From bc6dc698c938d0bed16729f671d37ca0782e0046 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rafael Vuijk Date: Mon, 16 Nov 2026 00:50:36 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Modenov's computations as a corpus, with the book's errata as rows the library must not confirm ModenovCorpus is a harness in the style of CasBench, over 642 computations from Modenov's Problems in Geometry (Mir, 1981) that the #2131 readings found and checked by value. There are 55 rows from Chapter I, 62 from II, 347 from III, 54 from IV and 124 from V. By kind, there are 341 identities, 200 reductions to a form the book gives, 45 equations with the book's root sets, and 56 errata. Every row's own claim is checked first, at six exact sample points from the row's domain (complex, real, positive, or the unit circle). The run fails on a row whose claim does not hold, so a mistyped row cannot pass as the library's failure. Each answer is then checked by value: - a simplification against its input; - each root substituted back, and every root the book gives found; - an erratum passes if the library neither reduces the difference to 0 nor decides the equality true. modenov-baseline.tsv records each row's verdict. The run fails when one changes either way, as CanonCheck's does, and on any wrong answer, which is never recorded. On 3abd4d9be the counts are 480 solved, 56 refused, 106 unsolved, 0 wrong, 0 error, 0 timeout, in about 85 s. Harnesses.yml runs it. Part of #2153 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 --- .github/workflows/Harnesses.yml | 7 + CLAUDE.md | 11 +- Sources/.editorconfig | 3 + Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/References.md | 7 + .../ModenovCorpus/ModenovCorpus.csproj | 31 + .../Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/Program.cs | 592 ++++++++++++++++ .../ModenovCorpus/modenov-baseline.tsv | 645 +++++++++++++++++ .../Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov.tsv | 660 ++++++++++++++++++ Sources/Tests/Harnesses/README.md | 12 +- 9 files changed, 1958 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) create mode 100644 Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/ModenovCorpus.csproj create mode 100644 Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/Program.cs create mode 100644 Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov-baseline.tsv create mode 100644 Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov.tsv diff --git a/.github/workflows/Harnesses.yml b/.github/workflows/Harnesses.yml index 9bd6ddbf1..648658371 100644 --- a/.github/workflows/Harnesses.yml +++ b/.github/workflows/Harnesses.yml @@ -48,6 +48,7 @@ jobs: dotnet build -c Release Sources/Tests/Harnesses/RuleCheck dotnet build -c Release Sources/Tests/Harnesses/CanonCheck dotnet build -c Release Sources/Tests/Harnesses/Confluence + dotnet build -c Release Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus # One step each, every one run whatever the one before did, so a red run names the harness. - name: BoundCheck @@ -82,6 +83,12 @@ jobs: if: success() || failure() run: dotnet Sources/Tests/Harnesses/Confluence/bin/Release/net10.0/confluence.dll + # Modenov's computations, each row's verdict committed in modenov-baseline.tsv: fails on a + # wrong answer, an erratum confirmed, or a verdict that moves either way. + - name: ModenovCorpus + if: success() || failure() + run: dotnet Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/bin/Release/net10.0/modenovcorpus.dll + - name: Reports if: always() uses: actions/upload-artifact@v6 diff --git a/CLAUDE.md b/CLAUDE.md index ac38a7d41..9b64cccbc 100644 --- a/CLAUDE.md +++ b/CLAUDE.md @@ -19,12 +19,13 @@ nothing else is read: [`Contributing/SimplificationContract.md`](Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/Contributing/SimplificationContract.md). A rule states the assumptions under which it holds, or it is asserting there are none. -Ten measurement harnesses live in `Sources/Tests/Harnesses` and run in CI on every change to the -library: the boundary checker, root completeness, the self-verifying solver corpus, the property +Eleven measurement harnesses live in `Sources/Tests/Harnesses` and run in CI on every change to +the library: the boundary checker, root completeness, the self-verifying solver corpus, the property checker, the simplification sweep, the rule-set checker, a crash harness that survives a stack -overflow, the canonical-form checker, the arm-order checker, and a checker for the code samples in -the wiki and on the website. Each fails on a defect, or the canonical-form and arm-order checkers on -a change to the findings they list; the README says which. The rest are still in the analysis +overflow, the canonical-form checker, the arm-order checker, the corpus of Modenov's computations +and his book's errata, and a checker for the code samples in the wiki and on the website. Each fails +on a defect, or the canonical-form and arm-order checkers and the Modenov corpus on a change to the +findings they list; the README says which. The rest are still in the analysis workspace one directory up (`work/`). Run them before claiming anything is fixed. There is also a *gate*, which is not a harness: diff --git a/Sources/.editorconfig b/Sources/.editorconfig index 141699634..502676743 100644 --- a/Sources/.editorconfig +++ b/Sources/.editorconfig @@ -48,6 +48,9 @@ file_header_template=\nCopyright (c) 2019-2026 Angouri.\nAngouriMath is licensed [Tests/UnitTests/Common/LogarithmOfAPerfectPowerTest.cs] file_header_template=\nCopyright (c) 2019-2026 Angouri.\nAngouriMath is licensed under MIT.\nDetails: https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/blob/master/LICENSE.md.\nWebsite: https://am.angouri.org.\n +[Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/*.cs] +file_header_template=\nCopyright (c) 2019-2026 Angouri.\nAngouriMath is licensed under MIT.\nDetails: https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/blob/master/LICENSE.md.\nWebsite: https://am.angouri.org.\n + [AngouriMath/Functions/PredicateEntailment.cs] file_header_template=\nCopyright (c) 2019-2026 Angouri.\nAngouriMath is licensed under MIT.\nDetails: https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/blob/master/LICENSE.md.\nWebsite: https://am.angouri.org.\n diff --git a/Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/References.md b/Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/References.md index 52aded799..c06cf1e8e 100644 --- a/Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/References.md +++ b/Sources/AngouriMath/Docs/References.md @@ -17,6 +17,13 @@ and the link. Add a work here when it is first cited. binomial identities, and induction — its examples and exercises are the rows of `QuantifierTest`, `SubsetTest`, `IndexedSetOperationTest`, `ImageAndPreImageTest`, `BinomialIdentityTest`, `InductionTest` and `ThresholdSetTest`. +- **Modenov, P. S.** *Problems in Geometry.* Translated from the Russian by George Yankovsky. + Mir, Moscow, 1981. . + Read for [#2131](https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/issues/2131): vector algebra, + analytic geometry, complex numbers in plane geometry, inversion. Its computations, and the + errors found in it by computing, are the rows of the `ModenovCorpus` harness + ([#2153](https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/issues/2153)), cited by chapter, section + and problem. - **Bronstein, Manuel.** *Symbolic Integration I: Transcendental Functions.* 2nd ed., Springer, 2005. The Hermite reduction, the rational and logarithmic parts, and the Risch structure the integrator follows. diff --git a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/ModenovCorpus.csproj b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/ModenovCorpus.csproj new file mode 100644 index 000000000..89eb90242 --- /dev/null +++ b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/ModenovCorpus.csproj @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ + + + + + + Exe + net10.0 + disable + preview + modenovcorpus + ModenovCorpus + true + false + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/Program.cs b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/Program.cs new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0ec30e5dd --- /dev/null +++ b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/Program.cs @@ -0,0 +1,592 @@ +// +// Copyright (c) 2019-2026 Angouri. +// AngouriMath is licensed under MIT. +// Details: https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/blob/master/LICENSE.md. +// Website: https://am.angouri.org. +// + +using System; +using System.Collections.Generic; +using System.IO; +using System.Linq; +using System.Text; +using System.Threading; +using AngouriMath; +using AngouriMath.Extensions; + +namespace ModenovCorpus +{ + /// + /// What a row earns. is the right answer to an erratum: the library did + /// not confirm the form the book printed. is the corpus's own error, a row + /// whose claim does not hold by value, and it fails the run whatever the baseline says. + /// + public enum Verdict { Solved, Refused, Unsolved, Wrong, Error, Timeout, BadRow } + + public enum Op { Zero, Equal, Solve, Erratum } + + /// One computation from Modenov's Problems in Geometry, as modenov.tsv records it. + public sealed record Row(string Id, string Source, Op Op, string Var, string Input, string Expected, char Points, string Note, int Line) + { + public string Chapter => Id.Substring(0, Id.IndexOf('.')); + } + + public sealed record Result(Row Row, Verdict Verdict, string Answer, string Note, long Ms); + + /// + /// Modenov's computations as a corpus. Every row is checked twice by value: the row's own claim + /// first, so that a mistyped identity cannot pass as the library's failure, and then the + /// library's answer against the input it came from. + /// https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/issues/2153 + /// + public static class Program + { + private static readonly TimeSpan Budget = TimeSpan.FromSeconds(20); + + public static int Main(string[] args) + { + var only = args.FirstOrDefault(a => a.StartsWith("--only=", StringComparison.Ordinal))?.Substring(7); + var rows = Load(Path.Combine(ProjectDirectory(), "modenov.tsv")); + var run = rows.Where(r => only is null || r.Id.StartsWith(only, StringComparison.Ordinal)).ToList(); + + var clock = System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch.StartNew(); + var results = new List(); + foreach (var row in run) + { + var r = RunWithBudget(row); + results.Add(r); + Console.Error.WriteLine($"{r.Verdict,-8} {r.Ms,6}ms {row.Id,-16} {Trunc(row.Input, 70)}"); + } + Report(results, clock.Elapsed); + + var failed = false; + foreach (var r in results.Where(r => r.Verdict is Verdict.Wrong or Verdict.BadRow)) + { + Console.WriteLine($"{r.Verdict.ToString().ToUpperInvariant()} {r.Row.Id} (modenov.tsv:{r.Row.Line}): {r.Row.Input} -> {r.Answer}: {r.Note}"); + failed = true; + } + if (only is not null) + { + Console.WriteLine("--only runs part of the corpus, so the baseline is not compared."); + return failed ? 1 : 0; + } + + // A wrong answer is never recorded as known: it fails the run by itself, as CasBench's does. + var timedOut = new HashSet(results.Where(r => r.Verdict == Verdict.Timeout).Select(r => r.Row.Id)); + var findings = results + .Where(r => r.Verdict is not (Verdict.Timeout or Verdict.Wrong or Verdict.BadRow)) + .Select(r => $"{r.Row.Id}\t{r.Verdict}"); + var baseline = Harness.Baseline.Check( + "modenov-baseline.tsv", + "modenovcorpus: a row of modenov.tsv and the verdict it earns. A timed-out row is unmeasured and not listed.", + findings, + line => timedOut.Contains(line.Split('\t')[0])); + return failed || baseline != 0 ? 1 : 0; + } + + // ---------- the data ---------- + + private static List Load(string path) + { + var rows = new List(); + var ids = new HashSet(); + var lines = File.ReadAllLines(path); + for (int n = 0; n < lines.Length; n++) + { + var line = lines[n]; + if (line.Length == 0 || line.StartsWith("#", StringComparison.Ordinal)) + continue; + var f = line.Split('\t'); + if (f.Length != 8) + throw new InvalidDataException($"modenov.tsv:{n + 1}: {f.Length} fields, not 8"); + var op = f[2] switch + { + "zero" => Op.Zero, + "equal" => Op.Equal, + "solve" => Op.Solve, + "erratum" => Op.Erratum, + _ => throw new InvalidDataException($"modenov.tsv:{n + 1}: unknown op '{f[2]}'"), + }; + if (f[6].Length != 1 || "CRPU-".IndexOf(f[6][0]) < 0) + throw new InvalidDataException($"modenov.tsv:{n + 1}: unknown points '{f[6]}'"); + if (!ids.Add(f[0]) || f[0].IndexOf('.') < 1) + throw new InvalidDataException($"modenov.tsv:{n + 1}: id '{f[0]}' is repeated or has no chapter"); + rows.Add(new Row(f[0], f[1], op, f[3], f[4], f[5], f[6][0], f[7], n + 1)); + } + return rows; + } + + private static string ProjectDirectory() + => Directory.GetParent(AppContext.BaseDirectory).Parent.Parent.Parent.FullName; + + // ---------- running ---------- + + /// + /// Each row runs on its own thread so that a hang costs the budget and not the run. The + /// thread is abandoned, not killed: .NET cannot abort a thread. + /// + private static Result RunWithBudget(Row row) + { + var sw = System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch.StartNew(); + Result result = null; + var done = new ManualResetEventSlim(false); + var t = new Thread(() => + { + try { result = Run(row, sw); } + catch (Exception e) { result = new Result(row, Verdict.Error, "", Short(e), sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); } + finally { done.Set(); } + }, 64 * 1024 * 1024); + t.IsBackground = true; + t.Start(); + if (!done.Wait(Budget)) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Timeout, "", $"no answer in {Budget.TotalSeconds:0}s", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + return result; + } + + private static Result Run(Row row, System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch sw) + { + Entity input, expected = null; + try + { + input = row.Input.ToEntity(); + if (row.Expected != "-") + expected = row.Expected.ToEntity(); + } + catch (Exception e) + { + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", "does not parse: " + Short(e), sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + return row.Op switch + { + Op.Zero => RunZero(row, input, sw), + Op.Equal => RunEqual(row, input, expected, sw), + Op.Erratum => RunErratum(row, input, expected, sw), + Op.Solve => RunSolve(row, input, expected, sw), + _ => throw new InvalidOperationException(), + }; + } + + /// An identity: the input is 0 wherever it has a value, and Simplify is to say so. + private static Result RunZero(Row row, Entity input, System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch sw) + { + var samples = Samples(row.Points, Free(input)); + var claim = Vanishes(input, samples); + if (claim is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", "the row's identity does not hold: " + claim, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + + var simplified = input.Simplify(); + var text = simplified.Stringize(); + if (Bare(simplified) == 0) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Solved, text, "reduced to 0", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + var moved = Disagrees(simplified, input, samples); + return moved is not null + ? new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, "Simplify changed the value: " + moved, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds) + : new Result(row, Verdict.Unsolved, text, "0 by value, not reduced to 0", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + + /// + /// A reduction the book gives: Simplify of the input is to equal the book's form by value + /// and be no larger than it, which is how CasBench decides that a target form was reached. + /// + private static Result RunEqual(Row row, Entity input, Entity expected, System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch sw) + { + var samples = Samples(row.Points, Free(input).Concat(Free(expected))); + var claim = Vanishes(input - expected, samples); + if (claim is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", "the row's equality does not hold: " + claim, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + + var simplified = input.Simplify(); + var text = simplified.Stringize(); + var moved = Disagrees(simplified, input, samples); + if (moved is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, "Simplify changed the value: " + moved, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + var bare = Bare(simplified); + var target = expected.Simplify(); + var reached = bare == Bare(target) || bare.Nodes.Count() <= Bare(target).Nodes.Count(); + return reached + ? new Result(row, Verdict.Solved, text, $"reached {row.Expected}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds) + : new Result(row, Verdict.Unsolved, text, $"equal by value, not reduced to {row.Expected}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + + /// + /// An error in the book: the input is not the form the book printed. The library must not + /// confirm the printed form, neither by reducing the difference to 0 nor by deciding the + /// equality true; giving the right value or leaving it undecided are both correct. + /// + private static Result RunErratum(Row row, Entity input, Entity printed, System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch sw) + { + var difference = input - printed; + var samples = Samples(row.Points, Free(difference)); + if (!DiffersSomewhere(difference, samples, out var why)) + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", "the erratum is not confirmed by value: " + why, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + + var simplified = difference.Simplify(); + var text = simplified.Stringize(); + if (Bare(simplified) == 0) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, "confirms the book's printed form: the difference reduces to 0", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + var statement = ((Entity)MathS.Equality(input, printed)).Simplify(); + if (Bare(statement) == MathS.Boolean.True) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, statement.Stringize(), "confirms the book's printed form: the equality simplifies to true", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + var moved = Disagrees(simplified, difference, samples); + return moved is not null + ? new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, "Simplify changed the value of the difference: " + moved, sw.ElapsedMilliseconds) + : new Result(row, Verdict.Refused, text, "the printed form is not confirmed", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + + /// + /// An equation: every root returned satisfies it, at every sample of the parameters, and + /// every root the book gives is among them. A finite set missing a root claims there is + /// none, so it is wrong, not unsolved. + /// + private static Result RunSolve(Row row, Entity statement, Entity expectedSet, System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch sw) + { + var x = MathS.Var(row.Var); + if (statement is not Entity.Equalsf eq || expectedSet is not Entity.Set.FiniteSet expectedRoots) + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", "a solve row is an equation and a finite set of roots", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + var residual = eq.Left - eq.Right; + var parameters = Free(statement).Where(v => v != x).ToArray(); + var samples = Samples(row.Points, parameters); + // A family of roots, 2 pi n_1 + pi / 3, carries an integer of its own: the book's + // families are bound to a few integers, the library's to a wider range around them. + var expectedConcrete = Concrete(expectedRoots, parameters, x, 1); + foreach (var root in expectedConcrete) + { + var claim = Vanishes(residual.Substitute(x, root), samples); + if (claim is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.BadRow, "", $"the book's root {root.Stringize()} does not satisfy the equation: {claim}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + + var solutions = statement.Solve(x); + var text = solutions.Stringize(); + if (solutions is not Entity.Set.FiniteSet found) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Unsolved, text, "not a finite set; not verified", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + + var foundConcrete = Concrete(found, parameters, x, 4); + foreach (var root in foundConcrete) + { + var fails = Vanishes(residual.Substitute(x, root), samples); + if (fails is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, $"{root.Stringize()} is not a root: {fails}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + foreach (var root in expectedConcrete) + { + var missing = Missing(root, foundConcrete, samples); + if (missing is not null) + return new Result(row, Verdict.Wrong, text, $"the root {root.Stringize()} is missing: {missing}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + var size = found.Sum(r => r.Nodes.Count()); + var target = expectedRoots.Sum(r => r.Simplify().Nodes.Count()); + return size <= target + ? new Result(row, Verdict.Solved, text, $"{found.Count} root(s) verified, complete", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds) + : new Result(row, Verdict.Unsolved, text, $"roots verified and complete, not reduced to {row.Expected}", sw.ElapsedMilliseconds); + } + + /// + /// The roots of a set with each family's own integer bound to every value from -reach to + /// reach; a root without one is itself. + /// + private static List Concrete(IEnumerable roots, Entity.Variable[] parameters, Entity.Variable x, int reach) + { + var concrete = new List(); + foreach (var root in roots) + { + var own = Free(root).Where(v => v != x && !parameters.Contains(v)).ToArray(); + if (own.Length == 0) + { + concrete.Add(root); + continue; + } + for (int n = -reach; n <= reach; n++) + concrete.Add(own.Aggregate(root, (r, v) => r.Substitute(v, n))); + } + return concrete; + } + + // ---------- sampling ---------- + // + // Exact rationals, so that a sample point adds no rounding of its own: abs of a point of the + // unit pool is exactly 1 and its conjugate is exactly its reciprocal. Each pool mixes signs + // and quadrants, and keeps away from 0, 1 and -1, where the book's denominators vanish. + + private static readonly string[] Complex = + { + "37/100 + 61/100*i", "-121/100 + 43/100*i", "19/10 - 7/10*i", "-53/100 - 137/100*i", "23/10 + 11/10*i", + "-17/10 - 29/100*i", "7/9 + 13/7*i", "-5/11 + 9/4*i", "41/20 - 33/20*i", "-3/7 - 2/9*i", + "13/8 + 1/3*i", "-29/12 + 17/10*i", "11/17 - 23/9*i", "-9/5 - 13/11*i", "31/30 + 47/20*i", + "-1/3 + 5/6*i", "17/9 - 1/8*i", + }; + + private static readonly string[] RealPool = + { + "37/100", "-121/100", "19/10", "-53/100", "231/100", "-17/10", "7/9", "-5/11", "41/20", "-3/7", + "13/8", "-29/12", "11/17", "-9/5", "31/30", "-1/3", "17/9", + }; + + private static readonly string[] Positive = + { + "37/100", "121/100", "19/10", "53/100", "231/100", "17/10", "7/9", "5/11", "41/20", "3/7", + "13/8", "29/12", "11/17", "9/5", "31/30", "1/3", "17/9", + }; + + // Pythagorean triples: (a/c)^2 + (b/c)^2 = 1 exactly. + private static readonly string[] Unit = + { + "3/5 + 4/5*i", "-5/13 + 12/13*i", "-8/17 - 15/17*i", "7/25 - 24/25*i", "20/29 + 21/29*i", + "-12/37 - 35/37*i", "40/41 - 9/41*i", "-28/53 + 45/53*i", "11/61 + 60/61*i", "-56/65 - 33/65*i", + "63/65 + 16/65*i", "-48/73 + 55/73*i", "13/85 - 84/85*i", "-77/85 - 36/85*i", "39/89 + 80/89*i", + "-72/97 + 65/97*i", "99/101 - 20/101*i", + }; + + private static readonly Dictionary Parsed = new(); + + private static Entity Parse(string text) + { + lock (Parsed) + { + if (!Parsed.TryGetValue(text, out var v)) + Parsed[text] = v = text.ToEntity().EvalNumerical(); + return v; + } + } + + private const int SampleCount = 6; + + /// + /// Six assignments of the row's free variables, drawn from the pool its points field names. + /// Within one assignment every variable gets a different value, so no difference of two + /// variables vanishes by accident. + /// + private static List> Samples(char points, IEnumerable variables) + { + var vars = variables.Distinct().OrderBy(v => v.Name, StringComparer.Ordinal).ToArray(); + var pool = points switch { 'R' => RealPool, 'P' => Positive, 'U' => Unit, _ => Complex }; + var samples = new List>(); + for (int i = 0; i < (vars.Length == 0 ? 1 : SampleCount); i++) + { + var s = new Dictionary(); + for (int v = 0; v < vars.Length; v++) + s[vars[v]] = Parse(pool[(5 * i + v) % pool.Length]); + samples.Add(s); + } + return samples; + } + + /// + /// The variables a value has to be given for: not a constant such as pi, and not a name a + /// binder declares, as the index of a sum or the variable of a limit. + /// + private static IEnumerable Free(Entity e) => e.FreeVariables.Where(v => !v.IsConstant); + + private static Entity Bare(Entity e) + { + while (e is Entity.Providedf(var inner, _)) + e = inner; + return e; + } + + /// + /// A value at a sample: one number, or the entries of a vector or matrix, which the + /// first chapters of the book compute with. + /// + private sealed record Value(Entity.Number.Complex[] Parts) + { + public double Size => Parts.Max(Magnitude); + + /// How far apart two values are; infinite when their shapes differ. + public double From(Value other) + => Parts.Length != other.Parts.Length + ? double.PositiveInfinity + : Parts.Zip(other.Parts, (a, b) => Magnitude((Entity.Number.Complex)(a - b).EvalNumerical())).Max(); + } + + /// The value at a sample, or null where there is none. + private static Value At(Entity e, Dictionary sample) + { + try + { + // A derivative is taken before its variable is given a value, which would + // otherwise differentiate with respect to a number. + var bare = Bare(e); + if (bare.Nodes.Any(n => n is Entity.Derivativef)) + bare = bare.Evaled; + var substituted = bare.Substitute(sample); + Entity.Number.Complex[] parts; + if (substituted.Nodes.Any(n => n is Entity.Matrix)) + { + // A dot product written aT * b is a matrix expression with a number for a value. + var evaled = substituted.Evaled; + parts = evaled is Entity.Matrix m + ? Enumerable.Range(0, m.RowCount).SelectMany(r => Enumerable.Range(0, m.ColumnCount).Select(c => m[r, c].EvalNumerical())).ToArray() + : new[] { evaled.EvalNumerical() }; + } + else + parts = new[] { substituted.EvalNumerical() }; + var v = new Value(parts); + return double.IsNaN(v.Size) || double.IsInfinity(v.Size) ? null : v; + } + catch { return null; } + } + + private static double Magnitude(Entity.Number.Complex c) + { + try + { + var re = c.RealPart.EDecimal.ToDouble(); + var im = c.ImaginaryPart.EDecimal.ToDouble(); + return Math.Sqrt(re * re + im * im); + } + catch { return double.NaN; } + } + + /// + /// How large the terms of a sum are at a sample, so that a cancellation is judged relative + /// to what cancelled, not to 1. + /// + private static double Scale(Entity e, Dictionary sample) + { + var scale = 1.0; + var stack = new Stack(); + stack.Push(Bare(e)); + while (stack.Count > 0) + { + var node = stack.Pop(); + if (node is Entity.Sumf or Entity.Minusf) + { + foreach (var child in node.DirectChildren) + stack.Push(child); + continue; + } + var v = At(node, sample); + if (v is not null) + scale = Math.Max(scale, v.Size); + } + return scale; + } + + private const double Tolerance = 1e-8; + private const int Required = 3; + + /// Null when the expression is 0 at every sample where it has a value, and at enough of them. + private static string Vanishes(Entity e, List> samples) + { + int usable = 0; + for (int i = 0; i < samples.Count; i++) + { + var v = At(e, samples[i]); + if (v is null) continue; + usable++; + var m = v.Size; + if (m > Tolerance * Scale(e, samples[i])) + return $"{m:0.###e+0} at sample {i}"; + } + return usable >= Math.Min(Required, samples.Count) ? null : $"a value at only {usable} of {samples.Count} samples"; + } + + private static bool DiffersSomewhere(Entity e, List> samples, out string why) + { + why = "0 at every sample with a value"; + for (int i = 0; i < samples.Count; i++) + { + var v = At(e, samples[i]); + if (v is not null && v.Size > 1e-6 * Scale(e, samples[i])) + return true; + } + return false; + } + + /// + /// Null when the answer has the input's value wherever the input has one. An answer with no + /// value where the input has one disagrees too: it says there is nothing there. + /// + private static string Disagrees(Entity answer, Entity input, List> samples) + { + for (int i = 0; i < samples.Count; i++) + { + var want = At(input, samples[i]); + if (want is null) continue; + var got = At(answer, samples[i]); + if (got is null) + return $"no value at sample {i}, where the input is {want.Size:0.###e+0} in size"; + var diff = got.From(want); + if (diff > 1e-6 * Math.Max(Scale(input, samples[i]), want.Size)) + return $"differs by {diff:0.###e+0} at sample {i}"; + } + return null; + } + + /// Null when, at every sample, the expected root's value is the value of one of the roots found. + private static string Missing(Entity root, List found, List> samples) + { + for (int i = 0; i < samples.Count; i++) + { + var want = At(root, samples[i]); + if (want is null) continue; + var hit = found.Any(r => + { + var got = At(r, samples[i]); + return got is not null + && got.From(want) <= 1e-6 * Math.Max(1, want.Size); + }); + if (!hit) + return $"no root found has its value at sample {i}"; + } + return null; + } + + // ---------- reporting ---------- + + private static void Report(List results, TimeSpan elapsed) + { + var verdicts = Enum.GetValues(); + var sb = new StringBuilder(); + sb.AppendLine("# Modenov's computations as a corpus"); + sb.AppendLine(); + sb.AppendLine($"Measured against `{Harness.Measured.Commit()}`, in {elapsed.TotalSeconds:0} s."); + sb.AppendLine(); + sb.AppendLine($"{results.Count} rows from Modenov, *Problems in Geometry* (Mir, 1981), {Budget.TotalSeconds:0} s budget each."); + sb.AppendLine("An identity is verified at exact sample points from its row's domain before Simplify is asked;"); + sb.AppendLine("a root is substituted back and the book's roots must all be found; an erratum must not be confirmed."); + sb.AppendLine("https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/issues/2153"); + sb.AppendLine(); + Table(sb, "Chapter", results.GroupBy(r => r.Row.Chapter), verdicts); + Table(sb, "Operation", results.GroupBy(r => r.Row.Op.ToString().ToLowerInvariant()), verdicts); + + sb.AppendLine("## Every row"); + sb.AppendLine(); + sb.AppendLine("| Row | Source | Op | Verdict | Answer | Note | ms |"); + sb.AppendLine("|---|---|---|---|---|---|--:|"); + foreach (var r in results) + sb.AppendLine($"| `{r.Row.Id}` | {Esc(r.Row.Source)} | {r.Row.Op.ToString().ToLowerInvariant()} | {r.Verdict} " + + $"| `{Esc(Trunc(r.Answer, 60))}` | {Esc(Trunc(r.Note, 80))} | {r.Ms} |"); + + var path = Harness.Reports.PathFor("modenov.md"); + File.WriteAllText(path, sb.ToString()); + Console.Error.WriteLine($"\nwrote {path}"); + Console.WriteLine($"OVERALL {results.Count} rows in {elapsed.TotalSeconds:0} s: " + + string.Join(", ", verdicts.Select(v => $"{results.Count(r => r.Verdict == v)} {v.ToString().ToLowerInvariant()}"))); + } + + private static void Table(StringBuilder sb, string what, IEnumerable> groups, Verdict[] verdicts) + { + sb.AppendLine($"## By {what.ToLowerInvariant()}"); + sb.AppendLine(); + sb.AppendLine($"| {what} | Rows | {string.Join(" | ", verdicts)} |"); + sb.AppendLine($"|---|--:|{string.Concat(verdicts.Select(_ => "--:|"))}"); + foreach (var g in groups.OrderBy(g => g.Key, StringComparer.Ordinal)) + sb.AppendLine($"| {g.Key} | {g.Count()} | {string.Join(" | ", verdicts.Select(v => g.Count(r => r.Verdict == v)))} |"); + sb.AppendLine(); + } + + private static string Short(Exception e) + { + var ex = e is AggregateException ae ? ae.InnerException ?? e : e; + var m = ex.Message.Replace("\n", " ").Replace("\r", ""); + return $"{ex.GetType().Name}: {(m.Length > 90 ? m.Substring(0, 90) + "..." : m)}"; + } + + private static string Trunc(string s, int n) => + string.IsNullOrEmpty(s) ? "" : s.Length <= n ? s : s.Substring(0, n) + "..."; + + private static string Esc(string s) => (s ?? "").Replace("|", "\\|"); + } +} diff --git a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov-baseline.tsv b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov-baseline.tsv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f013ebeef --- /dev/null +++ b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov-baseline.tsv @@ -0,0 +1,645 @@ +# modenovcorpus: a row of modenov.tsv and the verdict it earns. A timed-out row is unmeasured and not listed. +# One line per finding, tab separated, sorted. Generated by the harness, not edited by hand: +# to update it, run the harness with HARNESS_UPDATE_BASELINE=1 and commit it with the change that moved it. +I.Ex1.a Solved +I.Ex10.a Unsolved +I.Ex11.a Unsolved +I.Ex13.a Unsolved +I.Ex13.b Unsolved +I.Ex13.c Solved +I.Ex14.a Unsolved +I.Ex14.b Solved +I.Ex16.a Solved +I.Ex17.a Solved +I.Ex2.a Solved +I.Ex21.a Solved +I.Ex21.b Unsolved +I.Ex22.a Solved +I.Ex25.Er Refused +I.Ex25.a Solved +I.Ex26.a Solved +I.Ex26.b Unsolved +I.Ex3.a Solved +I.Ex9.a Solved +I.P1.1.a Unsolved +I.P1.1.b Solved +I.P1.2.a Solved +I.P1.2.b Solved +I.P1.3.a Solved +I.P1.3.b Solved +I.P1.3.c Solved +I.P1.3.d Solved +I.P1.4.Er Refused +I.P1.4.a Solved +I.P1.4.b Solved +I.P1.5.a Solved +I.P1.5.b Solved +I.P1.6.a Unsolved +I.P2.1.a Solved +I.P2.1.b Solved +I.P2.1.c Solved +I.P2.1.d Solved +I.P2.1.e Solved +I.P2.3.Er Refused +I.P2.3.a Solved +I.P2.3.b Solved +I.P2.3.c Solved +I.P2.3.d Solved +I.P2.5.a Solved +I.P2.5.b Solved +I.P2.6.a Solved +I.P2.6.b Solved +I.P2.6.c Unsolved +I.Pref1.a Solved +I.Pref2.a Solved +I.Pref7.Er1 Refused +I.Pref7.Er2 Refused +I.Pref7.Er3 Refused +I.Pref7.Er3c Solved +II.Def0.a Solved +II.E1 Refused +II.E3.a Refused +II.E3.b Refused +II.E3.c Solved +II.E4 Refused +II.E5 Refused +II.E5.c Unsolved +II.E6 Refused +II.E6.c Unsolved +II.Ex1.a Solved +II.Ex11.a Solved +II.Ex13.a Solved +II.Ex17.a Unsolved +II.Ex18.a Solved +II.Ex22.a Solved +II.Ex22.b Solved +II.Ex22.c Solved +II.Ex23.a Solved +II.Ex24.a Solved +II.Ex25.a Solved +II.Ex27.a Solved +II.Ex27.b Solved +II.Ex3.a Unsolved +II.Ex38.a Solved +II.Ex39.a Solved +II.Ex40.a Solved +II.Ex42.a Unsolved +II.Ex5.a Solved +II.Ex6.a Solved +II.Ex6.b Solved +II.Ex6.c Unsolved +II.Ex7.a Solved +II.Ex9.a Solved +II.P1.a Solved +II.P1.b Solved +II.P10.a Unsolved +II.P11.1.a Solved +II.P11.10.a Solved +II.P11.10.b Unsolved +II.P11.10.c Solved +II.P11.13.a Unsolved +II.P11.14.a Solved +II.P11.3.a Solved +II.P11.5.a Unsolved +II.P11.5.b Solved +II.P11.6.a Solved +II.P11.7.a Solved +II.P11.8.a Unsolved +II.P11.9.a Solved +II.P11R6.a Solved +II.P2.a Solved +II.P3.a Solved +II.P4def.a Unsolved +II.P5.a Unsolved +II.P5.b Solved +II.P6.a Solved +II.P7.a Unsolved +II.P9.a Unsolved +II.S1.a Solved +II.S4.a Solved +II.S4.b Solved +III.E1 Refused +III.E1.a Refused +III.E1.b Solved +III.E1.c Refused +III.E1.corr Solved +III.E1.d Solved +III.E10 Refused +III.E10.corr Solved +III.E3 Refused +III.E3.a Refused +III.E4 Refused +III.E4.a Refused +III.E5 Refused +III.E5.a Refused +III.E5.b Solved +III.E6 Refused +III.E7 Refused +III.E7.a Refused +III.E7.corr Solved +III.E8 Refused +III.E8.corr Solved +III.E9 Refused +III.E9.corr Solved +III.Ex1.1 Solved +III.Ex1.10 Solved +III.Ex1.10.alone Unsolved +III.Ex1.2 Solved +III.Ex1.3 Solved +III.Ex1.4 Solved +III.Ex1.5 Solved +III.Ex1.6 Solved +III.Ex1.7 Solved +III.Ex1.8 Solved +III.Ex1.8.alone Unsolved +III.Ex1.9 Solved +III.Ex1.9.alone Unsolved +III.Ex1.c Solved +III.Ex1.s1 Solved +III.Ex1.s2 Solved +III.Ex1.s3 Unsolved +III.Ex12 Unsolved +III.Ex14.1 Solved +III.Ex14.14 Solved +III.Ex14.15 Solved +III.Ex14.16.err Refused +III.Ex14.16a Solved +III.Ex14.16b Solved +III.Ex14.16c Solved +III.Ex14.17 Solved +III.Ex14.17.err Refused +III.Ex14.18a Solved +III.Ex14.18b Solved +III.Ex14.19 Solved +III.Ex14.2 Solved +III.Ex14.20 Solved +III.Ex14.21 Solved +III.Ex14.22 Solved +III.Ex14.24a Solved +III.Ex14.24b Solved +III.Ex14.24c Solved +III.Ex14.ac Solved +III.Ex14.bc1 Solved +III.Ex14.bc2 Solved +III.Ex14.cosA Solved +III.Ex14.cosB Solved +III.Ex14.cosC1 Solved +III.Ex14.cosC2 Solved +III.Ex14.pcos.alone Solved +III.Ex14.psin Solved +III.Ex14.psin.alone Unsolved +III.Ex14.ptan Solved +III.Ex14.ptan.alone Unsolved +III.Ex14.scc.alone Solved +III.Ex14.scos1 Solved +III.Ex14.scos2 Solved +III.Ex14.scos2.alone Solved +III.Ex14.sq.alone Solved +III.Ex14.ssin2.alone Solved +III.Ex15.a Solved +III.Ex15.b Solved +III.Ex16 Solved +III.Ex17 Solved +III.Ex18 Solved +III.Ex19 Solved +III.Ex2.1a Solved +III.Ex2.1b Unsolved +III.Ex2.1c Solved +III.Ex2.1d Solved +III.Ex2.1e Solved +III.Ex2.2 Solved +III.Ex20.a Solved +III.Ex20.b Solved +III.Ex20.c Unsolved +III.Ex20.err Refused +III.Ex22 Solved +III.Ex23 Solved +III.Ex24 Solved +III.Ex25 Solved +III.Ex26 Unsolved +III.Ex27 Solved +III.Ex29 Solved +III.Ex3 Solved +III.Ex31 Solved +III.Ex35 Unsolved +III.Ex36 Solved +III.Ex37.1 Solved +III.Ex37.6a Solved +III.Ex37.6b Solved +III.Ex4.2a Unsolved +III.Ex4.2b Solved +III.Ex4.2c Solved +III.Ex4.3 Solved +III.Ex6 Solved +III.Ex8.a Solved +III.Ex8.b Solved +III.Ex9.a Solved +III.Ex9.b Solved +III.P1.1.a Solved +III.P1.1.b Solved +III.P1.1.c Solved +III.P1.1.d Solved +III.P1.2.a Solved +III.P1.2.b Unsolved +III.P1.3.a Unsolved +III.P1.3.b Solved +III.P10a.a Solved +III.P10a.b Solved +III.P10a.c Solved +III.P10b.E1 Refused +III.P10b.E1c Solved +III.P10c.a Solved +III.P11.1.a Solved +III.P11.1.b Solved +III.P11.1.c Solved +III.P11.2.a Solved +III.P11.2.b Solved +III.P11.3.a Solved +III.P11.4.a Solved +III.P11.6.a Solved +III.P11.7.a Solved +III.P11.9.a Solved +III.P11.n.a Solved +III.P12a.a Solved +III.P12b.a Solved +III.P12c.a Unsolved +III.P12c.b Solved +III.P13.1.alt.a Solved +III.P13.1.alt.b Solved +III.P13.1.alt.c Solved +III.P13.1.forces Solved +III.P13.1.line Unsolved +III.P13.1.nested Solved +III.P13.1.pqr Solved +III.P13.1.slope Solved +III.P13.1.sq Solved +III.P13.2.line0 Unsolved +III.P13.2.lineh Unsolved +III.P13.2.sq Solved +III.P13.R.det Solved +III.P14.area1 Unsolved +III.P14.area2 Solved +III.P14.c0 Solved +III.P14.final Unsolved +III.P15.1.foot Solved +III.P15.1.mod Solved +III.P15.2 Solved +III.P15.V2.det Solved +III.P16.centroid Solved +III.P16.g Solved +III.P16.g2 Solved +III.P16.g3 Solved +III.P16.sqrt Solved +III.P17.factor Unsolved +III.P17.solve Unsolved +III.P17.solvef Solved +III.P18.1.p1 Solved +III.P18.1.trig Solved +III.P18.1.trig2 Solved +III.P18.2 Solved +III.P18.2.err Refused +III.P18.3 Solved +III.P19.b1 Solved +III.P2.a Unsolved +III.P2.b Solved +III.P2.c Solved +III.P2.d Solved +III.P2.e Solved +III.P20.a1 Solved +III.P21.o Solved +III.P21.o2 Solved +III.P21.r Unsolved +III.P21.s Unsolved +III.P21.t Unsolved +III.P22.1 Solved +III.P22.2.cor Solved +III.P22.2.err1 Refused +III.P22.2.err2 Refused +III.P22.R Unsolved +III.P23.1.A Solved +III.P23.1.B Solved +III.P23.1.C Solved +III.P23.2.pow Solved +III.P23.2.sum Solved +III.P23.4.slope Solved +III.P24.1 Solved +III.P24.2.pivot Solved +III.P24.3 Solved +III.P24.4 Solved +III.P24.5 Solved +III.P24.setup.a Unsolved +III.P24.setup.b Solved +III.P24.setup.c Solved +III.P25.1 Solved +III.P25.2 Solved +III.P25.3.75 Solved +III.P25.3.lam Unsolved +III.P25.3.line Solved +III.P25.4.79 Unsolved +III.P25.4.equi Solved +III.P25.4.inv Unsolved +III.P25.5 Unsolved +III.P25.5.solve Solved +III.P25.6 Solved +III.P25.Q1.det Unsolved +III.P25.Q1.ratio Solved +III.P25.setup.chord Solved +III.P25.setup.perp Solved +III.P26.10 Unsolved +III.P26.11 Unsolved +III.P26.12 Solved +III.P26.13 Solved +III.P26.13.factor Unsolved +III.P26.13.solve Solved +III.P26.14 Solved +III.P26.2 Solved +III.P26.3 Solved +III.P26.5.a Solved +III.P26.5.b Solved +III.P26.5.c Unsolved +III.P26.7 Unsolved +III.P26.8 Unsolved +III.P26.82 Solved +III.P26.9 Solved +III.P27.Ap Solved +III.P29.alpha Solved +III.P29.radius Unsolved +III.P29.simson Solved +III.P30 Solved +III.P31.aprime Solved +III.P31.astar Solved +III.P31.dstar Solved +III.P31.mid Solved +III.P31.remark Solved +III.P32.1.conj Unsolved +III.P32.1.equi Solved +III.P32.2.R Unsolved +III.P32.2.lam Solved +III.P32.4 Unsolved +III.P32.5 Unsolved +III.P32.6.dist Unsolved +III.P32.6.phi0 Unsolved +III.P32.7.conj Solved +III.P32.7.lemma Solved +III.P32.7.phi1 Unsolved +III.P32.7.ra Solved +III.P32.7.t1 Solved +III.P32.7.ta Solved +III.P32.7.u1 Solved +III.P33.a Solved +III.P33.b Solved +III.P33.c Solved +III.P34.a Solved +III.P34.b Unsolved +III.P34.c Solved +III.P34.d Solved +III.P34.e Solved +III.P34.f Solved +III.P34.g Unsolved +III.P34.h Solved +III.P34.i Unsolved +III.P35.a Unsolved +III.P35.b Solved +III.P35.c Solved +III.P35.d Solved +III.P35.e Solved +III.P36.a Unsolved +III.P36.b Solved +III.P36.c Solved +III.P37.a Unsolved +III.P37.b Solved +III.P37.c Solved +III.P37.d Solved +III.P38.a Solved +III.P38.b Solved +III.P38.c Solved +III.P38.d Solved +III.P39.a Solved +III.P39.b Unsolved +III.P39.c Unsolved +III.P39.d Solved +III.P39.e Solved +III.P39.f Solved +III.P39.g Solved +III.P3b.a Unsolved +III.P3b.b Unsolved +III.P3b.c Unsolved +III.P3b.d Solved +III.P4.a Solved +III.P40.a Solved +III.P40.b Solved +III.P40.c Solved +III.P40.d Unsolved +III.P40.e Solved +III.P41.a Solved +III.P41.b Solved +III.P41.c Solved +III.P41.d Unsolved +III.P41.e Unsolved +III.P42.a Solved +III.P42.b Solved +III.P42.c Solved +III.P42.d Solved +III.P43.a Solved +III.P43.b Solved +III.P44.a Solved +III.P45.a Solved +III.P45.b Solved +III.P45.c Solved +III.P45.d Solved +III.P45.e Solved +III.P45.f Solved +III.P5.1.a Solved +III.P5.2.a Solved +III.P6.1.a Unsolved +III.P6.2.a Solved +III.P6.3.a Solved +III.P6.5.a Solved +III.P9.E2 Refused +III.P9.E2c Solved +III.P9.a Unsolved +III.P9.b Solved +III.P9.c1 Solved +III.P9.c2 Solved +III.P9.c3 Solved +III.P9.c4 Solved +III.P9.c5 Solved +III.P9.c6 Solved +IV.1c.a Solved +IV.1c.b Unsolved +IV.1c.c Unsolved +IV.1c.d Unsolved +IV.1d.a Solved +IV.1g.a Solved +IV.1g.b Solved +IV.1n.a Solved +IV.1p.a Solved +IV.1p.b Solved +IV.1p.c Solved +IV.2.10.a Solved +IV.2.10.b Solved +IV.2.10.c Solved +IV.2.10.d Solved +IV.2.2.a Solved +IV.2.2.b Solved +IV.2.2.c Solved +IV.2.3.a Solved +IV.2.4.a Unsolved +IV.2.4.b Solved +IV.2.4.c Solved +IV.2.5.a Solved +IV.2.6.a Unsolved +IV.2.6.b Solved +IV.2.6.c Solved +IV.2.7.a Solved +IV.2.8.a Solved +IV.3.11.a Solved +IV.3.12.a Solved +IV.3.14.a Solved +IV.3.14.c Solved +IV.3.6.a Solved +IV.4.1.a Solved +IV.4.2.a Solved +IV.4.2.b Solved +IV.5.2.a Solved +IV.5.9.a Solved +IV.5.9.b Solved +IV.6.12.a Solved +IV.6.12.b Unsolved +IV.6.12.c Solved +IV.6.12.d Solved +IV.6.12.e Solved +IV.6.13.a Solved +IV.6.13.b Unsolved +IV.6.14.a Solved +IV.6.15.a Solved +IV.6.15.b Solved +IV.6.16.a Solved +IV.6.16.b Solved +IV.6.5.a Solved +IV.E1 Refused +IV.E5 Refused +V.A1.a Unsolved +V.A1.b Unsolved +V.A10.a Solved +V.A10.b Solved +V.A10.c Solved +V.A10.d Solved +V.A10.e Solved +V.A11.1.a Solved +V.A11.3.a Solved +V.A11.5.a Solved +V.A11.6.a Solved +V.A12.a Solved +V.A12.b Solved +V.A12.c Solved +V.A13.a Solved +V.A2.a Solved +V.A2.b Solved +V.A3.a Solved +V.A7.a Solved +V.A7.b Solved +V.A7.c Solved +V.A8.a Solved +V.A8.b Solved +V.A9.a Solved +V.A9.b Solved +V.A9.c Solved +V.A9.d Solved +V.A9.e Solved +V.C1.a Solved +V.C12.a Solved +V.C12.b Solved +V.C13.a Solved +V.C14.a Solved +V.C14.b Solved +V.C14.c Solved +V.C15.a Solved +V.C15.b Solved +V.C15.c Solved +V.C16.a Solved +V.C18.a Solved +V.C19.a Unsolved +V.C19.b Unsolved +V.C19.c Unsolved +V.C21.a Solved +V.C22.a Solved +V.C22.b Solved +V.C23.a Solved +V.C24.a Solved +V.C24.b Solved +V.C3.a Solved +V.C3.b Solved +V.C7.a Solved +V.C7.b Solved +V.C8.a Solved +V.C9.a Unsolved +V.D1.a Solved +V.D12.a Solved +V.D12.b Solved +V.D2.a Solved +V.D4.a Solved +V.D5.a Solved +V.E1 Refused +V.E1.c Solved +V.E10 Refused +V.E11 Refused +V.E12 Refused +V.E13 Refused +V.E13.b Refused +V.E15 Refused +V.E16 Refused +V.E16.c Solved +V.E2 Refused +V.E20 Refused +V.E21 Refused +V.E22 Refused +V.E23 Refused +V.E24 Refused +V.E3 Refused +V.E3.c Solved +V.E4 Refused +V.E5 Refused +V.E5.c Solved +V.E8 Refused +V.E9 Refused +V.G11.a Solved +V.G15.a Solved +V.G19.a Solved +V.G22.a Solved +V.G25.a Solved +V.G27.a Solved +V.G27.b Solved +V.G28.a Solved +V.G28.b Solved +V.G29.a Solved +V.G29.b Solved +V.G38.a Solved +V.G38.b Solved +V.G4.a Unsolved +V.G41.a Solved +V.G42.a Solved +V.G49.a Solved +V.G50.a Solved +V.G53.a Solved +V.G6.a Unsolved +V.G7.a Unsolved +V.G8.a Solved +V.L.crossratio Solved +V.V17.a Solved +V.V20.a Solved +V.V21.a Solved +V.V22.a Solved +V.V23.a Solved +V.V27.a Solved +V.V28.a Solved +V.V29.a Solved +V.V29.b Solved +V.V3.a Solved +V.V3.b Unsolved +V.V30.a Solved +V.V31.a Solved +V.V31.b Solved +V.V31.c Unsolved +V.V7.a Solved +V.V9.a Solved diff --git a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov.tsv b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov.tsv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c11cdcf8c --- /dev/null +++ b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/ModenovCorpus/modenov.tsv @@ -0,0 +1,660 @@ +# Modenov's computations as a corpus: https://github.com/asc-community/AngouriMath/issues/2153 +# Source: P. S. Modenov, Problems in Geometry, translated by George Yankovsky, Mir, Moscow, 1981 +# (https://archive.org/details/ModenovProblemsInGeometryMir1981). Each row is a computation the book makes or rests on, +# cited in its source field by chapter, section and problem; the readings of #2131 found them, each checked by value. +# +# Fields, tab separated: id, source, op, var, input, expected, points, note. +# zero input is identically 0, and Simplify is to reduce it to 0 +# equal input equals expected, and Simplify of the input is to reach a form no larger than expected +# solve input is an equation in var, and expected is the book's whole root set +# erratum the book prints expected where the value is input's; the library must not confirm the printed form +# points is where every free variable may be sampled: C complex, R real, P positive, U the unit circle, - none. +# The harness checks each row's own claim by value before asking the library, and fails on a row that does not hold. +# A conjugate is written as the book does on the unit circle, 1/z, or as a symbol of its own; a determinant as det. +# The note says what the reading saw the library do at 725481ca4; the verdict now is in modenov-baseline.tsv. +# +# Not here, because the harness cannot compare their values: a set by condition (Ch II §2 Exercise 4), a limit +# that is infinite (Ch IV §3 Problem 14), sums to a natural n and an infinite sum convergent only for |q| < 1 +# (Ch V Appendix 4, 5, 6), and a congruence of angles (Ch V §2, p. 342). +I.Pref1.a Preface p. 7, [a] rotation equal - [[0, -1], [1, 0]] * [ax, ay] [-ay, ax] C [a] = a rotated through +pi/2, as a matrix; was [-ay, ax] (E1) +I.Pref2.a Preface p. 7, pseudo-scalar equal - det([[ax, ay], [bx, by]]) ax*by - ay*bx C plane pseudo-scalar product (a, b) as a determinant; was right via det_s API only (E3) +I.Pref7.Er1 Preface p. 8, Mobius map erratum - (a*z + b)/(c*z + d) (a*z + b)/(a*z + d) C printed az+d in the denominator; true (az+b)/(cz+d); a=1,b=2,c=0,d=2 makes the printed map constant 1 +I.Pref7.Er2 Preface p. 8, anti-Mobius map erratum - (a*conjugate(z) + b)/(c*conjugate(z) + d) (a*conjugate(z) + c)/(c*z + d) C printed +c and no bar below; true (a*conj(z)+b)/(c*conj(z)+d); conjugate was refused by name (E38) +I.Pref7.Er3 Preface p. 9, inversion erratum - a/conjugate(z) a/z C printed z' = a/z; true inversion a/conj(z); for a=1 it must fix z=i but 1/i = -i +I.Pref7.Er3c Preface p. 9, inversion equal - 1/conjugate(i) i - correction of I.Pref7.Er3: inversion in the unit circle fixes i +I.P1.1.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 1 zero - ([c, 0]T * [(c + b*cos(al))/2, b*sin(al)/2]) / (abs([c, 0]) * abs([(c + b*cos(al))/2, b*sin(al)/2])) - (c + b*cos(al))/sqrt(b^2 + c^2 + 2*b*c*cos(al)) - P cos of angle BAM via the median; was unreduced, sqrt(c^2) survived (E9) +I.P1.1.b Ch I Sec 1 Problem 1 zero - (a - b*cos(g))^2 + (b*sin(g))^2 - (a^2 + b^2 - 2*a*b*cos(g)) - C norm squared in coordinates; difference was 0, the left side alone unchanged (E10) +I.P1.2.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 2 zero - ((a*b*cos(g) + a*b)/(a + b) * (b*sin(g)/2) - (a*b*sin(g)/(a + b)) * ((a + b*cos(g))/2)) / (-(a*b*sin(g))) - (a - b)/(2*(a + b)) - C (CDM):(ABC) = (a-b)/(2(a+b)); was an un-normalised rational zero (E11) +I.P1.2.b Ch I Sec 1 Problem 2 zero - cos(x/2)^2 - (1 + cos(x))/2 - C half-angle identity used for cos(C/2); was unchanged (E12) +I.P1.3.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 3 equal - [b*sin(g), a - b*cos(g)]T * [a - 2*b*cos(g), -2*b*sin(g)] -a*b*sin(g) C pseudo-scalar step for cos AOC; was -a * b * sin(g) (E14) +I.P1.3.b Ch I Sec 1 Problem 3 zero - sin(A)^2 + sin(B)^2 - 2*sin(A)*sin(B)*cos(pi - A - B) - sin(A + B)^2 - C law of cosines in sines with C = pi - A - B; was unchanged (E13) +I.P1.3.c Ch I Sec 1 Problem 3 zero - cos(pi - A - B) + cos(A + B) - C cos(pi - x) reduction inside the law-of-sines step; was unchanged (E13) +I.P1.3.d Ch I Sec 1 Problem 3 zero - cos(a + b) - cos(a)*cos(b) + sin(a)*sin(b) - C angle addition used in the law-of-sines step; was unchanged (E12) +I.P1.4.Er Ch I Sec 1 Problem 4 erratum - ((bx^2 + by^2) * [-ay, ax] - (ax^2 + ay^2) * [-by, bx]) / (2*(ax*by - ay*bx)) ((bx^2 + by^2) * [-ay, ax] - (ax^2 + ay^2) * [-by, bx]) / (ax*by - ay*bx) C circumcentre printed without factor 1/2; a=(1,0), b=(0,1): printed (1,1), true (1/2,1/2) +I.P1.4.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 4 zero - [ax, ay]T * (((bx^2 + by^2) * [-ay, ax] - (ax^2 + ay^2) * [-by, bx]) / (2*(ax*by - ay*bx))) - (ax^2 + ay^2)/2 - C correction of I.P1.4.Er: x.a = a^2/2; was 0 with spurious 'not by = 0' (E15) +I.P1.4.b Ch I Sec 1 Problem 4 zero - [bx, by]T * (((bx^2 + by^2) * [-ay, ax] - (ax^2 + ay^2) * [-by, bx]) / (2*(ax*by - ay*bx))) - (bx^2 + by^2)/2 - C correction of I.P1.4.Er: x.b = b^2/2; 'the b equation gives the same' (E15) +I.P1.5.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 5 zero - [-ay, ax]T * ((p*[bx, by] - q*[ax, ay]) / (ax*by - ay*bx)) - p - C x = (pb - qa)/(a,b) satisfies (a,x) = p; was 0 provided (a,b) != 0 (E17) +I.P1.5.b Ch I Sec 1 Problem 5 zero - [-by, bx]T * ((p*[bx, by] - q*[ax, ay]) / (ax*by - ay*bx)) - q - C x = (pb - qa)/(a,b) satisfies (b,x) = q; was 0 provided (a,b) != 0 (E17) +I.P1.6.a Ch I Sec 1 Problem 6 solve y 3*(1 - x) - 2*(1 - y) + (2 - x) - 4*(4 - y) = 0 { (4*x + 13)/6 } C line of the resultant, 4x - 6y + 13 = 0; was right but uncollected (E18) +I.P2.1.a Ch I Sec 2 Problem 1 1deg zero - ((((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by)))*(((cy)*(dz) - (cz)*(dy))) + (((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz)))*(((cz)*(dx) - (cx)*(dz))) + (((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx)))*(((cx)*(dy) - (cy)*(dx)))) - (((ax)*(cx) + (ay)*(cy) + (az)*(cz))*((bx)*(dx) + (by)*(dy) + (bz)*(dz)) - ((ax)*(dx) + (ay)*(dy) + (az)*(dz))*((bx)*(cx) + (by)*(cy) + (bz)*(cz))) - C Lagrange identity [a,b].[c,d] in components; was 0 (E19) +I.P2.1.b Ch I Sec 2 Problem 1 2deg equal - cos(pi - a) -cos(a) C reciprocal trihedral angle a* = pi - A needs cos(pi - x); was unchanged (E12) +I.P2.1.c Ch I Sec 2 Problem 1 4deg zero - (cos(pi - A) - cos(pi - B)*cos(pi - C))/(sin(pi - B)*sin(pi - C)) + (cos(A) + cos(B)*cos(C))/(sin(B)*sin(C)) - C polar cosine formula from 1deg on the reciprocal angle; was left with cos(pi - A) (E22) +I.P2.1.d Ch I Sec 2 Problem 1 5deg equal - det([[1, cos(g), cos(be)], [cos(g), 1, cos(al)], [cos(be), cos(al), 1]]) 1 + 2*cos(al)*cos(be)*cos(g) - cos(al)^2 - cos(be)^2 - cos(g)^2 C Gram determinant of unit edge vectors; det_s was right, as ... + sin(al)^2 (E20) +I.P2.1.e Ch I Sec 2 Problem 1 5deg zero - 1 - ((cos(a) - cos(b)*cos(c))/(sin(b)*sin(c)))^2 - (1 + 2*cos(a)*cos(b)*cos(c) - cos(a)^2 - cos(b)^2 - cos(c)^2)/(sin(b)^2*sin(c)^2) - C 1 - cos^2 A = Delta^2/(sin^2 b sin^2 c); was unchanged (E21) +I.P2.3.a Ch I Sec 2 Problem 3 zero - (sin(a)^2 + sin(b)^2 + sin(c)^2 + 2*(cos(b)*cos(c) - cos(a)) + 2*(cos(c)*cos(a) - cos(b)) + 2*(cos(a)*cos(b) - cos(c))) - (1 + 2*cos(a)*cos(b)*cos(c) - cos(a)^2 - cos(b)^2 - cos(c)^2) - 2*(1 - cos(a))*(1 - cos(b))*(1 - cos(c)) - C T1 - T2 = 2(1-cos a)(1-cos b)(1-cos c); was 0 (E23) +I.P2.3.b Ch I Sec 2 Problem 3 zero - (sin(a)^2 + sin(b)^2 + sin(c)^2 + 2*(cos(b)*cos(c) - cos(a)) + 2*(cos(c)*cos(a) - cos(b)) + 2*(cos(a)*cos(b) - cos(c))) - (1 + 2*cos(a)*cos(b)*cos(c) - cos(a)^2 - cos(b)^2 - cos(c)^2) - 16*sin(a/2)^2*sin(b/2)^2*sin(c/2)^2 - C T1 - T2 = 16 prod sin^2(./2); was left nonzero-looking (E23) +I.P2.3.c Ch I Sec 2 Problem 3 zero - 1 - cos(a) - 2*sin(a/2)^2 - C half-angle step of T1 - T2; was unchanged (E12) +I.P2.3.Er Ch I Sec 2 Problem 3 erratum - tan(arccos(2/sqrt(6))) 4*sin(pi/6)^3/(1 + 2*cos(pi/3)^3 - 3*cos(pi/3)^2) - tan phi at a=b=c=pi/3 printed over Delta (gives 1); true over sqrt(Delta), 1/sqrt(2) (E24) +I.P2.3.d Ch I Sec 2 Problem 3 equal - 4*sin(pi/6)^3/sqrt(1 + 2*cos(pi/3)^3 - 3*cos(pi/3)^2) tan(arccos(2/sqrt(6))) - correction of I.P2.3.Er: both evaluated to 0.70710678... (E24) +I.P2.5.a Ch I Sec 2 Problem 5 3deg zero - 2*(sin(p)/(cos(q)*cos(r)))*(-tan(q)*tan(r))/cos(p)^2 + 2*sin(p)*sin(q)*sin(r)/(cos(p)^2*cos(q)^2*cos(r)^2) - C sin 2beta_i/cos^2 alpha_i from 1deg and 2deg; was 0 provided cos p cos q cos r != 0 (E26) +I.P2.5.b Ch I Sec 2 Problem 5 1deg zero - (s^2 + t^2*(1 - s^2 - t^2))/((1 - t^2)*(1 - (1 - s^2 - t^2))) - 1 - C 1deg/2deg consistency, side relation substituted by hand; was 0 with a condition (E26) +I.P2.6.a Ch I Sec 2 Problem 6 equal - [((cc - bb)*(0) - (2*h)*(-1)), ((2*h)*(0) - (-pa)*(0)), ((-pa)*(-1) - (cc - bb)*(0))] [2*h, 0, pa] C wedge: y x x written in components; was [2 * h, 0, pa] (E27) +I.P2.6.b Ch I Sec 2 Problem 6 equal - [((cc - bb)*(0) - (2*h)*(0)), ((2*h)*(-1) - (-pa)*(0)), ((-pa)*(0) - (cc - bb)*(-1))] [0, -2*h, cc - bb] C wedge: y x z written in components; was [0, (-2) * h, cc - bb] (E27) +I.P2.6.c Ch I Sec 2 Problem 6 equal - [2*h, 0, pa]T * [0, -2*h, cc - bb] / (abs([2*h, 0, pa]) * abs([0, -2*h, cc - bb])) pa*(cc - bb)/(sqrt(4*h^2 + pa^2)*sqrt(4*h^2 + (cc - bb)^2)) R cos of the dihedral angle at CQ, a(c-b)/(...); matched the book (E27) +I.Ex1.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 1 zero - [ax, ay]T * ([bx, by] - ([ax, ay]T * [bx, by]) / ([ax, ay]T * [ax, ay]) * [ax, ay]) - C foot of the perpendicular: CP = (ab)a/a^2 makes PB perpendicular to a; was an unrecognised zero (E28) +I.Ex2.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 2 zero - ((ax)*((bx) - (cx)) + (ay)*((by) - (cy)) + (az)*((bz) - (cz))) + ((bx)*((cx) - (ax)) + (by)*((cy) - (ay)) + (bz)*((cz) - (az))) + ((cx)*((ax) - (bx)) + (cy)*((ay) - (by)) + (cz)*((az) - (bz))) - C r1(r2-r3) + r2(r3-r1) + r3(r1-r2) = 0 in components; was 0 (E19) +I.Ex3.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 3 zero - ((2*a - (a+b+c)) + (2*b - (a+b+c)) + (2*c - (a+b+c)) + (a+b+c))/4 - C O is the centroid of A', B', C', P; was 0 (E29) +I.Ex9.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 9 zero - (((1/(2*((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))))*(((((ax)*(ax) + (ay)*(ay) + (az)*(az)))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))) + ((((bx)*(bx) + (by)*(by) + (bz)*(bz)))*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay)))) + ((((cx)*(cx) + (cy)*(cy) + (cz)*(cz)))*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))))))*(ax) + ((1/(2*((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))))*(((((ax)*(ax) + (ay)*(ay) + (az)*(az)))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))) + ((((bx)*(bx) + (by)*(by) + (bz)*(bz)))*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az)))) + ((((cx)*(cx) + (cy)*(cy) + (cz)*(cz)))*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))))))*(ay) + ((1/(2*((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))))*(((((ax)*(ax) + (ay)*(ay) + (az)*(az)))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))) + ((((bx)*(bx) + (by)*(by) + (bz)*(bz)))*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax)))) + ((((cx)*(cx) + (cy)*(cy) + (cz)*(cz)))*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))))))*(az)) - ((ax)*(ax) + (ay)*(ay) + (az)*(az))/2 - C centre of the sphere OABC: x.a = a^2/2, written in components; timed out >20 s (E31) +I.Ex10.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 10 zero - (((ax) - ((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/((((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + ((ay) - ((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/((((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + ((az) - ((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/((((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))))*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))) - C foot of A on plane OBC lies in it: (h, b, c) = 0 in components; was a large unreduced quotient (E31) +I.Ex11.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 11 zero - ((((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/(((dx)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (dy)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (dz)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))) + ((dx)*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) + (dy)*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) + (dz)*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax)))) + ((dx)*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) + (dy)*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) + (dz)*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))))))*(dx)) - (ax))*((((by) - (ay))*((cz) - (az)) - ((bz) - (az))*((cy) - (ay)))) + (((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/(((dx)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (dy)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (dz)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))) + ((dx)*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) + (dy)*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) + (dz)*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax)))) + ((dx)*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) + (dy)*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) + (dz)*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))))))*(dy)) - (ay))*((((bz) - (az))*((cx) - (ax)) - ((bx) - (ax))*((cz) - (az)))) + (((((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))/(((dx)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (dy)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (dz)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))) + ((dx)*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) + (dy)*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) + (dz)*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax)))) + ((dx)*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) + (dy)*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) + (dz)*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))))))*(dz)) - (az))*((((bx) - (ax))*((cy) - (ay)) - ((by) - (ay))*((cx) - (ax))))) - C OD meets plane ABC at m: (m - a, b - a, c - a) = 0 in components; timed out >20 s (E31) +I.Ex13.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 13 zero - (ax*by*cz - ax*bz*cy - ay*bx*cz + ay*bz*cx + az*bx*cy - az*by*cx)/(cz*(ax*by - ay*bx) + cy*(az*bx - ax*bz) + cx*(ay*bz - az*by)) - 1 - C two spellings of (a,b,c) in Gibbs x.a - p; was 0 with spurious 'not by*cz - bz*cy = 0' (E31) +I.Ex13.b Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 13 zero - p*(ax*by*cz - ax*bz*cy - ay*bx*cz + ay*bz*cx + az*bx*cy - az*by*cx)/(cz*(ax*by - ay*bx) + cy*(az*bx - ax*bz) + cx*(ay*bz - az*by)) - p - C x.a - p for the Gibbs formula; was returned unreduced (E31) +I.Ex13.c Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 13 zero - (ax*by*cz - ax*bz*cy - ay*bx*cz + ay*bz*cx + az*bx*cy - az*by*cx) - (cz*(ax*by - ay*bx) + cy*(az*bx - ax*bz) + cx*(ay*bz - az*by)) - C two spellings of the triple product subtracted; was 0 (E31) +I.Ex14.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 14 solve l l^2 - l + (p + b^2/a^2)/a^2 = 0 { (1 - sqrt(1 - 4*(p + b^2/a^2)/a^2))/2, (1 + sqrt(1 - 4*(p + b^2/a^2)/a^2))/2 } C scalar core of x + y = a, xy = p, [x,y] = b; both roots found (E34) +I.Ex14.b Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 14 zero - (((xx) + (yx))*(((xy)*(yz) - (xz)*(yy))) + ((xy) + (yy))*(((xz)*(yx) - (xx)*(yz))) + ((xz) + (yz))*(((xx)*(yy) - (xy)*(yx)))) - C (x + y).[x, y] = 0 identically, why a.b = 0 is needed (erratum 10), in components; not probed +I.Ex16.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 16 equal - [(((ay)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))) - (az)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))))) + (((by)*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax))) - (bz)*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))))) + (((cy)*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))) - (cz)*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))))), (((az)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) - (ax)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))))) + (((bz)*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) - (bx)*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax))))) + (((cz)*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) - (cx)*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))))), (((ax)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) - (ay)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))))) + (((bx)*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) - (by)*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))))) + (((cx)*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) - (cy)*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by)))))] [0, 0, 0] C Jacobi identity in components; was [0, 0, 0] (E19) +I.Ex17.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 17 zero - (1/(p*((1/p)^2 + (1/q)^2 + (1/r)^2)) - p)*(0 - 0) + (1/(q*((1/p)^2 + (1/q)^2 + (1/r)^2)) - 0)*(0 - q) + (1/(r*((1/p)^2 + (1/q)^2 + (1/r)^2)) - 0)*(r - 0) - C (O' - A).(C - B) = 0, O' = n/|n|^2; was -q/(q*S) + r/(r*S) (E32) +I.Ex21.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 21 1deg equal - (1 + 2*cos(A)*cos(B)*cos(C) - cos(A)^2 - cos(B)^2 - cos(C)^2) - (1 - 2*cos(A)*cos(B)*cos(C) - cos(A)^2 - cos(B)^2 - cos(C)^2) 4*cos(A)*cos(B)*cos(C) C Delta^2 - Delta*^2 (also Sec 2 Problem 1 6deg); was 4 * cos(A) * cos(B) * cos(C) (E35) +I.Ex21.b Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 21 3deg solve x -x = (x - cos(A)*cos(B))/(sin(A)*sin(B)) { cos(A)*cos(B)/(1 + sin(A)*sin(B)) } C cos c = cos A cos B/(1 + sin A sin B); was right but uncollected (E35) +I.Ex22.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 22 1deg equal - [(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) + (((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) + ((((cy) - (ay))*((bz) - (az)) - ((cz) - (az))*((by) - (ay)))), (((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) + (((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) + ((((cz) - (az))*((bx) - (ax)) - ((cx) - (ax))*((bz) - (az)))), (((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx))) + (((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax))) + (((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx))) + ((((cx) - (ax))*((by) - (ay)) - ((cy) - (ay))*((bx) - (ax))))] [0, 0, 0] C [DB,DC] + [DC,DA] + [DA,DB] + [AC,AB] = 0 in components; was [0, 0, 0] (E19) +I.Ex25.Er Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 25 erratum - (((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (bx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (by)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (bz))) + (((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (cx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (cy)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (cz))) + (((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (dx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (dy)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (dz))) (((ax) - (bx))*((ax) - (bx)) + ((ay) - (by))*((ay) - (by)) + ((az) - (bz))*((az) - (bz))) + (((ax) - (cx))*((ax) - (cx)) + ((ay) - (cy))*((ay) - (cy)) + ((az) - (cz))*((az) - (cz))) + (((ax) - (dx))*((ax) - (dx)) + ((ay) - (dy))*((ay) - (dy)) + ((az) - (dz))*((az) - (dz))) + (((bx) - (cx))*((bx) - (cx)) + ((by) - (cy))*((by) - (cy)) + ((bz) - (cz))*((bz) - (cz))) + (((bx) - (dx))*((bx) - (dx)) + ((by) - (dy))*((by) - (dy)) + ((bz) - (dz))*((bz) - (dz))) + (((cx) - (dx))*((cx) - (dx)) + ((cy) - (dy))*((cy) - (dy)) + ((cz) - (dz))*((cz) - (dz))) C powers of A wrt spheres on MB, MC, MD vs sum of edges^2: false for one vertex (M = A gives 0); left a residue (E19) +I.Ex25.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 25 zero - ((((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (bx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (by)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (bz))) + (((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (cx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (cy)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (cz))) + (((ax) - (mx))*((ax) - (dx)) + ((ay) - (my))*((ay) - (dy)) + ((az) - (mz))*((az) - (dz))) + (((bx) - (mx))*((bx) - (ax)) + ((by) - (my))*((by) - (ay)) + ((bz) - (mz))*((bz) - (az))) + (((bx) - (mx))*((bx) - (cx)) + ((by) - (my))*((by) - (cy)) + ((bz) - (mz))*((bz) - (cz))) + (((bx) - (mx))*((bx) - (dx)) + ((by) - (my))*((by) - (dy)) + ((bz) - (mz))*((bz) - (dz))) + (((cx) - (mx))*((cx) - (ax)) + ((cy) - (my))*((cy) - (ay)) + ((cz) - (mz))*((cz) - (az))) + (((cx) - (mx))*((cx) - (bx)) + ((cy) - (my))*((cy) - (by)) + ((cz) - (mz))*((cz) - (bz))) + (((cx) - (mx))*((cx) - (dx)) + ((cy) - (my))*((cy) - (dy)) + ((cz) - (mz))*((cz) - (dz))) + (((dx) - (mx))*((dx) - (ax)) + ((dy) - (my))*((dy) - (ay)) + ((dz) - (mz))*((dz) - (az))) + (((dx) - (mx))*((dx) - (bx)) + ((dy) - (my))*((dy) - (by)) + ((dz) - (mz))*((dz) - (bz))) + (((dx) - (mx))*((dx) - (cx)) + ((dy) - (my))*((dy) - (cy)) + ((dz) - (mz))*((dz) - (cz)))) - ((((ax) - (bx))*((ax) - (bx)) + ((ay) - (by))*((ay) - (by)) + ((az) - (bz))*((az) - (bz))) + (((ax) - (cx))*((ax) - (cx)) + ((ay) - (cy))*((ay) - (cy)) + ((az) - (cz))*((az) - (cz))) + (((ax) - (dx))*((ax) - (dx)) + ((ay) - (dy))*((ay) - (dy)) + ((az) - (dz))*((az) - (dz))) + (((bx) - (cx))*((bx) - (cx)) + ((by) - (cy))*((by) - (cy)) + ((bz) - (cz))*((bz) - (cz))) + (((bx) - (dx))*((bx) - (dx)) + ((by) - (dy))*((by) - (dy)) + ((bz) - (dz))*((bz) - (dz))) + (((cx) - (dx))*((cx) - (dx)) + ((cy) - (dy))*((cy) - (dy)) + ((cz) - (dz))*((cz) - (dz)))) - C correction of I.Ex25.Er: true summed over all four vertices; was 0 (E19) +I.Ex26.a Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 26 zero - ((((((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax))) - (((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az)))))*(((ay)*(bz) - (az)*(by))) + (((((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay))) - (((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))*(((cx)*(ay) - (cy)*(ax)))))*(((az)*(bx) - (ax)*(bz))) + (((((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy)))*(((cz)*(ax) - (cx)*(az))) - (((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz)))*(((cy)*(az) - (cz)*(ay)))))*(((ax)*(by) - (ay)*(bx)))) - (((ax)*(((by)*(cz) - (bz)*(cy))) + (ay)*(((bz)*(cx) - (bx)*(cz))) + (az)*(((bx)*(cy) - (by)*(cx)))))^2 - C ([b,c],[c,a],[a,b]) = (a,b,c)^2 in components (also Sec 2 Problem 2 5deg); was 0 (E19) +I.Ex26.b Ch I Sec 3 Exercise 26 zero - derivative(ln((mu - p)*(mu - q)*(mu - r)*(mu - s)/mu), mu) - (1/(mu - p) + 1/(mu - q) + 1/(mu - r) + 1/(mu - s) - 1/mu) - C logarithmic derivative of F(mu); was a nonzero-looking rational expression after 5 s (E36) +II.P1.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 1 equal - det([[0,1/(1+l),1],[m/(1+m),0,1],[1/(1+v),v/(1+v),1]]) (1+l*m*v)/((1+l)*(1+m)*(1+v)) C affine oriented-area ratio; difference was unchanged, also with simplifyn 5 +II.P1.b Ch II Sec 1 Problem 1 equal - det([[0,1,1+l],[m,0,1+m],[1,v,1+v]]) 1 + l*m*v C homogeneous form of P1 (Menelaus); was 1 + l*m*v +II.P2.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 2 equal - (-c^2/b^2)*(-a^2/c^2)*(-b^2/a^2) -1 C Menelaus product for the tangents (Brianchon case); was -1 provided not a*b*c = 0 +II.P3.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 3 equal - (-R_2/R_3)*(-R_3/R_1)*(-R_1/R_2) -1 C centres of similitude, Menelaus product; was -1 provided not R_1*R_2*R_3 = 0 +II.P4def.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 4, pencil of lines equal - det([[1,1+l,-1],[1+m,m,-m],[v,-1,0]]) 1 - l*m*v C concurrency det of the cevian line coefficients; was 1 + -l*m*v +II.P5.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 5 1° equal - 1 + (l*m*v)^2 - 2*l*m*v (l*m*v - 1)^2 C homogeneous vertex det of A1B1C1; collapse gave (l*m*v - 1)^2 +II.P5.b Ch II Sec 1 Problem 5 2° equal - (2*2*2-1)^2/((1+2+2*2)*(1+2+2*2)*(1+2+2*2)) 1/7 - area ratio at l = m = v = 2; eval gave 1/7 +II.P6.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 6 equal - ((p-b)/(p-c))*((p-c)/(p-a))*((p-a)/(p-b)) 1 C Gergonne point, Ceva product; was 1 provided not (p-a)*(p-b)*(p-c) = 0 +II.P7.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 7 zero - abs([x,y]-[x_1,y_1])^2 + abs([x,y]-[x_2,y_2])^2 - 2*abs([x,y]-([x_1,y_1]+[x_2,y_2])/2)^2 - abs([x_2,y_2]-[x_1,y_1])^2/2 - R MA^2+MB^2 = 2MO^2 + AB^2/2; was 0 +II.P9.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 9 solve x abs([x,y]-[0-a,0])^2 - abs([x,y]-[a,0])^2 = k { k/(4*a) } R MC1^2 - MC2^2 = k is the line x = k/(4a); was { k / a / 4 } +II.P10.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 10 solve x (x+a)^2+y^2-r_1^2 = (x-a)^2+y^2-r_2^2 { (r_1^2 - r_2^2)/(4*a) } C radical axis; was right but unsimplified, -(a^2 + -a^2 + ...)/(2*a + 2*a), no a != 0 +II.Def0.a Ch II Sec 1, zero circle solve x (x-1)^2 + 0^2 = 0 { 1 } C a zero circle is a point; set-builder was { x : x - 1 = 0 }, not { 1 } +II.P11.1.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 1° zero - (x - a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1))^2 + y^2 - 4*a^2*k^2/(k^2-1)^2 - (x^2 + y^2 - 2*a*x*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) + a^2) - C Apollonius circle centre and radius; was 0 provided not k^2 - 1 = 0 +II.P11.3.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 3° zero - (a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1))^2 - (2*a*k/(k^2-1))^2 - a^2 - C power of O w.r.t. C_k is a^2; was 0 provided not k^2 - 1 = 0 +II.P11.5.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 5° equal - k_1*k_2^2 - k_1 - k_2 + k_1^2*k_2 (k_1 + k_2)*(k_1*k_2 - 1) C factor of R_k1 - R_k2; collapse gave (k_1 + k_2)*(k_1*k_2 - 1) +II.P11.5.b Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 5° zero - a*((1/k^2)+1)/((1/k^2)-1) + a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) - C x_(1/k) = -x_k, symmetry about s; was 0 provided not k = 0 and ... +II.E1 Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 5°, p. 57 erratum - a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) 2*a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) C book prints x_k = 2a(k^2+1)/(k^2-1); true centre a(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) (k=1/2, a=1: -5/3 not -10/3) +II.P11.6.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 6° equal - (2 + (-2)*(1 + 1/(k-1) + k) + 2/(k-1))/(2*k) -1 C cross ratio (A B P_k Q_k) after one simplify; a second simplify gave -1 (Simplify not idempotent) +II.P11.7.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 7° equal - (a + 2*a/(k^2-1))^2 + b^2 + (-4)*(a*k/(k^2-1))^2 a^2 + b^2 C power of S(0,b) w.r.t. C_k is SA^2; alone it stayed unreduced, the difference was 0 provided ... +II.P11.8.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 8° zero - abs(k^2-1)^2 - (k^2-1)^2 - R book's R_k = 2ak/|k^2-1| squared; stayed unchanged, also with the real codomain +II.P11R6.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 Remark (6) zero - 0^2 + 1^2 - 2*q*0 - 1 - C printed elliptic circle x^2+y^2-2qx-1 passes through (0, 1); was 0 +II.E3.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 Remark (6), p. 54 erratum - 1^2 + 0^2 - 2*q*1 - 1 0 C book: x^2+y^2-2qx-1 = 0 passes through (1, 0); it gives -2*q (true circle: x^2+y^2-2qy-1) +II.E3.b Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 Remark (6), p. 54 erratum - 2*(-p)*(-q) + 2*0*0 - 1 - (-1) 0 C orthogonality defect 2g1g2+2f1f2-c1-c2 of the printed pencils, claimed 0; true value 2*p*q +II.E3.c Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 Remark (6), p. 54 zero - 2*(-p)*0 + 2*0*(-q) - 1 - (-1) - C correction of II.E3.b: with x^2+y^2-2qy-1 the defect is 0 +II.P11.9.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 9° equal - derivative(2*a*k/(1-k^2), k) 2*a*(1 + k^2)/(1 - k^2)^2 C dR_k/dk for nesting; derive gave 2*a*(1 + k^2)/(1 - k^2)^2 +II.P11.10.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 10° (2) equal - (m+a)*(a-n) + (n+a)*(a-m) 2*(a^2 - m*n) C harmonic condition on AB; was 2*(a^2 - m*n) +II.P11.10.b Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 10° (2) solve n (m+a)/(a-m) = -(n+a)/(a-n) { a^2/m } C harmonic conjugate N0, OM0*ON0 = a^2; root was left nested, unsimplified +II.P11.10.c Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 10° (2) equal - -(-a*(a + m)/(a - m) - a)/(-1 + (a + m)/(a - m)) a^2/m C the solver's root for II.P11.10.b; Simplify left it unchanged +II.P11.13.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 13° solve t derivative(((t+1)^2+(t+2)^2)/((t-1)^2+(t+2)^2), t) = 0 { 1/2*sqrt(10), -1/2*sqrt(10) } - extrema of MA/MB on y = x + 2, A(-1,0), B(1,0); was { 1/2*sqrt(10), -1/2*sqrt(10) } +II.P11.14.a Ch II Sec 1 Problem 11 14° zero - (1 + 1/(k^2-1))*((-2)*b^2 + 2*b^2) - C Apollonius sphere identity after one simplify; a second simplify gave 0 (Simplify not idempotent) +II.Ex1.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 1 zero - 2*(x^2+y^2) + 3*((x-d)^2+y^2) - 5*((x-3*d/5)^2+y^2) - 6/5*d^2 - C 2MA^2+3MB^2 = 5MP^2 + (6/5)AB^2; was 0; also the correction of II.E4 +II.E4 Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 1 answer, p. 66 erratum - 2*(x^2+y^2) + 3*((x-d)^2+y^2) - 5*((x-3*d/5)^2+y^2) 5/6*d^2 C book: locus empty if k < 5/6 AB^2; the constant is 6/5*d^2 (correction: II.Ex1.a) +II.Ex3.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 3 zero - abs([x,y]-[a_1,a_2])^2 + abs([x,y]-[b_1,b_2])^2 - abs([x,y])^2 - (abs([x,y]-[a_1+b_1,a_2+b_2])^2 - 2*(a_1*b_1+a_2*b_2)) - R MA^2+MB^2-MC^2 = MD^2 - 2 CA.CB, C at origin; was 0 +II.Ex5.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 5 zero - (4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 + (4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 - 16*a^4/((X+a)^2+Y^2) - C inversion (A, 4a^2): image point at distance^2 16a^4/D from A; stayed unchanged +II.Ex6.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 equal - 1/(1 + (k - 1)*(k + 1)) 1/k^2 C (p-a)/(p+a) at p = a(k^2+1)/(k^2-1); 1 + (k-1)(k+1) was never collapsed to k^2 +II.Ex6.b Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 equal - (a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) - a)/(a*(k^2+1)/(k^2-1) + a) 1/k^2 C (p-a)/(p+a) with p = a(k^2+1)/(k^2-1); was 1 / (1 + (k - 1)*(k + 1)) +II.Ex6.c Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 equal - 2*a*sqrt(1/k^2) 2*a/k P radius 2a/k of the image circle; 2*a*sqrt(1/k^2) stayed (needs k > 0) +II.E5 Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 answer, p. 69 erratum - ((-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 + (4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 - 2*p*(-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2)) + a^2)*((X+a)^2+Y^2)/(2*a*(a+p)) + 4*a^2*(p-a)/(p+a) (X - a^2) + Y^2 C Gamma under inversion (A, 4a^2); book prints (X - a^2) + Y^2, true (X - a)^2 + Y^2 (SymPy) +II.E5.c Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 answer, p. 69 equal - ((-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 + (4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 - 2*p*(-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2)) + a^2)*((X+a)^2+Y^2)/(2*a*(a+p)) + 4*a^2*(p-a)/(p+a) (X - a)^2 + Y^2 C correction of II.E5; the Gamma identity stayed in AngouriMath, SymPy gave 0 +II.E6 Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 answer, p. 69 erratum - -((-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 + (4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 - 2*q*(4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2)) - a^2)*((X+a)^2+Y^2)/(8*a^2) a*(X-a) + p*Y C E under inversion; book prints a(X-a) + pY = 0, true a(X-a) + qY (p-form leaves 8a^2Y(p-q)/D) +II.E6.c Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 6 answer, p. 69 equal - -((-a + 4*a^2*(X+a)/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 + (4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2))^2 - 2*q*(4*a^2*Y/((X+a)^2+Y^2)) - a^2)*((X+a)^2+Y^2)/(8*a^2) a*(X-a) + q*Y C correction of II.E6; with u = X + a the q-form was 0 provided not u^2 + Y^2 = 0 +II.Ex7.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 7 zero - (l*(x^2+y^2-2*p_1*x+a^2) + m*(x^2+y^2-2*p_2*x+a^2))/(l+m) - (x^2+y^2-2*(l*p_1+m*p_2)/(l+m)*x+a^2) - C l*f + m*phi spans the hyperbolic pencil; was 0 provided not l + m = 0 +II.Ex9.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 9 zero - ((x+c)^2+y^2-r^2) - ((x-c)^2+y^2-q^2) - 2*(2*c)*(x - (r^2-q^2)/(4*c)) - C difference of powers = 2*OO'*KM; was 0 +II.Ex11.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 11 equal - 2 / ((1 + b/a)*(1 + a/c)*(1 + c/b)) 2*a*b*c/((b+c)*(c+a)*(a+b)) C bisector-feet area ratio from P1; difference did not reach 0 +II.Ex13.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 13 equal - 2*(1/sqrt(10))*(1/sqrt(2))*(1/sqrt(5)) 1/5 - 2cosA cosB cosC on (0,0),(4,0),(1,3), = (12/5)/12; was 1/5 +II.Ex17.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 17 equal - det([[-1, 2*b/(b+c), 2*c/(b+c)], [2*a/(a+c), -1, 2*c/(a+c)], [2*a/(a+b), 2*b/(a+b), -1]]) 3 + 8*a*b*c/((b+c)*(c+a)*(a+b)) C vertices reflected in bisector feet, barycentric det; difference did not reach 0 +II.Ex18.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 18 equal - (c^2/b^2)*(a^2/c^2)*(b^2/a^2) 1 C symmedians, Ceva product (Lemoine point); was 1 provided not a*b*c = 0 +II.Ex22.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 22 equal - det([[0,1,0],[1/4,1/2,1/4],[1/4,1/4,1/2]]) -1/16 - area (BMN)/(ABC); was -1/16 +II.Ex22.b Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 22 equal - det([[0,1,0],[1/4,1/4,1/2],[0,0,1]]) -1/4 - area (BNC)/(ABC); was -1/4 +II.Ex22.c Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 22 equal - abs(det([[0,1,0],[1/4,1/2,1/4],[1/4,1/4,1/2]]) + det([[0,1,0],[1/4,1/4,1/2],[0,0,1]])) 5/16 - quadrangle BMNC is 5S/16 +II.Ex23.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 23 equal - u/(u+v+w) + v/(u+v+w) + w/(u+v+w) 1 C OP/AP + OQ/BQ + OR/CR = 1; was 1 provided not u + v + w = 0 +II.Ex24.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 24 equal - 2/(q*b) + 2/(p*(q/(1-p/b))) 2/(p*q) C 1/(OAB) + 1/(OCA) is constant; was 2 / (p*q) provided ... +II.Ex25.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 25 zero - (1/(1+m))^2 - (1 - 1/(1+m))*(1/m - 1/(1+m)) - C AE^2 = EF*EG; was 0 provided not m^2*(1 + m)^5 = 0 +II.Ex27.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 27 equal - det([[0,1,p],[q,0,1],[1,r,0]]) 1 + p*q*r C Menelaus det for the transversal's points; was 1 + p*q*r +II.Ex27.b Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 27 equal - det([[0,p,1],[1,0,q],[r,1,0]]) 1 + p*q*r C the isotomic points give the same condition; was 1 + p*q*r +II.Ex38.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 38 zero - det([[a_2-a_1, b_2-b_1],[(0-a_2)-(0-a_1), (0-b_2)-(0-b_1)]]) - C opposite sides of the centrally symmetric hexagon are parallel; was 0 +II.Ex39.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 39 equal - 1 - (1 - t) t C the parallels path map t -> 1 - t applied twice; was t +II.Ex40.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 40 equal - det([[4/5,2/5,1],[3/5,4/5,1],[1/5,3/5,1]]) 1/5 - inner parallelogram of the unit square has area 1/5; was 1/5 +II.Ex42.a Ch II Sec 2 Exercise 42 solve t a*((x_1 + t*x_2)/(1+t)) + b*((y_1+t*y_2)/(1+t)) + c = 0 { -(a*x_1 + b*y_1 + c)/(a*x_2 + b*y_2 + c) } C ratio in which ax+by+c=0 divides M1M2; was the book's root provided not 1 + ... = 0 +II.S1.a Ch II Sec 2 Solid 1 zero - (r_1+r_2+r_3+r_4)/4 - r_1 - 3*((r_2+r_3+r_4)/3 - (r_1+r_2+r_3+r_4)/4) - C tetrahedron centroid divides a median 3:1 (scalar stand-ins); was 0 +II.S4.a Ch II Sec 2 Solid 4 1° solve t t + t + t = 1 { 1/3 } - plane ABC meets the diagonal OO' at t = 1/3; was { 1/3 } +II.S4.b Ch II Sec 2 Solid 4 2° equal - [1/3,1/3,1/3] - ([1,0,0]+[0,1,0]+[0,0,1])/3 [0, 0, 0] - the meeting point is the centroid of ABC; was [0, 0, 0] +III.P1.1.a Ch III §1 Problem 1 1° equal - (c - b)/(1/c - 1/b) -b*c C complex slope of BC on unit circle; was -b * c provided ... +III.P1.1.b Ch III §1 Problem 1 1° equal - (b + c)/(1/b + 1/c) b*c C complex slope of AH, H = a+b+c; was b * c +III.P1.1.c Ch III §1 Problem 1 1° zero - (c - b)/(1/c - 1/b) + (b + c)/(1/b + 1/c) - C AH perpendicular to BC: slopes sum to 0 (sum of P1.1.a, b); was 0 provided ... +III.P1.1.d Ch III §1 Problem 1 1° zero - (a+b+c) - 3*((a+b+c)/3) - C OH = 3 OG; was 0 +III.P1.2.a Ch III §1 Problem 1 2° equal - (a+b+c)/2 - (b+c)/2 a/2 C nine-point centre to side midpoint; was a / 2 +III.P1.2.b Ch III §1 Problem 1 2° equal - abs(a/2) 1/2 U nine-point radius R/2 with |a| = 1; was abs(a / 2), provided abs(a) = 1 changed nothing +III.P1.3.a Ch III §1 Problem 1 3° solve z z - a = b*c*(1/z - 1/a) { a, -b*c/a } C altitude meets circle again at N = -bc/a; was quadratic formula, square discriminant unrecognised +III.P1.3.b Ch III §1 Problem 1 3° zero - b + c - b*c*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) + b*c/a - C N is the reflection of H in BC; was 0 +III.P2.a Ch III §1 Problem 2 solve x x^3 = a*b*c { (a*b*c)^(1/3), (-1/2 + i*sqrt(3)/2)*(a*b*c)^(1/3), (-1/2 - i*sqrt(3)/2)*(a*b*c)^(1/3) } C cube roots of sigma3 form an equilateral triangle; was all three roots +III.P2.b Ch III §1 Problem 2 equal - ((-1 + i*sqrt(3))/2)^3 1 - epsilon is a cube root of unity; was 1 +III.P2.c Ch III §1 Problem 2 zero - cos(2*pi/3) + i*sin(2*pi/3) - (-1 + i*sqrt(3))/2 - - epsilon = cos 120 deg + i sin 120 deg; was 0 +III.P2.d Ch III §1 Problem 2 zero - 1 + ((-1 + i*sqrt(3))/2)^2 + ((-1 + i*sqrt(3))/2)^4 - - 1 + eps^2 + eps^4 = 0, eps written out; was 0 +III.P2.e Ch III §1 Problem 2 zero - (a/w)*(b/w)*(c/w) - a*b*c/w^3 - C change of unit point divides sigma3 by w^3; was 0 +III.P3b.a Ch III §1 Problem 3 equal - ((m+b+c-b*c/m)/2) - ((m+c+a-c*a/m)/2) (b-a)*(m-c)/(2*m) C numerator of slope of A1B1 (feet from m); reading's separate simplify gave this +III.P3b.b Ch III §1 Problem 3 equal - ((1/m+1/b+1/c-m/(b*c))/2) - ((1/m+1/c+1/a-m/(c*a))/2) (b-a)*(m-c)/(2*a*b*c) C denominator (conjugate difference) of slope of A1B1; reading's separate simplify gave this +III.P3b.c Ch III §1 Problem 3 equal - (((m+b+c-b*c/m)/2) - ((m+c+a-c*a/m)/2))/(((1/m+1/b+1/c-m/(b*c))/2) - ((1/m+1/c+1/a-m/(c*a))/2)) a*b*c/m C slope of A1B1 is sigma3 conj(z0); slope minus abc/m was unchanged after 2 passes +III.P3b.d Ch III §1 Problem 3 zero - (2 * (a * (2 * b + (-2) * m) + (-2) * b * m + (-2) * m ^ 2) + 4 * m * (a * (1 + -b / m) + b + m)) / (8 * m) - C C1 on Simson line (1), residue form; was b * (-a + a) / (2 * m), then 0 +III.P4.a Ch III §1 Problem 4 zero - (a + b + 1/(a*b)) - (a*b + b/(a*b) + a/(a*b)) + (1/a + 1/b + a*b) - (1/(a*b) + a*b/b + a*b/a) - C sigma3 = 1 (c = 1/(ab)): sigma1 - sigma2 purely imaginary; was 0 provided ... +III.P5.1.a Ch III §1 Problem 5 1° zero - 1/a + 1/b + 1/c - (a*b+b*c+c*a)/(a*b*c) - C conj(sigma1) = sigma2/sigma3; was 0 +III.P5.2.a Ch III §1 Problem 5 2° solve z z - 1 = s*(z - 1)/z { 1, s } C perpendicular meets unit circle at 1 and sigma3; was quadratic formula, (s-1)^2 unrecognised +III.P6.1.a Ch III §1 Problem 6 1° zero - (((R*(b+c) + p - b*c*q)/2)*(((R*(1/c+1/a) + q - p/(c*a))/2) - ((R*(1/a+1/b) + q - p/(a*b))/2)) - ((R*(1/b+1/c) + q - p/(b*c))/2)*(((R*(c+a) + p - c*a*q)/2) - ((R*(a+b) + p - a*b*q)/2)) + ((R*(c+a) + p - c*a*q)/2)*((R*(1/a+1/b) + q - p/(a*b))/2) - ((R*(a+b) + p - a*b*q)/2)*((R*(1/c+1/a) + q - p/(c*a))/2)) - 1/4*(1 - p*q/R^2)*((R*a)*((R/b) - (R/c)) - (R/a)*((R*b) - (R*c)) + (R*b)*(R/c) - (R*c)*(R/b)) - C pedal area = -power/(4R^2) * (ABC), q = conj(p); was 0 provided ... in 1 pass +III.P6.2.a Ch III §1 Problem 6 2° zero - R^2 - R^2*(a+b)*(1/a+1/b)/4 - R^2*(a-b)*(1/a-1/b)/4 - C minimal form of OG^2 identity; was R ^ 2 + -1/2 * (R ^ 2 + R ^ 2) provided ..., 0 on 2nd pass +III.P6.3.a Ch III §1 Problem 6 3° zero - (2*S/(x+y+v))/(2*x*y*v/(4*S)) - 4*S^2/(x*y*v*(x+y+v)) - P r/(2R) = 4S^2/(abc(a+b+c)) for incentre pedal; was 0 provided ... +III.P6.5.a Ch III §1 Problem 6 5° zero - sin(x)^2 + sin(y)^2 + sin(pi - x - y)^2 - 2 - 2*cos(x)*cos(y)*cos(pi - x - y) - R sum sin^2 - 2 = 2cosAcosBcosC; was unchanged after 2 passes, sin(pi - x - y) not reduced +III.P9.a Ch III §1 Problem 9 (26) zero - ((((u+v+w)-(u*v*w)/u^2)/(2*t) + (t-1)/t*u)*((((u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w)-v^2/(u*v*w))/(2*t) + (t-1)/(t*v)) - (((u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w)-w^2/(u*v*w))/(2*t) + (t-1)/(t*w))) - (((u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w)-u^2/(u*v*w))/(2*t) + (t-1)/(t*u))*((((u+v+w)-(u*v*w)/v^2)/(2*t) + (t-1)/t*v) - (((u+v+w)-(u*v*w)/w^2)/(2*t) + (t-1)/t*w)) + (((u+v+w)-(u*v*w)/v^2)/(2*t) + (t-1)/t*v)*(((u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w)-w^2/(u*v*w))/(2*t) + (t-1)/(t*w)) - (((u+v+w)-(u*v*w)/w^2)/(2*t) + (t-1)/t*w)*(((u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w)-v^2/(u*v*w))/(2*t) + (t-1)/(t*v))) - ((1 - (u+v+w)*(u*v+v*w+w*u)/(u*v*w))/(4*t^2) + (1 - 1/t)*(1 - 2/t))*(u*((1/v) - (1/w)) - (1/u)*(v - w) + v*(1/w) - w*(1/v)) - C determinant identity (26), built from appendix A2 recipe; was residue on pass 1, 0 on pass 2 +III.P9.b Ch III §1 Problem 9 zero - (u+v+w)*(1/u+1/v+1/w) - 1 - (2 + u/v + v/u + v/w + w/v + w/u + u/w) - C sigma1 conj(sigma1) - 1 = 2 + sum(zj/zk + zk/zj); was 0 +III.P9.c1 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(1)^2 + (1 - 1/(1))*(1 - 2/(1)) - (2*K) - C (27) at lambda = 1 gives 2K; was 0 +III.P9.c2 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(-1)^2 + (1 - 1/(-1))*(1 - 2/(-1)) - (6 + 2*K) - C (27) at lambda = -1 gives 6+2K; was 0 +III.P9.c3 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(1/2)^2 + (1 - 1/(1/2))*(1 - 2/(1/2)) - (3 + 8*K) - C (27) at lambda = 1/2 gives 3+8K; was 0 +III.P9.c4 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(-1/2)^2 + (1 - 1/(-1/2))*(1 - 2/(-1/2)) - (15 + 8*K) - C (27) at lambda = -1/2 gives 15+8K; was 0 +III.P9.c5 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(2)^2 + (1 - 1/(2))*(1 - 2/(2)) - (K/2) - C (27) at lambda = 2 gives K/2; was 0 +III.P9.c6 Ch III §1 Problem 9 (27) zero - 2*K/(-2)^2 + (1 - 1/(-2))*(1 - 2/(-2)) - (3 + K/2) - C (27) at lambda = -2 gives 3+K/2; was 0 +III.P9.E2 Ch III §1 Problem 9 p. 101 erratum - det([[1/a^2, 1/a, 1], [1/b^2, 1/b, 1], [1/c^2, 1/c, 1]]) det([[1/a, 1, a], [1/b, 1, b], [1/c, 1, c]])/(a*b*c)^3 C book prints 1/sigma3^3; true factor 1/sigma3; difference 899/135000 at (2,3,5) +III.P9.E2c Ch III §1 Problem 9 p. 101 zero - det([[1/a^2, 1/a, 1], [1/b^2, 1/b, 1], [1/c^2, 1/c, 1]]) - det([[1/a, 1, a], [1/b, 1, b], [1/c, 1, c]])/(a*b*c) - C correction of III.P9.E2; was 0 provided ... +III.P10a.a Ch III §1 Problem 10 zero - b * (-a * c / b + c) + c * (a - b) - C B' on AB' residue; with provided not a*c = 0 unchanged, without it 0 +III.P10a.b Ch III §1 Problem 10 zero - ((b)*((a^2*b)*(b^2 + c*a) - (a^2 + b*c)*(b^2*c)) - (c^2*a)*((c)*(b^2 + c*a) - (a^2 + b*c)*(a)) + (c^2 + a*b)*((c)*(b^2*c) - (a^2*b)*(a))) - (b-a)*(c-a)*(c-b)*((a+b+c)*(a*b+b*c+c*a) - 2*a*b*c) - C Delta = Vandermonde * (sigma1 sigma2 - 2 sigma3), appendix A3; was 0, factor refused +III.P10a.c Ch III §1 Problem 10 zero - (c-b)*(c-a)*(b-a) - a*b*c*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]]) - C Vandermonde = abc det[z 1/z 1]; was unchanged after 2 passes (det expanded by hand) +III.P10b.E1 Ch III §1 Problem 10 p. 107 erratum - 2*arccos(-1/(2*sqrt(2))) arccos(9/16) - admissible arc of A: book prints arccos(9/16) (55.77 deg); true 2arccos(-1/(2sqrt2)) = 221.41 deg +III.P10b.E1c Ch III §1 Problem 10 p. 107 equal - cos(2*arccos(-1/(2*sqrt(2)))) -3/4 - correction of III.P10b.E1: the true arc has cosine -3/4; was -3/4 +III.P10c.a Ch III §1 Problem 10 zero - (7/4 - 2)/2 + 1/8 - - sum sin^2 = 7/4 iff cosAcosBcosC = -1/8; was 0 +III.P11.1.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 1° zero - cos(2*pi/7)+cos(4*pi/7)+cos(6*pi/7) + 1/2 - - x = 2(cos2pi/7+cos4pi/7+cos6pi/7) = -1; was 0 in 1 pass +III.P11.1.b Ch III §1 Problem 11 1° zero - abs(1 + e^(2*pi*i/7) + e^(6*pi*i/7))^2 - 2 - - OH^2 = 2R^2; was 0 in 1 pass +III.P11.1.c Ch III §1 Problem 11 1° zero - abs(1 + cos(2*pi/7)/(2*cos(pi/7)) + i*sin(pi/7))^2 - 2 - - OIa^2 = 2R^2, tau_a written out; was 0 in 1 pass +III.P11.2.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 2° zero - sin(pi/7) + sin(2*pi/7) + sin(3*pi/7) - cot(pi/14)/2 - - sin pi/7 + sin 2pi/7 + sin 3pi/7 = cot(pi/14)/2; was 0 +III.P11.2.b Ch III §1 Problem 11 2° zero - tan(pi/14)*(sin(pi/7) + sin(2*pi/7) + sin(3*pi/7)) - 1/2 - - R = 2 r_a; was 0 +III.P11.3.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 3° zero - (1 + e^(2*pi*i/7) + e^(6*pi*i/7)) - (1 + cos(2*pi/7)/(2*cos(pi/7)) + i*sin(pi/7)) - (cos(5*pi/7) + i*sin(5*pi/7)) - - IaH = R since h - tau_a = a6 (also 5°: IaH = OA6); was 0 +III.P11.4.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 4° zero - 4*sin(pi/7)^2 + 4*sin(2*pi/7)^2 + 4*sin(3*pi/7)^2 - 7 - - a^2+b^2+c^2 = 7R^2; was 0 +III.P11.6.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 6° zero - abs(((1 + e^(2*pi*i/7) + e^(6*pi*i/7)) + (cos(5*pi/7) + i*sin(5*pi/7)))/2) - 1 - - midpoint of HA6 lies on (O); was 0 +III.P11.7.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 7° zero - det([[e^(6*pi*i/7), (1 + e^(2*pi*i/7) + e^(6*pi*i/7)), 1], [(1 + cos(2*pi/7)/(2*cos(pi/7)) + i*sin(pi/7)), 1, 1], [(1 + e^(2*pi*i/7) + e^(6*pi*i/7)), (1 + cos(2*pi/7)/(2*cos(pi/7)) + i*sin(pi/7)), 1]]) - - AIaH and HBIa directly similar, a7 = e^(6pi i/7) inferred; was 0 +III.P11.9.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 9° zero - abs((1 + cos(2*pi/7)/(2*cos(pi/7)) + i*sin(pi/7)) - (cos(5*pi/7) + i*sin(5*pi/7)))^2 - 4 - - squared side IaA6 is 4; was 0 +III.P11.n.a Ch III §1 Problem 11 note zero - abs(1 - e^(i*2*pi/7)) - 2*sin(pi/7) - - chord of arc alpha is 2 sin(alpha/2); was 0 +III.P12a.a Ch III §1 Problem 12 zero - x/c + (y*c - x*d)/(c^2*(z + d/c)) - (x*z + y)/(c*z + d) - C Mobius decomposition; was unchanged after 2 passes (nested fraction), 0 with c*(c*z+d) +III.P12b.a Ch III §1 Problem 12 zero - (1/((d*D - c*C)/(c*C)))*(D/C) - c*D/(d*D - c*C) - C centre of inverted circle via homothety (O, 1/sigma), C = conj c, D = conj d; was 0 +III.P12c.a Ch III §1 Problem 12 zero - ((x*z + y)/(c*z + d) - (y*D - x*C)/(d*D - c*C))*((X/z + Y)/(C/z + D) - (Y*d - X*c)/(d*D - c*C)) - (y*c - x*d)*(Y*C - X*D)/(d*D - c*C)^2 - C |u - omega6|^2 = R6^2 for conj z = 1/z, appendix A4; was unchanged after 2 passes +III.P12c.b Ch III §1 Problem 12 zero - (x*z + y)/(c*z + d) - (y*D - x*C)/(d*D - c*C) - (x*d - y*c)*(D*z + C)/((c*z + d)*(d*D - c*C)) - C u - omega6 split by hand as (xd - yc)(Dz + C)/((cz+d)(dD - cC)); was 0 +III.P13.1.pqr Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b) + (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c) + (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a) - (a + b + c) - C sum of square centres p+q+r = sigma1; was 0 +III.P13.1.forces Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - 1/2*(a + b - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b) - a*b*(2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)) + 1/2*(b + c - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b) - b*c*(2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)) + 1/2*(c + a - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b) - c*a*(2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)) + 1/2*(a + b - (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c) - a*b*(2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)) + 1/2*(b + c - (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c) - b*c*(2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)) + 1/2*(c + a - (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c) - c*a*(2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)) + 1/2*(a + b - (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a) - a*b*(2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)) + 1/2*(b + c - (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a) - b*c*(2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)) + 1/2*(c + a - (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a) - c*a*(2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)) - (1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))) - C nine-force sum = h' (orthocentre of orthic triangle), hand-conjugated; was 0 provided a,b,c != 0 (395 ms) +III.P13.1.slope Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - ((1/2*(b + c + a - c*a/b)) - (1/2*(c + a + b - a*b/c)))/((1/2*(1/b + 1/c + 1/a - b/(c*a))) - (1/2*(1/c + 1/a + 1/b - c/(a*b)))) + a^2 - C complex slope of B_hC_h (feet of altitudes) is -a^2; was 0 +III.P13.1.alt.a Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - ((1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))) - (1/2*(a + b + c - b*c/a)))*((1/2*(1/b + 1/c + 1/a - b/(c*a))) - (1/2*(1/c + 1/a + 1/b - c/(a*b)))) + ((1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c))) - (1/2*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c - a/(b*c))))*((1/2*(b + c + a - c*a/b)) - (1/2*(c + a + b - a*b/c))) - C h' on the altitude from the orthic vertex at a (u*conj v + conj u*v = 0); was 0 +III.P13.1.alt.b Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - ((1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))) - (1/2*(b + c + a - c*a/b)))*((1/2*(1/c + 1/a + 1/b - c/(a*b))) - (1/2*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c - a/(b*c)))) + ((1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c))) - (1/2*(1/b + 1/c + 1/a - b/(c*a))))*((1/2*(c + a + b - a*b/c)) - (1/2*(a + b + c - b*c/a))) - C h' on the altitude from the orthic vertex at b (u*conj v + conj u*v = 0); was 0 +III.P13.1.alt.c Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - ((1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))) - (1/2*(c + a + b - a*b/c)))*((1/2*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c - a/(b*c))) - (1/2*(1/b + 1/c + 1/a - b/(c*a)))) + ((1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c))) - (1/2*(1/c + 1/a + 1/b - c/(a*b))))*((1/2*(a + b + c - b*c/a)) - (1/2*(b + c + a - c*a/b))) - C h' on the altitude from the orthic vertex at c (u*conj v + conj u*v = 0); was 0 +III.P13.1.nested Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - 1/(1 - (b/a)^2) - a^2/(a^2 - b^2) - C nested denominator from h' in (36); was unchanged, also simplifyn::8 +III.P13.1.line Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° (37) zero - (4*(a + b + c))*((2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)/2)) - (4*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))*((2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b) - ((a + b + c) - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + ((2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)/2) - (2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)*((a + b + c) - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/c + (-i-1)/2/a - (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + (4*(a + b + c))*((2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)/2)) - (4*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))*((2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c) - ((a + b + c) - (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)/2)) + ((2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)/2) - (2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)*((a + b + c) - (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/a + (-i-1)/2/b - (1-i)/2/c)/2)) + (4*(a + b + c))*((2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)/2)) - (4*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c))*((2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a) - ((a + b + c) - (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)/2)) + ((2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)/2) - (2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)*((a + b + c) - (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(2/b + (-i-1)/2/c - (1-i)/2/a)/2)) - C resultant line (sum of 3 dets) passes through 4*OH; was 0 provided a,b,c != 0 (3.2 s) +III.P13.1.sq Ch III §1 Problem 13 1° zero - (2*c + (i-1)/2*a - (1+i)/2*b)^2 + (2*a + (i-1)/2*b - (1+i)/2*c)^2 + (2*b + (i-1)/2*c - (1+i)/2*a)^2 - (4*(a + b + c)^2 - 11*(a*b + b*c + c*a)) - C p^2+q^2+r^2 = 4 sigma1^2 - 11 sigma2; was 0 (also by expand) +III.P13.R.det Ch III §1 Problem 13 Remark (37) equal - det([[x, y, 1], [p, q, 1], [r, s, 1]]) p*(s - y) + q*(x - r) + r*y - s*x C line through two points as a 3x3 determinant; det_s gave this form +III.P13.2.sq Ch III §1 Problem 13 2° zero - ((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)^2 + ((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)^2 + ((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)^2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a) - C p*^2+q*^2+r*^2 = sigma2; was 0 +III.P13.2.lineh Ch III §1 Problem 13 2° zero - (1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c)))*(((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2)) - (1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c)))*(((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2)) + (1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c)))*(((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2)) - (1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c)))*(((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + (1/2*(3*(a + b + c) - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c)))*(((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2)) - (1/2*(3*(1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*(a + b + c)))*(((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2)) - C resultant line of the reversed triplet passes through H'; was 0 +III.P13.2.line0 Ch III §1 Problem 13 2° zero - 0*(((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2)) - 0*(((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2) - ((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*b + (1+i)/2*a)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/b + (1-i)/2/a)/2)) + 0*(((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2)) - 0*(((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2) - ((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*c + (1+i)/2*b)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/c + (1-i)/2/b)/2)) + 0*(((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c) - ((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2)) - 0*(((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c) - ((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2)) + (((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2 - (1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a))*((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2) - ((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)*((a + b + c) - ((1-i)/2*a + (1+i)/2*c)/2 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)*((1+i)/2/a + (1-i)/2/c)/2)) - C resultant line of the reversed triplet passes through O; was not reduced (1.8 s), 0 at exact points +III.P14.c0 Ch III §1 Problem 14 zero - (m + (-m^2 + m*(a + b) + (m*n - 2)*a*b)/(m + n*a*b - a - b))/2 - (m*n - 1)*a*b/(m + n*a*b - a - b) - C c0 = (mu + c)/2, mu and conj(mu)=n free; was TIMEOUT (>20 s) +III.P14.area1 Ch III §1 Problem 14 zero - (i/4*det([[((m + n*b*c - b - c)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(b*c) - 1/b - 1/c)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [((m + n*c*a - c - a)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(c*a) - 1/c - 1/a)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [((m + n*a*b - a - b)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(a*b) - 1/a - 1/b)/(m*n - 1)), 1]]))*(1 - m*n) - (i/4*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]])) - C (A'B'C')(1 - mu conj mu) = (PQR), oriented areas; was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P14.area2 Ch III §1 Problem 14 zero - (i/4*det([[(2*(m - a)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/a)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [(2*(m - b)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/b)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [(2*(m - c)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/c)/(m*n - 1)), 1]]))*(1 - m*n)^2 - 4*(i/4*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]])) - C (A''B''C'')(1 - mu conj mu)^2 = 4(PQR); was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P14.final Ch III §1 Problem 14 zero - (i/4*det([[((m + n*b*c - b - c)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(b*c) - 1/b - 1/c)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [((m + n*c*a - c - a)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(c*a) - 1/c - 1/a)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [((m + n*a*b - a - b)/(m*n - 1)), ((n + m/(a*b) - 1/a - 1/b)/(m*n - 1)), 1]]))^2 - 1/4*(i/4*det([[(2*(m - a)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/a)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [(2*(m - b)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/b)/(m*n - 1)), 1], [(2*(m - c)/(m*n - 1)), (2*(n - 1/c)/(m*n - 1)), 1]]))*(i/4*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]])) - C (A'B'C')^2 = 1/4 (A''B''C'')(PQR); was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P15.1.foot Ch III §1 Problem 15 1° zero - 1/2*(c*a + a*b + a - c*a*a*b/a) - 1/2*(a - b*c + (a*b + b*c + c*a) - a*b*c) - C foot of A on B'C' (P = 1, a' = bc); was 0 provided a != 0 +III.P15.1.mod Ch III §1 Problem 15 1° equal - (-b*c)*(-1/(b*c)) 1 C |a'' - o''|^2 hand-conjugated; was 1 provided b*c != 0 +III.P15.2 Ch III §1 Problem 15 2° zero - ((a*b + b*c + c*a) - a*b*c)*((1/(a*b) + 1/(b*c) + 1/(c*a)) - 1/(a*b*c)) - ((a + b + c) - 1)*((1/a + 1/b + 1/c) - 1) - C OO'' = PH: |s2 - s3|^2 - |s1 - 1|^2, hand-conjugated; was an unreduced Laurent expression +III.P15.V2.det Ch III §1 Problem 15 Version Two zero - det([[a, p*(b + (1/(a*b))) - p^2, 1], [b, p*((1/(a*b)) + a) - p^2, 1], [(1/(a*b)), p*(a + b) - p^2, 1]]) - C opposite-orientation determinant with sigma3 = 1 (c = 1/(ab)); was 0 provided a, b != 0 +III.P16.centroid Ch III §1 Problem 16 zero - (a*(x*b + (1 - x)*c) + b*(x*c + (1 - x)*a) + c*(x*a + (1 - x)*b))/3 - (a*b + b*c + c*a)/3 - C centroid of A''B''C'' (a'' = a*(x*b + (1-x)*c), x = alpha free) is sigma2/3; was 0 +III.P16.g Ch III §1 Problem 16 zero - (a*b+b*c+c*a)/3 - (a*b*c)*(1/a+1/b+1/c)/3 - C g'' - sigma3*conj(g''); was ((-a + a) * (b + c) + c * (-b + b)) / 3; expand left -1/3/a*a*b*c +III.P16.g2 Ch III §1 Problem 16 zero - a*b*c*(1/a+1/b+1/c) - (a*b+b*c+c*a) - C sigma3*conj(sigma1) - sigma2; was a*b + b*(-a + c) + -b*c (reversed order gave 0) +III.P16.g3 Ch III §1 Problem 16 zero - (a*b+b*c+c*a) - a*b*c*(1/a+1/b+1/c) - C reversed operand order of III.P16.g2; was 0 +III.P16.sqrt Ch III §1 Problem 16 zero - (a+b+c)/3/sqrt(a*b*c) - sqrt(a*b*c)*(1/(a*b)+1/(b*c)+1/(c*a))/3 - C centroid reflected in the Simson-direction diameter, via sqrt(sigma3); was 0 provided ... +III.P17.solve Ch III §1 Problem 17 solve z z - a = b*c*(1/z - 1/a) { a, -b*c/a } C second intersection of an altitude with (O); was quadratic formula keeping sqrt((bc/a + a)^2) +III.P17.factor Ch III §1 Problem 17 equal - a*z^2 + (b*c - a^2)*z - a*b*c (a - z)*(-a*z - b*c) C the quadratic factorised; collapse gave this, factor::z:: refused +III.P17.solvef Ch III §1 Problem 17 solve z (a - z)*(-a*z - b*c) = 0 { a, -b*c/a } C the factored form solved; was { a, -b * c / a } +III.P18.1.p1 Ch III §1 Problem 18 1° zero - s*((u - L*r/s + L*t/(s*u))/(1 - L)) + t*((1/u - r/(L*t) + s*u/(L*t))/(1 - 1/L)) - r - C P1 on the line s*z + t*conj(z) = r (s, t = conj s, r real, L = lambda); was 0 provided ... +III.P18.1.trig Ch III §1 Problem 18 1° zero - (cos(2*x) - 1)^2 + sin(2*x)^2 - 4*sin(x)^2 - C |e^(2ix) - 1|^2 = 4 sin^2 x; was 2 + (-2)*cos(2x) + (-4)*sin(x)^2, no further +III.P18.1.trig2 Ch III §1 Problem 18 1° zero - 2 - 2*cos(2*x) - 4*sin(x)^2 - C respelling of III.P18.1.trig; was 0 +III.P18.2 Ch III §1 Problem 18 2° zero - (cos(2*(x + pi - x)) + i*sin(2*(x + pi - x)))*1 - 1 - - lambda*mu = 1 for beta = pi - alpha, so m = 0 (concurrent); correction of III.P18.2.err; was 0 +III.P18.2.err Ch III §1 Problem 18 2° (p. 148) erratum - cos(2*(x + x)) + i*sin(2*(x + x)) 1 R book's theorem says beta = alpha; then lambda*mu = e^(4ix) != 1, lines do not concur; true beta = -alpha = pi - alpha +III.P18.3 Ch III §1 Problem 18 3° equal - (L*1 - 1)/(1 - L) -1 C m for beta = 0 (half-turn); was -1 provided L != 1 +III.P19.b1 Ch III §1 Problem 19 zero - (1 + u^2)/u - (u + 1/u) - C the residual of b1 in (52)/(53); was 0 provided u != 0 alone, the full b1 was not reduced +III.P20.a1 Ch III §1 Problem 20 zero - (v + w - v*w*(1/(v + w))) - ((u + v + w) - (u*v + v*w + w*u)/(v + w)) - C a1 = A0 (centre of OBC, a0 = vw/(v+w)) reflected in BC equals s1 - s2/(v+w); was 0 provided v + w != 0 +III.P21.r Ch III §1 Problem 21 (59) zero - 2*p*(((u + v - u*v*q) + (w + y - w*y*q))/2) - 2*q*(u*v*w*y)*(((1/u + 1/v - p/(u*v)) + (1/w + 1/y - p/(w*y)))/2) + (v*w*y + u*w*y + u*v*y + u*v*w)*q - p*(u + v + w + y) - C midpoint R of P_uvP_wy on line (59), q = conj p; was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P21.s Ch III §1 Problem 21 (59) zero - 2*p*(((u + w - u*w*q) + (v + y - v*y*q))/2) - 2*q*(u*v*w*y)*(((1/u + 1/w - p/(u*w)) + (1/v + 1/y - p/(v*y)))/2) + (v*w*y + u*w*y + u*v*y + u*v*w)*q - p*(u + v + w + y) - C midpoint S of P_uwP_vy on line (59), q = conj p; was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P21.t Ch III §1 Problem 21 (59) zero - 2*p*(((u + y - u*y*q) + (v + w - v*w*q))/2) - 2*q*(u*v*w*y)*(((1/u + 1/y - p/(u*y)) + (1/v + 1/w - p/(v*w)))/2) + (v*w*y + u*w*y + u*v*y + u*v*w)*q - p*(u + v + w + y) - C midpoint T of P_uyP_vw on line (59), q = conj p; was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P21.o Ch III §1 Problem 21 (59) zero - 2*p*((u + v + w + y)/2) - 2*q*(u*v*w*y)*((1/u + 1/v + 1/w + 1/y)/2) + (v*w*y + u*w*y + u*v*y + u*v*w)*q - p*(u + v + w + y) - C O' (O reflected in the centroid) on line (59); was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P21.o2 Ch III §1 Problem 21 (59) zero - q * (u * (v * (w + y) + w * y) + v * w * y) - q * u * v * w * y * (1 / u + 1 / v + 1 / w + 1 / y) - C the residual of III.P21.o, q*(sigma3 - sigma4*conj sigma1); was printed unreduced +III.P22.1 Ch III §1 Problem 22 zero - ((u + 1/u)/2*v*w + (v + w)/2)/2 - (u*v*w/4 + (u*v + v*w + w*u)/(4*u)) - C a4 = sigma3/4 + sigma2/(4 z1); was 0 provided u != 0 +III.P22.R Ch III §1 Problem 22 Remark (62) zero - (i/4*det([[(u*v*w/4 + (u*v + v*w + w*u)/(4*u)), (1/(4*u*v*w) + (u + v + w)*u/(4*u*v*w)), 1], [(v*w*u/4 + (v*w + w*u + u*v)/(4*v)), (1/(4*v*w*u) + (v + w + u)*v/(4*v*w*u)), 1], [(w*u*v/4 + (w*u + u*v + v*w)/(4*w)), (1/(4*w*u*v) + (w + u + v)*w/(4*w*u*v)), 1]])) + (u + v + w)*(1/u + 1/v + 1/w)/16*(i/4*det([[u, 1/u, 1], [v, 1/v, 1], [w, 1/w, 1]])) - C (A4B4C4)/(ABC) = -OH^2/16 for R = 1, hand-conjugated; was not reduced, 0 at exact points +III.P22.2.err1 Ch III §1 Problem 22 (p. 159) erratum - (u/b)*(v/b)*(w/b)/4 u*v*w/b^3 C centre in the frame turned by beta (=b): book prints sigma3/beta^3, true sigma3/(4 beta^3) +III.P22.2.err2 Ch III §1 Problem 22 (p. 159) erratum - b*((u/b)*(v/b)*(w/b)/4) u*v*w/b^2 C same centre in the old frame: book prints sigma3/beta^2, true sigma3/(4 beta^2) +III.P22.2.cor Ch III §1 Problem 22 zero - b*((u/b)*(v/b)*(w/b)/4) - u*v*w/(4*b^2) - C correction of III.P22.2.err2: centre sigma3/(4 beta^2), checked against the rebuilt A4B4C4 +III.P23.1.A Ch III §1 Problem 23 1° equal - pi / (7/4) 4*pi/7 - angle A from solvesys A - 2B, B - 2C, A + B + C = pi; printed unsimplified +III.P23.1.B Ch III §1 Problem 23 1° equal - -pi / (7/4) / (-2) 2*pi/7 - angle B from the same solvesys; printed unsimplified +III.P23.1.C Ch III §1 Problem 23 1° equal - --pi / (7/4) / (-2) / (-2) pi/7 - angle C from the same solvesys; printed unsimplified +III.P23.2.sum Ch III §1 Problem 23 2° zero - 1 + (e^(2*pi*i/7)) + (e^(2*pi*i/7))^2 + (e^(2*pi*i/7))^3 + (e^(2*pi*i/7))^4 + (e^(2*pi*i/7))^5 + (e^(2*pi*i/7))^6 - - 1 + alpha + ... + alpha^6 = 0, alpha a primitive 7th root of unity; was 0 +III.P23.2.pow Ch III §1 Problem 23 equal - (e^(2*pi*i/7))^7 1 - alpha^7 = 1 (bracketed power); was 1 +III.P23.4.slope Ch III §1 Problem 23 4° zero - (e^(2*pi*i/7))^5/((e^(2*pi*i/7))^6)^5 - (e^(2*pi*i/7))^3 - - complex slope of O-Omega (omega = alpha^5, conj alpha = alpha^6) is alpha^3; was 0 +III.P24.setup.a Ch III §3 Problem 24 solve x x^3 + 1 = 0 { -1, ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2), ((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2) } C alpha, conj(alpha) are the non-real roots of x^3+1; was right but roots printed as (..)*(-1) +III.P24.setup.b Ch III §3 Problem 24 zero - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)^2 - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2) + 1 - - alpha^2 - alpha + 1 = 0; was 0 +III.P24.setup.c Ch III §3 Problem 24 zero - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2) - (cos(pi/3)+i*sin(pi/3)) - - alpha = cis(pi/3); was 0 +III.P24.1 Ch III §3 Problem 24 1° (69) zero - ((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5)) - ((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1)) - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*(((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3)) - ((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1))) - C diagonal vectors p'_k=a'_{k+3}-a'_k form equilateral triangle; a'_k=conj(al)a_{k+1}+al*a_k; was 0 +III.P24.2.pivot Ch III §3 Problem 24 2° equal - a_1 + (((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1 + ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*c_1) + ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*c_2) + ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*c_3) ((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*c_1 + c_2 + ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*c_3 C a_1+a_4 independent of a_1 via chain a_{k+1}=conj(al)a_k+al*c_k (pivot O_1); was right +III.P24.3 Ch III §3 Problem 24 3° (71) zero - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2) - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1)) - (a_1 - a_2 + a_3) - C a''_1 = a_1 - a_2 + a_3 from a''_k = al(a'_{k+1} - al a'_k); was 0 +III.P24.4 Ch III §3 Problem 24 4° zero - (a_4-a_5+a_6) - (a_1-a_2+a_3) - (a_4-a_1+a_6-a_3+a_2-a_5) - C A''_1A''_4 = 3 OG; was 0 +III.P24.5 Ch III §3 Problem 24 5° zero - (a_1-a_2+a_3) + (a_2-a_3+a_4) - (a_1+a_4) - C a''_1 + a''_2 = a_1 + a_4 (common midpoint); linear +III.E1 Ch III §3 Problem 24 1°, p. 169 erratum - ((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5)) ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3)) + (1 - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)) C printed p'5 = al p'3 + (1-al); true: al p'3 + (1-al) p'1 (see III.P24.1) +III.E1.corr Ch III §3 Problem 24 1°, p. 169 zero - ((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5)) - (((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_6)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_3)) + (1 - ((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2))*((((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_5+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_4)-(((1-sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_2+((1+sqrt(3)*i)/2)*a_1))) - C correction of III.E1; was 0 +III.P25.setup.chord Ch III §3 Problem 25 (73)-(74) zero - ((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2) + z_2*z_3*((1/z_2+1/z_3+pc-p/(z_2*z_3))/2) - z_2 - z_3 - C foot a_1 lies on chord BC (z + z2 z3 conj(z) = z2 + z3); was 0 +III.P25.setup.perp Ch III §3 Problem 25 (74) zero - ((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2-p)/(z_3-z_2) + ((1/z_2+1/z_3+pc-p/(z_2*z_3))/2-pc)/(1/z_3-1/z_2) - C PA_1 perpendicular to BC; was unchanged (not 0), exact 0 +III.P25.Q1.ratio Ch III §3 Problem 25 Q_1 zero - ((((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc+p+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2)-((z_1+z_2+p-z_1*z_2*pc)/2))/(((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2)-((z_1+z_2+p-z_1*z_2*pc)/2)) - (pc-1/z_2)/(1/z_3-1/z_2) - C C1B1Q1 ~ BCP opposite orientation, ratio form; was 0 +III.P25.Q1.det Ch III §3 Problem 25 Q_1 zero - det([[1/z_2, ((z_1+z_2+p-z_1*z_2*pc)/2), 1],[1/z_3, ((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2), 1],[pc, (((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc+p+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2), 1]]) - C similarity determinant for Q_1; was 0 only on a second pass +III.P25.1 Ch III §3 Problem 25 1° zero - ((((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc+p+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2)-((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2))/(((z_1+z_2+p-z_1*z_2*pc)/2)-((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2)) - (pc-1/z_3)/(1/z_1-1/z_3) - C A1C1Q1 ~ CAP opposite orientation; was not 0 (relabelled 25-2° passed), exact 0 +III.P25.2 Ch III §3 Problem 25 2° zero - ((((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc+p+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2)-((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2))/(((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2)-((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2)) - (pc-1/z_1)/(1/z_2-1/z_1) - C B1A1Q1 ~ ABP opposite orientation; was 0 +III.P25.3.line Ch III §3 Problem 25 3° zero - ((-(1/z_1)*(p-z_1)/(pc-1/z_1))-p)/(z_1-p) - ((-z_1*(pc-1/z_1)/(p-z_1))-pc)/(1/z_1-pc) - C second intersection a' lies on line PA; was 0 only on a second pass +III.P25.3.lam Ch III §3 Problem 25 3° zero - (-(1/z_2)*(p-z_2)/(pc-1/z_2)) - (-(1/z_1)*(p-z_1)/(pc-1/z_1)) - (2*(p*pc-1)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^3-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc^2+(z_1+z_2+z_3)*pc-1))*(((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2) - ((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2)) - C b'-a' = lambda(b1-a1), lambda symmetric; was not 0, exact 0 +III.P25.3.75 Ch III §3 Problem 25 3° (75) zero - (z_1*z_2*z_3)*(pc-1/z_1)*(pc-1/z_2)*(pc-1/z_3) - ((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^3-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc^2+(z_1+z_2+z_3)*pc-1) - C Vieta with conjugates; was 0 only on a second pass +III.P25.4.equi Ch III §3 Problem 25 4° zero - (((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2))*(((pc^2*p-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2+(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((1/z_2+1/z_3+pc-p/(z_2*z_3))/2)) - (((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((z_3+z_1+p-z_3*z_1*pc)/2))*(((pc^2*p-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2+(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((1/z_3+1/z_1+pc-p/(z_3*z_1))/2)) - C O_1 equidistant from A_1 and B_1; was not 0, exact 0 +III.P25.4.79 Ch III §3 Problem 25 4° (79) zero - (-(1/z_1)*(p-z_1)/(pc-1/z_1)) + (-(1/z_2)*(p-z_2)/(pc-1/z_2)) + (-(1/z_3)*(p-z_3)/(pc-1/z_3)) + ((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*p*pc^2-2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*p*pc+3*p-3*(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/((z_1*z_2*z_3)*(pc-1/z_1)*(pc-1/z_2)*(pc-1/z_3)) - C a'+b'+c' = -X/(s3 Y), Y=prod(pc-1/z_k); was 0 +III.E3 Ch III §3 Problem 25 4°, p. 178 erratum - ((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*p*pc^2-2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*p*pc+3*p-3*(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3)) p*pc^2*(z_1*z_2*z_3) - 2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*p*pc + 3*p - 3*(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2 - 2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc - (z_1+z_2+z_3) C printed X has -2 s2 pc (and s3 p pc^2); true X = s2 p pc^2 - 2 s1 p pc + 3p - 3 s3 pc^2 + 2 s2 pc - s1 +III.P25.4.inv Ch III §3 Problem 25 4° inversion zero - ((((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc+p+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2)-((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1))))*(((p*pc+1)/(2*p))-((pc^2*p-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2+(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))) - (((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2))*(((pc^2*p-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2+(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))-((1/z_2+1/z_3+pc-p/(z_2*z_3))/2)) - C Q_1 is the inverse of T in (A1B1C1); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P25.5.solve Ch III §3 Problem 25 5° solve z l*z + m = z { -m/(l-1) } C fixed point of z -> lambda z + mu; was right +III.P25.5 Ch III §3 Problem 25 5° zero - ((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1)))/(1 - pc*(((p*pc+1)/(2*pc)) - ((p^2*pc-(z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^2+(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))/(2*(p*pc-1))))) - ((-(1/z_1)*(p-z_1)/(pc-1/z_1)) - (2*(p*pc-1)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^3-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc^2+(z_1+z_2+z_3)*pc-1))*((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2))/(1 - (2*(p*pc-1)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)*pc^3-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*pc^2+(z_1+z_2+z_3)*pc-1))) - C fixed point omega closed form vs (a'-lambda a1)/(1-lambda); was 20 s timeout, exact 0 +III.P25.6 Ch III §3 Problem 25 6° zero - ((z_1*z_2*z_3)*(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)^2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)*(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)+(z_1+z_2+z_3)+(z_1+z_2+z_3))/2 - (z_1+z_2+z_3) - C q_1 at P = H (p = s1) equals H; was not 0, exact 0 +III.E4 Ch III §3 Problem 25 6°, p. 180 erratum - 2*((z_2+z_3+p-z_2*z_3*pc)/2) z_2 - z_3 + p - z_2*z_3*pc C second numerator of a'-a_1 printed z2 - z3 + ...; true z2 + z3 + p - z2 z3 pc (= 2 a_1) +III.E5 Ch III §3 Problem 25 6°, p. 181 erratum - (1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2 - (1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p - pc + (1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3) (1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))*p^2 - (1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))*p - pc - (1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3) C conjugate of (80) printed with -conj(s1); true +conj(s1) = +s2/s3 +III.P26.82 Ch III §3 Problem 26 (82) zero - b + (1/(a*b)) - b*(1/(a*b))*(a^2/p^3) - ((a+b+(1/(a*b))) - (1+p^(-3))*a) - C a'' = s1 - (1+p^-3) a, reflection of p^3/a^2 in BC, c = 1/(ab); was 0 +III.P26.2 Ch III §3 Problem 26 2° zero - (a-((a+b+(1/(a*b)))-(1+p^(-3))*b))/(a-((a+b+(1/(a*b)))-(1+p^(-3))*(1/(a*b)))) - (1/a-((1/a+1/b+a*b)-(1+p^3)/b))/(1/a-((1/a+1/b+a*b)-(1+p^3)*a*b)) - C (a-b'')/(a-c'') is real, c = 1/(ab); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P26.3 Ch III §3 Problem 26 3° equal - apply(lambda(z, q - (1 + p^(-3))*z), 0) q C orthocentre s1 = q is the centre of (A"B"C"); was q provided not p = 0 +III.P26.5.a Ch III §3 Problem 26 5° equal - (1+cos(t))^2 + sin(t)^2 2 + 2*cos(t) C modulus squared of 1 + cis(t); was 2 + 2cos(t) +III.P26.5.b Ch III §3 Problem 26 5° zero - 2 + 2*cos(t) - 4*cos(t/2)^2 - C half-angle step; was unchanged +III.P26.5.c Ch III §3 Problem 26 5° equal - sqrt((1+cos(3*x))^2 + sin(3*x)^2) 2*abs(cos(3*x/2)) R R" = 2|cos(3 phi/2)|; was unchanged (also AM_REAL) +III.E6 Ch III §3 Problem 26 5°, p. 185 erratum - sqrt((1+cos(3*x))^2 + sin(3*x)^2) sqrt((1+cos(3*x))^2 + sin(x)^2) R printed sin^2(phi); true sin^2(3 phi); at phi = pi/9 printed - 2|cos(3phi/2)| = -0.1935 +III.P26.7 Ch III §3 Problem 26 7° solve x 2*cos(3*x/2) = 1 { 2/9*pi + 4/3*pi*n_1, -2/9*pi + 4/3*pi*n_1 } R one branch of |1+p^3| = 1; was right but unnormalised +III.E7 Ch III §3 Problem 26 7°, p. 186 erratum - abs(1 + e^(7/3*i*pi)) 1 - book: OT2 (60 deg) rotated 80 deg is a solution; true |1+e^(7i pi/3)| = sqrt(3); solutions 40,80,160,200,280,320 deg +III.E7.corr Ch III §3 Problem 26 7°, p. 186 zero - abs(1 + e^(4/3*i*pi)) - 1 - - correction of III.E7: OT1 rotated 80 deg, p^3 at 240 deg +III.P26.8 Ch III §3 Problem 26 8° solve z q - (1+p^(-3))*z = z { q/(2+p^(-3)) } C fixed point omega' = s1/(2+p^-3); was right, unnormalised +III.P26.9 Ch III §3 Problem 26 9° zero - ((q/(2+p^(-3)))-2*q/3)*((qc/(2+p^3))-2*qc/3) - q*qc/9 - C Omega' runs over circle (GH), conj p = 1/p; was 0 +III.P26.10 Ch III §3 Problem 26 10° solve p 1/(2+p^(-3)) = 1/3 { 1, -1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i, -1/2 - sqrt(3)/2*i } C Omega' = G iff p^3 = 1; was { } (wrong answer, solver bug) +III.P26.11 Ch III §3 Problem 26 11° solve p 1/(2+p^(-3)) = 1 { -1, 1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i, 1/2 - sqrt(3)/2*i } C Omega' = H iff p^3 = -1; was { } (wrong answer, solver bug) +III.P26.12 Ch III §3 Problem 26 12° zero - ((q/3*(2-p^(-3)))-2*q/3)*((qc/3*(2-p^3))-2*qc/3) - q*qc/9 - C G" runs over circle (GH); was 0 +III.P26.13 Ch III §3 Problem 26 13° zero - 3*(q/3*(2-p^(-3)))*(q/(2+p^(-3))) - 4*(q/(2+p^(-3)))*q + q^2 - C eliminating p: 3 g'' w' - 4 w' s1 + s1^2 = 0; was 0 +III.P26.13.factor Ch III §3 Problem 26 13° equal - 3*z^2 - 4*q*z + q^2 (q - 3*z)*(q - z) C fixed points H and G of the Moebius map; factor was right +III.P26.13.solve Ch III §3 Problem 26 13° solve z 3*z^2 - 4*q*z + q^2 = 0 { q, q/3 } C fixed points H and G; was 2/3 q -+ sqrt(q^2)/3, sqrt(q^2) unresolved +III.P26.14 Ch III §3 Problem 26 14° zero - q*qc*(-1/3 + (1 + (-2)/(p^3 + 2))/3) + 2/3*q*qc/(p^3 + 2) - C residual of the O1-Omega*-G" collinearity det; was left non-zero after re-simplifying +III.P27.Ap Ch III §3 Problem 27 zero - 1/((1/(z_2*z_3))*(z_0*z_0c-1)/(z_0c+z_0/(z_2*z_3)-1/z_2-1/z_3)) - (1/(z_0*z_0c-1))*(z_0 + z_0c*(1/z_1)*(z_1*z_2*z_3) + z_1 - (z_1+z_2+z_3)) - C a' = 1/conj(a0) = (1/sigma)(z0 + conj(z0) conj(z1) s3 + z1 - s1); was 0 only on a second pass +III.P29.alpha Ch III §3 Problem 29 zero - 2*z_1 - z_1^2*(z_2+z_3-z_2*z_3*p) - ((z_1*z_2*z_3) + z_1*(2 - (z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1) + p*(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - C alpha = s3 + z1(2 - s2 + p s3); was 0 +III.P29.simson Ch III §3 Problem 29 zero - (((z_2+z_3+(z_1*z_2*z_3)-z_2*z_3*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3)))/2) - ((z_1+z_2+(z_1*z_2*z_3)-z_1*z_2*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3)))/2)) - (((1/z_2+1/z_3+(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))-(z_1*z_2*z_3)/(z_2*z_3))/2) - ((1/z_1+1/z_2+(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))-(z_1*z_2*z_3)/(z_1*z_2))/2)) - C Simson line of Q = s3 w.r.t. DEF is parallel to the real axis; was 0 +III.P29.radius Ch III §3 Problem 29 zero - (2-(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)+p*(z_1*z_2*z_3))*(2-(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))+pc*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - (2*(z_1*z_2*z_3)+pc-(z_1+z_2+z_3))*(2*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))+p-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)) - C radius of (alpha beta gamma) = 2 IN; was not 0, exact 0 +III.E8 Ch III §3 Problem 29, p. 198 erratum - 1/z_3 - 1/z_2 (1/(z_2*z_3))*(z_3 - z_2) C F' on line E'F' as printed (slope +1/(z2 z3)); true slope -1/(z2 z3), residual 2(1/z3 - 1/z2) +III.E8.corr Ch III §3 Problem 29, p. 198 zero - 1/z_3 - 1/z_2 + (1/(z_2*z_3))*(z_3 - z_2) - C correction of III.E8: F' on z - conj(z2) = -(1/(z2 z3))(conj(z) - z2); was 0 +III.P30 Ch III §3 Problem 30 zero - z_3 + z_4 + z_3*z_4*(1/z_1+1/z_2) - z_3*z_4*(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3+1/z_4) - C apex A12 reflected in A3A4 is z3 z4 conj(s1); was 0 +III.P31.dstar Ch III §3 Problem 31 zero - (-z_2*z_3/z_1 - z_1)/(z_3 - z_2) + (-z_1/(z_2*z_3) - 1/z_1)/(1/z_3 - 1/z_2) - C d* = -z2 z3/z1 lies on the altitude from D; was 0 +III.P31.aprime Ch III §3 Problem 31 zero - (z_1/(z_2*z_3) + z_2*z_3/z_1) - (z_2*z_3/z_1 + z_1/(z_2*z_3)) - C a' - d* is real (D*A' parallel to delta); was 0 +III.P31.astar Ch III §3 Problem 31 zero - 2*z_1 - z_1^2*(z_2*z_3/z_1) - (2*z_1 - (z_1*z_2*z_3)) - C a* = 2 z1 - s3, reflection of a' in the tangent at D; was 0 +III.P31.mid Ch III §3 Problem 31 zero - ((z_1+z_2+z_3)/3 + (2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)/3 - (z_1*z_2*z_3)))/2 - ((z_1+z_2+z_3) - (z_1*z_2*z_3))/2 - C midpoint of g and g* is (s1 - s3)/2, the orthopole of delta; was 0 +III.P31.remark Ch III §3 Problem 31 zero - z_1^2*(z_2*z_3/z_1) - (z_1*z_2*z_3) - C reflection of a' in DI is s3: z1^2 conj(a') = s3 +III.P32.1.equi Ch III §3 Problem 32 1° zero - ((2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(1/z_2+1/z_3)))*((2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(z_2+z_3))) - ((2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(1/z_3+1/z_1)))*((2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(z_3+z_1))) - C circumcentre o = 2 s1 s3/(s1 s2 - s3) equidistant from a and b; was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.1.conj Ch III §3 Problem 32 1° zero - 2*(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))/((1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)*(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - (2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - C conj(o) = 2 s2/(s1 s2 - s3); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.2.R Ch III §3 Problem 32 2° zero - ((2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(1/z_2+1/z_3)))*((2*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))-(2/(z_2+z_3))) - (2*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))^2 - C R = 2 s3/(s3 - s1 s2); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.2.lam Ch III §3 Problem 32 2° zero - ((z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1))) - (1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))/((1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))-(1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)*(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))) - C lambda = s3/(s3 - s1 s2) is real; was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.4 Ch III §3 Problem 32 4° zero - (2/(1/z_2+1/z_3)) + (2/(1/z_3+1/z_1)) + (2/(1/z_1+1/z_2)) - 2*(2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - 2*((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)^2-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2*z_3))/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)) - C h = a+b+c-2o = 2(s2^2 - s1 s3)/(s1 s2 - s3); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.5 Ch III §3 Problem 32 5° zero - (1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))^2/((1/z_1+1/z_2+1/z_3)*(1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_2*z_3)+1/(z_3*z_1))-(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - ((z_1+z_2+z_3)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - C conj(eps) = s1^2/(s1 s2 - s3); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.6.dist Ch III §3 Problem 32 6° zero - ((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))*((z_1+z_2+z_3)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) - (((z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))-1)^2 - C |eps| = rho - 1, incircle touches Euler circle; was 0 +III.P32.6.phi0 Ch III §3 Problem 32 6° zero - ((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/(z_1+z_2+z_3) - ((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))))*((z_1+z_2+z_3)/(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1) - ((z_1+z_2+z_3)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3)))) - ((z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))^2 - C Feuerbach point phi0 = s2/s1 on the Euler circle; was not 0, exact 0 +III.E9 Ch III §3 Problem 32 6°, p. 211 erratum - 2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)) ((z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1))/((z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)) - 1 C printed (s3 - s1 s2)/(s3 - s1 s2) - 1; true (s3 + s1 s2)/(s3 - s1 s2) - 1 = 2 s1 s2/(s3 - s1 s2) +III.E9.corr Ch III §3 Problem 32 6°, p. 211 zero - ((z_1*z_2*z_3) + (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1))/((z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)) - 1 - 2*(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)/((z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)) - C correction of III.E9; was 0 +III.P32.7.conj Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - 4*(1/(z_1*z_2*z_3))/((1/z_1+1/z_2)*(1/z_1+1/z_3)) - (4*z_1/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) - C conj(tau_a) = 4 z1/((z1+z2)(z1+z3)); was 0 +III.E10 Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° (112), p. 212 erratum - (4*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) + z_1*z_2*(4*z_1/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) 4*z_1*z_3/(z_1+z_3) C printed line (112) z + z1 z2 conj(z); true z + z1 z3 conj(z) (slope -b/conj(b) = -z1 z3) +III.E10.corr Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° (112), p. 212 zero - (4*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) + z_1*z_3*(4*z_1/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) - 4*z_1*z_3/(z_1+z_3) - C correction of III.E10: tau_a on the corrected (112); was 0 only on a second pass +III.P32.7.ta Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - (4*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) + (2*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))*2*((z_1+z_2+z_3) - z_1) - C tau_a = -2R(s1 - z1); was 0 +III.P32.7.t1 Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - (2/(1/z_3+1/z_1)) + (2/(1/z_1+1/z_2)) - z_1 - ((2*(z_1*z_2*z_3)+z_1*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-z_1^3)/((z_1+z_3)*(z_1+z_2))) - C contact point t1 = b + c - z1 = (2 s3 + z1 s2 - z1^3)/((z1+z3)(z1+z2)); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.7.ra Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - ((4*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) - ((2*(z_1*z_2*z_3)+z_1*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-z_1^3)/((z_1+z_3)*(z_1+z_2))))/z_1 - ((z_1-z_2)*(z_1-z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))) - C exradius r_a = (tau_a - t1)/z1 = (z1-z2)(z1-z3)/((z1+z2)(z1+z3)); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P32.7.u1 Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - ((z_1*z_2+z_1*z_3-z_2*z_3)/(z_2+z_3-z_1))*((1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_1*z_3)-1/(z_2*z_3))/(1/z_2+1/z_3-1/z_1)) - 1 - C |u1| = 1 for u1 = (z1 z2 + z1 z3 - z2 z3)/(z2 + z3 - z1); was 0 +III.P32.7.lemma Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - (z_1-z_2)*(z_1-z_3)*(z_2+z_3) - (z_1*z_2*z_3) - (z_1-z_2-z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_1*z_3-z_2*z_3) - C factorisation lemma for the tangency double root; was 0 +III.P32.7.phi1 Ch III §3 Problem 32 7° zero - (((z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) + ((z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))*((z_1*z_2+z_1*z_3-z_2*z_3)/(z_2+z_3-z_1)) - (4*(z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3))))*(((z_1+z_2+z_3)^2/((z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)-(z_1*z_2*z_3))) + ((z_1*z_2*z_3)/((z_1*z_2*z_3)-(z_1+z_2+z_3)*(z_1*z_2+z_2*z_3+z_3*z_1)))*((1/(z_1*z_2)+1/(z_1*z_3)-1/(z_2*z_3))/(1/z_2+1/z_3-1/z_1)) - (4*z_1/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3)))) - ((z_1-z_2)*(z_1-z_3)/((z_1+z_2)*(z_1+z_3)))^2 - C Feuerbach point phi1 = eps + rho u1 lies on the excircle (I_a); was not 0, exact 0 +III.P33.a Ch III §1 Problem 33 zero - R^2*(1-(u-s*t)/u) - R^2*(1 - 2/R*(R*(u-s*t)/(2*u))) - C Euler d^2=R^2-2Rr, last line via R, conj sigma_1 by hand; was 0 provided R*u!=0 +III.P33.b Ch III §1 Problem 33 zero - 4*s*t*u/(s*t-u)^2 - 4*u^2/(u-s*t)^2 - 4*u/(s*t-u) - C Euler formula with R expanded; was returned unchanged +III.P33.c Ch III §1 Problem 33 zero - (2*s*u/(s*t-u))*(2*t/(s*t-u)) - ((2*u/(u-s*t))^2 - 2*(2*u/(u-s*t))) - C Euler formula, o*conj(o) vs R^2-2R; was not reduced to 0 +III.P34.a Ch III §1 Problem 34 zero - det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]]) - (c-a)*(c-b)*(b-a)/(a*b*c) - C oriented-area determinant on unit circle (conj = 1/z); was 0 provided +III.P34.b Ch III §1 Problem 34 equal - a^2 * (c - b) + a * (b ^ 2 - c ^ 2) + b * c ^ 2 - b ^ 2 * c (b - c) * -1 * (a - b) * (a - c) C area determinant cleared of denominators; collapse gave this product +III.P34.c Ch III §1 Problem 34 equal - b*c/(b^2+c^2) + b*c/(b^2+c^2) - 1 -(b-c)^2/(b^2+c^2) C f(a_0); was 2*b*c/(b^2+c^2) - 1, never the book's form +III.P34.d Ch III §1 Problem 34 equal - (b*c)^2/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) + a^2/(b^2+c^2) - 1 (a^2-b^2)*(a^2-c^2)/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) C f(z_1), expected as used in the ratio probe p9; was (a^4+(b*c)^2)/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) - 1 +III.P34.e Ch III §1 Problem 34 zero - (1/(b*c))/(1/b - 1/c)^2 - b*c/(b-c)^2 - C u = b0c0/(b0-c0)^2 equals its conjugate (reciprocals); was 0 provided +III.P34.f Ch III §1 Problem 34 zero - (a^2-b^2)*(a^2-c^2)/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) / (-(b-c)^2/(b^2+c^2)) + (a-b)*(a-c)*(b-c)*(a+b)*(a+c)/(a^2*(b-c)^3) - C ratio f(z_1)/f(a_0) before (121); correction of III.E1.a; was 0 provided +III.P34.g Ch III §1 Problem 34 (altitudes) solve z z - a = b*c*(1/z - 1/a) { a, -b*c/a } C second intersection z_1 = -b0c0/a0; was quadratic formula with a perfect square under sqrt +III.P34.h Ch III §1 Problem 34 (altitudes) solve z a*z^2 - (a^2 - b*c)*z - a*b*c = 0 { a, -b*c/a } C cleared form of the second intersection; was quadratic formula, unsimplified (D5) +III.P34.i Ch III §1 Problem 34 (altitudes) equal - a*z^2 - (a^2 - b*c)*z - a*b*c (a - z) * (-a * z - b * c) C factored second-intersection quadratic; collapse gave this, factor refused +III.P35.a Ch III §1 Problem 35 solve z z - c = a*b*(1/z - 1/c) { c, -a*b/c } C second intersection of altitude with circle; was the same unsimplified quadratic-formula pair +III.P35.b Ch III §1 Problem 35 solve z z^2 = b*c { sqrt(b)*sqrt(c), -sqrt(b)*sqrt(c) } C z_1 = +-sqrt(b1)sqrt(c1); was { sqrt(b*c), -sqrt(b*c) } +III.P35.c Ch III §1 Problem 35 (127) equal - -((-y*z)*(-z*x))/(-x*y) z^2 C row check of (127); was z^2 provided not x*y = 0 +III.P35.d Ch III §1 Problem 35 (126) equal - -((y*z)*(z*x))/(x*y) -z^2 C row check of (126): gives -z^2 not z^2, so (126) fails as the book says; was -z^2 provided +III.P35.e Ch III §1 Problem 35 zero - (-y*z)*(-z*x)*(-x*y) + x^2*y^2*z^2 - C compatibility a1b1c1 = -z1z2z3 (squared form); was 0 +III.P36.a Ch III §1 Problem 36 (128) equal - -(-q ^ 2 * r * p * -(-p ^ 2 + q * r) / (-p ^ 2 * q * r) + -q ^ 2 + r * p) / (1 + -q ^ 2 * r * p * (-1) * (-1) * 1 / p ^ 2 * 1 / q * 1 / r) -(p*q + q*r + r*p) C incentre from solvesys z entry (bisector lines); simplify never cancelled p - q +III.P36.b Ch III §1 Problem 36 (128) zero - (-(p ^ 2 * q - q ^ 2 * r) / p - p * r + q ^ 2) / (1 + -q / p) + (p*q + q*r + r*p) - C simplified incentre entry plus pq+qr+rp; was still nested, not 0 +III.P36.c Ch III §1 Problem 36 equal - ((a+b+c) + (a-b-c))/2 a C midpoint of I I_a is A_0; was a +III.P37.a Ch III §1 Problem 37 (1) equal - det([[1 - p/a, -b*c + a*b*c*P], [1 - p/b, -c*a + a*b*c*P]]) c*(b-a)*(1-p*P) C Cramer determinant Delta, P = conj(p); det_s gave expanded form provided a,b != 0 +III.P37.b Ch III §1 Problem 37 (1) zero - (1 - p/a)*(-c*a + a*b*c*P) - (1 - p/b)*(-b*c + a*b*c*P) - c*(b-a)*(1-p*P) - C Delta minus book form; was p*P*(-a*c + a*c + -b*c + b*c) provided, not a fixed point (D1) +III.P37.c Ch III §1 Problem 37 (2) zero - u*(1/a - 1/p)/(1 - p/a) + u/p - C reflected lines parallel, slope -sigma_3 conj(p) with |p|=1 by hand; was 0 provided +III.P37.d Ch III §1 Problem 37 (3) zero - x*b + y*c + a + a*b*c*(x/b + y/c)/a - (a + (x+y)*(b+c)) - C point on BC has A as isogonal conjugate, conj by hand; was 0 provided +III.P38.a Ch III §1 Problem 38 1° zero - (s/3 + (t/u)/3*t - s - u*((t/u)/3)^2)/((s/3)*((t/u)/3) - 1) - 2*(t*(t/u) - 3*s)/(s*(t/u) - 9) - C Lemoine point as isogonal conjugate of centroid; reading's probe had t/3 for s/3, was unchanged +III.P38.b Ch III §1 Problem 38 1° equal - s/3 + (t/u)/3*t - s - u*((t/u)/3)^2 -(2/3)*s + t^2/(3*u) - t^2/(9*u) C middle numerator of the Lemoine step; correction of III.E3.a +III.P38.c Ch III §1 Problem 38 2° zero - (s + (t/u)*t - s - u*(t/u)^2)/(s*(t/u) - 1) - C isogonal conjugate of orthocentre is O; was 0 provided not s*t/u - 1 = 0 +III.P38.d Ch III §1 Problem 38 3° zero - (s/2 + (t/u)/2*t - s - u*((t/u)/2)^2)/((s/2)*((t/u)/2) - 1) - (t*(t/u) - 2*s)/(s*(t/u) - 4) - C isogonal conjugate of nine-point centre; correction of III.E4.a; was not reduced to 0 +III.P39.a Ch III §1 Problem 39 equal - (u*P^2 - t*P - p + s)/(2*(1-p*P)) + (u*P^2 + t*P + p + s)/(2*(1-p*P)) (P^2*u + s)/(1 - p*P) C midpoint of isogonal conjugates of p, -p; was right value with spurious provided not P = 0 (D3) +III.P39.b Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (1) solve x x^2/(1-x^2) = 1 { sqrt(2)/2, -sqrt(2)/2 } - R_1 = R iff OP = R/sqrt(2); was { 1/2*sqrt(2), -1/2*sqrt(2) } +III.P39.c Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (2) solve x x^2/(1-x^2) = 1/2 { sqrt(3)/3, -sqrt(3)/3 } - R_1 = nine-point radius iff OP = R/sqrt(3); was { 1/3*sqrt(3), -1/3*sqrt(3) } +III.P39.d Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (3) solve x x^2/(1-x^2) = x { 0, (-1 - sqrt(5))/2, (-1 + sqrt(5))/2 } - R_1 = OP case OP < R; was exactly these three roots +III.P39.e Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (3) solve x x^2/(x^2-1) = x { 0, (1 + sqrt(5))/2, (1 - sqrt(5))/2 } - R_1 = OP case OP > R; was these roots written over (-2) +III.P39.f Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (3) solve x x^2/abs(1-x^2) = x { 0, (sqrt(5) - 1)/2, (sqrt(5) + 1)/2 } - R_1 = OP with the modulus as printed; was floats plus 2 spurious non-real roots (D4) +III.P39.g Ch III §1 Problem 39 Remark (1) solve x x^2/abs(1-x^2) = 1 { sqrt(2)/2, -sqrt(2)/2 } - R_1 = R with the modulus as printed; was { 1/2*sqrt(2), -1/2*sqrt(2) } +III.P40.a Ch III §1 Problem 40 zero - (s - u*T/t)/2 - s/2 + u*T/(2*t) - C Feuerbach point phi_0 minus nine-point centre, T = conj(tau_0); was 0 provided +III.P40.b Ch III §1 Problem 40 zero - s/2 - u*T/(2*t) - (s - u*T^2)/2 - u*T/(2*t)*(t*T - 1) - C phi_0 minus tau_0 via fixed-point relation; was 0 provided not t = 0 +III.P40.c Ch III §1 Problem 40 zero - (u*T/(2*t)*(t*T-1))/((1/u)*t/(2*T)*(t*T-1)) - u^2*T^2/t^2 - C slopes of phi_0-o_9 and phi_0-tau_0 equal (collinear centres); was 0 provided +III.P40.d Ch III §1 Problem 40 (149) solve d r/(2*R) = r^2/(d - R^2) { R^2 + 2*r*R } C lemma OI_a^2 = R^2 + 2R r_a; was { r^2/(r/(2*R)) + R^2 } unsimplified (D6) +III.P40.e Ch III §1 Problem 40 (149) equal - r ^ 2 / (r / (2 * R)) + R ^ 2 R^2 + 2*r*R C solve's answer for the lemma, simplified; was R^2 + 2*r*R provided not r = 0 +III.P41.a Ch III §1 Problem 41 1° zero - (T+u+v+w)*(T+u-v-w)*(T-u+v-w)*(T-u-v+w) - (T^4 - 2*(u^2+v^2+w^2)*T^2 + 8*u*v*w*T + (u^2+v^2+w^2)^2 - 4*(u^2*v^2+v^2*w^2+w^2*u^2)) - C incentre/excentres are the roots of the fixed-point quartic; expand gave 0 +III.P41.b Ch III §1 Problem 41 1° zero - 2*(-(q*r+r*p+p*q)) + p^2*q^2*r^2*((p+q+r)/(p*q*r))^2 - (p^2+q^2+r^2) - C tau_0 satisfies the fixed-point equation; was a zero polynomial left under provided (D2) +III.P41.c Ch III §1 Problem 41 2° zero - S ^ 2 * U ^ 2 * g ^ 4 - 4 * S * U ^ 2 * g ^ 3 - 2 * S * U ^ 2 * g ^ 2 * s - 4 * S * U - 4 * U ^ 3 * g ^ 4 * s - 4 * U ^ 2 * g * s + U ^ 2 * s ^ 2 - U^2*((S^2 - 4*s*U)*g^4 - 4*S*g^3 - 2*s*S*g^2 - 4*s*g + s^2 - 4*S/U) - C resultant (F#) of (160),(161) vs U^2 times the book's quartic for psi; Simplify gave 0 +III.P41.d Ch III §1 Problem 41 2° zero - 4*(g^3*U+1)^2*(U*((s - g^2*S)/(2*g^3*U + 2))^2 - 2*g*((s - g^2*S)/(2*g^3*U + 2))*U - S) - ((U*S^2 - 4*s*U^2)*g^4 - 4*U*S*g^3 - 2*U*s*S*g^2 - 4*s*U*g + U*s^2 - 4*S) - C book's route: tau substituted into (161) gives the psi quartic; was returned unsimplified +III.P41.e Ch III §1 Problem 41 2° zero - 4*(g^3*U+1)^2*(U*((s - g^2*S)/(2*(g^3*U + 1)))^2 - 2*g*((s - g^2*S)/(2*(g^3*U + 1)))*U - S) - ((U*S^2 - 4*s*U^2)*g^4 - 4*U*S*g^3 - 2*U*s*S*g^2 - 4*s*U*g + U*s^2 - 4*S) - C same as III.P41.d with the denominator 2*(g^3*U + 1); was returned unsimplified +III.P42.a Ch III §1 Problem 42 zero - 2*(a*b+b*c+c*a) - (a^2+b^2+c^2) - (4*(a*b+b*c+c*a) - (a+b+c)^2) - C affix q of Q; expand gave 0 +III.P42.b Ch III §1 Problem 42 zero - (c^2-(a+b)^2)*(c^2-(a-b)^2) - ((a^2+b^2+c^2)^2 - 4*(a^2*b^2+b^2*c^2+c^2*a^2)) - C tau_0 tau_1 tau_2 tau_3 = sigma_2^2 - 4 sigma_1 sigma_3; simplify 0, expand left (b^2)^2 + -b^4 +III.P42.c Ch III §1 Problem 42 equal - (b - c - a/m*(b - c))/(1/b - 1/c - m/a*(1/b - 1/c)) a*b*c/m C Simson line slope sigma_3/z_0 with conj by hand; was a*c*b/m provided (1.2 s) +III.P42.d Ch III §1 Problem 42 zero - (b - c - a/m*(b - c))/(1/b - 1/c - m/a*(1/b - 1/c)) - a*b*c/m - C Simson slope minus abc/m; was c*b*(-a + a)/m provided (3.5 s), not a fixed point (D1) +III.P43.a Ch III §1 Problem 43 zero - ((b*c+b*d+c*d)/(b+c+d) + a)/2 - (a*b+a*c+a*d+b*c+b*d+c*d)/(2*(b+c+d)) - C midpoint of A_1 and the book's phi_1 (wrong point, see E6) - algebra only; was not reduced to 0 +III.P43.b Ch III §1 Problem 43 zero - (t*2*S)/(4*s*S - 4) - t*S/(2*(s*S-1)) - C centre of the midpoint circle via Problem 12; was 0 provided +III.P44.a Ch III §1 Problem 44 equal - sqrt(x)*sqrt(y)/(1/(sqrt(x)*sqrt(y))) x*y C slope of IN is z_2 z_3, conj written as reciprocal; was x*y +III.P45.a Ch III §1 Problem 45 zero - (e^(8*pi*i/7) - e^(10*pi*i/7))/(e^(-8*pi*i/7) - e^(-10*pi*i/7)) + e^(4*pi*i/7) - - slope of BC is -alpha^2, alpha = e^(2 pi i/7); was 0 +III.P45.b Ch III §1 Problem 45 zero - e^(2*pi*i/7*9) - e^(2*pi*i/7*2) - - alpha^9 = alpha^2; was 0 +III.P45.c Ch III §1 Problem 45 zero - sum(e^(2*pi*i*k/7), k, 0, 6) - - sum of 7th roots of unity; was 0 +III.P45.d Ch III §1 Problem 45 equal - (a^4 - a^5)/(1/a^4 - 1/a^5) -a^9 C slope of BC with a bare symbol (no a^7 = 1); was -a^9 provided +III.P45.e Ch III §1 Problem 45 equal - abs(e^(i*pi/7)) 1 - a unit complex number; was 1 +III.P45.f Ch III §1 Problem 45 equal - arccos(((1 - e^(8*pi*i/7))*(1 - e^(-10*pi*i/7)) + (1 - e^(-8*pi*i/7))*(1-e^(10*pi*i/7)))/(2*abs(1 - e^(8*pi*i/7))*abs(1-e^(10*pi*i/7))))/pi 1/7 - angle A of (1, alpha^4, alpha^5) over pi; correction of III.E7.a; eval gave 1/7 +III.E1.a Ch III §1 Problem 34, pp. 219-220 erratum - (a^2-b^2)*(a^2-c^2)/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) / (-(b-c)^2/(b^2+c^2)) 4*i*a*b*c*(i/4)*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]])*(a+b)*(a+c)*(b-c)/(a^2*(b-c)^4) C E1: book prints +4i; true value is -4i a0b0c0(A0B0C0)(a0+b0)(a0+c0)(b0-c0)/(a0^2(b0-c0)^4) +III.E1.b Ch III §1 Problem 34, pp. 219-220 equal - (a^2-b^2)*(a^2-c^2)/(a^2*(b^2+c^2)) / (-(b-c)^2/(b^2+c^2)) -4*i*a*b*c*(i/4)*det([[a, 1/a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]])*(a+b)*(a+c)*(b-c)/(a^2*(b-c)^4) C correction of III.E1.a: the -4i sign +III.E1.c Ch III §1 Problem 34, p. 220 erratum - (a+b)*(a+c)*(b-c) 4*i*a*b*c*(i/4)*det([[-a, 1/-a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]]) C E1: book prints +4i a0b0c0(A0*B0C0), A0* = -a0; true value is -4i a0b0c0(A0*B0C0) +III.E1.d Ch III §1 Problem 34, p. 220 equal - (a+b)*(a+c)*(b-c) -4*i*a*b*c*(i/4)*det([[-a, 1/-a, 1], [b, 1/b, 1], [c, 1/c, 1]]) C correction of III.E1.c +III.E3.a Ch III §1 Problem 38 1°, p. 233 erratum - s/3 + (t/u)/3*t - s - u*((t/u)/3)^2 (2/3)*s + t^2/(3*u) - t^2/(9*u) C E3: printed +(2/3)sigma_1; true numerator is -(2/3)sigma_1 + sigma_2^2/(3sigma_3) - sigma_2^2/(9sigma_3) +III.E4.a Ch III §1 Problem 38 3°, p. 233 erratum - (s/2 + (t/u)/2*t - s - u*((t/u)/2)^2)/((s/2)*((t/u)/2) - 1) (t*(t/u) - 2*v)/(s*(t/u) - 4) C E4: printed 2tau_1 (v here) for 2sigma_1; true value (sigma_2 conj(sigma_1) - 2sigma_1)/(sigma_1 conj(sigma_1) - 4) +III.E5.a Ch III §1 Problem 42, p. 248 erratum - (s/u)^2 - 4*(t/u)*(1/u) s^2/t^2 - 4*t/t^2 C E5: conj(tau0tau1tau2tau3) printed over sigma_2^2; true (sigma_1^2 - 4sigma_2)/sigma_3^2 +III.E5.b Ch III §1 Problem 42, p. 248 equal - (s/u)^2 - 4*(t/u)*(1/u) (s^2 - 4*t)/u^2 C correction of III.E5.a; the book's final form +III.E7.a Ch III §1 Problem 45, p. 251 erratum - arccos(((1 - e^(8*pi*i/7))*(1 - e^(-10*pi*i/7)) + (1 - e^(-8*pi*i/7))*(1-e^(10*pi*i/7)))/(2*abs(1 - e^(8*pi*i/7))*abs(1-e^(10*pi*i/7)))) 2*pi/7 - E7: book says A = 2pi/7; true A = pi/7 (A + 2A + 4A = pi) +III.Ex1.1 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 1° zero - -2*cos(3*pi/13)*cos(9*pi/13) - 2*cos(9*pi/13)*cos(pi/13) - 2*cos(pi/13)*cos(3*pi/13) - 1/2 - - HA'+HB'-HC' = R/2, A = pi/13 (p01); was 0 +III.Ex1.2 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 2° zero - 1 - 8*sin(pi/26)*sin(3*pi/26)*sin(9*pi/26) + 9 - 4*(sin(pi/13)^2 + sin(3*pi/13)^2 + sin(9*pi/13)^2) - 5 - - OI^2 + OH^2 = 5R^2 (p02); was 0 +III.Ex1.3 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 3° zero - 4*(sin(3*pi/13)*sin(9*pi/13) + sin(9*pi/13)*sin(pi/13) + sin(pi/13)*sin(3*pi/13)) - sqrt(13) - - bc + ca + ab = R^2 sqrt(13) (p03); was 0 +III.Ex1.4 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 4° zero - cos(pi/13) + cos(3*pi/13) + cos(9*pi/13) - (1 + sqrt(13))/4 - - sum of cosines (p04); was 0, exact (a 10^-400 offset survived) +III.Ex1.5 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 5° zero - 1 - 8*sin(pi/26)*sin(3*pi/26)*sin(9*pi/26) - (5 - sqrt(13))/2 - - OI^2/R^2 closed form (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.6 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 6° zero - 4*sin(pi/26)*sin(3*pi/26)*sin(9*pi/26) - (sqrt(13) - 3)/4 - - r/R closed form (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.7 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 7° zero - 1 - 8*cos(pi/13)*cos(3*pi/13)*cos(9*pi/13) - (5 + sqrt(13))/2 - - OH^2/R^2 closed form (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.8 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 8° zero - cos(pi/13)*cos(3*pi/13)*cos(9*pi/13) + (3 + sqrt(13))/16 - - product of cosines (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.9 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 9° zero - sin(pi/13)*sin(3*pi/13)*sin(9*pi/13) - sqrt((13 - 3*sqrt(13))/128) - - product of sines (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.10 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 10° zero - sin(pi/13) + sin(3*pi/13) + sin(9*pi/13) - sqrt((13 + 3*sqrt(13))/8) - - sum of sines (p05); was 0 +III.Ex1.8.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 1 8° equal - cos(pi/13)*cos(3*pi/13)*cos(9*pi/13) -(3 + sqrt(13))/16 - product of cosines asked alone (p06); was unchanged +III.Ex1.9.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 1 9° equal - sin(pi/13)*sin(3*pi/13)*sin(9*pi/13) sqrt((13 - 3*sqrt(13))/128) - product of sines asked alone (p06); was unchanged +III.Ex1.10.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 1 10° equal - sin(pi/13) + sin(3*pi/13) + sin(9*pi/13) sqrt((13 + 3*sqrt(13))/8) - sum of sines asked alone (p06); was unchanged +III.Ex1.s1 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 solution zero - 4*(cos(2*pi/13)+cos(6*pi/13)+cos(8*pi/13))^2 + 2*(cos(2*pi/13)+cos(6*pi/13)+cos(8*pi/13)) - 3 - - Gauss period x solves 4x^2 + 2x - 3 = 0 (p07); was 0 +III.Ex1.s2 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 solution equal - cos(2*pi/13) + cos(4*pi/13) + cos(6*pi/13) + cos(8*pi/13) + cos(10*pi/13) + cos(12*pi/13) -1/2 - x + y = -1/2, six-cosine sum (p07, written with … in the log); was -1/2 +III.Ex1.s3 Ch III §2 Exercise 1 solution solve x 4*x^2 + 2*x - 3 = 0 { (-1 - sqrt(13))/4, (-1 + sqrt(13))/4 } - the quadratic for the Gauss periods (p08); solve gave (-2 ± 2sqrt(13))/8 unreduced +III.Ex1.c Ch III §2 Exercise 1 complex form equal - (cos(pi/13) + i*sin(pi/13))^26 1 - vertices are 26th roots of unity (p09); was 1 +III.Ex2.1a Ch III §2 Exercise 2 1° zero - ((a+b+c-b*c/a)/2 - (a+c+d-c*d/a)/2)/((1/a+1/b+1/c-a/(b*c))/2 - (1/a+1/c+1/d-a/(c*d))/2) - b*c*d/a - C Langer, (a1-a2)/conj(a1-a2) = bcd/a, conj by hand (p10); was quotient with zero numerator unexpanded +III.Ex2.1b Ch III §2 Exercise 2 1° zero - a*((a+b+c-b*c/a)/2 - (a+c+d-c*d/a)/2) - b*c*d*((1/a+1/b+1/c-a/(b*c))/2 - (1/a+1/c+1/d-a/(c*d))/2) - C same, cross-multiplied (p11); was ((-a + a)*(b + d) + ...)/2, not idempotent: 2nd pass gave 0 +III.Ex2.1c Ch III §2 Exercise 2 1° zero - ((a-c)*(b-d)/(2*a))/((1/a-1/c)*(1/b-1/d)/(2/a)) - b*c*d/a - C same ratio, factored form (p12); was 0 +III.Ex2.1d Ch III §2 Exercise 2 1° zero - ((a*d+b*c)/(2*a))/((1/(a*d)+1/(b*c))*a/2) - b*c*d/a - C same ratio, second factored form (p12); was 0 +III.Ex2.1e Ch III §2 Exercise 2 1° zero - ((a+b+c+d)/2 - (a+b+c-b*c/a)/2) - (a*d+b*c)/(2*a) - C f - a1 = (ad + bc)/(2a) (p13); was 0 +III.Ex2.2 Ch III §2 Exercise 2 2° zero - (a+b+c-b*c/a)/2 - (b+c+d-b*c/d)/2 - (a-d)*(a*d+b*c)/(2*a*d) - C a1 - d1 = (a - d)(ad + bc)/(2ad) (p13); was 0 +III.Ex3 Ch III §2 Exercise 3 zero - (b + c)/a - (1 + c/b)*(b/a) - C cevian ratio, barycentric form (p14); was 0 provided a, b nonzero +III.Ex4.2a Ch III §2 Exercise 4 2° equal - det([[0, 1/(1+l), l/(1+l)], [l/(1+l), 0, 1/(1+l)], [1/(1+l), l/(1+l), 0]]) (l^2 - l + 1)/(l + 1)^2 C oriented-area ratio (p15); det_s gave (1/(l+1))^3 + (l/(l+1))^3 +III.Ex4.2b Ch III §2 Exercise 4 2° equal - (1 + l^3)/(1 + l)^3 (l^2 - l + 1)/(l + 1)^2 C the same ratio (p15); was unchanged, common factor l + 1 not cancelled +III.Ex4.2c Ch III §2 Exercise 4 2° zero - (1 + l^3)/(1 + l)^3 - (l^2 - l + 1)/(l + 1)^2 - C the same ratio as a difference (p15); was unchanged +III.Ex4.3 Ch III §2 Exercise 4 3° zero - ((1/l)^2 - 1/l + 1)/(1/l + 1)^2 - (l^2 - l + 1)/(l + 1)^2 - C Deaux, ratio 1/l gives the same area ratio (p16; needs parallel sides, E1); was 0 +III.Ex6 Ch III §2 Exercise 6 equal - x^3 - (a - x)*(b - x)*(c - x) 2*x^3 - (a + b + c)*x^2 + (a*b + b*c + c*a)*x - a*b*c C Vatricant cubic (p17); expand gave it +III.Ex8.a Ch III §2 Exercise 8 zero - (b + i*(a+b) - i*a)*(1/b - i/a - i/b + i/a) - 2 - C b_a lies on circle (170), conj by hand (p18); was 0 +III.Ex8.b Ch III §2 Exercise 8 zero - (b + i*(a + b)) + a*b*(1/b - i*(1/a + 1/b)) - (a + b) - C b_a lies on AB, conj by hand (p18); was 0 +III.Ex9.a Ch III §2 Exercise 9 equal - det([[0, 0, 1], [2, 2, 1], [2*i, -2*i, 1]]) -8*i - det[z, conj z, 1] on a numeric triangle, gives z0 = 1 + i (p19); was -8i +III.Ex9.b Ch III §2 Exercise 9 equal - det([[z, w, 1], [u, v, 1], [p, q, 1]]) p*(w - v) + q*(u - z) - u*w + v*z C det[z, conj z, 1] with conjugates as symbols (p19); det_s gave this +III.Ex12 Ch III §2 Exercise 12 equal - (2*b^2 + 2*c^2 - a^2)*(b + c)^2 - 4*b*c*((b + c)^2 - a^2) (b - c)^2*(-a^2 + 2*b^2 + 4*b*c + 2*c^2) C m_a = l_a numerator (p21); collapse gave (b^2-2bc+c^2)(...), factor::b refused +III.Ex14.1 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 1° zero - 4*(sin(pi/7)^2+sin(2*pi/7)^2+sin(4*pi/7)^2) - 7 - - heptagonal triangle a^2+b^2+c^2 = 7R^2 (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.2 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 2° zero - 9 - 4*(sin(pi/7)^2+sin(2*pi/7)^2+sin(4*pi/7)^2) - 2 - - OH^2 = 9R^2 - sum a^2 = 2R^2 (p22, … in the log); was 0 +III.Ex14.cosA Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(pi/7) - sin(2*pi/7)/(2*sin(pi/7)) - - cos A = b/2a (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.cosB Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(2*pi/7) - sin(4*pi/7)/(2*sin(2*pi/7)) - - cos B = c/2b (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.cosC1 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(4*pi/7) - (sin(pi/7) - sin(2*pi/7))/(2*sin(2*pi/7)) - - cos C = (a - b)/2b (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.cosC2 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(4*pi/7) + sin(pi/7)/(2*sin(4*pi/7)) - - cos C = -a/2c (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.bc1 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) - sin(pi/7)*(sin(2*pi/7) + sin(4*pi/7)) - - bc = a(b + c) (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.bc2 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) - (sin(4*pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^2) - - bc = c^2 - a^2 (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.ac Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) - (sin(2*pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^2) - - ac = b^2 - a^2 (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.psin Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) - sqrt(7)/8 - - product of sines (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.scos1 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(pi/7) + cos(2*pi/7) + cos(4*pi/7) - (sin(2*pi/7)/sin(pi/7) - 1/2) - - sum of cosines = b/a - 1/2 (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.scos2 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - cos(pi/7) + cos(2*pi/7) + cos(4*pi/7) - (sin(4*pi/7) + sin(pi/7))/(2*(sin(4*pi/7) - sin(pi/7))) - - sum of cosines = (c + a)/(2(c - a)) (p22, left side … in the log); was 0 +III.Ex14.ptan Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° zero - tan(pi/7)*tan(2*pi/7)*tan(4*pi/7) + sqrt(7) - - product of tangents (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.pcos.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - cos(pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7)*cos(4*pi/7) -1/8 - product of cosines asked alone (p22); was -1/8 +III.Ex14.sq.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - (sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7))^2 + (cos(pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7)*cos(4*pi/7))^2 1/8 - asked alone (p22); was 1/8 +III.Ex14.scos2.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - cos(pi/7)^2 + cos(2*pi/7)^2 + cos(4*pi/7)^2 5/4 - sum of cos^2 asked alone (p22); was 5/4 +III.Ex14.ssin2.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - sin(pi/7)^2 + sin(2*pi/7)^2 + sin(4*pi/7)^2 7/4 - sum of sin^2 asked alone (p22); was 7/4 +III.Ex14.scc.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - (cos(2*pi/7)*cos(4*pi/7))^2 + (cos(4*pi/7)*cos(pi/7))^2 + (cos(pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7))^2 3/8 - sum of cos^2 cos^2 asked alone (p22); was 3/8 +III.Ex14.psin.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) sqrt(7)/8 - product of sines asked alone (p23); was a larger casus-irreducibilis radical form, value right +III.Ex14.ptan.alone Ch III §2 Exercise 14 4°–13° equal - tan(pi/7)*tan(2*pi/7)*tan(4*pi/7) -sqrt(7) - product of tangents asked alone (p23); was a casus-irreducibilis radical form +III.Ex14.14 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 14° zero - 1/sin(pi/7) - 1/sin(2*pi/7) - 1/sin(4*pi/7) - - h_a = h_b + h_c (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.15 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 15° zero - (sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7))^2 + (sin(4*pi/7)*sin(pi/7))^2 + (sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7))^2 - 7/8 - - sum h^2 = sum a^2/2 (p22); was 0 +III.Ex14.16a Ch III §2 Exercise 14 16° zero - sin(4*pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*cos(4*pi/7) + sin(pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/4 - - BA'*A'C = ac/4, signed (p24); was 0 +III.Ex14.16b Ch III §2 Exercise 14 16° zero - sin(pi/7)*cos(4*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*cos(pi/7) + sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)/4 - - CB'*B'A = ab/4, signed (p24); was 0 +III.Ex14.16.err Ch III §2 Exercise 14 16° erratum - sin(4*pi/7)*cos(pi/7)*sin(pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7) sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/4 - E5: printed AB'*C'B = bc/4; true difference 0.0470637747676583 (p24) +III.Ex14.16c Ch III §2 Exercise 14 16° zero - sin(2*pi/7)*cos(pi/7)*sin(pi/7)*cos(2*pi/7) - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/4 - - AC'*C'B = bc/4; correction of III.Ex14.16.err (p24); was 0 +III.Ex14.17.err Ch III §2 Exercise 14 17° erratum - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*(1 - sin(pi/7)^2/(sin(2*pi/7)+sin(4*pi/7))^2) (sin(2*pi/7)^2*sin(pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^4)/(sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)) - E6: printed AQa^2 = (b^2a^2-a^4)/bc; true (b^2c^2-a^4)/bc, difference 0.611260466978157 (p25) +III.Ex14.17 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 17° zero - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*(1 - sin(pi/7)^2/(sin(2*pi/7)+sin(4*pi/7))^2) - (sin(2*pi/7)^2*sin(4*pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^4)/(sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)) - - AQa^2 = (b^2c^2 - a^4)/bc; correction of III.Ex14.17.err (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.18a Ch III §2 Exercise 14 18° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*(1 - sin(2*pi/7)^2/(sin(pi/7)+sin(4*pi/7))^2) - (sin(4*pi/7) - sin(pi/7))^2 - - BQb = c - a (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.18b Ch III §2 Exercise 14 18° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*(1 - sin(4*pi/7)^2/(sin(pi/7)+sin(2*pi/7))^2) - (sin(2*pi/7) - sin(pi/7))^2 - - CQc = b - a (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.19 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 19° zero - sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*(1 - sin(pi/7)^2/(sin(2*pi/7)+sin(4*pi/7))^2) + sin(pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*(1 - sin(2*pi/7)^2/(sin(pi/7)+sin(4*pi/7))^2) + sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*(1 - sin(4*pi/7)^2/(sin(pi/7)+sin(2*pi/7))^2) - 6*sin(pi/7)^2 - - sum AQ^2 = 6a^2 (p25, sum written out from its terms); was 0 +III.Ex14.20 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 20° zero - 2*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*sin(pi/14)/(sin(4*pi/7) - sin(2*pi/7)) - (sin(2*pi/7) + sin(4*pi/7)) - - external bisector AQ'a = b + c (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.21 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 21° zero - (2*sin(pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)*sin(pi/7)/(sin(4*pi/7) - sin(pi/7)))^2 - (sin(pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7) + sin(2*pi/7)^2) - - BQ'b^2 = a^2 - ab + b^2 (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.22 Ch III §2 Exercise 14 22° zero - (2*sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)/(sin(2*pi/7) - sin(pi/7)))^2 - (sin(2*pi/7)^2 + sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7) + sin(4*pi/7)^2) - - CQ'c^2 = b^2 + bc + c^2 (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.24a Ch III §2 Exercise 14 24° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/(sin(4*pi/7)^2 - sin(2*pi/7)^2) - sin(4*pi/7) - - Apollonius circle radius = c (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.24b Ch III §2 Exercise 14 24° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/(sin(4*pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^2) - sin(pi/7) - - Apollonius circle radius = a (p25); was 0 +III.Ex14.24c Ch III §2 Exercise 14 24° zero - sin(pi/7)*sin(2*pi/7)*sin(4*pi/7)/(sin(2*pi/7)^2 - sin(pi/7)^2) - sin(2*pi/7) - - Apollonius circle radius = b (p25); was 0 +III.Ex15.a Ch III §2 Exercise 15 zero - (1/2 - sqrt(3)/2*i)*((1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i)*b + (1/2 - sqrt(3)/2*i)*a) + (1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i)*((1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i)*a + (1/2 - sqrt(3)/2*i)*c) - (b + c - a) - C Deaux, conj(alpha) c' + alpha b' = b + c - a, alpha explicit (p26); was 0 +III.Ex15.b Ch III §2 Exercise 15 equal - (1/2 + sqrt(3)/2*i)^3 -1 - alpha is a cube root of -1 (p26); was -1 +III.Ex16 Ch III §2 Exercise 16 equal - sin(y)*cos(x)/(cos(x)*tan(y)*cos(y)) 1 C Ceva product for altitude, median, bisector (p27); was 1 provided cos(x) sin(y), cos(y) nonzero +III.Ex17 Ch III §2 Exercise 17 zero - det([[(q*v + r*w)/(q + r), (q*V + r*W)/(q + r), 1], [(r*w + p*u)/(r + p), (r*W + p*U)/(r + p), 1], [(p*u + q*v)/(p + q), (p*U + q*V)/(p + q), 1]])/(u*(V - W) + v*(W - U) + w*(U - V)) - 2*p*q*r/((q + r)*(r + p)*(p + q)) - C cevian-triangle area ratio, conjugates as symbols (p28); det_s 115 nodes, difference unchanged after 4.5 s +III.Ex18 Ch III §2 Exercise 18 zero - (v - w)*(1/v - 1/w) - (2 - v/w - w/v) - C hint z2 conj z3 + conj z2 z3 = 2 - a^2, conj by hand (p29); was 0 +III.Ex19 Ch III §2 Exercise 19 zero - (u - v)*(1/u - 1/v) - (u - u^2/v)*(1/u - v/u^2) - C z1^2 = z2 z3 gives AB = AC, conj by hand (p30); was 0 +III.Ex20.a Ch III §2 Exercise 20 zero - ((1 - i)*(i + t)/(1 + t))/(1 + i - 2*t/(1 + t)) + ((1 + i)*(1 - i*t)/(t + 1))/(1 - i - 2/(1 + t)) - C a1 satisfies the first orthogonality condition (p31); was 0 +III.Ex20.b Ch III §2 Exercise 20 zero - ((1 - i)*(i + t)/(1 + t) - 2*t/(1 + t))/(1 + i) + ((1 + i)*(1 - i*t)/(t + 1) - 2/(1 + t))/(1 - i) - C a1 satisfies the second orthogonality condition (p31); was 0 +III.Ex20.err Ch III §2 Exercise 20 erratum - 2/(1/t + i) 2*t*i/(t + i) U E8: hint a = 2/(conj(alpha) + i) lost the bar on i; differs (3.40 at alpha = e^(-2.2i)) (p31) +III.Ex20.c Ch III §2 Exercise 20 zero - 2/(1/t - i) - 2*t*i/(t + i) - C correction of III.Ex20.err (p31); was left open: 2/(-i + 1/t) - (2i + 2/(t + i)) +III.Ex22 Ch III §2 Exercise 22 zero - ((z*W - w*Z + Q*(w - z))/(W - Z) - p)/(w - z) + ((Z*w - W*z + p*(W - Z))/(w - z) - Q)/(W - Z) - C reflection p': PP' perpendicular to AB, conjugates as symbols (p32); was 0 +III.Ex23 Ch III §2 Exercise 23 zero - ((z + l*w)/(1 + l) - z)*((Z + W/l)/(1 + 1/l) - Z) - ((z + l*w)/(1 + l) - w)*((Z + W/l)/(1 + 1/l) - W) - C M(l) equidistant from A and B, conj(l) = 1/l (p33); was left unsimplified +III.Ex24 Ch III §2 Exercise 24 zero - (u + v*w/(v + w))/2 - (u*v + v*w + w*u)/(2*(v + w)) - C A1 = s2/(2(z2 + z3)) (p34); was 0 +III.Ex25 Ch III §2 Exercise 25 zero - ((b - a)*(p - c)/(2*p)) / ((1/b - 1/a)*(1/p - 1/c)/(2/p)) - a*b*c/p - C Simson-direction identity, conj by hand (p35); was unchanged after 18.8 s +III.Ex26 Ch III §2 Exercise 26 zero - (t*x/(t - s) + s*y/(s - t)) - ((t^2*x/((t - s)*(t - r)) + s^2*y/((s - t)*(s - r)) + r^2*u/((r - t)*(r - s))) - r*(t*x/((t - s)*(t - r)) + s*y/((s - t)*(s - r)) + r*u/((r - t)*(r - s)))) - C (175) at n = 2, as an equality (p36); was an unreduced partial-fraction sum +III.Ex27 Ch III §2 Exercise 27 1°–2° zero - ((r + s)/2 + i*(s - r)/2 - ((p + q)/2 + i*(q - p)/2)) - i*((s + p)/2 + i*(p - s)/2 - ((q + r)/2 + i*(r - q)/2)) - C square centres form a pseudosquare (p37); was 0 +III.Ex29 Ch III §2 Exercise 29 zero - det([[(a^2*(b + c) - 2*a*b*c)/(a^2 - b*c), (b + c - 2*a)/(b*c - a^2), 1], [(b^2*(c + a) - 2*a*b*c)/(b^2 - c*a), (c + a - 2*b)/(c*a - b^2), 1], [(c^2*(a + b) - 2*a*b*c)/(c^2 - a*b), (a + b - 2*c)/(a*b - c^2), 1]]) - C tangents meet the sides in collinear points, conj by hand (p39); det_s stayed 207 nodes (4.2 s) +III.Ex31 Ch III §2 Exercise 31 zero - det([[(a*c*(b + d) - b*d*(a + c))/(a*c - b*d), ((b + d) - (a + c))/(b*d - a*c), 1], [2*a*d/(a + d), 2/(a + d), 1], [2*b*c/(b + c), 2/(b + c), 1]]) - C P, R, S collinear for a cyclic quadrilateral, conj by hand (p40); det_s stayed 95 nodes (5.2 s) +III.Ex35 Ch III §2 Exercise 35 solve z z^2 + 2*p*z + q = 0 { -p - sqrt(p^2 - q), -p + sqrt(p^2 - q) } C roots of z^2 + 2pz + q (p41); solve gave (-2p ± sqrt((2p)^2 - 4q))/2 +III.Ex36 Ch III §2 Exercise 36 equal - a*(x - b/a)^3 + 3*b*(x - b/a)^2 + 3*c*(x - b/a) + d a*x^3 + 3*(c - b^2/a)*x + d - 3*b*c/a + 2*b^3/a^2 C Tschirnhaus shift kills x^2 (p42); expand left (-3)*1/a*a*b*x^2, simplify did not collect +III.Ex37.1 Ch III §2 Exercise 37 1°–2° zero - ((m + k)/2 + i*(n - j)/2)*(x + i*y) + ((m - k)/2 + i*(n + j)/2)*(x - i*y) - ((m*x + j*y) + i*(n*x + k*y)) - C real affine map as az + b conj z (p43); was 0 +III.Ex37.6a Ch III §2 Exercise 37 6° equal - det([[1 - 2*i - (1 + 2*i), 3 + i, 1], [3 - i - (3 + i), -1 + 4*i, 1], [-1 - 4*i - (-1 + 4*i), 1 + 2*i, 1]]) -14 - 20*i - numerator determinant on a numeric instance (p43); was -14 - 20i +III.Ex37.6b Ch III §2 Exercise 37 6° equal - det([[1 + 2*i, 1 - 2*i, 1], [3 + i, 3 - i, 1], [-1 + 4*i, -1 - 4*i, 1]]) -4*i - denominator det[z, conj z, 1] on the instance (p43); was -4i +IV.1c.d Ch IV §1 I^2 = E equal - apply(lambda(z, k*z/abs(z)^2), apply(lambda(z, k*z/abs(z)^2), w)) w R I^2 = E, complex form, k real; was k^2*w/abs(k*w^2/abs(w)^2)^2 (stuck) +IV.1c.a Ch IV §1 I^2 = E equal - k*(k*x/(x^2+y^2))/((k*x/(x^2+y^2))^2+(k*y/(x^2+y^2))^2) x C involution, real form; was x provided not k^2*(x^4+2*(x*y)^2+y^4) = 0 +IV.1c.b Ch IV §1 I^2 = E equal - k*(k*z/abs(z)^2)/abs(k*z/abs(z)^2)^2 z R involution, complex form, k real; was k^2*z/abs(k*z^2/abs(z)^2)^2 (stuck) +IV.1c.c Ch IV §1 I^2 = E equal - abs(z^2)/abs(z)^2 1 C step of the complex involution; was unchanged +IV.1d.a Ch IV §1 positive inversion; §6 (E6) equal - k*x/(x^2 + (k - x^2)) x C K (x^2+y^2 = k) fixed pointwise; also S0 invariant (erratum E6); was x provided not k = 0 +IV.1g.a Ch IV §1 negative inversion equal - apply(lambda(z, -2*z/abs(z)^2), sqrt(2)*(3+4*i)/5) (-3/5 - 4/5*i)*sqrt(2) - k = -2 sends abs(z) = sqrt(2) to the antipode; was (-3/5 - 4/5*i)*sqrt(2) +IV.1g.b Ch IV §1 negative inversion equal - apply(lambda(z, -2*z/abs(z)^2), 3 + 4*i) -6/25 - 8/25*i - correction of IV.E1: M' = -(positive image); was -6/25 - 8/25*i +IV.E1 Ch IV §1 p. 282 erratum - apply(lambda(z, -2*z/abs(z)^2), 3 + 4*i) 6/25 + 8/25*i - book: M* by the "negative" inversion [O, abs(k)], reflected; true M' = -6/25 - 8/25*i +IV.1n.a Ch IV §1 Remark (motion along a ray) equal - derivative(k/r, r) -k/r^2 C M' approaches O as M recedes; was -k/r^2 +IV.1p.a Ch IV §1 Remark (linear fractional map) zero - (a*z+b)/(c*z+d) - (a/c + ((b*c - a*d)/c^2)/(z + d/c)) - C Mobius decomposition, needs c != 0 (erratum E2); was 0 provided not c^3*(c*z+d)*(d/c+z) = 0 +IV.1p.b Ch IV §1 Remark (linear fractional map) zero - 1/(x + y*i) - (x - y*i)/(x^2+y^2) - C 1/z as inversion then reflection; was 0 provided ... +IV.1p.c Ch IV §1 Remark, footnote equal - abs(1/z)*abs(z) 1 C abs(z2)*abs(z1) = 1; was 1 provided not z = 0 +IV.2.2.a Ch IV §2 Problem 2 I (Ptolemy) zero - (BC/(AB*AC) + CD/(AC*AD) - BD/(AB*AD))*AB*AC*AD - (BC*AD + CD*AB - BD*AC) - C Ptolemy via inversion [A, 1] and Problem 1; was 0 provided ... +IV.2.2.b Ch IV §2 Problem 2 I (Ptolemy) zero - (a - c)*(b - d) - ((a - b)*(c - d) + (b - c)*(a - d)) - C Ptolemy algebraic core; was 0 +IV.2.2.c Ch IV §2 Problem 2 I (Ptolemy) zero - 2*sqrt(18/5) - sqrt(2)*sqrt(16/5) - sqrt(2)*sqrt(4/5) - - Ptolemy on a unit-circle quadrilateral; was 0 +IV.2.3.a Ch IV §2 Problem 3 (Pompeiu) zero - -2*sin(u) + 2*sin(u + pi/3) - 2*sin(pi/3 - u) - C OB = OA + OC for O on the arc (with erratum E3 fixed); was 0 +IV.2.4.a Ch IV §2 Problem 4 solve a a^2 + (P - Q)^2 = (P + Q)^2 { 2*sqrt(P*Q), -2*sqrt(P*Q) } P tangency of two circles on a line; was +-sqrt(-((P-Q)^2 + -(P+Q)^2)) +IV.2.4.b Ch IV §2 Problem 4 equal - sqrt(-((P - Q)^2 + -(P + Q)^2)) 2*sqrt(P*Q) P the solve answer simplified; was sqrt(4*P*Q), radical not pulled out +IV.2.4.c Ch IV §2 Problem 4 equal - 4*P*Q/(2*P) 2*Q C image line at the diameter of C2; was 2*Q provided not P = 0 +IV.2.5.a Ch IV §2 Problem 5 equal - (3 - sqrt(3))*(3 + sqrt(3)) 6 - power of C = (1, 3) w.r.t. C1, C2; was 6 +IV.2.6.a Ch IV §2 Problem 6 (Euler) solve d r/(2*R) = r^2/(R^2 - d^2) { sqrt(R^2 - 2*R*r), -sqrt(R^2 - 2*R*r) } P d^2 = R^2 - 2Rr; was { sqrt(R^2 - r^2/(r/(2*R))), -... } +IV.2.6.b Ch IV §2 Problem 6 (Euler) equal - sqrt(R^2 - r^2/(r/(2*R))) sqrt(R^2 - 2*R*r) P the solve answer simplified; was sqrt(R^2 - 2*R*r) provided not r = 0 +IV.2.6.c Ch IV §2 Problem 6 (Euler) zero - (2 - 1)^2 + (3/2 - 1)^2 - ((5/2)^2 - 2*(5/2)*1) - - Euler on the 3-4-5 triangle, O = (2, 3/2), I = (1, 1); was 0 +IV.2.7.a Ch IV §2 Problem 7 equal - (2/(3 - 2*sqrt(2)) + 2/(3 + 2*sqrt(2)))/2 6 - projection of O is the midpoint of the tangency projections; was 6 +IV.2.8.a Ch IV §2 Problem 8 zero - (-3 + 2*sqrt(2))*32/((3 - 2*sqrt(2))^2 - 1) - 4*sqrt(2) - - common centre of the concentric images, 4*sqrt(2) from A; was 0 +IV.2.10.a Ch IV §2 Problem 10 (Feuerbach) zero - sqrt((1 - 1)^2 + (3/4 - 1)^2) - (5/4 - 1) - - nine-point circle touches the incircle, 3-4-5 triangle; was 0 +IV.2.10.b Ch IV §2 Problem 10 (Feuerbach) zero - sqrt((1 + 2)^2 + (3/4 - 2)^2) - (5/4 + 2) - - nine-point circle touches the excircle I_a; was 0 +IV.2.10.c Ch IV §2 Problem 10 (Feuerbach) zero - (3/2 - 4/3)*(3/2) - (3/2 - 1)^2 - - A'Q*A'A'' = A'R^2; was 0 +IV.2.10.d Ch IV §2 Problem 10 (Feuerbach) equal - apply(lambda(a, b, c, d, ((c - a)*(d - b))/((c - b)*(d - a))), 4, 0, 1, -2) -1 - harmonic set: cross ratio -1; was -1 +IV.3.6.a Ch IV §3 Problem 6 equal - 1/(2 - sqrt(3)) 2 + sqrt(3) - near arc of C goes to its far arc, not to K (erratum E10); was 2 + sqrt(3) +IV.3.11.a Ch IV §3 Problem 11 zero - (sin(t)/(1+cos(t)))^2 - (1 - 2*cos(t)/(1+cos(t))) - C cardioid image is y^2 = 1 - 2x; was unchanged, also at level 6 +IV.3.12.a Ch IV §3 Problem 12 solve c 3/2 + c = 1/(3/2 + c) { -1/2, -5/2 } - limacon meets the ellipse where cos t = -1/2; was { -1/2, -5/2 } +IV.3.14.a Ch IV §3 Problem 14 zero - 2*(cos(t)/(2*sin(t)^2)*sin(t))^2 - cos(t)/(2*sin(t)^2)*cos(t) - C cissoid image is 2y^2 = x; was 0 provided not sin(t) = 0 +IV.3.14.c Ch IV §3 Problem 14 equal - limitleft(2*sin(t)^2, t, pi/2) 2 - cissoid asymptote x = 2; was 2 +IV.4.1.a Ch IV §4 Peaucellier cell zero - (sqrt(OP^2-SP^2) + sqrt(PM^2-SP^2))*(sqrt(OP^2-SP^2) - sqrt(PM^2-SP^2)) - (OP^2 - PM^2) - C OM*OM' = OP^2 - PM^2; was 0 +IV.4.2.a Ch IV §4 Hart cell zero - ((a-b)^2 + h^2) + (2*b)*(2*a) - ((a+b)^2 + h^2) - C Ptolemy for the isosceles trapezoid; was 0 +IV.4.2.b Ch IV §4 Hart cell zero - (2*l*b)*(2*(1-l)*a) - l*(1-l)*(((a+b)^2+h^2) - ((a-b)^2+h^2)) - C OM*OM' constant with O at fraction l of AB; was 0 +IV.5.2.a Ch IV §5 Problem 2 1° solve x (x-1/4)^2+15/16-1 = 0 { 0, 1/2 } - inverse of M = (2, 0) in the unit circle is (1/2, 0); was { 0, 1/2 } exactly +IV.5.9.a Ch IV §5 Problem 9 equal - sqrt((1 + 1/sqrt(2))^2 + (1 - 1/sqrt(2))^2) sqrt(3) - correction of IV.E5: AQ = AB*sqrt(3); was sqrt(3) +IV.5.9.b Ch IV §5 Problem 9 equal - sqrt((1/sqrt(2))^2 + (1/sqrt(2))^2) 1 - correction of IV.E5: PQ = AB; was 1 +IV.E5 Ch IV §5 Problem 9 p. 313 erratum - sqrt((1/sqrt(2))^2 + (1/sqrt(2))^2) sqrt(3) - book: PQ = AB*sqrt(3); true PQ = 1 = AB (it is AQ that is sqrt(3)) +IV.6.5.a Ch IV §6 stereographic projection zero - 4/(2*z - z^2 + (z-2)^2) - 2/(2-z) - C inversion factor = projection factor on the sphere; was 0 provided not z - 2 = 0 +IV.6.12.a Ch IV §6 parallels near the equator zero - tan(pi/4 - t/2) - cot(pi/4 + t/2) - C cofunction; was unchanged +IV.6.12.b Ch IV §6 parallels near the equator zero - cot(pi/4 + t/2) - (1 - sin(t))/cos(t) - C x = cot(pi/4 + t/2) = (1 - sin t)/cos t; was unchanged +IV.6.12.c Ch IV §6 parallels near the equator zero - cot(a) + cot(b) - sin(a+b)/(sin(a)*sin(b)) - C sum of cotangents; was 0 provided ... +IV.6.12.d Ch IV §6 parallels near the equator zero - 2*sin(a)*sin(b) - cos(a-b) + cos(a+b) - C product-to-sum; was unchanged +IV.6.12.e Ch IV §6 parallels near the equator zero - cos(t)^2 - (1 - sin(t))*(1 + sin(t)) - C Pythagorean step; was 0 +IV.6.13.a Ch IV §6 Remark (derivatives) equal - derivative(cot(pi/4 + t/2), t) -1/(2*sin(pi/4 + t/2)^2) C x'; was -1/2/sin(pi/4 + t/2)^2 +IV.6.13.b Ch IV §6 Remark (derivatives) equal - sin(2*(pi/4 + t/2))/(cos(t/2) + sin(t/2))^4 cos(pi/4 + t/2)/(2*sin(pi/4 + t/2)^3) C x'' as the library gave it vs the book's form; was difference 0 provided ... +IV.6.14.a Ch IV §6 east/west maps zero - 1/sin(t) - cot(t) - tan(t/2) - C y = cosec t - cot t = tan(t/2); was unchanged +IV.6.15.a Ch IV §6 parallels near the poles zero - tan(a) + tan(b) - sin(a+b)/(cos(a)*cos(b)) - C sum of tangents; was 0 provided ... +IV.6.15.b Ch IV §6 parallels near the poles zero - 2*cos(a)*cos(b) - cos(a+b) - cos(a-b) - C product-to-sum; was unchanged +IV.6.16.a Ch IV §6 Remark (derivatives) equal - derivative(tan(t/2), t) 1/(2*cos(t/2)^2) C y'; was 1/2/cos(t/2)^2 +IV.6.16.b Ch IV §6 Remark (derivatives) equal - 1/4*sin(t)/cos(t/2)^4 sin(t/2)/(2*cos(t/2)^3) C y'' as the library gave it vs the book's form; Simplify does not show it +V.D1.a Ch V §1 formula (1), p. 334 equal - det([[a_1, b_1, c_1], [a_2, b_2, c_2], [a_3, b_3, c_3]]) a_1 * (b_2 * c_3 + -b_3 * c_2) + a_2 * b_3 * c_1 - a_2 * b_1 * c_3 + a_3 * b_1 * c_2 - a_3 * b_2 * c_1 C 3x3 determinant expansion; det_s gave this polynomial, det(...) parsed as a product at 725481ca4 +V.D2.a Ch V §1 property 1°, p. 334 equal - det([[a_1, a_2, a_3], [b_1, b_2, b_3], [c_1, c_2, c_3]]) a_1 * (b_2 * c_3 + -b_3 * c_2) + a_2 * b_3 * c_1 - a_2 * b_1 * c_3 + a_3 * b_1 * c_2 - a_3 * b_2 * c_1 C determinant unchanged by transposition; det_s printed the same polynomial +V.D4.a Ch V §1 property 3°, p. 335 zero - det([[a_1, a_1, c_1], [a_2, a_2, c_2], [a_3, a_3, c_3]]) - C two equal columns; det_s gave 0 +V.D5.a Ch V §1 property 4°, p. 335 zero - det([[0, b_1, c_1], [0, b_2, c_2], [0, b_3, c_3]]) - C zero column; det_s gave 0 +V.D12.a Ch V §1 cofactors, p. 336 zero - a_1*(a_3*c_2 - a_2*c_3) + a_2*(a_1*c_3 - a_3*c_1) + a_3*(a_2*c_1 - a_1*c_2) - C elements times cofactors of another column sum to 0; was 0 +V.D12.b Ch V §1 cofactors, p. 336 zero - a_1*(b_3*c_1 - b_1*c_3) + b_1*(a_1*c_3 - a_3*c_1) + c_1*(a_3*b_1 - a_1*b_3) - C row form of the alien-cofactor relation; was 0 +V.V3.a Ch V §2 magnitude, p. 337 equal - abs([3, 4]) 5 - length of a vector; was 5 +V.V3.b Ch V §2 magnitude, p. 337 equal - abs([x, y]) sqrt(x^2 + y^2) R length in components; was sqrt(x ^ 2 + y ^ 2) +V.V7.a Ch V §2 vector sum, p. 337 equal - [a_1, a_2] + [b_1, b_2] - ([b_1, b_2] + [a_1, a_2]) [0, 0] C commutativity of the vector sum; was [0, 0] +V.V9.a Ch V §2 scalar multiple, p. 338 equal - l*([a_1, a_2] + [b_1, b_2]) - l*[a_1, a_2] - l*[b_1, b_2] [0, 0] C distributivity of lambda over the vector sum; was [0, 0] +V.V17.a Ch V §2 collinearity det, p. 340 zero - det([[x, y], [l*x, l*y]]) - C collinear plane vectors give a zero 2x2 det; det_s gave 0 +V.V20.a Ch V §2 scalar product, p. 340 equal - [1, 2]T * [3, 4] 11 - dot product of literals; was 11 +V.V21.a Ch V §2 scalar square, p. 340 equal - abs([1, 2])^2 5 - the book's a^2 as abs(a)^2; was 5 ([1, 2]^2 is elementwise) +V.V22.a Ch V §2 dot in orthonormal basis, p. 340 equal - [a_1, a_2]T * [b_1, b_2] a_1 * b_1 + a_2 * b_2 C ab = xx' + yy'; was a_1 * b_1 + a_2 * b_2 +V.V23.a Ch V §2 dot in arbitrary basis, pp. 340-341 equal - [x, y]T * [[g_11, g_12], [g_12, g_22]] * [u, v] u * (g_11 * x + g_12 * y) + v * (g_12 * x + g_22 * y) C metric form of the dot product; was this form +V.V27.a Ch V §2 oriented angle, p. 342 equal - arccos(([1, 0]T * [1, 1]) / (abs([1, 0]) * abs([1, 1]))) pi / 4 - angle from cos = ab/(|a||b|); was pi / 4 +V.V28.a Ch V §2 Gram determinant, p. 342 zero - (p^2 + q^2)*(r^2 + s^2) - (p*r + q*s)^2 - (p*s - q*r)^2 - C g = (e1, e2)^2 for e1 = [p, q], e2 = [r, s]; was 0 +V.V29.a Ch V §2 rotation a_phi, pp. 342-343 equal - [[cos(t), -sin(t)], [sin(t), cos(t)]] * [x, y] [x * cos(t) + -y * sin(t), y * cos(t) + x * sin(t)] C coordinates of a rotated vector; was this form +V.V29.b Ch V §2 (a, b) = [a]b, p. 343 zero - [-a_2, a_1]T * [b_1, b_2] - (a_1*b_2 - a_2*b_1) - C pseudoscalar as the dot with the rotated vector; was 0 +V.V30.a Ch V §2 pseudoscalar, arbitrary basis, p. 343 zero - (x*p + y*r)*(u*q + v*s) - (x*q + y*s)*(u*p + v*r) - (p*s - q*r)*(x*v - y*u) - C (a, b) = sqrt(g) * det of components; was 0 +V.V31.a Ch V §2 dual basis, p. 343 equal - [-s, r]T * [p, q] / (r*q - s*p) 1 C e1 dot e^1 = 1; was 1 provided not p * s - q * r = 0 +V.V31.b Ch V §2 dual basis, p. 343 zero - [-s, r]T * [r, s] / (r*q - s*p) - C e2 dot e^1 = 0 (V31.a with [r, s]); was 0 provided not ... = 0 +V.V31.c Ch V §2 Gram inverse g^ij, p. 343 equal - [[0, b], [b, d]]^(-1) [[-d / b^2, 1 / b], [1 / b, 0]] C inverse Gram matrix; was this with provided not b = 0 on one entry only +V.G4.a Ch V §3 segment length, p. 348 equal - abs([x_2, y_2] - [x_1, y_1]) sqrt((x_2 - x_1)^2 + (y_2 - y_1)^2) R distance between two points; was this form +V.G6.a Ch V §3 polar coordinates, p. 349 equal - sqrt((r*cos(t))^2 + (r*sin(t))^2) r P rho from x = rho cos phi, y = rho sin phi; was unchanged, AM_REAL too +V.G7.a Ch V §3 division ratio, pp. 349-350 equal - ([x_1, y_1] + l*[x_2, y_2])/(1 + l) - [x_1, y_1] - l*([x_2, y_2] - ([x_1, y_1] + l*[x_2, y_2])/(1 + l)) [0, 0] C M1M = l*MM2 for r = (r1 + l r2)/(1 + l); was [0, 0] each provided not 1 + l = 0 +V.G8.a Ch V §3 collinear points, p. 350 zero - det([[x_1 - x_3, y_1 - y_3], [x_2 - x_3, y_2 - y_3]]) - det([[x_1, y_1, 1], [x_2, y_2, 1], [x_3, y_3, 1]]) - C 2x2 and 3x3 collinearity dets agree; det_s printed the same polynomial +V.G11.a Ch V §3 oriented area, pp. 350-351 equal - det([[0, 0, 1], [1, 0, 1], [0, 1, 1]]) 1 - twice the area of (0,0), (1,0), (0,1); det_s gave 1 +V.G15.a Ch V §3 area in space, p. 354 equal - 1/2*abs([0*(-1) - (-1)*1, (-1)*0 - 1*(-1), 1*1 - 0*0]) sqrt(3) / 2 - area via the cross product in components; was sqrt(3) / 2 +V.G19.a Ch V §3 line through a point with direction, p. 355 equal - det([[x - x_1, y - y_1], [l, m]]) l * (y_1 - y) + m * (x - x_1) C det form of the line equation; det_s gave this form +V.G22.a Ch V §3 line through two points, p. 357 equal - det([[x, y, 1], [x_1, y_1, 1], [x_2, y_2, 1]]) x_1 * (y_2 - y) + x_2 * (y - y_1) + x * (y_1 - y_2) C 3x3 det form; det_s gave this form +V.G25.a Ch V §3 pencil of lines, p. 358 zero - det([[1, 1, -2], [1, -1, 0], [2, -1, -1]]) - - three lines through (1, 1) have zero coefficient det; det_s gave 0 +V.G27.a Ch V §3 angle from slopes, p. 360 zero - (tan(b) - tan(a))/(1 + tan(a)*tan(b)) - tan(b - a) - C tan of the angle between lines; was unchanged +V.G27.b Ch V §3 perpendicular iff 1 + kk' = 0, p. 360 solve k_2 k_1*k_2 = -1 { (-1) / k_1 } C perpendicular slope; was { (-1) / k_1 } +V.G28.a Ch V §3 point-line distance, p. 360 equal - abs(3*1 + 4*1 - 2)/abs([3, 4]) 1 - |Ax0 + By0 + C|/sqrt(A^2 + B^2); was 1 +V.G28.b Ch V §3 point-line distance derivation, pp. 360-361 zero - A*(x_0 - A*(A*x_0 + B*y_0 + C)/(A^2 + B^2)) + B*(y_0 - B*(A*x_0 + B*y_0 + C)/(A^2 + B^2)) + C - C foot of the perpendicular lies on the line; was unchanged (collapse too) +V.G29.a Ch V §3 area from side equations, pp. 362-363 equal - det([[1, 1, -1], [1, 0, 0], [0, 1, 0]]) -1 - coefficient det of x + y - 1, x, y; det_s gave -1 +V.G29.b Ch V §3 area from side equations, pp. 362-363 equal - 1/2 * (-1)^2 / ((1*1 - 0*0) * (0*1 - 1*1) * (1*0 - 1*1)) 1/2 - oriented area of (0,0), (1,0), (0,1) from its sides; was 1/2 +V.G38.a Ch V §3 two planes, pp. 366-367 zero - A*(B*F - C*E) + B*(C*D - A*F) + C*(A*E - B*D) - C direction of the common line is orthogonal to the first normal; was 0 +V.G38.b Ch V §3 two planes, pp. 366-367 zero - D*(B*F - C*E) + E*(C*D - A*F) + F*(A*E - B*D) - C same with the second normal (D, E, F); was 0 +V.G41.a Ch V §3 point-plane distance, p. 368 equal - abs(1*0 + 2*0 + 2*0 - 6)/abs([1, 2, 2]) 2 - origin to x + 2y + 2z - 6 = 0; was 2 +V.G42.a Ch V §3 angle between planes, p. 370 equal - arccos(abs([1, 2, 2]T * [2, -1, 0])/(abs([1, 2, 2])*abs([2, -1, 0]))) pi / 2 - angle between normals; was pi / 2 +V.G49.a Ch V §3 line meets plane, p. 374 solve t 1*(1 + 2*t) + 2*(0 + 1*t) + 2*(0 + 0*t) - 6 = 0 { 5/4 } - parameter of the intersection point; was { 5/4 } +V.G50.a Ch V §3 angle line-plane, pp. 374-375 equal - arcsin(abs([1, 0, 1]T * [0, 0, 1])/(abs([1, 0, 1])*abs([0, 0, 1]))) pi / 4 - sin phi = |an|/(|a||n|); was pi / 4 +V.G53.a Ch V §3 power of a point, p. 376 equal - ((x_0 - a)^2 + (y_0 - b)^2 - r^2)/(cos(u)^2 + sin(u)^2) (x_0 - a)^2 + (y_0 - b)^2 - r^2 C Vieta product on a chord through M is sigma; was this form +V.C1.a Ch V §4 complex product, p. 377 equal - (x + y*i)*(u + v*i) u * x + i * v * x + i * u * y + -v * y C product of x + yi and u + vi; expand gave this form +V.C3.a Ch V §4 modulus, p. 377 equal - abs(3 + 4*i) 5 - |3 + 4i|; was 5 +V.C3.b Ch V §4 modulus, p. 377 equal - abs(x + y*i) sqrt(x^2 + y^2) R |z| = sqrt(x^2 + y^2) for real x, y; was unchanged, AM_REAL too +V.C7.a Ch V §4 product in trig form, p. 378 zero - (cos(a) + i*sin(a))*(cos(b) + i*sin(b)) - (cos(a + b) + i*sin(a + b)) - C arguments add under multiplication; was unchanged +V.C7.b Ch V §4 |z/z'|, p. 378 zero - abs((1 + 2*i)/(3 - i)) - abs(1 + 2*i)/abs(3 - i) - - modulus of a quotient; was 0 +V.C8.a Ch V §4 de Moivre, p. 379 zero - (cos(t) + i*sin(t))^3 - (cos(3*t) + i*sin(3*t)) - C de Moivre for n = 3; was 0 +V.C9.a Ch V §4 nth roots, p. 379 solve z z^4 = -1 { (-1)^(1/4), i * (-1)^(1/4), -(-1)^(1/4), (-i) * (-1)^(1/4) } - four fourth roots of -1; was this set +V.C12.a Ch V §4 area by affixes, p. 379 equal - det([[0, 0, 1], [1, 1, 1], [i, -i, 1]]) -2*i - det[z conj(z) 1] for 0, 1, i (conjugates by hand); det_s gave -2i +V.C12.b Ch V §4 area by affixes, p. 379 equal - i/4*det([[0, 0, 1], [1, 1, 1], [i, -i, 1]]) 1/2 - (ABC) = (i/4) det for 0, 1, i; reading: -2i times i/4 is 1/2 +V.C13.a Ch V §4 similarities, p. 380 zero - apply(lambda(z, k*(z - o) + o), apply(lambda(z, m*(z - o) + o), w)) - (k*m*(w - o) + o) - C homotheties with one centre compose; was 0 +V.C14.a Ch V §4 similar triangles, p. 380 zero - det([[0, 2, 1], [1, 3 + i, 1], [i, 1 + i, 1]]) - - same orientation, u = (1+i)z + 2; det_s gave 0 +V.C14.b Ch V §4 similar triangles, p. 380 zero - det([[0, 2, 1], [1, 3 + i, 1], [-i, 3 - i, 1]]) - - opposite orientation, u = (1+i)conj(z) + 2; det_s gave 0 +V.C14.c Ch V §4 similar triangles, p. 380 equal - det([[0, 2, 1], [1, 3 + i, 1], [i, 3 - i, 1]]) 2 - 2*i - same-orientation test on the opposite pair is nonzero; det_s gave 2 - 2i +V.C15.a Ch V §4 line through two points, p. 381 equal - det([[x + y*i, x - y*i, 1], [0, 0, 1], [1 + i, 1 - i, 1]]) 2*i*x + (-2*i)*y C line through 0 and 1 + i (y = x); det_s gave 2i * x + (-2i) * y +V.C15.b Ch V §4 complex slope, p. 381 equal - (1 + i)/(1 - i) i - slope of the line through 0 and 1 + i; was i +V.C15.c Ch V §4 |slope| = 1, p. 381 equal - abs((2 + 3*i)/(2 - 3*i)) 1 - complex slope has modulus 1; was 1 +V.C16.a Ch V §4 z = kappa conj(z), p. 382 zero - sqrt(i) - i*(1 - i)/sqrt(2) - - kappa = i meets the unit circle at sqrt(i); was 0 +V.C18.a Ch V §4 perpendicular iff kappa + kappa' = 0, p. 382 zero - 1/1 + i/(-i) - - x-axis and y-axis slopes sum to 0; was 0 +V.C19.a Ch V §4 remark, p. 383 zero - (1 - e^(i*t))/(1 + e^(i*t)) + i*tan(t/2) - C (1 - kappa)/(1 + kappa) = -i tan(phi/2); was unchanged +V.C19.b Ch V §4 remark, p. 383 zero - (1 - (cos(t) + i*sin(t)))/(1 + (cos(t) + i*sin(t))) + i*tan(t/2) - C C19.a with cos(t) + i*sin(t); was unchanged +V.C19.c Ch V §4 remark, p. 383 equal - i*(1 - (i - k)/(i + k))/(1 + (i - k)/(i + k)) k C k = i(1 - kappa)/(1 + kappa) at kappa = (i - k)/(i + k); was (k + i) * (2 + (-2i) / (k + i)) / 2 +V.C21.a Ch V §4 self-conjugate line equation, p. 384 equal - (P - Q*i)*(x + y*i) + (P + Q*i)*(x - y*i) 2 * P * x + 2 * Q * y C A z + conj(A) conj(z) in rectangular form; expand gave this +V.C22.a Ch V §4 distance to a line, p. 385 zero - sqrt(2)/2 - 1/abs(1 - i) - - distance from 0 to x + y - 1 = 0 by |Az0 + Bz0bar + C|/(2|A|); was 0 +V.C22.b Ch V §4 distance to a line, p. 385 equal - abs(-2)/(2*abs(1 - i)) sqrt(2)/2 - same distance, A = 1 - i, C = -2, z0 = 0; was 1 / abs(1 - i) +V.C23.a Ch V §4 half-planes, p. 386 equal - (1 - i)*(1 + (1 + i)) + (1 + i)*(1 + (1 - i)) - 2 4 - value at z0 + B is 2|B|^2 = 4; was 4 +V.C24.a Ch V §4 area from side equations, p. 386 equal - det([[1 - i, 1 + i, -2], [1, 1, 0], [-i, i, 0]]) -4*i - coefficient det for the triangle 0, 1, i; det_s gave -4i +V.C24.b Ch V §4 area from side equations, p. 386 equal - i/4*(-4*i)^2/((2*i)*(-2*i)*(-2*i)) 1/2 - (i/4) Delta^2 / product of minors 2i, -2i, -2i; was 1/2 +V.L.crossratio Ch V List of symbols, cross ratio, p. 389 equal - ((2 - 0)/(2 - 1)) / ((3 - 0)/(3 - 1)) 4/3 - cross ratio of affixes 0, 1, 2, 3; was 4/3 +V.A1.a Appendix 1, p. 390 solve x x^2 + p*x + q = 0 { (-p - sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2, (-p + sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2 } C roots of the reduced quadratic; was this set +V.A1.b Appendix 1, p. 390 solve x a*x^2 + 2*k*x + c = 0 { (-k - sqrt(k^2 - a*c)) / a, (-k + sqrt(k^2 - a*c)) / a } C the 2k form; was (-2 * k ± sqrt((2 * k) ^ 2 - 4 * a * c)) / (2 * a), unreduced +V.A2.a Appendix 2, p. 390 equal - (-p - sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2 + (-p + sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2 -p C Vieta: sum of A1.a's roots; was -p +V.A2.b Appendix 2, p. 390 equal - (-p - sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2 * ((-p + sqrt(p^2 - 4*q)) / 2) q C Vieta: product of A1.a's roots; was q +V.A3.a Appendix 3, p. 390 equal - x^2 - 5*x + 6 (x - 3) * (x - 2) C factor through the roots; collapse gave (x - 3) * (x - 2) +V.A7.a Appendix 7, p. 391 equal - log(a, 1) 0 P log of 1; was 0 provided not a = 1 +V.A7.b Appendix 7, p. 391 equal - log(a, a) 1 P log of the base; was 1 provided ... +V.A7.c Appendix 7, p. 391 equal - a^log(a, N) N P definition of the logarithm; was N provided ... +V.A8.a Appendix 8 relationship 7, p. 391 zero - 1 + tan(a)^2 - sec(a)^2 - C 1 + tan^2 = sec^2; was unchanged +V.A8.b Appendix 8, p. 391 zero - 1 + cot(a)^2 - cosec(a)^2 - C 1 + cot^2 = cosec^2; was 0 provided not sin(a) = 0 +V.A9.a Appendix 9 table of values, p. 391 equal - sin(pi/6) 1/2 - was 1/2 +V.A9.b Appendix 9 table of values, p. 391 equal - cos(pi/6) sqrt(3) / 2 - was sqrt(3) / 2 +V.A9.c Appendix 9 table of values, p. 391 equal - tan(pi/3) sqrt(3) - was sqrt(3) +V.A9.d Appendix 9 table of values, p. 391 equal - cot(pi/3) sqrt(3) / 3 - was sqrt(3) / 3 +V.A9.e Appendix 9 table of values, p. 391 equal - sin(3*pi/2) -1 - was -1 +V.A10.a Appendix 10 reduction formulas, p. 392 equal - sin(pi/2 - a) cos(a) C was cos(a) +V.A10.b Appendix 10 reduction formulas, p. 392 equal - sin(3*pi/2 + a) -cos(a) C was -cos(a) +V.A10.c Appendix 10 reduction formulas, p. 392 equal - cos(pi/2 + a) -sin(a) C was unchanged +V.A10.d Appendix 10 reduction formulas, p. 392 equal - tan(pi - a) -tan(a) C was unchanged +V.A10.e Appendix 10 reduction formulas, p. 392 equal - cot(3*pi/2 - a) tan(a) C was unchanged +V.A11.1.a Appendix 11.1 addition formulas, p. 392 zero - sin(s + t) - (sin(s)*cos(t) + cos(s)*sin(t)) - C sin addition; was 0 +V.A11.3.a Appendix 11.3 half-angle, p. 392 zero - sin(a/2)^2 - (1 - cos(a))/2 - C half-angle sin^2; was unchanged +V.A11.5.a Appendix 11.5, p. 392 zero - cos(a)^2 - (1 + cos(2*a))/2 - C power reduction; was unchanged +V.A11.6.a Appendix 11.6, p. 392 zero - tan(a) + tan(b) - sin(a + b)/(cos(a)*cos(b)) - C tan a + tan b; was 0 provided ... +V.A12.a Appendix 12, p. 393 equal - sin(arcsin(x)) x C was x +V.A12.b Appendix 12, p. 393 equal - cot(arccotan(x)) x C was x +V.A12.c Appendix 12, p. 393 equal - arccotan(-1) + pi*iverson(-1 < 0) 3/4 * pi - book's arccot(-1) in (0, pi) from the library's (-pi/2, pi/2] value; was 3/4 * pi +V.A13.a Appendix 13, p. 393 solve x sin(x) = a { arcsin(a) + 2 * pi * n_1, pi - arcsin(a) + 2 * pi * n_1 } C general solution, n_1 an integer (not stated in the set); was this set +V.E1 Ch V §1 formula (1), p. 334 (E1) erratum - det([[0, 0, 1], [0, 1, 0], [1, 0, 0]]) 1 - book's six-term sum has +a3*b2*c1, giving 1; true det is -1 +V.E1.c Ch V §1 formula (1), p. 334 (E1) equal - det([[0, 0, 1], [0, 1, 0], [1, 0, 0]]) -1 - correction of V.E1; det_s gave -1 +V.E2 Ch V §2 collinearity det, p. 340 (E2) erratum - det([[1, 2], [2, 4]]) 1*4 - 1*2 - book's first row 'x x' gives 2 for collinear {1,2}, {2,4}; true 0 +V.E3 Ch V §2 pseudoscalar definition, p. 341 (E3) erratum - [1, 0]T * [2, 0] 0 - book: a || b gives ab = 0; the dot is 2, it is (a, b) that is 0 +V.E3.c Ch V §2 pseudoscalar definition, p. 341 (E3) zero - det([[1, 0], [2, 0]]) - - correction of V.E3: pseudoscalar of collinear vectors is 0 +V.E4 Ch V §2 dot in arbitrary basis, p. 341 (E4) erratum - abs([0, 2, 0])^2 0 - a = b = e2 = (0,2,0): book's g12*y*y' term gives 0; true g22 = 4 +V.E5 Ch V §2 dual basis, p. 343 (E5) erratum - [1, 0]T * [0, 1] 1 - a = {1,0}, b* = {0,1}: book prints (a, b*) = 1; true a.b* = 0 +V.E5.c Ch V §2 dual basis, p. 343 (E5) equal - [1, 1]T * [0, 1] 1 - correction of V.E5: b.b* = 1 for b = {1,1}; was 1 +V.E8 Ch V §3 segment length, p. 348 (E8) erratum - abs([3, 4] - [0, 0]) sqrt((3 - 0)^2*(4 - 0)^2) - book drops the + between the squares: 12; true 5 +V.E9 Ch V §3 distance from origin, general, p. 349 (E9) erratum - abs([2, 0, 1]) 2 - e3 = (1,0,1), x = z = 1: book's g31*zx (no 2) gives 2; true sqrt(5) = 2.2360... +V.E10 Ch V §3 midpoint, p. 350 (E10) erratum - (0 + 2)/2 (0 + 7)/2 - midpoint x of (0,5)-(2,7): book (x1 + y2)/2 = 7/2; true 1 +V.E11 Ch V §3 area in space, p. 354 (E11) erratum - 1/2*abs([1*(-2) - (-2)*3, (-2)*1 - 0*(-2), 0*3 - 1*1]) sqrt(105)/2 - r1=(0,1,0), r2=(1,3,0), r3=(0,0,2): book's Delta1 with y1 - y2 gives 5.1234...; true sqrt(21)/2 = 2.2912... +V.E12 Ch V §3 angle between lines, general, p. 359 (E12) erratum - ([1, 2]T * [2, 2])/(abs([1, 2])*abs([2, 2])) 0 - e1=(1,0), e2=(1,2), lines x = 0, x - y = 0: book's lower g_ij on A, B give cos 0; true 3/sqrt(10) +V.E13 Ch V §3 angle between lines, general, p. 359 (E13) erratum - (5*1*1 - 1*(1*(-1) + 1*0) + 1*0*(-1))/(sqrt(5*1^2 - 2*1*1*0 + 1*0^2)*sqrt(5*1^2 - 2*1*1*(-1) + 1*(-1)^2)) (5*1*1 - 2*1*(1*(-1) + 1*0) + 1*0*(-1))/(sqrt(5*1^2 - 2*1*1*0 + 1*0^2)*sqrt(5*1^2 - 2*1*1*(-1) + 1*(-1)^2)) - same lines, g11=1, g12=1, g22=5: book's -2g12 gives cos 1.1067... > 1; true 3/sqrt(10) = 0.9486... +V.E13.b Ch V §3 angle between lines, general, p. 359 (E13) erratum - 2*(1*(-1) - 1*0)/(5*1*1 - 1*(1*(-1) + 1*0) + 1*0*(-1)) 2*(1*(-1) - 1*0)/(5*1*1 - 2*1*(1*(-1) + 1*0) + 1*0*(-1)) - same lines, oriented tan: book -2/7; true -1/3 +V.E15 Ch V §3 perpendicular slopes, general, p. 360 (E15) erratum - [1, 0]T * [2, 2] 1 - 1*(0 + 1) + 5*0*1 - e1=(1,0), e2=(1,2), k = 0, k' = 1: book's g11 - g12(k + k') + g22kk' = 0 says perpendicular; true 2 (45 deg) +V.E16 Ch V §3 plane through three points, p. 365 (E16) erratum - det([[x, y, z, 1], [0, 0, 0, 1], [1, 0, 0, 1], [0, 2, 3, 1]]) (-3) * y C M1=(0,0,0), M2=(1,0,0), M3=(0,2,3): book's last row x3 x3 z3 1 gives -3y; true -3y + 2z +V.E16.c Ch V §3 plane through three points, p. 365 (E16) equal - det([[x, y, z, 1], [0, 0, 0, 1], [1, 0, 0, 1], [0, 2, 3, 1]]) (-3) * y + 2 * z C correction of V.E16; det_s gave this +V.E20 Ch V §3 point-line distance in space, p. 372 (E20) erratum - abs([1*0 - 0*0, 0*1 - 0*0, 0*0 - 1*1])/abs([1, 0, 0]) abs([0, 1, 0]T * [1, 0, 0])/abs([1, 0, 0]) - r1 - r0 = {0,1,0}, a = {1,0,0}: book's (.,.) read as a dot gives 0; true distance 1 (cross product) +V.E21 Ch V §3 skew-line distance, general, p. 373 (E21) erratum - abs(det([[0, 0, 1], [1, 0, 0], [0, 1, 0]]))/sqrt(1/4*1^2) abs(det([[0, 0, 1], [1, 0, 0], [0, 1, 0]]))/(sqrt(4)*sqrt(1/4*1^2)) - g = diag(1,1,4), lines along e1, e2 offset e3: book's extra sqrt(g) gives 1; true 2 +V.E22 Ch V §3 line parallel to a plane, p. 375 (E22) erratum - [0, 0, 1]T * [0, 0, 1] 0 - plane z = 0, direction {0,0,1} meets the book's 'parallel' test, so Al + Bm + Cn should be 0; it is 1 +V.E23 Ch V §3 circle at the origin, p. 376 (E23) erratum - 2^2 + 0^2 - 2^2 2^2 + 0^2 - (2, 0) on the radius-2 circle: book x^2 + y^2 + z^2 gives 4; true 0 +V.E24 Ch V §4 complex numbers, p. 377 (E24) erratum - 1*2 1 - book prints 1*z = 1; at z = 2 it is 2 diff --git a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/README.md b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/README.md index 0ed966ee7..b30bea0f0 100644 --- a/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/README.md +++ b/Sources/Tests/Harnesses/README.md @@ -16,16 +16,18 @@ Each exits non-zero when it finds a defect, or when a list of findings it keeps | `PropCheck` | does each transformation satisfy a property it must: `Simplify`, `Expand` and `Factorize` keep the value, `Differentiate` agrees with a difference quotient, `Integrate` differentiates back | any property that does not hold | | `CanonCheck` | is there a **canonical form**: idempotence, order independence over commutative operators, and agreement between writings, for `InnerSimplified` and `Simplify` alike | a change to its findings, listed in `canoncheck-baseline.tsv` | | `Confluence` | where two arms of one rule set both fire at a node, do they agree, or is the order of the arms load-bearing | a change to its conflicting pairs, listed in `confluence-baseline.tsv` | +| `ModenovCorpus` | do the computations of Modenov's *Problems in Geometry* still come out — identities, reductions, equations, each verified by value — and are the book's own errors refused rather than confirmed | a wrong answer, an erratum confirmed, a row whose claim does not hold, or a change to its verdicts, listed in `modenov-baseline.tsv` | | `DocSamples` | does every code sample in the wiki, and every annotated one on the website, compile, run, and print what its page says | a sample that does not compile, throws, or prints something else | A timeout fails none of them: a shared runner is slower than the machine a budget was set on. -`CanonCheck` and `Confluence` report findings by design. `InnerSimplified` is a normalisation, and -does not reorder operands. Some rule sets depend on the order of their arms. So each commits its -list of findings beside it, and the run fails when the list changes in either direction: a finding -that appears, or one that goes away. To record an intended change, run the harness with +`CanonCheck`, `Confluence` and `ModenovCorpus` report findings by design. `InnerSimplified` is a +normalisation, and does not reorder operands. Some rule sets depend on the order of their arms. A +row of the Modenov corpus the library does not yet reduce is unsolved, not failed. So each commits +its list of findings beside it, and the run fails when the list changes in either direction: a +finding that appears, or one that goes away. To record an intended change, run the harness with `HARNESS_UPDATE_BASELINE=1` and commit the list with the change. A finding whose case timed out -counts as unmeasured, not gone. +counts as unmeasured, not gone. A wrong answer is never a finding: it fails the run on its own. Run one by hand with `dotnet run -c Release --project Sources/Tests/Harnesses/BoundCheck`. Its report goes to this folder, where it is ignored by git, or to the directory `HARNESS_REPORTS`