protocols keep essentials available 'regardless of individual capacity, disability, or temporary hardship', through the ITC's fairness signal, but sets no level and projects no rate; its access is in non-transferable time credits, which the Societal Poverty Line's income or consumption measure would read only through a projection the paper does not make (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no stress scenario for access to essentials (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: Alaska's dividend (about $1,000 to $3,300 a person a year) is a tenth to a quarter of a line of $13,627 a year; Norway's variant funds the budget, and Norway's headcount at the line rose from 7.2% in 2005 to 8.5% in 2023 with the fund at four times mainland GDP (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: below 85% on both variants (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs the appropriation and provision rules of common-pool resources, not household income or consumption at large; generalised to every commons, wage and transfer incomes stay outside it (reading 1.1.3) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: out of reach. out of reach, as clause 1 (reading 1.1.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. would achieve 95%+ elimination +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. no estimate under stress is stated or cited; the payment is specified as unconditional and fixed, part (b2) found no rule raising it with crisis severity, and Alaska's dividend, the long-running precedent, is set on an annual cycle (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. could eliminate poverty +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. the rationale names instruments (wealth caps, maximum income ratios, universal basic services) that could eliminate poverty; no stress scenario or estimate is stated or cited (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: the citizen's dividend governs part of household income; distributing the whole of US land rent (on the order of 5 to 10% of GDP, Larson 2015) would pay roughly $3,000 to $6,000 a person a year, against a line of $37.33 a day ($13,627 a year) that itself rises by half the median's gain; a floor that low lifts part of the poor over the line, far from nine in ten (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: land rent falls in a downturn, and the dividend with it (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: out of reach. out of reach: the profit-and-loss-sharing contract set allocates finance; zakat and the social-finance layer lie outside it (the extension test, D31: the Islamic finance precedent), so the mechanism governs no floor under household income (reading 1.1.3) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: out of reach. out of reach, as clause 1 (reading 1.1.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: mutual credit lets members with skills but no money trade through interest-free credit lines; the schemes' studies report gains to participants (the UK's LETS, the Bangla-Pesa) and no headcount at a national line, and a credit line transfers no income to those who cannot supply (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no stress scenario (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: the Poverty and Inequality Platform holds no Singapore survey and the state publishes no poverty line; the one academic estimate (Donaldson et al., 2013) is a single basic-needs level, not a change over the window (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no series, so no stress reading (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: the United States' headcount at the Societal Poverty Line went from 19.2% in 2005 to 20.2% in 2024, a reduction of -5.2% -- no reduction; the line rose with the median ($30.84 to $37.33 a day, 2021 PPP) and the headcount stayed near a fifth throughout (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: the base reduction is below 85%; the 2020-21 transfers cut the rate to 16.7% in 2021, and it returned to 19.5% in 2022 when they lapsed (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: transfer programmes are a real mechanism (they cut the rate in 2021), but the headcount did not fall + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: the services are in kind, and the Societal Poverty Line counts income or consumption; the proposal's sources value the services to a low-income household (the Institute for Global Prosperity, 2017) but project no headcount at any line (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no stress scenario (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. Near-universal poverty elimination achievable +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. no estimate of poverty reduction under stress is stated or cited; the guarantee is specified as countercyclical, which is a mechanism, not an estimate of the level (reading 3.1); the one crisis-tested precedent of the component, Argentina's Plan Jefes y Jefas in the 2002 crisis, in which poverty rose from 37% to 58%, cut the share of participants falling into indigence from an estimated 40% to 30% + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. Theoretical capacity for 100% poverty elimination +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. the rationale conditions its figure on technological assumptions proving correct; no scenario in which they fall short, this entry's stress case, is estimated (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: the reform changes corporate purpose and governance (living wages and fair taxes as aims) and leaves the host's transfers unmodified; on its principal host's record the headcount went from 19.2% in 2005 to 20.2% in 2024, a reduction of -5.2% (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: below 85% on the host's record (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: China's headcount at the Societal Poverty Line (consumption) went from 39.1% in 2005 to 19.7% in 2022, a reduction of 49.6%, a real reduction about half the bar's; the line itself rose from $3.38 to $8.02 a day as the median grew (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: the base reduction is below 85%; the rate kept falling through 2020 (21.0%) and rose in 2022 (19.2% to 19.7%) (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: the Platform holds one Qatar survey (17.6% at the line in 2017), so no reduction can be computed (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no series (reading 1.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: the rentier state's transfers are a real mechanism for citizens; the migrant majority is outside them + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: short. short: the platform phases out government income security and holds that 'the proper and most effective source of help for the poor is the voluntary efforts of private groups and individuals'; no public floor exists to project (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. short: private charity, the only mechanism, is itself procyclical under stress (reading 1.1.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, second condition: the system's own sources refuse poverty relief as a public function and leave it to private charity (reading 1.1.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: not shown. not shown: the social foundation's income dimension (no one below the poverty line) is a target, and 'Design to Distribute' offers land, money creation, enterprise, knowledge and basic income as options, not as an adopted design; no rate is projected (reading 1.1.1) +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: not shown. not shown: no stress scenario (reading 1.1.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition: no structural mechanism addresses poverty -- the framework names the target and adopts no instrument to meet it (reading 1.1.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: a target without an adopted mechanism + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-1) + +1. *≥90% poverty reduction within 20 years under base scenario*: cleared. near-universal elimination of absolute poverty +2. *≥85% under stress testing*: short. Cuba's Special Period (1990-95), after the loss of Soviet support, is a documented stress episode in a centrally planned economy with universal rationing: per capita daily energy intake fell from 2,899 to 1,863 kcal and average adult weight by 4-5 kg, a neuropathy outbreak, possibly due to vitamin deficiencies, affected about 50,000 people in 1992-93, and the decline in infant mortality reversed in 1990-93; a special rationing system shielded children, elderly people and pregnant women from the outbreak, but a basic necessity, food, fell short for the adult population at large + +Read in part (b3) (Session 40). + +### C1.2a Wealth Building for Resilience + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 12 at 0.5, 10 at 0.0. v1: 4 at 1.0, 9 at 0.5, 10 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: cleared. on the owner's reading (decision 79.1, as decision 58.1 reads C3.2), the backing of the currency by creative output, a community chest, is an original feature of the design and is read as backing what the Source pays; at full backing the design's published model at v5.6.0 (500 seeds, Reference) has 91.1% of participants reach net wealth with Acre Equity of $60,000 in 2019 dollars at year 20, in 500 of 500 seeds, median $437,409 (77.9% in the Adverse environment), and its BLEI ladder puts 76.2% of adults at Flourishing (two years of basic living and more); in the main reading, with no backing, the figures are 13.9% and 3.4% (48.0% Flourishing with no programme); held until an empirical study shows that the backing does not hold in real-world data + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.1 (Session 79). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Group 2.5's reading (decision 57.3): the clause holds only if new output backs what the Source pays, a condition the design's sources do not state; the release row shows 13.9% + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. no figure in the published rationale, which credited the vehicles for those who use them and left breadth to C1.5; on Norway's register data for 2024 the bar is NOK 734,447, and the 30th percentile of household net wealth is NOK 390,300 ($31,885 in 2019 dollars at PPP) while the 40th is NOK 1,131,000 ($92,396): between 60% and 70% of households hold the bar's figure, and 15.8% hold negative net wealth; the register excludes pension wealth, so collective and public pension entitlements are not counted (reading 3.5) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Published 1.0 read in the D28 form: the clause is short on the one Nordic register that publishes the distribution, so the unit falls to 0.5; Sweden publishes no household wealth statistics, and no Nordic source located shows 70% of househo + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. the rationale's evidence is qualitative: Mondragón members 'accumulate substantial wealth through capital accounts and profit distribution'; no source the unit cites states an accumulation figure, or the share of participants whose capital accounts and other net worth reach $60,000 (2019 dollars) over 20 years; a genuine, individually held vehicle, not shown at the bar for 70% of participants + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. no private accumulation; named community investment councils can build collective wealth; no figure or household buffer is stated; the 0.5 band's collectively held case + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Integral: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. Integral Time Credits cannot be saved or accumulated by design; no other vehicle; the 0.0 band's anchor case + +Why 0.0 stands: the system excludes accumulation by design (the band's anchor) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. a large, growing, professionally invested corpus held collectively; no individual holds a titled or severable claim, so no household's net worth includes it; the 0.5 band's collectively held case + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. a member's claim on the commons is a use-right, non-severable and extinguished on exit; no individual balance grows; no case reports household accumulation of the bar's order + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: use-rights, not assets (the published flag toward 0.5 stands) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: out of reach. an income transfer; no accumulation vehicle; the 0.0 band's own anchor case + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: income only (the band's anchor) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. community land trusts and cooperatives give real, collectively held security; individual accumulation is discouraged by design, and no source states a household figure; the 0.5 band's anchor case + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: out of reach. the citizen's dividend is an annual pass-through of land rent, income rather than a held corpus; lower taxes on income and capital raise saving capacity in the host economy, which the reach rule does not credit + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: the mechanism's payment is income only + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. profit-sharing investment accounts are a genuine, individually held, accumulating vehicle; returns are smoothed to market benchmarks, so accumulation is indistinguishable from bank saving in the host economy, which the reach rule does not credit; nothing shows 70% of participants at the bar through the mechanism + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. credit balances are claims on other members in a non-convertible unit, capped and in some designs subject to demurrage; no store of value usable as a buffer, for any participant + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: the instrument has no accumulation function by design + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. UBS's median wealth per adult, $96,434 at end-2025, is $100,395 in 2019 dollars at PPP, above the bar; but the clause asks for 70% of participants, and the scoring document estimates that about 75% of the population has a genuine vehicle, Work Permit holders (about a fifth) having none; no published distribution shows 70% of all who live and work in the economy at the figure, and 20-year accumulation, lease decay aside, is not reported + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Published 1.0 read in the D28 form: the median alone does not show the 70% clause, so the unit falls to 0.5 + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. on v2.0's price basis the bar is $75,557 in 2025 dollars; in the 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances 66.3% of US families hold net worth at or above it, a lifetime stock that overstates 20 years' accumulation, so fewer than 70% reach the figure; the 30th percentile is $43,835 and the median $171,606 (2019 dollars); among families whose head is 45 to 54, about 20 to 30 years into working life, 71.6% hold the bar's figure, before subtracting what they held at the start (reading 3.5); homeownership and retirement accounts are genuine vehicles, so the unit is 0.5, not 0.0 + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published rationale's bottom-half figure (~$3,200, from the Paper's calibration of 2019) is replaced by the 2025 survey's distribution, which v2.0's measure names; the verdict is unchanged + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: out of reach. in-kind services, among them zero-rent social housing, reduce expenses but create no asset, deed or account + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: services, not assets + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: out of reach. the Job Guarantee pays a wage and benefits; it holds no asset for its participants; the published 0.5 credited 'traditional markets', the host economy's vehicles, which the reach rule does not credit to a mechanism (protocol 3.2, D28(c)); generalised over the economy, the mechanism governs income, not accumulation + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: income only, the 0.0 band's own description (Appendix H.7v2) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. A correction (reading 3.6): income without an accumulation vehicle is the 0.0 band, as for Universal Basic Income and Georgism's dividend; one failure more, no tier change + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. no vehicle of any kind, individual or collective, is specified; 'abundance makes accumulation less relevant' describes consumption access, not a buffer + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. the vehicles are Status Quo's (homeownership, retirement accounts) with incremental stock options and profit-sharing; on the 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances 66.3% of families hold the bar's figure, short of 70%, and no source shows the reform raising it + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. UBS's median wealth per adult, $27,273 at end-2022, is $43,071 in 2019 dollars at PPP, under the bar, so fewer than half of adults hold the figure; v2.0 removes the middle-income adjustment on which the published rationale judged the magnitude likely to clear; homeownership near 90% is a genuine, individually titled vehicle, impaired by falling prices and restricted rural land rights + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. for citizens a generous vehicle (free plots, near-interest-free housing loans, a pension); UBS's median wealth per adult, $95,499, is $116,897 in 2019 dollars at PPP, a figure the scoring document could not reconcile with the wage structure; citizens are 9% to 13% of residents, migrant workers have no pension and restricted ownership, and well under half of residents have a vehicle reaching the figure + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: not shown. the system's own markets are its accumulation vehicles (property, ownership of enterprises, private saving), the same vehicles Status Quo Market Capitalism's unit credits at 0.5; the published 0.0 rested on their reach ('those born poor cannot accumulate initial capital'), which is the 0.5 band's partial coverage, not the absence of a mechanism; no source shows 70% of participants at the bar + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. A correction (reading 3.6): a reach shortfall is a 0.5 under protocol 2.1, as for Status Quo, Stakeholder Capitalism and China; one failure fewer, no tier change + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. the framework names the categories of wealth and cites others' vehicles as compatible, but adopts none as its own; no implementation reviewed established an accumulation vehicle + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism of the system's own addresses the criterion (the published flag toward 0.5 stands) + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-2a) + +1. *≥$60,000 median net-wealth accumulation over 20 years for 70%+ of participants, in constant 2019 US dollars at purchasing-power parity*: short. no accumulation vehicle beyond minimal personal property; the savings-bank deposits households did hold were frozen and then erased by the price liberalisation of 1992, so the historical record shows no buffer that survived; far below the bar for any share of participants + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion, and the historical record, collapse included (protocol 4.1), shows no credible pathway under the system's own logic + +Read in group 2.2 (Session 53). + +### C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution. Revision class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 15 at 0.5, 8 at 0.0. v1: 5 at 1.0, 9 at 0.5, 9 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: short. on the design's published model at v5.6.0 (500 seeds, Reference), the wealth Gini at year 20, as the engine reports it (debts as zero), is 0.492 in the release row (0.477 with Acre Equity) and 0.602 at full backing, against 0.755 with no programme; no seed is below 0.35 in any run or environment; the design narrows the distribution, but not to the bar (reading 3.6) + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Wealth Gini runs 0.65-0.75 — a real, meaningful reduction from unregulated capitalism's 0.85 through genuine redistributive policy — but well above the <0.35 threshold this criterion requires, with no structural cap holding concentration down beyond ordinary progressive taxation. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Wealth Gini in cooperative networks runs 0.40-0.50 — real, meaningful progress attributable to distributed ownership over unregulated capitalism's 0.85, but not confirmed under the 0.35 threshold, and membership-based capital accounts do not by themselves cap concentration among cooperative-sector participants. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: not shown. not shown: the design removes private productive property, capital markets and income from ownership, and rates incomes by effort and sacrifice, which bounds the top of the distribution more firmly than Degrowth's caps or Integral's parallel network; but it states no bound on personal holdings, which unequal effort ratings and saving across a lifetime leave unequal, and no source the unit cites, and none the outside reader names (it projects the Gini from the design's mechanisms, closed book), estimates the wealth Gini; a bound on the top does not bound a Gini, which the bottom of the distribution also sets + +Read in Session 84, then read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (decision 84.4, Session 84). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading and the outside reader's: no private capital ownership is a structural ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: not shown. not shown: inside the network time-decaying, non-transferable credits and node commons make accumulation impossible, but the design 'is designed to emerge gradually, non-coercively, and in parallel with existing market and state systems', becoming 'supplementary' before 'essential', and no source estimates the wealth held by its population, inside the network or outside it; Jev reads the clause not shown in both passes + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading: no stock of wealth exists anywhere in the network for any participant to convert into leverage over others + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The mechanism targets a specific, well-documented channel of wealth concentration — state-owned subsoil resource rent — arguably more completely than Georgism's LVT does for land value: under Norwegian and Alaskan mineral-rights law, this revenue was never privately held to begin with, so there is no equivalent of LVT's ongoing tax-collection contest against an existing private-property interest. But it is narrow in exactly the way Georgism's own C1.2b write-up already flags for its own mechanism: it does nothing about wealth concentration through equity ownership, business profits, or housing, and — a further, distinct point worth naming since it doesn't apply to Georgism — the fund's own growth strategy (roughly 71% global listed equities for GPFG) is not independent of, but deeply reliant on, the same corporate-profit and capital-market dynamics that drive concentration elsewhere in the economy. Norway itself is the clearest illustration of the resulting limits: income inequality there remains among the world's lowest, but wealth concentration at the top is real and, per a March 2026 analysis, rising — just ten people in Norway now own more wealth than the bottom 50% of the population combined, entirely outside anything the fund itself touches, since the fund is a public asset that leaves private equity and business ownership untouched. Alaska's own measured effect on income distribution is small and precisely estimated: a 0.02 reduction in the Gini coefficient (Berman, 2024) — real, but modest. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **Within the resource, accumulation is structurally blocked.** Boundaries (principle 1), appropriation limits fitted to the resource (principle 2), and graduated sanctions (principle 5) exist precisely to stop any party from taking more than its share. No owner can buy the commons out; that is what makes it a commons. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** UBI provides income but not economic power — ownership, wealth, and capital remain exactly as concentrated as before, and recipients remain subordinate to capital owners despite the transfer. No mechanism in a generically-funded UBI targets wealth concentration specifically (a UBI funded specifically by a wealth tax would score differently; this evaluation, like the original, scores UBI as generically proposed). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: not shown. not shown: the literature proposes caps on income and wealth, commons and universal services, which would lower concentration, but the design keeps private property and markets and no source estimates the wealth distribution; a cap on the top does not bound a Gini, which the bottom of the distribution also sets + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading: decentralisation, wealth caps and cooperative ownership as a named structural ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This is Georgism's most direct point of contact with any NEEC criterion — capturing unearned land-rent accumulation is the mechanism's entire purpose, targeting a well-documented channel of wealth concentration (including the dynamic where public infrastructure investment inflates private land values that titleholders capture without funding the investment). This is structural, not incidental. It is also narrow: it does nothing about wealth concentration through equity, business profits, or financial assets, all larger components of top-end wealth in most advanced economies. No Gini figure specific to a real Georgist implementation exists to cite, since none has run at single-tax intensity; this score rests on the strength of the targeted mechanism rather than a demonstrated outcome. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This is the first of the three criteria Handoff 21 predicted the practice-versus-design gap would bear on, and the prediction holds. The design argument is that risk sharing splits returns between capital and enterprise rather than guaranteeing the capital holder a claim. The practice is that the dominant contracts deliver a predetermined markup to the financier, the liability side pays a smoothed market return, and nothing in the mechanism caps or claws back concentration. Layered on an unmodified market economy, the wealth distribution is the market's. H.7v2's 0.0 band — "no structural prevention mechanism; concentration compounds without limit" — is met, as it is for Status Quo Market Capitalism and Universal Basic Services. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: out of reach. out of reach: a mutual-credit network governs its members' exchange balances (zero-sum, capped, usually interest-free), not the holdings of land, capital and savings that set an economy's wealth Gini, even generalised (protocol 3.2, D28(c)) + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The Ministry of Finance estimates Singapore's wealth Gini at 0.55 — above its income inequality, but below the 0.6–0.7 range it cites for the United Kingdom, Japan, and Germany (MOF Occasional Paper, 2026, as reported by Mothership). That places Singapore below the "social democracy: 0.65–0.75" band Section 12.3 uses. Two structural features limit particular concentration channels: residential land is state-owned and leased rather than sold (C1.2a), and foreign buyers pay a 60% Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty on any home (Global Property Guide). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Wealth Gini of 0.85 indicates extreme concentration, and no structural mechanism — no cap, no dissolution, no targeted capture of unearned gains — checks it. This is NEEC's own explicit anchor case for a full failure on this criterion (Paper Appendix H.7v2). + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This criterion asks whether the system structurally prevents wealth *concentration* — a Gini-coefficient-relevant question, distinct from C1.2a's resilience-buffer question. This is the single most consequential call in this evaluation, and it was revised once during drafting, disclosed here rather than silently settled. **The case for 0.5** (this evaluation's initial read): the shelter sector's plan to double the UK's social housing stock by 1.5 million units removes that many households from the private rental market entirely, a real, costed, committed mechanism — unlike Doughnut Economics, which was scored 0.0 here specifically for citing compatible redistributive mechanisms without adopting any of its own, UBS *does* adopt a specific mechanism of its own, which seemed to warrant credit above Doughnut Economics' clean zero, on the model of Georgism's own 0.5 for land value capture. **Why this evaluation lands at 0.0 instead:** on closer comparison with Georgism's actual mechanism, the analogy does not hold. Georgism's land value tax *captures wealth that would otherwise accumulate to landowners* — it is a device that removes an existing, ongoing accumulation from one party's hands. UBS's shelter sector does the opposite kind of thing: it *builds new housing and gives it away at zero rent*, funded by general taxation. This is real and valuable, but it does not capture, cap, or redistribute any existing stock of wealth; it is an expenditure commitment, not a wealth- concentration-prevention mechanism, and — like every other part of the proposal — it says nothing about the Gini coefficient of the population's existing asset holdings. The proposal's funding mechanism (reducing the Personal Allowance) is a tax-and-transfer adjustment, not a wealth tax, asset cap, or land-value-capture device either. On reflection, this evaluation concludes UBS has no C1.2b mechanism of the kind this criterion asks about, at any scale — a different, and weaker, case than either Georgism's or Mutual Credit/LETS's own targeted mechanisms. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The housing plank's pressure on land and rental values + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE** — *flagged as this Report's single most consequential contestable score.* No wealth tax, asset cap, or other mechanism targets accumulated capital directly; the job guarantee is an income and employment instrument, not one that touches how fast existing capital holdings grow. This system's own Power Distribution score (C4.4=0.5, below) credits the job-guarantee exit option with reducing capital's *bargaining* power — a real effect, but on a different causal channel than this criterion's own wealth-concentration threshold. A future scorer who reads that bargaining-power reduction as sufficient for this criterion's structural-prevention bar should feel free to revise this to 0.5; doing so is the single change that would move this system back to the Potentially Adequate tier. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. C4.4's reduction of capital power read as sufficient + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-2b) + +1. *Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution*: not shown. not shown: common ownership of automated production, universal services and socialised housing are named in the literature as the design's answer to concentration, but who owns and controls the machines is left unresolved (the entry's own C4.4) and no source estimates the distribution + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: the unresolved control of the machines read as no structural prevention + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** One-share-one-vote maintains wealth-based power concentration; token stakeholder voice does not challenge fundamental plutocratic control, and no structural cap on accumulation exists. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> UBS estimates China's wealth Gini at 70.9 (end-2022). That is inside the "social democracy: Gini 0.65–0.75" band that Section 12.3 already uses, and well below North America's 82.3 in the same dataset. The trend, however, runs the wrong way. Piketty, Yang & Zucman find that the top 10% income share rose from 27% to 41% between 1978 and 2015 while the bottom 50% share fell from 27% to 15% — a move from near-Nordic toward US levels — and that the top 10% wealth share reached about 67%, close to the US's 72% (as summarized by Stanford SCCEI). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> No official wealth-distribution figure for Qatar was found. Commentary on UBS's figures says Qatar has the second-best wealth Gini among the 25 countries with the highest median wealth (Yahoo Finance and lovemoney); the underlying number was not retrieved. The allocation described under C1.2a is a real deconcentrating channel: it spreads rent-derived land and housing wealth across the citizen body rather than leaving it to market allocation. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Citizenship divide, no limit at the top + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Wealth concentration accelerates without redistributive mechanisms — the literal opposite of prevention, and an explicit design feature rather than an oversight. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This criterion asks whether the system structurally prevents wealth concentration sufficient to enable governance capture — a Gini <0.35 threshold, per Section 12.3. Doughnut Economics has no cap, dissolution mechanism, progressive-taxation commitment, or land-rent capture of its own; as with C1.2a, it names the problem (concentrated ownership of land, money creation, and enterprise) and cites compatible literature without adopting a mechanism. This makes Doughnut Economics' case for C1.2b *weaker* than either Georgism's (which commits to capturing land rent specifically, scoring 0.5 here) or Mutual Credit/LETS's (whose zero-sum, capped design is this corpus's cleanest C1.2b anchor, scoring 1.0) — both of those systems commit to one specific channel; Doughnut Economics commits to none. The 2025 *Nature* update (Fanning & Raworth) itself documents, rather than resolves, this gap at the global scale: the richest 20% of nations (15% of the global population) are responsible for more than 40% of annual ecological overshoot while accounting for only about 2% of the social shortfall, and the poorest 40% of countries (43% of the population) account for only 4% of the overshoot but 63% of the shortfall — a stark, current, well-evidenced finding about the persistence of exactly the concentration this criterion asks whether the system prevents, published by the framework's own authors as a monitoring finding rather than as an indication that DE itself is closing this gap. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The 'harness the commons' language weighted more heavily + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-2b) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> *Flagged as a genuinely contestable score.* Abolishing private capital markets should, on its face, produce an extremely low measured monetary-wealth Gini — but this system's own Power Distribution finding (C4.4, below) documents that a new elite, the nomenklatura, concentrated real economic power through non-monetary privilege (housing, special stores, foreign travel) outside any formal wealth statistic. A clean Pass would let the absence of legal private property stand in for genuine concentration prevention when de facto concentration re-emerged through a different channel; this score holds both facts at once — extremely compressed *formal* distribution, real, documented *de facto* privilege capture. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The formal wealth Gini, with no private capital markets + +### C1.3 Housing Security + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods, housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. v1: 9 at 1.0, 11 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. the engine still models no housing tenure, eviction or rent line (Public Trust Housing enters from the member's side only: a 35% cut in the housing component and Acre Equity), so it computes no stability rate; on its nearest measure, a year in which cash income and savings cannot cover the year's cost, 78.0% of adults pass the weakest 5-year window with no such year in the release row and 86.1% at full backing, against 70.1% with no programme; inside Public Trust Housing (20.0% of adults) 79.4% and 87.3%; every figure is under 88%; the tenure forms the owner describes (selling in, buying in, earning in, renting, moving within the system and keeping Acre Equity) are design features the model does not yet carry (reading 3.7) +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. the engine carries no housing-cost line: Public Trust Housing cuts the housing component by 35% for its members (20.0% of adults), and no cost share at 80% of the median is stated or computed (reading 3.7) + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: cleared. about 90% or more housing stability +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: short. housing cost overburden (housing costs above 40% of disposable income) in 2024: Denmark 14.6% and Sweden 10.6%, among the highest rates in the EU; in Denmark's lowest income quintile, whose incomes fall below 80% of the median, the rate ranges from 44.6% to 60.4% across the EU-SILC series + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. housing cooperatives exist within the cooperative movement, but the market still allocates most housing; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected; cooperative housing is a minority tenure + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. housing is allocated by consumption councils on needs and effort and described as decommodified and stable; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected; allocation by effort rating sets no housing charge that can be read against income + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. community-controlled allocation and cooperative ownership; the rationale cites the criterion's own benchmark, community land trusts' foreclosure rate of 0.46% against 3.26% in 2008-2010, as making 90%+ plausible; a crisis foreclosure rate for trust homeowners is not a 5-year stability rate for the system's population, and no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: out of reach. the fund touches neither exemplar's housing market, both ordinary private mortgage-based systems; no housing allocation, land trust or tenancy protection is located +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: out of reach. the mechanism governs no housing cost + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: no housing channel of any kind + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. community land trusts are the commons' housing form (counted in, decision D31, with a scenario counting them out); no 5-year stability series for commons-governed housing was retrieved +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. nothing in the mechanism targets households at 80% of the median; no cost share is stated + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. stable income improves housing security for many; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. the transfer raises income, but without housing policy landlords can capture it through rent increases; no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. community land trusts, housing cooperatives and rent controls are named as the design's housing mechanism; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected; the design names decommodification, not a cost + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. the tax discourages land-banking and raises construction density, but addresses neither eviction nor rental stability; Estonia's land tax did not prevent the Tallinn housing bubble of about 2003 to 2008 +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. supply effects are measured in housing-unit growth, not in housing costs against income; no affordability figure for households at 80% of the median is located + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. diminishing partnership (musharakah mutanaqisah) is a real housing product: the financier bears ownership risk and a markup price cannot grow after default; allocation remains market-based and no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. profit rates are competitive with conventional mortgages, not below them; no affordability floor, and no cost share at 80% of the median is stated + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: out of reach. no housing-specific design element, volatility buffer or stability outcome in any source reviewed (WIR, Sardex, LETS, time banking, Trueque, Grassroots Economics) +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: out of reach. the instrument governs no housing cost + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: no housing channel of any kind + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: cleared. a documented stability rate far above the threshold for the resident population +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: short. not maintained for the rental segment, which houses most non-residents: private rents up 29.7% in 2022 after 9.9% in 2021, HDB rents up about 28.5% in 2022, foreigners about 65% of renters; the configured-economy population rule counts them (protocol 3.2) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. no national measure of 5-year involuntary displacement exists; in 2018 landlords filed 3.6 million eviction cases against 2.7 million households, and renters, about a third of households, carry most of the exposure; the published 72%, for market-rate rental only, has no located source (reading 3.5) +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: short. 80% of the 2023 median household income ($80,610) is $64,488, inside the $45,000 to $74,999 band, where 45% of renter households pay 30% or more of pre-tax income on housing and utilities; on disposable income, the clause's basis, the share is larger; half of all renter households, a record 22.6 million, are cost-burdened + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. zero-rent social housing on a needs basis, 1.5 million new units; Vienna's municipal and cooperative housing, the closest analogue, is durable at population scale; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. zero rent clears the clause for the households the shelter sector houses, but that design has not been implemented at the scale proposed, Vienna charges modest rents and new cooperative entrants pay an upfront sum of the order of $38,000; no cost share at 80% of the median is stated for the economy + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. the job guarantee would substantially improve housing security: an improvement, not a stability rate +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: out of reach. affordability is set by housing policy and land markets; no source located in the job-guarantee literature that pairs a housing programme with the guarantee in its design (D31) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. automated construction and universal provision are projected to achieve complete housing security; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no housing cost, and no share of income at 80% of the median, is stated or projected; provision is described as universal, not costed + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. the host economy's housing (Status Quo's) with some employer housing assistance; no national measure of 5-year displacement exists, as for Status Quo +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: short. housing remains market-allocated; at 80% of the US median, $64,488, 45% of renter households in the $45,000 to $74,999 band pay 30% or more of pre-tax income, and no source shows the reform changing it + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. about 12.6 million households were moved as their dwellings were demolished in 2008-2012; by 2022 more than 85% of homes were sold before completion, and mortgage boycotts spread to over 300 stalled developments; about 300 million migrant workers were historically shut out of city housing support; no 5-year stability rate is reported +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. ownership is broad and lightly leveraged (about 18% of owners with a mortgage in 2022), but no housing cost share for households at 80% of the median is located, for owners or for the migrant renters + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. for citizens housing is largely decommodified (free plots, long-term loans); for non-citizens, the large majority of residents, housing and residence depend on continuous employment with a cooperating employer, who can cancel the visa; no 5-year rate is reported for either +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. low-wage workers are housed by the employer or paid a housing allowance of at least QAR 500 a month; no housing cost share at 80% of the median is located + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. pure market allocation with no stabilizing mechanism; no rate is stated +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. no affordability instrument of any kind; housing costs are whatever the market sets + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: pure market allocation with no stabilizing mechanism (the 0.0 band's anchor) + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: not shown. housing is one of the twelve social-foundation dimensions and City Portraits track it; the one located policy output (Portland's 'From Excess to Access') is narrow; no stability rate, documented or designed, is stated, and no source the unit cites gives one +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: not shown. affordability is tracked as an indicator, not set by a mechanism of the framework's own + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Held at 0.5 on the published reading, which credits the diagnostic process and its one policy output; the reading that gave the framework's C1.2a 0.0 (no vehicle of its own) would give 0.0 here, and is flagged + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-3) + +1. *≥88% housing stability over 5-year periods*: cleared. no 5-year rate is documented, but the three causes of displacement the measure names were closed to state tenants: no mortgages, rents and fees unchanged since 1928, and eviction 'virtually unheard of in public housing'; the exposed segment, workers' hostels whose places went with the job, held 6% of households in the 1989 census; counting every hostel household as displaced within five years leaves 94% stable; through the collapse, flats passed to their occupants practically free of charge (reading 3.4) +2. *housing costs ≤30% of disposable income at 80% of regional median household disposable income*: cleared. housing fees, communal services included, were about 2.5% of an average worker's or employee's income in 1990, so a household at 80% of the median paid of the order of 3%; after the system ended, the poorest Russian quintile's rent-to-income ratio reached 18.6% in 1995, still under 30% + +Read in group 2.3 (Session 54). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The 1.0 band's anchor example; it holds + +### C1.4 Automation Resilience + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Poverty <8% and aggregate demand >85% baseline in each of the 30%, 50% and 70% displacement scenarios. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 18 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. v1: 4 at 1.0, 14 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. v2.0 names the design's own model of three scenarios displacing 30%, 50% and 70% of paid hours; the model at v5.6.0 still cannot run them: its automation wave slows wages and, since v5.4, ends jobs, at 2.377 automation job losses per 100 adult-years in the Adverse environment, with 3.587% of adult-years out of work, and its labour response lowers paid hours by 8.3% in the Reference and 11.3% in the Adverse environment, far from a 30% displacement; in the Adverse environment poverty on the Societal Poverty Line is 8.3% (release row) and 9.7% (full backing) at year 20, above 8% in both (reading 3.8) +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. the model computes no final consumption expenditure and no aggregate demand against a pre-displacement baseline (reading 3.8) + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. generous unemployment benefits and retraining are a buffer; the rationale says the configuration cannot sustain 50-70% displacement, without a model; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. cooperatives can reduce hours rather than shed members and distribute automation's gains to them, under competitive pressure to automate; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: cleared. while maintaining consumption access +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. remuneration by effort and sacrifice, with an average income for those who cannot work, is specified, and the rationale says the gains of automation could be distributed through reduced hours; no level of consumption or demand under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement scenario is stated or cited, and none is located in the model's literature (reading 3.2) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the white paper states that essentials remain accessible 'regardless of age or ability' and that automation lowers the labour needed for them, but access still 'emerges from participation' and redemption needs an ITC balance; it states no level of poverty under any displacement scenario and invites readers to stress-test it; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. production planned on needs assessed through CDS, not on purchasing power, so demand does not require employment; no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the fund's revenue does not erode with the wage base, but no payout scales with displacement (Norway's budget transfer; Alaska's fixed dividend); no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. a commons share is not conditioned on employment and its non-wage income is observed, for members of a bounded resource; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no aggregate-demand mechanism, as the rationale says; no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. an unconditional transfer is an explicit mechanism decoupling income from employment; the rationale's 'scales naturally with automation' is a design statement, not a level of poverty under a stated scenario; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. unconditional transfers sustain household spending, as the rationale says; no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. reduced hours and work-sharing could absorb displacement; no mechanism for income as labour becomes optional is specified; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. an LVT-funded dividend would capture automation's surplus to the extent it capitalises into land values, an assumption less secure for AI-era capital; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: out of reach. the mechanism prices and structures credit; it governs neither household income nor final consumption, and the host economy's are not credited to it (protocol 3.2) +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: out of reach. the mechanism prices and structures credit; it governs neither household income nor final consumption, and the host economy's are not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: changing how credit is priced leaves distribution running through wage labour, as for Status Quo + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. mutual credit sustains exchange without wage income, but a displaced member needs something other members want; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. Jobseeker Support pays up to S$6,000 over six months, conditional on job search, with training and reserve-funded wage subsidies; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the rationale asserts a deflationary spiral at 30% displacement without a model; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: income and demand run through paid work, and the configuration's support for the unemployed is insurance against cyclical job loss, not a provision for paid work becoming optional; the 0.0 band's anchor + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. free provision of housing, food, healthcare, education, transport and information lowers the wage income needed to avoid poverty; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. the rationale finds no mechanism for demand because the services pay no cash; on the measure v2.0 names, final consumption expenditure includes general government's, so the services themselves count toward it; no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the Job Guarantee keeps income tied to (guaranteed) work; the rationale's 'can maintain 30% displacement but fails at 50-70%' is a judgement, not an estimate; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the rationale states the design's premise, an economy in which human labour is optional; no poverty level under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement scenario is stated or cited, and none is located in the design's literature (reading 3.2) +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no level of aggregate demand under any displacement scenario is stated or cited (reading 3.2) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: stakeholder governance leaves firms automating to stay competitive and adds nothing for income distribution or demand as automation advances; the 0.0 band's description + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the state directs state-owned employers to absorb workers and has begun retraining for AI displacement; dibao reaches under 3% of the population; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. directed investment can sustain demand, as the rationale says (C3.1); no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. citizens' incomes rest on a hydrocarbon rent automation would not touch, through state jobs; non-citizens, most of the population the protocol counts (3.2), have no mechanism beyond departure; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The outside reader's reading: for the non-citizen majority, income and demand rest wholly on wage labour (the 0.0 band) + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: the design removes the safety nets that exist and leaves income and demand to paid work alone + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. the social foundation is a measurement target, not a provision; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: automation is named as a concern and met with no income-distribution, contribution-recognition or demand-maintenance mechanism in the framework or its implementations + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-4) + +1. *Poverty <8%*: not shown. employment guaranteed regardless of productivity separates income from market demand for labour; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located +2. *aggregate demand >85% baseline*: not shown. no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located + +Read in group 2.7 (Session 60). + +### C1.5 Universal Wealth Access + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥80% population with an active wealth-accumulation pathway. Revision class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 12 at 0.5, 10 at 0.0. v1: 1 at 1.0, 11 at 0.5, 11 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> PTF acre equity provides near-universal wealth access (projected 80%+ participation), but full universality depends on implementation completeness that remains modeled rather than field-validated — consistent with this system's own general caveat elsewhere about modeling versus real-world confirmation. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Approximately 70% have wealth accumulation pathways through homeownership programs, pension systems, and savings incentives — near-universal, non-gated reach, meeting this narrowed criterion's access-breadth threshold on the strength of institutional coverage rather than a numeric technicality. *(Unchanged from the legacy score — Paper Appendix H.7v2's own worked example notes this qualitative-tolerance judgment call "was never about the Gini clause," which has moved to C1.2b above.)* + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Members have wealth access, but require cooperative membership. Unemployed, between jobs, or unable to work lack access. Not truly universal across the entire population. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Participatory councils provide universal economic *input* — access to the underlying mechanism is explicitly universal by design, since all participants are council members — but C1.2a's own finding that the mechanism's asset-growth power is only partial keeps this at partial credit rather than a full Pass, to avoid crediting universal access to a mechanism that isn't itself fully load-bearing. + +**Integral: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** This narrowed criterion asks about access breadth to an asset-growth mechanism, not accumulation adequacy (C1.2a) or concentration prevention (C1.2b) — and Integral's universal contribution-recognition design means access would be about as broad as possible, if there were a mechanism to access. But C1.2a already establishes no such mechanism exists at all; access to a mechanism that builds no assets does not satisfy this criterion, following directly from C1.2a's own finding rather than a separate access-breadth problem. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This evaluation follows the precedent Participatory Economics' own C1.5 write-up already establishes for exactly this situation (Report, System 11): "access to the underlying mechanism is explicitly universal by design... but C1.2a's own finding that the mechanism's asset-growth power is only partial keeps this at partial credit rather than a full Pass, to avoid crediting universal access to a mechanism that isn't itself fully load-bearing." Access here is, if anything, more cleanly universal than that precedent's own case: Alaska's PFD reaches essentially 100% of qualifying residents with no means test, employment condition, or membership gate of any kind (more than 600,000 recipients in 2025 alone) — a broader, less-gated reach than even Nordic Social Democracy's own ~70% pension/homeownership coverage. But since C1.2a lands at 0.5 rather than 1.0, this criterion tracks it downward for the same reason Participatory Economics' does. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Follows C1.2a + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This is the criterion where the scale convention bites hardest, and it is a **bound rather than a shortfall**. Principle 1 — clearly defined boundaries, defining who may appropriate — makes exclusion **constitutive** of the mechanism. A commons that admits everyone is not an Ostrom-style commons; it is the open-access resource the whole design exists to prevent. Universality is therefore precluded by the first principle, not merely unachieved. The observed reach, up to 2.5 billion of roughly 8 billion people, is under a third, and the mechanism supplies no route to 80%. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Income is not wealth. UBI provides monthly survival but no ownership stakes, no asset accumulation, no economic power beyond consumption — following directly from C1.2a's own finding. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Commons-based wealth provides universal *access* to resources — community gardens, tool libraries, shared spaces — but personal wealth accumulation itself is limited by design, a different conception of wealth than this criterion assumes. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** This narrowed criterion asks whether the population has broad *access* to an *active mechanism producing asset growth* — access breadth is arguably the one part of this pairing Georgism gets right (no membership gate, no employment requirement, no means test), but C1.2a's analysis already establishes that the dividend mechanism does not function as an asset-growth vehicle at all, for any participant, regardless of access breadth. Access to a mechanism that does not itself build assets does not satisfy this criterion's stated requirement — the same underlying reason as C1.2a, not an access-breadth problem. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Access to the accumulation vehicles is not membership-gated: anyone may open a Shariah-compliant savings or investment account, and a PricewaterhouseCoopers Malaysia study cited by the World Bank found that the majority of Islamic finance customers in Malaysia are non-Muslim — direct evidence that the mechanism does not gate on religious affiliation. Against that, the equity-based products are effectively absent at the bottom of the distribution: the literature reports that **no Malaysian microfinance institution offers *musharakah* or *mudarabah* contracts**, leaving microcredit-style debt instruments in their place, and the unbanked remain unbanked for cost and documentation reasons the mechanism does not address. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Access breadth is, if anything, a genuine strength here — LETS and time banks are typically open to anyone in a community with essentially no entry barrier, unlike Market Socialism's membership-gated cooperative model — but C1.2a's analysis already establishes there is no asset-growth mechanism at all for that openness to apply to. Access to a mechanism that does not itself build assets does not satisfy this criterion's stated requirement, mirroring Georgism's identical C1.2a/C1.5 pairing immediately above. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Among residents, access is close to universal: CPF membership and HDB eligibility reach nearly every citizen and PR household, and 91.2% of resident households own their home. Access is gated by pass type, however. HDB ownership is restricted to citizens and eligible PRs, foreigners pay 60% stamp duty on any home (Global Property Guide), and Work Permit holders — about a fifth of the population — have no pathway to long-term residency (HOME). Migrant-worker advocates report that first-time construction workers commonly pay S$13,000–16,000 in recruitment fees (HOME and TWC2, as reported by The Online Citizen, 2026), which makes early asset-building unlikely. This is the gated-access pattern of H.7v2's Market Socialism anchor. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Only 60% have any wealth accumulation pathway at all — access, not just outcome, is structurally limited to those already positioned to reach capital ownership, falling well short of the 80% access-breadth threshold this narrowed criterion requires. *(Narrowed from the legacy version, which also carried a Gini clause now assigned solely to C1.2b above — see Revision Notice.)* + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This narrowed criterion asks about breadth of *access* to an *active asset-growth mechanism* — not accumulation adequacy (C1.2a) or concentration prevention (C1.2b). Access breadth would, in principle, be a genuine strength of UBS: none of its seven sectors gate eligibility by employment status, membership, or means test in the stigmatizing sense (the entire universalist design premise is to avoid exactly that kind of gate). But C1.2a's analysis already establishes that there is no asset-growth mechanism at all for that openness to apply to — following the identical reasoning already established for Integral, UBI, Georgism, Mutual Credit/LETS, and Doughnut Economics, each of which fails this criterion for the same underlying design-level reason once C1.2a fails. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Universal employment provides universal income access, but this narrowed criterion asks specifically about access to an asset-*growth* mechanism — and the underlying vehicle is the same traditional-market one Status Quo Capitalism's own C1.5 reaches only ~60% of participants through, with guaranteed income improving the capacity to use it rather than adding a new one. Revised down from the legacy 1.0, which had conflated universal employment/income access with universal wealth-mechanism access. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Universal access to abundant goods and services is consumption access, not access to an asset-*growth* mechanism — following directly from C1.2a's own finding that no such mechanism is specified. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Slightly broader wealth access through expanded stock ownership programs. However, fundamental ownership concentration persists. The bottom 50% still hold minimal wealth despite stakeholder rhetoric. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Measured by headcount, access looks broad (about 90% home ownership). Measured the way this criterion asks — an active pathway producing asset growth, not gated by membership or status — it is gated by hukou. Rural hukou holders' principal asset is a restricted use right (C1.2a); migrants face purchase restrictions in the largest cities; and the IMF (February 2026) describes hukou as effectively excluding rural migrants from full access to social benefits in large cities. That is the gated-access pattern H.7v2's Market Socialism anchor describes. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The narrowed threshold asks whether at least 80% of the population has an active wealth-accumulation pathway. Under the confirmed scope, the pathways described under C1.2a reach citizens and a minority of higher-paid foreign residents. The route into the citizen group is closed for practical purposes: *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Citizenship read as a membership gate + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c1-5) + +1. *≥80% population with an active wealth-accumulation pathway*: not shown. not shown: the design leaves wage saving, home and share ownership open to anyone through markets, gated by income rather than by prior wealth; no figure for the share with an active pathway is stated or located (the outside reader's closed-book estimate is 60-70%) + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: without public education and a safety net, effective access narrows to those born with capital (the 0.0 band) + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> This narrowed criterion asks about access *breadth* to an *active asset-growth mechanism* — not accumulation adequacy (C1.2a) or concentration prevention (C1.2b). Access breadth would, in principle, be one of Doughnut Economics' stronger claims: the framework's diagnostic and planning tools are explicitly designed to be participatory and open to a jurisdiction's entire population, with no membership gate or employment requirement of any kind. But C1.2a's analysis already establishes there is no asset-growth mechanism at all for that openness to apply to — following the identical reasoning already established for Georgism, Mutual Credit/LETS, and, originally, Integral's own C1.2/C1.5 pairing that first motivated the v2 split (Section 12.1). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c1-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** State ownership provides "universal" access in name only — since no individual wealth-accumulation mechanism exists at all (C1.2a, above), there is nothing for that access to be broad or narrow *to*. This is a downward revision from the legacy 0.5, which credited nominal universality without checking for an underlying mechanism to be universally accessing. + + +## Domain 2: Human Autonomy + +Six criteria: freedom from coercion (C2.1), freedom from the need to work (C2.2), creative development (C2.3), democratic +participation (C2.4), exit (C2.5), and, new in v2.0, civil liberties and the rule of law (C2.6). v1 scored 37 of the domain's +115 scored cells at 1.0; v2.0 scores four of 138. Three of C2.1 to C2.4's thresholds are class I (v2.0 names the indicator), +and on the named indicators no entry clears every clause. + +**C2.1, freedom from coercion.** None of the eight v1 passes holds. The second clause asks that self-reported autonomy be +validated by revealed preference, people accepting work or living arrangements they had refused once an alternative +exists, and no study or record shows it for any entry. Nordic Social Democracy clears the first clause on the survey's +latest year (92.0% to 94.4% satisfied with their freedom to choose, 2025); the designs clear it on their own texts. Five +entries fail: Centrally Planned Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Doughnut Economics, China (a state labour-transfer +programme for minority workers under surveillance) and Qatar. China's first clause (67.6%) turns on whether the latest year +or the three-year average is read, which the measurement field leaves open (ledger I12; the limits page). + +**C2.2, freedom from the need to work.** A class W criterion: the pass held 20 cells. One pass, Fully Automated Luxury +Communism (held). Universal Basic Income's 1.0 falls in the adjudication (the literature includes partial and full +variants, and the threshold asks for 100% of basic needs for all residents), and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's falls by the owner's +decision 84.2 (it pays citizens and legal residents 18 and over, and the design's own model leaves adults below their cost +of living); each keeps a close call toward 1.0. Eleven entries fail, among them the four configured economies whose floors +are means-tested or categorical (Status Quo, China, Singapore, Qatar), read as no unconditional baseline. Whether a +conditional floor is the 0.5 band's "conditional" provision is a class question the limits page records (I12); Nordic +Social Democracy's generous conditional benefits are held at 0.5. + +**C2.3, creative development.** None of the eight v1 passes holds; 22 entries score 0.5 and one 0.0. The pattern is one +clause of three: leisure hours (the second clause) are cleared from time-use data, while the share regularly engaged in +creative work and the meaning-and-purpose score are seldom measured. Nordic Social Democracy clears two (38 to 41 hours of +leisure a week; meaning-of-life ratings of 78 to 83 in EU-SILC's one wave) but not the first, since EU-SILC's 22% to 38% +practising artistic activities omits study and invention. Centrally Planned Socialism fails on the state's control of +cultural production (socialist realism the obligatory method; prior censorship from 1922 to 1991). + +**C2.4, democratic participation.** None of the eight v1 passes holds. The threshold asks for 70% participation, 35% of +citizen proposals adopted, and 65% satisfied with responsiveness. Nordic Social Democracy is short on all three +(Finland's turnout 68.9% in 2023; at most 11% of Finland's citizens' initiatives adopted, and Sweden has no national +process; external efficacy of 21% to 44% in the OECD Trust Survey). The designs clear participation on their own texts and +state no adoption rate or satisfaction. A mechanism such as the Job Guarantee is out of reach on all three (0.5, not 0.0, +under the reach rule). Four fail: Centrally Planned Socialism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, China and Qatar. + +**C2.5, exit.** The domain's most mixed movement: v2.0 deleted clauses (class D), and every unit is read on the three that +remain. Three entries pass: Universal Basic Income (up from 0.0: an unconditional, portable payment makes +leaving a job or household feasible at once), Libertarian Minarchism (no exit cost, no compulsory participation, free +movement), and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP on the owner's decision 79.2 (its close call toward 0.5 is the blind reading that an +early leaver forfeits most of Acre Equity). Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism, Degrowth and Fully Automated Luxury +Communism rise from 0.0 to 0.5. Eight v1 passes fall, each on a clause short, not shown or out of reach. Centrally Planned +Socialism falls to 0.0: emigration and non-participation were criminal offences under its own law. + +**C2.6, civil liberties and the rule of law (new).** No entry passes; China (11 of 60 on Freedom House's civil-liberties +checklist) and Centrally Planned Socialism (the USSR in the rating's two lowest bands through the planned years) fail. Nordic +Social Democracy clears the first two clauses (57 to 60 of 60; informed consent in law) and is short on the third, because +Sweden's quarantine and area-closure provisions state no time limit. The United States is short on the first (49 of 60 in +2025). The designs are mostly silent on medical consent and compulsion; Libertarian Minarchism's platform states the +strongest guarantees of the 17 designs and mechanisms, with its first clause estimated at the bar (a close call toward +1.0). Six mechanisms are out of reach on every clause, and two more on some: a mechanism does not govern its host economy's +liberties, and out of reach scores 0.5. + +**What the domain does not show.** C2.1, C2.3 and C2.4 rest on surveys that cover the configured economies unevenly (the +OECD Trust Survey does not cover China, and its coverage of Singapore, Qatar and the United States is unconfirmed), and +the designs are read on their own texts; the limits page lists the measures no source supplies. + + +### C2.1 Freedom from Coercion + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions, validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 18 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. v1: 8 at 1.0, 10 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. Modeling shows 75%+ report genuine autonomy +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. no validation of the design's self-reported share by observed behaviour is stated or cited; the closest component evidence, OpenResearch's randomised study of $1,000 a month for three years to 1,000 low-income adults (control group $50 a month), found recipients' unemployment spells about a month longer with fewer applications, job seekers 5.5 points more likely to require interesting or meaningful work, and more moves of home and neighbourhood, which is behaviour of the kind the Paper's method names, but it reports no self-reported autonomy share and no correlation between self-report and behaviour (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: DNK 92.4% (2025), FIN 94.1% (2025), NOR 94.4% (2025), SWE 92.0% (2025) (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2); Finland's 2017-2018 basic income experiment tested an unconditional payment outside the configuration's own institutions + +Read in part (a) (Session 37) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: short. the rationale concedes survival-linked compulsion persists (compete or close replaces work or starve); no autonomy survey located +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. no revealed-preference validation located + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. eliminates both market and state coercion +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. consumption councils and democratic planning are specified; no implementation of the model as specified is cited or located, so no participants' behaviour validates the self-reports (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. 70%+ genuine autonomy in major life decisions is plausible +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. democratic governance, cooperative production and transparent reciprocity are specified; no implementation's observed behaviour is cited or located (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: Dividend-dependent, as with Georgism. Alaska's unconditional annual payment (currently $1,200 for 2026: a $1,000 base dividend plus... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: Dividend-dependent, as with Georgism. Alaska's unconditional annual payment (currently $1,200 for 2026: a $1,000 base dividend plus... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 70% report genuine autonomy in major life... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 70% report genuine autonomy in major life... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. 65-75% report increased autonomy: straddles the bar, measures an increase rather than genuine autonomy, and is unsourced +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. no revealed-preference validation cited + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. provide genuine autonomy in how to spend time +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. universal basic services, reduced working hours and commons access are specified; no observed behaviour of a population the design serves, or of one a component serves, is compared with self-reported autonomy (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Dividend-dependent. A modest unconditional dividend plus reduced land/housing costs would provide some genuine reduction in survival-based labor compulsion, but at the one concrete... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Dividend-dependent. A modest unconditional dividend plus reduced land/housing costs would provide some genuine reduction in survival-based labor compulsion, but at the one concrete... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 70% report genuine autonomy in major life... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 70% report genuine autonomy in major life... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: The core design reduces one real form of coercion — no interest accrues on a negative balance, there is no external creditor. Genuinely complicating this: in the UK specifically, joining a... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: The core design reduces one real form of coercion — no interest accrues on a negative balance, there is no external creditor. Genuinely complicating this: in the UK specifically, joining a... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. cleared: 86.9% (2025) are satisfied with their freedom to choose (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. cleared: 75.4% (2025) of Americans are satisfied with their freedom to choose what they do with their life, the fourth year at or above 70% (2022 73.6, 2023 72.1, 2024 71.7) (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: By removing housing, food, healthcare, transport, education, and information costs from what a household must earn to survive,... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: By removing housing, food, healthcare, transport, education, and information costs from what a household must earn to survive,... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Job guarantee reduces "work or starve" coercion by providing alternatives to private sector exploitation. However, it still requires labor for survival—"work for government or starve"... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Job guarantee reduces "work or starve" coercion by providing alternatives to private sector exploitation. However, it still requires labor for survival—"work for government or starve"... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: cleared. Post-scarcity eliminates economic coercion entirely +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the rationale rests on post-scarcity abundance, which has no implementation whose participants' behaviour could be observed; no behavioural validation is stated or located (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Marginally better working conditions in stakeholder-oriented firms. However, survival is still contingent on employment. "Enlightened" exploitation remains... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Marginally better working conditions in stakeholder-oriented firms. However, survival is still contingent on employment. "Enlightened" exploitation remains... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: short. short: 67.6% (2025) are satisfied with their freedom to choose, below 70% (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): the configuration keeps market compulsion and adds state compulsion -- a state-mandated labour-transfer programme places Uyghur, Tibetan and other minority workers into jobs under surveillance with no real choice to refuse (UN human rights experts, January 2026; Xinjiang's 2021-2025 plan projected 13.75 million transfers), and workers cannot organise outside the party-affiliated federation (reading 2.1.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: market coercion kept and state coercion added, including state-directed labour transfers + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. not shown: the poll's latest Qatar reading is 92.4% (2012), before the configuration's stated date and before the 2018 and 2020 labour reforms; no later reading is published (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): survival compulsion is maximised by design for the non-citizen majority -- no safety net, and losing a job usually means losing the right to stay -- with absconding still criminalised and passport confiscation common (Human Rights Watch, World Report 2026; US Trafficking in Persons Report 2025) (reading 2.1.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: for most residents, no floor and residence tied to the job; reformed in law, not in effect + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Eliminates state coercion but maximizes economic coercion. "Work or starve" operates at full force. Without baseline security, all market exchanges occur under duress for those lacking... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Eliminates state coercion but maximizes economic coercion. "Work or starve" operates at full force. Without baseline security, all market exchanges occur under duress for those lacking... + +Why 0.0 stands: the published 0.0 stands on its published whole-criterion finding (protocol 2.1); the indicator cannot clear a clause the finding does not rest on + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: Doughnut Economics operates as a planning and diagnostic overlay on whatever employment, market, and welfare institutions a... +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: Doughnut Economics operates as a planning and diagnostic overlay on whatever employment, market, and welfare institutions a... + +Why 0.0 stands: the published 0.0 stands on its published whole-criterion finding (protocol 2.1); the indicator cannot clear a clause the finding does not rest on + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-1) + +1. *≥70% report genuine autonomy in major life decisions*: not shown. not shown: the Gallup poll begins in 2005; no comparable survey of the Soviet-type economy exists (reading 2.1.1) +2. *validated through revealed preference showing acceptance of initially refused employment/living situations when alternatives exist*: not shown. not shown: no study or record is found that shows acceptance of initially refused employment or living situations when an unconditional alternative exists, for this configuration (reading 2.1.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): the system's own law substitutes state compulsion for market compulsion -- systematic avoidance of 'socially useful work' was a crime (the 1961 RSFSR decree; Criminal Code article 209), and residence was administratively controlled through internal passports and the propiska (reading 2.1.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +### C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents. Revision class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 11 at 0.5, 11 at 0.0. v1: 3 at 1.0, 9 at 0.5, 11 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-2) + +1. *Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents*: not shown. not shown in full: the provision is unconditional (no means test or work requirement), but the design's legislative text pays 'every citizen and legal resident 18 years or older', its BLEI accounting values the Basic Units against food and utilities, essentials are paid partly in primary currency, and its published model leaves adults below their cost of living (the share falls 60.3% to 70.7% against no programme, the entry's C1.1) + +Read in Session 84, then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.2 (ledger D67, Session 84). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading: the basic amount covers essential needs unconditionally + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Generous unemployment and disability benefits provide baseline security, but still time-limited and conditional. Not truly unconditional; expectation of labor market participation remains. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Reduced coercion within employment, but survival still requires membership in a cooperative. Better than wage labor but not unconditional baseline security. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Effort-based remuneration still requires contribution. However, balanced job complexes and reduced hours make participation less burdensome. Not fully unconditional but substantial freedom compared to markets. + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The philosophical commitment is strong — "human creativity and ingenuity have always driven activity... it is about giving people real freedom" — but the document is genuinely ambiguous about whether essentials are provided unconditionally or require some ITC contribution, stating only that "unnecessary labor is reduced" (not eliminated) alongside continued contribution tracking. NEEC requires unconditional baseline security without work requirements; Integral doesn't clearly provide this, even if culturally reframed and reduced. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0 or 1.0. Essentials unconditional (1.0) or contribution-dependent (0.0) + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> NEEC's own Section 6 text already supplies this criterion's exact benchmark language for this system, again written before any system existed to claim it: the "Current Performance" line for C2.2 reads "Alaska PFD: Partial—universal but insufficient ($1,000–2,000 annually)." This is, like C1.1's Berman & Reamy citation, evidence the framework authors built in from the start, now finally scored under its native system rather than left as an unclaimed benchmark. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Principle 2's proportional equivalence between benefits and costs **ties appropriation to provision**: members earn their share by contributing to maintenance, monitoring and repair. That is a contribution requirement written into the design, which is the opposite of unconditional provision. Nor does any commons cover 100% of basic needs; it covers the goods that particular resource yields. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-2) + +1. *Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents*: not shown. not shown in full: the provision is unconditional, but the threshold asks that it cover 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents; the mechanism's literature includes partial and full variants (the definition sets no level), and the entry's own C1.3 records that rents can absorb the payment + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The 1.0 band's reading: provision explicitly unconditional + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Work-sharing and reduced hours move toward labor optionality but don't fully decouple survival from employment. Still assumes some labor participation for social contributions. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> *Dividend-dependent.* A Citizen's Dividend, structured as George proposed it ("share and share alike," unconditional, no means test), clears the unconditionality bar cleanly, which is a real strength distinct from means-tested welfare. What it does not clear at any evidenced real-world scale is covering 100% of basic needs — the transfer sizes located are a small fraction of a basic-needs budget in any high-income context, landing this between the unconditional-and-adequate Pass anchor and the no-baseline-at-all Fail anchor. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> There is no baseline provision of any kind in the mechanism. H.7 notes this threshold is binary in character. One of the two failures in this evaluation that no flagged call disputes. Not flagged. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-2) + +1. *Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents*: short. short: credit can be extended before a member has contributed, but balances are capped and are repaid by supplying goods or services, so the system expects reciprocity over time rather than providing a baseline with no expectation of return + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The outside reader's reading: a capped, repayable credit line is no baseline independent of work + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Support is deliberately tied to work or job search. Jobseeker Support requires job-search activity and ends when a job is found (MOM). ComCare short-term help lasts a median of six months, and about 49% of households that left it in 2021 returned within three years (MSF, via Malay Mail). The Workfare Income Supplement pays only those in work, and the Silver Support Scheme targets seniors with low lifetime incomes (MOF, via Mothership). In 2012 the then head of the national union federation, later Manpower Minister, said a minimum wage was not something Singapore embraced (People's World). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Survival entirely contingent on labor market participation or charity. No unconditional baseline security exists; unemployment benefits are temporary and conditional. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> NEEC's own threshold asks for "unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents" — language that maps almost directly onto UBS's own named sectors. Several UBS sectors genuinely clear an unconditional-access bar for the whole population (universal healthcare and education already function this way in the UK; free transport and basic information access are proposed as flatly universal, with no means test). But the shelter and food sectors, as actually costed, are targeted rather than flatly universal in the strongest sense: the housing plank provides zero-rent housing only to households allocated it on a needs basis (roughly 1.5 million of the UK's households, not all of them), and the food plank covers only a portion of meals for a defined food-insecure population (2.2 million households), not free food for every resident regardless of need. This is an important, and easy to miss, distinction: UBS's "universal" branding means "universally *available without stigma or means-testing bureaucracy* to anyone who needs it," not "everyone receives the same thing whether they need it or not" the way Universal Basic Income or CCO-PTF's baseline does. This is a real, substantive design difference from a clean unconditional-baseline system. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Ideologically committed to full employment. Treats joblessness as a problem to solve rather than potential liberation. Fundamentally rejects the premise that labor can become optional. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Defining features—labor becomes an optional hobby rather than survival requirement. Explicitly embodies labor non-necessity principle. Work as self-actualization, not compulsion. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Does not address labor-income linkage. Assumes continued full employment. Fundamentally conservative reform maintaining the existing system with gentler management. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The system's leadership rejects this criterion's premise explicitly. Xi Jinping's August 2021 speech on common prosperity, published in *Qiushi*, warns against setting excessively high goals or providing excessive guarantees, and against falling into a "welfarism" trap that encourages laziness (Caixin full text). His December 2021 remarks to the Central Economic Work Conference repeat the point, citing Latin American welfare states as the cautionary example (Ginger River translation). In practice, the only floor that resembles unconditional provision, dibao, is means-tested and shrinking — under 3% coverage in 2022 (C1.1). Pension eligibility is also tightening: the minimum contribution period rises from 15 to 20 years starting in 2030 (State Council Information Office). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Non-citizens have no baseline independent of work. Their residence depends on employment, and they are excluded from social assistance and the pension system (US Social Security Administration; HLB). Citizens have more: free land and housing finance (C1.3), free health care and state schooling, which the 2018 permanent-residency law extended to permanent residents (Al Jazeera), and an income-tested minimum income for specified groups (US Social Security Administration). But the citizen baseline is conditional: assistance is means-tested and limited to defined categories, and the main income channel is public employment. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Survival entirely contingent on market participation. No safety net whatsoever. Ideologically opposed to decoupling labor from survival. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> No unconditional baseline security of any kind — covering essentials without work requirements, behavior conditions, or means testing — exists anywhere in the Doughnut Economics framework or its implementations. This follows directly from the absence of any provision mechanism established in Domain 1. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Despite guaranteed employment, labor was compulsory. "Work or prison" replaced "work or starve." Parasitism laws criminalized unemployment, creating different but equally coercive systems. + +### C2.3 Creative Development Opportunities + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥50% regular creative engagement, average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits, meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 22 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. v1: 8 at 1.0, 14 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the design projects relative increases for its case studies (60% more cultural-event participation; 32% more creative output), not a level of weekly engagement (reading 3.5) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. time and resources for non-subsistence activities +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. no meaning or purpose satisfaction estimate located in the design's documents + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: EU-SILC 2022 records DNK 25.6%, FIN 37.8%, NOR 34.3%, SWE 22.1% practising artistic activities daily or weekly, but omits study and invention, so the clause's share is not established (reading 2.3.1) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: DNK 38.4, FIN 38.5, NOR 41.3, SWE 37.5 hours a week of leisure (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: meaning-of-life rating times ten DNK 83.0, FIN 80.0, NOR 81.0, SWE 78.0 (EU-SILC 2013, the item's one wave) (reading 2.3.3) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. Mondragon's training and education time bears on opportunity; no weekly creative-engagement figure located (reading 3.5) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. sabbaticals and education time +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. no estimate of weekly creative engagement (reading 3.5) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. reduced hours (20-30 a week) leave substantial time for self-directed pursuits +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: cleared. could exceed the 35-55% range; the comparison it rests on is unsourced (part (a), correction 3) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. space for arts, culture and personal development +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. no meaning or purpose satisfaction estimate (reading 3.5) + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: No direct mechanism was located; any effect runs through the same generic, modest income-supplementation channel Georgism's... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: No direct mechanism was located; any effect runs through the same generic, modest income-supplementation channel Georgism's... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: No direct mechanism was located; any effect runs through the same generic, modest income-supplementation channel Georgism's... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Time freed from survival labor enables creative pursuits. Kenya GiveDirectly recipients showed increased entrepreneurship. However, mere income without comprehensive support (education,... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Time freed from survival labor enables creative pursuits. Kenya GiveDirectly recipients showed increased entrepreneurship. However, mere income without comprehensive support (education,... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Time freed from survival labor enables creative pursuits. Kenya GiveDirectly recipients showed increased entrepreneurship. However, mere income without comprehensive support (education,... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the design reduces working hours to 20 a week and programmes community culture; no estimate of weekly creative engagement (reading 3.5) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. prioritises creative and social time +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. no meaning or purpose satisfaction estimate in the design's sources + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Dividend-dependent, indirect. Georgism does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming; whatever effect exists runs through modest additional disposable income and... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Dividend-dependent, indirect. Georgism does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming; whatever effect exists runs through modest additional disposable income and... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Dividend-dependent, indirect. Georgism does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming; whatever effect exists runs through modest additional disposable income and... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Pass threshold: 50% regular creative engagement, 10+ hours a... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Valuing skills markets systematically undervalue — caregiving, teaching, artistic and craft work — is one of the most consistently emphasized features of both the LETS and time-banking... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Valuing skills markets systematically undervalue — caregiving, teaching, artistic and craft work — is one of the most consistently emphasized features of both the LETS and time-banking... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Valuing skills markets systematically undervalue — caregiving, teaching, artistic and craft work — is one of the most consistently emphasized features of both the LETS and time-banking... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: no survey recording the weekly frequency of creative engagement is found for this economy (reading 2.3.1) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. not shown: no national time-use survey in the OECD Time Use Database (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not shown: neither EU-SILC nor the ONS fields the 'worthwhile' item here (reading 2.3.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: no survey recording the weekly frequency of creative engagement is found for this economy (reading 2.3.1); the NEA's arts participation survey records the past year, not the week +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. cleared: 32.6 hours a week of leisure (American Time Use Survey, OECD) (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not shown: neither EU-SILC nor the ONS fields the 'worthwhile' item here (reading 2.3.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: UBS does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming the way Degrowth's explicit shorter-week design does. What... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: UBS does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming the way Degrowth's explicit shorter-week design does. What... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: UBS does not itself reduce working hours or fund cultural programming the way Degrowth's explicit shorter-week design does. What... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Job guarantee jobs could include creative and community service work. However, a 40-hour workweek remains the norm. Reduced time scarcity compared to precarious employment but not dramatic... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Job guarantee jobs could include creative and community service work. However, a 40-hour workweek remains the norm. Reduced time scarcity compared to precarious employment but not dramatic... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Job guarantee jobs could include creative and community service work. However, a 40-hour workweek remains the norm. Reduced time scarcity compared to precarious employment but not dramatic... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: cleared. humans pursue art, science, philosophy and relationships +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. unlimited time and resources for creative pursuits +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. no meaning or purpose satisfaction estimate; the design's sources state the aim, not a level (reading 3.5) + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Some stakeholder firms offer sabbaticals, education support, creative time. However, it remains an exception rather than a norm. Competitive pressures limit how much productivity can be... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Some stakeholder firms offer sabbaticals, education support, creative time. However, it remains an exception rather than a norm. Competitive pressures limit how much productivity can be... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Some stakeholder firms offer sabbaticals, education support, creative time. However, it remains an exception rather than a norm. Competitive pressures limit how much productivity can be... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: no survey recording the weekly frequency of creative engagement is found for this economy (reading 2.3.1) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: cleared. cleared: 26.6 hours a week of leisure (National Bureau of Statistics' 2008 survey, OECD) (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not shown: neither EU-SILC nor the ONS fields the 'worthwhile' item here (reading 2.3.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a large creative economy under state censorship of content + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: no survey recording the weekly frequency of creative engagement is found for this economy (reading 2.3.1) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. not shown: no national time-use survey in the OECD Time Use Database (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not shown: neither EU-SILC nor the ONS fields the 'worthwhile' item here (reading 2.3.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: short. the rationale says the freedom applies only to economically secure minorities +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. claimed only for those with capital; not shown for the population +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not estimated in this pass + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: The "Be Agnostic about Growth" and "Create to Regenerate" chapters articulate a value orientation that explicitly... +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: The "Be Agnostic about Growth" and "Create to Regenerate" chapters articulate a value orientation that explicitly... +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: The "Be Agnostic about Growth" and "Create to Regenerate" chapters articulate a value orientation that explicitly... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-3) + +1. *≥50% regular creative engagement*: not shown. not shown: no comparable survey of the Soviet-type economy (reading 2.3.1) +2. *average 10+ hours weekly on non-subsistence pursuits*: not shown. not shown: not in the OECD Time Use Database (reading 2.3.2) +3. *meaning/purpose satisfaction scores ≥70/100*: not shown. not shown: no 'worthwhile' item fielded (reading 2.3.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): structural suppression through state control of cultural production -- socialist realism the obligatory method (1934 Writers' Union statute) and prior censorship (Glavlit, 1922-1991) make independent creative work illegitimate under the system's own doctrine (reading 2.3.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: creative activity organised and censored by the state + +### C2.4 Democratic Participation + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥70% participation in democratic processes, ≥35% citizen proposals adopted, ≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 4 at 0.0. v1: 8 at 1.0, 11 at 0.5, 4 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: cleared. as audited; the design's documents give 15-25% as the portal's pilot success metric and model participation rising from 55% to 85% at maturity +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. any citizen may submit proposals above a signature threshold, and binding changes need a 60-67% supermajority with a geographic distribution requirement; no estimate of the share adopted (reading 3.5) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. satisfaction with democratic processes is named as a metric, with no estimate + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: voting-age turnout at the latest parliamentary election is DNK 73.3% (2026), FIN 68.9% (2023), NOR 73.1% (2025), SWE 80.3% (2026): Finland is below 70% (reading 2.4.1) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: Finland's citizens' initiative had brought 64 proposals to Parliament by March 2023, of which five became law and two more in modified form (at most 11%); Sweden has no national process (reading 2.4.2) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: short. short: the OECD Trust Survey's external-efficacy share (2023) is DNK 44.3%, FIN 20.9%, NOR 34.8%, SWE 29.9%, each below 65% (reading 2.4.3) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: cleared. 75-85% participation in cooperative governance +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. no adoption share of member-initiated proposals located for Mondragon or other cooperative networks +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: cleared. everyone participates in planning affecting them +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the plan is assembled from council proposals revised through iteration until feasible; no estimate of the share adopted, and no implementation (reading 3.5) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: cleared. plausibly match or exceed the best documented cooperative precedents +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. weighted consensus and objection mapping specified; no estimate of the share of proposals adopted (reading 3.5) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: A real, if narrow, fund-specific deliberative layer exists on top of whatever ordinary representative democracy the host... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: A real, if narrow, fund-specific deliberative layer exists on top of whatever ordinary representative democracy the host... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: A real, if narrow, fund-specific deliberative layer exists on top of whatever ordinary representative democracy the host... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Economic security could enable increased political participation. However, UBI alone doesn't address governance capture, lobbying, or plutocratic power. Income provision without power... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Economic security could enable increased political participation. However, UBI alone doesn't address governance capture, lobbying, or plutocratic power. Income provision without power... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Economic security could enable increased political participation. However, UBI alone doesn't address governance capture, lobbying, or plutocratic power. Income provision without power... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: cleared. participatory democracy core principle +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the design specifies assemblies and consensus processes, not an estimate of the share of citizen proposals adopted; none located (reading 3.5) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Georgism, as classically formulated, is a fiscal policy, not a governance system — it specifies no deliberative or participatory architecture of its own. Every real implementation (Estonia,... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Georgism, as classically formulated, is a fiscal policy, not a governance system — it specifies no deliberative or participatory architecture of its own. Every real implementation (Estonia,... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Georgism, as classically formulated, is a fiscal policy, not a governance system — it specifies no deliberative or participatory architecture of its own. Every real implementation (Estonia,... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: — flagged as contestable Pass threshold: 70% participation, 35% of citizen proposals... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Individual nodes are typically self-governed by their own membership, functioning much like a small mutual-aid society — a genuine, real form of grassroots practice, evidenced directly by a... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Individual nodes are typically self-governed by their own membership, functioning much like a small mutual-aid society — a genuine, real form of grassroots practice, evidenced directly by a... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Individual nodes are typically self-governed by their own membership, functioning much like a small mutual-aid society — a genuine, real form of grassroots practice, evidenced directly by a... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: 51.0% of the voting-age population voted in the 2025 general election, though 92.8% of registered citizens did: the voting-age population counts the residents who are not citizens (reading 2.4.1; protocol 3.2) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: no national process of citizen-initiated proposals with a right to a decision exists (reading 2.4.2) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not shown: the OECD Trust Survey does not cover this economy (2021 and 2023 rounds), and the European Social Survey's equivalent item is fielded only in Europe (reading 2.4.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: 59.2% of the voting-age population voted in the 2024 federal election (64.5% of registered voters) (reading 2.4.1) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: no national process of citizen-initiated proposals with a right to a decision exists (reading 2.4.2); state-level initiatives exist in about half the states +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not shown: the OECD Trust Survey does not cover this economy (2021 and 2023 rounds), and the European Social Survey's equivalent item is fielded only in Europe (reading 2.4.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is a genuinely distinctive feature of UBS relative to several already-scored fiscal/service mechanisms: "democracy and... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is a genuinely distinctive feature of UBS relative to several already-scored fiscal/service mechanisms: "democracy and... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is a genuinely distinctive feature of UBS relative to several already-scored fiscal/service mechanisms: "democracy and... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: out of reach. participation in democratic processes is a property of the political system; no source located in the job-guarantee literature places democratic institutions inside the guarantee's design (D31) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: out of reach. the adoption of citizen proposals is a property of the political system +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: out of reach. satisfaction with responsiveness is a property of the political system + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Governance structures largely unspecified. Who controls the machines? Who decides production priorities? Technological determinism obscures political questions. Risk of technocratic elite... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Governance structures largely unspecified. Who controls the machines? Who decides production priorities? Technological determinism obscures political questions. Risk of technocratic elite... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Governance structures largely unspecified. Who controls the machines? Who decides production priorities? Technological determinism obscures political questions. Risk of technocratic elite... + +Why 0.0 stands: the published 0.0 stands on its published whole-criterion finding (protocol 2.1); the indicator cannot clear a clause the finding does not rest on + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Worker representation on boards provides minimal voice. However, one-share-one-vote rather than one-person-one-vote maintains plutocratic control. Tokenism more than genuine... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Worker representation on boards provides minimal voice. However, one-share-one-vote rather than one-person-one-vote maintains plutocratic control. Tokenism more than genuine... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Worker representation on boards provides minimal voice. However, one-share-one-vote rather than one-person-one-vote maintains plutocratic control. Tokenism more than genuine... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: no direct national election is held (the National People's Congress is chosen indirectly; direct elections reach only county and township congresses, with Party-vetted candidates); the binding decisions are taken within the Party, whose members are under a tenth of adults (reading 2.4.1) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: no national process of citizen-initiated proposals with a right to a decision exists (reading 2.4.2) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not shown: the OECD Trust Survey does not cover this economy (2021 and 2023 rounds), and the European Social Survey's equivalent item is fielded only in Europe (reading 2.4.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): no meaningful participation mechanism by design -- the Party's leadership is constitutionally entrenched (preamble; article 1), no national election is competitive, and organised dissent is suppressed (reading 2.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: a single-party state with consultative channels and no competitive national election + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: the one Shura Council election (2021) was ended by the referendum of 5 November 2024, after which the Council is wholly appointed; the referendum's participants were at most 15.2% of the voting-age population (2,104,798), since only citizens vote (reading 2.4.1) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: no national process of citizen-initiated proposals with a right to a decision exists (reading 2.4.2) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not shown: the OECD Trust Survey does not cover this economy (2021 and 2023 rounds), and the European Social Survey's equivalent item is fielded only in Europe (reading 2.4.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): no meaningful participation mechanism by design -- since the 2024 amendments no national body is elected, political parties are not permitted, and the non-citizen majority has no political participation at all (reading 2.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: an appointed legislature since the 2024 referendum; most residents are non-citizens without a vote + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. economic democracy is entirely absent (the rationale), and the criterion's Requirement counts it as much as political democracy +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. not estimated in this pass +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not estimated in this pass + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is one of the better-evidenced criteria in this evaluation. The City Portrait methodology is explicitly and... +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is one of the better-evidenced criteria in this evaluation. The City Portrait methodology is explicitly and... +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. the named indicator is not re-measured in this pass; the published rationale reads: Rationale: This is one of the better-evidenced criteria in this evaluation. The City Portrait methodology is explicitly and... + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-4) + +1. *≥70% participation in democratic processes*: short. short: official turnout near 99.9% in single-candidate elections to the soviets is not participation in a democratic process (reading 2.4.1) +2. *≥35% citizen proposals adopted*: short. short: no national process of citizen-initiated proposals with a right to a decision exists (reading 2.4.2) +3. *≥65% satisfaction with responsiveness*: not shown. not shown: no survey of external efficacy exists for the Soviet-type economy (reading 2.4.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1 (the 0.0 band's case): no meaningful participation mechanism by design -- the Party is 'the leading and guiding force' (1977 Constitution, article 6), elections are uncontested, and dissent is suppressed (reading 2.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +### C2.5 Exit Rights and Mobility + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty, no differential treatment, geographic mobility maintained. Revision class D (clauses deleted only). + +v2.0: 3 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. v1: 10 at 1.0, 8 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. on the owner's reading (decision 79.2), exit is leaving the system entirely: a member may stop taking Basic Units at any time, with no work requirement or other condition attached; Public Trust Housing's tenure-graded access to Acre Equity at exit (about 10-20% in the first six months, rising to 80-90% after five years) is read not as a material penalty but as a provision for the stability of the remaining members, on an asset a non-member never accrues: a member who leaves early keeps part of an equity that a renter outside the system does not build, so is no worse off than one who never joined; a member who moves (a job transfer, a new home) moves within the network keeping the equity +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: participation is opt-in only, the design preserves private markets and ownership, and its validation tracks non-participants' outcomes so that they are not harmed (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: members may move between Public Trust Housing properties keeping their equity status ('network portability'), and the Basic Unit allocation is made to citizens who opt in, not to a place (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75, then raised by the owner's decision 79.2 (Session 79). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The blind re-read's reading (Session 75, reading 2.5.1): Acre Equity is accessible at exit only in part in the early years, so an early leaver forfeits most of it, a material penalty + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: emigration is free; exit taxes reach unrealised share gains only and are deferred within the EEA; accrued pensions are paid abroad (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: social assistance and unemployment benefit are conditioned on availability for work in each of the four (Denmark's 2024 work obligation among them) (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: national benefits are portable within each economy, and EEA coordination and the Nordic Convention carry entitlements across borders (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: free exit and portable benefits, with activation conditions on assistance; residents cannot opt out of the tax base short of emigrating + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: workers may leave a self-managed firm at once, holding no capital stake to forfeit (Schweickart); the citizen's coupon portfolio is a dividend right, not a sold stake (Roemer) (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: a private firm may operate only at small scale and passes to its workers when its owner sells or retires (Schweickart), so those who stay outside worker self-management are treated differently (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: free exit from firms within a socialised economy that bars large private capital + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: with private productive property and markets abolished, there is no arrangement to leave for within the economy (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: besides the effort-rated budget, the design allows 'a consumption allowance for people who simply don't want to work' at a level meeting basic needs (Wright's statement of the procedure in Hahnel and Wright, 2016, kept by Hahnel; Session 71's record, section 6), so non-participants are not penalised (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: membership of councils is the economy; no alternative arrangement exists within it + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: participation 'remains voluntary' throughout the transition and Integral coexists with market production; a leaver loses only unused time credits, which are non-transferable access signals that decay (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: essentials stay accessible 'regardless of age or ability', but access is otherwise earned by contribution, and the paper does not say how non-participants fare once Integral displaces market production (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: a member who relocates has their account migrated to the new node by an equivalence rule (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: voluntary, federated and portable; the treatment of non-participants after displacement is unstated + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: out of reach. out of reach: a state fund is not an arrangement one enters or leaves, and the dividend does not fund leaving other arrangements (reading 2.5.1; D28(c)) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: the dividend requires a full calendar year's residency and excludes those incarcerated on a felony conviction (Alaska Statutes 43.23.005), so new and some residents are treated differently (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: generalised to a national economy, the dividend is kept on moving within it (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: members may leave a commons institution at any time, losing only the use right (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: non-members are excluded from the resource but not otherwise penalised (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: use rights are held by members of a bounded local community (design principle 1; the Törbel commons), so they are lost on relocating (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Universal Basic Income: 1.0** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: an unconditional individual payment makes leaving a job, household or community feasible at once without losing income -- the measurement's capacity to leave for alternative arrangements (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: paid to every member without means test or work requirement (Van Parijs and Vanderborght) (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: national and individual, so it moves with the recipient within the economy (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 1.0: the paradigm exit-enabling mechanism: no participation, no condition, portable + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no terms for leaving the system (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: caps on resource use and income bind every resident alike; the sources say nothing of treatment of those who stay outside degrowth's institutions (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: no exit terms stated; its caps are laws binding all, not a participation one could leave + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: out of reach. out of reach: a land value tax is not an arrangement one enters or leaves, and the dividend is too small to fund leaving other arrangements (reading 2.5.1; D28(c)) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: the tax falls on land whoever holds it and the citizen's dividend is paid to all alike (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: the dividend is national, and replacing transaction taxes lowers the cost of moving (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: either partner may end a musharaka or mudaraba by notice, and diminishing-musharaka home finance is settled by buying the remaining units (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: the contracts are open to all on the same terms (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: out of reach. out of reach: financing contracts govern no benefit a move could lose (reading 2.5.3; D28(c)) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: balances are in a unit not convertible to national currency, so a member leaving with a credit balance forfeits it, and one in debit must settle (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: non-members are not penalised (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: networks are local, so a member who relocates loses the network and its balance (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: national-service-liable males need exit permits and may not renounce citizenship before completing national service; otherwise CPF balances are released on renouncing and leaving (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: ComCare's assistance is conditioned on work or job search, and the CPF's housing and retirement provision rests on employment (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: the HDB's five-year Minimum Occupation Period bars selling or vacating a subsidised flat, so an early move forfeits it (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: no exit permit; the expatriation tax reaches only 'covered expatriates' (net worth of $2 million or more, or high income tax); accrued Social Security is paid abroad (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: SNAP's time limit for able-bodied adults without dependants and the 2025 Medicaid work requirement condition essential benefits on paid work (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: adult Medicaid eligibility differs between expansion and non-expansion states, so a move between them can end coverage; employer-tied health insurance locks workers to jobs (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: guaranteed housing, food, transport and information alongside health and education keep access to essentials when leaving a job or arrangement (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: services are universal, allocated by need, not by participation (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: housing is allocated by need and administered locally, and the proposals do not say whether an allocation moves with the household (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: universal in-kind provision; portability of locally allocated housing is unstated + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: the Job Guarantee is voluntary employment that may be left at any time, and its standing offer makes leaving any other job feasible without loss of income (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: the mechanism's own literature divides -- in Tcherneva's design the job offer adds to unemployment insurance and other income support; in the buffer-stock proposals it replaces unemployment benefit for those able to work, so declining it costs income (reading 2.5.2; protocol 4.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: the offer is national, funded federally and available wherever one lives (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: a voluntary, universal and portable job offer; whether declining it costs income support is disputed within the mechanism's own literature + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no terms for leaving the system (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not say how those who stay outside its institutions are treated (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: universal provision and public ownership; no exit terms stated (reading 2.5.4) + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no terms for leaving the system (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not say how those who stay outside its institutions are treated (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: exit is administratively restricted for whole populations (passports collected in Xinjiang from 2016; exit bans), though most residents may emigrate (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: residents without local household registration receive lesser access to schooling, health insurance and housing (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: hukou ties essential benefits to the place of registration, so migrants lose them on moving, though the 2014 and 2019 reforms eased registration in smaller cities (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: emigration open to most; internal mobility constrained by registration, under gradual reform + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: exit permits were abolished for most workers in 2018-2020, but residence remains tied to an employer sponsor and absconding charges and recruitment debt still penalise leaving (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: the non-citizen majority is excluded from the citizens' benefit system and its residence depends on employment (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: a migrant's right to stay ends with the sponsoring job unless a new sponsor is found (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: legal exit reforms since 2018; residence still sponsor-bound for most residents + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: cleared. cleared: every association is voluntary and the state imposes no exit permit or exit tax; the platform affirms the right to 'withdraw from' government (3.7) (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: cleared. cleared: the minimal state runs no programme whose non-participants it could penalise (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: cleared. cleared: 'individuals [are] not ... unreasonably constrained by government in the crossing of political boundaries' (3.4), and no state benefit is lost on moving (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 1.0: no system-imposed exit cost, no compulsory participation, free movement + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no terms for leaving the system (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not say how those who stay outside its institutions are treated (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: not shown. not shown: the sources do not address relocation or the portability of benefits (reading 2.5.3) + +Read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-5) + +1. *Exit feasible within 3 months without material penalty*: short. short: emigration required an exit visa rarely granted; flight abroad was treason (RSFSR Criminal Code article 64) (reading 2.5.1) +2. *no differential treatment*: short. short: non-participation in state employment was a crime ('parasitism', article 209) (reading 2.5.2) +3. *geographic mobility maintained*: short. short: residence required a propiska permit; collective farmers held no internal passport until 1974 (reading 2.5.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1: the system excludes exit as illegitimate -- emigration and non-participation were criminal offences under its own law (reading 2.5.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: exit, non-participation and relocation all criminalised or administratively barred + +### C2.6 Civil Liberties and Rule of Law + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist; informed consent to medical treatment protected in law; any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review. Revision class N (new criterion). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 21 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. New in v2.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown, estimate 46 to 54: the PTH charter states freedom of expression, assembly and political activity, privacy against surveillance, fair hearings before penalties, equal protection, 'notice, hearing, and appeal rights' for all enforcement, and that community governance shall not infringe constitutionally protected rights; independent courts hear discrimination complaints and zone decisions get independent review; personal data is held under zero-knowledge proofs and user-held keys. Against them: the risk framework's automated transaction limits and account restrictions reach judicial review only at the 'critical' level, merit assessments are appealed to 'democratic review', the 'independent judiciary' of PTH communities is an elected grievance committee, and officials' 'factual honesty' is enforceable by Judicial Guard referral and prosecution, which bears on expression (D1, D4) and due process (F2) (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: cleared. cleared: DNK 57, FIN 60, NOR 60, SWE 59 of 60 in 2025; V-Dem DNK 0.959, FIN 0.947, NOR 0.947, SWE 0.960, the cross-check agreeing (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: Denmark, 'no treatment may be begun or continued without the patient's informed consent', which may be withdrawn at any time (Health Act, section 15); Finland, the patient is treated 'in mutual understanding' and a refused treatment is replaced by another acceptable one, care against the patient's will only under the mental-health, substance-abuse, communicable-diseases and special-care acts (Patients' Rights Act, section 6); Sweden, 'care may not be given without the patient's consent', which may be withdrawn at any time (Patient Act, chapter 4, section 2); Norway, 'health care may only be given with the patient's consent', revocable, exceptions only in the communicable-diseases, mental-health and care acts (Patient and User Rights Act, section 4-1) (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. short in two of the four, so for the configuration: in Sweden a quarantine (Communicable Diseases Act, chapter 3, section 9) and an area closure (section 10) state no time limit, being lifted only when the grounds lapse, and the Public Health Agency's closure cannot be appealed except as a refusal of exemption (chapter 8, section 1); in Finland a standing requirement bars health and social-care workers without measles, varicella and influenza vaccination from work with vulnerable patients except for a special reason (Communicable Diseases Act, section 48), a penalty of refusal by loss of work with no lapse. Denmark's Epidemics Act meets the clause (admission, isolation and treatment orders of at most four weeks, renewable, each brought before a court within five weekdays; general rules valid four weeks at a time), as do Finland's quarantine (at most a month) and isolation (two months) with appeal to the administrative court and Sweden's isolation by the administrative court (three months, then six at a time); Norway's acts were not reached (reading 2.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: Roemer (1994, ch. 1) takes the political setting to be a democracy and Schweickart (2011, pt. II) presupposes political democracy beside workplace democracy; both specify economic institutions only and state no guarantees for the checklist's questions, nor the body that decides disputes between citizens and the public banks or planning boards, nor its independence (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: councils give each member a say in proportion to how far a decision affects them, and each worker council sets its own effort-rating procedure, 'grievance procedures' included; effort ratings set consumption rights, and the model names no body independent of the councils for disputes over them; the separate political proposal (Shalom's parpolity) is not specified for the checklist (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: self-management with internal grievance procedures; no guarantees stated + +**Integral: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: the white paper states data safeguards (only effects, not internals, exposed across nodes; local data sovereignty) and a non-punitive rule ('no credit confiscation, no reputation tribunal'), but no guarantees for the checklist's questions; a contributor's dispute over a host node's assessment, which sets the time credits that give access to goods, is 'resolved through the host's CDS or mediation', and 'individuals cannot bypass local CDS by appealing upward' (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: data limits and a non-punitive rule; disputes stay with the node that assessed + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); the fund is governed by statute, with a Council on Ethics, and neither adds to nor takes from the checklist's questions +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); it adds rapid, low-cost local arenas for resolving conflicts (principle 6) and recognised rights of users to make their own rules (principle 7); sanctions are graduated and applied by monitors who are users or accountable to them (principles 4 and 5) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); it adds a payment 'without means-test or work requirement' (BIEN), removing benefit conditionality and its policing, and takes nothing +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4); its own payment is unconditional by definition, so it cannot be withheld for refusing a health measure + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: Hickel (2020, ch. 5-6) and Kallis et al. (2020, ch. 3) propose democratic deliberation over production and expanded public services within an existing democracy; they state no guarantees for the checklist's questions and no adjudication of their own (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); it adds a public register of land values and takes nothing: titles stay where they are ('It is not necessary to confiscate land; it is only necessary to confiscate rent', book VIII, ch. 2) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); generalised to all finance, it would put every financial contract under a Shari'ah supervisory board's ruling, binding those of other faiths to a religious standard in their finance (D2), while disputes go to the civil courts or arbitration +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); membership is voluntary and each scheme's committee sets credit limits and resolves disputes, with the host's courts behind it; nothing is taken +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no health compulsion and no employment or service whose loss could penalise refusal (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: short. short: SGP 29 of 60 in 2025; V-Dem SGP 0.717, the cross-check agreeing (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: no statute, code or constitutional provision requiring consent to medical treatment was located; consent rests on the common law of negligence (cited, not cached) (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. short: the Director-General of Health may detain and isolate a person 'for such period of time ... as the Director-General of Health may determine' (Infectious Diseases Act, section 15), may order classes of people to be vaccinated in an outbreak (section 47), and during a public-health threat or emergency order there is 'no appeal' from the Director-General's orders (section 21K); Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1) (reading 2.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: short. short: USA 49 of 60 in 2025 (50 in 2024), below the bar; V-Dem's index fell from 0.927 to 0.826, between Singapore's and the Nordic economies', so the two sources agree that the bar is not met (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: cleared. cleared: a hospital patient 'has the right to make informed decisions regarding his or her care', including 'being able to request or refuse treatment' (42 CFR 482.13(b)(2), the conditions of participation every Medicare hospital meets), and the Supreme Court infers from the Fourteenth Amendment 'a constitutionally protected liberty interest in refusing unwanted medical treatment' (Cruzan, 1990) (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. short: school-entry requirements penalise refusal by loss of schooling and lapse at no stated time -- in Virginia 'no student shall be admitted by a school unless' immunised or exempted on religious or medical grounds, and a conditionally admitted student who falls behind 'shall be excluded from school' (Code of Virginia 22.1-271.2) -- though federal quarantine and isolation orders are reassessed within 72 hours and open to the courts (42 CFR 70.14, 71.37) and Freedom House scores the judiciary 3 of 4 on F1 (reading 2.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); it adds a universal 'democracy and legal' service (legal aid and access to courts), which bears on F1 and F2, and takes nothing +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: health care is one of the seven services, so consent in its delivery is within reach, and the proposal is silent on it, leaving it to the host's law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the proposal does not say whether access to a service could be conditioned on a health measure (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: out of reach. out of reach: a mechanism does not govern the host's 0-60 civil-liberties total (reading 2.6.2); it adds a standing, voluntary job offer that is 'not a workfare program' (WP 902, key features), which lessens economic coercion, and takes nothing +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism delivers no medical care and governs no consent law (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the job is an employment the programme governs, and the sources do not say whether refusing a health measure could end it (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: Bastani (2019) sets out automation, common ownership and 'popular municipalism' but states no court, no due-process institution and no guarantees for the checklist's questions (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: the Davos Manifesto 2020 commits companies to 'respect human rights' and the stakeholder metrics ask them to report on anti-corruption, lobbying and whistleblowing; the design leaves the checklist's questions to the host state's law and states no guarantees or adjudication of its own (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: short. far short: CHN 11 of 60 in 2025, in the 0.0 band's 16 or less; V-Dem CHN 0.179, the cross-check agreeing (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: short. short: the law gives a right to informed consent on condition, diagnosis and treatment (Basic Medical and Health Care Promotion Law, article 32) and requires explicit consent for surgery and special examinations or treatment (Civil Code, article 1219), but a patient who has harmed or may harm himself is admitted on the guardian's consent (Mental Health Law, articles 30 and 31), with re-diagnosis by other psychiatrists, not a court, as the only challenge (article 32) (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. short: isolation and medical observation run for periods 'determined according to national rules and medical examination results', refusal enforced by the police, and the isolation of a place is reviewed only by the superior government (Infectious Diseases Law, revised 2025); Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1) (reading 2.6.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: the civil-liberties score is in the 0.0 band's 16 or less, with no clause cleared (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: short. short: QAT 18 of 60 in 2025, two points above the 0.0 band; V-Dem QAT 0.357, the cross-check agreeing (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: Qatar's statutes (almeezan.qa) are served as a client-rendered application the container could not read, so the law in force on consent was not reached (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. short: Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1), so no compulsion is open to an independent court, whatever the communicable-disease law provides (not reached) (reading 2.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown, estimate 50 to 56 of 60, straddling the bar: the platform states full freedom of expression and religion, no control of media (1.2), privacy against surveillance (1.3), due process, speedy trial, counsel, jury and the presumption of innocence (1.7), equal rights before government whatever race, sex, creed or orientation (3.5), and no curtailment of rights in war or epidemic (3.2): D1, D2, D4, E1, E2, F2, F3, G1, G2 and G3 at 4; academic freedom (D3) and an independent judiciary (F1) implied, not stated, 3 each; labour agreements 'outside the scope of government' with bargaining at the employer's choice (2.11: E3 about 2.5), private discrimination left to association (F4 about 3), and no protection from economic exploitation short of force or fraud (G4 about 2) (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: cleared. cleared: individuals own their bodies (1.1) and the platform recognises each person's freedom to choose 'the medicines and treatments they will use', opposing any government mandate of treatment, vaccines included (2.13): intervention without consent is aggression, prohibited (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: cleared. cleared: 'Individual rights shall not be curtailed, whether based on circumstances of war, epidemic, natural disaster or emergency' (3.2), and no treatment or vaccine may be mandated (2.13); restraint of a person who deliberately places others at significant risk is a crime tried with due process and a jury (1.7), so any compulsion runs through a court (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: the strongest stated guarantees of the 17, with clause 1 at the bar; consent and the limits of compulsion stated + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: not shown. not shown: Raworth (2017) names the partner state, the commons and the household as provisioning domains and presupposes the host democracy; she states no guarantees or adjudication of her own (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on consent to medical treatment (reading 2.6.3) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: not shown. not shown: the sources are silent on compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c2-6) + +1. *Civil-liberties score ≥53 of 60 on the Freedom House checklist*: short. far short: Freedom House's civil-liberties rating of the USSR was 1972-1979 6; 1980-1986 7; 1987 6; 1988-1989 5; 1990 4 (1 best, 7 worst), the former rating's two lowest bands until the reforms of 1987-88; V-Dem's index for the Soviet Union (its Russia) was 0.145 to 0.150 in 1960-1984, the cross-check agreeing (reading 2.6.1) +2. *informed consent to medical treatment protected in law*: short. short: the Fundamentals of Health Legislation (1969) require consent only for surgery, complex diagnostic methods (article 35) and methods not yet approved (article 34), and for the mentally ill the consent of parents or guardians in place of their own; no provision protects refusal of other treatment (reading 2.6.2) +3. *any compulsory treatment, vaccination, quarantine or isolation prescribed by law, time-limited and open to independent judicial review*: short. far short: article 36 leaves 'the cases and procedure of compulsory treatment and compulsory hospitalisation' of whole classes (tuberculosis, mental, venereal disease, chronic alcoholism, addiction) to further legislation, with no time limit and no court; psychiatric confinement needed no court decision, and the USSR had no statute on psychiatric care until 1988 (reading 2.6.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: the civil-liberties rating stood in the former rating's two lowest bands (16 or less of 60) through the planned economy's years, with compulsory treatment and confinement outside any court (reading 2.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the rating's two lowest bands, consent and compulsion outside law and court + + +## Domain 3 + + +### C3.1 Crisis Response Capacity + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Response within 72 hours, scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase), ≥90% population coverage. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 20 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. v1: 7 at 1.0, 14 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. the design's Recession Protocol acts at 0-72 hours +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. the design raises Basic Units by a fixed 20% on a trigger of a GDP decline above 2% for two quarters, later steps discretionary: below the threshold's own example (30% decline, 30% increase); the Report's 50% is in no published CCO document located +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. re-read on the design's own sources: participation is opt-in and the rollout plan targets 60% opt-in; coverage of 90% of the affected population is not shown + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. benefits automatically increase in downturns without legislative delay +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. support rises by widening coverage at fixed replacement rates; no automatic rise in support per covered person at the threshold's own example (30% decline, 30% increase); the rationale says the stabilizers scale moderately +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not estimated in this pass + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: not shown. not shown: market socialism's sources (Roemer, 1994; Schweickart, 2011) state no automatic stabiliser; the state's control of investment could respond, by decision (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: no benefit rule to scale (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not shown: the designs leave social insurance to the state without specifying it (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. democratic councils can rapidly shift priorities during crises +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. support is reallocated by council deliberation; no automatic rule tying support per person to crisis severity is specified, and no implementation or model estimates one (reading 3.3) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. response within 72 hours for clearly defined crises is plausible given the architecture +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. the Feedback and Review System detects anomalies and suggests corrections; no rule scaling support with crisis severity is specified or estimated (reading 3.3) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: cleared. with universal coverage + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: Alaska's dividend is annual and set by formula; Norway's fund met 2020 through the Storting's revised budgets, drawing above the 3% path by decision, in weeks (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. short: the Alaska formula averages five years' realised earnings, so the dividend does not rise with a shock; Norway's draw scaled by decision, not by rule (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: cleared. cleared on the dividend variant: every resident of a year's standing receives it (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: out of reach. out of reach: commons governance sets appropriation rules and pays no benefit (reading 3.1.4) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: out of reach. out of reach (reading 3.1.4) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: out of reach. out of reach (reading 3.1.4) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. no application process, no verification, no delay +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. the benefit continues at its level regardless of employment: support per covered person does not rise with crisis severity, 0% at the threshold's 30% example; Alaska's dividend is set on an annual cycle, not by crisis severity (part (b), UBI C3.4) (reading 3.3) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: cleared. immediate crisis cushion for the entire population + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. commons and mutual aid networks provide automatic crisis support +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. no rule tying the support that commons and mutual-aid networks give to crisis severity is specified or modelled in the design's sources (reading 3.3) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the citizen's dividend is paid on a schedule and does not rise in a shock (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. short: land rent and land values fall in a downturn, so a dividend paid from the tax falls with the shock rather than rising (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: cleared. cleared: the dividend is paid to every resident, a universal cash benefit (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: out of reach. out of reach: profit-and-loss sharing lightens borrowers' payments automatically when their profits fall, but pays households no benefit; zakat lies outside the contract set (D31) (reading 3.1.4) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: out of reach. out of reach (reading 3.1.4) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: out of reach. out of reach (reading 3.1.4) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: out of reach. out of reach: mutual credit extends credit lines among members and pays no benefit (reading 3.1.4) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: out of reach. out of reach: no benefit to scale; the WIR network's turnover rises in downturns (Stodder, 2009), a counter-cyclical credit channel, not D.62 (reading 3.1.4) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: out of reach. out of reach: no cash benefit (reading 3.1.4) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: four Budgets in 2020, each passed by Parliament (Unity 18 February, Resilience 26 March, Solidarity 6 April, Fortitude 26 May); the Solidarity Payment was credited from 14 April and the Jobs Support Scheme paid employers by schedule -- weeks, by decision (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: real GDP fell 3.9% in 2020; no D.62 series for Singapore is at hand, and most of the support was paid to employers as wage subsidies, which are not D.62 (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: cleared. cleared: 100.0% (2023) covered by at least one cash benefit (SDG 1.3.1) (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the first official data showing the shock were the initial claims released on 26 March 2020 (2,914,000 for the week to 21 March, from 273,000); regular unemployment insurance pays after a claim is processed, two to four weeks on the criterion's own comparison, and the bulk of the increase came from the CARES Act, signed on 27 March, whose first payments were deposited from 10 April (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: cleared. cleared on the measure: social benefits to households (D.62) rose 35.5% from 2019 to 2020 while real GDP fell 2.1% (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: short. short: 78.8% (2023) of the population covered by at least one cash benefit (SDG 1.3.1) (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: automatic insurance and a fast legislated response, not automatic, coverage below 90% + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: out of reach. out of reach: the services are in kind and pay no benefit, so there is no increased payment to time (reading 3.1.4) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: out of reach. out of reach: no cash benefit to scale (reading 3.1.4) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: out of reach. out of reach: SDG 1.3.1 counts cash benefits, which the mechanism does not pay (reading 3.1.4) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: cleared. no legislative delay: enrolment rises automatically in a recession +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. the guarantee pays a fixed wage (the rationale's $15 an hour), so a downturn widens enrolment, which is clause 3's subject, and leaves support per covered person unchanged: 0% at the threshold's 30% example; the one national precedent, Argentina's Jefes de Hogar, paid a fixed 150 pesos per beneficiary (readings 3.3, 3.4) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: not shown. not shown: the design states no shock rule; its universal basic services continue regardless of employment, which steadies access but raises no payment (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: no cash benefit rule to scale (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not shown: services universal, cash benefits unspecified (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a universal service floor that holds in a downturn, without a crisis rule + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the reform leaves the host's stabilisers unmodified; on its principal host's 2020 record, the first official data showing the shock were the initial claims released on 26 March 2020 (2,914,000 for the week to 21 March, from 273,000); regular unemployment insurance pays after a claim is processed, two to four weeks on the criterion's own comparison, and the bulk of the increase came from the CARES Act, signed on 27 March, whose first payments were deposited from 10 April (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: cleared. cleared on the host's record: social benefits to households (D.62) rose 35.5% from 2019 to 2020 while real GDP fell 2.1% (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: short. short: on the host's record, 78.8% (2023) of the population covered by at least one cash benefit (SDG 1.3.1) (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the 2020 measures were State Council decisions from February to May (unemployment insurance and temporary living allowances extended to uninsured and migrant workers, dibao widened), not an automatic trigger; weeks to months, not 72 hours (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: real GDP grew 2.2% in 2020 (after a 6.8% fall on the year in the first quarter), and no D.62 series for China is at hand (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: short. short: 75.6% (2021) covered by at least one cash benefit, up from 63% in 2015 (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the Emir's directive of 15 March 2020 put QR 75 billion behind the private sector (guarantees, deferrals, exemptions), not into payments to households; no automatic benefit rises (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: no D.62 series for Qatar is at hand (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: short. far short: 4.1% (2022) covered by at least one cash benefit; the citizens' welfare state reaches about a tenth of residents and the migrant majority has no cash benefit (reading 3.1.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, read by reading 3.1.5: performance far below the threshold with no credible pathway under the configuration's own logic -- coverage of 4%, withheld by design from the non-citizen majority, and a crisis response directed to firms + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: coverage of 4% by the configuration's design + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: the platform opposes 'all forms of government subsidies and bailouts to business, labor, or any other special interest' and phases out public income security; no public payment rises (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: short. short: no public benefit to scale (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: short. short: public cash benefits phased out, so coverage falls toward none (reading 3.1.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, second condition: ideological opposition to stabilisation -- markets left to self-correct, bailouts and public income security refused (reading 3.1.5) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: not shown. not shown: the framework states no rule for a shock (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: no benefit rule to scale (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not shown: basic income is among its options, not adopted (reading 3.1.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition: no structural mechanism addresses crisis response -- the framework adopts no stabilisation instrument (reading 3.1.5) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: no stabilisation instrument adopted + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-1) + +1. *Response within 72 hours*: short. short: no automatic stabiliser; the planned economy's response to a shock is a revision of the plan, a political and administrative decision, and its record in the major shocks is of months' delay or denial: grain exports continued and relief came late in the famines of 1932-33 and 1946-47 (Davies and Wheatcroft, 2004; Ellman, 2000) (reading 3.1.1) +2. *scaling 1:1 with crisis severity (30% GDP decline = 30% benefit increase)*: not shown. not shown: no D.62 series or shock-year benefit record for the Soviet economy is at hand; full employment and fixed prices held nominal incomes, which is not a rise in benefits (reading 3.1.2) +3. *≥90% population coverage*: not shown. not shown: SDG 1.3.1 is not measured for the Soviet years; social insurance covered workers, and collective farmers' pensions only from 1964 (reading 3.1.3) + +Read in group 2.9 (Session 63) and re-read blind in Session 74. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a system-wide capacity to mobilise by decision without delay (1941), with relief to households delayed or denied in the famines; a mixed record + +### C3.2 Inflation Control Mechanisms + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Long-term inflation ≤3%, stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%), automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation. Revision class U (unchanged). + +v2.0: 2 at 1.0, 21 at 0.5, 0 at 0.0. v1: 9 at 1.0, 14 at 0.5, 0 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. on the owner's reading the design's backing of the currency by creative output, a community chest, is an original feature of the design and is read as backing what the Source pays; at full backing the design's published model raises prices 0.1% a year over 20 years in the Reference environment, in every seed under 3%; the dual-currency paper's own simulations give 0.95% a year; held until an empirical study shows that the backing does not hold in real-world data +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: cleared. carried, as group 2.1 carried it, on the framework paper's 8% scenario, in which local inflation is held to 3.2% while national inflation reaches 8.1%; the design's published model carries no 8% scenario, so it does not contradict the figure +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: cleared. carried, as group 2.1 carried it, on the design's automatic parameter adjustment (the dual-currency paper's adjustment rules); with every dollar the Source pays backed by new output, the model shows no runaway inflation for an adjustment to prevent + +Read in decision 58.1 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The owner's decision 58.1 restores the published 1.0 and supersedes group 2.5's unit (decision 57.7, S57-3.9); it reopens toward 0.5 on an empirical study showing that the backing by creative output does not hold in real-world data + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. Successfully maintained low inflation (2-3%) over decades +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: short. in the same episode every Nordic economy ran HICP inflation above 5% in every month from May to October 2022; in October Denmark stood at 11.4%, Sweden 9.8%, Finland 8.4%, Norway 8.4% and Iceland 6.4%, against 10.6% in the euro area and 2.9% in Switzerland, which shows the 5% bar was attainable in that environment (reading 3.4) +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Market mechanisms similar to capitalism. No specific innovations in inflation control. Democratic wage-setting could moderate wage-price spirals but unproven at scale. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. prevents systemic price instability +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: not shown. facilitation boards adjusting indicative prices through the iteration process are specified; no estimate of inflation under an external 8% scenario is stated or cited, and the clause applies because the design keeps indicative prices (reading 3.4) +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: cleared. adjusting indicative prices to balance supply/demand + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. there is no money supply to inflate +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: not shown. not shown: the white paper does specify the boundary -- Interface Cooperatives let the design 'operate inside a monetary environment without internalizing monetary logic', 'a containment strategy: money is allowed to cross the boundary only where necessary, and only in one direction' (section 11.6) -- correcting the earlier reading's 'a mechanism the design does not specify'; but no source estimates the system under an external 8% inflation while its nodes buy from markets, and the paper calls the hybrid integration 'an experimental concept that needs more development' +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: cleared. matched to capacity through COS + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The outside reader's reading: no internal prices and a one-way boundary keep internal inflation at zero, as clause 1 is read + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> A specific, purpose-built, well-documented design feature exists that most systems in this corpus cannot point to: GPFG invests exclusively abroad, a deliberate sterilization of the resource windfall from the domestic economy that is the textbook response to the Dutch- disease/currency-appreciation risk a windfall of this size would otherwise create. This is more distinctive than a generic "inherits whatever monetary policy the host country has" 0.5, but it addresses one specific inflation channel (resource-windfall sterilization) rather than the sectoral-demand-isolation and velocity-control apparatus the Pass Threshold specifies, and no evidence was located of either exemplar being stress-tested against an 8%-external-inflation scenario. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The mechanism has **no monetary function of any kind**: no unit of account, no credit creation, no reserve, no price-level instrument, no fiscal channel. The reason is simple absence rather than malfunction. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Major vulnerability. Most proposals lack specific inflation control beyond hoping taxation removes equivalent currency. Sectoral inflation risk (housing, healthcare) unaddressed. Requires complementary policies (price controls, supply enhancement). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Local currencies, time banks, and reduced monetization could limit monetary inflation. However, a transition period from growth economy to degrowth risks stagflation. Unproven inflation management. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> No specific inflation-control innovation is part of Georgist theory; a Georgist economy inherits whatever monetary policy its host country runs, the same reasoning already applied to Market Socialism and Stakeholder Capitalism elsewhere in this Report. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The mechanism supplies no distinct inflation-control instrument; outcomes track the host monetary framework. IMF Working Paper 16/72 found that low and stable inflation and a working transmission mechanism are attainable with a significant Islamic banking segment — Brunei, Bahrain, and Malaysia recorded the lowest inflation among such countries — while Iran, Sudan, Pakistan, and Yemen were identified as needing a stronger monetary framework. That contrast is informative precisely because it cuts across contract type: the two whole-system cases sit on the weak side, so the inflation record follows the monetary regime rather than the prohibition of interest. Malaysia's MYOR-i, mandated for Islamic products from the second half of 2027, is a benchmark rate, not a price-stability mechanism. H.7's 0.5 band — "relies on conventional monetary policy without novel safeguards" — applies. Not flagged. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The zero-sum-by-construction design is a genuine structural anti-inflation property: credit is created only at the moment of a matched trade, with no mechanism internal to a well-run system for the money supply to expand faster than real trading activity. Argentina's Redes de Trueque supplies a dramatic counter-example: as the network scaled into the millions, internal "créditos" vouchers used by several sub-networks were extensively counterfeited, and issuing organizations reportedly printed excess vouchers to keep pace with demand, producing severe internal inflation and a collapse in trust identified as a central cause of the network's disintegration. The zero-sum property is a feature of a *well-governed*, well-verified system, not an unconditional guarantee. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. cleared: core inflation averaged 0.7% in 2025 and long-run inflation is within the bar +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: short. short: headline inflation averaged 6.1% in 2022, the stress year, above the bar of 5% (core 4.1%), the measure on which the pass read Status Quo's clause 2 (part (b4)) +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: not shown. not estimated: whether the MAS's exchange-rate band, reset at its policy reviews, is automatic adjustment is left to Report v2.0, as for Status Quo + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading: core inflation of 4.1% in 2022 below the stress bar + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. maintains long-term inflation around 2-3% target +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: short. the 2021-23 shock is the documented stress episode, with global inflation averaging 8.7% in 2022: US consumer prices rose 7.0% over 2021, 8.5% in the year to March 2022 and 9.1% in the year to June 2022, the largest twelve-month rise since 1981; prices excluding food and energy rose 6.6% in the year to September 2022, so the bar is missed on the core measure as well (reading 3.4) +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 (whether rate-setting by the Federal Open Market Committee is automatic adjustment is left to Report v2.0) + +Read in part (b4) (Session 41). + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> UBS has no monetary-policy innovation of its own and inherits whatever the host country's central bank does — the same reasoning already applied to Market Socialism, Stakeholder Capitalism, Georgism, and Doughnut Economics. One narrow, real point worth crediting specifically: for the roughly one-fifth to one-third of a typical household budget UBS's covered sectors represent (housing, transport, and a share of food), market-price inflation in those specific categories no longer directly affects covered households' material welfare, since the price to the user is fixed at zero regardless of the state's own underlying procurement costs — a narrower, sector-specific version of the "sectoral demand isolation" logic credited more fully to CCO-PTF elsewhere in this corpus. This insulates household welfare in those categories without insulating the state's own fiscal exposure to inflation in them. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Buffer stock employment theoretically anchors wages and prices. However, the mechanism is unproven at scale. Risk of wage-price spiral if job guarantee wage set too high. Requires careful calibration. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: cleared. post-scarcity abundance claimed to remove inflation (a design's projection) +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: not shown. not shown +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: short. assumes the problem away through technology: no mechanism of its own, which D26 places in the 0.5 band + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> No innovations beyond traditional monetary policy. ESG metrics don't address macroeconomic stability. Inherits market capitalism's inflation control mechanisms and limitations. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> China passed this threshold's stress test in the one recent real-world instance of it. Consumer prices rose 2.0% in 2022, below the government's 3% target, while inflation ran around 8% in the United States, above 8% in the eurozone, and around 9% in the UK (National Development and Reform Commission, via SCIO). The mechanisms are specific and named. In September 2022 the state released about 200,000 tons of pork from government reserves, its largest monthly release on record, and it runs price-management schemes intended to keep pork and coal prices within set ranges (gov.cn), alongside conventional monetary policy. Consumer inflation peaked at 2.8% that September (Statista), and long-run inflation has stayed within the threshold's 3% bar. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Symmetric price-stability (deflation) reading + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The riyal is pegged to the US dollar, and the Qatar Central Bank sets its policy rates in close alignment with the Federal Reserve's (IMF, 2025). Consumer-price inflation averaged 3.2% a year from 1980 to 2024 and peaked at 15.1% in 2008, before turning negative in 2009 (IMF data, via TheGlobalEconomy.com); monthly inflation peaked at 16.59% in June 2008 (National Planning Council data, via Trading Economics). Recent inflation is low: 1.3% in 2024 (IMF) and 2.51% in February 2026 (Trading Economics). The long-run average sits just above the 3% threshold, and the 2008 peak was about three times the 5% stress bound (computed). Because a peg imports US monetary policy, it cannot tighten against a purely domestic boom (a structural observation, not a sourced finding about 2008). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Gold standard or commodity money could theoretically control inflation. However, it eliminates monetary policy flexibility needed for economic stabilization. Rigid money supply creates deflation risks. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-2) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Doughnut Economics has no monetary system, currency, or fiscal instrument of its own; it is layered onto whatever monetary policy the host jurisdiction already runs, exactly the same reasoning this paper already applies to Market Socialism, Stakeholder Capitalism, and Georgism. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-2) + +1. *Long-term inflation ≤3%*: short. official prices held by decree while excess demand appeared as queues, rationing and black markets (the entry's shortage inflation): repressed and hidden inflation, not price stability +2. *stress test inflation ≤5% (when external 8%)*: not shown. no stress record separable from the system's end +3. *automatic adjustment preventing runaway inflation*: short. no automatic adjustment: the monetary overhang was released as open inflation when prices were freed at the system's end + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +### C3.3 Multi-Failure Resistance + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%. Revision class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 21 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 4 at 1.0, 16 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-3) + +1. *Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%*: not shown. the design's published model at v5.6.0 runs one compound scenario, the Adverse environment (recessions, an automation wave and 2% outside inflation at the reference settings), milder than C3.3's recession-and-automation scenario, and a weaker-settings variant of it, the Stress Test; against the Reference environment on the same seeds at year 20, the share of adults not below the cost of living degrades 28.6% (release row) and 40.0% (full backing), and the share not in housing distress 28.7% and 14.7%; the share above the Societal Poverty Line degrades under 1%; essential-service and democratic-function capacity are not modelled, and the other three compound scenarios are not modelled (reading 3.10) + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Better than pure market systems due to stronger safety nets, but still vulnerable to compound crises. Small open economies exposed to global shocks; 2008-2012 showed vulnerability despite better resilience than others. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Distributed ownership provides some resilience—no single financial elite to trigger systemic crisis. However, market competition and interconnection still create vulnerability to cascading failures. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-3) + +1. *Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%*: not shown. not shown: distributed decision-making and the absence of a financial sector are the 1.0 band's features, but no source estimates the core functions' degradation under any of the four compound scenarios + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The 1.0 band's reading: explicit design for compound shocks through decentralisation + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-3) + +1. *Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%*: not shown. not shown: the published 1.0 cites a review of the design (not the white paper) estimating degradation under 25% in each scenario, which does not show under 20%; the white paper describes redundancy and monitoring (FRS, Coordination Envelopes) and estimates no degradation; Jev reads the clause not shown in both passes + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The 1.0 band's reading: redundancy at every layer, so that node failures do not cascade + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> GPFG's own diversification is extreme by any standard — roughly 1.5% of all globally listed equity, spread across more than 7,000 companies and dozens of countries — providing real, if incidental, insulation against any single-country or single-sector shock. But this is a property of the investment portfolio's construction, not a designed response to compound domestic shocks across economic, environmental, and social domains simultaneously, and no evidence was located of either exemplar being tested against NEEC's own four named compound scenarios. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **The longevity evidence is the best in the corpus by an order of magnitude.** Valencia's water tribunal has carried its core function through conquest, dynastic change, war and dictatorship for roughly a millennium; Törbel's alpine commons date from the thirteenth century; Araral's *zanjera* case is four hundred years old; Japanese irrigation institutions and *iriai* forest commons are of comparable vintage. Compound stress is not a thought experiment for these institutions, it is their history. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Better than employment-dependent systems, but inflation \+ supply disruption \+ climate disaster could overwhelm. UBI provides demand without ensuring supply. Needs complementary resilience mechanisms. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-3) + +1. *Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%*: not shown. not shown: low throughput, localised production and design 'for crisis as norm' are the 1.0 band's features, but no source estimates the fall of poverty, housing stability, essential services or democratic function under any of the four compound scenarios + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The 1.0 band's reading: explicit design for compound shocks through decentralisation and redundancy + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> A land-tax-funded dividend provides some income continuity during compound crises given its comparatively stable revenue base, a modest real advantage over purely wage- or income-tax-dependent systems, but this is an incidental property rather than a designed multi-failure architecture. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Asset-backing and the prohibition on trading debt kept Islamic banks out of the securitisation chain that transmitted the 2008 shock, which is a real structural source of compound-stress resistance. Set against it: in a dual system the Islamic segment funds and hedges alongside the conventional one; the IFSB's 2025 report names heavy commodity-*murabaha* reliance, persistent structural liquidity surpluses, and sectoral concentration as live vulnerabilities; and asset-backing concentrates exposure in property and commodities, which co-move. H.7's 0.5 band — "some resilience from distributed structure, but interconnection still transmits shocks" — applies. Not flagged. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The field is structurally decentralized — many small, independent nodes rather than one centralized system — providing genuine resistance to any single point of failure, and a 2025 academic study of Sardex's own network-resilience properties reflects active current scholarly interest. Argentina again supplies the clearest counter-evidence: under the compound stress of mass unemployment, a banking-system freeze, and a currency crisis simultaneously, the barter networks' internal controls were overwhelmed. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Singapore came through the one recent compound shock — pandemic, supply disruption, and recession together — with a 5.4% contraction in 2020 (IMF, 2021) and a recovery that outpaced its peers (IMF, 2025). Degradation stayed well inside the threshold's 20%. The IMF describes ample buffers and strong banks, with non-performing loans at 1.1% (IMF, 2026). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-3) + +1. *Maintain core functions across ≥3 of 4 compound scenarios with degradation <20%*: not shown. not shown: on the criterion's own poverty measure the configuration's two recent compound shocks did not degrade the function -- the United States' headcount at the Societal Poverty Line was 19.7% in 2008, 19.0% in 2009 and 19.2% in 2010, and 19.8% in 2019, 18.2% in 2020 and 16.7% in 2021 -- but the four scenarios (a 30% fall in GDP among them) lie beyond the record, and housing, services and democratic function under them are not estimated + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: optimised for normal conditions, with 2008 and 2020 requiring extraordinary policy action + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> No designed compound-crisis architecture exists (no federation or redundancy comparable to Integral or CCO-PTF). A real, if incidental, resilience property exists nonetheless: because housing, healthcare, food (for the covered subset), transport, and information are provided directly by the state rather than purchased entirely from private markets funded by wage income, a private-market financial shock or supply disruption does not automatically cut off access to these specific goods the way it would for someone relying entirely on wages to buy market equivalents — the same reasoning already credited to Georgism and Mutual Credit/LETS on this exact criterion. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Better than pure capitalism through automatic stabilizers. However, compound crises (inflation \+ supply shock \+ climate disaster) could overwhelm job guarantee capacity. Untested under extreme stress. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Automated resilience to economic crises. However, compound technical failures (cyber attack \+ infrastructure damage \+ supply disruption) could be catastrophic. Concentration of production creates single-point vulnerabilities. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Marginally more resilient due to stakeholder consideration. However, it is fundamentally similar to traditional capitalism. Interconnection and competitive pressures create the same vulnerability to cascading failures. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The system has absorbed large shocks without collapse. Growth stayed above 9% through the 2008–09 global crisis, recovered to 8.4% in 2021, and fell to 3.0% in 2022 under zero-COVID lockdowns (World Bank). State-owned banks and capital controls give it tools to roll over and absorb losses that market systems lack, and Stanford SCCEI's analysis argues that the property slump can curb growth for years even without a banking crisis. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Qatar has absorbed three compound shocks in under a decade: *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Three compound shocks absorbed + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** No institutional capacity to respond to compound crises. Every shock would trigger cascading failures with no circuit breakers. Complete vulnerability to systemic risks. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The "Get Savvy with Systems" chapter and the City Portrait's four-lens structure (local-social, local-ecological, global-social, global-ecological) explicitly train a jurisdiction to see interconnections and compound risk across social and ecological domains simultaneously — a genuine systems-thinking capacity, evidenced directly by academic case-study work (a 2025 study applying the four-lens framework in Glasgow found it useful for "identify[ing] possible co-benefits and/or unintended consequences of city policies" across a whole system rather than one domain at a time). This is a real, if soft, resilience-relevant capacity — seeing compound risk is a precondition for managing it — but it is a diagnostic lens, not a designed response architecture with redundancy, distributed production, or automatic multi-domain correction of the kind found in the corpus's strongest scorers here (Integral, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Participatory Economics, Degrowth). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** The system ultimately collapsed under compound stresses (technological stagnation, resource depletion, legitimacy crisis, arms race). Rigidity prevented adaptation to multiple simultaneous challenges. + +### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥30% parameter adjustability range, policy updates within 6 months of evidence, changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected, zero collapses during parameter adjustments. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 5 at 1.0, 16 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 17 at 1.0, 4 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. cleared: the design's documents give adjustable ranges well beyond 30% for several parameters without redesign: the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis cuts the maximum octaves from 8 to 4 (50%) and runs participation from 5% to 35%, keeping inflation below 1.8% and 89% of the welfare gains; the integrated framework sets the conversion multiplier at 1-9x against tested alternatives of 1-5x and 1-12x and a regional adjustment factor of 0.8-1.2; and the scorer's adjustment run on the v5.6 engine moves the Basic Unit by 30% either way (0.7 to 1.3) from year 10 +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. the design's crisis protocol schedules parameter recalibration within one to six months, and monthly cost-of-living adjustments in an inflation surge +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared: under the Citizens Internet Portal any citizen can submit a proposal (a signature threshold, a 30-90 day comment period, amendment), and a binding change passes by a 60-67% supermajority with geographic distribution, so those affected can challenge a parameter change and have it reversed by a process that does not run through the officials who made it; referenda move from advisory to binding in the second phase (years 4-7); the PTH charter template adds notice, hearing and appeal rights on every enforcement action +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. on the owner's reading (decision 79.3), a collapse is a breakdown that an adjustment causes (runaway prices, a run that fails), not the direct effect of a smaller allowance on the share below the cost of living; on the scorer's adjustment run (the Basic Unit multiplied by 0.7, 0.8, 1.2 or 1.3 from year 10, 500 seeds, Reference) no step causes such a breakdown at either backing: the 1.2 and 1.3 steps add at most 6.8 points to a year's price rise, and the 0.7 and 0.8 steps raise the share below the cost of living (the test fixed before the run counted 339 and 43 of 500 seeds in the release row, largest excess 16.6 points) as a smaller allowance does directly + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.3 (Session 79), then clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources (decision 84.3, Session 84). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Group 2.5's reading (reading 3.11): on the test fixed before the run, a 20-30% cut in the allowance raises the share below the cost of living by 10 points or more in 339 and 43 of 500 seeds + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. willing to adjust parameters based on research and outcomes +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. frequent policy experimentation and evaluation +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. parameter changes are enacted by elected parliaments (the national turnouts of part (a), NSD C2.4) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: short. the financial liberalisation of the 1980s led to systemic banking crises in Finland, Norway and Sweden, among the deepest in advanced economies since the Second World War, with Finland's output falling nearly 15%; Denmark, whose supervision was tightened, avoided a systemic crisis + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Market Socialism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. the pay-ratio cap, a core distributive parameter, moved from 1:3 at founding to 1:4.5 in the 1970s and 1:6 in 1988, a 100% range +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. democratic governance enables rapid adaptation to evidence; consistent with the record: in 2009 Eroski's worker-members voted to freeze pay and work 10% more, and a cooperative's assembly agreed rotating leave at 80% of pay, though no source dates a decision against the evidence that called for it +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. the pay-ratio changes were decided at the cooperatives' General Assemblies, the members themselves (v2.0's wording; ledger I9) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. stated search: no collapse caused by a parameter adjustment located; Fagor Electrodomesticos, the founding cooperative, failed in 2013 after heavy losses in the euro-area and Spanish real-estate crises, carrying debt from its 2005 Brandt acquisition, causes that clear it of an adjustment + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The outside reader's reading: no source dates a policy update within six months of the evidence + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. councils adjust proposals based on feedback, every planning cycle +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. not shown: 'democratic structure enables rapid evidence-based changes' dates no update against evidence; the planning cycle is annual (the outside reader reads the clause short) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared on v2.0's wording: self-managed councils of those affected decide and can reverse +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not shown: no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments in operation (part (b1), reading 3.1); decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84). + +**Integral: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. cleared: ITC's weighting bands, scarcity coefficients and access-valuation parameters are recalibrated within democratically approved bounds; the white paper's example raises an ecological weight to 1.7-1.8 in drought, a move of 70-80% (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. cleared, as designed: ITC parameters are recalibrated continuously, and CDS Module 10 opens a review when FRS signals or new evidence show outcomes diverging, its example acting on detection six months after a decision (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared, as designed: Module 1 takes proposals and objections from participants, decisions are reached by participants' weighted consensus with blocking objections detected, and Module 10 can amend, revoke or reopen a decision: there are no officials on whom the route depends (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. on the rule of decision 79.4: clauses 1 to 3 are cleared (the parameters adjust over a range of 30% or more, updates follow evidence within six months, and those affected can challenge and reverse them), and no implementation record or model located shows a collapse caused by a parameter adjustment, so clause 4 is cleared, as Georgism's clause 4 is read ('no collapse caused by an adjustment located'); the design bounds recalibration within democratically approved ranges and detects drift early (CDS Module 10), and has no implementation record or model of its adjustments + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71, then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The blind re-read's reading (Session 71, reading 3.4.4): no implementation record of a parameter adjustment and no modelling of the design's own adjustments in operation, so clause 4 is not shown + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. the strategic equity share moved from 40% (1998) to 60% (decided June 2007) to 70% (2017): a core parameter moved by half its value; the expected return in the fiscal rule from 4% to 3% (2017) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. the 2017 decisions came on 16 February, eleven weeks after Norges Bank's recommendation of 1 December 2016 +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared on v2.0's wording (contestable through a process that does not depend on the officials who made the change; ledger I9): Alaska's dividend veto of 2016 was challenged in the state Supreme Court (Wielechowski v. State, 2017), and Alaskans may legislate by initiative +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. the new equity share held through 2008-2009 without collapse + +Read in part (a) (Session 37), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Evidence dated from the market evidence of lower expected returns rather than from the formal assessment, which makes the expected-return revision slow + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. principle 3 is a procedure for changing the rules +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: cleared. in-period adjustment faster than six months (the acequia scarcity rule) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. rule changes governed by those affected +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. on the rule of decision 79.4: clauses 1 to 3 are cleared (the parameters adjust over a range of 30% or more, updates follow evidence within six months, and those affected can challenge and reverse them), and no implementation record or model located shows a collapse caused by a parameter adjustment, so clause 4 is cleared, as Georgism's clause 4 is read ('no collapse caused by an adjustment located'); the outright failures and fragile institutions the founding literature records are not attributed to rule changes, and principle 3 is the procedure by which those affected change the rules + +Read in part (a) (Session 37), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Part (a)'s reading: the founding literature records outright failures and fragile appropriator-designed institutions, and no analysis located attributes them to, or clears them of, adjustments, so clause 4 is not shown + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. simple parameter adjustment (benefit level, taxation rates) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. the longest-running precedent, Alaska's dividend, is set once a year; since the 2017 Supreme Court ruling it competes for annual funding like other programmes; the 2018 percent-of-market-value law came in the third budget year of the deficit that prompted the 2016 veto: annual cycles fall short +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. changes enacted by the legislature and governor and tested in the state Supreme Court +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: not shown. not shown: the published rationale's 'democratic governance allows evidence-based adjustments' states no range of adjustment +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. not shown: 'decentralised experimentation enables rapid learning' dates no update against evidence +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared on v2.0's wording: participatory democracy, citizens' assemblies and referendums let those affected challenge and reverse decisions +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not shown: no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation (part (b1), reading 3.1); decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. rates, valuation methods and phase-ins adjusted across jurisdictions +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. multi-year cycles, not updates within six months: Estonia's national revaluations in 2001 and then 2022; the ACT's transition review about every four years; Denmark's 2024 reform phased in to 2028 +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. changes through ordinary democratic process +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. no collapse caused by an adjustment located + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. product sets re-engineered and frameworks revised +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. after the 2012 tightening of bay' al-inah the industry re-engineered within a few years +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. changes set by Shariah Advisory Councils of appointed scholars and by central banks: governed, not democratic (the document's quotation drops democratic) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. no destabilisation + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. clearing and settlement mechanisms adapted over nine decades +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. the adaptations the unit cites run over decades (WIR) and years (the Credit Commons redesign, documented through 2024-2025); no update timed against the evidence that called for it located +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. nine decades of continuous operation + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. repeated recalibration: divestment, climate targets, a carbon tax +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. some evidence-based proposals slow or refused: unemployment support long resisted until 2025; an official poverty line refused +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. governed democratically but under a dominant-party supermajority +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. no collapse from recalibration + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. cleared: core parameters move far beyond 30% without redesign: the federal funds rate from 0.08% to 5.33% in 2022-23, the corporate tax rate from 35% to 21% in 2017 (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. short: some updates are fast (the CARES Act within a week of the jump in claims), but the central bank's first rise came in 2022-03 (0.20%), 11 months after CPI-U inflation first exceeded 4% (2021-04 (4.1%)), and much legislation waits on divided government (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared: agency rules can be set aside by independent courts at the suit of those affected (5 U.S.C. 706), statutes reviewed for constitutionality, and their authors removed in free elections (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: short. short: the deregulation of thrifts in 1980 and 1982 preceded the savings and loan crisis, at about $124 billion to taxpayers, and the financial crisis of 2007-09 followed decades of deregulation the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission named among its causes: systemic banking crises caused by changes to the configuration's own credit parameters (reading 3.4.4, as part (b1) read the Nordic crises) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. the framework's authors revising scope, framing and emphasis +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. the unit's own record is revision by the framework's authors at intervals of one to three years (2017, 2019, 2020, 2023): cycles longer than six months, as for Doughnut Economics in part (a) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. adjust job guarantee wage, spending levels and taxation +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. spending and taxation are adjusted through the legislative budget, and no update timed against the evidence that called for it was located; the one national precedent, Argentina's Jefes de Hogar, paid a fixed 150 pesos per beneficiary under decree 565/2002, the sum still stated in a 2003 amendment bill, while the programme was extended by statute to 2007 +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: not shown. not shown: the design names no parameters of its own or a procedure to adjust them (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. not shown: no rule of review or update is stated (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: not shown. not shown: who controls production and decides priorities is left unresolved, so no route to challenge a change is specified (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not shown: no implementation and no modelling of an adjustment (reading 3.4.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion -- the design specifies no procedure by which its rules or parameters are adjusted, by whom, or how a change is contested; its own scoring records its governance as largely unspecified (Report v1.6, FALC C2.4 and C4.4) (reading 3.4.5) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. easier to adjust metrics and targets than restructure the system +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. firms' metrics and targets are changed by boards under one-share-one-vote; the entry's own scoring records plutocratic control and token stakeholder voice: governed, not democratic (as Islamic finance's C3.4 in part (a)) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. cleared: the birth limit moved from one child to two (2016) and three (2021), and monetary, credit and registration parameters are adjusted often, without redesign (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. short: the 2008 stimulus came within two months, but zero-COVID was held for about a year after the evidence on Omicron and vaccines and the one-child rule for decades after fertility fell below replacement (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. short: administrative suits exist, but the courts answer to the Party's political-legal commissions and no election is free, so no route to reversal is independent of those who made the change (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: short. short: the abrupt end of zero-COVID on 7 December 2022 was followed by about 1.87 million excess deaths among those aged 30 and over within two months, and the 'three red lines' (August 2020) by the developers' defaults from December 2021 (reading 3.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. cleared: in 2020 the labour market's core parameters were reset without redesigning the state: a minimum wage where none existed and employer consent removed from job changes, which rose about tenfold a year (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. short: the labour reforms came six years after the 2014 complaint to the ILO and seven after the 2013 reporting on migrant workers' deaths and unpaid wages (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. short: the Emir holds executive and legislative power, judges are appointed by Emiri order, and the elected seats of the Shura Council were abolished by the referendum of November 2024; the migrant majority has labour dispute committees, not a route to reversing a law (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: cleared. cleared: stated search: no collapse caused by a parameter adjustment located; the 2015-17 fiscal adjustment to the oil price fall and the 2017-21 blockade were absorbed (reading 3.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: short. short: the state's scope is fixed on principle to protecting property, enforcing contracts and defence; money, regulation and transfers are not parameters it may adjust, so moving them is redesign (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. short: evidence of a market failure does not call for a policy update under the entry's principles (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: cleared. cleared: independent courts under a constitution of limited powers, the minimal state's core function, let those affected challenge a change and have it set aside (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not shown: no implementation of the design and no modelling of an adjustment (reading 3.4.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: clause 3 is cleared, so 2.1's 0.0 cannot hold with it (decision 53.2) + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: cleared. the global model and city portraits revised on new data +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. scheduled cycles longer than six months: the global monitor annually, Amsterdam biennially +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. the framework's own revisions are made by its authors and DEAL, not governed democratically; only city applications pass through councils +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: not shown. not shown either way + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-4) + +1. *≥30% parameter adjustability range*: short. short: state retail prices of staple foods were held from 1962 to 1991 against mounting shortage; each substantive change to allocation rules came as a reorganisation (the regional councils of 1957, undone in 1965; the 1965 reform, wound back; the Law on State Enterprise, 1987), so the range adjustable without redesign was narrow (reading 3.4.1) +2. *policy updates within 6 months of evidence*: short. short: Lysenko's doctrine governed Soviet biology from 1948 to 1964 against the evidence of genetics, and price reform waited decades on the evidence of shortage (reading 3.4.2) +3. *changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected*: short. short: no route to reversal ran outside the Party: no independent courts, no free elections; challenge took the form of strikes met with force (Novocherkassk, 1962; the Baltic coast, 1970) (reading 3.4.3) +4. *zero collapses during parameter adjustments*: short. short: Poland's food price rises of 1970, 1976 and 1980 each brought strikes, the first two were reversed and the third produced Solidarity; the Soviet reforms of 1987-88 preceded the collapse of 1989-91 (reading 3.4.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, third condition, with D29(a): performance far below the threshold on every clause, documented in several independent implementations (the Soviet Union, Poland), with no credible pathway under the system's own logic -- its adjustments of core parameters ended in unrest or collapse (reading 3.4.5) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +### C3.5 Failure-Mode Transparency + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Failure detection within 1 week, diagnosis success ≥80%, correction success ≥70%, externalization <10% of total costs. Revision class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 18 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. v1: 3 at 1.0, 13 at 0.5, 7 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: cleared. Failures legible and diagnosable +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: cleared. Failures legible and diagnosable +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. the design specifies monitoring institutions (real-time anomaly detection, AI risk models whose lowest alert level triggers enhanced monitoring with weekly human review, democratic review of major security changes, and a CIP dashboard) but states no share of identified failures successfully corrected; the nearest figure, the CIP paper's conviction probability of 0.62 for detected corruption, is an illustrative input to an expected-cost calculation for one class of failure, and below the bar in any case; the published model represents no detection, diagnosis or correction of failures (reading 3.2) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. no share of total costs externalised is stated or estimated; the rationale's grounds (flows visible on a ledger, member monitoring, a dashboard) concern the visibility of the system's own operations, not costs borne outside it; no design source located prices an environmental cost (none names a carbon tax), and the dashboard lists carbon emissions, energy use and waste reduction as metrics to display, not costs internalised (reading 3.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. the scoring document names no dated record of the entry's most consequential failure, which the measure requires +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. Sweden's Riksrevisionen reported in 2020 that agencies had acted on nearly 85% of its annual-audit recommendations within a year; no rate was located for Denmark, Finland, Iceland or Norway +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 0.05% (Finland) to 0.58% (Denmark) of GDP in 2022 in each of the five countries, under 10% + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. worker ownership makes firm failures visible to members immediately; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. market externalities (environmental costs) remain hidden, as the rationale says; no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. production and consumption imbalances are visible through the planning iterations; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: cleared. triggers alarms +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. FRS-2 analyses incoming signals against expected ranges, stated principles and prior baselines, and FRS-4 routes recommendations stating the observed problem and its likely cause to CDS; no share of failures whose cause is correctly identified is stated or modelled, the system has no implementation, and the corpus's own review sets a mechanism (system-dynamics modelling and historical comparison) beside the bar, not an estimate (reading 3.2) +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. recommendations go to democratic deliberation in CDS, and FRS-6 keeps time series to evaluate whether past decisions achieved their stated outcomes; no share of identified failures successfully corrected is stated or modelled, and the review sets democratic deliberation and adaptive implementation beside the bar, not a level (reading 3.2) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. tendency to externalize costs + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. Norway's fund scores 100 of 100 on the Truman scoreboard, with a Council on Ethics since 2004; funds such as Russia's and Iran's score about 5 of 10 on the Linaburg-Maduell index; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. over 180 disclosed exclusion decisions by 2025 are corrections of the fund's own holdings; no share of identified failures corrected is stated +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. principles 4 to 6 specify monitors accountable to the appropriators, graduated sanctions and cheap conflict resolution, at a scale where deviations are visible within days; no monitoring rule states a time +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. sanctions and conflict resolution are a correction apparatus, but no share of identified failures corrected is stated +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. principle 1's boundaries make costs borne by non-members a designed-in possibility (Stern, International Journal of the Commons, 2011); no share is stated + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: out of reach. the mechanism does not govern the economy's audit institution; the host's rate is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: a cash transfer has no channel that detects, diagnoses or corrects failures or prices externalized costs, and the host economy's are not the mechanism's + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. localized systems make failures visible to communities; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. ecological impacts still require technical monitoring, as the rationale says; no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. where well implemented, mass-valuation results are published with a correction channel for landowners (Estonia); no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. the valuation's appeal channel corrects parcel errors, but no share corrected is stated; the economy's audit institution is not the mechanism's +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. the disclosure regime on profit-equalisation and investment-risk reserves is largely observed (IFSB WP-10), but account holders are in some cases not informed of the bank's practices (IMF WP 15/120); no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. balances are visible to members in a shared ledger; the Redes de Trueque's counterfeiting and voucher inflation went undetected long enough to cause collapse; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. official data are extensive and the dormitory outbreak's case data were public; the scoring document names no dated record of the entry's most consequential failure, which the measure requires +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. the Auditor-General's Office publishes no recommendation-implementation rate that was located (its site refuses this container) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 3.03% of GDP in 2022, under 10% + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. the scoring document names no dated record of the entry's most consequential failure, which the measure requires; the rationale names the 2008 crisis without its inquiry +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: cleared. the four-year rate at which agencies implemented GAO's recommendations was 70% in fiscal 2024 (75% in fiscal 2023), at the bar +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 3.23% of GDP in 2022, under 10% + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. the transparency the published score credits is ordinary journalistic and academic scrutiny of specific implementations; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: out of reach. the mechanism does not govern the economy's audit institution; the host's rate is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: the scoring document finds no purpose-built mechanism and credits only the host economy's ordinary scrutiny, which is not the mechanism's (protocol 3.2), as for Universal Basic Income and MMT + Job Guarantee + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Published 0.5 on the host economy's scrutiny; a correction (reading 3.5) + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. the Job Guarantee's enrolment shows unemployment, not the failure of any institution; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: out of reach. the mechanism does not govern the economy's audit institution; the host's rate is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: out of reach. the mechanism prices no fuel use and governs no other externalized cost; the host's figure is not credited to it (protocol 3.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: a job guarantee and functional-finance budgeting have no channel that detects, diagnoses or corrects failures or prices externalized costs, and the host economy's are not the mechanism's + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. technical failures are highly visible (systems crash, production halts); no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. ESG metrics are self-reported with minimal enforcement; the scoring document names no dated record of the entry's most consequential failure, which the measure requires +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: cleared. the reform keeps the host economy's institutions, Status Quo's as group 2.3 read them: agencies implemented 70% of GAO's recommendations within four years in fiscal 2024 +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. on the same host economy, implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 3.23% of GDP in 2022, under 10% + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Published 0.0 (the 0.0 band's second anchor); with clauses 3 and 4 cleared on the host economy the reform keeps, 2.1's 0.0 conditions do not hold for the criterion as a whole, and the unit rises to 0.5, as Status Quo's holds (reading 3.4) + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: short. on the dated records the scoring document names, the Henan floods (a State Council investigation found reports of up to 139 dead or missing deliberately withheld) and the epidemic's onset (a doctor's warning met by a police reprimand), identification and correction took months, not a week +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. the National Audit Office reports 92% to 98% of the issues requiring immediate action rectified within the year (2023 to 2025); of all 4,238 issues in the 2024 audit, about 51% were resolved by the December report, the rest on roadmaps; no rate on GAO's basis, recommendations implemented within a stated period, is published +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: short. implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 10.95% of GDP in 2022, over 10% + +Why 0.0 stands: the configuration treats public disclosure of its signature failures as illegitimate (the epidemic warning punished as false information, a censorship directive during the floods, the labour-protest monitor dissolved), and on every clause the record shows it falls short + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The published 0.0 and its flag hold; v2.0's clause 4 figure confirms the externalization the rationale names + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: short. the ILO's report on 2020 found no categorical count of fatal occupational injuries possible, and the authorities do not classify unexplained or heat-related deaths of workers as work-related: failures are left unidentified, not identified within a week +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no recommendation-implementation rate of the State Audit Bureau was located (its site did not answer this container) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: cleared. implicit fossil fuel subsidies were 7.31% of GDP in 2022, under 10% (explicit subsidies, undercharging for supply costs, are a different quantity) + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Published 0.0 on a continuous estimate of 0.2 to 0.35; with clause 4 cleared on the measure v2.0 names, 2.1's 0.0 conditions do not hold for the criterion as a whole (decision 53.2), and the unit rises to 0.5 (reading 3.6) + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. losses and bankruptcy make a firm's failure visible to its owners and creditors; no monitoring rule stating how soon a failure is identified is specified or cited +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. no audit institution or correction record for systemic failures is specified; no correction record, and no share of identified failures corrected, is stated or cited +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. market externalities are left to claims by identifiable victims; no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Published 0.0 (the 0.0 band's anchor) read under protocol 2.1: firm failures visible to owners and diffuse costs externalized is the 0.5 band's description, which Market Socialism's unit holds; a correction, as decision 53.3 raised the desi + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: not shown. City Portraits surface shortfalls and overshoots publicly, but on a reporting cycle, not within a week of a failure; no dated record is named +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. aspirational: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause is established is cited +3. *correction success ≥70%*: not shown. correction is left to each jurisdiction's political process; an assessment found Amsterdam's implementation 'incipient and limited'; no share corrected is stated +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. the framework reports ecological overshoot but prices none of it; no externalized cost is projected as a share of total costs + +Read in group 2.4 (Session 56). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-5) + +1. *Failure detection within 1 week*: short. short: shortages and queues were visible to all, but failure information was suppressed: the Kyshtym accident of 1957 was acknowledged only in 1989, the famine of 1932-33 was officially denied, and Chernobyl's release was announced only after radiation was detected in Sweden (28 April 1986) +2. *diagnosis success ≥80%*: not shown. not shown: no diagnostic record or independent evaluation reporting the share of failures whose cause was established +3. *correction success ≥70%*: short. correction came through eventual collapse and reform, in every Soviet-type economy: a failure replicated across independent implementations (D29(a)) +4. *externalization <10% of total costs*: not shown. not estimated: no externalised cost is projected as a share of total costs (the outside reader, closed-book, puts unpriced pollution and energy far above 10% of GDP) + +Why 0.0 stands: the system actively suppressed failure information (protocol 2.1; the 0.0 band: active suppression of failure information), the ground on which China's C3.5 is 0.0 + +Read in part (a) (Session 37), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The published reading: failures such as shortages were visible, and correction came through reform + +### C3.6 Productive and Innovative Capacity + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years, total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years, basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time. Revision class N (new criterion). + +v2.0: 3 at 1.0, 20 at 0.5, 0 at 0.0. New in v2.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the dollar economy's market allocation is kept and the PTF adds public-trust investment; the design's productivity claims ('10-15% export improvements'; total productive work up 42%) come from its own simulation, a projection on untested assumptions (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: a 25-hour standard workweek is stated, 'viable with CCO Basic Unit supplementation' as AI and quantum computing reduce workloads ('hours move 35 to 25' in 2030-2035): a projection, with no account of basic-needs output at 25 hours on component evidence (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: DNK +1.07, FIN +0.61, NOR +0.22, SWE +0.91 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: short. short in two of the four, so for the configuration: DNK +0.18, FIN -0.38, NOR -0.78, SWE +0.18 % a year; Finland's and Norway's TFP fell over the 20 years (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: mean income DNK 2.30 times (income, 2023; 1380 hours a year), FIN 2.18 times (income, 2023; 1497 hours a year), NOR 2.16 times (income, 2023; 1412 hours a year), SWE 2.16 times (income, 2023; 1432 hours a year) the Societal Poverty Line (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: investment through public main banks that monitor firms, with the state steering it by interest rates (Roemer 1994, ch. 7-8), or a capital-assets tax funding public investment banks (Schweickart 2011, pt. II), beside markets for goods; the components' record is mixed -- Japan's main-bank system, which Roemer cites, against Yugoslavia's self-managed firms, whose productivity growth fell through the 1970s and 1980s (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the same mechanisms and record for improvement in methods; neither source provides a reward for innovation beyond firms' market returns (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no working time and no account of basic-needs output at it (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: investment is allocated by participatory planning with indicative prices; a council that adopts an innovation gains until others copy it and indicative prices adjust, and the model holds that diffusion is faster without private ownership of innovations; no economy has run on it (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: improvement rewarded by the temporary gain and by social recognition, on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: hours are each worker's, compensated as effort; no economy-wide working time and no provisioning account (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Integral: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: price is replaced by a stated multi-signal valuation (weighted labour, ecological impact, access and fairness signals) that sets each good's access value, with open design and cooperative production -- a stated replacement, so not the 0.0 case, but with no record (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: improvement comes through open design refinement, on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: contributions are recorded in hours but no standard working time is stated, and there is no provisioning account (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); the fund invests outside the economy under a statutory mandate (the Government Pension Fund Global) and allocates no domestic investment +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); a commons' rules govern its resource's yield, not the economy's productivity +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources treat growth of output as no aim, propose to scale down ecologically destructive production and move work toward care and agroecology under democratic planning (Hickel 2020, ch. 5-6; Kallis et al. 2020); they state no mechanism for allocating investment or rewarding improvement and no record (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: a shorter working week is stated (Hickel 2020, ch. 5), with no account of basic-needs output at it (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: no investment mechanism stated; shorter hours without a provisioning account + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); the tax falls on land value and lifts taxes from labour and capital, which bears on incentives but allocates nothing +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: generalised, profit-and-loss-sharing contracts would allocate all external finance by expected returns shared with the financier (Chapra 1985, ch. 3-4), so the clause is within reach; no record isolates the mechanism, since the economies that Islamised their banking kept debt-like contracts in practice (reading 3.6.2) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: on the same reading (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); mutual credit finances exchange between members, not investment +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 1.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: SGP +2.31 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: SGP +0.36 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: cleared. cleared: no survey in the Platform; output per person 309 dollars a day (2021 PPP, 2023) at 2283 hours a year, at least 1.98 times the highest Societal Poverty Line its median could set (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 1.0: productivity and TFP rising over 2003-2023 + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 1.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: USA +1.30 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: USA +0.45 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: cleared. cleared: mean income USA 2.56 times (income, 2024; 1789 hours a year) the Societal Poverty Line (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 1.0: productivity and TFP rising over 2003-2023; output well above the basket at actual hours + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); it provides services, financed by tax +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2); functional finance and the job guarantee manage demand and employment +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism allocates no investment and rewards no improvement economy-wide even when generalised (reading 3.6.2) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism sets no working time; the host's hours apply (reading 3.6.3); the job guarantee's own output is public-service work, not the basic-needs basket + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: automation and information goods are to drive costs toward zero, with socialised central banking and public investment (Bastani 2019, ch. 3-4, 8-11); no mechanism for allocating goods that stay scarce is stated, and none has a record (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: working time is to fall toward zero by automation, a projection on untested assumptions, with no provisioning account (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: abundance projected from automation; allocation of what stays scarce unstated + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: market allocation of investment by private capital, unchanged in kind, with company boards answering to stakeholders as well as shareholders (Schwab and Vanham 2021); its components' record is non-declining (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: improvement rewarded by profit and competition as in the market economies, whose TFP rose over the 20 years (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no working time and no account of basic-needs output at it (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 1.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: CHN +8.18 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: CHN +3.02 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: cleared. cleared: mean consumption CHN 2.15 times (consumption, 2022; 2328 hours a year) the Societal Poverty Line (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 1.0: on the named source, productivity and TFP rising fast; the official accounts' reliability flagged + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: short. short: QAT -1.22 (2005-2023) % a year, PWT's hours for Qatar beginning in 2005 (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: short. short: QAT -4.48 % a year (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: cleared. cleared: mean income QAT 2.32 times (income, 2017; 2435 hours a year) the Societal Poverty Line (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: productivity and TFP declining; the basket provisioned by rent + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: private capital markets and profit, the market economies' own components, but with the state's part in them removed -- education 'best provided by the free market' (2.12), no public research -- so no economy's record is of the design's mechanism (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: improvement rewarded by profit alone, on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no working time and no account of basic-needs output at it (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: Raworth is 'agnostic about growth' (2017, ch. 7) and states no mechanism of her own for allocating investment or rewarding improvement (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: on the same reading (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no working time and no account of basic-needs output at it (reading 3.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c3-6) + +1. *Real output per hour worked non-declining over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: output per worker in the total economy (Western estimates) grew 3.0%, 2.1% and 1.4% a year in 1960-69, 1970-79 and 1980-87, slowing but not declining (reading 3.6.1) +2. *total factor productivity non-declining over 20 years*: short. short: growth-accounting TFP for Western-estimate GNP was -0.1, -0.8 and -1.2% a year in 1960-70, 1970-80 and 1980-87, declining over the two decades to 1987 while capital per worker grew 4 to 5% a year: the extensive growth the criterion's second clause is written to catch (reading 3.6.1) +3. *basic-needs output sustained at the system's own working time*: not shown. not shown: no survey of incomes or consumption against a basket exists for the Soviet economy in the cache, and Easterly and Fischer's record is of growth, not provisioning (reading 3.6.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: output per worker rising, TFP declining on growth accounting; held from 0.0 by D28(f) + + +## Domain 4 + + +### C4.1 Intergenerational Justice + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Debt-to-GDP <80%, positive wealth transfer to next generation. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 22 at 0.5, 0 at 0.0. v1: 8 at 1.0, 12 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. far short, on the host's figures: Basic Units are pegged 1:1 to the primary currency and the deployment is self-funding through a 12% conversion tax at 60-65% participation, so the design adds no public debt, but it keeps the host's public finances and their debt, 124.4% of GDP in 2025 in the economy it is proposed for (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: Public Trust Housing and Foundations hold property in public trust and build Acre Equity, a collective stock carried forward, on top of the host's positive net saving (lowest 0.9% of GNI, 2016 to 2025) (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. short: Denmark 27.4%, Norway 54.0% and Sweden 34.5% of GDP in 2025, each below 80% in every year from 2016 (highest 45.2%, 54.0%, 43.2%); Finland 88.4%, above 80% since 2024 and 101.2% on the WEO's projection to 2031; the configuration clears only if each economy does (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: net national saving is positive in every year of 2012 to 2021 in all four (lowest 7.6%, 1.2%, 6.6% and 9.1% of GNI, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden); Norway's adjusted net savings, net of oil and gas depletion, is 13.6% to 22.7% (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: one of the four economies is above the bar at the stated date and projected to rise + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: not shown. not shown: the design's sources (worker cooperatives in competitive markets, Mondragon and the cooperative movements) state no public-finance rule or projected debt path (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared, by rule: the cooperatives retain their net surplus as capital -- at least 20% to an indivisible collective reserve and the rest, after the social fund, to members' capital accounts that stay invested until the member leaves (Mondragon), at least 30% to an indivisible legal reserve (Italian Civil Code, art. 2545-quater) -- so the productive sector's net saving is positive whenever it earns a surplus (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: not shown. not shown: there is no state borrowing in the market sense, but neighbourhood consumption councils authorise households' borrowing and saving, and consumers, councils and federations carry the year's differences as debt or savings; no rule bounds the federations' debts and no path is projected (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: not shown. not shown: each year's plan runs inside an investment plan that sets the capacity added to each industry, but the design states no net accumulation rule or projection (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: cleared. cleared, by construction: the design has no instrument of borrowing -- time credits are non-transferable, decay over time and are extinguished on use, so nothing can be lent or owed -- and no public debt arises within it (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: short. short, by the design's logic: success is measured 'rather than growth or capital accumulation', and 'prosperity is defined by sufficiency and reliability, not surplus accumulation'; the design sustains its material cycles but states no net accumulation (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1); the withdrawal rule governs what the fund pays into the budget, not the rest of the government's borrowing (Norway's gross debt, 54.0% of GDP in 2025, is the host's) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: short. short: the mechanism converts a non-recurring revenue into a held fund, a positive transfer while withdrawals stay within the return, as under Norway's rule; Timor-Leste withdrew above its Estimated Sustainable Income in 2008-12 and every year from 2014, and the IMF (2017) projects the fund's depletion, so the transfer rests on the rule's observance, not on the mechanism (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: sustained yield preserves a local resource stock, which is the ecological transfer (C4.2's), not national saving (readings 4.1.2, 4.1.4) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1); the funding (income taxation in the leading design, other variants not fixed by the mechanism) is a choice the transfer does not make +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: an income transfer, which governs neither saving nor investment (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: not shown. not shown: the degrowth literature argues against growth that is driven by debt and for audits of illegitimate debt, but states no projected path of the public debt ratio (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: short. short, by the design's logic: the transition its literature describes ends in a steady state, constant stocks of people and artifacts maintained by a low throughput (Daly, 1991; Kerschner, 2010), in which net accumulation is zero rather than positive; preservation of the natural stock is C4.2's (readings 4.1.2, 4.1.4) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1); the dividend is paid only from revenue left after public goods, which bounds the dividend, not the debt +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax captures land rent and the dividend distributes it rather than investing it (the scoring document's own contrast with a held corpus); national saving is the host's (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1); sovereign sukuk are market practice outside the profit-sharing contract set the scoring document scores +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: profit-sharing accounts are an accumulating household corpus, a channel for saving, not a rule that raises net national saving (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: balances sum to exactly zero by construction, so the mechanism creates no net financial saving and does not govern real saving (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. short: general government gross debt is 165.7% of GDP in 2025 and between 105.9% and 170.4% in every year from 2016; the securities are issued to develop the debt market and their proceeds invested, and the government's assets exceed its debt, but v2.0's measure is gross debt and governs (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: net national saving is positive in every year of 2012 to 2021, 25.7% to 34.9% of GNI (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. far short: general government gross debt is 124.4% of GDP in 2025, between 106.5% and 132.6% in every year from 2016, and 145.0% on the WEO's projection to 2031; no rule bounds it (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared, narrowly: net national saving is positive in every year of 2012 to 2021 (1.4% to 3.8% of GNI) and, on BEA's net saving, of 2016 to 2025 (lowest 0.9%) (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: debt is far above the bar; the positive transfer is small but positive in every year of the window + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no public borrowing, so the debt ratio is the host economy's (reading 4.1.1); the services are costed at about 2.3% of GDP and funded from taxation, so they add no debt by design +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: out of reach. out of reach: service provision governs neither national saving nor investment beyond its own stock (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. short: functional finance sets the deficit by employment and inflation, not by a debt ratio, and the framework's own account holds the debt's burden on the next generation to be a myth (Kelton, 2020, the third of six); the job guarantee is financed by the currency issuer's spending, so no rule bounds the ratio (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: not shown. not shown: the sectoral balances let public deficits meet private saving desires; no projection of net national saving is stated (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: clause 1 rejected by the framework's logic, clause 2 not addressed; 4.1.3 asks both for 0.0 + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: not shown. not shown: the design's sources call for public investment in energy and automation and an end to austerity, but state no projected path of the public debt ratio (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: not shown. not shown: the investment programme is stated, net national saving is not projected (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. far short: the entry keeps the host market economy's public finances unmodified and adds voluntary stakeholder governance and ESG metrics: in the economy it reforms gross debt is 124.4% of GDP in 2025, 145.0% on the WEO's projection to 2031 (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared, narrowly, on the host's figures: net saving is positive in every year of 2016 to 2025 (lowest 0.9% of GNI, BEA); the reform adds no saving rule (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: the host's readings, which the reform does not change + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. short: general government gross debt is 98.6% of GDP in 2025, above 80% since 2023, and 122.1% on the WEO's projection to 2031 (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: net national saving is positive in every year of 2012 to 2021, 17.1% to 26.7% of GNI (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 1.0** (v1 0.5, up). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: cleared. cleared: general government gross debt is 42.5% of GDP in 2025, between 41.4% and 72.6% in every year from 2016, and at most 46.4% on the WEO's projection to 2031 (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: net national saving is positive in every year of 2012 to 2021, 24.5% to 47.9% of GNI, and stays positive net of gas and oil depletion (adjusted net savings 17.9% to 33.5%), so the check finds no sign disagreement (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 1.0: both clauses are shown on the measures v2.0 names, net of resource depletion as well + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: cleared. cleared, by stated rule: 'Government should not incur debt, which burdens future generations without their consent', with a balanced-budget amendment balanced by cutting expenditure, in a state confined to protecting rights (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: not shown. not shown: the design replaces defined-benefit with defined-contribution pensions 'so as not to impose debt on future generations', a funded saving channel, but states no projection of net national saving (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a stated no-debt rule; the saving clause is not projected + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: not shown. not shown: the design is agnostic about growth and proposes redesigning money and finance, but states no projected path of the public debt ratio (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: not shown. not shown: regenerative design concerns the natural stock, which is C4.2's; no net national saving is projected (readings 4.1.2, 4.1.4) + +Read in part (b6) (Session 43) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-1) + +1. *Debt-to-GDP <80%*: short. short, on the path: the rouble state debt the USSR Ministry of Finance reported was to reach 470 billion roubles by the end of 1990, 74% of 1989's net material product and about half of the 930 billion roubles of GDP Ofer gives for 1989, so the level was below the bar; but the budget deficit, 2.3% of GDP in 1981-85, was 13.3% in the original plan for 1989 and 10.1% in the revised one, and a debt growing by a tenth of GDP a year is not kept below the bar by any rule of the configuration (reading 4.1.1) +2. *positive wealth transfer to next generation*: cleared. cleared: investment rose from 22% of GNP in 1960 to 33% in 1987 and the capital stock grew faster than output under extensive growth, so net accumulation was positive throughout; Ofer counts the backlog of infrastructure, technology and services and the obsolete equipment never retired as an internal debt in real terms, which the measure's depreciation does not see (reading 4.1.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 72. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: positive net accumulation, a debt below the bar in level but on a path through it + +### C4.2 Ecological Compliance + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year, biodiversity neutral or positive, resource extraction ≤ regeneration, no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 17 at 0.5, 6 at 0.0. v1: 7 at 1.0, 8 at 0.5, 8 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. the audited phrase, a 35-45% reduction trajectory with a carbon tax, states a size without a horizon and so no rate (reading 3.2); the design's model reports total emissions 45% below an unstated baseline trajectory over 20 years, of which consumption-driven emissions fall 24%, which fixes no absolute rate without the baseline (against a flat one it is about 2.9% a year), and the roadmap's carbon targets (15-20% in year 1 to 70-80% in year 7) are targets in a table that does not say whose emissions it covers; the published model represents no emissions (reading 3.4) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. biodiversity appears in the design's sources as a metric to monitor (environmental health: emissions, biodiversity, regeneration) and, in a glossary example, as one of the stewardship results a Public Trust Foundation may reward in Acre Equity; no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. the roadmap's resource table projects cuts of 60-90% in the paper, energy and water use it lists without saying whose use they are, and no comparison of resource use with regeneration or biocapacity is stated; the published model represents no resource flows, as part (b6) found for C4.1's regeneration clause +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. no planetary boundary is named in the design's sources, which list regeneration among the environmental metrics to monitor; no boundary is assessed for the design + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by -1.36%, -3.46%, -3.12%, -1.60% a year over 2013 to 2023 (Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden), none at the bar's -3.8%; the configuration clears only if each does (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: cleared. cleared: the Red List Index is not below its 2016 level in 2025 in all four (0.97453 to 0.97492; 0.98038 to 0.98100; 0.95113 to 0.95134; 0.98979 to 0.99037) (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the footprint of consumption is 4.25, 3.68, 3.50, 3.83 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: short. short: Denmark 3 of four; Finland 3 of four; Norway 3 of four; Sweden 3 of four transgressed (phosphorus, nitrogen and land-system change above the boundary; blue water within) (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. not shown: democratic firms that maximise income per worker lack capital's expansionary imperative, and social control of investment could direct it, but no cap or emissions path is stated (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. not shown: no pressure on species is projected (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. not shown: no footprint is projected (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. not shown: no boundary is projected (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a structural damper on the growth imperative, no limit stated + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. the model's pollution damage revealing mechanism prices pollution inside annual planning and, under the model's assumptions, reduces it to efficient levels; an efficient level is not a rate of reduction, and no emissions path is stated or cited for the model, which has no implementation, as part (b6) found for C4.1's carbon clause (reading 3.4) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. the planning councils can constrain production and consumption within ecological limits and price ecological damage; no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: cleared. sustainable resource use +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. within ecological limits + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. OAD computes embodied carbon and lifecycle impacts for each design, and CDS's context model carries emissions proxies into deliberation; no emissions path for the economy is stated or modelled, as part (b6) found for C4.1's carbon clause (reading 3.4) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. the white paper names biodiversity collapse among the crises of market systems and couples production to ecological thresholds, footprints and risk metrics in CDS, OAD and FRS; no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. the design states that production stays within planetary boundaries through real-time ecological feedback, with material footprints computed for designs and FRS flagging constraint violations; no footprint of consumption against biocapacity, or other comparison of extraction with regeneration, is estimated, and the system has no implementation +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. enforce planetary-boundary compliance + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: the fund invests a revenue stream and governs its portfolio (the coal exclusion, the climate action plan), not the national economy's emissions, extraction or habitat; consumption emissions are the host's (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: the fund invests a revenue stream and governs its portfolio (the coal exclusion, the climate action plan), not the national economy's emissions, extraction or habitat; species and habitat are the host's (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: the fund invests a revenue stream and governs its portfolio (the coal exclusion, the climate action plan), not the national economy's emissions, extraction or habitat; the footprint is the host's (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: the fund invests a revenue stream and governs its portfolio (the coal exclusion, the climate action plan), not the national economy's emissions, extraction or habitat; the boundaries are the host's (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: an investment mechanism that governs none of the four quantities (D28(c)) + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs local common-pool resources, not energy or consumption emissions; Ostrom's polycentric argument for climate action is not a commons institution governing them (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. not shown: sustained yield preserves the habitat of the resources the commons govern, but no economy-wide pressure on species is projected (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: within a commons the long-enduring cases hold extraction within regeneration, but generalised the mechanism does not govern the consumption footprint, which energy and traded goods dominate (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: the national boundaries are set by agriculture, water and land use beyond the commons (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: an income transfer governs no quantity of production, extraction or emissions; a carbon fee and dividend is a different design, not the mechanism scored; consumption emissions are the host's (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: an income transfer governs no quantity of production, extraction or emissions; a carbon fee and dividend is a different design, not the mechanism scored; species and habitat are the host's (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: an income transfer governs no quantity of production, extraction or emissions; a carbon fee and dividend is a different design, not the mechanism scored; the footprint is the host's (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: an income transfer governs no quantity of production, extraction or emissions; a carbon fee and dividend is a different design, not the mechanism scored; the boundaries are the host's (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: cleared. designed for absolute reductions +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. the degrowth literature's own scenario researchers write that, to date, degrowth scenarios have not been explored for biodiversity conservation and human wellbeing, and set out the steps (visions, pathways, social-ecological interactions, modelling) by which they could be; the IPBES Global Assessment, as they cite it, finds degrowth's transformative potential for biodiversity high but the evidence of its effectiveness still inconclusive; no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. explicitly bounded by planetary limits + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax governs the use of land, encouraging compact use, and its dividend distributes rent; neither governs emissions, extraction or habitat, and pollution charges are not part of the design scored; consumption emissions are the host's (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax governs the use of land, encouraging compact use, and its dividend distributes rent; neither governs emissions, extraction or habitat, and pollution charges are not part of the design scored; species and habitat are the host's (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax governs the use of land, encouraging compact use, and its dividend distributes rent; neither governs emissions, extraction or habitat, and pollution charges are not part of the design scored; the footprint is the host's (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax governs the use of land, encouraging compact use, and its dividend distributes rent; neither governs emissions, extraction or habitat, and pollution charges are not part of the design scored; the boundaries are the host's (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: the contracts set the terms of finance and exclude prohibited sectors, but govern no quantity of throughput; consumption emissions are the host's (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: the contracts set the terms of finance and exclude prohibited sectors, but govern no quantity of throughput; species and habitat are the host's (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: the contracts set the terms of finance and exclude prohibited sectors, but govern no quantity of throughput; the footprint is the host's (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: the contracts set the terms of finance and exclude prohibited sectors, but govern no quantity of throughput; the boundaries are the host's (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a financing mechanism that governs none of the four quantities (D28(c)) + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: out of reach. out of reach: a zero-sum credit network governs the medium of local exchange, not what is produced or extracted; consumption emissions are the host's (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: a zero-sum credit network governs the medium of local exchange, not what is produced or extracted; species and habitat are the host's (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: out of reach. out of reach: a zero-sum credit network governs the medium of local exchange, not what is produced or extracted; the footprint is the host's (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: a zero-sum credit network governs the medium of local exchange, not what is produced or extracted; the boundaries are the host's (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by -2.54% a year over 2013 to 2023 and 1.57% a year since 2019, against the bar's -3.8% (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the Red List Index is 0.88859 in 2025 against 0.91680 in 2016 (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the ecological footprint of consumption is 4.15 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (3.45 in 2011) (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. not shown: 2 transgressed and 1 not in the accounts (phosphorus 7.33, nitrogen 6.84, land-system change 0.79, blue water not in the accounts), so the missing boundary decides (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, read by reading 4.2.5: no clause cleared, consumption emissions up since 2019 and the decade's fall under the bar, the Red List Index falling, a footprint four times world biocapacity; and the configuration's own 2030 target lets emissions rise to their peak, so the tax is not an absolute-reduction mechanism within the window (the scoring document, as part (2.10) reads it) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the configuration's own target path rises to 2030, evidence the blind reading did not weigh + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by -0.37% a year over 2013 to 2023 and -0.67% a year since 2019, against the bar's -3.8% (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the Red List Index is 0.82214 in 2025 against 0.82820 in 2016 (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the ecological footprint of consumption is 5.03 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (3.93 in 2011) (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: short. short: 4 of the four transgressed (phosphorus 5.49, nitrogen 7.18, land-system change 1.19, blue water 1.06; 1 = the boundary) (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: far below on all four clauses -- consumption emissions falling a tenth as fast as the bar, the Red List Index declining, a footprint five times world biocapacity, all four boundaries transgressed -- with no national cap or price in the configuration at the stated date, whose federal direction in 2025 is reversal (the clean-electricity credits phased out, the Paris withdrawal); sub-national caps cover a minority of emissions (reading 4.2.5) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: far below on all four, no national absolute-reduction mechanism + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. not shown: collective provision of transport, housing and food is argued to lower consumption emissions, but no path is projected on the measure (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: out of reach. out of reach: service provision governs no pressure on species or habitat (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. not shown: the 'fair consumption space' argument places provision within a footprint ceiling, but no footprint is projected (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: out of reach. out of reach: the boundaries are set by agriculture, water and land use beyond the services (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. within reach under D31, as part (a) found; theoretically compatible with absolute reductions is not a rate of fall in consumption-based emissions +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. within reach under D31, as part (a) found; no estimate +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. within reach under D31, as part (a) found; no estimate +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. within reach under D31, as part (a) found; no estimate + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. the design's premise, energy abundance from renewables, is stated without an emissions path, as part (b6) found for C4.1's carbon clause; no rate of fall in consumption-based emissions is stated, cited or located (reading 3.4) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. the design's case for food without animals argues that precision fermentation and cellular agriculture could produce meat, milk and eggs on a small fraction of the land and water livestock needs, an argument about land demand that is conditional on the technology; no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: cleared. automated resource optimization could achieve ecological sustainability +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. harmonize human activity with planetary boundaries + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by -0.37% a year over 2013 to 2023 and -0.67% a year since 2019, against the bar's -3.8%, on the host's record, which the reform's voluntary metrics leave unchanged (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the Red List Index is 0.82214 in 2025 against 0.82820 in 2016 (reading 4.2.2), on the host's record +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the ecological footprint of consumption is 5.03 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (3.93 in 2011) (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: short. short: 4 of the four transgressed (phosphorus 5.49, nitrogen 7.18, land-system change 1.19, blue water 1.06; 1 = the boundary) (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: the reform's instruments are disclosure and voluntary metrics, relative or intensity targets substituting for absolute limits, on a host far below every clause (reading 4.2.5; the anchor's 0.0 band describes the same case) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: voluntary, relative metrics on the host's record + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by 2.33% a year over 2013 to 2023 and 2.68% a year since 2019, against the bar's -3.8%; emissions are still rising (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the Red List Index is 0.82952 in 2025 against 0.85073 in 2016 (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the ecological footprint of consumption is 2.24 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (1.45 in 2011) (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. cleared: 2 of the four transgressed (phosphorus 3.00, nitrogen 2.68, land-system change 0.42, blue water 0.54; 1 = the boundary) (reading 4.2.4) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: within two of the four downscaled boundaries (blue water and land-system change), short on the rest; the trading scheme is intensity-based + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: consumption-based CO2 changed by 4.01% a year over 2013 to 2023 and 1.36% a year since 2019, against the bar's -3.8% (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the Red List Index is 0.78040 in 2025 against 0.80704 in 2016 (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: short. short: the ecological footprint of consumption is 8.29 times world biocapacity per person in 2015 (4.05 in 2011) (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. not shown: 2 transgressed and 1 not in the accounts (phosphorus 2.69, nitrogen 3.16, land-system change 0.64, blue water not in the accounts), so the missing boundary decides (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: far below on the three clauses read -- consumption emissions rising 4% a year, the Red List Index falling, a footprint eight times world biocapacity -- and the configuration's target is relative to business as usual while its gas capacity is to nearly double by about 2030 (reading 4.2.5) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: the design rejects public limits on energy ('We oppose all government control of energy pricing, allocation, and production') and offers restitution 'where damages can be proven and quantified in a court of law', which cannot reach diffuse emissions with no identifiable injurer, so no cut is projected (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. not shown: private landowners' and conservation groups' interest in maintaining resources is asserted, no pressure on species is projected (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. not shown: no footprint is projected (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. not shown: no boundary is projected (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: the design's own logic rejects public limits on throughput and energy, and its one remedy, court restitution for proven and quantified damage, cannot reach diffuse emissions or habitat loss, so no structural mechanism addresses the criterion (reading 4.2.5) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: public limits rejected; the tort remedy cannot reach the criterion's quantities + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: not shown. by the entry's scope decision the framework is a compass, not a map, and commits to no mechanism, so a cut in the emissions of the places that adopt it is those places' own policy, not credited to a framework whose sources do not specify it, as part (b6) found for C4.1's carbon clause (reading 3.4) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: not shown. biodiversity breakdown is one of the nine boundaries of the framework's ecological ceiling, and its authors' monitoring measures the world's overshoot of it; the ceiling is a goalpost the economy should respect, and no projection of pressure on species or habitat under the design is stated, modelled or located (reading 3.3) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. the national doughnut accounts compare consumption-based footprints with per-person boundaries as a diagnosis; by the scope decision no reduction of extraction to regeneration is delivered by the framework or estimated for its adopters +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: cleared. incorporated as a hard structural design element + +Read in part (b7) (Session 47). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-2) + +1. *Consumption-based carbon emissions falling ≥3.8% a year*: short. short: the Soviet territories' emissions rose from 1446 Mt in 1960 to 3935 Mt in 1988 (1.54% a year in 1980 to 1988), 2.7 times in 28 years, on the territorial measure (consumption accounts begin in 1990) (reading 4.2.1) +2. *biodiversity neutral or positive*: short. short: the irrigation plan for the Amu Darya and Syr Darya halved the Aral Sea and ended its fishery, most of its native fish species lost, the defining case of the planned economy's pressure on habitat (reading 4.2.2) +3. *resource extraction ≤ regeneration*: not shown. not shown: the footprint accounts carry the USSR to 1991, but the figure was not cached (reading 4.2.3) +4. *no more than two of the four nationally downscaled planetary boundaries transgressed*: not shown. not shown: the downscaled boundary accounts begin in 1992 (reading 4.2.4) + +Why 0.0 stands: the plan's gross-output targets drove extensive growth in throughput with no absolute limit, emissions rising every decade to the collapse and the Aral Sea destroyed by the plan itself; the emission norms of 1980 were overridden by the plan (reading 4.2.5; D29(a), the same pattern across the Eastern Bloc's planned economies) + +Read in group 2.10 (Session 64) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: far below on the clauses read, the plan's own logic expanding throughput + +### C4.3 Group Equity + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years, convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years, on each declared axis, non-citizen residents included. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 4 at 0.0. v1: 7 at 1.0, 13 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, universal provision that addresses disparities without stigma, is the phrase re-read for Universal Basic Income: access to the benefit, not a fall in a gap; targeting disadvantaged communities first, with 150%+ proportional benefits during rollout, is a benefit flow, which v2.0's measurement counts as evidence for the trajectory, not a separate test, and it states no gap or rate; the design's published model represents no groups, and its research hub projects no gap; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, trafficking vulnerability eliminated through unconditional security, is an outcome on another measure, not the path of a household income gap, and aesthetic multipliers that value historically devalued creative work are a mechanism; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: short. the entry's own text names immigrant and minority communities, so immigrant background is a declared axis, read by country of birth and by citizenship (non-EU against natives or nationals); in each of the four countries a gap above 20% falls by less than 5 points in five years on both measures: {ROWS} (three-year means, 2023-2025 against 2018-2020; the trend is the least-squares fit over the ten editions, per five years) (reading 3.4) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, the strongest performance on gender equity globally, claims the gender axis, not the immigrant axis the entry's text declares; on the ten-edition trends the immigrant-axis gaps above 20% reach 20% by {LAST} except Denmark's by citizenship, whose trend rises ({DKTREND} points per five years) although its three-year mean fell; series this noisy do not establish a convergence trajectory (reading 3.4) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the cooperative structure's equity effects are mixed by the entry's own account (some cooperatives prioritise equity, others replicate societal biases); pay compression within a firm bears on gaps between groups but is not a projection of them; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, effort-based remuneration that addresses the devaluation of care work, is a remuneration rule: it ties income to effort, sacrifice and need, but the gaps that would result between groups depend on hours, need allowances and household composition, and no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. balanced job complexes and democratic participation are institutions, not an estimate of the gap's path; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the white paper, published after the corpus scored the design, adds what the review's document lacked: the contribution system is checked so that 'no person or demographic group is structurally disadvantaged', its rules carry 'protected-category adjustments', the deliberation system's analysis has a fairness layer of distributional effects, and detected access inequity amends a decision; but 'equity is not enforced through redistribution', no rule addresses a historical disparity, and the design's income is non-monetary contribution credit; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. Alaska's dividend, flat per resident, reduces poverty proportionally more for rural Alaska Natives, but the Native-non-Native poverty ratio, about 2.5, has not closed over the dividend's forty years, and the host economy's gaps are not credited to the mechanism (protocol 3.2); no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. participatory exclusion of women, Indigenous and landless users is documented across settings, and so are working remedies inside the mechanism (India's Joint Forest Management quotas) and collective tenure for some 370 million Indigenous people; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag kept + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, universal provision that addresses disparities without stigma, describes access to the benefit, not a fall in a gap; a flat payment narrows percentage gaps once, when it is introduced, which is not a reduction every five years; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. care work made viable without market employment is a mechanism; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, explicitly confronting structural inequalities, is a commitment; decolonial and feminist-economic aims and care valued equally with production are goals and means, and no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the Citizen's Dividend is universal and flat, which narrows percentage gaps once, by its form; land assessment carries a documented racial bias in current U.S. practice, which no Georgist proposal located corrects; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the contracts' terms are the same whoever signs, formal equality without a reparative mechanism; the documented gaps are in participation (women's uptake of Islamic microfinance and wealth management in Malaysia), not on the measure; the host economy's gaps are not credited to the mechanism (protocol 3.2); no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds on the owner-confirmed scope (Session 22, D5) and the 0.5 band's 'formal equality without reparative mechanisms' (reading 3.2); the published flag kept; it alone could change the entry's tier + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. time banking values care work, which bears on the gender axis, and Grassroots Economics reaches low-income non-white communities, but a long-running UK scheme's membership was overwhelmingly white in a diverse area; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: short. on the ethnic axis the entry's text declares, Malay households have the lowest median household market income and Indian households the highest: the gap is 35.9% in 2025 against 32.1% in 2020, +3.8 points in five years; per household member, against Chinese households, the highest, 43.6% against 41.7% (+1.9); the gap widened, so clause 1 is short (reading 3.4) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: short. a gap that widened over the one five-year interval the survey gives is not on a trajectory toward 20%; the entry's own record has Malay per-member incomes growing fastest from 2010 to 2020 (census), so the decade before ran the other way, and two intervals with opposite signs establish no trajectory (reading 3.4) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds: a group-directed, government-funded mechanism in force (the Tertiary Tuition Fee Subsidy for Malays, means-tested, since 1991), the 2025 Workplace Fairness Act, and a mixed record over 15 years (reading 3.4); the published flag t + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: short. on the race and Hispanic origin axis the entry's text declares, the least advantaged group is Black households and the most advantaged Asian households, whose median exceeds the white non-Hispanic median in every year 2002-2025; the gap is 52.1% in 2023-2025 against 52.6% in 2018-2020 (-0.5), trend +0.2 per five years over the ten editions, and 52.5% in 2025 against 44.8% in 2002; the gap against white non-Hispanic households, the comparison the entry's own text draws, is 37.9% against 40.2% (-2.3), trend -2.3 (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: short. no trajectory toward 20%: the Black-white non-Hispanic gap has stayed between 34.8% and 44.7% in all 53 editions since 1972 (42.5% in 1972, 38.0% in 2025), and the Black-Asian gap widened by 7.7 points from 2002 to 2025; at the long-run rate the 20% level is not reached within 30 years on either comparison (reading 3.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: the best evidence shows performance far below the threshold with no credible pathway under the system's own logic (protocol 2.1): on the measure v2.0 names the gap between the least and most advantaged groups is above 50% and wider than in 2002, the Black-white gap has not left the band of 35% to 45% in 53 years, and the system's group-directed remedies are being withdrawn (race-conscious admissions in 2023, federal contractors' affirmative action in 2025); the 0.0 band's own example + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. A correction (reading 3.3): the published 0.5 rests on 'some progress over decades', which the measure does not show; it resolves the inconsistency logged since Handoff 30, the 0.0 band's example published at 0.5 + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. universal non-means-tested provision removes a documented channel of racially disparate stigma, and Quebec's universal childcare raised mothers' employment, which bears on the gender axis; no reparative mechanism and a documented rollout-equity concern in the closest precedent; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, eliminating discrimination in hiring through the government as employer of last resort, is a process; the programme's proponents argue that it would effectively eliminate the racial unemployment gap and set an economy-wide floor on compensation, but a gap in unemployment is not a gap in median household income, and no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. the rationale's care and community-service jobs address gendered devaluation of labour, a mechanism; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any declared axis is stated, modelled or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. universal abundance narrows material gaps by its form, but governance and historical inequities are unaddressed by the entry's account; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. diversity initiatives and hiring targets are group-directed but address representation, not household income gaps, and the host economy's gaps are not credited to the mechanism (protocol 3.2); no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds: a group-directed mechanism of partial reach (reading 3.2); flagged now + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. no national household survey publishes median household income by ethnic group (the National Bureau of Statistics publishes by urban and rural residence and by region), so no gap on the ethnic axis can be measured, as for Centrally Planned Socialism (part (b8), reading 3.5) (reading 3.5) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. no series exists from which a convergence on the ethnic axis could be projected; top-level gender representation has fallen since 2022 (reading 3.5) + +Why 0.0 stands: the system excludes the criterion's concern for the minorities most affected (protocol 2.1): coercive state action targeting them, which the UN human rights office found may constitute crimes against humanity, and an assimilationist ethnic law of 2026, a harm beyond the formal neutrality of the 0.0 band + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0 holds + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the 2012/13 household survey reports average monthly household income of QR 72,700 for Qatari households and QR 24,400 for non-Qatari households, a gap of 66.4% on means, with workers in collective housing outside the survey; one survey gives no rate (reading 3.5) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. no series is located from which a convergence on the citizenship axis could be projected (reading 3.5) + +Why 0.0 stands: the system excludes the criterion's concern (protocol 2.1): rights and rent-funded benefits are allocated by nationality to the most advantaged legal group, the reverse of the flow the criterion asks for, and v2.0's scope counts the non-citizen residents, most of the population, whom the allocation excludes + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. formal equality before the law only: the minimal state's functions exclude any corrective measure, and no mechanism bears on a gap between groups; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: the system excludes the criterion's concern (protocol 2.1): its own logic confines the state to protecting rights and rules out any corrective flow, so historical disparities persist unchallenged, as its rationale says + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. gender equality is one of the social foundation's twelve dimensions and unpaid care work is engaged directly, which bears on the gender axis; no reparative mechanism for racial disparities is located; no projection of the gap between groups' median household incomes on any axis, from a model or calibrated components, is stated or located, so neither the rate nor the convergence is shown (part (b8), reading 3.3) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. as for clause 1: no projection of the gap's path is stated or located (part (b8), reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.8 (Session 61). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-3) + +1. *Disparity reduction ≥5 percentage points every 5 years*: not shown. the rationale is silent on the rate, as the audit found; the Soviet statistics office did not publish the size distribution of household income from the 1920s until 1989, and then by republic only for 1988 and 1990, two years apart, so no source can show a gap between nationalities' median household incomes falling 5 points in five years; the 1988 distributions show the southern republics' per capita household incomes well below the northern ones' (reading 3.5) +2. *convergence trajectory toward <20% disparities within 30 years*: not shown. the audited phrase, women's high labour force participation, education and leadership roles, is an outcome on another measure, not a trajectory of household income gaps; for the same reason no series by nationality exists from which a convergence could be projected (readings 3.2 and 3.5) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +### C4.4 Power Distribution + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions, removal/replacement mechanisms functional. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 3 at 1.0, 15 at 0.5, 5 at 0.0. v1: 6 at 1.0, 7 at 0.5, 10 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: not shown. the audited phrase, CIP provides direct democratic power, does not claim the defined condition, so the clause is estimated: CIP administers the currency and manages democratic voting for the Public Trust Housing and Public Trust Foundation decisions, and the Public Trust Foundations (grocers, restaurants, utilities and transit accepting basic units) are governed democratically by employees, customers and community representatives; but the design's sources say this network coexists with private markets rather than replacing them and complements rather than displaces private operations, its corporate paper describes a shift from shareholder to stakeholder models without saying who would elect the boards of transformed corporations, and the participation figures it states are for housing (a 50% market share target) and for merchants within designated zones (55% before synergy effects activate), not for employment; no source states or projects that the accountable organizations would employ 80% of workers +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. as part (b7) recorded: Public Trust Housing leadership has term limits, mandatory rotation and recall elections, and the merit juries are selected at random and rotated + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. V-Dem's Regimes of the World classes Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden as liberal democracies, so their public sectors count; on the most generous count (all of general government, every central-government state-owned enterprise, the self-employed, and every cooperative, mutual, association and foundation) the share of employment in organizations whose decisions answer to those they affect is at most {DK} in Denmark, {FI} in Finland and {SE} in Sweden, and {NO} in Norway before its social economy, which would have to employ {NOGAP} of workers, {RATIO} times the highest share in the EU-28 ({SEMAX}); the rest work in companies whose boards shareholders elect, employees electing a minority (Sweden two or three members, a quarter to a third of the board; Norway and Denmark a third; Finland as agreed, in companies of 150 or more); short of 80% in each, by at least {GAP} points (decision 48.3(d)) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. parliamentary removal functions: Sweden's prime minister lost a confidence vote on 21 June 2021, as part (a) found + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48). + +**Market Socialism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: cleared. the audited phrase, economic power distributed through democratic ownership, claims the defined condition: the system places enterprises in the ownership of those who work in them and removes the employer-employee hierarchy, and in its principal component each cooperative's worker-members elect the governing council, one member one vote, and can dismiss it in general assembly (all of the system's employment) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. as part (b7) recorded: administrators serve two to five years and the general assembly may dismiss them and elect their replacements in the same session + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The outside reader's reading: the design's family includes variants (Lange and Lerner's state firms, Roemer's coupon boards) that place firm control elsewhere (protocol 4.2) + +**Participatory Economics: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: cleared. the audited phrase, comprehensive economic democracy, claims the defined condition: the model has no owners of capital and no managerial hierarchy, places all production in workers' councils that decide by their members' votes and all consumption in consumers' councils, and federations of councils they elect decide wider matters, so the investment, production and employment decisions of every workplace are taken by those who work there or by those they elect (all of the design's employment) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. as part (b7) recorded: workers' and consumers' councils elect recallable and rotated representatives to their federations + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48). + +**Integral: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: cleared. the audited phrase, broad democratic accountability, claims the defined condition: the design delegates no managerial authority, decisions are taken by participants in CDS at every scale with local autonomy preserved, production is coordinated by rotating teams that coordinate rather than command, and ITC's non-accumulability keeps wealth from converting into power, so the investment, production and employment decisions are taken by those they affect (all of the design's employment) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. as part (b7) recorded: decisions taken in CDS can be reaffirmed, amended, revoked or reopened by its review module, and no managerial authority is delegated + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: the fund manages a portfolio of minority stakes and votes as a shareholder; it governs no organization's employment decisions beyond its own (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2); the fund answers to the host's parliament + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. short: within a commons the appropriators make and revise the rules (design principle 3), so its decisions are accountable; generalised to every common-pool resource it can govern, the commons employ a small share of an economy's workers and the mechanism governs no firm (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach beyond the commons: within it monitors are accountable to the appropriators or drawn from them (design principle 4), but generalised it governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: an unconditional income strengthens the power to refuse work (exit, C2.5's), but places no decision with those it affects (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a transfer mechanism that governs neither quantity (D28(c)) + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: not shown. on decision 48.3's measure as on part (b7)'s reading: the rationale names decentralisation, wealth caps, cooperative ownership and democratic governance, and degrowth research holds the forms of democracy compatible with degrowth to need additional study; no source states or projects the share of employment degrowth would place in organizations whose decisions answer to those they affect +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: not shown. as part (b7) recorded: no mechanism of the entry's own for removing or replacing those who hold decision-making authority is specified or located + +Read in decision 48.3 (Session 48). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: the tax captures land rent and the dividend distributes it; neither governs who takes the decisions of the organizations in which people work (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: the contracts set the terms of finance, not the governance of the firm; where they give voice (musharaka) it follows the capital contributed, and investment account holders have no governance rights (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: a financing mechanism that governs neither quantity (D28(c)) + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: the network's members govern the network and its credit limits, but it places no organization's investment, production or employment decisions (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. far short: Singapore is an electoral autocracy (Regimes of the World 1 throughout 2014 to 2025), so the public sector and the government-linked companies do not count; self-employment is 12.7% (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: short. short: multiparty elections are held and the opposition wins votes and seats (34.4% of the vote and the Workers' Party's 10 of 97 seats in 2025), but V-Dem does not rate them free and fair, and the party has governed since 1959 (reading 4.4.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, read by reading 4.4.3: no free elections (V-Dem's electoral autocracy throughout 2014 to 2025) and no member control, with clause 1 far short (the public sector not counted, self-employment 12.7%) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the blind reading's own 4.4.3 conditions hold + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. far short on the most generous count: the United States is an electoral democracy in 2025 (Regimes of the World 2), so government counts, 14.8% of nonfarm payrolls; self-employment is 6.1%; nonprofits (about a tenth of private employment) and cooperatives (about 2 million jobs) counted in, the share stays near a third; the rest work in enterprises whose boards their owners elect (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. cleared: legislators and executives are removable in free multiparty elections (Regimes of the World 3 to 2024, 2 in 2025) (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: political removal functions; economic decisions answer to owners for two thirds of employment + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. short: generalised to every service it provides (health, education, care, housing, transport, information), its public and community providers answer to elected authorities where the host is a democracy, but they employ a minority of the workforce, far from 80%, and participatory governance is proposed, not specified (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2); the services' governance is the host's + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: out of reach. out of reach: the job guarantee's jobs are run by local governments, nonprofits and community bodies, but the programme employs only the buffer of those who lack work and governs no other organization's decisions (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no removal of legislators, executives or managers (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: not shown. not shown: the design calls for public ownership of energy and data and for municipal and cooperative enterprise, but states no share of employment in accountable organizations (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. cleared: the design is pursued through elections ('luxury populism') within a liberal democracy, whose removal mechanisms it keeps (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: electoral removal kept; the ownership programme is not quantified + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. short: the reform widens boards' duties to stakeholders but leaves boards elected by owners; even parity codetermination gives the shareholder-side chair the casting vote, so the board answers to owners in the definition's sense (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. cleared, on the host's institutions, which the reform leaves unmodified: free elections remove legislators and executives (Regimes of the World 2, United States 2025) (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: the host's political removal; boards still answer to owners + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. far short: China is a closed autocracy (Regimes of the World 0 throughout), so neither public administration nor the state-owned enterprises count; self-employment is 37.7% of employment in 2025 (falling from 41.0% in 2016), and the collectives' and enterprises' leaders are appointed through the Party's cadre system (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: short. short: no free elections; the Party's leadership is constitutional (article 1), and neither legislators nor executives can be removed by those they govern (reading 4.4.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: the Party-state concentrates decision-making in a narrow group whose removal by those it governs its own constitution excludes, with clause 1 far short (reading 4.4.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. far short: Qatar is a closed autocracy (Regimes of the World 0 throughout), so the public sector does not count; self-employment is 0.8% of employment, the migrant majority of the workforce employed in owner-governed firms (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: short. short: the Emir is hereditary; the Shura Council's elected seats (2021) were abolished by the 2024 referendum, so no decision-maker is removable by those governed (reading 4.4.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: hereditary rule with no removal mechanism, and clause 1 far short (reading 4.4.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. short: the minimal state places the economy's work in privately owned enterprises governed by their owners, and its sources state no share of employment in accountable organizations; public employment shrinks to protection and courts (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: cleared. cleared: the minimal state remains an elected constitutional government, its legislators and executives removable at elections (reading 4.4.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: not shown. not shown: 'Design to Distribute' offers cooperatives, commons and employee ownership as a menu, not an adopted design, and no share of employment is stated (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: not shown. not shown: the framework specifies no institutions of removal; its city portraits sit in elected municipal governments, which are the host's, not the design's (reading 4.4.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion -- the framework adopts no ownership or governance design and specifies no institution of removal (the scoring document's scope decision) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the blind reading's own clause estimates found no mechanism adopted, which 2.1's first condition scores 0.0 + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-4) + +1. *Democratic accountability for ≥80% of major decisions*: short. far short: the Soviet Union was a closed autocracy (Regimes of the World 0 in every year from 1922 to 1990), so the state sector does not count; collective-farm chairmen were nominated by the district Party committee, enterprise directors appointed by their ministries, and private and cooperative work outside the collective farms was marginal until 1988 (reading 4.4.1) +2. *removal/replacement mechanisms functional*: short. short: no free elections; the nomenklatura appointed and removed decision-makers from above (reading 4.4.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: the planning hierarchy concentrated decisions in the Party's nomenklatura, removable only from above, with clause 1 far short (reading 4.4.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 73. + +### C4.5 Exploitation Elimination + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Extraction rates <10% GDP, genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships. Revision class D (clauses deleted only). + +v2.0: 3 at 1.0, 13 at 0.5, 7 at 0.0. v1: 6 at 1.0, 10 at 0.5, 7 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: Public Trust Housing turns 70-80% of a renter's payment into equity and Public Trust Foundations run essential businesses on a not-for-profit model, removing the owner's and landlord's share where they operate; the design coexists with private markets ('without ... the dismantling of private markets'), projects Public Trust Housing at 15-20% of the market within a decade, and taxes labour exploitation at a higher corporate rate rather than removing it (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: Basic Units, about $1,200 an adult a month, opt-in and restricted to essentials, and the pay-in pathway out of renting with no deposit or credit check, are real exits where they reach; at the projected reach of the housing trusts and with a floor near the poverty line, leaving an employer, landlord or lender is not assured for the population the design serves (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: one minus the labour share of GDP is 38.0% in Denmark, 42.9% in Finland, 47.1% in Norway (40.9% net of resource rents) and 44.3% in Sweden (2019), and the labour share in the SDG series is 57.0%, 54.3% and 51.7% in 2024 (Denmark, Finland, Sweden): around the United States' 40.3%, Denmark a little below and the others above; collective bargaining, codetermination and tenant law regulate the terms of the three relationships, none is removed (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short, but near: universal health care and social assistance do not depend on a job, unemployment insurance pays a voluntary quitter after a bounded suspension (in Sweden 45 benefit days, Lag 1997:238, 43 b), and tenants hold security of tenure; the floor is conditional on seeking work, so leaving wage employment as such carries a penalty (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: not shown. not shown: in worker cooperatives the surplus goes to the worker-members, removing the employer-employee transfer for them; rent to private landlords and interest to banks remain, which on US proportions would be about 5.7% of GDP, but the exemplar hires non-member workers in its subsidiaries, and the design projects no economy-wide rate (readings 4.5.1, 2.3(b)) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: a member may leave with the capital account repaid, and the group's mutual insurance pays unemployment support and relocates members between cooperatives; tenancy and credit have no exit beyond the market's (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Participatory Economics: 1.0** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: cleared. cleared, projected: no private ownership of productive assets, so no profit, rent or interest income accrues to owners; households' budgets are an effort rating plus any allowance, and production and investment are set in the participatory plan (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: cleared. cleared: the design keeps no employer, landlord or creditor; besides the effort-rated budget it provides allowances for those excused from production and a consumption allowance for people who do not want to work, in effect an unconditional basic income (Wright's statement of the procedure, which Hahnel's reply keeps as effort rating plus any allowance), so subsistence does not depend on any relationship (reading 4.5.2, as part (b8) read Integral and FALC) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Integral: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: cleared. removes employer-employee extraction +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: cleared. the design has no employer, landlord or creditor: housing is community-controlled, production cooperative, and ITC credits cannot be borrowed, lent or accrue interest; a participant can leave a team or a node, contribution in one node is recognised for access in another, basic needs are accessible below standard contribution thresholds with a need-based adjustment for caregiving and health constraints, and a participant can leave the federation without penalty (reading 3.6) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Read as requiring that a participant able to contribute who declines all contribution keep access to basic needs, the design does not show the clause: basic needs are accessible below standard contribution thresholds, which the design's sou + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: the fund holds a share of the capital stock and returns its income to the public, by budget rule or dividend, so part of the transfer to owners is publicly appropriated; the relationships in the economy it is layered onto and in the firms it owns are unmodified, and Norway's non-labour share is 47.1% of GDP (40.9% net of resource rents, 2019) (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: Alaska's dividend is universal but small, Norway's model pays none; no exit from employment, tenancy or credit follows (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition, read with reading 4.5.3: the fund removes no extractive relationship -- it neither regulates nor displaces the employment, tenancy and credit relations of the economy it is layered onto or of the firms it owns -- and redistributes part of the proceeds + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the blind reading's own clause estimates found every relationship unmodified, which reading 4.5.3 scores 0.0 + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: generalised, appropriators governing a common-pool resource pay no rent to an outside owner, and community land trusts (in scope, D31) remove the landlord's land rent for residents; the transfer to employers and lenders elsewhere in the economy is not governed (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: a land-trust resident holds a long ground lease and leaves with a share of the equity; commoners hold membership; no floor or alternative for employment or credit (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: out of reach. the economy-wide extraction share is not governed by an income transfer +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: cleared. an exit option from exploitative work + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: cleared. removes profit motive for extraction +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: not shown. universal basic services secure housing, healthcare, education and transport, but for employment the entry specifies reduced hours and work-sharing, not an income floor or an assured alternative, and its own C2.2 rationale says the design does not fully decouple survival from employment, so exit from an employment relationship without penalty is not shown (reading 3.6) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Read as the entry's C2.1 rationale reads its universal basic services, as eliminating survival coercion, exit from employment would be genuine; the services it names cover housing, healthcare, education and transport, not food or income, an + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: generalised, the land value tax captures land rent up to its full rental value, removing the landlord's share of the land flow, but rent on buildings, profit and interest, which George's design treats as earned returns, stay at the host economy's level, far above 10% of GDP (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: the citizen's dividend is unconditional, but the transfers located are a small fraction of a basic-needs budget, so leaving an employer, landlord or lender is not made survivable by it (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: generalised, the prohibition of interest replaces the loan with profit-and-loss sharing and sale-based contracts, but wage employment and rent (ijara) are permitted, and the fixed-return modes (markup sale, tawarruq) are more than 70% of financing in Malaysia and the Middle East, so the lender's return continues in another form (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: a debtor in hardship is owed respite and late-payment charges go to charity, a real limit on the creditor's hold; exit from employment and tenancy is the host's (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: profit-and-loss sharing is a genuine mechanism on the creditor-debtor relationship (reading 4.5.3) + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: generalised, credit created at zero balance and zero interest between members removes the lender's interest on the credit it replaces; the transfer to employers and landlords is not governed by the mechanism and stays the host's (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: an interest-free credit line is an assured alternative to borrowing from a lender, within its limit, but it gives no exit from employment or tenancy (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: one minus the labour share is 56.1% of GDP (2019), the highest of the configured economies after Qatar; the state owns most land and sells 99-year HDB leases at subsidised prices, so 77.2% of resident households (2025) pay no private landlord, while the transfer to the owners of government-linked and foreign firms and to lenders remains (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: residents may quit, with a jobseeker support scheme since 2025 for involuntary job loss only; Work Permit holders, about a quarter of the workforce, need the current employer's consent to transfer outside a window before the permit expires, and are outside HDB (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: HDB removes the private landlord for most residents, a structural mechanism on one relationship type (reading 4.5.3) + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: one minus the labour share is 40.3% of GDP (2019); on the narrow count corporate profits, rental income and net interest are 18.7% of GDP in 2025 (13.0%, 3.7% and 2.0%), up from 14.8% in 2000; each of the three relationships is in place and none is removed (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. far short: at-will employment gives the formal right to quit, but leaving is not survivable without another job: every state disqualifies a voluntary quit from unemployment insurance, 53.5% of people hold employment-based health insurance (2025), and tenancy and consumer credit carry no exit beyond the market's (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, third condition: performance far below the threshold on both clauses -- extraction four times the bar on the broad count and nearly twice on the narrow, and rising; exit no more than the formal right to quit -- with no rule or instrument in the configuration that removes an extractive relationship or moves the rate toward 10% (reading 4.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: generalised, housing, health, education and transport provided free or decommodified remove the landlord's rent for those housed and much borrowing for education and health; the transfer to employers is not governed (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: services in kind make losing a job less ruinous but give no income, so leaving wage employment is not survivable on them alone (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: the job guarantee's living wage sets a floor under private wages and raises workers' bargaining power; ownership, rent and lending stay the host's (readings 4.5.1, 4.5.4) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: the guaranteed public job is an assured alternative to an extractive employer that is not itself extractive; tenancy and credit have none (reading 4.5.2) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: cleared. Eliminates labor exploitation +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: cleared. the design provides universal material provision, housing included, through automated production and makes labour an optional hobby rather than a survival requirement, so no one depends on an employment, tenancy or credit relationship for subsistence (reading 3.6) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.5, down). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: the entry keeps shareholder ownership and wage employment and adds voluntary consideration of stakeholders and ESG metrics, which change neither the transfer to owners nor rent or interest; in the market economy it reforms the narrow count is 18.7% of GDP (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. far short: exit is the host market economy's, the formal right to quit with no floor added; the entry specifies no exit from employment, tenancy or credit (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, third condition: far below on both clauses with no pathway under the system's own logic -- the entry is voluntary corporate responsibility within the market framework, which leaves every extractive relationship in place, and Bebchuk and Tallarita (2020) found the 2019 Business Roundtable statement largely unaccompanied by changes in its signatories' corporate governance (reading 4.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: one minus the labour share is 41.4% of GDP (2019); urban land is state-owned and rural land collective, but the state takes the land rent only as the lease premium at sale: the 70-year use right leaves later gains in land value, the bulk of two decades' rise, with private holders, landlords included; profit, interest to state banks and private housing rent remain, and the state's share of the surplus is extraction relocated (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. far short: a worker may quit, but unemployment insurance covers about a third of the employed (245.89 million insured, end of 2024), the minimum living guarantee is means-tested and thin, household registration ties services to place, no union independent of the Party may organise, and the US Department of Labor lists goods made with state-organised forced labour in Xinjiang (2022) (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, third condition: far below on both clauses -- the transfer to private and state owners in place, state-organised coerced labour among its forms, no independent bargaining -- with no rule or instrument in the configuration that removes an extractive relationship (reading 4.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the blind reading's 0.5 rested on public capture of land rent, which holds only for the lease premium; the published reading's evidence of state-organised coerced labour, which the blind reading did not weigh, is extraction the configu + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. far short: one minus the labour share is 82.4% of GDP (2019); net of natural-resource rents (22.4% of GDP) it is still 60.0%; the migrant majority's wages are set by a sponsorship market, and the rent the state captures is distributed to citizens, about an eighth of residents (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. far short for the population the protocol counts (residents, non-citizens included, protocol 3.2): since 2020 a migrant worker may change employer without a No Objection Certificate (348,450 changes, November 2020 to August 2022, against about 18,000 in 2019), but residence depends on employment, recruitment debt is widespread and the ILO records retaliation by employers; citizens' floor (public employment, housing loans) covers about 12% of residents (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, third condition: far below on both clauses for the residents the configuration counts -- the non-labour share is the corpus's highest even net of resource rents, the low-wage migrant majority is load-bearing for the configuration, and its exit stops at changing sponsor -- with no rule or instrument in the configuration that removes an extractive relationship (reading 4.5.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.0** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. short: no mechanism limits extraction; the design treats voluntary exchange as non-exploitative by definition and keeps every relationship type (employer and employee, landlord and tenant, lender and borrower) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. short: exit is the formal right to quit, with no subsistence floor and no assured alternative + +Why 0.0 stands: reading 4.5.3's 0.0 line (protocol 2.1): far below on both clauses, every relationship type in place, exit no more than the formal right to quit, and no rule or instrument that removes one, as for Status Quo + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Parts (a) and (b8)'s reading: both clauses not shown, held at 0.5 under D28(f) + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: not shown. not shown: the framework's 'design to distribute' names redistribution of land, enterprise, money creation, technology and knowledge, with land value taxes, employee ownership and commons as examples, but fixes no mechanism and projects no rate (reading 4.5.1) +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: not shown. not shown: no floor or assured alternative is specified (reading 4.5.2) + +Why 0.0 stands: protocol 2.1, first condition: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion -- the framework names distributive directions but commits to none, and its implementations in over 50 jurisdictions operate as an overlay on the host's property, employment and credit relations (published reading) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the blind reading's own text found no mechanism, which reading 4.5.3 requires for 0.5 + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-5) + +1. *Extraction rates <10% GDP*: short. surplus appropriated by the state rather than private owners: extraction continued, to another appropriator, with nothing placing it below 10% of GDP, as part (a) found +2. *genuine exit rights from exploitative relationships*: short. exit from employment was penalised: the 1977 Constitution made conscientious work the duty of every able-bodied citizen and declared evasion of socially useful work incompatible with socialist society, and the RSFSR's decree of 4 May 1961 on persons avoiding socially useful work punished it (reading 3.6) + +Read in part (b8) (Session 49). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. State appropriation read as structural, load-bearing extraction, the 0.0 band's own test (part (a)) + +### C4.6 Harm Internalization + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years; those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed; regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more). Revision class N (new criterion). + +v2.0: 0 at 1.0, 22 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. New in v2.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the CIP paper names regulatory capture (Stigler) as the problem it answers, with FDA and EPA among its examples, but provides for elected officials, campaign finance and the Judicial Guard, not for the bodies that regulate food, water, air, chemicals and medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: DNK 51.3 to 23.5, FIN 19.1 to 7.7, NOR 28.0 to 8.3, SWE 23.2 to 7.4 per 100,000 (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the law in force makes polluters liable -- Denmark's Environmental Damage Compensation Act ('shall compensate the damage the pollution causes', section 3, save damage due to compliance with an authority's mandatory rules, a defence the clause may read as an immunity), Sweden's Environmental Code (chapter 32), Finland's Environmental Damage Compensation Act (liability 'even when the damage was not caused intentionally or negligently', section 7); Norway's act was not reached -- before courts Freedom House scores 4 of 4, but no claim decided against those who caused the harm and paid within the window is named in the cache for any of the four (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: cleared. cleared in each of the four: DNK 0.97, FIN 0.97, NOR 0.99, SWE 0.92, above 0.77 (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 0.5: mortality falling, regulation clean, strict liability in force; no claim record named + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2); Roemer argues that public bads such as pollution would be set lower because the rich would not dominate the political decision, a political-economy argument, not a liability provision +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no provision for the bodies that regulate food, water, air, chemicals and medicines or their independence (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: cleared. cleared: a community of affected parties decides how much of each pollutant may be emitted, the emitting council pays the damage price as a cost of production, and the affected receive credit for the damage they suffer: a compensation scheme funded by those who cause the harm, collective and controlled by those harmed (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the community of affected parties is advised by scientists in R&D units it runs, which is independence of the harmed from the harm-causers for pollution; regulation of food, water, chemicals and medicines is not addressed (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Integral: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: ecological impact signals raise the access value of harmful goods, and design constraints bar high-impact production from scaling: harm is made a cost through valuation, not liability, and no compensation of those harmed is stated (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: designs pass peer review and safety analysis with thresholds set by node or federation policy, under 'collective oversight'; the reviewers' independence from producers is not stated (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2); the Council on Ethics recommends excluding companies that cause severe environmental damage, a cost through divestment, not liability to those harmed +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: community-managed water systems lie within a commons' reach (unsafe water is one of the clause's harms), and no source measures their effect on mortality (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: graduated sanctions and local conflict-resolution arenas make a rule-breaker answer to the other users (principles 5 and 6), but the sources describe sanctions for overuse, not compensation of those harmed (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: monitors are the users or accountable to them (principle 4), so the regulated regulate themselves; the sources do not show the independence of those they regulate that the clause asks for (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2); harmful production is to be capped, scaled down or ended (planned obsolescence) by democratic decision (Hickel 2020, ch. 5) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no provision for the bodies that regulate food, water, air, chemicals and medicines or their independence (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2); charges on pollution as rent for the commons are not paired with the tax in the design scored (extension test, decision D31) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2); financing excludes prohibited activities, not harm as such +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: SGP 27.5 to 24.3 per 100,000 (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: short. short: Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1); no liability statute or claim record was read (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: cleared. cleared: SGP 0.94, above 0.77 (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: USA 33.8 to 15.7 per 100,000 (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: short. short: liability for releases is strict under CERCLA ('notwithstanding any other provision or rule of law') and claims run before courts Freedom House scores 3 of 4 on F1, but the PREP Act makes a covered person 'immune from suit and liability under Federal and State law' for loss from a declared countermeasure, the only remedy being a fund of 'emergency appropriations' that is 'exclusive of any other civil action': a class of harm compensated from public funds alone (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: cleared. cleared: USA 0.87, above 0.77 (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1); it provides services, not a rule on pollution +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no source of the pollution harms the clause counts (reading 4.6.1); job-guarantee projects may include environmental remediation, public work rather than a rule on those who cause harm +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no harm-causing activity's liability (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: out of reach. out of reach: the mechanism governs no regulator of food, water, air, chemicals or medicines (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no provision for the bodies that regulate food, water, air, chemicals and medicines or their independence (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1); the stakeholder metrics ask companies to disclose emissions of fine particulates and oxides of sulphur and nitrogen, 'a leading cause of ill-health and premature death' +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2); the Davos Manifesto asks companies to act as 'a steward of the environmental and material universe', with disclosure voluntary and liability left to the host's law +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: companies are asked to disclose their lobbying positions and any difference from their purpose; nothing is stated for the regulators themselves (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: CHN 144.7 to 127.5 per 100,000 (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: short. short: the Civil Code makes those who cause damage by pollution liable (article 1229) and lets organs of the state and organisations named by law claim restoration and compensation (articles 1234, 1235), but Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1), so the claims run before no independent court (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: short. short: CHN 0.61, below 0.77 (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: cleared. cleared: QAT 42.2 to 19.4 per 100,000 (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: short. short: Freedom House scores the judiciary's independence 1 of 4 (F1); the law in force was not reached (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: short. short: QAT 0.66, below 0.77 (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: 'Where damages can be proven and quantified in a court of law, restitution to the injured parties must be required' (2.2), and restitution falls on the negligent wrongdoer (1.7): liability enforceable by those harmed, but limited to damages proven and quantified, with no collective or representative claim for dispersed harm stated (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: short. short: occupational and other licensing is opposed in favour of voluntary certification (2.9) and medical products 'must be freely available in the marketplace without government restrictions or licenses' (2.13): regulation of medicines, and by the same principle of food and chemicals, is abolished, not freed of influence (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the sources project no pollution mortality for the economy they propose (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no liability of those who cause harm to those harmed (reading 4.6.2); Raworth (2017, ch. 6) calls for regenerative design and taxes on pollution, not for liability +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the sources state no provision for the bodies that regulate food, water, air, chemicals and medicines or their independence (reading 4.6.3) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76. + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (new in v2.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c4-6) + +1. *Mortality attributed to pollution non-increasing over 20 years*: not shown. not shown: the GBD's series begin in 1990, after the configuration's years (reading 4.6.1) +2. *those who cause harm to health or the environment liable for it, enforceably by those harmed*: not shown. not shown: no Soviet liability law or record of claims is in the cache; the state that owned the polluting enterprises 'was most often the agent of this pollution' (reading 4.6.2) +3. *regulation of food, water, air, chemicals and medicines applied and enforced without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a World Justice Project sub-factor 6.2 score of 0.77 or more)*: not shown. not shown: the Index does not cover the Soviet Union (reading 4.6.3) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism made harm a cost to whoever caused it: the state owned the polluting enterprises and there was no 'established regulatory agency' until the State Committee for the Protection of Nature in 1988, enforcement of the 1970s laws 'largely ignored' (reading 4.6.4) + +Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the polluter and the regulator one state, with no agency until 1988 + + +## Domain 5 + + +### C5.1 Proven Component Foundation + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants, with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits. Revision class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). + +v2.0: 2 at 1.0, 21 at 0.5, 0 at 0.0. v1: 13 at 1.0, 9 at 0.5, 1 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: not shown. the design's own site lists five components (CCO, PTF, PTH, SZH, CIP); the precedents the rationale cites cover three (CCO: WIR and Alaska's dividend; PTF and PTH: community land trusts); CIP's precedents, Consul (Madrid, 2015) and Decidim (Barcelona, 2016), have run for under twenty years, and none is cited for SZH: at most three of five (60%) are shown (reading 3.2) +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: cleared. the one benefit the rationale claims for a cited component is documented: at the end of 2010, 0.46% of community land trust mortgages were in foreclosure against 4.63% in the conventional market; Alaska's dividend's documented poverty reduction is recorded under UBI C5.1 above + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. decades of operation in Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Finland at national scale (populations of 5-10 million) +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the configuration's headline claims (near-universal material security; comprehensive security and dignity) are recorded short by the corpus's own amended scoring: housing cost overburden in 2024 at 14.6% in Denmark and 10.6% in Sweden, among the EU's highest (part (b), NSD C1.3), and about 6% of Finland's citizens' initiatives adopted (part (a), NSD C2.4); the rationale asserts validation without estimating a match (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Outcomes matched against the configuration's signature claims, low poverty and universal services, with the housing and initiative shortfalls read as outcomes on NEEC's thresholds rather than on the benefits the model claims + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. Mondragon: 70+ years at a scale far above 10,000 participants +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: short. the rationale claims 80,000+ worker-owners; in 2019 Mondragon's cooperatives employed over 81,000, of whom members were 32-45% depending on sector, with 18% of employment in subsidiaries abroad; the survival record is documented as 3 closures among the 103 cooperatives founded in 1956-1986, and the founding cooperative, Fagor Electrodomesticos, failed in 2013 + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Participatory budgeting exists in 3,000+ municipalities. Worker councils function in cooperatives. However, comprehensive parecon was never implemented nationally. Components proven separately but not as an integrated system. + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Individual components are well-evidenced — cybernetic theory (Ashby, Beer, the real if politically-terminated Project Cybersyn), cooperative organization (Mondragón's 70+ years and 97% five-year survival rate, 313 U.S. Community Land Trusts), and deliberation platforms (Decidim, Polis, Loomio) — but the document itself concedes the integration layer is untested: "None of this has to be invented from scratch. What needs to be built is the integration layer." No implementation of the full five-system architecture exists at any scale. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. Norway's fund since 1990 and Alaska's since 1976, both far above the scale bar +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. outcomes are mixed across the three implementations the rationale counts: Norway's fund matches its claims; Alaska's principal is preserved but its 2025 dividend was the smallest in real terms against a statutory formula above $3,800 (the entry's own C5.4); Timor-Leste has withdrawn above its sustainable income almost every year since 2008-09, and the IMF warns the fund could be exhausted by the late 2030s (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Timor-Leste weighed as a single implementation's shortfall (D29(a)), with Norway's and Alaska's funds preserved as the mechanism claims + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. Valencia's tribunal for about a thousand years; Nepal's programme with about 2.9 million households +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: cleared. the benefit claimed is that communities governed by these institutions sustain their resources: the three multi-case datasets the unit cites document it, and Cox, Arnold and Villamayor Tomas's review of 91 studies found the design principles well supported empirically; the survivorship caveat is scored where it changes the answer (C3.3, C5.2, C5.4), as the unit says + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**Universal Basic Income: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. Alaska Permanent Fund dividend: 40+ years, universal +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: cleared. the rationale claims cash transfers effective with positive outcomes, and the Report claims a 20% poverty reduction from Alaska's dividend (UBI C1.1): dividends cut Alaska's poverty rate by an estimated 2.5-4 points a year from 1990, lifting about 25,000 residents out of poverty in 2015, about a third, and from 11% to 9% across 2011-2015; the dividend has not reduced employment + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The documented outcomes are of a dividend of about $1,000-2,000 a year; no component precedent operates at the living-wage level at which the entry claims its benefits + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Components proven: cooperatives, time banks, community land trusts, transition towns. However, comprehensive degrowth was never implemented at national scale. Piecemeal validation but not system-level. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The individual components are unusually well-proven — LVT has 100+ years of continuous operation across multiple jurisdictions, and the Citizen's Dividend component has its own 40+-year precedent (Alaska PFD) already credited elsewhere in this Report. But the *specific* integration this evaluation scores — LVT as a primary revenue base paired with a universal dividend at near-single-tax intensity — has been tried and failed at least once in a directly relevant way: Britain's 1910 Land Value Duty (part of Lloyd George's "People's Budget") collapsed under valuation disputes and administrative costs reportedly running to roughly four times the revenue collected, and was eventually repealed. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. every named contract in commercial use at scale since 1983 +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: short. the design promises profit-and-loss sharing; debt-like sale contracts dominate (tawarruq 46% of Malaysian Islamic financing by 2019), and the document leaves the match to its other criteria + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. WIR Bank has operated continuously since 1934 +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the components the rationale counts have mixed documented outcomes, as the entry's own document records: WIR's credit moves countercyclically (C3.1), but UK LETS declined from its mid-1990s peak once cheap credit returned, its schemes drew participants already socially connected (C1.1), and Argentina's barter networks collapsed as they outgrew their governance (C3.2, C3.5); WIR's 2013 turnover was 1.43 billion francs, and Bank WIR reports demand for the currency falling again in 2024 (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. WIR's documented record, nine decades of operation and countercyclical credit, taken as the proof of the mechanism's core component, with the LETS and barter-network outcomes read as weaker implementations + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. operated since independence in 1965 at national scale +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the rationale certifies track record, not adequacy (Status Quo's reasoning), and cites Domains 1 and 3 for its documented outcomes, which the corpus's own scoring records short: C1.1 0.5, housing affordability not maintained for the rental segment (part (a), SG C1.3), and evidence-based updates slow or refused (part (a), SG C3.4) (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Outcomes matched against the narrow functions its sources claim for residents, home ownership and compulsory saving + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. operated for centuries; its components in continuous national-scale operation far beyond 20 years +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the rationale claims longevity, not a match of outcomes to claimed benefits, and concedes the record does not validate adequacy for contemporary challenges; the corpus's own scoring of this entry records outcomes short of the broad-prosperity benefits its defenders claim (C1.1 0.5; C1.2b, C1.4, C4.4 0.0) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Outcomes matched component by component against narrow claimed functions (price stability, growth) rather than the system's broad claims + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: not shown. the document defines seven sectors (healthcare, education, democracy and legal services, shelter, food, transport, information); its cited precedents of 20 years or more cover three (healthcare, education, shelter), its childcare precedent lies outside the seven, and it calls its transit precedents more recent and more mixed: three of seven (43%) are shown (reading 3.2) +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the rationale states that each precedent has documented outcomes without estimating a match to the benefits claimed, and the document itself records mixed outcomes: Quebec childcare's publicised child-development findings (the Baker, Gruber and Milligan research) and Kansas City's 2026 reversal of zero-fare transit (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Elements proven: WPA (1930s), CCC, CETA (1970s). Argentina Plan Jefes (2002) demonstrated job guarantee at scale. However, no comprehensive MMT+JG system operated long-term. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: short. short: the components with twenty-year records at scale (renewable energy, cooperatives, public services) are the design's peripheral ones; its distinctive ones (full automation, post-work distribution) have none, so well under 70% of its components are proven +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. not shown: no integrated implementation, so no outcome to match against the system's claims + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The 0.0 band's reading: the distinctive components are a novel projection + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> B-Corps, benefit corporations, ESG funds exist and operate. However, it remains a niche—less than 5% of the economy. When stakeholder principles conflict with profits, profit wins systematically. + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. operated continuously since 1978 for more than 1.4 billion people +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the rationale certifies track record, not adequacy (Status Quo's reasoning, which part (a) found does not show this clause), and cites C1.1 for its documented outcomes, which the entry's own document scores 0.5: a reduction of about 70-80% at the middle-income line the protocol prescribes, though over 99% at the extreme and national lines (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Outcomes matched against the narrower benefit the configuration's own sources claim, eliminating extreme and national-line poverty, which the World Bank and State Council study documents + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c5-1) + +1. *≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants*: cleared. components with long records at national scale +2. *with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits*: not shown. the rationale claims operation with documented outcomes and follows China and Singapore without estimating a match; the corpus's own scoring of the configuration, over its whole resident population (protocol 3.2), records outcomes short of broad welfare: C1.1 0.5 and ten structural failures, among them C4.5 (reading 3.1) + +Read in part (b2) (Session 39). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Outcomes matched against the narrow benefit claimed, welfare provision to the configuration's citizens, which the entry's document records + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> 19th-century laissez-faire provides historical precedent, but outcomes (robber barons, child labor, poverty, pollution) led to Progressive Era reforms. "Proven" in the sense of having existed, not in positive outcomes. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The diagnostic and planning component — the City Portrait methodology and its underlying indicator sets — is genuinely well-proven at real-world scale: piloted in three cities in 2019, adopted in some form by more than 50 local and regional governments and one national government by 2025, and, as of October 2025, anchored by a peer-reviewed publication in one of the world's most selective scientific journals. This is a strong, multi-year, multi-jurisdiction record for the specific thing being proven. But the fuller "economic system" NEEC evaluates requires more than a diagnostic apparatus, and that fuller doughnut economy — one that actually closes the gaps the diagnostic tool identifies — has not been achieved, or even attempted as an integrated whole, anywhere: the framework's own 2025 monitoring finds the global economy further from the doughnut than in 2000, not closer. The redistributive components that would be needed (Domain 1) are each separately proven elsewhere (as this project's own Georgism and Mutual Credit/LETS evaluations already establish) but are not part of what has actually been integrated into any Doughnut Economics implementation. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c5-1) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Historical existence proves technical feasibility but not desirability. 70+ years of operation in the USSR, continued existence in Cuba and North Korea. However, the collapse of the Eastern Bloc demonstrates lack of sustained viability. + +### C5.2 Staged Transition Pathways + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Staged (≥4 phases) and rapid (≤36 months) deployment, with specific milestones, resource requirements and risk mitigation, each shown feasible by precedent or component evidence. Revision class M (bar, measure or clause restated). + +v2.0: 2 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 7 at 1.0, 13 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the roadmap specifies seven phases over seven years, but its second phase launches the dual currency for all Americans in year 2, and its phases deploy components of which no deployment at comparable scale is located, a national complementary currency whose units expire monthly and convert at merit-based rates, and a national portal for blockchain-verified voting and direct policy proposals (the nearest located are local, Wörgl's stamp scrip of 1932-1933, or partial, Estonia's internet voting in national elections since 2007); the modelling paper's pilot-first pathway has three phases, municipal pilots, regional expansion and national implementation, and concludes that the computational evidence supports proceeding with municipal pilot programs to begin empirical validation (reading 3.4) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the three-month national launch plan and the Report's 18-36 months are plans; the precedents the entry cites, the New Deal's and the Marshall Plan's three years, are programmes of other kinds cited for their speed; component evidence covers the design's universal distribution (Alaska's dividend, paid to residents every year since 1982), but no deployment of a national expiring currency or of binding national digital democracy, within 36 months or at any pace, is located (reading 3.4) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. the milestones (poverty below 10% in year 1 and below 2% by year 7, enrolment of 80% in year 1, 10,000 Creator Collectives in year 1; the launch-phase KPIs) are the design's own targets; no precedent or component evidence is cited or located for them, and the modelling paper's phase success probabilities (84%, 78% and 71%) come from its own parameter sensitivity, a model outcome (reading 3.4) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. the resources are stated ($500 billion over five years for Public Trust Foundations; in the three-month plan, $950 billion of federal allocations and some 190,000 staff and coordinators), but no precedent or component evidence shows them sufficient for the deployment: the documents cite none, and the modelling paper's fiscal break-even is a model outcome (reading 3.4) +5. *risk mitigation*: cleared. the plan's risk section and the Risk Mitigation Framework specify mitigations of kinds in use elsewhere (redundant systems and manual backups, audits, independent oversight bodies, algorithmic transparency), and the modelling paper's mitigation of transition disruption is the parallel operation of existing systems: component evidence in the sense of reading 3.2 (reading 3.4) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Read as part (a) read the Session 44 clause, on the plans' specificity, with the precedents the entry cites for their timing (the New Deal, the Marshall Plan) and the modelling paper's success probabilities as evidence of feasibility, every + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: cleared. the audited phrase, occurred gradually over 40+ years, names the configuration's own deployment, a precedent in the sense of the scope; it was built in successive stages in each country, in Sweden alone at least four: crisis policy and the Saltsjöbaden Agreement (1932-1938), the universal pension and child allowance (1946-1948), compulsory health insurance and the earnings-related pension (1955-1960), and parental insurance and the Co-determination Act (1974-1976) (reading 3.2) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway, and its own history is a build of four decades; its universal social insurance has a precedent of rapid deployment elsewhere (Britain's, legislated in 1946 and in force by July 1948), but the entry names strong labor unions as defining, and no deployment of encompassing unions and centralised bargaining within 36 months is located: Sweden's took from the December Compromise of 1906 to the Saltsjöbaden Agreement of 1938 (reading 3.3) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the entry's pathway is incremental cooperative development; its component has grown in stages at a region's scale (Mondragón from 1956), but no stage beyond a niche is located from a market economy, and the one economy-wide deployment of worker self-management in markets, Yugoslavia's (in stages from 1950 to 1976), began from capital nationalised after a revolution (readings 3.2(a), 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway, and no deployment of a cooperative sector at an economy's scale within 36 months is located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: short. three levels, municipal, regional and national, against at least four, stated as a theoretical possibility; no deployment of participatory planning of production is located at any level; its nearest components have deployments at the first levels' scale only: participatory budgeting of a share of municipal investment (Porto Alegre from 1989) and the Kerala People's Campaign, which devolved 35 to 40% of a state's plan funds to local planning from August 1996 (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway, and holds that coordination complexity makes partial implementation difficult and that planning needs critical mass; no deployment within 36 months is located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the design's white paper, published after the corpus scored it, now states a staged pathway: proto-nodes grown from existing mutual aid networks, timebanks, tool libraries and repair cafés, each of the five systems formalised in three steps, and an arc of four stages, from marginal experiment to supplementary alternative, essential support layer and dominant substrate, 'inherently generational' and undated; its first stage's kind is deployed, but no node operating the design's systems is located: the project's site registers four communities in its own Phase 1, the building of its software (reading 3.3) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the white paper sets aside direct implementation in a nation-state as 'highly unlikely' and states no rapid pathway; none is located (reading 3.3) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. no milestones are stated: the transition's markers are 'incremental and often unremarkable' (reading 3.3) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. no resource requirements are stated; interface cooperatives take in external resources, without a figure (reading 3.3) +5. *risk mitigation*: cleared. section 11.10 specifies safeguards of kinds in use elsewhere: no single point of failure, peer-to-peer and federated infrastructure with replicated data, grounded in deployed technologies (decentralised identifiers, content-addressed storage, federated messaging); no central treasury; commons assets that cannot be pledged or sold; legal compliance as the default; and interface cooperatives with capped market exposure and sunset rules; component evidence in the sense of reading 3.2, as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's risk mitigation was cleared in part (b9) (reading 3.3) + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Re-read on the design's own white paper (v0.1, December 2025), as parts (b5) and (b8) read the design's own pages; the published 0.0's reason, that the source provides no phased pathway, no longer describes the design, and a clause is clear + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 1.0** (v1 0.5, up). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: cleared. the mechanism's own deployment, in at least four dated stages in Norway: the fund's law (1990), its first capital transfer (1996), the investment manager and a 40% equity share (1998), and the fiscal rule tying spending to the fund's expected real return (2001) (reading 3.4) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: cleared. a precedent of the same kind in a post-crisis context: Timor-Leste, independent in 2002 after the violence of 1999, put its petroleum fund out to public consultation (comments due 30 November 2004), promulgated its law on 3 August 2005 and made the fund's first investments on 9 September 2005, 10 months from the consultation's close (reading 3.4) +3. *specific milestones*: cleared. dated targets were set and met: a 40% equity share decided in 1997 and reached in the first half of 1998; 60% decided in 2007 and reached in June 2009; the fiscal rule's expected return revised from 4% to 3% in 2017 (reading 3.4) +4. *resource requirements*: cleared. what the deployments took is documented: the capital, the revenue stream transferred into the fund (in Timor-Leste, USD 79.6 million from the Timor Gap Account at the first investment), and the institution to manage it, built in Timor-Leste with Norway's assistance from 2002, about NOK 56 million to 2007, whose advisers were 'instrumental to the establishment of the petroleum fund and its operations' (reading 3.4) +5. *risk mitigation*: cleared. the deployments' mitigations operated: assets invested abroad only, a spending rule tying transfers to the expected real return (Norway) or to 3% of petroleum wealth (Timor-Leste), ethical guidelines from 2004; Norway's fund has been kept and has grown to more than four times mainland GDP under the rule, though Timor-Leste's parliament approved withdrawals above its rule in most years from 2008 (reading 3.4) + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Every clause is shown by deployments of the mechanism itself, which the published 0.5, judged on the absence of a phase-by-phase plan, did not credit; under v2.0's scope a precedent, not a plan, is the test (part (b9), reading 3.2) + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the framework declines to be a deployment plan; the national programmes that handed resources to commons did so over decades (Nepal's community forestry under the Forest Act 1993 and Regulation 1995, to more than 22,000 groups; India's Joint Forest Management), and no deployment within 36 months is located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. National programmes deployed the mechanism in stages, so the unit is not 0.0 (reading 3.2(f)); clause 1, which those programmes bear on, is not estimated, since clause 2 fixes the verdict; the register's flag toward 0.0 is kept + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the entry's pathway is to begin with a partial basic income and scale it upward; no such scaling in stages is located: the one long-running universal payment, Alaska's dividend (paid every year since 1982), follows the fund's earnings and the legislature's appropriation, not a schedule toward a full basic income (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the entry names municipal experiments, bioregional organisation and voluntary simplicity as pathways; no polity located has deployed a planned contraction of output in stages, and the experiments named are local (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway, and the transition it describes faces 'massive political and economic disruption'; none is located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: short. the precedent the entry cites, the Australian Capital Territory's 20-year shift from conveyance duty to general rates, has run in annual budget steps since 2012 with published evaluations, but it is not shown to completion: a review for the Legislative Assembly's estimates committee finds abolition by the 2032 deadline 'extremely unlikely', the substitution having come to 'a complete stop', with conveyance duty still about 10% of own-source revenue in 2029-30 (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway is located, and the one fast introduction, Britain's of 1910, is the entry's clearest failure case (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: cleared. the audited phrase, forty-year build, from the first Islamic bank in 1983, names a precedent: Malaysia's dual system was built in dated stages, among them the Islamic Banking Act and the first Islamic bank (1983), the interest-free banking scheme for conventional banks (1993), the Shariah Advisory Council (1997) and the Islamic Financial Services Act (2013) (reading 3.3) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: cleared. the audited phrase names a precedent within the window: Iran legislated the conversion of its banking system in 1983 and operated the converted system from March 1984 (reading 3.3) +3. *specific milestones*: cleared. the audited phrase, milestones are real enough to be missed, is the precedent's milestone record: Malaysia set a 50% Islamic share by 2025 and measured 48%, so its milestones were dated and checked (reading 3.3) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. the entry states no resource requirement for either pathway, and the precedents it cites document laws, dates and shares, not the resources the conversions took (capital, trained staff, liquidity instruments); reports of Pakistan's 2026 roadmap say that banks' Islamic windows already hold the technology and that staff training is under way, but give no estimate of cost, capital or staff (reading 3.3) +5. *risk mitigation*: cleared. the audited phrase, explicit grandfathering of existing conventional contracts, is Pakistan's measure, announced for 2028 and not yet in force; mitigation of the same kind has worked in the staged precedent: Malaysia's dual system required no forced conversion of existing contracts, running Islamic and conventional banking side by side for four decades (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Read as satisfied wherever a precedent was completed, whatever resources it took, the national conversions of Iran (1983-1984) and Malaysia's build show that the resources were found, and the clause is cleared (reading 3.3) + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. no deployment in dated stages is located: classic LETS, WIR, Sardex and Grassroots Economics each started small and grew without a multi-phase design; the Credit Commons federation effort is a design, early-stage and untested at scale, and a plan shows nothing under the scope (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. Argentina's barter networks scaled within months in the 2001-2002 crisis and then collapsed: the pace is shown, not the feasibility of a deployment that reaches stable operation (reading 3.2(c)) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The mechanism has operated for decades in its networks (WIR since 1934), so the unit is not 0.0 (reading 3.2(f)); the register's flag toward 0.0 is kept + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. parts of the model have documented, sequenced histories (Temasek's incorporation in 1974 from existing state holdings, the privatisation programme of 1985-1987, the transfer of administrative know-how to Suzhou), but they are stages of components, not four stages of the configuration, and its political precondition was secured by Operation Coldstore's detentions without trial in 1963, an episode whose purpose historians contest (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway is stated or located; the pathway unfolded over decades in a city-state (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: moot. moot: the entry is the existing system and requires no transition, as audited (code N), and v2.0's scope, which asks that a transition's elements be shown feasible, leaves nothing to show (reading 3.7) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: moot. moot, as clause 1 (reading 3.7) +3. *specific milestones*: moot. moot, as clause 1 (reading 3.7) +4. *resource requirements*: moot. moot, as clause 1 (reading 3.7) +5. *risk mitigation*: moot. moot, as clause 1 (reading 3.7) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: cleared. component evidence: Quebec's universal childcare was deployed in four dated stages, to four-year-olds in 1997, three-year-olds in 1998, two-year-olds in 1999 and all children under five not in kindergarten in 2000, and was the model for Canada's national programme from 2021; the entry's pathway is sector by sector (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway; one sector has a precedent of rapid deployment (Britain's national health service, legislated in 1946 and in force by July 1948), but no deployment of the package of universal services within 36 months is located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: short. three stages (pilot, regional, national) against at least four, as part (a) found; the one national precedent of its kind located was also phased in fewer: India's rural employment guarantee, extended to all districts in three phases between 2006 and 2008 (reading 3.4) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: cleared. a precedent of the same kind: Argentina's Plan Jefes y Jefas de Hogar, a public employment programme begun in April 2002 in the crisis, whose payrolls ballooned quickly, against a government estimate of 500,000, to nearly 2 million participants, 13% of the labour force, at a cost peaking at 1% of GDP (reading 3.4) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 (part (a) located none) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 (part (a) located none) +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 (part (a) located none) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. no pathway is specified: the entry's destination rests on technologies not yet developed (general artificial intelligence, abundant clean energy and storage) together with a political transformation, and no stage of deployment of that destination is located or possible before they exist (reading 3.5) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway is stated, and none can be deployed before the technologies exist (reading 3.5) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. no milestones are stated (reading 3.5) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. no resource requirements are stated (reading 3.5) +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. no risk mitigation for a transition is stated (reading 3.5) + +Why 0.0 stands: no structural mechanism addresses the criterion: 'fully automated' is a destination without a roadmap, whose defining condition cannot be deployed by any pathway until technologies not yet developed exist + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The outside reader's reading: the literature sketches a political route (municipal ownership, public banks, universal basic services), the 0.5 band's pathway sketched but unspecific + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: cleared. the audited phrase names corporate governance reforms, tax incentives and regulatory requirements, and the entry's governance reform includes worker representation on boards; component evidence: that component has been deployed in stages, in Germany in four: the Coal and Steel Codetermination Act (1951), the Works Constitution Act (1952), its revision (1972) and the Codetermination Act (1976) (reading 3.3) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states only an incremental pathway with minimal disruption, and no deployment of stakeholder governance across an economy within 36 months is located: Germany's took a quarter-century, from 1951 to 1976 (reading 3.3) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 2 + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the reform sequence is one of the best-documented staged transitions, local experiments first and national policy after, sector by sector from 1978, and Vietnam adapted it; but each runs from a party-state that came to power by revolution and civil war, which the entry names as defining, and no polity located has reached the configuration by stages from a pluralist starting point (readings 3.2(a), 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway is stated or located (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. Qatar's multi-phase plans (the National Vision 2030 and three national development strategies, the third for 2024-2030) develop a configuration already in place; they are not a pathway into it, and its precondition, large resource rents per citizen, cannot be deployed (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway exists (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. the audited phrase, could be implemented gradually, is a claim, and deregulation, welfare elimination and tax reduction is a sequence, not a deployment that took place: no state located has been reduced, in stages or otherwise, to the minimal functions the design specifies; component evidence covers deregulation, privatisation and tax cuts singly, but not the step the entry names as its own, the elimination of social programmes (reading 3.3) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the entry states no rapid pathway, and no deployment of a minimal state within 36 months, or at any pace, is located (reading 3.3) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clauses 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clauses 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clauses 1 and 2 + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. a first-stage methodology, the City Portrait process, has been followed in dozens of jurisdictions, but no stage beyond the initial portrait and strategy is specified or located (reading 3.6) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. no rapid pathway exists: Amsterdam's adoption in the pandemic reused an existing planning process (reading 3.6) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by clause 1 and 2 + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c5-2) + +1. *Staged (≥4 phases)*: not shown. no gradual transition to comprehensive central planning in a stable context is located: every transition to the configuration followed a seizure of power by force, by revolution and civil war (Russia, 1917-1921; China, 1949), by occupation (Eastern Europe, 1945-1949) or by a coup (Czechoslovakia, February 1948); the later stages of each, the five-year plans and collectivisation, rest on it (readings 3.2(a), 3.5) +2. *rapid (≤36 months) deployment*: not shown. the configuration was imposed within 36 months more than once (Soviet collectivisation from 1929; the nationalisations in Eastern Europe after 1945), but each deployment rested on a seizure of power by force, which the criterion's rationale names as what a pathway is to avoid, and none was a deployment a polity could adopt by its own procedures (readings 3.2(a), 3.5) +3. *specific milestones*: not shown. the five-year plans set dated targets, but in deployments that rest on force; no milestone of a pathway the criterion credits is located (reading 3.5) +4. *resource requirements*: not shown. no statement of what a transition into the configuration takes, other than the seizure of power, is located (reading 3.5) +5. *risk mitigation*: not shown. the entry's record shows rapid implementation 'invariably chaotic', and no mitigation of a transition's risks is stated or located (reading 3.5) + +Why 0.0 stands: every transition to the configuration located required non-gradual means, revolution, civil war, a coup or occupation (the 0.0 band's own example); no pathway the criterion credits exists to be shown feasible + +Read in group 2.6 (Session 58). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The 0.0 band's anchor example; it holds + +### C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Viable at ≥30% participation, coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity, scaling pathway validated through modeling, coordination protocols established. Revision class U (unchanged). + +v2.0: 7 at 1.0, 14 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 15 at 1.0, 6 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: short. short on the preponderance of the design's own texts (protocol 4.2): the modelling paper finds 'minimum viable participation at 55%' ('below 55% participation rate, network effects fail to sustain system growth'), the BLEI paper a self-funding threshold of 60-65%, the sensitivity analysis 55-60%, and the model warns below 55%; the integrated framework's 'viability at 30%' states no computation +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. Can coexist with traditional markets +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: cleared. Scaling pathway validated through modeling +4. *coordination protocols established*: cleared. Inter-jurisdictional coordination protocols specified + +Read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.2 (ledger D67, Session 84). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The integrated framework's reading: viability at 30% participation + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Components can be adopted piecemeal (universal healthcare, free education, progressive taxation), but a comprehensive model requires near-universal participation for funding sustainability. Partial deployment is possible but less effective. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. cooperatives function well in mixed economies +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. can coexist with traditional firms +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: not shown. no modelling of a scaling pathway cited; observed cooperative scale peaks at a regional federation (Mondragon: about 70,000 workers in 92 cooperatives), short of the national stage the Measurement line describes (reading 3.4) +4. *coordination protocols established*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Participatory planning could coexist with markets initially. However, the system is optimized for comprehensive adoption. Partial deployment loses efficiency advantages of full coordination. + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. the federated structure starts with a handful of people +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. nodes coexist with traditional markets +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: not shown. not shown: the white paper says thresholds 'are derived from: empirical system modeling, ecological science, historical performance data', how they are to be set, not a model validating the path from pilot to regional to national scale; Jev reads the clause short in both passes +4. *coordination protocols established*: cleared. cleared: the white paper establishes coordination protocols between nodes (Node State Summaries, threshold classification, Coordination Envelopes, internodal reciprocity protocols); Jev reads the clause cleared in both passes + +Read in part (a) (Session 37), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Definitionally and empirically clean. Every implementing jurisdiction operates independently of every other, and every one coexists with, rather than displaces, an ordinary market economy — this is simply the observed pattern across every exemplar located (Norway, Alaska, Timor-Leste, New Zealand, and dozens of others tracked by the Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute), not a projection requiring modeling. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Satisfied by construction and by observation. Commons institutions exist **inside** market economies and always have; there is no version of this mechanism that requires the market to be displaced first. Up to 2.5 billion people, at least 50% of the Earth's land customarily held collectively, and roughly one third of the world's forests under community-based, participatory or decentralised management — all coexisting with markets that carry the overwhelming majority of measured economic activity. The scaling pathway is principle 8 itself, nested enterprises, and it is validated rather than proposed: Nepal scaled from nothing to more than 22,000 user groups inside four decades. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Universal Basic Income: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. implementable at municipal, state or national scale +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. Alaska shows coexistence with the market economy +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: cleared. cleared on observed operation, at least as strong as modelling (protocol 2.3(d)): pilots of thousands; Alaska's dividend at state scale since 1982; and since December 2010 a universal, unconditional monthly cash transfer per person that nearly every resident of Iran receives +4. *coordination protocols established*: moot. moot: a single jurisdiction adopts the mechanism without coordination with others (Alaska, Iran), as Georgism's and Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism's clause 4 are read (protocol 2.3(e)) + +Read in part (a) (Session 37), then adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Iran's transfer compensates for removed price subsidies rather than paying an income as of right (Tabatabai), and no adequate basic income has been scaled + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Components can be implemented locally (transition towns, eco-villages). However, comprehensive degrowth requires systemic change. Difficult to maintain growth and degrowth economies simultaneously without degrowth being overwhelmed. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Every real-world case demonstrates this directly: a single city, a single sub-national territory (the ACT), or a single country (Estonia, Denmark) can adopt LVT independently, coexisting normally with an ordinary market economy and with neighboring jurisdictions that have not adopted it. No case of adoption requiring simultaneous multi-jurisdiction coordination was located — possibly the single most strongly-evidenced criterion in this entire evaluation. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The dual system is not an argument for partial deployability; it is a four-decade demonstration of it. Islamic and conventional banking operate side by side in Malaysia with no co-mingling of funds, the Islamic side at 48% of financing; in most other jurisdictions the mechanism operates at far lower shares without difficulty; conventional banks run Islamic windows; and sovereign issuers outside the traditional markets, including the United Kingdom, Luxembourg, and Hong Kong, have issued sukuk. The scaling pathway from a single licensed bank to near-parity is documented rather than modelled. Not flagged. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. can begin with as few as a handful of participants +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. operates alongside conventional currency +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: short. the entry's own document records a practical trust ceiling of 100-200 members per LETS node and WIR's centralisation under scale; the federated redesign meant to pass them is not yet validated +4. *coordination protocols established*: moot. no case of adoption requiring or attempting multi-jurisdiction coordination + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. the state's share can be dialled down +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. coexists with private and foreign firms by design +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: not shown. the record is of one city-state; the entry's own text says components transplanted abroad worked less well (China's Housing Provident Fund; the Temasek model's limited influence); no modelled pathway (reading 3.4) +4. *coordination protocols established*: cleared. enterprises operate on an equal basis with local and foreign businesses + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Currently deployed universally across most of the global economy. Mixed economies demonstrate coexistence with other elements. + +**Universal Basic Services: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. each of its sectors adopted independently +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. Quebec's universal low-fee childcare raised mothers' employment by nearly 70,000 (3.8% of women's employment) and provincial GDP by about 1.7% in 2008: market activity grew +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: cleared. universal childcare scaled from Quebec to all of Canada +4. *coordination protocols established*: cleared. Canada-wide Early Learning and Child Care agreements signed by the federal government with every province and territory by March 2022, including an asymmetrical agreement with Quebec (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Coordination protocols shown for one sector, childcare, and none for the seven-sector package + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Can implement partially (infrastructure spending, targeted job programs), but job guarantee requires comprehensive federal implementation to function optimally. State-level experiments are possible but limited. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Cannot function partially—requires comprehensive automation for post-scarcity. Pilot testing is impossible without technologies that don't yet exist at scale. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. partial deployment proven viable through existing examples +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. stakeholder firms coexist easily with traditional corporations +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: not shown. the unit cites existing examples (B Corps competing in the same markets); no modelled or observed pathway from pilots to national scale located (reading 3.4) +4. *coordination protocols established*: not shown. not estimated in this pass; the verdict is fixed by another clause + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Components are adopted piecemeal and coexist with markets. Within China, the private sector supplies most output and employment; abroad, Vietnam had 343 industrial and economic zones by 2019 (Braumiller Law Group), and Ethiopia built industrial parks on the Chinese pattern (C5.2). But the comprehensive form — party-state direction of the economy — requires comprehensive political control. The one formal arrangement for coexistence, Hong Kong's "one country, two systems," has been dismantled since the 2020 National Security Law (Freedom House). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. the distributive core serves citizens, 9-13% of residents +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. runs in parallel with a market economy +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: short. no validated scaling pathway exists (the entry's own flag) +4. *coordination protocols established*: not shown. not estimated in this pass + +Read in part (a) (Session 37). + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Aspects can be implemented partially (deregulation, lower taxes), but comprehensive minarchism requires near-total transformation. Mixed systems are more viable than pure versions. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c5-3) + +1. *Viable at ≥30% participation*: cleared. adopted piecemeal by voluntarily participating jurisdictions +2. *coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity*: cleared. coexists with the ordinary market economy +3. *scaling pathway validated through modeling*: cleared. the scaling record is concrete and dated +4. *coordination protocols established*: not shown. no inter-jurisdictional coordination protocol located in the entry's document; cities adopt the framework independently, but its ecological ceiling is planetary, so the text does not establish that coordination is unneeded and Mutual Credit's moot reading does not transfer (reading 3.3) + +Read in part (b1) (Session 38). + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c5-3) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** The system requires comprehensive control to function. Cannot coexist with market economy without either collapsing (market elements dominate) or suppressing markets (totalitarian control required). + +### C5.4 Political Coalition Potential + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): ≥60% support across political spectrum, ≥65% opposition to repeal, survival probability ≥80% across administration changes. Revision class U (unchanged). + +v2.0: 1 at 1.0, 19 at 0.5, 3 at 0.0. v1: 2 at 1.0, 17 at 0.5, 4 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c5-4) + +1. *≥60% support across political spectrum*: cleared. Alaska PFD demonstrates 80%+ approval across the spectrum +2. *≥65% opposition to repeal*: not shown. the design's documents state no projection of opposition to its repeal; its roadmap assumes full bipartisan political support with legislative supermajorities and a public mandate through 70%+ approval ratings, an assumption, not an estimate; the Alaska dividend's record is one component's, and the design's other components (the expiring currency, Public Trust Foundations, the portal, the zones) have none (reading 3.5) +3. *survival probability ≥80% across administration changes*: not shown. no record or projection of the design's survival across changes of administration is stated; the modelling paper puts political resistance in 34% of its scenarios and national implementation's success at 71%, neither of which is survival across administrations (reading 3.5) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c5-4) + +1. *≥60% support across political spectrum*: cleared. High public satisfaction (70-85%) +2. *≥65% opposition to repeal*: cleared. in the ISSP's 2016 Role of Government module, {SPEND} of those answering in each of the four countries wanted government spending on health, and on old age pensions, kept at its level or raised, and {RESP} held that health care for the sick and a decent standard of living for the old should be the government's responsibility; wanting the system's core provision kept or raised opposes its repeal a fortiori (reading 3.5) +3. *survival probability ≥80% across administration changes*: cleared. the configuration's universal social insurance and public services have been kept through every change of government since they were built, including centre-right governments in all four countries: Sweden 1976-1982, 1991-1994, 2006-2014 and from 2022; Denmark 1982-1993, 2001-2011 and 2015-2019; Norway 1981-1986, 1989-1990, 1997-2000, 2001-2005 and 2013-2021; Finland 1991-1995, 2015-2019 and from 2023 (reading 3.5) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Read as requiring a record for every institution the entry names as defining, strong labor unions and progressive taxation as well as the social programmes, clause 3 is not shown on the evidence located; the interpretation check read the re + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Appeals to socialists, progressive liberals, community organizers. However, limited appeal to business interests and fiscal conservatives. Mixed coalition potential. + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Appeals to democratic socialists, anarchists, participatory democracy advocates. However, coordination complexity creates skepticism. Moderate and conservative resistance to comprehensive economic planning. + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The system has genuine cross-ideological appeal (ecological compliance for environmentalists, voluntary participation for libertarians, cooperative ownership for progressives, efficiency for fiscal conservatives), but cybernetic terminology creates real communication barriers, and the radical departure from money, markets, and traditional employment alienates incrementalists. Estimated cross-spectrum support (40-50% among those who understand it deeply, below 30% among the general public) falls short of NEEC's 60% threshold. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c5-4) + +1. *≥60% support across political spectrum*: cleared. Alaska's dividend has held approval across the political spectrum for four decades, the corpus's own anchor case for this criterion +2. *≥65% opposition to repeal*: not shown. not shown: no measure of opposition to repeal is cited (the outside reader's closed-book figure, about 70% opposed to cutting the dividend, was not located) +3. *survival probability ≥80% across administration changes*: short. short: the dividend has been paid every year since 1982, but its statutory formula was overridden by veto in 2016 and by appropriation since, and the 2025 dividend was the smallest in real terms (the entry's own C5.1) + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The outside reader's reading, and the published flag: the mechanism has survived every change of administration, in Alaska since 1982 and in Norway since 1990 + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The survival clause has better evidence behind it than any other system could offer: Nepal's programme persisted through a decade of civil conflict and the replacement of a monarchy by a federal republic; Valencia's tribunal survived the Reconquista, and every regime since, with its procedure intact. The ideological reach is unusually wide — local self-governance, collective ownership, ecological stewardship and Indigenous rights are claims made by different political traditions about the same mechanism — and Ostrom's 2009 Nobel moved it into mainstream development and conservation practice. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Unusual coalition: progressive left \+ libertarian right \+ tech sector. However, challenges from labor unions (preferring jobs) and fiscal conservatives (cost concerns). Mixed political viability. + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c5-4) + +1. *≥60% support across political spectrum*: short. short: support is concentrated on the left and among Greens (the outside reader's closed-book estimate is 15-30%), with resistance from unions and developing nations +2. *≥65% opposition to repeal*: not shown. not shown: the design is not enacted, so no repeal can be measured +3. *survival probability ≥80% across administration changes*: not shown. not shown: no record across administrations + +Why 0.0 stands: structural or rhetorical features actively repel broad coalition-building (protocol 2.1; the 0.0 band): the name is chosen as a provocation, and the design's own literature records resistance among unions and developing nations + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The outside reader's reading: strong appeal to part of the spectrum against resistance from another (the 0.5 band) + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The cross-ideological intellectual case is unusually strong: historical supporters span Winston Churchill, William F. Buckley Jr., and Milton Friedman on the right to Bertrand Russell, John Dewey, and Paul Krugman on the left. Currently, a 2026 survey found majority support for a specific pending LVT bill among both renters and homeowners in New York State, and Detroit's pending LVT plan is backed by 83% of a surveyed panel of economists including four Nobel laureates, projected to cut taxes for roughly 97% of the city's homeowners. Against this: Detroit's plan remains stalled in the Michigan Legislature despite this expert backing, the broader current U.S. property-tax political environment favors cutting or eliminating property taxes generally rather than restructuring their base toward land value, and Altoona, Pennsylvania's 2016 reversal is a direct instance of an actual implementation losing its political coalition. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Support is durable where it exists: four decades of consistent Malaysian policy across changes of government, and a Pakistani constitutional amendment passed with the required two-thirds majority in both houses. But the coalition is bounded. In secular and non-Muslim-majority polities the mechanism is adopted as an instrument — sukuk issuance, window operations — rather than as an economic programme, and within the tradition it faces real scholarly opposition, with AAOIFI reservations about organised *tawarruq* and Middle Eastern rejection of structures Malaysia permits. H.7's 0.5 band — "appeals strongly to part of the spectrum while facing real resistance from another part" — applies. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The theoretical cross-ideological case is real — appeal to both libertarian-leaning mutual-aid values and left communitarian/degrowth-adjacent values — and WIR Bank has operated 90 years without evident political controversy. Against this, a real, repeated, cross-context pattern of friction with state authority: UK benefits-eligibility treatment (C2.1), Kenyan authorities briefly detaining Grassroots Economics organizers in 2013 over concerns Bangla-Pesa undermined the national currency before charges were dropped, and Argentina's own network founders facing arrest during the Trueque system's later troubles — a genuine, structural tension with states' legal monopoly on currency issuance, not isolated anecdotes. Separately, UK LETS's own well-documented decline by the 2000s–2010s is attributed in part to the widespread availability of cheap conventional credit reducing the perceived need for an alternative. + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Domestic support is strong and repeatedly tested at the ballot box. The PAP's vote share was 60.1% in 2011 (its lowest since independence), 69.9% in 2015, 61.24% in 2020, and 65.57% in 2025 (Malay Mail; The Asia Group). Trust in government stood at 77% in 2024 and rose during the pandemic (Civil Service College, citing Edelman). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. Six decades of contested majorities as cross-spectrum support + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Strong support from business interests, fiscal conservatives, some libertarians. However, growing dissatisfaction from the working class, youth, and those facing economic insecurity reduces coalition stability. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Real, current, and substantial evidence exists on both sides of this criterion's threshold. In favor: the UK Labour Party's 2019 conference named UBS one of three central pillars of its economic program (alongside ownership/democracy reform and a cash safety net), a genuine endorsement by a major political party's leadership; the concept has maintained sustained institutional traction at the international level, with IGP's own researchers serving as continuing lead authors on the G7's Think7 social-cohesion policy briefs across at least three separate presidency cycles (Germany 2022, Japan 2023, and into the 2026 cycle); and the underlying *principle* — universal, free-at-point-of-use, publicly delivered essential services — commands strong and, as of 2024–2026, *rising* cross-partisan UK public support for individual sectors specifically (YouGov polling finds 76% support for rail nationalization, including 60% of Conservative and 77% of Reform UK voters; 71% support for energy nationalization, up from 53% in 2017; and separate polling finds 86–90% support for keeping the NHS in public, free-at-point-of-use form). Against a stronger score: this polling measures support for individual, already-familiar sectors rather than the specific "Universal Basic Services" branded comprehensive package, which has not itself been polled as a whole to this evaluation's knowledge; Labour's 2019 enthusiasm predates that party's loss in the 2019 general election, so this evidence should be read as historical political-coalition proof-of-concept rather than confirmation of continuing current party policy; and Kansas City's own 2026 reversal of its zero-fare transit program (funding shortfalls following the exhaustion of pandemic-era federal relief funds, and documented year-over-year increases in bus-operator assaults and reported disturbances) is a real, recent, concrete illustration that even a comparatively narrow, single-sector UBS-adjacent policy can lose its political and fiscal coalition once initial funding conditions change. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Appeals to progressives, labor unions, Keynesian economists. However, "printing money" rhetoric triggers inflation fears among fiscal conservatives. Mixed coalition potential. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Appeals to tech-optimists and leftists but lacks concrete implementation to organize around. "Luxury communism" terminology alienates both moderates (communism) and leftists (luxury). No pathway to political power. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c5-4) + +1. *≥60% support across political spectrum*: short. short: business leaders and centrists back it (the Business Roundtable's 2019 statement; the World Economic Forum), while state laws against ESG investing, from 2021, show organised resistance on the right +2. *≥65% opposition to repeal*: not shown. not shown: no measure of opposition to repeal +3. *survival probability ≥80% across administration changes*: not shown. not shown: no record across administrations of a framework that is voluntary + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: it satisfies neither capital nor labour, a political homelessness + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Measured domestic support is high, with documented caveats. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Structural-repulsion reading + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Among citizens, the distributive bargain appears durable: in the 2024 referendum, 84% of eligible citizens voted and 90.6% of valid votes approved the amendments (International IDEA). But support across a political spectrum cannot be observed where parties are banned, the media is not independent, and most residents have no political rights (Freedom House). Outside Qatar, the configuration draws criticism from several directions: human-rights monitors on labour and guardianship, climate analysts on emissions, and the Heritage Foundation on government spending and reliance on expatriate labour (The Peninsula, 2025). The IMF, for its part, credits sound macroeconomic management (2026). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. 90.6% referendum approval + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Appeals to libertarians, some business interests, anti-tax activists. However, elimination of all social programs makes coalition building extremely difficult. Most voters support some safety net. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The framework's actual, dated adoption record spans a genuinely wide political and institutional range — a Swedish municipality, a UK county council, a Belgian regional government, a national government in Central America, cities across North America, Europe, Australasia, and, as of 2025–2026, a village-level local government in India (the Maniyur Gram Panchayat, which incorporated Doughnut Economics into its 2026–27 annual budget) — evidence of real cross-context appeal that a purely ideological or single-constituency framework would not show. Against this, a real and recurring durability problem: of the three cities that piloted the model together in 2019, an academic overview found that "only Amsterdam continues to work with the model," with Philadelphia's and Portland's engagement not sustained — direct evidence that symbolic or initial adoption is easier to achieve than sustained operational commitment. A doctoral case study of Cornwall Council separately documents real tension between local political and economic realities and the ambitions of Raworth's own vision once a jurisdiction moves from adopting the framework to implementing it. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c5-4) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **STRUCTURAL FAILURE.** Catastrophic historical record eliminates political viability. Post-1989 collapse of communism, recognition of authoritarian nature, economic dysfunction make democratic coalition building impossible. + +### C5.5 Cultural Adaptability + +Pass Threshold (v2.0): Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income), ≥5 cultural contexts, parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range, successful operation validated across diverse implementations. Revision class U (unchanged). + +v2.0: 3 at 1.0, 18 at 0.5, 2 at 0.0. v1: 4 at 1.0, 15 at 0.5, 4 at 0.0. + +**CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cco.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Parameter flexibility enables cultural adaptation (octave caps 3-9, basic amounts 5-20% GDP/capita, aesthetic criteria locally determined). Viable across high/middle/low-income contexts with adjustments. However, comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling rather than diverse real-world contexts. + +**Nordic Social Democracy: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/nsd.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Successful within a relatively homogeneous Northern European cultural context. Scalability to large, diverse populations is uncertain. Attempts to replicate elsewhere show mixed results; cultural preconditions may be significant. + +**Market Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/ms.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: not shown. not shown: implementations span high-income (the Basque Country, Northern Italy) and middle-income (Yugoslavia) economies; none is located in a low-income one +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: not shown. not shown: the strongest records are in regions with cooperative traditions, and wider transfer is 'uncertain' +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: not shown. not shown: no documented range of adjustment in a named parameter +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: not shown. not shown: one sustained national implementation (Yugoslavia) ended with the state + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: successful only in specific cultural contexts + +**Participatory Economics: 0.5** (v1 1.0, down). [Evidence](evidence/pe.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: not shown. the entry's text addresses cultural variation only (different communities could have different consumption patterns, work structures) and states no viability across high-, middle- and low-income economies (reading 3.6) +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: cleared. Councils respect cultural variation +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: cleared. Flexible system accommodating diverse values +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: not shown. no economy has been organised on the design: its councils, balanced job complexes and participatory planning have not operated as a system anywhere, so there is no operation across diverse implementations to validate; the corpus scores CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C5.5 0.5 on the same ground (comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling), applied alike (reading 3.6) + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +**Integral: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/int.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The federated structure allows local customization, but operating the five-system architecture requires systems-thinking literacy and comfort with digital, data-driven deliberation that may disadvantage elderly populations, oral-tradition cultures, and low-infrastructure communities — and the document doesn't address parameter adjustment across economic contexts, technological accessibility, or language/literacy requirements the way CCO-PTF's own explicit high/middle/low-income parameters do. + +**Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/swf.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Real, if narrower-than-typical, diversity of successful contexts was located: a wealthy Nordic democracy (Norway), a US state with its own distinct politics (Alaska), a small, high-income, non- resource-funded Pacific democracy (New Zealand), and a genuinely low-income, small, post-conflict Southeast Asian state (Timor-Leste) have each built a working version of this mechanism. But nearly every large-scale, long-running success case shares one structural precondition this evaluation could not find a clean workaround for: a large, lumpy, non-recurring revenue source — a resource windfall in most cases, or a sustained, politically-durable general budget contribution in New Zealand's rarer case — to seed and sustain the fund. Even that rarer, non-resource case shows real fragility: New Zealand's own government contributions were suspended for roughly a decade (contributions resuming only from 2020/21 after a multi-year pause) as they competed against other budget priorities, and at least one 2026 critical analysis argues the fund now returns more to the Crown in tax than the Crown contributes to it annually — a specific, sourced critique this evaluation treats as one contested viewpoint rather than settled fact, but one pointing at a real structural tension: a windfall-funded model doesn't compete with existing spending commitments the way a contribution funded from ordinary revenue does. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Ostrom-Style Commons Governance: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/os.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> **The strongest C5.5 case in the corpus, and the one criterion on which this entry scores above CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH.** The 1.0 is joint-best, shared with Participatory Economics, Mutual Credit / LETS and Islamic finance. Validated implementations span Swiss alpine pasture, Japanese irrigation and *iriai* forest commons, the Spanish *huerta*, Philippine *zanjera* irrigation, the Nepali middle hills, the Maine lobster fishery, Latin American artisanal shellfisheries, Mexican community forestry, East African and Latin American forests, and Indonesian *sasi* and *panglima laot* — across subsistence, middle-income and advanced market economies. Gutiérrez et al. state the breadth explicitly: 130 fisheries across countries at different development levels, ecosystems, fishing sectors and resource types. Cox et al. add 91 studies and Chhatre and Agrawal 80 commons across three continents. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Universal Basic Income: 0.5** (v1 0.0, up). [Evidence](evidence/ubi.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: cleared. cleared: transfers of the kind have operated at high income (Alaska, Finland), middle income (Iran, Mongolia) and low income (Kenya, Namibia, India) +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: cleared. cleared: in more than five cultural settings (the same programmes) +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: cleared. cleared: the payment level, a named parameter, ranges far more than 40% across implementations (Alaska's dividend alone from $331 in 1984 to $3,284 in 2022) +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: short. short: no full, permanent national basic income has operated, so successful operation across diverse implementations is shown for partial or temporary forms only + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. The published reading: acceptance of income without work is a cultural precondition the mechanism cannot itself produce + +**Degrowth Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/dg.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Requires profound cultural transformation from growth/accumulation values to sufficiency/community. Some cultures (indigenous, traditional) are more compatible. Modern consumer cultures require a massive mindset shift. + +**Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/geo.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The geographic spread of real implementations is genuinely broad — post-Soviet Eastern Europe (Estonia), Scandinavia (Denmark), Anglo-federal Australia (the ACT), U.S. municipal contexts (Pennsylvania), and East Asian contexts with land tax variants (Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, per historical accounts). What has actually been validated across this spread is modest-rate LVT as one revenue source among several, not the full-intensity, dividend-paired system this evaluation scores throughout — the same evidentiary gap running through most of this evaluation. + +**Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/if.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: cleared. cleared: high income (the United Kingdom, Qatar), middle income (Malaysia, Turkiye) and low income (Bangladesh, Sudan, the Kyrgyz Republic) +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: cleared. cleared: Southeast Asia, South Asia, the Gulf and wider Middle East, Sub-Saharan Africa, Central Asia and Europe +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: cleared. cleared on the scoring document's reading: the schools of jurisprudence produce materially different permissible product sets, and jurisdictions choose among them +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: cleared. cleared: operation validated in Malaysia, the Gulf, Iran and the sukuk markets + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Read as requiring a documented range of at least 40% in a named parameter, which the scoring document does not give (as Mutual Credit's flag reads its clause 3) + +**Mutual Credit / LETS: 1.0** (v1 1.0). [Evidence](evidence/mc.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: cleared. and low-income context +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: cleared. at least five cultural contexts +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: cleared. the design fixes no parameter centrally: each network sets its members' credit limits on their demonstrated capacity to contribute and adjusts its own rules, and its implementations differ in kind, most with no interest or fee on balances and some with demurrage; parameters that each network sets, with no common value, meet a 40% adjustment range by construction (reading 3.6) +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: cleared. a genuinely broad implementation record + +Read in part (b9) (Session 50). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Read as requiring a documented range of at least 40% in a named parameter, the entry gives no figure, and clause 3 is not shown (reading 3.6) + +**State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sg.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The model operates across three major ethnic communities (C4.3) and has been partly transferred to a very different setting, China, with mixed results. The Suzhou park adapted and diffused Singapore's rules (C5.1), and a Harvard Kennedy School teaching case on the project is titled "Same Bed, Different Dreams," signalling the partners' divergent aims. The Housing Provident Fund underperformed its model (C5.3). No low-income replication was located, and the city-state configuration may not generalize (reasoning). *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Status Quo Market Capitalism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/sq.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Has adapted to diverse cultural contexts historically, though often through coercive imposition. Cultural variation is accommodated within the market framework but core mechanisms remain similar. + +**Universal Basic Services: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/ubs.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The seven-sector framework has been explicitly aimed at multiple national contexts through the Think7/G7 policy-engagement channel (not a UK-only proposal by design), and its constituent evidence base spans several distinct wealthy and middle-income cultural contexts: the UK (the original costing), Austria (Vienna's housing precedent), Canada (Quebec's childcare precedent, later nationalized), and two small European states (Luxembourg and Estonia, for transport). This is a real, if geographically concentrated, spread. Against a stronger score: every one of these contexts is a high-income, Western or Western-adjacent democracy; this evaluation located no genuine low-income-country implementation or adaptation of the comprehensive concept comparable to Mutual Credit/LETS's own Kenyan example, and no explicit parameter- adjustment guidance for different income contexts comparable to CCO-PTF's own explicit high/middle/low-income parameters. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**MMT + Job Guarantee: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/mmt.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Work-centric cultures (U.S., Japan) are more receptive. Cultures valuing leisure or community time over employment may resist. Requires cultural context where work is the primary source of meaning and dignity. + +**Fully Automated Luxury Communism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/falc.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Universal material abundance could appeal across cultures. However, work-centric cultures would resist post-labor society. Requires profound cultural transformation around meaning, purpose, and value. + +**Stakeholder Capitalism: 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/sc.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: not shown. not shown: no whole-system implementation in a low-income economy +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: not shown. not shown: stakeholder-oriented governance operates in Germany, Japan and the Nordic economies, but the comprehensive system is not validated in five settings +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: not shown. not shown: principle-based, with no parameters to adjust +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: short. short: signatories' commitments are not reflected in their governance (Bebchuk and Tallarita, The Illusory Promise of Stakeholder Governance, Cornell Law Review, 2020) + +Why 0.0 stands: the system requires a cultural consensus that corporations serve the social good, which competitive pressures contradict and which it cannot itself produce (the 0.0 band) + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. The outside reader's reading: stakeholder governance operates in several economies + +**State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy): 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cn.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Working versions exist in culturally proximate Vietnam (C5.1). The clearest cross-cultural test, Ethiopia, made rapid progress on nearly every available socioeconomic indicator and launched a series of mega-projects. It then saw mass protests from 2014 and an unraveling of elite cohesion after Prime Minister Meles Zenawi's death in 2012, and the ruling coalition was dissolved in 2019 (*Ethiopia's "Developmental State": Political Order and Distributive Crisis*, open-access book, University of Manchester Global Development Institute, 2023). The model contains no explicit mechanism for adapting to different cultural contexts. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism): 0.0** (v1 0.0). [Evidence](evidence/qa.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The rentier-distributive configuration needs a precondition it cannot produce: resource rents that are very large relative to the citizen body. Rentier-state theory, from Beblawi and Luciani's distinction between allocation and production states onward, links such rents to states that secure consent through welfare rather than taxation (as summarised in a 2021 review; see also Gray's theory of "late rentierism," Georgetown University in Qatar, 2011). But rents do not reliably produce distribution. Oman and Equatorial Guinea had similar resource rents per person, a little over US$8,000 in 1995–2014, yet illustrate opposite outcomes, generosity and neglect (*American Political Science Review*, 2023, citing Ross). The configuration's successes are small, high-rent Gulf monarchies: one regional and cultural context. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. SWF Statism precedent, GCC variation + +**Libertarian Minarchism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/lm.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> Individualist cultures (U.S.) are more receptive. Collectivist cultures strongly resist. Requires cultural context valuing negative liberty above positive liberty and security. + +**Doughnut Economics: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/de.md#c5-5) + +Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale: + +> The geographic reach is real but skewed. A 2025 academic survey of 50 local governments working with Doughnut Economics found the following regional breakdown outside Europe: North America, 6; Asia, 5; Latin America and the Caribbean, 4; Australia and New Zealand, 3; and Sub-Saharan Africa, 1 — implying that roughly three-fifths of the sample is concentrated in Europe specifically, consistent with a separate bibliometric finding that the UK leads academic research on the topic, followed by the USA and other European countries. Costa Rica's national-scale application and the emergence of examples in Malaysia (Ipoh), India (the Maniyur panchayat), and parts of Latin America are genuine, if still modest, evidence of reach beyond wealthy, Western contexts — broader than Georgism's own evidence base, though not as deep into low-income contexts as Mutual Credit/LETS's Kenyan example. No systematic parameter-adjustment guidance for different income contexts (comparable to CCO-PTF's own explicit high/middle/low-income parameters) was located. *(continues in the scoring document)* + +**Centrally Planned Socialism: 0.5** (v1 0.5). [Evidence](evidence/cps.md#c5-5) + +1. *Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income)*: short. short: low- and middle-income economies only; no centrally planned economy reached high income +2. *≥5 cultural contexts*: cleared. cleared: implemented in Russian, Chinese, Cuban, Eastern European, Korean and Vietnamese settings +3. *parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range*: short. short: key parameters were fixed centrally, and cultural variation suppressed rather than accommodated +4. *successful operation validated across diverse implementations*: short. short: every implementation either collapsed or survived by abandoning central planning + +Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83). + +Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. A failure replicated across independent implementations is evidence about the system's own logic (D29(a)), read as far below with no pathway + diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 54ccbd3..eb24560 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -93,7 +93,7 @@ Requirements: Python 3.12 (standard library only) and, for three checks, Node.js python3 run_all_checks.py ``` -This runs 145 checks. Each copies exactly the files one script needs into a fresh temporary +This runs 148 checks. Each copies exactly the files one script needs into a fresh temporary directory, runs the script there, and compares its output byte for byte with the captured copy in this repository; negative controls confirm that the verifiers reject superseded states. The captured output of the whole run is [`run_all_checks_output.txt`](run_all_checks_output.txt), and GitHub Actions repeats the diff --git a/STATE.md b/STATE.md index 28e3c4c..5c79554 100644 --- a/STATE.md +++ b/STATE.md @@ -7,7 +7,8 @@ generator if they change anything (`adjudicate_s83.OWNER` holds the units); if y scores as they stand and state both readings. Send `Continue NEEC.` **What is true now.** Rewritten by every session before its pull request (`CLAUDE.md`); the handoff says what -changed, this file says what holds. Last rewritten by Session 83 (the outside review's 177 disagreements adjudicated; decisions 83.1 to 83.13) (2026-10-20). It consolidates the standing notes and open items of Handoffs 43 to 58, which no longer +changed, this file says what holds. Last rewritten by Session 84 (the owner's items applied, two consistency gaps closed, the entry renamed, Report v2.0 Part I +begun; decisions 84.1 to 84.8) (2026-10-21). It consolidates the standing notes and open items of Handoffs 43 to 58, which no longer need to be read for them. ## Position @@ -70,6 +71,23 @@ provisional notice (decision 66.1; the owner confirmed d49, decision 67.1).** Th Groups 2.1 to 2.3 read `5a7a7b1` (v4.20) and stand as the pass's history. **Research Hub pin:** `8e8a6ba` (its later commits, to `1f7781d` on 2026-10-15, move only the simulation's replication page and README and the wiki index; no design paper changed). +- **Standing now (Session 84, ledger S68 and S69 done; decisions 84.1 to 84.8; `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`).** The adjudicated + state with Session 84's layer laid over it (`owner_s84.py`, `final_pass.settled_state()`, written by `apply_owner_s84.py`): + the owner's answers applied as the adjudication reads them (D66: Degrowth's and Participatory Economics' C3.4 1.0 to 0.5; + D67: CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 1.0 to 0.5), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP C3.4's clauses 1 and 3 sourced (the verdict holds + at 1.0 on decision 79.3), and Participatory Economics' C1.2b 1.0 to 0.5 by the adjudication's rule 4. **CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP + 16.5 first alone**; Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism and Participatory Economics 15.5; Integral, Sovereign Wealth + Fund Statism and Ostrom 15.0; UBI, Degrowth, Georgism and Islamic Finance 14.0; no tier changes. First under all four + weighting schemes and every single-criterion drop. **On the readings alone** (the owner's raises 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 + reversed) CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5, fifth, and Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy and Participatory + Economics share first at 15.5 (the record, section 5, gives every decision singly). **The scores freeze at the `s84` tag** + (decision 83.13 moved on), except through the push-back route (S72). The Session 83 state is kept as + `neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json` and its two companions (`apply_adjudication_s83.py` writes them). +- **The entry's name (decision 84.5, ledger D68, S69 done).** The entry is shown as **CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP** everywhere the + current state is generated (corpus `display_name`, CSV, blocks, evidence reports, site and its visual suite), through one + mapping, `display_names.py`. Its `key` (`CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH`) and code (`CCO`) are identifiers and do not change. **The records + of Sessions 1 to 83, and the generators that rebuild them, keep the old name CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH**; it names the same entry. + Quotations of published documents keep their words (the v1 rationales quoted in the evidence reports). - **Outside review adjudicated (Session 83, ledger S65 done; decisions 83.1 to 83.13; ledger D65, D66, I12; I9 settled).** Every one of the 177 disagreements was adjudicated on the sources by one rule (`NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`, section 2; `adjudicate_s83.py`): 150 hold NEEC's verdict, 17 adopt the reader's, 1 reaches a third reading, 4 go to the owner, 5 are owner-decided cells that @@ -105,7 +123,8 @@ provisional notice (decision 66.1; the owner confirmed d49, decision 67.1).** Th units. It is not the pack's length alone (failures start at 60,676 characters; ok requests reach 104,048), and 35 requests had their pack cut at 200,000 characters. Cause unknown; no key here to test. The workflow keeps retrying them every 4 hours at no cost, and no `DONE` is written while any is missing. Harness unchanged (v50, 140 checks). **Superseded on 2026-10-20 13:41Z:** the 105 units were rerun under D63 and `DONE` was written; see the bullet above. -- **Harness:** v52, 145 checks (`apply_adjudication_s83.py --check` and its negative control, `weighting_s83.py`, since Session 83; +- **Harness:** v53, 147 checks (`apply_owner_s84.py --check` and its negative control, since Session 84; + `apply_adjudication_s83.py --check` and its negative control, `weighting_s83.py`, since Session 83; `compare_outside.py` and its negative control, since Session 82; `outside_kit.py --check` and its negative control, `outside_kit_check.py` and `--negative`, `outside_review_runner.py --selftest`, since Session 80; `evidence_cache_s77.py` and `blind_s77.py`, since Session 77; `evidence_cache_s76.py` and `blind_s76.py`, since Session 76; `evidence_cache_s75.py` and `blind_s75.py`, since Session 75; `evidence_cache_s74.py` and `blind_s74.py`, since Session 74; `evidence_cache_s73.py` and `blind_s73.py`, since Session 73; `evidence_cache_s72.py` and `blind_s72.py`, since Session 72; `evidence_cache_s71.py` and `blind_s71.py`, since Session 71; `evidence_cache_s70.py`, since Session 70; `blind_review.py --selftest`, since Session 69; build_evidence.py --check and its negative control, since Session 68; rescoring_s65.py, apply_pass_s65.py --check), @@ -117,7 +136,7 @@ provisional notice (decision 66.1; the owner confirmed d49, decision 67.1).** Th score, each clause's status, reading and source with the `evidence_cache/` files linked, the close call, the pass's note, and links by line to the pass record and the published (v1) rationale (quoted). 667 sections: 427 re-read, 69 new in v2.0, 171 held (no unit reads them; the published rationale is shown). Never edited by hand (check 113). -- **Standing now** (Session 79; published provisionally on the site, `NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md`, section 3). The +- **Standing after Session 79** (superseded by Sessions 83 and 84 above; published provisionally then, `NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md`, section 3). The Session 78 state with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 laid over it (`final_pass.owner_state()`, `apply_owner_s79.py`): seven cells 0.5 to 1.0, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH C1.2a, C2.5 and C3.4, and C3.4 for Integral, Participatory Economics, Degrowth Economics and Ostrom-Style Commons Governance. **CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH 17.5 alone first**, Participatory Economics 17.0, diff --git a/apply_adjudication_s83.py b/apply_adjudication_s83.py index e798bd9..1557af3 100644 --- a/apply_adjudication_s83.py +++ b/apply_adjudication_s83.py @@ -6,14 +6,17 @@ each on the sources (adjudicate_s83.py; the record NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). final_pass.adjudicated_state() lays the adjudication's units over the owner's decisions of Session 79; this script writes, never by hand: - neec_corpus_v2.json the 23 entries on the 29 criteria, with the adjudication applied - neec_scores_v2.csv their totals, domain sums, failures and tiers - summary_blocks_v2.json the site's per-entry blocks (each changed or flagged unit's alternative is its close call) + neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json the 23 entries on the 29 criteria, with the adjudication applied + neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv their totals, domain sums, failures and tiers + summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json the site's per-entry blocks (each changed or flagged unit's alternative is its + close call) NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md the generated tables only, between the record's '' and '' markers: the 177 outcomes, the changes, the standing, the summary The Session 79 state is kept as neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json and its two companions (apply_owner_s79.py writes them); -compare_outside.py and outside_kit.py read those, the files the pre-registration and the kit name. +compare_outside.py and outside_kit.py read those, the files the pre-registration and the kit name. Since Session 84 this +script writes the Session 83 state as the three *_s83_snapshot files above; apply_owner_s84.py writes the v2 files with the +owner's items of Session 84 laid over this state. Usage: python3 apply_adjudication_s83.py write the three files and the record's generated tables python3 apply_adjudication_s83.py --check recompute and compare with the files on disk (exit 1 on any difference); @@ -36,7 +39,8 @@ import final_pass as fp # noqa: E402 import pass_common as pc # noqa: E402 -OUT = {"corpus": "neec_corpus_v2.json", "csv": "neec_scores_v2.csv", "blocks": "summary_blocks_v2.json"} +OUT = {"corpus": "neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json", "csv": "neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv", + "blocks": "summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json"} SNAP = {"corpus": "neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json", "csv": "neec_scores_v2_s79_snapshot.csv", "blocks": "summary_blocks_v2_s79_snapshot.json"} RECORD = "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md" diff --git a/apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt b/apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt index f70cab4..ce0f694 100644 --- a/apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt +++ b/apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ - FAIL neec_corpus_v2.json equals what the generator produces - PASS neec_scores_v2.csv equals what the generator produces - PASS summary_blocks_v2.json equals what the generator produces + FAIL neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json equals what the generator produces + PASS neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv equals what the generator produces + PASS summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json equals what the generator produces PASS NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md carries every generated table (changes, outcomes, revisions, standing, summary) as the generator produces it FAIL the corpus carries the verdict of each of the 517 units PASS the run's reader results (667 first readings) against the Session 79 corpus give 177 disagreements, each with its outcome and the verdicts the outcome names diff --git a/apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt b/apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt index eb3940c..628bf1e 100644 --- a/apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt +++ b/apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ - PASS neec_corpus_v2.json equals what the generator produces - PASS neec_scores_v2.csv equals what the generator produces - PASS summary_blocks_v2.json equals what the generator produces + PASS neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json equals what the generator produces + PASS neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv equals what the generator produces + PASS summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json equals what the generator produces PASS NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md carries every generated table (changes, outcomes, revisions, standing, summary) as the generator produces it PASS the corpus carries the verdict of each of the 517 units PASS the run's reader results (667 first readings) against the Session 79 corpus give 177 disagreements, each with its outcome and the verdicts the outcome names diff --git a/apply_owner_s84.py b/apply_owner_s84.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..34b95a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/apply_owner_s84.py @@ -0,0 +1,264 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +""" +apply_owner_s84.py -- NEEC: the generator that applies the owner's items and closes two consistency gaps (Session 84, ledger S68) +============================================================================================================================= +Session 83's adjudication put four readings to the owner; the owner answered (D66, D67). Session 84 also re-read the two +clauses of CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C3.4 that rested on the unit's own text, and read Participatory Economics' C1.2b by the +adjudication's rule 4 (owner_s84.py; the record NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). final_pass.settled_state() lays the layer over the +adjudicated state; this script writes, never by hand: + + neec_corpus_v2.json the 23 entries on the 29 criteria, with the layer applied + neec_scores_v2.csv their totals, domain sums, failures and tiers + summary_blocks_v2.json the site's per-entry blocks (each unit's alternative is its close call) + NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md the generated tables only, between the record's '' and + '' markers: the changes, the standing, the standing with and without + each owner decision, the summary + +Every displayed name comes from display_names.py (the entry renamed CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, ledger D68, decision 84.5); an +entry's key and code do not change. The Session 83 state is kept as neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json and its two companions +(apply_adjudication_s83.py writes them). + +Usage: python3 apply_owner_s84.py write the three files and the record's generated tables + python3 apply_owner_s84.py --check recompute and compare with the files on disk (exit 1 on any difference); also + checks the changed cells, the display name, totals, tiers and the standing +Prints file names and summaries only. Deterministic. +""" +import csv +import io +import json +import os +import re +import sys +from contextlib import redirect_stdout + +HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) +sys.path.insert(0, HERE) +import apply_pass_s65 as ap # noqa: E402 +import display_names as dn # noqa: E402 +import final_pass as fp # noqa: E402 +import pass_common as pc # noqa: E402 + +OUT = {"corpus": "neec_corpus_v2.json", "csv": "neec_scores_v2.csv", "blocks": "summary_blocks_v2.json"} +SNAP = {"corpus": "neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json", "csv": "neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv", + "blocks": "summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json"} +S78 = "neec_corpus_v2_s78_snapshot.json" +RECORD = "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md" +NOTE = ("NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), " + "the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to " + "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication " + "of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), " + "applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0") +DESCRIPTION = ("The NEEC corpus on the v2.0 criteria (29 criteria in five domains): the published 26-criterion vectors with the " + "rescoring pass applied, the three new criteria scored, the blind re-read's final readings (Sessions 71 to 77), " + "the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (Session 79), the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83) and the " + "owner's items with two consistency readings (Session 84) laid over them. Generated by apply_owner_s84.py; " + "never edited by hand. Scores: 1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure; totals, failures and tiers " + "follow by protocol section 2, with integer failure bands 0-2, 3-5 and 6+ on the 29 (decision 45.1).") +GEN = re.compile(r"(\n)(.*?)()", re.S) +# the owner's decisions and the cells each decided: (decision, cells, the value each cell takes without the decision, label) +WITHOUT = (("58.1", [("CCO", "C3.2")], 0.5, "58.1 (C3.2)"), + ("79.1", [("CCO", "C1.2a")], 0.5, "79.1 (C1.2a)"), + ("79.2", [("CCO", "C2.5")], 0.5, "79.2 (C2.5)"), + ("79.3", [("CCO", "C3.4")], 0.5, "79.3 (C3.4)"), + ("79.4", [("INT", "C3.4"), ("OS", "C3.4")], 0.5, "79.4 (C3.4 for Integral and Ostrom)"), + ("D66", [("DG", "C3.4"), ("PE", "C3.4")], 1.0, "D66 (C3.4 for Degrowth and PE)"), + ("D67", [("CCO", "C2.2"), ("CCO", "C5.3")], 1.0, "D67 (C2.2 and C5.3)")) +# on the readings alone: every cell at its reading, without the owner. The five raises are reversed; D66 and D67 applied the +# readings, so their cells already stand there (reversing them would restore 1.0s the readings do not give) +READINGS = ("58.1", "79.1", "79.2", "79.3", "79.4") + + +def state(): + with redirect_stdout(io.StringIO()): + p = pc.Pass() + units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, _, _, _ = fp.settled_state(p) + adj = pc.load("adjudicate_s83", "adjudicate_s83.py") + ow = pc.load("owner_s79", "owner_s79.py") + s84 = pc.load("owner_s84", "owner_s84.py") + return p, units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, adj, ow, s84 + + +def build(): + p, units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, adj, ow, s84 = state() + rec = {t: r for t, _, _, r, _ in fp.GROUPS} + rec[ow.TAG] = ow.RECORD + rec[adj.TAG] = adj.RECORD + rec[s84.TAG] = s84.RECORD + + def record_of(c, k): + tag = new_part_of.get((c, k)) or part_of.get((c, k)) + if tag in rec: + return rec[tag] + if (c, k) in new_units or k in p.mods[-1].CRITS: + return "NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md" + return "the rescoring record of the part that read it" + + def row_notes(changed): + return [f"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's " + f"items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): {changed} of the " + f"26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time", + "Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records " + "(NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to " + "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md."] + texts, _, vec, _ = ap.build({"units": units, "new_units": new_units, "part_of": part_of, "note": NOTE, + "description": DESCRIPTION, "row_notes": row_notes, "record_of": record_of}) + out = {} + for k in ("corpus", "blocks"): + obj = dn.rename_obj(json.loads(texts[ap.OUT[k]])) + out[OUT[k]] = json.dumps(obj, indent=1, ensure_ascii=False) + "\n" + out[OUT["csv"]] = dn.rename(texts[ap.OUT["csv"]]) + snap = json.load(open(os.path.join(HERE, SNAP["corpus"]), encoding="utf-8")) + v_old = {e["code"]: e["vector"] for e in snap["entries"]} + return out, p, adj, ow, s84, units, new_units, vec, v_old + + +def without(vec, decisions): + """The vectors with the named owner decisions reversed (each cell to the value it takes without the decision).""" + v = {c: dict(x) for c, x in vec.items()} + for d, cells, val, _ in WITHOUT: + if d in decisions: + for c, k in cells: + v[c][k] = val + return v + + +def tables(p, s84, vec, v_old): + """The record's generated tables, by name.""" + f1 = pc.f1 + names = {c: dn.DISPLAY.get(c, n) for c, n in p.names.items()} + crit = json.load(open(os.path.join(HERE, "criteria.json"), encoding="utf-8")) + cname = {c["id"]: c["name"] for c in crit["criteria"]} + order = [c for d in crit["domains"] for c in d["criteria"]] + out = {} + def dec(k): + return (s84.OWNER.get(k) or s84.REVISIONS.get(k) or s84.UNITS.get(k))["decision"] + keys = sorted(set(s84.OWNER) | set(s84.REVISIONS) | set(s84.UNITS), key=lambda k: (dec(k), p.order.index(k[0]), order.index(k[1]))) + rows = ["| Decision | Criterion | Entry | Before | After | What changed |", "|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|"] + for c, k in keys: + if (c, k) in s84.OWNER: + d, what = s84.OWNER[(c, k)]["decision"], f"the owner's answer to {s84.OWNER[(c, k)]['ledger']}: the adjudication's reading applied" + elif (c, k) in s84.REVISIONS: + d, what = s84.REVISIONS[(c, k)]["decision"], ("clauses " + " and ".join(str(n) for n in s84.REVISIONS[(c, k)]["clauses"]) + + " re-read on cited sources; the verdict holds") + else: + d, what = s84.UNITS[(c, k)]["decision"], "read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (one reading per class)" + rows.append(f"| {d} | {k} {cname[k]} | {names[c]} | {f1(v_old[c][k])} | {f1(vec[c][k])} | {what} |") + out["changes"] = "\n".join(rows) + now = {c: sum(v.values()) for c, v in vec.items()} + old = {c: sum(v.values()) for c, v in v_old.items()} + fn = {c: sum(1 for x in v.values() if x == 0.0) for c, v in vec.items()} + fo = {c: sum(1 for x in v.values() if x == 0.0) for c, v in v_old.items()} + rk_o, rk_n = pc.ranks(old), pc.ranks(now) + rows = ["| Entry | Session 83 (rank) | Session 84 (rank) | Change | Failures | Tier |", "|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|"] + for c in sorted(p.order, key=lambda x: (-now[x], p.order.index(x))): + tier = pc.tier(fn[c]) + ("" if pc.tier(fn[c]) == pc.tier(fo[c]) else f" (was {pc.tier(fo[c])})") + rows.append(f"| {names[c]} | {f1(old[c])} ({rk_o[c]}) | {f1(now[c])} ({rk_n[c]}) | {f1(now[c] - old[c])} | " + f"{fo[c]} to {fn[c]} | {tier} |") + out["standing"] = "\n".join(rows) + cols = [("Session 84", ())] + [(f"without {lab}", (d,)) for d, _, _, lab in WITHOUT] + \ + [("on the readings alone (no owner decision)", READINGS)] + tots = [] + for _, ds in cols: + t = {c: sum(v.values()) for c, v in without(vec, ds).items()} + tots.append((t, pc.ranks(t))) + rows = ["| Entry | " + " | ".join(lab for lab, _ in cols) + " |", "|---|" + "---:|" * len(cols)] + for c in sorted(p.order, key=lambda x: (-now[x], p.order.index(x)))[:10]: + rows.append(f"| {names[c]} | " + " | ".join(f"{f1(t[c])} ({r[c]})" for t, r in tots) + " |") + out["withwithout"] = "\n".join(rows) + first = [c for c in p.order if now[c] == max(now.values())] + second = max(now[c] for c in p.order if c not in first) + at2 = [c for c in p.order if now[c] == second] + alone = tots[-1][0] + top = max(alone.values()) + out["summary"] = (f"The layer writes {len(keys)} units: {len(s84.OWNER)} owner items applied (decisions 84.1 and 84.2), " + f"{len(s84.REVISIONS)} clause revision with the verdict held (84.3) and {len(s84.UNITS)} class reading " + f"(84.4); {sum(1 for c, k in keys if vec[c][k] != v_old[c][k])} verdicts change. First place: " + f"{', '.join(names[c] for c in first)} at {f1(now[first[0]])}, ahead of {', '.join(names[c] for c in at2)} " + f"at {f1(second)}; tier changes: " + f"{', '.join(names[c] for c in p.order if pc.tier(fn[c]) != pc.tier(fo[c])) or 'none'}. On the readings " + f"alone (no owner decision: the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed): {', '.join(names[c] for c in p.order if alone[c] == top)} " + f"first at {f1(top)}, {names['CCO']} {f1(alone['CCO'])}.") + return out + + +def record_text(gen): + path = os.path.join(HERE, RECORD) + if not os.path.isfile(path): + return None, None + old = open(path, encoding="utf-8").read() + new = GEN.sub(lambda m: m.group(1) + gen[m.group(2)] + "\n" + m.group(4), old) + return old, new + + +def main(): + texts, p, adj, ow, s84, units, new_units, vec, v_old = build() + gen = tables(p, s84, vec, v_old) + old_rec, new_rec = record_text(gen) + if "--check" in sys.argv[1:]: + ok = True + + def check(cond, text, detail=""): + nonlocal ok + print(f" {'PASS' if cond else 'FAIL'} {text}" + ("" if cond or not detail else f": {detail}")) + ok = ok and bool(cond) + for name, t in texts.items(): + good = os.path.isfile(os.path.join(HERE, name)) and open(os.path.join(HERE, name), encoding="utf-8").read() == t + check(good, f"{name} equals what the generator produces") + names_in = {m.group(2) for m in GEN.finditer(old_rec or "")} + check(old_rec is not None and old_rec == new_rec and names_in == set(gen), + f"{RECORD} carries every generated table ({', '.join(sorted(gen))}) as the generator produces it") + corpus = json.loads(open(os.path.join(HERE, OUT["corpus"]), encoding="utf-8").read()) + v_now = {e["code"]: e["vector"] for e in corpus["entries"]} + allu = {**units, **new_units} + check(all(v_now[c][k] == u["verdict"] for (c, k), u in allu.items()), + f"the corpus carries the verdict of each of the {len(allu)} units") + moved = {(c, k) for c in v_now for k in v_now[c] if v_now[c][k] != v_old[c][k]} + want = set(s84.OWNER) | set(s84.UNITS) + check(moved == want and all(v_now[c][k] == 0.5 and v_old[c][k] == 1.0 for c, k in moved) + and all(v_now[c][k] == adj.OWNER[(c, k)]["proposed"] for c, k in s84.OWNER) + and all(v_now[c][k] == v_old[c][k] == 1.0 for c, k in s84.REVISIONS), + f"the corpus differs from the Session 83 snapshot in exactly the {len(want)} cells the layer changes, each 1.0 to " + "0.5 (the four owner items as the adjudication reads them, and Participatory Economics' C1.2b); " + "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4 holds at 1.0") + e = {x["code"]: x for x in corpus["entries"]} + raw = "".join(texts.values()) + check(e["CCO"]["display_name"] == dn.DISPLAY["CCO"] and e["CCO"]["key"] == dn.OLD["CCO"] + and dn.OLD["CCO"] not in raw.replace(f'"key": "{dn.OLD["CCO"]}"', ""), + "the entry is shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP in the corpus, the CSV and the blocks; its key keeps the identifier") + rows = {r["system"]: r for r in csv.DictReader(io.StringIO(texts[OUT["csv"]]))} + check(all(abs(float(rows[e[c]["display_name"]]["total_score"]) - sum(v_now[c].values())) < 1e-9 + and int(rows[e[c]["display_name"]]["failures"]) == sum(1 for x in v_now[c].values() if x == 0.0) + for c in v_now), + "each total and failure count in the CSV is the sum of the corpus vector") + blocks = json.loads(texts[OUT["blocks"]]) + flagged = {(b["code"], f["criterion"]): f["alternatives"] for b in blocks for f in b["flags"]} + check(all(b["vector"] == v_now[b["code"]] and b["summary"]["total"] == sum(v_now[b["code"]].values()) for b in blocks) + and all(flagged.get(k) == [allu[k]["flag"][0][0]] for k in want if allu[k]["flag"]), + "each block's vector and total equal the corpus's, and each changed unit with a flag is a close call toward " + "its alternative") + now = {c: sum(v.values()) for c, v in v_now.items()} + fails = {c: sum(1 for x in v.values() if x == 0.0) for c, v in v_now.items()} + fails_old = {c: sum(1 for x in v.values() if x == 0.0) for c, v in v_old.items()} + top = sorted(now, key=lambda c: -now[c]) + check(top[0] == "CCO" and abs(now["CCO"] - 16.5) < 1e-9 and abs(now["PE"] - 15.5) < 1e-9 + and max(now[c] for c in now if c != "CCO") == 15.5, + "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is first alone at 16.5; Participatory Economics 15.5, level with the next") + check(all(pc.tier(fails[c]) == pc.tier(fails_old[c]) for c in now), "no tier changes") + alone = {c: sum(v.values()) for c, v in without(v_now, READINGS).items()} + check(abs(alone["CCO"] - 14.5) < 1e-9 and max(alone.values()) == 15.5 and alone["CCO"] < max(alone.values()), + "on the readings alone (the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5, below the " + "first place at 15.5") + print("\nOWNER ITEMS OF SESSION 84: APPLICATION CHECKED." if ok else "\nOWNER ITEMS OF SESSION 84: CHECKS FAILED.") + return 0 if ok else 1 + for name, t in texts.items(): + open(os.path.join(HERE, name), "w", encoding="utf-8").write(t) + print(f" wrote {name}") + if new_rec is not None and new_rec != old_rec: + open(os.path.join(HERE, RECORD), "w", encoding="utf-8").write(new_rec) + print(f" wrote the generated tables of {RECORD}") + print(" " + gen["summary"]) + return 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + sys.exit(main()) diff --git a/apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt b/apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a4d3e45 --- /dev/null +++ b/apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ + FAIL neec_corpus_v2.json equals what the generator produces + PASS summary_blocks_v2.json equals what the generator produces + PASS neec_scores_v2.csv equals what the generator produces + PASS NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md carries every generated table (changes, standing, summary, withwithout) as the generator produces it + FAIL the corpus carries the verdict of each of the 519 units + FAIL the corpus differs from the Session 83 snapshot in exactly the 5 cells the layer changes, each 1.0 to 0.5 (the four owner items as the adjudication reads them, and Participatory Economics' C1.2b); CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4 holds at 1.0 + FAIL the entry is shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP in the corpus, the CSV and the blocks; its key keeps the identifier + FAIL each total and failure count in the CSV is the sum of the corpus vector + FAIL each block's vector and total equal the corpus's, and each changed unit with a flag is a close call toward its alternative + FAIL CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is first alone at 16.5; Participatory Economics 15.5, level with the next + PASS no tier changes + FAIL on the readings alone (the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5, below the first place at 15.5 + +OWNER ITEMS OF SESSION 84: CHECKS FAILED. diff --git a/apply_owner_s84_output.txt b/apply_owner_s84_output.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e20240c --- /dev/null +++ b/apply_owner_s84_output.txt @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ + PASS neec_corpus_v2.json equals what the generator produces + PASS summary_blocks_v2.json equals what the generator produces + PASS neec_scores_v2.csv equals what the generator produces + PASS NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md carries every generated table (changes, standing, summary, withwithout) as the generator produces it + PASS the corpus carries the verdict of each of the 519 units + PASS the corpus differs from the Session 83 snapshot in exactly the 5 cells the layer changes, each 1.0 to 0.5 (the four owner items as the adjudication reads them, and Participatory Economics' C1.2b); CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4 holds at 1.0 + PASS the entry is shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP in the corpus, the CSV and the blocks; its key keeps the identifier + PASS each total and failure count in the CSV is the sum of the corpus vector + PASS each block's vector and total equal the corpus's, and each changed unit with a flag is a close call toward its alternative + PASS CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is first alone at 16.5; Participatory Economics 15.5, level with the next + PASS no tier changes + PASS on the readings alone (the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5, below the first place at 15.5 + +OWNER ITEMS OF SESSION 84: APPLICATION CHECKED. diff --git a/build_evidence.py b/build_evidence.py index 9656754..d086dbb 100644 --- a/build_evidence.py +++ b/build_evidence.py @@ -16,7 +16,10 @@ rescoring record that read it; * since Session 83, the outside blind review's verdict wherever its reader disagreed with NEEC (177 cells) and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, with the adjudication's outcome and a link to its record; a cell the pass held - at its published score but the adjudication read shows the adjudication's reading. + at its published score but the adjudication read shows the adjudication's reading; + * since Session 84, the owner's items and the two consistency readings of owner_s84.py (final_pass.settled_state), with + the decision that applied each and a link to its record. Every displayed name comes from display_names.py (the entry + shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, decision 84.5); a quotation of a published document keeps its words. Nothing in a report is typed by hand or newly judged. Every score, clause reading, source, flag and note is read from the files the pass already holds (criteria.json, neec_corpus_v2.json, summary_blocks_v2.json, neec_scores_v2.csv, the pass's @@ -40,6 +43,7 @@ HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) sys.path.insert(0, HERE) +import display_names as dn # noqa: E402 import final_pass as fp # noqa: E402 import pass_common as pc # noqa: E402 import gzip # noqa: E402 @@ -98,13 +102,17 @@ def __init__(self): # Session 79: the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 laid over them (final_pass.owner_state); `final_part` is the part or # blind group that read each unit before the owner's layer # Session 83: the adjudication of the outside review laid over the owner's state (final_pass.adjudicated_state) - units, part, new_units, new_part, final_part, _ = fp.adjudicated_state(self.p) + # Session 84: the owner's items and two consistency readings over that (final_pass.settled_state); `prev_part` is the + # part, group or layer that read each unit before Session 84's layer + units, part, new_units, new_part, final_part, _, adj_part = fp.settled_state(self.p) self.units = {**units, **new_units} self.part = {**part, **new_part} self.final_part = final_part with redirect_stdout(io.StringIO()): self.owner = pc.load("owner_s79", "owner_s79.py") self.adj = pc.load("adjudicate_s83", "adjudicate_s83.py") + self.s84 = pc.load("owner_s84", "owner_s84.py") + self.prev_part = {k: (adj_part.get(k) if t == self.s84.TAG else t) for k, t in self.part.items()} self.outside, self.stage_b = outside_verdicts() self.pass_part = {**self.p.part_of, **{k: self.last.TAG for k in self.last.NEW_UNITS}} self.parts = {tag: (mod, path, sess) for (tag, mod, path, sess), m in zip(pc.PARTS, self.p.mods)} @@ -132,11 +140,27 @@ def read_in(self, code, crit): txt = f"{part_label(pt)} (Session {self.sess[pt]})" bt = self.final_part[(code, crit)] txt += f" and re-read blind in Session {self.sess[bt]}" if bt != pt else "" - if self.part[(code, crit)] == self.owner.TAG: + if self.prev_part[(code, crit)] == self.owner.TAG: txt += f", then raised by the owner's decision {self.owner.CHANGES[(code, crit)]['decision']} (Session {self.owner.SESSION})" - if self.part[(code, crit)] == self.adj.TAG: + if self.prev_part[(code, crit)] == self.adj.TAG: txt += f", then adjudicated after the outside review (Session {self.adj.SESSION})" - return txt + return txt + self.s84_in(code, crit) + + def s84_in(self, code, crit): + """Session 84's clause: '', or how its layer read the cell.""" + if self.part[(code, crit)] != self.s84.TAG: + return "" + k, s = (code, crit), self.s84.SESSION + if k in self.s84.OWNER: + it = self.s84.OWNER[k] + return (f", then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision {it['decision']} (ledger " + f"{it['ledger']}, Session {s})") + if k in self.s84.REVISIONS: + rv = self.s84.REVISIONS[k] + return (f", then clause{'s' if len(rv['clauses']) > 1 else ''} " + f"{' and '.join(str(n) for n in rv['clauses'])} re-read on cited sources (decision {rv['decision']}, " + f"Session {s})") + return f", then read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (decision {self.s84.UNITS[k]['decision']}, Session {s})" def blob(self, path, line=None): u = f"{self.repo}/blob/main/{quote(path)}" @@ -234,10 +258,17 @@ def outside_line(ctx, code, crit): owner_cell = (code, crit) in ctx.owner.CHANGES or (code, crit) == ("CCO", "C3.2") o = ctx.adj.OUTCOMES.get((code, crit)) r = ctx.outside.get((code, crit)) - if o is None and not (code == "CCO" or owner_cell) or r is None: + s84 = (code, crit) in ctx.s84.UNITS + if o is None and not (code == "CCO" or owner_cell or s84) or r is None: return None rec = f"[{ctx.adj.RECORD}]({ctx.blob(ctx.adj.RECORD)})" - if o is None: + if s84 and o is None: + u = ctx.s84.UNITS[(code, crit)] + txt = (f"The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit {fmt(r)}, as NEEC then did, so the adjudication did not " + f"reach it; Session {ctx.s84.SESSION} read it {fmt(u['verdict'])} by the adjudication's rule 4 (decision " + f"{u['decision']}).") + rec += f", [{ctx.s84.RECORD}]({ctx.blob(ctx.s84.RECORD)})" + elif o is None: txt = f"The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit {fmt(r)}, as NEEC does." else: it = ctx.adj.OWNER.get((code, crit), {}) @@ -245,6 +276,12 @@ def outside_line(ctx, code, crit): if code == "CCO" else "decision 79.4, whose rule raised the cell, is the owner's") out = OUTCOME[o["outcome"]].format(stands=fmt(o["stands"]), neec=fmt(o["neec"]), proposed=fmt(it.get("proposed", o["stands"])), why_owner=why_owner) + if (code, crit) in ctx.s84.OWNER: + it = ctx.s84.OWNER[(code, crit)] + out = (f"the adjudication read it {fmt(ctx.adj.OWNER[(code, crit)]['proposed'])}, which went to the owner " + f"({why_owner}); the owner applied it (decision {it['decision']}, ledger {it['ledger']}, Session " + f"{ctx.s84.SESSION})") + rec += f", [{ctx.s84.RECORD}]({ctx.blob(ctx.s84.RECORD)})" txt = (f"The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit {fmt(r)}, against NEEC's {fmt(o['neec'])}; {out}: " f"{linked(ctx, o['why'])}.") if owner_cell and (code, crit) in ctx.stage_b: @@ -302,17 +339,29 @@ def cell(ctx, code, crit, stats): unit = ctx.units.get((code, crit)) rev = c["revision"]["cls"] out = [f'', f'### {crit} {c["name"]}: {fmt(v)} ({WORD[v]})', ""] - adjud = unit is not None and ctx.part[(code, crit)] == ctx.adj.TAG + adjud = unit is not None and ctx.prev_part[(code, crit)] == ctx.adj.TAG + late = unit is not None and ctx.part[(code, crit)] == ctx.s84.TAG if unit is not None and (code, crit) not in ctx.pass_part: - assert adjud and unit["verdict"] == v and pub is not None, f"{code} {crit}: a unit outside the pass that is not the adjudication's" + assert (adjud or late) and unit["verdict"] == v and pub is not None, \ + f"{code} {crit}: a unit outside the pass that is not the adjudication's or Session 84's" stats["adjudicated"] += 1 - prov = (f"No unit of the rescoring pass read this cell; {ctx.adj.LABEL} read it after the outside review disagreed " - f"(the adjudicated reading is shown). Published (v1) score {fmt(pub)}; v2.0 score {fmt(v)}" + if adjud: + who = f"{ctx.adj.LABEL} read it after the outside review disagreed (the adjudicated reading is shown)" + elif (code, crit) in ctx.s84.OWNER: + it = ctx.s84.OWNER[(code, crit)] + who = (f"{ctx.adj.LABEL} read it after the outside review disagreed, and the owner applied that reading " + f"(decision {it['decision']}, ledger {it['ledger']}, Session {ctx.s84.SESSION}; the adjudicated reading is " + f"shown)") + else: + who = (f"Session {ctx.s84.SESSION} read it by the adjudication's rule 4, one reading per class (decision " + f"{ctx.s84.UNITS[(code, crit)]['decision']}; that reading is shown)") + prov = (f"No unit of the rescoring pass read this cell; {who}. Published (v1) score {fmt(pub)}; v2.0 score {fmt(v)}" + (": changed." if pub != v else ": unchanged.")) elif unit is not None: assert unit["verdict"] == v, f"{code} {crit}: the unit's verdict {unit['verdict']} is not the corpus score {v}" - blind = ctx.part[(code, crit)] in ctx.blind_record or ctx.part[(code, crit)] == ctx.owner.TAG - shown = " (the adjudicated reading is shown)" if adjud else (" (the final reading is shown)" if blind else "") + blind = ctx.prev_part[(code, crit)] in ctx.blind_record or ctx.prev_part[(code, crit)] == ctx.owner.TAG + shown = (" (the adjudicated reading is shown)" if adjud or (code, crit) in ctx.s84.OWNER else + " (Session 84's reading is shown)" if late else (" (the final reading is shown)" if blind else "")) if pub is None: stats["new"] += 1 prov = (f"New in v2.0: scored for the first time in {ctx.read_in(code, crit)}, " @@ -378,13 +427,16 @@ def cell(ctx, code, crit, stats): btag = ctx.final_part[(code, crit)] if btag in ctx.blind_record: refs.append(f"Blind re-read record: [{ctx.blind_record[btag]}]({ctx.blob(ctx.blind_record[btag])})") - if ctx.part[(code, crit)] == ctx.owner.TAG: + if ctx.prev_part[(code, crit)] == ctx.owner.TAG: d = ctx.owner.CHANGES[(code, crit)]["decision"] refs.append(f"Applied by the owner's decision {d}: [{ctx.owner.RECORD}]({ctx.blob(ctx.owner.RECORD)}), " f"[owner_s79.py]({ctx.blob('owner_s79.py')})") - if adjud: + if adjud or (code, crit) in ctx.s84.OWNER: refs.append(f"Adjudicated after the outside review (Session {ctx.adj.SESSION}): [{ctx.adj.RECORD}]" f"({ctx.blob(ctx.adj.RECORD)}), [adjudicate_s83.py]({ctx.blob('adjudicate_s83.py')})") + if late: + refs.append(f"Applied in Session {ctx.s84.SESSION}: [{ctx.s84.RECORD}]({ctx.blob(ctx.s84.RECORD)}), " + f"[owner_s84.py]({ctx.blob('owner_s84.py')})") if refs: out += [" \n".join(refs), ""] if pub is not None: @@ -433,7 +485,8 @@ def report(ctx, code, rk, stats): "published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read " "says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. " "Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided " - "cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83).", "", + "cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner " + "applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84).", "", "## Contents", ""] body = [] for d in ctx.domains: @@ -449,7 +502,8 @@ def report(ctx, code, rk, stats): if unit is None: basis = "held at the published score" elif (code, crit) not in ctx.pass_part: - basis = (f"adjudicated after the outside review (Session {ctx.adj.SESSION})" + basis = ((f"adjudicated after the outside review (Session {ctx.adj.SESSION})" if ctx.prev_part[(code, crit)] + == ctx.adj.TAG else "held at the published score") + ctx.s84_in(code, crit) + (f", changed from {fmt(pub)}" if pub != v else "")) elif pub is None: basis = f"new in v2.0, scored in {ctx.read_in(code, crit)}" @@ -469,7 +523,7 @@ def report(ctx, code, rk, stats): def index(ctx, rk): tiers = {t["name"]: i for i, t in enumerate(ctx.crit["tiers"])} codes = sorted(ctx.blocks, key=lambda c: (tiers[ctx.blocks[c]["summary"]["tier"]], -ctx.blocks[c]["summary"]["total"], - ctx.cfg["systems"][c]["short"].lower())) + ctx.cfg["systems"][c].get("short", ctx.entries[c]["display_name"]).lower())) out = ["# NEEC evidence reports", "", "> Generated by `build_evidence.py`; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.", "", @@ -493,8 +547,8 @@ def build(): stats = dict(new=0, read=0, held=0, adjudicated=0, flag=0, structure=0, recline=0, rat=0, rattext=0, outside=0) files = {} for code in ctx.entries: - files[f"{OUTDIR}/{slug(code)}.md"] = report(ctx, code, rk, stats) - files[f"{OUTDIR}/index.md"] = index(ctx, rk) + files[f"{OUTDIR}/{slug(code)}.md"] = dn.keep_quotes(report(ctx, code, rk, stats)) + files[f"{OUTDIR}/index.md"] = dn.keep_quotes(index(ctx, rk)) # totals in the corpus equal the blocks' (the reports show the blocks' totals; the sections show the corpus' scores) for code, e in ctx.entries.items(): t = sum(e["vector"][c] for c in ctx.order) @@ -527,9 +581,9 @@ def main(): f.write(text) print(f"{'CHECK' if check else 'WROTE'} {len(files)} files in {OUTDIR}/: the index and {len(files) - 1} system reports") print(f" {cells} criterion sections: {stats['read']} read by the pass, {stats['new']} new in v2.0, {stats['adjudicated']} read " - f"only by the adjudication of Session 83, {stats['held']} held at the published score") - print(f" {stats['outside']} sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, and every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and " - "owner-decided cell)") + f"only by the adjudication of Session 83 or Session 84's layer, {stats['held']} held at the published score") + print(f" {stats['outside']} sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, every {dn.DISPLAY['CCO']} and " + "owner-decided cell, and Session 84's class reading)") print(f" {stats['flag']} close calls shown; {stats['rat']} published rationales linked by line, {stats['rattext']} quoted; " f"{stats['recline']} of {stats['read'] + stats['new']} pass units linked to their record's line") print(f" {stats['structure']} units shown on the clause structure they were read on (it differs from v2.0's)") diff --git a/build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt b/build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt index c00bcfd..dd7862a 100644 --- a/build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt +++ b/build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ CHECK 24 files in evidence/: the index and 23 system reports - 667 criterion sections: 427 read by the pass, 69 new in v2.0, 21 read only by the adjudication of Session 83, 150 held at the published score - 198 sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, and every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell) - 184 close calls shown; 598 published rationales linked by line, 598 quoted; 495 of 496 pass units linked to their record's line + 667 criterion sections: 427 read by the pass, 69 new in v2.0, 23 read only by the adjudication of Session 83 or Session 84's layer, 148 held at the published score + 199 sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, and Session 84's class reading) + 185 close calls shown; 598 published rationales linked by line, 598 quoted; 495 of 496 pass units linked to their record's line 0 units shown on the clause structure they were read on (it differs from v2.0's) 777 links to data files and to documents by line; 0 dangling FAIL evidence/sq.md: differs from what the script generates diff --git a/build_evidence_output.txt b/build_evidence_output.txt index 518b094..0632b6a 100644 --- a/build_evidence_output.txt +++ b/build_evidence_output.txt @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ CHECK 24 files in evidence/: the index and 23 system reports - 667 criterion sections: 427 read by the pass, 69 new in v2.0, 21 read only by the adjudication of Session 83, 150 held at the published score - 198 sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, and every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell) - 184 close calls shown; 598 published rationales linked by line, 598 quoted; 495 of 496 pass units linked to their record's line + 667 criterion sections: 427 read by the pass, 69 new in v2.0, 23 read only by the adjudication of Session 83 or Session 84's layer, 148 held at the published score + 199 sections give the outside review's verdict (its disagreements, every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, and Session 84's class reading) + 185 close calls shown; 598 published rationales linked by line, 598 quoted; 495 of 496 pass units linked to their record's line 0 units shown on the clause structure they were read on (it differs from v2.0's) 777 links to data files and to documents by line; 0 dangling EVIDENCE REPORTS CHECKED. diff --git a/build_report_v2.py b/build_report_v2.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2bef74a --- /dev/null +++ b/build_report_v2.py @@ -0,0 +1,168 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +""" +build_report_v2.py -- NEEC Report v2.0 Part I: the generated scorecards, one domain at a time (Session 84, ledger S41) +=================================================================================================================== +Decision 52.8 (W7): Report v2.0 Part I is generated from the per-unit readings carried into the corpus, not retyped. This +script writes the generated parts of NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md, between its '' and +'' markers; the prose between them (each domain's account of what moved and why) is written by hand +and never touched here. + + standing the 23 entries on the 29 criteria: total, domain sums, failures, tier, and the change from v1's 26 criteria + D1 .. D5 per domain, per criterion: the threshold, the count of each score in v1 and in v2.0, then one entry per + system in the order of the standing: its v2.0 score and v1 score, each clause's status and reading (or, for a + cell no unit of v2.0 read, the published v1 rationale, quoted), the reason for a 0.0, the close call, and a + link to the system's evidence report, where every source is given + counts per domain: cells read in v2.0, held, moved up, moved down, close calls (the prose cites these) + +Everything is read through build_evidence.Ctx (the pass, the blind groups, the owner's decisions, the adjudication and +Session 84's layer, final_pass.settled_state()); every displayed name through display_names.py. Scores change only through +the pass; this script changes none. + +Usage: python3 build_report_v2.py write the generated parts + python3 build_report_v2.py --check rebuild them in memory and compare with the file (exit 1 on any difference) +Prints the file name and a summary only. Deterministic. +""" +import io +import os +import re +import sys +from contextlib import redirect_stdout + +HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) +sys.path.insert(0, HERE) +import build_evidence as be # noqa: E402 +import display_names as dn # noqa: E402 +import pass_common as pc # noqa: E402 + +DOC = "NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md" +GEN = re.compile(r"(\n)(.*?)()", re.S) +WORD = {1.0: "pass", 0.5: "partial", 0.0: "structural failure"} + + +def context(): + with redirect_stdout(io.StringIO()): + ctx = be.Ctx() + return ctx + + +def name(ctx, code): + return ctx.entries[code]["display_name"] + + +def standing_order(ctx): + tot = {c: sum(e["vector"].values()) for c, e in ctx.entries.items()} + order = list(ctx.entries) + return sorted(order, key=lambda c: (-tot[c], order.index(c))), tot + + +def plain(s): + """A reading as prose: the evidence report's links are not repeated here.""" + return be.esc(s).replace("\n", " ") + + +def entry(ctx, code, crit, stats): + v = ctx.entries[code]["vector"][crit] + pub = ctx.p.vec[code].get(crit) + unit = ctx.units.get((code, crit)) + c = ctx.cmap[crit] + link = f"evidence/{be.slug(code)}.md#{be.anchor(crit)}" + was = "new in v2.0" if pub is None else (f"v1 {be.fmt(pub)}" + ("" if pub == v else f", {'up' if v > pub else 'down'}")) + out = [f"**{be.esc(name(ctx, code))}: {be.fmt(v)}** ({was}). [Evidence]({link})", ""] + if pub is not None and v != pub: + stats["up" if v > pub else "down"] += 1 + if unit is None: + stats["held"] += 1 + fn, ln, label, text, more = ctx.published_rationale(code, crit) + out += ["Held at the published score; no unit of v2.0 read it. The v1 rationale:", ""] + out += ([f"> {be.esc(text)}" + (" *(continues in the scoring document)*" if more else ""), ""] if text + else [f"*(No rationale paragraph under the v1 heading; {fn}, line {ln}.)*", ""]) + else: + stats["read"] += 1 + defs = c["definition"]["clauses"] + rows = [] + for i, (st, txt, _src) in enumerate(unit["clauses"], 1): + label = be.esc(defs[i - 1]) if len(unit["clauses"]) == len(defs) else f"clause {i}" + rows.append(f"{i}. *{label}*: {pc.STATUS[st]}. {plain(txt)}") + out += rows + [""] + if unit.get("zero"): + out += [f"Why 0.0 stands: {plain(unit['zero'])}", ""] + how = ctx.read_in(code, crit) if (code, crit) in ctx.pass_part else None + if how: + out += [f"Read in {how}.", ""] + elif ctx.prev_part.get((code, crit)) == ctx.adj.TAG: + out += [f"Read in the adjudication of the outside review (Session {ctx.adj.SESSION}){ctx.s84_in(code, crit)}.", ""] + else: + out += [f"Read in Session {ctx.s84.SESSION}{ctx.s84_in(code, crit)}.", ""] + for f in [f for f in ctx.blocks[code]["flags"] if f["criterion"] == crit]: + stats["flag"] += 1 + rd = f.get("reading") or "" + rd = "" if rd in ("", "see the pass record") else " " + be.cap(plain(rd)) + out += [f"Close call: a reasonable scorer could set {' or '.join(be.fmt(a) for a in f['alternatives'])}.{rd}", ""] + return out + + +def domain(ctx, d, order): + stats = dict(read=0, held=0, up=0, down=0, flag=0) + out = [] + for crit in d["criteria"]: + c = ctx.cmap[crit] + v2 = [ctx.entries[k]["vector"][crit] for k in order] + v1 = [ctx.p.vec[k].get(crit) for k in order] + dist = lambda xs: ", ".join(f"{sum(1 for x in xs if x == s)} at {be.fmt(s)}" for s in (1.0, 0.5, 0.0)) + out += [f"### {crit} {be.esc(c['name'])}", "", + f"Pass Threshold (v2.0): {be.esc(c['definition']['pass_threshold'])}. Revision class " + f"{c['revision']['cls']} ({be.CLASS_GLOSS[c['revision']['cls']]}).", "", + f"v2.0: {dist(v2)}." + (f" v1: {dist(v1)}." if None not in v1 else " New in v2.0."), ""] + for code in order: + out += entry(ctx, code, crit, stats) + return "\n".join(out).rstrip("\n"), stats + + +def build(ctx): + order, tot = standing_order(ctx) + gen = {} + rows = ["| Rank | Entry | Total of 29 | " + " | ".join(f"D{i + 1}" for i in range(len(ctx.domains))) + + " | Failures | Tier | v1 (of 26) |", "|---:|---|---:|" + "---:|" * len(ctx.domains) + "---:|---|---:|"] + rk = pc.ranks(tot) + for code in order: + b = ctx.blocks[code]["summary"] + v1 = sum(ctx.p.vec[code].values()) + rows.append(f"| {rk[code]} | {be.esc(name(ctx, code))} | {be.fmt(tot[code])} | " + + " | ".join(be.fmt(b[d["id"]]) for d in ctx.domains) + + f" | {b['failures']} | {b['tier']} | {be.fmt(v1)} |") + gen["standing"] = "\n".join(rows) + counts = [] + for d in ctx.domains: + text, st = domain(ctx, d, order) + gen[d["id"]] = text + counts.append(f"| {d['id'][1:]}. {be.esc(d['name'])} | {len(d['criteria']) * len(order)} | {st['read']} | {st['held']} | " + f"{st['up']} | {st['down']} | {st['flag']} |") + gen["counts"] = "\n".join(["| Domain | Cells | Read in v2.0 | Held | Up from v1 | Down from v1 | Close calls |", + "|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|"] + counts) + return {k: dn.keep_quotes(v) for k, v in gen.items()} + + +def main(): + path = os.path.join(HERE, DOC) + if not os.path.isfile(path): + sys.exit(f"ERROR: missing {DOC}") + gen = build(context()) + old = open(path, encoding="utf-8").read() + names = {m.group(2) for m in GEN.finditer(old)} + missing = sorted(set(gen) - names) + new = GEN.sub(lambda m: m.group(1) + gen[m.group(2)] + "\n" + m.group(4) if m.group(2) in gen else m.group(0), old) + if "--check" in sys.argv[1:]: + ok = new == old and not missing and names <= set(gen) + print(f"{DOC}: {len(names)} generated parts ({', '.join(sorted(names))}) " + + ("equal what the script generates" if ok else "differ from what the script generates") + + (f"; missing: {', '.join(missing)}" if missing else "")) + return 0 if ok else 1 + if new != old: + open(path, "w", encoding="utf-8").write(new) + print(f" wrote the generated parts of {DOC}") + print(f" {len(names)} generated parts; {len(gen) - len(names & set(gen))} of the script's not in the file") + return 0 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + sys.exit(main()) diff --git a/build_report_v2_output.txt b/build_report_v2_output.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1e17a30 --- /dev/null +++ b/build_report_v2_output.txt @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md: 7 generated parts (D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, counts, standing) equal what the script generates diff --git a/build_site.py b/build_site.py index 0dbf25e..028d547 100644 --- a/build_site.py +++ b/build_site.py @@ -19,6 +19,9 @@ python3 build_site.py --preview DIR write a preview to DIR (never docs/) that shows the corpus's published scores whatever the gate says, under a preview banner +Every displayed name passes through display_names.py, the one display-name mapping (Session 84, decision 84.5: the entry +shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP). + Standard library only. The output is byte-deterministic: no dates, no random ordering. """ import argparse @@ -40,6 +43,8 @@ VERSION = "1.0" HERE = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)) +sys.path.insert(0, HERE) +import display_names as dn # noqa: E402 def P(*a): @@ -390,7 +395,8 @@ def discuss(self, title): def put(self, rel, text): assert rel not in self.files, rel - self.files[rel] = text.encode("utf-8") if isinstance(text, str) else text + # every displayed name from the one mapping (display_names.py, decision 84.5) + self.files[rel] = dn.rename(text).encode("utf-8") if isinstance(text, str) else text def page(self, rel, pid, title, desc, main, data=None, jsonld=None, absolute=False): depth = rel.count("/") diff --git a/display_names.py b/display_names.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..80d93bc --- /dev/null +++ b/display_names.py @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +""" +display_names.py -- NEEC: the one display-name mapping for the generators of the current state (Session 84, ledger S69, D68) +========================================================================================================================== +The owner renamed the scored entry CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH to CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (ledger D68, decision 84.5): PTH (Public Trust +Housing) is already read in the entry's units, so the name is corrected, not the scope. The records of Sessions 1 to 83 keep the +old name, and so do the generators that rebuild them (their outputs are those records). The generators of the current state +(apply_owner_s84.py: the corpus, the CSV and the site's blocks; build_evidence.py: the evidence reports; build_site.py: the +site and its visual suite) take every displayed name from here. An entry's `key` and `code` are identifiers and do not change. + + DISPLAY {code: the name shown now}, for the entries whose name changed + OLD {code: the name the records before Session 84 use} + rename(s) the string with every old name replaced by the name shown now, except where 'formerly ' precedes it (the + entry's note on the site names its earlier name that way) + rename_obj(o) the same through a JSON value, leaving `key` fields (identifiers) as they are + keep_quotes(s) rename(s) for a Markdown text, leaving quoted lines ('> ') and the published-rationale heading lines alone: + a quotation of a published document keeps its words + +No main; nothing is printed. Deterministic. +""" +import re + +DISPLAY = {"CCO": "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP"} +OLD = {"CCO": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH"} + + +def rename(s): + for code, old in OLD.items(): + s = re.sub(r"(? ") or ln.startswith("**Published (v1) rationale**") else rename(ln) + for ln in s.split("\n")) diff --git a/docs/404.html b/docs/404.html index f0cae0e..ea1acd0 100644 --- a/docs/404.html +++ b/docs/404.html @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@

Page not found

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/contribute.html b/docs/contribute.html index ae965e6..1e388fa 100644 --- a/docs/contribute.html +++ b/docs/contribute.html @@ -53,7 +53,7 @@

What happens to a report

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-1.html b/docs/criteria/c1-1.html index bd9fa3a..b0759ad 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-1.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-1.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

How scores are anchored

(Note: Section 6's "Requirement" line states an aspirational 95%; the operative Pass Threshold used for actual scoring throughout this corpus is 90%/85% — use the Pass Threshold, not the Requirement line, when the two differ, and flag any future criterion where this gap exists rather than silently picking one.)

Normative roots

From N1 (Human Flourishing) + N2 (Labor Non-Necessity) + N3 (Coercion Minimization).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-2a.html b/docs/criteria/c1-2a.html index eee7f93..f4e0b1b 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-2a.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-2a.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

How scores are anchored

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K6, R2; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N4 (Universal Wealth Access) + N3 (Coercion Minimization) — unchanged from legacy C1.2's derivation, since this sub-criterion inherits the resilience-buffer half of what legacy C1.2 asked..

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7v2.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criter

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-2b.html b/docs/criteria/c1-2b.html index c8d3884..d5d6201 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-2b.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-2b.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How scores are anchored

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was reworded without a change of bar (W; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md); the band texts stand.

Normative roots

From N4 (Universal Wealth Access) + N7 (Governance Legitimacy and Anti-Capture) — a new derivation pairing for this sub-criterion: N4 supplies the "wealth is power" logic, N7 supplies the anti-capture framing that concentration specifically threatens..

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7v2.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criter

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-3.html b/docs/criteria/c1-3.html index b711419..e51aecc 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-3.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-3.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

Benchmark

Community Land Trusts achieve 10x lower foreclosure rates t

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Structural decommodification or strong regulatory stabilization with a documented or clearly-designed stability rate at or above threshold. Centrally Planned Socialism (1.0): "Universal housing provision through state allocation... homelessness essentially eliminated."

0.5, partial

Partial protection or a real but incomplete mechanism — e.g., some cooperative/social housing alongside a still-dominant market allocation. Universal Basic Income (0.5): "Stable income improves housing security... but without housing policy, landlords can capture UBI through rent increases."

0.0, structural failure

Pure market allocation with no stabilizing mechanism. Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Pure market allocation with no stabilization... homelessness treated as individual failing rather than systemic outcome."

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K6, R2; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N1 (Human Flourishing) + N3 (Coercion Minimization).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-4.html b/docs/criteria/c1-4.html index 8ec3f58..ba66b96 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-4.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-4.html @@ -38,11 +38,11 @@

What it asks

Maintain material security as human labor becomes increa

Why it matters

This criterion alone disqualifies most existing frameworks. When machines replace humans at scale, systems dependent on wage labor for both income and aggregate demand collapse into deflationary spirals that no monetary policy can resolve.

How it is measured

Stress test across the three automation scenarios, a displacement of 30%, 50% or 70% of baseline paid working hours, with no assumption about when each occurs. In each, poverty is measured at the Societal Poverty Line, as in C1.1, and aggregate demand as real final consumption expenditure relative to the pre-displacement baseline. The Pass Threshold's figures apply in every scenario.

Indicators

Societal Poverty Line (as C1.1); national accounts final consumption expenditure; for a design, its own model of the three scenarios.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

An explicit mechanism decoupling income/demand from employment, robust in the system's own design logic across displacement severities. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "Stress testing shows the system maintains poverty <5% and aggregate demand 90-110% baseline across 30%, 50%, 70% job displacement scenarios."

0.5, partial

A buffer or partial mechanism exists but is not designed for or shown to survive the higher-severity scenarios. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Generous unemployment benefits... still fundamentally dependent on wage labor for tax revenue and social cohesion. Cannot sustain 50-70% displacement scenarios."

0.0, structural failure

No mechanism; system structurally requires wage labor for both income distribution and demand. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "No mechanism exists to maintain either as automation advances... would trigger a deflationary spiral."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

An explicit mechanism decoupling income/demand from employment, robust in the system's own design logic across displacement severities. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "Stress testing shows the system maintains poverty <5% and aggregate demand 90-110% baseline across 30%, 50%, 70% job displacement scenarios."

0.5, partial

A buffer or partial mechanism exists but is not designed for or shown to survive the higher-severity scenarios. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Generous unemployment benefits... still fundamentally dependent on wage labor for tax revenue and social cohesion. Cannot sustain 50-70% displacement scenarios."

0.0, structural failure

No mechanism; system structurally requires wage labor for both income distribution and demand. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "No mechanism exists to maintain either as automation advances... would trigger a deflationary spiral."

Apply it carefully; see also Appendix G for a documented case where a candidate evidentiary source (a companion simulation) could not actually be used to evaluate a system at this criterion's higher severities. v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was reworded without a change of bar (K6, R1; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md); the band texts stand.

Normative roots

From N2 (Labor Non-Necessity) + N11 (Automation Compatibility).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c1-5.html b/docs/criteria/c1-5.html index 187b3d1..ed17790 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c1-5.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c1-5.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

Note on the threshold

Gini clause removed, moved to C1.2b, Paper Sect

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Broad-based access not contingent on prior wealth or narrow membership. Nordic Social Democracy (1.0): "Approximately 70% have wealth accumulation pathways... meets the threshold for broad-based access" — the same qualitative-tolerance judgment call already documented in H.7's own C1.5 entry above carries over unchanged, since it was never about the Gini clause.

0.5, partial

Access exists but is gated such that a meaningful population segment is excluded. Market Socialism (0.5): "Members have wealth access, but require cooperative membership. Unemployed, between jobs, or unable to work lack access."

0.0, structural failure

Access concentrated among those already positioned to have it. Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Wealth concentration accelerates without redistributive mechanisms... only those born with capital have genuine wealth-building access."

This band's reasoning is unchanged from legacy C1.5's anchors (H.7 above); narrowing the threshold doesn't change which systems clear an access-breadth bar, only removes a second, now-separate test that used to ride alongside it. v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was reworded without a change of bar (W; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md); the band texts stand.

Normative roots

From N4 (Universal Wealth Access) + N7 (Anti-Capture) — unchanged from legacy C1.5..

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7v2.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 12.3; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criter

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-1.html b/docs/criteria/c2-1.html index e8c7117..c6bde83 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-1.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-1.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Clause 1: the share of adults satisfied with their

Indicators

clause 1, Gallup World Poll (World Happiness Report data); clause 2, aspirational.

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Structural design removes survival-based compulsion without substituting a comparably coercive replacement. Universal Basic Income (1.0): "Pilots show 65-75% report increased autonomy... genuine choice because survival is not contingent on accepting any available job."

0.5, partial

Meaningfully reduces coercion relative to a harsher baseline but does not eliminate it. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "Only 15-25% report genuine autonomy... though better than complete absence of choice."

0.0, structural failure

Eliminates one form of coercion only to substitute another of comparable severity, or maximizes economic coercion by design. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Eliminated market coercion but replaced with state coercion." Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Eliminates state coercion but maximizes economic coercion... all market exchanges occur under duress for those lacking capital."

Normative roots

From N3 (Coercion Minimization) + N2 (Labor Non-Necessity).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-2.html b/docs/criteria/c2-2.html index a246cd9..f2ffeb0 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-2.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-2.html @@ -37,10 +37,10 @@

Why it matters

As automation makes labor optional, tying survival to

How it differs from nearby criteria

Labor opportunity (valuable) from labor compulsion (coercive). Systems can and should provide meaningful work opportunities without making survival contingent on employment.

How it is measured

Provision of unconditional basic security covering essential needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) without work requirements, behavior conditions, or means testing.

Disclosure

"Unconditional" is the content of N2 itself, not an instrument clause, and stays; this is the one criterion that favors unconditional-provision designs by definition, and Paper v2.0 says so.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Provision is explicitly unconditional. Fully Automated Luxury Communism (1.0): "labor becomes an optional hobby rather than survival requirement." CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "No work requirements, behavior conditions, or means testing."

0.5, partial

A real baseline exists but is time-limited, conditional, or requires some ongoing contribution. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Generous... benefits provide baseline security, but still time-limited and conditional."

0.0, structural failure

No baseline security independent of labor market participation, whether by absence or by ideological commitment to full employment. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "Survival entirely contingent on labor market participation or charity." MMT+Job Guarantee (0.0): "Ideologically committed to full employment... fundamentally rejects the premise that labor can become optional."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Provision is explicitly unconditional. Fully Automated Luxury Communism (1.0): "labor becomes an optional hobby rather than survival requirement." CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "No work requirements, behavior conditions, or means testing."

0.5, partial

A real baseline exists but is time-limited, conditional, or requires some ongoing contribution. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Generous... benefits provide baseline security, but still time-limited and conditional."

0.0, structural failure

No baseline security independent of labor market participation, whether by absence or by ideological commitment to full employment. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "Survival entirely contingent on labor market participation or charity." MMT+Job Guarantee (0.0): "Ideologically committed to full employment... fundamentally rejects the premise that labor can become optional."

This threshold is binary in character (unconditional or not) more than most others — score accordingly; partial credit here specifically means time-limited or conditional provision, not "provision covering less than 100% of needs."

Normative roots

From N2 (Labor Non-Necessity) + N1 (Human Flourishing).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-3.html b/docs/criteria/c2-3.html index bb322e4..dac1dec 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-3.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-3.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Clause 1 (regular creative engagement): the share

Indicators

clause 1, aspirational; clause 2, OECD Time Use Database, HETUS, ATUS; clause 3, EU-SILC and ONS "worthwhile" item.

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

System structurally frees substantial time/resources for non-subsistence pursuits, at or plausibly above the threshold. Degrowth Economics (1.0): "Reduced working hours (20-hour week)... explicitly prioritizes creative and social time over productivity."

0.5, partial

Some engagement, meaningfully constrained by time scarcity or narrow access. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "Only 20-30% engage regularly... time poverty prevents meaningful pursuit."

0.0, structural failure

Structural suppression of creative/cultural activity, typically via state control of cultural production rather than mere time scarcity. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "State control of cultural production suppressed creative expression... culture subordinated to political ideology."

Normative roots

From N1 (Human Flourishing) + N13 (Incentive Alignment).

-

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

+

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-4.html b/docs/criteria/c2-4.html index e42f621..a8e571e 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-4.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-4.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Clause 1 (participation): turnout as a share of th

Indicators

International IDEA Voter Turnout Database; official records of initiative and participatory processes; OECD Trust Survey external-efficacy item.

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Structural mechanisms for continuous, substantive citizen influence over both political and economic decisions. Participatory Economics (1.0): "Comprehensive economic democracy through nested councils. Everyone participates in planning affecting them."

0.5, partial

Formal democratic rights exist but influence is diluted by concentrated economic power. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "Average citizens have 'near-zero independent impact' (Gilens & Page, 2014)."

0.0, structural failure

No meaningful participation mechanism, by design or suppression. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Single-party rule eliminated meaningful democratic participation... political dissent suppressed systematically." FALC (0.0): "Governance structures largely unspecified. Who controls the machines?"

Normative roots

From N7 (Governance Legitimacy) + N1 (Human Flourishing).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-5.html b/docs/criteria/c2-5.html index 61a8ff7..111ad42 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-5.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-5.html @@ -36,10 +36,10 @@

C2.5 Exit Rights and Mobility

What it asks

Participants can opt out without penalty and relocate without losing essential benefits; freedom of association is measured in C2.6.

Why it matters

Systems forcing universal participation become totalitarian regardless of ostensible benefits. Ability to exit, form alternative communities, and organize based on preference rather than necessity represents crucial freedom distinguishing voluntary cooperation from imposed uniformity.

How it is measured

Ease of exit (time and resources required to leave the system). Penalties for non-participation (differential treatment of non-participants). Capacity to leave for alternative arrangements, including forming or joining alternative communities. Geographic mobility (freedom to relocate without losing essential benefits).

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Individuals can opt out without penalty and the system continues functioning at partial participation. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "System viable at 30%+ participation, enabling opt-out without penalty... can exit to the traditional market economy while the system continues functioning."

0.5, partial

Formal exit rights exist but are constrained by real economic costs (job/healthcare/housing lock-in) not imposed by the system's own design. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "High exit barriers from job mobility costs, healthcare tied to employment, housing market barriers."

0.0, structural failure

The system's own funding or coherence structurally requires near-universal participation, such that a meaningful opt-out rate would collapse it. Nordic Social Democracy (0.0): "Systems require near-universal participation for funding sustainability. Cannot function with 30% opt-out; tax base would collapse." Degrowth Economics (0.0): "Cannot function if a significant population chooses a high-consumption lifestyle."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Individuals can opt out without penalty and the system continues functioning at partial participation. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "System viable at 30%+ participation, enabling opt-out without penalty... can exit to the traditional market economy while the system continues functioning."

0.5, partial

Formal exit rights exist but are constrained by real economic costs (job/healthcare/housing lock-in) not imposed by the system's own design. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "High exit barriers from job mobility costs, healthcare tied to employment, housing market barriers."

0.0, structural failure

The system's own funding or coherence structurally requires near-universal participation, such that a meaningful opt-out rate would collapse it. Nordic Social Democracy (0.0): "Systems require near-universal participation for funding sustainability. Cannot function with 30% opt-out; tax base would collapse." Degrowth Economics (0.0): "Cannot function if a significant population chooses a high-consumption lifestyle."

Read carefully: the failure mode is almost always funding or coherence dependent on near-universal participation, not an intent to trap individuals. v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K7; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N9 (Partial Deployability) + N3 (Coercion Minimization).

-

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

+

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c2-6.html b/docs/criteria/c2-6.html index 9517d15..6b02f53 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c2-6.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c2-6.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

Indicators

clause 1, Freedom House, Freedom in the World, civil-liber

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Score of 53 or more of 60 (the top band of Freedom House's former 1–7 civil-liberties rating), consent to medical treatment protected in law, and every medical or public-health compulsion prescribed by law, time-limited and open to an independent court; or a design whose stated guarantees and independent adjudication answer the checklist at that level and state the same protections, with component evidence where it relies on institutions not yet built.

0.5, partial

Score of 17 to 52; or a score of 53 or more with consent or the limits of compulsion not shown; or a design whose guarantees are partial, unstated for some questions, or left to administrators' discretion without an independent hearing, where the gap has a credible pathway to close under the system's own logic.

0.0, structural failure

Score of 16 or less (the two lowest bands of the former rating), or a design that subordinates expression, association, due process or consent to medical treatment to its allocation or administration with no independent adjudication.

Normative roots

From N3 (Coercion Minimization) + N7 (Governance Legitimacy and Anti-Capture).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, decision 45.1; clauses 2 and 3, Package C, decision 46.1). Anchors: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, decision 45.1; clauses 2 and 3, Package C, decision 46.1).

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, d

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-1.html b/docs/criteria/c3-1.html index 7233c7d..fdefb47 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-1.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-1.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

Indicators

system rules or IMF database of COVID-19 fiscal measures;

Comparison

Traditional stimulus: 3-6 months legislative delay, limited coverage. Unemployment insurance: 2-4 weeks processing, 40% coverage. Automatic stabilizers: Immediate response, universal coverage.

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Automatic, trigger-based stabilization requiring no legislative action. Universal Basic Income (1.0): "Benefit continues regardless of employment. No application process, no verification, no delay."

0.5, partial

Some crisis-responsive capacity exists but is not automatic, is firm/local-level rather than system-wide, or is unproven at the relevant scale. Market Socialism (0.5): "Cooperatives demonstrate better crisis resilience than traditional firms... but no automatic macroeconomic stabilizers. Firm-level resilience doesn't translate to system-level response."

0.0, structural failure

Response requires legislative/political action with characteristic multi-month delay, or is ideologically opposed to stabilization mechanisms. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "Traditional stimulus requires 3-6 months of legislative debate while populations suffer." Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Ideologically opposed to stabilization mechanisms... markets expected to self-correct while populations suffer."

Normative roots

From N5 (Crisis Robustness) + N10 (Failure Transparency).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-2.html b/docs/criteria/c3-2.html index dd58754..c91d62e 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-2.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-2.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Long-term inflation rates in system-controlled sec

Mechanisms required

Sectoral demand isolation (basic income for essentials only). Velocity controls (expiration mechanisms preventing hoarding). Supply response (production capacity scaling with demand). Automatic parameter adjustment (rates adjust based on inflation data).

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Specific, named mechanism(s) preventing inflation, whether monetary-policy-based or structural (e.g., no money supply to inflate). Participatory Economics (1.0): "'Facilitation boards' adjusting indicative prices to balance supply/demand... prevents systemic price instability."

0.5, partial

Relies on conventional monetary policy without novel safeguards, or a proposed mechanism is theoretically plausible but unproven at scale, or the system specifies no inflation-control mechanism of its own and has no active inflationary mechanism (decision D26). MMT+Job Guarantee (0.5): "Buffer stock employment theoretically anchors wages and prices. However, the mechanism is unproven at scale."

0.0, structural failure

The system's design actively risks compounding inflation, with no counterbalancing design element. Reserve this band for an active inflationary mechanism: a system that specifies no inflation-control mechanism of its own, or has no monetary function, scores 0.5, not 0.0 (decision D26).

Normative roots

From N5 (Crisis Robustness) + N13 (Incentive Alignment).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7 (0.0 and 0.5 bands corrected: decision D26 (revision R3); Correction 7's stale count removed from this anchor).

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7 (0.0

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-3.html b/docs/criteria/c3-3.html index 4181788..a2b708e 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-3.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-3.html @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@

How it is measured

Core functions: poverty (the share of the populati

Stress test scenarios

Recession + Automation (30% GDP decline, 15% unemployment, 40% business closures). Inflation + Climate Crisis (8% inflation, 30% agricultural disruption, infrastructure damage). Cyber Attack + Economic Crisis (72-hour infrastructure compromise, simultaneous market shock). Pandemic + Supply Chain (health crisis, border closures, 50% disruption).

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicit design for compound/simultaneous shocks, typically via decentralization or redundancy. Degrowth Economics (1.0): "Low-throughput systems less vulnerable to supply disruptions. Localized production creates resilience. Explicitly designed for crisis as norm rather than exception."

0.5, partial

Some resilience from distributed structure, but interconnection or market competition still transmits shocks. Market Socialism (0.5): "No single financial elite to trigger systemic crisis. However, market competition and interconnection still create vulnerability to cascading failures."

0.0, structural failure

Optimized for normal conditions only; historically or structurally demonstrated to fail under compound stress. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "2008 demonstrated vulnerability to financial + economic crisis; COVID showed inability to handle pandemic + supply chain + economic shock simultaneously." Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "The system ultimately collapsed under compound stresses."

Normative roots

From N5 (Crisis Robustness) + N10 (Failure Transparency).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-4.html b/docs/criteria/c3-4.html index cd2badb..c612211 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-4.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-4.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

How it is measured

Parameter flexibility (range of adjustable variabl

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Demonstrated or clearly-designed capacity for rapid, evidence-based parameter adjustment without destabilization. Market Socialism (1.0): "Democratic governance enables rapid adaptation to evidence... Mondragon demonstrates 50+ years of continuous adaptation."

0.5, partial

Adaptation is possible but slow or politically resisted. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.5): "The system can adjust through policy changes but often slowly and with political resistance... tendency toward regulatory capture and reversal."

0.0, structural failure

Ideological or structural rigidity prevents evidence-based adaptation. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Ideological rigidity prevented evidence-based adaptation... The Lysenko affair." Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "When market failures occur, ideology blames insufficient market purity rather than structural flaws."

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (R4; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N8 (Epistemic Adaptability) + N7 (Anti-Capture).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-5.html b/docs/criteria/c3-5.html index 11d2f48..a1583cd 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-5.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-5.html @@ -37,10 +37,10 @@

What it asks

Failure states legible, diagnosable, and correctable rat

Why it matters

Hidden failures enable exploitation and prevent adaptive response. The 2008 financial crisis demonstrated catastrophic hidden failures. Transparent failures enable correction before catastrophe.

How it is measured

Clause 1 (detection) is aspirational: the time from a failure's occurrence to its official identification can be shown from the dated record of the entry's most consequential failure in the scoring window (an official inquiry, audit or evaluation) or, for a design, from its monitoring rule, and the scoring document must name that record. Clause 2 (diagnosis) is aspirational: no agency publishes the share of failures whose cause is established; it can be shown only from a design's documented diagnostic record or an independent evaluation that reports it. Clause 3 (correction): the share of the supreme audit institution's recommendations implemented, as the US Government Accountability Office and other INTOSAI members publish, or for a design its correction record. Clause 4 (externalization): unpriced environmental costs of fuel use as a share of GDP, the implicit subsidies in the IMF's Fossil Fuel Subsidies Data, a lower bound on externalized cost, with GDP standing for total costs; for a design, projected.

Indicators

clauses 1–2, aspirational; clause 3, supreme audit institutions' recommendation-implementation rates; clause 4, IMF Fossil Fuel Subsidies Data (implicit subsidies, % of GDP).

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Systematic, comprehensive monitoring with no major category of cost or failure hidden. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "CCO flows visible through blockchain transparency... CIP provides dashboard tracking system performance across all metrics."

0.5, partial

Some failures are visible (often internally, e.g., to firm members) while others (typically ecological or diffuse social costs) remain externalized. Market Socialism (0.5): "Worker ownership makes firm failures visible to members immediately. However, market externalities (environmental costs) are still hidden."

0.0, structural failure

Systematic externalization or active suppression of failure information. Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Market externalities maximally hidden... no mechanism for making systemic failures legible." Stakeholder Capitalism (0.0): "ESG metrics susceptible to greenwashing... systemic failures obscured behind public relations."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Systematic, comprehensive monitoring with no major category of cost or failure hidden. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "CCO flows visible through blockchain transparency... CIP provides dashboard tracking system performance across all metrics."

0.5, partial

Some failures are visible (often internally, e.g., to firm members) while others (typically ecological or diffuse social costs) remain externalized. Market Socialism (0.5): "Worker ownership makes firm failures visible to members immediately. However, market externalities (environmental costs) are still hidden."

0.0, structural failure

Systematic externalization or active suppression of failure information. Libertarian Minarchism (0.0): "Market externalities maximally hidden... no mechanism for making systemic failures legible." Stakeholder Capitalism (0.0): "ESG metrics susceptible to greenwashing... systemic failures obscured behind public relations."

Normative roots

From N10 (Failure Transparency) + N7 (Anti-Capture).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c3-6.html b/docs/criteria/c3-6.html index b4eb8fd..757835e 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c3-6.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c3-6.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

Indicators

OECD Productivity Database; Penn World Table 11.0 (rtfpna)

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

All three clauses shown: productivity and TFP non-declining over 20 years on published data, or, for a design, mechanisms for allocating investment and rewarding improvement whose components have that record, and a provisioning account at its stated hours.

0.5, partial

One or more clauses not shown, or shown only by projection resting on untested assumptions, where the system has a functioning allocation mechanism of its own (markets, planning with feedback, or another stated mechanism).

0.0, structural failure

Productivity or TFP declining over 20 years with no credible pathway under the system's own logic, or a design whose own assumptions imply that basic needs cannot be provisioned at its stated hours, or that suppresses allocation signals with no replacement.

Normative roots

From N13 (Incentive Alignment) + N1 (Human Flourishing).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, decision 45.1). Anchors: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, decision 45.1).

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package B, d

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-1.html b/docs/criteria/c4-1.html index e70a160..6d0fac3 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-1.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-1.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

How scores are anchored

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K3, K4, K6, R1; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N12 (Intergenerational Equity) + N5 (Crisis Robustness).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-2.html b/docs/criteria/c4-2.html index 983a3f9..33f7424 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-2.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-2.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

How scores are anchored

Hold this one to absolute-reduction standards, not relative/efficiency framing. v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K3, K4, R1, G3, S2; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N6 (Ecological Compliance) + N12 (Intergenerational Equity).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-3.html b/docs/criteria/c4-3.html index d466a74..de827ba 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-3.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-3.html @@ -39,10 +39,10 @@

Why it matters

Colorblind or gender-neutral policies ignoring structu

How it is measured

Disparity: the gap between the median household income, and wealth where published, of the least and most advantaged groups on each declared axis, as a percentage of the most advantaged group's median, from national household surveys. Axes are declared in the entry's scope declaration (protocol 3.3); non-citizen residents are included in the population measured and counted as a group where citizenship is a salient axis. Reduction is the fall in each gap in percentage points per 5 years; convergence is whether the trend reaches the threshold's level within 30 years. Disproportionate benefit flows are evidence for the trajectory, not a separate test.

Indicators

national household income and wealth surveys, by declared group.

Evidence of need

Black household median wealth: $24,100 vs $188,200 white (87% gap). Black women 5.56x trafficking vulnerability; Native women 8.75x. Gender wage gap persists: women earn 80-84% of male wages. Systems perpetuating these disparities fail ethical standards.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicit, disproportionate (not merely equal) benefit flows to historically disadvantaged groups. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "PTF deliberately targets disadvantaged communities first (example: 150%+ proportional benefits during rollout)."

0.5, partial

Formal equality without reparative mechanisms, or genuine effort with unclear/unspecified reach. Integral (0.5): "Democratic architecture prevents elite capture... but no explicit reparative mechanisms are discussed... how the system repairs centuries of accumulated disparity" remains unaddressed.

0.0, structural failure

Formally neutral policy in a context of large documented disparities, with no active correction. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "'Colorblind' markets replicate structural racism. Without active intervention, discriminatory outcomes persist across generations."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicit, disproportionate (not merely equal) benefit flows to historically disadvantaged groups. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "PTF deliberately targets disadvantaged communities first (example: 150%+ proportional benefits during rollout)."

0.5, partial

Formal equality without reparative mechanisms, or genuine effort with unclear/unspecified reach. Integral (0.5): "Democratic architecture prevents elite capture... but no explicit reparative mechanisms are discussed... how the system repairs centuries of accumulated disparity" remains unaddressed.

0.0, structural failure

Formally neutral policy in a context of large documented disparities, with no active correction. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "'Colorblind' markets replicate structural racism. Without active intervention, discriminatory outcomes persist across generations."

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (R4, R6, G3; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N1 (Human Flourishing) + N7 (Anti-Capture).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-4.html b/docs/criteria/c4-4.html index a729733..99030d6 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-4.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-4.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

How scores are anchored

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K1, K2; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N7 (Anti-Capture) + N3 (Coercion Minimization).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-5.html b/docs/criteria/c4-5.html index a66ae5f..3436785 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-5.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-5.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Extraction rates (wealth transfer from labor to ca

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Structural elimination of extractive relationships (landlord-tenant, employer-employee, creditor-debtor), not merely regulation of their terms. Participatory Economics (1.0): "Eliminates capital accumulation and growth imperative driving exploitation... removes profit motive for extraction."

0.5, partial

Reduced but not eliminated extraction, or elimination in one relationship type (e.g., capital-labor) while another persists (e.g., inter-firm competition). Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Reduced exploitation through labor protections, collective bargaining... but still maintains capital-labor relationships with surplus extraction, albeit more equitably distributed."

0.0, structural failure

Extraction is a structural, load-bearing feature of the system rather than an incidental flaw. Status Quo Market Capitalism (0.0): "42% of GDP extracted from labor to capital... exploitation is a structural feature, not aberration."

v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (K5; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N3 (Coercion Minimization) + N4 (Universal Wealth Access).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c4-6.html b/docs/criteria/c4-6.html index 9515ddc..0a52872 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c4-6.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c4-6.html @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@

Indicators

clause 1, WHO Global Health Observatory (SDG 3.9.1, 3.9.2

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

All three clauses shown: the pollution mortality rate no higher at the end of the 20 years than at their start; those who cause harm liable for it in the law in force, enforceably by those harmed, with a record of claims paid; and regulation applied without improper influence (for a configured national economy, a score of 0.77 or more on the World Justice Project's sub-factor 6.2); or a design whose stated provisions do the same, with component evidence where it relies on institutions not yet built.

0.5, partial

One or more clauses not shown, or shown only by projection resting on untested assumptions, where the system has a functioning mechanism that makes some harm a cost to whoever causes it (liability, a compensation scheme funded by those who cause the harm, pricing, or independent regulation).

0.0, structural failure

No structural mechanism makes harm a cost to whoever causes it (those who cause harm are shielded from liability with no compensation they fund, and its regulation is controlled by those it regulates), or pollution mortality rising over 20 years with no credible pathway to reverse it under the system's own logic.

Normative roots

From N13 (Incentive Alignment) + N6 (Ecological Compliance).

Judgment calls on this criterion

-

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

+

How the systems score

0.0, structural failure

Centrally Planned Socialism

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package C, decision 46.1). Anchors: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package C, decision 46.1).

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V (Package C, d

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c5-1.html b/docs/criteria/c5-1.html index 451c4d0..549b1be 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c5-1.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c5-1.html @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@

How it is measured

Component validation (years of successful operatio

Examples of proven components

Alternative currencies: WIR Bank (90 years operation, billions in annual turnover). Community land trusts: 313 U.S. CLTs, 10x lower foreclosure rates. Sovereign wealth funds: Alaska PFD (40+ years), Norway (271% GDP). Cooperative governance: Mondragón (70+ years, 97% survival rate).

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Cite specific components with specific track records. Market Socialism (1.0): "Mondragon Corporation: 70+ years, 80,000+ worker-owners, €12 billion revenue... 97% survival rate over 5 years vs 44% for traditional startups."

0.5, partial

Individual components are proven but the integrated system is not, or the historical precedent's outcomes are mixed/contested. Integral (0.5): "Individual components proven: 70%+ of pieces have 20+ years validation... Integrated system unproven: No actual Integral implementation exists at any scale."

0.0, structural failure

No components with a comparable track record exist; the system is a novel projection. FALC (0.0): "No comprehensive FALC system exists anywhere... entirely theoretical projection."

Normative roots

From N9 (Partial Deployability) + N8 (Epistemic Adaptability).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c5-2.html b/docs/criteria/c5-2.html index 096c8b6..29f21a1 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c5-2.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c5-2.html @@ -39,10 +39,10 @@

Why it matters

Revolutions typically produce chaos, reaction, and sys

Staged transition 10 25 years for stable contexts

Phase 1 (Years 1-3): Municipal pilots in receptive jurisdictions. Phase 2 (Years 3-5): Regional expansion with integration testing. Phase 3 (Years 5-10): Multi-jurisdictional coordination. Phase 4 (Years 10-25): National integration and optimization.

Rapid deployment 18 36 months for post crisis contexts

Month 0-6: Emergency legal framework, digital infrastructure. Month 6-12: Universal distribution begins, initial asset acquisition. Month 12-18: System activation, governance establishment. Month 18-36: Stabilization, parameter optimization.

Historical precedents

New Deal (1933-1936): 3 years for comprehensive programs. Marshall Plan (1948-1951): 3 years for economic restructuring. CCO-PTF modeling: Both pathways validated through simulation.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Both a multi-phase gradual plan and a rapid crisis-deployment plan are specified with concrete milestones. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "Detailed pathways specified for both gradual (10-25 years: municipal pilots → regional → national) and rapid (18-36 months: post-crisis emergency deployment)."

0.5, partial

A pathway is sketched but lacks the specificity (legal framework, resource figures, sequencing) the threshold requires. Market Socialism (0.5): "Can be implemented incrementally through cooperative development, but scaling to the majority of the economy faces challenges. No clear pathway from niche to dominant form."

0.0, structural failure

No operational pathway despite acknowledging transition as necessary, or historical transitions required non-gradual means (revolution, occupation). Integral (0.0): "Despite acknowledging transition as 'the challenge,' the document provides almost no operational pathway... 'starts small and expands' ... That's it." Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Historical transitions required revolution, civil war, or imposition by occupying force."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Both a multi-phase gradual plan and a rapid crisis-deployment plan are specified with concrete milestones. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "Detailed pathways specified for both gradual (10-25 years: municipal pilots → regional → national) and rapid (18-36 months: post-crisis emergency deployment)."

0.5, partial

A pathway is sketched but lacks the specificity (legal framework, resource figures, sequencing) the threshold requires. Market Socialism (0.5): "Can be implemented incrementally through cooperative development, but scaling to the majority of the economy faces challenges. No clear pathway from niche to dominant form."

0.0, structural failure

No operational pathway despite acknowledging transition as necessary, or historical transitions required non-gradual means (revolution, occupation). Integral (0.0): "Despite acknowledging transition as 'the challenge,' the document provides almost no operational pathway... 'starts small and expands' ... That's it." Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Historical transitions required revolution, civil war, or imposition by occupying force."

Judge this on specificity, not on whether a pathway exists in principle — "starts small and expands" is not a pathway under this threshold, however true it may be. v2.0 (Session 45): this criterion's Pass Threshold was restated (R4; NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md). The band texts and examples were written against Paper v1.4's threshold: they describe, and the threshold above governs (protocol 2.3(g)). Examples are re-estimated in the rescoring pass.

Normative roots

From N9 (Partial Deployability).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md, Appendix V). Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6; restated in v2.0 (NEEC_Criteria_

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c5-3.html b/docs/criteria/c5-3.html index d4193d3..0ae49e9 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c5-3.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c5-3.html @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@

C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability

What it asks

System functions with selective participation (30%+ population), coexists with traditional markets without displacement

Why it matters

Unlike systems requiring universal enrollment, partial deployability enables pilot testing, iterative improvement, and voluntary adoption. This dramatically reduces political barriers and technical risks.

How it is measured

Minimum participation threshold for viability. Mixed-economy performance (coexistence with traditional institutions). Scaling pathways from pilots (10,000) to regional (1M+) to national (100M+). Inter-jurisdictional coordination protocols.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicitly designed to function at partial adoption and coexist with existing institutions. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "Viable at 30%+ participation. Can coexist with traditional markets. Scaling pathway validated through modeling: pilots (10,000) → regional (1M+) → national (100M+)."

0.5, partial

Components can be adopted piecemeal, but the comprehensive form requires much higher participation to function as designed. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Components can be adopted piecemeal... but a comprehensive model requires near-universal participation for funding sustainability."

0.0, structural failure

The system requires comprehensive, near-total adoption to function at all. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Requires comprehensive control to function. Cannot coexist with market economy without either collapsing... or suppressing markets." FALC (0.0): "Cannot function partially—requires comprehensive automation for post-scarcity."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicitly designed to function at partial adoption and coexist with existing institutions. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "Viable at 30%+ participation. Can coexist with traditional markets. Scaling pathway validated through modeling: pilots (10,000) → regional (1M+) → national (100M+)."

0.5, partial

Components can be adopted piecemeal, but the comprehensive form requires much higher participation to function as designed. Nordic Social Democracy (0.5): "Components can be adopted piecemeal... but a comprehensive model requires near-universal participation for funding sustainability."

0.0, structural failure

The system requires comprehensive, near-total adoption to function at all. Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Requires comprehensive control to function. Cannot coexist with market economy without either collapsing... or suppressing markets." FALC (0.0): "Cannot function partially—requires comprehensive automation for post-scarcity."

Normative roots

From N9 (Partial Deployability).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c5-4.html b/docs/criteria/c5-4.html index 28b3850..36d8bcc 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c5-4.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c5-4.html @@ -37,9 +37,9 @@

What it asks

Build broad support across ideological divides through o

Why it matters

Solutions appealing only to the left or right face permanent political warfare and likely reversal after the next election party flip. Best frameworks offer value to diverse constituencies: fiscal conservatives (cost savings), libertarians (reduced coercion), progressives (equity focus), communitarians (enhanced cohesion).

How it is measured

Coalition breadth (support percentage across ideological spectrum). Policy stability (resistance to repeal attempts). Long-term political sustainability (survival across multiple administrations).

Cross ideological appeal examples

Alaska PFD: 80%+ approval across political spectrum for 40+ years. Community wealth building: Attracts both cooperative socialists and property rights conservatives. Cooperative movements: Bridge socialist and market advocate divisions.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Demonstrated or clearly-arguable appeal across ideologically opposed constituencies, each for their own reasons. Nordic Social Democracy (1.0): "High public satisfaction (70-85%) sustains support across the political spectrum." CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (1.0): "Cross-ideological appeal: progressives... libertarians... fiscal conservatives... communitarians."

0.5, partial

Appeals strongly to part of the spectrum while facing real resistance from another part. Market Socialism (0.5): "Appeals to socialists, progressive liberals, community organizers. However, limited appeal to business interests and fiscal conservatives."

0.0, structural failure

Structural or rhetorical features actively repel broad coalition-building, or historical record forecloses it. Degrowth Economics (0.0): "'Degrowth' terminology is politically toxic in growth-oriented cultures." Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Catastrophic historical record eliminates political viability."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Demonstrated or clearly-arguable appeal across ideologically opposed constituencies, each for their own reasons. Nordic Social Democracy (1.0): "High public satisfaction (70-85%) sustains support across the political spectrum." CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (1.0): "Cross-ideological appeal: progressives... libertarians... fiscal conservatives... communitarians."

0.5, partial

Appeals strongly to part of the spectrum while facing real resistance from another part. Market Socialism (0.5): "Appeals to socialists, progressive liberals, community organizers. However, limited appeal to business interests and fiscal conservatives."

0.0, structural failure

Structural or rhetorical features actively repel broad coalition-building, or historical record forecloses it. Degrowth Economics (0.0): "'Degrowth' terminology is politically toxic in growth-oriented cultures." Centrally Planned Socialism (0.0): "Catastrophic historical record eliminates political viability."

Normative roots

From N9 (Partial Deployability) + N7 (Anti-Capture).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/c5-5.html b/docs/criteria/c5-5.html index 3f627e8..ee98849 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/c5-5.html +++ b/docs/criteria/c5-5.html @@ -39,9 +39,9 @@

Parameter adjustment examples high income nations

Octave caps: 7+ (hi

Middle income nations

Octave caps: 5 (moderate capacity). Basic amounts: 10-15% GDP/capita. Conversion multipliers: 1-7x.

Low income nations

Octave caps: 3 (limited capacity initially). Basic amounts: 15-20% GDP/capita. Conversion multipliers: 1-5x.

Cultural variation accommodated

Aesthetic criteria: Different communities set different phi-rate standards. Governance structures: Consensus, majority, elder councils—all compatible. Social organization: Multigenerational, nuclear, communal—all supported.

-

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicit parameter adjustment mechanisms for diverse economic/cultural contexts, with reasoning for how they'd apply. Participatory Economics (1.0): "Different communities could have different consumption patterns, work structures. Councils respect cultural variation while coordinating economically."

0.5, partial

Some real adaptability, but concentrated in a narrow cultural/economic range, or claimed but underspecified. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (0.5): "Parameter flexibility enables cultural adaptation... viable across high/middle/low-income contexts with adjustments. However, comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling."

0.0, structural failure

Successful only in a narrow cultural context with no credible generalization argument, or requires a specific cultural precondition (e.g., a particular work ethic) the system cannot itself produce. Market Socialism (0.0): "Most successful in specific cultural contexts (Basque Country, Northern Italy, Scandinavian regions). Scaling to cultures with different traditions... is uncertain." Universal Basic Income (0.0): "Work-centric cultures resist 'paying people to do nothing'... U.S. Protestant work ethic creates resistance."

+

How scores are anchored

1.0, pass

Explicit parameter adjustment mechanisms for diverse economic/cultural contexts, with reasoning for how they'd apply. Participatory Economics (1.0): "Different communities could have different consumption patterns, work structures. Councils respect cultural variation while coordinating economically."

0.5, partial

Some real adaptability, but concentrated in a narrow cultural/economic range, or claimed but underspecified. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (0.5): "Parameter flexibility enables cultural adaptation... viable across high/middle/low-income contexts with adjustments. However, comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling."

0.0, structural failure

Successful only in a narrow cultural context with no credible generalization argument, or requires a specific cultural precondition (e.g., a particular work ethic) the system cannot itself produce. Market Socialism (0.0): "Most successful in specific cultural contexts (Basque Country, Northern Italy, Scandinavian regions). Scaling to cultures with different traditions... is uncertain." Universal Basic Income (0.0): "Work-centric cultures resist 'paying people to do nothing'... U.S. Protestant work ethic creates resistance."

Normative roots

From N14 (Global Scalability).

-

How the systems score

+

How the systems score

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

Check this criterion with an AIPush back on this threshold

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@

Sources

Definition: Paper Section 6. Anchors: Paper Appendix H.7.

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/criteria/index.html b/docs/criteria/index.html index 98cfbfb..60e81c2 100644 --- a/docs/criteria/index.html +++ b/docs/criteria/index.html @@ -40,7 +40,7 @@

From premises to criteria

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/data/neec.json b/docs/data/neec.json index 50e3d9a..c163c7d 100644 --- a/docs/data/neec.json +++ b/docs/data/neec.json @@ -521,7 +521,7 @@ "decisions": [ "48.3" ], - "effect": "Recorded in the rescoring pass, not yet published: the alternative would raise Nordic Social Democracy's C4.4 to 1.0 and restore CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's to 1.0. Because the adopted reading lowers the owner's own design, the owner has been asked to confirm it.", + "effect": "Recorded in the rescoring pass, not yet published: the alternative would raise Nordic Social Democracy's C4.4 to 1.0 and restore CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's to 1.0. Because the adopted reading lowers the owner's own design, the owner has been asked to confirm it.", "id": "c44-accountability", "interactive": null, "status": "Set under the owner's delegation; flagged for the owner's confirmation.", @@ -699,7 +699,7 @@ "scores_published": true, "sources": { "criteria.json": "255180b0", - "neec_corpus.json": "05d2b4dc" + "neec_corpus.json": "17aa3228" }, "systems": [ { @@ -709,11 +709,11 @@ "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], "failures": 0, - "name": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "name": "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP", "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/cco.html", "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", "tier": "Potentially Adequate", - "total": 17.5, + "total": 16.5, "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, "C1.2a": 1.0, @@ -722,7 +722,7 @@ "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, "C2.1": 0.5, - "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.2": 0.5, "C2.3": 0.5, "C2.4": 0.5, "C2.5": 1.0, @@ -741,27 +741,27 @@ "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, - "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.3": 0.5, "C5.4": 0.5, "C5.5": 0.5 } }, { - "code": "PE", + "code": "MS", "documents": [ "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], "failures": 0, - "name": "Participatory Economics", - "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/pe.html", + "name": "Market Socialism", + "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/ms.html", "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", "tier": "Potentially Adequate", - "total": 16.5, + "total": 15.5, "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, "C1.2a": 0.5, - "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, "C1.3": 0.5, "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, @@ -781,7 +781,7 @@ "C4.2": 0.5, "C4.3": 0.5, "C4.4": 1.0, - "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, @@ -791,15 +791,15 @@ } }, { - "code": "MS", + "code": "NSD", "documents": [ "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], "failures": 0, - "name": "Market Socialism", - "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/ms.html", - "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "name": "Nordic Social Democracy", + "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/nsd.html", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", "tier": "Potentially Adequate", "total": 15.5, "vector": { @@ -808,7 +808,7 @@ "C1.2b": 0.5, "C1.3": 0.5, "C1.4": 0.5, - "C1.5": 0.5, + "C1.5": 1.0, "C2.1": 0.5, "C2.2": 0.5, "C2.3": 0.5, @@ -818,32 +818,32 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, "C4.2": 0.5, "C4.3": 0.5, - "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, "C4.5": 0.5, "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, "C5.3": 0.5, - "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.4": 1.0, "C5.5": 0.5 } }, { - "code": "NSD", + "code": "PE", "documents": [ "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/main/NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], "failures": 0, - "name": "Nordic Social Democracy", - "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/nsd.html", - "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "name": "Participatory Economics", + "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/pe.html", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", "tier": "Potentially Adequate", "total": 15.5, "vector": { @@ -852,7 +852,7 @@ "C1.2b": 0.5, "C1.3": 0.5, "C1.4": 0.5, - "C1.5": 1.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, "C2.1": 0.5, "C2.2": 0.5, "C2.3": 0.5, @@ -868,13 +868,13 @@ "C4.1": 0.5, "C4.2": 0.5, "C4.3": 0.5, - "C4.4": 0.5, - "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, "C5.3": 0.5, - "C5.4": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, "C5.5": 0.5 } }, @@ -977,7 +977,7 @@ "page": "https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/systems/dg.html", "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", "tier": "Potentially Adequate", - "total": 14.5, + "total": 14.0, "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, "C1.2a": 0.5, @@ -994,7 +994,7 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, diff --git a/docs/findings.html b/docs/findings.html index 4208908..46c80f6 100644 --- a/docs/findings.html +++ b/docs/findings.html @@ -31,22 +31,22 @@

Findings

What the scores show, drawn from the published data each time the site is built. Every finding is one reading of the evidence under stated thresholds; the Thresholds page shows how it moves when a bar or a weight changes.

Key findings

-
  • 23 systems on 29 criteria: 8 Potentially Adequate, 7 Partially Adequate, 8 Structurally Inadequate. Tiers depend only on the number of structural failures, so they do not move with the weights.
  • Among the configured national economies, existing or historical, the highest total is Nordic Social Democracy's: 15.5 of 29 (53%), with 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate.
  • A higher total can sit in a lower tier: Ostrom Commons (15.0, 3 failures) outscores Georgism / LVT (14.0, 2 failures) and sits one tier lower.
  • No system scores 1.0 on 12 of the 29 criteria: C1.1, C1.4, C2.1, C2.3, C2.4, C2.6, C3.1, C3.3, C3.5, C4.2, C4.3, C4.6.
  • The most often failed criterion is C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 11 of 23 systems score 0.0 on it.
  • 14 systems are not dominated: no other system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on one. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Participatory Economics, Nordic Social Democracy, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism.

Totals use equal weights. Each statement is computed from the published scores when the site is built, and none is typed by hand.

+
  • 23 systems on 29 criteria: 8 Potentially Adequate, 7 Partially Adequate, 8 Structurally Inadequate. Tiers depend only on the number of structural failures, so they do not move with the weights.
  • Among the configured national economies, existing or historical, the highest total is Nordic Social Democracy's: 15.5 of 29 (53%), with 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate.
  • A higher total can sit in a lower tier: Ostrom Commons (15.0, 3 failures) outscores Degrowth Economics (14.0, 1 failures) and sits one tier lower.
  • No system scores 1.0 on 13 of the 29 criteria: C1.1, C1.2b, C1.4, C2.1, C2.3, C2.4, C2.6, C3.1, C3.3, C3.5, C4.2, C4.3, C4.6.
  • The most often failed criterion is C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 11 of 23 systems score 0.0 on it.
  • 17 systems are not dominated: no other system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on one. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy, Participatory Economics, Integral, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Georgism / LVT, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism.

Totals use equal weights. Each statement is computed from the published scores when the site is built, and none is typed by hand.

Totals and structural failures

-

The bar is each system's total on equal weights; the rings count its structural failures, which alone decide the tier. Order the rows by total to see where a higher total sits in a lower tier.

  • Potentially Adequate
  • Partially Adequate
  • Structurally Inadequate
Totals, percentages, structural failures and tiers
SystemTotal as a barTotalPercentStructural failuresTier
CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH17.560%0Potentially Adequate
Participatory Economics16.557%0Potentially Adequate
Market Socialism15.553%0Potentially Adequate
Nordic Social Democracy15.553%0Potentially Adequate
Integral15.052%2Potentially Adequate
Ostrom Commons15.052%3Partially Adequate
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism15.052%2Potentially Adequate
Degrowth Economics14.550%1Potentially Adequate
Georgism / LVT14.048%2Potentially Adequate
Islamic Finance14.048%3Partially Adequate
Universal Basic Income14.048%4Partially Adequate
Mutual Credit / LETS13.547%3Partially Adequate
State Capitalism / Singapore13.547%3Partially Adequate
Status Quo Market Capitalism13.045%6Structurally Inadequate
Universal Basic Services13.045%4Partially Adequate
MMT + Job Guarantee12.543%4Partially Adequate
Fully Automated Luxury Communism12.041%7Structurally Inadequate
Stakeholder Capitalism11.540%6Structurally Inadequate
State Capitalism / China11.540%8Structurally Inadequate
State Capitalism / Qatar10.034%10Structurally Inadequate
Doughnut Economics9.533%10Structurally Inadequate
Libertarian Minarchism9.533%11Structurally Inadequate
Centrally Planned Socialism6.522%17Structurally Inadequate
+

The bar is each system's total on equal weights; the rings count its structural failures, which alone decide the tier. Order the rows by total to see where a higher total sits in a lower tier.

  • Potentially Adequate
  • Partially Adequate
  • Structurally Inadequate
Totals, percentages, structural failures and tiers
SystemTotal as a barTotalPercentStructural failuresTier
CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP16.557%0Potentially Adequate
Market Socialism15.553%0Potentially Adequate
Nordic Social Democracy15.553%0Potentially Adequate
Participatory Economics15.553%0Potentially Adequate
Integral15.052%2Potentially Adequate
Ostrom Commons15.052%3Partially Adequate
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism15.052%2Potentially Adequate
Degrowth Economics14.048%1Potentially Adequate
Georgism / LVT14.048%2Potentially Adequate
Islamic Finance14.048%3Partially Adequate
Universal Basic Income14.048%4Partially Adequate
Mutual Credit / LETS13.547%3Partially Adequate
State Capitalism / Singapore13.547%3Partially Adequate
Status Quo Market Capitalism13.045%6Structurally Inadequate
Universal Basic Services13.045%4Partially Adequate
MMT + Job Guarantee12.543%4Partially Adequate
Fully Automated Luxury Communism12.041%7Structurally Inadequate
Stakeholder Capitalism11.540%6Structurally Inadequate
State Capitalism / China11.540%8Structurally Inadequate
State Capitalism / Qatar10.034%10Structurally Inadequate
Doughnut Economics9.533%10Structurally Inadequate
Libertarian Minarchism9.533%11Structurally Inadequate
Centrally Planned Socialism6.522%17Structurally Inadequate

Domain profiles

-

Each axis is the share of a domain's points a system earns; the dashed outline is the median of all 23 systems. The first choices below are the highest total in each kind of system. Read the axes one by one: the area of a shape has no meaning of its own.

Every system's domain percentages as a table
SystemMaterial SecurityHuman AutonomySystem ResilienceEthical IntegrityImplementation Viability
CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH58%67%67%50%60%
Participatory Economics58%50%58%67%50%
Market Socialism50%50%58%58%50%
Nordic Social Democracy58%50%50%50%60%
Integral33%50%58%67%50%
Ostrom Commons33%42%58%50%80%
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism42%50%58%42%70%
Degrowth Economics50%50%58%50%40%
Georgism / LVT33%50%50%50%60%
Islamic Finance33%42%50%50%70%
Universal Basic Income25%58%42%50%70%
Mutual Credit / LETS25%50%50%50%60%
State Capitalism / Singapore50%42%58%33%50%
Status Quo Market Capitalism33%42%58%25%70%
Universal Basic Services25%50%42%50%60%
MMT + Job Guarantee33%42%42%50%50%
Fully Automated Luxury Communism33%50%42%58%20%
Stakeholder Capitalism33%42%50%33%40%
State Capitalism / China50%17%58%25%50%
State Capitalism / Qatar42%25%42%25%40%
Doughnut Economics8%33%42%33%50%
Libertarian Minarchism17%42%33%25%50%
Centrally Planned Socialism42%0%25%25%20%
+

Each axis is the share of a domain's points a system earns; the dashed outline is the median of all 23 systems. The first choices below are the highest total in each kind of system. Read the axes one by one: the area of a shape has no meaning of its own.

Every system's domain percentages as a table
SystemMaterial SecurityHuman AutonomySystem ResilienceEthical IntegrityImplementation Viability
CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP58%58%67%50%50%
Market Socialism50%50%58%58%50%
Nordic Social Democracy58%50%50%50%60%
Participatory Economics50%50%50%67%50%
Integral33%50%58%67%50%
Ostrom Commons33%42%58%50%80%
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism42%50%58%42%70%
Degrowth Economics50%50%50%50%40%
Georgism / LVT33%50%50%50%60%
Islamic Finance33%42%50%50%70%
Universal Basic Income25%58%42%50%70%
Mutual Credit / LETS25%50%50%50%60%
State Capitalism / Singapore50%42%58%33%50%
Status Quo Market Capitalism33%42%58%25%70%
Universal Basic Services25%50%42%50%60%
MMT + Job Guarantee33%42%42%50%50%
Fully Automated Luxury Communism33%50%42%58%20%
Stakeholder Capitalism33%42%50%33%40%
State Capitalism / China50%17%58%25%50%
State Capitalism / Qatar42%25%42%25%40%
Doughnut Economics8%33%42%33%50%
Libertarian Minarchism17%42%33%25%50%
Centrally Planned Socialism42%0%25%25%20%

Trade-offs and the frontier

-

Plot any two dimensions against each other. A system is on the frontier of the two you choose when no other system scores at least as high on both and higher on one. The frontier depends on the axes: it is a statement about two dimensions, not about every criterion.

  • Potentially Adequate
  • Partially Adequate
  • Structurally Inadequate

Hover over any dot to see which systems it stands for and their scores. Click or tap a dot to keep its details open, and click it again to close them; with a keyboard, tab to a dot and press Enter.

Systems plotted on the two chosen dimensions

On total and Material Security, the frontier is CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH.

Understanding the frontier and dominance

One system dominates another when it scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on at least one. The dominated system then has a rival that is no worse anywhere and better somewhere, under the criteria as written.

The Pareto frontier is the set of systems that no other system dominates. On the chart it is drawn for the two dimensions you choose: frontier systems are ringed in green, labelled, and joined by the dashed line. It depends on the axes, so a system can sit on the frontier for one pair of dimensions and off it for another. The statement that matters most is the one across every criterion at once.

Across all 29 criteria, 14 of the 23 systems are on the frontier: CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Participatory Economics, Nordic Social Democracy, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism. Each of the other 9 is dominated by at least one of them. The number after each name is how many criteria it scores higher on; on every other criterion the two score the same.

Dominated systemDominated by (criteria on which it scores higher)
Market SocialismParticipatory Economics (2)
IntegralParticipatory Economics (3)
Degrowth EconomicsParticipatory Economics (4), CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (6)
Georgism / LVTCCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (6)
Universal Basic ServicesUniversal Basic Income (2), CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (8)
MMT + Job GuaranteeNordic Social Democracy (6), Participatory Economics (7), CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (8)
Stakeholder CapitalismIslamic Finance (4), Nordic Social Democracy (8), Participatory Economics (8), CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (11)
Doughnut EconomicsIslamic Finance (9), Nordic Social Democracy (11), Ostrom Commons (11), Participatory Economics (11), CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (14)
Libertarian MinarchismCCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (15)

Dominance is the strongest comparison the scores support, because it needs no weights: under the criteria as written, preferring a dominated system to one that dominates it gives up points somewhere and gains none anywhere. It says nothing about what the criteria leave out, and nothing about margins: one system can dominate another by a single half point on a single criterion. A system off the frontier is not thereby a poor one, and a system on it can still carry structural failures; its tier says how many. The comparison tool sets any two or three systems side by side, criterion by criterion.

+

Plot any two dimensions against each other. A system is on the frontier of the two you choose when no other system scores at least as high on both and higher on one. The frontier depends on the axes: it is a statement about two dimensions, not about every criterion.

  • Potentially Adequate
  • Partially Adequate
  • Structurally Inadequate

Hover over any dot to see which systems it stands for and their scores. Click or tap a dot to keep its details open, and click it again to close them; with a keyboard, tab to a dot and press Enter.

Systems plotted on the two chosen dimensions

On total and Material Security, the frontier is CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP.

Understanding the frontier and dominance

One system dominates another when it scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on at least one. The dominated system then has a rival that is no worse anywhere and better somewhere, under the criteria as written.

The Pareto frontier is the set of systems that no other system dominates. On the chart it is drawn for the two dimensions you choose: frontier systems are ringed in green, labelled, and joined by the dashed line. It depends on the axes, so a system can sit on the frontier for one pair of dimensions and off it for another. The statement that matters most is the one across every criterion at once.

Across all 29 criteria, 17 of the 23 systems are on the frontier: CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy, Participatory Economics, Integral, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Georgism / LVT, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism. Each of the other 6 is dominated by at least one of them. The number after each name is how many criteria it scores higher on; on every other criterion the two score the same.

Dominated systemDominated by (criteria on which it scores higher)
Degrowth EconomicsNordic Social Democracy (2), Market Socialism (3), Participatory Economics (3), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (5)
Universal Basic ServicesGeorgism / LVT (2), Universal Basic Income (2)
MMT + Job GuaranteeMarket Socialism (6), Nordic Social Democracy (6), Participatory Economics (6), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (7)
Stakeholder CapitalismIslamic Finance (4), Participatory Economics (7), Market Socialism (8), Nordic Social Democracy (8), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (10)
Doughnut EconomicsGeorgism / LVT (9), Integral (9), Islamic Finance (9), Participatory Economics (10), Market Socialism (11), Nordic Social Democracy (11), Ostrom Commons (11), CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (13)
Libertarian MinarchismCCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (14)

Dominance is the strongest comparison the scores support, because it needs no weights: under the criteria as written, preferring a dominated system to one that dominates it gives up points somewhere and gains none anywhere. It says nothing about what the criteria leave out, and nothing about margins: one system can dominate another by a single half point on a single criterion. A system off the frontier is not thereby a poor one, and a system on it can still carry structural failures; its tier says how many. The comparison tool sets any two or three systems side by side, criterion by criterion.

- + diff --git a/docs/index.html b/docs/index.html index 5bb5663..9788f7e 100644 --- a/docs/index.html +++ b/docs/index.html @@ -32,7 +32,7 @@

NEEC compares economic systems against one fixed set of normative criteria,

NEEC stands for Normative Economic Evaluation Criteria. Normative means the criteria say what an economy ought to achieve: security from poverty, freedom to choose, resilience in a crisis, fairness across groups and generations, and a credible way to get there. Each of the 23 systems is scored 1, 0.5 or 0 on each of the 29 criteria. A 0 is a structural failure, and failures, not totals, decide a system's tier.

-
23 systems, one mark per criterion, grouped by domain and ordered by tier.
Material SecurityHuman AutonomySystem ResilienceEthical IntegrityImplementation Viability
SystemC1.1 Poverty Elimination CapacityC1.2a Wealth Building for ResilienceC1.2b Prevention of Exploitative AccumulationC1.3 Housing SecurityC1.4 Automation ResilienceC1.5 Universal Wealth AccessC2.1 Freedom from CoercionC2.2 Labor Non-NecessityC2.3 Creative Development OpportunitiesC2.4 Democratic ParticipationC2.5 Exit Rights and MobilityC2.6 Civil Liberties and Rule of LawC3.1 Crisis Response CapacityC3.2 Inflation Control MechanismsC3.3 Multi-Failure ResistanceC3.4 Epistemic AdaptabilityC3.5 Failure-Mode TransparencyC3.6 Productive and Innovative CapacityC4.1 Intergenerational JusticeC4.2 Ecological ComplianceC4.3 Group EquityC4.4 Power DistributionC4.5 Exploitation EliminationC4.6 Harm InternalizationC5.1 Proven Component FoundationC5.2 Staged Transition PathwaysC5.3 Partial and Parallel DeployabilityC5.4 Political Coalition PotentialC5.5 Cultural AdaptabilityTotalFailures
Potentially Adequate0 to 2 structural failures
CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial17.50
Participatory Economics0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial16.50
Market Socialism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial15.50
Nordic Social Democracy0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial15.50
Integral0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial15.02
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial15.02
Degrowth Economics0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial14.51
Georgism / LVT0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial14.02
Partially Adequate3 to 5 structural failures
Ostrom Commons0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass15.03
Islamic Finance0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass14.03
Universal Basic Income0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial14.04
Mutual Credit / LETS0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass13.53
State Capitalism / Singapore0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial13.53
Universal Basic Services0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial13.04
MMT + Job Guarantee0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial12.54
Structurally Inadequate6 or more structural failures
Status Quo Market Capitalism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial13.06
Fully Automated Luxury Communism0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial12.07
Stakeholder Capitalism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure11.56
State Capitalism / China0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial11.58
State Capitalism / Qatar0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure10.010
Doughnut Economics0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial9.510
Libertarian Minarchism0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial9.511
Centrally Planned Socialism0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial6.517
  • 1.0, pass
  • 0.5, partial
  • 0.0, structural failure

Select a mark, or move through the field with the arrow keys, to see the criterion and a link to the evidence.

+
23 systems, one mark per criterion, grouped by domain and ordered by tier.
Material SecurityHuman AutonomySystem ResilienceEthical IntegrityImplementation Viability
SystemC1.1 Poverty Elimination CapacityC1.2a Wealth Building for ResilienceC1.2b Prevention of Exploitative AccumulationC1.3 Housing SecurityC1.4 Automation ResilienceC1.5 Universal Wealth AccessC2.1 Freedom from CoercionC2.2 Labor Non-NecessityC2.3 Creative Development OpportunitiesC2.4 Democratic ParticipationC2.5 Exit Rights and MobilityC2.6 Civil Liberties and Rule of LawC3.1 Crisis Response CapacityC3.2 Inflation Control MechanismsC3.3 Multi-Failure ResistanceC3.4 Epistemic AdaptabilityC3.5 Failure-Mode TransparencyC3.6 Productive and Innovative CapacityC4.1 Intergenerational JusticeC4.2 Ecological ComplianceC4.3 Group EquityC4.4 Power DistributionC4.5 Exploitation EliminationC4.6 Harm InternalizationC5.1 Proven Component FoundationC5.2 Staged Transition PathwaysC5.3 Partial and Parallel DeployabilityC5.4 Political Coalition PotentialC5.5 Cultural AdaptabilityTotalFailures
Potentially Adequate0 to 2 structural failures
CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial16.50
Market Socialism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial15.50
Nordic Social Democracy0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial15.50
Participatory Economics0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial15.50
Integral0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial15.02
Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial15.02
Degrowth Economics0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial14.01
Georgism / LVT0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial14.02
Partially Adequate3 to 5 structural failures
Ostrom Commons0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass15.03
Islamic Finance0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass14.03
Universal Basic Income0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial14.04
Mutual Credit / LETS0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass13.53
State Capitalism / Singapore0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial13.53
Universal Basic Services0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial13.04
MMT + Job Guarantee0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial12.54
Structurally Inadequate6 or more structural failures
Status Quo Market Capitalism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial13.06
Fully Automated Luxury Communism0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial12.07
Stakeholder Capitalism0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure11.56
State Capitalism / China0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure1.0, pass0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial11.58
State Capitalism / Qatar0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure10.010
Doughnut Economics0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial9.510
Libertarian Minarchism0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial0.5, partial9.511
Centrally Planned Socialism0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial1.0, pass0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.5, partial0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.0, structural failure0.5, partial6.517
  • 1.0, pass
  • 0.5, partial
  • 0.0, structural failure

Select a mark, or move through the field with the arrow keys, to see the criterion and a link to the evidence.

Where to start

@@ -45,11 +45,11 @@

Where to start

Findings

-
  • 23 systems on 29 criteria: 8 Potentially Adequate, 7 Partially Adequate, 8 Structurally Inadequate. Tiers depend only on the number of structural failures, so they do not move with the weights.
  • Among the configured national economies, existing or historical, the highest total is Nordic Social Democracy's: 15.5 of 29 (53%), with 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate.
  • A higher total can sit in a lower tier: Ostrom Commons (15.0, 3 failures) outscores Georgism / LVT (14.0, 2 failures) and sits one tier lower.
  • No system scores 1.0 on 12 of the 29 criteria: C1.1, C1.4, C2.1, C2.3, C2.4, C2.6, C3.1, C3.3, C3.5, C4.2, C4.3, C4.6.
  • The most often failed criterion is C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 11 of 23 systems score 0.0 on it.
  • 14 systems are not dominated: no other system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on one. CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Participatory Economics, Nordic Social Democracy, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism.

The findings as charts: totals and failures, domain profiles, and trade-offs.

Totals use equal weights and are one reading of the evidence, not a measurement. Each system's page registers the close calls a reasonable scorer could set differently, and the Thresholds page shows how the ranking moves when you weigh the domains differently.

+
  • 23 systems on 29 criteria: 8 Potentially Adequate, 7 Partially Adequate, 8 Structurally Inadequate. Tiers depend only on the number of structural failures, so they do not move with the weights.
  • Among the configured national economies, existing or historical, the highest total is Nordic Social Democracy's: 15.5 of 29 (53%), with 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate.
  • A higher total can sit in a lower tier: Ostrom Commons (15.0, 3 failures) outscores Degrowth Economics (14.0, 1 failures) and sits one tier lower.
  • No system scores 1.0 on 13 of the 29 criteria: C1.1, C1.2b, C1.4, C2.1, C2.3, C2.4, C2.6, C3.1, C3.3, C3.5, C4.2, C4.3, C4.6.
  • The most often failed criterion is C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 11 of 23 systems score 0.0 on it.
  • 17 systems are not dominated: no other system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on one. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy, Participatory Economics, Integral, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Georgism / LVT, Ostrom Commons, Islamic Finance, Universal Basic Income, Mutual Credit / LETS, State Capitalism / Singapore, Status Quo Market Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, State Capitalism / China, State Capitalism / Qatar, Centrally Planned Socialism.

The findings as charts: totals and failures, domain profiles, and trade-offs.

Totals use equal weights and are one reading of the evidence, not a measurement. Each system's page registers the close calls a reasonable scorer could set differently, and the Thresholds page shows how the ranking moves when you weigh the domains differently.

Who made this

-

NEEC is written by Duke Johnson, an independent researcher, and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (opens the Research Hub in a new tab), one of the scored systems; Claude does the scoring and the engineering. On the published totals it ranks 1 of 23, at 17.5 of 29, with 0 structural failures. The published protocol, the evidence behind each score, the registers of close calls and blind replication by scorers outside the project exist so that any score can be checked and contested. The full disclosure.

+

NEEC is written by Duke Johnson, an independent researcher, and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (opens the Research Hub in a new tab), one of the scored systems; Claude does the scoring and the engineering. On the published totals it ranks 1 of 23, at 16.5 of 29, with 0 structural failures. The published protocol, the evidence behind each score, the registers of close calls and blind replication by scorers outside the project exist so that any score can be checked and contested. The full disclosure.

Documents and data

@@ -66,9 +66,9 @@

Documents and data

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

- + diff --git a/docs/llms.txt b/docs/llms.txt index 63879be..e4c13cd 100644 --- a/docs/llms.txt +++ b/docs/llms.txt @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # NEEC: Normative Economic Evaluation Criteria -> NEEC compares economic systems against one fixed set of 29 normative criteria in five domains. Each criterion is scored 1.0, 0.5 or 0.0, clause by clause against its Pass Threshold; a 0.0 is a structural failure, and a system's tier depends only on its number of structural failures (0 to 2 Potentially Adequate, 3 to 5 Partially Adequate, 6 or more Structurally Inadequate). Version 2.0 scores are published on the site. Authors: Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, one of the scored systems. Licence: CC BY 4.0. +> NEEC compares economic systems against one fixed set of 29 normative criteria in five domains. Each criterion is scored 1.0, 0.5 or 0.0, clause by clause against its Pass Threshold; a 0.0 is a structural failure, and a system's tier depends only on its number of structural failures (0 to 2 Potentially Adequate, 3 to 5 Partially Adequate, 6 or more Structurally Inadequate). Version 2.0 scores are published on the site. Authors: Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, one of the scored systems. Licence: CC BY 4.0. ## Start here diff --git a/docs/method.html b/docs/method.html index c46ed79..54622e8 100644 --- a/docs/method.html +++ b/docs/method.html @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@

Weights

How the framework grows

NEEC is a living framework. New systems can be scored, and new criteria added as evidence accumulates and new threats to economic security appear. Changes follow the same discipline as scores. A criterion joins only through a recorded decision and a new version of the criteria: version 2.0 added three, on civil liberties and the rule of law, productive and innovative capacity, and harm internalization. A new system is scored in its own document under the protocol, then inserted by a separate maintainers' pass. Every methodological decision is recorded with its reason, in the criteria record and the protocol's decision register; every change is checked by the harness before it is merged; and every working session is published as a release.

Disclosure

-

NEEC is written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (opens the Research Hub in a new tab), one of the scored systems: four of the five components of his Compassionism framework, scored as one system. Claude does the scoring and the engineering. The Paper addresses this self-referential concern in its section 10.5. The published protocol, the evidence for every score, the registers of close calls and blind replication by scorers outside the project exist so that any score can be checked and contested. The first blind replication is on the record; the next is planned for CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH itself, with a replicator outside the Claude model family.

+

NEEC is written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Duke Johnson designed CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (opens the Research Hub in a new tab), one of the scored systems: four of the five components of his Compassionism framework, scored as one system. Claude does the scoring and the engineering. The Paper addresses this self-referential concern in its section 10.5. The published protocol, the evidence for every score, the registers of close calls and blind replication by scorers outside the project exist so that any score can be checked and contested. The first blind replication is on the record; the next is planned for CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP itself, with a replicator outside the Claude model family.

Limits

A score is a judgment against a stated threshold, made from the evidence available when the system was scored; it is not a measurement, and evidence dates. A few clauses ask for quantities no agency publishes; for those, a 1.0 needs evidence the scorer names, so in practice they separate only 0.0 from 0.5 until such evidence exists. A comparison across different kinds of system is only as fair as the scope rules that make it, and the protocol states those rules so that they can be contested.

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@

Limits

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

diff --git a/docs/replicate.html b/docs/replicate.html index 9bd2ad7..fc920c8 100644 --- a/docs/replicate.html +++ b/docs/replicate.html @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@

Check a score with an AI

- +
@@ -284,9 +284,9 @@

Formal blind replication

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

- + diff --git a/docs/systems/cco.html b/docs/systems/cco.html index d741c23..2d29df7 100644 --- a/docs/systems/cco.html +++ b/docs/systems/cco.html @@ -3,14 +3,14 @@ -CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH | NEEC - +CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | NEEC + - - + + @@ -27,24 +27,24 @@
-

CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH

+

CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP

Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. Code CCO.

-

CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH combines four components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, CIP is Citizens Internet Portal, and SZH is Social Zone Harmonization. Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism.

+

CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP combines five components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, PTH is Public Trust Housing, SZH is Social Zone Harmonization, and CIP is Citizens Internet Portal. NEEC's records before Session 84 call it by its earlier name (formerly CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH); PTH was always read in its units, and the name now lists it (the owner's decision D68). Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism.

Designed by Duke Johnson, one of NEEC's two authors. The disclosure says how the project handles this.

-

17.5 of 29 (60%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 1 of 23 on equal weights.

-
Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.
-

By domain

Material Security

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

System Resilience

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

-

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a1.00.5stated
C2.51.00.5stated
C3.21.00.5stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C5.20.51.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored17.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward18.00Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward15.50Potentially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

-

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

+

16.5 of 29 (57%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 1 of 23 on equal weights.

+
Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.
+

By domain

Material Security

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

System Resilience

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

+

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a1.00.5stated
C2.20.51.0stated
C2.51.00.5stated
C3.21.00.5stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C5.20.51.0stated
C5.30.51.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored16.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward18.00Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward14.50Potentially Adequate
+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

- + diff --git a/docs/systems/cn.html b/docs/systems/cn.html index 7d9fc04..c4ba790 100644 --- a/docs/systems/cn.html +++ b/docs/systems/cn.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy)

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

1.0 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 1.0

Ethical Integrity

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C2.10.00.5stated
C2.30.50.0stated
C2.40.00.5stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.21.00.5register
C3.50.00.5stated
C3.61.00.5stated
C4.20.50.0stated
C4.30.00.5stated
C4.50.00.5stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.40.50.0register

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored11.58Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward14.53Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward8.512Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/cps.html b/docs/systems/cps.html index b1bb8d8..debf4e8 100644 --- a/docs/systems/cps.html +++ b/docs/systems/cps.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Centrally Planned Socialism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

0.0 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0

System Resilience

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0

Implementation Viability

1.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0stated
C1.31.00.5stated
C2.30.00.5stated
C2.50.00.5stated
C2.60.00.5stated
C3.10.50.0stated
C3.40.00.5stated
C3.50.00.5stated
C3.60.50.0stated
C4.10.51.0stated
C4.20.00.5stated
C4.50.50.0stated
C4.60.00.5stated
C5.20.00.5stated
C5.50.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored6.517Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward11.59Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved downward4.021Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/de.html b/docs/systems/de.html index 575da17..e2701a1 100644 --- a/docs/systems/de.html +++ b/docs/systems/de.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Doughnut Economics

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

0.5 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

2.0 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.10.00.5stated
C1.2b0.00.5stated
C1.30.50.0stated
C3.10.00.5stated
C4.40.00.5stated
C4.50.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored9.510Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward12.05Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward9.011Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/dg.html b/docs/systems/dg.html index 783c077..0ee241e 100644 --- a/docs/systems/dg.html +++ b/docs/systems/dg.html @@ -29,20 +29,20 @@

Degrowth Economics

Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. Code DG.

-

14.5 of 29 (50%), 1 structural failure, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 of 23 on equal weights.

+

14.0 of 29 (48%), 1 structural failure, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.
-

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

-

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.30.51.0stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C3.60.50.0stated
C4.50.51.0stated
C5.40.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored14.51Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward13.03Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

+

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.30.51.0stated
C3.60.50.0stated
C4.50.51.0stated
C5.40.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored14.01Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.00Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward13.03Partially Adequate
+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

- + diff --git a/docs/systems/falc.html b/docs/systems/falc.html index 78400b2..e1ec75a 100644 --- a/docs/systems/falc.html +++ b/docs/systems/falc.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Fully Automated Luxury Communism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

1.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.50.0stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.10.50.0stated
C3.40.00.5stated
C3.60.50.0stated
C4.40.50.0stated
C5.10.50.0stated
C5.20.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored12.07Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward13.05Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward9.013Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/geo.html b/docs/systems/geo.html index acc1bcf..9d6f9ef 100644 --- a/docs/systems/geo.html +++ b/docs/systems/geo.html @@ -30,18 +30,18 @@

Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)

Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. Code GEO.

LVT is Land Value Tax, a levy on the value of land itself rather than on buildings or labour.

-

14.0 of 29 (48%), 2 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

+

14.0 of 29 (48%), 2 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C4.30.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored14.02Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward13.53Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/if.html b/docs/systems/if.html index 45a9dc0..2958930 100644 --- a/docs/systems/if.html +++ b/docs/systems/if.html @@ -29,18 +29,18 @@

Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking

Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. Code IF.

-

14.0 of 29 (48%), 3 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

+

14.0 of 29 (48%), 3 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.00.5register
C1.40.00.5stated
C1.50.50.0register
C3.50.50.0stated
C4.20.50.0stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C4.40.50.0stated
C4.50.50.0stated
C5.20.51.0stated
C5.40.51.0register
C5.51.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored14.03Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.01Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward10.59Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/index.html b/docs/systems/index.html index 1586380..58edf7d 100644 --- a/docs/systems/index.html +++ b/docs/systems/index.html @@ -27,15 +27,15 @@
-

Systems

NEEC scores 23 economic systems of three kinds: 6 configured national economies, 9 comprehensive systems, 8 mechanisms. The kind decides how a threshold written for a whole population is read. Each system has an evidence report, criterion by criterion, and its full scoring documents, linked below.

Compare side by side

Choose up to three systems to set their rows next to each other. Where one system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on at least one, the comparison says so.

Configured national economies

An existing or historical national political economy, scored as configured at a stated date.

Comprehensive systems

A design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it.

Mechanisms

An institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy.

Propose a system to score

+

Systems

NEEC scores 23 economic systems of three kinds: 6 configured national economies, 9 comprehensive systems, 8 mechanisms. The kind decides how a threshold written for a whole population is read. Each system has an evidence report, criterion by criterion, and its full scoring documents, linked below.

Compare side by side

Choose up to three systems to set their rows next to each other. Where one system scores at least as high on every criterion and higher on at least one, the comparison says so.

Configured national economies

An existing or historical national political economy, scored as configured at a stated date.

Comprehensive systems

A design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it.

Mechanisms

An institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy.

Propose a system to score

- + diff --git a/docs/systems/int.html b/docs/systems/int.html index 448677f..0d57e5a 100644 --- a/docs/systems/int.html +++ b/docs/systems/int.html @@ -34,14 +34,14 @@

Integral

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0stated
C2.20.50.0, 1.0stated
C2.50.51.0stated
C2.60.50.0stated
C3.20.51.0stated
C3.30.51.0stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C4.51.00.5stated
C5.20.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.02Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward17.52Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward12.55Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/lm.html b/docs/systems/lm.html index 5605f2f..d8c544e 100644 --- a/docs/systems/lm.html +++ b/docs/systems/lm.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Libertarian Minarchism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

1.0 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.0 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a0.50.0stated
C1.50.50.0stated
C2.51.00.5stated
C2.60.51.0stated
C3.40.50.0stated
C3.50.50.0stated
C4.10.50.0stated
C4.20.00.5stated
C4.50.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored9.511Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward11.09Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved downward6.516Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/mc.html b/docs/systems/mc.html index 6bfe67b..3dd37c6 100644 --- a/docs/systems/mc.html +++ b/docs/systems/mc.html @@ -34,14 +34,14 @@

Mutual Credit / LETS

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C2.20.50.0stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.20.50.0stated
C5.51.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored13.53Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward14.03Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward11.56Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/mmt.html b/docs/systems/mmt.html index 67f29bd..8b22d80 100644 --- a/docs/systems/mmt.html +++ b/docs/systems/mmt.html @@ -34,14 +34,14 @@

MMT + Job Guarantee

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a0.00.5stated
C1.2b0.00.5stated
C2.50.51.0stated
C4.10.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored12.54Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward14.02Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward12.05Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/ms.html b/docs/systems/ms.html index 1b8fe49..db6642a 100644 --- a/docs/systems/ms.html +++ b/docs/systems/ms.html @@ -29,18 +29,18 @@

Market Socialism

Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. Code MS.

-

15.5 of 29 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 3 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

+

15.5 of 29 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C4.20.50.0stated
C4.41.00.5stated
C5.50.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward13.03Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/nsd.html b/docs/systems/nsd.html index 9367f44..852407f 100644 --- a/docs/systems/nsd.html +++ b/docs/systems/nsd.html @@ -29,18 +29,18 @@

Nordic Social Democracy

Configured national economy: an existing or historical national political economy, scored as configured at a stated date. Code NSD.

-

15.5 of 29 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 3 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

+

15.5 of 29 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a0.51.0stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C4.10.51.0stated
C4.60.51.0stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.41.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward17.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward14.51Potentially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/os.html b/docs/systems/os.html index 1a3263f..2dca0c6 100644 --- a/docs/systems/os.html +++ b/docs/systems/os.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Ostrom-Style Commons Governance

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

4.0 of 5 = 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0register
C1.40.50.0stated
C1.50.00.5register
C2.20.00.5register
C3.30.51.0register
C3.41.00.5stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C5.20.50.0stated
C5.40.51.0register

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.03Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward17.51Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward13.06Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/pe.html b/docs/systems/pe.html index 4bd4376..ed7324d 100644 --- a/docs/systems/pe.html +++ b/docs/systems/pe.html @@ -29,20 +29,20 @@

Participatory Economics

Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. Code PE.

-

16.5 of 29 (57%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 of 23 on equal weights.

+

15.5 of 29 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.
-

By domain

Material Security

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

-

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C2.50.50.0stated
C2.60.50.0stated
C3.30.51.0stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C4.51.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored16.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward17.00Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward14.52Potentially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

4.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

+

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.51.0stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C2.60.50.0stated
C3.30.51.0stated
C4.51.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.50Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward14.02Potentially Adequate
+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

- + diff --git a/docs/systems/qa.html b/docs/systems/qa.html index f5ad4f3..7e4cd76 100644 --- a/docs/systems/qa.html +++ b/docs/systems/qa.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism)

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

1.5 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

1.5 of 6 = 1.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.10.50.0stated
C1.2a0.51.0stated
C1.2b0.50.0register
C1.40.50.0stated
C1.50.00.5register
C2.10.00.5stated
C2.40.00.5stated
C2.50.50.0stated
C3.10.00.5stated
C3.30.51.0register
C3.50.50.0stated
C3.60.50.0stated
C4.11.00.5stated
C4.50.00.5stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.40.51.0register
C5.50.00.5register

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored10.010Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward15.04Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward6.516Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/sc.html b/docs/systems/sc.html index 53ca392..3063298 100644 --- a/docs/systems/sc.html +++ b/docs/systems/sc.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Stakeholder Capitalism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.40.00.5stated
C3.50.50.0stated
C4.10.50.0stated
C4.20.00.5stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C4.40.50.0stated
C4.50.00.5stated
C5.40.50.0stated
C5.50.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored11.56Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward13.52Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward9.011Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/sg.html b/docs/systems/sg.html index 926efd8..9f5022d 100644 --- a/docs/systems/sg.html +++ b/docs/systems/sg.html @@ -34,14 +34,14 @@

State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism)

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0

Ethical Integrity

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

2.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2a0.51.0stated
C1.40.50.0stated
C3.20.51.0stated
C3.50.50.0stated
C3.61.00.5stated
C4.20.00.5stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C4.40.00.5stated
C4.50.50.0stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.40.51.0register

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored13.53Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.51Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward11.07Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/sq.html b/docs/systems/sq.html index 50ca82a..8f82d52 100644 --- a/docs/systems/sq.html +++ b/docs/systems/sq.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Status Quo Market Capitalism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0

Ethical Integrity

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.10.50.0stated
C1.2a0.51.0stated
C1.40.00.5stated
C3.10.50.0stated
C3.30.50.0stated
C3.61.00.5stated
C4.10.50.0stated
C4.20.00.5stated
C4.30.00.5stated
C4.40.50.0stated
C4.50.00.5stated
C5.10.51.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored13.06Structurally Inadequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.02Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward10.011Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/swf.html b/docs/systems/swf.html index 079ef25..72a5a08 100644 --- a/docs/systems/swf.html +++ b/docs/systems/swf.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.5 of 5 = 0.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.50.50.0stated
C3.41.00.5stated
C4.20.50.0stated
C4.30.50.0stated
C4.50.00.5stated
C5.10.51.0stated
C5.21.00.5stated
C5.40.51.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored15.02Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward16.51Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward12.55Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/ubi.html b/docs/systems/ubi.html index 49c8355..a6ab99b 100644 --- a/docs/systems/ubi.html +++ b/docs/systems/ubi.html @@ -29,18 +29,18 @@

Universal Basic Income

Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. Code UBI.

-

14.0 of 29 (48%), 4 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

+

14.0 of 29 (48%), 4 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights.

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.5 of 5 = 1.0 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C2.20.51.0stated
C2.51.00.0stated
C4.40.50.0stated
C5.11.00.5stated
C5.31.00.5stated
C5.50.50.0stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored14.04Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward14.54Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward11.07Structurally Inadequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/systems/ubs.html b/docs/systems/ubs.html index 98c2cb6..9242f49 100644 --- a/docs/systems/ubs.html +++ b/docs/systems/ubs.html @@ -33,14 +33,14 @@

Universal Basic Services

Share of each domain's points; the dashed outline is the median of all systems. Compare profiles.

By domain

Material Security

1.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0

Human Autonomy

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

System Resilience

2.5 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.0 + 0.5

Ethical Integrity

3.0 of 6 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5

Implementation Viability

3.0 of 5 = 0.5 + 0.5 + 1.0 + 0.5 + 0.5

Close calls

The scoring document registers these scores as calls a reasonable scorer could set differently.

CriterionScoredAlternativeDirection
C1.2b0.00.5stated
C2.50.51.0stated
C3.50.00.5stated
C5.31.00.5stated

Resolved together, they give:

ReadingTotalFailuresTier
As scored13.04Partially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved upward14.52Potentially Adequate
Every flagged call resolved downward12.54Partially Adequate
-

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

+

Evidence

NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0.

The evidence report for this system has one section for each criterion: the score, the reading of each clause with its source, the close call if there is one, and links to the exact line of the published rationale and of the rescoring record that read it.

The full text is in the scoring documents:

Check this system with an AIChallenge a scoreAdd evidence

diff --git a/docs/thresholds.html b/docs/thresholds.html index ef5cf5b..9475b97 100644 --- a/docs/thresholds.html +++ b/docs/thresholds.html @@ -84,7 +84,7 @@

Whose decisions count as accountable?

Adopted
The share of employment in organizations whose investment, production and employment decisions answer to those they affect, at least 80%.
Alternative
  • Decisions made within law by an elected legislature count as accountable.
Why
Under the alternative, C4.4 would measure only whether power can be removed, and it would contradict the published reading of Stakeholder Capitalism.
-
What it changes
Recorded in the rescoring pass, not yet published: the alternative would raise Nordic Social Democracy's C4.4 to 1.0 and restore CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's to 1.0. Because the adopted reading lowers the owner's own design, the owner has been asked to confirm it.
+
What it changes
Recorded in the rescoring pass, not yet published: the alternative would raise Nordic Social Democracy's C4.4 to 1.0 and restore CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's to 1.0. Because the adopted reading lowers the owner's own design, the owner has been asked to confirm it.

Push back on this choice

@@ -183,9 +183,9 @@

Should the tier bands grow with the number of criteria?

NEEC is part of the Better To Best Research Hub. Written by Duke Johnson and Claude (Anthropic). Text and data under CC BY 4.0.

Repository Replicate Report an error For AI systems

-

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 05d2b4dc).

+

Built by build_site.py 1.0 from criteria.json (29 criteria, md5 255180b0) and neec_corpus.json (md5 17aa3228).

- + diff --git a/evidence/cco.md b/evidence/cco.md index 95c611c..5ebefa2 100644 --- a/evidence/cco.md +++ b/evidence/cco.md @@ -1,12 +1,12 @@ -# CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH (CCO): evidence report +# CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP (CCO): evidence report > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 17.5 of 29.0 (60%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 1 of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 16.5 of 29.0 (57%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 1 of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. -**About the name:** CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH combines four components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, CIP is Citizens Internet Portal, and SZH is Social Zone Harmonization. Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism. +**About the name:** CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP combines five components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, PTH is Public Trust Housing, SZH is Social Zone Harmonization, and CIP is Citizens Internet Portal. NEEC's records before Session 84 call it by its earlier name (formerly CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH); PTH was always read in its units, and the name now lists it (the owner's decision D68). Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism. **Disclosure:** designed by Duke Johnson, one of NEEC's two authors. [How the project handles this](https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/method.html#disclosure). @@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -29,12 +29,12 @@ Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the | [C1.4 Automation Resilience](#c1-4) | 0.5 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57), changed from 1.0 | | [C1.5 Universal Wealth Access](#c1-5) | 0.5 | held at the published score | -**2. Human Autonomy: 4.0 of 6.0** +**2. Human Autonomy: 3.5 of 6.0** | Criterion | Score | Basis | |---|---|---| | [C2.1 Freedom from Coercion](#c2-1) | 0.5 | read in part (b4) (Session 41), changed from 1.0 | -| [C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity](#c2-2) | 1.0 | held at the published score; outside review: owner | +| [C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity](#c2-2) | 0.5 | held at the published score, then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.2 (ledger D67, Session 84), changed from 1.0; close call; outside review: owner | | [C2.3 Creative Development Opportunities](#c2-3) | 0.5 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), changed from 1.0 | | [C2.4 Democratic Participation](#c2-4) | 0.5 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), changed from 1.0 | | [C2.5 Exit Rights and Mobility](#c2-5) | 1.0 | read in part (b5) (Session 42) and re-read blind in Session 75, then raised by the owner's decision 79.2 (Session 79); close call; outside review: stands | @@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the | [C3.1 Crisis Response Capacity](#c3-1) | 0.5 | read in part (a) (Session 37), changed from 1.0 | | [C3.2 Inflation Control Mechanisms](#c3-2) | 1.0 | read in decision 58.1 (Session 58); close call | | [C3.3 Multi-Failure Resistance](#c3-3) | 0.5 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57), changed from 1.0 | -| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 1.0 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.3 (Session 79); close call; outside review: stands | +| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 1.0 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.3 (Session 79), then clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources (decision 84.3, Session 84); close call; outside review: stands | | [C3.5 Failure-Mode Transparency](#c3-5) | 0.5 | read in part (b6) (Session 43), changed from 1.0 | | [C3.6 Productive and Innovative Capacity](#c3-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76 | @@ -62,13 +62,13 @@ Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the | [C4.5 Exploitation Elimination](#c4-5) | 0.5 | read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 71 | | [C4.6 Harm Internalization](#c4-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76 | -**5. Implementation Viability: 3.0 of 5.0** +**5. Implementation Viability: 2.5 of 5.0** | Criterion | Score | Basis | |---|---|---| | [C5.1 Proven Component Foundation](#c5-1) | 0.5 | read in part (b2) (Session 39), changed from 1.0; outside review: hold | | [C5.2 Staged Transition Pathways](#c5-2) | 0.5 | read in part (b9) (Session 50), changed from 1.0; close call; outside review: hold | -| [C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability](#c5-3) | 1.0 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57); outside review: owner | +| [C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability](#c5-3) | 0.5 | read in group 2.5 (Session 57), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.2 (ledger D67, Session 84), changed from 1.0; close call; outside review: owner | | [C5.4 Political Coalition Potential](#c5-4) | 0.5 | read in part (b9) (Session 50), changed from 1.0 | | [C5.5 Cultural Adaptability](#c5-5) | 0.5 | held at the published score | @@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: **Close call.** Scored 1.0; a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Group 2.5's reading (decision 57.3): the clause holds only if new output backs what the Source pays, a condition the design's sources do not state; the release row shows 13.9% -**Note.** The owner's decision 79.1 raises the unit to 1.0 on decision 58.1's reading of the backing, which lifts no other CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH unit (C1.1, C1.2b, C1.3 and C3.3 stay short at full backing); it supersedes group 2.5's unit and reopens toward 0.5 on an empirical study showing that the backing by creative output does not hold in real-world data +**Note.** The owner's decision 79.1 raises the unit to 1.0 on decision 58.1's reading of the backing, which lifts no other CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP unit (C1.1, C1.2b, C1.3 and C3.3 stay short at full backing); it supersedes group 2.5's unit and reopens toward 0.5 on an empirical study showing that the backing by creative output does not hold in real-world data **Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the cell is the owner's decision, which stands: the reader's not shown repeats the reading before decision 79.1 (no backing) and adds no fact the decision did not weigh; stage B held 0.5. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). @@ -223,13 +223,22 @@ Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s41.md, line 198](https://github.com/BetterToBest/N > CCO unconditional provision eliminates survival-based employment coercion. Modeling shows 75%+ report genuine autonomy. PTF housing removes landlord coercion. -### C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 1.0 (pass) +### C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 0.5 (partial) -*No unit of the rescoring pass reads this cell. The published score stands: 1.0. The reading behind it is the published rationale linked below.* +*No unit of the rescoring pass read this cell; the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83) read it after the outside review disagreed, and the owner applied that reading (decision 84.2, ledger D67, Session 84; the adjudicated reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 0.5: changed.* Criterion in v2.0: class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). Pass Threshold: Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents. -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication reads it 0.5, which goes to the owner (decision 57.2 reserves CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's changes to the owner, and decision 69.4 holds a fall); NEEC's 1.0 stands until the owner decides: the design's text pays citizens and legal residents aged 18 or more, and its own model leaves adults below their cost of living. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +| # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| 1 | Unconditional provision covering 100% of basic needs (housing, food, healthcare, utilities) for all residents | not shown | not shown in full: the provision is unconditional (no means test or work requirement), but the design's legislative text pays 'every citizen and legal resident 18 years or older', its BLEI accounting values the Basic Units against food and utilities, essentials are paid partly in primary currency, and its published model leaves adults below their cost of living (the share falls 60.3% to 70.7% against no programme, the entry's C1.1) | the source pack design__CCO__C2.2 (integrated-implementation-roadmap.html, section 102; basic-living-economic-index.html); NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, CCO C1.1 | + +**Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading: the basic amount covers essential needs unconditionally + +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication read it 0.5, which went to the owner (decision 57.2 reserves CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's changes to the owner, and decision 69.4 holds a fall); the owner applied it (decision 84.2, ledger D67, Session 84): the design's text pays citizens and legal residents aged 18 or more, and its own model leaves adults below their cost of living. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). + +Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [adjudicate_s83.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/adjudicate_s83.py) +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C2.2 Labor Non-Necessity: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1296](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1296): @@ -396,25 +405,26 @@ Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, line 302](https://github.com/BetterToBest/N ### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0 (pass) -*Read by the rescoring pass in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.3 (Session 79) (the final reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 1.0: unchanged.* +*Read by the rescoring pass in group 2.5 (Session 57), then raised by the owner's decision 79.3 (Session 79), then clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources (decision 84.3, Session 84) (Session 84's reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 1.0: unchanged.* Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: ≥30% parameter adjustability range, policy updates within 6 months of evidence, changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected, zero collapses during parameter adjustments. | # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | |---|---|---|---|---| -| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | octave caps, basic amounts (5-20% of GDP per capita), conversion multipliers and the phi-rate adjustable | as audited (the unit's own text) | +| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | cleared: the design's documents give adjustable ranges well beyond 30% for several parameters without redesign: the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis cuts the maximum octaves from 8 to 4 (50%) and runs participation from 5% to 35%, keeping inflation below 1.8% and 89% of the welfare gains; the integrated framework sets the conversion multiplier at 1-9x against tested alternatives of 1-5x and 1-12x and a regional adjustment factor of 0.8-1.2; and the scorer's adjustment run on the v5.6 engine moves the Basic Unit by 30% either way (0.7 to 1.3) from year 10 | the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba: dual-currency-inflation.html, section 5.3; cco-ptf-integrated-framework.html, sections 3.1.2 and 5.4 (outside_kit_sources/cco_hub__dual-currency-inflation.txt, cco_hub__cco-ptf-integrated-framework.txt); NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, reading 3.11 | | 2 | policy updates within 6 months of evidence | cleared | the design's crisis protocol schedules parameter recalibration within one to six months, and monthly cost-of-living adjustments in an inflation surge | research hub at 8e8a6ba, integrated-implementation-roadmap.html (Appendix G) | -| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | CIP enables democratic parameter adjustment | as audited (the unit's own text) | +| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | cleared: under the Citizens Internet Portal any citizen can submit a proposal (a signature threshold, a 30-90 day comment period, amendment), and a binding change passes by a 60-67% supermajority with geographic distribution, so those affected can challenge a parameter change and have it reversed by a process that does not run through the officials who made it; referenda move from advisory to binding in the second phase (years 4-7); the PTH charter template adds notice, hearing and appeal rights on every enforcement action | the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba: citizens-internet-portal.html, sections 4.4 and 7.1; democratic-governance-pth.html, Appendix B.1 (charter template), Article VI, section 2 (outside_kit_sources/cco_hub__citizens-internet-portal.txt, cco_hub__democratic-governance-pth.txt) | | 4 | zero collapses during parameter adjustments | cleared | on the owner's reading (decision 79.3), a collapse is a breakdown that an adjustment causes (runaway prices, a run that fails), not the direct effect of a smaller allowance on the share below the cost of living; on the scorer's adjustment run (the Basic Unit multiplied by 0.7, 0.8, 1.2 or 1.3 from year 10, 500 seeds, Reference) no step causes such a breakdown at either backing: the 1.2 and 1.3 steps add at most 6.8 points to a year's price rise, and the 0.7 and 0.8 steps raise the share below the cost of living (the test fixed before the run counted 339 and 43 of 500 seeds in the release row, largest excess 16.6 points) as a smaller allowance does directly | the owner's decision 79.3 (2026-10-19); Compassionism Simulation at d10ed6e (v5.6.0), harness.js (md5 84be3bc9) and index.html (md5 2e1cc8c7), the v5.6 release's engine; cco_sim_v56_checks_s57_output.txt; NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, reading 3.11 | **Close call.** Scored 1.0; a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Group 2.5's reading (reading 3.11): on the test fixed before the run, a 20-30% cut in the allowance raises the share below the cost of living by 10 points or more in 339 and 43 of 500 seeds -**Note.** The owner's decision 79.3 raises the unit to 1.0 and reads the test fixed before the run as counting the cut's direct effect, which the record discloses; the reading changes no other entry (the four other entries short on clause 4 record banking crises, excess deaths or a regime's collapse, which are breakdowns on any reading); it reopens toward 0.5 on a run in which an adjustment causes a breakdown +**Note.** The owner's decision 79.3 raises the unit to 1.0 and reads the test fixed before the run as counting the cut's direct effect, which the record discloses; the reading changes no other entry (the four other entries short on clause 4 record banking crises, excess deaths or a regime's collapse, which are breakdowns on any reading); it reopens toward 0.5 on a run in which an adjustment causes a breakdown; Session 84 re-read clauses 1 and 3 on the design's own documents (decision 84.3): each had rested on the unit's own text, which rule 3 of decision 83.4 does not accept; both clear, and the verdict holds **Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the cell is the owner's decision, which stands: the reader's clause 4 rests on stability across participation levels and crisis scenarios, not on parameter adjustments, the reading decision 79.3 decided. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, line 310](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md?plain=1#L310) -Applied by the owner's decision 79.3: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Applied by the owner's decision 79.3: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1312](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1312): @@ -650,24 +660,26 @@ Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s50.md, line 345](https://github.com/BetterToBest/N > Detailed pathways specified for both gradual (10-25 years: municipal pilots → regional → national) and rapid (18-36 months: post-crisis emergency deployment). Historical precedents validate timelines (New Deal: 3 years; Marshall Plan: 3 years). -### C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability: 1.0 (pass) +### C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability: 0.5 (partial) -*Read by the rescoring pass in group 2.5 (Session 57). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 1.0: unchanged.* +*Read by the rescoring pass in group 2.5 (Session 57), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.2 (ledger D67, Session 84) (the adjudicated reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 0.5: changed.* Criterion in v2.0: class U (unchanged). Pass Threshold: Viable at ≥30% participation, coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity, scaling pathway validated through modeling, coordination protocols established. | # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | |---|---|---|---|---| -| 1 | Viable at ≥30% participation | cleared | Viable at 30%+ participation | as audited (the unit's own text) | +| 1 | Viable at ≥30% participation | short | short on the preponderance of the design's own texts (protocol 4.2): the modelling paper finds 'minimum viable participation at 55%' ('below 55% participation rate, network effects fail to sustain system growth'), the BLEI paper a self-funding threshold of 60-65%, the sensitivity analysis 55-60%, and the model warns below 55%; the integrated framework's 'viability at 30%' states no computation | the source pack design__CCO__C5.3 (economic-modeling-simulation.html, section 7.1; basic-living-economic-index.html, section 6.3; cco-ptf-simulation-replication.html); NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, reading 3.12 | | 2 | coexistence with traditional markets maintaining ≥90% economic activity | cleared | Can coexist with traditional markets | as audited (the unit's own text) | | 3 | scaling pathway validated through modeling | cleared | Scaling pathway validated through modeling | as audited (the unit's own text) | | 4 | coordination protocols established | cleared | Inter-jurisdictional coordination protocols specified | as audited (the unit's own text) | -**Note.** Re-read on v5.6.0 and carried (reading 3.12): the model still reads no aggregate participation threshold (the 55% minimum is a run warning), computes no economic activity or scaling path, and its Stress Test, at 40% taking part (43.7% by year 19), still lowers the share below the cost of living against no programme, so it neither supports nor contradicts the rationale's figures; its labour response lowers paid hours by 8.3% to 11.3%, while the projects' output, which it values separately, is not an economic-activity measure +**Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The integrated framework's reading: viability at 30% participation -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication reads it 0.5, which goes to the owner (decision 57.2 reserves CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's changes to the owner, and decision 69.4 holds a fall); NEEC's 1.0 stands until the owner decides: the design's modelling paper (minimum viable participation 55%), its BLEI paper (self-funding at 60-65%) and its model's run warning outweigh the framework paper's 30%. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication read it 0.5, which went to the owner (decision 57.2 reserves CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's changes to the owner, and decision 69.4 holds a fall); the owner applied it (decision 84.2, ledger D67, Session 84): the design's modelling paper (minimum viable participation 55%), its BLEI paper (self-funding at 60-65%) and its model's run warning outweigh the framework paper's 30%. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). -Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, line 323](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md?plain=1#L323) +Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, line 323](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md?plain=1#L323) +Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [adjudicate_s83.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/adjudicate_s83.py) +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C5.3 Partial and Parallel Deployability: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1334](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1334): diff --git a/evidence/cn.md b/evidence/cn.md index aae55e0..85dfdba 100644 --- a/evidence/cn.md +++ b/evidence/cn.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/cps.md b/evidence/cps.md index bcc2428..31e8f5d 100644 --- a/evidence/cps.md +++ b/evidence/cps.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/de.md b/evidence/de.md index 3342828..20c1fcf 100644 --- a/evidence/de.md +++ b/evidence/de.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/dg.md b/evidence/dg.md index 6425b75..6cb679f 100644 --- a/evidence/dg.md +++ b/evidence/dg.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 14.5 of 29.0 (50%), 1 structural failure, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 1 structural failure, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -36,14 +36,14 @@ Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the | [C2.5 Exit Rights and Mobility](#c2-5) | 0.5 | read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75, changed from 0.0; close call | | [C2.6 Civil Liberties and Rule of Law](#c2-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76 | -**3. System Resilience: 3.5 of 6.0** +**3. System Resilience: 3.0 of 6.0** | Criterion | Score | Basis | |---|---|---| | [C3.1 Crisis Response Capacity](#c3-1) | 0.5 | read in part (b2) (Session 39), changed from 1.0 | | [C3.2 Inflation Control Mechanisms](#c3-2) | 0.5 | held at the published score | | [C3.3 Multi-Failure Resistance](#c3-3) | 0.5 | adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83), changed from 1.0; close call; outside review: adopt | -| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 1.0 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79); close call; outside review: owner | +| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 0.5 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84), changed from 1.0; outside review: owner | | [C3.5 Failure-Mode Transparency](#c3-5) | 0.5 | read in group 2.4 (Session 56) | | [C3.6 Productive and Innovative Capacity](#c3-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76; close call | @@ -344,27 +344,25 @@ Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](ht > Core strength—low-throughput systems less vulnerable to supply disruptions. Localized production creates resilience. Explicitly designed for crisis as norm rather than exception. -### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0 (pass) +### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 0.5 (partial) -*Read by the rescoring pass in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79) (the final reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 1.0: unchanged.* +*Read by the rescoring pass in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84) (the adjudicated reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 0.5: changed.* Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: ≥30% parameter adjustability range, policy updates within 6 months of evidence, changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected, zero collapses during parameter adjustments. | # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | |---|---|---|---|---| -| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | democratic governance allows evidence-based adjustments | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 2 | policy updates within 6 months of evidence | cleared | decentralised experimentation enables rapid learning and adaptation | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | democratic governance allows evidence-based adjustments | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 4 | zero collapses during parameter adjustments | cleared | on the rule of decision 79.4: clauses 1 to 3 are cleared (the parameters adjust over a range of 30% or more, updates follow evidence within six months, and those affected can challenge and reverse them), and no implementation record or model located shows a collapse caused by a parameter adjustment, so clause 4 is cleared, as Georgism's clause 4 is read ('no collapse caused by an adjustment located'); the design's democratic governance and decentralised experimentation adjust its parameters, and it has no implementation record or model of its adjustments | the owner's decision 79.4 (2026-10-19); Report v1.6, Degrowth Economics C3.4 | +| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | not shown | not shown: the published rationale's 'democratic governance allows evidence-based adjustments' states no range of adjustment | Report v1.6, DG C3.4; the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | +| 2 | policy updates within 6 months of evidence | not shown | not shown: 'decentralised experimentation enables rapid learning' dates no update against evidence | Report v1.6, DG C3.4; the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | +| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | cleared on v2.0's wording: participatory democracy, citizens' assemblies and referendums let those affected challenge and reverse decisions | the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | +| 4 | zero collapses during parameter adjustments | not shown | not shown: no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation (part (b1), reading 3.1); decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared | Report v1.6, DG C3.4 | -**Close call.** Scored 1.0; a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation located in its sources, so clause 4 is not shown - -**Note.** The owner's decision 79.4 raises the unit to 1.0 on a rule applied to every entry; it reopens toward 0.5 on an implementation record or a model of the design's own adjustments showing a collapse that an adjustment caused - -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication reads it 0.5, which goes to the owner (decision 79.4, whose rule raised the cell, is the owner's); NEEC's 1.0 stands until the owner decides: decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared; clauses 1 and 2 rest on the published rationale's words, which no source estimates. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication read it 0.5, which went to the owner (decision 79.4, whose rule raised the cell, is the owner's); the owner applied it (decision 84.1, ledger D66, Session 84): decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared; clauses 1 and 2 rest on the published rationale's words, which no source estimates. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s38.md, line 235](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s38.md?plain=1#L235) -Applied by the owner's decision 79.4: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Applied by the owner's decision 79.4: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [adjudicate_s83.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/adjudicate_s83.py) +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 952](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L952): diff --git a/evidence/falc.md b/evidence/falc.md index 7cc854a..933927f 100644 --- a/evidence/falc.md +++ b/evidence/falc.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -555,7 +555,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). Pass Thresh **Note.** Adjudicated in Session 83 (adopt): the published text, components proven individually but not integrated, is the 0.5 band -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 0.0; the adjudication adopted the reader's verdict: NEEC's own text (components proven individually, not integrated) is the 0.5 band, as for Participatory Economics, Integral and CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 0.0; the adjudication adopted the reader's verdict: NEEC's own text (components proven individually, not integrated) is the 0.5 band, as for Participatory Economics, Integral and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [adjudicate_s83.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/adjudicate_s83.py) diff --git a/evidence/geo.md b/evidence/geo.md index d92f204..bc8f56e 100644 --- a/evidence/geo.md +++ b/evidence/geo.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 2 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 2 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -457,7 +457,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: Di **Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.0, against NEEC's 0.5; the adjudication held NEEC's verdict: a universal flat dividend, read as for Universal Basic Income and CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH; NEEC's flag already names 0.0. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.0, against NEEC's 0.5; the adjudication held NEEC's verdict: a universal flat dividend, read as for Universal Basic Income and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP; NEEC's flag already names 0.0. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s61.md, line 258](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s61.md?plain=1#L258) diff --git a/evidence/if.md b/evidence/if.md index cad6fc2..088d555 100644 --- a/evidence/if.md +++ b/evidence/if.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 3 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 3 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/index.md b/evidence/index.md index c80d3c2..4a66466 100644 --- a/evidence/index.md +++ b/evidence/index.md @@ -8,17 +8,17 @@ Site: [https://bettertobest.github.io/NormativeEvaluation/](https://bettertobest | System | Code | Total | Failures | Tier | Rank (equal weights) | |---|---|---|---|---|---| -| [CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH](cco.md) | `CCO` | 17.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 1 | -| [Participatory Economics](pe.md) | `PE` | 16.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 2 | -| [Market Socialism](ms.md) | `MS` | 15.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 3 (tied) | -| [Nordic Social Democracy](nsd.md) | `NSD` | 15.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 3 (tied) | +| [CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP](cco.md) | `CCO` | 16.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 1 | +| [Market Socialism](ms.md) | `MS` | 15.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 2 (tied) | +| [Nordic Social Democracy](nsd.md) | `NSD` | 15.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 2 (tied) | +| [Participatory Economics](pe.md) | `PE` | 15.5 | 0 | Potentially Adequate | 2 (tied) | | [Integral](int.md) | `INT` | 15.0 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 5 (tied) | | [Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism](swf.md) | `SWF` | 15.0 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 5 (tied) | -| [Degrowth Economics](dg.md) | `DG` | 14.5 | 1 | Potentially Adequate | 8 | -| [Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)](geo.md) | `GEO` | 14.0 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 9 (tied) | +| [Degrowth Economics](dg.md) | `DG` | 14.0 | 1 | Potentially Adequate | 8 (tied) | +| [Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)](geo.md) | `GEO` | 14.0 | 2 | Potentially Adequate | 8 (tied) | | [Ostrom-Style Commons Governance](os.md) | `OS` | 15.0 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 5 (tied) | -| [Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking](if.md) | `IF` | 14.0 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 9 (tied) | -| [Universal Basic Income](ubi.md) | `UBI` | 14.0 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 9 (tied) | +| [Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking](if.md) | `IF` | 14.0 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 8 (tied) | +| [Universal Basic Income](ubi.md) | `UBI` | 14.0 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 8 (tied) | | [Mutual Credit / LETS](mc.md) | `MC` | 13.5 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 12 (tied) | | [State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism)](sg.md) | `SG` | 13.5 | 3 | Partially Adequate | 12 (tied) | | [Universal Basic Services](ubs.md) | `UBS` | 13.0 | 4 | Partially Adequate | 14 (tied) | diff --git a/evidence/int.md b/evidence/int.md index 0649995..aff4c52 100644 --- a/evidence/int.md +++ b/evidence/int.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -582,7 +582,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: St | 2 | rapid (≤36 months) deployment | not shown | the white paper sets aside direct implementation in a nation-state as 'highly unlikely' and states no rapid pathway; none is located (reading 3.3) | Joseph, INTEGRAL: Technical White Paper v0.1 (integralcollective.io, December 2025; PDF md5 a6defc9a, retrieved 2026-10-15), section 11.1 | | 3 | specific milestones | not shown | no milestones are stated: the transition's markers are 'incremental and often unremarkable' (reading 3.3) | Joseph, INTEGRAL: Technical White Paper v0.1 (integralcollective.io, December 2025; PDF md5 a6defc9a, retrieved 2026-10-15), section 11.11 | | 4 | resource requirements | not shown | no resource requirements are stated; interface cooperatives take in external resources, without a figure (reading 3.3) | Joseph, INTEGRAL: Technical White Paper v0.1 (integralcollective.io, December 2025; PDF md5 a6defc9a, retrieved 2026-10-15), sections 11.5 and 11.6 | -| 5 | risk mitigation | cleared | section 11.10 specifies safeguards of kinds in use elsewhere: no single point of failure, peer-to-peer and federated infrastructure with replicated data, grounded in deployed technologies (decentralised identifiers, content-addressed storage, federated messaging); no central treasury; commons assets that cannot be pledged or sold; legal compliance as the default; and interface cooperatives with capped market exposure and sunset rules; component evidence in the sense of reading 3.2, as CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's risk mitigation was cleared in part (b9) (reading 3.3) | Joseph, INTEGRAL: Technical White Paper v0.1 (integralcollective.io, December 2025; PDF md5 a6defc9a, retrieved 2026-10-15), sections 11.6 and 11.10 | +| 5 | risk mitigation | cleared | section 11.10 specifies safeguards of kinds in use elsewhere: no single point of failure, peer-to-peer and federated infrastructure with replicated data, grounded in deployed technologies (decentralised identifiers, content-addressed storage, federated messaging); no central treasury; commons assets that cannot be pledged or sold; legal compliance as the default; and interface cooperatives with capped market exposure and sunset rules; component evidence in the sense of reading 3.2, as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's risk mitigation was cleared in part (b9) (reading 3.3) | Joseph, INTEGRAL: Technical White Paper v0.1 (integralcollective.io, December 2025; PDF md5 a6defc9a, retrieved 2026-10-15), sections 11.6 and 11.10 | **Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. Re-read on the design's own white paper (v0.1, December 2025), as parts (b5) and (b8) read the design's own pages; the published 0.0's reason, that the source provides no phased pathway, no longer describes the design, and a clause is clear diff --git a/evidence/lm.md b/evidence/lm.md index 56a65aa..c4108e0 100644 --- a/evidence/lm.md +++ b/evidence/lm.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/mc.md b/evidence/mc.md index 286cf39..36b0822 100644 --- a/evidence/mc.md +++ b/evidence/mc.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/mmt.md b/evidence/mmt.md index f0a9226..b567696 100644 --- a/evidence/mmt.md +++ b/evidence/mmt.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/ms.md b/evidence/ms.md index d961e4e..4cd1af6 100644 --- a/evidence/ms.md +++ b/evidence/ms.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 15.5 of 29.0 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 3 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 15.5 of 29.0 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/nsd.md b/evidence/nsd.md index df03900..46cdb96 100644 --- a/evidence/nsd.md +++ b/evidence/nsd.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 15.5 of 29.0 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 3 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 15.5 of 29.0 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Configured national economy: an existing or historical national political economy, scored as configured at a stated date. @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/os.md b/evidence/os.md index 85b62ac..6c099c0 100644 --- a/evidence/os.md +++ b/evidence/os.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/pe.md b/evidence/pe.md index fd1fb0b..e335c2e 100644 --- a/evidence/pe.md +++ b/evidence/pe.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 16.5 of 29.0 (57%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 15.5 of 29.0 (53%), 0 structural failures, Potentially Adequate. Rank 2 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Comprehensive system: a design or vision for a whole economy, scored as its own sources specify it. @@ -10,17 +10,17 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents -**1. Material Security: 3.5 of 6.0** +**1. Material Security: 3.0 of 6.0** | Criterion | Score | Basis | |---|---|---| | [C1.1 Poverty Elimination Capacity](#c1-1) | 0.5 | read in part (b3) (Session 40), changed from 1.0 | | [C1.2a Wealth Building for Resilience](#c1-2a) | 0.5 | read in group 2.2 (Session 53) | -| [C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation](#c1-2b) | 1.0 | held at the published score | +| [C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation](#c1-2b) | 0.5 | held at the published score, then read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (decision 84.4, Session 84), changed from 1.0; close call | | [C1.3 Housing Security](#c1-3) | 0.5 | read in group 2.3 (Session 54), changed from 1.0; outside review: hold | | [C1.4 Automation Resilience](#c1-4) | 0.5 | read in part (b4) (Session 41), changed from 1.0 | | [C1.5 Universal Wealth Access](#c1-5) | 0.5 | held at the published score; outside review: hold | @@ -36,14 +36,14 @@ Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the | [C2.5 Exit Rights and Mobility](#c2-5) | 0.5 | read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 75; close call; outside review: hold | | [C2.6 Civil Liberties and Rule of Law](#c2-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76; close call | -**3. System Resilience: 3.5 of 6.0** +**3. System Resilience: 3.0 of 6.0** | Criterion | Score | Basis | |---|---|---| | [C3.1 Crisis Response Capacity](#c3-1) | 0.5 | read in part (b2) (Session 39), changed from 1.0 | | [C3.2 Inflation Control Mechanisms](#c3-2) | 0.5 | read in part (b4) (Session 41), changed from 1.0 | | [C3.3 Multi-Failure Resistance](#c3-3) | 0.5 | adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83), changed from 1.0; close call; outside review: adopt | -| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 1.0 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79); close call; outside review: owner | +| [C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability](#c3-4) | 0.5 | read in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84), changed from 1.0; outside review: owner | | [C3.5 Failure-Mode Transparency](#c3-5) | 0.5 | read in group 2.4 (Session 56) | | [C3.6 Productive and Innovative Capacity](#c3-6) | 0.5 | new in v2.0, scored in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 76 | @@ -106,12 +106,24 @@ Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s53.md, line 258](https://github.com/BetterToBest/N > No private capital accumulation is permitted by design, but participatory planning enables collective wealth-building through named community investment councils — a genuine, if collectively-rather-than-individually-held, mechanism matching this criterion's own 0.5-band logic (the same logic behind Degrowth's anchor case, above), not the 0.0 band's requirement of no mechanism whatsoever. *(This score was reconsidered once during the retrofit's own drafting: an initial pass scored 0.0 by analogy to Centrally Planned Socialism's flat absence, then was revised to 0.5 on the grounds that "could enable collective wealth-building through [a named institution]" is meaningfully different from "no mechanisms... beyond X" — the revision is what keeps this system at 1 structural failure rather than 3; see Structural Failures, below.)* -### C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation: 1.0 (pass) +### C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation: 0.5 (partial) -*No unit of the rescoring pass reads this cell. The published score stands: 1.0. The reading behind it is the published rationale linked below.* +*No unit of the rescoring pass read this cell; Session 84 read it by the adjudication's rule 4, one reading per class (decision 84.4; that reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 0.5: changed.* Criterion in v2.0: class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). Pass Threshold: Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution. +| # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| 1 | Gini <0.35 for wealth distribution | not shown | not shown: the design removes private productive property, capital markets and income from ownership, and rates incomes by effort and sacrifice, which bounds the top of the distribution more firmly than Degrowth's caps or Integral's parallel network; but it states no bound on personal holdings, which unequal effort ratings and saving across a lifetime leave unequal, and no source the unit cites, and none the outside reader names (it projects the Gini from the design's mechanisms, closed book), estimates the wealth Gini; a bound on the top does not bound a Gini, which the bottom of the distribution also sets | Report v1.6, PE C1.2b; NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md, sections 3 and 9; the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | + +**Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The published reading and the outside reader's: no private capital ownership is a structural ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes + +**Note.** Read in Session 84 by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (ledger I12 item 1): the class W 1.0 rested on the same reading the adjudication found insufficient for Degrowth, Integral and Mutual Credit + +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 1.0, as NEEC then did, so the adjudication did not reach it; Session 84 read it 0.5 by the adjudication's rule 4 (decision 84.4). Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). + +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) + **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C1.2b Prevention of Exploitative Accumulation: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1194](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1194): > No concentrated wealth, no capital owners, no managerial hierarchy — this system's own Power Distribution rationale (C4.4, below) is as clean a Pass anchor as exists in the corpus: comprehensive elimination of private capital ownership. @@ -346,27 +358,25 @@ Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](ht > Distributed decision-making creates resilience. No financial sector to trigger cascading failures. Production prioritizes needs directly rather than through market signals. Strong compound crisis resistance. -### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0 (pass) +### C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 0.5 (partial) -*Read by the rescoring pass in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79) (the final reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 1.0: unchanged.* +*Read by the rescoring pass in part (b1) (Session 38), then raised by the owner's decision 79.4 (Session 79), then lowered to the adjudication's reading by the owner's decision 84.1 (ledger D66, Session 84) (the adjudicated reading is shown). Published (v1) score 1.0; v2.0 score 0.5: changed.* Criterion in v2.0: class M (bar, measure or clause restated). Pass Threshold: ≥30% parameter adjustability range, policy updates within 6 months of evidence, changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected, zero collapses during parameter adjustments. | # | Clause (v2.0) | Status | Reading | Source | |---|---|---|---|---| -| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | councils adjust proposals based on feedback | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 2 | policy updates within 6 months of evidence | cleared | democratic structure enables rapid evidence-based changes | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | democratic structure enables rapid evidence-based changes | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 4 | zero collapses during parameter adjustments | cleared | on the rule of decision 79.4: clauses 1 to 3 are cleared (the parameters adjust over a range of 30% or more, updates follow evidence within six months, and those affected can challenge and reverse them), and no implementation record or model located shows a collapse caused by a parameter adjustment, so clause 4 is cleared, as Georgism's clause 4 is read ('no collapse caused by an adjustment located'); the design's councils adjust proposals on feedback, and it has no implementation record or model of its adjustments | the owner's decision 79.4 (2026-10-19); Report v1.6, Participatory Economics C3.4 | - -**Close call.** Scored 1.0; a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. Part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation, so clause 4 is not shown - -**Note.** The owner's decision 79.4 raises the unit to 1.0 on a rule applied to every entry; it reopens toward 0.5 on an implementation record or a model of the design's own adjustments showing a collapse that an adjustment caused +| 1 | ≥30% parameter adjustability range | cleared | councils adjust proposals based on feedback, every planning cycle | as audited (the unit's own text) | +| 2 | policy updates within 6 months of evidence | not shown | not shown: 'democratic structure enables rapid evidence-based changes' dates no update against evidence; the planning cycle is annual (the outside reader reads the clause short) | Report v1.6, PE C3.4; the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | +| 3 | changes open to challenge and reversal by those affected | cleared | cleared on v2.0's wording: self-managed councils of those affected decide and can reverse | the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz) | +| 4 | zero collapses during parameter adjustments | not shown | not shown: no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments in operation (part (b1), reading 3.1); decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared | Report v1.6, PE C3.4 | -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication reads it 0.5, which goes to the owner (decision 79.4, whose rule raised the cell, is the owner's); NEEC's 1.0 stands until the owner decides: decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared; clause 2 rests on the published rationale's words, which no source estimates. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication read it 0.5, which went to the owner (decision 79.4, whose rule raised the cell, is the owner's); the owner applied it (decision 84.1, ledger D66, Session 84): decision 79.4's rule needs clauses 1 to 3 cleared; clause 2 rests on the published rationale's words, which no source estimates. Shown the argument for the owner's reading (stage B), the reader read it 0.5. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md). Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s38.md, line 286](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s38.md?plain=1#L286) -Applied by the owner's decision 79.4: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Applied by the owner's decision 79.4: [NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), [owner_s79.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s79.py) +Adjudicated after the outside review (Session 83): [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), [adjudicate_s83.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/adjudicate_s83.py) +Applied in Session 84: [NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), [owner_s84.py](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/owner_s84.py) **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C3.4 Epistemic Adaptability: 1.0" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1222](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1222): @@ -539,7 +549,7 @@ Blind re-read record: [NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/ Criterion in v2.0: class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). Pass Threshold: ≥70% of system components proven through ≥20 years operation at scale ≥10,000 participants, with documented outcomes matching claimed benefits. -**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.0, against NEEC's 0.5; the adjudication held NEEC's verdict: participatory budgeting and worker councils have records; the 0.5 band, as for CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and Integral. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). +**Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.0, against NEEC's 0.5; the adjudication held NEEC's verdict: participatory budgeting and worker councils have records; the 0.5 band, as for CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and Integral. Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). **Published (v1) rationale**, under the heading "C5.1 Proven Component Foundation: 0.5" at [NEEC_Report_v1_6.md, line 1240](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Report_v1_6.md?plain=1#L1240): @@ -604,7 +614,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class U (unchanged). Pass Threshold: Viable across ≥3 econo | 1 | Viable across ≥3 economic contexts (high/middle/low income) | not shown | the entry's text addresses cultural variation only (different communities could have different consumption patterns, work structures) and states no viability across high-, middle- and low-income economies (reading 3.6) | Report v1.6, PE C5.5 | | 2 | ≥5 cultural contexts | cleared | Councils respect cultural variation | as audited (the unit's own text) | | 3 | parameter flexibility ≥40% adjustment range | cleared | Flexible system accommodating diverse values | as audited (the unit's own text) | -| 4 | successful operation validated across diverse implementations | not shown | no economy has been organised on the design: its councils, balanced job complexes and participatory planning have not operated as a system anywhere, so there is no operation across diverse implementations to validate; the corpus scores CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C5.5 0.5 on the same ground (comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling), applied alike (reading 3.6) | Report v1.6, PE C5.5 and CCO C5.5 | +| 4 | successful operation validated across diverse implementations | not shown | no economy has been organised on the design: its councils, balanced job complexes and participatory planning have not operated as a system anywhere, so there is no operation across diverse implementations to validate; the corpus scores CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C5.5 0.5 on the same ground (comprehensive implementation validation is limited to modeling), applied alike (reading 3.6) | Report v1.6, PE C5.5 and CCO C5.5 | **Note.** The audit coded clauses 2 and 3 A and clauses 1 and 4 silent diff --git a/evidence/qa.md b/evidence/qa.md index ea99085..cf3a045 100644 --- a/evidence/qa.md +++ b/evidence/qa.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/sc.md b/evidence/sc.md index faa14f2..d5f141f 100644 --- a/evidence/sc.md +++ b/evidence/sc.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/sg.md b/evidence/sg.md index 55f3ceb..8279b60 100644 --- a/evidence/sg.md +++ b/evidence/sg.md @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/sq.md b/evidence/sq.md index d453956..baea022 100644 --- a/evidence/sq.md +++ b/evidence/sq.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/swf.md b/evidence/swf.md index 2197397..28720b1 100644 --- a/evidence/swf.md +++ b/evidence/swf.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/evidence/ubi.md b/evidence/ubi.md index 73b6b3a..0e801fb 100644 --- a/evidence/ubi.md +++ b/evidence/ubi.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > Generated by `build_evidence.py` from the rescoring pass and the published records; never edit by hand. The v2.0 scores are provisional until Report and Paper v2.0. -**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 4 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 9 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. +**v2.0 score:** 14.0 of 29.0 (48%), 4 structural failures, Partially Adequate. Rank 8 (tied) of 23 on equal weights. **Kind:** Mechanism: an institution, instrument or policy family that operates inside a wider economy without itself specifying that economy. @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents @@ -152,7 +152,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class I (indicator named for an unchanged clause and bar). Pa | 1 | Poverty <8% | not shown | an unconditional transfer is an explicit mechanism decoupling income from employment; the rationale's 'scales naturally with automation' is a design statement, not a level of poverty under a stated scenario; no model or estimate of poverty on the Societal Poverty Line under a 30%, 50% or 70% displacement of paid hours is stated or cited, and none was located | Report v1.6, System 7, C1.4 | | 2 | aggregate demand >85% baseline | not shown | unconditional transfers sustain household spending, as the rationale says; no model or estimate of real final consumption expenditure against a pre-displacement baseline in any of the three scenarios is stated or cited, and none was located | Report v1.6, System 7, C1.4 | -**Note.** Published 1.0 on the design's logic; under D28 silence is not clearance (protocol 2.3(b)), as parts (b4) and group 2.5 read Fully Automated Luxury Communism's, Participatory Economics' and CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's 1.0s; a correction (reading 3.2) +**Note.** Published 1.0 on the design's logic; under D28 silence is not clearance (protocol 2.3(b)), as parts (b4) and group 2.5 read Fully Automated Luxury Communism's, Participatory Economics' and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's 1.0s; a correction (reading 3.2) Pass record: [NEEC_Rescoring_s60.md, line 218](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Rescoring_s60.md?plain=1#L218) @@ -206,7 +206,7 @@ Criterion in v2.0: class W (wording, commentary or disclosure only). Pass Thresh **Close call.** Scored 0.5; a reasonable scorer could set 1.0. The 1.0 band's reading: provision explicitly unconditional -**Note.** Adjudicated in Session 83 (adopt), with CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C2.2 read alike (to the owner) +**Note.** Adjudicated in Session 83 (adopt), with CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 read alike (to the owner) **Outside review.** The outside blind reader (run r1) read this unit 0.5, against NEEC's 1.0; the adjudication adopted the reader's verdict: the threshold asks for 100% of basic needs, not only unconditionality: the level is a free parameter in the literature, and rents can absorb the payment (NEEC's own C1.3). Record: [NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md](https://github.com/BetterToBest/NormativeEvaluation/blob/main/NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md). diff --git a/evidence/ubs.md b/evidence/ubs.md index 0f5eaac..7987bb9 100644 --- a/evidence/ubs.md +++ b/evidence/ubs.md @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ ## How to read this report -Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83). +Each criterion has one section, linked from the table below. A section gives the score (1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure), then one row per clause of the criterion's v2.0 Pass Threshold: its status (cleared, short, not shown, out of reach, or moot), the reading, and the source, with each data file in `evidence_cache/` linked. Links at the foot of a section go straight to the line: the pass record that read the unit, for a unit re-read blind the blind re-read record whose final reading is shown, and the published (v1) rationale in the long scoring document. A cell the pass did not read says so and keeps its published rationale. Close calls are scores a reasonable scorer could set differently. Where the outside blind review's reader disagreed with NEEC, and on every CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP and owner-decided cell, the section gives the reader's verdict and the adjudication's outcome (Session 83), and where the owner applied an outcome, the decision (Session 84). ## Contents diff --git a/final_pass.py b/final_pass.py index 4f8ed18..59b4824 100644 --- a/final_pass.py +++ b/final_pass.py @@ -131,6 +131,43 @@ def adjudicated_state(p): return units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, final_part_of, owner_part_of +def settled_units(units, new_units): + """Session 84's units (owner_s84.py): the four owner items as the adjudication reads them, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C3.4 with + clauses 1 and 3 re-read (every other clause carried, the verdict by D28), and Participatory Economics' C1.2b.""" + with redirect_stdout(io.StringIO()): + adj = pc.load("adjudicate_s83", "adjudicate_s83.py") + s84 = pc.load("owner_s84", "owner_s84.py") + out = {} + for k in s84.OWNER: + u = adj.OWNER[k]["unit"] + out[k] = {x: u[x] for x in ("verdict", "clauses", "flag", "note", "zero")} + for k, rv in s84.REVISIONS.items(): + prior = new_units[k] if k in new_units else units[k] + cl = [tuple(c) for c in prior["clauses"]] + for n, c in rv["clauses"].items(): + cl[n - 1] = tuple(c) + out[k] = {"verdict": pc.verdict_of(cl), "clauses": cl, "flag": prior["flag"], + "note": prior["note"] + "; " + rv["note"], "zero": None} + for k, u in s84.UNITS.items(): + out[k] = {x: u[x] for x in ("verdict", "clauses", "flag", "note", "zero")} + return s84, out + + +def settled_state(p): + """adjudicated_state(p) with Session 84's layer laid over it (owner_s84.py: the owner's answers to D66 and D67, and two + consistency gaps closed): (units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, final_part_of, owner_part_of, adj_part_of), where + adj_part_of is the part, group or layer that read each unit before this layer.""" + units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, final_part_of, owner_part_of = adjudicated_state(p) + adj_part_of = {**part_of, **new_part_of} + s84, rev = settled_units(units, new_units) + for k, u in rev.items(): + if k in new_units: + new_units[k], new_part_of[k] = u, s84.TAG + else: + units[k], part_of[k] = u, s84.TAG + return units, part_of, new_units, new_part_of, final_part_of, owner_part_of, adj_part_of + + def selftest(): ok = True @@ -185,6 +222,25 @@ def check(cond, text, detail=""): ok6 = pc.check_rule({k: a_all[k] for k in lay}, lambda c, t, d="": lines.append(f"{'PASS' if c else 'FAIL'} {t} {d}") or c) check(ok5 and ok6, "every adjudicated unit has one status per v2.0 clause with estimate and source, and follows D28 (0.0 " "only on a stated whole-criterion reason)", "; ".join(l for l in lines if l.startswith("FAIL"))[:200]) + # Session 84's layer: the four owner items, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH C3.4's two re-read clauses, Participatory Economics' C1.2b + with redirect_stdout(io.StringIO()): + s84 = pc.load("owner_s84", "owner_s84.py") + s_units, s_part, s_new, s_new_part, _, _, _ = settled_state(p) + s_all = {**s_units, **s_new} + lay = {k for k in s_all if s_all[k] != a_all.get(k)} + keys = set(s84.OWNER) | set(s84.REVISIONS) | set(s84.UNITS) + check(lay == keys and all({**s_part, **s_new_part}[k] == s84.TAG for k in lay) + and all(s_all[k]["clauses"] == [tuple(c) for c in adj.OWNER[k]["unit"]["clauses"]] for k in s84.OWNER) + and all(sum(a != b for a, b in zip(a_all[k]["clauses"], s_all[k]["clauses"])) == len(r["clauses"]) + and s_all[k]["verdict"] == a_all[k]["verdict"] for k, r in s84.REVISIONS.items()), + f"Session 84's layer (owner_s84.py) writes exactly its {len(keys)} units: the four owner items as the adjudication " + "reads them, the revised unit with only its re-read clauses changed and its verdict held, and the class reading") + lines = [] + ok7 = pc.check_records(p, {k: s_all[k] for k in lay}, lambda c, t, d="": lines.append(f"{'PASS' if c else 'FAIL'} {t} {d}") or c) + ok8 = pc.check_rule({k: s_all[k] for k in lay}, lambda c, t, d="": lines.append(f"{'PASS' if c else 'FAIL'} {t} {d}") or c) + check(ok7 and ok8 and all("as audited" not in c[2] for c in s_all[("CCO", "C3.4")]["clauses"]), + "every unit of Session 84's layer has one status per v2.0 clause with estimate and source, and follows D28; no " + "clause of CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C3.4 rests on the unit's own text", "; ".join(l for l in lines if l.startswith("FAIL"))[:200]) print("\nFINAL PASS MODULE SELFTEST: ALL CHECKS PASSED." if ok else "\nFINAL PASS MODULE SELFTEST: CHECKS FAILED.") return 0 if ok else 1 diff --git a/final_pass_selftest_output.txt b/final_pass_selftest_output.txt index f9774ed..fdeb6d3 100644 --- a/final_pass_selftest_output.txt +++ b/final_pass_selftest_output.txt @@ -9,5 +9,7 @@ final_pass.py --selftest: the seven blind groups' final readings laid over the r PASS every revised unit has one status per v2.0 clause with estimate and source, and follows D28 PASS the adjudication's layer (adjudicate_s83.py) writes exactly its 31 units, none of them a CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH unit or a cell of the owner's decisions; every other unit is the owner's state PASS every adjudicated unit has one status per v2.0 clause with estimate and source, and follows D28 (0.0 only on a stated whole-criterion reason) + PASS Session 84's layer (owner_s84.py) writes exactly its 6 units: the four owner items as the adjudication reads them, the revised unit with only its re-read clauses changed and its verdict held, and the class reading + PASS every unit of Session 84's layer has one status per v2.0 clause with estimate and source, and follows D28; no clause of CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C3.4 rests on the unit's own text FINAL PASS MODULE SELFTEST: ALL CHECKS PASSED. diff --git a/neec_corpus_v2.json b/neec_corpus_v2.json index 9e278b5..fc6a3fa 100644 --- a/neec_corpus_v2.json +++ b/neec_corpus_v2.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "schema": "neec-corpus/2.0", - "description": "The NEEC corpus on the v2.0 criteria (29 criteria in five domains): the published 26-criterion vectors with the rescoring pass applied, the three new criteria scored, the blind re-read's final readings (Sessions 71 to 77), the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (Session 79) and the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83) laid over them. Generated by apply_adjudication_s83.py; never edited by hand. Scores: 1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure; totals, failures and tiers follow by protocol section 2, with integer failure bands 0-2, 3-5 and 6+ on the 29 (decision 45.1).", + "description": "The NEEC corpus on the v2.0 criteria (29 criteria in five domains): the published 26-criterion vectors with the rescoring pass applied, the three new criteria scored, the blind re-read's final readings (Sessions 71 to 77), the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (Session 79), the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83) and the owner's items with two consistency readings (Session 84) laid over them. Generated by apply_owner_s84.py; never edited by hand. Scores: 1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure; totals, failures and tiers follow by protocol section 2, with integer failure bands 0-2, 3-5 and 6+ on the 29 (decision 45.1).", "criteria": [ "C1.1", "C1.2a", @@ -313,7 +313,7 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, @@ -411,7 +411,7 @@ "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, "C1.2a": 0.5, - "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, "C1.3": 0.5, "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, @@ -424,7 +424,7 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, @@ -443,7 +443,7 @@ { "key": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", "code": "CCO", - "display_name": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "display_name": "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP", "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, @@ -453,7 +453,7 @@ "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, "C2.1": 0.5, - "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.2": 0.5, "C2.3": 0.5, "C2.4": 0.5, "C2.5": 1.0, @@ -472,7 +472,7 @@ "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, - "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.3": 0.5, "C5.4": 0.5, "C5.5": 0.5 } diff --git a/neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json b/neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9e278b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json @@ -0,0 +1,888 @@ +{ + "schema": "neec-corpus/2.0", + "description": "The NEEC corpus on the v2.0 criteria (29 criteria in five domains): the published 26-criterion vectors with the rescoring pass applied, the three new criteria scored, the blind re-read's final readings (Sessions 71 to 77), the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (Session 79) and the adjudication of the outside review (Session 83) laid over them. Generated by apply_adjudication_s83.py; never edited by hand. Scores: 1.0 pass, 0.5 partial, 0.0 structural failure; totals, failures and tiers follow by protocol section 2, with integer failure bands 0-2, 3-5 and 6+ on the 29 (decision 45.1).", + "criteria": [ + "C1.1", + "C1.2a", + "C1.2b", + "C1.3", + "C1.4", + "C1.5", + "C2.1", + "C2.2", + "C2.3", + "C2.4", + "C2.5", + "C2.6", + "C3.1", + "C3.2", + "C3.3", + "C3.4", + "C3.5", + "C3.6", + "C4.1", + "C4.2", + "C4.3", + "C4.4", + "C4.5", + "C4.6", + "C5.1", + "C5.2", + "C5.3", + "C5.4", + "C5.5" + ], + "entries": [ + { + "key": "Status Quo Market Capitalism", + "code": "SQ", + "display_name": "Status Quo Market Capitalism", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Nordic Social Democracy", + "code": "NSD", + "display_name": "Nordic Social Democracy", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 1.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 1.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Centrally Planned Socialism", + "code": "CPS", + "display_name": "Centrally Planned Socialism", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 1.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.0, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.0, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.0, + "C5.3": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Market Socialism", + "code": "MS", + "display_name": "Market Socialism", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Libertarian Minarchism", + "code": "LM", + "display_name": "Libertarian Minarchism", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "MMT + Job Guarantee", + "code": "MMT", + "display_name": "MMT + Job Guarantee", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Universal Basic Income", + "code": "UBI", + "display_name": "Universal Basic Income", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Degrowth Economics", + "code": "DG", + "display_name": "Degrowth Economics", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Stakeholder Capitalism", + "code": "SC", + "display_name": "Stakeholder Capitalism", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + } + }, + { + "key": "Fully Automated Luxury Communism", + "code": "FALC", + "display_name": "Fully Automated Luxury Communism", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.0, + "C5.3": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Participatory Economics", + "code": "PE", + "display_name": "Participatory Economics", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "code": "CCO", + "display_name": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Integral", + "code": "INT", + "display_name": "Integral", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Georgism / Land Value Tax", + "code": "GEO", + "display_name": "Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Mutual Credit / LETS", + "code": "MC", + "display_name": "Mutual Credit / LETS", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + } + }, + { + "key": "Doughnut Economics", + "code": "DE", + "display_name": "Doughnut Economics", + "scope_class": "comprehensive_system", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Universal Basic Services", + "code": "UBS", + "display_name": "Universal Basic Services", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism", + "code": "SWF", + "display_name": "Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "State Capitalism / China", + "code": "CN", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy)", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "State Capitalism / Singapore", + "code": "SG", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism)", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + } + }, + { + "key": "State Capitalism / Qatar", + "code": "QA", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism)", + "scope_class": "configured_national_economy", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 1.0, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + } + }, + { + "key": "Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking", + "code": "IF", + "display_name": "Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + } + }, + { + "key": "Ostrom-Style Commons Governance", + "code": "OS", + "display_name": "Ostrom-Style Commons Governance", + "scope_class": "mechanism", + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/neec_scores_v2.csv b/neec_scores_v2.csv index 0e2d7d2..01ff8e0 100644 --- a/neec_scores_v2.csv +++ b/neec_scores_v2.csv @@ -1,24 +1,24 @@ system,criteria_count,domain1_max,domain1_material_security,domain2_human_autonomy,domain3_system_resilience,domain4_ethical_integrity,domain5_implementation_viability,total_score,total_percent,failures,adequacy_tier,revision_note,notes -Status Quo Market Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,1.5,3.5,13.0,45%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Nordic Social Democracy,29,6.0,3.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 15 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Centrally Planned Socialism,29,6.0,2.5,0.0,1.5,1.5,1.0,6.5,22%,17,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Market Socialism,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.5,3.5,2.5,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Libertarian Minarchism,29,6.0,1.0,2.5,2.0,1.5,2.5,9.5,33%,11,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -MMT + Job Guarantee,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,2.5,3.0,2.5,12.5,43%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Universal Basic Income,29,6.0,1.5,3.5,2.5,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 11 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Degrowth Economics,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.5,3.0,2.0,14.5,50%,1,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Stakeholder Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,2.0,2.0,11.5,40%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 8 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Fully Automated Luxury Communism,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,1.0,12.0,41%,7,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 13 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Participatory Economics,29,6.0,3.5,3.0,3.5,4.0,2.5,16.5,57%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH,29,6.0,3.5,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,17.5,60%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 17 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Integral,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.5,4.0,2.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend),29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,14.0,48%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Mutual Credit / LETS,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Doughnut Economics,29,6.0,0.5,2.0,2.5,2.0,2.5,9.5,33%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Universal Basic Services,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,13.0,45%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 4 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism,29,6.0,2.5,3.0,3.5,2.5,3.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy),29,6.0,3.0,1.0,3.5,1.5,2.5,11.5,40%,8,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism),29,6.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,2.0,2.5,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism),29,6.0,2.5,1.5,2.5,1.5,2.0,10.0,34%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 6 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." -Ostrom-Style Commons Governance,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,3.0,4.0,15.0,52%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Status Quo Market Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,1.5,3.5,13.0,45%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Nordic Social Democracy,29,6.0,3.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 15 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Centrally Planned Socialism,29,6.0,2.5,0.0,1.5,1.5,1.0,6.5,22%,17,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Market Socialism,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.5,3.5,2.5,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Libertarian Minarchism,29,6.0,1.0,2.5,2.0,1.5,2.5,9.5,33%,11,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +MMT + Job Guarantee,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,2.5,3.0,2.5,12.5,43%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Universal Basic Income,29,6.0,1.5,3.5,2.5,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 11 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Degrowth Economics,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,14.0,48%,1,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 15 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Stakeholder Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,2.0,2.0,11.5,40%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 8 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Fully Automated Luxury Communism,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,1.0,12.0,41%,7,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 13 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Participatory Economics,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,2.5,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 16 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP,29,6.0,3.5,3.5,4.0,3.0,2.5,16.5,57%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 19 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Integral,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.5,4.0,2.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend),29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,14.0,48%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Mutual Credit / LETS,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Doughnut Economics,29,6.0,0.5,2.0,2.5,2.0,2.5,9.5,33%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Universal Basic Services,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,13.0,45%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 4 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism,29,6.0,2.5,3.0,3.5,2.5,3.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy),29,6.0,3.0,1.0,3.5,1.5,2.5,11.5,40%,8,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism),29,6.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,2.0,2.5,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism),29,6.0,2.5,1.5,2.5,1.5,2.0,10.0,34%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 6 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." +Ostrom-Style Commons Governance,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,3.0,4.0,15.0,52%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions, the adjudication of the outside review and the owner's items applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79, 83 and 84; generators Sessions 78, 79, 83 and 84): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md, NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md and NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md." diff --git a/neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv b/neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0e2d7d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +system,criteria_count,domain1_max,domain1_material_security,domain2_human_autonomy,domain3_system_resilience,domain4_ethical_integrity,domain5_implementation_viability,total_score,total_percent,failures,adequacy_tier,revision_note,notes +Status Quo Market Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,1.5,3.5,13.0,45%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Nordic Social Democracy,29,6.0,3.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 15 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Centrally Planned Socialism,29,6.0,2.5,0.0,1.5,1.5,1.0,6.5,22%,17,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Market Socialism,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.5,3.5,2.5,15.5,53%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Libertarian Minarchism,29,6.0,1.0,2.5,2.0,1.5,2.5,9.5,33%,11,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +MMT + Job Guarantee,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,2.5,3.0,2.5,12.5,43%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 9 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Universal Basic Income,29,6.0,1.5,3.5,2.5,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 11 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Degrowth Economics,29,6.0,3.0,3.0,3.5,3.0,2.0,14.5,50%,1,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Stakeholder Capitalism,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,2.0,2.0,11.5,40%,6,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 8 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Fully Automated Luxury Communism,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,1.0,12.0,41%,7,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 13 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Participatory Economics,29,6.0,3.5,3.0,3.5,4.0,2.5,16.5,57%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH,29,6.0,3.5,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,17.5,60%,0,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 17 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Integral,29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.5,4.0,2.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 14 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend),29,6.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,14.0,48%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Mutual Credit / LETS,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Doughnut Economics,29,6.0,0.5,2.0,2.5,2.0,2.5,9.5,33%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Universal Basic Services,29,6.0,1.5,3.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,13.0,45%,4,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 4 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism,29,6.0,2.5,3.0,3.5,2.5,3.5,15.0,52%,2,Potentially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy),29,6.0,3.0,1.0,3.5,1.5,2.5,11.5,40%,8,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism),29,6.0,3.0,2.5,3.5,2.0,2.5,13.5,47%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 7 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism),29,6.0,2.5,1.5,2.5,1.5,2.0,10.0,34%,10,Structurally Inadequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 5 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.0,3.0,3.5,14.0,48%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 6 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." +Ostrom-Style Commons Governance,29,6.0,2.0,2.5,3.5,3.0,4.0,15.0,52%,3,Partially Adequate,"Rescoring pass, blind re-read, the owner's decisions and the adjudication of the outside review applied (Sessions 65, 71 to 77, 79 and 83; generators Sessions 78, 79 and 83): 2 of the 26 published scores changed; C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 scored for the first time","Provisional until Report and Paper v2.0; every unit's reading is in the rescoring records (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the blind records (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md and NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md." diff --git a/owner_s84.py b/owner_s84.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3fc3bfd --- /dev/null +++ b/owner_s84.py @@ -0,0 +1,83 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +""" +owner_s84.py -- NEEC: the owner's items applied and two consistency gaps closed (Session 84, ledger S68) +==================================================================================================== +Session 83's adjudication of the outside review put four readings to the owner (adjudicate_s83.OWNER) and found two gaps it +could not close within its scope. The owner answered in the ledger (2026-10-20): D66, return Degrowth's and Participatory +Economics' C3.4 to 0.5; D67, apply CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C2.2 and C5.3 at 0.5 (superseding D65's hold under decision 69.4). This +file holds the layer that applies them, over the adjudicated state (final_pass.settled_state(); apply_owner_s84.py writes the +v2 files from it). Record: NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md. + + OWNER the four owner items, each applied as the adjudication reads it (adjudicate_s83.OWNER's unit, unchanged); + decision 84.1 (D66) and 84.2 (D67). + REVISIONS CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C3.4: clauses 1 and 3 rested on "as audited (the unit's own text)", the footing rule 3 of + decision 83.4 rejected for Degrowth and Participatory Economics. Each is re-read on the design's own documents + (the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba, cached in outside_kit_sources/); the verdict holds (decision 84.3). Decision 79.3 + governs clause 4 only, which is carried. + UNITS Participatory Economics' C1.2b, read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (one reading per class; ledger I12 item 1): + decision 84.4. + +No main; nothing is printed. Deterministic. +""" + +TAG = "owner s84" +SESSION = 84 +RECORD = "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md" +DATE = "2026-10-21" +LABEL = "the owner's items and the consistency gaps of Session 84" + +HUB = "the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba" + +# the owner's answers (ledger, 2026-10-20): the adjudication's reading of each cell is applied unchanged +OWNER = { + ("DG", "C3.4"): dict(decision="84.1", ledger="D66"), + ("PE", "C3.4"): dict(decision="84.1", ledger="D66"), + ("CCO", "C2.2"): dict(decision="84.2", ledger="D67"), + ("CCO", "C5.3"): dict(decision="84.2", ledger="D67"), +} + +# CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH C3.4: the two clauses that rested on the unit's own text, each re-read on a cited source +REVISIONS = { + ("CCO", "C3.4"): dict(decision="84.3", clauses={ + 1: ("C", "cleared: the design's documents give adjustable ranges well beyond 30% for several parameters without " + "redesign: the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis cuts the maximum octaves from 8 to 4 (50%) and runs " + "participation from 5% to 35%, keeping inflation below 1.8% and 89% of the welfare gains; the integrated " + "framework sets the conversion multiplier at 1-9x against tested alternatives of 1-5x and 1-12x and a " + "regional adjustment factor of 0.8-1.2; and the scorer's adjustment run on the v5.6 engine moves the Basic " + "Unit by 30% either way (0.7 to 1.3) from year 10", + f"{HUB}: dual-currency-inflation.html, section 5.3; cco-ptf-integrated-framework.html, sections 3.1.2 and 5.4 " + f"(outside_kit_sources/cco_hub__dual-currency-inflation.txt, cco_hub__cco-ptf-integrated-framework.txt); " + f"NEEC_Rescoring_s57.md, reading 3.11"), + 3: ("C", "cleared: under the Citizens Internet Portal any citizen can submit a proposal (a signature threshold, a " + "30-90 day comment period, amendment), and a binding change passes by a 60-67% supermajority with " + "geographic distribution, so those affected can challenge a parameter change and have it reversed by a " + "process that does not run through the officials who made it; referenda move from advisory to binding in " + "the second phase (years 4-7); the PTH charter template adds notice, hearing and appeal rights on every " + "enforcement action", + f"{HUB}: citizens-internet-portal.html, sections 4.4 and 7.1; democratic-governance-pth.html, Appendix " + f"B.1 (charter template), Article VI, section 2 (outside_kit_sources/cco_hub__citizens-internet-portal.txt, " + f"cco_hub__democratic-governance-pth.txt)"), + }, note="Session 84 re-read clauses 1 and 3 on the design's own documents (decision 84.3): each had rested on the " + "unit's own text, which rule 3 of decision 83.4 does not accept; both clear, and the verdict holds"), +} + +ADJ = "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md, sections 3 and 9" +OR = "the outside review r1, the reader's reading (outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz)" + +UNITS = { + # rule 4 of decision 83.4: Degrowth, Integral and Mutual Credit's class W 1.0s fell for want of an estimate of the + # distribution or a structural argument that bounds all of it; Participatory Economics' sources distinguish it in + # strength, not on that point + ("PE", "C1.2b"): dict(kind="change", verdict=0.5, decision="84.4", clauses=[ + ("U", "not shown: the design removes private productive property, capital markets and income from ownership, and " + "rates incomes by effort and sacrifice, which bounds the top of the distribution more firmly than Degrowth's " + "caps or Integral's parallel network; but it states no bound on personal holdings, which unequal effort " + "ratings and saving across a lifetime leave unequal, and no source the unit cites, and none the outside " + "reader names (it projects the Gini from the design's mechanisms, closed book), estimates the wealth Gini; a " + "bound on the top does not bound a Gini, which the bottom of the distribution also sets", + f"Report v1.6, PE C1.2b; {ADJ}; {OR}")], + flag=[[1.0], "the published reading and the outside reader's: no private capital ownership is a structural " + "ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes"], + note="read in Session 84 by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (ledger I12 item 1): the class W 1.0 rested on the same " + "reading the adjudication found insufficient for Degrowth, Integral and Mutual Credit", zero=None), +} diff --git a/run_all_checks.py b/run_all_checks.py index 0e4a3f4..768f071 100644 --- a/run_all_checks.py +++ b/run_all_checks.py @@ -324,6 +324,13 @@ class M on v2.0's price basis, every 2019-dollar figure recomputed from the seri pre-registration and the kit name); final_pass.py --selftest also checks the adjudication's layer; build_evidence.py shows the outside review's verdict and the adjudication's outcome; build_evidence.py and build_site.py check the regenerated files: 145 checks. +Version 53 (Session 84) adds apply_owner_s84.py --check, which writes the v2 files with the owner's items (D66, D67) and two +consistency readings laid over the adjudicated state (owner_s84.py, by final_pass.settled_state()), with a negative control; +apply_adjudication_s83.py's files are kept as neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json and its two companions; weighting_s83.py runs +four states; final_pass.py --selftest also checks Session 84's layer; every displayed name in the corpus, the CSV, the +blocks, the evidence reports and the site passes through display_names.py (the entry shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP); +build_evidence.py and build_site.py check the regenerated files; build_report_v2.py --check (decision 52.8) checks the +generated parts of Report v2.0 Part I: 148 checks. HOW EACH CHECK RUNS. A check copies exactly the files its script needs into a fresh temporary directory (under the names the script expects), runs the @@ -1156,7 +1163,7 @@ def tree(*roots): "the corpus, the record, Paper v1.4, the A.4 weighting script, the WJP extract, the issue forms and " "site/ (decision 49.7)", cmd=["python", "build_site.py", "--check"], - files={**{k: k for k in ("build_site.py", "criteria.json", "neec_corpus_v2.json", "neec_scores_v2.csv", + files={**{k: k for k in ("build_site.py", "display_names.py", "criteria.json", "neec_corpus_v2.json", "neec_scores_v2.csv", "summary_blocks_v2.json", "NEEC_Criteria_v2_s45.md", "NEEC_Paper_v1_4.md", "wjp_rol_sf62_2012_2025.csv", "neec_weighting_robustness_analysis_v2.py")}, **tree("site", "docs", "evidence", os.path.join(".github", "ISSUE_TEMPLATE"))}, @@ -1748,7 +1755,8 @@ def tree(*roots): # Session 79: apply_final_s78.py's three files are kept as the Session 78 snapshots; final_pass.py loads owner_s79.py S78_SNAP = ("neec_corpus_v2_s78_snapshot.json", "neec_scores_v2_s78_snapshot.csv", "summary_blocks_v2_s78_snapshot.json") S78_FILES = {**S77_FILES, **{k: k for k in ("final_pass.py", "apply_final_s78.py", "build_evidence.py", "NEEC_FinalApplication_s78.md", - "site/config.json", "owner_s79.py", "adjudicate_s83.py") + S78_V2 + S78_SNAP}} + "site/config.json", "owner_s79.py", "adjudicate_s83.py", "owner_s84.py", + "display_names.py") + S78_V2 + S78_SNAP}} S78_CHECKS = [ dict(name="final_pass.py --selftest: the seven blind groups' FINAL dictionaries (221 units: 24, 23, 33, 31, 41, 51, 18) load, " "overlap nowhere, replace the pass's reading of the same cell (the 26 published criteria's merged units and the 69 " @@ -1854,36 +1862,74 @@ def tree(*roots): # build_site.py read them, and build_evidence.py also reads the run's reader and stage B results. S83_RUN = ("outside_review_r1/kit_units.jsonl", "outside_review_r1/results/reader.jsonl.gz", "outside_review_r1/results/stage_b.jsonl.gz") -S83_FILES = {**S79_FILES, **{k: k for k in ("apply_adjudication_s83.py", "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md") + S83_RUN}} +# Session 84: apply_adjudication_s83.py's three files are kept as the Session 83 snapshots (the v2 files carry Session 84's layer) +S83_SNAP = ("neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json", "neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv", "summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json") +S83_FILES = {**S79_FILES, **{k: k for k in ("apply_adjudication_s83.py", "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md") + S83_RUN + S83_SNAP}} S83_CHECKS = [ - dict(name="apply_adjudication_s83.py --check: the adjudication of the outside review applied: the v2 corpus, scores and " - "blocks and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the run's reader results against the Session " + dict(name="apply_adjudication_s83.py --check: the adjudication of the outside review applied: the corpus, scores and " + "blocks, kept from Session 84 as the Session 83 snapshots (neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json and its two " + "companions), and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the run's reader results against the Session " "79 corpus give 177 disagreements, each with its outcome (150 hold, 17 adopt, 1 third reading, 4 to the owner, 5 " "owner-decided cells that stand); the corpus differs from the Session 79 snapshot in exactly the 18 changed cells; " "no CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH or owner-decided cell changes; no tier changes; CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH first alone at 17.5, " "Participatory Economics 16.5", cmd=["python", "apply_adjudication_s83.py", "--check"], files=S83_FILES, stdout="apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt", stderr=EMPTY), - dict(name="weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes (equal; D1 x2; D5 x0.5; C1.4 and C4.2 x3) on the v2 corpus in three " - "states (Session 79, adjudicated, adjudicated with the four owner items), first place when each criterion is " - "dropped in turn, and when the leader's close calls all resolve down and the runner-up's up", - cmd=["python", "weighting_s83.py"], files={**S83_FILES, "weighting_s83.py": "weighting_s83.py"}, + dict(name="weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes (equal; D1 x2; D5 x0.5; C1.4 and C4.2 x3) on the v2 corpus in four " + "states (Session 79, adjudicated in Session 83, Session 84 with the owner's items, Session 84 on the readings " + "alone), first place when each criterion is dropped in turn, and when the leader's close calls all resolve " + "down and the runner-up's up", + cmd=["python", "weighting_s83.py"], files=None, stdout="weighting_s83_output.txt", stderr=EMPTY), ] -S83_CHECKS.insert(1, dict(S83_CHECKS[0], files={**S83_FILES, "neec_corpus_v2.json": "neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json"}, - name="apply_adjudication_s83.py --check rejects a neec_corpus_v2.json that is the Session 79 snapshot " +S83_CHECKS.insert(1, dict(S83_CHECKS[0], files={**S83_FILES, "neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json": "neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json"}, + name="apply_adjudication_s83.py --check rejects a Session 83 corpus that is the Session 79 snapshot " "(negative control; exit 1 expected)", stdout="apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt", expect_exit=1)) for _c in S68_CHECKS: # build_evidence.py --check shows the adjudication's layer and the outside review's verdicts _c["files"] = {**_c["files"], **{k: k for k in ("adjudicate_s83.py", "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md") + S83_RUN}} +# Session 84: the owner's items (D66, D67) and two consistency readings (owner_s84.py, ledger S68), laid over the adjudicated +# state by final_pass.settled_state() and written by apply_owner_s84.py into the v2 files, every displayed name through +# display_names.py (the entry shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, ledger S69, D68); build_evidence.py and build_site.py read them. +S84_FILES = {**S83_FILES, **{k: k for k in ("apply_owner_s84.py", "owner_s84.py", "display_names.py", + "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md")}} +S84_CHECKS = [ + dict(name="apply_owner_s84.py --check: the owner's items and two consistency readings applied: the v2 corpus, scores and " + "blocks and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the corpus differs from the Session 83 " + "snapshot in exactly five cells, each 1.0 to 0.5 (Degrowth Economics' and Participatory Economics' C3.4, D66; " + "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3, D67; Participatory Economics' C1.2b by rule 4); CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's " + "C3.4 holds at 1.0 with clauses 1 and 3 sourced; the entry is shown under its new name and keeps its key; no " + "tier changes; CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP first alone at 16.5; on the readings alone it stands at 14.5, below a first " + "place of 15.5", + cmd=["python", "apply_owner_s84.py", "--check"], files=S84_FILES, + stdout="apply_owner_s84_output.txt", stderr=EMPTY), +] +S84_CHECKS.append(dict(S84_CHECKS[0], files={**S84_FILES, "neec_corpus_v2.json": "neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json"}, + name="apply_owner_s84.py --check rejects a neec_corpus_v2.json that is the Session 83 snapshot " + "(negative control; exit 1 expected)", + stdout="apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt", expect_exit=1)) +S83_CHECKS[-1]["files"] = {**S84_FILES, "weighting_s83.py": "weighting_s83.py"} +S84_CHECKS.append( + dict(name="build_report_v2.py --check: the generated parts of Report v2.0 Part I (NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md: the standing, " + "the counts by domain, and per domain every criterion's scorecard of the 23 entries, from the units' readings " + "and the published rationales, decision 52.8) equal what the script generates; the prose between them is not " + "checked", + cmd=["python", "build_report_v2.py", "--check"], + files={**{k: v for k, v in S68_CHECKS[0]["files"].items()}, **S84_FILES, + **{k: k for k in ("build_report_v2.py", "NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md", "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md")}}, + stdout="build_report_v2_output.txt", stderr=EMPTY)) +for _c in S68_CHECKS: # build_evidence.py --check shows Session 84's layer and links its record + _c["files"] = {**_c["files"], **{k: k for k in ("NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md", "owner_s84.py")}} + CHECKS = (S33_CHECKS + [pin32(c) for c in V7_CHECKS] + S34_CHECKS + S35_CHECKS + [pin44(c) for c in S36_CHECKS + S37_CHECKS + S38_CHECKS + S39_CHECKS + S40_CHECKS + S41_CHECKS + S42_CHECKS + S43_CHECKS + S44_CHECKS] + S45_CHECKS + S47_CHECKS + S48_CHECKS + S49_CHECKS + S50_CHECKS + S51_CHECKS + S52_CHECKS + S53_CHECKS + S54_CHECKS + S56_CHECKS + S57_CHECKS + S58_CHECKS + S60_CHECKS + S61_CHECKS + S63_CHECKS + S64_CHECKS + S65_CHECKS + S68_CHECKS + S69_CHECKS + S70_CHECKS + S71_CHECKS + S72_CHECKS + S73_CHECKS + S74_CHECKS - + S75_CHECKS + S76_CHECKS + S77_CHECKS + S78_CHECKS + S79_CHECKS + S80_CHECKS + S82_CHECKS + S83_CHECKS) + + S75_CHECKS + S76_CHECKS + S77_CHECKS + S78_CHECKS + S79_CHECKS + S80_CHECKS + S82_CHECKS + S83_CHECKS + + S84_CHECKS) def md5(data): diff --git a/run_all_checks_output.txt b/run_all_checks_output.txt index 4d7b0c1..7b4c369 100644 --- a/run_all_checks_output.txt +++ b/run_all_checks_output.txt @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ ============================================================================================ -run_all_checks.py -- 145 reproducibility checks +run_all_checks.py -- 148 reproducibility checks ============================================================================================ [ 1] PASS insert_session33.py writes both canonical scripts from their Session 32 snapshots (decision D26) @@ -273,7 +273,7 @@ run_all_checks.py -- 145 reproducibility checks stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [74] PASS build_readme.py regenerates README.md from neec_scores.csv and this harness (the landing page cannot drift from the data) - README.md == README.md (md5 d8dd9bc4) + README.md == README.md (md5 a924088c) [75] PASS r4_audit_s35.py (revision R4: every corpus 1.0 on a multi-clause Pass Threshold, audited clause by clause; decision D28 and its bound; the record's tables; changes no file) [Session 35 state] stdout == r4_audit_s35_output.txt (md5 d110a899) @@ -436,12 +436,12 @@ run_all_checks.py -- 145 reproducibility checks stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [113] PASS build_evidence.py --check: the 23 per-system evidence reports and their index (evidence/) equal what the script generates from the rescoring pass, the v2 corpus, scores and blocks and the scoring documents: 667 criterion sections (the pass's units with their clause readings and sources, the held cells with their published rationale), each score and each unit's verdict equal to the corpus, each total equal to the blocks', every link to a data file in evidence_cache/ or to a document by line pointing at a file that exists; no score changed - stdout == build_evidence_output.txt (md5 5335b0ee) + stdout == build_evidence_output.txt (md5 b2a76c16) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [114] PASS build_evidence.py --check rejects an evidence/ whose Status Quo report is replaced by another system's (negative control; exit 1 expected) exit status 1, as expected - stdout == build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt (md5 8574c55e) + stdout == build_evidence_check_negative_output.txt (md5 619bac45) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [115] PASS blind_review.py --selftest: compare_unit agrees only when every clause status and the verdict match; blind_view exposes no verdict, status, estimate or source for a real unit of each Sonnet-read part ((2.9) C3.1, (2.10) C4.2, (2.11) C1.1) @@ -509,7 +509,7 @@ run_all_checks.py -- 145 reproducibility checks stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [131] PASS final_pass.py --selftest: the seven blind groups' FINAL dictionaries (221 units: 24, 23, 33, 31, 41, 51, 18) load, overlap nowhere, replace the pass's reading of the same cell (the 26 published criteria's merged units and the 69 class N units), and each has one status per v2.0 clause and follows D28; the owner's layer of Session 79 (owner_s79.py) revises seven final units, one clause each, 0.5 to 1.0 by D28, each keeping its prior reading as its flag - stdout == final_pass_selftest_output.txt (md5 deee6f4e) + stdout == final_pass_selftest_output.txt (md5 0c8baa97) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) [132] PASS apply_final_s78.py --check: stage 3b, the generator that applies the blind re-read: the 23 entries on the 29 criteria, their totals, failures and tiers and the site's blocks, kept from Session 79 as the Session 78 snapshots (neec_corpus_v2_s78_snapshot.json and its two companions), and the record (NEEC_FinalApplication_s78.md) equal what it produces; the corpus carries each unit's final verdict and differs from the Session 65 snapshot in exactly the 28 cells the groups changed (5, 2, 8, 3, 6, 0 and 4 by group); the tier changes are Universal Basic Income's and Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism's; Participatory Economics is first alone at 16.5; CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's vector is unchanged @@ -560,20 +560,33 @@ run_all_checks.py -- 145 reproducibility checks stdout == compare_outside_negative_output.txt (md5 faabfc61) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) -[143] PASS apply_adjudication_s83.py --check: the adjudication of the outside review applied: the v2 corpus, scores and blocks and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the run's reader results against the Session 79 corpus give 177 disagreements, each with its outcome (150 hold, 17 adopt, 1 third reading, 4 to the owner, 5 owner-decided cells that stand); the corpus differs from the Session 79 snapshot in exactly the 18 changed cells; no CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH or owner-decided cell changes; no tier changes; CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH first alone at 17.5, Participatory Economics 16.5 - stdout == apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt (md5 2fd188e8) +[143] PASS apply_adjudication_s83.py --check: the adjudication of the outside review applied: the corpus, scores and blocks, kept from Session 84 as the Session 83 snapshots (neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json and its two companions), and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the run's reader results against the Session 79 corpus give 177 disagreements, each with its outcome (150 hold, 17 adopt, 1 third reading, 4 to the owner, 5 owner-decided cells that stand); the corpus differs from the Session 79 snapshot in exactly the 18 changed cells; no CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH or owner-decided cell changes; no tier changes; CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH first alone at 17.5, Participatory Economics 16.5 + stdout == apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt (md5 92bd372c) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) -[144] PASS apply_adjudication_s83.py --check rejects a neec_corpus_v2.json that is the Session 79 snapshot (negative control; exit 1 expected) +[144] PASS apply_adjudication_s83.py --check rejects a Session 83 corpus that is the Session 79 snapshot (negative control; exit 1 expected) exit status 1, as expected - stdout == apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt (md5 0a6de017) + stdout == apply_adjudication_s83_check_negative_output.txt (md5 e29d64f3) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) -[145] PASS weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes (equal; D1 x2; D5 x0.5; C1.4 and C4.2 x3) on the v2 corpus in three states (Session 79, adjudicated, adjudicated with the four owner items), first place when each criterion is dropped in turn, and when the leader's close calls all resolve down and the runner-up's up - stdout == weighting_s83_output.txt (md5 104155d4) +[145] PASS weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes (equal; D1 x2; D5 x0.5; C1.4 and C4.2 x3) on the v2 corpus in four states (Session 79, adjudicated in Session 83, Session 84 with the owner's items, Session 84 on the readings alone), first place when each criterion is dropped in turn, and when the leader's close calls all resolve down and the runner-up's up + stdout == weighting_s83_output.txt (md5 8bf1f7de) + stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) + +[146] PASS apply_owner_s84.py --check: the owner's items and two consistency readings applied: the v2 corpus, scores and blocks and the record's generated tables equal what it produces; the corpus differs from the Session 83 snapshot in exactly five cells, each 1.0 to 0.5 (Degrowth Economics' and Participatory Economics' C3.4, D66; CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3, D67; Participatory Economics' C1.2b by rule 4); CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4 holds at 1.0 with clauses 1 and 3 sourced; the entry is shown under its new name and keeps its key; no tier changes; CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP first alone at 16.5; on the readings alone it stands at 14.5, below a first place of 15.5 + stdout == apply_owner_s84_output.txt (md5 2be4e5be) + stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) + +[147] PASS apply_owner_s84.py --check rejects a neec_corpus_v2.json that is the Session 83 snapshot (negative control; exit 1 expected) + exit status 1, as expected + stdout == apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt (md5 04339a53) + stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) + +[148] PASS build_report_v2.py --check: the generated parts of Report v2.0 Part I (NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md: the standing, the counts by domain, and per domain every criterion's scorecard of the 23 entries, from the units' readings and the published rationales, decision 52.8) equal what the script generates; the prose between them is not checked + stdout == build_report_v2_output.txt (md5 ad376dc4) stderr == (empty) (md5 d41d8cd9) ============================================================================================ -SUMMARY: 145 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped (of 145). +SUMMARY: 148 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped (of 148). Not covered here: the realjs scripts' fidelity to index.html (the Compassionism Simulation source, which is not in this directory), and the Report and Paper prose. diff --git a/site/config.json b/site/config.json index 16b9f4f..1ff3319 100644 --- a/site/config.json +++ b/site/config.json @@ -135,8 +135,7 @@ "short": "Participatory Economics" }, "CCO": { - "short": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", - "note": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH combines four components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, CIP is Citizens Internet Portal, and SZH is Social Zone Harmonization. Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism." + "note": "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP combines five components: CCO is Creative Currency Octaves, PTF is Public Trust Foundations, PTH is Public Trust Housing, SZH is Social Zone Harmonization, and CIP is Citizens Internet Portal. NEEC's records before Session 84 call it by its earlier name (formerly CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH); PTH was always read in its units, and the name now lists it (the owner's decision D68). Also referred to in the literature as Compassionism." }, "INT": { "short": "Integral", diff --git a/summary_blocks_v2.json b/summary_blocks_v2.json index 6c01107..ebc6591 100644 --- a/summary_blocks_v2.json +++ b/summary_blocks_v2.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -305,7 +305,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -505,7 +505,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -849,7 +849,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -858,7 +858,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -1021,7 +1021,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -1030,7 +1030,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -1269,7 +1269,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -1437,7 +1437,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -1637,7 +1637,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -1646,7 +1646,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -1665,7 +1665,7 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, @@ -1683,10 +1683,10 @@ "summary": { "D1": 3.0, "D2": 3.0, - "D3": 3.5, + "D3": 3.0, "D4": 3.0, "D5": 2.0, - "total": 14.5, + "total": 14.0, "failures": 1, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" }, @@ -1736,21 +1736,6 @@ "phrase": "Flag" } }, - { - "criterion": "C3.4", - "scored": 1.0, - "alternatives": [ - 0.5 - ], - "basis": "stated", - "reading": "part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation located in its sources, so clause 4 is not shown", - "tracks": null, - "source": { - "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", - "locator": "DG C3.4", - "phrase": "Flag" - } - }, { "criterion": "C3.6", "scored": 0.5, @@ -1804,7 +1789,7 @@ "basis": "scored", "resolve": {}, "result": { - "total": 14.5, + "total": 14.0, "failures": 1, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -1820,7 +1805,7 @@ "C5.4": 0.5 }, "result": { - "total": 16.5, + "total": 16.0, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -1831,7 +1816,6 @@ "basis": "extremes", "resolve": { "C2.5": 0.0, - "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.0 }, "result": { @@ -1853,7 +1837,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -1862,7 +1846,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -2101,7 +2085,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -2110,7 +2094,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -2333,7 +2317,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -2342,13 +2326,13 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { "C1.1": 0.5, "C1.2a": 0.5, - "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, "C1.3": 0.5, "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, @@ -2361,7 +2345,7 @@ "C3.1": 0.5, "C3.2": 0.5, "C3.3": 0.5, - "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, "C3.5": 0.5, "C3.6": 0.5, "C4.1": 0.5, @@ -2377,16 +2361,31 @@ "C5.5": 0.5 }, "summary": { - "D1": 3.5, + "D1": 3.0, "D2": 3.0, - "D3": 3.5, + "D3": 3.0, "D4": 4.0, "D5": 2.5, - "total": 16.5, + "total": 15.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" }, "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading and the outside reader's: no private capital ownership is a structural ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md", + "locator": "PE C1.2b", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, { "criterion": "C2.5", "scored": 0.5, @@ -2432,21 +2431,6 @@ "phrase": "Flag" } }, - { - "criterion": "C3.4", - "scored": 1.0, - "alternatives": [ - 0.5 - ], - "basis": "stated", - "reading": "part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation, so clause 4 is not shown", - "tracks": null, - "source": { - "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", - "locator": "PE C3.4", - "phrase": "Flag" - } - }, { "criterion": "C4.5", "scored": 1.0, @@ -2470,7 +2454,7 @@ "basis": "scored", "resolve": {}, "result": { - "total": 16.5, + "total": 15.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -2480,10 +2464,11 @@ "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", "basis": "extremes", "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 1.0, "C3.3": 1.0 }, "result": { - "total": 17.0, + "total": 16.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -2495,11 +2480,10 @@ "resolve": { "C2.5": 0.0, "C2.6": 0.0, - "C3.4": 0.5, "C4.5": 0.5 }, "result": { - "total": 14.5, + "total": 14.0, "failures": 2, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -2511,13 +2495,13 @@ "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", "key": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", "code": "CCO", - "display_name": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "display_name": "CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP", "record": { "documents": [ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -2526,7 +2510,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -2537,7 +2521,7 @@ "C1.4": 0.5, "C1.5": 0.5, "C2.1": 0.5, - "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.2": 0.5, "C2.3": 0.5, "C2.4": 0.5, "C2.5": 1.0, @@ -2556,17 +2540,17 @@ "C4.6": 0.5, "C5.1": 0.5, "C5.2": 0.5, - "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.3": 0.5, "C5.4": 0.5, "C5.5": 0.5 }, "summary": { "D1": 3.5, - "D2": 4.0, + "D2": 3.5, "D3": 4.0, "D4": 3.0, - "D5": 3.0, - "total": 17.5, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 16.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" }, @@ -2586,6 +2570,21 @@ "phrase": "Flag" } }, + { + "criterion": "C2.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: the basic amount covers essential needs unconditionally", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md", + "locator": "CCO C2.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, { "criterion": "C2.5", "scored": 1.0, @@ -2626,7 +2625,7 @@ "reading": "group 2.5's reading (reading 3.11): on the test fixed before the run, a 20-30% cut in the allowance raises the share below the cost of living by 10 points or more in 339 and 43 of 500 seeds", "tracks": null, "source": { - "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "file": "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md", "locator": "CCO C3.4", "phrase": "Flag" } @@ -2645,6 +2644,21 @@ "locator": "CCO C5.2", "phrase": "Flag" } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the integrated framework's reading: viability at 30% participation", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md", + "locator": "CCO C5.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } } ], "joint_readings": [ @@ -2654,7 +2668,7 @@ "basis": "scored", "resolve": {}, "result": { - "total": 17.5, + "total": 16.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -2664,7 +2678,9 @@ "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", "basis": "extremes", "resolve": { - "C5.2": 1.0 + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.3": 1.0 }, "result": { "total": 18.0, @@ -2683,7 +2699,7 @@ "C3.4": 0.5 }, "result": { - "total": 15.5, + "total": 14.5, "failures": 0, "tier": "Potentially Adequate" } @@ -2702,7 +2718,7 @@ "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -2711,7 +2727,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -2951,7 +2967,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_Georgism_LVT_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -3058,7 +3074,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_MutualCredit_LETS_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -3241,7 +3257,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_DoughnutEconomics_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -3250,7 +3266,7 @@ "source": { "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", "locator": "3.1", - "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Integral, Doughnut Economics." } }, "vector": { @@ -3440,7 +3456,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_UniversalBasicServices_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -3607,7 +3623,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_SovereignWealthFundStatism_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -3838,7 +3854,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_StateCapitalism_China_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -4131,7 +4147,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Singapore_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -4425,7 +4441,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -4816,7 +4832,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_IslamicFinance_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { @@ -5108,7 +5124,7 @@ "documents": [ "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md" ], - "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md), the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md) and the owner's items of Session 84 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md), applied by apply_owner_s84.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" }, "scope": { diff --git a/summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json b/summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6c01107 --- /dev/null +++ b/summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json @@ -0,0 +1,5360 @@ +[ + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Status Quo Market Capitalism", + "code": "SQ", + "display_name": "Status Quo Market Capitalism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Configured national economy: Status Quo Market Capitalism, Nordic Social Democracy, Centrally Planned Socialism." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 1.5, + "D5": 3.5, + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: transfer programmes are a real mechanism (they cut the rate in 2021), but the headcount did not fall", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "SQ C1.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published rationale's bottom-half figure (~$3,200, from the Paper's calibration of 2019) is replaced by the 2025 survey's distribution, which v2.0's measure names; the verdict is unchanged", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SQ C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SQ C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: automatic insurance and a fast legislated response, not automatic, coverage below 90%", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "SQ C3.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: optimised for normal conditions, with 2008 and 2020 requiring extraordinary policy action", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SQ C3.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: productivity and TFP rising over 2003-2023; output well above the basket at actual hours", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "SQ C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: debt is far above the bar; the positive transfer is small but positive in every year of the window", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "SQ C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: far below on all four, no national absolute-reduction mechanism", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SQ C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "a correction (reading 3.3): the published 0.5 rests on 'some progress over decades', which the measure does not show; it resolves the inconsistency logged since Handoff 30, the 0.0 band's example published at 0.5", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SQ C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: political removal functions; economic decisions answer to owners for two thirds of employment", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SQ C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "SQ C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "outcomes matched component by component against narrow claimed functions (price stability, growth) rather than the system's broad claims", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SQ C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 16.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.3": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 10.0, + "failures": 11, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Nordic Social Democracy", + "code": "NSD", + "display_name": "Nordic Social Democracy", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Configured national economy: Status Quo Market Capitalism, Nordic Social Democracy, Centrally Planned Socialism." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 1.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 1.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.5, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.0, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.0, + "total": 15.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 1.0 read in the D28 form: the clause is short on the one Nordic register that publishes the distribution, so the unit falls to 0.5; Sweden publishes no household wealth statistics, and no Nordic source located shows 70% of househo", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "NSD C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: free exit and portable benefits, with activation conditions on assistance; residents cannot opt out of the tax base short of emigrating", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "NSD C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: one of the four economies is above the bar at the stated date and projected to rise", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "NSD C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: mortality falling, regulation clean, strict liability in force; no claim record named", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "NSD C4.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "outcomes matched against the configuration's signature claims, low poverty and universal services, with the housing and initiative shortfalls read as outcomes on NEEC's thresholds rather than on the benefits the model claims", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "NSD C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as requiring a record for every institution the entry names as defining, strong labor unions and progressive taxation as well as the social programmes, clause 3 is not shown on the evidence located; the interpretation check read the re", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "NSD C5.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 15.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C4.1": 1.0, + "C4.6": 1.0, + "C5.1": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 17.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Centrally Planned Socialism", + "code": "CPS", + "display_name": "Centrally Planned Socialism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Configured national economy: Status Quo Market Capitalism, Nordic Social Democracy, Centrally Planned Socialism." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 1.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.0, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.0, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.0, + "C5.3": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.5, + "D2": 0.0, + "D3": 1.5, + "D4": 1.5, + "D5": 1.0, + "total": 6.5, + "failures": 17, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the formal wealth Gini, with no private capital markets", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "The case for 1.0." + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.3", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 1.0 band's anchor example; it holds", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CPS C1.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.3", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: creative activity organised and censored by the state", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CPS C2.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: exit, non-participation and relocation all criminalised or administratively barred", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CPS C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.6", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the rating's two lowest bands, consent and compulsion outside law and court", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "CPS C2.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a system-wide capacity to mobilise by decision without delay (1941), with relief to households delayed or denied in the famines; a mixed record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "CPS C3.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "CPS C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: failures such as shortages were visible, and correction came through reform", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "CPS C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: output per worker rising, TFP declining on growth accounting; held from 0.0 by D28(f)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "CPS C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: positive net accumulation, a debt below the bar in level but on a path through it", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "CPS C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: far below on the clauses read, the plan's own logic expanding throughput", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "CPS C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "state appropriation read as structural, load-bearing extraction, the 0.0 band's own test (part (a))", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md", + "locator": "CPS C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.6", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the polluter and the regulator one state, with no agency until 1988", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "CPS C4.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 0.0 band's anchor example; it holds", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CPS C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "a failure replicated across independent implementations is evidence about the system's own logic (D29(a)), read as far below with no pathway", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "CPS C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 6.5, + "failures": 17, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C4.1": 1.0, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 9, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 4.0, + "failures": 21, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Market Socialism", + "code": "MS", + "display_name": "Market Socialism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.0, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 3.5, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 15.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: free exit from firms within a socialised economy that bars large private capital", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "MS C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: no source dates a policy update within six months of the evidence", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "MS C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a structural damper on the growth imperative, no limit stated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "MS C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: the design's family includes variants (Lange and Lerner's state firms, Roemer's coupon boards) that place firm control elsewhere (protocol 4.2)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "MS C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: successful only in specific cultural contexts", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "MS C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 15.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Libertarian Minarchism", + "code": "LM", + "display_name": "Libertarian Minarchism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 1.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 2.0, + "D4": 1.5, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 9.5, + "failures": 11, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "a correction (reading 3.6): a reach shortfall is a 0.5 under protocol 2.1, as for Status Quo, Stakeholder Capitalism and China; one failure fewer, no tier change", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "LM C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: without public education and a safety net, effective access narrows to those born with capital (the 0.0 band)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "LM C1.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: no system-imposed exit cost, no compulsory participation, free movement", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "LM C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: the strongest stated guarantees of the 17, with clause 1 at the bar; consent and the limits of compulsion stated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md", + "locator": "LM C2.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: clause 3 is cleared, so 2.1's 0.0 cannot hold with it (decision 53.2)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "LM C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 0.0 (the 0.0 band's anchor) read under protocol 2.1: firm failures visible to owners and diffuse costs externalized is the 0.5 band's description, which Market Socialism's unit holds; a correction, as decision 53.3 raised the desi", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "LM C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a stated no-debt rule; the saving clause is not projected", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "LM C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: public limits rejected; the tort remedy cannot reach the criterion's quantities", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "LM C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "parts (a) and (b8)'s reading: both clauses not shown, held at 0.5 under D28(f)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "LM C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 9.5, + "failures": 11, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.6": 1.0, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 11.0, + "failures": 9, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C4.1": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 6.5, + "failures": 16, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "MMT + Job Guarantee", + "code": "MMT", + "display_name": "MMT + Job Guarantee", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Mechanism: MMT + Job Guarantee, Universal Basic Income, Universal Basic Services." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 12.5, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "a correction (reading 3.6): income without an accumulation vehicle is the 0.0 band, as for Universal Basic Income and Georgism's dividend; one failure more, no tier change", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "MMT C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "C4.4's reduction of capital power read as sufficient", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "override this call to 0.5" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a voluntary, universal and portable job offer; whether declining it costs income support is disputed within the mechanism's own literature", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "MMT C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: clause 1 rejected by the framework's logic, clause 2 not addressed; 4.1.3 asks both for 0.0", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "MMT C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 12.5, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C4.1": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 12.0, + "failures": 5, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Universal Basic Income", + "code": "UBI", + "display_name": "Universal Basic Income", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Mechanism: MMT + Job Guarantee, Universal Basic Income, Universal Basic Services." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 1.5, + "D2": 3.5, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.5, + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C2.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 1.0 band's reading: provision explicitly unconditional", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "UBI C2.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: the paradigm exit-enabling mechanism: no participation, no condition, portable", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "UBI C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a transfer mechanism that governs neither quantity (D28(c))", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "UBI C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the documented outcomes are of a dividend of about $1,000-2,000 a year; no component precedent operates at the living-wage level at which the entry claims its benefits", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "UBI C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.3", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "Iran's transfer compensates for removed price subsidies rather than paying an income as of right (Tabatabai), and no adequate basic income has been scaled", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "UBI C5.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: acceptance of income without work is a cultural precondition the mechanism cannot itself produce", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "UBI C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.2": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 11.0, + "failures": 7, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Degrowth Economics", + "code": "DG", + "display_name": "Degrowth Economics", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.0, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 2.0, + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: decentralisation, wealth caps and cooperative ownership as a named structural ceiling of the kind the 1.0 band describes", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "DG C1.2b", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: no exit terms stated; its caps are laws binding all, not a participation one could leave", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "DG C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 1.0 band's reading: explicit design for compound shocks through decentralisation and redundancy", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "DG C3.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation located in its sources, so clause 4 is not shown", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "DG C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: no investment mechanism stated; shorter hours without a provisioning account", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md", + "locator": "DG C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as the entry's C2.1 rationale reads its universal basic services, as eliminating survival coercion, exit from employment would be genuine; the services it names cover housing, healthcare, education and transport, not food or income, an", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md", + "locator": "DG C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: strong appeal to part of the spectrum against resistance from another (the 0.5 band)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "DG C5.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C3.3": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 16.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Stakeholder Capitalism", + "code": "SC", + "display_name": "Stakeholder Capitalism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 3.0, + "D4": 2.0, + "D5": 2.0, + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SC C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 0.0 (the 0.0 band's second anchor); with clauses 3 and 4 cleared on the host economy the reform keeps, 2.1's 0.0 conditions do not hold for the criterion as a whole, and the unit rises to 0.5, as Status Quo's holds (reading 3.4)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SC C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: the host's readings, which the reform does not change", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "SC C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: voluntary, relative metrics on the host's record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SC C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds: a group-directed mechanism of partial reach (reading 3.2); flagged now", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SC C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: the host's political removal; boards still answer to owners", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SC C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "SC C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: it satisfies neither capital nor labour, a political homelessness", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SC C5.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: stakeholder governance operates in several economies", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SC C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C4.1": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 9.0, + "failures": 11, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Fully Automated Luxury Communism", + "code": "FALC", + "display_name": "Fully Automated Luxury Communism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.0, + "C5.3": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 3.5, + "D5": 1.0, + "total": 12.0, + "failures": 7, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: the unresolved control of the machines read as no structural prevention", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "FALC C1.2b", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: universal provision and public ownership; no exit terms stated (reading 2.5.4)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "FALC C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a universal service floor that holds in a downturn, without a crisis rule", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "FALC C3.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "FALC C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: abundance projected from automation; allocation of what stays scarce unstated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md", + "locator": "FALC C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: electoral removal kept; the ownership programme is not quantified", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "FALC C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 0.0 band's reading: the distinctive components are a novel projection", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "FALC C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: the literature sketches a political route (municipal ownership, public banks, universal basic services), the 0.5 band's pathway sketched but unspecific", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "FALC C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 12.0, + "failures": 7, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 5, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C5.1": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 9.0, + "failures": 13, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Participatory Economics", + "code": "PE", + "display_name": "Participatory Economics", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.5, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 4.0, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 16.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: membership of councils is the economy; no alternative arrangement exists within it", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "PE C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: self-management with internal grievance procedures; no guarantees stated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md", + "locator": "PE C2.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 1.0 band's reading: explicit design for compound shocks through decentralisation", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "PE C3.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "part (b1)'s reading (reading 3.1): no implementation record, and no modelling of adjustments to the design's parameters in operation, so clause 4 is not shown", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "PE C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "PE C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 16.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C3.3": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 17.0, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "code": "CCO", + "display_name": "CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.5, + "D2": 4.0, + "D3": 4.0, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.0, + "total": 17.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "group 2.5's reading (decision 57.3): the clause holds only if new output backs what the Source pays, a condition the design's sources do not state; the release row shows 13.9%", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "CCO C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the blind re-read's reading (Session 75, reading 2.5.1): Acre Equity is accessible at exit only in part in the early years, so an early leaver forfeits most of it, a material penalty", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "CCO C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.2", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the owner's decision 58.1 restores the published 1.0 and supersedes group 2.5's unit (decision 57.7, S57-3.9); it reopens toward 0.5 on an empirical study showing that the backing by creative output does not hold in real-world data", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CCO C3.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "group 2.5's reading (reading 3.11): on the test fixed before the run, a 20-30% cut in the allowance raises the share below the cost of living by 10 points or more in 339 and 43 of 500 seeds", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "CCO C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as part (a) read the Session 44 clause, on the plans' specificity, with the precedents the entry cites for their timing (the New Deal, the Marshall Plan) and the modelling paper's success probabilities as evidence of feasibility, every", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CCO C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 17.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C5.2": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 18.0, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 15.5, + "failures": 0, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Integral", + "code": "INT", + "display_name": "Integral", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Paper_v1_4.md", + "NEEC_Report_v1_6.md", + "NEEC_Step1c_Retrofit_C1_2ab_C1_5.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 1.0, + "C4.5": 1.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 4.0, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: no stock of wealth exists anywhere in the network for any participant to convert into leverage over others", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "INT C1.2b", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0, + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "essentials unconditional (1.0) or contribution-dependent (0.0)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Paper_v1_4.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Contribution-Dependent (would score 0.0)" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: voluntary, federated and portable; the treatment of non-participants after displacement is unstated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "INT C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: data limits and a non-punitive rule; disputes stay with the node that assessed", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s76.md", + "locator": "INT C2.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: no internal prices and a one-way boundary keep internal inflation at zero, as clause 1 is read", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "INT C3.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 1.0 band's reading: redundancy at every layer, so that node failures do not cascade", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "INT C3.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the blind re-read's reading (Session 71, reading 3.4.4): no implementation record of a parameter adjustment and no modelling of the design's own adjustments in operation, so clause 4 is not shown", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "INT C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as requiring that a participant able to contribute who declines all contribution keep access to basic needs, the design does not show the clause: basic needs are accessible below standard contribution thresholds, which the design's sou", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md", + "locator": "INT C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "re-read on the design's own white paper (v0.1, December 2025), as parts (b5) and (b8) read the design's own pages; the published 0.0's reason, that the source provides no phased pathway, no longer describes the design, and a clause is clear", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "INT C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C2.2": 1.0, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C3.3": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 17.5, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 12.5, + "failures": 5, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Georgism / Land Value Tax", + "code": "GEO", + "display_name": "Georgism / Land Value Tax (LVT + Citizen's Dividend)", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Georgism_LVT_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "stated", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Commons governance joins archetype 1, narrow single-mechanism systems, as its fifth member after Georgism, Mutual Credit / LETS, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic finance." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.0, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.0, + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "GEO C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C4.3": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Mutual Credit / LETS", + "code": "MC", + "display_name": "Mutual Credit / LETS", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_MutualCredit_LETS_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "stated", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Commons governance joins archetype 1, narrow single-mechanism systems, as its fifth member after Georgism, Mutual Credit / LETS, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic finance." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 1.5, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.0, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.0, + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C2.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: a capped, repayable credit line is no baseline independent of work", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "MC C2.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "MC C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "WIR's documented record, nine decades of operation and countercyclical credit, taken as the proof of the mechanism's core component, with the LETS and barter-network outcomes read as weaker implementations", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "MC C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the mechanism has operated for decades in its networks (WIR since 1934), so the unit is not 0.0 (reading 3.2(f)); the register's flag toward 0.0 is kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "MC C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as requiring a documented range of at least 40% in a named parameter, the entry gives no figure, and clause 3 is not shown (reading 3.6)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "MC C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C5.1": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C5.2": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Doughnut Economics", + "code": "DE", + "display_name": "Doughnut Economics", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_DoughnutEconomics_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "comprehensive_system", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Comprehensive system: Market Socialism, Libertarian Minarchism, Degrowth Economics, Stakeholder Capitalism, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, Participatory Economics, CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH, Integral, Doughnut Economics." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 0.5, + "D2": 2.0, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 2.0, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 9.5, + "failures": 10, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.1", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: a target without an adopted mechanism", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "DE C1.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the 'harness the commons' language weighted more heavily", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_DoughnutEconomics_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "C1.2b", + "phrase": "could land at 0.5 instead" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "held at 0.5 on the published reading, which credits the diagnostic process and its one policy output; the reading that gave the framework's C1.2a 0.0 (no vehicle of its own) would give 0.0 here, and is flagged", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "DE C1.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.1", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: no stabilisation instrument adopted", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "DE C3.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the blind reading's own clause estimates found no mechanism adopted, which 2.1's first condition scores 0.0", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "DE C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the blind reading's own text found no mechanism, which reading 4.5.3 requires for 0.5", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "DE C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 9.5, + "failures": 10, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 12.0, + "failures": 5, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.3": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 9.0, + "failures": 11, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Universal Basic Services", + "code": "UBS", + "display_name": "Universal Basic Services", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_UniversalBasicServices_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "assigned", + "source": { + "file": "SCORING_PROTOCOL.md", + "locator": "3.1", + "phrase": "Mechanism: MMT + Job Guarantee, Universal Basic Income, Universal Basic Services." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 1.5, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.0, + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the housing plank's pressure on land and rental values", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_UniversalBasicServices_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "C1.2b", + "phrase": "could defensibly land at 0.5 instead" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: universal in-kind provision; portability of locally allocated housing is unstated", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "UBS C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 0.5 on the host economy's scrutiny; a correction (reading 3.5)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "UBS C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.3", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "coordination protocols shown for one sector, childcare, and none for the seven-sector package", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "UBS C5.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C2.5": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C5.3": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 12.5, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism", + "code": "SWF", + "display_name": "Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_SovereignWealthFundStatism_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "stated", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Commons governance joins archetype 1, narrow single-mechanism systems, as its fifth member after Georgism, Mutual Credit / LETS, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic finance." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.5, + "D2": 3.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 2.5, + "D5": 3.5, + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "follows C1.2a", + "tracks": "C1.2a", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_SovereignWealthFundStatism_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "C1.5", + "phrase": "if C1.2a resolves to 0.0, this criterion follows to 0.0" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "evidence dated from the market evidence of lower expected returns rather than from the formal assessment, which makes the expected-return revision slow", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SWF C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: an investment mechanism that governs none of the four quantities (D28(c))", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SWF C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag's 0.0 side kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SWF C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the blind reading's own clause estimates found every relationship unmodified, which reading 4.5.3 scores 0.0", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "SWF C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "Timor-Leste weighed as a single implementation's shortfall (D29(a)), with Norway's and Alaska's funds preserved as the mechanism claims", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SWF C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "every clause is shown by deployments of the mechanism itself, which the published 0.5, judged on the absence of a phase-by-phase plan, did not credit; under v2.0's scope a precedent, not a plan, is the test (part (b9), reading 3.2)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SWF C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading, and the published flag: the mechanism has survived every change of administration, in Alaska since 1982 and in Norway since 1990", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SWF C5.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 2, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.4": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 16.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C5.2": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 12.5, + "failures": 5, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "State Capitalism / China", + "code": "CN", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / China (Party-State-Directed Market Economy)", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_StateCapitalism_China_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "stated", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Qatar is the third instance of the fourth Step 1b archetype, \"configured national political economy\" (confirmed in Session 20), after China and Singapore." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.0, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.0, + "D2": 1.0, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 1.5, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 8, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C2.1", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: market coercion kept and state coercion added, including state-directed labour transfers", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CN C2.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a large creative economy under state censorship of content", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CN C2.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: a single-party state with consultative channels and no competitive national election", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CN C2.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: emigration open to most; internal mobility constrained by registration, under gradual reform", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "CN C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.2", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "symmetric price-stability (deflation) reading", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_china.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published 0.0 and its flag hold; v2.0's clause 4 figure confirms the externalization the rationale names", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CN C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: on the named source, productivity and TFP rising fast; the official accounts' reliability flagged", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "CN C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: within two of the four downscaled boundaries (blue water and land-system change), short on the rest; the trading scheme is intensity-based", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "CN C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0 holds", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CN C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the blind reading's 0.5 rested on public capture of land rent, which holds only for the lease premium; the published reading's evidence of state-organised coerced labour, which the blind reading did not weigh, is extraction the configu", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "CN C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "outcomes matched against the narrower benefit the configuration's own sources claim, eliminating extreme and national-line poverty, which the World Bank and State Council study documents", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "CN C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "structural-repulsion reading", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_china.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 11.5, + "failures": 8, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C2.3": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C5.4": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 8.5, + "failures": 12, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "State Capitalism / Singapore", + "code": "SG", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / Singapore (GLC Developmental Capitalism)", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Singapore_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "stated", + "population": "This evaluation counts everyone who lives and works inside the system, non-residents included,", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Qatar is the third instance of the fourth Step 1b archetype, \"configured national political economy\" (confirmed in Session 20), after China and Singapore." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 1.0, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 3.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 2.0, + "D5": 2.5, + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 1.0 read in the D28 form: the median alone does not show the 70% clause, so the unit falls to 0.5", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SG C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SG C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the published reading: core inflation of 4.1% in 2022 below the stress bar", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "SG C3.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SG C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: productivity and TFP rising over 2003-2023", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "SG C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the configuration's own target path rises to 2030, evidence the blind reading did not weigh", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SG C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds: a group-directed, government-funded mechanism in force (the Tertiary Tuition Fee Subsidy for Malays, means-tested, since 1991), the 2025 Workplace Fairness Act, and a mixed record over 15 years (reading 3.4); the published flag t", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SG C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: the blind reading's own 4.4.3 conditions hold", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "SG C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: HDB removes the private landlord for most residents, a structural mechanism on one relationship type (reading 4.5.3)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "SG C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "outcomes matched against the narrow functions its sources claim for residents, home ownership and compulsory saving", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "SG C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "six decades of contested majorities as cross-spectrum support", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_singapore.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 13.5, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C3.2": 1.0, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.4": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 16.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 11.0, + "failures": 7, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [ + { + "id": "citizens-and-PRs-only", + "label": "citizens and permanent residents only; the scored scope counts every resident", + "kind": "scope", + "changes": { + "C1.5": 1.0, + "C4.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "State Capitalism / Qatar", + "code": "QA", + "display_name": "State Capitalism / Qatar (Gulf Rentier-Distributive Statism)", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "configured_national_economy", + "basis": "stated", + "population": "Population scope: everyone who lives and works in Qatar, non-citizens included.", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_StateCapitalism_Qatar_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Qatar is the third instance of the fourth Step 1b archetype, \"configured national political economy\" (confirmed in Session 20), after China and Singapore." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.0, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.0, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 1.0, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 0.5, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 0.0 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.5, + "D2": 1.5, + "D3": 2.5, + "D4": 1.5, + "D5": 2.0, + "total": 10.0, + "failures": 10, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: the rentier state's transfers are a real mechanism for citizens; the migrant majority is outside them", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "QA C1.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.2a", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "QA C1.2a", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "citizenship divide, no limit at the top", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_qatar.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "the outside reader's reading: for the non-citizen majority, income and demand rest wholly on wage labour (the 0.0 band)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "QA C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "citizenship read as a membership gate", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_qatar.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.1", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: for most residents, no floor and residence tied to the job; reformed in law, not in effect", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "QA C2.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: an appointed legislature since the 2024 referendum; most residents are non-citizens without a vote", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "QA C2.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: legal exit reforms since 2018; residence still sponsor-bound for most residents", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md", + "locator": "QA C2.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.1", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.0: coverage of 4% by the configuration's design", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md", + "locator": "QA C3.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "three compound shocks absorbed", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_qatar.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "published 0.0 on a continuous estimate of 0.2 to 0.35; with clause 4 cleared on the measure v2.0 names, 2.1's 0.0 conditions do not hold for the criterion as a whole (decision 53.2), and the unit rises to 0.5 (reading 3.6)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "QA C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.6", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: productivity and TFP declining; the basket provisioned by rent", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md", + "locator": "QA C3.6", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.1", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "1.0: both clauses are shown on the measures v2.0 names, net of resource depletion as well", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s72.md", + "locator": "QA C4.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "QA C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.1", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "outcomes matched against the narrow benefit claimed, welfare provision to the configuration's citizens, which the entry's document records", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "QA C5.1", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "90.6% referendum approval", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_qatar.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": "SWF Statism precedent, GCC variation", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_qatar.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 10.0, + "failures": 10, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.3": 1.0, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.4": 1.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.1": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C2.5": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C3.6": 0.0, + "C4.1": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 6.5, + "failures": 16, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [ + { + "id": "citizens-only", + "label": "citizens only; the scored scope counts every resident", + "kind": "scope", + "changes": { + "C1.1": 1.0, + "C1.2a": 1.0, + "C1.3": 1.0, + "C1.5": 1.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking", + "code": "IF", + "display_name": "Islamic Finance / Profit-Sharing Banking", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_IslamicFinance_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "stated", + "population": "Score the mechanism, not a country.", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Commons governance joins archetype 1, narrow single-mechanism systems, as its fifth member after Georgism, Mutual Credit / LETS, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic finance." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.5, + "C1.2b": 0.0, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 0.5, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 3.0, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 3.5, + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_islamicfinance.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "IF C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_islamicfinance.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "IF C3.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a financing mechanism that governs none of the four quantities (D28(c))", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "IF C4.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds on the owner-confirmed scope (Session 22, D5) and the 0.5 band's 'formal equality without reparative mechanisms' (reading 3.2); the published flag kept; it alone could change the entry's tier", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "IF C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: a financing mechanism that governs neither quantity (D28(c))", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md", + "locator": "IF C4.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.5", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5: profit-and-loss sharing is a genuine mechanism on the creditor-debtor relationship (reading 4.5.3)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md", + "locator": "IF C4.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as satisfied wherever a precedent was completed, whatever resources it took, the national conversions of Iran (1983-1984) and Malaysia's build show that the resources were found, and the clause is cleared (reading 3.3)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "IF C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_islamicfinance.py", + "locator": "FLAGGED" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.5", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "read as requiring a documented range of at least 40% in a named parameter, which the scoring document does not give (as Mutual Credit's flag reads its clause 3)", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md", + "locator": "IF C5.5", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 14.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C5.2": 1.0, + "C5.4": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 16.0, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C3.5": 0.0, + "C4.2": 0.0, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C4.4": 0.0, + "C4.5": 0.0, + "C5.5": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 10.5, + "failures": 9, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [ + { + "id": "social-finance-layer", + "label": "the Islamic social-finance layer (zakat, waqf, takaful) counted in", + "kind": "scope", + "changes": { + "C1.1": 1.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5 + }, + "result": { + "total": 14.5, + "failures": 4, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "schema": "neec-summary-block/1.0", + "key": "Ostrom-Style Commons Governance", + "code": "OS", + "display_name": "Ostrom-Style Commons Governance", + "record": { + "documents": [ + "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md" + ], + "scored": "NEEC v1 scores re-estimated on the v2.0 criteria by the rescoring pass (NEEC_Rescoring_s37.md to NEEC_Rescoring_s65.md), the three new criteria scored in Session 65, re-read blind in Sessions 71 to 77 (NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md to NEEC_BlindReview_s77.md), with the owner's decisions 79.1 to 79.4 (NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md) and the adjudication of the outside review (NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md), applied by apply_adjudication_s83.py; provisional until Report and Paper v2.0", + "structure": "v2.0, 29 criteria" + }, + "scope": { + "class": "mechanism", + "basis": "stated", + "population": "The convention applied throughout is generalisation, not best-casing: the mechanism is scored as though every common-pool resource in an economy were governed by an Ostrom-principled institution, and the population-scope thresholds are then applied to the resulting economy-wide", + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_Ostrom_Commons_scoring_scratch.md", + "locator": "document", + "phrase": "Commons governance joins archetype 1, narrow single-mechanism systems, as its fifth member after Georgism, Mutual Credit / LETS, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic finance." + } + }, + "vector": { + "C1.1": 0.5, + "C1.2a": 0.0, + "C1.2b": 0.5, + "C1.3": 0.5, + "C1.4": 0.5, + "C1.5": 0.0, + "C2.1": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.0, + "C2.3": 0.5, + "C2.4": 0.5, + "C2.5": 0.5, + "C2.6": 0.5, + "C3.1": 0.5, + "C3.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 0.5, + "C3.4": 1.0, + "C3.5": 0.5, + "C3.6": 0.5, + "C4.1": 0.5, + "C4.2": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.5, + "C4.4": 0.5, + "C4.5": 0.5, + "C4.6": 0.5, + "C5.1": 1.0, + "C5.2": 0.5, + "C5.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 0.5, + "C5.5": 1.0 + }, + "summary": { + "D1": 2.0, + "D2": 2.5, + "D3": 3.5, + "D4": 3.0, + "D5": 4.0, + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + }, + "flags": [ + { + "criterion": "C1.2b", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_ostrom.py", + "locator": "FLAGS" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "see the pass record", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "OS C1.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C1.5", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_ostrom.py", + "locator": "FLAGS" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C2.2", + "scored": 0.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_ostrom.py", + "locator": "FLAGS" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_ostrom.py", + "locator": "FLAGS" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C3.4", + "scored": 1.0, + "alternatives": [ + 0.5 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "part (a)'s reading: the founding literature records outright failures and fragile appropriator-designed institutions, and no analysis located attributes them to, or clears them of, adjustments, so clause 4 is not shown", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "NEEC_OwnerDecisions_s79.md", + "locator": "OS C3.4", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C4.3", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "0.5 holds (reading 3.2); the published flag kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "OS C4.3", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.2", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 0.0 + ], + "basis": "stated", + "reading": "national programmes deployed the mechanism in stages, so the unit is not 0.0 (reading 3.2(f)); clause 1, which those programmes bear on, is not estimated, since clause 2 fixes the verdict; the register's flag toward 0.0 is kept", + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "the rescoring record of the part that read it", + "locator": "OS C5.2", + "phrase": "Flag" + } + }, + { + "criterion": "C5.4", + "scored": 0.5, + "alternatives": [ + 1.0 + ], + "basis": "register", + "reading": null, + "tracks": null, + "source": { + "file": "verify_ostrom.py", + "locator": "FLAGS" + } + } + ], + "joint_readings": [ + { + "id": "scored", + "label": "as scored", + "basis": "scored", + "resolve": {}, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "up", + "label": "every flagged call resolved upward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.2b": 1.0, + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.2": 0.5, + "C3.3": 1.0, + "C5.4": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 17.5, + "failures": 1, + "tier": "Potentially Adequate" + } + }, + { + "id": "down", + "label": "every flagged call resolved downward", + "basis": "extremes", + "resolve": { + "C1.4": 0.0, + "C3.4": 0.5, + "C4.3": 0.0, + "C5.2": 0.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 13.0, + "failures": 6, + "tier": "Structurally Inadequate" + } + } + ], + "scenarios": [ + { + "id": "knowledge-commons", + "label": "the knowledge and digital commons counted in", + "kind": "scope", + "changes": { + "C1.5": 0.5, + "C2.3": 1.0 + }, + "result": { + "total": 15.0, + "failures": 3, + "tier": "Partially Adequate" + } + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/weighting_s83.py b/weighting_s83.py index fbeda0d..1b6c003 100644 --- a/weighting_s83.py +++ b/weighting_s83.py @@ -9,8 +9,11 @@ two tests of first place: dropping each criterion in turn, and resolving every registered close call against the leader and for the runner-up. -Three states: Session 79 (neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json), the adjudicated scores (neec_corpus_v2.json), and the -adjudicated scores with the four owner items applied as the adjudication reads them (adjudicate_s83.OWNER; never written). +Four states (since Session 84): Session 79 (neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json), the adjudicated scores of Session 83 +(neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json), the scores of Session 84 with the owner's items applied (neec_corpus_v2.json), and the +Session 84 scores on the readings alone, with the owner's raises (decisions 58.1, 79.1 to 79.4) reversed +(apply_owner_s84.READINGS; never written). Session 83's third state, the four owner items applied as the adjudication reads +them, is now written: it is the Session 84 state less Participatory Economics' C1.2b (decision 84.4). Usage: python3 weighting_s83.py (prints the tables; writes nothing). Deterministic. """ @@ -45,17 +48,14 @@ def vectors(name): return {e["code"]: e["vector"] for e in load(name)["entries"]}, {e["code"]: e["display_name"] for e in load(name)["entries"]} -def owner_applied(vec): +def readings_alone(vec): with open(os.devnull, "w") as dn: stdout, sys.stdout = sys.stdout, dn try: - adj = pc.load("adjudicate_s83", "adjudicate_s83.py") + a84 = pc.load("apply_owner_s84", "apply_owner_s84.py") finally: sys.stdout = stdout - out = {c: dict(v) for c, v in vec.items()} - for (c, k), it in adj.OWNER.items(): - out[c][k] = it["proposed"] - return out + return a84.without(vec, a84.READINGS) def ranked(vec, w): @@ -67,11 +67,15 @@ def ranked(vec, w): def main(): v79, names = vectors("neec_corpus_v2_s79_snapshot.json") - vadj, _ = vectors("neec_corpus_v2.json") - vown = owner_applied(vadj) - blocks = {b["code"]: b for b in load("summary_blocks_v2.json")} - states = [("Session 79", v79), ("Adjudicated (Session 83)", vadj), ("Adjudicated, with the four owner items", vown)] - print("weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes on the v2.0 corpus (29 criteria), three states\n") + vadj, _ = vectors("neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json") + v84, _ = vectors("neec_corpus_v2.json") + valone = readings_alone(v84) + b83 = {b["code"]: b for b in load("summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json")} + b84 = {b["code"]: b for b in load("summary_blocks_v2.json")} + states = [("Session 79", v79), ("Adjudicated (Session 83)", vadj), ("Session 84, the owner's items applied", v84), + ("Session 84, on the readings alone", valone)] + blocks_of = {"Adjudicated (Session 83)": b83} + print("weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes on the v2.0 corpus (29 criteria), four states\n") firsts = {} for label, vec in states: print(f"== {label}") @@ -93,26 +97,34 @@ def main(): print("\n== Dropping one criterion at a time (equal weights): where first place changes") for label, vec in states: w = schemes()["Equal (baseline)"] - base = ranked(vec, w)[2][0] + tot, _, order = ranked(vec, w) + base = [c for c in order if tot[c] == tot[order[0]]] moved = [] for k in ORDER: ww = dict(w, **{k: 0.0}) tot, _, order = ranked(vec, ww) lead = [c for c in order if tot[c] == tot[order[0]]] - if lead != [base]: + if lead != base: moved.append(f"{k} ({' and '.join(lead)})") - print(f" {label}: first {base} alone in {29 - len(moved)} of 29; " + ("otherwise " + ", ".join(moved) if moved else - "never changes")) + print(f" {label}: first {' and '.join(base)}{' alone' if len(base) == 1 else ''} in {29 - len(moved)} of 29; " + + ("otherwise " + ", ".join(moved) if moved else "never changes")) print("\n== Close calls (equal weights): the leader's flagged calls all resolved down, the runner-up's all up") for label, vec in states[1:]: + blocks = blocks_of.get(label, b84) tot, _, order = ranked(vec, schemes()["Equal (baseline)"]) - a, b = order[0], order[1] + lead = [c for c in order if tot[c] == tot[order[0]]] + if len(lead) > 1: + print(f" {label}: first place is shared ({' and '.join(lead)} at {tot[lead[0]]:.1f}); no single leader to test") + continue + a = lead[0] down = sum(min(f["alternatives"] + [f["scored"]]) - f["scored"] for f in blocks[a]["flags"] if vec[a].get(f["criterion"]) == f["scored"]) - up = sum(max(f["alternatives"] + [f["scored"]]) - f["scored"] for f in blocks[b]["flags"] - if vec[b].get(f["criterion"]) == f["scored"]) - print(f" {label}: {a} {tot[a]:.1f} to {tot[a] + down:.1f}; {b} {tot[b]:.1f} to {tot[b] + up:.1f}: " - + (f"{b} first" if tot[b] + up > tot[a] + down else (f"{a} first" if tot[a] + down > tot[b] + up else "tied"))) + up = {b: sum(max(f["alternatives"] + [f["scored"]]) - f["scored"] for f in blocks[b]["flags"] + if vec[b].get(f["criterion"]) == f["scored"]) for b in order if b != a and tot[b] == tot[order[1]]} + b = max(up, key=lambda x: (up[x], -order.index(x))) + print(f" {label}: {a} {tot[a]:.1f} to {tot[a] + down:.1f}; {b} {tot[b]:.1f} to {tot[b] + up[b]:.1f}" + + (f" (the most of the {len(up)} level at {tot[b]:.1f})" if len(up) > 1 else "") + ": " + + (f"{b} first" if tot[b] + up[b] > tot[a] + down else (f"{a} first" if tot[a] + down > tot[b] + up[b] else "tied"))) print("\nSUMMARY: " + "; ".join(f"{label}: first {' and '.join(firsts[(label, 'Equal (baseline)')][0])} by " f"{firsts[(label, 'Equal (baseline)')][1]:.1f} on equal weights" for label, _ in states)) return 0 diff --git a/weighting_s83_output.txt b/weighting_s83_output.txt index 2458ad9..a34d47f 100644 --- a/weighting_s83_output.txt +++ b/weighting_s83_output.txt @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes on the v2.0 corpus (29 criteria), three states +weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes on the v2.0 corpus (29 criteria), four states == Session 79 Equal (baseline) first CCO by 0.50; top six: CCO 60.3%, PE 58.6%, INT 55.2%, DG 53.4%, NSD 53.4%, MS 51.7% @@ -12,24 +12,33 @@ weighting_s83.py: the four weighting schemes on the v2.0 corpus (29 criteria), t Feasibility discounted (D5 x0.5) first CCO by 0.75; top six: CCO 60.4%, PE 57.5%, MS 53.8%, NSD 52.8%, INT 51.9%, DG 50.9% Crisis risk (C1.4, C4.2 x3) first CCO by 1.00; top six: CCO 59.1%, PE 56.1%, MS 53.0%, NSD 53.0%, INT 51.5%, OS 51.5% -== Adjudicated, with the four owner items - Equal (baseline) first CCO by 0.50; top six: CCO 56.9%, PE 55.2%, MS 53.4%, NSD 53.4%, INT 51.7%, OS 51.7% - Material security (D1 x2) first CCO by 0.50; top six: CCO 57.1%, PE 55.7%, NSD 54.3%, MS 52.9%, SWF 50.0%, DG 48.6% - Feasibility discounted (D5 x0.5) first CCO by 0.50; top six: CCO 57.5%, PE 55.7%, MS 53.8%, NSD 52.8%, INT 51.9%, SWF 50.0% - Crisis risk (C1.4, C4.2 x3) first CCO by 0.50; top six: CCO 56.1%, PE 54.5%, MS 53.0%, NSD 53.0%, INT 51.5%, OS 51.5% +== Session 84, the owner's items applied + Equal (baseline) first CCO by 1.00; top six: CCO 56.9%, MS 53.4%, NSD 53.4%, PE 53.4%, INT 51.7%, OS 51.7% + Material security (D1 x2) first CCO by 1.00; top six: CCO 57.1%, NSD 54.3%, MS 52.9%, PE 52.9%, SWF 50.0%, DG 48.6% + Feasibility discounted (D5 x0.5) first CCO by 1.00; top six: CCO 57.5%, MS 53.8%, PE 53.8%, NSD 52.8%, INT 51.9%, SWF 50.0% + Crisis risk (C1.4, C4.2 x3) first CCO by 1.00; top six: CCO 56.1%, MS 53.0%, NSD 53.0%, PE 53.0%, INT 51.5%, OS 51.5% + +== Session 84, on the readings alone + Equal (baseline) first MS and NSD and PE by 0.50; top six: MS 53.4%, NSD 53.4%, PE 53.4%, SWF 51.7%, CCO 50.0%, INT 50.0% + Material security (D1 x2) first NSD by 0.50; top six: NSD 54.3%, MS 52.9%, PE 52.9%, CCO 50.0%, SWF 50.0%, DG 48.6% + Feasibility discounted (D5 x0.5) first MS and PE by 0.25; top six: MS 53.8%, PE 53.8%, NSD 52.8%, CCO 50.0%, INT 50.0%, SWF 50.0% + Crisis risk (C1.4, C4.2 x3) first MS and NSD and PE by 0.50; top six: MS 53.0%, NSD 53.0%, PE 53.0%, SWF 51.5%, CCO 50.0%, INT 50.0% == First place under each scheme Session 79: the same entry first under all four schemes: CCO Adjudicated (Session 83): the same entry first under all four schemes: CCO - Adjudicated, with the four owner items: the same entry first under all four schemes: CCO + Session 84, the owner's items applied: the same entry first under all four schemes: CCO + Session 84, on the readings alone: first place changes with the scheme: Equal (baseline) MS and NSD and PE; Material security (D1 x2) NSD; Feasibility discounted (D5 x0.5) MS and PE; Crisis risk (C1.4, C4.2 x3) MS and NSD and PE == Dropping one criterion at a time (equal weights): where first place changes Session 79: first CCO alone in 24 of 29; otherwise C1.2a (CCO and PE), C2.2 (CCO and PE), C2.5 (CCO and PE), C3.2 (CCO and PE), C5.3 (CCO and PE) Adjudicated (Session 83): first CCO alone in 29 of 29; never changes - Adjudicated, with the four owner items: first CCO alone in 25 of 29; otherwise C1.2a (CCO and PE), C2.5 (CCO and PE), C3.2 (CCO and PE), C3.4 (CCO and PE) + Session 84, the owner's items applied: first CCO alone in 29 of 29; never changes + Session 84, on the readings alone: first MS and NSD and PE in 23 of 29; otherwise C1.3 (MS and NSD and PE and SWF), C1.5 (MS and PE), C3.4 (NSD and PE), C4.4 (NSD), C4.5 (MS and NSD and SWF), C5.4 (MS and PE) == Close calls (equal weights): the leader's flagged calls all resolved down, the runner-up's all up Adjudicated (Session 83): CCO 17.5 to 15.5; PE 16.5 to 17.0: PE first - Adjudicated, with the four owner items: CCO 16.5 to 14.5; PE 16.0 to 16.5: PE first + Session 84, the owner's items applied: CCO 16.5 to 14.5; NSD 15.5 to 17.5 (the most of the 3 level at 15.5): NSD first + Session 84, on the readings alone: first place is shared (MS and NSD and PE at 15.5); no single leader to test -SUMMARY: Session 79: first CCO by 0.5 on equal weights; Adjudicated (Session 83): first CCO by 1.0 on equal weights; Adjudicated, with the four owner items: first CCO by 0.5 on equal weights +SUMMARY: Session 79: first CCO by 0.5 on equal weights; Adjudicated (Session 83): first CCO by 1.0 on equal weights; Session 84, the owner's items applied: first CCO by 1.0 on equal weights; Session 84, on the readings alone: first MS and NSD and PE by 0.5 on equal weights From a6280e8b85f4af0fcd89d7db165d6d418b13c1cd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:31:46 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/5] NEEC checkpoint s84: Report v2.0 Part I, Domain 3 prose Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JSRwEe3ANJ8vNhgXmYKT7f --- NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md | 63 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 62 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md index a470d04..6dbec11 100644 --- a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md +++ b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md @@ -2398,7 +2398,68 @@ Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the rating's two lowest bands, consent and compulsion outside law and court -## Domain 3 +## Domain 3: System Resilience + +Six criteria: crisis response (C3.1), inflation control (C3.2), resistance to compound failures (C3.3), adaptability (C3.4), +transparency about failure (C3.5), and, new in v2.0, productive and innovative capacity (C3.6). v1 scored 40 of the 115 cells +it scored at 1.0; v2.0 scores ten of 138, three of them on the new criterion. Resilience is the domain where a design's +description of a mechanism most often stood in for a record of it working, and the domain where v2.0's thresholds ask most +often for a record. + +**C3.1, crisis response.** None of the seven v1 passes holds. The designs clear the first clause (a response within 72 hours) +on their automatic stabilisers and fall on the second, support that rises one for one with the severity of the crisis: +Nordic Social Democracy's support rises by widening coverage at fixed replacement rates, not per person. Status Quo rises +from 0.0 to 0.5: in 2020 social benefits to households rose 35.5% while real GDP fell 2.1%, which clears the second clause, +but the first official data showing the shock came on 26 March and 78.8% of the population is covered by a cash benefit. +Three fail: Libertarian Minarchism; Doughnut Economics, which adopts no stabilisation instrument (down from 0.5); and Qatar, +where 4.1% of residents are covered by a cash benefit and the migrant majority by none (down from 0.5). + +**C3.2, inflation control.** Two pass. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP holds its 1.0 on the owner's decision 58.1, which reads the +design's backing of the currency by creative output as backing what it pays; its second clause (inflation of 5% or less when +outside inflation is 8%) is carried on the framework paper's 8% scenario (local inflation 3.2% against national 8.1%), since +the design's published model runs no 8% scenario. China's v1 1.0 is held at the published score, with a close call toward +0.5. Seven v1 passes fall. The decisive record is 2022: every Nordic economy ran inflation above 5% in every month from May +to October (Denmark 11.4% in October), so Nordic Social Democracy is short on the stress clause. Centrally Planned Socialism +falls because official prices held by decree hid inflation in queues and rationing rather than preventing it. + +**C3.3, compound failures.** A class W criterion; no entry passes. The four v1 passes fall: Degrowth's, Participatory +Economics' and Integral's in the adjudication, since none models the four compound scenarios, and CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's on its +own model, whose one compound scenario (the Adverse environment) is milder than the criterion's. Status Quo rises from 0.0 +to 0.5 in the adjudication: on the criterion's own poverty measure the 2008 to 2009 shock did not degrade the function. +Libertarian Minarchism and Centrally Planned Socialism are held at 0.0. + +**C3.4, adaptability.** Five pass, each with a close call toward 0.5, and twelve of v1's seventeen passes fall. Market +Socialism passes on a record: Mondragon's pay-ratio cap moved from 1:3 at founding to 1:6 in 1988, a 100% range, decided by +the cooperatives' General Assemblies, with no collapse caused by an adjustment located. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP passes on the +owner's decision 79.3, which reads clause 4 (zero collapses during parameter adjustments) as excluding a smaller +allowance's direct effect, with clauses 1 and 3 sourced in Session 84 (`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 3). Integral and +Ostrom-Style Commons Governance pass on the owner's decision 79.4 (clause 4 cleared where clauses 1 to 3 are cleared and no +collapse is located); Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism passes on Norway's record (the fund's equity share moved from 40% to 70% +between 1998 and 2017 without collapse, the 2017 decisions eleven weeks after the central bank's advice) and Alaska's +(the 2016 dividend veto challenged in the state Supreme Court). Degrowth and Participatory Economics, raised by 79.4, return +to 0.5 by the owner's decision 84.1: clauses that 79.4's rule needs cleared were not shown on sources. +Nordic Social Democracy is short on the fourth: the financial liberalisation of the 1980s led to systemic banking crises in +Finland, Norway and Sweden. Fully Automated Luxury Communism falls to 0.0 (no procedure for adjusting its rules is specified) +and Libertarian Minarchism rises from 0.0 to 0.5. + +**C3.5, transparency about failure.** No entry passes; the three v1 passes fall, Centrally Planned Socialism's to 0.0 on its +active suppression of failure information (the Kyshtym accident of 1957 acknowledged only in 1989; the famine of 1932 to 1933 +denied). China fails on the same ground (the epidemic warning punished as false information; a State Council investigation +found deaths in the Henan floods withheld). Three mechanisms fail because a transfer or a guarantee has no channel that +detects or corrects failures (Universal Basic Income, Universal Basic Services, MMT + Job Guarantee). Four entries rise from +0.0 to 0.5, among them Nordic Social Democracy (implicit fossil-fuel subsidies under 1% of GDP; Sweden's audit office reports +action on nearly 85% of its recommendations within a year). + +**C3.6, productive and innovative capacity (new).** Three pass, all configured economies, each with a close call toward 0.5: +Status Quo (output per hour up 1.30% a year and total factor productivity 0.45% a year over 20 years), China (8.18% and +3.02%) and Singapore (2.31% and 0.36%). Nordic Social Democracy is short on total factor productivity, which fell in Finland and Norway over the +20 years. No design shows the clauses: their productivity figures are projections, and none accounts for basic-needs output +at its own working time; the mechanisms are out of reach. So the criterion separates the measured economies from the +designs by evidence, not by a finding that the designs would be less productive. + +**What the domain does not show.** The designs' resilience is read on their own models and texts; none has an +implementation that has met a compound shock. The limits page states it, with the clause readings that rest on a design's +own text. ### C3.1 Crisis Response Capacity From 306e2c68ff9e1ebb09247e91eeb1315ba264c65d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:33:24 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/5] NEEC checkpoint s84: Report v2.0 Part I, Domain 4 prose Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JSRwEe3ANJ8vNhgXmYKT7f --- NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md | 55 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 54 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md index 6dbec11..6a5ee8b 100644 --- a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md +++ b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md @@ -3669,7 +3669,60 @@ Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.0. 0.5: output per worker rising, TFP declining on growth accounting; held from 0.0 by D28(f) -## Domain 4 +## Domain 4: Ethical Integrity + +Six criteria: intergenerational justice (C4.1), ecological compliance (C4.2), group equity (C4.3), the distribution of power +(C4.4), the elimination of exploitation (C4.5), and, new in v2.0, the internalisation of harm (C4.6). Every one of the +domain's 138 cells was read in v2.0, and it moved most in both directions: 14 cells up and 32 down. v1 scored 34 of 115 at +1.0; v2.0 scores seven of 138. The criteria where a design's structure decides the question (C4.4, C4.5) keep their passes; +the criteria that ask for a measured trend (C4.2, C4.3) have none. + +**C4.1, intergenerational justice.** One pass, and it is new: Qatar (general government debt 42.5% of GDP in 2025, at most +46.4% on the IMF's projection to 2031; net national saving positive in every year from 2012 to 2021 and positive net of gas +and oil depletion), with a close call toward 0.5. All eight v1 passes fall, on one clause or both: a design that adds no public debt keeps its +host's (CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP is far short on its host's figures, though it clears the transfer clause), several designs state +neither figure, and two mechanisms are out of reach. Finland's debt, above 80% since 2024, makes Nordic Social Democracy +short. Status Quo, Stakeholder Capitalism and Libertarian +Minarchism rise from 0.0 to 0.5; no entry fails, against three in v1. + +**C4.2, ecological compliance.** No entry passes; v1's seven passes all fall, because no design states a trend in +consumption-based emissions, biodiversity, extraction or the downscaled planetary boundaries. Six fail. Status Quo's +consumption emissions fall 0.37% a year against the bar's 3.8%, its Red List Index declines and all four boundaries are +transgressed; Singapore, Qatar, Stakeholder Capitalism and Libertarian Minarchism also fail; Centrally Planned +Socialism falls to 0.0 (the Soviet territories' emissions rose 2.7 times between 1960 and 1988, and the plan itself destroyed +the Aral Sea). China rises from 0.0 to 0.5: its emissions still rise, but only two of the four boundaries are transgressed. +Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Islamic Finance rise from 0.0 to 0.5 as mechanisms out of reach of their hosts' ecology. + +**C4.3, group equity.** No entry passes; v1's seven passes fall. The designs state no disparity trend on any axis. Status Quo +falls to 0.0 on the measure v2.0 names: the gap between Black and Asian households' medians is above 50% and widened by 7.7 +points from 2002 to 2025, and the Black-white gap has stayed between 34.8% and 44.7% in all 53 editions since 1972. Nordic +Social Democracy is short on the immigrant axis its own text declares. Four fail: Status Quo, Libertarian Minarchism, China +and Qatar. + +**C4.4, power distribution.** Three pass, all designs whose structure is the threshold's condition: Market Socialism +(enterprises owned by those who work in them; administrators the general assembly can dismiss), Participatory Economics (no +owners of capital or managerial hierarchy; recallable, rotated delegates) and Integral. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP, Nordic Social +Democracy and Degrowth fall from 1.0: Nordic Social Democracy's public sectors are accountable but most major decisions are +taken in private firms. Five entries rise from 0.0 to 0.5, among them Status Quo and Stakeholder Capitalism (functioning +removal of governments, the first clause short); five fail: Centrally Planned Socialism, Doughnut Economics, China, Singapore +and Qatar. + +**C4.5, exploitation.** Three pass: Participatory Economics (up from 0.0; no private ownership of productive assets, so no +profit, rent or interest accrues to owners, and an allowance for those who do not work), Integral and Fully Automated Luxury +Communism; the first two carry close calls toward 0.5. Libertarian Minarchism falls from 1.0 to 0.0 (every extractive +relationship kept, exit no more than the formal right to quit; the reading that settled ledger I9), and Stakeholder +Capitalism from 0.5 to 0.0. Seven fail: Status Quo, China, Qatar, Stakeholder Capitalism, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, +Libertarian Minarchism and Doughnut Economics. + +**C4.6, harm internalisation (new).** No entry passes; Centrally Planned Socialism fails (the state owned the polluting +enterprises, and no regulatory agency existed until 1988). Nordic Social Democracy clears the first and third clauses +(pollution mortality fell in each of the four, Denmark's from 51.3 to 23.5 per 100,000; World Justice Project scores of 0.92 +to 0.99 against the bar of 0.77) and the second is not shown: the law in force makes polluters liable, but no claim decided +and paid within the window is named for any of the four. Every other entry scores 0.5: none shows all three clauses. + +**What the domain does not show.** One clause reading in this domain carries an unfilled template field from Session 49 +(Nordic Social Democracy's C4.3, clause 2: "{LAST}" and "{DKTREND}" where the generator's figures belong); the score is +unaffected, and the record is listed for correction (ledger I13). ### C4.1 Intergenerational Justice From a9f17b8a785ad36ca241266ddda1466b5d64d047 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:34:49 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/5] NEEC checkpoint s84: Report v2.0 Part I, Domain 5 prose (all five domains drafted) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JSRwEe3ANJ8vNhgXmYKT7f --- NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md | 62 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 57 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md index 6a5ee8b..00abceb 100644 --- a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md +++ b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md @@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ poverty and demand under 30%, 50% and 70% displacement of paid hours), and almos economy, states them. **C1.1, poverty.** None of the nine v1 passes holds; 21 entries score 0.5 and two 0.0. The threshold asks for a 90% -reduction within 20 years and 85% under stress. Seven designs clear the first clause on their own projections (Market +reduction within 20 years and 85% under stress. Seven entries clear the first clause on their own projections (Market Socialism, Participatory Economics, Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, MMT + Job Guarantee, Fully Automated Luxury Communism, and Centrally Planned Socialism on its record of absolute poverty), but none states a figure under stress; where a stress episode is documented, as Cuba's Special Period is for Centrally Planned Socialism, it records a fall in food intake, not a @@ -3720,9 +3720,10 @@ enterprises, and no regulatory agency existed until 1988). Nordic Social Democra to 0.99 against the bar of 0.77) and the second is not shown: the law in force makes polluters liable, but no claim decided and paid within the window is named for any of the four. Every other entry scores 0.5: none shows all three clauses. -**What the domain does not show.** One clause reading in this domain carries an unfilled template field from Session 49 -(Nordic Social Democracy's C4.3, clause 2: "{LAST}" and "{DKTREND}" where the generator's figures belong); the score is -unaffected, and the record is listed for correction (ledger I13). +**What the domain does not show.** Three of Nordic Social Democracy's readings carry unfilled template fields from the +pass's scripts of Sessions 48 to 50 (C4.3 and C4.4 here, C5.4 in Domain 5: braced names such as "{LAST}" or "{RATIO}" where the +scripts' computed figures belong; the scripts fill them in their own records, but the stored units keep the template). The +statuses and the scores are unaffected; the readings are listed for correction (ledger I13). ### C4.1 Intergenerational Justice @@ -4939,7 +4940,58 @@ Read in group 2.11 (Session 65) and re-read blind in Session 77. Close call: a reasonable scorer could set 0.5. 0.0: the polluter and the regulator one state, with no agency until 1988 -## Domain 5 +## Domain 5: Implementation Viability + +Five criteria: a proven foundation (C5.1), staged transition (C5.2), partial and parallel deployment (C5.3), political +coalition (C5.4) and cultural adaptability (C5.5). It is the domain with the most held cells (56 of 115), because three of +its thresholds were unchanged in v2.0 (class U) and one was reworded (class W). v1 scored 41 cells at 1.0; v2.0 scores 15, +the most of any domain, and every one belongs to a mechanism or a configured economy, which have records; none belongs to +one of the nine comprehensive designs, which have plans. + +**C5.1, a proven foundation.** Two pass: Ostrom-Style Commons Governance (Valencia's water tribunal for about a thousand +years; Nepal's community forestry with about 2.9 million households; outcomes documented across three multi-case +datasets) and Universal Basic Income (Alaska's dividend, universal for more than 40 years, with a documented reduction in +poverty), the latter with a close call toward 0.5. Eleven of v1's thirteen passes fall, most on the second clause, +documented outcomes matching the benefits claimed: Nordic Social Democracy's decades at national scale are proven, but its +headline claims of near-universal material security are recorded short by the corpus's own amended scores. Seven of the +falls carry close calls toward 1.0. CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's cited precedents cover three of its five components. Fully +Automated Luxury Communism rises from 0.0 to 0.5. + +**C5.2, staged transition.** Two pass. Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism rises from 0.5 on its own deployments: four dated +stages in Norway from 1990 to 1998, Timor-Leste's fund after 2002 as a post-crisis precedent, dated targets set and met, and +documented resources and mitigations. Status Quo passes because the existing system needs no transition (every clause +moot). Six of v1's seven passes fall: the designs' phases, milestones and resources are their own plans, with no precedent +of comparable deployment (CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's roadmap launches its dual currency for all Americans in year 2, and only its +risk mitigation clears). Fully Automated Luxury Communism ("a destination without a roadmap") and Centrally Planned Socialism +fail. + +**C5.3, partial and parallel deployment.** Seven pass, the domain's most: five held at their published 1.0 (Sovereign Wealth +Fund Statism, Ostrom, Georgism, Islamic Finance, Status Quo) and two re-read (Universal Basic Income; Universal Basic +Services, whose sectors were adopted one at a time, as Quebec's low-fee childcare raised mothers' employment and scaled to +all of Canada by 2022). The seven that fall from 1.0 fall on the third or fourth clause, a modelled scaling pathway or +coordination protocols in operation (Market Socialism's largest federation, Mondragon, has about 70,000 workers). CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's +falls by the owner's decision 84.2: its own papers put minimum viable participation at 55% to 65%, against the threshold's +30%. Fully Automated Luxury Communism and Centrally Planned Socialism are held at 0.0. + +**C5.4, political coalition.** One pass: Nordic Social Democracy (public satisfaction of 70% to 85%; its universal insurance +and services kept through every change of government, centre-right governments included), with a close call toward 0.5. +CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP falls from 1.0: Alaska's dividend shows broad approval of one component, but its documents project no +opposition to repeal and no survival across administrations (its own modelling paper puts political resistance in 34% of +scenarios). Degrowth fails on structural or rhetorical features that repel coalition-building (the name is chosen as a +provocation; resistance among unions is recorded in its own literature), with Fully Automated Luxury Communism and Centrally +Planned Socialism held at 0.0. Stakeholder Capitalism rises from 0.0 to 0.5. + +**C5.5, cultural adaptability.** Three pass: Mutual Credit (each network sets its own credit limits and rules; implementations +in at least five cultural contexts and across income levels), Islamic Finance, and Ostrom-Style Commons Governance (held); +the first two carry close calls toward 0.5. Participatory Economics falls from 1.0: no economy has been organised on the +design, so nothing validates its operation across implementations. Market Socialism and Universal Basic Income rise from 0.0 +to 0.5 in the adjudication. Stakeholder Capitalism fails (it needs a cultural consensus that corporations serve the social +good, which competitive pressure contradicts and the system cannot itself produce), and Qatar is held at 0.0. + +**What the domain does not show.** Its held cells (56) rest on v1 rationales; three of its criteria were unchanged in v2.0, +so the pass did not re-read them unless another reading reached them, and the outside review and its adjudication are the +only second reading most of them have had. The domain's verdicts on the designs measure what has been demonstrated, which +for a design not yet built is little by construction; the limits page states this. ### C5.1 Proven Component Foundation From 6e5d013a04ded9c35d2942b98617fd5dbf518a20 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:41:29 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/5] NEEC Session 84: owner items D66/D67 applied by generator, CCO C3.4 sourced, PE C1.2b by rule 4; entry renamed CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP; Report v2.0 Part I drafted (five domains) Decisions 84.1 to 84.10 (NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md, section 7). CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP 16.5 first; NSD, MS, PE 15.5; on the readings alone CCO 14.5 (fifth). Harness v53, 148 checks, all pass. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01JSRwEe3ANJ8vNhgXmYKT7f --- NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md | 7 +++ NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md | 98 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md | 2 +- STATE.md | 77 ++++++++++++++++++++++-------- 4 files changed, 162 insertions(+), 22 deletions(-) create mode 100644 NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md diff --git a/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md b/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md index c417c2d..4418ddf 100644 --- a/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md +++ b/NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md @@ -172,6 +172,13 @@ year or the World Happiness Report's three-year average; the measurement field i - **84.8** (optional, tooling): `owner_s84.py`, `final_pass.settled_state()` with its self-test, `apply_owner_s84.py` with `--check` and a negative control, the Session 83 snapshots, `weighting_s83.py`'s four states and its handling of a shared first place, harness v53. +- **84.9** (method, optional): Report v2.0 Part I (`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`) is ordered by domain, criterion and entry. Its + scorecards are generated by `build_report_v2.py` from the units' readings and, for cells no unit read, the published + rationales (decision 52.8), and checked by the harness; the prose between them is written by hand. +- **84.10** (record; ledger I13): three of Nordic Social Democracy's stored readings (C4.3, C4.4 and C5.4) carry unfilled + template fields ("{LAST}", "{RATIO}", "{SPEND}" and others) from `rescoring_s48.py` to `rescoring_s50.py`, which fill + them only in their own records. The statuses and scores are unaffected; the fields are filled by generator before the + landing (S43), and `evidence/` and the Report's scorecards regenerated. ## 8. What this record does not do, and disclosure diff --git a/NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md b/NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..25ad685 --- /dev/null +++ b/NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md @@ -0,0 +1,98 @@ +> **Next session (85, the Paper's disclosures and the limits page): Opus 5.5 at high** (ledger S42, then S44). Reason: both +> are judgment prose on settled scores, as S41 was; nothing contested remains to read, so high, not xhigh. If the session +> runs short, S44 can move to Session 86 at the same model and effort. + +# NEEC Project Handoff 84 (2026-10-21) + +## 1. What changed (Session 84; ledger S67, S68, S69 and S41 done) + +**S67.** Pull request #51 (Session 83) was merged on 2026-10-20 and `land-session.yml` tagged `s83`; the start-of-session +check passed (145 of 145, no difference from the captured output). + +**S68, by generator, on the s83 state** (`owner_s84.py`, the layer; `apply_owner_s84.py`, the generator; the record +`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`). The owner's answers applied as the adjudication reads them: D66, Degrowth's and Participatory +Economics' C3.4 1.0 to 0.5 (decision 84.1); D67, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 1.0 to 0.5, superseding D65's hold +under 69.4 (84.2). CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C3.4: clauses 1 and 3 had rested on "as audited (the unit's own text)"; both are now +read on the design's documents (the Research Hub at 8e8a6ba: the inflation paper's sensitivity analysis and the integrated +framework's documented ranges for clause 1; the Citizens Internet Portal paper's initiative and binding-referendum +provisions and the PTH charter template's appeal rights for clause 3); both clear, and the verdict holds at 1.0 on +decision 79.3, which governs clause 4 only (84.3). Participatory Economics' C1.2b read by rule 4 of decision 83.4 (I12 item +1): its sources distinguish it from Degrowth, Integral and Mutual Credit in strength, not on the point the clause turns on +(no estimate of the wealth Gini, and a bound on the top of the distribution does not bound it), so 0.5 with a close call +toward 1.0 (84.4). I12 items 2 and 3 go to the limits page (84.6). The standing, `weighting_s83.py` (now four states) and +the evidence reports regenerated; the harness passes (v53, 148 checks). + +**The standing.** CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP 16.5, first alone; Nordic Social Democracy, Market Socialism and Participatory +Economics 15.5; Integral, Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism and Ostrom 15.0; no tier changes. First under all four weighting +schemes and every single-criterion drop. **With and without every owner decision** (the record, section 5): reversing any +one of 58.1, 79.1, 79.2 or 79.3 leaves CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP first at 16.0; reversing 79.4 changes only Integral and Ostrom; +reversing D66 puts Participatory Economics second alone at 16.0; reversing D67 restores 17.5. **On the readings alone** +(the raises of 58.1 and 79.1 to 79.4 reversed; D66 and D67 already apply the readings) CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands at 14.5, +fifth, and Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy and Participatory Economics share first at 15.5. The scores freeze at +the `s84` tag except through the push-back route. + +**S69, the name (D68, decision 84.5).** One display-name mapping, `display_names.py`, used by `apply_owner_s84.py` (corpus +`display_name`, CSV, blocks), `build_evidence.py` (the reports; quotations of the v1 rationales keep their words) and +`build_site.py` (every page and data file, the visual suite included). The entry's `key` (`CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH`) and code +(`CCO`) are identifiers and do not change; `site/config.json`'s note now names five components and the earlier name. The +records of Sessions 1 to 83, and the generators that rebuild them, keep the old name; `STATE.md` (Position) says so. + +**S41, Report v2.0 Part I** (`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`, about 590 KB). Ordered domain, criterion, entry. The standing, +the counts by domain and every criterion's scorecard of the 23 entries are generated by `build_report_v2.py` from the units' +readings and, for cells no unit read, the published v1 rationales (decision 52.8; harness check 148); each domain's prose, +what moved from v1 and why, the passes and failures, the close calls and what the domain does not show, is by hand. A +checkpoint was pushed after each domain. The draft is for the owner's review; it lands with S43. + +**Planned, not built (D69 and its note, decision 84.7).** v2.0 lands with 23 entries; OEIAS (S70) joins in v2.1 as the 24th, +and Claude's system (S71) as the 25th, released with it. S71: the design document is published before any scoring; every +unit also goes to the outside blind reader; the Paper discloses Claude's authorship. + +**Found.** Three of Nordic Social Democracy's stored readings (C4.3, C4.4, C5.4) carry unfilled template fields from +`rescoring_s48.py` to `rescoring_s50.py` ("{LAST}", "{RATIO}", "{SPEND}" and others), visible in `evidence/nsd.md` and the +Report's scorecards; statuses and scores are unaffected (decision 84.10; ledger I13; fixed by generator in S43). + +The session did not stop at a limit. + +## 2. Files + +New: `owner_s84.py`, `apply_owner_s84.py`, `display_names.py`, `build_report_v2.py`, `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, +`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`, `neec_corpus_v2_s83_snapshot.json`, `neec_scores_v2_s83_snapshot.csv`, +`summary_blocks_v2_s83_snapshot.json` (the Session 83 state, byte for byte), `apply_owner_s84_output.txt`, +`apply_owner_s84_check_negative_output.txt`, `build_report_v2_output.txt`, `NEEC_Project_Handoff_84.md`. +Changed: `neec_corpus_v2.json`, `neec_scores_v2.csv`, `summary_blocks_v2.json` (regenerated); `final_pass.py` +(`settled_state()`, self-test); `apply_adjudication_s83.py` (writes the s83 snapshots); `weighting_s83.py` (four states; +shared first place handled); `build_evidence.py` (Session 84's layer; the name mapping; the index's sort without a config +`short`); `build_site.py` (the name mapping); `site/config.json` (CCO's note; its `short` removed so the name comes from the +mapping); `evidence/`, `docs/` (regenerated); `run_all_checks.py` (v53, 148 checks) and its regenerated captures +(`final_pass_selftest_output.txt`, `apply_adjudication_s83_output.txt` and its negative control, +`build_evidence_output.txt` and its negative control, `weighting_s83_output.txt`, `run_all_checks_output.txt`); `README.md` +(the check count); `STATE.md` (rewritten). + +## 3. Decisions + +84.1 (owner, D66) and 84.2 (owner, D67): the four owner items applied. 84.3 (correction to the record): CCO C3.4 clauses 1 +and 3 sourced. 84.4 (correction under the delegation): Participatory Economics' C1.2b to 0.5 by rule 4. 84.5 (owner, D68): +the name, through one mapping. 84.6 (record): I12 items 2 and 3 to S44. 84.7 (owner, D69): v2.1 brings OEIAS and Claude's +system. 84.8 (optional, tooling): the layer, the generator, the snapshots, the weighting's four states, harness v53. 84.9 +(method, optional): Part I's order and its generated scorecards. 84.10 (record, I13): the template fields. Full text: +`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 7. + +## 4. Ledger entries + +Applied in the same session (one batch, pinned to version 51; now version 52): S67, S68, S69 and S41 `done`, moved to +`archive/neec/items`; S73 added (the Report's front matter and Part II, which the plan lacked); I13 added; I12's item 1 +ticked; S42, S43, S44, S70 and S71 rewritten (S71: Claude's system the 25th entry, with OEIAS in v2.1, design published +first, outside blind reader on every unit, authorship disclosed); `pending`: four flags (review the Part I draft; the +readings-alone finding for the Paper; approve or drop S73; I12 ready to confirm once S44 states items 2 and 3); `msg` +cleared (acted on); `next` S42, S44, S73, S43; `left`, `summary`, `reads`, `watch`, `updated`, `log`. No `conf` set. + +## 5. Next session (85): start here + +1. `python3 run_all_checks.py > /tmp/out.txt; cmp /tmp/out.txt run_all_checks_output.txt` (no difference; about 4 minutes). +2. Read the ledger (`next`: S42, S44, S73, S43; the `pending` flags and any answers to them). +3. S42, the Paper v2.0 disclosures: the ledger's text. Sources: `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` sections 1 and 5 (the standing + with and without every owner decision, generated), `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` sections 1, 5 and 6, the Report draft's front + matter. Lead with the conflict of interest in the body. +4. S44, the limits page: `STATE.md`, Next work, open items (a) to (e); the adjudication's sections 7 to 9; I12 items 2 and 3; + the clause readings that rest on a design's own text. Then tick I12's items 2 and 3. +5. Finish as `CLAUDE.md` says. diff --git a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md index 00abceb..8a7c26b 100644 --- a/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md +++ b/NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md @@ -4968,7 +4968,7 @@ fail. **C5.3, partial and parallel deployment.** Seven pass, the domain's most: five held at their published 1.0 (Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism, Ostrom, Georgism, Islamic Finance, Status Quo) and two re-read (Universal Basic Income; Universal Basic Services, whose sectors were adopted one at a time, as Quebec's low-fee childcare raised mothers' employment and scaled to -all of Canada by 2022). The seven that fall from 1.0 fall on the third or fourth clause, a modelled scaling pathway or +all of Canada by 2022). Seven of the eight that fall from 1.0 fall on the third or fourth clause, a modelled scaling pathway or coordination protocols in operation (Market Socialism's largest federation, Mondragon, has about 70,000 workers). CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's falls by the owner's decision 84.2: its own papers put minimum viable participation at 55% to 65%, against the threshold's 30%. Fully Automated Luxury Communism and Centrally Planned Socialism are held at 0.0. diff --git a/STATE.md b/STATE.md index 5c79554..9d7b77d 100644 --- a/STATE.md +++ b/STATE.md @@ -1,10 +1,9 @@ # NEEC state -**Next session (84, the prose): Opus 5.5 at high** (ledger S41, Report v2.0 Part I). Reason: the adjudication is done -(`NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`) and the scores freeze at the `s83` tag except the four owner items (ledger D65, D66); the prose is -judgment work on settled scores, not contested readings, so high, not xhigh. First step: apply your answers to D65 and D66 by -generator if they change anything (`adjudicate_s83.OWNER` holds the units); if you have not answered, write the prose on the -scores as they stand and state both readings. Send `Continue NEEC.` +**Next session (85, the Paper's disclosures and the limits page): Opus 5.5 at high** (ledger S42, then S44). Reason: both +are judgment prose on settled scores, as S41 was; nothing contested remains to read, so high, not xhigh. First step: read +`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` (sections 1 and 5: the standing with and without every owner decision) and the Report draft's +front matter. Send `Continue NEEC.` **What is true now.** Rewritten by every session before its pull request (`CLAUDE.md`); the handoff says what changed, this file says what holds. Last rewritten by Session 84 (the owner's items applied, two consistency gaps closed, the entry renamed, Report v2.0 Part I @@ -262,6 +261,11 @@ provisional notice (decision 66.1; the owner confirmed d49, decision 67.1).** Th ## Next work, in order +**First: Session 85, Opus 5.5 at high** (S42, the Paper v2.0 disclosures, then S44, the limits page; judgment prose on +settled scores). Then S73 (Report v2.0 front matter and Part II, Opus 5.5 at high), then S43 (landing, Sonnet 5.5 at +medium, which first fills I13's template fields by generator), then S49 (the PDF, Sonnet 5.5). Items 10 to 12 below say +more. + Stage 3b, the blind re-read (decisions 69.1, 69.2), ran Sessions 70 to 78 (complete); stage 4 (the Report and Paper prose) and landing now run Sessions 79 to 83. Every blind-review session works the same way, on `blind_review.py` (built Session 69) and `pass_common.py`: read the unit blind first (`blind_view()`: the v2.0 clauses and the cached sources, never the @@ -405,19 +409,25 @@ prose (decision 79.6, `NEEC_OutsideReview_Plan_s79.md`), with Jev as a second in (`NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`, `adjudicate_s83.py`, `apply_adjudication_s83.py`); 18 verdicts changed by generator; four readings to the owner; the outside result on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided cell published (evidence reports and the record, section 6); I9 settled (decision 83.10); the weighting robustness rerun on the v2 corpus (`weighting_s83.py`). -11. **The scores freeze at the `s83` tag** (decision 83.13; `land-session.yml` creates it when this pull request is merged), - except the four owner items: CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C2.2 and C5.3 (ledger D65) and Degrowth's and Participatory Economics' - C3.4 (D66). The owner's half of I7 stays the owner's. Session 84's first step applies the owner's answers to D65 and D66 - by generator (a layer like `adjudicate_s83.UNITS`, or `adjudicate_s83.OWNER`'s units moved into it), if they change - anything; Report and Paper v2.0 state the standing with and without the owner's decisions and items. -12. **Sessions 84 to 88, the prose and landing**, in the ledger's order: S41 Report v2.0 Part I (Opus 5.5 at high), S42 - Paper v2.0 disclosures (Opus 5.5 at high; the owner's decisions, the standing with and without them, the outside - review's result and its adjudication, with the result on every CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH and owner-decided unit, up or down), S44 - the limits page (Opus 5.5 at high; now also the class notes of `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`, sections 7 to 9, and ledger - I12), S43 land the drafts (Sonnet 5.5 at medium: remove `provisional_note`, rebuild, harness, pull request), S49 the - PDF (Sonnet 5.5). - -This order is also in the ledger (`steps` S63 to S66, S41 to S44, S49, each with its own model and effort; `next`); a +11. **Done: Session 84** (Opus 5.5 at high; ledger S67, S68, S69 done, S41 drafted; decisions 84.1 to 84.10; + `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`). The owner's answers to D66 and D67 applied by generator (`owner_s84.py`, + `apply_owner_s84.py`); CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP C3.4's clauses 1 and 3 sourced; Participatory Economics' C1.2b 0.5 by rule 4 + (I12 item 1); the standing with and without every owner decision recorded (the record, section 5); the entry renamed + through `display_names.py` (S69); Report v2.0 Part I drafted, all five domains (`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`, its + scorecards generated by `build_report_v2.py`, decision 52.8; its prose by hand). **The scores freeze at the `s84` tag** + (decision 83.13, moved on), except through the push-back route (S72). The owner's half of I7 stays the owner's. +12. **Sessions 85 to 88, the prose and landing**, in the ledger's order: S42 Paper v2.0 disclosures (Opus 5.5 at high; the + owner's decisions with the standing with and without each, from `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` section 5; the conflict of + interest in the body; the outside review's result and its adjudication; that on the readings alone CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP + stands fifth at 14.5 and Market Socialism, Nordic Social Democracy and Participatory Economics share first at 15.5; the + name change), S44 the limits page (Opus 5.5 at high; open items (a) to (e) below, the class notes of + `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` sections 7 to 9, I12 items 2 and 3, and the clause readings that rest on a design's own text, + such as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP C5.3's clauses 2 to 4), S73 the Report's front matter and Part II (Opus 5.5 at high; the + comparative analysis on the settled standing and `weighting_s83.py`'s four states), S43 land the drafts (Sonnet 5.5 at + medium: first fill I13's template fields by generator and regenerate `evidence/` and the Report's scorecards; then + remove `provisional_note`, rebuild, harness, pull request), S49 the PDF (Sonnet 5.5). + +This order is also in the ledger (`steps` S42, S44, S73, S43, S49, each with its own model and effort; `next`); a session that finishes early, runs long, or finds a group needs splitting updates both there and here. **Open items, each folded into a session above (none changes a verdict as recorded; each is a challenge route until @@ -445,6 +455,22 @@ condition), and clause 3 on v2.0's wording clears for every C3.4 1.0 while no ot C2.5 and Session 76's C2.6, C3.6 and C4.6 agreed at 0.5); Session 77's group held no CCO unit. 14. The site's contribution route (the Contribute page) is how users challenge a score or threshold; no code change needed. +## Decided (Session 84; `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 7) + +**84.1** (owner, recorded; ledger D66) Degrowth's and Participatory Economics' C3.4 to 0.5, the adjudication's reading. +**84.2** (owner, recorded; ledger D67, superseding D65's hold under 69.4) CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP's C2.2 and C5.3 to 0.5. +**84.3** (correction to the record) CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP C3.4's clauses 1 and 3 re-read on cited sources (the Hub's inflation +paper, integrated framework, CIP paper and PTH charter template); both clear; the verdict holds at 1.0 on 79.3. **84.4** +(correction under the delegation; I12 item 1) Participatory Economics' C1.2b 1.0 to 0.5 by rule 4 of 83.4. **84.5** (owner, +recorded; D68) the entry shown as CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP through `display_names.py`; key and code unchanged; earlier records keep +the old name. **84.6** (record) I12 items 2 and 3 to the limits page (S44). **84.7** (owner, recorded; D69 and its note) +v2.0 lands with 23 entries; OEIAS (S70) the 24th and Claude's system (S71) the 25th, both in v2.1. **84.8** (optional, +tooling) the layer, the generator, the Session 83 snapshots, `weighting_s83.py`'s four states, harness v53. **84.9** +(method, optional) Report v2.0 Part I is ordered domain, criterion, entry; its scorecards are generated by +`build_report_v2.py` from the units' readings and the published rationales (decision 52.8), checked by the harness; the prose +is by hand. **84.10** (record; ledger I13) three of Nordic Social Democracy's stored readings (C4.3, C4.4, C5.4) carry unfilled +template fields from `rescoring_s48.py` to `rescoring_s50.py`; scores unaffected; filled by generator before landing (S43). + ## Decided (Session 83; `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md`, section 10) **83.1 to 83.3** (owner, recorded) D63 (Jev's windows), D64 (the comparison's five readings; the owner added that a further @@ -786,6 +812,12 @@ at `5a7a7b1` for v2.0, W9 landing by pull request, W10 chat path. ## Awaiting the owner +Session 84 added: **ledger I13** (three Nordic Social Democracy readings carry unfilled template fields; fixed by generator +in S43, nothing for the owner to decide) and **S73** (the Report's front matter and Part II, a step the plan lacked); it +asks the owner to **review the Report v2.0 Part I draft** (`NEEC_Report_v2_0_Part_I.md`) and to note that, on the readings +alone, CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP stands fifth (`NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md`, section 5), which the Paper must state. The owner's +answers to D66 to D69 are recorded (decisions 84.1, 84.2, 84.5, 84.7); D65 is superseded by D67; I12's item 1 is read +(84.4) and items 2 and 3 go to S44 (84.6), so I12 is ready to confirm once S44 states them. Session 83 added: **ledger D65** (CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH's C2.2 and C5.3: the adjudication reads both 0.5; held at 1.0 under decision 69.4 unless you apply them), **D66** (Degrowth's and Participatory Economics' C3.4: decision 79.4's condition is not shown for them; kept at 1.0 unless you return them to 0.5), **I12** (three consistency items outside the adjudication's scope) @@ -820,9 +852,12 @@ eight C4.1 design units should be re-read on v2.0's clauses (Handoff 68, section | — | Re-read the 8 C4.1 and 10 C2.5 pre-v2.0-clause units on v2.0's clauses? | Handoff 68, section 3, item 1 | D54 | 69.2: yes, in the blind-review pass (sessions 72, 75) | | S71-6 | Apply Session 71's five verdict changes at S61 (Participatory Economics alone first)? | `NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md` 6 to 8 | D55 | 72.1: apply all five as read | | S71-9 | Libertarian Minarchism and Centrally Planned Socialism on C4.5; C3.4's clause 3 for 16 units | `NEEC_BlindReview_s71.md` 9 | I9 | 83.10: settled; confirm in the ledger | -| S83-6a | CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH C2.2 and C5.3 read 0.5 (held at 1.0 under 69.4) | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 6 | D65 | open | -| S83-6b | Degrowth and Participatory Economics C3.4: decision 79.4's condition not shown | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 6 | D66 | open | -| S83-9 | PE C1.2b; C2.2's means-tested floors; C2.1's measure | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 9 | I12 | open | +| S83-6a | CCO-PTF-CIP-SZH C2.2 and C5.3 read 0.5 (held at 1.0 under 69.4) | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 6 | D65, D67 | 84.2: apply both at 0.5 (D67 supersedes D65) | +| S83-6b | Degrowth and Participatory Economics C3.4: decision 79.4's condition not shown | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 6 | D66 | 84.1: return both to 0.5 | +| S83-9 | PE C1.2b; C2.2's means-tested floors; C2.1's measure | `NEEC_Adjudication_s83.md` 9 | I12 | 84.4 (item 1, 0.5); 84.6 (items 2 and 3 to S44) | +| S84-name | Rename the entry; OEIAS a 24th entry | `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` 7 | D68 | 84.5: CCO-PTF-PTH-SZH-CIP | +| S84-v21 | When OEIAS joins; Claude's system | `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` 7 | D69 | 84.7: v2.1, with Claude's system as the 25th | +| S84-tmpl | Unfilled template fields in three NSD readings | `NEEC_OwnerItems_s84.md` 7 (84.10) | I13 | open: fixed by generator in S43 | | S73-6 | Apply Session 73's eight verdict changes at S61 (Sovereign Wealth Fund Statism to Potentially Adequate)? | `NEEC_BlindReview_s73.md` 6 to 8 | D56 | 74.1: apply all eight as read | | S75-9 | Apply Session 75's six C2.5 verdict changes at S61 (Universal Basic Income to Partially Adequate)? | `NEEC_BlindReview_s75.md` 6 to 9 | D57 | 76.1: apply all six as read | | S74-7 | The Nordic finding: Nordic Social Democracy's C1.1 (clause 1 short, verdict 0.5 unchanged) | `NEEC_BlindReview_s74.md` 7 | I7 | the owner's review (item 2) |